{ "dataset": "authority-disagreements", "generatedAt": "2026-08-07", "ruleset": "v7", "sources": { "proposals": { "file": "traits-proposals-v7.jsonl", "sha256": "0aa57cbe723933cb3dbf268c5cbaab25dccbca635be3aaa3096c4b7dfab66690", "lines": 5556 }, "ledgers": { "applied": { "file": "applied.jsonl", "sha256": "00ae7ad7f7dd6cf941f3d96accf88831378f1c67285ac237821729abda47668f", "lines": 352 }, "appliedValues": { "file": "applied-values.jsonl", "sha256": "d972233ddd30e6d1be54ad1063a5912b939cd0ddba9f7455299ce095bedf7756", "lines": 3 } }, "evidenceFiles": [ "pilot-evidence.json", "taskb-evidence.jsonl", "v4-evidence.jsonl", "v5-evidence.jsonl", "v6-evidence.jsonl", "v7-evidence.jsonl" ], "publishers": { "distinct": 571, "byHost": { "plants.ces.ncsu.edu": 2672, "plantfinder.mobot.org": 1424, "www.missouribotanicalgarden.org": 1247, "www.rhs.org.uk": 622, "hgic.clemson.edu": 422, "plantaddicts.com": 285, "www.chicagobotanic.org": 274, "www.perennials.com": 258, "www.waltersgardens.com": 251, "hort.extension.wisc.edu": 231, "www.davidaustinroses.com": 228, "www.provenwinners.com": 220, "heirloomroses.com": 218, "mortonarb.org": 180, "www.americanmeadows.com": 179, "extension.illinois.edu": 178, "www.gracerosefarm.com": 172, "www.soonerplantfarm.com": 170, "web.extension.illinois.edu": 169, "www.wildflower.org": 166, "www.davidaustinroses.co.uk": 154, "gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu": 121, "www.northcreeknurseries.com": 114, "menagerieflower.com": 107, "www.perennialresource.com": 105, "newmoonnursery.com": 101, "www.plantdelights.com": 95, "naturehills.com": 92, "yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu": 92, "www.highcountrygardens.com": 87, "ask.ifas.ufl.edu": 84, "extension.psu.edu": 80, "landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu": 78, "www.pleasantrunnursery.com": 76, "www.thetreecenter.com": 72, "www.monrovia.com": 71, "www.helpmefind.com": 68, "www.longfield-gardens.com": 67, "www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com": 67, "www.finegardening.com": 65, "brentandbeckysbulbs.com": 59, "www.gertens.com": 59, "www.outsidepride.com": 58, "patents.google.com": 57, "www.arboretum.purdue.edu": 55, "www.vanengelen.com": 55, "extension.umn.edu": 54, "www.fast-growing-trees.com": 53, "www.nvknurseries.com": 53, "www.terranovanurseries.com": 53, "www.dutchgrown.com": 52, "www.brecks.com": 51, "plants.gertens.com": 49, "www.pridescorner.com": 46, "mtcubacenter.org": 45, "patuxentnursery.com": 44, "www.colesvillenursery.com": 44, "www.hollandbulbfarms.com": 44, "www.sandysplants.com": 44, "pza.sanbi.org": 43, "blogs.ifas.ufl.edu": 42, "extension.usu.edu": 42, "www.johnscheepers.com": 42, "www.usperennials.com": 42, "devilmountainnursery.com": 41, "www.hoffienursery.com": 40, "www.wilsonbrosgardens.com": 40, "www.uaex.uada.edu": 37, "extension.umd.edu": 36, "www.arborvalleynursery.com": 36, "www.gardenersworld.com": 36, "www.gardening.cornell.edu": 36, "www.prairiemoon.com": 36, "buchanansplants.com": 35, "gardengoodsdirect.com": 35, "www.edenbrothers.com": 35, "info.ballseed.com": 34, "plants.oaklandnursery.com": 34, "kb.jniplants.com": 33, "springhillnursery.com": 33, "www.adrbulbs.com": 32, "pfaf.org": 31, "www.depts.ttu.edu": 31, "www.saundersbrothers.com": 30, "edis.ifas.ufl.edu": 29, "www.darwinperennials.com": 28, "www.heirloomroses.com": 28, "fieldreport.caes.uga.edu": 27, "mdc.mo.gov": 27, "pw.waltersgardens.com": 27, "www.highcountryroses.com": 27, "www.asu.edu": 26, "www.bloomables.com": 26, "www.easytogrowbulbs.com": 26, "www.gurneys.com": 26, "fieldstonegardens.com": 25, "plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org": 25, "www.prairienursery.com": 25, "trees.umn.edu": 24, "www.regannursery.com": 23, "www.selectseeds.com": 23, "www.brighterblooms.com": 22, "www.johnnyseeds.com": 22, "extension.msstate.edu": 21, "kiefernursery.com": 21, "stonehousenursery.com": 21, "www.boethingtreeland.com": 21, "www.siteone.com": 21, "www.swiftgreenhouses.com": 21, "extension.missouri.edu": 20, "roguevalleyroses.com": 20, "www.farmergracy.co.uk": 20, "www.botanicalinterests.com": 19, "www.diggingdog.com": 19, "www.dutchbulbs.com": 19, "conifersociety.org": 18, "extension.uga.edu": 18, "grownbyoverdevest.com": 18, "plants.shopsteins.com": 17, "servescape.com": 17, "www.everwilde.com": 17, "www.newgardenplants.com": 17, "fedcoseeds.com": 16, "gardencrossings.com": 16, "gobotany.nativeplanttrust.org": 16, "plants.westonnurseries.com": 16, "www.gardencentermarketing.com": 16, "plants.platthillnursery.com": 15, "ucanr.edu": 15, "www.almostedenplants.com": 15, "www.colorblends.com": 15, "www.piedmontmastergardeners.org": 15, "mountainvalleygrowers.com": 14, "www.plantaddicts.com": 14, "hortech.com": 13, "plants.homesteadgardens.com": 13, "www.ballyrobertgardens.com": 13, "www.netherlandbulb.com": 13, "www.thepollennation.com": 13, "www.vanzyverden.com": 13, "cavanos.com": 12, "jeffriesnurseries.com": 12, "plantlust.com": 12, "plants.thegrowingplace.com": 12, "provenwinnersdirect.com": 12, "woodyplants.cals.cornell.edu": 12, "www.devroomen.com": 12, "www.gardencrossings.com": 12, "www.jparkers.co.uk": 12, "www.newblooms.com": 12, "www.smgrowers.com": 12, "firsteditionsplants.com": 11, "gilberthwild.com": 11, "ottoandsonsnursery.com": 11, "plantdatabase.uconn.edu": 11, "www.babikow.com": 11, "www.brushwoodnursery.com": 11, "www.northshoreplantclub.com": 11, "www.rdwholesalenursery.com": 11, "www.springhillnursery.com": 11, "agsci.psu.edu": 10, "all-americaselections.org": 10, "calscape.org": 10, "lancaster.unl.edu": 10, "littleprinceplants.com": 10, "mygardenlife.com": 10, "plants.rogersgardens.com": 10, "rosariumlottum.com": 10, "www.harvesting-history.com": 10, "www.lucasgreenhouses.com": 10, "www.northwestblooms.com": 10, "www.terraceiafarms.com": 10, "www.uvm.edu": 10, "charsawfarms.com": 9, "extension.colostate.edu": 9, "tnyards.utk.edu": 9, "tomorrowseeds.com": 9, "woodlanders.net": 9, "www.applewoodseed.com": 9, "www.greenleafnursery.com": 9, "www.lsuagcenter.com": 9, "www.northlandrosarium.com": 9, "www.plantingtree.com": 9, "www.superseeds.com": 9, "baygardens.com": 8, "dancingoaks.com": 8, "degroot-inc.com": 8, "ipm.missouri.edu": 8, "midvalleytrees.com": 8, "plants.minorsgardencenter.com": 8, "proctorsnursery.co.uk": 8, "romencegardens.com": 8, "southernlivingplants.com": 8, "toptropicals.com": 8, "www.almanac.com": 8, "www.bloomindesigns.com": 8, "www.brentandbeckysbulbs.com": 8, "www.coldstreamfarm.net": 8, "www.edmundsroses.com": 8, "www.greenwoodnursery.com": 8, "www.sarahraven.com": 8, "www.umass.edu": 8, "www.witherspoonrose.com": 8, "belle-epoque.nl": 7, "butterflybushes.com": 7, "daylilies.org": 7, "dendro.cnre.vt.edu": 7, "eu.davidaustinroses.com": 7, "greatlakeslavenderfarm.com": 7, "greenvalleygardensupply.com": 7, "homenursery.com": 7, "meilland.com": 7, "myperfectplants.com": 7, "palatinefruit.com": 7, "plants.natorp.com": 7, "plants.skh.com": 7, "shop.myflowerland.com": 7, "soonerplantfarm.com": 7, "windingcreek-nursery.com": 7, "www.antiqueroseemporium.com": 7, "www.claireaustin-hardyplants.co.uk": 7, "www.dianeseeds.com": 7, "www.fnps.org": 7, "www.greenheartfarms.com": 7, "www.ipni.org": 7, "www.jamesgreenhouses.com": 7, "www.kimmelorchard.org": 7, "www.laddsgardencenter.com": 7, "www.meillandrichardier.com": 7, "www.mortellaros.com": 7, "www.pubs.ext.vt.edu": 7, "www.vanberkumnursery.com": 7, "angelgardens.com": 6, "blueskynursery.ca": 6, "grow.edenbrothers.com": 6, "horsfordnursery.com": 6, "hydrangeasplus.com": 6, "mountaincrestgardens.com": 6, "oakesdaylilies.com": 6, "oldhousegardens.com": 6, "plantfactorydirect.com": 6, "plants.hoerrnursery.com": 6, "plants.valleyviewfarms.com": 6, "shop.wassonnursery.com": 6, "springmeadownursery.com": 6, "www.buddlejacollection.com": 6, "www.classic-groundcovers.com": 6, "www.eastcoastnurseries.com": 6, "www.growingcolors.com": 6, "www.hartsnursery.co.uk": 6, "www.logees.com": 6, "www.mygardenlife.com": 6, "www.perennialfarmmarketplace.com": 6, "www.plant-world-seeds.com": 6, "www.roguevalleyroses.com": 6, "www.rosen.de": 6, "www.stadlergardencenters.com": 6, "www.sugarcreekgardens.com": 6, "www.valdosta.edu": 6, "www.weeksroses.com": 6, "bloomoutlet.com": 5, "botanicgardens.uw.edu": 5, "costafarms.com": 5, "en.wikipedia.org": 5, "encoreazalea.com": 5, "ferrymorse.com": 5, "greenpromisefarms.com": 5, "harvestnestseeds.com": 5, "hydrangea.com": 5, "loghouseplants.com": 5, "lonewolflavender.com": 5, "pharmarosa.de": 5, "plants.dammannsgardenco.com": 5, "plants.jimwhitingnursery.com": 5, "plants.longfellowsgreenhouses.com": 5, "plants.mischlersflorist.com": 5, "plants.theflowerbin.net": 5, "plants.waltonsgarden.com": 5, "plantsexpress.com": 5, "rosefarmcanada.com": 5, "seedterra.com": 5, "shop.armstronggarden.com": 5, "sugarcreekgardens.com": 5, "taylorsnursery.com": 5, "u.osu.edu": 5, "www.aces.edu": 5, "www.backyardgardener.com": 5, "www.bethchatto.co.uk": 5, "www.coniferkingdom.com": 5, "www.fs.usda.gov": 5, "www.greatplantpicks.org": 5, "www.grimmsgardens.com": 5, "www.hooksgreenherbs.com": 5, "www.jamiesonbrothers.com": 5, "www.knockoutroses.com": 5, "www.martinnursery.com": 5, "www.myblackthumb.com": 5, "www.myseeds.co": 5, "www.naturehills.com": 5, "www.panamseed.com": 5, "www.plantsnouveau.com": 5, "www.ricksgarden.com": 5, "www.rumrivertreefarm.com": 5, "www.seedman.com": 5, "www.shireplants.co.uk": 5, "www.slcgardenwise.com": 5, "www.southernbulbs.com": 5, "www.tynursery.com": 5, "www.ufseeds.com": 5, "www.vermontwildflowerfarm.com": 5, "www.vhherbs.com": 5, "www.watershednursery.com": 5, "almanacplanting.com": 4, "apps.cals.arizona.edu": 4, "brunswick.ces.ncsu.edu": 4, "camtoocamellia.com": 4, "cwelwnp.usu.edu": 4, "gaskosfamilyfarm.com": 4, "goldenvalleyplants.co.uk": 4, "hillcountrywatergardens.com": 4, "hudsonvalleyseed.com": 4, "knightsroses.com.au": 4, "m.bloomingadvantage.com": 4, "monticelloshop.org": 4, "planthaven.com": 4, "plants.buyallseasons.com": 4, "pondsidenursery.com": 4, "portlandnursery.com": 4, "powo.science.kew.org": 4, "premiergrowersinc.com": 4, "qualitycuttings.com": 4, "redbuttegarden.org": 4, "shop.mahoneysgarden.com": 4, "strictlymedicinalseeds.com": 4, "trueleafmarket.com": 4, "wildwood.express": 4, "witherspoonrose.com": 4, "www.anniesannuals.com": 4, "www.artformnurseries.com": 4, "www.ashridgetrees.co.uk": 4, "www.bachmanswholesale.com": 4, "www.csu.org": 4, "www.floralencounters.com": 4, "www.gardendesign.com": 4, "www.greenthumbsgalore.com": 4, "www.letsgoplanting.co.uk": 4, "www.nativeson.com": 4, "www.palatineroses.com": 4, "www.parransgreenhouse.com": 4, "www.plantsbymail.com": 4, "www.plantsomethingmontana.org": 4, "www.promessedefleurs.com": 4, "www.swiftcreeknursery.com": 4, "www.treesandplants.com": 4, "www.treestodaynursery.com": 4, "www.trevorwhiteroses.co.uk": 4, "www.unf.edu": 4, "www.vannoortbulb.com": 4, "www.vdberk.co.uk": 4, "xeraplants.com": 4, "amarylia.com": 3, "bhfnursery.com": 3, "catalog.extension.oregonstate.edu": 3, "chicagobotanic.org": 3, "daylilydatabase.org": 3, "extension.oregonstate.edu": 3, "ffl-apps.ifas.ufl.edu": 3, "greatbasinseeds.com": 3, "highgardenroses.com": 3, "homegarden.cahnr.uconn.edu": 3, "ipm.ucanr.edu": 3, "kennedyscountrygardens.com": 3, "ngb.org": 3, "perennialplantoftheyear.com": 3, "plants.chaletnursery.com": 3, "plants.dickmanfarms.com": 3, "plants.hicksnurseries.com": 3, "plants.pikenursery.com": 3, "plants.rutgersln.com": 3, "plants.squakmtnursery.com": 3, "plantura.garden": 3, "pueblo.extension.colostate.edu": 3, "riverbendnursery.com": 3, "scenichillfarmnursery.com": 3, "sierravistagrowers.net": 3, "suntoryflowers.com": 3, "territorialseed.com": 3, "utianews.tennessee.edu": 3, "waterwisegardenplanner.org": 3, "www.ab-cultivars.com": 3, "www.angelgardens.com": 3, "www.avantgardensne.com": 3, "www.bbg.org": 3, "www.briggsnursery.com": 3, "www.calfloranursery.com": 3, "www.dahlias.com": 3, "www.farmyardnurseries.co.uk": 3, "www.freepatentsonline.com": 3, "www.gardenexpress.com.au": 3, "www.gardenplantsonline.co.uk": 3, "www.georgesdelbard.com": 3, "www.herboo.com": 3, "www.hickoryhollownursery.com": 3, "www.illinoiswildflowers.info": 3, "www.instanthedge.com": 3, "www.monrosier.com": 3, "www.mrfothergills.com.au": 3, "www.northcoastperennials.com": 3, "www.onrockgarden.com": 3, "www.public.asu.edu": 3, "www.purdue.edu": 3, "www.rareseeds.com": 3, "www.rosenhof-odendahl.de": 3, "www.roundstoneseed.com": 3, "www.seedstore.com": 3, "www.succulentspot.com": 3, "www.treesandshrubsonline.org": 3, "www.urbantreefarm.com": 3, "www.usna.usda.gov": 3, "3porchfarm.com": 2, "app.lsuagcenter.com": 2, "blomsbulbs.com": 2, "bygl.osu.edu": 2, "cannas.net": 2, "depts.washington.edu": 2, "edgeofthewoodsnursery.com": 2, "elnativogrowers.com": 2, "extension.sdstate.edu": 2, "extension.umaine.edu": 2, "extension.unh.edu": 2, "extensiongardener.ces.ncsu.edu": 2, "fleurfarm.com": 2, "greatplainsnursery.com": 2, "greenthingsaz.com": 2, "harlequinsgardens.com": 2, "hortnews.extension.iastate.edu": 2, "jcra.ncsu.edu": 2, "joshsfrogs.com": 2, "ladybirdnursery.com.au": 2, "lakevalleyseed.com": 2, "missouribotanicalgarden.org": 2, "morningsunherbfarm.com": 2, "mr-fothergills.co.uk": 2, "njaes.rutgers.edu": 2, "nursery.iowadnr.gov": 2, "plants.fernwoodgardencenter.com": 2, "plants.frisellanursery.com": 2, "plants.penderpines.com": 2, "planttalk.colostate.edu": 2, "ruigrokflowerbulbs.com": 2, "scholar.lib.vt.edu": 2, "shopucscarboretum.com": 2, "styleroses.co.uk": 2, "theodorepayne.org": 2, "tripplebrookfarm.com": 2, "wp.towson.edu": 2, "www.alexandrafarms.com": 2, "www.angliabulbs.com": 2, "www.bostonbulbswholesale.co.uk": 2, "www.bulkwildflowers.com": 2, "www.campbellsnursery.com": 2, "www.certifiednurseries.com": 2, "www.clearviewhort.com": 2, "www.cnygardening.org": 2, "www.dallasplanttrials.org": 2, "www.davidaustin.com": 2, "www.flowerfeatherfarm.com": 2, "www.gchouston.org": 2, "www.goodegreenhouses.com": 2, "www.highplainsgardening.com": 2, "www.jekkas.com": 2, "www.jparkers.com": 2, "www.kansasforests.org": 2, "www.lincsplants.com": 2, "www.lindavistanatives.com": 2, "www.milmont.com": 2, "www.moosecrossinggardencenter.com": 2, "www.muddymountainflowers.com": 2, "www.old.clematis.com.pl": 2, "www.organic-heirloom-seed.com": 2, "www.pacificbulbsociety.org": 2, "www.perennialreference.com": 2, "www.pinelanenursery.com": 2, "www.plantvine.com": 2, "www.portlandnursery.com": 2, "www.promessedefleurs.ie": 2, "www.rhododendron.org": 2, "www.rootsplants.co.uk": 2, "www.rozenlottum.nl": 2, "www.theplantcompany.co.nz": 2, "www.toadshade.com": 2, "www.tulipworld.com": 2, "www.walmart.com": 2, "anpsa.org.au": 1, "arboretum.psu.edu": 1, "atlantabg.org": 1, "avondalenursery.co.uk": 1, "bbbseed.com": 1, "blogs.cornell.edu": 1, "bloomingbulb.com": 1, "byf.unl.edu": 1, "camforest.com": 1, "cistus.com": 1, "daffodilusa.org": 1, "dallascountymastergardeners.org": 1, "extension.k-state.edu": 1, "fairfaxgardening.org": 1, "farmerbailey.com": 1, "florabase.dbca.wa.gov.au": 1, "gardenerstreasures.com.au": 1, "gardens.duke.edu": 1, "jacquesamandintl.com": 1, "jerseyyards.org": 1, "jmgvines.com": 1, "mgnv.org": 1, "mnhardy.umn.edu": 1, "mrmaple.com": 1, "mswn.com": 1, "naturalresources.extension.iastate.edu": 1, "navigate.botanicgardens.org": 1, "nfs.unl.edu": 1, "plantdatabase.kpu.ca": 1, "premierepeau.com": 1, "rainyside.com": 1, "shop.glendoick.com": 1, "singtree.com": 1, "summerdreamsfarm.com": 1, "terranovanurseries.com": 1, "treesandshrubsonline.org": 1, "tropical.theferns.info": 1, "utgardens.tennessee.edu": 1, "victoryseeds.com": 1, "www.adaptiveseeds.com": 1, "www.botanic.cam.ac.uk": 1, "www.brokenarrownursery.com": 1, "www.conifers.org": 1, "www.danzigeronline.com": 1, "www.dutchbulbs.co.uk": 1, "www.efloras.org": 1, "www.fleursdescevennes.fr": 1, "www.gardeningexpress.co.uk": 1, "www.gardensonline.com.au": 1, "www.harrisseeds.com": 1, "www.helleborus.de": 1, "www.heritageflowerfarm.com": 1, "www.hort.cornell.edu": 1, "www.horticopia.info": 1, "www.iselinursery.com": 1, "www.jungseed.com": 1, "www.kingsgardencenter.com": 1, "www.kitchengardenseeds.com": 1, "www.lageschaar.nl": 1, "www.laspilitas.com": 1, "www.luriegarden.org": 1, "www.ndsu.edu": 1, "www.nijssenbulbs.com": 1, "www.nparks.gov.sg": 1, "www.plantcetera.com": 1, "www.plantencentrumvandenbeuken.nl": 1, "www.po.flowerscanadagrowers.com": 1, "www.randomharvest.co.za": 1, "www.rhododendronsdirect.com": 1, "www.rosecottageplants.co.uk": 1, "www.srs.fs.usda.gov": 1, "www.summerwindsnursery.com": 1, "www.sunnyfield.com": 1, "www.sunsetviewfarmdahlias.com": 1, "www.suntoryflowers.com": 1, "www.vitegreenhouses.com": 1, "www.westcoastseeds.com": 1, "www.worldfloraonline.org": 1 } } }, "methodNotes": [ "Derived read-only from traits-proposals-v7.jsonl, the live trait-verification file, whose every line check-v7.mjs re-derives from the frozen source evidence. No verdict is recomputed here and no rule is re-implemented; rows are the pipeline's own records, re-sorted.", "current is the catalog value the evidence was scored against (the value at freeze). Where a later apply moved the catalog, the row carries appliedSince with the ledger's own from/to, and the appliedValues section is the value ledger verbatim.", "A SPLIT means the published authorities disagree with each other about one plant; the pipeline proposes nothing on a SPLIT. splitRate is SPLIT records over all collected records for the field, including INSUFFICIENT ones; answered is records whose outcome is not INSUFFICIENT and not NAME-UNVERIFIED.", "Set-aside sources are summarized on each row by the pipeline's own sub-records: shape (the taxonomic-level rule), climate (the grown-as-annual rule), horizon (the tree/conifer maturity-horizon rule) and taxa (the distinct-taxa rule for tag claims). Each records how many figures or claims were set aside and the pipeline's own reason sentences; set-aside figures are not in sources.", "bloom and water have no rows because no machine verdict exists for them anywhere: both were cut from the trait method in v2, and the v9/v12 field evidence is note-based prose without scoring rules. Deriving a split rate for them would invent one.", "Hardiness zones need exact consensus by design (any end-to-end difference is real), so their splitRate reads high on purpose: a SPLIT is a discovery about the literature, not a failure of the plants.", "Rows are sorted by slug, then by the brief's field order. Two runs over the same inputs are byte-identical given the same --date." ], "totals": { "records": 5556, "plants": 700, "outcomes": { "AGREE": 1713, "SPLIT": 555, "INSUFFICIENT": 2584, "CORRECTION": 683, "NAME-UNVERIFIED": 3, "DUAL-FORM": 6, "CONVENTION": 12 } }, "fields": { "matureHeight": { "collected": 697, "split": 54, "splitRate": 0.0775, "answered": 409, "outcomes": { "AGREE": 337, "SPLIT": 54, "INSUFFICIENT": 288, "DUAL-FORM": 4, "CORRECTION": 14 } }, "matureSpread": { "collected": 697, "split": 102, "splitRate": 0.1463, "answered": 362, "outcomes": { "AGREE": 237, "INSUFFICIENT": 335, "CORRECTION": 21, "SPLIT": 102, "DUAL-FORM": 2 } }, "hardinessZones": { "collected": 697, "split": 374, "splitRate": 0.5366, "answered": 499, "outcomes": { "SPLIT": 374, "INSUFFICIENT": 198, "AGREE": 84, "CORRECTION": 29, "CONVENTION": 12 } }, "sun": { "collected": 697, "split": 1, "splitRate": 0.0014, "answered": 618, "outcomes": { "AGREE": 615, "INSUFFICIENT": 79, "CORRECTION": 2, "SPLIT": 1 } }, "tags.fragrant": { "collected": 697, "split": 6, "splitRate": 0.0086, "answered": 211, "outcomes": { "AGREE": 119, "INSUFFICIENT": 486, "CORRECTION": 86, "SPLIT": 6 } }, "tags.cutFlower": { "collected": 692, "split": 0, "splitRate": 0, "answered": 237, "outcomes": { "CORRECTION": 199, "INSUFFICIENT": 455, "AGREE": 38 } }, "tags.drought": { "collected": 676, "split": 16, "splitRate": 0.0237, "answered": 292, "outcomes": { "CORRECTION": 94, "INSUFFICIENT": 384, "AGREE": 182, "SPLIT": 16 } }, "tags.pollinator": { "collected": 676, "split": 2, "splitRate": 0.003, "answered": 323, "outcomes": { "CORRECTION": 233, "INSUFFICIENT": 353, "AGREE": 88, "SPLIT": 2 } }, "tags.thornless": { "collected": 10, "split": 0, "splitRate": 0, "answered": 5, "outcomes": { "INSUFFICIENT": 5, "CORRECTION": 5 } }, "botanicalName": { "collected": 17, "split": 0, "splitRate": 0, "answered": 13, "outcomes": { "AGREE": 13, "INSUFFICIENT": 1, "NAME-UNVERIFIED": 3 } } }, "appliedValues": [ { "slug": "black-eyed-susan", "field": "bloomEnd", "prev": 9, "next": 10, "outcome": "CORRECTION", "ruleset": "v12", "set": "builtin", "appliedAt": "2026-08-03" }, { "slug": "coneflower", "field": "zoneMax", "prev": 9, "next": 8, "outcome": "CORRECTION", "ruleset": "v12", "set": "builtin", "appliedAt": "2026-08-03" }, { "slug": "yarrow", "field": "bloomEnd", "prev": 8, "next": 9, "outcome": "CORRECTION", "ruleset": "v12", "set": "builtin", "appliedAt": "2026-08-03" } ], "rows": [ {"slug":"abraham-darby","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.52,1.67],"union":[1.37,2.13],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/abraham-darby","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"5ft","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-abraham-darby-auscot/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"5-7 feet tall (8-10 feet in mild climates)","metres":[1.52,2.13],"band":[1.52,2.13],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-abraham-darby%C2%AE-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Approximately 5 ft","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/abraham-darby","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"4 1/2ft (140cm)","metres":1.4,"band":[1.26,1.54],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"abraham-darby","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.37,1.52],"union":[0.91,1.67],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/abraham-darby","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"5ft","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-abraham-darby-auscot/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"3-5 foot spread","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-abraham-darby%C2%AE-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Approximately 5 ft","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/abraham-darby","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"4ft (125cm)","metres":1.25,"band":[1.13,1.38],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"abraham-darby","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/abraham-darby","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zones 5-11"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-abraham-darby-auscot/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-abraham-darby%C2%AE-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"USDA Zones 5-11"}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"abraham-darby","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/abraham-darby","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/abraham-darby","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"East, South, West Facing; Full Sunlight"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-abraham-darby-auscot/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-abraham-darby%C2%AE-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"abraham-darby","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/abraham-darby","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Strong, Fruity"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/abraham-darby","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Strong, Fruity - a rich, fruity fragrance with a refreshing sharpness"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-abraham-darby-auscot/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Rich fruity fragrance / strong fruity fragrance"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-abraham-darby%C2%AE-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Strong, rich fruity fragrance with refreshing sharpness"}],"note":"sources rate it strong","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"agapanthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.1,1.22],"union":[0.2,1.5],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Agapanthus (group)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a434","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.46,1.22],"band":[0.46,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Charlotte County","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/charlotteco/2023/05/23/in-search-of-the-lily-of-the-nile/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"While there are dwarf cultivars, most Agapanthus will grow up to four-feet tall and two-feet wide.","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/agapanthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Individual plants can reach up to 4 feet tall and 2 feet wide, but dwarf forms are available.","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/agapanthus/growing-guide","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Agapanthus range in height, some are quite small 20-60cm (8in-2ft); while others can grow up to 1.5 m (5ft).","metres":[0.2,1.5],"band":[0.2,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":7,"species":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.55,0.67],"union":[0.3,0.84],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Agapanthus (group)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a434","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.76],"band":[0.3,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Charlotte County","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/charlotteco/2023/05/23/in-search-of-the-lily-of-the-nile/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"While there are dwarf cultivars, most Agapanthus will grow up to four-feet tall and two-feet wide.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/agapanthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Individual plants can reach up to 4 feet tall and 2 feet wide, but dwarf forms are available.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/tips-and-tricks-for-growing-lily-of-the-nile/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Rhizomes also reproduce, so over time, a one-gallon plant of a vigorous cultivar like 'Blue Storm' will make a clump 2.5 feet wide.","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":7,"species":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["6-10","8-11","7-11","9-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Agapanthus (group)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a434","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 6 to 10","zones":[6,10],"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Agapanthus (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agapanthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[8,11],"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension - Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/agapanthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"There are numerous hybrid cultivars with a range of characteristics and sizes, hardy in zones 7a to 11b unless noted otherwise.","zones":[7,11],"level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/agapanthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Agapanthus grows best in USDA hardiness zones 9-11.","zones":[9,11],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":7,"species":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Agapanthus (group)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a434","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Agapanthus (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agapanthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Agapanthus africanus","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a433","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"agapanthus africanus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Agapanthus praecox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agapanthus-praecox/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"agapanthus praecox"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension - Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/agapanthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant blooms best when grown in full sun and pot-bound, so don't divide or replant until the plant is pushing out of its pot.","level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Charlotte County","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/charlotteco/2023/05/23/in-search-of-the-lily-of-the-nile/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The best planting site for Agapanthus is full sun although they can tolerate some partial shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/agapanthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It performs well in partial shade or full sun, drought, and even our sandy loam soil.","level":"genus"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica - Agapanthus praecox","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/agapanthus-praecox","country":"ZA","form":null,"value":"It prefers full sun, and some cultivars will flower in semi-shade.","level":"species","taxon":"agapanthus praecox"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica - Agapanthus africanus","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/agapanthus-africanus","country":"ZA","form":null,"value":"Aspect: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"agapanthus africanus"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica - Agapanthus campanulatus","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/agapanthus-campanulatus","country":"ZA","form":null,"value":"It does well in full sun, or semi-shade.","level":"species","taxon":"agapanthus campanulatus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Charlotte County","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/charlotteco/2023/05/23/in-search-of-the-lily-of-the-nile/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are not fragrant, but more than compensate with color and use as a great cut flower.","claim":false,"level":"genus"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Agapanthus (group)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a434","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Agapanthus (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agapanthus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long-lasting and good cut. Blooms in summer.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Agapanthus africanus","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a433","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pots, containers. Good fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agapanthus africanus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Agapanthus praecox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agapanthus-praecox/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agapanthus praecox"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension - Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/agapanthus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are good cut flowers, and the dried seed heads can be used in arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Charlotte County","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/charlotteco/2023/05/23/in-search-of-the-lily-of-the-nile/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are not fragrant, but more than compensate with color and use as a great cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/agapanthus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Agapanthus can bring fresh shape to your cut flower garden.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"agapanthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Charlotte County","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/charlotteco/2023/05/23/in-search-of-the-lily-of-the-nile/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, this plant is moderate in drought-tolerance and does best on the dry side during the late fall and winter.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/agapanthus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It performs well in partial shade or full sun, drought, and even our sandy loam soil.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/tips-and-tricks-for-growing-lily-of-the-nile/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Although agapanthus is drought tolerant, they don't bloom well if planted in low-nutrient sandy soil.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Agapanthus (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agapanthus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Agapanthus praecox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agapanthus-praecox/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees and butterflies to the nectar-rich flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agapanthus praecox"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Charlotte County","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/charlotteco/2023/05/23/in-search-of-the-lily-of-the-nile/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies, hummingbirds and bees love these flowers as well.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/agapanthus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It will liven up a Florida-Friendly landscape by attracting hummingbirds and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica - Agapanthus praecox","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/agapanthus-praecox","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Feeds honeybees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agapanthus praecox"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica - Agapanthus africanus","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/agapanthus-africanus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollination is by wind, bees and sunbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agapanthus africanus"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica - Agapanthus campanulatus","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/agapanthus-campanulatus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Agapanthus flowers are visited by bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agapanthus campanulatus"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"agapanthus-storm-cloud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.3,1.34],"split":[{"range":[0.3,0.61],"sources":["San Marcos Growers"]},{"range":[1.1,1.34],"sources":["Plant Delights Nursery"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/agapanthus-storm-cloud","country":"US","form":null,"value":"flower heads of bluish-purple on very sturdy stalks to 4' tall","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"San Marcos Growers","url":"https://www.smgrowers.com/products/plants/plantdisplay.asp?plant_id=57","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1-2 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus-storm-cloud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"San Marcos Growers","url":"https://www.smgrowers.com/products/plants/plantdisplay.asp?plant_id=57","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2-3 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus-storm-cloud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/agapanthus-storm-cloud","country":"US","form":"flower-stalk height, foliage 24 in.","value":"7b to 10b, at least","zones":[7,10]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus-storm-cloud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/agapanthus-storm-cloud","country":"US","form":"flower-stalk height, foliage 24 in.","value":"Sun to Part Sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus-storm-cloud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus-storm-cloud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/agapanthus-storm-cloud","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower Plants","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus-storm-cloud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/agapanthus-storm-cloud","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant Plants","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus-storm-cloud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/agapanthus-storm-cloud","country":null,"form":null,"value":"hummingbird-friendly flower heads","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.76],"union":[0.3,1],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/65201/agapanthus-africanus-albus/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"El Nativo Growers","url":"https://elnativogrowers.com/agapanthus-africanus-albus-1g/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 2-3'","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/agapanthus-africanus-albus-white/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 2 - 3 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Mid Valley Trees","url":"https://midvalleytrees.com/product/white-lily-of-the-nile/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: Foliage 1 1/2′, Flowers 2 1/2′","metres":[0.46,0.76],"band":[0.46,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plants Express","url":"https://plantsexpress.com/products/white-lily-of-the-nile","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature height 1-3 ft.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"T-Y Nursery","url":"https://www.tynursery.com/plant-library/perennial/agapanthus-africanus-white/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 1.5 - 2 ft.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.1,1],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/65201/agapanthus-africanus-albus/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"El Nativo Growers","url":"https://elnativogrowers.com/agapanthus-africanus-albus-1g/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 2-3'","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/agapanthus-africanus-albus-white/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 2 - 3 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Mid Valley Trees","url":"https://midvalleytrees.com/product/white-lily-of-the-nile/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3′","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plants Express","url":"https://plantsexpress.com/products/white-lily-of-the-nile","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width 1.5-2 ft.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"T-Y Nursery","url":"https://www.tynursery.com/plant-library/perennial/agapanthus-africanus-white/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 1.5 - 2 ft.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["8-10","8-11","9-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Agapanthus africanus, species page)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275759&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8 to 10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Agapanthus, genus page listing 'Albus')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agapanthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[8,11]},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension FPS-18 (Agapanthus spp. and hybrids)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp018","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA hardiness zones: 9A through 11B","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/agapanthus-africanus-albus-white/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: Zones 8 - 11","zones":[8,11]},{"name":"Mid Valley Trees","url":"https://midvalleytrees.com/product/white-lily-of-the-nile/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 8-11","zones":[8,11]},{"name":"Plants Express","url":"https://plantsexpress.com/products/white-lily-of-the-nile","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well in Zones 8 9 10 11","zones":[8,11]},{"name":"T-Y Nursery","url":"https://www.tynursery.com/plant-library/perennial/agapanthus-africanus-white/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 10 , 8 , 9","zones":[8,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Agapanthus africanus, species page)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275759&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Agapanthus, genus page listing 'Albus')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agapanthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension FPS-18 (Agapanthus spp. and hybrids)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp018","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in full sun, plant grows in partial shade"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/65201/agapanthus-africanus-albus/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/agapanthus-africanus-albus-white/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs: Full Sun, Filtered Sun, Partial Sun"},{"name":"Mid Valley Trees","url":"https://midvalleytrees.com/product/white-lily-of-the-nile/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure: Full Sun to Partial Sun"},{"name":"Plants Express","url":"https://plantsexpress.com/products/white-lily-of-the-nile","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun exposure Full Sun Partial Shade"},{"name":"T-Y Nursery","url":"https://www.tynursery.com/plant-library/perennial/agapanthus-africanus-white/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Agapanthus africanus, species page)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275759&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut flower.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Agapanthus, genus page listing 'Albus')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agapanthus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long-lasting and good cut.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension FPS-18 (Agapanthus spp. and hybrids)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp018","country":null,"form":null,"value":"make good cut flowers for arrangements","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://midvalleytrees.com/product/white-lily-of-the-nile/","https://www.tynursery.com/plant-library/perennial/agapanthus-africanus-white/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Mid Valley Trees","url":"https://midvalleytrees.com/product/white-lily-of-the-nile/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"tolerant of mild drought once established","claim":true},{"name":"T-Y Nursery","url":"https://www.tynursery.com/plant-library/perennial/agapanthus-africanus-white/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Category: Drought Tolerant , Perennial","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agapanthus-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension FPS-18 (Agapanthus spp. and hybrids)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp018","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Agapanthus attracts pollinators","claim":true},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/agapanthus-africanus-albus-white/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"bringing structure and pollinator value to borders, mass plantings, and containers","claim":true},{"name":"Plants Express","url":"https://plantsexpress.com/products/white-lily-of-the-nile","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wildlife Bees, Birds","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agastache","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Illinois Extension, Prairies to Perennials (Agastache, hummingbird mint)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/prairies-perennials/2016-09-23-hummingbird-mint-creating-buzz","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants generally grow 24 to 30 inches high and 18 to 24 inches wide and bloom from mid to early fall without needing deadheaded.","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"agastache"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":11,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":10,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 11 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"agastache","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Illinois Extension, Prairies to Perennials (Agastache, hummingbird mint)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/prairies-perennials/2016-09-23-hummingbird-mint-creating-buzz","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants generally grow 24 to 30 inches high and 18 to 24 inches wide and bloom from mid to early fall without needing deadheaded.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"agastache"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":10,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"agastache","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Agastache)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agastache/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[5,10],"level":"genus","taxon":"agastache"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":10,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":10,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[4,8]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"agastache","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Agastache)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agastache/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"agastache"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Agastache)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/agastache","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"These plants like full sun and fertile soil that drains easily.","level":"genus","taxon":"agastache"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Agastache foeniculum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agastache-foeniculum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Agastache foeniculum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281382","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Agastache cana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281381","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"agastache cana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Agastache rupestris)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254221","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"agastache rupestris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Agastache nepetoides)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281383","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"agastache nepetoides"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Agastache rugosa 'Golden Jubilee')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260770","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"agastache rugosa"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Anise hyssop, Agastache foeniculum)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/anise-hyssop-agastache-foeniculum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow anise hyssop in full sun to partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension, Home & Garden Information Center (Anise Hyssop)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/anise-hyssop/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is best planted in full sun to part shade in well-drained, moist soil and is hardy in USDA planting zones 4 to 8.","level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Agastache foeniculum)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/agastache-foeniculum-anise-hyssop","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It will tolerate partial shade but does best in full sun.","level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Native Plant Database (Agastache foeniculum)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=AGFO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade , Shade","level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"agastache","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Agastache)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agastache/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are showy, fragrant, long-blooming perennials with spikes of flowers that bloom most of the summer.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"agastache"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Prairies to Perennials (Agastache, hummingbird mint)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/prairies-perennials/2016-09-23-hummingbird-mint-creating-buzz","country":null,"form":null,"value":"One group of showy sun loving perennialsis Agastache, a fragrant plant that is sometimes referred to as hummingbird mint, licorice mint, or hyssop.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"agastache"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Agastache)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/agastache","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Liquorice scented foliage and spires of flowers that bees love; these are just a couple of reasons to plant agastache.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"agastache"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Agastache foeniculum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agastache-foeniculum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is an herbaceous perennial with an erect growth habit and fragrant foliage.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Agastache foeniculum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281382","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Agastache cana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281381","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache cana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Agastache rupestris)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254221","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache rupestris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Agastache rugosa 'Golden Jubilee')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260770","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"agastache rugosa"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Anise hyssop, Agastache foeniculum)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/anise-hyssop-agastache-foeniculum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The aromatic leaves have a licorice-like (anise) scent and are used in herbal teas, to flavor jellies or eaten fresh in small quantities, such as in a salad with other greens.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension, Home & Garden Information Center (Anise Hyssop)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/anise-hyssop/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The leaves are opposite of each other on the stem, and when crushed, they give off an anise or licorice fragrance, thus the common name.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Agastache foeniculum)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/agastache-foeniculum-anise-hyssop","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The crushed leaves smell of licorice.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Native Plant Database (Agastache foeniculum)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=AGFO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Foliage: yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Agastache foeniculum, Anise Hyssop)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/agastache-foeniculum-anise-hyssop","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sturdy and upright, the square stem supports fragrant foliage, which smells like anise or licorice.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["agastache nepetoides"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (agastache nepetoides), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"13 sources state this trait and the tag is present; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (agastache nepetoides) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"agastache","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":4,"covered":["agastache foeniculum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (agastache foeniculum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 4 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (agastache foeniculum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"agastache","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Agastache)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agastache/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are also heat and drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"agastache"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Agastache foeniculum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agastache-foeniculum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Anise hyssop makes a great addition to butterfly, cottage, cutting, edible, pollinator and drought tolerant gardens.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Agastache foeniculum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281382","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Agastache cana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281381","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Also tolerates drought, poor soils, summer heat and humidity.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache cana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Agastache rupestris)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254221","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache rupestris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Agastache rugosa 'Golden Jubilee')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260770","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants tolerate heat and some dry soils once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"agastache rugosa"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Anise hyssop, Agastache foeniculum)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/anise-hyssop-agastache-foeniculum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It tolerates drought once established but will also do well in moist soils as long as it has good drainage.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Agastache foeniculum, Anise Hyssop)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/agastache-foeniculum-anise-hyssop","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, Anise Hyssop is drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"agastache","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Agastache)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agastache/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer and rabbit resistant. Attracts pollinators and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"agastache"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Prairies to Perennials (Agastache, hummingbird mint)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/prairies-perennials/2016-09-23-hummingbird-mint-creating-buzz","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Several varieties of Agastache planted together produce a beautiful and long-lasting cloud of colorattracting hummingbirds and a great number of pollinating insects including bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"agastache"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Agastache)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/agastache","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Agastache are one of the very best plants for attracting bees to your garden.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"agastache"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Agastache foeniculum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agastache-foeniculum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It attracts bees, butterflies and birds to the garden and is resistant to deer and rabbits.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Agastache foeniculum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281382","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Agastache cana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281381","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache cana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Agastache rupestris)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254221","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache rupestris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Agastache nepetoides)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281383","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache nepetoides"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Agastache rugosa 'Golden Jubilee')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260770","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to bees, hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"agastache rugosa"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Anise hyssop, Agastache foeniculum)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/anise-hyssop-agastache-foeniculum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The unscented flowers are very attractive to bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension, Home & Garden Information Center (Anise Hyssop)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/anise-hyssop/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"perfect for attracting hummingbirds, bees, wasps, butterflies, and other pollinating insects.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Agastache foeniculum)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/agastache-foeniculum-anise-hyssop","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It blooms from June through September with lavender flower spikes that attract hummingbirds and butterflies; the seeds are attractive to birds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Native Plant Database (Agastache foeniculum)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=AGFO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies , Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Agastache foeniculum, Anise Hyssop)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/agastache-foeniculum-anise-hyssop","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The blossoms pop open in intervals, providing a long nectar season for bumblebees, hummingbirds, and butterflies; this plant is abuzz with pollinators all summer long!","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"agastache foeniculum"}],"note":"14 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"agastache-firebird","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.5,1],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/67593/agastache-firebird/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/anise-hyssop-firebird","country":"US","form":null,"value":"24-36 inches","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agastache-firebird","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.45,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.46,0.5],"union":[0.1,0.61],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/67593/agastache-firebird/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/anise-hyssop-firebird","country":"US","form":null,"value":"18-24 inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agastache-firebird","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/anise-hyssop-firebird","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6-9","zones":[6,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agastache-firebird","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/67593/agastache-firebird/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/anise-hyssop-firebird","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agastache-firebird","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/67593/agastache-firebird/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"grey-green, mint-scented leaves","claim":true},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/anise-hyssop-firebird","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agastache-firebird","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agastache-firebird","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/anise-hyssop-firebird","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agastache-firebird","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","nearMiss":["bee friendly"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/anise-hyssop-firebird","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the row carries [\"bee friendly\"], which nothing in the product reads: hasTag is an equality test against \"pollinator\"","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"agastache-firebird","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"botanicalName","current":"Agastache 'Firebird'","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/67593/agastache-firebird/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Accepted: the RHS lists the cultivar as Agastache 'Firebird', giving Agastache barberi 'Firebird' as a synonym"},{"name":"POWO","url":"https://powo.science.kew.org/taxon/urn:lsid:ipni.org:names:30025210-2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Not read: the POWO genus page for Agastache J.Clayton ex Gronov. returned HTTP 403 to the fetch tool, so no genus-level confirmation was read first hand"}],"note":"name resolves as Agastache 'Firebird'","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ageratum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":10},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.50 to 2.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The species grows to a height of over two feet and reseeds itself liberally.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height: 6 - 36 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Ageratum is often grown as an edging or border plant, since it ranges from about 4-24\" in height.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Ultimate Height: 1.5 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"It reaches heights between 15 cm and 60 cm.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ageratum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":10},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.50 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 10 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ageratum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-11","9-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"http://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277131","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ageratum-houstonianum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[2,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"Seedman.com","url":"https://www.seedman.com/ageratum.htm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ageratum is an annual except in zones 9 and 10, where it may survive as a perennial.","zones":[9,10],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":10},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ageratum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"http://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277131","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ageratum-houstonianum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/ageratum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers full sun, but tolerates very light shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"Cornell University Department of Horticulture, NYS Horticulture Study Guide","url":"http://www.hort.cornell.edu/4hplants/Flowers/Ageratum.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It will do best in full sun, but will tolerate partial shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21533","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/ageratum.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun in cooler climates, part shade elsewhere.","level":"species"},{"name":"Eden Brothers planting guide","url":"https://grow.edenbrothers.com/planting-guides/ageratum-seeds/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in full sun where available (6-8 hours of sun per day). Ageratum will tolerate partial shade (4-6 hours of sun per day)","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ageratum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/ageratum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The soft, fuzzy flowers are dainty and feathery, often delightfully fragrant, and usually completely cover the plants.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ageratum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"http://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277131","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Taller varieties make good cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ageratum-houstonianum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Taller varieties make good cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/ageratum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There are many different varieties of Ageratum available, ranging from dwarf, tufted plants to tall, upright growers that can be used as cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/ageratum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent low growing, mound plant useful for borders while the taller cultivars make excellent cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Plantura Magazine","url":"https://plantura.garden/uk/flowers-perennials/ageratum-houstonianum/ageratum-houstonianum-overview","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The tall varieties of floss flower are particularly suitable as cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/ageratum.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The powder puff blooms of Ageratum make outstanding cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"ageratum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ageratum-houstonianum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant is moderately drought tolerance but prefers rich, moist, well-drained soil as well as full sun.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/ageratum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Ageratum prefers a moist, well drained soil but tolerates dry conditions.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Plantura Magazine","url":"https://plantura.garden/uk/flowers-perennials/ageratum-houstonianum/ageratum-houstonianum-overview","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Under drought floss flower vitality suffers significantly.","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ageratum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"http://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277131","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ageratum-houstonianum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plant is seldom damaged by deer or rabbits and attracts butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Plantura Magazine","url":"https://plantura.garden/uk/flowers-perennials/ageratum-houstonianum/ageratum-houstonianum-overview","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The nectar and pollen supply of the plant is not high but because of the extremely long flowering period of floss flower, it is quite important for bees.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/ageratum.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"ajuga","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.15,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.1,0.23],"union":[0,0.3],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ajuga reptans)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ajuga-reptans/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ajuga reptans)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281384&isprofile=0&basic=Ajuga+reptans","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.50 to 0.75 feet","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database, Herbaceous Plant Finder (Ajuga reptans)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Ajuga_reptans.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 - 6 inches","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension FPS26/FP026 (Ajuga reptans: Common Bugle, Bugleweed, Carpet Bugleweed)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP026","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 to 1/2 feet","metres":[0,0.15],"band":[0,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ajuga","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.25,0.3],"union":[0.15,0.3],"proposed":0.28,"margin":33.3,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ajuga reptans)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ajuga-reptans/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ajuga reptans)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281384&isprofile=0&basic=Ajuga+reptans","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.50 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database, Herbaceous Plant Finder (Ajuga reptans)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Ajuga_reptans.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 10 - 12 inches","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension FPS26/FP026 (Ajuga reptans: Common Bugle, Bugleweed, Carpet Bugleweed)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP026","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1/2 to 1 feet","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.15 to 0.3 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ajuga","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-10","4-8","4-10","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ajuga reptans)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ajuga-reptans/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[3,10],"level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ajuga reptans)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281384&isprofile=0&basic=Ajuga+reptans","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 10","zones":[3,10],"level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database, Herbaceous Plant Finder (Ajuga reptans)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Ajuga_reptans.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: zones 4 - 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension FPS26/FP026 (Ajuga reptans: Common Bugle, Bugleweed, Carpet Bugleweed)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP026","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA hardiness zones: 4 through 10A","zones":[4,10],"level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service, Plant of the Week: Ajuga, Bugleweed","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/ajuga-bugleweed-6-27-14.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is hardy from zone 3 through 9.","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ajuga","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ajuga reptans)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281384&isprofile=0&basic=Ajuga+reptans","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database, Herbaceous Plant Finder (Ajuga reptans)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Ajuga_reptans.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension FPS26/FP026 (Ajuga reptans: Common Bugle, Bugleweed, Carpet Bugleweed)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP026","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in part shade/part sun; plant grows in the shade","level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center, HGIC 1102 Ajuga","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/ajuga/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These species grow in any reasonably well drained soil and although tolerant of full sun, growth is more rapid in partial shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"ajuga"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ajuga","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ajuga","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ajuga","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database, Herbaceous Plant Finder (Ajuga reptans)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Ajuga_reptans.php","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water: high water requirement","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension FPS26/FP026 (Ajuga reptans: Common Bugle, Bugleweed, Carpet Bugleweed)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP026","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance: moderate","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ajuga","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ajuga reptans)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ajuga-reptans/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bumblebees, hummingbirds and songbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ajuga reptans"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.1,1.12],"union":[0.3,2.5],"voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j250","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-giganteum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,1.83],"band":[0.3,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/allium-giganteum-giant-onion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In midspring, the foliage starts to wither, and 4-foot flowering stems rise up with large, 6-inch globes of purple (rarely white) flowers.","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/829/allium-giganteum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-ornamental-onions","country":"US","form":null,"value":"For larger, softball-sized flowers, Allium giganteum attracts attention in the garden. This onion has pale purple flowers in late spring on 40-inch stems.","metres":1.02,"band":[0.92,1.12],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Colorado State University Extension PlantTalk","url":"https://planttalk.colostate.edu/topics/annuals-perennials/1006-bulbs-alliums/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These bloom in the summer and produce softball size clusters of bright lilac flowers, with stalks that are up to 5' tall.","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/allium-giganteum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 36 - 60 inches","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/fall-allium-flower-bulbs-giganteum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 50-60\" tall","metres":[1.27,1.52],"band":[1.27,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/fall-planting-bulbs/allium/allium-giganteum-giant-allium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 36\" to 48\"","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Stein's Garden & Home plant finder","url":"https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/2326/Giant_Onion/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Flower Height: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":10},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.46,0.5],"union":[0.1,0.61],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j250","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-giganteum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/829/allium-giganteum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Stein's Garden & Home plant finder","url":"https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/2326/Giant_Onion/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12 inches","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":10},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","4-8","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j250","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-giganteum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8],"level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/allium-giganteum-giant-onion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4 - 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/allium-giganteum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/fall-planting-bulbs/allium/allium-giganteum-giant-allium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":10},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j250","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-giganteum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/allium-giganteum-giant-onion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/829/allium-giganteum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/allium-giganteum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Full Sun","level":"species"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/fall-allium-flower-bulbs-giganteum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun Half Sun / Half Shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/fall-planting-bulbs/allium/allium-giganteum-giant-allium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Stein's Garden & Home plant finder","url":"https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/2326/Giant_Onion/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j250","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaves and scapes smell like onions when bruised, but plant is not used for culinary purposes.","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-giganteum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/829/allium-giganteum/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Foliage","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/allium-giganteum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer Resistant Attract Bees Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/fall-allium-flower-bulbs-giganteum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Advantages Easy To Grow Cut Flowers Dried Flowers Fragrant Deer Resistant Squirrel Resistant","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Stein's Garden & Home plant finder","url":"https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/2326/Giant_Onion/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Giant Onion features bold balls of lightly-scented purple flowers at the ends of the stems from early to mid summer.","claim":null,"contradicted":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 source(s) were filed as stating this trait but their own words contradict it, so they count for neither side","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"allium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j250","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-giganteum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The purple star-shaped flowers are small, 6-parted, and in a cluster 5-6 inches wide at the top of a naked stem. Blooms early summer in June-July and lasts 2-3 weeks. Good cut or dried.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/829/allium-giganteum/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Ideal for cut flowers and dried flower arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/fall-allium-flower-bulbs-giganteum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Advantages Easy To Grow Cut Flowers Dried Flowers Fragrant Deer Resistant Squirrel Resistant","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/fall-planting-bulbs/allium/allium-giganteum-giant-allium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Benefits Attracts Butterflies and Hummingbirds, Deer Resistant, Good as Cut Flowers, Perennializing","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Stein's Garden & Home plant finder","url":"https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/2326/Giant_Onion/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Giant Onion features bold balls of lightly-scented purple flowers at the ends of the stems from early to mid summer. The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"allium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-giganteum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Although ornamental onion tolerates summer drought, it should be kept moist during the growing season.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/allium-giganteum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies and bees love them, but pesky deer and rabbits stay away. Drought tolerant, too!","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-giganteum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/allium-giganteum-giant-onion","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Interest: Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/allium-giganteum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flower heads rest atop thick, sturdy 36-60\" tall stems, ideal for adding vertical interest to a back border or creating a colorful focal point. Butterflies and bees love them, but pesky deer and rabbits stay away.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/fall-planting-bulbs/allium/allium-giganteum-giant-allium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Benefits Attracts Butterflies and Hummingbirds, Deer Resistant, Good as Cut Flowers, Perennializing","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Stein's Garden & Home plant finder","url":"https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/2326/Giant_Onion/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies to your yard, but is not particularly attractive to deer who tend to leave it alone in favor of tastier treats.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"allium-christophii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.61],"union":[0.15,0.61],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-cristophii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"0 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.15,0.61],"band":[0.15,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282301","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium-christophii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.25,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.15,0.61],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-cristophii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282301","country":"US","form":null,"value":"0.50 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.15,0.46],"band":[0.15,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium-christophii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-cristophii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282301","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium-christophii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-cristophii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282301","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium-christophii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium-christophii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-cristophii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"make great cut or dried flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282301","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers are excellent for both fresh cut and dried flower arrangements.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium-christophii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-cristophii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"normally not susceptible to animals, drought","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282301","country":null,"form":null,"value":"good drought tolerance","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium-christophii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-cristophii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts pollinators and songbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282301","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium-globemaster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.84],"union":[0.46,1.02],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243553&isprofile=0&cv=5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.46,0.76],"band":[0.46,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/53832/allium-globemaster/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/allium-globemaster-globemaster-onion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Globemaster is an upright bulb that grows to a maximum height of 30 inches.","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/allium-globemaster.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24\" to 36\".","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Van Engelen (REPRINT of the John Scheepers copy, same firm, treat as ONE voice with it)","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/allium-globemaster.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24\" to 36\".","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fedco Seeds","url":"https://fedcoseeds.com/bulbs/globemaster-tall-allium-6421","country":"US","form":null,"value":"30-40\" tall.","metres":[0.76,1.02],"band":[0.76,1.02],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/allium-globemaster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Flowering Height 36 inches","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium-globemaster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.25,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243553&isprofile=0&cv=5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/53832/allium-globemaster/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium-globemaster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","4-8","5-7","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243553&isprofile=0&cv=5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/allium-globemaster-globemaster-onion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4 - 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/allium-globemaster.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 5-7.","zones":[5,7],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Van Engelen (REPRINT of the John Scheepers copy, same firm, treat as ONE voice with it)","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/allium-globemaster.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 5-7.","zones":[5,7],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fedco Seeds","url":"https://fedcoseeds.com/bulbs/globemaster-tall-allium-6421","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy in Zones 4-8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/allium-globemaster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium-globemaster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243553&isprofile=0&cv=5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/53832/allium-globemaster/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/allium-globemaster-globemaster-onion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"allium"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/allium-globemaster.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Allium require full sunlight although there are several varieties that can also thrive in partial sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fedco Seeds","url":"https://fedcoseeds.com/bulbs/globemaster-tall-allium-6421","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Alliums are deer resistant and prefer full sun and well-drained soil, but can tolerate some shade.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/allium-globemaster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full Sun/Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium-globemaster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243553&isprofile=0&cv=5","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers generally lack fragrance.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#fragrant flowers","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"allium"},{"name":"Fedco Seeds","url":"https://fedcoseeds.com/bulbs/globemaster-tall-allium-6421","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sweet-smelling blooms make great fresh cutflowers or dried winter arrangements; only if crushed will they smell like onion.","claim":null,"contradicted":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/allium-globemaster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 source(s) were filed as stating this trait but their own words contradict it, so they count for neither side","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"allium-globemaster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/53832/allium-globemaster/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/allium-globemaster.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are also valuable cut and dried flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fedco Seeds","url":"https://fedcoseeds.com/bulbs/globemaster-tall-allium-6421","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sweet-smelling blooms make great fresh cutflowers or dried winter arrangements; only if crushed will they smell like onion.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/allium-globemaster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cutting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"allium-globemaster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243553&isprofile=0&cv=5","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Black Walnut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium-globemaster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243553&isprofile=0&cv=5","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/allium-globemaster-globemaster-onion","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"allium"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/allium-globemaster.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Each bee-loved, long-lasting globe is comprised of hundreds of tightly compacted, star-shaped florets.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Van Engelen (REPRINT of the John Scheepers copy, same firm, treat as ONE voice with it)","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/allium-globemaster.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Each bee-loved, long-lasting globe is comprised of hundreds of tightly compacted, star-shaped florets.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fedco Seeds","url":"https://fedcoseeds.com/bulbs/globemaster-tall-allium-6421","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator Friendly Yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/allium-globemaster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Loved by pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"allium-millenium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.45,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.41,0.46],"union":[0.3,0.56],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-millenium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263431","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ALLMI","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 15.0-20.0 Inches","metres":[0.38,0.51],"band":[0.38,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Millenium Ornamental Onion, Allium hybrid)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/allium/millenium-ornamental-onion-allium-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 15\" - 20\"","metres":[0.38,0.51],"band":[0.38,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21788/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Height: 1.5 feet","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/allium-millenium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height : 12 - 18 in","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase (Millenium Ornamental Onion)","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/millenium-ornamental-onion-allium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 12-18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center (Allium, Ornamental Onion 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.gertens.com/millenium-allium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 20 inches","metres":0.51,"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"US Perennials (Ornamental Onion 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/allium-millenium-ornamental-onion-millenium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1-1.5' tall and wide.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":9},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium-millenium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.34,0.38],"union":[0.25,0.51],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-millenium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 10 in. - 1 ft. 3 in.","metres":[0.25,0.38],"band":[0.25,0.38],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263431","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ALLMI","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 10.0-15.0 Inches","metres":[0.25,0.38],"band":[0.25,0.38],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Millenium Ornamental Onion, Allium hybrid)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/allium/millenium-ornamental-onion-allium-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 10\" - 15\"","metres":[0.25,0.38],"band":[0.25,0.38],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21788/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Spread: 1.5 feet","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/allium-millenium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread : 12 - 18 in","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase (Millenium Ornamental Onion)","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/millenium-ornamental-onion-allium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 12-18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center (Allium, Ornamental Onion 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.gertens.com/millenium-allium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 15 inches","metres":0.38,"band":[0.34,0.42],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"US Perennials (Ornamental Onion 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/allium-millenium-ornamental-onion-millenium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1-1.5' tall and wide.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":9},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium-millenium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","4-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-millenium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263431","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ALLMI","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4,5,6,7,8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Millenium Ornamental Onion, Allium hybrid)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/allium/millenium-ornamental-onion-allium-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/allium-millenium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This cultivar is hardy in USDA Zones 5-8.","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center (Allium, Ornamental Onion 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.gertens.com/millenium-allium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"US Perennials (Ornamental Onion 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/allium-millenium-ornamental-onion-millenium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy in zones 4 to 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":9},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium-millenium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-millenium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263431","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ALLMI","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Millenium Ornamental Onion, Allium hybrid)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/allium/millenium-ornamental-onion-allium-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Sun to Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21788/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/allium-millenium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Allium 'Millenium' is a hardy and adaptable perennial that thrives in full sun to partial shade.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase (Millenium Ornamental Onion)","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/millenium-ornamental-onion-allium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center (Allium, Ornamental Onion 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.gertens.com/millenium-allium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"US Perennials (Ornamental Onion 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/allium-millenium-ornamental-onion-millenium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun is the best","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium-millenium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-millenium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ALLMI","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Drought Tolerant Easy To Grow Fragrant Flowers Fragrant Foliage Mass Planting Fire Resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Millenium Ornamental Onion, Allium hybrid)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/allium/millenium-ornamental-onion-allium-hybrid","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flower Fragrant Foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21788/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center (Allium, Ornamental Onion 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.gertens.com/millenium-allium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Millenium Allium features bold balls of lightly-scented lilac purple flowers with purple overtones at the ends of the stems in mid summer.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"allium-millenium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-millenium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263431","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are suitable for fresh cut arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ALLMI","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Drought Tolerant Easy To Grow Fragrant Flowers Fragrant Foliage Mass Planting Fire Resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Millenium Ornamental Onion, Allium hybrid)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/allium/millenium-ornamental-onion-allium-hybrid","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/allium-millenium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attributes Cut Flower, Dried Flower, Drought Tolerant, Long Blooming, Rock Garden","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase (Millenium Ornamental Onion)","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/millenium-ornamental-onion-allium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting garden (unique flowers, fresh or dried, add interest to any bouquet).","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center (Allium, Ornamental Onion 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.gertens.com/millenium-allium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"great as a long lasting cut flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"allium-millenium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263431","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ALLMI","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Drought Tolerant Easy To Grow Fragrant Flowers Fragrant Foliage Mass Planting Fire Resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Millenium Ornamental Onion, Allium hybrid)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/allium/millenium-ornamental-onion-allium-hybrid","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long Blooming Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/allium-millenium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attributes Cut Flower, Dried Flower, Drought Tolerant, Long Blooming, Rock Garden","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"US Perennials (Ornamental Onion 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/allium-millenium-ornamental-onion-millenium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"isn't bothered by the heat, summer droughts, clay soil or overpopulated deer","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium-millenium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-millenium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263431","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ALLMI","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies and honeybees adore the flowers' sweet nectar but deer and rabbits steer clear of this perennial beauty.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Millenium Ornamental Onion, Allium hybrid)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/allium/millenium-ornamental-onion-allium-hybrid","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Allium 'Millenium')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/allium-millenium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer and rabbit resistant, but very attractive to butterflies and pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase (Millenium Ornamental Onion)","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/millenium-ornamental-onion-allium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to bees, butterflies, hummingbirds, and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center (Allium, Ornamental Onion 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.gertens.com/millenium-allium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies to your yard","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"US Perennials (Ornamental Onion 'Millenium')","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/allium-millenium-ornamental-onion-millenium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer and rabbit resistant and highly attractive for butterflies and bees.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium-moly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.25,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.25,0.46],"union":[0.23,0.46],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281724","country":"US","form":null,"value":"0.75 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.23,0.46],"band":[0.23,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-moly/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"0 ft. 10 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.25,0.46],"band":[0.25,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium-moly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.15,0.3],"split":[{"range":[0.15,0.23],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder"]},{"range":[0.25,0.3],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281724","country":"US","form":null,"value":"0.50 to 0.75 feet","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-moly/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"0 ft. 10 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium-moly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281724","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 to 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-moly/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium-moly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281724","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-moly/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium-moly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium-moly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281724","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy, Good Cut","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium-moly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-moly/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established they are quite drought tolerant.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium-moly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281724","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-moly/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The showy yellow flowers attract butterflies.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"allium-mount-everest","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.12,1.22],"union":[0.68,1.34],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Allium stipitatum 'Mount Everest')","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest-mount-everest-onion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This bulb can grow to a height of 4 feet and forms a compact clump 1 foot wide.","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"Van Engelen (Allium stipitatum Mount Everest)","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 36\".","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs (Allium stipitatum Mount Everest)","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 36\".","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"Colorblends Wholesale Flowerbulbs (Allium Mount Everest)","url":"https://www.colorblends.com/wholesale/alliums/allium-mount-everest/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 44-48 inches","metres":[1.12,1.22],"band":[1.12,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fedco Seeds (Mount Everest Tall Allium)","url":"https://fedcoseeds.com/bulbs/mount-everest-tall-allium-6423","country":"US","form":null,"value":"36-48\" tall.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery (Allium stipitatum 'Mount Everest')","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Allium-x-Mount-Everest","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 30 Inches","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"Golden Valley Plants (Allium stipitatum 'Mount Everest')","url":"https://goldenvalleyplants.co.uk/product/plants/perennials/allium/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"held by strong ribbed stems and measuring an impressive 1.2m in height","metres":1.2,"band":[1.08,1.32],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":1,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium-mount-everest","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.27,0.56],"split":[{"range":[0.27,0.33],"sources":["Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Allium stipitatum 'Mount Everest')"]},{"range":[0.46,0.56],"sources":["Pleasant Run Nursery (Allium stipitatum 'Mount Everest')"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Allium stipitatum 'Mount Everest')","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest-mount-everest-onion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This bulb can grow to a height of 4 feet and forms a compact clump 1 foot wide.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery (Allium stipitatum 'Mount Everest')","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Allium-x-Mount-Everest","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 20 Inches","metres":0.51,"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":1,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium-mount-everest","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","5-8","4-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Allium stipitatum 'Mount Everest')","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest-mount-everest-onion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4 - 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"Van Engelen (Allium stipitatum Mount Everest)","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 5-8.","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs (Allium stipitatum Mount Everest)","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 5-8.","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"Colorblends Wholesale Flowerbulbs (Allium Mount Everest)","url":"https://www.colorblends.com/wholesale/alliums/allium-mount-everest/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 4a-7b(S) / 10b(W)","zones":[4,7],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fedco Seeds (Mount Everest Tall Allium)","url":"https://fedcoseeds.com/bulbs/mount-everest-tall-allium-6423","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 4-8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":1,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium-mount-everest","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Allium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"allium"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Allium stipitatum 'Mount Everest')","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest-mount-everest-onion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It prefers average, well-drained soil in full sun.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs (Allium stipitatum Mount Everest)","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Allium require full sunlight although there are several varieties that can also thrive in partial sunlight","level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"Fedco Seeds (Mount Everest Tall Allium)","url":"https://fedcoseeds.com/bulbs/mount-everest-tall-allium-6423","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Alliums are deer resistant and prefer full sun and well-drained soil, but can tolerate some shade.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"Golden Valley Plants (Allium stipitatum 'Mount Everest')","url":"https://goldenvalleyplants.co.uk/product/plants/perennials/allium/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"From full sun to partial shade, it adapts effortlessly to different light conditions.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium-mount-everest","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Allium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Edible Fragrant Long-lasting Showy","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"allium"},{"name":"Fedco Seeds (Mount Everest Tall Allium)","url":"https://fedcoseeds.com/bulbs/mount-everest-tall-allium-6423","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sweet-smelling blooms make great fresh cutflowers or dried winter arrangements; only if crushed will they smell like onion.","claim":null,"contradicted":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery (Allium stipitatum 'Mount Everest')","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Allium-x-Mount-Everest","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Despite its pleasant and enticing fragrance, deer don't pay 'Mount Everest' Ornamental Onion any mind.","claim":null,"contradicted":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 2 source(s) were filed as stating this trait but their own words contradict it, so they count for neither side","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium-mount-everest","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.johnscheepers.com/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest.html","https://www.colorblends.com/wholesale/alliums/allium-mount-everest/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.johnscheepers.com/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest.html","https://fedcoseeds.com/bulbs/mount-everest-tall-allium-6423"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.johnscheepers.com/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest.html","https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Allium-x-Mount-Everest"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.johnscheepers.com/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest.html","https://goldenvalleyplants.co.uk/product/plants/perennials/allium/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs (Allium stipitatum Mount Everest)","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are also valuable cut and dried flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"Colorblends Wholesale Flowerbulbs (Allium Mount Everest)","url":"https://www.colorblends.com/wholesale/alliums/allium-mount-everest/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Mount Everest is splendid grown against a dark background, and like all of the big alliums, it makes an impressive cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fedco Seeds (Mount Everest Tall Allium)","url":"https://fedcoseeds.com/bulbs/mount-everest-tall-allium-6423","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sweet-smelling blooms make great fresh cutflowers or dried winter arrangements; only if crushed will they smell like onion.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery (Allium stipitatum 'Mount Everest')","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Allium-x-Mount-Everest","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"Golden Valley Plants (Allium stipitatum 'Mount Everest')","url":"https://goldenvalleyplants.co.uk/product/plants/perennials/allium/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the blooms are great for cutting, offering an elegant addition to fresh or dried flower arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium-mount-everest","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Allium-x-Mount-Everest","https://goldenvalleyplants.co.uk/product/plants/perennials/allium/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery (Allium stipitatum 'Mount Everest')","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Allium-x-Mount-Everest","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"Golden Valley Plants (Allium stipitatum 'Mount Everest')","url":"https://goldenvalleyplants.co.uk/product/plants/perennials/allium/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"it can handle occasional droughts and rainy spells alike.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"allium-mount-everest","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Allium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"allium"},{"name":"Van Engelen (Allium stipitatum Mount Everest)","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It too is rabbit-, rodent- and deer-resistant and much loved by bees, butterflies and helpful pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs (Allium stipitatum Mount Everest)","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/allium-stipitatum-mount-everest.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It too is rabbit-, rodent- and deer-resistant and much loved by bees, butterflies and helpful pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"Fedco Seeds (Mount Everest Tall Allium)","url":"https://fedcoseeds.com/bulbs/mount-everest-tall-allium-6423","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery (Allium stipitatum 'Mount Everest')","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Allium-x-Mount-Everest","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium stipitatum"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"allium-purple-sensation","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.71,0.76],"union":[0.61,0.84],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243555&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Colorblends Wholesale Flowerbulbs","url":"https://www.colorblends.com/wholesale/alliums/allium-purple-sensation/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 28-32 inches","metres":[0.71,0.81],"band":[0.71,0.81],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/allium-purple-sensation","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Flowering Height 30 inches","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium aflatunense"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/allium-purple-sensation","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 24-30\" tall","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":4,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"allium-purple-sensation","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243555&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.50 to 0.75 feet","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":4,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"allium-purple-sensation","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","4-7","3-9","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243555&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Colorblends Wholesale Flowerbulbs","url":"https://www.colorblends.com/wholesale/alliums/allium-purple-sensation/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Suitable for USDA zones 4a to 7b in the South, 10b on the West Coast.","zones":[4,7],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/allium-purple-sensation","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium aflatunense"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/allium-purple-sensation","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3 through 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":4,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"allium-purple-sensation","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243555&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Allium hollandicum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-hollandicum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"allium hollandicum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Allium aflatunense)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-aflatunense/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"allium aflatunense"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/allium-purple-sensation","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full Sun/Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium aflatunense"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"allium-purple-sensation","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243555&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"All possess oniony smelling flowers and foliage.","claim":null,"contradicted":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Allium aflatunense)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-aflatunense/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The cluster is 4-5 inches across and last 2-3 weeks in May with a garlic or onion aroma, good cut flower.","claim":null,"contradicted":true,"level":"species","taxon":"allium aflatunense"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/allium-purple-sensation","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium aflatunense"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 2 source(s) were filed as stating this trait but their own words contradict it, so they count for neither side","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"allium-purple-sensation","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243555&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Allium hollandicum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-hollandicum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut Good Dried Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"allium hollandicum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Allium aflatunense)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-aflatunense/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"allium aflatunense"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/allium-purple-sensation","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cutting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium aflatunense"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/allium-purple-sensation","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plant Features: Great for Cut Flowers, Deer Resistant, Naturalizing, Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"allium-purple-sensation","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243555&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Allium hollandicum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-hollandicum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Dry Soil Rabbits","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"allium hollandicum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Allium aflatunense)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-aflatunense/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Rabbits","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"allium aflatunense"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"allium-purple-sensation","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243555&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Allium hollandicum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-hollandicum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract butterflies. Deer and rabbit resistant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"allium hollandicum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Allium aflatunense)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-aflatunense/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"allium aflatunense"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/allium-purple-sensation","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Loved by pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"allium aflatunense"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/allium-purple-sensation","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plant Features: Great for Cut Flowers, Deer Resistant, Naturalizing, Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"amaranth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":9,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 2.00 to 4.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 1-1.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant Height: 36-60\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plants grow 3 to 5 ft. tall and produce rope-like bright red tassels over a long summer and fall season.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant Height 36 to 60 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant Height Tall (Greater than 24\")\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Reaches 3–5 feet tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Amaranthus caudatus is a ANNUAL growing to 2 m (6ft) by 0.5 m (1ft 8in).\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaranth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Amaranthus caudatus is a ANNUAL growing to 2 m (6ft) by 0.5 m (1ft 8in).\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaranth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-11","4-8","3-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a558","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amaranthus-caudatus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[2,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://chicagobotanic.org/plant-collections/plant-finder/amaranthus-caudatus-love-lies-bleeding","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4 - 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/love_lies_bleeding_seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10","zones":[3,10],"level":"species"},{"name":"Plants For A Future","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Amaranthus+caudatus","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"USDA hardiness 4-8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaranth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a558","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amaranthus-caudatus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://chicagobotanic.org/plant-collections/plant-finder/amaranthus-caudatus-love-lies-bleeding","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/143016/amaranthus-caudatus/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Grow in moist, fertile, humus-rich soil in full sun, in a sheltered site.","level":"species"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/amaranthus/love-lies-bleeding-amaranthus-seeds.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full or part shade. Plants tolerate high heat, and any soil as long as drainage is good.","level":"species"},{"name":"Botanical Interests","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/love-lies-bleeding-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Required Full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"Territorial Seed Company","url":"https://territorialseed.com/products/love-lies-bleeding","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Amaranth flowers thrive in full sun, requiring 6-8 hours of direct sunlight daily for optimal growth and vibrant blooms.","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaranth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amaranthus-caudatus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaranth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a558","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant is an everlasting whose flowers retain good color when dried for arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amaranthus-caudatus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut Good Dried Long-lasting Showy","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/143016/amaranthus-caudatus/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the flowers can be used for fresh or dried arrangements and birds love the seedheads","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/amaranthus/love-lies-bleeding-amaranthus-seed-1139.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"USES: Fresh or dried cut flower, back of bed, accent in borders, containers.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/amaranthus/love-lies-bleeding-amaranthus-seeds.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are excellent for cutting or drying.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/love_lies_bleeding_seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Easy to grow summer bloomer that's great for cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Botanical Interests","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/love-lies-bleeding-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plant Characteristics Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Territorial Seed Company","url":"https://territorialseed.com/products/love-lies-bleeding","country":null,"form":null,"value":"An iconic spiller for both fresh and everlasting arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"True Leaf Market","url":"https://trueleafmarket.com/products/amaranth-seeds-love-lies-bleeding-amaranthus-caudatus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Love Lies Bleeding is one of the most popular cut flowers in the floral industry, making an interesting addition to nearly any arrangement.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"amaranth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a558","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amaranthus-caudatus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/143016/amaranthus-caudatus/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/ilriverhort/2015-01-09-amaranth","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The ornamental plant love-lies-bleeding ( Amaranthus caudatus ) has tassel-like long green or purple flowers and tolerates heat, drought, and poor soil.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/amaranthus/love-lies-bleeding-amaranthus-seeds.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Amaranthus will grow faster, produce more flowers with regular water; will tolerate some drought once established.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Territorial Seed Company","url":"https://territorialseed.com/products/love-lies-bleeding","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Amaranth is somewhat drought tolerant once established, but prefers consistent moisture.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Plants For A Future","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Amaranthus+caudatus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It prefers dry or moist soil and can tolerate drought.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaranth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://chicagobotanic.org/plant-collections/plant-finder/amaranthus-caudatus-love-lies-bleeding","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Interest: Attracts Birds Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/love_lies_bleeding_seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A unique growth habit of cascading pink plumes to attract pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Plants For A Future","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Amaranthus+caudatus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"is pollinated by Wind","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"amaranth-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"36-60\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"60\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaranth-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"18\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaranth-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Amaranthus caudatus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amaranthus-caudatus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[2,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaranth-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Hudson Valley Seed Company","url":"https://hudsonvalleyseed.com/products/emerald-tassels-amaranth","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun (8+ Hours Sun)"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Amaranthus caudatus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amaranthus-caudatus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaranth-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaranth-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/amaranthus/emerald-tassels-amaranthus-seed-1786.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Variety good for fresh cut-flower displays","claim":true},{"name":"Hudson Valley Seed Company","url":"https://hudsonvalleyseed.com/products/emerald-tassels-amaranth","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Elegant tassels perfect for flower arranging","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Amaranthus caudatus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amaranthus-caudatus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaranth-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Amaranthus caudatus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amaranthus-caudatus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaranth-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":10,"species":3,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":8,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Each amaryllis bulb produces tall flower stalks that grow from one to three feet tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Each 18 to 24 inch tall scape produces two to six large flowers in an umbelliform inflorescence.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Amaryllis may be purchased as bare or planted bulbs, and are prized for their exotic trumpet-shaped flowers born on 1- to 2-foot leafless stalks or scapes.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The trumpet-shaped flowers can be as large as 8 to 10 inches across and are produced atop an 18- to 30-inch-tall flower stalk.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Hippeastrum hybrids Amaryllis T S see text 1′ late* 1-2′\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"They can grow to about 24 inches tall and when properly cared for may live for several years.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":10,"species":3,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.75 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 9 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["8-10","7-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264599&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8 to 10","zones":[8,10],"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hippeastrum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[7,10],"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/amaryllis-hippeastrum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They are typically hardy in zones 8 to 10.","zones":[8,10],"level":"genus"},{"name":"LSU AgCenter","url":"https://www.lsuagcenter.com/articles/page1702483159438","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In addition, amaryllis can be grown outdoors in garden environments, particularly in the South in USDA hardiness zones 8 to 10.","zones":[8,10],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":10,"species":3,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264599&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hippeastrum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Amaryllis grow best in full sun or partial shade and in soil high in organic matter and moist but with good drainage.","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/amaryllis-hippeastrum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Gradually move it to an area where it will receive full sun for at least 6 hours daily.","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FP255, Hippeastrum x hybridum)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP255","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in part shade/part sun","level":"species","taxon":"hippeastrum hybridum"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/amaryllis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Gradually move the container to a location or garden bed where it will receive full sun for at least 6 hours daily.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach (Yard and Garden)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-amaryllis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Once hardened, select a site in part sun.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Hippeastrum papilio)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hippeastrum-papilio-butterfly-amaryllis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"hippeastrum papilio"},{"name":"Pacific Bulb Society wiki (Hippeastrum calyptratum)","url":"https://www.pacificbulbsociety.org/pbswiki/index.php/Hippeastrum_calyptratum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Bright, filtered sun or part-shade and humidity above 60% is recommended.","level":"species","taxon":"hippeastrum calyptratum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["hippeastrum calyptratum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (hippeastrum calyptratum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (hippeastrum calyptratum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hippeastrum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The large, showy blooms of amaryllis last for three to four weeks making them great for use in borders, cutting gardens, as specimens or garden accents, and as houseplants.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/amaryllis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Should the flower stalk bend too far over, cut it and place it in a vase. The flowers will continue to bloom.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"amaryllis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hippeastrum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They tolerate drought but need moisture during the active growing season.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["hippeastrum hybridum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (hippeastrum hybridum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (hippeastrum hybridum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hippeastrum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Landscape Theme: Butterfly Garden","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":12,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"stout stems to 45cm in height\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Average of 20\" height per stem\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"reaching a mature height of 20-24”\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height 12-24\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: Grows 18-24\" tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height 20\"- 26\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height inches 20-25\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"H. ‘Orange Sovereign’ - has orange-red flowers and grows 18″ tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Established height 50-70cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 60cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Established Height 40-60 cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height at maturity 50 cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 12 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Established spread 20-30cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Spread 25cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Established spread 20-30 cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread at maturity 20 cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["8-10","7-10","9-11","7-11","9-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264599&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8 to 10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hippeastrum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FP255)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP255","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA hardiness zones: 8 through 10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/amaryllis-hippeastrum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They are typically hardy in zones 8 to 10.","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"Blooming Bulb","url":"https://bloomingbulb.com/products/orange-sovereign-amaryllis-bulb","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 9, 10, 11","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"Plantcetera","url":"https://www.plantcetera.com/products/amaryllis-orange-souvereign-mega-bulb","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones: Indoor forcing; Grow outdoors as Perennial in zones 7B-11.","zones":[7,11]},{"name":"Amarylia","url":"https://amarylia.com/products/amaryllis-orange-souvereign","country":"NL","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 9-10","zones":[9,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264599&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hippeastrum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/85364/hippeastrum-galaxy-group-orange-souvereign/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FP255)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP255","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in part shade/part sun"},{"name":"The Garden Club of Houston Bulb and Plant Mart","url":"https://www.gchouston.org/bulb-plant-mart/amaryllis-orange-souvereign/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun Yes Part Sun Yes"},{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/amaryllis-orange-souvereign-bulbs-uk","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/amaryllis-orange-souvereign-bulbs-uk","https://amarylia.com/products/amaryllis-orange-souvereign"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/amaryllis-orange-souvereign-bulbs-uk","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Scented No","claim":false},{"name":"Amarylia","url":"https://amarylia.com/products/amaryllis-orange-souvereign","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance No fragrance","claim":false}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.gchouston.org/bulb-plant-mart/amaryllis-orange-souvereign/","https://www.dutchbulbs.co.uk/plant-0009269/amaryllis-orange-soverign-34cm.htm"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.gchouston.org/bulb-plant-mart/amaryllis-orange-souvereign/","https://amarylia.com/products/amaryllis-orange-souvereign"]}],"sources":[{"name":"The Garden Club of Houston Bulb and Plant Mart","url":"https://www.gchouston.org/bulb-plant-mart/amaryllis-orange-souvereign/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut Flower Yes","claim":true},{"name":"DutchBulbs.co.uk","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.co.uk/plant-0009269/amaryllis-orange-soverign-34cm.htm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Amarylia","url":"https://amarylia.com/products/amaryllis-orange-souvereign","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Suitable as cutting flower Yes","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hippeastrum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They tolerate drought but need moisture during the active growing season.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/amaryllis-orange-souvereign-bulbs-uk","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator-friendly No","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis-salmon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"14 - 18 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"20-25 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis-salmon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis-salmon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/naked-rilona-amaryllis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3-11","zones":[3,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis-salmon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis-salmon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis-salmon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/naked-rilona-amaryllis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The blooms are large and make excellent cut flowers in arrangements or bouquets.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis-salmon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"amaryllis-salmon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"anemone","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.25,0.3],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286104","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.75 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.23,0.46],"band":[0.23,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-coronaria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 10 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.25,0.46],"band":[0.25,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/108378/anemone-coronaria/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"A clump-forming perennial about 45cm tall","metres":0.45,"band":[0.41,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Pacific Bulb Society","url":"https://www.pacificbulbsociety.org/pbswiki/index.php/Anemone_coronaria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10-30 cm (0.3-1 ft)","metres":[0.1,0.3],"band":[0.1,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/anemonecoronaria.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Evergreen, herbaceous perennial (cool season annual in Phoenix) that grows from rhizomatous tubers, small and basally clumping growing to 10 to 12 inches tall, plants go dormant after flowering.","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Van Zyverden","url":"https://www.vanzyverden.com/garden-guides/spring-planting/bulbs/anemone-coronaria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: 10-16\"","metres":[0.25,0.41],"band":[0.25,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"The Old Farmer's Almanac","url":"https://www.almanac.com/plant/anemone","country":"US","form":null,"value":"A. coronaria, aka poppy anemone, is another smaller species, growing 1 to 1.5 feet tall.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":10,"cultivar":4},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"anemone","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.15,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.15,0.23],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286104","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.50 to 0.75 feet","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-coronaria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 0 ft. 9 in.","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/108378/anemone-coronaria/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":10,"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"anemone","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-10","7-11","7-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286104","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 7 to 10","zones":[7,10],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-coronaria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[7,10],"level":"species"},{"name":"Van Zyverden","url":"https://www.vanzyverden.com/garden-guides/spring-planting/bulbs/anemone-coronaria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow as Perennial in zones 7-11. Grow as Annual elsewhere.","zones":[7,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/blogs/all-about-fall-planted-bulbs/all-about-anemones","country":"US","form":null,"value":"De Caen and St. Brigid anemones are winter hardy in zones 7-9.","zones":[7,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"The Old Farmer's Almanac","url":"https://www.almanac.com/plant/anemone","country":"US","form":null,"value":"they are ideally grown in Zones 7 to 10","zones":[7,10],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":10,"cultivar":4},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"anemone","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286104","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-coronaria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/108378/anemone-coronaria/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden (Anemone coronaria 'Harmony Blue')","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/anemone-coronaria-harmony-blue-harmony-blue-anemone","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This anemone is recommended as a cool season annual in Chicago-area gardens, in shaded to full sun locations.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"anemone coronaria"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden (Anemone coronaria 'PAS1863', Mona Lisa)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/anemone-coronaria-pas1863-poppy-anemone","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"anemone coronaria"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/anemone-giant-blue-poppy-single.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant the corms 4\" to 5\" deep and 3\" apart in full to partial sunlight and well-draining soil.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"anemone coronaria"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/anemonecoronaria.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Partial shade to eastern full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"Van Zyverden","url":"https://www.vanzyverden.com/garden-guides/spring-planting/bulbs/anemone-coronaria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Terra Ceia Farms","url":"https://www.terraceiafarms.com/anemone-coronaria-blue-poppy.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Planting Location: Sun - partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"anemone coronaria"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/blogs/all-about-fall-planted-bulbs/all-about-anemones","country":"US","form":null,"value":"De Caen and St. Brigid anemones may be grown in sun or partial shade, but in cooler zones they flower best in full sun.","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"anemone","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Premiere Peau (perfumery glossary, NOT a horticultural source)","url":"https://premierepeau.com/pages/glossary-terms/anemone","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Anemone coronaria is essentially scentless - pollinated by wind and by insects drawn to color, not fragrance.","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"anemone","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286104","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Borders and rock gardens. Good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-coronaria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/spring-is-here-and-so-are-my-anemones/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Anemone is a fantastic early blooming cut flower with sturdy stems that make flower arranging a breeze.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Van Zyverden","url":"https://www.vanzyverden.com/garden-guides/spring-planting/bulbs/anemone-coronaria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long-lasting cut flowers perfect for bouquets & arrangements","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/blogs/all-about-fall-planted-bulbs/all-about-anemones","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Anemone coronaria is best known as a cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"The Old Farmer's Almanac","url":"https://www.almanac.com/plant/anemone","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Anemones make excellent cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["anemone coronaria"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (anemone coronaria), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (anemone coronaria) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"anemone","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-coronaria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Particularly Resistant To (Insects/Diseases/Other Problems): summer drought","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/anemonecoronaria.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Watering: Regular and frequent watering best, no drought tolerance.","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"anemone","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-coronaria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use in the border front, in groups, in containers, under deciduous trees and shrubs in the cutting, pollinator or cottage garden.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["anemone coronaria"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (anemone coronaria), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (anemone coronaria) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"anemone-sylphide","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.2,0.22],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/65288/anemone-coronaria-sylphide-mona-lisa-series/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/anemone-sylphide","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: Grows 10-12\" tall","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/anemone-coronaria-sylphide-windflower-or-poppy-anemone/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8-12 inches","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Terra Ceia Farms","url":"https://www.terraceiafarms.com/anemone-coronaria-sylphide.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8-10\"","metres":[0.2,0.25],"band":[0.2,0.25],"role":"scored"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/anemone-de-caen-sylphide","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Flowering Height 8 inches","metres":0.2,"band":[0.18,0.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/ane0041b-anemone-bulb-coronaria-sylphide-windflower/p/871889","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growth Height Min 12 in. Growth Height Max 18 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Jamieson Brothers","url":"https://www.jamiesonbrothers.com/anemone-sylphide","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height & Spread: 30-45cm tall, spread 20-30cm","metres":[0.3,0.45],"band":[0.3,0.45],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/anemone-sylphide-bulbs-uk","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Established height 20-30cm","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Tulip World","url":"https://www.tulipworld.com/Fall-Planted-Bulbs/Anemone/Sylphide-Anemone.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 8 - 10 inches","metres":[0.2,0.25],"band":[0.2,0.25],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"anemone-sylphide","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.15,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.1,0.3],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/65288/anemone-coronaria-sylphide-mona-lisa-series/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Jamieson Brothers","url":"https://www.jamiesonbrothers.com/anemone-sylphide","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height & Spread: 30-45cm tall, spread 20-30cm","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/anemone-sylphide-bulbs-uk","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Established spread 10-20cm","metres":[0.1,0.2],"band":[0.1,0.2],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"anemone-sylphide","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-10","7-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286104&isprofile=0&basic=Anemone+coronaria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 7 to 10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-coronaria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/anemone-sylphide","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 7 through 10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/anemone-coronaria-sylphide-windflower-or-poppy-anemone/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 7, 8, 9, 10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Terra Ceia Farms","url":"https://www.terraceiafarms.com/anemone-coronaria-sylphide.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 7-10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/anemone-de-caen-sylphide","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 7-10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/ane0041b-anemone-bulb-coronaria-sylphide-windflower/p/871889","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone Max Zone 10b Hardiness Zone Min Zone 7a","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Tulip World","url":"https://www.tulipworld.com/Fall-Planted-Bulbs/Anemone/Sylphide-Anemone.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sylphide Anemone are winter hardy in zones 7-9.","zones":[7,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"anemone-sylphide","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286104&isprofile=0&basic=Anemone+coronaria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-coronaria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/65288/anemone-coronaria-sylphide-mona-lisa-series/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/anemone-sylphide","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Sun to Part Shade"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/anemone-coronaria-sylphide-windflower-or-poppy-anemone/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun, Part Shade"},{"name":"Terra Ceia Farms","url":"https://www.terraceiafarms.com/anemone-coronaria-sylphide.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Planting Location: Sun - partial shade"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/anemone-de-caen-sylphide","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full Sun/Partial Shade"},{"name":"Jamieson Brothers","url":"https://www.jamiesonbrothers.com/anemone-sylphide","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position: Full sun or partial shade in fertile, well-drained soil"},{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/anemone-sylphide-bulbs-uk","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full sun Partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"anemone-sylphide","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"anemone-sylphide","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286104&isprofile=0&basic=Anemone+coronaria","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Borders and rock gardens. Good cut flower.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-coronaria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/anemone-sylphide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long-Lasting Cut Flower","claim":true},{"name":"Terra Ceia Farms","url":"https://www.terraceiafarms.com/anemone-coronaria-sylphide.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These very showy, poppy-like purple anemone flowers are fine for gardens, cut flowers and make wonderful border plants.","claim":true},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/anemone-de-caen-sylphide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cutting","claim":true},{"name":"Jamieson Brothers","url":"https://www.jamiesonbrothers.com/anemone-sylphide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flower arrangements - Long-lasting, striking blooms perfect for bouquets","claim":true},{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/anemone-sylphide-bulbs-uk","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the cut blooms last well in the vase, so you'll have a supply of cut flowers every year","claim":true}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"anemone-sylphide","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-coronaria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Black Walnut Deer Drought Rabbits","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"anemone-sylphide","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-coronaria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/anemone-sylphide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The blossoms open wide to show off amazing, blue-black centers that bees and butterflies can't resist.","claim":true},{"name":"Terra Ceia Farms","url":"https://www.terraceiafarms.com/anemone-coronaria-sylphide.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This Windflower thrives in hardy zones 7-10, repels deer and rabbit, and attracts pollinators.","claim":true},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/anemone-de-caen-sylphide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Loved by pollinators","claim":true},{"name":"Jamieson Brothers","url":"https://www.jamiesonbrothers.com/anemone-sylphide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Their charming blooms attract bees and butterflies, adding beauty and biodiversity to your outdoor space.","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"angel-face","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1],"union":[0.82,1.22],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/angel-face","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 3' x 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/floribundas-small-landscape-shrubs/angel-face/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 3-4ft","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/angel-face-bush/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":3},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"angel-face","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.61,1],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/angel-face","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 3' x 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/floribundas-small-landscape-shrubs/angel-face/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 2-3ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":3},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"angel-face","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-10","6-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/angel-face","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 5-10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/angel-face-bush/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone: 6-9","zones":[6,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":3},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"angel-face","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/angel-face","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun Requires 6+ hours of direct sunlight to thrive.","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"angel-face","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["strong","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/angel-face","https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/floribundas-small-landscape-shrubs/angel-face/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/angel-face","https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/angel-face-bush/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/angel-face","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Her 3½” flowers are blessed with the most wonderful and intense perfume for a Floribunda, exuding a captivating sweet citrus fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/floribundas-small-landscape-shrubs/angel-face/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Loads of ruffled lavender blossoms permeate the air with the strong perfume of sweet citrus flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/angel-face-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"That said, it is still a very good lavender floribunda for fragrance, performance, and charm.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"angel-face","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/angel-face","https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/angel-face-bush/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/angel-face","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets and floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/angel-face-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Uses: Good for cutting , Good for pots , Spreading","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"angel-face","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"angel-face","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/angel-face","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator Friendly Attracts bees, butterflies, and other beneficial insects that support a healthy garden.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"angelonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.45,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"typically in the South, angelonias will get 1½ to 3 feet tall and 1 foot wide\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"By the end of the season, the plants should reach eighteen to twenty-four inches tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 12-24 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height:\n14 - 18 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"angelonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.75 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 8 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"typically in the South, angelonias will get 1½ to 3 feet tall and 1 foot wide\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread:\n12 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"angelonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b444","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 9 to 11","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/angelonia-angustifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Angelonia_angustifolia.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone:\nzones 9 - 11","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"angelonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b444","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/angelonia-angustifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/angelonias-summer-snapdragons/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Angelonias perform best in full sun and are exceptionally drought tolerant."},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/angelonia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"plant angelonia in late spring in a spot that receives full sun and has moist, well-drained soil"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=3&PlantTypeID=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Full Sun"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Angelonia_angustifolia.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun:\nfull sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"angelonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/angelonia-angustifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/angelonias-summer-snapdragons/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"long rows of softly fragrant blooms that gradually open over several weeks","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"angelonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/angelonia-angustifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/angelonias-summer-snapdragons/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"angelonias make splendid cut flowers with their tall straight stems covered with long rows of softly fragrant blooms","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/angelonia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Angelonia also makes a good cut flower, lasting for a long time and producing a pleasant grape-soda scent.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"angelonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b444","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/angelonia-angustifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Heat and drought tolerant. Resistant to phytophthora fungus.","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/angelonias-summer-snapdragons/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Angelonias perform best in full sun and are exceptionally drought tolerant.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/angelonia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, these plants can be quite drought-tolerant, especially if the soil is rich in organic material and a layer of mulch has been added.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"angelonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annabelle","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.5,1.52],"union":[0.91,2.5],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249034","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/63034/hydrangea-arborescens-annabelle/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annabelle","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.5,1.83],"union":[1.22,2.5],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249034","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/63034/hydrangea-arborescens-annabelle/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annabelle","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249034","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 to 9","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annabelle","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249034","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part shade"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/63034/hydrangea-arborescens-annabelle/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annabelle","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annabelle","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","nearMiss":["cut flowers"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249034","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the row carries [\"cut flowers\"], which nothing in the product reads: hasTag is an equality test against \"cut flower\"","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annabelle","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249034","country":null,"form":null,"value":"intolerant of drought","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annabelle","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annabelle","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"botanicalName","current":"Hydrangea arborescens 'Annabelle'","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"IPNI (Kew)","url":"https://www.ipni.org/api/1/search?q=Hydrangea%20arborescens","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hydrangea arborescens L., family Hydrangeaceae, rank spec., IPNI id 30010549-2. Confirms the genus and species are validly published. POWO itself could not be read this session: https://powo.science.kew.org/api/2/search returned HTTP 403, so this is Kew's nomenclatural index rather than a POWO acceptance statement."},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/63034/hydrangea-arborescens-annabelle/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Accepted. RHS prints the name as Hydrangea arborescens 'Annabelle', lists no synonyms, and gives it an Award of Garden Merit. This is the registry hit for the CULTIVAR epithet."}],"note":"name resolves as Hydrangea arborescens 'Annabelle'","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annual-phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":9,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.50 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 3 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plants grow 6 to 15 inches tall, depending on cultivar and bloom profusely for their relatively short season.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Size Notes: 6-20 inches tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The flowers are clustered at the terminal end of the flowering stem which can vary from 6 – 15 (20) inches tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 14 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 8-20″\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: Up to 1 ft.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annual-phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.50 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annual-phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-11","1-12","3-10","1-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b735","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-drummondii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[2,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"Everwilde Farms","url":"https://www.everwilde.com/store/Phlox-drummondii-mixed-WildFlower-Seed.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12","zones":[1,12],"level":"species"},{"name":"BBB Seed","url":"https://bbbseed.com/product/phlox-annual-phlox-drummondii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3-10","zones":[3,10],"level":"species"},{"name":"Vermont Wildflower Farm","url":"https://www.vermontwildflowerfarm.com/products/drummond-phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 1 through 10","zones":[1,10],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annual-phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b735","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-drummondii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PHDR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/73455/phlox-drummondii/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Everwilde Farms","url":"https://www.everwilde.com/store/Phlox-drummondii-mixed-WildFlower-Seed.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annual-phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b735","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-drummondii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/phlox/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are fragrant, 1 inch wide in white, red, magenta, lavender, or pink and usually have a lighter-colored “eye” in the center.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Everwilde Farms","url":"https://www.everwilde.com/store/Phlox-drummondii-mixed-WildFlower-Seed.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bearing clusters of lovely, fragrant flowers, this popular mix blooms in pink, red, rose, purple, and white.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["phlox drummondii"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (phlox drummondii), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (phlox drummondii) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"annual-phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-drummondii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/73455/phlox-drummondii/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Has long, branching, wiry stems, very suited as a cut flower","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Everwilde Farms","url":"https://www.everwilde.com/store/Phlox-drummondii-mixed-WildFlower-Seed.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: Attracts Pollinators, Hummingbirds, Aromatic, Cut Flowers, Deer Resistant","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["phlox drummondii"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (phlox drummondii), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (phlox drummondii) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"annual-phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b735","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates some soil dryness.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-drummondii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"USDA Forest Service (Plant of the Week)","url":"https://www.fs.usda.gov/managing-land/wildflowers/plant-of-the-week/phlox-drummondii","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Easy to grow, and somewhat heat and drought-tolerant, it is robust in cool summer climates, and can bloom throughout the summer.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Everwilde Farms","url":"https://www.everwilde.com/store/Phlox-drummondii-mixed-WildFlower-Seed.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Mature plants tolerate occasional drought, though they prefer moist soil and will benefit from watering in dry weather.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annual-phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b735","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-drummondii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds. The species is pollinated almost exclusively by Battus philenor, the pipevine swallowtail.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PHDR","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Nectar Source: yes","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"USDA Forest Service (Plant of the Week)","url":"https://www.fs.usda.gov/managing-land/wildflowers/plant-of-the-week/phlox-drummondii","country":null,"form":null,"value":"provides a good source of nectar for visiting butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Everwilde Farms","url":"https://www.everwilde.com/store/Phlox-drummondii-mixed-WildFlower-Seed.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant often reseeds itself, and is highly attractive to bees, hummingbirds, and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["phlox drummondii"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (phlox drummondii), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (phlox drummondii) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"annual-phlox-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0.50 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annual-phlox-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0.50 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annual-phlox-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285429","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2 to 11","zones":[2,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annual-phlox-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285429","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annual-phlox-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285429","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant, trumpet-shaped, five-lobed, rose-red flowers","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annual-phlox-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annual-phlox-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"annual-phlox-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285429","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":12,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 20.00 to 40.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 40 ft. 0 in. - 60 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Eastern arborvitae often grows 40-60 ft. tall, sometimes taller, but under cultivation will probably be no taller than 30 ft.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature height 40-60 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Conifer, evergreen tree/shrub, to 40 ft (12 m) high, broad pyramidal, branches erect and out spreading, densely crowded.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 20 to 40 ft\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page's figure is a final size and this row's is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"They are slow growing and not too tall at maturity commonly 40-50 feet.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"their natural height of 50 to 60 feet can become unmanageable in residential gardens\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"The American arborvitae is a dense, broad-pyramidal evergreen tree reaching heights of 40' to 60'.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Height: 25'-45'\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Northern white-cedar is a medium-sized tree, commonly 12 to 15 m (40 to 50 ft) tall and 30 to 60 cm (12 to 24 in) in d.b.h. at maturity.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 12 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 10.00 to 15.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 10 ft. 0 in. - 15 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature width 10-15 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 10 to 15 ft\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page's figure is a final size and this row's is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-7","3-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c246","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 7","zones":[2,7],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[3,7],"level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/eastern-arborvitae/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones Zone 3, Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7","zones":[3,7],"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Trees","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/northern-white-cedar-thuja-occidentalis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 2 to 7","zones":[2,7],"level":"species"},{"name":"UConn Home & Garden Education Center","url":"https://homegarden.cahnr.uconn.edu/factsheets/arborvitae/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is hardy in USDA zones 2 through 7.","zones":[2,7],"level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/thuja-occidentalis-american-arborvitae","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 7","zones":[3,7],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c246","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=THOC2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade , Shade","level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/eastern-arborvitae/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily)","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Trees","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/northern-white-cedar-thuja-occidentalis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The white-cedar prefers cooler sites that experience full sun to partial shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/665","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/the-mighty-arborvitae","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Arborvitaes grow best in full sun, though they can take some light shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/thuja-occidentalis-american-arborvitae","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species"},{"name":"NDSU Extension","url":"https://www.ndsu.edu/agriculture/extension/publications/american-arborvitae","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full sun to partial shade.","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c246","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Scale-like, aromatic, yellow-green to green foliage appears in flattened sprays.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=THOC2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Foliage: yes","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Trees","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/northern-white-cedar-thuja-occidentalis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The white cedar has a pleasant, aromatic scent when crushed.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/the-mighty-arborvitae","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The leaves are flat, scaly, and arranged in fan-like clusters; they give off a pleasant citrusy scent when crushed.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"arborvitae","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c246","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bloom Description: Non-flowering","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Description: Conifer, non-flowering.","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c246","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Intolerant of dry conditions.","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It does not tolerate dry or exposed, windy sites; the foliage can become winter-burned (yellow-brown).","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=THOC2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerance: High","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/eastern-arborvitae/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance Moderately tolerant","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"When established it can withstand considerable heat and drought.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Trees","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/northern-white-cedar-thuja-occidentalis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It will tolerate dry sites and road salts.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/the-mighty-arborvitae","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are not drought-tolerant and may need irrigation during dry spells.","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"4 source(s) state this trait and 3 deny it","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c246","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bloom Time: Non-flowering","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Description: Conifer, non-flowering.","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=THOC2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"3 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-danica","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Cornell University Woody Plants Database","url":"https://woodyplants.cals.cornell.edu/cultivar/12115","country":"US","form":null,"value":"'Danica' - dwarf, dense, squat-bun form; emerald-green foliage keeps its color even in winter; resembles a dwarf Chamaecyparis obtusa; grows to 12\" tall x 16\" wide in 10 years","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"}],"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"'Danica' is a slow-growing, dense, globular, evergreen shrub that grows to only 20\" tall and as wide in the first 20 years.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-danica","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Cornell University Woody Plants Database","url":"https://woodyplants.cals.cornell.edu/cultivar/12115","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows to 12\" tall x 16\" wide in 10 years","metres":0.41,"band":[0.37,0.45],"role":"scored"}],"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"'Danica' is a slow-growing, dense, globular, evergreen shrub that grows to only 20\" tall and as wide in the first 20 years.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-danica","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-7","3-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=267837","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 7","zones":[2,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[3,7]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-danica","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=267837","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"University of Connecticut Plant Database (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plantdatabase.uconn.edu/detail.php?pid=500","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun; partial shade is tolerated but plants become thin, open and much less appealing"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-danica","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=267837","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Scale-like, aromatic, yellow-green to green foliage appears in flattened sprays.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-danica","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-danica","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=267837","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Intolerant of dry conditions.","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-danica","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-emerald-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/75683/thuja-occidentalis-smaragd/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Time to Maturity 10-20 years Max Spread 1.5-2.5 metres Max Height 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored"}],"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 12.00 to 14.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page's figure is a final size and this row's is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Height: 20-25 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-emerald-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 3.00 to 4.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page's figure is a final size and this row's is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Spread: 3-5 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Max Spread 1.5-2.5 metres\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-emerald-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-7","3-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254004","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 7","zones":[2,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[3,7]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-emerald-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254004","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/673/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/emerald-arborvitae-thuja-occidentalis-smaragd","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/75683/thuja-occidentalis-smaragd/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-emerald-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254004","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Scale-like, aromatic, yellow-green to green foliage appears in flattened sprays.","claim":true},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/emerald-arborvitae-thuja-occidentalis-smaragd","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Foliage: Emerald green, aromatic","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-emerald-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-emerald-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254004","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Intolerant of dry conditions.","claim":false},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/emerald-arborvitae-thuja-occidentalis-smaragd","country":null,"form":null,"value":"are tolerant of drought once they are established","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-emerald-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-golden-globe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Conifer Society Conifer Database","url":"https://conifersociety.org/conifers/thuja-occidentalis-golden-globe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"After 10 years of growth, a mature specimen will measure 3 feet (1 m) tall and wide, an annual growth rateo of 3 to 4 inches (7.5 - 10 cm).","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 2.00 to 4.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Conifer, evergreen shrub, dwarf, to 3-5 ft (0.9-1.5 m) tall and wide, globose form without shearing, soft yellow needle color.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-golden-globe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Conifer Society Conifer Database","url":"https://conifersociety.org/conifers/thuja-occidentalis-golden-globe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"After 10 years of growth, a mature specimen will measure 3 feet (1 m) tall and wide, an annual growth rateo of 3 to 4 inches (7.5 - 10 cm).","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 2.00 to 4.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Conifer, evergreen shrub, dwarf, to 3-5 ft (0.9-1.5 m) tall and wide, globose form without shearing, soft yellow needle color.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-golden-globe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-8","3-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253997","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 8","zones":[2,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[3,7]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-golden-globe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253997","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis-golden-globe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun or part shade, well-drained soil."},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-golden-globe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253997","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Scale-like, aromatic, yellow-green to green foliage appears in flattened sprays.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-golden-globe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-golden-globe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253997","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Intolerant of dry conditions.","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-golden-globe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-green-giant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":12,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":8,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 40 ft. 0 in. - 60 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 40.00 to 60.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page's figure is a 10 to 10 year size and this row's is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Size: 45’ tall x 12’ wide\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Green Giant arborvitae is a big, fast-growing evergreen that will probably top out at around 60 feet tall but with a basal spread of around 15 to 20 feet.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Size: Up to 12’ height and 4’ width - trimmed\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Height : 30-50 ft.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Height: 20-40 ft\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-green-giant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":8,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 12 ft. 0 in. - 18 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 12.00 to 18.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page's figure is a 10 to 10 year size and this row's is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Size: 45’ tall x 12’ wide\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Green Giant arborvitae is a big, fast-growing evergreen that will probably top out at around 60 feet tall but with a basal spread of around 15 to 20 feet.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Size: Up to 12’ height and 4’ width - trimmed\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Width : 12-15 ft.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Width: 6-12 ft\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-green-giant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thuja 'Green Giant')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-green-giant/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Thuja 'Green Giant')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254365","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"InstantHedge (Green Giant Arborvitae)","url":"https://www.instanthedge.com/green-giant-arborvitae/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 5 - 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees (Thuja Green Giant)","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/thuja-green-giant","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In Zones : 5-8 outdoors","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Tree Center (Thuja Green Giant)","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/thuja-green-giant/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In: Zones 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-green-giant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thuja 'Green Giant')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-green-giant/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Thuja 'Green Giant')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254365","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Plant Database (Green Giant Arborvitae)","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-database/shrubs/green-giant-arborvitae.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: full sun to partial shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Plant of the Week (Green Giant Arborvitae)","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/green-giant-arborvitae-1-27-06.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows best in full sun in a wide range of soil conditions.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"InstantHedge (Green Giant Arborvitae)","url":"https://www.instanthedge.com/green-giant-arborvitae/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun/Shade: Full Sun to Full Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees (Thuja Green Giant)","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/thuja-green-giant","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight : Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Tree Center (Thuja Green Giant)","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/thuja-green-giant/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs : Full Sun, Partial Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-green-giant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thuja 'Green Giant')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-green-giant/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-green-giant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-green-giant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thuja 'Green Giant')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-green-giant/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It resists most diseases, insects, periodic droughts, and deer.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Thuja 'Green Giant')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254365","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates somewhat wide range of soils and some dry conditions.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Plant of the Week (Green Giant Arborvitae)","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/green-giant-arborvitae-1-27-06.aspx","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, Green Giant has good drought tolerance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"InstantHedge (Green Giant Arborvitae)","url":"https://www.instanthedge.com/green-giant-arborvitae/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerance: Moderate","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees (Thuja Green Giant)","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/thuja-green-giant","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They're drought tolerant and have no significant insect or disease problems.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-green-giant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-holmstrup","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Conifer Society conifer database","url":"https://conifersociety.org/conifers/thuja-occidentalis-holmstrup/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"After 10 years of growth, a mature specimen will measure 6 to 10 feet (2 - 3 m) tall and 2.5 feet (80 cm) wide, an annual growth rate of 8 to 12 inches (20 - 30 cm).","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored"}],"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"It is a slow-growing cultivar that grows to 5-8' tall over the first 10 years, eventually maturing to as much as 10-15' over time.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"This shrub is slow growing and will take 10 years to reach 10 feet tall and 2.5 feet wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"It is a slow-growing cultivar that reaches 8' in the first 10 years, eventually maturing to a dense narrow-pyramid of 10-15 in height'.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-holmstrup","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Conifer Society conifer database","url":"https://conifersociety.org/conifers/thuja-occidentalis-holmstrup/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"After 10 years of growth, a mature specimen will measure 6 to 10 feet (2 - 3 m) tall and 2.5 feet (80 cm) wide, an annual growth rate of 8 to 12 inches (20 - 30 cm).","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored"}],"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 3.00 to 5.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"This shrub is slow growing and will take 10 years to reach 10 feet tall and 2.5 feet wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-holmstrup","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-7","2-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264031","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 7","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis-holmstrup/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/thuja-occidentalis-holmstrup-holmstrup-arborvitae","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 2 - 8","zones":[2,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-holmstrup","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264031","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis-holmstrup/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows well in full sun, partial shade, or dappled sunlight."},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/thuja-occidentalis-holmstrup-holmstrup-arborvitae","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It prefers moist, well-drained loams in full sun to part shade."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-holmstrup","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264031","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Scale-like, aromatic, yellow-green to green foliage appears in flattened sprays.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis-holmstrup/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The foliage has an attractive fragrance.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-holmstrup","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-holmstrup","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264031","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Intolerant of dry conditions.","claim":false},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis-holmstrup/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is not drought tolerant.","claim":false},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/thuja-occidentalis-holmstrup-holmstrup-arborvitae","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is not fussy about soil pH but is intolerant of dry conditions.","claim":false}],"note":"3 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-holmstrup","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-techny","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":4.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 10.00 to 15.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page's figure is a final size and this row's is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"'Techny' is a compact, dwarf cultivar that matures to a 10-15' tall pyramid.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Height: 25-30 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-techny","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 6.00 to 10.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page's figure is a final size and this row's is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Spread: 10-15 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-techny","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-8","3-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254006","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 8","zones":[2,8]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/thuja-occidentalis-techny-techny-arborvitae","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 2 - 8","zones":[2,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, sun and zones only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[3,7]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-techny","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254006","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Purdue University)","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/674/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/thuja-occidentalis-techny-techny-arborvitae","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It prefers moist, well-drained loams in full sun to part shade."},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, sun and zones only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thuja-occidentalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery (Wisconsin) knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/techny-arborvitae-thuja-occidentalis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-techny","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254006","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Scale-like, aromatic, yellow-green to green foliage appears in flattened sprays.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-techny","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-techny","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254006","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Intolerant of dry conditions.","claim":false},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/thuja-occidentalis-techny-techny-arborvitae","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is not fussy about soil pH but is intolerant of dry conditions.","claim":false},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery (Wisconsin) knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/techny-arborvitae-thuja-occidentalis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Thuja occidentalis are tolerant of drought once they are established.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"arborvitae-techny","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"aster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,1.52],"union":[0.15,2.13],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Symphyotrichum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.52],"band":[0.61,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (genus, Aster Symphyotrichum spp.)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/asters/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"There are numerous species that range in size from 6 inches to 7 feet tall, many of which are native to North America.","metres":[0.15,2.13],"band":[0.15,2.13],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":13,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":13},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 13 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"aster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Symphyotrichum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.52],"band":[0.61,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":13},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"aster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":12,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":13},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 12 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"aster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Symphyotrichum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Asters do best in full sun, which promotes flowering and plant growth, but will tolerate some light shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae)","url":"https://missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b540","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Symphyotrichum novi-belgii)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=371788&isprofile=0&gen=Symphyotrichum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum novi-belgii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j490","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Symphyotrichum laeve)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g420","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum laeve"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Symphyotrichum ericoides)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j480","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum ericoides"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (genus, Aster Symphyotrichum spp.)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/asters/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Asters are easy to grow in full sun or part shade in moist, well-drained soil.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Penn State Extension (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae, New England aster)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/rain-garden-plants-new-england-aster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Sun/partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"Penn State Extension (Symphyotrichum laeve, smooth aster)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/rain-garden-plants-smooth-aster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Sun/partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum laeve"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=syno2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in the full sun with well-drained soil.","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum pilosum)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/symphyotrichum-pilosum-hairy-aster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It should be planted in full sun and well-drained soil.","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum pilosum"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Symphyotrichum lateriflorum)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=899&PlantTypeID=14","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial shade; moist well drained soils.","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum lateriflorum"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae-new-england-aster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Popular with pollinators, it thrives in full sun or light shade in all but the driest soils.","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"aster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["symphyotrichum oblongifolium"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (symphyotrichum oblongifolium), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (symphyotrichum oblongifolium) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"aster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy deep pink-purple flowers are attractive to wildlife including bees and butterflies and also make great cut flowers for arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j490","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Symphyotrichum ericoides)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j480","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum ericoides"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"aster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j490","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Symphyotrichum laeve)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g420","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum laeve"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Symphyotrichum ericoides)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j480","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum ericoides"},{"name":"Penn State Extension (Symphyotrichum laeve, smooth aster)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/rain-garden-plants-smooth-aster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soil: Dry, shallow-rocky; tolerates drought, erosion","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum laeve"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant is resistant to browsing by deer and rabbits and is both drought-tolerant and tolerant of coastal conditions.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum pilosum)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/symphyotrichum-pilosum-hairy-aster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, it is both heat and drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum pilosum"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae-new-england-aster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"New England Aster is drought-tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"aster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Symphyotrichum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae)","url":"https://missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b540","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy deep pink-purple flowers are attractive to wildlife including bees and butterflies and also make great cut flowers for arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Symphyotrichum novi-belgii)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=371788&isprofile=0&gen=Symphyotrichum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The blooms are attractive to butterflies and other insect pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum novi-belgii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j490","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Symphyotrichum laeve)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g420","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum laeve"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Symphyotrichum ericoides)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j480","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum ericoides"},{"name":"Penn State Extension (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae, New England aster)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/rain-garden-plants-new-england-aster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"Penn State Extension (Symphyotrichum laeve, smooth aster)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/rain-garden-plants-smooth-aster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum laeve"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=syno2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees and butterflies frequent this wildflower. Nectar source for Monarch butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#pollinator plant #NC native #food source nectar #food source pollen","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae-new-england-aster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees and butterflies are attracted to it, and the nectar of the flower provides an excellent source for Monarchs and other butterflies late into the fall.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"}],"note":"12 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"aster-october-skies","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium 'October Skies')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271326","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center (October Skies Aromatic Aster)","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/october-skies-aromatic-aster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exhibiting a compact and mounding habit, it is densely branched and grows 1-2’ tall and easily spreads to 3’ wide.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Aster oblongifolius 'October Skies')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-oblongifolius-october-skies/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants grow up to 15” tall with 30” spread.","metres":0.38,"band":[0.34,0.42],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"US Perennials (Aster oblongifolius 'October Skies')","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aster-oblongifolius-october-skies-aromatic-aster-october-skies/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 1.5-2' tall x 2-2.5' wide","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"aster-october-skies","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.68,0.76],"union":[0.46,1],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium 'October Skies')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271326","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center (October Skies Aromatic Aster)","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/october-skies-aromatic-aster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"easily spreads to 3’ wide","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Aster oblongifolius 'October Skies')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-oblongifolius-october-skies/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants grow up to 15” tall with 30” spread.","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"US Perennials (Aster oblongifolius 'October Skies')","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aster-oblongifolius-october-skies-aromatic-aster-october-skies/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 1.5-2' tall x 2-2.5' wide","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"aster-october-skies","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","5-8","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium 'October Skies')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271326","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center (October Skies Aromatic Aster)","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/october-skies-aromatic-aster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 5-8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium 'October Skies')","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium-october-skies-october-skies-aromatic","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Aster oblongifolius 'October Skies')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-oblongifolius-october-skies/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants are hardy from USDA Zones 5-8.","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"US Perennials (Aster oblongifolius 'October Skies')","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aster-oblongifolius-october-skies-aromatic-aster-october-skies/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"aster-october-skies","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium 'October Skies')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271326","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center (October Skies Aromatic Aster)","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/october-skies-aromatic-aster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"October Skies aromatic aster thrives in full sun in dry to moist, well-drained soil, and is capable of a decent floral display even in a part sun site.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium 'October Skies')","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium-october-skies-october-skies-aromatic","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Aster oblongifolius 'October Skies')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-oblongifolius-october-skies/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Aster oblongifolius ‘October Skies’ grows best in full sun but will tolerate partly shaded areas that have at least a half day of sun.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292653","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium, Aromatic Aster)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/symphiotrichum-oblongifolium-aromatic-aster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun and drier soils are preferred but average soil is tolerated if it drains well.","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"aster-october-skies","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium 'October Skies')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271326","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center (October Skies Aromatic Aster)","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/october-skies-aromatic-aster/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The blue green foliage is sticky and releases an herbal aroma when rubbed","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium 'October Skies')","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium-october-skies-october-skies-aromatic","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The leaves are fragrant when crushed","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Aster oblongifolius 'October Skies')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-oblongifolius-october-skies/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Clay Soil, Cut Flower, Dried Flower, Drought Tolerant, Fragrant, Ground Cover","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"US Perennials (Aster oblongifolius 'October Skies')","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aster-oblongifolius-october-skies-aromatic-aster-october-skies/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Crushed or rubbed leaves have a pleasant aroma.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292653","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium, Aromatic Aster)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/symphiotrichum-oblongifolium-aromatic-aster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Despite the name, the flowers have no aroma, but the leaves do when crushed.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"aster-october-skies","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium 'October Skies')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271326","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Aster oblongifolius 'October Skies')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-oblongifolius-october-skies/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Clay Soil, Cut Flower, Dried Flower, Drought Tolerant, Fragrant, Ground Cover","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"US Perennials (Aster oblongifolius 'October Skies')","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aster-oblongifolius-october-skies-aromatic-aster-october-skies/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"makes a great cut flower and is an herb too","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292653","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"aster-october-skies","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium 'October Skies')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271326","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center (October Skies Aromatic Aster)","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/october-skies-aromatic-aster/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"is an easy care and drought-tolerant herbaceous perennial","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Aster oblongifolius 'October Skies')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-oblongifolius-october-skies/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Clay Soil, Cut Flower, Dried Flower, Drought Tolerant, Fragrant, Ground Cover","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"US Perennials (Aster oblongifolius 'October Skies')","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aster-oblongifolius-october-skies-aromatic-aster-october-skies/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"is deer and rabbit resistant, black walnut, drought, and heat tolerant, and a virtually no-care plant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant is resistant to browsing by deer and rabbits and is both drought-tolerant and tolerant of coastal conditions.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292653","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"aster-october-skies","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium 'October Skies')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271326","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center (October Skies Aromatic Aster)","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/october-skies-aromatic-aster/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"provide a late season nectar source for butterflies and bees, making this aster ideal for a pollinator garden","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium 'October Skies')","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium-october-skies-october-skies-aromatic","country":null,"form":null,"value":"are magnets for butterflies and bees still seeking nectar and pollen at the end of the blooming season","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Aster oblongifolius 'October Skies')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-oblongifolius-october-skies/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The prolific flowers are large, showy and attractive to bees, skippers and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"US Perennials (Aster oblongifolius 'October Skies')","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aster-oblongifolius-october-skies-aromatic-aster-october-skies/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"provides an important, late source of nectar for butterflies, including monarchs as they migrate back to Mexico","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum oblongifolium)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292653","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"aster-professor-kippenberg","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.46],"union":[0.27,0.61],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271334","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-aster-new-york-professor-kippenberg","country":"US","form":null,"value":"16-24\" tall x 18-24\" wide.","metres":[0.41,0.61],"band":[0.41,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/340425/symphyotrichum-novi-belgii-professor-anton-kippenberg/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"A clump-forming herbaceous perennial, up to 45cm high, with lance-shaped green leaves.","metres":0.45,"band":[0.41,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ASTPK","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12.0 Inches","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"aster-professor-kippenberg","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.34,0.42],"union":[0.1,0.61],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271334","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-aster-new-york-professor-kippenberg","country":"US","form":null,"value":"16-24\" tall x 18-24\" wide.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/340425/symphyotrichum-novi-belgii-professor-anton-kippenberg/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ASTPK","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 15.0 Inches","metres":0.38,"band":[0.34,0.42],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"aster-professor-kippenberg","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271334","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-novi-belgii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-aster-new-york-professor-kippenberg","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones Zone 4 Zone 5 Zone 6 Zone 7 Zone 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ASTPK","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"aster-professor-kippenberg","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271334","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-novi-belgii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-aster-new-york-professor-kippenberg","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/340425/symphyotrichum-novi-belgii-professor-anton-kippenberg/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ASTPK","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"aster-professor-kippenberg","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"aster-professor-kippenberg","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-aster-new-york-professor-kippenberg","http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ASTPK"]}],"sources":[{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-aster-new-york-professor-kippenberg","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Low Maintenance Cut Flowers Deer Resistant","claim":true},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ASTPK","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Border Plant Container Cut Flower Cut Foliage Mass Planting Salt Tolerant","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"aster-professor-kippenberg","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271334","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Easily grown in evenly moist to wet, well-drained soil in full sun.","claim":false},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-aster-new-york-professor-kippenberg","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water Tolerance Low-Water","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"aster-professor-kippenberg","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271334","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-aster-new-york-professor-kippenberg","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This is an essential late-season source of nectar for our treasured butterfly and bee pollinators!","claim":true},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ASTPK","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"aster-purple-dome","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.55,0.61],"union":[0.46,0.67],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271321","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center (Purple Dome New England Aster, the introducer)","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/purple-dome-new-england-aster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"is a refined plant for the garden border with its symmetrical, compact mounded form reaching only 2' tall","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Aster novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-novae-angliae-purple-dome/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height : 2 ft","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"},{"name":"Gertens (Aster, New England 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.gertens.com/purple-dome-aster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24 inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"},{"name":"The Pollen Nation (Aster novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.thepollennation.com/aster-novae-angliae-purple-dome-new-england-aster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 feet","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"},{"name":"Northwest Blooms (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.northwestblooms.com/perennials/p/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae-purple-dome","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18 to 24 inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":1,"genus":2},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"aster-purple-dome","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.67],"union":[0.55,0.91],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271321","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"Gertens (Aster, New England 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.gertens.com/purple-dome-aster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24 inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"},{"name":"The Pollen Nation (Aster novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.thepollennation.com/aster-novae-angliae-purple-dome-new-england-aster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2-3 feet, forming low mounding colonies from underground rhizomes","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"},{"name":"Northwest Blooms (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.northwestblooms.com/perennials/p/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae-purple-dome","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 24 to 36 inches","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":1,"genus":2},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"aster-purple-dome","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","3-8","3-9","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271321","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center (Purple Dome New England Aster, the introducer)","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/purple-dome-new-england-aster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 5-8.","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Aster novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-novae-angliae-purple-dome/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants are hardy from USDA Zones 3-8.","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"},{"name":"Gertens (Aster, New England 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.gertens.com/purple-dome-aster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"},{"name":"The Pollen Nation (Aster novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.thepollennation.com/aster-novae-angliae-purple-dome-new-england-aster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"},{"name":"Northwest Blooms (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.northwestblooms.com/perennials/p/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae-purple-dome","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing zone: USDA zones 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":1,"genus":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"aster-purple-dome","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271321","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Aster novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-novae-angliae-purple-dome/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"},{"name":"Gertens (Aster, New England 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.gertens.com/purple-dome-aster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: full sun to partials shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"},{"name":"The Pollen Nation (Aster novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.thepollennation.com/aster-novae-angliae-purple-dome-new-england-aster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"},{"name":"Northwest Blooms (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.northwestblooms.com/perennials/p/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae-purple-dome","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirements: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Symphyotrichum, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Asters do best in full sun, which promotes flowering and plant growth, but will tolerate some light shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"symphyotrichum"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Asters)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/asters/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Asters are easy to grow in full sun or part shade in moist, well-drained soil.","level":"genus","taxon":"symphyotrichum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"aster-purple-dome","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"The Pollen Nation (Aster novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.thepollennation.com/aster-novae-angliae-purple-dome-new-england-aster/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attributes: cut flower, provides late season nectar source for migrating monarch butterflies, groundcover, fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"aster-purple-dome","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271321","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Aster novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-novae-angliae-purple-dome/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower, Dried Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"},{"name":"Gertens (Aster, New England 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.gertens.com/purple-dome-aster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"},{"name":"The Pollen Nation (Aster novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.thepollennation.com/aster-novae-angliae-purple-dome-new-england-aster/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attributes: cut flower, provides late season nectar source for migrating monarch butterflies, groundcover, fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"aster-purple-dome","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center (Purple Dome New England Aster, the introducer)","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/purple-dome-new-england-aster/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Purple Dome New England aster grows in sun to filtered shade and performs best in moist, well-drained soil, though it is tolerant of short dry periods.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"Gertens (Aster, New England 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.gertens.com/purple-dome-aster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It prefers to grow in average to moist conditions, and shouldn't be allowed to dry out.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"aster-purple-dome","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271321","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Aster novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-novae-angliae-purple-dome/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers provide a valuable late season nectar source for migrating Monarch butterflies. Blooms are also visited by other butterflies, skippers and bees.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"},{"name":"Gertens (Aster, New England 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.gertens.com/purple-dome-aster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies to your yard, but is not particularly attractive to deer who tend to leave it alone in favor of tastier treats.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"},{"name":"The Pollen Nation (Aster novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.thepollennation.com/aster-novae-angliae-purple-dome-new-england-aster/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wildlife: butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster novae-angliae"},{"name":"Northwest Blooms (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae 'Purple Dome')","url":"https://www.northwestblooms.com/perennials/p/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae-purple-dome","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife attractors: Attracts bees, butterflies and other pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Symphyotrichum novae-angliae)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy deep pink-purple flowers are attractive to wildlife including bees and butterflies and also make great cut flowers for arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum novae-angliae"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Symphyotrichum, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"symphyotrichum"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"aster-raydons-favorite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.61,1],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271327&isprofile=0&gen=Symphyotrichum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It has a strikingly beautiful mounded appearance with masses of violet-blue, daisy-like flowers on 2-3' tall multi-stemmed plants in mid to late autumn.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium-raydons-favorite-raydons-favorite","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Aromatic aster 'Raydon's Favorite' is a mounded perennial that reaches a maximum size of 3 three feet.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/AsteroblongifoliusRaydonsFavorite","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2-3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster-raydons-favorite/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1 - dense ground covering mounds, completely covered with small blue flowers, about 3' tall and over 3' wide (leave enough room for it)","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants grow up to 3' tall with at least a 3' spread.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 2-3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Pollen Nation","url":"https://www.thepollennation.com/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster oblongifolius"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"aster-raydons-favorite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.27,1],"split":[{"range":[0.27,0.61],"sources":["Plant Addicts","The Pollen Nation","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","North Creek Nurseries"]},{"range":[0.82,1],"sources":["US Perennials","New Moon Nursery"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271327&isprofile=0&gen=Symphyotrichum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/AsteroblongifoliusRaydonsFavorite","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1-2 Feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster-raydons-favorite/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1 - dense ground covering mounds, completely covered with small blue flowers, about 3' tall and over 3' wide (leave enough room for it)","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants grow up to 3' tall with at least a 3' spread.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 1 Foot","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Pollen Nation","url":"https://www.thepollennation.com/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1 foot","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster oblongifolius"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.45},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"aster-raydons-favorite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","5-9","5-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271327&isprofile=0&gen=Symphyotrichum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 3-8.","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium-raydons-favorite-raydons-favorite","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5 - 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/AsteroblongifoliusRaydonsFavorite","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster-raydons-favorite/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy in zones 3 to 8.","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Pollen Nation","url":"https://www.thepollennation.com/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster oblongifolius"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"aster-raydons-favorite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271327&isprofile=0&gen=Symphyotrichum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"prefers full sun in well-drained alkaline to slightly acidic soil","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium-raydons-favorite-raydons-favorite","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/AsteroblongifoliusRaydonsFavorite","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow in full sun in average to dry soil.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun (6+ Hours Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Pollen Nation","url":"https://www.thepollennation.com/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: full sun to partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster oblongifolius"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=SYOB","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade","level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"aster-raydons-favorite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271327&isprofile=0&gen=Symphyotrichum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The common name comes from the balsam-like fragrance it gives off when its rigid stems are crushed.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium-raydons-favorite-raydons-favorite","country":null,"form":null,"value":"it is called aromatic aster because of the sticky, scented glands on the small, narrow leaves","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/AsteroblongifoliusRaydonsFavorite","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In 2016, it was named Plant of the Year by The Garden Club of America because of its more compact form, fragrance, dazzling bright blue flower, and durability in harsh sites.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster-raydons-favorite/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Crushed or rubbed leaves have pleasant aroma.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers have a sweet, balsam-like fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"aster-raydons-favorite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271327&isprofile=0&gen=Symphyotrichum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster-raydons-favorite/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"great cut flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Clay Soil, Cut Flower, Dried Flower, Drought Tolerant, Favorite, Long Blooming, Rain Garden","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"The Pollen Nation","url":"https://www.thepollennation.com/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attributes: cut flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster oblongifolius"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"aster-raydons-favorite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271327&isprofile=0&gen=Symphyotrichum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Generally tolerates poor soils and drought.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant is resistant to browsing by deer and rabbits and is both drought-tolerant and tolerant of coastal conditions.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/AsteroblongifoliusRaydonsFavorite","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster-raydons-favorite/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"very adaptable plant to all the soil types and moisture reaching from dry to medium/moist, tough, drought and heat tolerant perennial.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Clay Soil, Cut Flower, Dried Flower, Drought Tolerant, Favorite, Long Blooming, Rain Garden","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"aster-raydons-favorite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271327&isprofile=0&gen=Symphyotrichum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In fall plants are covered in a profusion of violet blue, daisy-type flowers that attract butterflies and other insect pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#pollinator plant #NC native #food source nectar #food source pollen","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This aster, like many of its relatives, is a preferred nectar source for many butterfly species","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium-raydons-favorite-raydons-favorite","country":null,"form":null,"value":"it produces showy violet blue flowers that attract birds and butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/AsteroblongifoliusRaydonsFavorite","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator-friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster-raydons-favorite/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"important late source of nectar for butterflies, including back to Mexico migrating monarchs","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wildlife Butterflies, Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Raydon's Favorite Aromatic Aster is a favorite of butterflies and other pollinators with its outstanding floral display from late summer into fall.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Pollen Nation","url":"https://www.thepollennation.com/aster-oblongifolius-raydons-favorite-aromatic-aster/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wildlife: butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aster oblongifolius"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=SYOB","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nectar Source: yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"},{"name":"Master Gardeners of Northern Virginia (MGNV)","url":"https://mgnv.org/plants/native-plants/perennials/symphyotrichum-oblongifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dense mounds of showy Aromatic Aster flowers, among the last to bloom before hard frost, attract myriad pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"symphyotrichum oblongifolium"}],"note":"11 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"astilbe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.15,1.67],"split":[{"range":[0.15,1.22],"sources":["Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","The Morton Arboretum"]},{"range":[1.37,1.67],"sources":["Chicago Botanic Garden"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/how-to-grow-and-care-for-astilbe/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants are available in multiple heights; some compact, reaching less than 12 inches tall when in bloom, and others taller, reaching over 3 feet tall.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/growing-astilbe-iowa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Some varieties like 'Sprite' or 'Perkeo' grow only 6 to 12 inches tall (bloom included), while 'Purple Lance' or 'Purple Candles' can reach 4 feet in height.","metres":[0.15,1.22],"band":[0.15,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/astilbe-hybrids/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This perennial is 18 to 36 inches tall and 12 to 18 inches wide.","metres":[0.46,0.91],"band":[0.46,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"For a dramatic statement, the tallest of the genus, Astilbe chinensis var. taquetii 'Superba', grows 4 to 5 feet and features purple-rose flowers.","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":10,"levels":{"species":10,"genus":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/astilbe-hybrids/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This perennial is 18 to 36 inches tall and 12 to 18 inches wide.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"species":10,"genus":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/how-to-grow-and-care-for-astilbe/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant hardiness zones: Astilbes are hardy in zones 3 to 9.","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/astilbe-hybrids/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"genus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy from zones 4 to 8, they are a favored winter-interest plant and many gardeners keep them standing in their dried form.","zones":[4,8],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":10,"levels":{"species":10,"genus":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=371855&isprofile=1&gen=Astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"astilbe japonica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286952&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"astilbe chinensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b580","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"astilbe chinensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242018&isprofile=0&z=5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"astilbe simplicifolia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-x-arendsii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They prefer shady and moist sites. The soil needs to be organically rich and well-drained. The plant may grow in full sun but will require constant moisture.","level":"species","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-japonica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant grows in clumps 1.5 to 2.5 feet tall and wide, requiring partial to full shade and moist, rich, well-drained soils. In cooler summer areas, it will tolerate more sun.","level":"species","taxon":"astilbe japonica"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-biternata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant grows 3 to 6 feet Tall and 2 to 3 feet wide in partial shade to dappled shade.","level":"species","taxon":"astilbe biternata"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/how-to-grow-and-care-for-astilbe/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Grow astilbe in a part shade to shady location. They can tolerate more sun if the soil is moist.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/growing-astilbe-iowa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants grow best in part shade locations, and can do well in full shade, but may have fewer flowers. Astible can also tolerate full sun if provided abundant moisture.","level":"genus"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/astilbe-hybrids/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily), Full shade (4 hrs or less of light daily)","level":"genus"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/chinese-astilbe/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily), Full shade (4 hrs or less of light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"astilbe chinensis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Demanding full to part shade and a ready supply of moisture throughout the season, they are one of the few such plants not bothered by slugs.","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/false-spirea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Partial Sun/Shade","level":"species","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=711&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements\n\nPartial Sun/Shade","level":"species","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=371855&isprofile=1&gen=Astilbe","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe japonica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b580","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe chinensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242018&isprofile=0&z=5","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe simplicifolia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-x-arendsii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The showy flowers are excellent for floral cuttings or use in a dried arrangement.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-japonica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use false spirea in the border of shade, cottage, woodland or cutting gardens.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe japonica"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-biternata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It works well as a background plant in perennial planting beds, in woodland or shade gardens and makes for excellent cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe biternata"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/how-to-grow-and-care-for-astilbe/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers can be cut for arrangements and drying.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/growing-astilbe-iowa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Astilbes also make wonderful cut or dried flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"astilbe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"taxon-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286952&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Although Chinese astilbes have better drought tolerance than most other astilbes, they still do best with uniformly moist soils.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe chinensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242018&isprofile=0&z=5","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soils must not be allowed to dry out.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe simplicifolia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-x-arendsii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In hot summer or periods of drought, the foliage may decline if the soil is not kept moist.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/how-to-grow-and-care-for-astilbe/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The foliage may go dormant in drought.","claim":false,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/growing-astilbe-iowa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Astilbes are unforgiving in dry soils, as the leaves will brown quickly.","claim":false,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/astilbe","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Astilbes can be problematic if planted in strong sun or exposed to drought","claim":false,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["astilbe chinensis"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (astilbe chinensis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"this came out more confident than v6 only once the distinct-taxa rule removed the claim(s) that disagreed, so it is a disagreement about which taxa were speaking rather than a finding; v6 recorded SPLIT; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (astilbe chinensis) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-x-arendsii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The plant attracts butterflies and is resistant to rabbits and deer.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-japonica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe japonica"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-biternata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There is plenty of nectar to attract many pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe biternata"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/astilbe-hybrids/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies are attracted to this plant.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/chinese-astilbe/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies are attracted to the blooms.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe chinensis"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"astilbe-bridal-veil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.64,0.7],"union":[0.46,0.91],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (Astilbe 'Bridal Veil')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBBV","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 28.0 Inches","metres":0.71,"band":[0.64,0.78],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries (Astilbe arendsii Bridal Veil 'Brautschleier')","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Astilbe-arendsii-Bridal-Veil-Brautschleier","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"HEIGHT: 60-70 cm","metres":[0.6,0.7],"band":[0.6,0.7],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (Bridal Veil Astilbe)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bridal-veil-astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 24 - 36 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"The Tree Center (Bridal Veil Astilbe)","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/bridal-veil-astilbe/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 2-3 ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery (Astilbe arendsii (Brautschleier) 'Bridal Veil')","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ASTILBE-ARENDSII-BRIDAL-VEIL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 28 in","metres":0.71,"band":[0.64,0.78],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"North Shore Plant Club (Astilbe Bridal Veil)","url":"https://www.northshoreplantclub.com/plant?ID=7579","country":"US","form":null,"value":"18 - 28 inches tall.","metres":[0.46,0.71],"band":[0.46,0.71],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Bloomin Designs Nursery (Astilbe 'Bridal Veil' ('Brautschleier'))","url":"https://www.bloomindesigns.com/astilbe-bridal-veil-4-1-gallons/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants reach 28 inches tall and 18 to 22 inches wide.","metres":0.71,"band":[0.64,0.78],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":1,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"astilbe-bridal-veil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.5,0.56],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (Astilbe 'Bridal Veil')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBBV","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18.0-22.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.56],"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries (Astilbe arendsii Bridal Veil 'Brautschleier')","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Astilbe-arendsii-Bridal-Veil-Brautschleier","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"SPREAD: 50-60 cm","metres":[0.5,0.6],"band":[0.5,0.6],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (Bridal Veil Astilbe)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bridal-veil-astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 18 - 24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"The Tree Center (Bridal Veil Astilbe)","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/bridal-veil-astilbe/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 1-2 ft","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"North Shore Plant Club (Astilbe Bridal Veil)","url":"https://www.northshoreplantclub.com/plant?ID=7579","country":"US","form":null,"value":"18 - 24 inches wide.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Bloomin Designs Nursery (Astilbe 'Bridal Veil' ('Brautschleier'))","url":"https://www.bloomindesigns.com/astilbe-bridal-veil-4-1-gallons/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants reach 28 inches tall and 18 to 22 inches wide.","metres":[0.46,0.56],"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":1,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"astilbe-bridal-veil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","3-8","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (Astilbe 'Bridal Veil')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBBV","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (Bridal Veil Astilbe)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bridal-veil-astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"The Tree Center (Bridal Veil Astilbe)","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/bridal-veil-astilbe/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In: Zones 4-8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery (Astilbe arendsii (Brautschleier) 'Bridal Veil')","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ASTILBE-ARENDSII-BRIDAL-VEIL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"North Shore Plant Club (Astilbe Bridal Veil)","url":"https://www.northshoreplantclub.com/plant?ID=7579","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 4a - 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Bloomin Designs Nursery (Astilbe 'Bridal Veil' ('Brautschleier'))","url":"https://www.bloomindesigns.com/astilbe-bridal-veil-4-1-gallons/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 4 to 9.","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":1,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"astilbe-bridal-veil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Astilbe x arendsii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-x-arendsii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Astilbe 'Bridal Veil')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBBV","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (Bridal Veil Astilbe)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bridal-veil-astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Partial Shade to Partial Sun (3 - 6 Hours Of Direct Sunlight)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"The Tree Center (Bridal Veil Astilbe)","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/bridal-veil-astilbe/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs : Partial Sun, Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery (Astilbe arendsii (Brautschleier) 'Bridal Veil')","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ASTILBE-ARENDSII-BRIDAL-VEIL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Partial Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"North Shore Plant Club (Astilbe Bridal Veil)","url":"https://www.northshoreplantclub.com/plant?ID=7579","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Partial Sun - Full Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Bloomin Designs Nursery (Astilbe 'Bridal Veil' ('Brautschleier'))","url":"https://www.bloomindesigns.com/astilbe-bridal-veil-4-1-gallons/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to full shade.","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"astilbe-bridal-veil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBBV","https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Astilbe-arendsii-Bridal-Veil-Brautschleier"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (Astilbe 'Bridal Veil')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBBV","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Fragrant Flowers Mass Planting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries (Astilbe arendsii Bridal Veil 'Brautschleier')","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Astilbe-arendsii-Bridal-Veil-Brautschleier","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"astilbe-bridal-veil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Astilbe x arendsii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-x-arendsii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The showy flowers are excellent for floral cuttings or use in a dried arrangement.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Astilbe 'Bridal Veil')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBBV","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Fragrant Flowers Mass Planting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries (Astilbe arendsii Bridal Veil 'Brautschleier')","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Astilbe-arendsii-Bridal-Veil-Brautschleier","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Astilbe 'Bridal Veil' makes an excellent cut flower, fresh or dried","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (Bridal Veil Astilbe)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bridal-veil-astilbe","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features: Attracts Pollinators, Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery (Astilbe arendsii (Brautschleier) 'Bridal Veil')","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ASTILBE-ARENDSII-BRIDAL-VEIL","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage/Fruit","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"astilbe-bridal-veil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Astilbe x arendsii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-x-arendsii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In hot summer or periods of drought, the foliage may decline if the soil is not kept moist.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (Bridal Veil Astilbe)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bridal-veil-astilbe","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates: Drought","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"The Tree Center (Bridal Veil Astilbe)","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/bridal-veil-astilbe/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its only requirement is moisture, and it won't grow in dry soil.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"astilbe-bridal-veil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Astilbe x arendsii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-x-arendsii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Astilbe 'Bridal Veil')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBBV","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (Bridal Veil Astilbe)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bridal-veil-astilbe","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery (Astilbe arendsii (Brautschleier) 'Bridal Veil')","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ASTILBE-ARENDSII-BRIDAL-VEIL","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wildlife Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"astilbe-deutschland","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.76],"union":[0.46,0.76],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241996","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBDE","country":"US","form":null,"value":"24.0-30.0 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-deutschland","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.46,0.61],"union":[0.46,0.61],"proposed":0.54,"margin":13,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241996","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBDE","country":"US","form":null,"value":"18.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.46 to 0.61 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-deutschland","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241996","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-deutschland","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241996","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part shade to full shade"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-deutschland","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-deutschland","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241996","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy, Good Cut","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-deutschland","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241996","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Foliage decline (leaves brown up) may occur in hot summers and/or periods of drought if soils are not kept moist.","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-deutschland","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-fanal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.5,0.51],"union":[0.3,0.67],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Astilbe x arendsii 'Fanal')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242008","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Walters Gardens, Inc. (Astilbe 'Fanal')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBFA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 20.0 Inches","metres":0.51,"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (Fanal Astilbe)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/fanal-astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 18 - 24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center (Fanal Astilbe)","url":"https://www.gertens.com/fanal-astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 22 inches","metres":0.56,"band":[0.5,0.62],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery (Astilbe x arendsii 'Fanal')","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Astilbe-x-arendsii-Fanal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18 Inches","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery (Astilbe arendsii 'Fanal')","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ASTILBE-ARENDSII-FANAL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24 in","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"astilbe-fanal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.23,0.71],"split":[{"range":[0.23,0.33],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Astilbe x arendsii 'Fanal')","Pleasant Run Nursery (Astilbe x arendsii 'Fanal')"]},{"range":[0.46,0.71],"sources":["Walters Gardens, Inc. (Astilbe 'Fanal')","Plant Addicts (Fanal Astilbe)","Gertens Garden Center (Fanal Astilbe)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Astilbe x arendsii 'Fanal')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242008","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Walters Gardens, Inc. (Astilbe 'Fanal')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBFA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18.0-20.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (Fanal Astilbe)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/fanal-astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 18 - 28 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.71],"band":[0.46,0.71],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center (Fanal Astilbe)","url":"https://www.gertens.com/fanal-astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24 inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery (Astilbe x arendsii 'Fanal')","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Astilbe-x-arendsii-Fanal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12 Inches","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"astilbe-fanal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","4-9","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Astilbe x arendsii 'Fanal')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242008","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Walters Gardens, Inc. (Astilbe 'Fanal')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBFA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (Fanal Astilbe)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/fanal-astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center (Fanal Astilbe)","url":"https://www.gertens.com/fanal-astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery (Astilbe arendsii 'Fanal')","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ASTILBE-ARENDSII-FANAL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"astilbe-fanal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Astilbe x arendsii 'Fanal')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242008","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Walters Gardens, Inc. (Astilbe 'Fanal')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBFA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Astilbe x arendsii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-x-arendsii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (Fanal Astilbe)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/fanal-astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Full Shade to Partial Sun (0 - 6 Hours Of Direct Sunlight)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center (Fanal Astilbe)","url":"https://www.gertens.com/fanal-astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: part sun to full shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery (Astilbe x arendsii 'Fanal')","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Astilbe-x-arendsii-Fanal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade/Shade Tolerant","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery (Astilbe arendsii 'Fanal')","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ASTILBE-ARENDSII-FANAL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Partial Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"astilbe-fanal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens, Inc. (Astilbe 'Fanal')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBFA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Fragrant Flowers Mass Planting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"astilbe-fanal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Astilbe x arendsii 'Fanal')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242008","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Walters Gardens, Inc. (Astilbe 'Fanal')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBFA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Fragrant Flowers Mass Planting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Astilbe x arendsii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-x-arendsii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The showy flowers are excellent for floral cuttings or use in a dried arrangement.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (Fanal Astilbe)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/fanal-astilbe","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The deep crimson-red plumes are lovely in cut-flower arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center (Fanal Astilbe)","url":"https://www.gertens.com/fanal-astilbe","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery (Astilbe x arendsii 'Fanal')","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Astilbe-x-arendsii-Fanal","country":null,"form":null,"value":"does best in moist cool sites, and makes a good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery (Astilbe arendsii 'Fanal')","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ASTILBE-ARENDSII-FANAL","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage/Fruit","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"astilbe-fanal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Astilbe x arendsii 'Fanal')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242008","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Foliage decline (leaves brown up) may occur in hot summers and/or periods of drought if soils are not kept moist.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Walters Gardens, Inc. (Astilbe 'Fanal')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBFA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants must have consistently moist soil; dryness leads to a quick demise, especially in sun.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Astilbe x arendsii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-x-arendsii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In hot summer or periods of drought, the foliage may decline if the soil is not kept moist.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center (Fanal Astilbe)","url":"https://www.gertens.com/fanal-astilbe","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It requires an evenly moist well-drained soil for optimal growth.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"}],"note":"4 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"astilbe-fanal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens, Inc. (Astilbe 'Fanal')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBFA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Astilbe x arendsii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-x-arendsii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The plant attracts butterflies and is resistant to rabbits and deer.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (Fanal Astilbe)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/fanal-astilbe","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center (Fanal Astilbe)","url":"https://www.gertens.com/fanal-astilbe","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies to your yard, but is not particularly attractive to deer who tend to leave it alone in favor of tastier treats.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery (Astilbe x arendsii 'Fanal')","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Astilbe-x-arendsii-Fanal","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery (Astilbe arendsii 'Fanal')","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ASTILBE-ARENDSII-FANAL","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"astilbe arendsii"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"astilbe-peach-blossom","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.55,0.61],"union":[0.46,0.76],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242017","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/368554/astilbe-japonica-peach-blossom/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"A clump-forming perennial to 60cm with shiny, mid-green, divided foliage.","metres":0.6,"band":[0.54,0.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ball Seed (Ball Horticultural) plant information","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/WEBTRACKPLANTINFO.ASPX?PHID=007800756003952&env=P","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 20 - 24\" (51 - 61cm)","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBPB","country":"US","form":null,"value":"24.0 Inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/astilbe/peach-blossom-japanese-astilbe-astilbe-japonica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2'","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-collections/plant-finder/astilbe-x-rosea-peach-blossom-rose-astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The stalks stand 2 feet high.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/astilbe-peach-blossom","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 20-24 Inches","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ASTILBE-JAPONICA-PEACH-BLOSSOM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24 in","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Natorp's Nursery","url":"https://plants.natorp.com/plants/perennial/83160-peach-blossom-astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"18in to 24in","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/astilbe-peach-blossom/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The flowers rise on slender stems, reaching a height of 24–30 inches, while the plant spreads about 18–24 inches","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Stein's Garden and Home (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/2153/Peach_Blossom_Astilbe/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Peach Blossom Astilbe will grow to be about 18 inches tall at maturity extending to 24 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 32 inches.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-peach-blossom","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.1,0.89],"split":[{"range":[0.1,0.61],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Natorp's Nursery","Walters Gardens","Proven Winners","Sooner Plant Farm","Patuxent Nursery","Ball Seed (Ball Horticultural) plant information"]},{"range":[0.73,0.89],"sources":["Stein's Garden and Home (NetPS Plant Finder database)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242017","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/368554/astilbe-japonica-peach-blossom/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ball Seed (Ball Horticultural) plant information","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/WEBTRACKPLANTINFO.ASPX?PHID=007800756003952&env=P","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 20 - 22\" (51 - 56cm)","metres":[0.51,0.56],"band":[0.51,0.56],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBPB","country":"US","form":null,"value":"15.0-18.0 Inches","metres":[0.38,0.46],"band":[0.38,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/astilbe/peach-blossom-japanese-astilbe-astilbe-japonica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 15\" - 18\"","metres":[0.38,0.46],"band":[0.38,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/astilbe-peach-blossom","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 15-18 Inches","metres":[0.38,0.46],"band":[0.38,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Natorp's Nursery","url":"https://plants.natorp.com/plants/perennial/83160-peach-blossom-astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"12in to 18in","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/astilbe-peach-blossom/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The flowers rise on slender stems, reaching a height of 24–30 inches, while the plant spreads about 18–24 inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Stein's Garden and Home (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/2153/Peach_Blossom_Astilbe/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Peach Blossom Astilbe will grow to be about 18 inches tall at maturity extending to 24 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 32 inches.","metres":0.81,"band":[0.73,0.89],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-peach-blossom","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","3-8","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242017","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Astilbe japonica, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-japonica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Ball Seed (Ball Horticultural) plant information","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/WEBTRACKPLANTINFO.ASPX?PHID=007800756003952&env=P","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3a - 8b","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBPB","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/astilbe/peach-blossom-japanese-astilbe-astilbe-japonica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b , 9a , 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-collections/plant-finder/astilbe-x-rosea-peach-blossom-rose-astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 - 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/astilbe-peach-blossom","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ASTILBE-JAPONICA-PEACH-BLOSSOM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/astilbe-peach-blossom/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This perennial thrives in USDA hardiness zones 4–8 and prefers partial to full shade.","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-peach-blossom","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":11,"distinctPublishers":11,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242017","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Astilbe japonica, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-japonica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/368554/astilbe-japonica-peach-blossom/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Partial shade"},{"name":"Ball Seed (Ball Horticultural) plant information","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/WEBTRACKPLANTINFO.ASPX?PHID=007800756003952&env=P","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Partial Sun"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBPB","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/astilbe/peach-blossom-japanese-astilbe-astilbe-japonica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Shade to Shade"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-collections/plant-finder/astilbe-x-rosea-peach-blossom-rose-astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"does well in shade to partial shade in constantly moist soil"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ASTILBE-JAPONICA-PEACH-BLOSSOM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Sun"},{"name":"Natorp's Nursery","url":"https://plants.natorp.com/plants/perennial/83160-peach-blossom-astilbe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Likes Shade to Part Shade"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/astilbe-peach-blossom/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This perennial thrives in USDA hardiness zones 4–8 and prefers partial to full shade."},{"name":"Stein's Garden and Home (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/2153/Peach_Blossom_Astilbe/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in partial shade to shade."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-peach-blossom","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBPB","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-peach-blossom","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242017","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Astilbe japonica, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-japonica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBPB","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/astilbe/peach-blossom-japanese-astilbe-astilbe-japonica","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great cut flower","claim":true},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-collections/plant-finder/astilbe-x-rosea-peach-blossom-rose-astilbe","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This is an excellent cut flower.","claim":true},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/astilbe-peach-blossom","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ASTILBE-JAPONICA-PEACH-BLOSSOM","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage/Fruit","claim":true},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/astilbe-peach-blossom/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers, Dried Arrangements","claim":true},{"name":"Stein's Garden and Home (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/2153/Peach_Blossom_Astilbe/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true}],"note":"9 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-peach-blossom","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242017","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Foliage decline (leaf margins brown up), sometimes with significant dieback, may occur in hot summers and/or periods of drought if soils are not kept moist.","claim":false},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/368554/astilbe-japonica-peach-blossom/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought intolerant, may be damaged in hot sun","claim":false},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBPB","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants must have consistently moist soil; dryness leads to a quick demise, especially in sun.","claim":false}],"note":"3 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-peach-blossom","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Astilbe japonica, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/astilbe-japonica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBPB","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bee Friendly","claim":true},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-collections/plant-finder/astilbe-x-rosea-peach-blossom-rose-astilbe","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attractive to butterflies and hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/astilbe-peach-blossom","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Natorp's Nursery","url":"https://plants.natorp.com/plants/perennial/83160-peach-blossom-astilbe","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/astilbe-peach-blossom/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attract pollinators like bees and butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Stein's Garden and Home (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/2153/Peach_Blossom_Astilbe/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies to your yard","claim":true}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-red-sentinel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.51,0.76],"union":[0.51,0.76],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260359&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBRS","country":"US","form":null,"value":"20.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-red-sentinel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260359&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBRS","country":"US","form":null,"value":"12.0-18.0 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-red-sentinel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[4,9],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260359&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBRS","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"every source states 4-9; catalog states 3-8","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-red-sentinel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260359&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBRS","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun) Full Shade (< 4 hrs. Direct Sun)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-red-sentinel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-red-sentinel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260359&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy, Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBRS","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-red-sentinel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBRS","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants must have consistently moist soil; dryness leads to a quick demise, especially in sun.","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-red-sentinel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ASBRS","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bee Friendly","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-sprite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.27,0.28],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Astilbe 'Sprite')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260361","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/astilbe-simplicifolia-sprite.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 20-30 cm 8-12 inches","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/astilbe-sprite","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10\" tall","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/astilbe-sprite","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 1 ft Tall and Wide","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"CNY Gardening","url":"https://www.cnygardening.org/plants/astilbe-simplicifolia-sprite","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 10” H x 12” W","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored"},{"name":"The Beth Chatto Gardens","url":"https://www.bethchatto.co.uk/a-z-plants/astilbe-sprite.htm","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height 30cm","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Let's Go Planting","url":"https://www.letsgoplanting.co.uk/product/astilbe-simplicifolia-sprite/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Eventual Height: 0.1-0.5m","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-sprite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.27,0.33],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Astilbe 'Sprite')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260361","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/astilbe-simplicifolia-sprite.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 25-30 cm 10-12 inches","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/astilbe-sprite","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 1 ft Tall and Wide","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"CNY Gardening","url":"https://www.cnygardening.org/plants/astilbe-simplicifolia-sprite","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 10” H x 12” W","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"The Beth Chatto Gardens","url":"https://www.bethchatto.co.uk/a-z-plants/astilbe-sprite.htm","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Spread 30cm","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Let's Go Planting","url":"https://www.letsgoplanting.co.uk/product/astilbe-simplicifolia-sprite/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Eventual Spread: 0.1-0.5m","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-sprite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","4-8","3-9","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Astilbe 'Sprite')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260361","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Astilbe simplicifolia, species page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242018","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/astilbe-simplicifolia-sprite.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/astilbe-sprite","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3a to 8b","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/astilbe-sprite","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Thrives in Zones 3-8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/how-to-grow-and-care-for-astilbe/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant hardiness zones: Astilbes are hardy in zones 3 to 9.","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-sprite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Astilbe 'Sprite')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260361","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Astilbe simplicifolia, species page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242018","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/astilbe-simplicifolia-sprite.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Partial Shade or Full Shade"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/astilbe-sprite","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Part Sun to Light Shade"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/astilbe-sprite","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Partial shade"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/how-to-grow-and-care-for-astilbe/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Grow astilbe in a part shade to shady location. They can tolerate more sun if the soil is moist."},{"name":"The Beth Chatto Gardens","url":"https://www.bethchatto.co.uk/a-z-plants/astilbe-sprite.htm","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Aspect Sun or part shade"},{"name":"Let's Go Planting","url":"https://www.letsgoplanting.co.uk/product/astilbe-simplicifolia-sprite/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position: Full sun, partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-sprite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-sprite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Astilbe 'Sprite')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260361","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/astilbe-simplicifolia-sprite.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nice for cutting.","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/how-to-grow-and-care-for-astilbe/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers can be cut for arrangements and drying.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-sprite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Astilbe 'Sprite')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260361","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soils must not be allowed to dry out.","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"astilbe-sprite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennials.com/plants/astilbe-simplicifolia-sprite.html","https://naturehills.com/products/astilbe-sprite"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennials.com/plants/astilbe-simplicifolia-sprite.html","https://www.letsgoplanting.co.uk/product/astilbe-simplicifolia-sprite/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/astilbe-simplicifolia-sprite.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/astilbe-sprite","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator-Friendly Perennial","claim":true},{"name":"Let's Go Planting","url":"https://www.letsgoplanting.co.uk/product/astilbe-simplicifolia-sprite/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A magnet for a wide variety of bees, butterflies and other beneficial insects.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"autumn-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.55,0.61],"union":[0.46,1],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285661","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.46,0.76],"band":[0.46,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dryopteris-erythrosora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/dryopteris-erythrosora-japanese-shield-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is a medium-sized fern, growing to about 2 feet tall and a foot wide.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/dryopteris-erythrosora-autumn-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24\" tall","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/25899/dryopteris-erythrosora/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"autumn-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.27,1],"split":[{"range":[0.27,0.33],"sources":["Chicago Botanic Garden"]},{"range":[0.46,1],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden","RHS","Plant Delights Nursery","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285661","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.46,0.76],"band":[0.46,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dryopteris-erythrosora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/dryopteris-erythrosora-japanese-shield-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is a medium-sized fern, growing to about 2 feet tall and a foot wide.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/dryopteris-erythrosora-autumn-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"We love scattering these 2' wide clumpers throughout the woodland garden as a background for hostas and other bold textured woodland plants.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/25899/dryopteris-erythrosora/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"autumn-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","6-12","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285661","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dryopteris-erythrosora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b, 12a, 12b","zones":[6,12]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/dryopteris-erythrosora-japanese-shield-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5 - 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/dryopteris-erythrosora-autumn-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 5a to 9b","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"autumn-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285661","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dryopteris-erythrosora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/dryopteris-erythrosora-japanese-shield-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Partial Shade Full Shade"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/dryopteris-erythrosora-autumn-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Part Sun to Shade"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/25899/dryopteris-erythrosora/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full shade, Full sun, Partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"autumn-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"autumn-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"autumn-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285661","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soils must not be allowed to dry out.","claim":false},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dryopteris-erythrosora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Dry Soil Heavy Shade Rabbits Urban Conditions","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"autumn-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.83,3.05],"union":[0.91,6.1],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rhododendron, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rhododendron/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Azaleas and rhododendrons typically grow 6 to 10 feet tall and 5 to 8 feet wide.","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (How to Grow Rhododendrons in South Carolina)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/how-to-grow-rhododendrons-in-south-carolina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height & Spread: 5 to 6 feet for Carolina types; up to 20+ feet for rosebay; forms range from compact to loose","metres":[1.52,6.1],"band":[1.52,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension, Bulletin 670 (Selecting and Growing Azaleas)","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/B670/selecting-and-growing-azaleas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Several species of azaleas are native to Georgia and the Southeast. Their flower color ranges from white to pink, yellow, orange, scarlet or crimson, with several shades in between. Plant size is also variable, ranging from 3 ft to more than 20 ft.","metres":[0.91,6.1],"band":[0.91,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rhododendron, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rhododendron/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Azaleas and rhododendrons typically grow 6 to 10 feet tall and 5 to 8 feet wide.","metres":[1.52,2.44],"band":[1.52,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rhododendron catawbiense)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/plantfinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279982","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade","level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron catawbiense"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rhododendron periclymenoides)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279988","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron periclymenoides"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rhododendron catawbiense)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rhododendron-catawbiense/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant this shrub in full to partial shade in acidic, rich, well-drained but moist soils.","level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron catawbiense"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Carolina Rhododendron, Rhododendron carolinianum)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=423&PlantTypeID=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial to full shade; moist, well drained soil is best; needs acid soil.","level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron carolinianum"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Catawba rhododendron)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/catawba-rhododendron/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily), Full shade (4 hrs or less of light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron catawbiense"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Rhododendron catawbiense)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/rhododendron-catawbiense","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part shade, tough plant.","level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron catawbiense"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden (Rhododendron plant profile, genus page)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/rhododendron","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Select a spot that offers dappled shade. Avoid full sun and south- or west-facing sites, where winter winds can dry evergreen leaves.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Azalea Planting)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/azaleas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Site selection is very important. Azaleas prefer light to moderate shade. In spring, flowers last longer on plants in filtered sun than those in full sun.","level":"genus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rhododendron periclymenoides)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279988","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Clusters of soft pink to white to lavender, slightly fragrant, funnel-shaped flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron periclymenoides"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Carolina Rhododendron, Rhododendron carolinianum)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=423&PlantTypeID=8","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy flowers (white, pink or rosy) in mid to late spring; mildly fragrant; leaves are evergreen and leathery","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron carolinianum"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"azalea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"University of Georgia Extension, Bulletin 670 (Selecting and Growing Azaleas)","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/B670/selecting-and-growing-azaleas/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"On the other hand, azaleas are sensitive to drought and require irrigation during periods of limited rainfall.","claim":false,"level":"genus"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rhododendron, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rhododendron/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"as specimens where the flowers will attract hummingbirds and the specialized bee Andrena cornelli","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rhododendron catawbiense)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/plantfinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279982","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are a nectar source for butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron catawbiense"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rhododendron periclymenoides)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279988","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron periclymenoides"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rhododendron catawbiense)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rhododendron-catawbiense/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are attractive to hummingbirds, butterflies, and bees, so consider catawba rhododendron for butterfly and pollinator gardens.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron catawbiense"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden (Rhododendron plant profile, genus page)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/rhododendron","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In spring they offer an assortment of cheery flowers that attract butterflies and bees.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"azalea-encore-autumn-amethyst","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.83],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"US Plant Patent PP10,567, Azalea hybrid variety named 'Conlee' (breeder registration, full text via Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP10567P/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5-6'.","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Encore Azalea (breeder / introducer, Plant Development Services)","url":"https://encoreazalea.com/products/autumn-amethyst","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service, Plant of the Week","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/azalea-encore-10-14-05.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It's slightly wider than tall, with the final height usually reaching around 4 to 5 feet.","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/autumn-amethyst-encore-azalea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height : 4 Feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/autumn-amethyst-encore-azalea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 4 ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"All Seasons Nursery, Lafayette LA (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.buyallseasons.com/12250004/Plant/14256/Encore_Autumn_Amethyst_Azalea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Center Marketing plant library","url":"https://www.gardencentermarketing.com/plantName/Rhododendron-x-Autumn-Amethyst","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3-4 ft","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/azalea-encore-autumn-amethyst","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"azalea-encore-autumn-amethyst","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.91,1.83],"split":[{"range":[0.91,1.34],"sources":["Garden Center Marketing plant library","Sooner Plant Farm","Encore Azalea (breeder / introducer, Plant Development Services)","Plant Addicts","The Tree Center"]},{"range":[1.37,1.83],"sources":["All Seasons Nursery, Lafayette LA (NetPS Plant Finder)","US Plant Patent PP10,567, Azalea hybrid variety named 'Conlee' (breeder registration, full text via Google Patents)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"US Plant Patent PP10,567, Azalea hybrid variety named 'Conlee' (breeder registration, full text via Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP10567P/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 5-6'.","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Encore Azalea (breeder / introducer, Plant Development Services)","url":"https://encoreazalea.com/products/autumn-amethyst","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/autumn-amethyst-encore-azalea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread : 4 Feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/autumn-amethyst-encore-azalea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 4 ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"All Seasons Nursery, Lafayette LA (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.buyallseasons.com/12250004/Plant/14256/Encore_Autumn_Amethyst_Azalea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 5 feet","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Center Marketing plant library","url":"https://www.gardencentermarketing.com/plantName/Rhododendron-x-Autumn-Amethyst","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3-4 ft","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/azalea-encore-autumn-amethyst","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"azalea-encore-autumn-amethyst","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://encoreazalea.com/products/autumn-amethyst","https://plantaddicts.com/autumn-amethyst-encore-azalea"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://encoreazalea.com/products/autumn-amethyst","https://www.thetreecenter.com/autumn-amethyst-encore-azalea/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://encoreazalea.com/products/autumn-amethyst","https://www.gardencentermarketing.com/plantName/Rhododendron-x-Autumn-Amethyst"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://encoreazalea.com/products/autumn-amethyst","https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/azalea-encore-autumn-amethyst"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Encore Azalea (breeder / introducer, Plant Development Services)","url":"https://encoreazalea.com/products/autumn-amethyst","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in Zones: 6a - 10b","zones":[6,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/autumn-amethyst-encore-azalea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones : 6-10","zones":[6,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/autumn-amethyst-encore-azalea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In: Zones 6-10","zones":[6,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Center Marketing plant library","url":"https://www.gardencentermarketing.com/plantName/Rhododendron-x-Autumn-Amethyst","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 6-10","zones":[6,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/azalea-encore-autumn-amethyst","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 6-10","zones":[6,10],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[6,10]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"azalea-encore-autumn-amethyst","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Encore Azalea (breeder / introducer, Plant Development Services)","url":"https://encoreazalea.com/products/autumn-amethyst","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant your Encore Azaleas in light shade to full sun; allow 4-6 hours direct sun for best blooming.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Rhododendron (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rhododendron/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"genus","taxon":"rhododendron"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/autumn-amethyst-encore-azalea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure : Partial Shade to Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/autumn-amethyst-encore-azalea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs : Full Sun, Partial Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"All Seasons Nursery, Lafayette LA (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.buyallseasons.com/12250004/Plant/14256/Encore_Autumn_Amethyst_Azalea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub does best in a location that gets morning sunlight but is shaded from the hot afternoon sun, although it will also grow in partial shade.","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"azalea-encore-autumn-amethyst","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"US Plant Patent PP10,567, Azalea hybrid variety named 'Conlee' (breeder registration, full text via Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP10567P/en","country":null,"form":null,"value":"borne on current season's growth, non-fragrant","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"azalea-encore-autumn-amethyst","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"azalea-encore-autumn-amethyst","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Encore Azalea (breeder / introducer, Plant Development Services)","url":"https://encoreazalea.com/products/autumn-amethyst","country":null,"form":null,"value":"After the first year, Encore Azaleas are quite drought-tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"All Seasons Nursery, Lafayette LA (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.buyallseasons.com/12250004/Plant/14256/Encore_Autumn_Amethyst_Azalea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It may require supplemental watering during periods of drought or extended heat.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/azalea-encore-autumn-amethyst","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"azalea-encore-autumn-amethyst","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"US Plant Patent PP10,567, Azalea hybrid variety named 'Conlee' (breeder registration, full text via Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP10567P/en","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Rhododendron (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rhododendron/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds Pollinators Specialized Bees","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rhododendron"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/autumn-amethyst-encore-azalea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features : Fall Blooming, Flowering, Rebloomer, Winter/Fall Foliage Color, Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/azalea-encore-autumn-amethyst","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"azalea-george-tabor","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"edge","consensus":[1.83,3.66],"union":[1.83,3.66],"edge":[1.78,3.77],"edgeMargin":1.6,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension fact sheet FP509","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP509","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10 to 12 feet","metres":[3.05,3.66],"band":[3.05,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/azalea-southern-indica-george-lindley-taber/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6-10' x 4-10'","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored"}],"withdrawnFromV2":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":2.75},"note":"the catalog value sits 1.6% outside the sources' union (1.83 to 3.66 m) and inside the 3% margin v3 allows at a stated range edge (1.78 to 3.77 m), so v2's proposal of 2.75 m is withdrawn rather than applied; 2 of these 2 scored sources publish a range, and a range edge is a figure converted and rounded from another unit rather than a measurement to the centimetre","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-george-tabor","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[2.44,3.05],"union":[1.22,3.05],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension fact sheet FP509","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP509","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8 to 10 feet","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/azalea-southern-indica-george-lindley-taber/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6-10' x 4-10'","metres":[1.22,3.05],"band":[1.22,3.05],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-george-tabor","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["8-10","7-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension fact sheet FP509","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP509","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8 through 10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/azalea-southern-indica-george-lindley-taber/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"7b-10b","zones":[7,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-george-tabor","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/azalea-southern-indica-george-lindley-taber/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-george-tabor","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-george-tabor","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension fact sheet FP509","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP509","country":null,"form":null,"value":"cut flowers","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-george-tabor","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/azalea-southern-indica-george-lindley-taber/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"requires consistently moist soil","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-george-tabor","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension fact sheet FP509","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP509","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attracts butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/azalea-southern-indica-george-lindley-taber/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Birds/Butterflies/Bees","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-gibraltar","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.8,2.68],"split":[{"range":[0.8,2.01],"sources":["Glendoick Garden Centre (specialist rhododendron nursery, Scotland)","Royal Horticultural Society","Missouri Botanical Garden","Fieldstone Gardens","Journal American Rhododendron Society v60n1, Rhododendron of the Year Awards (Virginia Tech scholar.lib)"]},{"range":[2.2,2.68],"sources":["Pleasant Run Nursery"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253325","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Journal American Rhododendron Society v60n1, Rhododendron of the Year Awards (Virginia Tech scholar.lib)","url":"https://scholar.lib.vt.edu/ejournals/JARS/v60n1/v60n1-smith.htm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"has a compact growing habit, to 6' in 10 years","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/91149/rhododendron-gibraltar-(k)/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Glendoick Garden Centre (specialist rhododendron nursery, Scotland)","url":"https://shop.glendoick.com/plantShop/product-GIBRALTAR-EX--id2469","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Final Height low-Med 0.8-1.5m (3-5ft)","metres":[0.8,1.5],"band":[0.8,1.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Rhododendron-Gibraltar","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8 Feet","metres":2.44,"band":[2.2,2.68],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/azalea-gibraltar-azalea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4–6 ft","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-gibraltar","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.34],"union":[0.91,1.52],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253325","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/91149/rhododendron-gibraltar-(k)/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Rhododendron-Gibraltar","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4 Feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/azalea-gibraltar-azalea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3–5 ft","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-gibraltar","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253325","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rhododendron hybrids: Exbury, Ghent, Knaphill Azaleas)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rhododendron-hybrids/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Journal American Rhododendron Society v60n1, Rhododendron of the Year Awards (Virginia Tech scholar.lib)","url":"https://scholar.lib.vt.edu/ejournals/JARS/v60n1/v60n1-smith.htm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"hardy in zones 5a-8a","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/azalea-gibraltar-azalea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 5–8","zones":[5,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-gibraltar","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253325","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rhododendron hybrids: Exbury, Ghent, Knaphill Azaleas)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rhododendron-hybrids/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/91149/rhododendron-gibraltar-(k)/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Rhododendron-Gibraltar","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade/Shade Tolerant"},{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/azalea-gibraltar-azalea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun to partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-gibraltar","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253325","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Rhododendron-Gibraltar","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The large ruffled flowers have a faint fragrance","claim":true},{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/azalea-gibraltar-azalea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"huge trusses of lightly scented, coppery-orange flowers","claim":true},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension B670, Selecting and Growing Azaleas","url":"https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=B670&title=selecting-and-growing-azaleas","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It has fragrant, frilled, crimson-orange flowers in a ball-shaped cluster.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-gibraltar","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-gibraltar","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-gibraltar","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253325","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Rhododendron-Gibraltar","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-karen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.61,1.22],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253371","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/karen-azalea.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2 to 4 ft. tall, 3 to 5 ft. wide","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-karen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.52],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253371","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/karen-azalea.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2 to 4 ft. tall, 3 to 5 ft. wide","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-karen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253371","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/karen-azalea.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone 4-9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-karen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253371","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part shade"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/karen-azalea.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Filtered sun, Partial sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-karen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-karen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-karen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"azalea-karen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253371","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/karen-azalea.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bacopa","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"species":5,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The plant grows 3 to 6 inches tall and has a sprawling habit.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height: 3 - 6 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 3-6 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"This evergreen, perennial herb varies in height from ground-hugging to about 300 mm.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Size 10 to 15cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bacopa","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"species":5,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread is approximately 300-500 mm.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bacopa","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chaenostoma-cordatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant is winter hardy in zones 9 to 11. In cooler climates, it is used as an annual.","zones":[9,11],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":5,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bacopa","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chaenostoma-cordatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/bacopa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to very light afternoon shade in moist well-drained soil","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=767&PlantTypeID=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to very light afternoon shade in moist well-drained soil","level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Sutera cordata 'Balmecoblu')","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/sutera-cordata-balmecoblu-bacopa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow in full sun for best flower production (although it tolerates partial shade well).","level":"cultivar","taxon":"sutera cordata"},{"name":"Proven Winners, Snowstorm Giant Snowflake bacopa","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/sutera/snowstorm-giant-snowflake-bacopa-sutera-cordata-1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Sun to Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"sutera cordata"},{"name":"Proven Winners, Snowstorm Blue bacopa","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/sutera/snowstorm-blue-bacopa-sutera-cordata-1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Sun to Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"sutera cordata"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/chaenostoma-cordatum","country":"ZA","form":null,"value":"Aspect: Full Sun, Shade, Morning Sun (Semi Shade), Afternoon Sun (Semi Shade)","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Chaenostoma cordatum 'Snowflake')","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/354014/chaenostoma-cordatum-snowflake/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Best grown in fertile, moist but well-drained soil in sun or partial shade.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"chaenostoma cordatum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bacopa","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chaenostoma-cordatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bacopa","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bacopa","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/bacopa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uniform soil moisture assures best flowering as dry soils will interrupt flowering and cause flower buds to dry up and fall off.","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/chaenostoma-cordatum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is sensitive to frost and not particularly drought tolerant.","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"Random Harvest Indigenous Nursery","url":"https://www.randomharvest.co.za/South-African-Indigenous-Plants/Show-Plant/PlantId/326/Plant/Sutera-cordata?Filter=All","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hardiness - Drought: Needs Watering","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["sutera cordata"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (sutera cordata), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (sutera cordata) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bacopa","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/chaenostoma-cordatum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This prostrate species with its white flowers and unmistakable yellow centre is most likely to be pollinated by bees.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["sutera cordata"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (sutera cordata), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (sutera cordata) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":18,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":10},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":20,"sourcesDropped":10,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 50.00 to 70.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 50 ft. 0 in. - 70 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Most landscape specimens tend to grow 50 to 70 feet tall and 20 to 30 feet wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature height 50-70 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 60 to 80 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Deciduous conifer, 50-70 ft (15-21 m) tall, 20-30 ft (6-9 m) wide, narrow, pyramidal when young.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Size Notes: 50-75 feet tall.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Height: 50-75 Feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"it will grow up to 70 feet tall and nearly 50 feet wide\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"With a narrow pyramidal habit, bald cypress reaches a mature height of 50' to 70'.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 20 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":10},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":20,"sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 20.00 to 45.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 20 ft. 0 in. - 30 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Most landscape specimens tend to grow 50 to 70 feet tall and 20 to 30 feet wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature width 20-30 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 25 to 35 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Deciduous conifer, 50-70 ft (15-21 m) tall, 20-30 ft (6-9 m) wide, narrow, pyramidal when young.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"it will grow up to 70 feet tall and nearly 50 feet wide\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 20 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","5-11","4-11","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=m510","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/taxodium-distichum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/bald-cypress/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA zones: 5 to 11","zones":[5,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/bald-cypress/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8, Zone 9, Zone 10, Zone 11","zones":[4,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS ST620)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/ST620","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA hardiness zones: 5A through 10B (Figure 2)","zones":[5,10],"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Selecting Trees for Your Home)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/treeselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=273","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5 - 10","zones":[5,10],"level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plantcollections/plantfinder/taxodium_distichum--bald_cypress","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4 - 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":10},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=m510","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/taxodium-distichum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/bald-cypress/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"expect better growth in moist, well-drained soils in full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/bald-cypress/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily)","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS ST620)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/ST620","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: full sun to partial shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=tadi2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Selecting Trees for Your Home)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/treeselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=273","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun; moist, well drained soil, but can grow in wet sites, even shallow water; prefers slightly acid soil.","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Good Growing)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/good-growing/2023-01-27-one-tough-tree-bald-cypress","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Bald cypress will tolerate partial shade, but full sun is needed to attain its full potential.","level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plantcollections/plantfinder/taxodium_distichum--bald_cypress","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/bald-cypress/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower color and fragrance Inconspicuous","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=m510","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bloom Time: Non-flowering","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/taxodium-distichum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#drought tolerant #highly beneficial coastal plants","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/bald-cypress/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance Moderately sensitive","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS ST620)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/ST620","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance: high","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/taxodium-distichum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Very adaptable to wet, dry and well drained soil.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Good Growing)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/good-growing/2023-01-27-one-tough-tree-bald-cypress","country":null,"form":null,"value":"From wet to dry soils, this tree does surprisingly well in most environments and is hardy to zone 4.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress-falling-waters","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":18,"sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["the page's figure is a final size and this row's is its size at 18 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"The Falling Waters Bald Cypress is a long-lived, slow-growing tree that grows 20 feet tall and 15 feet wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 18 years","the page's figure is a 10 to 10 year size and this row's is its size at 18 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 18 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress-falling-waters","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":18,"sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["the page's figure is a final size and this row's is its size at 18 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"The Falling Waters Bald Cypress is a long-lived, slow-growing tree that grows 20 feet tall and 15 feet wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 18 years","the page's figure is a 10 to 10 year size and this row's is its size at 18 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 18 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress-falling-waters","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/taxodium-distichum-falling-waters-baldcypress","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5 - 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Mr Maple (nursery cultivar spotlight)","url":"https://mrmaple.com/blogs/news/taxodium-distichum-falling-waters-cultivar-spotlight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 4-9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/taxodium-distichum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271366","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress-falling-waters","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21541/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade"},{"name":"Atlanta Botanical Garden","url":"https://atlantabg.org/plant-profile/falling-waters-bald-cypress/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Falling Waters best grows in full sunlight."},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/taxodium-distichum-falling-waters-baldcypress","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun"},{"name":"Singing Tree Gardens Nursery","url":"https://singtree.com/products/taxodium-distichum-falling-waters-1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/taxodium-distichum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271366","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress-falling-waters","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress-falling-waters","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress-falling-waters","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/taxodium-distichum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#drought tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress-falling-waters","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress-shawnee-brave","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":20,"sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 50.00 to 75.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"'Shawnee Brave' - narrow, fastigiate form; grows to 80' tall x 20' wide; high quality green foliage; mite resistant\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 60 Feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page's figure is a 10 to 10 year size and this row's is its size at 20 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 20 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress-shawnee-brave","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":20,"sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 15.00 to 20.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"'Shawnee Brave' - narrow, fastigiate form; grows to 80' tall x 20' wide; high quality green foliage; mite resistant\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 20 Feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page's figure is a 10 to 10 year size and this row's is its size at 20 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 20 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress-shawnee-brave","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d946","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/taxodium-distichum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress-shawnee-brave","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d946","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/taxodium-distichum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress-shawnee-brave","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress-shawnee-brave","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress-shawnee-brave","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bald-cypress-shawnee-brave","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"balloon-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":12,"levels":{"species":6,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 12 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"balloon-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"species":6,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"balloon-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":12,"levels":{"species":6,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 12 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"balloon-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c282","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"platycodon grandiflorus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/platycodon-grandiflorus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"platycodon grandiflorus"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/balloon-flower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"platycodon grandiflorus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Hort Answers)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=743&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Well drained moist soil in a full sun to very light shade location","level":"species","taxon":"platycodon grandiflorus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Flowers)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/balloon-flower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun, Partial Sun/Shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/13246/platycodon-grandiflorus/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"platycodon grandiflorus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden (Plant Finder, 'Mariesii')","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/platycodon-grandiflorus-mariesii-balloon-flower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"platycodon grandiflorus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden ('Fuji White')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257104","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"platycodon grandiflorus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden ('Astra Blue')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257102","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"platycodon grandiflorus"},{"name":"Walters Gardens ('Fuji Blue')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=PLAFB","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"platycodon grandiflorus"},{"name":"Walters Gardens ('Sentimental Blue')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=PLASB","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"platycodon grandiflorus"},{"name":"Proven Winners ('Astra Blue')","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/platycodon/astra-blue-balloon-flower-platycodon-grandiflorus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Sun to Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"platycodon grandiflorus"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/balloon_flower.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants prefer part shade to light shade and regular water.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"platycodon grandiflorus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"balloon-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"balloon-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":6,"covered":["platycodon grandiflorus"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (platycodon grandiflorus), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 6 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (platycodon grandiflorus) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"balloon-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["platycodon grandiflorus"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (platycodon grandiflorus), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (platycodon grandiflorus) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"balloon-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":4,"covered":["platycodon grandiflorus"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (platycodon grandiflorus), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 4 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (platycodon grandiflorus) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"balloon-flower-fuji-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.6],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257104","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=PLAFW","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/platycodon-grandiflorus-fuji-white.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Height 45-60 cm 18-23 inches","metres":[0.45,0.6],"band":[0.45,0.6],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"balloon-flower-fuji-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.45],"union":[0.3,0.46],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257104","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=PLAFW","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12.0-18.0 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/platycodon-grandiflorus-fuji-white.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Spread 30-45 cm 12-18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.45],"band":[0.3,0.45],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"balloon-flower-fuji-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","3-8","3-9","3-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257104","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/platycodon-grandiflorus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=PLAFW","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/platycodon-grandiflorus-fuji-white.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (archived entry)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/platycodon-grandiflorus-fuji-white-balloon-flower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 7","zones":[3,7]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"balloon-flower-fuji-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257104","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/platycodon-grandiflorus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=PLAFW","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/platycodon-grandiflorus-fuji-white.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun or Partial Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"balloon-flower-fuji-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"balloon-flower-fuji-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257104","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut flower.","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=PLAFW","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Mass Planting","claim":true},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/platycodon-grandiflorus-fuji-white.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Especially good for cutting.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"balloon-flower-fuji-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"balloon-flower-fuji-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"baptisia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.22],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page: Baptisia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/baptisia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/baptisia-false-or-wild-indigo/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The most common species, B. alba and B. australis , grow 3 to 4 feet tall by 3 to 4 feet wide in cultivation.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Good Growing (genus feature)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/good-growing/2025-05-30-baptisia-bold-beautiful-and-underused-native-perennials","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Baptisia plants typically grow 3 to 4 feet tall and wide, forming a bushy, shrub-like mound.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":11,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":11},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 11 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"baptisia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"edge","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.22],"edge":[0.88,1.26],"edgeMargin":1.1,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page: Baptisia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/baptisia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/baptisia-false-or-wild-indigo/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The most common species, B. alba and B. australis , grow 3 to 4 feet tall by 3 to 4 feet wide in cultivation.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Good Growing (genus feature)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/good-growing/2025-05-30-baptisia-bold-beautiful-and-underused-native-perennials","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Baptisia plants typically grow 3 to 4 feet tall and wide, forming a bushy, shrub-like mound.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":11},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV2":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":1.07},"note":"the catalog value sits 1.1% outside the sources' union (0.91 to 1.22 m) and inside the 3% margin v3 allows at a stated range edge (0.88 to 1.26 m), so v2's proposal of 1.07 m is withdrawn rather than applied; 3 of these 3 scored sources publish a range, and a range edge is a figure converted and rounded from another unit rather than a measurement to the centimetre; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"baptisia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":10,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":11},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"baptisia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page: Baptisia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/baptisia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/baptisia-false-or-wild-indigo/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun is preferred, but baptisias will tolerate light shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Good Growing (genus feature)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/good-growing/2025-05-30-baptisia-bold-beautiful-and-underused-native-perennials","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They do best in full sun and can tolerate part shade, but blooming may be reduced, and the plant may become leggy.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Baptisia australis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b660","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"baptisia australis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Baptisia australis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/baptisia-australis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"baptisia australis"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Baptisia australis)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/blue-false-indigo-baptisia-australis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It does best in full sun, although it can tolerate light shade.","level":"species","taxon":"baptisia australis"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Baptisia australis)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=815&PlantTypeID=14","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to partial shade; moist, well drained soil. Tolerates dry sites and infertile soil.","level":"species","taxon":"baptisia australis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Baptisia alba)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b650","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"baptisia alba"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Baptisia sphaerocarpa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a769","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"baptisia sphaerocarpa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Baptisia tinctoria)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j500","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"baptisia tinctoria"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Baptisia tinctoria)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/baptisia-tinctoria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"baptisia tinctoria"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Baptisia australis)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=BAPAU","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"species","taxon":"baptisia australis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"baptisia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page: Baptisia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/baptisia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"genus"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"baptisia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/baptisia-false-or-wild-indigo/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Many enjoy the pods in dry flower arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Good Growing (genus feature)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/good-growing/2025-05-30-baptisia-bold-beautiful-and-underused-native-perennials","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In addition to being a great garden plant, the flowers, pods, and leaves can also be utilized in cut flower arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Baptisia australis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b660","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stems with seed pods are valued additions to dried flower arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia australis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Baptisia australis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/baptisia-australis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fruit Value To Gardener: Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia australis"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Baptisia australis)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/blue-false-indigo-baptisia-australis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The stems make good cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia australis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Baptisia alba)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b650","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia alba"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Baptisia australis)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=BAPAU","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Drought Tolerant Salt Tolerant Specimen Focal Point Fire Resistant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia australis"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"baptisia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page: Baptisia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/baptisia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Particularly Resistant To (Insects/Diseases/Other Problems): Deer damage; tolerates drought, poor soils, dry soil, and erosion","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/baptisia-false-or-wild-indigo/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"As a group, these perennials are deer resistant, heat and humidity tolerant, and drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Good Growing (genus feature)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/good-growing/2025-05-30-baptisia-bold-beautiful-and-underused-native-perennials","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, plants are drought-tolerant due to their deep, extensive root system.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Baptisia australis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b660","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia australis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Baptisia australis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/baptisia-australis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Particularly Resistant To (Insects/Diseases/Other Problems): Drought, salt, poor soil, rabbit, erosion, dry soil, clay soil, shallow-rocky soil, highly resistant to deer damage","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia australis"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Baptisia australis)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/blue-false-indigo-baptisia-australis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Keep well-watered until established, after which time it is drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia australis"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Baptisia australis)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=815&PlantTypeID=14","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates dry sites and infertile soil.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia australis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Baptisia alba)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b650","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia alba"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Baptisia sphaerocarpa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a769","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia sphaerocarpa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Baptisia tinctoria)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j500","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia tinctoria"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Baptisia tinctoria)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/baptisia-tinctoria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Particularly Resistant To (Insects/Diseases/Other Problems): Deer damage, drought, poor and dry soils, and works well when planted to manage erosion","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia tinctoria"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Baptisia australis)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=BAPAU","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Drought Tolerant Salt Tolerant Specimen Focal Point Fire Resistant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia australis"}],"note":"12 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"baptisia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page: Baptisia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/baptisia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees and is a host plant for the ashgray blister beetle (adult version).","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/baptisia-false-or-wild-indigo/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Baptisias are host plants for the larvae of several butterfly species, including orange sulphur, clouded sulphur, frosted elfin, eastern tailed blue, hoary edge, and wild indigo duskywing.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Good Growing (genus feature)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/good-growing/2025-05-30-baptisia-bold-beautiful-and-underused-native-perennials","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are frequently visited by bumble bees, which are able to force open their pea-like flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Baptisia australis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b660","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia australis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Baptisia australis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/baptisia-australis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its flowers are attractive to butterflies, bees, and other insects. This plant is also a larval host plant for a variety of butterflies including: Orange sulphur, Clouded Sulphur, Frosted Elfin, Eastern Tailed Blue, Hoary Edge, and Wild Indigo Duskywing.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia australis"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Baptisia australis)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=BAAU","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Value to Native Bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia australis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Baptisia alba)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b650","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia alba"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Baptisia sphaerocarpa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a769","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia sphaerocarpa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Baptisia tinctoria)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j500","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia tinctoria"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Baptisia tinctoria)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/baptisia-tinctoria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia tinctoria"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Baptisia australis)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=BAPAU","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"baptisia australis"}],"note":"11 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"baptisia-screaming-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.61,1],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242075","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/baptisia-sphaerocarpa-screamin-yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In our gardens, Baptisia 'Screamin' Yellow' makes a 3' tall x 5' wide deer-resistant clump","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"baptisia-screaming-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.37,1.52],"union":[0.61,1.67],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242075","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.61,1.52],"band":[0.61,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/baptisia-sphaerocarpa-screamin-yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In our gardens, Baptisia 'Screamin' Yellow' makes a 3' tall x 5' wide deer-resistant clump","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"baptisia-screaming-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242075","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/baptisia-sphaerocarpa-screamin-yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 4a to 9b, at least","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"baptisia-screaming-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242075","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/baptisia-sphaerocarpa-screamin-yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to Part Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"baptisia-screaming-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"baptisia-screaming-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"baptisia-screaming-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242075","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates drought and poor soils","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/baptisia-sphaerocarpa-screamin-yellow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"For a drought-tolerant perennial and a great spring show, it don't get no better than this.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"baptisia-screaming-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"basil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Herb","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.50 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 4 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height and Width: Height is 12 to 24 inches; width is 12 to 24 inches.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"It grows 12 to 18 inches tall and foliage color can range from green to purple.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"basil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Herb","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 4 in. - 1 ft. 2 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height and Width: Height is 12 to 24 inches; width is 12 to 24 inches.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"basil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-11","10-10","3-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281408","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ocimum-basilicum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 10a, 10b","zones":[10,10]},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Pasco County","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/pascoco/2024/03/08/spice-up-your-life-a-beginners-guide-to-growing-basil/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sweet basil is another widely grown variety, prized for its mild, slightly sweet flavor. USDA Hardiness Zone: 3-11.","zones":[3,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"basil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281408","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ocimum-basilicum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/11649/ocimum-basilicum/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/herb-garden-plants-basil","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light and Soil: Full sun and well-drained soil."},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Pasco County","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/pascoco/2024/03/08/spice-up-your-life-a-beginners-guide-to-growing-basil/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 3-11. Growing conditions: Full sun and well-draining soil."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"basil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281408","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ocimum-basilicum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Edible Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/11649/ocimum-basilicum/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Colour & Scent Fragrance Foliage","claim":true},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/herb-garden-plants-basil","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Basil is used for its fragrance in potpourris and sachets, soaps, perfumes, and aromatherapy.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/herbs/basil","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a tender annual, aromatic plant with a spicy odor and flavor.","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"basil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"basil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281408","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Grows best in full sun in moderately rich, evenly moist, well-draining soils.","claim":false},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ocimum-basilicum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sweet basil prefers full sun and moist, well-drained soils.","claim":false},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/herb-garden-plants-basil","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Susceptible to cold and frost, drought, and water stress.","claim":false},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/herbs/basil","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Basil also likes to be kept well-watered.","claim":false}],"note":"4 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"basil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281408","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The small, white to purple flowers are attractive to insect pollinators.","claim":true},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/herb-garden-plants-basil","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinators: Nectar-bearing flowers attract bees, butterflies, and other pollinators.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"batsheba-rose","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"consensus":[2.75,3.36],"union":[2.75,3.36],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/bathsheba-climbing-rose","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/bathsheba-potted-rose-bush"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/bathsheba-climbing-rose","https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.78427.0"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/bathsheba-climbing-rose","https://heirloomroses.com/products/bathsheba"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/bathsheba-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"10ft","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/bathsheba-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"10'+","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.78427.0","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"up to 10' (up to 305cm)","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/bathsheba","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"10' x 4'","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/bathsheba","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"10ft (3m)","metres":3,"band":[2.7,3.3],"role":"regional-note"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":3.06},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"batsheba-rose","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[1.22,1.34],"union":[1.1,1.83],"proposed":1.28,"margin":18.2,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/bathsheba-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"4-6'","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/bathsheba","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"10' x 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (1.1 to 1.83 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"batsheba-rose","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/bathsheba-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zones 5-11"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/bathsheba-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"5-11"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.78427.0","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"USDA zone 5b through 9b"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/bathsheba","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zone 5-11"}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"batsheba-rose","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/bathsheba-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/bathsheba","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/bathsheba-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"batsheba-rose","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/bathsheba-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Medium-strong, Myrrh"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/bathsheba","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Medium-strong, Myrrh"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/bathsheba-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Strong, honey, myrrh fragrance"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.78427.0","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Strong, honey, myrrh fragrance. up to 170 petals. Very double bloom form."}],"note":"sources rate it medium/strong","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"batsheba-rose","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/bathsheba-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Vase Life: 4-6 days"}],"note":"only 1 source mentions it","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"batsheba-rose","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"botanicalName","current":"Rosa 'Auschimbley'","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/bathsheba-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"David Austin Roses (US)"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/bathsheba","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"David Austin Roses (UK)"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/bathsheba-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Grace Rose Farm"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.78427.0","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"HelpMeFind Roses"}],"note":"name resolves as Rosa 'AUSchimbley'","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"beautyberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.52,1.83],"union":[1.22,1.83],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1086, Beautyberry (genus page)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/beautyberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"American beautyberry and Japanese beautyberry grow 4 to 6 feet tall and wide, but can reach 8 to10 feet under favorable growing conditions.","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, The Garden Scoop: Beautyberry","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/garden-scoop/2025-10-20-beautyberry-flashy-fall-performer-purple-pop","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Beautyberry is typically a smaller shrub, reaching about 5 to 6 feet tall at maturity, although I have seen some older specimens on the right site reach 8 to 10 feet in height.","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":13,"levels":{"species":13,"genus":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 13 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1086, Beautyberry (genus page)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/beautyberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"American beautyberry and Japanese beautyberry grow 4 to 6 feet tall and wide, but can reach 8 to10 feet under favorable growing conditions.","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":13,"levels":{"species":13,"genus":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 13 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","6-12"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1086, Beautyberry (genus page)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/beautyberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"American beautyberry ( C. americana ) is a native woodland plant in the warmer areas of the southeastern states; it is considered hardy in Zones 7-11. Three Asian species, C. japonica from Japan, and C. dichotoma and C. bodinieri from China, are cultivated and are considered to have more tolerance to cold (Zones 5-8).","zones":[5,11],"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, The Garden Scoop: Beautyberry","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/garden-scoop/2025-10-20-beautyberry-flashy-fall-performer-purple-pop","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant is hardy from Zone 6 all the way down to Zone 12, with a native range that encompasses swaths of northern Mexico and the Caribbean.","zones":[6,12],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":12,"levels":{"species":13,"genus":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 12 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Callicarpa americana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-americana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa americana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Callicarpa americana)","url":"http://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j580","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa americana"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1086, Beautyberry (genus page)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/beautyberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants grow naturally in light to moderate shade, but can be planted in full sun for maximum flowering and berry production when adequate moisture is available.","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Callicarpa dichotoma)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-dichotoma/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa dichotoma"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Callicarpa dichotoma)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287487&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa dichotoma"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Callicarpa bodinieri)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-bodinieri/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa bodinieri"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Callicarpa bodinieri)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287488&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa bodinieri"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Callicarpa japonica)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-japonica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa japonica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Callicarpa japonica)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287491&isprofile=0&pt=4","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa japonica"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension EDIS FPS90 (Callicarpa americana)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/fp090","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in partial shade; plant grows in full sun","level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa americana"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension EDIS FPS92 (Callicarpa japonica)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/fp092","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in full sun; plant grows in partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa japonica"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Callicarpa americana)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CAAM2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade","level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa americana"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Callicarpa japonica)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=328","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to light shade; moist, well-drained soil; best in acid soil, but tolerates neutral soil pH.","level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa japonica"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Callicarpa dichotoma)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=327","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to light shade; moist, well-drained soil; best in acid soil, but tolerates neutral soil pH.","level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa dichotoma"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, The Garden Scoop: Beautyberry","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/garden-scoop/2025-10-20-beautyberry-flashy-fall-performer-purple-pop","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In the landscape, beautyberry is a performer, flourishing in a wide range of soil conditions and tolerating full sun to nearly full shade.","level":"genus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Callicarpa americana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-americana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa americana"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension EDIS FPS90 (Callicarpa americana)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/fp090","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf type and persistence: fragrant; deciduous","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa americana"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension EDIS FPS92 (Callicarpa japonica)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/fp092","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf type and persistence: fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa japonica"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Callicarpa americana)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CAAM2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Foliage: yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa americana"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"beautyberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Callicarpa americana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-americana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Dry Soil Heat Rabbits","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa americana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Callicarpa americana)","url":"http://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j580","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Clay Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa americana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Callicarpa dichotoma)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-dichotoma/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa dichotoma"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Callicarpa dichotoma)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287487&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Some tolerance for drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa dichotoma"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Callicarpa japonica)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-japonica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa japonica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Callicarpa japonica)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287491&isprofile=0&pt=4","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Some tolerance for drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa japonica"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension EDIS FPS90 (Callicarpa americana)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/fp090","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance: moderate","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa americana"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension EDIS FPS92 (Callicarpa japonica)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/fp092","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance: moderate","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa japonica"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Callicarpa americana)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CAAM2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water Use: Low","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa americana"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Callicarpa japonica)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=328","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerance: Alkaline Soil Dry Sites Salt Soil Compaction Wet Sites Wind","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa japonica"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Callicarpa dichotoma)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=327","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerance: Alkaline Soil Dry Sites Salt Soil Compaction Wet Sites Wind","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa dichotoma"}],"note":"11 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Callicarpa americana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-americana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Pollinators Small Mammals Songbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa americana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Callicarpa dichotoma)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-dichotoma/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Songbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa dichotoma"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Callicarpa bodinieri)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-bodinieri/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Pollinators Songbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa bodinieri"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Callicarpa japonica)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-japonica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Songbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa japonica"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension EDIS FPS90 (Callicarpa americana)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/fp090","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers of this plant also attract pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa americana"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Callicarpa americana)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CAAM2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds , Butterflies Nectar Source: yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"callicarpa americana"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"beautyberry-early-amethyst","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.34],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=262957","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Washington Botanic Gardens","url":"https://botanicgardens.uw.edu/about/blog/2014/11/03/november-2014-plant-profile-callicarpa-dichotoma-early-amethyst/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height and Spread: 4′ high x 4-5′ wide","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Spring Meadow Nursery","url":"https://springmeadownursery.com/plantfinder/early-amethyst-08150","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 3 - 4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/early-amethyst-beautyberry-callicarpa-dichotoma","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 3-4 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/beautyberry-early-amethyst","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Callicarpa-dichotoma-Early-Amethyst","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 Feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry-early-amethyst","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.22,1.34],"union":[1.1,1.52],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=262957","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Washington Botanic Gardens","url":"https://botanicgardens.uw.edu/about/blog/2014/11/03/november-2014-plant-profile-callicarpa-dichotoma-early-amethyst/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height and Spread: 4′ high x 4-5′ wide","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Spring Meadow Nursery","url":"https://springmeadownursery.com/plantfinder/early-amethyst-08150","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 4 - 5'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/early-amethyst-beautyberry-callicarpa-dichotoma","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 4-5 feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/beautyberry-early-amethyst","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 4-5 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Callicarpa-dichotoma-Early-Amethyst","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4 Feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry-early-amethyst","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=262957","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/callicarpa-dichotoma-early-amethyst-purple-beautyberry","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5 - 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Spring Meadow Nursery","url":"https://springmeadownursery.com/plantfinder/early-amethyst-08150","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone 5 - 8 (-20°F/-28.9°C)","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/beautyberry-early-amethyst","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-dichotoma/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (species page)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/beautyberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"C. dichotoma and C. bodinieri from China, are cultivated and are considered to have more tolerance to cold (Zones 5-8).","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Piedmont Master Gardeners (species page)","url":"https://www.piedmontmastergardeners.org/article/callicarpa-beautyberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This species has been cultivated to have greater cold tolerance and is hardy in Zones 5 – 8.","zones":[5,8]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry-early-amethyst","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=262957","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/callicarpa-dichotoma-early-amethyst-purple-beautyberry","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade"},{"name":"Spring Meadow Nursery","url":"https://springmeadownursery.com/plantfinder/early-amethyst-08150","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full sun"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/early-amethyst-beautyberry-callicarpa-dichotoma","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-dichotoma/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (species page)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/callicarpa-dichotoma","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun for best heavy fruiting"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry-early-amethyst","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry-early-amethyst","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Spring Meadow Nursery","url":"https://springmeadownursery.com/plantfinder/early-amethyst-08150","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Makes an excellent cut flower for fall harvest, though it does not dry or preserve well.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry-early-amethyst","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=262957","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Some tolerance for drought.","claim":true},{"name":"Spring Meadow Nursery","url":"https://springmeadownursery.com/plantfinder/early-amethyst-08150","country":null,"form":null,"value":"beautyberry tolerates all soil types, deer, and drought.","claim":true},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/beautyberry-early-amethyst","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Quite heat and drought tolerant.","claim":true},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Callicarpa-dichotoma-Early-Amethyst","country":null,"form":null,"value":"once established are quite drought tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry-early-amethyst","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry-pearl-glam","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,1.52],"union":[0.61,1.52],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-pearl-glam-nccx2/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners Direct","url":"https://provenwinnersdirect.com/products/pearl-glam-beautyberry","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4-5 feet tall and 3-4 feet wide at maturity","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry-pearl-glam","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.52],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-pearl-glam-nccx2/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners Direct","url":"https://provenwinnersdirect.com/products/pearl-glam-beautyberry","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4-5 feet tall and 3-4 feet wide at maturity","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry-pearl-glam","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-pearl-glam-nccx2/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Proven Winners Direct","url":"https://provenwinnersdirect.com/products/pearl-glam-beautyberry","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy in zones 5-8, be sure to check your USDA zone to ensure success","zones":[5,8]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry-pearl-glam","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":"full-sun","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-pearl-glam-nccx2/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Proven Winners Direct","url":"https://provenwinnersdirect.com/products/pearl-glam-beautyberry","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in full sun (6+ hours daily)"}],"note":"catalog value \"part-sun\" is outside every source's stated range","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry-pearl-glam","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry-pearl-glam","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry-pearl-glam","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"beautyberry-pearl-glam","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/callicarpa-pearl-glam-nccx2/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In the spring, the white flowers attract bees and other insects.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":14,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":14},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 14 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":14},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":12,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":14},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 12 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Monarda didyma)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=q250","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Monarda fistulosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g560","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda didyma)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-didyma/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda fistulosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-fistulosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda bradburyana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-bradburiana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"monarda bradburyana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda punctata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-punctata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"monarda punctata"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension, Monarda trial (C1332-01, genus)","url":"https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=C1332-01&title=discovering-the-beauty-and-benefits-of-beebalm-part-1-a-journey-into-monardas-horticultural-excellence","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Monarda thrives in well-drained soil and full sun but can tolerate partial shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Beebalm","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/beebalm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun, Partial Sun/Shade","level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension HortAnswers, Beebalm (perennial)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=735&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Moist well-drained soil in sun to partial sun location.","level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension HortAnswers, Bee Balm (wildflower)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=857&PlantTypeID=14","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to shade; consistently moist soils.","level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"Penn State Extension, Rain Garden Plants: Bee Balm","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/rain-garden-plants-bee-balm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Sun/partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Monarda fistulosa)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=MOFI","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade","level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Monarda didyma)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=MODI","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade","level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"Sugar Creek Gardens (Monarda fistulosa, Wild Bergamot)","url":"https://sugarcreekgardens.com/product/monarda-fistulosa-wild-bergamot/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Part Shade , Sun","level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Monarda didyma)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=q250","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Monarda fistulosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g560","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda didyma)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-didyma/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda fistulosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-fistulosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda bradburyana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-bradburiana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Edible Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda bradburyana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda punctata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-punctata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda punctata"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension, Monarda trial (C1332-01, genus)","url":"https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=C1332-01&title=discovering-the-beauty-and-benefits-of-beebalm-part-1-a-journey-into-monardas-horticultural-excellence","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Monarda belongs to the mint family, and shares features with other relatives, such as leaf fragrance (from essential oils within the leaves).","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Beebalm","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/beebalm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good for cutting and aromatic foliage.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension HortAnswers, Beebalm (perennial)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=735&PlantTypeID=2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A late and long flowering perennial that forms large clumps of color. Good for cutting and aromatic foliage.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension HortAnswers, Bee Balm (wildflower)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=857&PlantTypeID=14","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tubular red flowers held in dense clusters. Foliage is strongly scented.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"Penn State Extension, Rain Garden Plants: Bee Balm","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/rain-garden-plants-bee-balm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaves are dark green above and have a minty aroma.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Monarda fistulosa)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=MOFI","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use Ornamental: A hardy garden standard, with brilliant blooms and pleasantly fragrant foliage, many cultivars.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Monarda didyma)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=MODI","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Foliage: yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide, Wild Bergamot","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/wild-bergamot","country":null,"form":null,"value":"a much-branched, clump-forming perennial, pleasantly scented, with square stems","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"},{"name":"Sugar Creek Gardens (Monarda fistulosa, Wild Bergamot)","url":"https://sugarcreekgardens.com/product/monarda-fistulosa-wild-bergamot/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its aromatic foliage smells like mint and can be used to flavor teas.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"}],"note":"16 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Monarda didyma)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=q250","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Monarda fistulosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g560","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda fistulosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-fistulosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda punctata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-punctata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut Long-lasting Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda punctata"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Beebalm","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/beebalm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good for cutting and aromatic foliage.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension HortAnswers, Beebalm (perennial)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=735&PlantTypeID=2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A late and long flowering perennial that forms large clumps of color. Good for cutting and aromatic foliage.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"Sugar Creek Gardens (Monarda fistulosa, Wild Bergamot)","url":"https://sugarcreekgardens.com/product/monarda-fistulosa-wild-bergamot/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A long-blooming plant, Wild Bergamot makes a wonderful cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"bee-balm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"taxon-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Monarda fistulosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g560","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil, Black Walnut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda fistulosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-fistulosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Although tolerant of occasional drought, water-stressed plants are more susceptible to mildew.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda punctata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-punctata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Insect Pests Poor Soil Rabbits Wet Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda punctata"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Monarda fistulosa)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=MOFI","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerance: Medium","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"},{"name":"Sugar Creek Gardens (Monarda fistulosa, Wild Bergamot)","url":"https://sugarcreekgardens.com/product/monarda-fistulosa-wild-bergamot/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"performing especially well in heat and drought, which makes it ideal for sun-loving and drought tolerant landscapes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["monarda didyma"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (monarda didyma), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"this came out more confident than v6 only once the distinct-taxa rule removed the claim(s) that disagreed, so it is a disagreement about which taxa were speaking rather than a finding; v6 recorded SPLIT and true is not proposed; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (monarda didyma) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Hummingbirds Pollinators Songbirds","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Monarda didyma)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=q250","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to bees, hummingbirds and butterflies, particularly when massed.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Monarda fistulosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g560","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda didyma)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-didyma/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Hummingbirds Moths Pollinators Specialized Bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda fistulosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-fistulosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Hummingbirds Moths Pollinators Specialized Bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda bradburyana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-bradburiana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda bradburyana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda punctata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-punctata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Hummingbirds Moths Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda punctata"},{"name":"Penn State Extension, Rain Garden Plants: Bee Balm","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/rain-garden-plants-bee-balm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts hummingbirds, butterflies, and bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Monarda fistulosa)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=MOFI","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use Wildlife: Birds, Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Monarda didyma)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=MODI","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use Wildlife: Hummingbirds, butterflies, and bees are attracted to the blossoms of Oswego tea.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda didyma"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide, Wild Bergamot","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/wild-bergamot","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Many types of insects, including bees, wasps, moths, and butterflies, visit the flowers to drink nectar.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"},{"name":"Sugar Creek Gardens (Monarda fistulosa, Wild Bergamot)","url":"https://sugarcreekgardens.com/product/monarda-fistulosa-wild-bergamot/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The sweet nectar attracts hordes of hummingbirds, butterflies, and bees to the garden.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"monarda fistulosa"}],"note":"12 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-pardon-my-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.27,0.3],"union":[0.2,0.33],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=294060&isprofile=0&basic=monarda","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/monarda-didyma-pardon-my-purple-pardon-my-purple-beebalm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows to about 12 inches high and around 12 inches wide","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (breeder and introducer)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=MONPM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10.0-12.0 Inches","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/monarda/pardon-my-purple-bee-balm-monarda-didyma","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10\" - 12\"","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Home Nursery","url":"https://homenursery.com/plant/Monarda-didyma-Pardon-My-Purple","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 9-12 Inches","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Monarda-didyma-Pardon-My-Purple","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"25-30 cm","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Overdevest Nurseries","url":"https://grownbyoverdevest.com/plant/pardon-my-purple-bee-balm/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10-12\"","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Natorp's Nursery","url":"https://plants.natorp.com/plants/perennial/88098-pardon-my-purple-bee-balm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8in to 12in","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"North Shore Plant Club","url":"https://www.northshoreplantclub.com/plant?ID=15329","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing 10-12 inches tall and wide","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-pardon-my-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.27,0.3],"union":[0.2,0.33],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=294060&isprofile=0&basic=monarda","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/monarda-didyma-pardon-my-purple-pardon-my-purple-beebalm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows to about 12 inches high and around 12 inches wide","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (breeder and introducer)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=MONPM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10.0-12.0 Inches","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/monarda/pardon-my-purple-bee-balm-monarda-didyma","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 10\" - 12\"","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Home Nursery","url":"https://homenursery.com/plant/Monarda-didyma-Pardon-My-Purple","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 9-12 Inches","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Monarda-didyma-Pardon-My-Purple","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"20-25 cm","metres":[0.2,0.25],"band":[0.2,0.25],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Overdevest Nurseries","url":"https://grownbyoverdevest.com/plant/pardon-my-purple-bee-balm/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10-12\"","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Natorp's Nursery","url":"https://plants.natorp.com/plants/perennial/88098-pardon-my-purple-bee-balm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8in to 12in","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"North Shore Plant Club","url":"https://www.northshoreplantclub.com/plant?ID=15329","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing 10-12 inches tall and wide","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-pardon-my-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","4-8","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=294060&isprofile=0&basic=monarda","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/monarda-didyma-pardon-my-purple-pardon-my-purple-beebalm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 - 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda didyma, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-didyma/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (breeder and introducer)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=MONPM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4,5,6,7,8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/monarda/pardon-my-purple-bee-balm-monarda-didyma","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Home Nursery","url":"https://homenursery.com/plant/Monarda-didyma-Pardon-My-Purple","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"North Shore Plant Club","url":"https://www.northshoreplantclub.com/plant?ID=15329","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a - 8b","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-pardon-my-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=294060&isprofile=0&basic=monarda","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda didyma, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-didyma/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (breeder and introducer)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=MONPM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/monarda/pardon-my-purple-bee-balm-monarda-didyma","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Sun to Sun"},{"name":"Home Nursery","url":"https://homenursery.com/plant/Monarda-didyma-Pardon-My-Purple","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Monarda-didyma-Pardon-My-Purple","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Best grown in an average to moist soil, in full sun, however, it is tolerant of partially shady locations."},{"name":"Overdevest Nurseries","url":"https://grownbyoverdevest.com/plant/pardon-my-purple-bee-balm/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to Partial Shade"},{"name":"North Shore Plant Club","url":"https://www.northshoreplantclub.com/plant?ID=15329","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade - Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-pardon-my-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=294060&isprofile=0&basic=monarda","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/monarda-didyma-pardon-my-purple-pardon-my-purple-beebalm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"you'll be pleasantly surprised by its fragrance","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (breeder and introducer)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=MONPM","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/monarda/pardon-my-purple-bee-balm-monarda-didyma","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flower","claim":true},{"name":"Home Nursery","url":"https://homenursery.com/plant/Monarda-didyma-Pardon-My-Purple","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers","claim":true},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Monarda-didyma-Pardon-My-Purple","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Foliage has a minty scent when crushed","claim":true},{"name":"Overdevest Nurseries","url":"https://grownbyoverdevest.com/plant/pardon-my-purple-bee-balm/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Blooms","claim":true},{"name":"North Shore Plant Club","url":"https://www.northshoreplantclub.com/plant?ID=15329","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Foliage","claim":true}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-pardon-my-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=294060&isprofile=0&basic=monarda","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (breeder and introducer)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=MONPM","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/monarda/pardon-my-purple-bee-balm-monarda-didyma","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true},{"name":"Home Nursery","url":"https://homenursery.com/plant/Monarda-didyma-Pardon-My-Purple","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut Flower","claim":true},{"name":"Overdevest Nurseries","url":"https://grownbyoverdevest.com/plant/pardon-my-purple-bee-balm/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers","claim":true},{"name":"North Shore Plant Club","url":"https://www.northshoreplantclub.com/plant?ID=15329","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good for Cut Flowers","claim":true}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-pardon-my-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-pardon-my-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=294060&isprofile=0&basic=monarda","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/monarda-didyma-pardon-my-purple-pardon-my-purple-beebalm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Beebalm is great for attracting bees, butterflies and hummingbirds to your garden.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda didyma, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-didyma/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Blossoms attract bees, hummingbirds and butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (breeder and introducer)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=MONPM","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/monarda/pardon-my-purple-bee-balm-monarda-didyma","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees, Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Home Nursery","url":"https://homenursery.com/plant/Monarda-didyma-Pardon-My-Purple","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Monarda-didyma-Pardon-My-Purple","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Overdevest Nurseries","url":"https://grownbyoverdevest.com/plant/pardon-my-purple-bee-balm/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true},{"name":"Natorp's Nursery","url":"https://plants.natorp.com/plants/perennial/88098-pardon-my-purple-bee-balm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true},{"name":"North Shore Plant Club","url":"https://www.northshoreplantclub.com/plant?ID=15329","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"10 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-purple-rooster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.89],"union":[0.61,1.23],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=456615","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 3.50 feet","metres":[0.91,1.07],"band":[0.91,1.07],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center (Monarda trial)","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/monarda/monarda-purple-rooster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 44”","metres":1.12,"band":[1.01,1.23],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Platt Hill Nursery","url":"https://plants.platthillnursery.com/12120026/Plant/13920/Purple_Rooster_Beebalm/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Purple Rooster Beebalm will grow to be about 32 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 26 inches.","metres":0.81,"band":[0.73,0.89],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Art Form Nurseries","url":"https://www.artformnurseries.com/perennials/monarda-purple-rooster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 36\" tall x 26\" wide","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/monarda-purple-rooster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height : 2 - 3 ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/monarda-didyma-purple-rooster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 36\"","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Monarda-Purple-Rooster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Tall: 2-3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Babikow Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.babikow.com/plant-name/Monarda-Purple-Rooster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 36-40 in","metres":[0.91,1.02],"band":[0.91,1.02],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Hortech","url":"https://hortech.com/plant/monarda-didyma-purple-rooster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Max Height: 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/monarda-didyma-purple-rooster-bee-balm-1g.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height at Maturity: 30-36\"","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-purple-rooster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.3,1.18],"split":[{"range":[0.3,0.91],"sources":["New Moon Nursery","Saunders Brothers","Wilson Bros Gardens","Platt Hill Nursery","Art Form Nurseries","Babikow Wholesale Nursery","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Stonehouse Nursery"]},{"range":[0.96,1.18],"sources":["Mt. Cuba Center (Monarda trial)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=456615","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center (Monarda trial)","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/monarda/monarda-purple-rooster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width after three years 42”","metres":1.07,"band":[0.96,1.18],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Platt Hill Nursery","url":"https://plants.platthillnursery.com/12120026/Plant/13920/Purple_Rooster_Beebalm/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Purple Rooster Beebalm will grow to be about 32 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 26 inches.","metres":0.66,"band":[0.59,0.73],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Art Form Nurseries","url":"https://www.artformnurseries.com/perennials/monarda-purple-rooster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 36\" tall x 26\" wide","metres":0.66,"band":[0.59,0.73],"role":"scored"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/monarda-purple-rooster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread : 1 - 2 ft","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/monarda-didyma-purple-rooster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 26-30\"","metres":[0.66,0.76],"band":[0.66,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Monarda-Purple-Rooster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Wide: 1-2 Feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Babikow Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.babikow.com/plant-name/Monarda-Purple-Rooster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24-30 in","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/monarda-didyma-purple-rooster-bee-balm-1g.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width at Maturity: 18-24\"","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-purple-rooster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","3-9","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=456615","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda didyma, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-didyma/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/monarda-purple-rooster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This cultivar had been proven to be hardy in USDA zones 4-9.","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/monarda-didyma-purple-rooster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 - 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Monarda-Purple-Rooster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Babikow Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.babikow.com/plant-name/Monarda-Purple-Rooster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/monarda-didyma-purple-rooster-bee-balm-1g.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zones: 4a-9b","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-purple-rooster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=456615","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Monarda didyma, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-didyma/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Platt Hill Nursery","url":"https://plants.platthillnursery.com/12120026/Plant/13920/Purple_Rooster_Beebalm/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in full sun to partial shade."},{"name":"Art Form Nurseries","url":"https://www.artformnurseries.com/perennials/monarda-purple-rooster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun to Part Shade"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/monarda-purple-rooster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun to Partial Shade"},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/monarda-didyma-purple-rooster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun, Part Shade"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Monarda-Purple-Rooster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure • Sun • Part Shade"},{"name":"Babikow Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.babikow.com/plant-name/Monarda-Purple-Rooster","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure • Full Sun • Sun/ Part Shade"},{"name":"Hortech","url":"https://hortech.com/plant/monarda-didyma-purple-rooster/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun Light Shade"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/monarda-didyma-purple-rooster-bee-balm-1g.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Bee Balm is easy to grow in most any consistently moist but well-drained humusy, fertile soil and full sun or part shade."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-purple-rooster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=456615","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Platt Hill Nursery","url":"https://plants.platthillnursery.com/12120026/Plant/13920/Purple_Rooster_Beebalm/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"masses of beautiful clusters of fragrant purple flowers at the ends of the stems","claim":true},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/monarda-purple-rooster/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the foliage will release a spicey fragrance when disturbed or crushed","claim":true},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/monarda-didyma-purple-rooster/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant: Yes","claim":true},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Monarda-Purple-Rooster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Babikow Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.babikow.com/plant-name/Monarda-Purple-Rooster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/monarda-didyma-purple-rooster-bee-balm-1g.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the rich green, mint-scented foliage is mildew-resistant","claim":true}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-purple-rooster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=456615","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Can be used in fresh cut arrangements.","claim":true},{"name":"Platt Hill Nursery","url":"https://plants.platthillnursery.com/12120026/Plant/13920/Purple_Rooster_Beebalm/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/monarda-purple-rooster/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Clay Soil, Cut Flower, Dried Flower, Drought Tolerant, Fragrant, Long Blooming, Naturalizing, Reblooming","claim":true},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/monarda-didyma-purple-rooster/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut Flower: Yes","claim":true},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Monarda-Purple-Rooster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true},{"name":"Babikow Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.babikow.com/plant-name/Monarda-Purple-Rooster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/monarda-didyma-purple-rooster-bee-balm-1g.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"also excellent for cutting and use in flower arrangements","claim":true}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-purple-rooster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/monarda-purple-rooster/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Clay Soil, Cut Flower, Dried Flower, Drought Tolerant, Fragrant, Long Blooming, Naturalizing, Reblooming","claim":true},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/monarda-didyma-purple-rooster/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant: No","claim":false}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-purple-rooster","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=456615","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to bees, hummingbirds and butterflies, particularly when massed.","claim":true},{"name":"Platt Hill Nursery","url":"https://plants.platthillnursery.com/12120026/Plant/13920/Purple_Rooster_Beebalm/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting bees, butterflies and hummingbirds to your yard","claim":true},{"name":"Art Form Nurseries","url":"https://www.artformnurseries.com/perennials/monarda-purple-rooster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterfly/Hummingbird Attracting","claim":true},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/monarda-purple-rooster/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies, Hummingbirds, Pollinators, Songbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Monarda-Purple-Rooster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees","claim":true},{"name":"Babikow Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.babikow.com/plant-name/Monarda-Purple-Rooster","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Superior powdery mildew resistance. Attracts hummingbirds and pollinators.","claim":true},{"name":"Hortech","url":"https://hortech.com/plant/monarda-didyma-purple-rooster/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"welcoming bees and butterflies and moving gracefully in the breeze","claim":true},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/monarda-didyma-purple-rooster-bee-balm-1g.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A hummingbird and beneficial pollinator dream flower","claim":true}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-raspberry-wine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.22],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=364292","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-raspberry-wine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Monarda--Raspberry-Wine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-raspberry-wine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.67],"union":[0.55,0.91],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=364292","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-raspberry-wine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Monarda--Raspberry-Wine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2 Feet","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-raspberry-wine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=364292","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-raspberry-wine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Monarda--Raspberry-Wine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-raspberry-wine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=364292","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-raspberry-wine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Monarda--Raspberry-Wine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers average to moist, organically rich, well-drained soil in full sun."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-raspberry-wine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=364292","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its tubular, two-lipped, raspberry-red, fragrant flowers are crowded into dense, globular, terminal flowerheads","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-raspberry-wine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are fragrant, showy and have a raspberry-red color.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-raspberry-wine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=364292","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-raspberry-wine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut Showy","claim":true},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Monarda--Raspberry-Wine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Also makes an excellent cut flower.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-raspberry-wine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=364292","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soils must not be allowed to dry out.","claim":false},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-raspberry-wine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is not too picky about the soil type as long as it is well-drained and moisture-retentive.","claim":false}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bee-balm-raspberry-wine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=364292","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/monarda-raspberry-wine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant attracts hummingbirds, butterflies and bees.","claim":true},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Monarda--Raspberry-Wine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cherished by butterflies and hummingbirds, but loathed by deer.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":10,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":8,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 8 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"While most begonias will be between 8 inches and 2 feet tall, growth habits will vary widely with different species and cultivars.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plants can come in a range of sizes varying anywhere from six to twenty-four inches in height and can have a single stalk, bushy habit, or anything in between.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 15-18 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":8,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 9 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[10,11],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":8,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most commonly cultivated begonias prefer partial shade and a humid environment.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a562","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263000&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=e482","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"begonia benariensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=262180&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia-wax-types/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia-tuberous-types/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia-cane-types/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/begonia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most begonias grow well in partial shade with moist, well-drained soil containing plenty of organic matter.","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/flowers/begonia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Very few cultivars will tolerate full sun so plant them in a shady location. They can tolerate morning sun but avoid putting them in a location that receives afternoon sun.","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=6&PlantTypeID=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to partial shade. Prefers rich organic soils that are moist and well-drained.","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Flowers)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/wax-begonia-fibrous-begonia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun, Full Shade","level":"species","taxon":"begonia semperflorens-cultorum"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Flowers)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/tubrose-begonia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Shade","level":"species","taxon":"begonia tuberhybrida"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/begonia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Begonias are tolerant of a range of light conditions, from full sun to shade. In colder climates, plants can tolerate more light. In warm regions, they need protection from hot afternoon sun to prevent leaf scald.","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/begonia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Double Delight ® Blush Rose ( Begonia tuberhybrida ) is a tuberous begonia with lightly fragrant flowers in warm pastel tones of coral-pink and yellow.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a562","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Dry Soil, Black Walnut","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263000&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Dry Soil, Black Walnut","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=262180&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Heavy Shade, Dry Soil, Black Walnut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia-wax-types/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant resists browsing by deer and rabbits and is tolerant of hot summer temperatures, some mild drought and heavy shade.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/begonia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wax begonias withstand drought and heat better than other begonias, although they prefer moist, well-drained, fertile soil.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/begonia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Begonias are somewhat drought-tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia-wax-types/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia-dragon-wing-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 16 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 12 - 15\" (30 - 38cm)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 14\" - 18\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 12-15 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 14-18 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"HEIGHT 12 - 15 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height and Width: 12-18\" x 15-18\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.38},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia-dragon-wing-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 29 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 15 - 18\" (38 - 46cm)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 15\" - 18\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 15-18 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height and Width: 12-18\" x 15-18\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"SPLIT"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia-dragon-wing-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["9-11","10-11","9-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/begonia/dragon-wing-pink-angelwing-begonia-begonia-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 9a , 9b , 10a , 10b , 11a , 11b","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"Lucas Greenhouses","url":"https://www.lucasgreenhouses.com/plant/Begonia-hybrida-Dragon-Wing-Pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: Zones 10-11","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/dragon-wing-pink-begonia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 9-11","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/begonia/begonia-dragon-wing-seeds-pink.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA ZONES 9 - 10","zones":[9,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia-dragon-wing-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/begonia/dragon-wing-pink-angelwing-begonia-begonia-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade to Shade"},{"name":"Lucas Greenhouses","url":"https://www.lucasgreenhouses.com/plant/Begonia-hybrida-Dragon-Wing-Pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Part Sun / Part Shade"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/dragon-wing-pink-begonia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Full Shade to Partial Shade"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/begonia/begonia-dragon-wing-seeds-pink.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ENVIRONMENT Full sun to partial shade"},{"name":"Pinetree Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.superseeds.com/products/dragon-wing-pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs: Part sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia-dragon-wing-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia-dragon-wing-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia-dragon-wing-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Ball Horticultural / PanAmerican Seed (breeder, 'Bepapink')","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=009202294004054","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Characteristics: Drought Tolerant, Colorful/Attractive Foliage, Heat Tolerant, Shade Tolerant, Low Maintenance","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia-dragon-wing-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/begonia/begonia-dragon-wing-seeds-pink.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Create a pollinator paradise and butterfly garden by planting seeds of our Dragon Wing Begonias, a valuable addition to any pollinator seed mix, attracting bees and butterflies with their vibrant blooms.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia-wax-pink-bronze","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height: 6 - 12 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia-wax-pink-bronze","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia-wax-pink-bronze","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia-wax-types/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone 9a to 11b","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia-wax-pink-bronze","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia-wax-types/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/wax-begonia-fibrous-begonia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Will do well in full sun once well-established and if moisture is available"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia-wax-pink-bronze","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia-wax-pink-bronze","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia-wax-pink-bronze","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"begonia-wax-pink-bronze","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"betty-magnolia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"10.00 to 15.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"betty-magnolia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"10.00 to 15.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"betty-magnolia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249456","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/magnolia-betty-betty-magnolia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 - 8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"betty-magnolia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249456","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/magnolia-betty-betty-magnolia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"betty-magnolia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"betty-magnolia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"betty-magnolia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"betty-magnolia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/27935/bidens-ferulifolia/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"A spreading, short-lived perennial to 30cm in height, grown as an annual, with small, finely divided bright green leaves and rich yellow daisies 3-4cm across","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":5,"cultivar":5},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 10-15 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height: 10 - 15 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 60cm Spread: 45cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height Range: 6-12\" (15-30cm)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":5,"cultivar":5},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 1-1.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 60cm Spread: 45cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":5,"cultivar":5},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/27935/bidens-ferulifolia/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/bidens-ferulifolia/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure: Full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"Pick Ontario, Flowers Canada Growers","url":"https://www.po.flowerscanadagrowers.com/our-products/1043/bidens/ferulifolia","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Plant Light: Full Sun","level":"species"},{"name":"Chalet Nursery (NetPS Plant Finder feed)","url":"https://plants.chaletnursery.com/12120004/Plant/13334/Goldilocks_Rocks_Bidens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"bidens ferulifolia"},{"name":"Lucas Greenhouses","url":"https://www.lucasgreenhouses.com/plant/Bidens-ferulifolia-Goldilocks-Rocks","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"bidens ferulifolia"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["bidens ferulifolia"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (bidens ferulifolia), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (bidens ferulifolia) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/27935/bidens-ferulifolia/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["bidens ferulifolia"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (bidens ferulifolia), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (bidens ferulifolia) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/bidens-ferulifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bidens 'Ferulifolia' has no particular known value to wildlife in the UK.","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["bidens ferulifolia"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (bidens ferulifolia), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (bidens ferulifolia) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"9-11 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"36-48 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Lucas Greenhouses","url":"https://www.lucasgreenhouses.com/plant/Bidens-ferulifolia-Beedance-Painted-Orange","country":"US","form":null,"value":"9 to 10","zones":[9,10]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Lucas Greenhouses","url":"https://www.lucasgreenhouses.com/plant/Bidens-ferulifolia-Beedance-Painted-Orange","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Lucas Greenhouses","url":"https://www.lucasgreenhouses.com/plant/Bidens-ferulifolia-Beedance-Painted-Orange","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Lucas Greenhouses","url":"https://www.lucasgreenhouses.com/plant/Bidens-ferulifolia-Beedance-Painted-Orange","country":null,"form":null,"value":"drought tolerance","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Lucas Greenhouses","url":"https://www.lucasgreenhouses.com/plant/Bidens-ferulifolia-Beedance-Painted-Orange","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bidens-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Danziger (breeder), TIMELESS Collection Pretty in Pink Imp.","url":"https://www.danzigeronline.com/catalog/annuals/timeless-collection-pretty-in-pink-imp/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator Friendly","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.61,3.05],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,3.05],"band":[0.61,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (genus factsheet 1192)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rudbeckia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Black-eyed Susans will average 2–3 feet in height and about 1–2 feet in clump width.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":11,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":11},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 11 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.91],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (genus factsheet 1192)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rudbeckia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Black-eyed Susans will average 2–3 feet in height and about 1–2 feet in clump width.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":11},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-10","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[4,10],"level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (genus factsheet 1192)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rudbeckia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Rudbeckia are perennial flowering plants that are hardy in Zones 4–9.","zones":[4,9],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":11},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They tolerate full sun to partial shade in dry to moist conditions and tolerate poorer soils.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (genus factsheet 1192)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rudbeckia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Rudbeckia species have an average growth rate and prefer full sun (greater than 6 hours of direct sunlight) but will tolerate partial shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277225","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-hirta/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Rudbeckia fulgida)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g630","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rudbeckia fulgida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-fulgida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It does best in full sun but tolerates partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Rudbeckia fulgida var. sullivantii)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277462&isprofile=0&gen=Rudbeckia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rudbeckia triloba)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-triloba/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia triloba"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, UW-Madison Division of Extension (Rudbeckia triloba)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/brown-eyed-susan-rudbeckia-triloba/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"R. triloba is tolerant of most conditions but does best in full sun or light shade in sandy, loamy soil.","level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia triloba"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=962&PlantTypeID=14","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun; moist, well drained soils.","level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/black-eyed-susan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Western Maryland black-eyed susans are more tolerant of shade; our state-wide black-eyed susans do best in full sun to part sun.","level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-hirta/"]},{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-fulgida/"]},{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-triloba/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-hirta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rudbeckia fulgida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-fulgida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rudbeckia triloba)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-triloba/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia triloba"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are ncsu.edu. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277225","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Borders. Annual beds. Cottage gardens. Wild gardens. Meadows. Groups or mass plantings. Good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-hirta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Rudbeckia fulgida)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g630","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rudbeckia fulgida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-fulgida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Rudbeckia fulgida var. sullivantii)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277462&isprofile=0&gen=Rudbeckia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rudbeckia triloba)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-triloba/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers bloom in late summer through fall and make an excellent cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia triloba"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, UW-Madison Division of Extension (Rudbeckia triloba)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/brown-eyed-susan-rudbeckia-triloba/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It makes an excellent cut flower and is well suited to prairie plantings.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia triloba"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=RUHI2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The cheerful blossoms of the Black-eyed Susans liven up bouquets.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/black-eyed-susan","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There are many cultivators available to use in the border of a pollinator/native garden, drought tolerant garden or cottage garden.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (genus factsheet 1192)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rudbeckia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Rudbeckia prefer evenly moist, well-drained soils, but they are drought and heat tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277225","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-hirta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Each plant may reach 2 to 4 feet tall and 1 to 2 feet wide and is moderately resistant to salt, deer, and drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Rudbeckia fulgida)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g630","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rudbeckia fulgida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-fulgida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It also bears up under hot, humid summers and, once established, will tolerate drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Rudbeckia fulgida var. sullivantii)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277462&isprofile=0&gen=Rudbeckia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rudbeckia triloba)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-triloba/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a rugged plant, somewhat weedy, that tolerates heat, drought, deer predation, and a wide range of soils.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia triloba"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, UW-Madison Division of Extension (Rudbeckia triloba)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/brown-eyed-susan-rudbeckia-triloba/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It prefers moderate moisture, but it is drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia triloba"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=962&PlantTypeID=14","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates some dryness.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=RUHI2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerance: High","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/rudbeckia-hirta-black-eyed-susan","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Incredibly drought tolerant, Black-eyed Susans are sure to please!","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"}],"note":"12 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They typically have a long bloom season, are easy to grow and attract pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (genus factsheet 1192)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rudbeckia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The showy flowers will attract bees, butterflies, and the seeds are loved by birds.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277225","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-hirta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract a variety of insect visitors and pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Rudbeckia fulgida)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g630","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are attractive to butterflies and other insect pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rudbeckia fulgida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-fulgida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant provides nectar for pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Rudbeckia fulgida var. sullivantii)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277462&isprofile=0&gen=Rudbeckia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are attractive to butterflies and other insect pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rudbeckia triloba)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-triloba/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees, butterflies, and other pollinators with nectar and pollen in the blooms.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia triloba"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=RUHI2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use Wildlife: Nectar-Bees, Nectar-Butterflies, Nectar-insects, Seeds-Granivorous birds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/black-eyed-susan","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Black-eyed susans attract a particularly wide diversity of pollinating insects including flies, beetles, moths, small butterflies, bees, wasps, and sawflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Rudbeckia hirta)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/rudbeckia-hirta-black-eyed-susan","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its bright yellow flowers attract many different butterflies, moths, and bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia hirta"}],"note":"11 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-goldsturm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,0.74],"union":[0.3,1],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-sullivantii-goldsturm/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia sullivantii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=i780","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (HGIC 1192)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rudbeckia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"'Goldsturm' grows to 23-29 inches in height and spreads 18-23 inches.","metres":[0.58,0.74],"band":[0.58,0.74],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/black-eyed-susan-beautiful-and-beneficial","country":"US","form":null,"value":"'Goldstrum' grows to a height of 24 to 36 inches.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=RUDGO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24.0-36.0 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Rudbeckia-fulgida-Goldsturm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1-3 Feet","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Hortech","url":"https://hortech.com/plant/rudbeckia-fulgida-var-sullivantii-goldsturm/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Max Height: 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-goldsturm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.58],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-sullivantii-goldsturm/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia sullivantii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=i780","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (HGIC 1192)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rudbeckia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"'Goldsturm' grows to 23-29 inches in height and spreads 18-23 inches.","metres":[0.46,0.58],"band":[0.46,0.58],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=RUDGO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Rudbeckia-fulgida-Goldsturm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18-24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-goldsturm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","4-9","4-10","5-7","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-sullivantii-goldsturm/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"'Goldsturm' black-eye Susan performs best in full sun and moist, well-drained soils in hardiness zones 3-9.","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia sullivantii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=i780","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (HGIC 1192)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rudbeckia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Goldstrum rudbeckia ( Rudbeckia fuldiga 'Goldstrum') is perennial in zones 4 - 9.","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=RUDGO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4,5,6,7,8,9,10","zones":[4,10],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Rudbeckia-fulgida-Goldsturm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-7","zones":[5,7],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/rudbeckia-fulgida-var-speciosa-goldsturm-goldsturm-black-eyed-susan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-goldsturm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-sullivantii-goldsturm/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia sullivantii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=i780","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (HGIC 1192)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rudbeckia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Rudbeckia species have an average growth rate and prefer full sun (greater than 6 hours of direct sunlight) but will tolerate partial shade.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/black-eyed-susan-beautiful-and-beneficial","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They grow best in full sun but can tolerate partial shade.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=744&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Well-drained soil in full sun location","level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-fulgida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=RUDGO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Rudbeckia-fulgida-Goldsturm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Adaptable to a wide variety of soil conditions in full to partial sun.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Hortech","url":"https://hortech.com/plant/rudbeckia-fulgida-var-sullivantii-goldsturm/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/rudbeckia-fulgida-var-speciosa-goldsturm-goldsturm-black-eyed-susan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants flower best in full sun and moist soil and attract birds and butterflies.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-goldsturm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-goldsturm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-sullivantii-goldsturm/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia sullivantii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=i780","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (HGIC 1192)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rudbeckia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Rudbeckia also make excellent cut flowers for arrangements due to their bright color and strong stems.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/black-eyed-susan-beautiful-and-beneficial","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They make excellent cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-fulgida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=RUDGO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They also make great cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Rudbeckia-fulgida-Goldsturm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Makes a wonderful and long lasting cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-goldsturm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-sullivantii-goldsturm/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is tolerant of partial shade and, once established, it will become more drought-tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia sullivantii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=i780","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Established plants have some tolerance for drought.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (HGIC 1192)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rudbeckia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Rudbeckia prefer evenly moist, well-drained soils, but they are drought and heat tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/black-eyed-susan-beautiful-and-beneficial","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, they are heat and drought-tolerant, blooming from July into October.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-fulgida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It also bears up under hot, humid summers and, once established, will tolerate drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Rudbeckia-fulgida-Goldsturm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates hot, humid summers and some drought.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Hortech","url":"https://hortech.com/plant/rudbeckia-fulgida-var-sullivantii-goldsturm/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"'Goldsturm' Orange Coneflower is moderately drought tolerant but benefits from occasional watering, to maintain soil in a moist but not wet condition, during the summer months.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-goldsturm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-sullivantii-goldsturm/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract birds, butterflies, and bees.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia sullivantii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=i780","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are attractive to butterflies and other insect pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (HGIC 1192)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rudbeckia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The showy flowers will attract bees, butterflies, and the seeds are loved by birds.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/black-eyed-susan-beautiful-and-beneficial","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The halo of yellow petals provides a target and landing pad for many pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=744&PlantTypeID=2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts birds, and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rudbeckia-fulgida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant provides nectar for pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=RUDGO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Rudbeckia-fulgida-Goldsturm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Provides seeds in the winter for birds and nectar for butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/rudbeckia-fulgida-var-speciosa-goldsturm-goldsturm-black-eyed-susan","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants flower best in full sun and moist soil and attract birds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"rudbeckia fulgida"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[2.2,2.44],"union":[0.91,2.68],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a552","country":"US","form":null,"value":"As an annual, it will grow to 3-8’ tall in a single season.","metres":[0.91,2.44],"band":[0.91,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/black-eyed-susan-vine-thunbergia-alata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This trailing or twining vine grows rapidly from seed, reaching up to 8 feet in a single season under ideal conditions, but more often only 3 to 5 feet in the Midwest (and much more in frost free climates).","metres":[0.91,2.44],"band":[0.91,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/black-eyed-susan-vine-thunbergia-alata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Where grown as an annual, plants can reach 8 feet; when grown as a perennial, 20 feet.","metres":2.44,"band":[2.2,2.68],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Climber","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 6-8 Feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The twining vines will grow 3 to 6 feet tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Thunbergia alata 6 to 8 ft.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Thunbergia alata is a soft, perennial climber about 1-5 x 1 m with many twining stems.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"A long-lived (i.e. perennial) herbaceous climber growing up to 5 m in height.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Climber","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 3.00 to 6.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant Width : 6 to 10 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Thunbergia alata is a soft, perennial climber about 1-5 x 1 m with many twining stems.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-11","9-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a552","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Winter hardy to USDA Zones 10-11. In St. Louis, it is perhaps best grown as an annual vine that is replaced each spring.","zones":[10,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thunbergia-alata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[10,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/black-eyed-susan-vine-thunbergia-alata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Thunbergia alata is a tender evergreen perennial in the acanthus family (Acanthaceae) native from tropical East Africa to eastern South Africa that is hardy only in zone 9a and 10a.","zones":[9,10],"level":"species"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/black-eyed-susan-vine-thunbergia-alata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones : 10, 11","zones":[10,11],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a552","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thunbergia-alata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/black-eyed-susan-vine-thunbergia-alata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Thunbergia alata grows best in fertile, moist soil in full sun. It tolerates partial shade but flowering may be reduced.","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=534&PlantTypeID=5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to partail shade. Moist, well drained soils are best.","level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center, Vine Selections for Landscaping","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/vine-selections-for-landscaping/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade; Soils rich in organic matter and regular watering;","level":"species"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/black-eyed-susan-vine-thunbergia-alata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Provide moist, well-drained soil in full sun with some afternoon shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica (South African National Biodiversity Institute)","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/thunbergia-alata","country":"ZA","form":null,"value":"It needs full sun or light shade. It is half-hardy, needing fairly warm conditions but, with protection, young plants can survive some frost. In cold areas treat it as an annual.","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thunbergia-alata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"'Angel Wings' White flowers with a hint of fragrance","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thunbergia-alata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Butterflies, bees, and hummingbirds visit the flowers for nectar.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/black-eyed-susan-vine-thunbergia-alata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies, bees, and hummingbirds will visit the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica (South African National Biodiversity Institute)","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/thunbergia-alata","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Black-eyed susan is probably pollinated by bees.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/89138b-thunbergia-alata-blushing-susie-black-eyed-susan-vine/p/896798","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Vigorous Growth: Rapidly climbs structures, reaching heights of 6-8 feet in a single season.","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored"}],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Climber","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 1.5-2.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Final garden height: 150cm (5 feet).\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height and Width: 5-8'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Blushing Susie Black-Eyed Susan Vine is a trailing or twining, heavy-blooming 4-5 ft. vine with especially showy, 1.5 in. tubular flowers.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"HEIGHT 60 - 96 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 6-10 ft\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Climber","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Growth Width Max 72 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height and Width: 5-8'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 6-10 ft\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-11","9-10","9-11","3-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thunbergia-alata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275277","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (species page)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/black-eyed-susan-vine-thunbergia-alata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"hardy only in zone 9a and 10a","zones":[9,10]},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/89138b-thunbergia-alata-blushing-susie-black-eyed-susan-vine/p/896798","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone Maximum Zone 11b Hardiness Zone Minimum Zone 9a","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"Outsidepride Seed Source","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/thunbergia/thunbergia-seeds-blushing-susie.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA ZONES 3 - 10","zones":[3,10]},{"name":"GardenCenterMarketing plant database","url":"https://www.gardencentermarketing.com/plantName/Thunbergia-alata-Blushing-Susie","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 9-11","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/378501/thunbergia-alata-african-sunset-blushing-susie-mixed/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thunbergia-alata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275277","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (species page)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/black-eyed-susan-vine-thunbergia-alata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows best in fertile, moist soil in full sun. It tolerates partial shade but flowering may be reduced."},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (species page)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=534&PlantTypeID=5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to partail shade. Moist, well drained soils are best."},{"name":"Pinetree Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.superseeds.com/products/blushing-susie-thunbergia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs: Full sun"},{"name":"Outsidepride Seed Source","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/thunbergia/thunbergia-seeds-blushing-susie.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ENVIRONMENT Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thunbergia-alata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies, bees, and hummingbirds visit the flowers for nectar.","claim":true},{"name":"Pinetree Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.superseeds.com/products/blushing-susie-thunbergia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attracts bees, butterflies and hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Climber","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Fast-growing vines reach 4-5 ft. tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Climber","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-11","9-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thunbergia-alata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a552","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/black-eyed-susan-vine-thunbergia-alata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"hardy only in zone 9a and 10a","zones":[9,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thunbergia-alata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a552","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/black-eyed-susan-vine-thunbergia-alata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Thunbergia alata grows best in fertile, moist soil in full sun. It tolerates partial shade but flowering may be reduced."},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/66108/thunbergia-alata/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"black-eyed-susan-vine-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thunbergia-alata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies, bees, and hummingbirds visit the flowers for nectar.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/black-eyed-susan-vine-thunbergia-alata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies, bees, and hummingbirds will visit the flowers.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.61,1],"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lamprocapnos-spectabilis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/the-timeless-beauty-of-bleeding-hearts-in-the-garden/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It typically grows in a loose and graceful mound, reaching a mature height and width of 2 to 3 feet.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Vermont Extension","url":"https://www.uvm.edu/extension/news/plant-profile-bleeding-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They grow 2 to 3 feet tall and wide and bloom for 4 to 6 weeks each spring.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This herbaceous plant forms loose, bushy clumps up to 3 feet tall and 4 feet wide from brittle, fleshy roots.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-bleeding-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows 2 to 3 feet tall and blooms in late spring with rose-pink, heart-shaped flowers that dangle from long leafless stems.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DICSP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"30.0-36.0 Inches","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Fine Gardening","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants can form clumps 3 feet across and almost as tall.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/bleeding-heart-specatabilis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2-3 feet tall and wide","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":1,"species":10},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.3,1.34],"split":[{"range":[0.3,1],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","Penn State Extension","University of Vermont Extension","Nature Hills Nursery","Walters Gardens","Fine Gardening"]},{"range":[1.1,1.34],"sources":["University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lamprocapnos-spectabilis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/the-timeless-beauty-of-bleeding-hearts-in-the-garden/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It typically grows in a loose and graceful mound, reaching a mature height and width of 2 to 3 feet.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Vermont Extension","url":"https://www.uvm.edu/extension/news/plant-profile-bleeding-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They grow 2 to 3 feet tall and wide and bloom for 4 to 6 weeks each spring.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This herbaceous plant forms loose, bushy clumps up to 3 feet tall and 4 feet wide from brittle, fleshy roots.","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DICSP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"30.0-36.0 Inches","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Fine Gardening","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants can form clumps 3 feet across and almost as tall.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/bleeding-heart-specatabilis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2-3 feet tall and wide","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":1,"species":10},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","2-8","2-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lamprocapnos-spectabilis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/the-timeless-beauty-of-bleeding-hearts-in-the-garden/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is hardy from USDA Plant Hardiness Zones 3a through 9b.","zones":[3,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Vermont Extension","url":"https://www.uvm.edu/extension/news/plant-profile-bleeding-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Bleeding hearts are hardy in United States Department of Agriculture Plant Hardiness Zones 3 to 9.","zones":[3,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"is hardy in zones 2-8","zones":[2,8],"level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-bleeding-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is hardy in Zones 3-9.","zones":[3,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DICSP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3,4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"Ohio State University Extension (Buckeye Yard and Garden Line)","url":"https://bygl.osu.edu/node/1539","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The Bleeding Heart Plant can be expected to grow in Hardiness Zones 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"Fine Gardening","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/bleeding-heart-specatabilis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"the extreme cold-hardiness and heat tolerance of these herbaceous perennials throughout USDA growing zones 3 through 9!","zones":[3,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Columbia County","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/columbiaco/2022/02/14/bleeding-hearts-in-the-garden/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant experts say that it can survive in zones 2-9 and is worth trying if you are an adventurous North Florida gardener.","zones":[2,9],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":1,"species":10},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=258957&isprofile=0&basic=lamprocapnos","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lamprocapnos-spectabilis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant grows best in the morning sun with afternoon shade and is tolerant to heavy and partial shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/the-timeless-beauty-of-bleeding-hearts-in-the-garden/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Bleeding hearts thrive in partial to full shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Vermont Extension","url":"https://www.uvm.edu/extension/news/plant-profile-bleeding-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"For best results, plant in partial shade or filtered sunlight in rich soil that drains well.","level":"species"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DICSP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"species"},{"name":"Ohio State University Extension (Buckeye Yard and Garden Line)","url":"https://bygl.osu.edu/node/1539","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Bleeding hearts do best in partial to full shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"Fine Gardening","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Care Grow in moist, humusy soil in part shade. Can take full sun in reliably moist soil.","level":"species"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/bleeding-heart-specatabilis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: These perennials thrive in partial shade to full shade, performing best with cool morning sun and protection from the harsh afternoon heat.","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","strengths":["light"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"University of Vermont Extension","url":"https://www.uvm.edu/extension/news/plant-profile-bleeding-heart","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract bees, butterflies and hummingbirds and offer a mild, sweet fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lamprocapnos-spectabilis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/the-timeless-beauty-of-bleeding-hearts-in-the-garden/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They make good cut flowers, lasting up to 2 weeks in a vase.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants flower from late spring to early summer and the entire stems can be used for cut flowers, lasting up to 2 weeks in a vase.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DICSP","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These racemes make delightful additions to fresh bouquets, lasting about 2 weeks in a vase.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lamprocapnos-spectabilis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/the-timeless-beauty-of-bleeding-hearts-in-the-garden/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers also attract butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Vermont Extension","url":"https://www.uvm.edu/extension/news/plant-profile-bleeding-heart","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract bees, butterflies and hummingbirds and offer a mild, sweet fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-bleeding-heart","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is attractive to hummingbirds and butterflies, while resistant to deer and rabbits.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DICSP","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Hummingbirds Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/bleeding-heart-specatabilis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cold hardy, Low Maintenance, Flowering, Deer-resistant, Attracts pollinators, Non-invasive","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,0.76],"union":[0.5,1],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=y860","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-alba-white-bleeding-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows 2 - 3 feet tall and blooms in late spring with white flowers.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/293051/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-alba/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Dicentra-spectabilis-White-Bleeding-Heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2-3 ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Almanac Planting Co","url":"https://almanacplanting.com/products/bleeding-heart-alba","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 24\"-30\"","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"species":4},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.5,0.61],"union":[0.3,1],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=y860","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/293051/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-alba/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Dicentra-spectabilis-White-Bleeding-Heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1-3 ft","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Almanac Planting Co","url":"https://almanacplanting.com/products/bleeding-heart-alba","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 18\"-24\"","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"species":4},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=y860","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-alba-white-bleeding-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is hardy in zones 3 - 9.","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Dicentra-spectabilis-White-Bleeding-Heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Almanac Planting Co","url":"https://almanacplanting.com/products/bleeding-heart-alba","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"species":4},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=y860","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c480","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lamprocapnos-spectabilis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/the-timeless-beauty-of-bleeding-hearts-in-the-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Bleeding hearts thrive in partial to full shade.","level":"species","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-alba-white-bleeding-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Partial Shade Full Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/293051/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-alba/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Almanac Planting Co","url":"https://almanacplanting.com/products/bleeding-heart-alba","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Partial Shade to Full Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c480","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lamprocapnos-spectabilis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the entire stems can be used for cut flowers, lasting up to 2 weeks in a vase","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/the-timeless-beauty-of-bleeding-hearts-in-the-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They make good cut flowers, lasting up to 2 weeks in a vase.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Dicentra-spectabilis-White-Bleeding-Heart","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=y860","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Intolerant of wet soils in winter and dry soils in summer.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lamprocapnos-spectabilis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is intolerant to wet soils in the winter and dry soils during the summer.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lamprocapnos-spectabilis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Attracts hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/the-timeless-beauty-of-bleeding-hearts-in-the-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers also attract butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-alba-white-bleeding-heart","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The plant is attractive to hummingbirds and butterflies while resistant to deer and rabbits.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamprocapnos spectabilis"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-gold-heart","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.55,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.91],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=258957&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-gold-heart-bleeding-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It has greenish gold foliage and grows 2 to 3 feet tall.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DICGH","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/dicentra/gold-heart-old-fashioned-bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18\" - 2'","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/293050/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-gold-heart-pbr/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"A clump-forming perennial to 60cm tall","metres":0.6,"band":[0.54,0.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis-gold-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height : 1 to 3 feet","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/dicentra-spectabilis-goldheart-dic825","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18-24 inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Dicentra-spectabilis-Gold-Heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24 Inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ballyrobert Gardens","url":"https://www.ballyrobertgardens.com/products/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-gold-heart","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height: 40 - 75 cm (1.3 - 2.5 ft)","metres":[0.4,0.75],"band":[0.4,0.75],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-gold-heart","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.75],"union":[0.3,1],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=258957&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DICGH","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24.0-36.0 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/dicentra/gold-heart-old-fashioned-bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2' - 3'","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/293050/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-gold-heart-pbr/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis-gold-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Width : 1 to 3 feet","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Dicentra-spectabilis-Gold-Heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18 Inches","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ballyrobert Gardens","url":"https://www.ballyrobertgardens.com/products/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-gold-heart","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Spread: 40 - 75 cm (1.3 - 2.5 ft)","metres":[0.4,0.75],"band":[0.4,0.75],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-gold-heart","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","2-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=258957&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lamprocapnos-spectabilis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-gold-heart-bleeding-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plant is hardy in zones 3 to 9.","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DICGH","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/dicentra/gold-heart-old-fashioned-bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3a , 3b , 4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b , 9a , 9b","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"is hardy in zones 2-8","zones":[2,8]},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/the-timeless-beauty-of-bleeding-hearts-in-the-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is hardy from USDA Plant Hardiness Zones 3a through 9b.","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis-gold-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones : 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/dicentra-spectabilis-goldheart-dic825","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3-9","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-gold-heart","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":11,"distinctPublishers":11,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=258957&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lamprocapnos-spectabilis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-gold-heart-bleeding-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Partial Shade"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DICGH","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/dicentra/gold-heart-old-fashioned-bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade to Shade"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/293050/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-gold-heart-pbr/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Partial shade"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/the-timeless-beauty-of-bleeding-hearts-in-the-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Bleeding hearts thrive in partial to full shade."},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis-gold-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Partial Shade"},{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/dicentra-spectabilis-goldheart-dic825","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Dicentra-spectabilis-Gold-Heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade/Shade Tolerant"},{"name":"Ballyrobert Gardens","url":"https://www.ballyrobertgardens.com/products/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-gold-heart","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position: Full sun, partial shade, full shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-gold-heart","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-gold-heart","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DICGH","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower Cut Foliage","claim":true},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/dicentra/gold-heart-old-fashioned-bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: Cut Flower","claim":true},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the entire stems can be used for cut flowers, lasting up to 2 weeks in a vase","claim":true},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/the-timeless-beauty-of-bleeding-hearts-in-the-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They make good cut flowers, lasting up to 2 weeks in a vase.","claim":true},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Dicentra-spectabilis-Gold-Heart","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-gold-heart","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-gold-heart","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lamprocapnos-spectabilis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/lamprocapnos-spectabilis-gold-heart-bleeding-heart","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are attractive to hummingbirds and butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DICGH","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Hummingbirds Bee Friendly","claim":true},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/dicentra/gold-heart-old-fashioned-bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees, Hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/the-timeless-beauty-of-bleeding-hearts-in-the-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers also attract butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/bleeding-heart-dicentra-spectabilis-gold-heart","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Hummingbirds, Showy Foliage","claim":true}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-king-of-hearts","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.25,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.14,0.51],"split":[{"range":[0.14,0.17],"sources":["TERRA NOVA Nurseries"]},{"range":[0.2,0.51],"sources":["Perennials.com","Plant Delights Nursery","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Pleasant Run Nursery"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255537&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.75 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.23,0.46],"band":[0.23,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"TERRA NOVA Nurseries","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/dicentra-king-of-hearts/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size (HT/W/FL HT): 6″ / 14″ / 14″","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennials.com","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/dicentra-king-of-hearts.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 20-25 cm 8-10 inches","metres":[0.2,0.25],"band":[0.2,0.25],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Dicentra-x-King-of-Hearts","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18 Inches","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/dicentra-king-of-hearts","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10\" tall","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-king-of-hearts","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.32,0.33],"union":[0.23,0.46],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255537&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.75 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.23,0.46],"band":[0.23,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"TERRA NOVA Nurseries","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/dicentra-king-of-hearts/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size (HT/W/FL HT): 6″ / 14″ / 14″","metres":0.36,"band":[0.32,0.4],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennials.com","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/dicentra-king-of-hearts.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 30-40 cm 12-16 inches","metres":[0.3,0.41],"band":[0.3,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Dicentra-x-King-of-Hearts","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12 Inches","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-king-of-hearts","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","5-9","2-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255537&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"TERRA NOVA Nurseries","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/dicentra-king-of-hearts/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone(s): 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennials.com","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/dicentra-king-of-hearts.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 2-9","zones":[2,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fine Gardening","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/article/dicentra-king-of-hearts","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dicentra 'King of Hearts' (USDA Hardiness Zones 5-9)","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/dicentra-king-of-hearts","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3a to 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-king-of-hearts","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255537&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dicentra eximia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dicentra-eximia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"dicentra eximia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dicentra)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dicentra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"genus","taxon":"dicentra"},{"name":"TERRA NOVA Nurseries","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/dicentra-king-of-hearts/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Part Shade , Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennials.com","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/dicentra-king-of-hearts.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Dicentra-x-King-of-Hearts","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade/Shade Tolerant","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fine Gardening","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/article/dicentra-king-of-hearts","country":"US","form":null,"value":"For the best flowering, plant it in full sun to partial shade.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/dicentra-king-of-hearts","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Part Sun to Light Shade","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-king-of-hearts","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-king-of-hearts","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dicentra eximia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dicentra-eximia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dicentra eximia"},{"name":"Perennials.com","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/dicentra-king-of-hearts.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-king-of-hearts","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255537&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soils must not be allowed to dry out during summer.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fine Gardening","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/article/dicentra-king-of-hearts","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Similar to other bleeding hearts, 'King of Hearts' needs humus-rich, slightly acidic, sandy to loamy soil; if the soil dries, flowering will wane.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"bleeding-heart-king-of-hearts","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dicentra eximia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dicentra-eximia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dicentra eximia"},{"name":"Perennials.com","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/dicentra-king-of-hearts.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"blue-fescue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.25,0.3],"union":[0.23,0.3],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285404","country":"US","form":null,"value":"0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/festuca-glauca/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 9 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Horticulture Extension","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/blue-fescue-festuca-ovina-glauca/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The clumps grow 10-12 inches high with a similar spread","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fescue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.25,0.46],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285404","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/festuca-glauca/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Horticulture Extension","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/blue-fescue-festuca-ovina-glauca/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The clumps grow 10-12 inches high with a similar spread","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fescue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285404","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/festuca-glauca/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Horticulture Extension","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/blue-fescue-festuca-ovina-glauca/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"hardy in zones 4-8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fescue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285404","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/festuca-glauca/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Horticulture Extension","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/blue-fescue-festuca-ovina-glauca/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Blue fescue grows best in full sun and requires well-drained soil"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fescue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fescue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fescue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285404","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of drought and poor soils.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/festuca-glauca/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fescue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/festuca-glauca/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fescue-silver","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.23,0.56],"split":[{"range":[0.23,0.28],"sources":["Minor's Garden Center plant database"]},{"range":[0.46,0.56],"sources":["Mahoney's Garden Center"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Minor's Garden Center plant database","url":"https://plants.minorsgardencenter.com/12100004/Plant/27154/Cool_As_Ice_Blue_Fescue/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: 10 inches","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Mahoney's Garden Center","url":"https://shop.mahoneysgarden.com/product/blue-fescue-festuca-glauca-cool-as-ice-1-container/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"20″","metres":0.51,"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fescue-silver","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.34,0.67],"split":[{"range":[0.34,0.42],"sources":["Mahoney's Garden Center"]},{"range":[0.55,0.67],"sources":["Minor's Garden Center plant database"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Minor's Garden Center plant database","url":"https://plants.minorsgardencenter.com/12100004/Plant/27154/Cool_As_Ice_Blue_Fescue/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24 inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Mahoney's Garden Center","url":"https://shop.mahoneysgarden.com/product/blue-fescue-festuca-glauca-cool-as-ice-1-container/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"15″","metres":0.38,"band":[0.34,0.42],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fescue-silver","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Mahoney's Garden Center","url":"https://shop.mahoneysgarden.com/product/blue-fescue-festuca-glauca-cool-as-ice-1-container/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 – 9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fescue-silver","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Minor's Garden Center plant database","url":"https://plants.minorsgardencenter.com/12100004/Plant/27154/Cool_As_Ice_Blue_Fescue/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun"},{"name":"Mahoney's Garden Center","url":"https://shop.mahoneysgarden.com/product/blue-fescue-festuca-glauca-cool-as-ice-1-container/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun – part sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fescue-silver","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fescue-silver","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fescue-silver","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Minor's Garden Center plant database","url":"https://plants.minorsgardencenter.com/12100004/Plant/27154/Cool_As_Ice_Blue_Fescue/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is considered to be drought-tolerant, and thus makes an ideal choice for a low-water garden or xeriscape application.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fescue-silver","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fortune-agastache","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.5,1],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243500","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agastache-blue-fortune/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/109004/agastache-blue-fortune/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fortune-agastache","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.46,0.5],"union":[0.1,0.61],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243500","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agastache-blue-fortune/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/109004/agastache-blue-fortune/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fortune-agastache","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[5,9],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243500","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agastache-blue-fortune/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"every source states 5-9; catalog states 5-10","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fortune-agastache","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243500","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agastache-blue-fortune/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/109004/agastache-blue-fortune/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fortune-agastache","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243500","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agastache-blue-fortune/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Blooms are showy and fragrant spikes of lavender-blue flowers appearing from summer through fall and will be covered in pollinators all day.","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/109004/agastache-blue-fortune/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"forming a clump of green, aromatic leafy stems","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fortune-agastache","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243500","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good cut flower.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agastache-blue-fortune/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Good Dried Long Bloom Season Showy","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fortune-agastache","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243500","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants tolerate heat and some dry soils once established.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agastache-blue-fortune/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is tolerant of dry soils and heat once established but it will not tolerate heavy clay or poorly draining soils.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fortune-agastache","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243500","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/agastache-blue-fortune/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract butterflies, hummingbirds, birds, and bees.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-fortune-agastache","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"botanicalName","current":"Agastache 'Blue Fortune'","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[],"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/109004/agastache-blue-fortune/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Accepted"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 1 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. nothing here was scored. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 1","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-girl","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"botanicalName","current":"Rosa 'Blue Girl'","outcome":"NAME-UNVERIFIED","sources":[],"note":"the botanical name could not be confirmed against a registry, so no trait was checked","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"blue-oat-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.61,0.91],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285347","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helictotrichon-sempervirens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/blue-oat-grass.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"reaches 2 to 3 ft. tall and wide","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-oat-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.76],"union":[0.3,0.91],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285347","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helictotrichon-sempervirens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.76],"band":[0.3,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/blue-oat-grass.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"reaches 2 to 3 ft. tall and wide","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-oat-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[4,8],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285347","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helictotrichon-sempervirens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"every source states 4-8; catalog states 4-9","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-oat-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285347","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helictotrichon-sempervirens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/blue-oat-grass.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-oat-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-oat-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-oat-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285347","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helictotrichon-sempervirens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant Garden","claim":true},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/blue-oat-grass.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant in cool climates","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-oat-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"horizon":{"years":20,"sourcesDropped":9,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 30.00 to 60.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 30 ft. 0 in. - 60 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature height 30-60 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Conifer, evergreen tree, 30-60(135) ft [9-18(41) m] tall, dense, narrow to broad pyramid, stiff horizontal branches to the ground, formal in outline.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Colorado spruce is an evergreen coniferous species of tree that grows to mature heights of 165 feet (50 m) tall with a trunk 5 feet (150 cm) in diameter, measured at breast height.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Size Notes: Up to about 150 feet tall.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Tree 30–50 m tall, 1–1.5 m dbh.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Picea pungens is an evergreen Tree growing to 20 m (65ft) by 5 m (16ft) at a medium rate.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Trees to 50 m tall and 150 cm dbh\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 20 years and they do not say which horizon they describe; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"horizon":{"years":20,"sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 10.00 to 20.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 10 ft. 0 in. - 20 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature width 10-20 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Picea pungens is an evergreen Tree growing to 20 m (65ft) by 5 m (16ft) at a medium rate.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 20 years and they do not say which horizon they describe; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,7],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-7","3-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284991&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 7","zones":[2,7],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-pungens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a","zones":[2,7],"level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/blue-spruce/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones Zone 2, Zone 3, Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7","zones":[2,7],"level":"species"},{"name":"Trees and Shrubs Online (International Dendrology Society)","url":"https://www.treesandshrubsonline.org/articles/picea/picea-pungens/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone  3-7","zones":[3,7],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284991&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-pungens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/blue-spruce/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily)","level":"species"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PIPU","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade","level":"species"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/colorado-blue-spruce/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows well in sun or partial shade in any soil","level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea pungens"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-pungens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/blue-spruce/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower color and fragrance Inconspicuous","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"Plants For A Future","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Picea+pungens","country":null,"form":null,"value":"All parts of the plant emit a powerful pungent smell when bruised","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284991&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bloom Time: Non-flowering","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284991&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-pungens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"As this spruce matures, it becomes more drought tolerant and is overall more drought tolerant than other spruces.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/blue-spruce/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance Moderately tolerant","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/picea-pungens","country":null,"form":null,"value":"More drought tolerant than other spruces.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"American Conifer Society","url":"https://conifersociety.org/conifers/picea-pungens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is the most drought-tolerant species of Picea in North America.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PIPU","country":null,"form":null,"value":"More drought-tolerant than other Picea spp.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"The Gymnosperm Database (conifers.org)","url":"https://www.conifers.org/pi/Picea_pungens.php","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is the most drought-tolerant species of Picea in North America ( Burns and Honkala 1990 ).","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plants For A Future","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Picea+pungens","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The species is monoecious (individual flowers are either male or female, but both sexes can be found on the same plant) and is pollinated by Wind.","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-baby-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":18,"sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 15-25 ft\", and this row's size is its size at 18 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"HEIGHT: 8-10 m\", and this row's size is its size at 18 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 15' - 25'\", and this row's size is its size at 18 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Height 15-20 Feet\", and this row's size is its size at 18 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"The Baby Blue spruce reaches a height of 15 to 20 feet, and it usually spreads out to 10 feet.\", and this row's size is its size at 18 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 25 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 18 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 18 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-baby-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":18,"sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 15-20 ft\", and this row's size is its size at 18 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"SPREAD: 4-5 m\", and this row's size is its size at 18 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 10' - 15'\", and this row's size is its size at 18 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Width 10-15 Feet\", and this row's size is its size at 18 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"The Baby Blue spruce reaches a height of 15 to 20 feet, and it usually spreads out to 10 feet.\", and this row's size is its size at 18 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 10 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 18 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Spread: 15 - 20 Feet\", and this row's size is its size at 18 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 18 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-baby-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,7],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-7","4-7","2-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Prides Corner Farms (wholesale grower, Lebanon CT)","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Picea-pungens-Baby-Blue-Blue-Spruce","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"ServeScape (nursery, Atlanta GA)","url":"https://servescape.com/products/picea-pungens-baby-blue-baby-blue-spruce","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"PlantingTree (online nursery, NC)","url":"https://www.plantingtree.com/products/baby-blue-spruce","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones 3-7","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery (wholesale grower, Brighton CO)","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/baby-blue-spruce","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The Baby Blue spruce is a robust tree that can be successfully grown in USDA hardiness zones 4 to 7.","zones":[4,7]},{"name":"Plant Addicts (online nursery)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/baby-blue-blue-spruce","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page, Picea pungens)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284991","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 7","zones":[2,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Picea pungens)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-pungens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a","zones":[2,7]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-baby-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Prides Corner Farms (wholesale grower, Lebanon CT)","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Picea-pungens-Baby-Blue-Blue-Spruce","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow in full sunlight."},{"name":"NVK Nurseries (wholesale grower, Dundas ON)","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Picea-pungens-Baby-Blue","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Characteristics & Attributes Full Sun"},{"name":"ServeScape (nursery, Atlanta GA)","url":"https://servescape.com/products/picea-pungens-baby-blue-baby-blue-spruce","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Full Sun, Part Sun"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery (wholesale grower, Brighton CO)","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/baby-blue-spruce","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Your tree should only be grown in full sunlight."},{"name":"Gertens (garden centre, Inver Grove Heights MN; NetPS Plant Finder entry)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/20666/Baby_Blue_Colorado_Blue_Spruce/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This tree should only be grown in full sunlight."},{"name":"Plant Addicts (online nursery)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/baby-blue-blue-spruce","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Full Sun (At Least 6 Hours Of Direct Sunlight)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page, Picea pungens)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284991","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Picea pungens)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-pungens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-baby-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-baby-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-baby-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Picea-pungens-Baby-Blue","https://servescape.com/products/picea-pungens-baby-blue-baby-blue-spruce"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Picea-pungens-Baby-Blue","https://www.plantingtree.com/products/baby-blue-spruce"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Picea-pungens-Baby-Blue","https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/baby-blue-spruce"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Picea-pungens-Baby-Blue","https://plantaddicts.com/baby-blue-blue-spruce"]}],"sources":[{"name":"NVK Nurseries (wholesale grower, Dundas ON)","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Picea-pungens-Baby-Blue","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"ServeScape (nursery, Atlanta GA)","url":"https://servescape.com/products/picea-pungens-baby-blue-baby-blue-spruce","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established.","claim":true},{"name":"PlantingTree (online nursery, NC)","url":"https://www.plantingtree.com/products/baby-blue-spruce","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once your tree is established it will be drought tolerant.","claim":true},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery (wholesale grower, Brighton CO)","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/baby-blue-spruce","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once it has matured, the Baby Blue spruce is a drought-tolerant tree.","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Addicts (online nursery)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/baby-blue-blue-spruce","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates: Drought","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-baby-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-fat-albert","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":20,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"10.00 to 15.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"8 ft. 0 in. - 15 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 20 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-fat-albert","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":20,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"7.00 to 10.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"7 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 20 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-fat-albert","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,7],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[3,7],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252823","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 to 7","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-pungens-fat-albert/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[3,7]}],"note":"every source states 3-7; catalog states 2-7","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-fat-albert","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252823","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-pungens-fat-albert/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-fat-albert","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-fat-albert","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-fat-albert","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252823","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Although established plants have some drought tolerance, soils should be kept consistently moist and not allowed to dry out in the early years.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-fat-albert","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-hoopsii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":20,"sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 30.00 to 50.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height Width Zone Growth Rate Water Use 30-50 ft. 15-20 ft. 2 Medium Medium\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page's figure is a final size and this row's is its size at 20 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 20 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-hoopsii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":20,"sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 15.00 to 20.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height Width Zone Growth Rate Water Use 30-50 ft. 15-20 ft. 2 Medium Medium\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page's figure is a final size and this row's is its size at 20 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 20 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-hoopsii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,7],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255100&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 7","zones":[2,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Picea pungens)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-pungens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a","zones":[2,7]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-hoopsii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255100&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Picea pungens)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-pungens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-hoopsii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-hoopsii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-hoopsii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255100&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Urban Conditions","claim":true},{"name":"Utah State University Extension, Botanical Center (William A. Varga Arboretum)","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/botanicalcenter/trees-of-varga-arboretum/hoopsi-blue-spruce","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once matured.","claim":true},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Purdue University)","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/481/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Some drought tolerance.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"blue-spruce-hoopsii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bluestar","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/native-amsonia-for-the-home-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They reach heights of 3-4 feet and a similar, if not greater, width.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"amsonia"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"species":8,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"bluestar","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"species":8,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"bluestar","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[4,9],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/native-amsonia-for-the-home-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most native species in the Amsonia genus do well in hardiness zones 4 to 9.","zones":[4,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"amsonia"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/perennials/amsonia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"amsonia"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"species":8,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source states 4-9; catalog states 3-9; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"bluestar","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j320","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"amsonia tabernaemontana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=w810","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"amsonia hubrichtii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amsonia-tabernaemontana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant will grow 2-3 feet tall and wide in an erect clumping form in full sun to partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"amsonia tabernaemontana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amsonia-hubrichtii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Blue star is easily grown in average, medium, well-drained soil in full sun to part shade.","level":"species","taxon":"amsonia hubrichtii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amsonia-ciliata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Blue Star prefers sandy very well-drained soils in full sun but tolerates light shade.","level":"species","taxon":"amsonia ciliata"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/native-amsonia-for-the-home-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They prefer a range of full sun to partial shade, but too much shade can cause them to become open and floppy.","level":"genus","taxon":"amsonia"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture (University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/willowleaf-bluestar-amsonia-tabernaemontana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Willowleaf bluestar grows best in full sun but tolerates partial shade (although it may not flower as well in any shade)","level":"species","taxon":"amsonia tabernaemontana"},{"name":"Brooklyn Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.bbg.org/article/eastern_bluestar","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Though most at home in partial shade and rich organic soil with good moisture retention, it is also tolerant of drought once established and will thrive in full sun and lean soils.","level":"species","taxon":"amsonia tabernaemontana"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center Trial Garden","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/amsonia-for-the-mid-atlantic-region/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Amsonia grow well in a broad spectrum of soil types and sun exposure ranging from full sun to part shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"amsonia"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=AMTA2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade","level":"species","taxon":"amsonia tabernaemontana"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/perennials/amsonia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Sun to Full Sun","level":"genus","taxon":"amsonia"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"bluestar","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/native-amsonia-for-the-home-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There is no noticeable floral fragrance.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"amsonia"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"bluestar","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j320","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers can be used in fresh cut arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amsonia tabernaemontana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=w810","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers can be used in fresh cut arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amsonia hubrichtii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amsonia-tabernaemontana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amsonia tabernaemontana"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture (University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/willowleaf-bluestar-amsonia-tabernaemontana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They last very well as cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amsonia tabernaemontana"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"bluestar","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j320","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates some drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amsonia tabernaemontana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amsonia-tabernaemontana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established and resistant to damage by deer and other herbivores due to the foliage containing a toxic white latex.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amsonia tabernaemontana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amsonia-hubrichtii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It will tolerate poor soils and some drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amsonia hubrichtii"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/native-amsonia-for-the-home-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Mature plants, however, can tolerate dry spells because of a deep taproot and dense fibrous roots.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"amsonia"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture (University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/willowleaf-bluestar-amsonia-tabernaemontana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, plants are drought resistant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amsonia tabernaemontana"},{"name":"Brooklyn Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.bbg.org/article/eastern_bluestar","country":null,"form":null,"value":"it is also tolerant of drought once established and will thrive in full sun and lean soils","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amsonia tabernaemontana"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"bluestar","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j320","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The blooms are attractive to butterflies and other insect pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amsonia tabernaemontana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=w810","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The blooms are attractive to butterflies and other insect pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amsonia hubrichtii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amsonia-tabernaemontana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use eastern bluestar in the border or in groups in native, pollinator, cutting or cottage gardens.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amsonia tabernaemontana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amsonia-hubrichtii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use this plant in borders or groups of cottage, rock or pollinator gardens.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amsonia hubrichtii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amsonia-ciliata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use the plant in groups or borders in pollinator, cottage or rock gardens.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amsonia ciliata"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/native-amsonia-for-the-home-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Native bluestar supports pollinators, including native bees and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"amsonia"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture (University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/willowleaf-bluestar-amsonia-tabernaemontana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are visited by ruby-throated hummingbirds, carpenter and other bees, hummingbird moths","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amsonia tabernaemontana"},{"name":"Brooklyn Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.bbg.org/article/eastern_bluestar","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds, carpenter bees, hummingbird moths, and several other pollinators are also drawn to the plant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amsonia tabernaemontana"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center Trial Garden","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/amsonia-for-the-mid-atlantic-region/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bluestars support early-season pollinators including native bees and hummingbirds and are the host plant for several species of butterflies and moths.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"amsonia"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"bolero-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.05,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.22],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/bolero","https://www.highcountryroses.com/products/bolero"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/bolero","https://www.witherspoonrose.com/products/bolero"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/bolero","https://www.angelgardens.com/products/bolero"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/bolero","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 3' - 4' x 2' - 3'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/products/bolero","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height 3-4ft","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Witherspoon Rose Culture","url":"https://www.witherspoonrose.com/products/bolero","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 3-4' h x 2-3' w","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Angel Gardens","url":"https://www.angelgardens.com/products/bolero","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 3 - 4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"bolero-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.65,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.61,0.91],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/bolero","https://www.highcountryroses.com/products/bolero"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/bolero","https://www.witherspoonrose.com/products/bolero"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/bolero","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 3' - 4' x 2' - 3'","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/products/bolero","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width 2-3ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Witherspoon Rose Culture","url":"https://www.witherspoonrose.com/products/bolero","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 3-4' h x 2-3' w","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"bolero-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","4-9","7-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/bolero","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Witherspoon Rose Culture","url":"https://www.witherspoonrose.com/products/bolero","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardy to Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Angel Gardens","url":"https://www.angelgardens.com/products/bolero","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 7 - 10","zones":[7,10],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"bolero-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/bolero","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sun Requires 6+ hours of direct sunlight to thrive.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Witherspoon Rose Culture","url":"https://www.witherspoonrose.com/products/bolero","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Sun Requirements: Full Sun 6+ Hours","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"bolero-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["strong","strong","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/bolero","https://www.highcountryroses.com/products/bolero"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/bolero","https://www.witherspoonrose.com/products/bolero"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/bolero","https://www.angelgardens.com/products/bolero"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/bolero","country":null,"form":null,"value":"an extraordinarily strong fragrance of traditional rose mixed with tropical fruit","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/products/bolero","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bolero's scent is very strong rose with fruity notes.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Witherspoon Rose Culture","url":"https://www.witherspoonrose.com/products/bolero","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Lemon, verbena","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Angel Gardens","url":"https://www.angelgardens.com/products/bolero","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Strong fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"bolero-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/bolero","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets and floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"bolero-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"bolero-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"bonica-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.52],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253426","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ball Seed","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/WEBTRACKPLANTINFO.ASPX?PHID=181400001011287&env=P","country":"US","form":null,"value":"36 - 60\" (91 - 152cm)","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bonica-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.37,1.52],"union":[0.91,1.52],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253426","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ball Seed","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/WEBTRACKPLANTINFO.ASPX?PHID=181400001011287&env=P","country":"US","form":null,"value":"54 - 60\" (137 - 152cm)","metres":[1.37,1.52],"band":[1.37,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bonica-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253426","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Ball Seed","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/WEBTRACKPLANTINFO.ASPX?PHID=181400001011287&env=P","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5a - 9b","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bonica-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253426","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bonica-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Ball Seed","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/WEBTRACKPLANTINFO.ASPX?PHID=181400001011287&env=P","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bonica-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bonica-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"bonica-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253426","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boscobel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.2],"union":[0.82,1.34],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/boscobel","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/boscobel","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4'x4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/boscobel-english-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mature Height 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Angel Gardens","url":"https://angelgardens.com/rose/boscobel/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/boscobel-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Belle Epoque Rozenkwekerij","url":"https://belle-epoque.nl/products/boscobel-auscousin","country":"NL","form":"shrub","value":"Hoogte 100-120 cm","metres":[1,1.2],"band":[1,1.2],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/boscobel","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 3 1/2ft (110cm)","metres":1.07,"band":[0.96,1.18],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"boscobel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.1,1.34],"union":[0.61,1.34],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/boscobel","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/boscobel","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4'x4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/boscobel-english-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mature Spread 2-3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/boscobel-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Spread: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Belle Epoque Rozenkwekerij","url":"https://belle-epoque.nl/products/boscobel-auscousin","country":"NL","form":"shrub","value":"Boscobel groeit uit tot een compacte, bossige struik van ongeveer 100 tot 120 cm hoog en circa 100 cm breed","metres":1,"band":[0.9,1.1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/boscobel","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3 1/2ft (110cm)","metres":1.07,"band":[0.96,1.18],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"SPLIT"},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"boscobel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","5-8","6-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/boscobel","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/boscobel","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/boscobel-english-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"USDA Hardiness Zones 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Angel Gardens","url":"https://angelgardens.com/rose/boscobel/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 6 - 9","zones":[6,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/boscobel-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable Zones: 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"boscobel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/boscobel","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/boscobel","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/boscobel","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sun Requires 6+ hours of direct sunlight to thrive.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/boscobel-english-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light Exposure Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"boscobel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["medium","medium","medium","medium","medium","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/boscobel","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/boscobel"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/boscobel","https://heirloomroses.com/products/boscobel"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/boscobel","https://plantaddicts.com/boscobel-english-rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/boscobel","https://angelgardens.com/rose/boscobel/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/boscobel","https://menagerieflower.com/products/boscobel-rose-david-austin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/boscobel","https://belle-epoque.nl/products/boscobel-auscousin"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/boscobel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The myrrh fragrance has delicious hints of hawthorn, elderflower, pear and almond.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/boscobel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The myrrh fragrance has delicious hints of hawthorn, elderflower, pear and almond.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/boscobel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Moderately Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/boscobel-english-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Angel Gardens","url":"https://angelgardens.com/rose/boscobel/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Moderate, myrrh fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/boscobel-rose-david-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong - Myrrh","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Belle Epoque Rozenkwekerij","url":"https://belle-epoque.nl/products/boscobel-auscousin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"De geur is een van de grote kwaliteiten van Boscobel.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 7 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 7","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"boscobel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/boscobel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Mixed Border Rose Border","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/boscobel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Boscobel is a repeat bloomer that is perfect for cutting gardens in zones 5-11.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/boscobel-english-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Garden","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"boscobel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"boscobel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/boscobel-english-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"boston-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Fern","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.5 to 4 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Fern","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-12","10-13","8-11","9-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c548","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 12","zones":[10,12]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nephrolepis-exaltata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10a, 10b, 11a, 11b, 12a, 12b, 13a, 13b","zones":[10,13]},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FP427)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP427","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA hardiness zones: 8B through 11","zones":[8,11]},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/boston-fern-nephrolepis-exaltata-bostoniensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This evergreen fern is hardy in zones 9 to 11","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c548","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nephrolepis-exaltata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight)"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FP427)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP427","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in part shade/part sun; plant grows in the shade"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/boston-fern-nephrolepis-exaltata-bostoniensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"If growing outdoors, provide full or partial shade."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c548","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Will shed fronds if soils dry out","claim":false},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nephrolepis-exaltata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This fern needs high humidity and moist soil that should never be allowed to dry out.","claim":false},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/boston-fern-nephrolepis-exaltata-bostoniensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Boston fern does best with consistent moisture, but is fairly drought tolerant.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-ivy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":12,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[10.8,12.19],"union":[9.14,20.12],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287537","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 30.00 to 50.00 feet","metres":[9.14,15.24],"band":[9.14,15.24],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/parthenocissus-tricuspidata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 30 ft. 0 in. - 60 ft. 0 in.","metres":[9.14,18.29],"band":[9.14,18.29],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Minnesota UFOR Nursery & Lab","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/boston-ivy-parthenocissus-tricuspidata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 30 to 50 ft","metres":[9.14,15.24],"band":[9.14,15.24],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/ivy/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"when supported, may reach a height of 60 feet","metres":18.29,"band":[16.46,20.12],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21180/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Height: 30-50 feet","metres":[9.14,15.24],"band":[9.14,15.24],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/parthenocissus-tricuspidata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Deciduous vine, 30-40 ft (9-12 m).","metres":[9.14,12.19],"band":[9.14,12.19],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/12350/parthenocissus-tricuspidata/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height Higher than 12 metres","metres":12,"band":[10.8,13.2],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-ivy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":3,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1.52,15.24],"split":[{"range":[1.52,3.05],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","University of Minnesota UFOR Nursery & Lab","Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC"]},{"range":[7.2,8.8],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society"]},{"range":[9.14,15.24],"sources":["Purdue Arboretum Explorer"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287537","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 5.00 to 10.00 feet","metres":[1.52,3.05],"band":[1.52,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/parthenocissus-tricuspidata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 5 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.52,3.05],"band":[1.52,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Minnesota UFOR Nursery & Lab","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/boston-ivy-parthenocissus-tricuspidata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 5 to 10 ft","metres":[1.52,3.05],"band":[1.52,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/ivy/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is typically 5 to 10 feet wide","metres":[1.52,3.05],"band":[1.52,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21180/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Spread: 30-50 feet","metres":[9.14,15.24],"band":[9.14,15.24],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/12350/parthenocissus-tricuspidata/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread wider than 8 metres","metres":8,"band":[7.2,8.8],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 3 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-ivy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287537","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/parthenocissus-tricuspidata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"University of Minnesota UFOR Nursery & Lab","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/boston-ivy-parthenocissus-tricuspidata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/ivy/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"hardy in USDA Plant Hardiness Zones 4 through 9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-ivy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287537","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/parthenocissus-tricuspidata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"University of Minnesota UFOR Nursery & Lab","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/boston-ivy-parthenocissus-tricuspidata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Boston Ivy is easily grown in average, dry to medium, well-drained soils in full sun to part shade."},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21180/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/parthenocissus-tricuspidata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to full shade."},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/12350/parthenocissus-tricuspidata/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full shade, Full sun, Partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-ivy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-ivy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-ivy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287537","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Heavy Shade, Erosion, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil, Black Walnut","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/parthenocissus-tricuspidata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Black Walnut Deer Drought Dry Soil Erosion Heavy Shade Poor Soil","claim":true},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21180/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-ivy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/parthenocissus-tricuspidata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant attracts bees and birds.","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/ivy/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers, though inconspicuous, are attractive to bees, and songbirds consume the fruit.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-ivy-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[9.14,12],"union":[8,15.24],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/plantfinderdetails.aspx?taxonid=251629","country":"US","form":null,"value":"30.00 to 50.00 feet","metres":[9.14,15.24],"band":[9.14,15.24],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/93819/parthenocissus-tricuspidata-veitchii/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"8-12 metres","metres":[8,12],"band":[8,12],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-ivy-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":3,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1.52,8],"split":[{"range":[1.52,3.05],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder"]},{"range":[4,8],"sources":["RHS"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/plantfinderdetails.aspx?taxonid=251629","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5.00 to 10.00 feet","metres":[1.52,3.05],"band":[1.52,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/93819/parthenocissus-tricuspidata-veitchii/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"4-8 metres","metres":[4,8],"band":[4,8],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-ivy-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/plantfinderdetails.aspx?taxonid=251629","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-ivy-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/plantfinderdetails.aspx?taxonid=251629","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/93819/parthenocissus-tricuspidata-veitchii/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-ivy-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-ivy-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-ivy-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/plantfinderdetails.aspx?taxonid=251629","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer, Drought, Heavy Shade, Erosion, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil, Black Walnut","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boston-ivy-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/93819/parthenocissus-tricuspidata-veitchii/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants for pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boxwood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/boxwood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Boxwood varieties come in a range of shapes including rounded, upright, pyramidal or spreading, with sizes ranging from 1-20 feet tall and 2-8 feet wide, depending on the variety.","metres":[0.3,6.1],"band":[0.3,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"species":8,"cultivar":1,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boxwood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/boxwood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Boxwood varieties come in a range of shapes including rounded, upright, pyramidal or spreading, with sizes ranging from 1-20 feet tall and 2-8 feet wide, depending on the variety.","metres":[0.61,2.44],"band":[0.61,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"species":8,"cultivar":1,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boxwood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most boxwoods are suitable for USDA zones 5-9, Hybrid boxwood varieties are available that can tolerate cold down to USDA zones 4-5.","zones":[5,9],"level":"genus"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/boxwood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Boxwood hardiness zone is generally from 5-9, though a few cultivars are hardy to zone 4.","zones":[5,9],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"species":8,"cultivar":1,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boxwood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=e223","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"buxus sempervirens"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278322","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g120","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They prefer partial or dappled shade but can tolerate full sun.","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus-sempervirens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"buxus sempervirens"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus-microphylla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in full sun to light shade but provide some protection from wind and winter weather, as foliage tends to turn an orangish-brown with extremes on some varieties.","level":"species","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus-sinica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It can be grown in average garden soil with medium moisture and good drainage in full to partial sun.","level":"species","taxon":"buxus sinica"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Boxwood grow best in part shade. They can tolerate morning sun so long as they have afternoon shade. Korean boxwood is the most sun-tolerant boxwood. Boxwood grown in full sun are more likely to have cold damage in the winter.","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=326&PlantTypeID=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to partial shade; mulch to keep root system cool and moist; does well in alkaline soils; the evergreen foliage needs to be protected from drying winds in winter.","level":"species","taxon":"buxus sempervirens"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/common-boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily), Full shade (4 hrs or less of light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"buxus sempervirens"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/boxwood-hybrids/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily)","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boxwood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Malodorous","claim":false,"level":"genus"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/boxwood-hybrids/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tiny, fragrant, creamy yellow clusters form in the leaf axils.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":4,"covered":["buxus microphylla","buxus sempervirens"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (buxus microphylla), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus","this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (buxus sempervirens), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"SPLIT"},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required; 4 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover 2 taxa and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boxwood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boxwood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"While tolerant of some drought, boxwoods should be mulched and irrigated during long dry periods particularly in the first year to prevent stress that may make them susceptible to disease.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus-sempervirens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Particularly Resistant To (Insects/Diseases/Other Problems): Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buxus sempervirens"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus-microphylla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established this plant is typically quite drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus-sinica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#drought tolerant #broadleaf evergreen","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buxus sinica"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/common-boxwood/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other tolerances Dry sites, Road salt","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buxus sempervirens"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/boxwood-hybrids/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other tolerances Alkaline soil, Dry sites","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boxwood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["buxus microphylla"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (buxus microphylla), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (buxus microphylla) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"boxwood-green-velvet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1],"union":[0.61,1.22],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243327","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus-green-velvet/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/green-velvet-boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 3 - 4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/green-velvet-boxwood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height : 3-4 ft.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/green-velvet-boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 3-4 ft","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/boxwood-green-velvet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 36-48 Inches","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/green-velvet-boxwood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Green Velvet Boxwood will grow to be about 3 feet tall at maturity, with a spread of 3 feet.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/boxwood-green-velvet/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height 3' - 4' (ft)","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"boxwood-green-velvet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1],"union":[0.61,1.22],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243327","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus-green-velvet/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/green-velvet-boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 3 - 4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/green-velvet-boxwood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width : 3-4 ft.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/green-velvet-boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 3-4 ft","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/boxwood-green-velvet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 36-48 Inches","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/green-velvet-boxwood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Green Velvet Boxwood will grow to be about 3 feet tall at maturity, with a spread of 3 feet.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/boxwood-green-velvet/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Spread 3' - 4' (ft)","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"boxwood-green-velvet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243327","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus-green-velvet/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/green-velvet-boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 4 - 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/green-velvet-boxwood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In Zones : 4-9 outdoors","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/green-velvet-boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In: Zones 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/boxwood-green-velvet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/boxwood-green-velvet/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone(s) 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"boxwood-green-velvet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243327","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus-green-velvet/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/green-velvet-boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Partial Shade to Full Sun (At Least 3 Hours Of Direct Sunlight)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/green-velvet-boxwood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight : Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/green-velvet-boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs : Full Sun, Partial Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/boxwood-green-velvet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/green-velvet-boxwood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub does best in full sun to partial shade.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/boxwood-green-velvet/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun, Partial Sun, Shade","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"boxwood-green-velvet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus-green-velvet/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"boxwood-green-velvet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"boxwood-green-velvet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://plantaddicts.com/green-velvet-boxwood/","https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/green-velvet-boxwood"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://plantaddicts.com/green-velvet-boxwood/","https://www.thetreecenter.com/green-velvet-boxwood/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://plantaddicts.com/green-velvet-boxwood/","https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/boxwood-green-velvet"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://plantaddicts.com/green-velvet-boxwood/","https://patuxentnursery.com/product/boxwood-green-velvet/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/green-velvet-boxwood/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates: Drought","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/green-velvet-boxwood","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates urban pollution and drought","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/green-velvet-boxwood/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water regularly when young, but established plants will be unaffected by normal summer dry periods.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/boxwood-green-velvet","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/boxwood-green-velvet/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Afterward, this plant tolerates moderate drought but flourishes with consistent moisture.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"boxwood-green-velvet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus-green-velvet/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/green-velvet-boxwood/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/green-velvet-boxwood","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting bees to your yard, but is not particularly attractive to deer who tend to leave it alone in favor of tastier treats.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"boxwood-winter-gem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,1.22],"union":[0.61,1.52],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=449822&isprofile=0&fam=1083","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus sinica"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Buxus-microphylla-var-japonica-Winter-Gem","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Tall: 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/winter-gem-boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 2-5 ft","metres":[0.61,1.52],"band":[0.61,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/winter-gem-boxwood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height : 4-5 ft.","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/winter-gem-boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 3 - 4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/boxwood-winter-gem","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 2-3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":2,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"boxwood-winter-gem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,1.22],"union":[0.61,1.52],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=449822&isprofile=0&fam=1083","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus sinica"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Buxus-microphylla-var-japonica-Winter-Gem","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Wide: 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/winter-gem-boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 2-4 ft","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/winter-gem-boxwood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width : 4-5 ft.","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/winter-gem-boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 3 - 4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/boxwood-winter-gem","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 2-3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":2,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"boxwood-winter-gem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","6-8","6-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=449822&isprofile=0&fam=1083","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus sinica"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Buxus-microphylla-var-japonica-Winter-Gem","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 6-8","zones":[6,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/winter-gem-boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In: Zones 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/winter-gem-boxwood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In Zones : 5-9 outdoors","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/winter-gem-boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 5 - 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/boxwood-winter-gem","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 6-10","zones":[6,10],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":2,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"boxwood-winter-gem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=449822&isprofile=0&fam=1083","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus sinica"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus-microphylla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus-microphylla-var-japonica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Boxwood grow best in part shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"buxus"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/winter-gem-boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Winter Gem Japanese Boxwood grows well in a wide range of light conditions, from full sun to moderate shade, and it will thrive in any kind of soil that is not constantly wet.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/winter-gem-boxwood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The Winter Gem works best in full sun to partial shade in any well-drained soil.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/winter-gem-boxwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Partial Sun to Full Sun (At Least 5 Hours of Direct Sunlight)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/boxwood-winter-gem","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"boxwood-winter-gem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=449822&isprofile=0&fam=1083","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are sparse and insignificant, but quite fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus sinica"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/winter-gem-boxwood/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Discreet, lightly fragrant spring flowers draw early pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"boxwood-winter-gem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"boxwood-winter-gem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus-microphylla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established this plant is typically quite drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus-microphylla-var-japonica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, it is very drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/winter-gem-boxwood/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established it is tolerant of normal summer dry periods, and if you don't feel like trimming, but want an attractive background evergreen shrub, it will be that too.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/winter-gem-boxwood/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates: Drought","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/boxwood-winter-gem","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"boxwood-winter-gem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus-microphylla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buxus-microphylla-var-japonica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buxus microphylla"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/winter-gem-boxwood/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buxus microphylla"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"browallia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.35,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 to 2 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height: 12 - 20 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 12-20 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 12-18\" / 30-46cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"browallia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.75 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1 to 2 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.5 to 1 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"browallia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["9-10","9-11","10-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b739","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 9 to 10","zones":[9,10],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/browallia-speciosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[9,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"MyGardenLife Plant Library","url":"https://mygardenlife.com/plant-library/browallia-bush-violet-browallia-speciosa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 10, 11","zones":[10,11],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":3},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"browallia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b739","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/browallia-speciosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FPS75)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp075","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in partial shade","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Flowers)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/browallia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun, Partial Sun/Shade","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=979&PlantTypeID=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Full Shade Partial Sun/Shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene3b12.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: part shade full shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Chalet Nursery (NetPS Plant Finder), Browallia speciosa 'Blue Bells'","url":"https://plants.chaletnursery.com/12120004/Plant/16788/Blue_Bells_Amethyst_Flower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in partial shade to shade.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"browallia speciosa"},{"name":"MyGardenLife Plant Library","url":"https://mygardenlife.com/plant-library/browallia-bush-violet-browallia-speciosa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Sun to Part Shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Horticopia, Browallia speciosa 'Marine Bells'","url":"https://www.horticopia.info/Plants/098/brospe004.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full shade to partial shade or partial sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"browallia speciosa"},{"name":"Vite Greenhouses, Browallia speciosa 'Marine Bells'","url":"https://www.vitegreenhouses.com/PlantDetail.asp?PlantID=A008007","country":"US","form":null,"value":"EXPOSURE Full Sun to Part Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"browallia speciosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"browallia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"browallia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/browallia-speciosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Landscape Theme: Cottage Garden Cutting Garden Rock Garden","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FPS75)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp075","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Browallia is well suited for containers, planted en masse, or may be used as cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"browallia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b739","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Do not allow soils to dry out.","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FPS75)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp075","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance: low","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["browallia speciosa"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (browallia speciosa), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (browallia speciosa) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"browallia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/browallia-speciosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FPS75)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp075","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attracts pollinators and hummingbirds with its tubular-shaped flowers","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["browallia speciosa"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (browallia speciosa), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (browallia speciosa) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"brunner-silver-heart","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.45,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.36,0.46],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-brunnera","country":"US","form":null,"value":"'Silver Heart' Spring 6\"-12\" 12\"-24\" Compact with thick, bright silver foliage.","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/322075/brunnera-macrophylla-silver-heart-pbr/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Brunnera-macrophylla-Silver-Heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12 Inches","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/bnrunnera-silver-heart-forget-me-not-1g.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height at Maturity: 14-18\"","metres":[0.36,0.46],"band":[0.36,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Northwest Blooms","url":"https://www.northwestblooms.com/groundcovers/p/brunnera-macrophylla-silver-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12 to 18 inches tall","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"brunner-silver-heart","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.5,0.61],"union":[0.3,1],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-brunnera","country":"US","form":null,"value":"'Silver Heart' Spring 6\"-12\" 12\"-24\" Compact with thick, bright silver foliage.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/322075/brunnera-macrophylla-silver-heart-pbr/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Brunnera-macrophylla-Silver-Heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18 Inches","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/bnrunnera-silver-heart-forget-me-not-1g.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width at Maturity: 20-24\"","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Northwest Blooms","url":"https://www.northwestblooms.com/groundcovers/p/brunnera-macrophylla-silver-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 18 to 24 inches wide","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"brunner-silver-heart","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-7","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243231","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/brunnera-macrophylla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/brunnera-macrophylla-silver-heart-silver-heart-siberian-bugloss","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 7","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/bnrunnera-silver-heart-forget-me-not-1g.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zones: 4a-8b","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Northwest Blooms","url":"https://www.northwestblooms.com/groundcovers/p/brunnera-macrophylla-silver-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing zone: USDA Zones 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"brunner-silver-heart","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243231","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/brunnera-macrophylla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-brunnera","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Brunnera performs best in partial to full shade."},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/322075/brunnera-macrophylla-silver-heart-pbr/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full shade, Partial shade"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/brunnera-macrophylla-silver-heart-silver-heart-siberian-bugloss","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Partial Shade Full Shade"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Brunnera-macrophylla-Silver-Heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade/Shade Tolerant"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/bnrunnera-silver-heart-forget-me-not-1g.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs: Full Shade to Mostly Shade (avoid direct afternoon sun)"},{"name":"Northwest Blooms","url":"https://www.northwestblooms.com/groundcovers/p/brunnera-macrophylla-silver-heart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirements: Partial to full shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"brunner-silver-heart","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"brunner-silver-heart","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"brunner-silver-heart","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/brunnera-macrophylla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is intolerant of dry soils and hot and humid climates.","claim":false},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-brunnera","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dry soils or drought conditions, often results in browning or tattered foliage later in the season.","claim":false}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"brunner-silver-heart","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/brunnera-macrophylla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#pollinator plant","claim":true},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Brunnera-macrophylla-Silver-Heart","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/bnrunnera-silver-heart-forget-me-not-1g.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies, Hummingbirds, Visual Attention","claim":true},{"name":"Northwest Blooms","url":"https://www.northwestblooms.com/groundcovers/p/brunnera-macrophylla-silver-heart","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife attractors: Attracts bees and butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"brunner-silver-heart","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"botanicalName","current":"Brunnera macrophylla 'Silver Heart'","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"IPNI (Kew)","url":"https://www.ipni.org/n/113714-1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Accepted: Brunnera macrophylla ( Adams ) I.M.Johnst. , Contr. Gray Herb. 73: 54 (1924). The IPNI record for this name carries inPowo: true"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/322075/brunnera-macrophylla-silver-heart-pbr/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Accepted cultivar: RHS Plant Profile page titled Brunnera macrophylla 'Silver Heart' PBR, common name Siberian bugloss 'Silver Heart'"},{"name":"POWO","url":"https://powo.science.kew.org/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Not searched: every powo.science.kew.org URL returned HTTP 403 behind a Cloudflare interstitial from this environment. Kew's nomenclator IPNI was used instead and its record reports the name as present in POWO"}],"note":"name resolves as Brunnera macrophylla 'Silver Heart' PBR (US plant patent PP24685)","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"brunnera","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.3,0.38],"union":[0.1,0.91],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/brunnera-macrophylla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/plantfinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243231","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/2433/brunnera-macrophylla/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/brunnera-macrophylla.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Height 30-45 cm 12-18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.45],"band":[0.3,0.45],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Brunnera-macrophylla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12-15 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.38],"band":[0.3,0.38],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Babikow Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.babikow.com/plant-name/Brunnera-macrophylla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12-15 in","metres":[0.3,0.38],"band":[0.3,0.38],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/siberian-bugloss-brunnera-macrophylla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height : 1 to 3 feet","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"brunnera","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.5],"union":[0.1,0.91],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/brunnera-macrophylla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.46,0.76],"band":[0.46,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/plantfinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243231","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.46,0.76],"band":[0.46,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/2433/brunnera-macrophylla/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/brunnera-macrophylla.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Spread 30-45 cm 12-18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.45],"band":[0.3,0.45],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Brunnera-macrophylla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 15-18 Inches","metres":[0.38,0.46],"band":[0.38,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Babikow Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.babikow.com/plant-name/Brunnera-macrophylla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18-30 in","metres":[0.46,0.76],"band":[0.46,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/siberian-bugloss-brunnera-macrophylla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Width : 1 to 3 feet","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"brunnera","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","2-9","3-7","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/brunnera-macrophylla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/plantfinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243231","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/brunnera-macrophylla.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 2-9","zones":[2,9],"level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Brunnera-macrophylla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-7","zones":[3,7],"level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Babikow Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.babikow.com/plant-name/Brunnera-macrophylla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Avant Gardens","url":"https://www.avantgardensne.com/product/brunnera-macrophylla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Heritage Flower Farm","url":"https://www.heritageflowerfarm.com/product/brunnera-macrophyllum-siberian-bugloss-z-3-7/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Siberian bugloss Z 3-7","zones":[3,7],"level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/siberian-bugloss-brunnera-macrophylla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones : 3, 4, 5, 6, 7","zones":[3,7],"level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"brunnera","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/brunnera-macrophylla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant prefers partial shade to full shade with protection from the afternoon sun, and fertile, moist, well-drained soils.","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/plantfinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243231","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/2433/brunnera-macrophylla/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full shade, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (University of Wisconsin-Madison)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/brunnera-macrophylla-jack-frost/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant 'Jack Frost' in part shade (preferably morning sun and afternoon shade) in moist soil with good drainage.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/brunnera-macrophylla.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Partial Shade or Full Shade","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Brunnera-macrophylla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Shade","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Avant Gardens","url":"https://www.avantgardensne.com/product/brunnera-macrophylla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Part Shade","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/siberian-bugloss-brunnera-macrophylla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Partial Shade to Full Shade","level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"brunnera","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"brunnera","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.perennials.com/plants/brunnera-macrophylla.html","https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Brunnera-macrophylla"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.perennials.com/plants/brunnera-macrophylla.html","https://www.babikow.com/plant-name/Brunnera-macrophylla"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/brunnera-macrophylla.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Brunnera-macrophylla","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Babikow Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.babikow.com/plant-name/Brunnera-macrophylla","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"brunnera","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"taxon-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/brunnera-macrophylla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is intolerant of dry soils and hot and humid climates.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/plantfinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243231","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Generally intolerant of dry soils, but tolerates some dryness better than most other cultivars of this species.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["brunnera macrophylla"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (brunnera macrophylla), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"this came out more confident than v6 only once the distinct-taxa rule removed the claim(s) that disagreed, so it is a disagreement about which taxa were speaking rather than a finding; v6 recorded INSUFFICIENT; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (brunnera macrophylla) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"brunnera","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/brunnera-macrophylla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"},{"name":"Avant Gardens","url":"https://www.avantgardensne.com/product/brunnera-macrophylla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer and rabbit resistant and pollinator friendly.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"brunnera macrophylla"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"butterfly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"7.00 to 12.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"grows 7 to 12 feet in height with a slightly narrower spread\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"4.00 to 8.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","6-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241783","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/acer-palmatum-butterfly-japanese-maple","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6 - 9","zones":[6,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241783","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/acer-palmatum-butterfly-japanese-maple","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1.52,5.03],"split":[{"range":[1.52,4],"sources":["Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","The Morton Arboretum","Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","Missouri Botanical Garden","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","University of Maryland Extension","Royal Horticultural Society"]},{"range":[4.11,5.03],"sources":["University of Missouri IPM (Summer Color from Shrubs)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271488","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6.00 to 12.00 feet","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6 ft. 0 in. - 12 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/butterfly-bush/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This deciduous to semi-evergreen shrub typically grows from 6 to 10 feet tall by 4 to 10 feet wide with a rather open, arching form.","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/butterfly-bush/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This is a medium shrub or woody perennial which grows 6 to 8 feet high and 5 to 8 feet wide.","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/butterfly-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Typical mature size: 6 to 12 feet tall for non-dwarf forms; dwarf cultivars can stay as short as 4 to 5 feet or less in height and width, especially if pruned","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/2002/2-22-2002/butterflybushes.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"However, they're generally regarded as herbaceous perennials in Iowa because they typically die back to the ground each winter. Fortunately, their performance is not greatly affected by the extensive dieback. Butterfly bushes grow back rapidly after the dead wood is removed in early spring and bloom on the current year's growth. Plants generally have a loose, open, arching habit. By the end of summer, plants are often 5 to 6 feet tall.","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/2448/buddleja-davidii/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 2.5-4 metres","metres":[2.5,4],"band":[2.5,4],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Missouri IPM (Summer Color from Shrubs)","url":"https://ipm.missouri.edu/MEG/2018/7/summerShrubs/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"the species is a vigorous shrub which can grow to a mature height of 15 feet","metres":4.57,"band":[4.11,5.03],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.52,2.44],"union":[1.22,8],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271488","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4.00 to 15.00 feet","metres":[1.22,4.57],"band":[1.22,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 4 ft. 0 in. - 15 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,4.57],"band":[1.22,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/butterfly-bush/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This deciduous to semi-evergreen shrub typically grows from 6 to 10 feet tall by 4 to 10 feet wide with a rather open, arching form.","metres":[1.22,3.05],"band":[1.22,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/butterfly-bush/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This is a medium shrub or woody perennial which grows 6 to 8 feet high and 5 to 8 feet wide.","metres":[1.52,2.44],"band":[1.52,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/2448/buddleja-davidii/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 4-8 metres","metres":[4,8],"band":[4,8],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271488","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/butterfly-bush/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These shrubs are very cold-hardy (USDA Zones 5 - 9), but as mentioned earlier, they may be killed to the ground by very low temperatures.","zones":[5,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/butterfly-bush/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8, Zone 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271488","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/butterfly-bush/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun is needed to ensure adequate flowering, and they prefer a soil pH of 6.0 to 7.0.","level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/butterfly-bush/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily)","level":"species"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/2002/2-22-2002/butterflybushes.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Butterfly bushes perform best in moist, well-drained soils in partial to full sun.","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/2448/buddleja-davidii/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Missouri IPM (Buddleia: A Butterfly Magnet)","url":"https://ipm.missouri.edu/meg/2024/2/buddleia-dt/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Buddlia is a full-sun shrub that requires a minimum of eight hours of direct sun in order to thrive.","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271488","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies, hummingbirds, pollinators are attracted to this rich nectar source. Blossoms have a honey-like fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/butterfly-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Additionally, their flowers have a pleasant fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/butterfly-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower color and fragrance Fragrant, Blue, Pink, Purple, White","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/butterfly-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The very long bloom season (from midsummer until mid-autumn), fragrance, ease of cultivation, and butterfly draw are the main appeal for gardeners.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/2002/2-22-2002/butterflybushes.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In addition to attracting butterflies, the fragrant flowers also lure bees and hummingbirds to the garden.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/2448/buddleja-davidii/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"of small, fragrant flowers in various shades of purple","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Missouri IPM (Summer Color from Shrubs)","url":"https://ipm.missouri.edu/MEG/2018/7/summerShrubs/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It produces arching branches tipped with fragrant dark blue panicles up to eight inches long from June through September.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271488","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Popular fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/proven-winners-ultimate-guide-butterfly-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Yes, but unfortunately, they don't hold up very well in a vase.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"buddleia"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Heat Humidity Rabbits Salt","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/butterfly-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established they are fairly drought tolerant and only require moderate fertilization.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/butterfly-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"As long as they are well drained, the plants are tolerant of heat, humidity, drought, and poor soils.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/2448/buddleja-davidii/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Missouri IPM (Buddleia: A Butterfly Magnet)","url":"https://ipm.missouri.edu/meg/2024/2/buddleia-dt/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Considered fairly drought resistant, Buddleia suffers more when over-watered than under-watered.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271488","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Hummingbirds Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/butterfly-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are a nearly irresistible nectar source for butterflies, bees, lady beetles, and other pollinating insects as well as the occasional hummingbird.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/butterfly-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant is a nectar source, attracting the monarch, black swallowtail, pipevine swallowtail, snout butterfly, great spangled fritillary, pear crescent, red admiral, painted lady, common checkered-skipper, and nymphalid butterflies. This plant does not, however, support butterfly larvae (caterpillars).","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/butterfly-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The attractiveness of the blooms to pollinators like butterflies is what gives the plant its common name","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/2002/2-22-2002/butterflybushes.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In addition to attracting butterflies, the fragrant flowers also lure bees and hummingbirds to the garden.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/proven-winners-ultimate-guide-butterfly-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterfly bush attracts butterflies because its flowers are high in nectar.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"buddleia"},{"name":"University of Missouri IPM (Buddleia: A Butterfly Magnet)","url":"https://ipm.missouri.edu/meg/2024/2/buddleia-dt/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In the world of flowering shrubs, few plants can match Buddleia for the ability to attract butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-black-knight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1.14,4],"split":[{"range":[1.14,1.4],"sources":["Plant Delights Nursery"]},{"range":[1.5,4],"sources":["National Plant Collection of Buddleja, Longstock Park (Buddleja Collection)","Missouri Botanical Garden","Sooner Plant Farm","Boething Treeland Farms","RHS"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b750","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6.00 to 8.00 feet","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/99262/buddleja-davidii-black-knight/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 2.5-4 metres","metres":[2.5,4],"band":[2.5,4],"role":"scored"},{"name":"National Plant Collection of Buddleja, Longstock Park (Buddleja Collection)","url":"https://www.buddlejacollection.com/plants/black-knight/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Eventual height: 150-250cm (5-8ft)","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/buddleia-davidii-black-knight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 50\" tall","metres":1.27,"band":[1.14,1.4],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/butterfly-bush-black-knight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 6-8 Feet","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/buddleia-davidii-black-knight/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height & Spread: 6-10' x 6-10'","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-black-knight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.8,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.91,4],"split":[{"range":[0.91,1.65],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden","Sooner Plant Farm","National Plant Collection of Buddleja, Longstock Park (Buddleja Collection)"]},{"range":[1.83,4],"sources":["Boething Treeland Farms","RHS"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b750","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/99262/buddleja-davidii-black-knight/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 2.5-4 metres","metres":[2.5,4],"band":[2.5,4],"role":"scored"},{"name":"National Plant Collection of Buddleja, Longstock Park (Buddleja Collection)","url":"https://www.buddlejacollection.com/plants/black-knight/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Spread: 150cm (5ft)","metres":1.5,"band":[1.35,1.65],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/butterfly-bush-black-knight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 3-5 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/buddleia-davidii-black-knight/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height & Spread: 6-10' x 6-10'","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-black-knight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b750","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"National Plant Collection of Buddleja, Longstock Park (Buddleja Collection)","url":"https://www.buddlejacollection.com/plants/black-knight/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Hardiness: Very hardy - 20°C USDA zones 5-9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/buddleia-davidii-black-knight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 5a to 10b","zones":[5,10]},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/butterfly-bush-black-knight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/buddleia-davidii-black-knight/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 5-9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-black-knight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b750","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/99262/buddleja-davidii-black-knight/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/butterfly-bush-black-knight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States"},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/buddleia-davidii-black-knight/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-black-knight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b750","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"National Plant Collection of Buddleja, Longstock Park (Buddleja Collection)","url":"https://www.buddlejacollection.com/plants/black-knight/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Sweetly scented and rich in nectar","claim":true},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/buddleia-davidii-black-knight/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"deep purple, fragrant flowers that attract butterflies and hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-black-knight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b750","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Popular fresh cut flower.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-black-knight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/99262/buddleja-davidii-black-knight/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true},{"name":"National Plant Collection of Buddleja, Longstock Park (Buddleja Collection)","url":"https://www.buddlejacollection.com/plants/black-knight/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Easy to grow and drought tolerant once established","claim":true},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/buddleia-davidii-black-knight/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"drought-tolerant once established","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-black-knight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b750","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"National Plant Collection of Buddleja, Longstock Park (Buddleja Collection)","url":"https://www.buddlejacollection.com/plants/black-knight/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife: Good for bees, butterflies and other insects","claim":true},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/buddleia-davidii-black-knight/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attract butterflies and hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-nanho-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.35,1.52],"union":[0.91,2.13],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243238","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/nanho-blue-butterfly-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 5 - 6 Feet","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"Greenleaf Nursery Company","url":"https://www.greenleafnursery.com/plant/NANHO-BLUE-COMPACT-BUTTERFLY-BUSH","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Smaller compact Butterfly Bush reaching 3 to 5 feet tall and wide at maturity.","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"East Coast Nurseries","url":"https://www.eastcoastnurseries.com/Plant-Name/Buddleia-davidii-Nanho-Blue-Butterfly-Bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5-7 ft","metres":[1.52,2.13],"band":[1.52,2.13],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/nanho-blue-butterfly-bush/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 3-5 ft","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Gardeners' World plant database","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/buddleja-davidii-nanho-blue/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.5m","metres":1.5,"band":[1.35,1.65],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-nanho-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.35,1.52],"union":[0.91,2.13],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243238","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/nanho-blue-butterfly-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 4 - 5 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"Greenleaf Nursery Company","url":"https://www.greenleafnursery.com/plant/NANHO-BLUE-COMPACT-BUTTERFLY-BUSH","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Smaller compact Butterfly Bush reaching 3 to 5 feet tall and wide at maturity.","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"East Coast Nurseries","url":"https://www.eastcoastnurseries.com/Plant-Name/Buddleia-davidii-Nanho-Blue-Butterfly-Bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 5-7 ft","metres":[1.52,2.13],"band":[1.52,2.13],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/nanho-blue-butterfly-bush/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 3-5 ft","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Gardeners' World plant database","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/buddleja-davidii-nanho-blue/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.5m","metres":1.5,"band":[1.35,1.65],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-nanho-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243238","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/nanho-blue-butterfly-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 5 - 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"East Coast Nurseries","url":"https://www.eastcoastnurseries.com/Plant-Name/Buddleia-davidii-Nanho-Blue-Butterfly-Bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/nanho-blue-butterfly-bush/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In: Zones 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-nanho-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243238","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/butterfly-bush/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun is needed to ensure adequate flowering, and they prefer a soil pH of 6.0 to 7.0.","level":"species","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/nanho-blue-butterfly-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Partial Sun to Full Sun (At Least 5 Hours of Direct Sunlight)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"East Coast Nurseries","url":"https://www.eastcoastnurseries.com/Plant-Name/Buddleia-davidii-Nanho-Blue-Butterfly-Bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/nanho-blue-butterfly-bush/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs : Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Gardeners' World plant database","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/buddleja-davidii-nanho-blue/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Dappled shade, full sun, partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-nanho-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243238","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Blossoms have a honey-like fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/butterfly-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Additionally, their flowers have a pleasant fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/nanho-blue-butterfly-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features: Attracts Pollinators, Cut Flowers, Foliage Interest, Fragrant, Low Maintenance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/nanho-blue-butterfly-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sweet honey scent fills the garden","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Gardeners' World plant database","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/buddleja-davidii-nanho-blue/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Scented flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-nanho-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243238","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Popular fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Long Bloom Season","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/nanho-blue-butterfly-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features: Attracts Pollinators, Cut Flowers, Foliage Interest, Fragrant, Low Maintenance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-nanho-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its resistance to many gardening challenges, including deer, drought, heat, humidity, and salt, helped it grow in popularity.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/butterfly-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established they are fairly drought tolerant and only require moderate fertilization.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/nanho-blue-butterfly-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates: Drought","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"East Coast Nurseries","url":"https://www.eastcoastnurseries.com/Plant-Name/Buddleia-davidii-Nanho-Blue-Butterfly-Bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/nanho-blue-butterfly-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established it is drought-resistant, and it thrives in the heat.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-nanho-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243238","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies, hummingbirds, pollinators are attracted to this rich nectar source.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/butterfly-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are a nearly irresistible nectar source for butterflies, bees, lady beetles, and other pollinating insects as well as the occasional hummingbird.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/nanho-blue-butterfly-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"East Coast Nurseries","url":"https://www.eastcoastnurseries.com/Plant-Name/Buddleia-davidii-Nanho-Blue-Butterfly-Bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/nanho-blue-butterfly-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Not only are they sweetly scented, like honey, they attract many different types of butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Gardeners' World plant database","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/buddleja-davidii-nanho-blue/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Buddleja 'Nanho blue' is known for attracting bees, birds, butterflies/moths and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleja davidii"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-pugster-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.67],"union":[0.55,0.91],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/buddleia/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush-buddleia-x","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This compact plant reaches just 2'/.6 m tall and wide but has the large, full flowers normally seen on a much larger plant.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"United States Plant Patent USPP 28,794 P2, Buddleia plant named 'SMNBDBT' (via Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP28794P2/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants have an overall height of less than two feet.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It reaches a height of twenty-four inches.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height : 2-3 ft.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/butterfly-bush-pugster-blue/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height 2' - 3' (ft)","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"ButterflyBushes.com (Great Garden Plants)","url":"https://butterflybushes.com/products/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 2' tall and wide","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Average Landscape Size: Moderately sized, typically reaching a height of 24 inches and spreading 24-36 inches wide.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Parrans Greenhouse","url":"https://www.parransgreenhouse.com/butterfly-bush-buddleia-pugster-blue-p/butterflybushpugsterblue.htm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This compact plant reaches just 2 feet tall and wide, but has the large, full flowers normally seen on a much larger plant.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":2,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-pugster-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.67],"union":[0.55,1],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/buddleia/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush-buddleia-x","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2' - 3'","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This butterfly bush has a spread of up to thirty-six inches.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width : 2-3 ft.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/butterfly-bush-pugster-blue/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Spread 2' - 3' (ft)","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"ButterflyBushes.com (Great Garden Plants)","url":"https://butterflybushes.com/products/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 2' tall and wide","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Average Landscape Size: Moderately sized, typically reaching a height of 24 inches and spreading 24-36 inches wide.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Parrans Greenhouse","url":"https://www.parransgreenhouse.com/butterfly-bush-buddleia-pugster-blue-p/butterflybushpugsterblue.htm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This compact plant reaches just 2 feet tall and wide, but has the large, full flowers normally seen on a much larger plant.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":2,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-pugster-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/buddleia/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush-buddleia-x","https://plantaddicts.com/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/buddleia/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush-buddleia-x","https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/buddleia/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush-buddleia-x","https://patuxentnursery.com/product/butterfly-bush-pugster-blue/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/buddleia/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush-buddleia-x","https://butterflybushes.com/products/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/buddleia/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush-buddleia-x","https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/buddleia/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush-buddleia-x","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b , 9a , 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones : 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones: 5-9 outdoors","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/butterfly-bush-pugster-blue/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone(s) 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"ButterflyBushes.com (Great Garden Plants)","url":"https://butterflybushes.com/products/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness: USDA zone 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: Suitable for zones 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, and 9b.","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":2,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 6 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 6; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-pugster-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Buddleja davidii","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Buddleja (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most are drought and poor-soil-tolerant, and they prefer full sun and well-drained soil.","level":"genus","taxon":"buddleja"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/butterfly-bush/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun is needed to ensure adequate flowering, and they prefer a soil pH of 6.0 to 7.0.","level":"species","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It needs to be planted in full sun and receive at minimum six hours of sun per day.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight : Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/butterfly-bush-pugster-blue/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"ButterflyBushes.com (Great Garden Plants)","url":"https://butterflybushes.com/products/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: full sun (6+ hrs/day)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Thrives in full sun, needing at least 6 hours of sunlight per day.","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-pugster-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","strengths":["light"],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/buddleia/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush-buddleia-x","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"United States Plant Patent USPP 28,794 P2, Buddleia plant named 'SMNBDBT' (via Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP28794P2/en","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Light floral fragrance with sweet honey scent.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Buddleja davidii","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Blossoms have a honey-like fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Buddleja (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are terminal panicles or cymes of small tubular fragrant blooms that produce nectar and pollen.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"buddleja"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/butterfly-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Additionally, their flowers have a pleasant fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flower it produces is fragrant which attracts pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/butterfly-bush-pugster-blue/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pugster Blue Butterfly Bush is a compact yet vigorous flowering shrub prized for its oversized violet-blue flower spikes, strong fragrance, and exceptional pollinator appeal.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"ButterflyBushes.com (Great Garden Plants)","url":"https://butterflybushes.com/products/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Each dainty floret is dotted with a yellow center, and is powerfully fragrant, perfuming the warm summer air with a sweet honey scent that you, the butterflies, and the hummingbirds will love.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Continuous Bloomer: Blooms consistently from early summer through frost with fragrant, true-blue flowers, each featuring a charming yellow-orange center.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Parrans Greenhouse","url":"https://www.parransgreenhouse.com/butterfly-bush-buddleia-pugster-blue-p/butterflybushpugsterblue.htm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"10 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-pugster-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-pugster-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/buddleia/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush-buddleia-x","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Buddleja davidii","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its resistance to many gardening challenges, including deer, drought, heat, humidity, and salt, helped it grow in popularity.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Buddleja (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Most are drought and poor-soil-tolerant, and they prefer full sun and well-drained soil.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"buddleja"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/butterfly-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established they are fairly drought tolerant and only require moderate fertilization.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant, and resistant to deer.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/butterfly-bush-pugster-blue/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterfly Bushes are drought-tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"ButterflyBushes.com (Great Garden Plants)","url":"https://butterflybushes.com/products/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Notable features: Proven Winners, fragrant, deer resistant, drought tolerant, long blooming, deadheading not required.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, these shrubs are considered drought-tolerant and require less frequent watering, making them a low-maintenance addition to your garden.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-bush-pugster-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/buddleia/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush-buddleia-x","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees, Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Buddleja davidii","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja-davidii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies, hummingbirds, pollinators are attracted to this rich nectar source.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Buddleja (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/buddleja/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The species are primarily used as ornamentals and for their ability to attract butterflies and pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"buddleja"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/butterfly-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are a nearly irresistible nectar source for butterflies, bees, lady beetles, and other pollinating insects as well as the occasional hummingbird.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"buddleja davidii"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It attracts pollinators with its fragrant flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This bush attracts pollinators like butterflies, bees, and hummingbirds to your outdoor space.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/butterfly-bush-pugster-blue/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fragrant flowers are highly attractive to butterflies, honey bees, and hummingbirds, making it an outstanding choice for pollinator gardens.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"ButterflyBushes.com (Great Garden Plants)","url":"https://butterflybushes.com/products/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator value: attracts adult butterflies of many species; also attracts hummingbird moths","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"buddleia davidii"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/pugster-blue-butterfly-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It attracts bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds with its striking blue flowers, while also resisting deer and rabbits.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Parrans Greenhouse","url":"https://www.parransgreenhouse.com/butterfly-bush-buddleia-pugster-blue-p/butterflybushpugsterblue.htm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees, butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"10 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-weed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.55,0.61],"union":[0.3,1],"voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b490","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.76],"band":[0.3,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/asclepias-tuberosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/43609/asclepias-tuberosa/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ASTU","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size Notes: 1-2 ft (30-60 cm).","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/butterfly-weed","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: Up to 3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/butterflyweed-asclepias-tuberosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"forming clumps 1½ to 3 feet tall and wide","metres":[0.46,0.91],"band":[0.46,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/asclepias-tuberosa-butterfly-weed","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 2 feet","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/asclepias-tuberosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants grow 3' tall with 3' spread.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/butterfly-weed","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: to 3 feet.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust GoBotany","url":"https://gobotany.nativeplanttrust.org/species/asclepias/tuberosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant height 30-70 cm","metres":[0.3,0.7],"band":[0.3,0.7],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":10},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-weed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.1,1],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b490","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/asclepias-tuberosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/43609/asclepias-tuberosa/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/butterflyweed-asclepias-tuberosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"forming clumps 1½ to 3 feet tall and wide","metres":[0.46,0.91],"band":[0.46,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/asclepias-tuberosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants grow 3' tall with 3' spread.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":10},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-weed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","4-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b490","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/asclepias-tuberosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/butterflyweed-asclepias-tuberosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"hardy in zones 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/asclepias-tuberosa-butterfly-weed","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/asclepias-tuberosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants are hardy from USDA Zones 4-10.","zones":[4,10],"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":10},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-weed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b490","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/asclepias-tuberosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/43609/asclepias-tuberosa/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/butterfly-weed","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part sun to full sun","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/butterflyweed-asclepias-tuberosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Butterfly weed needs full sun to bloom and prefers sandy soil but grows in almost any type of well-drained soil","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/asclepias-tuberosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-weed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-weed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ASTU","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterfly weed makes a delightful cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/butterfly-weed","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/butterflyweed-asclepias-tuberosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They can also be used as cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"butterfly-weed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b490","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Erosion, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/asclepias-tuberosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought-tolerant, moderately salt-tolerant, and does well in poor, dry soils.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ASTU","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerance: High","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/butterflyweed-asclepias-tuberosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants are very drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/asclepias-tuberosa-butterfly-weed","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Due to this deep, drought-tolerant tap root, it can be late to emerge in the spring, especially in northern climates, so be patient.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/asclepias-tuberosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Established plants are very drought tolerant but are difficult to transplant due to the taproot.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"butterfly-weed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b490","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are a nectar source for hummingbirds, butterflies and many other pollinators, and leaves are a food source for monarch butterfly larvae (caterpillars).","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/asclepias-tuberosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are a nectar source for many butterflies and insect pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ASTU","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its brilliant flowers attract butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/butterfly-weed","country":null,"form":null,"value":"One of the best nectar plants for a wide variety of pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/butterflyweed-asclepias-tuberosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers produce copious amounts of nectar, making them very attractive to hummingbirds, butterflies, and many other insects.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/asclepias-tuberosa-butterfly-weed","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The vivid orange color, low mounded profile, and ability to attract and sustain butterflies make this plant a well-known landscape favorite for all types of gardens.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/asclepias-tuberosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This milkweed is a repeat bloomer that attracts butterflies, moths, bees and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"asclepias tuberosa"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"caladium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/caladiums/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Caladium plants usually grow between 1 and 2.5 feet tall. The attractive leaves grow between 6 and 12 inches in length. The plants grow from tubers and will mature to full size in one season.","metres":[0.3,0.76],"band":[0.3,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":2,"genus":6,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Depending on cultivar and growing conditions, fancy-leafed caladiums grow between 12 and 30 inches tall. Lance-leafed caladiums are generally smaller, usually less than 12 inches tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The two main types of caladiums are the fancy-leaved types , which have large, heart-shaped or semi-heart-shaped leaves on long petioles (12 to 30 inches tall), and the strap-leaved or lance-leaved types , with their shorter and narrower, ruffle-edged leaves on short petioles and a more compact habit (usually less than 12 inches tall).\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Caladium hortulanum Caladium T S 1″ 12″ - 1-2′\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"caladium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":2,"genus":6,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 6 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"caladium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["9-10","8-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/caladium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[9,10],"level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/caladium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They are hardy only to USDA zone 9 or 10; therefore, caladiums should be used as annuals in South Carolina gardens.","zones":[9,10],"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/caladiums/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Although they are only hardy to zone 9a or 10b, they are easily grown as summer “bulbs” or as houseplants.","zones":[9,10],"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/caladiums/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In USDA Hardiness Zones 8-11 caladiums with foliage can be planted at any time of the year, though bare tubers are usually planted in the spring.","zones":[8,11],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":2,"genus":6,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"caladium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a438","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"caladium bicolor"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/caladium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most Caladium cultivars are adapted to full shade, but some selections tolerate partial sun or early morning sunlight. However, full sun generally reduces the intensity of the foliage color of most cultivars.","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Caladium bicolor)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/caladium-bicolor/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in partial shade to full in fertile, acidic, high organic matter well-drained soils.","level":"species","taxon":"caladium bicolor"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/caladium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Caladiums need protection from full, hot sun for best growth and color. Some newer cultivars will tolerate full sun for a couple of hours daily, but all prefer dappled or moderate shade with protection from the hot afternoon sun.","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/caladiums/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Older cultivars grow best in partial shade . Although they will grow in full shade, vigor and color is not as good. Newer, sun-tolerant varieties can be grown in part to full sun , especially in cooler, northern areas.","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/caladiums/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most caladiums thrive in partial shade and only need two to four hours of direct sunlight per day.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Caladium 'Burning Heart')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=441140","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"caladium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/caladium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["caladium bicolor"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (caladium bicolor), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (caladium bicolor) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"caladium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"caladium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/caladium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Caladiums require warm, moist, well-drained soil to grow.","claim":false,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["caladium bicolor"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (caladium bicolor), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (caladium bicolor) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"caladium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calendula","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"species":10,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plants grow 8 to 24 inches tall and require regular irrigation for best performance.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calendula","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":10,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calendula","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":10,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calendula","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/calendula-officinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"calendula officinalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a566","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"calendula officinalis"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (FP087)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP087","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in full sun","level":"species","taxon":"calendula officinalis"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/calendula-in-the-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows best in fertile, well drained soils from full sun to part shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of New Hampshire Extension","url":"https://extension.unh.edu/resource/how-grow-calendula-calendula-officinalis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"calendula officinalis"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/calendula-calendula-officinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Calendula is easy to grow in any well-drained soil in full sun","level":"species","taxon":"calendula officinalis"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Calendula officinalis)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/62350/calendula-officinalis/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"calendula officinalis"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Calendula genus page)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/calendula","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"They flower best in full sun, but also tolerate light shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/calendula.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun, part shade in hot climates.","level":"species","taxon":"calendula officinalis"},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant database","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/pot-marigold-calendula-officinalis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"calendula officinalis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calendula","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Calendula genus page)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/calendula","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Calendulas produce a profusion of daisy-like single or double flowers on low, bushy plants with slightly hairy, aromatic foliage.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":5,"covered":["calendula officinalis"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (calendula officinalis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 5 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (calendula officinalis) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calendula","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Utah State University Extension","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/calendula-in-the-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Ornamental uses of calendula include cut flowers and as border annuals.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Calendula genus page)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/calendula","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are good for cutting, have edible petals and are also used by herbalists to make skincare products.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/calendula/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"We offer Calendula varieties that show outstanding cut-flower performance, as well as a high-resin variety for medicinal use.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":7,"covered":["calendula officinalis"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (calendula officinalis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 7 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (calendula officinalis) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"calendula","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Utah State University Extension","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/calendula-in-the-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants grow 8 to 24 inches tall and require regular irrigation for best performance.","claim":false,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Calendula genus page)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/calendula","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Calendulas are unfussy plants that do well in most ordinary garden soil, including poor, dry soil.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["calendula officinalis"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (calendula officinalis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"SPLIT"},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (calendula officinalis) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calendula","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":7,"covered":["calendula officinalis"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (calendula officinalis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 7 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (calendula officinalis) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calendula-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":11,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 to 2 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"'Indian Prince' produces 2 to 3 inch flowers on 14 to 24 inch tall plants.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plants grow 8 to 24 inches tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"'Indian Prince' is an annual or biennial, 60-75cm in height\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: up to 35cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height and Width: 14-16” x 12\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant Height 24 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"ranging from dwarf and rosetting to upright and branched, 12 inches to 3-feet tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 11 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calendula-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1 to 2 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1 to 1.5 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: up to 35cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height and Width: 14-16” x 12\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calendula-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-11","3-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277409","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/calendula-officinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[2,11]},{"name":"Bulk Wildflowers","url":"https://www.bulkwildflowers.com/products/indian-prince-calendula-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10","zones":[3,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calendula-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":11,"distinctPublishers":11,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277409","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/calendula-officinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FPS87)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP087","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in full sun"},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening flower growing guide","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/sceneff01.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: full sun part shade"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/calendula-calendula-officinalis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Calendula is easy to grow in any well-drained soil in full sun"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/calendula-in-the-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows best in fertile, well drained soils from full sun to part shade."},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/177767/calendula-officinalis-indian-prince-(prince-series)/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"Jekka's Herb Farm (Jekkapedia)","url":"https://www.jekkas.com/products/marigold-indian-prince","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Aspect: Full Sun, Partial Shade"},{"name":"Pinetree Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.superseeds.com/products/indian-prince-calendula","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs: Full sun to part shade in hot areas"},{"name":"Bulk Wildflowers","url":"https://www.bulkwildflowers.com/products/indian-prince-calendula-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement Full Sun"},{"name":"Arizona State University plant library (Chris Martin)","url":"https://www.public.asu.edu/~camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/calendulaofficinalis.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calendula-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calendula-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277409","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Beds, borders, cottage gardens, cutting gardens or pots/containers.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/calendula-officinalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Marigolds attract butterflies and are useful as cut flowers.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FPS87)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP087","country":null,"form":null,"value":"adds dramatic color when planted en masse, may be used as cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening flower growing guide","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/sceneff01.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special uses: cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/calendula-calendula-officinalis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the flowers are good for cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Utah State University Extension","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/calendula-in-the-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Ornamental uses of calendula include cut flowers and as border annuals.","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/177767/calendula-officinalis-indian-prince-(prince-series)/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good for cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Pinetree Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.superseeds.com/products/indian-prince-calendula","country":null,"form":null,"value":"cut flowers, flower beds, containers, edible/medicinal flowers","claim":true}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calendula-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/calendula-officinalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Marigolds do not do well in hot summer weather or times of drought, but can be cut back to rejuvenate in the fall.","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calendula-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277409","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/calendula-officinalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and pollinators","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FPS87)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP087","country":null,"form":null,"value":"in mass plantings, as cut flowers, in pollinator gardens","claim":true},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening flower growing guide","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/sceneff01.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/calendula-calendula-officinalis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Calendula flowers attract pollinators adn beneficial insects.","claim":true},{"name":"Jekka's Herb Farm (Jekkapedia)","url":"https://www.jekkas.com/products/marigold-indian-prince","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts pollinators: Yes","claim":true}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calibrachoa","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":1,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.25 to 0.75 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"This plant is native to South America and typically grows to a height of 6 to 12 inches and a width of 12 to 24 inches due to its trailing habit, which makes it suitable for hanging baskets.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calibrachoa","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":1,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.50 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"This plant is native to South America and typically grows to a height of 6 to 12 inches and a width of 12 to 24 inches due to its trailing habit, which makes it suitable for hanging baskets.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calibrachoa","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Calibrachoa group)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a119","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 9 to 11","zones":[9,11],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":1,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calibrachoa","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Calibrachoa group)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a119","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Calibrachoa x hybrida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/calibrachoa-x-hybrida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"calibrachoa hybrida"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/calibrachoa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They require full sun and are very sensitive to pH levels.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/calibrachoa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They prefer full sun to part shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Calibrachoa 'Sunbelkist' MILLION BELLS TERRA COTTA)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260008","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Superbells Double Amber)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/calibrachoa/superbells-double-amber-double-calibrachoa-calibrachoa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Sun to Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Superbells Cherry Star)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/calibrachoa/superbells-cherry-star-calibrachoa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Sun to Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Suntory Flowers (MILLION BELLS MOUNDING Terra Cotta)","url":"https://suntoryflowers.com/variety/million-bells-mounding-terra-cotta/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Levels: Partial-Sun, Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Suntory Flowers (MILLION BELLS TRAILING Blue)","url":"https://suntoryflowers.com/variety/million-bells-trailing-blue/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Levels: Partial-Sun, Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Crossings (Superbells Evening Star)","url":"https://gardencrossings.com/products/superbells-evening-star-calibrachoa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (+6 hrs.), Part Shade (4-6 hrs.)","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calibrachoa","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calibrachoa","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calibrachoa","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Calibrachoa group)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a119","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Also tolerates drought.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Calibrachoa 'Sunbelkist' MILLION BELLS TERRA COTTA)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260008","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Also tolerates drought.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Crossings (Superbells Evening Star)","url":"https://gardencrossings.com/products/superbells-evening-star-calibrachoa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attributes: Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["calibrachoa hybrida"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (calibrachoa hybrida), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (calibrachoa hybrida) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calibrachoa","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Calibrachoa group)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a119","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The blooms are attractive to hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Calibrachoa 'Sunbelkist' MILLION BELLS TERRA COTTA)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260008","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Superbells Cherry Star)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/calibrachoa/superbells-cherry-star-calibrachoa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Crossings (Superbells Evening Star)","url":"https://gardencrossings.com/products/superbells-evening-star-calibrachoa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Enjoy the flutter of butterflies and hummingbirds as they sip the sweet nectar.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["calibrachoa hybrida"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (calibrachoa hybrida), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (calibrachoa hybrida) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"calibrachoa-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"6\" - 12\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calibrachoa-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"12\" - 2'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calibrachoa-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer of the Superbells series)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/calibrachoa/superbells-coralina-calibrachoa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calibrachoa-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer of the Superbells series)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/calibrachoa/superbells-coralina-calibrachoa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Sun to Sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calibrachoa-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calibrachoa-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calibrachoa-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calibrachoa-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer of the Superbells series)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/calibrachoa/superbells-coralina-calibrachoa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-flannel-bush-ken-taylor","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":8,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"to 5 ft (1.5 m) tall, greater width\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"2-4 ft Tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Size: 6 to 8 ft. tall, 6 to 8 ft. wide\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 4-5 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"height[m]: 2.00 to 4.00\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Average Height: 4 - 6 ft\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"reaching 4-5 ft tall and spreading to 6-8 ft wide or more\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height X Width: 5' X 12'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-flannel-bush-ken-taylor","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"4-8 ft Wide\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Size: 6 to 8 ft. tall, 6 to 8 ft. wide\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 6-8 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"width[m]: 2.00 to 3.00\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Average Width: 6 - 10 ft\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"reaching 4-5 ft tall and spreading to 6-8 ft wide or more\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height X Width: 5' X 12'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-flannel-bush-ken-taylor","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["8-10","7-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Fremontodendron californicum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287267&isprofile=0&basic=Fremontodendron","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8 to 10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"Las Pilitas Nursery","url":"https://www.laspilitas.com/nature-of-california/plants/659--fremontodendron-ken-taylor","country":"US","form":null,"value":"usda: 7 to 10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/fremontodendron-ken-taylor/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: Zones 8 - 10","zones":[8,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-flannel-bush-ken-taylor","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Fremontodendron californicum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287267&isprofile=0&basic=Fremontodendron","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"Calscape (California Native Plant Society)","url":"https://calscape.org/plant/71031/Fremontodendron-%27Ken-Taylor%27-(Ken-Taylor-Flannelbush)","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Full Sun"},{"name":"UC Santa Cruz Arboretum and Botanic Garden (Norrie's)","url":"https://shopucscarboretum.com/products/fremontodendron-ken-taylor-5-gallon-plant","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers: full sun"},{"name":"San Marcos Growers","url":"https://www.smgrowers.com/products/plants/plantdisplay.asp?plant_id=656","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun"},{"name":"Cistus Nursery","url":"https://cistus.com/products/fremontodendron-ken-taylor","country":"US","form":null,"value":"wonderful on any well-drained site in full sun and mineral soil with NO summer water once established"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/fremontodendron-ken-taylor/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Thrives in full sun with excellent drainage and low summer irrigation once established."},{"name":"Linda Vista Native Plants","url":"https://www.lindavistanatives.com/product/fremontodendron-ken-taylor/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Partial Shade, Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-flannel-bush-ken-taylor","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-flannel-bush-ken-taylor","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"California Flora Nursery","url":"https://www.calfloranursery.com/plants/fremontodendron-ken-taylor/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Uses Cut Flowers","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-flannel-bush-ken-taylor","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Calscape (California Native Plant Society)","url":"https://calscape.org/plant/71031/Fremontodendron-%27Ken-Taylor%27-(Ken-Taylor-Flannelbush)","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This shrub will not need supplemental water after establishment.","claim":true},{"name":"San Marcos Growers","url":"https://www.smgrowers.com/products/plants/plantdisplay.asp?plant_id=656","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plant in full sun in a well-drained soil with no supplemental irrigation required once established.","claim":true},{"name":"California Flora Nursery","url":"https://www.calfloranursery.com/plants/fremontodendron-ken-taylor/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, this selection of flannel bush is completely drought tolerant and will accept infrequent summer water only where drainage is excellent.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-flannel-bush-ken-taylor","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.smgrowers.com/products/plants/plantdisplay.asp?plant_id=656","https://www.calfloranursery.com/plants/fremontodendron-ken-taylor/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.smgrowers.com/products/plants/plantdisplay.asp?plant_id=656","https://www.lindavistanatives.com/product/fremontodendron-ken-taylor/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"San Marcos Growers","url":"https://www.smgrowers.com/products/plants/plantdisplay.asp?plant_id=656","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its flowers are attractive to beneficial insects, bees and butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"California Flora Nursery","url":"https://www.calfloranursery.com/plants/fremontodendron-ken-taylor/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Highly attractive to bees and other pollinators.","claim":true},{"name":"Linda Vista Native Plants","url":"https://www.lindavistanatives.com/product/fremontodendron-ken-taylor/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to Bees: Yes","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-flannel-bush-ken-taylor","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"botanicalName","current":"Fremontodendron 'Ken Taylor'","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"IPNI (Kew)","url":"https://www.ipni.org/n/30048452-2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Accepted"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/fremontodendron","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cultivar listed"},{"name":"UC Santa Cruz Arboretum and Botanic Garden","url":"https://shopucscarboretum.com/products/fremontodendron-ken-taylor-5-gallon-plant","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cultivar listed"}],"note":"name resolves as Fremontodendron 'Ken Taylor'","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-fuchsia","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"The Watershed Nursery","url":"https://www.watershednursery.com/nursery/plant-finder/epilobium-canum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows 1.5 feet tall and 2 feet wide","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-fuchsia","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"The Watershed Nursery","url":"https://www.watershednursery.com/nursery/plant-finder/epilobium-canum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows 1.5 feet tall and 2 feet wide","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-fuchsia","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-fuchsia","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"The Watershed Nursery","url":"https://www.watershednursery.com/nursery/plant-finder/epilobium-canum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"Calscape (California Native Plant Society)","url":"https://calscape.org/Epilobium-canum-(California-Fuchsia)","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It does best and will flower most profusely in full sun."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-fuchsia","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-fuchsia","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-fuchsia","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"The Watershed Nursery","url":"https://www.watershednursery.com/nursery/plant-finder/epilobium-canum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-fuchsia","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"nearMiss":["hummingbird"],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"The Watershed Nursery","url":"https://www.watershednursery.com/nursery/plant-finder/epilobium-canum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A terrific hummingbird plant","claim":true},{"name":"Calscape (California Native Plant Society)","url":"https://calscape.org/Epilobium-canum-(California-Fuchsia)","country":null,"form":null,"value":"no better California native plant for attracting hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; the row carries [\"hummingbird\"], which nothing in the product reads: hasTag is an equality test against \"pollinator\"","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-fuchsia","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"botanicalName","current":"Epilobium canum","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"IPNI (Kew)","url":"https://www.ipni.org/api/1/search?q=Epilobium%20canum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Indexed: Epilobium canum (Greene) P.H.Raven, family Onagraceae, IPNI id 92449-2, with seven infraspecific taxa (subsp. angustifolium, garrettii, latifolium, mexicanum, septentrionale and two varieties)"},{"name":"Calscape (California Native Plant Society)","url":"https://calscape.org/Epilobium-canum-(California-Fuchsia)","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Published under the name Epilobium canum, common name California Fuchsia"}],"note":"name resolves as Epilobium canum (Greene) P.H.Raven","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":6,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":6,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b753","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"eschscholzia californica"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eschscholzia-californica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"eschscholzia californica"},{"name":"Calscape (California Native Plant Society)","url":"https://calscape.org/plant/1602/Eschscholzia-californica-(California-Poppy)","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plant grows in full sun but will tolerate part shade.","level":"species","taxon":"eschscholzia californica"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/california-poppy-wildflower-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"eschscholzia californica"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/california-poppy","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"eschscholzia californica"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","strengths":["light"],"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["eschscholzia californica"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (eschscholzia californica), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (eschscholzia californica) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["eschscholzia californica"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (eschscholzia californica), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (eschscholzia californica) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","nearMiss":["drought"],"derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":4,"covered":["eschscholzia californica"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (eschscholzia californica), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; the row carries [\"drought\"], which nothing in the product reads: hasTag is an equality test against \"drought tolerant\"; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged; 4 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (eschscholzia californica) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":5,"covered":["eschscholzia californica"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (eschscholzia californica), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 5 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (eschscholzia californica) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":6,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"To 10″ x 12″ forming a spreading plant\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1-2 ft Tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"SPLIT"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":6,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"To 10″ x 12″ forming a spreading plant\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"6-12 in Wide\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Xera Plants","url":"https://xeraplants.com/plants/eschscholzia-californica-purple-gleam/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Calscape (California Native Plant Society)","url":"https://calscape.org/Eschscholzia-californica-'Purple-Gleam'-(Purple-Gleam-California-Poppy)","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","nearMiss":["drought"],"derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Xera Plants","url":"https://xeraplants.com/plants/eschscholzia-californica-purple-gleam/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Low Water/No Water","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the row carries [\"drought\"], which nothing in the product reads: hasTag is an equality test against \"drought tolerant\"; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Xera Plants","url":"https://xeraplants.com/plants/eschscholzia-californica-purple-gleam/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great pollinator plant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":6,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":9,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Size Notes: Up to about 2 feet tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Annual to perennial forb that is low-spreading to erect, 6 inches to 2 feet tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"2-24 in Tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height by Width: 1-2' H x 1' W\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The California poppy will grow to around eighteen inches tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"will grow up 12-20 inches and spread up to 20 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant Height: 12-15\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":6,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1-2 ft Wide\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height by Width: 1-2' H x 1' W\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"will grow up 12-20 inches and spread up to 20 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.32},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["6-10","8-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284842","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 6 to 10","zones":[6,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eschscholzia-californica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[6,10]},{"name":"Duke Gardens (Duke University)","url":"https://gardens.duke.edu/garden-talk/california-poppy/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones : 6-10","zones":[6,10]},{"name":"University of Washington Plant Data Sheet","url":"https://depts.washington.edu/propplnt/Plants/ESCA.htm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA range 8 to 10","zones":[8,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284842","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eschscholzia-californica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Calscape (California Native Plant Society)","url":"https://calscape.org/plant/1602/Eschscholzia-californica-(California-Poppy)","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plant grows in full sun but will tolerate part shade."},{"name":"Theodore Payne Foundation Native Plant Database","url":"https://theodorepayne.org/nativeplantdatabase/index.php?title=Eschscholzia_californica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure: Full Sun"},{"name":"University of Washington Plant Data Sheet","url":"https://depts.washington.edu/propplnt/Plants/ESCA.htm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun, grows excellent on slopes and roadsides"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","nearMiss":["drought"],"derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eschscholzia-californica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is considered a drought-tolerant, cool-season annual and a short-lived perennial in zones 8 through 10.","claim":true},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=esca2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is easy to grow, drought tolerant, and reseeds so readily that is can become weedy.","claim":true},{"name":"Theodore Payne Foundation Native Plant Database","url":"https://theodorepayne.org/nativeplantdatabase/index.php?title=Eschscholzia_californica","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water Requirements: Drought-tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/california-poppy/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"is fairly drought-tolerant, but grows best with weekly waterings","claim":true},{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/poppy/california-poppy-flower-seed-1229.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant.","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the row carries [\"drought\"], which nothing in the product reads: hasTag is an equality test against \"drought tolerant\"; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"california-poppy-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Oregon State University Extension Service (EM 9491)","url":"https://extension.oregonstate.edu/catalog/em-9491-eschscholzia-californica-california-poppy","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bumble bees, sweat bees, mining bees and butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"Calscape (California Native Plant Society)","url":"https://calscape.org/plant/1602/Eschscholzia-californica-(California-Poppy)","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Birds, butterflies, bees and other pollinators are attracted to this plant.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calla-lily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":11,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":3,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Most cultivars will range 1 to 3 feet tall and 1 to 1 ½ feet wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plants of the genus Zantedeschia are deciduous perennials (may be evergreen) up to 1 m high and survive the dry season through rhizomes or tubers.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 11 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calla-lily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":10,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":3,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Most cultivars will range 1 to 3 feet tall and 1 to 1 ½ feet wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calla-lily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-10","8-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Zantedeschia (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zantedeschia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[7,10],"level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center - Calla Lily","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/calla-lily/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They are winter hardy in USDA planting zones 8 to 10.","zones":[8,10],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":3,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calla-lily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Zantedeschia aethiopica","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a475","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"zantedeschia aethiopica"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Zantedeschia (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zantedeschia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These plants can be grown in full sun to 25% shade and prefer moist, humus-rich soil, doing well in boggy areas.","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Zantedeschia aethiopica","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zantedeschia-aethiopica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in the full sun to partial shade in moist, organically rich soil with plenty of leaf mold, rotted manure, and humus.","level":"species","taxon":"zantedeschia aethiopica"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica - Zantedeschia (genus)","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/zantedeschia","country":"ZA","form":null,"value":"Plants in the genus prefer full sun, soil rich in humus, and seasonal watering.","level":"genus"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica - Zantedeschia aethiopica","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/zantedeschia-aethiopica","country":"ZA","form":null,"value":"Aspect: Full Sun, Morning Sun (Semi Shade)","level":"species","taxon":"zantedeschia aethiopica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Zantedeschia rehmannii","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276472&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"zantedeschia rehmannii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Zantedeschia 'Black Magic'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255864&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Zantedeschia 'Flame'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255865&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Zantedeschia 'Fantasia' BE MY FIRST LOVE","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=451949&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Zantedeschia 'Hawk Eye'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=452414&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Zantedeschia 'Rubylite Pink Ice'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=258865&isprofile=0&chr=48","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Zantedeschia aethiopica 'White Giant'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263575&isprofile=0&chr=48","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"zantedeschia aethiopica"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calla-lily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["zantedeschia aethiopica"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (zantedeschia aethiopica), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (zantedeschia aethiopica) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calla-lily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Zantedeschia aethiopica","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a475","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Commercially grown as a very popular cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zantedeschia aethiopica"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Zantedeschia (genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zantedeschia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The uniquely shaped flower heads, consisting of small flowers in a spadix surrounded by a spathe, make great cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Zantedeschia aethiopica","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zantedeschia-aethiopica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant is known for its very large showy white flowers that are popular as cut flower in the floral industry.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zantedeschia aethiopica"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica - Zantedeschia aethiopica","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/zantedeschia-aethiopica","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is an excellent cut flower and lasts a long time in water.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zantedeschia aethiopica"},{"name":"Plants For A Future - Zantedeschia aethiopica","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Zantedeschia+aethiopica","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive foliage, Not North American native, Naturalizing, All or parts of this plant are poisonous, Wetlands plant, Suitable for cut flowers, Fragrant flowers, Attractive flowers or blooms.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zantedeschia aethiopica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Zantedeschia rehmannii","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276472&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zantedeschia rehmannii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Zantedeschia 'Black Magic'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255864&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Zantedeschia 'Flame'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255865&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Zantedeschia 'Fantasia' BE MY FIRST LOVE","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=451949&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Zantedeschia 'Hawk Eye'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=452414&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Zantedeschia 'Rubylite Pink Ice'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=258865&isprofile=0&chr=48","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden - Zantedeschia aethiopica 'White Giant'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263575&isprofile=0&chr=48","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"zantedeschia aethiopica"}],"note":"12 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"calla-lily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calla-lily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica - Zantedeschia (genus)","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/zantedeschia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Beetles are the most likely pollinators of Zantedeschia flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["zantedeschia aethiopica"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (zantedeschia aethiopica), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (zantedeschia aethiopica) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calla-lily-black","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"calla-lily-black","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"calla-lily-black","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"calla-lily-black","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zantedeschia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These plants can be grown in full sun to 25% shade and prefer moist, humus-rich soil, doing well in boggy areas.","level":"genus","taxon":"zantedeschia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zantedeschia-aethiopica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in the full sun to partial shade in moist, organically rich soil with plenty of leaf mold, rotted manure, and humus.","level":"species","taxon":"zantedeschia aethiopica"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/zantedeschia-aethiopica","country":"ZA","form":null,"value":"Aspect: Full Sun, Morning Sun (Semi Shade)","level":"species","taxon":"zantedeschia aethiopica"},{"name":"RHS growing guide (Zantedeschia)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/zantedeschia/growing-guide","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"sun or partial shade - although they usually flower best in full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"zantedeschia"},{"name":"Harts Nursery","url":"https://www.hartsnursery.co.uk/Zantedeschia-Schwarzwalder-Pack-of-3-Bulbs.html","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Aspect: Full Sun/Partial Shade","level":"genus","taxon":"zantedeschia"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"calla-lily-black","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zantedeschia-aethiopica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lightly fragrant blooms appear from June-July.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zantedeschia aethiopica"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/zantedeschia-aethiopica","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers of Zantedeschia aethiopica are faintly scented and this attracts various crawling insects and bees which are responsible for pollinating the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zantedeschia aethiopica"},{"name":"Harts Nursery","url":"https://www.hartsnursery.co.uk/Zantedeschia-Schwarzwalder-Pack-of-3-Bulbs.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Scented: No","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"zantedeschia"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"calla-lily-black","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zantedeschia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The uniquely shaped flower heads, consisting of small flowers in a spadix surrounded by a spathe, make great cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"zantedeschia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zantedeschia-aethiopica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zantedeschia aethiopica"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/zantedeschia-aethiopica","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is an excellent cut flower and lasts a long time in water.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zantedeschia aethiopica"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"calla-lily-black","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"calla-lily-black","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zantedeschia-aethiopica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Beetles and bees pollinate the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zantedeschia aethiopica"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/zantedeschia-aethiopica","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers of Zantedeschia aethiopica are faintly scented and this attracts various crawling insects and bees which are responsible for pollinating the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zantedeschia aethiopica"},{"name":"Harts Nursery","url":"https://www.hartsnursery.co.uk/Zantedeschia-Schwarzwalder-Pack-of-3-Bulbs.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator: No","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"zantedeschia"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"calla-lily-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":10,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"It grows 20 inches tall and wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Impressive 16-20 inch height with matching spread\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: Grows 16-20\" tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 16-24\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 10\" to 16\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Garnet Glow Calla Lily will grow to be about 12 inches tall at maturity extending to 24 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Reaches 1 to 2 feet tall and wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 24 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height 10 - 20 in\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calla-lily-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"It grows 20 inches tall and wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Impressive 16-20 inch height with matching spread\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 12-18\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"extending to 24 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Reaches 1 to 2 feet tall and wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calla-lily-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-10","8-10","8-11","7-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Zantedeschia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zantedeschia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Costa Farms","url":"https://costafarms.com/blogs/plant-finder/calla-lily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows 20 inches tall and wide. Zones 8-10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"De Vroomen Garden Products","url":"https://www.devroomen.com/product/calla-garnet-glow-15-pcs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In zones 8-10, bulbs can remain in-ground year-round","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/calla-lily-garnet-glow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 8 through 11","zones":[8,11]},{"name":"Easy to Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/calla-garnet-glow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8-10 (as a perennial) annuals elsewhere","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/calla-lilies/garnet-glow-calla-lilies","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 7 to 10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Roger's Gardens (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.rogersgardens.com/12290002/Plant/13316/Garnet_Glow_Calla_Lily/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 7b","zones":[7,7]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calla-lily-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Zantedeschia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zantedeschia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/158373/zantedeschia-garnet-glow/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"De Vroomen Garden Products","url":"https://www.devroomen.com/product/calla-garnet-glow-15-pcs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Excellent performance in both full sun and partial shade environments"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/calla-lily-garnet-glow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Sun to Part Sun"},{"name":"Easy to Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/calla-garnet-glow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Quantity: Full Sun to Partial Shade"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/calla-lilies/garnet-glow-calla-lilies","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun, Partial Shade"},{"name":"Roger's Gardens (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.rogersgardens.com/12290002/Plant/13316/Garnet_Glow_Calla_Lily/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in full sun to partial shade."},{"name":"Dutch Bulbs (Van Bourgondien)","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/garnet_glow_hybrid_calla_lilies","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun, Half Sun / Half Shade"},{"name":"Kings Garden Center","url":"https://www.kingsgardencenter.com/Plant-Name/Zantedeschia-aethiopica-Garnet-Glow-Callafornia-Garnet-Glow-Calla-Lily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calla-lily-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calla-lily-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Zantedeschia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zantedeschia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The uniquely shaped flower heads, consisting of small flowers in a spadix surrounded by a spathe, make great cut flowers.","claim":true},{"name":"De Vroomen Garden Products","url":"https://www.devroomen.com/product/calla-garnet-glow-15-pcs","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Versatile usage in garden beds, borders, containers, and as striking cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/calla-lily-garnet-glow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Container Friendly, Great for Cut Flowers, Deer Resistant","claim":true},{"name":"Easy to Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/calla-garnet-glow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Benefits: Colorful tropical interest. Great for cutting.","claim":true},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/calla-lilies/garnet-glow-calla-lilies","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies and Hummingbirds, Deer Resistant, Good as Cut Flowers, Good For Indoor Forcing, Grows Well In Containers, Naturalizing, Perennializing","claim":true},{"name":"Roger's Gardens (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.rogersgardens.com/12290002/Plant/13316/Garnet_Glow_Calla_Lily/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true},{"name":"Dutch Bulbs (Van Bourgondien)","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/garnet_glow_hybrid_calla_lilies","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Suggested Uses: Borders, Bouquets, Container Gardening, Cut Flowers, Perennializing, Showy Flowers, Deer Resistant","claim":true}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calla-lily-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"calla-lily-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/calla-lilies/garnet-glow-calla-lilies","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies and Hummingbirds, Deer Resistant, Good as Cut Flowers, Good For Indoor Forcing, Grows Well In Containers, Naturalizing, Perennializing","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1.5,11],"split":[{"range":[1.5,6],"sources":["Flora of China (eFloras, Missouri Botanical Garden / Science Press)","Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Oregon State University Landscape Plants","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox"]},{"range":[9,11],"sources":["Plants For A Future"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287331&isprofile=0&basic=Camellia+japonica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 7.00 to 12.00 feet","metres":[2.13,3.66],"band":[2.13,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/camellia-japonica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10 ft. 0 in. - 13 ft. 0 in.","metres":[3.05,3.96],"band":[3.05,3.96],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Common Japanese Camellia ( Camellia japonica ) is a broadleaved, evergreen shrub, which may grow to a height of 25 feet, but more often to 6 to 12 feet.","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/camellia-japonica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Broadleaf evergreen shrub, 10-15 ft (3-4.5 m) high, usually dense pyramidal.","metres":[3,4.5],"band":[3,4.5],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Flora of China (eFloras, Missouri Botanical Garden / Science Press)","url":"http://www.efloras.org/florataxon.aspx?flora_id=2&taxon_id=200014034","country":"CN","form":null,"value":"Shrubs or trees, 1.5-6(-11) m tall.","metres":[1.5,6],"band":[1.5,6],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Plants For A Future","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Camellia+japonica","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Camellia japonica is an evergreen Shrub growing to 10 m (32ft) by 8 m (26ft) at a slow rate.","metres":10,"band":[9,11],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":3.36},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1.52,8.8],"split":[{"range":[1.52,3.05],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center"]},{"range":[7.2,8.8],"sources":["Plants For A Future"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287331&isprofile=0&basic=Camellia+japonica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 5.00 to 10.00 feet","metres":[1.52,3.05],"band":[1.52,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/camellia-japonica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 5 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.52,3.05],"band":[1.52,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It has a spread of 6 to 10 feet.","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Plants For A Future","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Camellia+japonica","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Camellia japonica is an evergreen Shrub growing to 10 m (32ft) by 8 m (26ft) at a slow rate.","metres":8,"band":[7.2,8.8],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":7,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287331&isprofile=0&basic=Camellia+japonica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Camellia japonica and most of its cultivars are considered to be winter hardy to USDA Zones 7-9.","zones":[7,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/camellia-japonica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[7,9],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287331&isprofile=0&basic=Camellia+japonica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/camellia-japonica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They thrive and bloom best when sheltered from full sun and drying winds.","level":"species"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/camellia-japonica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to part shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"Plants For A Future","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Camellia+japonica","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"It can grow in full shade (deep woodland) semi-shade (light woodland) or no shade. It prefers moist soil.","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/camellia-japonica","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers perfect, not fragrant, 6-13 cm across; white, pink, rose and red, with many different forms, e.g., single, semidouble, formal double, peony, etc.","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/publications/camellias-camellia-japonica-for-the-farmer-florist","country":null,"form":null,"value":"is a beautiful and versatile flowering plant that is popular among farmer florists for its vibrant blooms and glossy evergreen foliage","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/camellia-japonica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts pollinators and provides cover for wintering birds.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Plants For A Future","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Camellia+japonica","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The species is hermaphrodite (has both male and female organs) and is pollinated by Bees.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"camellia-debutante","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.83,3.66],"union":[1.83,3.66],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/debutante-camellia.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Slowly reaches 6 to 8 ft. tall and wide; larger with age.","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Cam Too Camellia Nursery","url":"https://camtoocamellia.com/debutante/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature height 8ft - 12ft, width 6ft - 10ft","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia-debutante","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[1.83,2.44],"union":[1.83,3.05],"proposed":2.13,"margin":18,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/debutante-camellia.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Slowly reaches 6 to 8 ft. tall and wide; larger with age.","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Cam Too Camellia Nursery","url":"https://camtoocamellia.com/debutante/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature height 8ft - 12ft, width 6ft - 10ft","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (1.83 to 3.05 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia-debutante","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/debutante-camellia.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8-10","zones":[8,10]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia-debutante","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia-debutante","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia-debutante","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia-debutante","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia-debutante","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia-professor-sargent","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[2.75,3.05],"union":[1.83,4.57],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"JC Raulston Arboretum, NC State University","url":"https://jcra.ncsu.edu/horticulture/our-plants/results-by-name-serial-number.php?serial=100808","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 10'","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Cam Too Camellia Nursery","url":"https://camtoocamellia.com/prof-charles-s-sargent/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature height 8ft - 10ft, width 6ft - 8ft.","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Almost Eden","url":"https://www.almostedenplants.com/shopping/products/9195-professor-charles-s-sargent-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows To: 8-12'H x 6-10'W","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/professor-sargent-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 8-10 ft","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perfect Plants Nursery","url":"https://myperfectplants.com/products/professor-sargent-camellia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 6-10 ft","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/shade-shrubs/professor-sargent-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature height 8 feet","metres":2.44,"band":[2.2,2.68],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plants by Mail","url":"https://www.plantsbymail.com/products/professor-sargent-camellia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Reaches 10-15' H x 8' W at maturity","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia-professor-sargent","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[2.2,2.44],"union":[1.83,3.05],"proposed":2.32,"margin":18,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Cam Too Camellia Nursery","url":"https://camtoocamellia.com/prof-charles-s-sargent/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature height 8ft - 10ft, width 6ft - 8ft.","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Almost Eden","url":"https://www.almostedenplants.com/shopping/products/9195-professor-charles-s-sargent-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows To: 8-12'H x 6-10'W","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/professor-sargent-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 6-8 ft","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perfect Plants Nursery","url":"https://myperfectplants.com/products/professor-sargent-camellia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width 6-8 ft","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/shade-shrubs/professor-sargent-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 8 feet","metres":2.44,"band":[2.2,2.68],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plants by Mail","url":"https://www.plantsbymail.com/products/professor-sargent-camellia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Reaches 10-15' H x 8' W at maturity","metres":2.44,"band":[2.2,2.68],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (1.83 to 3.05 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia-professor-sargent","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Camellia japonica, species page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287331","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 7 to 9","zones":[7,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Camellia japonica, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/camellia-japonica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[7,9]},{"name":"Camellia Forest Nursery","url":"https://camforest.com/products/c-prosar","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 7b-9","zones":[7,9]},{"name":"Almost Eden","url":"https://www.almostedenplants.com/shopping/products/9195-professor-charles-s-sargent-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Cold Hardiness Zones (2012): 7,8,9","zones":[7,9]},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/professor-sargent-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In: Zones 7-9","zones":[7,9]},{"name":"Perfect Plants Nursery","url":"https://myperfectplants.com/products/professor-sargent-camellia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones 7, 8, 9","zones":[7,9]},{"name":"Plants by Mail","url":"https://www.plantsbymail.com/products/professor-sargent-camellia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy in USDA Zones 7-9","zones":[7,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia-professor-sargent","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Camellia japonica, species page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287331","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Camellia japonica, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/camellia-japonica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"JC Raulston Arboretum, NC State University","url":"https://jcra.ncsu.edu/horticulture/our-plants/results-by-name-serial-number.php?serial=100808","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: part sun"},{"name":"Almost Eden","url":"https://www.almostedenplants.com/shopping/products/9195-professor-charles-s-sargent-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Outdoor Light: Morning sun, Part sun, Part shade, Filtered shade, Light shade"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/professor-sargent-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs : Full Sun, Partial Sun"},{"name":"Perfect Plants Nursery","url":"https://myperfectplants.com/products/professor-sargent-camellia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Partial Sun / Partial Shade"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/shade-shrubs/professor-sargent-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirements full sun to shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia-professor-sargent","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia-professor-sargent","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia-professor-sargent","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plants by Mail","url":"https://www.plantsbymail.com/products/professor-sargent-camellia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"considered somewhat drought tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia-professor-sargent","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Camellia japonica, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/camellia-japonica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Camellia attracts pollinators and songbirds","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"camellia-yuletide","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[2.44,3.05],"union":[1.83,3.66],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Southern Living Plant Collection","url":"https://southernlivingplants.com/the-collection/plant/yuletide-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8-10′ high x 6-8′ wide","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/yuletide-camellia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 8-10 Feet","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/yuletide-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 8-10 ft","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/yuletide-camellia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height : 8-10 ft.","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/camellia-sasanqua-yuletide-red/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 6 - 12 feet","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/CAMELLIA-SASANQUA-YULETIDE","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6-10 ft","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Gasko's Family Farm and Greenhouses","url":"https://gaskosfamilyfarm.com/upcp_product/camellia-yuletide/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height and Width: 8-10' tall × 6-8' wide","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":3,"genus":1,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"camellia-yuletide","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.3,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[1.83,2.44],"union":[1.52,3.66],"proposed":2.13,"margin":14.5,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Southern Living Plant Collection","url":"https://southernlivingplants.com/the-collection/plant/yuletide-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8-10′ high x 6-8′ wide","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/yuletide-camellia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 6-8 Feet","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/yuletide-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 6-8 ft","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/yuletide-camellia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width : 8-10 ft.","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/camellia-sasanqua-yuletide-red/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 6 - 12 feet","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/CAMELLIA-SASANQUA-YULETIDE","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 5-6 ft","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Gasko's Family Farm and Greenhouses","url":"https://gaskosfamilyfarm.com/upcp_product/camellia-yuletide/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height and Width: 8-10' tall × 6-8' wide","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":3,"genus":1,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (1.52 to 3.66 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"camellia-yuletide","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-10","7-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Southern Living Plant Collection","url":"https://southernlivingplants.com/the-collection/plant/yuletide-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 7a - 10b","zones":[7,10],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/yuletide-camellia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones 7 to 10","zones":[7,10],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/yuletide-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In: Zones 7-9","zones":[7,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/yuletide-camellia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In Zones : 7-9 outdoors","zones":[7,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/camellia-sasanqua-yuletide-red/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: Zones 7 - 9","zones":[7,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/CAMELLIA-SASANQUA-YULETIDE","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 7-10","zones":[7,10],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Gasko's Family Farm and Greenhouses","url":"https://gaskosfamilyfarm.com/upcp_product/camellia-yuletide/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: USDA Zones 7-9 (protected Zone 6 locations possible)","zones":[7,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":3,"genus":1,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"camellia-yuletide","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":11,"distinctPublishers":11,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287336","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/camellia-sasanqua/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/camellia-sasanqua","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part shade or sun.","level":"species","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They thrive and bloom best when sheltered from full sun and drying winds.","level":"genus","taxon":"camellia"},{"name":"Southern Living Plant Collection","url":"https://southernlivingplants.com/the-collection/plant/yuletide-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs Part Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/yuletide-camellia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure : Partial Shade to Partial Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/yuletide-camellia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs : Full Sun, Partial Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/yuletide-camellia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight : Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/camellia-sasanqua-yuletide-red/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs: Filtered Sun, Partial Shade, Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/CAMELLIA-SASANQUA-YULETIDE","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Partial Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Gasko's Family Farm and Greenhouses","url":"https://gaskosfamilyfarm.com/upcp_product/camellia-yuletide/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Partial shade to filtered sun; tolerates morning sun.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"camellia-yuletide","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287336","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/camellia-sasanqua/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/camellia-sasanqua","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers, 5-7.5 cm diam, open in fall or early winter, with wide cultivar variation in doubleness and color, from white to deep red, elusive fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/camellia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are mostly single or semi-double, 2 to 3 inches in diameter, and very fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"camellia"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/camellia-sasanqua-yuletide-red/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are small to midsize, single, and fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"camellia-yuletide","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/camellia-sasanqua/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers last only a few days before dropping so they do not make good cut flowers.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Southern Living Plant Collection","url":"https://southernlivingplants.com/the-collection/plant/yuletide-camellia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Birds / Butterflies, Compact Habit, Cut Flowers, Drought Tolerance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/yuletide-camellia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features : Cut Flowers, Drought Tolerant, Fall Blooming, Longer Blooming, Rebloomer, Wet Areas","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/yuletide-camellia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut blooms before they open and place in a vase of water to watch them come to life.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"camellia-yuletide","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/camellia-sasanqua/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It appreciates shelter from afternoon sun, winter winds, and cold, and-once established-will tolerate drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Southern Living Plant Collection","url":"https://southernlivingplants.com/the-collection/plant/yuletide-camellia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Birds / Butterflies, Compact Habit, Cut Flowers, Drought Tolerance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/yuletide-camellia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features : Cut Flowers, Drought Tolerant, Fall Blooming, Longer Blooming, Rebloomer, Wet Areas","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/CAMELLIA-SASANQUA-YULETIDE","country":null,"form":null,"value":"After established is slightly drought tolerant and slightly salt tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"camellia-yuletide","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/camellia-sasanqua/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Southern Living Plant Collection","url":"https://southernlivingplants.com/the-collection/plant/yuletide-camellia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Birds / Butterflies, Compact Habit, Cut Flowers, Drought Tolerance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/CAMELLIA-SASANQUA-YULETIDE","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"camellia sasanqua"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"canna","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.3,5.03],"split":[{"range":[0.3,2.44],"sources":["University of Illinois Extension","Missouri Botanical Garden","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna, genus)","Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","Royal Horticultural Society"]},{"range":[4.11,5.03],"sources":["UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a439","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 8.00 feet","metres":[0.46,2.44],"band":[0.46,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna, genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 6 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.46,2.44],"band":[0.46,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/summer-and-fall-flowering-bulbs/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Although most cannas grow 3 to 6 feet tall or more, new dwarf cultivars may reach only 2 feet tall.","metres":[0.61,1.83],"band":[0.61,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/plants/canna","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Heights range from 12-18 inches to six feet or more.","metres":[0.3,1.83],"band":[0.3,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/cannas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"With proper care, plants can grow anywhere from a few feet in height ('Lucifer' and 'Picasso') to over fifteen feet tall ('Musifolia').","metres":4.57,"band":[4.11,5.03],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/canna","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Height and spread - 1.8m (6ft) by 1m (3½ ft)","metres":1.8,"band":[1.62,1.98],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"genus":6,"cultivar":1,"species":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.9,1.1],"union":[0.46,1.83],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a439","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.46,1.83],"band":[0.46,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna, genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 6 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.46,1.83],"band":[0.46,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/canna","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Height and spread - 1.8m (6ft) by 1m (3½ ft)","metres":1,"band":[0.9,1.1],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":6,"cultivar":1,"species":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-10","6-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a439","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 7 to 10","zones":[7,10],"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna, genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[6,10],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"genus":6,"cultivar":1,"species":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a439","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Canna aquatic group)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=265515","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna, genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They grow in a variety of soil textures but prefer organically-rich, well-drained soil and a site that receives full sun to partial shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna x generalis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna-x-generalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"canna generalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna indica)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna-indica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"canna indica"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna glauca)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna-glauca/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"canna glauca"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna flaccida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna-flaccida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"canna flaccida"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/plants/canna","country":"US","form":null,"value":"For the best foliage and heaviest bloom, grow them in full sun in rich, moist soil.","level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/cannas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Cannas grow best in sites that have rich, organic soil and full sun","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture Cooperative Extension (Plant of the Week)","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/garden-canna.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun is the best location to grow cannas.","level":"species","taxon":"canna generalis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["canna flaccida"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (canna flaccida), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (canna flaccida) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna, genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#flower arrangements","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna, genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates drought, poor soil, wet soil, heat, and humidity.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["canna generalis"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (canna generalis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (canna generalis) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a439","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are attractive to hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Canna aquatic group)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=265515","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna, genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cultivars with red blooms attract hummingbirds. Host plant for Brazilian Skipper caterpillar and moth.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna x generalis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna-x-generalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"canna generalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna indica)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna-indica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds and bees are attracted to the flowers during the day. Bats and moths visit during the night.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"canna indica"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna glauca)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna-glauca/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and is a larval host for the Brazilian Skipper.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"canna glauca"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna flaccida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna-flaccida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinated by hummingbirds. It is a larval host to skipper butterflies. Other pollinators are attracted to the nectar.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"canna flaccida"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Canna flaccida)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CAFL11","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nectar Source: yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"canna flaccida"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"canna-australia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1.22,2.68],"split":[{"range":[1.22,1.67],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Brent and Becky's Bulbs","Longfield Gardens","Kiefer Landscaping and Nursery","James Greenhouses"]},{"range":[1.83,2.68],"sources":["Green Thumbs Galore","Buchanan's Native Plants"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d651","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/canna-australia-indian-shot/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4′-5′","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/canna-australia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 48-60\" tall","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"James Greenhouses","url":"https://www.jamesgreenhouses.com/plants/canna-australia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"height: 60\"","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Kiefer Landscaping and Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/canna-australia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 4 to 5'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Green Thumbs Galore","url":"https://www.greenthumbsgalore.com/canna-colocasia/canna-australia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 6-8 feet","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/annuals/australia-canna/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Australia Canna will grow to be about 8 feet tall at maturity, with a spread of 4 feet.","metres":2.44,"band":[2.2,2.68],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":2,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"canna-australia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.46,1.34],"split":[{"range":[0.46,0.91],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Kiefer Landscaping and Nursery"]},{"range":[1.1,1.34],"sources":["Buchanan's Native Plants"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d651","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Kiefer Landscaping and Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/canna-australia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 2 to 3 ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/annuals/australia-canna/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Australia Canna will grow to be about 8 feet tall at maturity, with a spread of 4 feet.","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":2,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"canna-australia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-10","7-11","5-9","8-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d651","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 7 to 10","zones":[7,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/canna-australia-indian-shot/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 7, 8, 9, 10","zones":[7,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/canna-australia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 7 through 11","zones":[7,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"James Greenhouses","url":"https://www.jamesgreenhouses.com/plants/canna-australia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"hardiness zone: 7 - 10","zones":[7,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Kiefer Landscaping and Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/canna-australia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Green Thumbs Galore","url":"https://www.greenthumbsgalore.com/canna-colocasia/canna-australia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 8 through 10","zones":[8,10],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":2,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"canna-australia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d651","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna, genus record)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"canna"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna x generalis, species record)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna-x-generalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"canna generalis"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/canna-australia-indian-shot/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/canna-australia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Sun to Part Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"James Greenhouses","url":"https://www.jamesgreenhouses.com/plants/canna-australia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"light: full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Kiefer Landscaping and Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/canna-australia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Green Thumbs Galore","url":"https://www.greenthumbsgalore.com/canna-colocasia/canna-australia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun (over 6 hrs)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/annuals/australia-canna/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/cannas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Cannas grow best in sites that have rich, organic soil and full sun, though they will grow in most soils if they are well watered and fertilized, either with monthly applications of a balanced fertilizer or with fewer applications of a controlled-release fertilizer.","level":"genus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"canna-australia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"canna-australia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna, genus record)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#flower arrangements","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"canna"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"canna-australia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna, genus record)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates drought, poor soil, wet soil, heat, and humidity.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"canna"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"canna-australia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d651","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna, genus record)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cultivars with red blooms attract hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"canna"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna x generalis, species record)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna-x-generalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"canna generalis"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/canna-australia-indian-shot/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attractive to hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/canna-australia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Late summer brings crimson red flowers that draw hummingbirds like a magnet.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"James Greenhouses","url":"https://www.jamesgreenhouses.com/plants/canna-australia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cannas are a fantastic butterfly and hummingbird attractor.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Green Thumbs Galore","url":"https://www.greenthumbsgalore.com/canna-colocasia/canna-australia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/annuals/australia-canna/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting hummingbirds to your yard.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"canna-bengal-tiger","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Swift Creek Nursery","url":"https://www.swiftcreeknursery.com/plant-name/Canna-Bengal-Tiger","country":"US","form":null,"value":"60-72 in","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-bengal-tiger","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Swift Creek Nursery","url":"https://www.swiftcreeknursery.com/plant-name/Canna-Bengal-Tiger","country":"US","form":null,"value":"24-36 in","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-bengal-tiger","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Swift Creek Nursery","url":"https://www.swiftcreeknursery.com/plant-name/Canna-Bengal-Tiger","country":"US","form":null,"value":"7-10","zones":[7,10]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-bengal-tiger","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Swift Creek Nursery","url":"https://www.swiftcreeknursery.com/plant-name/Canna-Bengal-Tiger","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-bengal-tiger","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-bengal-tiger","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-bengal-tiger","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-bengal-tiger","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-lucifer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.91,1],"union":[0.46,1.22],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/94336/canna-lucifer/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/canna-lucifer-red-yellow/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 - 4 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"K. van Bourgondien (Dutch Bulbs)","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/lucifer_dwarf_cannas","country":"US","form":null,"value":"20 inches","metres":0.51,"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-lucifer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.1,0.91],"split":[{"range":[0.1,0.5],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)"]},{"range":[0.61,0.91],"sources":["Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/94336/canna-lucifer/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/canna-lucifer-red-yellow/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2 - 3 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-lucifer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-11","3-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/canna-lucifer-red-yellow/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 7 - 11","zones":[7,11]},{"name":"K. van Bourgondien (Dutch Bulbs)","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/lucifer_dwarf_cannas","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3-10","zones":[3,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-lucifer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/94336/canna-lucifer/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/canna-lucifer-red-yellow/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"K. van Bourgondien (Dutch Bulbs)","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/lucifer_dwarf_cannas","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-lucifer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-lucifer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-lucifer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-lucifer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-wyoming","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.5,1.52],"union":[0.81,2.5],"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/faq/what-canna-cultivars-are-recommended-grow-landscape","country":"US","form":null,"value":"‘Wyoming’ - orange flowers, 3 to 4 feet, bronze-red foliage","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/90931/canna-wyoming/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-canna-lily-flower-bulbs-wyoming","country":"US","form":null,"value":"36-48\" tall x 12-24\" wide","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/spring-canna-lily-flower-bulbs-wyoming","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 42-60\" tall","metres":[1.07,1.52],"band":[1.07,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Horn Canna Farm","url":"https://cannas.net/products/wyoming-bulb","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 to 4 feet.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Netherland Bulb Company","url":"https://www.netherlandbulb.com/bulb/Canna-indica-Wyoming","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: 32-42 In","metres":[0.81,1.07],"band":[0.81,1.07],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/canna-lilies/wyoming-canna","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 42\" to 60\"","metres":[1.07,1.52],"band":[1.07,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Canna-Wyoming","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 60 Inches","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"DeGroot Inc.","url":"https://degroot-inc.com/product/canna-wyoming/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 48-60\"","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/canna-wyoming-rhizomes-uk","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Established height 1.5-2m","metres":[1.5,2],"band":[1.5,2],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-wyoming","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.3,1],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/90931/canna-wyoming/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-canna-lily-flower-bulbs-wyoming","country":"US","form":null,"value":"36-48\" tall x 12-24\" wide","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Canna-Wyoming","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 12-18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/canna-wyoming-rhizomes-uk","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Established spread 30-50cm","metres":[0.3,0.5],"band":[0.3,0.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-wyoming","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-10","6-10","8-11","8-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Canna group page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a439","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 7 to 10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[6,10]},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-canna-lily-flower-bulbs-wyoming","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone Zone 8 Zone 9 Zone 10 Zone 11","zones":[8,11]},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/spring-canna-lily-flower-bulbs-wyoming","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone Zone 8 Zone 9 Zone 10 Zone 11","zones":[8,11]},{"name":"Netherland Bulb Company","url":"https://www.netherlandbulb.com/bulb/Canna-indica-Wyoming","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 7-10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/canna-lilies/wyoming-canna","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 8 to 11","zones":[8,11]},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Canna-Wyoming","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 8-10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"DeGroot Inc.","url":"https://degroot-inc.com/product/canna-wyoming/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 7-10; Annual in 2-6","zones":[7,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-wyoming","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/90931/canna-wyoming/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Canna group page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a439","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Canna genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/canna/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-canna-lily-flower-bulbs-wyoming","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/spring-canna-lily-flower-bulbs-wyoming","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun"},{"name":"Horn Canna Farm","url":"https://cannas.net/products/wyoming-bulb","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Part To Full Sun"},{"name":"Netherland Bulb Company","url":"https://www.netherlandbulb.com/bulb/Canna-indica-Wyoming","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/canna-lilies/wyoming-canna","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun"},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Canna-Wyoming","country":"US","form":null,"value":"thrives in full sun with organically rich, moist, well-drained soil"},{"name":"DeGroot Inc.","url":"https://degroot-inc.com/product/canna-wyoming/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full sun"},{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/canna-wyoming-rhizomes-uk","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full sun Partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-wyoming","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-wyoming","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-wyoming","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canna-wyoming","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-canna-lily-flower-bulbs-wyoming","https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/canna-lilies/wyoming-canna"]}],"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-canna-lily-flower-bulbs-wyoming","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/canna-lilies/wyoming-canna","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies and Hummingbirds, Deer Resistant, Grows Well In Containers","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canterbury-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":10,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":4,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":10,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plants usually branch from the base of the rosette with the central stem reaching 3 feet high while surrounded with side branches only 1-2 feet tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height 60-90 cm 23-35 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Campanula medium is an evergreen Biennial growing to 1.2 m (4ft) by 0.3 m (1ft in) at a medium rate.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Each plant provides masses of large, vivid purply-blue flowers on 18 to 36\" tall scapes, from late spring through mid-summer.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"After overwintering, in the spring to early summer of the second year, rises to a height of 3 feet and produces gobs of flowers.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"A Biennial that grows up to 32 inches, this mix is a delight in the garden as well as containers.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant Height Tall (Greater than 24\")\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Typically pest-free, Canterbury Bells will reach up to 3 feet tall in their second year and may require staking to support their long, slender stalks.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: Often 24-36 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canterbury-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":10,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":4,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread 30-40 cm 12-16 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Campanula medium is an evergreen Biennial growing to 1.2 m (4ft) by 0.3 m (1ft in) at a medium rate.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canterbury-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","2-9","6-8","4-10","5-8","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/campanula-medium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/campanula-medium-single-mixture.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 2-9","zones":[2,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"Plants For A Future","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Campanula+medium","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"USDA hardiness 6-8","zones":[6,8],"level":"species"},{"name":"Strictly Medicinal Seeds","url":"https://strictlymedicinalseeds.com/product/canterbury-bells-seeds/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Overwinters in zones 4 to 10.","zones":[4,10],"level":"species"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/canterbury-bells-seeds-mix","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"Botanical Interests (Storybook Blend)","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/canterbury-bells-storybook-blend-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species"},{"name":"Baker Creek Heirloom Seeds (Rare Seeds)","url":"https://www.rareseeds.com/blog/post/how-to-grow-canterbury-bells","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy from USDA zones 4-8.","zones":[4,8],"level":"species"},{"name":"Seedman","url":"https://www.seedman.com/ai/campanula-canterbury-bells.htm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones: Commonly hardy in zones 4-8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":10,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canterbury-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/campanula-medium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant thrives in full sun to partial shade and moist, well-draining soil and reasonably cool temperatures.","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture, Plant of the Week","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/canterbury-bells.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants can be grown in full sun or light shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/campanula-medium-single-mixture.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun or Partial Shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Harlequin's Gardens (Boulder, Colorado)","url":"https://harlequinsgardens.com/canterbury-bells-blue-campanula-medium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow in sun or part-shade in fertile, well-drained soil.","level":"species"},{"name":"Rainyside Gardeners","url":"https://rainyside.com/plant_gallery/annuals/Campanula_mediumCalycanthema.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to partial shade. Full sun is best in our maritime climate.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"campanula medium"},{"name":"Strictly Medicinal Seeds","url":"https://strictlymedicinalseeds.com/product/canterbury-bells-seeds/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant prefers a part sun to shady position, and does best when closely spaced to 6 inches apart, so that the plants hold each other up.","level":"species"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/canterbury-bells-seeds-mix","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Botanical Interests (Storybook Blend)","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/canterbury-bells-storybook-blend-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Required Full sun to part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Baker Creek Heirloom Seeds (Rare Seeds)","url":"https://www.rareseeds.com/blog/post/how-to-grow-canterbury-bells","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Campanula prefers rich, well-drained soil and full sun to part shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"Seedman","url":"https://www.seedman.com/ai/campanula-canterbury-bells.htm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun to partial shade","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canterbury-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/campanula-medium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Long-lasting Showy","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canterbury-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/campanula-medium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Long-lasting Showy","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/campanula-medium-single-mixture.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stems are superb for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Plants For A Future","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Campanula+medium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Not North American native, Suitable for cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Harlequin's Gardens (Boulder, Colorado)","url":"https://harlequinsgardens.com/canterbury-bells-blue-campanula-medium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"And Canterbury Bells are among the longest-lasting of cut-flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Strictly Medicinal Seeds","url":"https://strictlymedicinalseeds.com/product/canterbury-bells-seeds/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"As a cut flower, these are extremely long lasting and will go for a week when cut and placed in a vase of water.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/canterbury-bells-seeds-mix","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use Container Garden, Cut Flower Garden","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Botanical Interests (Storybook Blend)","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/canterbury-bells-storybook-blend-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attracts pollinators, and is a wonderful, long-lasting cut flower!","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Baker Creek Heirloom Seeds (Rare Seeds)","url":"https://www.rareseeds.com/blog/post/how-to-grow-canterbury-bells","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the bells are shaped like little drinking glasses and make a superb cut flower","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Seedman","url":"https://www.seedman.com/ai/campanula-canterbury-bells.htm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cottage gardens Cut flowers Pollinator borders Old-fashioned flower beds","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["campanula medium"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (campanula medium), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"9 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (campanula medium) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"canterbury-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"canterbury-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/campanula-medium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Plants For A Future","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Campanula+medium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"pollinated by Bees, flies, beetles, Lepidoptera (Moths & Butterflies)","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Strictly Medicinal Seeds","url":"https://strictlymedicinalseeds.com/product/canterbury-bells-seeds/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees, butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/canterbury-bells-seeds-mix","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plant Characteristics Attracts Bees, Attracts Butterflies, Attracts Hummingbirds, Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Botanical Interests (Storybook Blend)","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/canterbury-bells-storybook-blend-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plant Characteristics Attracts Pollinators Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Seedman","url":"https://www.seedman.com/ai/campanula-canterbury-bells.htm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cottage gardens Cut flowers Pollinator borders Old-fashioned flower beds","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"cardinal-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1],"union":[0.3,1.83],"voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d940","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lobelia-cardinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/cardinal-flower-lobelia-cardinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Leafy inflorescences ranging from 3-6 feet tall appear from midsummer to fall.","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension, Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/cardinal-flower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2-4 feet","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=LOCA2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This 1-6 ft. perennial has showy, red flowers in 8 in., terminal spikes.","metres":[0.3,1.83],"band":[0.3,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust GoBotany","url":"https://gobotany.nativeplanttrust.org/species/lobelia/cardinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant height 50-150 cm","metres":[0.5,1.5],"band":[0.5,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/cardinal-flower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: to 5 feet, but usually shorter (2-4 feet).","metres":[0.61,1.52],"band":[0.61,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center Native Plant Finder","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/cardinal-flower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"pure red flowers appear on 2' long spikes atop 3-4' tall plants","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/10394/lobelia-cardinalis/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/cardinal-flower-lobelia-cardinalis.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 2' - 4'","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/lobelia-cardinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants are 2-4' tall with a 1-2' spread.","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cardinal-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.5],"union":[0.1,0.61],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d940","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lobelia-cardinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/10394/lobelia-cardinalis/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/lobelia-cardinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants are 2-4' tall with a 1-2' spread.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cardinal-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d940","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lobelia-cardinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/cardinal-flower-lobelia-cardinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Cardinal flower is hardy in zones 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center Native Plant Finder","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/cardinal-flower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 3-9.","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/cardinal-flower-lobelia-cardinalis.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/lobelia-cardinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants are hardy from USDA Zones 3-9.","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cardinal-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d940","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lobelia-cardinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant is easily grown in rich, medium to wet soil and in part shade to full sun, although afternoon shade is appreciated in hot summer climates.","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/cardinal-flower-lobelia-cardinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lobelia cardinalis is easily grown in moist soils in full sun to partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension, Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/cardinal-flower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Shade or partial shade, full sun works if soil is consistently wet","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=LOCA2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade , Shade","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/cardinal-flower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Also found in cultivation, where it prefers rich, humusy, medium to wet soils and partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center Native Plant Finder","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/cardinal-flower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun/Shade Conditions full-sun-to-partial-shade","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/10394/lobelia-cardinalis/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/cardinal-flower-lobelia-cardinalis.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun, Partial","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/lobelia-cardinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun to Full Shade","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cardinal-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=LOCA2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use Ornamental: Aromatic, Color, Showy, Garden, Perennial garden","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cardinal-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/cardinal-flower-lobelia-cardinalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cardinal flower is also good for cut flowers, but the stems do have a milky sap.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/lobelia-cardinalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bog, Cut Flower, East-Coast Native, Naturalizing, Rain Garden","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"cardinal-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d940","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Needs constant moisture.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lobelia-cardinalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The soil should never be allowed to dry out, and it will tolerate brief flooding.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=LOCA2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerance: Low","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/cardinal-flower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It needs constant moisture.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/lobelia-cardinalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The species adapts to sandy loam and gravelly or clay soil but will not tolerate drought.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"}],"note":"5 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cardinal-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d940","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lobelia-cardinalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its flowers are attractive to hummingbirds, butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/cardinal-flower-lobelia-cardinalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The bright red flowers are pollinated by hummingbirds, which are readily attracted, along with butterflies and bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension, Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/cardinal-flower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife: Excellent nectar plant; attracts large bees, swallowtail butterflies, and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=LOCA2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds , Butterflies , Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust GoBotany","url":"https://gobotany.nativeplanttrust.org/species/lobelia/cardinalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The red bell-shaped flowers of red lobelia are pollinated by hummingbirds and are a dramatic addition to the native plant garden.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/cardinal-flower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The red flowers of this species are attractive to ruby-throated hummingbirds , which are probably the major pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center Native Plant Finder","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/cardinal-flower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"C ardinal flower ( Lobelia c ardinalis ) is a sure bet for gardeners anxious to have hummingbirds visit their gardens.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/cardinal-flower-lobelia-cardinalis.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Benefits Butterflies, Hummingbirds, Deer Resistant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/lobelia-cardinalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are pollinated by ruby throated hummingbirds and are also visited by swallowtail and sulfur butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia cardinalis"}],"note":"10 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"carding-mill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.34],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/carding-mill","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/carding-mill","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4' x 3.5'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/carding-mill-english-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mature Height 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/carding-mill","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"SPLIT"},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"carding-mill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.96,1.18],"union":[0.61,1.22],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/carding-mill","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3 1/2ft","metres":1.07,"band":[0.96,1.18],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/carding-mill","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4' x 3.5'","metres":1.07,"band":[0.96,1.18],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/carding-mill-english-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mature Spread 2-3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/carding-mill","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"carding-mill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","5-8","6-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/carding-mill","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/carding-mill","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/carding-mill-english-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"USDA Hardiness Zones 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/carding-mill","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zones: 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Angel Gardens","url":"https://angelgardens.com/rose/carding-mill/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 6 - 9","zones":[6,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"carding-mill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/carding-mill","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/carding-mill","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sun Requires 6+ hours of direct sunlight to thrive.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/carding-mill-english-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light Exposure Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/carding-mill","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"carding-mill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["medium","medium","medium","medium"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/carding-mill","https://heirloomroses.com/products/carding-mill"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/carding-mill","https://plantaddicts.com/carding-mill-english-rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/carding-mill","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/carding-mill"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/carding-mill","https://angelgardens.com/rose/carding-mill/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/carding-mill","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They carry a gentle myrrh fragrance and are held elegantly on straight stems, forming a rounded, bushy shrub of tidy habit.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/carding-mill","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Moderately Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/carding-mill-english-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/carding-mill","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The blooms have a sweet, yet spicy, scent.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Angel Gardens","url":"https://angelgardens.com/rose/carding-mill/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Moderate, myrrh fragrance. 80 petals.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"carding-mill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/carding-mill-english-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/carding-mill","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vase Life: 1-2 Days","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Garden","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"carding-mill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"carding-mill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/carding-mill-english-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"catmint","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":13,"levels":{"genus":1,"cultivar":3,"species":11},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 13 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"catmint","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":10,"levels":{"genus":1,"cultivar":3,"species":11},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"catmint","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nepeta, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":11,"levels":{"genus":1,"cultivar":3,"species":11},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 11 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"catmint","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nepeta, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Catmint requires full sun and good drainage.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta 'Six Hills Giant'; also carries the genus paragraph)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260507","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta x faassenii)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250745","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta racemosa)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292468","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta racemosa 'Walker's Low')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255085","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta cataria)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281406","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"nepeta cataria"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta subsessilis)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281588","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"nepeta subsessilis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nepeta x faassenii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nepeta x faassenii 'Walker's Low')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii-walkers-low/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nepeta cataria)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-cataria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"nepeta cataria"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Nepeta cataria)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/catnip-nepeta-cataria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Catnip grows best in full sun and average, well-drained soil, but survives in partial shade and thrives in poor soils.","level":"species","taxon":"nepeta cataria"},{"name":"Illinois Wildflowers (Nepeta cataria)","url":"https://www.illinoiswildflowers.info/weeds/plants/catnip.htm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This is an adaptable plant that typically grows in full or partial sun, moist to dry conditions, and a soil that is loamy, rocky, or gravelly.","level":"species","taxon":"nepeta cataria"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"catmint","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"taxon-disagreement","strengths":["strong"],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nepeta, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It came to be called catmint owing to having a strong scent that cats find attractive.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta 'Six Hills Giant'; also carries the genus paragraph)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260507","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nepeta is a genus which contains about 250 species of perennials plus a few annuals, all of which are native to Europe, Asia, and Africa. Plants are usually aromatic, and mostly feature sharply toothed or deeply cut leaves and whorls of blue, lavender or white flowers in elongated spikes or panicles.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta x faassenii)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250745","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gray-green leaves and lavender-blue flowers are highly aromatic.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta racemosa)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292468","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaves are highly aromatic when crushed or bruised.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta racemosa 'Walker's Low')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255085","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta cataria)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281406","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta cataria"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta subsessilis)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281588","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta subsessilis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nepeta x faassenii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gray-green leaves and lavender-blue flowers are highly aromatic.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nepeta x faassenii 'Walker's Low')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii-walkers-low/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant silvery leaves, especially when crushed, make this plant appealing.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nepeta cataria)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-cataria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Aromatic, coarsely-toothed, triangular to ovate, grey-green leaves","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta cataria"},{"name":"Plants For A Future (Nepeta cataria)","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Nepeta+cataria","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The dried leaves retain their fragrance and can be used in pot-pourri","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta cataria"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["nepeta cataria"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (nepeta cataria), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"this came out more confident than v6 only once the distinct-taxa rule removed the claim(s) that disagreed, so it is a disagreement about which taxa were speaking rather than a finding; v6 recorded SPLIT and true is not proposed; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (nepeta cataria) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"catmint","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"catmint","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nepeta, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta 'Six Hills Giant'; also carries the genus paragraph)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260507","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Thrives in dry soils and is tolerant of drought.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta racemosa)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292468","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Thrives in dry soils and is very tolerant of drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta racemosa 'Walker's Low')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255085","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta cataria)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281406","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta cataria"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta subsessilis)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281588","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta subsessilis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nepeta x faassenii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, blue catmint is drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nepeta x faassenii 'Walker's Low')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii-walkers-low/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Dry Soil Pollution","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nepeta cataria)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-cataria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The plant is resistant to drought, dry soil, and air pollution but is somewhat intolerant of heat and humidity, so give it some afternoon shade.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta cataria"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Nepeta cataria)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/catnip-nepeta-cataria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, this plant is fairly drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta cataria"},{"name":"Illinois Wildflowers (Nepeta cataria)","url":"https://www.illinoiswildflowers.info/weeds/plants/catnip.htm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It's more drought resistant than many other members of the Mint family.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta cataria"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["nepeta faassenii"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (nepeta faassenii), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"11 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (nepeta faassenii) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"catmint","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nepeta, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta racemosa)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292468","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Nepeta cataria)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281406","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta cataria"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nepeta x faassenii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nepeta x faassenii 'Walker's Low')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii-walkers-low/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"However, Walker's Low catmint is a pollinator magnet.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nepeta cataria)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-cataria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"'Cataria' catmint is a pollinator plant for honey bees as well as other bees, insects, and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta cataria"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Nepeta cataria)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/catnip-nepeta-cataria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees of all types, wasps and flies, as well as many different types of butterflies, visit the nectar-laden flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta cataria"},{"name":"Illinois Wildflowers (Nepeta cataria)","url":"https://www.illinoiswildflowers.info/weeds/plants/catnip.htm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The nectar of the flowers attracts long-tongued bees primarily, including honeybees, bumblebees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta cataria"},{"name":"Plants For A Future (Nepeta cataria)","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Nepeta+cataria","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are very attractive to bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta cataria"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"catmint-early-bird","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.27,0.3],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/336531/nepeta-early-bird/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/nepeta-early-bird-early-bird-catmint","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This perennial grows to about 1 foot with full sun to partial shade and moderate moisture conditions.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/nepeta-early-bird.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Height 25-30 cm 10-12 inches","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/catmint-early-bird","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 10-12 Inches","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Greenleaf Nursery Company","url":"https://www.greenleafnursery.com/plant/EARLY-BIRD-CATMINT","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 10 to 12 inches high with a 12 to 14 inch spread.","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Overdevest Nurseries","url":"https://grownbyoverdevest.com/plant/early-bird-catmint/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 10-12\"","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"genus":1,"cultivar":6},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-early-bird","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.3,0.33],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/336531/nepeta-early-bird/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/nepeta-early-bird.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Spread 25-30 cm 10-12 inches","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/catmint-early-bird","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 12-14 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.36],"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Greenleaf Nursery Company","url":"https://www.greenleafnursery.com/plant/EARLY-BIRD-CATMINT","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 10 to 12 inches high with a 12 to 14 inch spread.","metres":[0.3,0.36],"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Overdevest Nurseries","url":"https://grownbyoverdevest.com/plant/early-bird-catmint/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 12\"","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"genus":1,"cultivar":6},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-early-bird","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/nepeta-early-bird-early-bird-catmint","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/nepeta-early-bird.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/catmint-early-bird","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":1,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-early-bird","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"nepeta"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/336531/nepeta-early-bird/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/nepeta-early-bird-early-bird-catmint","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/nepeta-early-bird.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/catmint-early-bird","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-early-bird","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#fragrant leaves","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"nepeta"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/336531/nepeta-early-bird/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"An early-flowering, low-growing, clump-forming deciduous herbaceous perennial with aromatic grey-green foliage and upright stems which produce lavender-blue flowers from late spring throughout the summer.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/nepeta-early-bird.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/catmint-early-bird","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Clean, aromatic foliage and a compact habit make it an excellent groundcover.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Greenleaf Nursery Company","url":"https://www.greenleafnursery.com/plant/EARLY-BIRD-CATMINT","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Clean, aromatic foliage and a compact habit make it an excellent groundcover.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Overdevest Nurseries","url":"https://grownbyoverdevest.com/plant/early-bird-catmint/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Blooms","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"catmint-early-bird","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/336531/nepeta-early-bird/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/nepeta-early-bird.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"catmint-early-bird","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"nepeta"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/336531/nepeta-early-bird/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/nepeta-early-bird.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/catmint-early-bird","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Overdevest Nurseries","url":"https://grownbyoverdevest.com/plant/early-bird-catmint/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-early-bird","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"nepeta"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/nepeta-early-bird-early-bird-catmint","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In spring and summer it produces lavender and purple blooms that attract birds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/nepeta-early-bird.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/catmint-early-bird","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Overdevest Nurseries","url":"https://grownbyoverdevest.com/plant/early-bird-catmint/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-little-titch","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.23,0.25],"union":[0.15,0.33],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/71006/nepeta-racemosa-little-titch/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"A compact perennial to 30cm tall forming a low carpet of aromatic, green to grey-green foliage topped by short spikes of lavender-blue flowers in summer","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=plants.plantDetail&plant_id=1841","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6-10 Inches","metres":[0.15,0.25],"band":[0.15,0.25],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/3790/Little_Titch_Catmint/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10 inches","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Nepeta-racemosa-Little-Titch","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8-10 in","metres":[0.2,0.25],"band":[0.2,0.25],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Blooming Advantage","url":"https://m.bloomingadvantage.com/info.asp?code=7115","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size Range: 6-10\" tall x 12-16\" wide","metres":[0.15,0.25],"band":[0.15,0.25],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":1,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-little-titch","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.33],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/71006/nepeta-racemosa-little-titch/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=plants.plantDetail&plant_id=1841","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12-15 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.38],"band":[0.3,0.38],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/3790/Little_Titch_Catmint/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12 inches","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Nepeta-racemosa-Little-Titch","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 14-16 in","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Blooming Advantage","url":"https://m.bloomingadvantage.com/info.asp?code=7115","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size Range: 6-10\" tall x 12-16\" wide","metres":[0.3,0.41],"band":[0.3,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":1,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-little-titch","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","4-8","3-8","4-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/nepeta-racemosa-little-titch-little-titch-catmint","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5 - 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=plants.plantDetail&plant_id=1841","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Nepeta-racemosa-Little-Titch","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Blooming Advantage","url":"https://m.bloomingadvantage.com/info.asp?code=7115","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone :4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11","zones":[4,11],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":1,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-little-titch","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"nepeta"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Site this plant in full sun to partial shade, especially in the South.","level":"species","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/71006/nepeta-racemosa-little-titch/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Grow in any well-drained soil in full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/nepeta-racemosa-little-titch-little-titch-catmint","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=plants.plantDetail&plant_id=1841","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers full sun to very light shade and any well-drained soil.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/3790/Little_Titch_Catmint/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in full sun to partial shade.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Nepeta-racemosa-Little-Titch","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-little-titch","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Edible Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"nepeta"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gray-green leaves and lavender-blue flowers are highly aromatic.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/71006/nepeta-racemosa-little-titch/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=plants.plantDetail&plant_id=1841","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Masses of fragrant, tubular lavender blue flower spikes over gray foliage.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/3790/Little_Titch_Catmint/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its tiny fragrant pointy leaves remain grayish green in color throughout the season.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Nepeta-racemosa-Little-Titch","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Aromatic, textured foliage is silvery blue-green with deep veins.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"catmint-little-titch","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-little-titch","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"nepeta"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, blue catmint is drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=plants.plantDetail&plant_id=1841","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant and good under coastal conditions.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/3790/Little_Titch_Catmint/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is considered to be drought-tolerant, and thus makes an ideal choice for a low-water garden or xeriscape application.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Nepeta-racemosa-Little-Titch","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Very tolerant of heat and drought.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Blooming Advantage","url":"https://m.bloomingadvantage.com/info.asp?code=7115","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water Requirement Drought Tolerant,Low","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-little-titch","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"nepeta"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/nepeta-racemosa-little-titch-little-titch-catmint","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Interest: Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=plants.plantDetail&plant_id=1841","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to butterflies, hummingbirds, and bees.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/3790/Little_Titch_Catmint/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies and hummingbirds to your yard, but is not particularly attractive to deer who tend to leave it alone in favor of tastier treats.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-walkers-low","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"edge","consensus":[0.68,0.76],"union":[0.61,1.22],"edge":[0.59,1.26],"edgeMargin":1.6,"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii-walkers-low/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=t160","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=NEPWL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24.0-36.0 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/nepeta-racemosa-walkers-low/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants grow to 2.5' tall with a 3' spread.","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21803/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Height: 2.5 feet","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Kimmel Orchard & Vineyard","url":"https://www.kimmelorchard.org/education/our-gardens/nepeta-racemosa-walkers-low","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2-4 ft","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/walkers-low-catmint/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height 2' - 4' (ft)","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/walkers-low-catmint","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This perennial grows 2 to 2.5 feet tall with a spread of 2.5 to 3 feet, creating a low, bushy mound perfect for edging, borders, or ground cover.","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV2":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.72},"note":"the catalog value sits 1.6% outside the sources' union (0.61 to 1.22 m) and inside the 3% margin v3 allows at a stated range edge (0.59 to 1.26 m), so v2's proposal of 0.72 m is withdrawn rather than applied; 6 of these 8 scored sources publish a range, and a range edge is a figure converted and rounded from another unit rather than a measurement to the centimetre; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-walkers-low","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.46,1.22],"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii-walkers-low/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 6 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=t160","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.50 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=NEPWL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/nepeta-racemosa-walkers-low/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants grow to 2.5' tall with a 3' spread.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21803/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Spread: 3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Kimmel Orchard & Vineyard","url":"https://www.kimmelorchard.org/education/our-gardens/nepeta-racemosa-walkers-low","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3-4 ft","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/walkers-low-catmint/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Spread 2' - 4' (ft)","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/walkers-low-catmint","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This perennial grows 2 to 2.5 feet tall with a spread of 2.5 to 3 feet, creating a low, bushy mound perfect for edging, borders, or ground cover.","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-walkers-low","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","3-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii-walkers-low/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=t160","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=NEPWL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/nepeta-racemosa-walkers-low/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants are hardy from USDA Zones 4-9.","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Kimmel Orchard & Vineyard","url":"https://www.kimmelorchard.org/education/our-gardens/nepeta-racemosa-walkers-low","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones (1-13): 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/walkers-low-catmint/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone(s) 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/walkers-low-catmint","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It thrives in USDA Zones 4 to 8, where it can handle full sun to part shade and adapts well to poor, dry soils.","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-walkers-low","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii-walkers-low/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=t160","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=NEPWL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/nepeta-racemosa-walkers-low/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21803/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Partial Shade to Full Shade Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Kimmel Orchard & Vineyard","url":"https://www.kimmelorchard.org/education/our-gardens/nepeta-racemosa-walkers-low","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/walkers-low-catmint/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun, Partial Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/walkers-low-catmint","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It thrives in USDA Zones 4 to 8, where it can handle full sun to part shade and adapts well to poor, dry soils.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-walkers-low","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii-walkers-low/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant silvery leaves, especially when crushed, make this plant appealing.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=t160","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=NEPWL","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Cut Flower Cut Foliage Drought Tolerant Easy To Grow Fragrant Flowers Fragrant Foliage Mass Planting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/nepeta-racemosa-walkers-low/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nepeta 'Walker's Low' is a mounding aromatic perennial.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21803/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The leaves are fragrant when crushed or damaged.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Kimmel Orchard & Vineyard","url":"https://www.kimmelorchard.org/education/our-gardens/nepeta-racemosa-walkers-low","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Characteristics: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/walkers-low-catmint/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Characteristics Fragrant, Plant of Merit, Showy, Flowering","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/walkers-low-catmint","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fragrant, gray-green leaves add visual interest even when the plant is not in bloom, and their aroma deters rabbits and deer, making Nepeta racemosa an ideal choice for wildlife-resistant gardens.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#drought tolerant #dry soils tolerant #fragrant leaves","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"catmint-walkers-low","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=NEPWL","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Cut Flower Cut Foliage Drought Tolerant Easy To Grow Fragrant Flowers Fragrant Foliage Mass Planting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-walkers-low","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii-walkers-low/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#dry soils tolerant #low maintenance #drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=t160","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=NEPWL","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Cut Flower Cut Foliage Drought Tolerant Easy To Grow Fragrant Flowers Fragrant Foliage Mass Planting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/nepeta-racemosa-walkers-low/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants tolerate drought, heat, moderate salinity and shallow rocky soils.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Kimmel Orchard & Vineyard","url":"https://www.kimmelorchard.org/education/our-gardens/nepeta-racemosa-walkers-low","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants that Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/walkers-low-catmint/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerances Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Rabbit, Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/walkers-low-catmint","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Thriving in dry to medium soils, it is drought-tolerant and resistant to deer and rabbits, making it a versatile plant for a wide range of garden settings.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, blue catmint is drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"catmint-walkers-low","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii-walkers-low/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinators are attracted to the flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=NEPWL","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/nepeta-racemosa-walkers-low/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies, bees and hummingbirds flock to the blooms in sunny gardens with sandy well drained soils.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Kimmel Orchard & Vineyard","url":"https://www.kimmelorchard.org/education/our-gardens/nepeta-racemosa-walkers-low","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wildlife: Bees, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/walkers-low-catmint/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/walkers-low-catmint","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant attracts pollinators, making it an ideal addition to pollinator gardens as well.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"nepeta racemosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nepeta-x-faassenii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#groundcover #pollinator plant #drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nepeta faassenii"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"celosia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"They are often between 8 and 24 inches tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height: 8 - 24 Inches (8-24 inches tall depending on cultivar)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"They can range anywhere from 6\" to 36\" tall, depending on the cultivar.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"these plant range in size from 8\" to 36\" tall depending on the variety.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"celosia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 4 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"celosia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-11","10-12"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Celosia, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/celosia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[10,11],"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension IPM, Missouri Environment & Garden (Celosia: Pigweed's Attractive Cousin)","url":"https://ipm.missouri.edu/MEG/2023/5/celosia-DT/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grown in the United States as an annual, it is a tender perennial in zones 10 to 12.","zones":[10,12],"level":"genus"},{"name":"National Garden Bureau (Year of the Celosia, 2023)","url":"https://ngb.org/year-of-the-celosia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"it is a tender perennial in zones 10 to 12","zones":[10,12],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"celosia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Celosia, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/celosia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Celosia argentea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/celosia-argentea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"celosia argentea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Celosia argentea var. cristata, Cristata Group)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264502&isprofile=0&basic=celosia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"celosia argentea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Celosia argentea var. cristata, Plumosa Group)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263002&isprofile=0&basic=celosia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"celosia argentea"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Wheat celosia, Celosia spicata)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/wheat-celosia-celosia-spicata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Wheat celosia does best in full sun.","level":"species","taxon":"celosia spicata"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Celosia)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/celosia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Must have full sun for 8+ hours a day. They perform best in a very warm location.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Illinois Extension (Celosia)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/celosia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"genus"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension (Annual and Perennial Flowers for Mississippi Gardens)","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/publications/annual-and-perennial-flowers-for-mississippi-gardens","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Cockscomb (celosia) Celosia argentea or cristata Full sun 1-2' 8-12\" Crested or plumed cut flowers; heat tolerant; some reseed","level":"species","taxon":"celosia argentea"},{"name":"National Garden Bureau (Year of the Celosia, 2023)","url":"https://ngb.org/year-of-the-celosia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Celosia likes a warm sunny spot in the garden. Be sure to give these plants at least 6-8 hours of full sun","level":"genus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"celosia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Celosia, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/celosia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["celosia argentea"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (celosia argentea), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (celosia argentea) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"celosia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Celosia, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/celosia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Edible Good Cut Good Dried Long Bloom Season Long-lasting Showy","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Celosia argentea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/celosia-argentea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are good cut and dried and plants can be used in the border, in groups or in containers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"celosia argentea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Celosia argentea var. cristata, Cristata Group)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264502&isprofile=0&basic=celosia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"celosia argentea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Celosia argentea var. cristata, Plumosa Group)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263002&isprofile=0&basic=celosia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Mass or group in beds, borders or cutting gardens. Edging. Good fresh cut or dried flower. Containers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"celosia argentea"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Wheat celosia, Celosia spicata)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/wheat-celosia-celosia-spicata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This makes the flowers excellent fresh or dried cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"celosia spicata"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Celosia)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/celosia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Celosia are often used in cut flower displays, both fresh and dried.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension IPM, Missouri Environment & Garden (Celosia: Pigweed's Attractive Cousin)","url":"https://ipm.missouri.edu/MEG/2023/5/celosia-DT/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Additionally, they can be marketed as fresh cut flowers at farmers' markets or other local outlets.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension (Annual and Perennial Flowers for Mississippi Gardens)","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/publications/annual-and-perennial-flowers-for-mississippi-gardens","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cockscomb (celosia) Celosia argentea or cristata Full sun 1-2' 8-12\" Crested or plumed cut flowers; heat tolerant; some reseed","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"celosia argentea"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Growing Annuals)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/growing-annuals/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Annuals for Use as Cut Flowers Annual Carnation ( Dianthus caryophyllus ) Annual Phlox ( Phlox drummondi ) Pot Marigold ( Calendula officinalis ) African Daisy ( Dimorphotheca or Osteospermum ) Cockscomb ( Celosia argentea )","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"celosia argentea"},{"name":"National Garden Bureau (Year of the Celosia, 2023)","url":"https://ngb.org/year-of-the-celosia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Celosia flowers can be used as dried flowers for displays.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"10 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"celosia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Celosia argentea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/celosia-argentea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought Dry Soil Heat Humidity","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"celosia argentea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Celosia argentea var. cristata, Cristata Group)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264502&isprofile=0&basic=celosia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"celosia argentea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Celosia argentea var. cristata, Plumosa Group)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263002&isprofile=0&basic=celosia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"celosia argentea"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Wheat celosia, Celosia spicata)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/wheat-celosia-celosia-spicata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wheat celosia is tolerant of heat and drought and generally has few pest problems","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"celosia spicata"},{"name":"Illinois Extension (Celosia)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/celosia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Will tolerate dry, porous soil.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"celosia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Celosia, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/celosia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Celosia argentea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/celosia-argentea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies, bees and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"celosia argentea"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Wheat celosia, Celosia spicata)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/wheat-celosia-celosia-spicata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are visited by bees, wasps, butterflies, and occasionally hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"celosia spicata"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"celosia-century-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"14 - 16\" (36 - 41cm)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"celosia-century-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"6 - 8\" (15 - 20cm)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"celosia-century-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"celosia-century-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"celosia-century-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"celosia-century-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Ball Seed (PlantInfo)","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=166300277004054","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Suitable for greenhouse, field or garden cut flower production","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"celosia-century-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Ball Seed (PlantInfo)","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=166300277004054","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"celosia-century-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"charlotte-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"union":[1.1,2.01],"split":[{"range":[1.1,1.34],"sources":["David Austin Roses (US)","Grace Rose Farm","Menagerie Farm & Flower"]},{"range":[1.65,2.01],"sources":["David Austin Roses (US) - English Standard Tree Rose page"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are davidaustinroses.com","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte","https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte-tree-rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/charlotte%C2%AE"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte","https://menagerieflower.com/products/charlotte-rose-david-austin"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Standard Tree Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte-tree-rose","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"6ft","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/charlotte%C2%AE","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"~4′","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/charlotte-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/charlotte","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"3 1/2ft (110cm)","metres":1.1,"band":[0.99,1.21],"role":"regional-note"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"SPLIT"},"note":"SPLIT withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are davidaustinroses.com; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"charlotte-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.82,1],"union":[0.82,1],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/charlotte%C2%AE"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte","https://menagerieflower.com/products/charlotte-rose-david-austin"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"3ft","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/charlotte%C2%AE","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"~3′","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/charlotte-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/charlotte","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"3ft (90cm)","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"regional-note"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"charlotte-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are davidaustinroses.com","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte","https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte-tree-rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/charlotte%C2%AE"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte","https://menagerieflower.com/products/charlotte-rose-david-austin"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zones 4-10"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Standard Tree Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte-tree-rose","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Zones 4-10"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/charlotte%C2%AE","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"USDA Zones 4–10"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/charlotte-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable Zones: 4-10"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[4,10]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are davidaustinroses.com; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"charlotte-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Standard Tree Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte-tree-rose","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Full Sunlight"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/charlotte","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/charlotte%C2%AE","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full sun to light shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"charlotte-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light-medium, Tea"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Standard Tree Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/charlotte-tree-rose","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Light-medium, Tea"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/charlotte","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Light-medium, Tea"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/charlotte%C2%AE","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light to medium tea fragrance"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/charlotte-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Strong - Tea"}],"note":"sources rate it light/strong","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"charlotte-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/charlotte%C2%AE","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Fair - best used fresh in informal arrangements"}],"note":"only 1 source mentions it","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"chives","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.25,0.46],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282062","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-schoenoprasum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/herbs/chives","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They are a hardy, drought-tolerant perennial growing to about 10-12 inches tall.","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chives","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.43],"union":[0.3,0.46],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282062","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-schoenoprasum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 5 in.","metres":[0.3,0.43],"band":[0.3,0.43],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chives","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[4,8],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282062","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-schoenoprasum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"every source states 4-8; catalog states 3-9","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chives","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282062","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-schoenoprasum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/herbs/chives","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Chives prefer a full sun location and are tolerant of a wide variety of soils but will grow best in soils that are high in organic matter."},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/yard-and-garden/growing-chives","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Chives thrive in full sun and well drained soil rich in organic matter."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chives","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282062","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-schoenoprasum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Clusters of 1/2-3/4 inch star-shaped pale purple flowers with 6 petals bloom April-May on hollow tubular scapes. Fragrant and edible.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chives","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/herbs/chives","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Chives also make attractive edging in the perennial border and flowers can be cut for arrangements.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/yard-and-garden/growing-chives","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These are edible, and you can use them in salads and flower arrangements.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chives","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282062","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Black Walnut","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-schoenoprasum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of deer, drought and Black Walnut","claim":true},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/herbs/chives","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are a hardy, drought-tolerant perennial growing to about 10-12 inches tall.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chives","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-schoenoprasum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Chives have a high nectar volume and are thus well suited as pollinator plants.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"christmas-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.91],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a710","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/polystichum-acrostichoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"christmas-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.91],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a710","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/polystichum-acrostichoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"christmas-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a710","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 to 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/polystichum-acrostichoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"christmas-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a710","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/polystichum-acrostichoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"christmas-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"christmas-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"christmas-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"christmas-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.3,1.22],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Chrysanthemum x morifolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Chrysanthemum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (HGIC 1161)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/chrysanthemums-how-to-grow-garden-mums-in-south-carolina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height/Spread: 1½ to 3 feet tall (varies by cultivar and pinching)","metres":[0.46,0.91],"band":[0.46,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Flowers, Fruits, and Frass)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/flowers-fruits-and-frass/2025-08-25-mums-and-asters-fall-favorites-colorful-landscape","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Chrysanthemums typically grow between 2 to 4 feet tall in garden settings.","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.3,0.91],"union":[0.3,0.91],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Chrysanthemum x morifolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Chrysanthemum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are ncsu.edu. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Chrysanthemum x morifolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Chrysanthemum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (HGIC 1161)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/chrysanthemums-how-to-grow-garden-mums-in-south-carolina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness: Hardy across South Carolina (USDA Hardiness Zones 5a to 9b)","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Chrysanthemum x morifolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Chrysanthemum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (HGIC 1161)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/chrysanthemums-how-to-grow-garden-mums-in-south-carolina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full sun"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Flowers, Fruits, and Frass)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/flowers-fruits-and-frass/2025-08-25-mums-and-asters-fall-favorites-colorful-landscape","country":"US","form":null,"value":"To help them thrive, plant them in a spot that receives full sun or light shade, and ensure the soil is well-drained."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Chrysanthemum x morifolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The edible, aromatic flowers come in many colors from brownish shades to pastels and vibrant yellows.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Chrysanthemum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are alternate on the stem, aromatic and deeply serrated or lobed.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are ncsu.edu. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Chrysanthemum x morifolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Autumn mums can be planted along edges, in the front of borders, or in cut flower gardens.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (HGIC 1161)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/chrysanthemums-how-to-grow-garden-mums-in-south-carolina/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Too little water will slow their growth or stop it completely.","claim":false},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/growing-chrysanthemums-iowa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Garden mums like a consistent supply of moisture throughout the growing season.","claim":false}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Chrysanthemum x morifolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract pollinators, making them a welcome late-season nectar source in a pollinator garden.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Chrysanthemum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees","claim":true},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Flowers, Fruits, and Frass)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/flowers-fruits-and-frass/2025-08-25-mums-and-asters-fall-favorites-colorful-landscape","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fall favorites of bees and butterflies, mums and asters, are a reliable source of fall nectar for pollinators that are traveling on their fall migration.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-bronze","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":4,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-bronze","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":4,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-bronze","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":4,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-bronze","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"chrysanthemum morifolium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"genus","taxon":"chrysanthemum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/chrysanthemums-how-to-grow-garden-mums-in-south-carolina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Chrysanthemums prefer fertile, well-drained, highly organic soil in full sun.","level":"species","taxon":"chrysanthemum morifolium"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/chrysanthemums/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Garden mums are cold hardy and prefer full sun, but can also thrive with just morning or afternoon sun.","level":"species","taxon":"chrysanthemum morifolium"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Chrysanthemum-x-morifolium","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Garden mums need fertile soil and can take light shade, although they grow best in full sun.","level":"species","taxon":"chrysanthemum morifolium"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-bronze","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Edible Fragrant Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"chrysanthemum morifolium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"chrysanthemum"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are ncsu.edu. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-bronze","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Autumn mums can be planted along edges, in the front of borders, or in cut flower gardens.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"chrysanthemum morifolium"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/chrysanthemums/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Mums are great for mass plantings and cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"chrysanthemum morifolium"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Chrysanthemum-x-morifolium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long stems are good for cutting and provide lots of colour for the fall garden","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"chrysanthemum morifolium"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (growing guide)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/chrysanthemum/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They make colourful, long-lasting cut flowers too.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"chrysanthemum"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-bronze","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (genus guide)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/chrysanthemum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They don’t perform well in dry conditions, poor soil or shade.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"chrysanthemum"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-bronze","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract pollinators, making them a welcome late-season nectar source in a pollinator garden.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"chrysanthemum morifolium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Some flowers attract bees","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"chrysanthemum"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/chrysanthemums/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"As a bonus, the flowers attract butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"chrysanthemum morifolium"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (growing guide)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/chrysanthemum/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The single, daisy-style flowers provide valuable nectar for late-flying bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"chrysanthemum"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.61],"union":[0.15,0.91],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Chrysanthemum x morifolium, Hardy Garden Mum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Garden Mums, Chrysanthemum x morifolium)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/chrysanthemums-how-to-grow-garden-mums-in-south-carolina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height/Spread: 1½ to 3 feet tall (varies by cultivar and pinching)","metres":[0.46,0.91],"band":[0.46,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension EDIS FP171 (Dendranthema x grandiflora, Garden Mum)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP171","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 to 2 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions (Chrysanthemums)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/chrysanthemums/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Generally these plants grow to be about 6 inches tall although they can reach 2 feet in height when flowering.","metres":[0.15,0.61],"band":[0.15,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Chrysanthemum x morifolium, Hardy Garden Mum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension EDIS FP171 (Dendranthema x grandiflora, Garden Mum)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP171","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1 to 2 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","8-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Chrysanthemum x morifolium, Hardy Garden Mum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Garden Mums, Chrysanthemum x morifolium)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/chrysanthemums-how-to-grow-garden-mums-in-south-carolina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness: Hardy across South Carolina (USDA Hardiness Zones 5a to 9b)","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension EDIS FP171 (Dendranthema x grandiflora, Garden Mum)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP171","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA hardiness zones: 8 through 10A (Figure 3)","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"Penn State Extension Master Gardener (November Birth Flower: Chrysanthemum)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/programs/master-gardener/counties/luzerne/news/november-birth-flower-chrysanthemum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The majority of mum varieties are winter hardy in zones 5 through 9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Chrysanthemum x morifolium, Hardy Garden Mum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Garden Mums, Chrysanthemum x morifolium)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/chrysanthemums-how-to-grow-garden-mums-in-south-carolina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full sun"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension EDIS FP171 (Dendranthema x grandiflora, Garden Mum)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP171","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in part shade/part sun"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions (Chrysanthemums)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/chrysanthemums/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Garden mums are cold hardy and prefer full sun, but can also thrive with just morning or afternoon sun."},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Mums the Word for Fall Flowers)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/mums-the-word-for-fall-flowers/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Choose an area in full sun, or a minimum of six hours of sunlight each day."},{"name":"Utah State University Extension (Growing Chrysanthemums in the Home Garden)","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/growing-chrysanthemums-in-the-home-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants should be in full sunshine all day."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Chrysanthemum x morifolium, Hardy Garden Mum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Autumn mums can be planted along edges, in the front of borders, or in cut flower gardens.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension EDIS FP171 (Dendranthema x grandiflora, Garden Mum)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP171","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers may be cut for flower arrangements, and the plant is commonly massed in the landscape.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions (Chrysanthemums)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/chrysanthemums/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Mums are great for mass plantings and cut flowers.","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Chrysanthemum growing guide)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/chrysanthemum/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They make colourful, long-lasting cut flowers too.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Mums the Word for Fall Flowers)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/mums-the-word-for-fall-flowers/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Make sure they are watered throughout the season to avoid drought stress.","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Chrysanthemum x morifolium, Hardy Garden Mum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-x-morifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension EDIS FP171 (Dendranthema x grandiflora, Garden Mum)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP171","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: mass planting; edging; attracts butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions (Chrysanthemums)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/chrysanthemums/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"As a bonus, the flowers attract butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Chrysanthemum growing guide)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/chrysanthemum/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The single, daisy-style flowers provide valuable nectar for late-flying bees and butterflies.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-morifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/chrysanthemum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones 5a to 9b","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chrysanthemum-morifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/chrysanthemum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-rust","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-rust","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-rust","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/good-growing/2021-09-10-why-do-my-mums-always-die-how-grow-and-care-fall-mums-your-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"mums are hardy from zones 5-9, meaning they can survive outdoors in Illinois (Illinois spans zones 5-7a)","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Penn State Extension (Luzerne County Master Gardener)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/programs/master-gardener/counties/luzerne/news/november-birth-flower-chrysanthemum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The majority of mum varieties are winter hardy in zones 5 through 9; Pennsylvania’s zones generally range from 5a to 7b.","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-rust","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/good-growing/2021-09-10-why-do-my-mums-always-die-how-grow-and-care-fall-mums-your-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mums also need a site that receives full sun (at least 6 hours)."}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-rust","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-rust","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-rust","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"chrysanthemum-rust","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cinnamon-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.61,2.01],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=359554","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/osmundastrum-cinnamomeum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.83],"band":[0.61,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=OSCI","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size Notes: Up to about 6 feet tall.","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Tennessee Extension (Tennessee Smart Yards)","url":"https://tnyards.utk.edu/osmunda-cinnamomea-osmundastrum-cinnamomeum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2-3 feet tall by 2-3 feet spread.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cinnamon-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.61,1.22],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=359554","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/osmundastrum-cinnamomeum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Tennessee Extension (Tennessee Smart Yards)","url":"https://tnyards.utk.edu/osmunda-cinnamomea-osmundastrum-cinnamomeum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2-3 feet tall by 2-3 feet spread.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cinnamon-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","4-9","4-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=359554","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/osmundastrum-cinnamomeum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=OSCI","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Native Distribution: Lab. to MN, s. to FL, TX, Mex, and Central America. Zones 4 to 11.","zones":[4,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cinnamon-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=359554","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/osmundastrum-cinnamomeum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=OSCI","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade , Shade"},{"name":"University of Tennessee Extension (Tennessee Smart Yards)","url":"https://tnyards.utk.edu/osmunda-cinnamomea-osmundastrum-cinnamomeum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part shade to full shade and tolerates heavy shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cinnamon-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cinnamon-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cinnamon-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/osmundastrum-cinnamomeum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It may go dormant with dry soil.","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cinnamon-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"claire-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"DUAL-FORM","agreement":null,"forms":{"shrub":null,"climber":[1.22,4.03]},"catalogForm":"shrub","catalogFormAgreement":"unverified","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=449661&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.00 to 12.00 feet","metres":[1.22,3.66],"band":[1.22,3.66],"role":"unstated-form","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/258240/rosa-claire-austin-ausprior-pbr-cl/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"unstated-form","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/claire-austin-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Height: 12ft","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"other-form","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/claire-austin-climbing-rose","country":"GB","form":"climber","value":"Height: 12ft (3.75m)","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"other-form","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/claire-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Size 11'-12' x 3'-4'","metres":[3.35,3.66],"band":[3.35,3.66],"role":"other-form","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/claire-austin-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Height: 4-12 feet","metres":[1.22,3.66],"band":[1.22,3.66],"role":"other-form","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/ca","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Height : 8-12'","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"other-form","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rosarium Lottum","url":"https://rosariumlottum.com/en/product/claire-austin-ausprior/","country":"NL","form":"climber","value":"100-150 cm ( Busch Rose ) or as a small climbing Rose (200-300 cm )","metres":[2,3],"band":[2,3],"role":"other-form","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"no source in this record describes the shrub form the catalog holds; the pilot's verified dual-form register (PILOT-2026-07-28.md section 3) is what says David Austin sells this rose both ways; so the catalogued value is neither confirmed nor contradicted by anything here; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"claire-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"DUAL-FORM","agreement":null,"forms":{"shrub":null,"climber":[0.91,1.34]},"catalogForm":"shrub","catalogFormAgreement":"unverified","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=449661&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"unstated-form","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/258240/rosa-claire-austin-ausprior-pbr-cl/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"unstated-form","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/claire-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Size 11'-12' x 3'-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"other-form","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/claire-austin-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Spread: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"other-form","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/ca","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Width : 3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"other-form","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"no source in this record describes the shrub form the catalog holds; the pilot's verified dual-form register (PILOT-2026-07-28.md section 3) is what says David Austin sells this rose both ways; so the catalogued value is neither confirmed nor contradicted by anything here; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"claire-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","5-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=449661&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/claire-austin-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/claire-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zone 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/claire-austin-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Suitable Zones: 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/ca","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Hardiness Zones : 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"claire-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=449661&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/258240/rosa-claire-austin-ausprior-pbr-cl/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/claire-austin-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/claire-austin-climbing-rose","country":"GB","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/claire-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Partial Shade or Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/ca","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Light Requirements : Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Rosa genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"claire-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","strengths":["strong","strong","strong","strong","strong","strong"],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=449661&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/258240/rosa-claire-austin-ausprior-pbr-cl/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Large, cupped, creamy-white, highly-fragrant double flowers open from pale lemon buds throughout the summer and autumn","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/claire-austin-climbing-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They have a strong myrrh fragrance with dashes of meadowsweet, vanilla and heliotrope.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/claire-austin-climbing-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They have a strong myrrh fragrance with dashes of meadowsweet, vanilla and heliotrope.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/claire-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Exceptionally Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/claire-austin-rose-david-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong - Myrrh","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/ca","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance : Strong - Myrrh, Vanilla, Heliotrope","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rosarium Lottum","url":"https://rosariumlottum.com/en/product/claire-austin-ausprior/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant strong fragrance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Rosa genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"claire-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/claire-austin-rose-david-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nice long canes make this rose a great climber and perfect for nice long stem cuts.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/ca","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vase Life : 2-3 days","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Rosa genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"claire-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"claire-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"clematis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[2.7,3.3],"union":[0.3,5.49],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Depending upon the species and the support structure, they can grow to 1 to 18 feet long.","metres":[0.3,5.49],"band":[0.3,5.49],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1104 (genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most of the large-flowered hybrids grow to around 8 to 12 feet tall, but the small herbaceous species only grow to 2 to 5 feet tall.","metres":[0.61,3.66],"band":[0.61,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, Clematis growing guide (genus page)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/clematis/growing-guide","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"The vast majority reach around 3m high","metres":3,"band":[2.7,3.3],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":10,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":10},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":10},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":10},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, Clematis growing guide (genus page)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/clematis/growing-guide","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Most clematis will grow well in sun or partial shade, but flowering is normally disappointing in a very shady spot.","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis x hybrida","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-x-hybrida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"clematis hybrida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis x jackmanii","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-x-jackmanii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"clematis jackmanii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis viticella","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-viticella/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"clematis viticella"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis terniflora","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-terniflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis virginiana","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-virginiana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"clematis virginiana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis montana","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-montana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"clematis montana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis texensis","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-texensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"clematis texensis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis integrifolia","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-integrifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"clematis integrifolia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis armandi","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-armandi/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"clematis armandi"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Clematis virginiana","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CLVI5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade , Shade","level":"species","taxon":"clematis virginiana"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Showy","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1104 (genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/clematis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Many of the species have fragrant blooms, with the exception of most hybrids.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis x hybrida","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-x-hybrida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Their flowers are showy, fragrant and long-blooming.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis hybrida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis terniflora","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-terniflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis virginiana","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-virginiana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis virginiana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis montana","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-montana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis montana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis armandi","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-armandi/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis armandi"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Clematis virginiana","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CLVI5","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers: yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis virginiana"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"clematis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1104 (genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/clematis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"As cut flowers, clematis are long-lasting.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["clematis jackmanii"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (clematis jackmanii), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (clematis jackmanii) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Clematis flowers attract bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds; other birds may nest in the vines.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1104 (genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/clematis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies and hummingbirds are attracted to clematis flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis x jackmanii","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-x-jackmanii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis jackmanii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis viticella","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-viticella/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis viticella"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis terniflora","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-terniflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis virginiana","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-virginiana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Hummingbirds Moths Songbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis virginiana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis montana","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-montana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis montana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis integrifolia","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-integrifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Hummingbirds Songbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis integrifolia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Clematis armandi","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-armandi/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis armandi"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Clematis virginiana","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CLVI5","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies , Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis virginiana"}],"note":"10 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"clematis-comtesse-de-bouchaud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[2.44,3.66],"union":[2.44,3.66],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244340","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8.00 to 12.00 feet","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/clematis-comtesse-de-bouchaud","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8-12 Feet","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-comtesse-de-bouchaud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1.83],"union":[0.91,1.83],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244340","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/clematis-comtesse-de-bouchaud","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3-6 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-comtesse-de-bouchaud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244340","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/clematis-comtesse-de-bouchaud","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4-9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-comtesse-de-bouchaud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244340","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/clematis-comtesse-de-bouchaud","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-comtesse-de-bouchaud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-comtesse-de-bouchaud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/clematis-comtesse-de-bouchaud","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-comtesse-de-bouchaud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-comtesse-de-bouchaud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/clematis-comtesse-de-bouchaud","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-doctor-ruppel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[2.75,3],"union":[1.83,4.03],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS) Plant Profile","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/42310/clematis-doctor-ruppel-el/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 2.5-4 metres","metres":[2.5,4],"band":[2.5,4],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clematis Zrodlo Dobrych Pnaczy (Marczynski) clematis encyclopaedia","url":"http://www.old.clematis.com.pl/en/encyklopedia?view=plant&plantid=211","country":"PL","form":null,"value":"Plants height: 2-3 m","metres":[2,3],"band":[2,3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Brushwood Nursery, Clematis Specialists","url":"https://www.brushwoodnursery.com/products/clematis-dr-ruppel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8-10 feet","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clearview Horticultural Products","url":"https://www.clearviewhort.com/product/dr-ruppel/","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 6-9′ (2-3m)","metres":[1.83,2.74],"band":[1.83,2.74],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder, via Minor's Garden Center","url":"https://plants.minorsgardencenter.com/12100004/Plant/4500/Dr_Ruppel_Clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10 feet","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://gardencrossings.com/products/dr-ruppel-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Max Height: 8 - 10 Feet","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Overdevest Nurseries","url":"https://grownbyoverdevest.com/plant/doctor-ruppel-clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 8-10'","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Botanical Interests","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/dr-ruppel-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"With a compact height of 6-12 feet","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/63387b-clematis-doctor-ruppel-early-large-flowered-clematis/p/574346","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growth Height Max 144 in.","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-doctor-ruppel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.3,2.5],"split":[{"range":[0.3,0.67],"sources":["Garden Crossings","NetPS Plant Finder, via Minor's Garden Center"]},{"range":[0.91,1.22],"sources":["Overdevest Nurseries"]},{"range":[1.5,2.5],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society (RHS) Plant Profile","SiteOne Landscape Supply"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS) Plant Profile","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/42310/clematis-doctor-ruppel-el/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder, via Minor's Garden Center","url":"https://plants.minorsgardencenter.com/12100004/Plant/4500/Dr_Ruppel_Clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24 inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://gardencrossings.com/products/dr-ruppel-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Max Spread: 1 - 2 Feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Overdevest Nurseries","url":"https://grownbyoverdevest.com/plant/doctor-ruppel-clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/63387b-clematis-doctor-ruppel-early-large-flowered-clematis/p/574346","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growth Width Max 72 in.","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 3 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-doctor-ruppel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","4-11","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Clematis Zrodlo Dobrych Pnaczy (Marczynski) clematis encyclopaedia","url":"http://www.old.clematis.com.pl/en/encyklopedia?view=plant&plantid=211","country":"PL","form":null,"value":"Frost hardiness: Zones 4 - 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Brushwood Nursery, Clematis Specialists","url":"https://www.brushwoodnursery.com/products/clematis-dr-ruppel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4-11","zones":[4,11]},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://gardencrossings.com/products/dr-ruppel-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Botanical Interests","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/dr-ruppel-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It's a hardy perennial that grows well in USDA zones 4-9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/63387b-clematis-doctor-ruppel-early-large-flowered-clematis/p/574346","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone Maximum Zone 9b Hardiness Zone Minimum Zone 4a","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-doctor-ruppel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS) Plant Profile","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/42310/clematis-doctor-ruppel-el/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"Clearview Horticultural Products","url":"https://www.clearviewhort.com/product/dr-ruppel/","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Planting Aspect: Sun/ Partial Sun / Bright Shade"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder, via Minor's Garden Center","url":"https://plants.minorsgardencenter.com/12100004/Plant/4500/Dr_Ruppel_Clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This woody vine does best in full sun to partial shade."},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://gardencrossings.com/products/dr-ruppel-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (+6 hrs.), Part Shade (4-6 hrs.)"},{"name":"Overdevest Nurseries","url":"https://grownbyoverdevest.com/plant/doctor-ruppel-clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Sun to Partial Shade"},{"name":"Botanical Interests","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/dr-ruppel-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dr. Ruppel Clematis thrives in full to partial sun and appreciates a little afternoon shade in hotter climates."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-doctor-ruppel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-doctor-ruppel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.brushwoodnursery.com/products/clematis-dr-ruppel","https://gardencrossings.com/products/dr-ruppel-clematis"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Brushwood Nursery, Clematis Specialists","url":"https://www.brushwoodnursery.com/products/clematis-dr-ruppel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It makes a good cut flower and the seedheads are beautiful, too!","claim":true},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://gardencrossings.com/products/dr-ruppel-clematis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"'Dr Ruppel' is also a great option for cut flower designs.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-doctor-ruppel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-doctor-ruppel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://plants.minorsgardencenter.com/12100004/Plant/4500/Dr_Ruppel_Clematis/","https://gardencrossings.com/products/dr-ruppel-clematis"]}],"sources":[{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder, via Minor's Garden Center","url":"https://plants.minorsgardencenter.com/12100004/Plant/4500/Dr_Ruppel_Clematis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting hummingbirds to your yard.","claim":true},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://gardencrossings.com/products/dr-ruppel-clematis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Bee Friendly, Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-hagley-hybrid","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1.22,3.36],"split":[{"range":[1.22,2.68],"sources":["Brushwood Nursery (clematis specialist)","Royal Horticultural Society","Missouri Botanical Garden","Jeffries Nurseries","Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center"]},{"range":[2.75,3.36],"sources":["Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244344","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6.00 to 8.00 feet","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/95071/clematis-hagley-hybrid-ll/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"‘Hagley Hybrid’ grows to 8 feet and flowers June to September.","metres":2.44,"band":[2.2,2.68],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Brushwood Nursery (clematis specialist)","url":"https://www.brushwoodnursery.com/products/clematis-hagley-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4-6 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.westonnurseries.com/12130019/Plant/3426/Hagley_Hybrid_Clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10 feet","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Jeffries Nurseries","url":"https://jeffriesnurseries.com/hagley-hybrid-clematis/","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Height: 6-8′","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-hagley-hybrid","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.55,1.83],"split":[{"range":[0.55,0.67],"sources":["Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","Jeffries Nurseries"]},{"range":[0.91,1.83],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden","Royal Horticultural Society"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244344","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/95071/clematis-hagley-hybrid-ll/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.westonnurseries.com/12130019/Plant/3426/Hagley_Hybrid_Clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24 inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Jeffries Nurseries","url":"https://jeffriesnurseries.com/hagley-hybrid-clematis/","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2′ (0.6 m)","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-hagley-hybrid","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-11","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244344","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Brushwood Nursery (clematis specialist)","url":"https://www.brushwoodnursery.com/products/clematis-hagley-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4-11","zones":[4,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Clematis x hybrida, group page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-x-hybrida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-hagley-hybrid","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244344","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/95071/clematis-hagley-hybrid-ll/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Partial shade"},{"name":"Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.westonnurseries.com/12130019/Plant/3426/Hagley_Hybrid_Clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This woody vine should only be grown in full sunlight."},{"name":"Jeffries Nurseries","url":"https://jeffriesnurseries.com/hagley-hybrid-clematis/","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Light Needs: Full Sun to Part Shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Clematis x hybrida, group page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-x-hybrida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Clematis hybrid, group page)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/clematis-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part shade, most Clematis can handle sun if soil cool (not exposed), but semi-shade protects blossoms from fading."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-hagley-hybrid","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-hagley-hybrid","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-hagley-hybrid","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-hagley-hybrid","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://plants.westonnurseries.com/12130019/Plant/3426/Hagley_Hybrid_Clematis/","https://jeffriesnurseries.com/hagley-hybrid-clematis/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.westonnurseries.com/12130019/Plant/3426/Hagley_Hybrid_Clematis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting hummingbirds to your yard.","claim":true},{"name":"Jeffries Nurseries","url":"https://jeffriesnurseries.com/hagley-hybrid-clematis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Key Features: Attracts Hummingbirds, Deer Tolerant","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-jackmanii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[2.13,6.04],"split":[{"range":[2.13,4.57],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","Royal Horticultural Society","Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","Brushwood Nursery (clematis specialists)","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox"]},{"range":[4.94,6.04],"sources":["Purdue Arboretum Explorer"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a280","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 7.00 to 10.00 feet","metres":[2.13,3.05],"band":[2.13,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-x-jackmanii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10 ft. 0 in. - 15 ft. 0 in.","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/96731/clematis-jackmanii-ll/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 2.5-4 metres","metres":[2.5,4],"band":[2.5,4],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/156","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Height: 18 feet","metres":5.49,"band":[4.94,6.04],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"'Jackmanii' grows 8 to 10 feet and blooms from July to August.","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/clematis-x-jackmanii-jackman-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows in full to partial sun 10 to 12 feet tall","metres":[3.05,3.66],"band":[3.05,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Brushwood Nursery (clematis specialists)","url":"https://www.brushwoodnursery.com/products/clematis-jackmanii","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10-12 feet","metres":[3.05,3.66],"band":[3.05,3.66],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-jackmanii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.5,6.04],"split":[{"range":[0.5,1.83],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox"]},{"range":[4.94,6.04],"sources":["Purdue Arboretum Explorer"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a280","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-x-jackmanii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/96731/clematis-jackmanii-ll/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/156","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Spread: 18 feet","metres":5.49,"band":[4.94,6.04],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-jackmanii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-9","3-8","4-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a280","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-x-jackmanii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/clematis-x-jackmanii-jackman-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Brushwood Nursery (clematis specialists)","url":"https://www.brushwoodnursery.com/products/clematis-jackmanii","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4-11","zones":[4,11]},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=535&PlantTypeID=5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 4 - 8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-jackmanii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a280","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-x-jackmanii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/96731/clematis-jackmanii-ll/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/156","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/clematis-x-jackmanii-jackman-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=535&PlantTypeID=5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun Partial Sun/Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-jackmanii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-jackmanii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-x-jackmanii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-jackmanii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-jackmanii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-x-jackmanii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-nelly-moser","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[2.13,2.5],"union":[1.5,3.96],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244347&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6.00 to 10.00 feet","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/57420/clematis-nelly-moser-el/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fine Gardening","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/clematis-nelly-moser","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height : 6 to 10 feet","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Brushwood Nursery (clematis specialist)","url":"https://www.brushwoodnursery.com/products/clematis-nelly-moser","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 7-13 feet","metres":[2.13,3.96],"band":[2.13,3.96],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-clematis-vine-nelly-moser","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 72-120\" tall (6-10 feet)","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://www.gardencrossings.com/product/clematis-nelly-moser-clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Max Height: 6 - 10 Feet","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Clematis-Nelly-Moser","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10 Feet","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-nelly-moser","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.3,3.05],"split":[{"range":[0.3,1],"sources":["Garden Crossings","Fine Gardening","Royal Horticultural Society","American Meadows"]},{"range":[1.83,3.05],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244347&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 6.00 to 10.00 feet","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/57420/clematis-nelly-moser-el/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fine Gardening","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/clematis-nelly-moser","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Width : 1 to 3 feet","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-clematis-vine-nelly-moser","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread Up to 36\" wide","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://www.gardencrossings.com/product/clematis-nelly-moser-clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Max Spread: 1 - 2 Feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-nelly-moser","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-9","4-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244347&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-x-hybrida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Fine Gardening","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/clematis-nelly-moser","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones : 10, 11, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[4,11]},{"name":"Brushwood Nursery (clematis specialist)","url":"https://www.brushwoodnursery.com/products/clematis-nelly-moser","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4-11","zones":[4,11]},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-clematis-vine-nelly-moser","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ZONES 4-9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://www.gardencrossings.com/product/clematis-nelly-moser-clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-nelly-moser","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244347&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-x-hybrida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/57420/clematis-nelly-moser-el/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"Fine Gardening","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/clematis-nelly-moser","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full Sun to Partial Shade"},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://www.gardencrossings.com/product/clematis-nelly-moser-clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Shade (0-4 hrs.), Full Sun (+6 hrs.), Part Shade (4-6 hrs.)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-nelly-moser","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-nelly-moser","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://www.gardencrossings.com/product/clematis-nelly-moser-clematis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attributes: Cut Flower or Foliage, Deciduous","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-nelly-moser","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-nelly-moser","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://www.gardencrossings.com/product/clematis-nelly-moser-clematis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Bee Friendly, Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-niobe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[2.44,2.5],"union":[1.5,3.66],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244348&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8.00 to 12.00 feet","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/96069/clematis-niobe-(el)/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-niobe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.5,3.05],"split":[{"range":[0.5,1],"sources":["RHS"]},{"range":[1.83,3.05],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244348&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6.00 to 10.00 feet","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/96069/clematis-niobe-(el)/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-niobe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244348&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-niobe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244348&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/96069/clematis-niobe-(el)/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-niobe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-niobe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244348&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers may be cut and floated in bowls.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-niobe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-niobe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-sweet-autumn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[4.57,6],"union":[2.44,10.05],"voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-terniflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 15 ft. 0 in. - 30 ft. 0 in.","metres":[4.57,9.14],"band":[4.57,9.14],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a300","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 15.00 to 30.00 feet","metres":[4.57,9.14],"band":[4.57,9.14],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/sweet-autumn-clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sweet autumn clematis can grow 10 to 20 feet long and is a twining vine on which both the stems and the leafstalks twine.","metres":[3.05,6.1],"band":[3.05,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Go Botany","url":"https://gobotany.nativeplanttrust.org/species/clematis/terniflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant height 300-600 cm","metres":[3,6],"band":[3,6],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/clematis-terniflora","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Semi-evergreen or deciduous semi-woody, rampant vine, may grow to 15 or even 30 ft (5-9 m) high.","metres":[4.57,9.14],"band":[4.57,9.14],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=509&PlantTypeID=5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 10 Feet","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Virginia Tech Dendrology","url":"https://dendro.cnre.vt.edu/dendrology/syllabus/factsheet.cfm?ID=494","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Form: A climbing vine that can completely overtake its supporting stucture in a dense tangle, to 30 feet and a main stem diameter of 4 inches.","metres":9.14,"band":[8.23,10.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/sweet-autumn-clematis-clematis-terniflora","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height : 10 to 15 feet","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sweet-autumn-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 10 - 20 Feet","metres":[3.05,6.1],"band":[3.05,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/sweet-autumn-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height : 30 ft.","metres":9.14,"band":[8.23,10.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clematis paniculata"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/sweet-autumn-clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 96\" to 144\"","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clematis paniculata"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":12,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":6.86},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"clematis-sweet-autumn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.61,9.14],"split":[{"range":[0.61,0.91],"sources":["Plant Addicts"]},{"range":[1.83,3.05],"sources":["Fine Gardening plant guide"]},{"range":[4.57,9.14],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-terniflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 15 ft. 0 in. - 30 ft. 0 in.","metres":[4.57,9.14],"band":[4.57,9.14],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a300","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 15.00 to 30.00 feet","metres":[4.57,9.14],"band":[4.57,9.14],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/sweet-autumn-clematis-clematis-terniflora","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Width : 6 to 10 feet","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sweet-autumn-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 2 - 3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 3 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"clematis-sweet-autumn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","5-8","4-8","5-11","4-9","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-terniflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a300","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/sweet-autumn-clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=509&PlantTypeID=5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 4 - 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/sweet-autumn-clematis-clematis-terniflora","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones : 10, 11, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[5,11],"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sweet-autumn-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/sweet-autumn-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In Zones : 5-9 outdoors","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"clematis paniculata"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/sweet-autumn-clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Suitable Zones 3 to 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"clematis paniculata"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"clematis-sweet-autumn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-terniflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a300","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/sweet-autumn-clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sweet autumn clematis grows in full sun or part shade and is actually quite tolerant of more dense shade.","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Colorado State University Extension","url":"https://extension.colostate.edu/resource/sweet-autumn-clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Although some sources suggest it will bloom well in part shade, Sweet Autumn blooms most prolifically for me when planted in full sun.","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/sweet-autumn-clematis-clematis-terniflora","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers full sun and average, well-drained but moist soil.","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sweet-autumn-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Exposure: Partial Shade to Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/sweet-autumn-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight : Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"clematis paniculata"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"clematis-sweet-autumn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-terniflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a300","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/sweet-autumn-clematis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sweet autumn clematis is a vine that produces an abundance of small, fragrant white flowers in late summer and early autumn.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/clematis-terniflora","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers fragrant, white, about 3 cm wide, with 4 narrow, wide spreading, sepals, borne many (3-12) per axillary or terminal cluster (cyme or panicle), summer flowering.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=509&PlantTypeID=5","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Small, fragrant whit flowers, produced in large quantities; small, fluffy fruit in autumn.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Virginia Tech Dendrology","url":"https://dendro.cnre.vt.edu/dendrology/syllabus/factsheet.cfm?ID=494","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Species is monoecious; fragrant and showy, described as refreshing, white with 4 sepals, 1 inch across, borne on branching panicles, present late summer and early fall.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Colorado State University Extension","url":"https://extension.colostate.edu/resource/sweet-autumn-clematis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Reasons to love this vine include the attractive green leaves in summer, the stunning amount of beautiful blooms, the wonderful fragrance, and the fact that it is a fast growing vine.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/sweet-autumn-clematis-clematis-terniflora","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Characteristics : Fragrant Flowers, Self Seeds, Showy Seed Heads","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sweet-autumn-clematis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features: Attracts Pollinators, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/sweet-autumn-clematis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Just like its name, the Sweet Autumn Clematis offers a lovely, light scent in late summer to fall as it blooms.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis paniculata"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/sweet-autumn-clematis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Benefits Deer Resistant, Perennializing, Pleasantly Scented","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis paniculata"}],"note":"11 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"clematis-sweet-autumn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/clematis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"As cut flowers, clematis are long-lasting.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"clematis"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"clematis-sweet-autumn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/sweet-autumn-clematis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other tolerances Alkaline soil, clay soil, Dry sites, Wet sites","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"clematis-sweet-autumn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clematis-terniflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/clematis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies and hummingbirds are attracted to clematis flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"clematis"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sweet-autumn-clematis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees, Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis terniflora"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/sweet-autumn-clematis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Prune it back to contain its height or growth, or let it expand to create your own pollinator garden, attracting bees and butterflies!","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clematis paniculata"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"clematis-ville-de-lyon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[3.05,3.36],"union":[2.44,4],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244353","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10.00 to 12.00 feet","metres":[3.05,3.66],"band":[3.05,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/94458/clematis-ville-de-lyon-ll/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 2.5-4 metres","metres":[2.5,4],"band":[2.5,4],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Brushwood Nursery (clematis specialist)","url":"https://www.brushwoodnursery.com/products/clematis-ville-de-lyon","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10-12 feet","metres":[3.05,3.66],"band":[3.05,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=CLEVL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8.0-12.0 Feet","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://www.gardencrossings.com/product/clematis-ville-de-lyon-clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Max Height: 10 - 12 Feet","metres":[3.05,3.66],"band":[3.05,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center","url":"https://www.gertens.com/ville-de-lyon-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10 feet","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-ville-de-lyon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1],"union":[0.5,1.83],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244353","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/94458/clematis-ville-de-lyon-ll/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://www.gardencrossings.com/product/clematis-ville-de-lyon-clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Max Spread: 3 - 4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center","url":"https://www.gertens.com/ville-de-lyon-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24 inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-ville-de-lyon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","4-11","4-8","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244353","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Brushwood Nursery (clematis specialist)","url":"https://www.brushwoodnursery.com/products/clematis-ville-de-lyon","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4-11","zones":[4,11]},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=CLEVL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4,5,6,7,8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://www.gardencrossings.com/product/clematis-ville-de-lyon-clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center","url":"https://www.gertens.com/ville-de-lyon-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-ville-de-lyon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244353","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/94458/clematis-ville-de-lyon-ll/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=CLEVL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)"},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://www.gardencrossings.com/product/clematis-ville-de-lyon-clematis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (+6 hrs.), Part Shade (4-6 hrs.)"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center","url":"https://www.gertens.com/ville-de-lyon-clematis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Preference Full-Sun, Part-Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-ville-de-lyon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-ville-de-lyon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=CLEVL","https://www.gardencrossings.com/product/clematis-ville-de-lyon-clematis/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=CLEVL","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Climbing Container Cut Flower Cut Foliage Specimen Focal Point","claim":true},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://www.gardencrossings.com/product/clematis-ville-de-lyon-clematis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attributes: Cut Flower or Foliage, Deciduous","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-ville-de-lyon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"clematis-ville-de-lyon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://www.gardencrossings.com/product/clematis-ville-de-lyon-clematis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Bee Friendly, Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cleome","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"This tender annual grows quickly from seed to form tall, strong stems up to 6 feet tall from a stout taproot.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Depending on the cultivar or series, cleome will range in height 1½- to 5-feet tall with a 1- to 2-feet spread.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 18 Inches - 5 Feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 1-1.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spiderflower will grow to be about 3 feet tall at maturity extending to 4 feet tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Queen series cleome plants grow 4-6 ft. tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cleome","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":2},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Depending on the cultivar or series, cleome will range in height 1½- to 5-feet tall with a 1- to 2-feet spread.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spiderflower will grow to be about 3 feet tall at maturity extending to 4 feet tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cleome","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cleome-houtteana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[10,11],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cleome","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cleome-houtteana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/spider-flower-cleome-hassleriana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spider flower grows best in full sun in moist, well-drained soil","level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension, Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/cleome-or-spider-flower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows best in average, well-drained soils and in full sun to light shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=774&PlantTypeID=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun, in moist well-drained soil.","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/73965/cleome-hassleriana/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Cleome hassleriana 'Violet Queen')","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/cleome-hassleriana-violet-queen-violet-queen-spider-flower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"cleome hassleriana"},{"name":"Platt Hill Nursery plant database","url":"https://plants.platthillnursery.com/12120026/Plant/17494/Spiderflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"species"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (cleome species page)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/cleome.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun to part shade","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cleome","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"source-disagreement","strengths":["light","strong"],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cleome-houtteana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The musky odor, especially if planted in groups, is offensive to some.","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/spider-flower-cleome-hassleriana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers of many cultivars have no noticeable fragrance, while other varieties have fragrant flowers, often described as a musky, sweet and pungent, or spicy scent.","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension, Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/cleome-or-spider-flower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The sticky, palmate green leaves have 5 to 7 leaflets that have a strong, sometimes unpleasant fragrance and sharp spines at the base of each leaf.","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/73965/cleome-hassleriana/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Strongly scented, white, pink or purple flowers are produced in broad, terminal spikes in summer","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Platt Hill Nursery plant database","url":"https://plants.platthillnursery.com/12120026/Plant/17494/Spiderflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"dense terminal racemes of fragrant, pink, purple, or white, spider-like flowers from early summer until frost","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"2 source(s) state this trait and 3 deny it","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cleome","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cleome-houtteana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/spider-flower-cleome-hassleriana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cleome can be an excellent, striking cut flower if the scent is not considered disagreeable.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension, Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/cleome-or-spider-flower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cleome works well in borders, background plantings, masses, cutting gardens, and containers.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/73965/cleome-hassleriana/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bedding Cut flowers Flower borders and beds","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"cleome","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cleome-houtteana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are heat, humidity, drought and deer tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/spider-flower-cleome-hassleriana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Although it tolerates dry conditions, watering will promote better growth and flowering but overwatering and overfertilizing causes leggy growth.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension, Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/cleome-or-spider-flower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Somewhat drought tolerant, cleome will benefit from supplemental irrigation during dry periods.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=774&PlantTypeID=1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates dry soils but looks better with some moisture.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Platt Hill Nursery plant database","url":"https://plants.platthillnursery.com/12120026/Plant/17494/Spiderflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is considered to be drought-tolerant, and thus makes an ideal choice for a low-water garden or xeriscape application.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (cleome species page)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/cleome.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants are deer resistant, and will tolerate heat and drought.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["cleome hassleriana"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (cleome hassleriana), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (cleome hassleriana) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cleome","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cleome-houtteana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts many varieties of pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/spider-flower-cleome-hassleriana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are commonly visited by hummingbirds, hummingbird moths, many types of bees, and butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension, Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/cleome-or-spider-flower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flower nectar attracts hummingbirds, butterflies, bees, and other pollinating insects.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=774&PlantTypeID=1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Platt Hill Nursery plant database","url":"https://plants.platthillnursery.com/12120026/Plant/17494/Spiderflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies to your yard, but is not particularly attractive to deer who tend to leave it alone in favor of tastier treats.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (cleome species page)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/cleome.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds love cleome blossoms.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["cleome hassleriana"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (cleome hassleriana), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (cleome hassleriana) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"cleome-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"It is the tallest at 3- to 5-feet tall by 1- to 2-feet wide and will self-seed aggressively.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"‘Queen’ series grows 3 to 5 feet tall. It is available in ‘Cherry’, (rosy red) ‘Lilac’, ‘Rose’, ‘Violet’, ‘White’, and a mix of these colors.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Cherry Queen Spiderflower will grow to be about 3 feet tall at maturity extending to 4 feet tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"3-5' h x 1.5' w\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height and Width: 48-60” x 18-24”\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"36 to 60 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"80 cm - 1.2 m\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cleome-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"It is the tallest at 3- to 5-feet tall by 1- to 2-feet wide and will self-seed aggressively.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Cherry Queen Spiderflower will grow to be about 3 feet tall at maturity extending to 4 feet tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"3-5' h x 1.5' w\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height and Width: 48-60” x 18-24”\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cleome-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-11","3-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Cleome houtteana, syn. C. hassleriana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cleome-houtteana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/cleome-cherry-queen","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10","zones":[3,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cleome-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Cleome houtteana, syn. C. hassleriana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cleome-houtteana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Cleome or Spider Flower)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/cleome-or-spider-flower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows best in average, well-drained soils and in full sun to light shade."},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/spider-flower-cleome-hassleriana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spider flower grows best in full sun in moist, well-drained soil"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/cleome/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Cleome performs best when planted in a spot that has well-drained soil and receives full sun, but it can also take some shade."},{"name":"Roger's Gardens Plant Finder (NetPS)","url":"https://plants.rogersgardens.com/12290002/Plant/25403/Cherry_Queen_Spiderflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight."},{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/cleome-cherry-queen-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Pinetree Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.superseeds.com/products/cherry-queen-cleome","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs: Full sun"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/cleome-cherry-queen","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"Plant World Seeds","url":"https://www.plant-world-seeds.com/store/view_seed_item/6517/cleome-spinosa-cherry-queen-seeds","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cleome-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://plants.rogersgardens.com/12290002/Plant/25403/Cherry_Queen_Spiderflower/","https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/cleome-cherry-queen"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://plants.rogersgardens.com/12290002/Plant/25403/Cherry_Queen_Spiderflower/","https://www.plant-world-seeds.com/store/view_seed_item/6517/cleome-spinosa-cherry-queen-seeds"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Roger's Gardens Plant Finder (NetPS)","url":"https://plants.rogersgardens.com/12290002/Plant/25403/Cherry_Queen_Spiderflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"dense terminal racemes of fragrant, cherry red spider-like flowers from early summer until frost","claim":true},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/cleome-cherry-queen","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees, Attracts Butterflies, Attracts Hummingbirds, Attracts Pollinators, Extended Bloom Time, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Plant World Seeds","url":"https://www.plant-world-seeds.com/store/view_seed_item/6517/cleome-spinosa-cherry-queen-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Elegant cherry to pink spiral blooms carry a delicious scent adored by bees and butterflies, and indeed all pollinators will love it.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cleome-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Cleome or Spider Flower)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/cleome-or-spider-flower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cleome works well in borders, background plantings, masses, cutting gardens, and containers.","claim":true},{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/cleome-cherry-queen-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is an excellent cut flower; however, you should beware of the small thorns on the stems.","claim":true},{"name":"Pinetree Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.superseeds.com/products/cherry-queen-cleome","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A very stately centerpiece in the garden or as a cut flower for large arrangements.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cleome-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Cleome or Spider Flower)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/cleome-or-spider-flower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Somewhat drought tolerant, cleome will benefit from supplemental irrigation during dry periods.","claim":true},{"name":"Roger's Gardens Plant Finder (NetPS)","url":"https://plants.rogersgardens.com/12290002/Plant/25403/Cherry_Queen_Spiderflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is considered to be drought-tolerant, and thus makes an ideal choice for a low-water garden or xeriscape application.","claim":true},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/cleome-cherry-queen","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant, Heat Tolerant, Outdoor","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cleome-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Cleome houtteana, syn. C. hassleriana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cleome-houtteana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts many varieties of pollinators","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Cleome or Spider Flower)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/cleome-or-spider-flower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flower nectar attracts hummingbirds, butterflies, bees, and other pollinating insects.","claim":true},{"name":"Roger's Gardens Plant Finder (NetPS)","url":"https://plants.rogersgardens.com/12290002/Plant/25403/Cherry_Queen_Spiderflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies to your yard","claim":true},{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/cleome-cherry-queen-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is not only deer-resistant but also attracts a variety of pollinators, such as butterflies, hummingbirds, and hawk moths.","claim":true},{"name":"Pinetree Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.superseeds.com/products/cherry-queen-cleome","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A good bee plant.","claim":true},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/cleome-cherry-queen","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees, Attracts Butterflies, Attracts Hummingbirds, Attracts Pollinators, Extended Bloom Time, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Plant World Seeds","url":"https://www.plant-world-seeds.com/store/view_seed_item/6517/cleome-spinosa-cherry-queen-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Elegant cherry to pink spiral blooms carry a delicious scent adored by bees and butterflies, and indeed all pollinators will love it.","claim":true}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"climbing-hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":8,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[10.8,12.19],"union":[9.14,24.38],"proposed":11.5,"margin":12.5,"voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-petiolaris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 30 ft. 0 in. - 60 ft. 0 in.","metres":[9.14,18.29],"band":[9.14,18.29],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d370","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 30.00 to 50.00 feet","metres":[9.14,15.24],"band":[9.14,15.24],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea anomala"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture Cooperative Extension Service","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/hydrangeas/climbing-hydrangea.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This is a deciduous climbing vine that will reach 30 to 40' if situated properly.","metres":[9.14,12.19],"band":[9.14,12.19],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea anomala"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hydrangea-anomala-ssp-petiolaris-climbing-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Climbing hydrangea is a clinging ornamental perennial vine that can reach 60 to 80 feet tall.","metres":[18.29,24.38],"band":[18.29,24.38],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea anomala"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/8948/hydrangea-petiolaris/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height Higher than 12 metres","metres":12,"band":[10.8,13.2],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/hydrangea-anomala-var-petiolaris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Deciduous vine, 60-80 ft (18-24 m), climbing, clinging by root-like holdfasts.","metres":[18.29,24.38],"band":[18.29,24.38],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea anomala"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/climbing-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Over the course of years, it may reach 30 to 80 feet in length.","metres":[9.14,24.38],"band":[9.14,24.38],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/climbing-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height : 50 ft.","metres":15.24,"band":[13.72,16.76],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/climbing-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 30-50 ft","metres":[9.14,15.24],"band":[9.14,15.24],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (9.14 to 24.38 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"climbing-hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.61,8],"split":[{"range":[0.61,1.22],"sources":["Fast Growing Trees"]},{"range":[1.52,1.83],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","The Tree Center"]},{"range":[4,8],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-petiolaris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 5 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d370","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 5.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea anomala"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/8948/hydrangea-petiolaris/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 4-8 metres","metres":[4,8],"band":[4,8],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/climbing-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width : 2-4 ft.","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/climbing-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 5-6 ft","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 3 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"climbing-hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-7","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-petiolaris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d370","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea anomala"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hydrangea-anomala-ssp-petiolaris-climbing-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4 - 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea anomala"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/climbing-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7","zones":[4,7],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/climbing-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In Zones : 5-9 outdoors","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/climbing-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In: Zones 4-8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"climbing-hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d370","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea anomala"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture Cooperative Extension Service","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/hydrangeas/climbing-hydrangea.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In Arkansas, this plant must be located in at least partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea anomala"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hydrangea-anomala-ssp-petiolaris-climbing-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow in moist, well-drained soil in part to full shade.","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea anomala"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/8948/hydrangea-petiolaris/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/hydrangea-anomala-var-petiolaris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to part shade, requires rich, well-drained, moist soil","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea anomala"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/climbing-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Best flowering occurs in full sun but will grow in full shade.","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/climbing-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight : Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/climbing-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs : Partial Sun, Shade","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"climbing-hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-petiolaris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"numerous small, creamy white, sweetly fragrant, fertile flowers in the center.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d370","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea anomala"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/climbing-hydrangea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In early July, it has flat, lacy clusters of fragrant small white flowers that show up well against the glossy green leaves.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/climbing-hydrangea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Produces fragrant white blooms in late spring","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"climbing-hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-petiolaris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Good Dried Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d370","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea anomala"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"climbing-hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-petiolaris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea petiolaris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d370","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Drought, Heavy Shade","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea anomala"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"climbing-hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"climbing-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[3.05,4.57],"union":[2.44,7.62],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC, Growing Roses","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/growing-roses/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most popular pillar and climbing roses reach 8 to 15 feet tall.","metres":[2.44,4.57],"band":[2.44,4.57],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Rose Types","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/roses/roses-types","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Climbers range in height from 8-25 feet.","metres":[2.44,7.62],"band":[2.44,7.62],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Vermont Extension, A Rose Isn't Just a Rose","url":"https://www.uvm.edu/extension/news/rose-isnt-just-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They offer plenty of flowers along their 10- to 20-foot long canes.","metres":[3.05,6.1],"band":[3.05,6.1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"climbing-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"climbing-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","3-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[5,11]},{"name":"University of Vermont Extension, A Rose Isn't Just a Rose","url":"https://www.uvm.edu/extension/news/rose-isnt-just-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In general, roses are hardy in Zones 3 to 11, depending on the specific variety.","zones":[3,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"climbing-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"climbing-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"climbing-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"climbing-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"climbing-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Single-flowered species and cultivars are attractive to bees.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"colchicum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.15,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.18,0.2],"union":[0.15,0.23],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=265441&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.50 to 0.75 feet","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/colchicum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 0 ft. 9 in.","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Piedmont Master Gardeners (Virginia Cooperative Extension volunteers)","url":"https://www.piedmontmastergardeners.org/article/colchicum-and-other-late-season-oddities/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"One downside to some Colclicum species is that their blossoms, which generally grow about 6 to 8 inches tall, tend to flop over after a few days.","metres":[0.15,0.2],"band":[0.15,0.2],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society plant guide","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/colchicum","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Taller types, reaching around 20cm tall, are ideal for naturalising in grass or under trees, while smaller ones are perfect for rock gardens.","metres":0.2,"band":[0.18,0.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":8,"species":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"colchicum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.1,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.15,0.23],"union":[0.15,0.23],"proposed":0.19,"margin":33.3,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=265441&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.50 to 0.75 feet","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/colchicum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 0 ft. 9 in.","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":8,"species":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.15 to 0.23 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"colchicum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-7","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=265441&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 7","zones":[4,7],"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/colchicum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8],"level":"genus"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/category/fall-planted-bulbs/colchicum-fall-planted-bulbs/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"whz 4–8; 13/+ cm unless otherwise noted.","zones":[4,8],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":8,"species":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"colchicum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=265441&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282050&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"colchicum autumnale"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/colchicum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/colchicum-autumnale/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"colchicum autumnale"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Good Growing","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/good-growing/2024-09-20-theyre-not-just-spring-fall-blooming-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Colchicums are hardy to zone 5 and grow best in well-drained soils in full sun or partial shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/the-unexpected-delight-of-fall-blooming-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant the corm 2 to 3 inches deep in full sun and well-drained soil.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/fall-blooming-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant corms in well-drained soils in full sun to partial shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/colchicum-waterlily-waterlily-autumn-crocus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant these bulbs in full sun to partial shade and avoid disturbance.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/4190/colchicum-autumnale/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"colchicum autumnale"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/category/fall-planted-bulbs/colchicum-fall-planted-bulbs/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"prefers rich, well drained soil and partial shade to full sun","level":"genus"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/bornmuelleri/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part Shade, Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"colchicum bornmuelleri"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"colchicum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["colchicum bornmuelleri"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (colchicum bornmuelleri), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (colchicum bornmuelleri) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"colchicum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"colchicum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/colchicum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["colchicum autumnale"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (colchicum autumnale), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (colchicum autumnale) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"colchicum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/colchicum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/colchicum-waterlily-waterlily-autumn-crocus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["colchicum autumnale"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (colchicum autumnale), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (colchicum autumnale) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"colchicum-speciosum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.2,0.25],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/speciosum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8″-10″","metres":[0.2,0.25],"band":[0.2,0.25],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/4232/colchicum-speciosum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"colchicum-speciosum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.12,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/4232/colchicum-speciosum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"colchicum-speciosum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/speciosum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"colchicum-speciosum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/speciosum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun, Part Shade"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/4232/colchicum-speciosum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"colchicum-speciosum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"colchicum-speciosum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"colchicum-speciosum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"colchicum-speciosum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coleus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12,"cultivar":1},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":8,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.50 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Coleus vary from smaller types that will reach only 1 foot tall to tall bushy types of 3 feet.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.5 to 3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plants grow between 6 and 36 inches tall and often nearly as wide as they are tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 8 Inches - 2 Feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Some of the more dwarf types may only grow about 8 to 12 inches tall and wide, while many of the newest releases can reach 24 to 30 inches in height and 12 to 18 inches wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coleus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12,"cultivar":1},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.50 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.5 to 3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Some of the more dwarf types may only grow about 8 to 12 inches tall and wide, while many of the newest releases can reach 24 to 30 inches in height and 12 to 18 inches wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coleus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a547","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/coleus-scutellarioides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[10,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"Proven Winners coleus growing guide","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/how-plant/coleus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy in USDA zones 10-11","zones":[10,11],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12,"cultivar":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coleus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a547","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/coleus-scutellarioides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant grows best in moist, rich, loose soil in part shade, even tolerating full shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/coleus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most coleus grow best in part shade or dappled light.","level":"species"},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening Flower Growing Guides","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scened7dc.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/flowers/coleus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"There are cultivars available for shade, partial shade and full sun.","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=11&PlantTypeID=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants available favor both full sun and shade conditions.","level":"species"},{"name":"South Dakota State University Extension","url":"https://extension.sdstate.edu/coleus-color-every-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Coleus come in a wide variety of foliage colors and grow well in part shade to sun.","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/coleus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Traditionally, most coleus plants have grown best in partial shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/132520/coleus-scutellarioides/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Outdoors grow in humus-rich, moist but well-drained soil in sun or partial shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Proven Winners coleus growing guide","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/how-plant/coleus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Coleus does best in partial to full shade, though many newer varieties can tolerate full sun.","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coleus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/coleus-scutellarioides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coleus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/coleus-scutellarioides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#cutting garden","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coleus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a547","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soils must not be allowed to dry out.","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/coleus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Coleus grown in containers are more susceptible to drought and need to be watered frequently.","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"South Dakota State University Extension","url":"https://extension.sdstate.edu/coleus-color-every-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Since these plants can grow quite large, keeping them well watered during the heat of the summer is very important.","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/coleus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soil for these plants should be kept lightly moist at all times","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension Southern Gardening","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/news/southern-gardening/2021/sun-coleus-offers-colorful-foliage-all-summer-long","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Coleuses are easy-to-grow, low-maintenance plants that are almost foolproof when grown in well-drained landscape beds or containers and consistently watered through droughty periods.","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"5 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coleus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/coleus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The insignificant blooms do attract a wide variety of pollinating insects.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"columbine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.54,0.66],"union":[0.3,0.91],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Aquilegia, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"},{"name":"RHS (Aquilegia, the genus page)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/aquilegia","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"flower stalks up to 60cm (2ft) tall","metres":0.6,"band":[0.54,0.66],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"columbine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Aquilegia, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.15,0.61],"band":[0.15,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"columbine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Aquilegia, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"columbine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Aquilegia, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant prefers well-drained moist average soil in part shade but will tolerate full sun if kept moist.","level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers (Columbine, the genus entry)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/columbine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to partial shade in moist well-drained soils","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia hybrida"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden (All About Columbine, the genus)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-columbine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Columbine prefers part-shade and cool growing conditions.","level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"columbine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden (All About Columbine, the genus)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-columbine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants are favorites for hummingbirds and bees and some species are fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"columbine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden (All About Columbine, the genus)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-columbine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers make excellent cut flowers for spring arrangements, and the interesting seed capsules are great in dried floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"},{"name":"PlantTalk Colorado, Colorado State University Extension (Columbine, the genus)","url":"https://planttalk.colostate.edu/topics/annuals-perennials/1031-columbine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Enjoy this popular flower in your garden, and be sure to use it as a cut flower too.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"},{"name":"RHS (Aquilegia, the genus page)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/aquilegia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Aquilegia can also be picked as cut flowers when they appear in the garden.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"},{"name":"Portland Nursery plant library (Aquilegia: Columbine, the genus entry)","url":"https://portlandnursery.com/plant-library/perennials/aquilegia-columbine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts hummingbirds and butterflies. Deer resistant. Cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"columbine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden (All About Columbine, the genus)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-columbine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants tend to suffer in heavy, compacted soils, but they are also not drought tolerant.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"columbine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Aquilegia, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers generally appear in spring in various colors that attract hummingbirds and pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden (All About Columbine, the genus)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-columbine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants are favorites for hummingbirds and bees and some species are fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"},{"name":"RHS (Aquilegia, the genus page)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/aquilegia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The nectar-rich flowers are attractive to bumblebees.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"},{"name":"Portland Nursery plant library (Aquilegia: Columbine, the genus entry)","url":"https://portlandnursery.com/plant-library/perennials/aquilegia-columbine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["aquilegia hybrida"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (aquilegia hybrida), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (aquilegia hybrida) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"columbine-black-barlow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.76,0.8],"union":[0.46,1],"voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/131116/aquilegia-vulgaris-var-stellata-black-barlow-barlow-series-d/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Homestead Gardens (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.homesteadgardens.com/12170008/Plant/4305/Black_Barlow_Columbine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Black Barlow Columbine will grow to be about 18 inches tall at maturity extending to 24 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Aquilegia-Black-Barlow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24-32 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.81],"band":[0.61,0.81],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/columbine/black-barlow-columbine-seeds.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants grow to 32 in. tall.","metres":0.81,"band":[0.73,0.89],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/perennials/columbine/black-barlow-columbine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 30\" to 36\"","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/aquilegia-vulgaris-black-barlow.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 60-80 cm","metres":[0.6,0.8],"band":[0.6,0.8],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"MyGardenLife Plant Library","url":"https://mygardenlife.com/plant-library/columbine-black-barlow-aquilegia-vulgaris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24-28\"","metres":[0.61,0.71],"band":[0.61,0.71],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Little Prince Plants","url":"https://littleprinceplants.com/our-plants/perennials/aquilegia-vulgaris-barlow-black-columbine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Approximate Mature Height 30\"","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Shire Plants","url":"https://www.shireplants.co.uk/aquilegia-vulgaris-var-stellata-black-barlow","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Height and spread: 90cm x 45cm","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":2,"cultivar":9},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"columbine-black-barlow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.45],"union":[0.1,0.67],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/131116/aquilegia-vulgaris-var-stellata-black-barlow-barlow-series-d/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Homestead Gardens (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.homesteadgardens.com/12170008/Plant/4305/Black_Barlow_Columbine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24 inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Aquilegia-Black-Barlow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18-24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/aquilegia-vulgaris-black-barlow.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 30-40 cm","metres":[0.3,0.4],"band":[0.3,0.4],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Little Prince Plants","url":"https://littleprinceplants.com/our-plants/perennials/aquilegia-vulgaris-barlow-black-columbine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Approximate Mature Width 16\"","metres":0.41,"band":[0.37,0.45],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Shire Plants","url":"https://www.shireplants.co.uk/aquilegia-vulgaris-var-stellata-black-barlow","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Height and spread: 90cm x 45cm","metres":0.45,"band":[0.41,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":2,"cultivar":9},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"columbine-black-barlow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-9","2-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Aquilegia-Black-Barlow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/perennials/columbine/black-barlow-columbine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 3 to 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/aquilegia-vulgaris-black-barlow.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 2-9","zones":[2,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"MyGardenLife Plant Library","url":"https://mygardenlife.com/plant-library/columbine-black-barlow-aquilegia-vulgaris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Little Prince Plants","url":"https://littleprinceplants.com/our-plants/perennials/aquilegia-vulgaris-barlow-black-columbine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 3 , Zone 4 , Zone 5 , Zone 6 , Zone 7 , Zone 8 , Zone 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":2,"cultivar":9},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"columbine-black-barlow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Aquilegia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Aquilegia x hybrida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia-x-hybrida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia hybrida"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Columbine)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/columbine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun, Partial Sun/Shade","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia hybrida"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/131116/aquilegia-vulgaris-var-stellata-black-barlow-barlow-series-d/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Homestead Gardens (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.homesteadgardens.com/12170008/Plant/4305/Black_Barlow_Columbine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant performs well in both full sun and full shade.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Aquilegia-Black-Barlow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers moist, well-drained soil and light to partial shade, but will tolerate sun with sufficient moisture.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/perennials/columbine/black-barlow-columbine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/aquilegia-vulgaris-black-barlow.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun or Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"MyGardenLife Plant Library","url":"https://mygardenlife.com/plant-library/columbine-black-barlow-aquilegia-vulgaris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Sun to Part Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Little Prince Plants","url":"https://littleprinceplants.com/our-plants/perennials/aquilegia-vulgaris-barlow-black-columbine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Filtered/Partial Sun , Full Sun , Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Shire Plants","url":"https://www.shireplants.co.uk/aquilegia-vulgaris-var-stellata-black-barlow","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Aspect: Full Sun; Light/Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"columbine-black-barlow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia-x-hybrida/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Aquilegia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Aquilegia x hybrida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia-x-hybrida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia hybrida"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are ncsu.edu. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"columbine-black-barlow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Aquilegia x hybrida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia-x-hybrida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#cutting garden","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia hybrida"},{"name":"Homestead Gardens (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.homesteadgardens.com/12170008/Plant/4305/Black_Barlow_Columbine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Aquilegia-Black-Barlow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/columbine/black-barlow-columbine-seeds.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/perennials/columbine/black-barlow-columbine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good as Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/aquilegia-vulgaris-black-barlow.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Little Prince Plants","url":"https://littleprinceplants.com/our-plants/perennials/aquilegia-vulgaris-barlow-black-columbine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Shire Plants","url":"https://www.shireplants.co.uk/aquilegia-vulgaris-var-stellata-black-barlow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The long, strong stems last for ages in the vase, making it an excellent cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"columbine-black-barlow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Aquilegia-Black-Barlow","http://www.perennials.com/plants/aquilegia-vulgaris-black-barlow.html"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Aquilegia-Black-Barlow","https://www.shireplants.co.uk/aquilegia-vulgaris-var-stellata-black-barlow"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Aquilegia-Black-Barlow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great for woodland settings and is drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/aquilegia-vulgaris-black-barlow.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Shire Plants","url":"https://www.shireplants.co.uk/aquilegia-vulgaris-var-stellata-black-barlow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It tolerates quite dry soil when established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"columbine-black-barlow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Aquilegia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"aquilegia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Aquilegia x hybrida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia-x-hybrida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer resistant. Attracts hummingbirds and butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia hybrida"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Columbine)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/columbine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia hybrida"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Aquilegia-Black-Barlow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/perennials/columbine/black-barlow-columbine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies and Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/aquilegia-vulgaris-black-barlow.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"MyGardenLife Plant Library","url":"https://mygardenlife.com/plant-library/columbine-black-barlow-aquilegia-vulgaris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are loved by hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"},{"name":"Little Prince Plants","url":"https://littleprinceplants.com/our-plants/perennials/aquilegia-vulgaris-barlow-black-columbine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aquilegia vulgaris"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"columbine-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.55,0.61],"union":[0.15,1],"voices":11,"distinctPublishers":11,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b400","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia-canadensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=AQCA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size Notes: Up to about 3 feet tall.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Aquilegia-canadensis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8-24 in","metres":[0.2,0.61],"band":[0.2,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"USDA Forest Service, Celebrating Wildflowers","url":"https://www.fs.usda.gov/wildflowers/beauty/columbines/aquilegia_canadensis.shtml","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Aquilegia canadensis ranges in height from 15 to 90 cm.","metres":[0.15,0.9],"band":[0.15,0.9],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/columbine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: to 2 feet.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aquilegia-canadensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height : 2 - 3 ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/aquilegia-canadensis-columbine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 2 feet","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/columbine-aquilegia-canadensis.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 1' -3'","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aquilegia-canadensis-wild-columbine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: usually 1.5-2' high x 1.5' wide","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"New Blooms Nursery","url":"https://www.newblooms.com/products/aquilegia-canadensis-columbine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 20 to 24 inches","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"columbine-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.46],"union":[0.2,0.61],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b400","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia-canadensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Aquilegia-canadensis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 8-12 in","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aquilegia-canadensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread : 1 - 2 ft","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aquilegia-canadensis-wild-columbine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: usually 1.5-2' high x 1.5' wide","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"New Blooms Nursery","url":"https://www.newblooms.com/products/aquilegia-canadensis-columbine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 20 to 24 inches","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"columbine-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b400","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia-canadensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Aquilegia-canadensis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aquilegia-canadensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy from USDA Zones 3-8.","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/aquilegia-canadensis-columbine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/columbine-aquilegia-canadensis.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aquilegia-canadensis-wild-columbine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone s: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"New Blooms Nursery","url":"https://www.newblooms.com/products/aquilegia-canadensis-columbine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"columbine-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b400","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia-canadensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=AQCA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade , Shade","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aquilegia-canadensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Aquilegia canadensis grows best in partial shade but also adapts to sun and shade.","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/columbine-aquilegia-canadensis.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun, Partial, Shade","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aquilegia-canadensis-wild-columbine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Partial shade, shade, dappled sun, but adaptable to full sun too.","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"New Blooms Nursery","url":"https://www.newblooms.com/products/aquilegia-canadensis-columbine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure: Full sun (6+ hours) to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"columbine-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"columbine-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b400","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aquilegia-canadensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower, Dried Flower, Naturalizing","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"columbine-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b400","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=AQCA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerance: High","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Aquilegia-canadensis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aquilegia-canadensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants need a well drained soil and are tolerant of drought and alkaline soil.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/columbine-aquilegia-canadensis.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant to some degree.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"columbine-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b400","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aquilegia-canadensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Provides nectar to bumblebees, butterflies, hummingbirds and other pollinators. The seeds may be eaten by songbirds. Deer resistant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=AQCA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use Wildlife: Blooms attract hummingbirds, bees, butterflies, and hawk moths. Seeds consumed by finches and buntings.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Aquilegia-canadensis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Important nectar source for hummingbirds; host to the Columbine Duskywing butterfly.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"USDA Forest Service, Celebrating Wildflowers","url":"https://www.fs.usda.gov/wildflowers/beauty/columbines/aquilegia_canadensis.shtml","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Aquilegia canadensis is critical food source for returning ruby-throated hummingbirds in spring.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/columbine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It attracts hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/aquilegia-canadensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The petal spurs point up and contain nectar that is only accessible to long tongued pollinators like hawk moths and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/aquilegia-canadensis-columbine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"one of the first plants to provide nectar in the spring for bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/columbine-aquilegia-canadensis.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinators, Hummingbirds, Host Plant, Deer Resistant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/aquilegia-canadensis-wild-columbine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies or Pollinators: bumblebees, butterflies, hawk moths. Host to the Columbine Duskywing Caterpillar.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"},{"name":"New Blooms Nursery","url":"https://www.newblooms.com/products/aquilegia-canadensis-columbine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Feeds Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aquilegia canadensis"}],"note":"11 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"columbine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Utah State University, Center for Water Efficient Landscaping (western native plants)","url":"https://cwelwnp.usu.edu/westernnativeplants/plantlist_view.php?id=78&name=aquilegiachrysantha","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In-bloom the plants are 30 to 40 inches tall and almost as wide.","metres":[0.76,1.02],"band":[0.76,1.02],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"columbine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"columbine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"columbine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Utah State University, Center for Water Efficient Landscaping (western native plants)","url":"https://cwelwnp.usu.edu/westernnativeplants/plantlist_view.php?id=78&name=aquilegiachrysantha","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Adapted to part shade but will grow well and bloom freely in site with full sun to moderate shade."}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"columbine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"columbine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"columbine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Utah State University, Center for Water Efficient Landscaping (western native plants)","url":"https://cwelwnp.usu.edu/westernnativeplants/plantlist_view.php?id=78&name=aquilegiachrysantha","country":null,"form":null,"value":"can withstand moderately dry conditions","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"columbine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Utah State University, Center for Water Efficient Landscaping (western native plants)","url":"https://cwelwnp.usu.edu/westernnativeplants/plantlist_view.php?id=78&name=aquilegiachrysantha","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are very attractive to hummingbirds.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.91,1.07],"union":[0.61,1.52],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277422","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.61,1.52],"band":[0.61,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows up to 2 to 3½ feet tall and 1½ feet wide","metres":[0.61,1.07],"band":[0.61,1.07],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ecpu","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size Notes: Up to about 4 feet tall.","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.51],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277422","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows up to 2 to 3½ feet tall and 1½ feet wide","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277422","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"value","catalogField":"zoneMax","from":9,"to":8,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"coneflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277422","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ecpu","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277422","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut or dried flower.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"specialty cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ecpu","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attractive in flower arrangements","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"coneflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277422","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant once established and can grow in full sun to partial shade.","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"drought and heat-tolerant once established","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277422","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its flowers are attractive to bees, butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies use Echinacea as a nectar source","claim":true},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ecpu","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Value to Native Bees","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower-cheyenne-spirit","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.66,0.73],"union":[0.3,0.81],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea-cheyenne-spirit/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293471","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.76],"band":[0.3,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"All-America Selections","url":"https://all-americaselections.org/product/echinacea-cheyenne-spirit/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: 26-32 inches","metres":[0.66,0.81],"band":[0.66,0.81],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center Trial Garden","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/echinacea-mid-atlantic-region/echinacea-cheyenne-spirit/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 26\" x 24\"","metres":0.66,"band":[0.59,0.73],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Echinacea-Cheyenne-Spirit","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24-30 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/echinacea/echinacea-seeds-cheyenne-spirit.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Reaching a height of 24-30 inches, these vibrant perennials thrive in USDA zones 4-9.","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/cheyenne-spirit-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 18 - 30 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.76],"band":[0.46,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-cheyenne-spirit","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.51],"union":[0.25,0.67],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea-cheyenne-spirit/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 8 in.","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293471","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center Trial Garden","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/echinacea-mid-atlantic-region/echinacea-cheyenne-spirit/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 26\" x 24\"","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Echinacea-Cheyenne-Spirit","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 14-20 Inches","metres":[0.36,0.51],"band":[0.36,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/cheyenne-spirit-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 10 - 20 Inches","metres":[0.25,0.51],"band":[0.25,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-cheyenne-spirit","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea-cheyenne-spirit/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293471","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/echinacea-cheyenne-spirit-cheyenne-spirit-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4 - 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Echinacea-Cheyenne-Spirit","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/echinacea/echinacea-seeds-cheyenne-spirit.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA ZONES 4 - 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/cheyenne-spirit-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-cheyenne-spirit","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea-cheyenne-spirit/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293471","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"All-America Selections","url":"https://all-americaselections.org/product/echinacea-cheyenne-spirit/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/echinacea-cheyenne-spirit-cheyenne-spirit-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Echinacea-Cheyenne-Spirit","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Thrives in average, dry to medium-moisture, well-drained soils in full sun to partial shade, with optimal growth in full sun.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/echinacea/echinacea-seeds-cheyenne-spirit.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ENVIRONMENT Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/cheyenne-spirit-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Partial Sun to Full Sun (At Least 5 Hours of Direct Sunlight)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/echinacea.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun.","level":"genus","taxon":"echinacea"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-cheyenne-spirit","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-cheyenne-spirit","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea-cheyenne-spirit/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#showy flowers #cutting garden #herbaceous perennial","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293471","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"All-America Selections","url":"https://all-americaselections.org/product/echinacea-cheyenne-spirit/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"As an added bonus, 'Cheyenne Spirit' does not require a lot of water and offers a wide range of uses from the perennial border, in a mass landscape planting, in a butterfly garden or as a cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Echinacea-Cheyenne-Spirit","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/echinacea/echinacea-seeds-cheyenne-spirit.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Whether used as a vibrant garden centerpiece or as cut flowers, they bring long-lasting beauty and wildlife to any outdoor space, while supporting crucial pollinator activity throughout the growing season.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/cheyenne-spirit-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Trim some of the stems to use the blooms as cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/echinacea.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Blooms are long lasting when cut.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"echinacea"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-cheyenne-spirit","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea-cheyenne-spirit/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#clay soils tolerant #drought tolerant #deer resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293471","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"All-America Selections","url":"https://all-americaselections.org/product/echinacea-cheyenne-spirit/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water Needs: Drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Echinacea-Cheyenne-Spirit","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Exceptionally tough, 'Cheyenne Spirit' thrives in drought, heat, and low-maintenance conditions, making it a resilient and beautiful addition to any garden.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/echinacea/echinacea-seeds-cheyenne-spirit.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A drought tolerance mixture of flowers perfect for xeriscaping.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/cheyenne-spirit-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The Cheyenne Spirit Coneflower is drought-tolerant and attracts butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/echinacea.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Echinaceas will tolerate some drought once established; performance is better with regular water.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"echinacea"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-cheyenne-spirit","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea-cheyenne-spirit/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies, bees, and hummingbirds are attracted to the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293471","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"All-America Selections","url":"https://all-americaselections.org/product/echinacea-cheyenne-spirit/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Container Suitable , Cut Flower , One year summer trial , Pollinator Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/echinacea-cheyenne-spirit-cheyenne-spirit-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Interest: Attracts Birds Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Echinacea-Cheyenne-Spirit","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies and other pollinators flock to these blooms, while spent flower heads left through winter provide a valuable food source for birds.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/echinacea/echinacea-seeds-cheyenne-spirit.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cheyenne Spirit Cone flowers offer a wonderful way to attract bees and butterflies, making them ideal for pollinator-friendly gardens.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/cheyenne-spirit-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The Cheyenne Spirit Coneflower is drought-tolerant and attracts butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/echinacea.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Echinaceas attract bees, butterflies, and beneficial insects.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"echinacea"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-coconut-lime","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.68,0.75],"union":[0.46,0.84],"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269183","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"AB Cultivars (the breeder, Arie Blom)","url":"https://www.ab-cultivars.com/?portfolio=echinacea-coconut-lime","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 24-30″ tall by 24-30″ tall","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP18,617 'Coconut Lime' (via Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP18617P2/en","country":"NL","form":null,"value":"Plant height. -About 73 cm.","metres":0.73,"band":[0.66,0.8],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHCL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24.0-30.0 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-purpurea-coconut-lime.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 60-75 cm 23-29 inches","metres":[0.6,0.75],"band":[0.6,0.75],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-coconut-lime/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size (HT/W/FL HT): 20″ / 24″ / 30″","metres":0.51,"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-coconut-lime","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 20-30 Inches","metres":[0.51,0.76],"band":[0.51,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/4574/Coconut_Lime_Coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Coconut Lime Coneflower will grow to be about 18 inches tall at maturity extending to 24 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/79518b-echinacea-purpurea-cone-fections-coconut-lime-coneflower/p/906793","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growth Height Max 30 in.","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"MyGardenLife Plant Library","url":"https://www.mygardenlife.com/plant-library/4029/echinacea/hybrid/coconut-lime","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24-30\" / 61-76cm","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":2,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"coneflower-coconut-lime","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.29,0.91],"split":[{"range":[0.29,0.42],"sources":["US Plant Patent PP18,617 'Coconut Lime' (via Google Patents)","SiteOne Landscape Supply"]},{"range":[0.45,0.67],"sources":["Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Sooner Plant Farm","Terra Nova Nurseries","Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)"]},{"range":[0.76,0.91],"sources":["Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269183","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP18,617 'Coconut Lime' (via Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP18617P2/en","country":"NL","form":null,"value":"Plant diameter or spread. -About 32 cm.","metres":0.32,"band":[0.29,0.35],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHCL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 30.0-36.0 Inches","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-purpurea-coconut-lime.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 45-60 cm 18-23 inches","metres":[0.45,0.6],"band":[0.45,0.6],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-coconut-lime/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size (HT/W/FL HT): 20″ / 24″ / 30″","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-coconut-lime","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 18-24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/4574/Coconut_Lime_Coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Coconut Lime Coneflower will grow to be about 18 inches tall at maturity extending to 24 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/79518b-echinacea-purpurea-cone-fections-coconut-lime-coneflower/p/906793","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growth Width Max 15 in.","metres":0.38,"band":[0.34,0.42],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":2,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 3 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"coneflower-coconut-lime","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-9","4-9","5-12"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269183","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHCL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-purpurea-coconut-lime.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-coconut-lime/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone(s): 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-coconut-lime","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/79518b-echinacea-purpurea-cone-fections-coconut-lime-coneflower/p/906793","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone Maximum Zone 9b Hardiness Zone Minimum Zone 3a","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"MyGardenLife Plant Library","url":"https://www.mygardenlife.com/plant-library/4029/echinacea/hybrid/coconut-lime","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12","zones":[5,12],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":2,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[3,8]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"coneflower-coconut-lime","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":11,"distinctPublishers":11,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269183","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"AB Cultivars (the breeder, Arie Blom)","url":"https://www.ab-cultivars.com/?portfolio=echinacea-coconut-lime","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun/Shade: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHCL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-purpurea-coconut-lime.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun or Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-coconut-lime/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-coconut-lime","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/4574/Coconut_Lime_Coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"MyGardenLife Plant Library","url":"https://www.mygardenlife.com/plant-library/4029/echinacea/hybrid/coconut-lime","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Echinacea purpurea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1182","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full sun to part shade","level":"genus","taxon":"echinacea"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Echinacea purpurea)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ECPU","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade","level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"coneflower-coconut-lime","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP18617P2/en","https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/4574/Coconut_Lime_Coneflower/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"US Plant Patent PP18,617 'Coconut Lime' (via Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP18617P2/en","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance. -Faint; sweet.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/4574/Coconut_Lime_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Coconut Lime Coneflower has masses of beautiful lightly-scented double white pincushion flowers with gold overtones and chartreuse centers at the ends of the stems from mid summer to mid fall, which are most effective when planted in groupings.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"coneflower-coconut-lime","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269183","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHCL","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-purpurea-coconut-lime.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-coconut-lime/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Well-branched, sturdy flower stems are perfect for cutting!","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-coconut-lime","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Well-branched, sturdy flower stems are perfect for cutting!","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/4574/Coconut_Lime_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"MyGardenLife Plant Library","url":"https://www.mygardenlife.com/plant-library/4029/echinacea/hybrid/coconut-lime","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers are long-lasting in fresh bouquets.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1182","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Echinacea species have strong, sturdy stems that require no staking, making them popular as low-maintenance perennials in the flower garden, as well as specialty cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"echinacea"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-coconut-lime","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269183","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"AB Cultivars (the breeder, Arie Blom)","url":"https://www.ab-cultivars.com/?portfolio=echinacea-coconut-lime","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Moisture: Moist, but well drained to get established, once established, it is very drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHCL","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, they are quite drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-purpurea-coconut-lime.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower Deer Resistant Dried Flower Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-coconut-lime","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/4574/Coconut_Lime_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is considered to be drought-tolerant, and thus makes an ideal choice for a low-water garden or xeriscape application.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"MyGardenLife Plant Library","url":"https://www.mygardenlife.com/plant-library/4029/echinacea/hybrid/coconut-lime","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates hot, dry conditions.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Echinacea purpurea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant once established and can grow in full sun to partial shade.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1182","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Coneflowers have a high degree of drought resistance once established, making them a great addition to a water-wise landscape.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"echinacea"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"coneflower-coconut-lime","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269183","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The double blooms this cultivar produces are not as beneficial to wildlife since they do not produce pollen, nectar, or seeds.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHCL","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies Attracts Songbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-purpurea-coconut-lime.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-coconut-lime","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/4574/Coconut_Lime_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies to your yard, but is not particularly attractive to deer who tend to leave it alone in favor of tastier treats.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"MyGardenLife Plant Library","url":"https://www.mygardenlife.com/plant-library/4029/echinacea/hybrid/coconut-lime","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies to the garden.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Echinacea purpurea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Several pollinators are attracted to the flower, especially butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1182","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies use Echinacea as a nectar source, and birds enjoy the seeds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"echinacea"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Echinacea purpurea)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ECPU","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use Wildlife: Echinacea spp. attract butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-double-scoop-raspberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.58,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.61,0.66],"union":[0.61,0.66],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.brecks.com/product/double-scoop-raspberry-coneflower","https://www.plantaddicts.com/double-scoop-raspberry-coneflower/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/product/double-scoop-raspberry-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 24 - 26 inches","metres":[0.61,0.66],"band":[0.61,0.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://www.plantaddicts.com/double-scoop-raspberry-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 24-26 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.66],"band":[0.61,0.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":2,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.64},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"coneflower-double-scoop-raspberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.48,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://www.plantaddicts.com/double-scoop-raspberry-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 16-22 Inches","metres":[0.41,0.56],"band":[0.41,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":2,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"coneflower-double-scoop-raspberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/product/double-scoop-raspberry-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://www.plantaddicts.com/double-scoop-raspberry-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones 4 to 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":2,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"coneflower-double-scoop-raspberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/product/double-scoop-raspberry-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://www.plantaddicts.com/double-scoop-raspberry-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Sun to Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Echinacea purpurea, the species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"coneflower-double-scoop-raspberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/product/double-scoop-raspberry-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"you'll delight in its subtle fragrance and the butterflies that flit around the blooms with the distinctive center cones","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"coneflower-double-scoop-raspberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://www.plantaddicts.com/double-scoop-raspberry-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"its cut flowers make for stunning arrangements","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"coneflower-double-scoop-raspberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/product/double-scoop-raspberry-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Will Tolerate Acidic Soil, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Loamy Soil, Sandy Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://www.plantaddicts.com/double-scoop-raspberry-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The Double Scoop Raspberry Coneflower is a heat and drought tolerant plant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Echinacea purpurea, the species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant once established and can grow in full sun to partial shade.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"coneflower-double-scoop-raspberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/product/double-scoop-raspberry-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attract Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://www.plantaddicts.com/double-scoop-raspberry-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It brings in pollinators, and resists deer.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Echinacea purpurea, the species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Several pollinators are attracted to the flower, especially butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"coneflower-green-jewel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.51,0.6],"union":[0.46,1],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=445808&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHGJ","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 20.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/green-jewel-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Garden Height: 20 - 24 Inches","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/300307/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel-pbr/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Valleybrook International Ventures / Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Height 50-60 cm 20-23 inches","metres":[0.5,0.6],"band":[0.5,0.6],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-green-jewel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 18-24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Cavano's Perennial Farms","url":"https://cavanos.com/product/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.5-2'","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Bay Gardens","url":"https://baygardens.com/products/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 20-24 Inches","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-green-jewel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.3,0.45],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=445808&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHGJ","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12.0-18.0 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/green-jewel-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12 - 18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/300307/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel-pbr/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Valleybrook International Ventures / Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Spread 30-45 cm 12-18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.45],"band":[0.3,0.45],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-green-jewel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 12-18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Cavano's Perennial Farms","url":"https://cavanos.com/product/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1-1.5'","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Bay Gardens","url":"https://baygardens.com/products/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 12-18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-green-jewel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=445808&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHGJ","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/green-jewel-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3a , 3b , 4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Valleybrook International Ventures / Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-green-jewel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Cavano's Perennial Farms","url":"https://cavanos.com/product/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Bay Gardens","url":"https://baygardens.com/products/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: Zone 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-green-jewel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=445808&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHGJ","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/green-jewel-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Sun to Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/300307/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel-pbr/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Valleybrook International Ventures / Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun or Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-green-jewel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Cavano's Perennial Farms","url":"https://cavanos.com/product/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure: full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Bay Gardens","url":"https://baygardens.com/products/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Part to Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-green-jewel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"strengths":["light"],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=445808&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers have a mild but sweet fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHGJ","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Light green ray petals surround the large, green cone of this fragrant coneflower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/green-jewel-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant, light green flowers. Dark green cone. Excellent cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Valleybrook International Ventures / Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The large and fragrant blooms have a row of light-green petals surrounding a large central cone of deep green.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-green-jewel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This unique coneflower has the fragrance of honey and light green ray pedals surround a green center cone.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Cavano's Perennial Farms","url":"https://cavanos.com/product/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Notes: deer tolerant, drought tolerant, fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Bay Gardens","url":"https://baygardens.com/products/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-green-jewel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=445808&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut or dried flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHGJ","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Dried Flower Drought Tolerant Fragrant Flowers Mass Planting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/green-jewel-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant, light green flowers. Dark green cone. Excellent cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Valleybrook International Ventures / Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-green-jewel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Bay Gardens","url":"https://baygardens.com/products/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut Good Dried Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-green-jewel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=445808&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHGJ","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, they are quite drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/green-jewel-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Valleybrook International Ventures / Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-green-jewel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Cavano's Perennial Farms","url":"https://cavanos.com/product/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Notes: deer tolerant, drought tolerant, fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Bay Gardens","url":"https://baygardens.com/products/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant once established and can grow in full sun to partial shade.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-green-jewel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=445808&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to butterflies and other insect pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHGJ","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Attracts Songbirds Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/green-jewel-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/300307/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel-pbr/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Echinacea are erect, clump-forming rhizomatous perennials with simple or pinnately lobed leaves and solitary, long-stalked daisies with prominent conical central disks and often drooping ray florets; attractive to butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Valleybrook International Ventures / Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are very attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-green-jewel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Cavano's Perennial Farms","url":"https://cavanos.com/product/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Benefit: pollinators, songbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Bay Gardens","url":"https://baygardens.com/products/echinacea-purpurea-green-jewel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its flowers are attractive to bees, butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-hot-papaya","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.76,0.78],"union":[0.61,0.91],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271288&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.50 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"United States Plant Patent PP21,022 (breeder's registration, Arie Blom / AB-Cultivars)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP21022P2/en","country":"NL","form":null,"value":"Plant height.- About 70.6 cm.","metres":0.71,"band":[0.64,0.78],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens, Inc.)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHHP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 30.0-36.0 Inches","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Garden Height: 30 - 36 Inches","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-hot-papaya.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Height 75-90 cm","metres":[0.75,0.9],"band":[0.75,0.9],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://gardencrossings.com/products/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower-echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Max Height: 2 - 3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-hot-papaya","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 30-36 Inches","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 2.5 - 3 Feet","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ECHINACEA-HOT-PAPAYA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24-30 in","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Horsford Gardens and Nursery","url":"https://horsfordnursery.com/echinacea-hot-papaya/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Plant Height: HT 30-36\"","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-hot-papaya","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.27,0.91],"split":[{"range":[0.27,0.33],"sources":["United States Plant Patent PP21,022 (breeder's registration, Arie Blom / AB-Cultivars)"]},{"range":[0.45,0.91],"sources":["Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","Horsford Gardens and Nursery","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens, Inc.)","Proven Winners","Sooner Plant Farm","Plant Addicts","Garden Crossings"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271288&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"United States Plant Patent PP21,022 (breeder's registration, Arie Blom / AB-Cultivars)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP21022P2/en","country":"NL","form":null,"value":"Plant diameter or spread.- About 30 cm.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens, Inc.)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHHP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24.0-30.0 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24 - 30 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-hot-papaya.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Spread 45-60 cm","metres":[0.45,0.6],"band":[0.45,0.6],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://gardencrossings.com/products/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower-echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Max Spread: 2 - 3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-hot-papaya","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 24-30 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 2 - 2.5 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Horsford Gardens and Nursery","url":"https://horsfordnursery.com/echinacea-hot-papaya/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Spread: SP 18-24\"","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-hot-papaya","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271288&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens, Inc.)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHHP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b , 9a , 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-hot-papaya.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://gardencrossings.com/products/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower-echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-hot-papaya","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ECHINACEA-HOT-PAPAYA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-hot-papaya","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271288&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Echinacea purpurea, species page with a 'Hot Papaya' cultivar entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens, Inc.)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHHP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Sun to Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-hot-papaya.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://gardencrossings.com/products/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower-echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (+6 hrs.)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-hot-papaya","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Exposure: Partial Sun to Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ECHINACEA-HOT-PAPAYA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun Partial Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-hot-papaya","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"United States Plant Patent PP21,022 (breeder's registration, Arie Blom / AB-Cultivars)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP21022P2/en","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance.- None detected.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens, Inc.)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHHP","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-hot-papaya","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is very fragrant and makes excellent cut flowers that last for days.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fragrant and fiery flowers bloom in summer, enticing butterflies and bees through the season.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ECHINACEA-HOT-PAPAYA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Horsford Gardens and Nursery","url":"https://horsfordnursery.com/echinacea-hot-papaya/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Blooms are terribly eye-catching, fragrant, and long lasting cut-flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-hot-papaya","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271288&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens, Inc.)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHHP","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Be sure to cut a few for a fresh bouquet that will last nearly two weeks.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long lasting in bouquets.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-hot-papaya.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://gardencrossings.com/products/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower-echinacea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The long-lasting flowers of Cone-Fections™ Hot Papaya Echinacea attract butterflies and hummingbirds and are great in cut flower arrangements!","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-hot-papaya","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is very fragrant and makes excellent cut flowers that last for days.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"You'll love the richness it adds to bouquets as a cut flower, too!","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ECHINACEA-HOT-PAPAYA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage/Fruit","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Horsford Gardens and Nursery","url":"https://horsfordnursery.com/echinacea-hot-papaya/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Blooms are terribly eye-catching, fragrant, and long lasting cut-flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-hot-papaya","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271288&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This is an adaptable plant that is tolerant of drought, heat, humidity and poor soil.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Echinacea purpurea, species page with a 'Hot Papaya' cultivar entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant once established and can grow in full sun to partial shade.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens, Inc.)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHHP","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, they are quite drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-hot-papaya.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://gardencrossings.com/products/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower-echinacea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"'Hot Papaya' grows 36 inches high and up to 30 inches wide, loving full to part sun, and drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-hot-papaya","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates: Heat, Drought, Salt","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-hot-papaya","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271288&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The double blooms this cultivar produces are not as beneficial to wildlife since they do not produce pollen, nectar, or seeds.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Echinacea purpurea, species page with a 'Hot Papaya' cultivar entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its flowers are attractive to bees, butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens, Inc.)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHHP","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-hot-papaya.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Crossings","url":"https://gardencrossings.com/products/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower-echinacea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The long-lasting flowers of Cone-Fections™ Hot Papaya Echinacea attract butterflies and hummingbirds and are great in cut flower arrangements!","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-hot-papaya","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/cone-fections-hot-papaya-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees, Birds, Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/ECHINACEA-HOT-PAPAYA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-kismet-raspberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.3,0.89],"split":[{"range":[0.3,0.51],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Johnson's Nursery Knowledge Base","Perennials.com (Heritage Perennials)","Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","Overdevest Nurseries","Plant Addicts","Hydrangea.com","Stonehouse Nursery","Gertens"]},{"range":[0.73,0.89],"sources":["Mt. Cuba Center Trial Garden"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=371990&isprofile=0&pt=8&mv=11","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center Trial Garden","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/echinacea-mid-atlantic-region/echinacea-tnechkr-kismet-raspberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 32\" x 32\"","metres":0.81,"band":[0.73,0.89],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-kismet-raspberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size (HT/W/FL HT) 16\" / 24\" / 18\"","metres":0.41,"band":[0.37,0.45],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledge Base","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/kismet-raspberry-coneflower-echinacea-tnechkr","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 12-18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-kismet-raspberry.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Height 35-40 cm 14-16 inches","metres":[0.35,0.4],"band":[0.35,0.4],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-kismet%C2%A8-raspberry-otnechkro-pp28768/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/kismet-raspberry-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 16 - 18 Inches","metres":[0.41,0.46],"band":[0.41,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Hydrangea.com","url":"https://hydrangea.com/products/kismet%C2%AE-raspberry-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height x width: 16-18\" x 24\"","metres":[0.41,0.46],"band":[0.41,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/24093/Kismet%C2%AE_Raspberry_Coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18 inches","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Overdevest Nurseries","url":"https://grownbyoverdevest.com/plant/kismet-raspberry-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 16\"","metres":0.41,"band":[0.37,0.45],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-kismet-raspberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.45,0.89],"split":[{"range":[0.45,0.67],"sources":["Perennials.com (Heritage Perennials)","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Johnson's Nursery Knowledge Base","Stonehouse Nursery","Plant Addicts","Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","Hydrangea.com","Gertens","Overdevest Nurseries"]},{"range":[0.73,0.89],"sources":["Mt. Cuba Center Trial Garden"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=371990&isprofile=0&pt=8&mv=11","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center Trial Garden","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/echinacea-mid-atlantic-region/echinacea-tnechkr-kismet-raspberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 32\" x 32\"","metres":0.81,"band":[0.73,0.89],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-kismet-raspberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size (HT/W/FL HT) 16\" / 24\" / 18\"","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledge Base","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/kismet-raspberry-coneflower-echinacea-tnechkr","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 18-24 inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-kismet-raspberry.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Spread 45-60 cm 18-23 inches","metres":[0.45,0.6],"band":[0.45,0.6],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-kismet%C2%A8-raspberry-otnechkro-pp28768/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18-24","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/kismet-raspberry-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 18 - 24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Hydrangea.com","url":"https://hydrangea.com/products/kismet%C2%AE-raspberry-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height x width: 16-18\" x 24\"","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/24093/Kismet%C2%AE_Raspberry_Coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24 inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Overdevest Nurseries","url":"https://grownbyoverdevest.com/plant/kismet-raspberry-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 24\"","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-kismet-raspberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-10","4-9","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=371990&isprofile=0&pt=8&mv=11","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 10","zones":[4,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-kismet-raspberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone(s): 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-kismet-raspberry.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-kismet%C2%A8-raspberry-otnechkro-pp28768/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 - 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/kismet-raspberry-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 4 - 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Hydrangea.com","url":"https://hydrangea.com/products/kismet%C2%AE-raspberry-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 - 10","zones":[4,10],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-kismet-raspberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=371990&isprofile=0&pt=8&mv=11","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-kismet-raspberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledge Base","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/kismet-raspberry-coneflower-echinacea-tnechkr","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-kismet-raspberry.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-kismet%C2%A8-raspberry-otnechkro-pp28768/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun, Part Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/kismet-raspberry-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Full Sun (At Least 6 Hours Of Direct Sunlight)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/24093/Kismet%C2%AE_Raspberry_Coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-kismet-raspberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-kismet-raspberry/","https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-kismet%C2%A8-raspberry-otnechkro-pp28768/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-kismet-raspberry/","https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/24093/Kismet%C2%AE_Raspberry_Coneflower/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-kismet-raspberry/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Uses Cut Flower , Deep South , Deer Resistant , Fragrant , Hummingbird Attractor , Low Water Usage , Pollinator Attractor","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-kismet%C2%A8-raspberry-otnechkro-pp28768/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant: Yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/24093/Kismet%C2%AE_Raspberry_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"has masses of beautiful lightly-scented hot pink daisy flowers with scarlet overtones and gold eyes at the ends of the stems from early summer to mid fall, which are most effective when planted in groupings","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-kismet-raspberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=371990&isprofile=0&pt=8&mv=11","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut or dried flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-kismet-raspberry/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Uses Cut Flower , Deep South , Deer Resistant , Fragrant , Hummingbird Attractor , Low Water Usage , Pollinator Attractor","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledge Base","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/kismet-raspberry-coneflower-echinacea-tnechkr","country":null,"form":null,"value":"its huge flowers are sure to be the main focus of your creation","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-kismet-raspberry.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-kismet%C2%A8-raspberry-otnechkro-pp28768/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut Flower: Yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/kismet-raspberry-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features: Attracts Pollinators, Cut Flowers, Low Maintenance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/24093/Kismet%C2%AE_Raspberry_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Overdevest Nurseries","url":"https://grownbyoverdevest.com/plant/kismet-raspberry-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-kismet-raspberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=371990&isprofile=0&pt=8&mv=11","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-kismet-raspberry/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Uses Cut Flower , Deep South , Deer Resistant , Fragrant , Hummingbird Attractor , Low Water Usage , Pollinator Attractor","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant once established and can grow in full sun to partial shade.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-kismet-raspberry.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-kismet%C2%A8-raspberry-otnechkro-pp28768/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant: Yes, Once Established","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/kismet-raspberry-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates: Heat, Drought","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Hydrangea.com","url":"https://hydrangea.com/products/kismet%C2%AE-raspberry-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features: Native, heat tolerant, drought tolerant, deer resistant, cold tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/24093/Kismet%C2%AE_Raspberry_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is considered to be drought-tolerant, and thus makes an ideal choice for a low-water garden or xeriscape application.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-kismet-raspberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=371990&isprofile=0&pt=8&mv=11","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center Trial Garden","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/echinacea-mid-atlantic-region/echinacea-tnechkr-kismet-raspberry/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator Watch Pollinator Favorite","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-kismet-raspberry/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Uses Cut Flower , Deep South , Deer Resistant , Fragrant , Hummingbird Attractor , Low Water Usage , Pollinator Attractor","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledge Base","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/kismet-raspberry-coneflower-echinacea-tnechkr","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This is beneficial for long-term ornamental value, but also attractive to pollinators throughout the season.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Several pollinators are attracted to the flower, especially butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Heritage Perennials)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-kismet-raspberry.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-kismet%C2%A8-raspberry-otnechkro-pp28768/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies: Yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/kismet-raspberry-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees, Birds, Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Hydrangea.com","url":"https://hydrangea.com/products/kismet%C2%AE-raspberry-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: Border, cottage gardening, massing, naturalizing, pollinator specimen, wildflower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/24093/Kismet%C2%AE_Raspberry_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies and hummingbirds to your yard, but is not particularly attractive to deer who tend to leave it alone in favor of tastier treats.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Overdevest Nurseries","url":"https://grownbyoverdevest.com/plant/kismet-raspberry-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"11 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-magnus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.61,1.22],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245977&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.50 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHMA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 36.0 Inches","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/magnus-purple-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea-0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Garden Height: 36 Inches","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/perennial-plants/echinacea-purpurea-magnus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 36-48\" tall","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-magnus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 30-36 Inches","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Echinacea-purpurea-Magnus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2-3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/echinacea-purpurea-magnus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants grow 2-3' tall with 2' spread.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"species":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-magnus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.55,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.67],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245977&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHMA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/magnus-purple-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea-0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18 - 24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/perennial-plants/echinacea-purpurea-magnus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 18-24\" wide","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-magnus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 12-18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Echinacea-purpurea-Magnus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12-18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/echinacea-purpurea-magnus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants grow 2-3' tall with 2' spread.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"species":1,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-magnus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-10","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245977&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHMA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/magnus-purple-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea-0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3a , 3b , 4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b , 9a , 9b , 10a , 10b","zones":[3,10],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/perennial-plants/echinacea-purpurea-magnus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones Zone 4 Zone 5 Zone 6 Zone 7 Zone 8 Zone 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-magnus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Echinacea-purpurea-Magnus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/echinacea-purpurea-magnus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants are hardy from USDA Zones 4-9.","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"species":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-magnus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245977&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full sun to part shade","level":"genus","taxon":"echinacea"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHMA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/perennial-plants/echinacea-purpurea-magnus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-magnus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure* • Prefers Full Sun in Northern States • Prefers Full Sun in Southern States","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Echinacea-purpurea-Magnus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure • Full Sun • Part Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/echinacea-purpurea-magnus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The ideal site for Echinacea purpurea 'Magnus' has full sun and fertile well drained soil.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-magnus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-magnus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245977&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut Good Dried Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Echinacea species have strong, sturdy stems that require no staking, making them popular as low-maintenance perennials in the flower garden, as well as specialty cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"echinacea"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHMA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Dried Flower Drought Tolerant Mass Planting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/magnus-purple-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea-0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/perennial-plants/echinacea-purpurea-magnus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers Dried Flowers Deer Resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-magnus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses* • Accent Plant • Border Plant • Cut Flowers • Dried Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Echinacea-purpurea-Magnus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Their roots have famous medicinal qualities, they make great, long lasting cut flowers and attract numerous butterflies and small birds.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/echinacea-purpurea-magnus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attributes Cut Flower, Dried Flower, Drought Tolerant, Interesting Foliage, Long Blooming, Rock Garden, Rain Garden","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-magnus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245977&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant once established and can grow in full sun to partial shade.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Watering: Avoid overhead irrigation, drought tolerant once established","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"echinacea"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHMA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, they are quite drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/magnus-purple-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea-0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vibrant rose-colored, daisylike flowers summer to fall; very heat and drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-magnus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Preferred Soil Conditions* • Adapts Well to Most Soil Types • Average • Drought Tolerant • Low Water Use • Prefers Dry Soils • Well-Drained","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Echinacea-purpurea-Magnus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants are tough and heat and drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/echinacea-purpurea-magnus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This vigorous cultivar endures hot, dry sites and intense cold.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-magnus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245977&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its flowers are attractive to bees, butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies use Echinacea as a nectar source, and birds enjoy the seeds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"echinacea"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHMA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Attracts Songbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/magnus-purple-coneflower-echinacea-purpurea-0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/perennial-plants/echinacea-purpurea-magnus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bee Friendly Attracts Butterflies Attracts Birds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-magnus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nature Assets* • Attracts Bees • Attracts Butterflies • Deer Resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Echinacea-purpurea-Magnus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"For Animals • Deer Resistant • Hummingbird-friendly • Pollinator-friendly • Songbird-friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/echinacea-purpurea-magnus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants are also used as Accents or Butterfly Nectar Plants, Butterfly Host Plants or as part of a Grouping or Mass Planting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-marmalade","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.71,0.72],"union":[0.46,0.91],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273870&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHMR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 26.0-30.0 Inches","metres":[0.66,0.76],"band":[0.66,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP22,602 (breeder's registration, AB-Cultivars)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP22602P2/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant height.- About 53.6 cm.","metres":0.54,"band":[0.49,0.59],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stauffers of Kissel Hill plant database","url":"https://plants.skh.com/12170005/Plant/11651/Cone-fections_Marmalade_Coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"will grow to be about 18 inches tall at maturity extending to 30 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.","metres":[0.46,0.76],"band":[0.46,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/315659/echinacea-marmalade-pbr-cone-fections-series-d/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"A clump-forming, upright perennial to around 65cm tall with roughly hairy foliage.","metres":0.65,"band":[0.59,0.72],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Center Marketing plant library","url":"https://www.gardencentermarketing.com/plantName/Echinacea-Marmalade1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 28-36 in","metres":[0.71,0.91],"band":[0.71,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":1,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-marmalade","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.63],"union":[0.1,0.76],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273870&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHMR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24.0-30.0 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP22,602 (breeder's registration, AB-Cultivars)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP22602P2/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant diameter or spread.- About 56.5 cm.","metres":0.57,"band":[0.51,0.63],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stauffers of Kissel Hill plant database","url":"https://plants.skh.com/12170005/Plant/11651/Cone-fections_Marmalade_Coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"will grow to be about 18 inches tall at maturity extending to 30 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/315659/echinacea-marmalade-pbr-cone-fections-series-d/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Center Marketing plant library","url":"https://www.gardencentermarketing.com/plantName/Echinacea-Marmalade1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18-24 in","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":1,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-marmalade","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273870&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHMR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: (4)5,6,7,8,9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Center Marketing plant library","url":"https://www.gardencentermarketing.com/plantName/Echinacea-Marmalade1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-marmalade","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273870&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHMR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stauffers of Kissel Hill plant database","url":"https://plants.skh.com/12170005/Plant/11651/Cone-fections_Marmalade_Coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/315659/echinacea-marmalade-pbr-cone-fections-series-d/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full sun to part shade","level":"genus","taxon":"echinacea"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-marmalade","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHMR","https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP22602P2/en"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHMR","https://plants.skh.com/12170005/Plant/11651/Cone-fections_Marmalade_Coneflower/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHMR","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Strong, well-branched stems carry the fragrant blossoms from about mid-June into August.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP22,602 (breeder's registration, AB-Cultivars)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP22602P2/en","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance.- Moderate; sweetly acidic, pleasant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stauffers of Kissel Hill plant database","url":"https://plants.skh.com/12170005/Plant/11651/Cone-fections_Marmalade_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"has masses of beautiful lightly-scented double orange daisy flowers at the ends of the stems from mid summer to mid fall","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-marmalade","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHMR","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They all make delightfully long-lasting cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stauffers of Kissel Hill plant database","url":"https://plants.skh.com/12170005/Plant/11651/Cone-fections_Marmalade_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/315659/echinacea-marmalade-pbr-cone-fections-series-d/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Suggested planting locations and garden types Cottage and informal garden Patio and container plants Wildflower meadow Prairie planting Wildlife gardens Flower borders and beds Cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Center Marketing plant library","url":"https://www.gardencentermarketing.com/plantName/Echinacea-Marmalade1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cut flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Landscape Theme: Butterfly Garden Children's Garden Cottage Garden Cutting Garden Drought Tolerant Garden Native Garden Pollinator Garden Rain Garden Rock Garden","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Echinacea species have strong, sturdy stems that require no staking, making them popular as low-maintenance perennials in the flower garden, as well as specialty cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"echinacea"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-marmalade","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273870&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHMR","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Drought Tolerant Mass Planting Specimen Focal Point","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stauffers of Kissel Hill plant database","url":"https://plants.skh.com/12170005/Plant/11651/Cone-fections_Marmalade_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is considered to be drought-tolerant, and thus makes an ideal choice for a low-water garden or xeriscape application.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Dry Soil Heat Humidity Poor Soil Salt","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Coneflowers have a high degree of drought resistance once established, making them a great addition to a water-wise landscape.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"echinacea"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-marmalade","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273870&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The double blooms this cultivar produces are not as beneficial to wildlife since they do not produce pollen, nectar, or seeds.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHMR","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Attracts Songbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stauffers of Kissel Hill plant database","url":"https://plants.skh.com/12170005/Plant/11651/Cone-fections_Marmalade_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attracts pollinators and feeds the birds at winter","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its flowers are attractive to bees, butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/echinacea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies use Echinacea as a nectar source, and birds enjoy the seeds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"echinacea"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-pink-double-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.51],"union":[0.41,0.91],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=272022","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"TERRA NOVA Nurseries (introducer and licensor)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-pink-double-delight/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size (HT/W/FL HT) 16\" / 12\" / 20\"","metres":[0.41,0.51],"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP18,803, Echinacea plant named 'Pink Double Delight'","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP18803","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant height.- About 74 cm.","metres":0.74,"band":[0.67,0.81],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/echinacea-purpurea-pink-double-delight-pp-18803","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24\" tall","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-pink-double-delight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 16-20 Inches","metres":[0.41,0.51],"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder record)","url":"https://plants.westonnurseries.com/12130019/Plant/6302/Cone-fections_Pink_Double_Delight_Coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"will grow to be about 18 inches tall at maturity extending to 3 feet tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches","metres":[0.46,0.91],"band":[0.46,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Echinacea-purpurea-Pink-Double-Delight","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"HEIGHT: 45-60 cm","metres":[0.45,0.6],"band":[0.45,0.6],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-pink-double-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.25,0.67],"split":[{"range":[0.25,0.5],"sources":["Sooner Plant Farm","TERRA NOVA Nurseries (introducer and licensor)","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","US Plant Patent PP18,803, Echinacea plant named 'Pink Double Delight'","NVK Nurseries"]},{"range":[0.55,0.67],"sources":["Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder record)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=272022","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"TERRA NOVA Nurseries (introducer and licensor)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-pink-double-delight/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size (HT/W/FL HT) 16\" / 12\" / 20\"","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP18,803, Echinacea plant named 'Pink Double Delight'","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP18803","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant diameter or spread.- About 39.5 cm.","metres":0.4,"band":[0.36,0.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-pink-double-delight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 10-12 Inches","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder record)","url":"https://plants.westonnurseries.com/12130019/Plant/6302/Cone-fections_Pink_Double_Delight_Coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24 inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Echinacea-purpurea-Pink-Double-Delight","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"SPREAD: 40-50 cm","metres":[0.4,0.5],"band":[0.4,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-pink-double-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=272022","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"TERRA NOVA Nurseries (introducer and licensor)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-pink-double-delight/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone(s): 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/echinacea-purpurea-pink-double-delight-pp-18803","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 4a to 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-pink-double-delight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"New Garden Plants","url":"https://www.newgardenplants.com/pink-double-delight-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zone 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-pink-double-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=272022","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"TERRA NOVA Nurseries (introducer and licensor)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-pink-double-delight/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-pink-double-delight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder record)","url":"https://plants.westonnurseries.com/12130019/Plant/6302/Cone-fections_Pink_Double_Delight_Coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Echinacea-purpurea-Pink-Double-Delight","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Echinacea thrives in an average to moist, well-drained soil, in full sun to partial shade.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"New Garden Plants","url":"https://www.newgardenplants.com/pink-double-delight-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun-Shade Partial Sun/Shade, Full Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-pink-double-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"TERRA NOVA Nurseries (introducer and licensor)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-pink-double-delight/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Award Winners , Cut Flower , Deep South , Deer Resistant , Fragrant , Low Water Usage , Pollinator Attractor","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP18,803, Echinacea plant named 'Pink Double Delight'","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP18803","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance.- None detected.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder record)","url":"https://plants.westonnurseries.com/12130019/Plant/6302/Cone-fections_Pink_Double_Delight_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"highly fragrant blooms","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"New Garden Plants","url":"https://www.newgardenplants.com/pink-double-delight-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gardening Solution Perennial, Container Plant, Carefree, Deer Resistant, Fragrant, Border Plant, Drought Tolerant, Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-pink-double-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=272022","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut or dried flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"TERRA NOVA Nurseries (introducer and licensor)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-pink-double-delight/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Well-branched, sturdy flower stems are perfect for cutting!","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-pink-double-delight","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder record)","url":"https://plants.westonnurseries.com/12130019/Plant/6302/Cone-fections_Pink_Double_Delight_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Echinacea-purpurea-Pink-Double-Delight","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-pink-double-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=272022","country":null,"form":null,"value":"An adaptable plant that is tolerant of drought, heat, humidity and poor soil.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant once established and can grow in full sun to partial shade.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-pink-double-delight","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder record)","url":"https://plants.westonnurseries.com/12130019/Plant/6302/Cone-fections_Pink_Double_Delight_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is considered to be drought-tolerant, and thus makes an ideal choice for a low-water garden or xeriscape application.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Echinacea-purpurea-Pink-Double-Delight","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are drought tolerant once established and adaptable to heat and poor soils.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"New Garden Plants","url":"https://www.newgardenplants.com/pink-double-delight-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gardening Solution Perennial, Container Plant, Carefree, Deer Resistant, Fragrant, Border Plant, Drought Tolerant, Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-pink-double-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=272022","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The double blooms this cultivar produces are not as beneficial to wildlife since they do not produce pollen, nectar, or seeds.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its flowers are attractive to bees, butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"TERRA NOVA Nurseries (introducer and licensor)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-pink-double-delight/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Award Winners , Cut Flower , Deep South , Deer Resistant , Fragrant , Low Water Usage , Pollinator Attractor","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-pink-double-delight","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder record)","url":"https://plants.westonnurseries.com/12130019/Plant/6302/Cone-fections_Pink_Double_Delight_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies to your yard","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Echinacea-purpurea-Pink-Double-Delight","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"New Garden Plants","url":"https://www.newgardenplants.com/pink-double-delight-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gardening Solution Perennial, Container Plant, Carefree, Deer Resistant, Fragrant, Border Plant, Drought Tolerant, Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-powwow-wild-berry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.55,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.51,0.61],"union":[0.46,0.91],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293472","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"All-America Selections","url":"https://all-americaselections.org/product/echinacea-powwow-wild-berry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Reaching a mid-height of 20-24 inches in the full sun garden, it will bloom continually without deadheading or grooming.","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/echinacea-purpurea-powwow-wild-berry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This compact plant grows 18-24″ tall with 18-24″spread.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/echinacea/powwow-wild-berry-echinacea-seeds.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 20-24 in. tall and is winter hardy to zone 3.","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed & Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/powwow-wild-berry-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 24 - 36","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower-powwow-wild-berry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.41],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293472","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/echinacea-purpurea-powwow-wild-berry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This compact plant grows 18-24″ tall with 18-24″spread.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed & Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/powwow-wild-berry-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 12\" - 16\"","metres":[0.3,0.41],"band":[0.3,0.41],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower-powwow-wild-berry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293472","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone:\n3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/echinacea-purpurea-powwow-wild-berry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants are hardy from USDA Zones 3-9.","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Gurney's Seed & Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/powwow-wild-berry-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3-9","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower-powwow-wild-berry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293472","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"All-America Selections","url":"https://all-americaselections.org/product/echinacea-powwow-wild-berry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs:\nFull sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/echinacea-purpurea-powwow-wild-berry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun to Partial Shade"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/echinacea/powwow-wild-berry-echinacea-seeds.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun."},{"name":"Gurney's Seed & Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/powwow-wild-berry-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light\nFull Sun, Partial Shade"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ECPU","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower-powwow-wild-berry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower-powwow-wild-berry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293472","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut or dried flower.","claim":true},{"name":"All-America Selections","url":"https://all-americaselections.org/product/echinacea-powwow-wild-berry/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower:\nYes","claim":true},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/echinacea-purpurea-powwow-wild-berry/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This is a good choice for as an Accent for a Wildlife Garden or Cut Flower Garden.","claim":true},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/echinacea/powwow-wild-berry-echinacea-seeds.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"make superb cut flowers","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower-powwow-wild-berry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293472","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true},{"name":"All-America Selections","url":"https://all-americaselections.org/product/echinacea-powwow-wild-berry/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Weather Tolerance:\nDrought","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant once established and can grow in full sun to partial shade.","claim":true},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/echinacea-purpurea-powwow-wild-berry/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Established plants endure heat and some drought.","claim":true},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/echinacea/powwow-wild-berry-echinacea-seeds.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Echinaceas will tolerate some drought once established","claim":true},{"name":"Gurney's Seed & Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/powwow-wild-berry-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"maintains a strong tolerance to drought","claim":true}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower-powwow-wild-berry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293472","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"All-America Selections","url":"https://all-americaselections.org/product/echinacea-powwow-wild-berry/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator Friendly","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Several pollinators are attracted to the flower, especially butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/echinacea-purpurea-powwow-wild-berry/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Native bees, butterflies and skippers seek the nectar.","claim":true},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/echinacea/powwow-wild-berry-echinacea-seeds.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Echinaceas attract bees, butterflies, and beneficial insects.","claim":true},{"name":"Gurney's Seed & Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/powwow-wild-berry-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The brightly colored flowers attract butterflies, pollinators and hummingbirds to the area","claim":true},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ECPU","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Echinacea spp. attract butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.55,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.43,0.78],"split":[{"range":[0.43,0.61],"sources":["US Plant Patent PP26639 (Echinacea plant named 'Balsomador')","Darwin Perennials (breeder)","Walters Gardens","Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens consumer site)","Proven Winners","Plant Addicts","Saunders Brothers","Sooner Plant Farm"]},{"range":[0.64,0.78],"sources":["Mt. Cuba Center trial garden"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Darwin Perennials (breeder)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18 - 20\" (46 - 51cm)","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea hybrida"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP26639 (Echinacea plant named 'Balsomador')","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP26639P3/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height from soil level to top of plant plane: Approximately 48.1 cm.","metres":0.48,"band":[0.43,0.53],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea hybrida"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center trial garden","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/echinacea-mid-atlantic-region/echinacea-balsomador-sombrero-adobe-orange/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 28\" x 28\"","metres":0.71,"band":[0.64,0.78],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18.0-20.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens consumer site)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18.0-20.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18\" - 20\"","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 18-24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 18 - 20 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Balsomador-Sombrero-Adobe-Orange","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Tall: 18-20 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":10},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.36,0.78],"split":[{"range":[0.36,0.44],"sources":["US Plant Patent PP26639 (Echinacea plant named 'Balsomador')"]},{"range":[0.46,0.78],"sources":["Walters Gardens","Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens consumer site)","Proven Winners","Plant Addicts","Saunders Brothers","Sooner Plant Farm","Darwin Perennials (breeder)","Mt. Cuba Center trial garden"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Darwin Perennials (breeder)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 22 - 24\" (56 - 61cm)","metres":[0.56,0.61],"band":[0.56,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea hybrida"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP26639 (Echinacea plant named 'Balsomador')","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP26639P3/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: Approximately 39.5 cm.","metres":0.4,"band":[0.36,0.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea hybrida"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center trial garden","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/echinacea-mid-atlantic-region/echinacea-balsomador-sombrero-adobe-orange/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 28\" x 28\"","metres":0.71,"band":[0.64,0.78],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18.0-20.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens consumer site)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18.0-20.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18\" - 20\"","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 20-28 Inches","metres":[0.51,0.71],"band":[0.51,0.71],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 18 - 20 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Balsomador-Sombrero-Adobe-Orange","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Wide: 18-20 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":10},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","https://soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","https://plantaddicts.com/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Balsomador-Sombrero-Adobe-Orange"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-sombrero%C2%A8-adobe-orange-balsomador-pp26639-us7982110/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Darwin Perennials (breeder)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4b - 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea hybrida"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens consumer site)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b , 9a , 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Balsomador-Sombrero-Adobe-Orange","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-sombrero%C2%A8-adobe-orange-balsomador-pp26639-us7982110/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 - 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":10},"reasons":[]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 8 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 8","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens consumer site)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Sun to Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Exposure: Partial Sun to Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-sombrero%C2%A8-adobe-orange-balsomador-pp26639-us7982110/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun, Part Shade","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP26639P3/en","https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-sombrero%C2%A8-adobe-orange-balsomador-pp26639-us7982110/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"US Plant Patent PP26639 (Echinacea plant named 'Balsomador')","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP26639P3/en","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Faintly sweet.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea hybrida"},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-sombrero%C2%A8-adobe-orange-balsomador-pp26639-us7982110/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant: Yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as walters-gardens","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","https://soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","https://plantaddicts.com/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Balsomador-Sombrero-Adobe-Orange"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-sombrero%C2%A8-adobe-orange-balsomador-pp26639-us7982110/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Dried Flower Drought Tolerant Easy To Grow Mass Planting Salt Tolerant Fire Resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens consumer site)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Dried Flower Drought Tolerant Easy To Grow Mass Planting Salt Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The plants also produce pretty orange cut or dried flowers for arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Balsomador-Sombrero-Adobe-Orange","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-sombrero%C2%A8-adobe-orange-balsomador-pp26639-us7982110/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut Flower: Yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 6 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as walters-gardens; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 6","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as walters-gardens","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","https://soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","https://plantaddicts.com/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Balsomador-Sombrero-Adobe-Orange"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-sombrero%C2%A8-adobe-orange-balsomador-pp26639-us7982110/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, they are quite drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens consumer site)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, they are quite drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant Salt Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It can tolerate both salt and drought, giving it appeal to coastal and dry areas of zones 4 through 9.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Balsomador-Sombrero-Adobe-Orange","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-sombrero%C2%A8-adobe-orange-balsomador-pp26639-us7982110/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant: Yes, Once Established","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 7 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as walters-gardens; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 7; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/echinacea-mid-atlantic-region/echinacea-balsomador-sombrero-adobe-orange/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","https://soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","https://plantaddicts.com/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Balsomador-Sombrero-Adobe-Orange"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-sombrero%C2%A8-adobe-orange-balsomador-pp26639-us7982110/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Darwin Perennials (breeder)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187031533","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Characteristics: Attracts Butterflies, Deer Resistant, Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea hybrida"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center trial garden","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/echinacea-mid-atlantic-region/echinacea-balsomador-sombrero-adobe-orange/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"this was one of three red to orange flowered cultivars that were included in the top 15 insect preferred coneflowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Attracts Songbirds Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens consumer site)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=ECHAO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Attracts Songbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://soonerplantfarm.com/plant/coneflower-sombrero-adobe-orange","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sombrero-adobe-orange-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"As a plant native to North America, coneflower is an easy-care, drought-tolerant flower that attracts butterflies but resists munching deer.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Balsomador-Sombrero-Adobe-Orange","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stonehouse Nursery","url":"https://stonehousenursery.com/plant/echinacea-sombrero%C2%A8-adobe-orange-balsomador-pp26639-us7982110/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies: Yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 9 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 9","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-hot-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.55,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.66],"union":[0.41,1],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/315602/echinacea-sombrero-hot-coral-balsomcor-pbr-sombrero-series/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Growing Place (NetPS Plant Finder database entry, Plant/14799)","url":"https://plants.thegrowingplace.com/12120014/Plant/14799/Sombrero_Hot_Coral_Coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: 18 inches","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/Echinacea-purpurea-Sombrero-Hot-Coral","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 26 in","metres":0.66,"band":[0.59,0.73],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Jim Whiting Nursery and Garden Center","url":"https://plants.jimwhitingnursery.com/Plant-Name/Echinacea-Hot-Coral-Sombrero-Hot-Coral","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 24 - 26 in","metres":[0.61,0.66],"band":[0.61,0.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Echinacea-x-Sombrero-Hot-Coral-Balsomcor","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"HEIGHT: 55-60 cm","metres":[0.55,0.6],"band":[0.55,0.6],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"species":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-hot-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.5,0.51],"union":[0.45,1],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/315602/echinacea-sombrero-hot-coral-balsomcor-pbr-sombrero-series/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Growing Place (NetPS Plant Finder database entry, Plant/14799)","url":"https://plants.thegrowingplace.com/12120014/Plant/14799/Sombrero_Hot_Coral_Coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 20 inches","metres":0.51,"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/Echinacea-purpurea-Sombrero-Hot-Coral","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 22 in","metres":0.56,"band":[0.5,0.62],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Jim Whiting Nursery and Garden Center","url":"https://plants.jimwhitingnursery.com/Plant-Name/Echinacea-Hot-Coral-Sombrero-Hot-Coral","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 18 - 20 in","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Echinacea-x-Sombrero-Hot-Coral-Balsomcor","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"SPREAD: 45-50 cm","metres":[0.45,0.5],"band":[0.45,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"species":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-hot-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/Echinacea-purpurea-Sombrero-Hot-Coral","https://plants.jimwhitingnursery.com/Plant-Name/Echinacea-Hot-Coral-Sombrero-Hot-Coral"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/Echinacea-purpurea-Sombrero-Hot-Coral","https://www.gertens.com/sombrero-hot-coral-coneflower"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/Echinacea-purpurea-Sombrero-Hot-Coral","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Jim Whiting Nursery and Garden Center","url":"https://plants.jimwhitingnursery.com/Plant-Name/Echinacea-Hot-Coral-Sombrero-Hot-Coral","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center (own product attribute block)","url":"https://www.gertens.com/sombrero-hot-coral-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-hot-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/315602/echinacea-sombrero-hot-coral-balsomcor-pbr-sombrero-series/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Growing Place (NetPS Plant Finder database entry, Plant/14799)","url":"https://plants.thegrowingplace.com/12120014/Plant/14799/Sombrero_Hot_Coral_Coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/Echinacea-purpurea-Sombrero-Hot-Coral","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center (own product attribute block)","url":"https://www.gertens.com/sombrero-hot-coral-coneflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Preference Full-Sun, Part-Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Echinacea purpurea, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-hot-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP23097","https://plants.thegrowingplace.com/12120014/Plant/14799/Sombrero_Hot_Coral_Coneflower/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"United States Plant Patent USPP23097 P2, Echinacea plant named 'Balsomcor' (breeder registration, Ball Horticultural)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP23097","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Faintly sweet","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Growing Place (NetPS Plant Finder database entry, Plant/14799)","url":"https://plants.thegrowingplace.com/12120014/Plant/14799/Sombrero_Hot_Coral_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"large and fragrant flowers have striking coral petals with orange tips, surrounding a copper cone","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-hot-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://plants.thegrowingplace.com/12120014/Plant/14799/Sombrero_Hot_Coral_Coneflower/","https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/Echinacea-purpurea-Sombrero-Hot-Coral"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://plants.thegrowingplace.com/12120014/Plant/14799/Sombrero_Hot_Coral_Coneflower/","https://plants.jimwhitingnursery.com/Plant-Name/Echinacea-Hot-Coral-Sombrero-Hot-Coral"]}],"sources":[{"name":"The Growing Place (NetPS Plant Finder database entry, Plant/14799)","url":"https://plants.thegrowingplace.com/12120014/Plant/14799/Sombrero_Hot_Coral_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/Echinacea-purpurea-Sombrero-Hot-Coral","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage/Fruit","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Jim Whiting Nursery and Garden Center","url":"https://plants.jimwhitingnursery.com/Plant-Name/Echinacea-Hot-Coral-Sombrero-Hot-Coral","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-hot-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"The Growing Place (NetPS Plant Finder database entry, Plant/14799)","url":"https://plants.thegrowingplace.com/12120014/Plant/14799/Sombrero_Hot_Coral_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is considered to be drought-tolerant, and thus makes an ideal choice for a low-water garden or xeriscape application.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Jim Whiting Nursery and Garden Center","url":"https://plants.jimwhitingnursery.com/Plant-Name/Echinacea-Hot-Coral-Sombrero-Hot-Coral","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Echinacea purpurea, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant once established and can grow in full sun to partial shade.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-hot-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/315602/echinacea-sombrero-hot-coral-balsomcor-pbr-sombrero-series/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for container growing and small gardens, extremely attractive to pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Growing Place (NetPS Plant Finder database entry, Plant/14799)","url":"https://plants.thegrowingplace.com/12120014/Plant/14799/Sombrero_Hot_Coral_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies to your yard","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/Echinacea-purpurea-Sombrero-Hot-Coral","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center (own product attribute block)","url":"https://www.gertens.com/sombrero-hot-coral-coneflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Grown For Floral Features, Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Echinacea purpurea, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Several pollinators are attracted to the flower, especially butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-lemon-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.55,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.46,0.51],"union":[0.43,0.69],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=439365","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 2.25 feet","metres":[0.61,0.69],"band":[0.61,0.69],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center Trial Garden","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/echinacea-mid-atlantic-region/echinacea-balsomemy-sombrero-lemon-yellow/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"24” x 24”","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Penn State Flower Trials","url":"https://agsci.psu.edu/flower-trials/Plant-Name/Echinacea-Sombrero-Lemon-Yellow-Improved","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 19 inches","metres":0.48,"band":[0.43,0.53],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Darwin Perennials (breeder)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187002904","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18 - 20\" (46 - 51cm)","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Garden Height: 18 - 22 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.56],"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHLI","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18.0-22.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.56],"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Sombrero-Lemon-Yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Tall: 18-22 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.56],"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://www.plantaddicts.com/sombrero-lemon-yellow-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 18 - 22 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.56],"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Almost Eden","url":"https://www.almostedenplants.com/shopping/products/13600-sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows To: 18-22\"H x 22-24\"W","metres":[0.46,0.56],"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Echinacea-Sombrero--Lemon-Yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18-20 in","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":12,"species":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-lemon-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.3,0.91],"split":[{"range":[0.3,0.36],"sources":["Hoffie Nursery"]},{"range":[0.5,0.67],"sources":["Penn State Flower Trials","Mt. Cuba Center Trial Garden","Darwin Perennials (breeder)","Proven Winners","Walters Gardens","Saunders Brothers","Plant Addicts","Almost Eden"]},{"range":[0.76,0.91],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=439365","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.50 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center Trial Garden","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/echinacea-mid-atlantic-region/echinacea-balsomemy-sombrero-lemon-yellow/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"24” x 24”","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Penn State Flower Trials","url":"https://agsci.psu.edu/flower-trials/Plant-Name/Echinacea-Sombrero-Lemon-Yellow-Improved","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 22 inches","metres":0.56,"band":[0.5,0.62],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Darwin Perennials (breeder)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187002904","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 22 - 24\" (56 - 61cm)","metres":[0.56,0.61],"band":[0.56,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 22 - 24 Inches","metres":[0.56,0.61],"band":[0.56,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHLI","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 22.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.56,0.61],"band":[0.56,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Sombrero-Lemon-Yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Wide: 22-24 Inches","metres":[0.56,0.61],"band":[0.56,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://www.plantaddicts.com/sombrero-lemon-yellow-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 22 - 24 Inches","metres":[0.56,0.61],"band":[0.56,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Almost Eden","url":"https://www.almostedenplants.com/shopping/products/13600-sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows To: 18-22\"H x 22-24\"W","metres":[0.56,0.61],"band":[0.56,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Echinacea-Sombrero--Lemon-Yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12-14 in","metres":[0.3,0.36],"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":12,"species":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 3 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-lemon-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=439365","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Darwin Perennials (breeder)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187002904","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4b - 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b , 9a , 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHLI","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Sombrero-Lemon-Yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://www.plantaddicts.com/sombrero-lemon-yellow-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Almost Eden","url":"https://www.almostedenplants.com/shopping/products/13600-sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Cold Hardiness Zones (2012): 4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Echinacea-Sombrero--Lemon-Yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":12,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-lemon-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=439365","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Sun to Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHLI","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Sombrero-Lemon-Yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure • Sun • Part Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://www.plantaddicts.com/sombrero-lemon-yellow-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Exposure: Partial Sun to Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Almost Eden","url":"https://www.almostedenplants.com/shopping/products/13600-sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Outdoor Light: Full sun, Mostly sunny","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Echinacea-Sombrero--Lemon-Yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-lemon-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Sombrero-Lemon-Yellow"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","https://www.almostedenplants.com/shopping/products/13600-sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP24768P2/en"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP30116P2/en"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant, rich yellow flowers. Sturdy, upright clump. Dark green foliage.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Sombrero-Lemon-Yellow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower • Dried Flower • Drought Tolerant • Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Almost Eden","url":"https://www.almostedenplants.com/shopping/products/13600-sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Like all of the Echinaceas, the fragrant nectar rich flowers attract a variety of pollinators, especially butterflies and bees.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"US Plant Patent 24,768 ('Balsomemy', the original SOMBRERO Lemon Yellow)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP24768P2/en","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Faintly sweet.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"US Plant Patent 30,116 ('Balsomemyim', SOMBRERO Lemon Yellow Improved)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP30116P2/en","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Faintly sweet.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-lemon-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=439365","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Makes an excellent cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHLI","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Dried Flower Drought Tolerant Easy To Grow Mass Planting Focal Point Fire Resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Sombrero-Lemon-Yellow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower • Dried Flower • Drought Tolerant • Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://www.plantaddicts.com/sombrero-lemon-yellow-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It will prove to be an essential part of any cut-flower garden, and adapts to a variety of conditions.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Echinacea-Sombrero--Lemon-Yellow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Landscape Theme: Butterfly Garden Children's Garden Cottage Garden Cutting Garden Drought Tolerant Garden Native Garden Pollinator Garden Rain Garden Rock Garden","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-lemon-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=439365","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, this selection is tolerant of some drought.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Adapts to hot, windy, sunny locations. Average to dry soil is best. Drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHLI","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Dried Flower Drought Tolerant Easy To Grow Mass Planting Focal Point Fire Resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Sombrero-Lemon-Yellow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower • Dried Flower • Drought Tolerant • Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://www.plantaddicts.com/sombrero-lemon-yellow-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates: Heat, Drought, Salt","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Almost Eden","url":"https://www.almostedenplants.com/shopping/products/13600-sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Somewhat drought resistant once well-established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant once established and can grow in full sun to partial shade.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-lemon-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=439365","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to butterflies and other insect pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Darwin Perennials (breeder)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=024102187002904","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Characteristics: Attracts Butterflies, Deer Resistant, Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHLI","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Attracts Songbirds Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Echinacea-Sombrero-Lemon-Yellow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees • Attracts Butterflies • Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://www.plantaddicts.com/sombrero-lemon-yellow-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees, Birds, Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Almost Eden","url":"https://www.almostedenplants.com/shopping/products/13600-sombrero-lemon-yellow-improved-coneflower-echinacea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Like all of the Echinaceas, the fragrant nectar rich flowers attract a variety of pollinators, especially butterflies and bees.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Echinacea-Sombrero--Lemon-Yellow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attract butterflies and onlookers as well.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its flowers are attractive to bees, butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-salsa-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.55,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.66],"union":[0.38,0.91],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea-sombrero-salsa-red/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273875","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Darwin Perennials (breeder catalogue)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/products/plantinfo/?phid=024102187004883","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18 - 20\" (46 - 51cm)","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea hybrida"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP23,105 ('Balsomsed'), via Google Patents","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP23105P2/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size .-Height from soil level to top of plant plane: Approximately 41.8 cm.","metres":0.42,"band":[0.38,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea hybrida"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHSL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24.0-26.0 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.66],"band":[0.61,0.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-salsa-red-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2' - 2'2\"","metres":[0.61,0.66],"band":[0.61,0.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sombrero-salsa-red-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 24 - 26 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.66],"band":[0.61,0.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-salsa-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.46],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea-sombrero-salsa-red/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273875","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Darwin Perennials (breeder catalogue)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/products/plantinfo/?phid=024102187004883","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 22 - 24\" (56 - 61cm)","metres":[0.56,0.61],"band":[0.56,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea hybrida"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP23,105 ('Balsomsed'), via Google Patents","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP23105P2/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: Approximately 36.7 cm.","metres":0.37,"band":[0.33,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea hybrida"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHSL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 16.0-22.0 Inches","metres":[0.41,0.56],"band":[0.41,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-salsa-red-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 16\" - 22\"","metres":[0.41,0.56],"band":[0.41,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sombrero-salsa-red-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 16 - 22 Inches","metres":[0.41,0.56],"band":[0.41,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-salsa-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea-sombrero-salsa-red/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273875","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Darwin Perennials (breeder catalogue)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/products/plantinfo/?phid=024102187004883","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4b - 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea hybrida"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHSL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-salsa-red-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b , 9a , 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sombrero-salsa-red-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-salsa-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea-sombrero-salsa-red/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273875","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHSL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-salsa-red-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Sun to Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sombrero-salsa-red-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Exposure: Partial Sun to Full Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-salsa-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea-sombrero-salsa-red/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Long Bloom Season Showy","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273875","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Each mildly-aromatic flower (to 3\" diameter) features drooping, showy, deep orange-red rays in a single whorl","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP23,105 ('Balsomsed'), via Google Patents","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP23105P2/en","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Faintly sweet.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea hybrida"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHSL","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Salsa Red produces softly fragrant, spicy orange-red blossoms with an orange-brown cone.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-salsa-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea-sombrero-salsa-red/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Long Bloom Season Showy","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273875","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut or dried flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHSL","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Dried Flower Drought Tolerant Easy To Grow","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-salsa-red-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sombrero-salsa-red-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use the flowers in fresh or dried flower arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-salsa-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea-sombrero-salsa-red/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought-tolerant once established and can grow in full sun to partial shade.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273875","country":null,"form":null,"value":"An adaptable plant that is tolerant of drought, heat, humidity and poor soil.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHSL","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, they are quite drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-salsa-red-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sombrero-salsa-red-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This drought-tolerant perennial will only need to be watered during dry spells once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-sombrero-salsa-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea-sombrero-salsa-red/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Birds, butterflies, bees and hummingbirds are attracted to the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273875","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Darwin Perennials (breeder catalogue)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/products/plantinfo/?phid=024102187004883","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Characteristics: Attracts Butterflies, Deer Resistant, Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea hybrida"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHSL","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Attracts Songbirds Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/echinacea/sombrero-salsa-red-coneflower-echinacea-hybrid","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sombrero-salsa-red-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Add Sombrero Salsa Red Coneflower in hardiness zones 4 to 9 gardens to attract butterflies to your gardens.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-tomato-soup","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.73,0.8],"union":[0.61,0.91],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=270865","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-tomato-soup/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-tomato-soup/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"A real treat which grows to 32″ tall and nearly as wide.","metres":0.81,"band":[0.73,0.89],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Resource / Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-tomato-soup.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Height 70-80 cm 27-31 inches","metres":[0.7,0.8],"band":[0.7,0.8],"role":"scored"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP19,427 (Terra Nova, via Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP19427P2/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"70 cm wide and 80 cm tall to top of flowers","metres":0.8,"band":[0.72,0.88],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/echinacea-tomato-soup-pp-19427","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 32\" tall","metres":0.81,"band":[0.73,0.89],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-echinacea-tomato-soup","country":"US","form":null,"value":"24-36\" tall x 12-24\" wide.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower-tomato-soup","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.73,0.75],"union":[0.3,0.91],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=270865","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-tomato-soup/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-tomato-soup/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size (HT/W/FL HT) 22\" / 32\" / 32\"","metres":0.81,"band":[0.73,0.89],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Resource / Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-tomato-soup.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Spread 60-75 cm 23-29 inches","metres":[0.6,0.75],"band":[0.6,0.75],"role":"scored"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP19,427 (Terra Nova, via Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP19427P2/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"70 cm wide and 80 cm tall to top of flowers","metres":0.7,"band":[0.63,0.77],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-echinacea-tomato-soup","country":"US","form":null,"value":"24-36\" tall x 12-24\" wide.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower-tomato-soup","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=270865","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-tomato-soup/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-tomato-soup/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone(s): 4-9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Perennial Resource / Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-tomato-soup.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP19,427 (Terra Nova, via Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP19427P2/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 4 to 9.","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/echinacea-tomato-soup-pp-19427","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 4a to 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-echinacea-tomato-soup","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 4-9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower-tomato-soup","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=270865","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-tomato-soup/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Coneflower 'Tomato Soup' does best in full sun but will tolerate partial shade and prefers moist to dry soils."},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-tomato-soup/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun"},{"name":"Perennial Resource / Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-tomato-soup.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-echinacea-tomato-soup","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Tomato Soup requires full sun to show best red color"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower-tomato-soup","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-tomato-soup/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the bright, red blooms have a lovely, floral scent","claim":true},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-tomato-soup/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer Resistant , Fragrant , Hummingbird Attractor","claim":true},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP19,427 (Terra Nova, via Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP19427P2/en","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lovely, floral.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower-tomato-soup","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=270865","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut or dried flower.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-tomato-soup/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#cutting garden","claim":true},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-tomato-soup/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Novelty, mixed border, accent. Great cut flower.","claim":true},{"name":"Perennial Resource / Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-tomato-soup.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cutting.","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-echinacea-tomato-soup","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower-tomato-soup","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=270865","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-tomato-soup/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"it is very tolerant of many conditions, including drought, dry soil, heat, humidity, poor soil, rocky soil, and deer","claim":true},{"name":"Perennial Resource / Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-tomato-soup.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-echinacea-tomato-soup","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants tolerate heat and humidity and are drought-tolerant once established.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower-tomato-soup","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=270865","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-tomato-soup/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts birds and butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/echinacea-tomato-soup/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbird Attractor , Low Water Usage , Pollinator Attractor","claim":true},{"name":"Perennial Resource / Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/echinacea-tomato-soup.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/echinacea-tomato-soup-pp-19427","country":null,"form":null,"value":"a hummingbird feast","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-echinacea-tomato-soup","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coneflower-white-swan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.76],"union":[0.5,1],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245979&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Echinacea-purpurea-White-Swan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2-3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Echinacea-purpurea-White-Swan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2-3 ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/69049/echinacea-purpurea-white-swan/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/white-swan-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"White Swan Coneflower will grow to be about 24 inches tall at maturity extending to 32 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.","metres":[0.61,0.81],"band":[0.61,0.81],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/echinacea/echinacea-white-swan.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HEIGHT 24 - 30 inches","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Echinacea-purpurea-White-Swan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24-36 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/2315/White_Swan_Coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"White Swan Coneflower will grow to be about 24 inches tall at maturity extending to 3 feet tall with the flowers, with a spread of 3 feet.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-white-swan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.1,1],"split":[{"range":[0.1,0.67],"sources":["RHS","North Creek Nurseries","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","Buchanan's Native Plants","Hoffie Nursery"]},{"range":[0.82,1],"sources":["Gertens"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245979&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Echinacea-purpurea-White-Swan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12-18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Echinacea-purpurea-White-Swan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1-2 ft","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/69049/echinacea-purpurea-white-swan/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/white-swan-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"White Swan Coneflower will grow to be about 24 inches tall at maturity extending to 32 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Echinacea-purpurea-White-Swan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24 Inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/2315/White_Swan_Coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"White Swan Coneflower will grow to be about 24 inches tall at maturity extending to 3 feet tall with the flowers, with a spread of 3 feet.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-white-swan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245979&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Echinacea-purpurea-White-Swan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Echinacea-purpurea-White-Swan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/echinacea/echinacea-white-swan.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA ZONES 3 - 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Echinacea-purpurea-White-Swan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-white-swan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245979&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Echinacea-purpurea-White-Swan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure • Full Sun • Part Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/69049/echinacea-purpurea-white-swan/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/white-swan-coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/echinacea/echinacea-white-swan.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ENVIRONMENT Full sun to partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Echinacea-purpurea-White-Swan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure • Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/2315/White_Swan_Coneflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-white-swan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["light","light"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/white-swan-coneflower/","https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/echinacea/echinacea-white-swan.html"]},{"tier":4,"why":"both carry the same 203 character sentence, so one is reprinting the other","urls":["https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/white-swan-coneflower/","https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/2315/White_Swan_Coneflower/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/white-swan-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"White Swan Coneflower has masses of beautiful lightly-scented white daisy flowers with brown eyes at the ends of the stems from mid summer to mid fall, which are most effective when planted in groupings.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/echinacea/echinacea-white-swan.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"White Swan Coneflower (Echinacea Purpurea alba) - Huge, pure white, wonderfully fragrant blooms burst on top of these hardy, drought tolerant native plants that bloom freely over a very long season.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/2315/White_Swan_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"White Swan Coneflower has masses of beautiful lightly-scented white daisy flowers with brown eyes at the ends of the stems from mid summer to mid fall, which are most effective when planted in groupings.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first; both carry the same 203 character sentence, so one is reprinting the other. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-white-swan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245979&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut Good Dried Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Echinacea-purpurea-White-Swan","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Their roots have famous medicinal qualities, they make great, long lasting, cut flowers and attract numerous butterflies and small birds.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/69049/echinacea-purpurea-white-swan/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers Flower borders and beds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/white-swan-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/echinacea/echinacea-white-swan.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Available in 2 sizes, their long-lasting blooms are excellent for cut flowers and attract pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Echinacea-purpurea-White-Swan","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attributes • Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/2315/White_Swan_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coneflower-white-swan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245979&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Dry Soil Heat Humidity Poor Soil Salt","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Echinacea-purpurea-White-Swan","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants are tough and heat and drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Echinacea-purpurea-White-Swan","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerance • Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/white-swan-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is considered to be drought-tolerant, and thus makes an ideal choice for a low-water garden or xeriscape application.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/echinacea/echinacea-white-swan.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"White Swan Coneflower (Echinacea Purpurea alba) - Huge, pure white, wonderfully fragrant blooms burst on top of these hardy, drought tolerant native plants that bloom freely over a very long season.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coneflower-white-swan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245979&isprofile=0&gen=Echinacea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinacea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its flowers are attractive to bees, butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Echinacea-purpurea-White-Swan","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Their roots have famous medicinal qualities, they make great, long lasting, cut flowers and attract numerous butterflies and small birds.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Echinacea-purpurea-White-Swan","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wildlife • Attracts Bees • Attracts Songbirds • Other Pollinators/Wildlife • Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/69049/echinacea-purpurea-white-swan/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Echinacea are erect, clump-forming rhizomatous perennials with simple or pinnately lobed leaves and solitary, long-stalked daisies with prominent conical central disks and often drooping ray florets; attractive to butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/white-swan-coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies to your yard, but is not particularly attractive to deer who tend to leave it alone in favor of tastier treats.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/echinacea/echinacea-white-swan.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"White Swan Coneflower is known for its large, daisy-like white blooms and russet cones, attracting butterflies from all around.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Echinacea-purpurea-White-Swan","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wildlife • Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/2315/White_Swan_Coneflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies to your yard, but is not particularly attractive to deer who tend to leave it alone in favor of tastier treats.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinacea purpurea"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coral-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.2,0.67],"split":[{"range":[0.2,0.46],"sources":["RHS growing guide: How to grow heuchera","N.C. Cooperative Extension, Brunswick County Center: Heuchera (Coral Bells, Alumroot)","Illinois Extension, Landscaping / Ground Covers: Coral Bells (Heuchera sp.)","Utah State University Extension: Landscaping in Dry Shade (Heuchera / Coral bells entry)"]},{"range":[0.55,0.67],"sources":["UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County: What can you tell me about the plant called Coral Bells?"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"N.C. Cooperative Extension, Brunswick County Center: Heuchera (Coral Bells, Alumroot)","url":"https://brunswick.ces.ncsu.edu/news/heuchera-coral-bells-alumroot/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"When in bloom, the plants reach 12- to 16-in. tall","metres":[0.3,0.41],"band":[0.3,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Landscaping / Ground Covers: Coral Bells (Heuchera sp.)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/landscaping/coral-bells","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants grow to 12–16 inches in nice tight mounds.","metres":[0.3,0.41],"band":[0.3,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension: Landscaping in Dry Shade (Heuchera / Coral bells entry)","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/cwel/research/landscaping-in-dry-shade","country":"US","form":null,"value":"is an herbaceous perennial with a mounding habit that grows 1 to 1 ½ feet tall and wide","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County: What can you tell me about the plant called Coral Bells?","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/06/14/q-can-tell-plant-called-coral-bells","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plant reaches heights of about 2 feet with 1-2 foot spread.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"RHS growing guide: How to grow heuchera","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/heuchera/growing-guide","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Heucheras are compact, with their mounds of foliage generally around 20–30cm (8–12in) tall and wide","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":11,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.2,0.61],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Utah State University Extension: Landscaping in Dry Shade (Heuchera / Coral bells entry)","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/cwel/research/landscaping-in-dry-shade","country":"US","form":null,"value":"is an herbaceous perennial with a mounding habit that grows 1 to 1 ½ feet tall and wide","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County: What can you tell me about the plant called Coral Bells?","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/06/14/q-can-tell-plant-called-coral-bells","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plant reaches heights of about 2 feet with 1-2 foot spread.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"RHS growing guide: How to grow heuchera","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/heuchera/growing-guide","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Heucheras are compact, with their mounds of foliage generally around 20–30cm (8–12in) tall and wide","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":11,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener newsletter: Heuchera Provides Bold, Colorful Foliage","url":"https://extensiongardener.ces.ncsu.edu/gardening-publications-2/extgardener-previous-newsletters/extgardener-past-features/extgardener-heuchera-provides-bold-colorful-foliage/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"is hardy from zones 4 to 9 depending on species and cultivar","zones":[4,9],"level":"genus"},{"name":"N.C. Cooperative Extension, Brunswick County Center: Heuchera (Coral Bells, Alumroot)","url":"https://brunswick.ces.ncsu.edu/news/heuchera-coral-bells-alumroot/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Depending on species and variety, they grow in zones 3 (Zone 3 plants can withstand cold temperatures of -40°F to -30°F) to 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County: What can you tell me about the plant called Coral Bells?","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/06/14/q-can-tell-plant-called-coral-bells","country":"US","form":null,"value":"There is conflicting information regarding their cold hardiness zones which range from zones 4 – 9.","zones":[4,9],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":11,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Heuchera sanguinea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d250","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"heuchera sanguinea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Heuchera sanguinea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/heuchera-sanguinea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"heuchera sanguinea"},{"name":"N.C. Cooperative Extension, Brunswick County Center: Heuchera (Coral Bells, Alumroot)","url":"https://brunswick.ces.ncsu.edu/news/heuchera-coral-bells-alumroot/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In the South, these perennials grow best in partial shade","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC: Heuchera - Coral Bells","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/heuchera-coral-bells/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In the South, these perennials grow best in partial shade, preferring morning sunlight and afternoon shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers: Coral Bells (Heuchera sanguinea)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/coral-bells","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun, Partial Sun/Shade","level":"species","taxon":"heuchera sanguinea"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers: Coral Bells (Heuchera sanguinea)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=728&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Full Sun Partial Sun/Shade","level":"species","taxon":"heuchera sanguinea"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden: Heuchera or Coral Bells","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/2021/06/heuchera-or-coral-bells","country":"US","form":null,"value":"most Heuchera grow best in partial shade to full sun in moist, but well-drained soils in Iowa","level":"genus"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery / Juniper Level Botanic Garden: Ringing the Coral Bells - The Heuchera Story","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/blogs/articles/coral-bells-heuchera-plant-varieties","country":"US","form":null,"value":"A light open woodland or light shade to part sun spot is perfect.","level":"genus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["heuchera sanguinea"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (heuchera sanguinea), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (heuchera sanguinea) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"RHS Plant Guide: Heuchera (Coral bells)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/heuchera","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Heucheras dislike permanently wet, heavy or very dry soil and deep shade.","claim":false,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery / Juniper Level Botanic Garden: Ringing the Coral Bells - The Heuchera Story","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/blogs/articles/coral-bells-heuchera-plant-varieties","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Heuchera and x Heucherella both have good drought tolerance.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["heuchera sanguinea"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (heuchera sanguinea), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"SPLIT"},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (heuchera sanguinea) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Heuchera, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/heuchera/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attractive pink or red flowers that are favored by butterflies and bees","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener newsletter: Heuchera Provides Bold, Colorful Foliage","url":"https://extensiongardener.ces.ncsu.edu/gardening-publications-2/extgardener-previous-newsletters/extgardener-past-features/extgardener-heuchera-provides-bold-colorful-foliage/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"many species also have attractive flowers that are favored by butterflies","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"N.C. Cooperative Extension, Brunswick County Center: Heuchera (Coral Bells, Alumroot)","url":"https://brunswick.ces.ncsu.edu/news/heuchera-coral-bells-alumroot/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"favored by hummingbirds, butterflies, and bees","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden: Heuchera or Coral Bells","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/2021/06/heuchera-or-coral-bells","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are attractive to many pollinators, including hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County: What can you tell me about the plant called Coral Bells?","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/06/14/q-can-tell-plant-called-coral-bells","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flower apparently also attracts butterflies and bees.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden plant profile: Coral Bells (Heuchera spp.)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/plant-information/coral-bells","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Red-flowered coral bells are known to attract hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"RHS growing guide: How to grow heuchera","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/heuchera/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are popular with pollinating insects","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["heuchera sanguinea"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (heuchera sanguinea), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (heuchera sanguinea) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"coral-bells-forever-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.35,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.3,0.33],"union":[0.27,0.41],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/heuchera-forever-purple/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"12″ / 22″ / 15″","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/forever-purple-coral-bells/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"12 - 16 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.41],"band":[0.3,0.41],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-forever-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.45,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"edge","consensus":[0.5,0.61],"union":[0.46,0.62],"edge":[0.45,0.63],"edgeMargin":2.2,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/heuchera-forever-purple/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"12″ / 22″ / 15″","metres":0.56,"band":[0.5,0.62],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/forever-purple-coral-bells/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"18 - 24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"withdrawnFromV2":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.55},"note":"the catalog value sits 2.2% outside the sources' union (0.46 to 0.62 m) and inside the 3% margin v3 allows at a stated range edge (0.45 to 0.63 m), so v2's proposal of 0.55 m is withdrawn rather than applied; 1 of these 2 scored sources publish a range, and a range edge is a figure converted and rounded from another unit rather than a measurement to the centimetre","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-forever-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/heuchera-forever-purple/","https://plantaddicts.com/forever-purple-coral-bells/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/heuchera-forever-purple/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4-9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/forever-purple-coral-bells/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 9","zones":[4,9]}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-forever-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-forever-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-forever-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-forever-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/forever-purple-coral-bells/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates: Drought","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-forever-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/forever-purple-coral-bells/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-lime-rickey","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c468","country":"US","form":null,"value":"0.75 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.23,0.46],"band":[0.23,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-lime-rickey","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c468","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-lime-rickey","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c468","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"TERRA NOVA Nurseries (breeder/introducer) growing recipe PDF","url":"https://terranovanurseries.com/growing_recipes/Heuchera-Lime-Rickey.pdf","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4 - 9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-lime-rickey","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-shade","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c468","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-lime-rickey","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-lime-rickey","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-lime-rickey","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-lime-rickey","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-marmalade","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.35,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.23,0.28],"union":[0.23,0.46],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=262340&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.75 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.23,0.46],"band":[0.23,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/heuchera-marmalade-marmalade-coral-bells","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature size is 10 inches tall by 18 inches wide.","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/heuchera-marmalade/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size (HT/W/FL HT) 10\" / 18\" / 16\"","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Annie's Annuals & Perennials","url":"https://www.anniesannuals.com/products/heuchera-marmalade","country":"US","form":null,"value":"this eye-catching Heuchera reaches about 12–18\" tall and wide","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-marmalade","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.45,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.41,0.46],"union":[0.23,0.51],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=262340&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.75 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.23,0.46],"band":[0.23,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/heuchera-marmalade-marmalade-coral-bells","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature size is 10 inches tall by 18 inches wide.","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/heuchera-marmalade/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size (HT/W/FL HT) 10\" / 18\" / 16\"","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Annie's Annuals & Perennials","url":"https://www.anniesannuals.com/products/heuchera-marmalade","country":"US","form":null,"value":"this eye-catching Heuchera reaches about 12–18\" tall and wide","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-marmalade","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-9","4-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=262340&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/heuchera-marmalade-marmalade-coral-bells","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4 - 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/heuchera-marmalade/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone(s): 4-9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Annie's Annuals & Perennials","url":"https://www.anniesannuals.com/products/heuchera-marmalade","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11","zones":[4,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-marmalade","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=262340&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/heuchera-marmalade-marmalade-coral-bells","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/heuchera-marmalade/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Part Shade , Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-marmalade","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-marmalade","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-marmalade","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/heuchera-marmalade/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Award Winners , Deep South , Hummingbird Attractor , Low Water Usage , Pollinator Attractor , Winter Color","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-marmalade","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/heuchera-marmalade-marmalade-coral-bells","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It will attract hummingbirds and bees when in flower and is resistant to deer.","claim":true},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/heuchera-marmalade/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Award Winners , Deep South , Hummingbird Attractor , Low Water Usage , Pollinator Attractor , Winter Color","claim":true},{"name":"Annie's Annuals & Perennials","url":"https://www.anniesannuals.com/products/heuchera-marmalade","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Airy sprays of small flowers rise above the foliage, attracting pollinators and adding graceful movement.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-obsidian","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.35,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.23,0.28],"union":[0.1,0.61],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=258936&isprofile=1&basic=Heuchera","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"TERRA NOVA Nurseries (breeder and introducer)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/heuchera-obsidian/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size (HT/W/FL HT) 10\" / 16\" / 24\"","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP14,836 (Heuchera plant named 'Obsidian')","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP14836P2/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size.- 23 cm tall and 35 cm wide.","metres":0.23,"band":[0.21,0.25],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=HEUOB","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10.0 Inches","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/heuchera-obsidian.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Height 25-60 cm 10-23 inches","metres":[0.25,0.6],"band":[0.25,0.6],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Heuchera-x-Obsidian","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 16 Inches","metres":0.41,"band":[0.37,0.45],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Platt Hill Nursery (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.platthillnursery.com/12120026/Plant/2521/Obsidian_Coral_Bells/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Obsidian Coral Bells will grow to be about 10 inches tall at maturity extending to 24 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 12 inches.","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/heuchera","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Heuchera 'Obsidian' PBR alum root 'Obsidian' Height 0.1-0.5 metres Width 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"genus":1,"species":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-obsidian","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.37,0.39],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=258936&isprofile=1&basic=Heuchera","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.75 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.23,0.46],"band":[0.23,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"TERRA NOVA Nurseries (breeder and introducer)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/heuchera-obsidian/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size (HT/W/FL HT) 10\" / 16\" / 24\"","metres":0.41,"band":[0.37,0.45],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP14,836 (Heuchera plant named 'Obsidian')","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP14836P2/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size.- 23 cm tall and 35 cm wide.","metres":0.35,"band":[0.32,0.39],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=HEUOB","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12.0-16.0 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.41],"band":[0.3,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/heuchera-obsidian.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Spread 30-40 cm 12-16 inches","metres":[0.3,0.4],"band":[0.3,0.4],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Heuchera-x-Obsidian","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 16 Inches","metres":0.41,"band":[0.37,0.45],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Platt Hill Nursery (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.platthillnursery.com/12120026/Plant/2521/Obsidian_Coral_Bells/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Obsidian Coral Bells will grow to be about 10 inches tall at maturity extending to 24 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 12 inches.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/heuchera","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Heuchera 'Obsidian' PBR alum root 'Obsidian' Height 0.1-0.5 metres Width 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"genus":1,"species":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-obsidian","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=258936&isprofile=1&basic=Heuchera","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"TERRA NOVA Nurseries (breeder and introducer)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/heuchera-obsidian/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone(s): 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP14,836 (Heuchera plant named 'Obsidian')","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP14836P2/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness.- USDA Zone 4 to 9.","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=HEUOB","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/heuchera-obsidian.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"genus":1,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-obsidian","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=258936&isprofile=1&basic=Heuchera","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"TERRA NOVA Nurseries (breeder and introducer)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/heuchera-obsidian/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Part Shade , Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=HEUOB","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/heuchera-obsidian.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun or Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Heuchera-x-Obsidian","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade/Shade Tolerant","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Platt Hill Nursery (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.platthillnursery.com/12120026/Plant/2521/Obsidian_Coral_Bells/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant performs well in both full sun and full shade.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/heuchera/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"genus","taxon":"heuchera"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/heuchera-americana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"heuchera americana"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-obsidian","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"US Plant Patent PP14,836 (Heuchera plant named 'Obsidian')","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP14836P2/en","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance.- None.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-obsidian","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Platt Hill Nursery (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.platthillnursery.com/12120026/Plant/2521/Obsidian_Coral_Bells/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"tall flower spikes of creamy white appear during the early summer; flowers are suitable for cutting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-obsidian","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"TERRA NOVA Nurseries (breeder and introducer)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/heuchera-obsidian/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Uses Award Winners , Deep South , Hummingbird Attractor , Low Water Usage , Pollinator Attractor , Winter Color","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/heuchera-americana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"American alumroot is drought-tolerant and works well planted in small groups in the front of a border, along pathways, near a patio, in a woodland, rock, rain or shade garden.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"heuchera americana"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-obsidian","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"TERRA NOVA Nurseries (breeder and introducer)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/heuchera-obsidian/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Uses Award Winners , Deep South , Hummingbird Attractor , Low Water Usage , Pollinator Attractor , Winter Color","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=HEUOB","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Platt Hill Nursery (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.platthillnursery.com/12120026/Plant/2521/Obsidian_Coral_Bells/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting hummingbirds to your yard.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/heuchera/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Hummingbirds Specialized Bees","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"heuchera"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/heuchera-americana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Pollinators Specialized Bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"heuchera americana"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coral-bells-palace-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.25,0.46],"union":[0.18,0.61],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/heuchera-palace-purple/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 8 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d240","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Perennial Plant Association, Perennial Plant of the Year","url":"https://perennialplantoftheyear.com/2025/02/05/heuchera/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 12-18 inches tall","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HEUPP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8.0-12.0 Inches","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/heuchera-micrantha-palace-purple.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Height 30-60 cm 12-23 inches","metres":[0.3,0.6],"band":[0.3,0.6],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Heuchera-micrantha-Palace-Purple-","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12-18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/palace-purple-coral-bells","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height (Range) 7-12\"","metres":[0.18,0.3],"band":[0.18,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/HEUCHERA-PALACE-PURPLE","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18-24 in","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Heuchera-micrantha-Palace-Purple","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"HEIGHT: 25-30 cm","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":9,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-palace-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.4,0.41],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/heuchera-palace-purple/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 4 in.","metres":[0.3,0.41],"band":[0.3,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d240","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HEUPP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12.0-16.0 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.41],"band":[0.3,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/heuchera-micrantha-palace-purple.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Spread 30-45 cm 12-18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.45],"band":[0.3,0.45],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Heuchera-micrantha-Palace-Purple-","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12-18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/palace-purple-coral-bells","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread (Range) 12\" - 24\"","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Heuchera-micrantha-Palace-Purple","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"SPREAD: 40-45 cm","metres":[0.4,0.45],"band":[0.4,0.45],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":9,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-palace-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","4-8","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/heuchera-palace-purple/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d240","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Perennial Plant Association, Perennial Plant of the Year","url":"https://perennialplantoftheyear.com/2025/02/05/heuchera/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness USDA Zones 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HEUPP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/heuchera-micrantha-palace-purple.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Heuchera-micrantha-Palace-Purple-","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/palace-purple-coral-bells","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/HEUCHERA-PALACE-PURPLE","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":9,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-palace-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/heuchera-palace-purple/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"'Palace Purple' should be planted with the crown at or above the soil surface in organically rich soil, in the sun or partial shade.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d240","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Perennial Plant Association, Perennial Plant of the Year","url":"https://perennialplantoftheyear.com/2025/02/05/heuchera/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun in northern gardens to partial shade in areas with very long, hot summers","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HEUPP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/heuchera-micrantha-palace-purple.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun or Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/palace-purple-coral-bells","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Preference Full-Sun, Part-Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/HEUCHERA-PALACE-PURPLE","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Partial Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Heuchera-micrantha-Palace-Purple","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Grows best in an average to moist well-drained soil in partial sun.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-palace-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-palace-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.perennials.com/plants/heuchera-micrantha-palace-purple.html","https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Heuchera-micrantha-Palace-Purple-"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.perennials.com/plants/heuchera-micrantha-palace-purple.html","https://www.gertens.com/palace-purple-coral-bells"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/heuchera-micrantha-palace-purple.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Heuchera-micrantha-Palace-Purple-","country":null,"form":null,"value":"An attractive accent in the garden or cut flower arrangement.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/palace-purple-coral-bells","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Early Summer-Mid Summer Bloom;Bronze- Purple Black Foliage;Attracts Butterflies;Cut Flower;Deer Resistant and Rabbit Resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-palace-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/heuchera-palace-purple/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Planting in full sun will require extra care in watering, as the soil should not be allowed to dry out.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d240","country":null,"form":null,"value":"If grown in full sun, consistent moisture is needed and soil should not be allowed to dry out.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/palace-purple-coral-bells","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It prefers to grow in average to moist conditions, and shouldn't be allowed to dry out.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"}],"note":"3 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coral-bells-palace-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/heuchera-palace-purple/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees, butterflies, and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HEUPP","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/heuchera-micrantha-palace-purple.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/palace-purple-coral-bells","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting hummingbirds to your yard.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/HEUCHERA-PALACE-PURPLE","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Heuchera-micrantha-Palace-Purple","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"heuchera micrantha"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Heuchera genus entry","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/heuchera/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"heuchera"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coreopsis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.91],"union":[0.15,1.22],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/native-plant-spotlight-tickseed-coreopsis-spp/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"There are multiple species native to South Carolina, ranging from 6 in to 4 ft tall at maturity.","metres":[0.15,1.22],"band":[0.15,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/1993/6-23-1993/coreop.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"There are several species of Coreopsis to select from offering a range of plant heights from less than 1 foot to almost 4 feet.","metres":[0.3,1.22],"band":[0.3,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Georgia Cooperative Extension, Bulletin B944 Flowering Perennials for Georgia Gardens","url":"https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=B944&title=flowering-perennials-for-georgia-gardens","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Coreopsis grows from 1 to 3 feet high and bloom from May to fall if the old flowers are removed.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":6,"species":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":6,"species":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/native-plant-spotlight-tickseed-coreopsis-spp/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy in USDA zones 4a-9b, with the exception of swamp and coastal tickseed, which are hardy in zones 7a-10b.","zones":[4,9],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":6,"species":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/native-plant-spotlight-tickseed-coreopsis-spp/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants need full sun, at least 6 hours a day.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/1993/6-23-1993/coreop.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They perform best in full sun or light shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Georgia Cooperative Extension, Bulletin B944 Flowering Perennials for Georgia Gardens","url":"https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=B944&title=flowering-perennials-for-georgia-gardens","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows best in full sun and is fairly drought tolerant.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Proven Winners, How to Grow Coreopsis","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-to/coreopsis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant coreopsis in a site that receives full sun","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Coreopsis verticillata","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=n870","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Coreopsis grandiflora","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/coreopsis-grandiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"coreopsis grandiflora"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers: Tickseed","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/tickseed","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"coreopsis grandiflora"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Coreopsis lanceolata","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=cola5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade , Shade","level":"species","taxon":"coreopsis lanceolata"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/1993/6-23-1993/coreop.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Coreopsis can also be used as fresh cut flowers, especially those with long flower stems.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["coreopsis lanceolata"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (coreopsis lanceolata), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (coreopsis lanceolata) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/native-plant-spotlight-tickseed-coreopsis-spp/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Coreopsis species are low-maintenance, hardy, and extremely drought-tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/1993/6-23-1993/coreop.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other advantages include drought tolerance, poor soil adaptability, and durability.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Georgia Cooperative Extension, Bulletin B944 Flowering Perennials for Georgia Gardens","url":"https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=B944&title=flowering-perennials-for-georgia-gardens","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It grows best in full sun and is fairly drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Proven Winners, How to Grow Coreopsis","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-to/coreopsis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants are drought tolerant once established","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/coreopsis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, this Florida-Friendly plant is drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension Service","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/blogs/extension-for-real-life/coreopsis-mississippis-state-wildflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It tolerates the Mississippi heat well and can handle drought spells.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Coreopsis verticillata","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=n870","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Coreopsis grandiflora","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/coreopsis-grandiflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#drought tolerant #dry soils tolerant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"coreopsis grandiflora"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Coreopsis lanceolata","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=cola5","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant but is not a reliably perennial.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"coreopsis lanceolata"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/native-plant-spotlight-tickseed-coreopsis-spp/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tickseed makes a great pollinator plant that provides nectar throughout the season.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Proven Winners, How to Grow Coreopsis","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-to/coreopsis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are a rich nectar source for insect pollinators, while the seeds provide food for songbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"American Meadows, All About Coreopsis","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/perennials/coreopsis/all-about-coreopsis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Coreopsis attracts butterflies, beneficial insects, and birds","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/coreopsis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They attract butterflies, honeybees and native bees.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension Service","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/blogs/extension-for-real-life/coreopsis-mississippis-state-wildflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Coreopsis is great to have in your garden because it attracts a wide range of pollinators, including butterflies, bees, and other insects.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Coreopsis verticillata","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=n870","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Coreopsis grandiflora","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/coreopsis-grandiflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"coreopsis grandiflora"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Coreopsis lanceolata","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=cola5","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"coreopsis lanceolata"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-jethro-tull","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-coreopsis-jethro-tull","country":"US","form":null,"value":"15-18\" tall","metres":[0.38,0.46],"band":[0.38,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-jethro-tull","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-coreopsis-jethro-tull","country":"US","form":null,"value":"18-24\" wide","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-jethro-tull","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-coreopsis-jethro-tull","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-jethro-tull","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-coreopsis-jethro-tull","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-jethro-tull","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-jethro-tull","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-coreopsis-jethro-tull","country":null,"form":null,"value":"both in the garden and as cut flowers","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-jethro-tull","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-coreopsis-jethro-tull","country":null,"form":null,"value":"is drought-tolerant once established","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-jethro-tull","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-coreopsis-jethro-tull","country":null,"form":null,"value":"commanding attention and enticing pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-mercury-rising","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.46],"union":[0.3,0.46],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299642","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-coreopsis-mercury-rising","country":"US","form":null,"value":"16-18\" tall","metres":[0.41,0.46],"band":[0.41,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-mercury-rising","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.61,0.91],"proposed":0.76,"margin":34.4,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299642","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-coreopsis-mercury-rising","country":"US","form":null,"value":"24-36\" wide","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.61 to 0.91 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-mercury-rising","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299642","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-mercury-rising","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299642","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-coreopsis-mercury-rising","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-mercury-rising","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-mercury-rising","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299642","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy, Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-coreopsis-mercury-rising","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-mercury-rising","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299642","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer, Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-coreopsis-mercury-rising","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dry Sites","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-mercury-rising","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299642","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-coreopsis-mercury-rising","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-moonbeam","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.5],"union":[0.1,0.91],"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant grows 1-3 feet tall with a similar spread and has many light yellow flowers all summer long.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"anacis verticillata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c260","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer, trade site)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CORMO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens consumer site (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 30-45 cm 12-18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/coreopsis/moonbeam-threadleaf-coreopsis-coreopsis-verticillata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Garden Height: 15 - 18 Inches","metres":[0.38,0.46],"band":[0.38,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Coreopsis-verticillata-Moonbeam","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18-24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Coreopsis-verticillata-Moonbeam","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18-24 in","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Gertens (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/2257/Moonbeam_Coreopsis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Moonbeam Coreopsis will grow to be about 18 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 24 inches.","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam-threadleaf-coreopsis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It blooms in the summer and grows to a height of 18 inches.","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/4370/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-moonbeam","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.5],"union":[0.1,0.91],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant grows 1-3 feet tall with a similar spread and has many light yellow flowers all summer long.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"anacis verticillata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c260","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer, trade site)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CORMO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens consumer site (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 30-45 cm 12-18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/coreopsis/moonbeam-threadleaf-coreopsis-coreopsis-verticillata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 16 - 20 Inches","metres":[0.41,0.51],"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Coreopsis-verticillata-Moonbeam","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18-24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Coreopsis-verticillata-Moonbeam","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18-24 in","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Gertens (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/2257/Moonbeam_Coreopsis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Moonbeam Coreopsis will grow to be about 18 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 24 inches.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/4370/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-moonbeam","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","4-9","5-8","3-8","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"anacis verticillata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c260","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer, trade site)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CORMO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens consumer site (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/coreopsis/moonbeam-threadleaf-coreopsis-coreopsis-verticillata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3a , 3b , 4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b , 9a , 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Coreopsis-verticillata-Moonbeam","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Coreopsis-verticillata-Moonbeam","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam-threadleaf-coreopsis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5 - 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-moonbeam","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"anacis verticillata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c260","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer, trade site)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CORMO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens consumer site (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Coreopsis-verticillata-Moonbeam","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure • Full Sun • Part Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Coreopsis-verticillata-Moonbeam","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers well-drained soil in full sun.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Gertens (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/2257/Moonbeam_Coreopsis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam-threadleaf-coreopsis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It prefers full sun and a well-drained site and makes an excellent border plant.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/4370/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Grow in a fertile, well-drained soil in full sun or partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/coreopsis-verticillata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"anacis verticillata"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-moonbeam","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-moonbeam","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer, trade site)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CORMO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Drought Tolerant Easy To Grow Mass Planting Fire Resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens consumer site (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Coreopsis-verticillata-Moonbeam","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Makes a nice cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Gertens (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/2257/Moonbeam_Coreopsis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/4370/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower borders and beds Cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coreopsis-moonbeam","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is also drought, deer, heat and humidity tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"anacis verticillata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c260","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer, trade site)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CORMO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Drought Tolerant Easy To Grow Mass Planting Fire Resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens consumer site (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of hot, dry sites, once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/coreopsis/moonbeam-threadleaf-coreopsis-coreopsis-verticillata","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Award Winner Heat Tolerant Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Coreopsis-verticillata-Moonbeam","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attributes • Native to North America • Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Coreopsis-verticillata-Moonbeam","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Upright clump-forming grower. Cut spent flowers to promote re-bloom. Prefers well-drained soil in full sun. Drought tolerant. May be divided in spring or fall.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Gertens (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/2257/Moonbeam_Coreopsis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Non-stop parade of yellow blooms throughout summer; delicate, fine textured foliage-good drought tolerance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/coreopsis-verticillata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant thrives with full sun to partial shade in infertile sandy and rocky soils and tolerates drought, low levels of salt, infertile soil, heat, and humidity.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anacis verticillata"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-moonbeam","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees and butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"anacis verticillata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c260","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer, trade site)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CORMO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens consumer site (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/coreopsis/moonbeam-threadleaf-coreopsis-coreopsis-verticillata","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Coreopsis-verticillata-Moonbeam","country":null,"form":null,"value":"For Animals • Pollinator-friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Gertens (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/2257/Moonbeam_Coreopsis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies to your yard","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/coreopsis-verticillata-moonbeam-threadleaf-coreopsis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Interest: Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/coreopsis-verticillata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its nectar are attractive to butterflies and other pollinators. Its seeds are eaten by songbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anacis verticillata"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-pink-sapphire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.35,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.36,0.4],"union":[0.32,0.41],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/coreopsis-pink-sapphire/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"14″ / 16″ / 16″","metres":0.36,"band":[0.32,0.4],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/tickseed-pink-sapphire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"14-16 Inches","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-pink-sapphire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.38,0.41],"union":[0.37,0.45],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/coreopsis-pink-sapphire/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"14″ / 16″ / 16″","metres":0.41,"band":[0.37,0.45],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/tickseed-pink-sapphire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"15-16 Inches","metres":[0.38,0.41],"band":[0.38,0.41],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-pink-sapphire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/coreopsis-pink-sapphire/","https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/tickseed-pink-sapphire"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/coreopsis-pink-sapphire/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6-10","zones":[6,10]},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/tickseed-pink-sapphire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6-10","zones":[6,10]}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[6,10]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-pink-sapphire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries (breeder)","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/coreopsis-pink-sapphire/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/tickseed-pink-sapphire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-pink-sapphire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-pink-sapphire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-pink-sapphire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/tickseed-pink-sapphire","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-pink-sapphire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/tickseed-pink-sapphire","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-zagreb","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.42],"union":[0.27,0.51],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c270","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CORZA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 15.0 Inches","metres":0.38,"band":[0.34,0.42],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 30-45 cm 12-18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Coreopsis-verticillata-Zagreb","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12-18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18 Inches","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant is generally 1' tall with a 1.5' spread.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Coreopsis-verticilata-Zagreb","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12-18 in","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Growing Colors","url":"https://www.growingcolors.com/plant/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 15 in","metres":0.38,"band":[0.34,0.42],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-zagreb","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.48],"union":[0.2,0.67],"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c270","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 1.50 feet","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CORZA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12.0-15.0 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.38],"band":[0.3,0.38],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 30-45 cm 12-18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Coreopsis-verticillata-Zagreb","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18-24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24 Inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant is generally 1' tall with a 1.5' spread.","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Coreopsis-verticilata-Zagreb","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 8-14 in","metres":[0.2,0.36],"band":[0.2,0.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Growing Colors","url":"https://www.growingcolors.com/plant/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 11-19 in","metres":[0.28,0.48],"band":[0.28,0.48],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-zagreb","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","4-9","5-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c270","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CORZA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Coreopsis-verticillata-Zagreb","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants are hardy from USDA Zones 3-9.","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Coreopsis-verticilata-Zagreb","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Growing Colors","url":"https://www.growingcolors.com/plant/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-zagreb","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c270","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anacis-verticillata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"anacis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CORZA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Coreopsis-verticillata-Zagreb","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure • Full Sun • Part Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Coreopsis-verticilata-Zagreb","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure • Sun • Part Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-zagreb","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-zagreb","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anacis-verticillata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Landscape Theme: Butterfly Garden Children's Garden Cottage Garden Cutting Garden Drought Tolerant Garden Native Garden Pollinator Garden Rock Garden","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anacis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CORZA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Drought Tolerant Easy To Grow Mass Planting Fire Resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Coreopsis-verticillata-Zagreb","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Makes a good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Growing Colors","url":"https://www.growingcolors.com/plant/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attributes • Good Container Plant • Good Cut Flower / Foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"coreopsis-zagreb","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c270","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anacis-verticillata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Dry Soil Heat Humidity","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anacis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CORZA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Drought Tolerant Easy To Grow Mass Planting Fire Resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of hot, dry sites once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Coreopsis-verticillata-Zagreb","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attributes • Native to North America • Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants thrive in infertile sandy and rocky soils and tolerate drought, some salt, infertile soil, heat and humidity.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Coreopsis-verticilata-Zagreb","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerance • Drought Tolerant • Deer/Rabbit Resistant • Urban Environment","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Growing Colors","url":"https://www.growingcolors.com/plant/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb","country":null,"form":null,"value":"· Drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"coreopsis-zagreb","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anacis-verticillata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its nectar are attractive to butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anacis verticillata"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CORZA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Perennials.com (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plant Uses & Characteristics Accent: Good Texture/Form Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds Border Containers Cut Flower Deer Resistant Drought Tolerant Edging Rabbit Resistant Massed Wild Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Coreopsis-verticillata-Zagreb","country":null,"form":null,"value":"For Animals • Pollinator-friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wildlife • Attracts Butterflies • Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wildlife Butterflies, Pollinators, Songbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Coreopsis-verticilata-Zagreb","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wildlife • Attracts Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"},{"name":"Growing Colors","url":"https://www.growingcolors.com/plant/coreopsis-verticillata-zagreb","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nature Attraction • Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"coreopsis verticillata"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cornelian-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"15 ft. 0 in. - 25 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"15.00 to 25.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornelian-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"15 ft. 0 in. - 20 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"15.00 to 20.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornelian-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cornus-mas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zones 4a to 8b","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c290","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornelian-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cornus-mas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c290","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornelian-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornelian-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornelian-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornelian-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cornus-mas/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Members of the genus Cornus support the following specialized bees: Andrena (Gonandrena) fragilis, Andrena (Gonandrena) integra, and Andrena (Gonandrena) platyparia.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"the plants grow from 1-3 feet tall, depending on the cultivar\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height: 12 - 18 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: to 3 feet.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Average height 2-3ft\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,11],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Centaurea cyanus)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277177","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Centaurea cyanus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/centaurea-cyanus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[2,11],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Centaurea cyanus)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277177","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Centaurea cyanus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/centaurea-cyanus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Cornflower prefers full sun to light shade but the stems will flop with too much shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers (Bachelor's Button)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/bachelors-button","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species"},{"name":"RHS, Centaurea cyanus","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/46174/centaurea-cyanus/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Grow in well-drained soil in full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"Botanical Interests, Tall Blend Bachelor's Button Seeds","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/tall-blend-bachelors-button-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Required Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"centaurea cyanus"},{"name":"Roundstone Native Seed, Tall Blue Cornflower (Centaurea cyanus)","url":"https://www.roundstoneseed.com/product/tall-blue-cornflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It requires a full sun site.","level":"species"},{"name":"West Coast Seeds, How to Grow Centaurea Cornflowers","url":"https://www.westcoastseeds.com/blogs/wcs-academy/grow-centaurea","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full sun","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Centaurea cyanus)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277177","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Centaurea cyanus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/centaurea-cyanus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is an attractive and long-lasting cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Purdue University Consumer Horticulture, Indiana Yard and Garden","url":"https://www.purdue.edu/hla/sites/yardandgarden/2001-the-year-of-the-centaurea/?cat=21","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Centaurea also make excellent cut flowers for both fresh and dried arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers (Bachelor's Button)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/bachelors-button","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds, Centaurea Key Growing Information","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/growers-library/flowers/centaurea-bachelors-button/centaurea-key-growing-information.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flower, edible flower, and beneficial insect attractant.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Roundstone Native Seed, Tall Blue Cornflower (Centaurea cyanus)","url":"https://www.roundstoneseed.com/product/tall-blue-cornflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Aesthetic Value;Low Growing;Cut Flowers;","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["centaurea cyanus"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (centaurea cyanus), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (centaurea cyanus) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"cornflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Centaurea cyanus)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277177","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Centaurea cyanus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/centaurea-cyanus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer and drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Roundstone Native Seed, Tall Blue Cornflower (Centaurea cyanus)","url":"https://www.roundstoneseed.com/product/tall-blue-cornflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant prefers dry to medium moisture soils but does not tolerate drought.","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["centaurea cyanus"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (centaurea cyanus), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (centaurea cyanus) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Centaurea cyanus)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277177","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Centaurea cyanus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/centaurea-cyanus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Birds and butterflies use the flowers and fruit as a food source","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide (cornflower, bachelor's button)","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/cornflower-bachelors-button","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees, flies, butterflies, aphids, beetles, and other insects gain nourishment from cornflower's nectar, pollen, sap, and foliage.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["centaurea cyanus"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (centaurea cyanus), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (centaurea cyanus) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornflower-maroon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":11,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height (in.) 28-36\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant Height: 2 - 3 Feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 75cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"HEIGHT 32 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: Up to 2 ft.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Black Ball bachelor's button plants are deer resistant and grow to 24-36 in. tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plants grow to 3′ tall and may need staking.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"the plants grow 24 to thirty six inches in height\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height 30 cm - 90 cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 80–90cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 11 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornflower-maroon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 9 - 12 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 30cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornflower-maroon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-11","3-12","3-10","1-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277177","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/centaurea-cyanus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[2,11]},{"name":"TomorrowSeeds","url":"https://tomorrowseeds.com/products/black-ball-bachelor-button","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones: 3-12","zones":[3,12]},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/cornflower/cornflower-black.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA ZONES 3 - 10","zones":[3,10]},{"name":"Vermont Wildflower Farm","url":"https://www.vermontwildflowerfarm.com/products/cornflower-black-ball-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 1 through 10","zones":[1,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornflower-maroon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277177","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/centaurea-cyanus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/196601/centaurea-cyanus-black-ball/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"Applewood Seed Company","url":"https://www.applewoodseed.com/product/cornflower-black-ball/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Full Sun"},{"name":"TomorrowSeeds","url":"https://tomorrowseeds.com/products/black-ball-bachelor-button","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun, Partial Shade"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/centaurea-cyanus-black-ball/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure: Full sun"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/cornflower/cornflower-black.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ENVIRONMENT Full sun to partial shade"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/bachelor_button/black-ball-bachelors-button-seeds.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun, part shade in warm climates."},{"name":"Adaptive Seeds","url":"https://www.adaptiveseeds.com/product/flowers/bachelor-button-black-ball-organic/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants prefer full sun."},{"name":"Plant World Seeds","url":"https://www.plant-world-seeds.com/store/view_seed_item/7395/centaurea-cyanus-black-ball-seeds","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Light level Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornflower-maroon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornflower-maroon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277177","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/centaurea-cyanus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is an attractive and long-lasting cut flower.","claim":true},{"name":"Applewood Seed Company","url":"https://www.applewoodseed.com/product/cornflower-black-ball/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"tall silver stems that are perfect for cutting","claim":true},{"name":"TomorrowSeeds","url":"https://tomorrowseeds.com/products/black-ball-bachelor-button","country":null,"form":null,"value":"this cut flower is hardy, drought-tolerant and a stunning addition to any bouquet and flower arrangements","claim":true},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/cornflower/cornflower-black.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"they make an excellent cut flower","claim":true},{"name":"Vermont Wildflower Farm","url":"https://www.vermontwildflowerfarm.com/products/cornflower-black-ball-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great for any area, cut flowers, border, pollinators and the flower petals are edible.","claim":true},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/bachelor_button/black-ball-bachelors-button-seeds.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cut flowers, fresh or dried.","claim":true},{"name":"Victory Seed Company","url":"https://victoryseeds.com/products/cornflower-black-ball-bachelors-buttons","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cornflowers are excellent for beds, borders and as cut flowers.","claim":true},{"name":"Plant World Seeds","url":"https://www.plant-world-seeds.com/store/view_seed_item/7395/centaurea-cyanus-black-ball-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This variety makes for an ideal choice for a cut flower and dries brilliantly too.","claim":true}],"note":"9 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornflower-maroon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277177","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/centaurea-cyanus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Particularly Resistant To (Insects/Diseases/Other Problems): Deer and drought tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Applewood Seed Company","url":"https://www.applewoodseed.com/product/cornflower-black-ball/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These versatile plants are also heat and drought tolerant, and are ignored by deer.","claim":true},{"name":"TomorrowSeeds","url":"https://tomorrowseeds.com/products/black-ball-bachelor-button","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, bachelor buttons are drought-tolerant and require minimal care.","claim":true},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/cornflower/cornflower-black.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Centaurea Cyanus Black Ball certainly adds drama and is resistant to drought.","claim":true},{"name":"Vermont Wildflower Farm","url":"https://www.vermontwildflowerfarm.com/products/cornflower-black-ball-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Adapts to a variety of soils, heat and drought tolerant, deer resistant.","claim":true}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cornflower-maroon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277177","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/centaurea-cyanus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Pollinators Songbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Applewood Seed Company","url":"https://www.applewoodseed.com/product/cornflower-black-ball/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attracts numerous pollinators and beneficial insects","claim":true},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/cornflower/cornflower-black.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cornflowers are very attractive to both bees and butterflies, but fortunately deer leave the plants alone.","claim":true},{"name":"Vermont Wildflower Farm","url":"https://www.vermontwildflowerfarm.com/products/cornflower-black-ball-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great for any area, cut flowers, border, pollinators and the flower petals are edible.","claim":true},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/bachelor_button/black-ball-bachelors-button-seeds.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees and butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"Plant World Seeds","url":"https://www.plant-world-seeds.com/store/view_seed_item/7395/centaurea-cyanus-black-ball-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator-friendly Yes","claim":true}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":8,"cultivar":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 4.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Cosmos bipinnatus is usually a mix of purple, pink, and white flowers and can range in size from 1 to 6 feet tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 12-24 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 1.5-2.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 to 6 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 12-72\" tall (1-6' tall)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":8,"cultivar":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1 to 2 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"CONVENTION","wouldPropose":[2,11],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Cosmos bipinnatus","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b733","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Cosmos bipinnatus","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cosmos-bipinnatus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[2,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"American Meadows, Cosmos bipinnatus Seeds","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/cosmos-wildflower-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 2-11","zones":[2,11],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8,"cultivar":1,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source states 2-11 and this row deliberately stores no zones, which is the library's way of saying \"grown everywhere\" (docs/CATALOG-AUDIT.md records the two zone conventions for annuals as expected). Nothing is proposed: writing a zone range onto a zone-less row would remove it from every zone filter outside that range, and this is one library-wide decision rather than a per-plant error","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Cosmos bipinnatus","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b733","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Cosmos bipinnatus","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cosmos-bipinnatus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension, Yard and Garden: Cosmos in the Garden","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/cosmos-in-the-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Cosmos likes full sun, needing at least 8 hours of light.","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers, Cosmos bipinnatus","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=12&PlantTypeID=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, Cosmos bipinnatus","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/30717/cosmos-bipinnatus/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, FP149 Cosmos bipinnatus","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP149","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos bipinnatus"},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening, Flower Growing Guide: Cosmos","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene9a85.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: full sun part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"American Meadows, Cosmos bipinnatus Seeds","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/cosmos-wildflower-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"species"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds, Cosmos","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/cosmos.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun to part shade","level":"genus","taxon":"cosmos"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Utah State University Extension, Yard and Garden: Cosmos in the Garden","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/cosmos-in-the-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cosmos has a pleasant aroma and attracts butterflies to the garden.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Go Botany, Cosmos bipinnatus","url":"https://gobotany.nativeplanttrust.org/species/cosmos/bipinnatus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the plant does not have much of an odor","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Cosmos bipinnatus","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b733","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Mixed beds and borders. Cutting gardens. Cottage gardens and wild gardens.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Cosmos bipinnatus","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cosmos-bipinnatus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use these plants to add summer color to the border of cottage, cutting and butterfly gardens.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension, Yard and Garden: Cosmos in the Garden","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/cosmos-in-the-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Ornamental uses of Cosmos include cut flowers and as backdrop or border annual.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers, Cosmos bipinnatus","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=12&PlantTypeID=1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Useful as a cutting garden plant, or in a wild meadow garden.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening, Flower Growing Guide: Cosmos","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene9a85.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special uses: cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"American Meadows, Cosmos bipinnatus Seeds","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/cosmos-wildflower-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cosmos is a popular cutting flower with ferny foliage and strong stems and looks lovely planted along a fenceline.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds, Cosmos","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/cosmos.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers typically last 5 to 9 days when blooms are cut as petals unfold.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"cosmos"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["cosmos bipinnatus"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (cosmos bipinnatus), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (cosmos bipinnatus) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Cosmos bipinnatus","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b733","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Appreciates even moisture, but tolerates some dry soils.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Cosmos bipinnatus","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cosmos-bipinnatus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#dry soils tolerant #drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension, Yard and Garden: Cosmos in the Garden","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/cosmos-in-the-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, Cosmos needs little water, no fertilizer and not much care, which makes it well suited to Utah's climate.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"American Meadows, Cosmos bipinnatus Seeds","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/cosmos-wildflower-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"If you have a dry season, cosmos plants don't care, and revert to their drought-tolerant roots.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds, Cosmos","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/cosmos.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cosmos will grow in hot sun and poor soil, and will withstand drought conditions.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"cosmos"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["cosmos bipinnatus"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (cosmos bipinnatus), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (cosmos bipinnatus) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Cosmos bipinnatus","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b733","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Cosmos bipinnatus","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cosmos-bipinnatus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts pollinators, birds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension, Yard and Garden: Cosmos in the Garden","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/cosmos-in-the-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It attracts butterflies and is easily used as an attractive border or backdrop plant.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers, Cosmos bipinnatus","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=12&PlantTypeID=1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"An easy care annual that offers colorful flowers all summer, lacy foliage and attracts butterflies and birds.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening, Flower Growing Guide: Cosmos","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene9a85.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"American Meadows, Cosmos bipinnatus Seeds","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/cosmos-wildflower-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to both butterflies and hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds, Cosmos","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/cosmos.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract beautiful friends to our gardens: birds, bees, and butterflies love cosmos.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"cosmos"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["cosmos bipinnatus"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (cosmos bipinnatus), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (cosmos bipinnatus) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-bright-lights","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":2,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"'Bright Lights' grows 3-4 feet tall, and flowers come in shades of gold, orange, red and yellow.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Bright Lights seeds grow hardy, drought tolerant cosmos shrubs as high as 36\" tall with sunburst golden 2-3\" daisy-like blooms.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"HEIGHT 30 - 40 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant Height: 2 ft. - 4 ft.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant Height 30 to 40 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 3-4 ft\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"cosmos-bright-lights","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":2,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"cosmos-bright-lights","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-10","2-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/cosmos/cosmos-sulphureus-seeds-bright-lights.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA ZONES 3 - 10","zones":[3,10],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/sulphur_cosmos_seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10","zones":[2,10],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":2,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"cosmos-bright-lights","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277308&isprofile=0&bt=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cosmos-sulphureus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"Applewood Seed Co","url":"https://www.applewoodseed.com/product/sulphur-cosmos-bright-lights/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/cosmos/cosmos-sulphureus-seeds-bright-lights.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ENVIRONMENT Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"SeedStore.com","url":"https://www.seedstore.com/catalog/cosmos-seeds/bright-lights-cosmos-seeds-235.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Partial Shade/Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/sulphur_cosmos_seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"3 Porch Farm","url":"https://3porchfarm.com/products/cosmos-bright-lights-seeds-shipped","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Preference: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"cosmos-bright-lights","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"cosmos-bright-lights","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277308&isprofile=0&bt=8","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Beds and borders. Cottage gardens. Cutting gardens. Wild areas.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cosmos-sulphureus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use in the background as a bedding plant or in a cut flower garden.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"Applewood Seed Co","url":"https://www.applewoodseed.com/product/sulphur-cosmos-bright-lights/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants are very adaptable and are suitable for cutting, beds & borders, and the pollinator garden.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"True Leaf Market","url":"https://trueleafmarket.com/products/cosmos-bright-lights-flower-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bright Lights seeds promise long-lasting blooms that are a floral shop favorite used to brightly excite any seasonal fresh cut arrangement, basket, or bouquet.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/cosmos/cosmos-sulphureus-seeds-bright-lights.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sulfur Cosmos are known as an excellent cut flower with a vase life of 7 - 10 days.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"SeedStore.com","url":"https://www.seedstore.com/catalog/cosmos-seeds/bright-lights-cosmos-seeds-235.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent eye-catching border plant and wonderful for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/sulphur_cosmos_seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use Container Garden, Cut Flower Garden, Landscaping","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"3 Porch Farm","url":"https://3porchfarm.com/products/cosmos-bright-lights-seeds-shipped","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These 2-3\" semi double Cosmos add a real pop of color to any garden or arrangement.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"cosmos-bright-lights","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277308&isprofile=0&bt=8","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cosmos-sulphureus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#dry soils tolerant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"True Leaf Market","url":"https://trueleafmarket.com/products/cosmos-bright-lights-flower-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bright Lights seeds grow hardy, drought tolerant cosmos shrubs as high as 36\" tall with sunburst golden 2-3\" daisy-like blooms.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/cosmos/cosmos-sulphureus-seeds-bright-lights.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Will survive with very little water as these plants are quite resistant to drought.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/sulphur_cosmos_seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Growing Conditions Drought Tolerant, Heat Tolerant, Outdoor, Poor Soil Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"cosmos-bright-lights","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277308&isprofile=0&bt=8","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cosmos-sulphureus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts pollinators and butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"Applewood Seed Co","url":"https://www.applewoodseed.com/product/sulphur-cosmos-bright-lights/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract honey bees and wild bees.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/cosmos/cosmos-sulphureus-seeds-bright-lights.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Yes, it attracts pollinators such as bees and butterflies, as well as other beneficial insects.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"SeedStore.com","url":"https://www.seedstore.com/catalog/cosmos-seeds/bright-lights-cosmos-seeds-235.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features: Open Pollinated, Attracts Pollinators, Easy to Grow & Maintain, Fast Growing","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/sulphur_cosmos_seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plant Characteristics Attracts Bees, Attracts Butterflies, Attracts Hummingbirds, Attracts Pollinators, Easy to Grow & Maintain, Extended Bloom Time, Fast Growing","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"cosmos sulphureus"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"cosmos-cosmic-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"12\" (30cm)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-cosmic-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"12 - 18\" (30 - 46cm)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-cosmic-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-cosmic-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-cosmic-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-cosmic-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-cosmic-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Ball Seed (breeder / introducer catalog)","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/webtrackplantinfo.aspx?phid=019502214004463&ENV=P","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-cosmic-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-sensation-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1-1.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-sensation-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-sensation-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"CONVENTION","wouldPropose":[2,11],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Cosmos bipinnatus, species)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cosmos-bipinnatus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone 2a to 11b","zones":[2,11]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Cosmos bipinnatus, species)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277181","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2 to 11","zones":[2,11]}],"note":"every source states 2-11 and this row deliberately stores no zones, which is the library's way of saying \"grown everywhere\" (docs/CATALOG-AUDIT.md records the two zone conventions for annuals as expected). Nothing is proposed: writing a zone range onto a zone-less row would remove it from every zone filter outside that range, and this is one library-wide decision rather than a per-plant error","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-sensation-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"RHS (Cosmos bipinnatus Sensation Series)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/30720/cosmos-bipinnatus-sensation-series/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Cosmos bipinnatus, species)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cosmos-bipinnatus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Cosmos bipinnatus, species)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277181","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-sensation-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-sensation-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-sensation-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-sensation-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-xanthos","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1.5-2' h\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-xanthos","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1.5' w\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.51},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-xanthos","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-xanthos","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/award-winners/cosmos_xanthos_seeds.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/350254/cosmos-bipinnatus-xanthos-/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-xanthos","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-xanthos","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/award-winners/cosmos_xanthos_seeds.aspx","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great Cut Flower","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/350254/cosmos-bipinnatus-xanthos-/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"cut-flower borders","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-xanthos","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/award-winners/cosmos_xanthos_seeds.aspx","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cosmos-xanthos","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/award-winners/cosmos_xanthos_seeds.aspx","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/350254/cosmos-bipinnatus-xanthos-/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants for pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crabapple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":11,"levels":{"genus":4,"cultivar":1,"species":11},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 14 ft. 0 in. - 44 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"The height and width of the crown or canopy can range from 10 to 25 feet.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Crabapples are generally small trees, less than 20 feet tall. However, some varieties can reach 30 feet or more.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature height 15-20 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe; 11 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crabapple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"genus":4,"cultivar":1,"species":11},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 25 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"The height and width of the crown or canopy can range from 10 to 25 feet.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crabapple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","4-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/malus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Crabapple cultivars)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/crabapple-cultivars/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7","zones":[4,7],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"genus":4,"cultivar":1,"species":11},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crabapple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/malus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Malus '5-28')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249482","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1007","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/crabapple/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The tree is adapted to most sites, but should be placed in full sun for best flowers and fruit.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Profiles","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/crabapples","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Give them a spot in full sun although some will tolerate partial shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Crabapple cultivars)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/crabapple-cultivars/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Crabapples thrive in full sun and grow best in well drained, slightly acidic soils (pH 5.5-6.5); however, they will grow well in many soil types.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Malus floribunda)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286525","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"malus floribunda"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Malus sargentii)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286563","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"malus sargentii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Malus baccata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286425","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"malus baccata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Malus toringo)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/malus-toringo/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"malus toringo"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Malus coronaria)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/malus-coronaria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"malus coronaria"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Malus angustifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/malus-angustifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"malus angustifolia"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Japanese flowering crabapple)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-flowering-crabapple/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"malus floribunda"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Sargent's crabapple)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/sargents-crabapple/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Best planted in full sun, Sargent's crabapple is pH adaptable and tolerant of occasional wet or dry soils.","level":"species","taxon":"malus sargentii"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Malus angustifolia)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=MAAN3","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade","level":"species","taxon":"malus angustifolia"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crabapple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"strengths":["light"],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/malus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1007","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/crabapple/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"'Tina' - This is a low-spreading dwarf selection of Sargent crabapple that grows to 5 feet tall and 6 feet wide. The pink buds open to white fragrant flowers","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Profiles","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/crabapples","country":null,"form":null,"value":"flowers attract pollinators and some blossoms have a light, spicy scent","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Crabapple cultivars)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/crabapple-cultivars/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower color and fragrance Fragrant, Pink, Red, White","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/top-ornamental-crabapples-wisconsin/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"mounded, shrubby form; wide spreading; fragrant flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus sargentii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Malus floribunda)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286525","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus floribunda"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Malus sargentii)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286563","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pink buds open to a profuse, but brief, spring bloom of fragrant, white flowers (1\" diameter).","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus sargentii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Malus baccata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286425","country":null,"form":null,"value":"showy April-May bloom of fragrant, 5-petaled, white flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus baccata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Malus toringo)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/malus-toringo/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant has pink buds that open to a profuse spring bloom of fragrant, 1 inch, white flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus toringo"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Malus coronaria)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/malus-coronaria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus coronaria"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Malus angustifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/malus-angustifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus angustifolia"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Japanese flowering crabapple)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-flowering-crabapple/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A small ornamental tree known for its showy, bright pink buds that open to fragrant white flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus floribunda"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Sargent's crabapple)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/sargents-crabapple/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pale pink buds open up to clusters of fragrant white flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus sargentii"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Malus ioensis)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=MAIO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers: yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus ioensis"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Malus angustifolia)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=MAAN3","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Profuse pink flowers make a beautiful, fragrant show in early spring.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus angustifolia"}],"note":"15 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"crabapple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Malus sargentii)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286563","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus sargentii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Malus toringo)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/malus-toringo/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus toringo"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"crabapple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/malus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established they are drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Malus '5-28')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249482","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Established trees have some drought tolerance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Crabapple cultivars)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/crabapple-cultivars/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Most crabapple selections tolerate the cold winters and hot, dry summers prevalent in the Midwest.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Malus floribunda)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286525","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Established trees have some drought tolerance.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus floribunda"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Malus sargentii)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286563","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Established trees have some drought tolerance.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus sargentii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Malus baccata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286425","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Established trees have some drought tolerance.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus baccata"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Japanese flowering crabapple)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-flowering-crabapple/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance Moderately tolerant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus floribunda"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Sargent's crabapple)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/sargents-crabapple/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other tolerances Alkaline soil, clay soil, Dry sites, Occasional drought, Occasional flooding","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus sargentii"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Malus ioensis)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=MAIO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Though it prefers moist, rich sites, this crabapple will tolerate dry conditions on limestone or alkali soil.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus ioensis"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crabapple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/malus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinators visit the flowers. Several butterfly and moth larvae feed on the trees.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Malus '5-28')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249482","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Profiles","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/crabapples","country":null,"form":null,"value":"flowers attract pollinators and some blossoms have a light, spicy scent","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Malus floribunda)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286525","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus floribunda"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Malus sargentii)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286563","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus sargentii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Malus baccata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286425","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus baccata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Malus toringo)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/malus-toringo/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Hummingbirds Songbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus toringo"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Malus coronaria)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/malus-coronaria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nectar from flowers attracts native bees and honey bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus coronaria"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Malus angustifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/malus-angustifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bloom pollen is especially useful for bees as a food source in early spring as this tree blooms early.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus angustifolia"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Malus ioensis)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=MAIO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds , Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus ioensis"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Malus angustifolia)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=MAAN3","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Value to Native Bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"malus angustifolia"}],"note":"11 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[3.05,6.1],"union":[0.91,9.14],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lagerstroemia, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 20 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,6.1],"band":[0.91,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Crape Myrtle, Lagerstroemia species)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/crape-myrtle/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The height range is from 10 to 30 feet, and width range is 15 to 25 feet.","metres":[3.05,9.14],"band":[3.05,9.14],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions (Crapemyrtle, genus)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/trees-and-shrubs/trees/crapemyrtle/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These versatile shrubs come in range of shapes and sizes, from dwarf varieties that reach less than four feet to tree-sized varieties that can grow to more than twenty feet.","metres":[1.22,6.1],"band":[1.22,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":11,"levels":{"species":10,"genus":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 11 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[4.57,6.1],"union":[0.91,7.62],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lagerstroemia, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 20 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,6.1],"band":[0.91,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Crape Myrtle, Lagerstroemia species)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/crape-myrtle/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The height range is from 10 to 30 feet, and width range is 15 to 25 feet.","metres":[4.57,7.62],"band":[4.57,7.62],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":10,"levels":{"species":10,"genus":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lagerstroemia, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[6,9],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":11,"levels":{"species":10,"genus":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[6,9]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 11 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lagerstroemia indica)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282496","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"lagerstroemia indica"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lagerstroemia, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lagerstroemia indica)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia-indica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"lagerstroemia indica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lagerstroemia fauriei)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=444151","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"lagerstroemia fauriei"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lagerstroemia subcostata var. fauriei)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia-subcostata-var-fauriei/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"lagerstroemia subcostata"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Crape Myrtle, Lagerstroemia species)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/crape-myrtle/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The ideal planting site is in well-prepared, well-drained soil, with full sun exposure and good air circulation.","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, EDIS ST-342 (Lagerstroemia indica)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/ST342","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: full sun","level":"species","taxon":"lagerstroemia indica"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions (Crapemyrtle, genus)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/trees-and-shrubs/trees/crapemyrtle/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Crapemyrtles perform best when they receive full sun.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Lagerstroemia indica)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/lagerstroemia-indica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun, moist well-drained soil; when established, irrigate infrequently but deeply.","level":"species","taxon":"lagerstroemia indica"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide (Lagerstroemia indica)","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/crape-myrtle-lagerstroemia-indica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"lagerstroemia indica"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lagerstroemia limii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia-limii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"lagerstroemia limii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lagerstroemia speciosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia-speciosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"lagerstroemia speciosa"},{"name":"Alabama Cooperative Extension System, Auburn University (crape myrtle management)","url":"https://www.aces.edu/blog/topics/lawn-garden/auburn-extension-provide-a-new-look-at-crape-myrtle-management/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Wherever a crape myrtle is planted, full sun is essential. Sun equals flowers.","level":"genus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["lagerstroemia subcostata"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (lagerstroemia subcostata), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (lagerstroemia subcostata) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["lagerstroemia indica"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (lagerstroemia indica), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (lagerstroemia indica) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lagerstroemia indica)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282496","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Clay Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lagerstroemia indica"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lagerstroemia, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought Pollution","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lagerstroemia indica)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia-indica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Pollution","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lagerstroemia indica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lagerstroemia fauriei)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=444151","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Clay Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lagerstroemia fauriei"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Crape Myrtle, Lagerstroemia species)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/crape-myrtle/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Although it tolerates drought, it requires irrigation until it is well-established (approximately two years).","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, EDIS ST-342 (Lagerstroemia indica)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/ST342","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance: high","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lagerstroemia indica"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions (Crapemyrtle, genus)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/trees-and-shrubs/trees/crapemyrtle/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, these plants are extremely drought tolerant and have low fertility requirements, though they respond to fertilizer and water with lush growth.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lagerstroemia limii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia-limii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought Heat Pollution","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lagerstroemia limii"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lagerstroemia, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Food plant of some moth and butterfly larvae.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["lagerstroemia indica"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (lagerstroemia indica), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (lagerstroemia indica) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-catawba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[4.11,4.57],"union":[3.05,5.03],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia-indica-catawba/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10 ft. 0 in. - 15 ft. 0 in.","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/catawba-crape-myrtle.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"15 ft. tall","metres":4.57,"band":[4.11,5.03],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-catawba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"edge","consensus":[3.84,4.27],"union":[3.05,4.7],"edge":[2.96,4.7],"edgeMargin":1.6,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia-indica-catawba/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10 ft. 0 in. - 14 ft. 0 in.","metres":[3.05,4.27],"band":[3.05,4.27],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/catawba-crape-myrtle.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"14 ft. wide","metres":4.27,"band":[3.84,4.7],"role":"scored"}],"withdrawnFromV2":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":4.06},"note":"the catalog value sits 1.6% outside the sources' union (3.05 to 4.7 m) and inside the 3% margin v3 allows at a stated range edge (2.96 to 4.7 m), so v2's proposal of 4.06 m is withdrawn rather than applied; 1 of these 2 scored sources publish a range, and a range edge is a figure converted and rounded from another unit rather than a measurement to the centimetre","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-catawba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[7,9],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia-indica-catawba/","country":"US","form":"Lagerstroemia indica 'Catawba'","value":"7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[7,9]},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/catawba-crape-myrtle.html","country":"US","form":"Lagerstroemia indica 'Catawba'","value":"7-9","zones":[7,9]}],"note":"every source states 7-9; catalog states 7-10","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-catawba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia-indica-catawba/","country":"US","form":"Lagerstroemia indica 'Catawba'","value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/catawba-crape-myrtle.html","country":"US","form":"Lagerstroemia indica 'Catawba'","value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-catawba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-catawba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-catawba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/catawba-crape-myrtle.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Waterwise","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-catawba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/catawba-crape-myrtle.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-dynamite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[4.57,6.1],"union":[1.52,6.1],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249354","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5.00 to 20.00 feet","metres":[1.52,6.1],"band":[1.52,6.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/dynamite-crape-myrtle.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"15 to 20 ft. tall","metres":[4.57,6.1],"band":[4.57,6.1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-dynamite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[3.05,4.57],"union":[1.52,5.49],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249354","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5.00 to 18.00 feet","metres":[1.52,5.49],"band":[1.52,5.49],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/dynamite-crape-myrtle.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10 to 15 ft. wide","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-dynamite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["6-9","6-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249354","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 6 to 9","zones":[6,9]},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/dynamite-crape-myrtle.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6-10","zones":[6,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-dynamite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249354","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/dynamite-crape-myrtle.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-dynamite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-dynamite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-dynamite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249354","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Clay Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/dynamite-crape-myrtle.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Waterwise","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-dynamite","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/dynamite-crape-myrtle.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-red-rocket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[6.1,6.71],"union":[4.11,9.14],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia-indica-whit-iv/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 20 ft. 0 in. - 30 ft. 0 in.","metres":[6.1,9.14],"band":[6.1,9.14],"role":"scored"},{"name":"US National Arboretum, Lagerstroemia Cultivar Checklist (ICRA registry, Whitcomb material for 'Whit IV')","url":"https://www.usna.usda.gov/science/icra/lagerstroemia/vw/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growth habit: single or multiple stem, very large shrub or small tree, 20 ft. or more in height","metres":6.1,"band":[5.49,6.71],"role":"scored"},{"name":"ServeScape","url":"https://servescape.com/products/lagerstroemia-indica-whit-iv-crape-myrtle-red-rocket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 15' - 20'","metres":[4.57,6.1],"band":[4.57,6.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Rutgers Landscape & Nursery","url":"http://plants.rutgersln.com/12150011/Plant/18391/Red_Rocket_Crapemyrtle/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Red Rocket Crapemyrtle will grow to be about 15 feet tall at maturity, with a spread of 15 feet.","metres":4.57,"band":[4.11,5.03],"role":"scored"},{"name":"PlantingTree","url":"https://www.plantingtree.com/products/red-rocket-crape-myrtle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 20-30 Feet","metres":[6.1,9.14],"band":[6.1,9.14],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-red-rocket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":4,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[4.57,5.03],"union":[4.11,6.1],"proposed":4.8,"margin":2.7,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia-indica-whit-iv/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 15 ft. 0 in. - 20 ft. 0 in.","metres":[4.57,6.1],"band":[4.57,6.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"ServeScape","url":"https://servescape.com/products/lagerstroemia-indica-whit-iv-crape-myrtle-red-rocket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 15’ - 20'","metres":[4.57,6.1],"band":[4.57,6.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Rutgers Landscape & Nursery","url":"http://plants.rutgersln.com/12150011/Plant/18391/Red_Rocket_Crapemyrtle/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 15 feet","metres":4.57,"band":[4.11,5.03],"role":"scored"},{"name":"PlantingTree","url":"https://www.plantingtree.com/products/red-rocket-crape-myrtle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width 15-20 Feet","metres":[4.57,6.1],"band":[4.57,6.1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (4.11 to 6.1 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-red-rocket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["6-9","6-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia-indica-whit-iv/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[6,9]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lagerstroemia indica, species page: zones and sun only)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282496","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 6 to 9","zones":[6,9]},{"name":"ServeScape","url":"https://servescape.com/products/lagerstroemia-indica-whit-iv-crape-myrtle-red-rocket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 6 - 9","zones":[6,9]},{"name":"PlantingTree","url":"https://www.plantingtree.com/products/red-rocket-crape-myrtle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones 6-10","zones":[6,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-red-rocket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia-indica-whit-iv/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"US National Arboretum, Lagerstroemia Cultivar Checklist (ICRA registry, Whitcomb material for 'Whit IV')","url":"https://www.usna.usda.gov/science/icra/lagerstroemia/vw/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Flowering best in full sun."},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lagerstroemia indica, species page: zones and sun only)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282496","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"ServeScape","url":"https://servescape.com/products/lagerstroemia-indica-whit-iv-crape-myrtle-red-rocket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Full Sun , Partial Sun"},{"name":"Rutgers Landscape & Nursery","url":"http://plants.rutgersln.com/12150011/Plant/18391/Red_Rocket_Crapemyrtle/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub does best in full sun to partial shade."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-red-rocket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-red-rocket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-red-rocket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia-indica-whit-iv/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#heat tolerant #clay soils tolerant #drought tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"US National Arboretum, Lagerstroemia Cultivar Checklist (ICRA registry, Whitcomb material for 'Whit IV')","url":"https://www.usna.usda.gov/science/icra/lagerstroemia/vw/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Very drought tolerant.","claim":true},{"name":"PlantingTree","url":"https://www.plantingtree.com/products/red-rocket-crape-myrtle","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerance Good","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-red-rocket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"ServeScape","url":"https://servescape.com/products/lagerstroemia-indica-whit-iv-crape-myrtle-red-rocket","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are held on long panicles and attract butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-sioux","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":4,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[4.57,6.1],"union":[4.57,6.1],"proposed":5.34,"margin":12.5,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension, fact sheet FPS-328","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP328","country":"US","form":null,"value":"15 to 20 feet","metres":[4.57,6.1],"band":[4.57,6.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/lagerstroemia-x-sioux/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"15 - 20 feet","metres":[4.57,6.1],"band":[4.57,6.1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (4.57 to 6.1 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-sioux","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"edge","consensus":[3.05,3.66],"union":[3.05,4.57],"edge":[2.96,4.71],"edgeMargin":1.6,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension, fact sheet FPS-328","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP328","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10 to 15 feet","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/lagerstroemia-x-sioux/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10 - 12 feet","metres":[3.05,3.66],"band":[3.05,3.66],"role":"scored"}],"withdrawnFromV2":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":3.36},"note":"the catalog value sits 1.6% outside the sources' union (3.05 to 4.57 m) and inside the 3% margin v3 allows at a stated range edge (2.96 to 4.71 m), so v2's proposal of 3.36 m is withdrawn rather than applied; 2 of these 2 scored sources publish a range, and a range edge is a figure converted and rounded from another unit rather than a measurement to the centimetre","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-sioux","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-9","6-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension, fact sheet FPS-328","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP328","country":"US","form":null,"value":"7 through 9","zones":[7,9]},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/lagerstroemia-x-sioux/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 6 - 9","zones":[6,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia-sioux/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[7,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-sioux","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension, fact sheet FPS-328","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP328","country":"US","form":null,"value":"plant grows in full sun"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/lagerstroemia-x-sioux/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lagerstroemia-sioux/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-sioux","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-sioux","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-sioux","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension, fact sheet FPS-328","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP328","country":null,"form":null,"value":"high","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-sioux","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/lagerstroemia-x-sioux/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Blooms last from summer into fall, attracting honeybees and other pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-tuscarora","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[4.11,4.88],"union":[0.61,5.03],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261536","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2.00 to 16.00 feet","metres":[0.61,4.88],"band":[0.61,4.88],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/tuscarora-crape-myrtle.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Reaches 15 ft. tall and wide.","metres":4.57,"band":[4.11,5.03],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-tuscarora","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[4.11,4.88],"union":[0.61,5.03],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261536","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2.00 to 16.00 feet","metres":[0.61,4.88],"band":[0.61,4.88],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/tuscarora-crape-myrtle.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Reaches 15 ft. tall and wide.","metres":4.57,"band":[4.11,5.03],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-tuscarora","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[6,9],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261536","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6 to 9","zones":[6,9]},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/tuscarora-crape-myrtle.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6-9","zones":[6,9]}],"note":"every source states 6-9; catalog states 7-10","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-tuscarora","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261536","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/tuscarora-crape-myrtle.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-tuscarora","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-tuscarora","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261536","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-tuscarora","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261536","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Clay Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/tuscarora-crape-myrtle.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Waterwise","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crape-myrtle-tuscarora","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/tuscarora-crape-myrtle.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.15,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.1,0.15],"union":[0.05,0.5],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285439","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.25 to 0.50 feet","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-subulata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 4 in. - 0 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/phlox/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"height varying between 3 to 6 inches for moss phlox","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PHSU3","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size Notes: Up to about 8 inches tall.","metres":0.2,"band":[0.18,0.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Go Botany, Native Plant Trust","url":"https://gobotany.nativeplanttrust.org/species/phlox/subulata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant height 5-20 cm","metres":[0.05,0.2],"band":[0.05,0.2],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/97337/phlox-subulata-moss-phlox-ground-pink/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.5],"union":[0.1,0.91],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285439","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-subulata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/97337/phlox-subulata-moss-phlox-ground-pink/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285439","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-subulata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285439","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-subulata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/phlox/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Moss pink prefers full sun, and well-drained soil."},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PHSU3","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/97337/phlox-subulata-moss-phlox-ground-pink/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285439","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Loose clusters (cymes) of fragrant, tubular flowers","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-subulata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"flattened clusters or cymes of 2 to 8, fragrant, tubular flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Go Botany, Native Plant Trust","url":"https://gobotany.nativeplanttrust.org/species/phlox/subulata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plant odor the plant does not have much of a smell","claim":false}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285439","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Erosion, Urban Conditions","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-subulata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is tolerant of deer, erosion, drought, and air pollution.","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/phlox/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It will tolerate poor soil, and withstands drought once established.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285439","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-subulata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract hummingbirds, butterflies, skippers, and bees.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-candy-stripe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.15,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.08,0.33],"split":[{"range":[0.08,0.17],"sources":["US Perennials","NVK Nurseries","Prides Corner Farms","Pleasant Run Nursery","Classic Groundcovers","Hortech","Little Prince of Oregon Nursery","Royal Horticultural Society"]},{"range":[0.27,0.33],"sources":["Nature Hills Nursery"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/phlox-candy-stripe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 1 ft","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Hortech","url":"https://hortech.com/plant/phlox-subulata-candy-stripe/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Max Height: 6\"","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Classic Groundcovers","url":"https://www.classic-groundcovers.com/plant/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4-6 Inches","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe-Moss-Phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3-6 in","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 Inches","metres":0.1,"band":[0.09,0.11],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Little Prince of Oregon Nursery","url":"https://littleprinceplants.com/our-plants/perennials/phlox-subulata-candy-stripe-creeping-phlox/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Approximate Mature Height 6\"","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/phlox-subulata-candy-stripes-moss-phlox-candy-stripes-moderate-spreading/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: about 3-4\" tall x 24\" wide","metres":[0.08,0.1],"band":[0.08,0.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe-Tamaongalei","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"HEIGHT: 8-12 cm","metres":[0.08,0.12],"band":[0.08,0.12],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/115904/phlox-subulata-candy-stripe/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"low-growing to 15cm","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-candy-stripe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.1,0.91],"split":[{"range":[0.1,0.5],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society","Pleasant Run Nursery","Classic Groundcovers","Little Prince of Oregon Nursery","NVK Nurseries"]},{"range":[0.55,0.91],"sources":["Nature Hills Nursery","US Perennials","Prides Corner Farms"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/phlox-candy-stripe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 2 ft","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Classic Groundcovers","url":"https://www.classic-groundcovers.com/plant/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 10-12 Inches","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe-Moss-Phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2-3 ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 10 Inches","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Little Prince of Oregon Nursery","url":"https://littleprinceplants.com/our-plants/perennials/phlox-subulata-candy-stripe-creeping-phlox/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Approximate Mature Width 1'","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/phlox-subulata-candy-stripes-moss-phlox-candy-stripes-moderate-spreading/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: about 3-4\" tall x 24\" wide","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe-Tamaongalei","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"SPREAD: 40-45 cm","metres":[0.4,0.45],"band":[0.4,0.45],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/115904/phlox-subulata-candy-stripe/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-candy-stripe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","3-8","2-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c268","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-subulata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/moss-phlox/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 3-9.","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/phlox-candy-stripe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3a - to 9b","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Classic Groundcovers","url":"https://www.classic-groundcovers.com/plant/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe-Moss-Phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Little Prince of Oregon Nursery","url":"https://littleprinceplants.com/our-plants/perennials/phlox-subulata-candy-stripe-creeping-phlox/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 2 , Zone 3 , Zone 4 , Zone 5 , Zone 6 , Zone 7 , Zone 8","zones":[2,8]},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/phlox-subulata-candy-stripes-moss-phlox-candy-stripes-moderate-spreading/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-candy-stripe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c268","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-subulata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/moss-phlox/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It prefers full sun conditions, but appreciates some dappled sun in locations where summers are hot and humid."},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/phlox-candy-stripe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full sun"},{"name":"Hortech","url":"https://hortech.com/plant/phlox-subulata-candy-stripe/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun Light Shade"},{"name":"Classic Groundcovers","url":"https://www.classic-groundcovers.com/plant/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun Blooms early Spring"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe-Moss-Phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers a moist, well-drained soil in full sun to part shade."},{"name":"Little Prince of Oregon Nursery","url":"https://littleprinceplants.com/our-plants/perennials/phlox-subulata-candy-stripe-creeping-phlox/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Recommended Light Conditions Full Sun"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/phlox-subulata-candy-stripes-moss-phlox-candy-stripes-moderate-spreading/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: full sun, half shade, dappled sun"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe-Tamaongalei","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Grows in a well-drained soil with a high organic content, with medium moisture, in full sun, however it will tolerate partial shade."},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/115904/phlox-subulata-candy-stripe/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-candy-stripe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c268","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Loose clusters (cymes) of fragrant, tubular flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/phlox-candy-stripe","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Yes","claim":true},{"name":"Hortech","url":"https://hortech.com/plant/phlox-subulata-candy-stripe/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"'Candy Stripe' blooms during early spring, is fragrant, attracts hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-candy-stripe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-candy-stripe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/moss-phlox/","https://naturehills.com/products/phlox-candy-stripe"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/moss-phlox/","https://www.classic-groundcovers.com/plant/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/moss-phlox/","https://www.usperennials.com/phlox-subulata-candy-stripes-moss-phlox-candy-stripes-moderate-spreading/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/moss-phlox/","https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe-Tamaongalei"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/moss-phlox/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It can tolerate drought and shallow soils.","claim":true},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/phlox-candy-stripe","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, this plant is remarkably drought tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Classic Groundcovers","url":"https://www.classic-groundcovers.com/plant/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates drought once established.","claim":true},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/phlox-subulata-candy-stripes-moss-phlox-candy-stripes-moderate-spreading/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"black walnut, drought, heat, and humidity tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe-Tamaongalei","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought-tolerant, once established.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-candy-stripe","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c268","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to butterflies and other insect pollinators.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-subulata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract hummingbirds, butterflies, skippers, and bees.","claim":true},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/phlox-candy-stripe","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts pollinators","claim":true},{"name":"Hortech","url":"https://hortech.com/plant/phlox-subulata-candy-stripe/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"is fragrant, attracts hummingbirds, and is ideal for rock gardens","claim":true},{"name":"Classic Groundcovers","url":"https://www.classic-groundcovers.com/plant/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Phlox-subulata-Candy-Stripe-Moss-Phlox","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-drummonds-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.1,0.15],"union":[0.1,0.15],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://info.ballseed.com/WEBTRACKPLANTINFO.ASPX?PHID=049201449007181&env=P","https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Phlox-subulata-Drummond-s-Pink"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Ball Seed (Ball Horticultural Company) plant information","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/WEBTRACKPLANTINFO.ASPX?PHID=049201449007181&env=P","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 - 6\" (10 - 15cm)","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Phlox-subulata-Drummond-s-Pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4-6 Inches","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-drummonds-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Ball Seed (Ball Horticultural Company) plant information","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/WEBTRACKPLANTINFO.ASPX?PHID=049201449007181&env=P","country":"US","form":null,"value":"12 - 18\" (30 - 46cm)","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Phlox-subulata-Drummond-s-Pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"18-24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-drummonds-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://info.ballseed.com/WEBTRACKPLANTINFO.ASPX?PHID=049201449007181&env=P","https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Phlox-subulata-Drummond-s-Pink"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Ball Seed (Ball Horticultural Company) plant information","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/WEBTRACKPLANTINFO.ASPX?PHID=049201449007181&env=P","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a - 8b","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Phlox-subulata-Drummond-s-Pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3-8","zones":[3,8]}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[3,8]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-drummonds-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Phlox-subulata-Drummond-s-Pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-drummonds-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-drummonds-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-drummonds-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Phlox-subulata-Drummond-s-Pink","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of drought and coastal conditions","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-drummonds-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Phlox-subulata-Drummond-s-Pink","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to butterflies and hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-emerald-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.15,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.1,0.15],"union":[0.1,0.15],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=440995&bt=4","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.33 to 0.50 feet","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=PHSEP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.0-6.0 Inches","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-creeping-phlox-emerald-pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 4-6\" tall","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-emerald-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.3,0.46],"proposed":0.38,"margin":8.7,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=440995&bt=4","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=PHSEP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12.0-18.0 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-creeping-phlox-emerald-pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 12-18\" wide","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.3 to 0.46 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-emerald-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-9","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=440995&bt=4","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 9","zones":[2,9]},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=PHSEP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[2,9]},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-creeping-phlox-emerald-pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones Zone 2 Zone 3 Zone 4 Zone 5 Zone 6 Zone 7 Zone 8 Zone 9","zones":[2,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-subulata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-emerald-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=440995&bt=4","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=PHSEP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-creeping-phlox-emerald-pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-subulata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-emerald-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=440995&bt=4","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Loose clusters (cymes) of fragrant, tubular flowers (to 3/4\" wide) bloom in April-May.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-emerald-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-emerald-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=440995&bt=4","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-creeping-phlox-emerald-pink","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This water-wise selection looks lovely stretched along a stony walkway and tucked against decorative boulders.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-emerald-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=440995&bt=4","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=PHSEP","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-creeping-phlox-emerald-pink","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bee Friendly Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-white-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/phlox-subulata-white-delight-moss-phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows only 4 -6 inches high, forming a dense mat of dark green foliage 2 feet wide.","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-white-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/phlox-subulata-white-delight-moss-phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows only 4 -6 inches high, forming a dense mat of dark green foliage 2 feet wide.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-white-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-9","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/phlox-subulata-white-delight-moss-phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"hardy in zones 2 - 9","zones":[2,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Phlox subulata, species)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-subulata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone 3a to 9b","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-white-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/phlox-subulata-white-delight-moss-phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Phlox subulata, species)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-subulata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-white-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-white-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-white-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/phlox-subulata-white-delight-moss-phlox","country":null,"form":null,"value":"drought tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"creeping-phlox-white-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.68,0.84],"union":[0.6,2],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, How to grow crocosmias","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/crocosmia/growing-guide","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Range from 60cm-2m (2-6½ft) tall","metres":[0.6,2],"band":[0.6,2],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/collections/crocosmia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"these plants create dense, structural clumps that stand 30 inches tall","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":7,"cultivar":3,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 4 in. - 0 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":7,"cultivar":3,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["6-9","6-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[6,9],"level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County, Fact sheet: Crocosmia","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/06/01/fact-sheet-crocosmia-2/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Crocosmias are easy to grow in USDA zones 6 through 10, where they are hardy.","zones":[6,10],"level":"genus"},{"name":"Breck's, How to Grow Crocosmia Plants","url":"https://www.brecks.com/blogs/blog-post/how-to-grow-crocosmia-plants","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Many cultivars are hardy to zones 6-10; some need lifting in colder zones.","zones":[6,10],"level":"genus"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/collections/crocosmia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most varieties of Crocosmia are winter-hardy in USDA zones 6 to 9","zones":[6,9],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":7,"cultivar":3,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, How to grow crocosmias","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/crocosmia/growing-guide","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Like moist but well-drained soil in full sun","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=h680","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/crocosmia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant yours in sun or part shade","level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County, Fact sheet: Crocosmia","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/06/01/fact-sheet-crocosmia-2/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Select a site in full sun (part shade in hot areas) with moist, well-drained, slightly acidic soil of average fertility.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Breck's, How to Grow Crocosmia Plants","url":"https://www.brecks.com/blogs/blog-post/how-to-grow-crocosmia-plants","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Make sure the location for planting crocosmia bulbs gets full sun for at least 4-5 hours a day.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/collections/crocosmia-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Thrives in full sun or partially shaded areas","level":"genus"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/collections/crocosmia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Crocosmia performs best in full sun but can tolerate dappled or light shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica, Crocosmia aurea","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/crocosmia-aurea","country":"ZA","form":null,"value":"Aspect: Full Sun, Morning Sun (Semi Shade)","level":"species","taxon":"crocosmia aurea"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica, Crocosmia paniculata","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/crocosmia-paniculata","country":"ZA","form":null,"value":"Aspect: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"crocosmia paniculata"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/crocosmia-lucifer-montbretia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Breck's, How to Grow Crocosmia Plants","url":"https://www.brecks.com/blogs/blog-post/how-to-grow-crocosmia-plants","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gorgeous flowers, striking foliage and captivating aroma, Crocosmia plants are perfect for background and border planting","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"crocosmia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Crocosmia may also be grown in a cutting garden, as many are excellent as cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, How to grow crocosmias","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/crocosmia/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They make long-lasting and architectural cut flowers too.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=h680","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/crocosmia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Crocosmia begins blooming in May or June and can be cut and used in bouquets.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County, Fact sheet: Crocosmia","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/06/01/fact-sheet-crocosmia-2/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Crocosmia flowers last well in the garden and in the vase, especially if properly conditioned in the latter case.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Breck's, How to Grow Crocosmia Plants","url":"https://www.brecks.com/blogs/blog-post/how-to-grow-crocosmia-plants","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Another benefit of growing crocosmia plants is the ready supply of cut flowers for ornamental use.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/collections/crocosmia-bulbs","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The lengthy stalks and bright colors of crocosmia also make for excellent cut flower displays.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/crocosmia-lucifer-montbretia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Often seen in floral arrangements and bouquets","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["crocosmia aurea"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (crocosmia aurea), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (crocosmia aurea) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"crocosmia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Irrigate as often as necessary to maintain even moisture in your soil, as the plants do not like to dry out.","claim":false,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, How to grow crocosmias","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/crocosmia/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Avoid planting in waterlogged or very dry conditions","claim":false,"level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/crocosmia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Crocosmia has few diseases or pests, and is usually drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/collections/crocosmia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, Crocosmia is fairly drought-tolerant, but regular watering during dry spells will ensure healthy growth.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"2 source(s) state this trait and 2 deny it","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds, bees, and butterflies are attracted to the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County, Fact sheet: Crocosmia","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/06/01/fact-sheet-crocosmia-2/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Humans and hummingbirds alike appreciate the red, orange and yellow crocosmia flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/collections/crocosmia-bulbs","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers bloom for five to eight weeks in the mid summer, beckoning hummingbirds to feed from them.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/collections/crocosmia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its nectar-rich flowers attract hummingbirds, bees, and butterflies, making it an excellent choice for pollinator gardens.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/crocosmia-lucifer-montbretia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Their tubular flowers attract both hummingbirds and spider mites.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["crocosmia paniculata"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (crocosmia paniculata), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (crocosmia paniculata) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"crocosmia-emily-mckenzie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.68,0.76],"union":[0.5,1],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244060&isprofile=0&pt=3","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/64912/crocosmia-x-crocosmiiflora-emily-mckenzie/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"crocosmia crocosmiiflora"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=CROEM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24.0-30.0 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/crocosmia-emily-mckenzie","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 24-36 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"K. van Bourgondien","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/emily_mckenzie_crocosmia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 30 inches","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Horsford Gardens and Nursery","url":"https://horsfordnursery.com/crocosmia-emily-mckenzie/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Plant Height: HT 24-30\"","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Harvesting History","url":"https://www.harvesting-history.com/product/crocosmia-emily-mckenzie/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plants reach a height of 24 inches and bloom during the late summer and early fall, just when the garden could really use a boost in color.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":1,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-emily-mckenzie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.1,0.61],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244060&isprofile=0&pt=3","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/64912/crocosmia-x-crocosmiiflora-emily-mckenzie/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"crocosmia crocosmiiflora"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=CROEM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12.0-18.0 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/crocosmia-emily-mckenzie","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 12-24 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Horsford Gardens and Nursery","url":"https://horsfordnursery.com/crocosmia-emily-mckenzie/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Spread: SP 12-24\"","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":1,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-emily-mckenzie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","6-9","3-9","8-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244060&isprofile=0&pt=3","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=CROEM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 6,7,8,9","zones":[6,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/crocosmia-emily-mckenzie","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"K. van Bourgondien","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/emily_mckenzie_crocosmia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Harvesting History","url":"https://www.harvesting-history.com/product/crocosmia-emily-mckenzie/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Winter hardy Zones 8-10","zones":[8,10],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":1,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-emily-mckenzie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244060&isprofile=0&pt=3","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/64912/crocosmia-x-crocosmiiflora-emily-mckenzie/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"crocosmia crocosmiiflora"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=CROEM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/crocosmia-emily-mckenzie","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"K. van Bourgondien","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/emily_mckenzie_crocosmia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun, Half Sun / Half Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Harvesting History","url":"https://www.harvesting-history.com/product/crocosmia-emily-mckenzie/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They do best in full sun, but can also tolerate light shade.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Crocosmia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"crocosmia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Crocosmia x crocosmiiflora)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia-x-crocosmiiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"crocosmia crocosmiiflora"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-emily-mckenzie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Crocosmia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"crocosmia"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-emily-mckenzie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244060&isprofile=0&pt=3","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=CROEM","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These stems make long-lasting cut flowers and add tropical flair to any bouquet or garden.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/crocosmia-emily-mckenzie","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is also known for its brilliant late summer color and taller stems, making this an excellent cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"K. van Bourgondien","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/emily_mckenzie_crocosmia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This large-flowered variety is a favorite for cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Crocosmia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#cutting garden","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"crocosmia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Crocosmia x crocosmiiflora)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia-x-crocosmiiflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#cutting garden","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"crocosmia crocosmiiflora"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"crocosmia-emily-mckenzie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/crocosmia-emily-mckenzie","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"K. van Bourgondien","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/emily_mckenzie_crocosmia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Will Tolerate: Acidic Soil, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Loamy Soil, Sandy Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Crocosmia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#dry soils intolerant","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"crocosmia"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-emily-mckenzie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=CROEM","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/crocosmia-emily-mckenzie","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees • Attracts Butterflies • Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"K. van Bourgondien","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/emily_mckenzie_crocosmia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Suggested Uses: Borders, Bouquets, Cut Flowers, Naturalizing, Showy Flowers, Deer Resistant, Attract Pollinator, Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Crocosmia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds, bees, and butterflies are attracted to the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"crocosmia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Crocosmia x crocosmiiflora)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia-x-crocosmiiflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds love the tubular shaped flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"crocosmia crocosmiiflora"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"crocosmia-lucifer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.61,2.5],"split":[{"range":[0.61,1.22],"sources":["Longfield Gardens","Missouri Botanical Garden","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","Walters Gardens","Brent and Becky's Bulbs","American Meadows"]},{"range":[1.5,2.5],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=h680","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia-lucifer/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CROLU","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 36.0-42.0 Inches","metres":[0.91,1.07],"band":[0.91,1.07],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/91289/crocosmia-lucifer/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/crocosmia-lucifer-montbretia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 36″-42″","metres":[0.91,1.07],"band":[0.91,1.07],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-crocosmia-flower-bulbs-lucifer","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 36-48\" tall","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/crocosmia-lucifer","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: Grows 24-36\" tall","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-lucifer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.1,0.61],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=h680","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia-lucifer/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CROLU","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12.0-18.0 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/91289/crocosmia-lucifer/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-lucifer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=h680","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia-lucifer/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CROLU","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 5,6,7,8,9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/crocosmia-lucifer-montbretia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-crocosmia-flower-bulbs-lucifer","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones Zone 5 Zone 6 Zone 7 Zone 8 Zone 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/crocosmia-lucifer","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4 through 9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-lucifer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=h680","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia-lucifer/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CROLU","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/91289/crocosmia-lucifer/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/crocosmia-lucifer-montbretia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-crocosmia-flower-bulbs-lucifer","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun Half Sun / Half Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-lucifer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-lucifer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=h680","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia-lucifer/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-crocosmia-flower-bulbs-lucifer","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Advantages Mass Plantings Cut Flowers Deer Resistant Rabbit Resistant","claim":true},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/crocosmia-lucifer","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plant Features: Great for Cut Flowers, Deer Resistant, Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-lucifer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-lucifer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocosmia-lucifer/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=CROLU","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Hummingbirds Bee Friendly","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-solfatare","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250189","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-solfatare","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250189","country":"US","form":null,"value":"0.75 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.23,0.46],"band":[0.23,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-solfatare","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250189","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6 to 9","zones":[6,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-solfatare","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250189","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-solfatare","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-solfatare","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250189","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Montbretias are good fresh cut flowers that are frequently used in commercial flower arrangements","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-solfatare","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250189","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of some drought once established","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocosmia-solfatare","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.14,0.15],"union":[0.05,0.17],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 2 in. - 0 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.05,0.15],"band":[0.05,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/spring-flowering-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Habit: upright; 6 inches","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/minor-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants are approximately 3 to 6 inches tall.","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"UC Marin Master Gardeners (UC ANR)","url":"https://ucanr.edu/site/uc-marin-master-gardeners/article/focus-crocus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"typically grow a petite 3 to 6 inches tall","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC, This Month in Your Garden (March 2025)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/this-month-in-your-garden-march-2025/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The petite crocus (< 6 inches) is in the iris family and has sweetly fragrant blooms","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":10,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.08,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 3 in. - 0 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":10,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"genus"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs, Crocus Hort Tips","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/hcrocus.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"hardy in horticultural zones 4 through 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":10,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Crocus need full sun to partial shade","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281107","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"crocus vernus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/spring-flowering-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"plant in well-drained soil; full sun or partial shade","level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/minor-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grow well in either full sun or partial shade","level":"genus"},{"name":"UC Marin Master Gardeners (UC ANR)","url":"https://ucanr.edu/site/uc-marin-master-gardeners/article/focus-crocus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow in sun or part shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC, Spring-Flowering Bulbs","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/spring-flowering-bulbs/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant crocuses in full sun or light shade in November, 3 inches deep and 3 to 4 inches apart.","level":"genus"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs, Crocus Hort Tips","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/hcrocus.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"All Crocus require neutral pH, well-draining soil in full to partial sunlight.","level":"genus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"strengths":["light"],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"UC Marin Master Gardeners (UC ANR)","url":"https://ucanr.edu/site/uc-marin-master-gardeners/article/focus-crocus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Crocus chrysanthus has a mild honey-like scent","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC, This Month in Your Garden (March 2025)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/this-month-in-your-garden-march-2025/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The petite crocus (< 6 inches) is in the iris family and has sweetly fragrant blooms","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, How to grow crocuses","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/crocus/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The goblet-shaped, sometimes fragrant, flowers bloom in early spring or autumn.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"crocus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They tolerate drought, but keep them moist during the growing season.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"UC Marin Master Gardeners (UC ANR)","url":"https://ucanr.edu/site/uc-marin-master-gardeners/article/focus-crocus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"are a favorite of pollinators, providing them with an early source of nectar in late winter or early spring","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of New Hampshire Extension","url":"https://extension.unh.edu/blog/2020/10/which-bulbs-are-best-naturalizing","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are rich in pollen and nectar and tend to be very popular with bees in early spring when little else is blooming.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden, Plant Profiles","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plantinfo/crocus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"seeing how happy the bees are to discover these lovely flowers on a cold day","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"crocus-ruby-giant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.09,0.1],"union":[0.07,0.15],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d172","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.25 to 0.50 feet","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/258245/crocus-ruby-giant/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height Up to 10 cm","metres":0.1,"band":[0.09,0.11],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Van Engelen Wholesale Flower Bulbs","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/crocus-tommasinianus-ruby-giant.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4\".","metres":0.1,"band":[0.09,0.11],"role":"scored"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/crocus-tommasinianus-ruby-giant.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4\".","metres":0.1,"band":[0.09,0.11],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/tommasinianus-ruby-giant/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3″-6″","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/flower-bulbs/crocus-tommasinianus-bulbs-ruby-giant","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 3\" tall","metres":0.08,"band":[0.07,0.09],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Colorblends Wholesale Flowerbulbs","url":"https://www.colorblends.com/products/ruby-giant","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 3-4 inches","metres":[0.08,0.1],"band":[0.08,0.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Easy to Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/crocus-tommasinianus-ruby-giant-fragrant","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 - 4\"","metres":[0.08,0.1],"band":[0.08,0.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/ruby-giant-snow-crocus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height/Habit 4 - 6 inches","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocus-ruby-giant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.08,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.05,0.1],"union":[0,0.15],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d172","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.25 to 0.50 feet","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/258245/crocus-ruby-giant/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0-0.1 metre","metres":[0,0.1],"band":[0,0.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Easy to Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/crocus-tommasinianus-ruby-giant-fragrant","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2 - 3\"","metres":[0.05,0.08],"band":[0.05,0.08],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocus-ruby-giant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","5-9","4-8","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d172","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocus-tommasinianus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/crocus-tommasinianus-ruby-giant-tommy-crocus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5 - 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Van Engelen Wholesale Flower Bulbs","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/crocus-tommasinianus-ruby-giant.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 4-8.","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/crocus-tommasinianus-ruby-giant.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 4-8.","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/tommasinianus-ruby-giant/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/flower-bulbs/crocus-tommasinianus-bulbs-ruby-giant","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ZONES 4-8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Colorblends Wholesale Flowerbulbs","url":"https://www.colorblends.com/products/ruby-giant","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Suitable for USDA zones 3a to 8b in the South, 10b on the West Coast.","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Easy to Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/crocus-tommasinianus-ruby-giant-fragrant","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/ruby-giant-snow-crocus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3-9","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocus-ruby-giant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d172","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/crocus-tommasinianus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/crocus-tommasinianus-ruby-giant-tommy-crocus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/258245/crocus-ruby-giant/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"Van Engelen Wholesale Flower Bulbs","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/crocus-tommasinianus-ruby-giant.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full to partial sunlight."},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/crocus-tommasinianus-ruby-giant.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full to partial sunlight."},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/tommasinianus-ruby-giant/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun, Part Shade"},{"name":"Easy to Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/crocus-tommasinianus-ruby-giant-fragrant","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full sun"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/ruby-giant-snow-crocus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun, Partial Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocus-ruby-giant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Easy to Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/crocus-tommasinianus-ruby-giant-fragrant","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Crocus - Ruby Giant (Fragrant)","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocus-ruby-giant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocus-ruby-giant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crocus-ruby-giant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"crown-princess-margareta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.83,3.66],"union":[1.22,3.66],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/crown-princess-margareta","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Size 6' - 12' x 5'","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/crown-princess-margareta-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Height: 4-12 feet","metres":[1.22,3.66],"band":[1.22,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/crown-princess-margareta%C2%AE-climbing-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Height: 6–12′","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK, the breeder)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/crown-princess-margareta","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 5ft (150cm)","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"other-form","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"crown-princess-margareta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.8,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[1.37,1.52],"union":[1.1,1.67],"proposed":1.45,"margin":7.8,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/crown-princess-margareta","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Size 6' - 12' x 5'","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/crown-princess-margareta-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Spread: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/crown-princess-margareta%C2%AE-climbing-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Width: 4–5′","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK, the breeder)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/crown-princess-margareta","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 5ft (150cm)","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"other-form","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (1.1 to 1.67 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"crown-princess-margareta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-10","5-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/crown-princess-margareta","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zone 5-10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/crown-princess-margareta-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Suitable Zones: 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/crown-princess-margareta%C2%AE-climbing-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Hardiness Zones: 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"crown-princess-margareta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK, the breeder)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/crown-princess-margareta","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/crown-princess-margareta","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Partial Shade or Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/crown-princess-margareta%C2%AE-climbing-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Light Requirements: Full sun to partial shade","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"crown-princess-margareta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["strong","medium","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/crown-princess-margareta","https://heirloomroses.com/products/crown-princess-margareta"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/crown-princess-margareta","https://menagerieflower.com/products/crown-princess-margareta-rose-david-austin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/crown-princess-margareta","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/crown-princess-margareta%C2%AE-climbing-rose-bush"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK, the breeder)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/crown-princess-margareta","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They have a strong, fruity fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/crown-princess-margareta","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Very Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/crown-princess-margareta-rose-david-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"a pleasant fruity fragrance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/crown-princess-margareta%C2%AE-climbing-rose-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong, fruity tea rose","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"crown-princess-margareta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/crown-princess-margareta%C2%AE-climbing-rose-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vase Life: 4–6 days","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"crown-princess-margareta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"crown-princess-margareta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"cuphea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":8,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.50 to 2.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"A spreading evergreen sub-shrub to 40cm in height, with lance-shaped leaves and tubular scarlet flowers, black at the tip and edged white\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 to 3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"It grows about 2 feet tall and wide with a twiggy look.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"About a foot tall, it's a perfect companion plant for containers or window boxes\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Firecracker Plant will grow to be about 3 feet tall at maturity, with a spread of 3 feet.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 20-30″\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cuphea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.50 to 2.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 2 to 3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"It grows about 2 feet tall and wide with a twiggy look.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Firecracker Plant will grow to be about 3 feet tall at maturity, with a spread of 3 feet.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 20-30″\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cuphea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-12","9-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cuphea-ignea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is intolerant to frost and winter hardy in zones 10 to 12.","zones":[10,12],"level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282501","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 12","zones":[10,12],"level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension EDIS fact sheet FP160 (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP160","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA hardiness zones: 9B through 11","zones":[9,11],"level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"Quality Cuttings wholesale catalog (Cuphea Ignea)","url":"https://qualitycuttings.com/product/cuphea-ignea-cigar-plant/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy to Zones: 9-11","zones":[9,11],"level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cuphea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cuphea-ignea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The Mexican cigar plant performs best in full sun to partial shade and moist, well-drained soils of loam and sand.","level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282501","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society plant profile (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/5037/cuphea-ignea/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension EDIS fact sheet FP160 (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP160","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in part shade/part sun","level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture Extension, Plant of the Week: Firecracker Plant (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/firecracker-plant-7-1-05.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It does best in full sun, but will take light shade.","level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"University of Georgia CAES Field Report, Cuphea annual plants provide nonstop summer color (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/news/cuphea-annual-plants-provide-nonstop-summer-color/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Like the other Cuphea species, firecracker plant does best in full sun and moist, well-drained soils.","level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"Roger's Gardens plant database, Firecracker Plant (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://plants.rogersgardens.com/12290002/Plant/16821/Firecracker_Plant/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub does best in full sun to partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"Quality Cuttings wholesale catalog (Cuphea Ignea)","url":"https://qualitycuttings.com/product/cuphea-ignea-cigar-plant/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"A fantastic choice to any landscape with shade to partial sun.","level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cuphea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cuphea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cuphea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cuphea-ignea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The plant likes moisture, but it is somewhat drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282501","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It also tolerates some drought, but performs best with regular moisture.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension EDIS fact sheet FP160 (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP160","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance: moderate","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"Quality Cuttings wholesale catalog (Cuphea Ignea)","url":"https://qualitycuttings.com/product/cuphea-ignea-cigar-plant/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cuphea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cuphea-ignea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds, butterflies, and other pollinators are attracted to its nectar.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282501","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension EDIS fact sheet FP160 (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP160","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: container or above-ground planter; specimen; foundation; attracts hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture Extension, Plant of the Week: Firecracker Plant (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/firecracker-plant-7-1-05.aspx","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The tubular red flowers of this summertime bloomer make it an attractive plant for hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"University of Georgia CAES Field Report, Cuphea annual plants provide nonstop summer color (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/news/cuphea-annual-plants-provide-nonstop-summer-color/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They attract butterflies and hummingbirds like magnets.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"Roger's Gardens plant database, Firecracker Plant (Cuphea ignea)","url":"https://plants.rogersgardens.com/12290002/Plant/16821/Firecracker_Plant/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting bees and butterflies to your yard.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"},{"name":"Quality Cuttings wholesale catalog (Cuphea Ignea)","url":"https://qualitycuttings.com/product/cuphea-ignea-cigar-plant/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cuphea Ignea is loved by all gardeners and pollinators alike!","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cuphea ignea"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cuphea-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 - 2 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height 1-2 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Only a foot or two in height, and maybe up to three feet wide given time\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"It is a small shrub with a rounded growth habit and can grow up to two feet tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cuphea-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.75 to 2.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 9 in. - 2 ft. 8 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1 - 4 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread 2-3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"maybe up to three feet wide given time\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cuphea-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["9-11","8-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282494&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 9 to 11","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cuphea-hyssopifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database (Herbaceous Plant Finder)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Cuphea_hyssopifolia.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: zones 9 - 11","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"UF/IFAS Florida-Friendly Landscaping Florida Bee Gardens","url":"https://ffl-apps.ifas.ufl.edu/bees/Plants/Details/119","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 8a to 11","zones":[8,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cuphea-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282494&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cuphea-hyssopifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Florida-Friendly Landscaping Florida Bee Gardens","url":"https://ffl-apps.ifas.ufl.edu/bees/Plants/Details/119","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It performs in Partial Shade to Full Sun"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Charlotte County","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/charlotteco/2023/10/04/false-heather-several-colors-one-plant/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Best in full-sun to part-shade sites"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/cupheas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"All cupheas are easy to grow in the sun to partial shade."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cuphea-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cuphea-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cuphea-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282494&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates high summer heat and some drought.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cuphea-hyssopifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"tolerates full sun, and withstands high summer heat and some drought","claim":true},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database (Herbaceous Plant Finder)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Cuphea_hyssopifolia.php","country":null,"form":null,"value":"low water requirement drought-tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"UF/IFAS Florida-Friendly Landscaping Florida Bee Gardens","url":"https://ffl-apps.ifas.ufl.edu/bees/Plants/Details/119","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerance High","claim":true},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Charlotte County","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/charlotteco/2023/10/04/false-heather-several-colors-one-plant/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"false heather is drought-tolerant and moderately salt-tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cuphea-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282494&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cuphea-hyssopifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract butterflies, bees, and hummingbirds.","claim":true},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Charlotte County","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/charlotteco/2023/10/04/false-heather-several-colors-one-plant/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinators appreciate these flowers and often visit false heather","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/cupheas/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attract hummingbirds, butterflies, bees, and other pollinating insects","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"cyclamen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.23,0.28],"union":[0.05,0.3],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyclamen/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 4 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.1,0.3],"band":[0.1,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"cyclamen"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/cyclamen/growing-guide","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Height and spread - 5-13cm (2-5in) by 8-15cm (3-6in)","metres":[0.05,0.13],"band":[0.05,0.13],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"cyclamen"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/cyclamen/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Cyclamen grows from a tuber and can get as large as ten inches.","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"cyclamen"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":10},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cyclamen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.08,0.3],"split":[{"range":[0.08,0.15],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society"]},{"range":[0.2,0.3],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyclamen/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 8 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"cyclamen"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/cyclamen/growing-guide","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Height and spread - 5-13cm (2-5in) by 8-15cm (3-6in)","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"cyclamen"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":10},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cyclamen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyclamen/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[4,11],"level":"genus","taxon":"cyclamen"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":10},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cyclamen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/cyclamen/growing-guide","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Aspect - Partial shade","level":"genus","taxon":"cyclamen"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyclamen-hederifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant prefers humus-rich, moist soil in partial shade but will grow in average dry to moist soil.","level":"species","taxon":"cyclamen hederifolium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyclamen-graecum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"While it prefers full fun or partial shade, it can withstand even deep shade.","level":"species","taxon":"cyclamen graecum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285539","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade","level":"species","taxon":"cyclamen hederifolium"},{"name":"Fairfax Master Gardeners, Virginia Cooperative Extension","url":"https://fairfaxgardening.org/cyclamen/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Cyclamen grow well in partial sun and need rich, moist, well-drained soil.","level":"species","taxon":"cyclamen hederifolium"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/cyclamen-hederifolium/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure: Dappled shade, full shade, partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"cyclamen hederifolium"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cyclamen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyclamen/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Some flowers are scented.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"cyclamen"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyclamen-persicum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Their leaves are heart-shaped, and the flowers are sweetly scented.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cyclamen persicum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyclamen-graecum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are white or pink with a darker blotch and are often fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cyclamen graecum"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/cyclamen/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Some miniature types have standard size leaves, but tiny, lightly scented flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cyclamen persicum"},{"name":"Purdue Extension, Indiana Yard and Garden","url":"https://www.purdue.edu/hla/sites/yardandgarden/cyclamen-cyclamen-persicum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It produces sweet-scented pink, red, or white flowers, 1/2 to 3/4 inches or more long on tall, slender stems, from early winter to early spring.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cyclamen persicum"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/plant-information/cyclamen","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Petals are frilled, folded, crested, doubled, and often fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cyclamen persicum"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"cyclamen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cyclamen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["cyclamen hederifolium"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (cyclamen hederifolium), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (cyclamen hederifolium) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"cyclamen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyclamen/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyclamen-hederifolium/"]},{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyclamen/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyclamen-persicum/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyclamen/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees pollinate the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"cyclamen"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyclamen-hederifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cyclamen hederifolium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyclamen-persicum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are pollinated by bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cyclamen persicum"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["cyclamen hederifolium"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (cyclamen hederifolium), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are ncsu.edu. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (cyclamen hederifolium) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"daffodil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.2,0.51],"union":[0.05,0.76],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264603","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.50 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.15,0.76],"band":[0.15,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 8 in. - 2 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.2,0.76],"band":[0.2,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-daffodils","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants can be as short as 4 to 6 inches and as tall as 20 inches when in bloom.","metres":[0.1,0.51],"band":[0.1,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Georgia Cooperative Extension, bulletin B918 Flowering Bulbs for Georgia Gardens","url":"https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=B918&title=flowering-bulbs-for-georgia-gardens","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Narcissus species & hybrids Narcissus, Daffodil, Jonquil H F 3-6″ 3-6″ early-mid* 6-24″","metres":[0.15,0.61],"band":[0.15,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"American Daffodil Society","url":"https://daffodilusa.org/daffodil-info/daffodil-faqs/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Daffodils come in all sizes from 5-inch blooms on 2-foot stems to half-inch flowers on 2-inch stems.","metres":[0.05,0.61],"band":[0.05,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"genus":14},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daffodil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.15,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.15,0.3],"union":[0.15,0.3],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264603","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.50 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"genus":14},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daffodil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264603","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8],"level":"genus"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/narcissus-the-daffodil","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The daffodil is a hardy bulb that overwinters in USDA zones 3 through 8.","zones":[3,8],"level":"genus"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension Service","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/publications/daffodils-for-the-farmer-florist","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Daffodils are winter hardy in USDA zones 3 through 8 and will return to bloom again year after year.","zones":[3,8],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"genus":14},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daffodil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264603","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Daffodils require full sun to partial shade and acidic soil.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-daffodils","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Daffodils should be planted in a full-sun location, but they can tolerate part-sun locations under deciduous trees.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/narcissus-the-daffodil","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Daffodil flowers like to follow the sun, so light is crucial, but they may bloom in partial shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Penn State Extension Master Gardener, Luzerne County","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/programs/master-gardener/counties/luzerne/resources/monthly-birth-flowers/march-daffodil-narcissus-spp","country":"US","form":null,"value":"While they grow and bloom best in direct sun, they will tolerate part shade (about 4 to 6 hours of direct sun).","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/spring-daffodils","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They need good drainage and grow best in full sun locations.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Ohio State University Extension, Clermont County","url":"https://u.osu.edu/extensionclermont/2023/03/03/daffodils/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Daffodils do best in full sun, though they will grow in partial shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/growing-tips-daffodils-narcissus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most Narcissus prefer full sun, although they will tolerate partial shade.","level":"genus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daffodil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264603","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are sometimes fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fragrant flowers bloom for two to three weeks between late winter and late spring.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-daffodils","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Division VII: Jonquilla Daffodils - Several fragrant flowers per stem.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/spring-flowering-bulbs/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This group of daffodils typically has small, yellow flowers held in clusters of two to six sweetly fragrant blooms per stem and slender rush-like leaves.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension, guide G6610 Spring Flowering Bulbs: Daffodils","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/publications/g6610","country":null,"form":null,"value":"True jonquils have a reed-like leaves and fragrant flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Van Engelen Inc. wholesale flower bulbs, Narcissus Horticultural Tips","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/narcissus.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are usually fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"daffodil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Daffodils are great for use in beds, borders, rock gardens, as fresh cut flowers, ground covers, and in woodland gardens.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-daffodils","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Daffodils make excellent cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension Service","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/publications/daffodils-for-the-farmer-florist","country":null,"form":null,"value":"When growing daffodils as fresh cut flowers, harvest the stems when they are just showing color","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Van Engelen Inc. wholesale flower bulbs, Narcissus Horticultural Tips","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/narcissus.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Even individual stems in bud vases are spectacular indoors.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"daffodil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264603","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soils should be kept uniformly moist during the growing season, but drought is tolerated while dormant.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"While drought tolerant, the plants require moisture and good drainage during the growing season.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daffodil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"genus":10,"unstated":1},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 6.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Most dahlias reach about 1.2m (4ft), for mid-border positions, and need staking for support.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"up to 5 feet or more\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"genus":10,"unstated":1},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,10],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[7,10],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a445","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 7 to 10","zones":[7,10],"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[7,10],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"genus":10,"unstated":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source states 7-10; catalog states 8-10","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a445","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dahlias need fertile, moist but well-drained soil, and full sun to partial shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Home and Garden Information Center, Summer- and Fall-Flowering Bulbs","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/summer-and-fall-flowering-bulbs/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dahlias prefer full sun and a rich, well-drained soil.","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Plant of the Week: Dahlias","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/hort-home-landscape/2015-09-03-plant-week-dahlias","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These roots should be planted outside in spring 1-2 weeks before the last frost date (or start earlier indoors in pots) in organically rich, medium moisture, well-drained soils in full sun.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Yard and Garden, Planting and Caring for Tender Perennials","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/planting-and-caring-tender-perennials","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dahlias perform best in well-drained soil in full sun.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Proven Winners, Dahlia growing guide","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-to/dahlia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dahlias perform best with at least 6 hours of full sun per day."},{"name":"Swan Island Dahlias, How to Grow Dahlias","url":"https://www.dahlias.com/help-center/how-to-grow-dahlias/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant them in a full sun location (giving them 6-8 hours of direct sunlight) and enjoy blooms all summer long.","level":"genus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a445","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They bloom from mid-summer to mid-fall, showy and excellent in flower arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Oregon State University Extension, Dahlias in Oregon (FS 95)","url":"https://catalog.extension.oregonstate.edu/fs95/html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"All the blooms in the classification chart below also work as cut flowers for a bouquet.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Plant of the Week: Dahlias","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/hort-home-landscape/2015-09-03-plant-week-dahlias","country":null,"form":null,"value":"are an excellent cut flower which is why I love to grow them","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of California ANR Master Gardeners, Growing Dahlias","url":"https://ucanr.edu/blog/savvy-sage/article/growing-dahlias","country":null,"form":null,"value":"makes a lovely cut flower","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, Dahlias growing guide","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/dahlia/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dahlias are popular as cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Proven Winners, Dahlia growing guide","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-to/dahlia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Include dahlias in a cutting garden alongside other plants such as gladiolus, Shasta daisy, sunflower, zinnias and cosmos for colorful bouquets to display in your home.","claim":true},{"name":"Swan Island Dahlias, How to Grow Dahlias","url":"https://www.dahlias.com/help-center/how-to-grow-dahlias/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They will bloom and provide you with color and abundant flowers for cutting and enjoying throughout the summer.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a445","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Provide consistent moisture during the growing season and do not allow soils to dry out.","claim":false,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Keep them mulched and provide plenty of water, and they will reward you with a long bloom season, from late summer to first frost.","claim":false,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Oregon State University Extension, Dahlias in Oregon (FS 95)","url":"https://catalog.extension.oregonstate.edu/fs95/html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dahlias are large plants and need a fair amount of water.","claim":false,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension, Dahlias (Circular 576)","url":"https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=C576&title=dahlias","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dahlia plants are composed mostly of water. Don't expect good flowers unless you plan to water during dry periods.","claim":false,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Home and Garden Information Center, Summer- and Fall-Flowering Bulbs","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/summer-and-fall-flowering-bulbs/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Keep them actively growing for best results with ample water and fertilization.","claim":false,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Plant of the Week: Dahlias","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/hort-home-landscape/2015-09-03-plant-week-dahlias","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They do best when consistent moisture is provided during the growing season.","claim":false,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of California ANR Master Gardeners, Growing Dahlias","url":"https://ucanr.edu/blog/savvy-sage/article/growing-dahlias","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water deeply once or twice a week and more often in extreme heat or if your dahlia is in a container.","claim":false,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Proven Winners, Dahlia growing guide","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-to/dahlia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water regularly to keep the soil consistently moist, especially during hot, dry periods.","claim":false}],"note":"8 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a445","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They attract bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Oregon State University Extension, Dahlias in Oregon (FS 95)","url":"https://catalog.extension.oregonstate.edu/fs95/html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Not only do dahlia flowers make beautiful arrangements, but they are also a great source of nectar and pollen for bees, butterflies and other insects.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, Dahlias growing guide","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/dahlia/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Single flowers are best for pollinators","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Proven Winners, Dahlia growing guide","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-to/dahlia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinators are attracted to the long-lasting blooms.","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"dahlia-arabian-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":1,"cultivar":11},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":11,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 18″-24″\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Flowering Height 35 to 40 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The plants reach a height of 36-40 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"HEIGHT 3½-4'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Plant Height: Approx. 38\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Decorative, 3-4.5\" bloom on plants 3-4' tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 36-40\" tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant Height: 36-48 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height 100 cm.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Standing tall at 36-48 inches with sturdy stems, these magnificent flowers are perfect for creating striking visual impact in gardens and floral arrangements.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level; 11 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-arabian-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":1,"cultivar":11},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-arabian-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["8-10","9-10","3-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://www.brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/dahlia-arabian-night/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 8, 9, 10","zones":[8,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/dahlia-arabian-night","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones Hardy 9-10, Suitable 3-10","zones":[9,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Old House Gardens","url":"https://oldhousegardens.com/store/bulb-info/SD02/Arabian-Night-Dahlia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ZONES 3a-7b(10bWC)","zones":[3,7],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-dahlia-flower-bulbs-arabian-night","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dahlias are perennial in zones 8-10, but in cooler zones, tubers can be dug after frost comes, stored over winter, then re-planted the following spring.","zones":[8,10],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":1,"cultivar":11},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-arabian-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dahlia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/82617/dahlia-arabian-night-d/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://www.brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/dahlia-arabian-night/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun, Part Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/dahlia-arabian-night","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Harvesting History","url":"https://www.harvesting-history.com/product/decorative-dahlia-arabian-night/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"FULL SUN TO PARTIAL SHADE","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Old House Gardens","url":"https://oldhousegardens.com/store/bulb-info/SD02/Arabian-Night-Dahlia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"LIGHT full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-dahlia-flower-bulbs-arabian-night","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Muddy Mountain Flower Farm","url":"https://www.muddymountainflowers.com/shop/p/arabiannightdahliatuber","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Requirements: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Kennedy's Country Gardens","url":"https://kennedyscountrygardens.com/product/dahlia-arabian-night/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"well-drained soil and full sun (6-8 hours daily)","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-arabian-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/dahlia-arabian-night","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant No","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-arabian-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dahlia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/82617/dahlia-arabian-night-d/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://www.brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/dahlia-arabian-night/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"If they are picked for arrangements, these 'cut and come again' plants require almost no care and come in a myriad of colors.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/dahlia-arabian-night","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Arabian Night is one of the most sultry and unique Dahlias around and has been a firm favorite in cutting gardens for over 60 years.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Old House Gardens","url":"https://oldhousegardens.com/store/bulb-info/SD02/Arabian-Night-Dahlia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This deep velvety crimson beauty will bring a stunning contrast to your summer bouquets and gardens as its medium (4-6\") flowers and darker green foliage add hints of mystery without overwhelming lighter colors.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Summer Dreams Farm","url":"https://summerdreamsfarm.com/dahlias-by-color-red/dahlia-arabian-night","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This highly prolific flower is perfect in arrangements with other dahlias or can even create a spectacular arrangement by itself as each flower has a different amount of light and dark in its petals.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sunset View Farm Dahlias","url":"https://www.sunsetviewfarmdahlias.com/product-page/arabian-night","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Arabian Night has a long history as a cutting garden favorite.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-dahlia-flower-bulbs-arabian-night","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These huge, stunning flowers are perfect for adding to summer bouquets, or for blending into multi-foliage backdrops where they can add another subtle layer of depth for brighter blooms to play off of.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Muddy Mountain Flower Farm","url":"https://www.muddymountainflowers.com/shop/p/arabiannightdahliatuber","country":null,"form":null,"value":"perfect for cut flower gardens, bouquets , and borders.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Anglia Bulb Company","url":"https://www.angliabulbs.com/product/dahlia-arabian-night/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are a good size for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Kennedy's Country Gardens","url":"https://kennedyscountrygardens.com/product/dahlia-arabian-night/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"great for borders and cutting gardens","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"11 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-arabian-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Harvesting History","url":"https://www.harvesting-history.com/product/decorative-dahlia-arabian-night/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dahlias require frequent watering, and if left to dry out will put on a dramatic display of horrendously drooping leaves and blossoms.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-arabian-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dahlia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attracts butterflies, bees, and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-dahlia-flower-bulbs-arabian-night","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Kennedy's Country Gardens","url":"https://kennedyscountrygardens.com/product/dahlia-arabian-night/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and humming birds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"dahlia-bishop-of-llandaff","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":4,"cultivar":5},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height 36 - 40 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 2′-3′\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 100cm / 39\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height 1.1m\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-bishop-of-llandaff","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":4,"cultivar":5},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread 0.45m\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-bishop-of-llandaff","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-10","8-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/bishop-of-llandaff-dahlia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3-10","zones":[3,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/dahlia-bishop-of-llandaff/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 8, 9, 10","zones":[8,10],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":4,"cultivar":5},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-bishop-of-llandaff","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264590","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dahlias need fertile, moist but well-drained soil, and full sun to partial shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp169","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Best growth occurs in full sun, but the plants tolerate partial shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/96238/dahlia-bishop-of-llandaff-p/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/bishop-of-llandaff-dahlia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/dahlia-bishop-of-llandaff/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun, Part Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Harts Nursery","url":"https://www.hartsnursery.co.uk/Dahlia-Bishop-of-Llandaff.html","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Aspect: Full Sun/Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proctors Nursery","url":"https://proctorsnursery.co.uk/product/dahlia-bishop-of-llandaff/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Sun/shade Likes full sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-bishop-of-llandaff","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"Harts Nursery","url":"https://www.hartsnursery.co.uk/Dahlia-Bishop-of-Llandaff.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Scented: No","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proctors Nursery","url":"https://proctorsnursery.co.uk/product/dahlia-bishop-of-llandaff/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Scent No","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-bishop-of-llandaff","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264590","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp169","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: container or above-ground planter; cut flowers; border","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/C576/dahlias/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers only after they open to mature size","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/dahlia-bishop-of-llandaff/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They produce an abundance of wonderful flowers perfect for 'gift giving flower arrangements' throughout early summer and again in late summer until frost.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-bishop-of-llandaff","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-bishop-of-llandaff","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264590","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They attract bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"Harts Nursery","url":"https://www.hartsnursery.co.uk/Dahlia-Bishop-of-Llandaff.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This single-flowered dahlia is not only eye-catching but also pollinator-friendly, attracting bees and butterflies throughout its long flowering season-from mid-summer through to the first frost.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"dahlia-cafe-au-lait","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":3,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"A clump-forming, tuberous perennial to 1.2m in height with toothed, dark green leaves.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 3′-4′\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Flowering Height 36-48 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height 40 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The plants reach a height of 40-48 inches.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 36-48”\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-cafe-au-lait","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":3,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread 18-20 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 18-24”\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-cafe-au-lait","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["8-11","9-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/dahlia-cafe-au-lait/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 8, 9, 10, 11","zones":[8,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/dahlia-cafe-au-lait","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones Hardy 9-10, Suitable 3-10","zones":[9,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"A.D.R. Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Dahlia-Dinnerplate-Cafe-Au-Lait","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy in USDA zones 8 to 11.","zones":[8,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Easy To Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/dahlia-caf-au-lait","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8-11","zones":[8,11],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":3,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-cafe-au-lait","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264590&isprofile=0&letter=D","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/50819/dahlia-cafe-au-lait-d/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/dahlia-cafe-au-lait/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun, Part Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/dahlia-cafe-au-lait","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"A.D.R. Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Dahlia-Dinnerplate-Cafe-Au-Lait","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6–8 hours daily) is essential.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Harvesting History","url":"https://www.harvesting-history.com/product/dinnerplate-dahlia-cafe-au-lait/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"FULL SUN TO PARTIAL SHADE","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/hort-home-landscape/2015-09-03-plant-week-dahlias","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These roots should be planted outside in spring 1-2 weeks before the last frost date (or start earlier indoors in pots) in organically rich, medium moisture, well-drained soils in full sun.","level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"Easy To Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/dahlia-caf-au-lait","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-cafe-au-lait","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/dahlia-cafe-au-lait","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant No","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-cafe-au-lait","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264590&isprofile=0&letter=D","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Best in groups of at least five. Borders, window boxes, containers. Good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They bloom from mid-summer to mid-fall, showy and excellent in flower arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/50819/dahlia-cafe-au-lait-d/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/dahlia-cafe-au-lait/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They produce an abundance of wonderful flowers perfect for ‘gift giving flower arrangements’ throughout early summer and again in late summer until frost.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/dahlia-cafe-au-lait","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cut flower with long vase life","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"A.D.R. Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Dahlia-Dinnerplate-Cafe-Au-Lait","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A favorite for weddings and cut flower arrangements, Cafe au Lait is one of the most popular and famous dahlia varieties.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Harvesting History","url":"https://www.harvesting-history.com/product/dinnerplate-dahlia-cafe-au-lait/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This dahlia is one of the most sought after specimens for summer bridal bouquets","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/hort-home-landscape/2015-09-03-plant-week-dahlias","country":null,"form":null,"value":"are an excellent cut flower which is why I love to grow them","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"Easy To Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/dahlia-caf-au-lait","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Summer blooming favorite, especially for cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-cafe-au-lait","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264590&isprofile=0&letter=D","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Provide consistent moisture during the growing season and do not allow soils to dry out.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Keep them mulched and provide plenty of water, and they will reward you with a long bloom season, from late summer to first frost.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"Harvesting History","url":"https://www.harvesting-history.com/product/dinnerplate-dahlia-cafe-au-lait/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dahlias require frequent watering, and if left to dry out will put on a dramatic display of horrendously drooping leaves and blossoms.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/hort-home-landscape/2015-09-03-plant-week-dahlias","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They do best when consistent moisture is provided during the growing season.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"}],"note":"4 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-cafe-au-lait","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264590&isprofile=0&letter=D","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They attract bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"A.D.R. Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Dahlia-Dinnerplate-Cafe-Au-Lait","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"dahlia-david-howard","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":6,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"HEIGHT 3-4'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height 40 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 3.5-4 ft\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant height 46\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Bloom Size: 4 inches; Height: 3-4 feet; Type: Decorative\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 75cm Spread: 75cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-david-howard","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":6,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread 18-20 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 75cm Spread: 75cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-david-howard","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"A.D.R. Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Dahlia-Decorative-David-Howard","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 8-11","zones":[8,11],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":6,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-david-howard","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":11,"distinctPublishers":11,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264590","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dahlias need fertile, moist but well-drained soil, and full sun to partial shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp169","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Best growth occurs in full sun, but the plants tolerate partial shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/hort-home-landscape/2015-09-03-plant-week-dahlias","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These roots should be planted outside in spring 1-2 weeks before the last frost date (or start earlier indoors in pots) in organically rich, medium moisture, well-drained soils in full sun.","level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/57111/dahlia-david-howard-(d)/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Old House Gardens","url":"https://oldhousegardens.com/store/bulb-info/SD78/David-Howard-Dahlia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"LIGHT full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"A.D.R. Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Dahlia-Decorative-David-Howard","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6–8 hours daily) is essential for strong stems and prolific blooms.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fleur Farm","url":"https://fleurfarm.com/product/dahlia-david-howard/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light preference Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Flower Feather Farm","url":"https://www.flowerfeatherfarm.com/dahlia-tubers/p/david-howard-dahlia-tubers","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fine Gardening","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/dahlia-dahlia-david-howard","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/dahlia-david-howard/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure: Full sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-david-howard","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-david-howard","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264590","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp169","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: container or above-ground planter; cut flowers; border","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/C576/dahlias/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers only after they open to mature size","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/hort-home-landscape/2015-09-03-plant-week-dahlias","country":null,"form":null,"value":"an excellent cut flower which is why I love to grow them","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/57111/dahlia-david-howard-(d)/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"A.D.R. Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Dahlia-Decorative-David-Howard","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fleur Farm","url":"https://fleurfarm.com/product/dahlia-david-howard/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vase life 5-7 days","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Flower Feather Farm","url":"https://www.flowerfeatherfarm.com/dahlia-tubers/p/david-howard-dahlia-tubers","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cut flowers and long-lasting bloomers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-david-howard","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dahlia-david-howard","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264590","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They attract bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"dahlia"},{"name":"A.D.R. Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Dahlia-Decorative-David-Howard","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/dahlia-david-howard/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"has no particular known value to wildlife in the UK","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"dahlia-fleurel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":11,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: Grows 36-48\" tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 2′-3′\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Flowering Height 36 to 48 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height/Habit 36 - 48 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 36 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 1-1.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 120 cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Eventual height 1-1.2m\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Höhe 0,8 - 1 m\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Hauteur à maturité 70 cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 11 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-fleurel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 24 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Spread 60 cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spreads approximately 40-60cm.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Breite 50 - 60 cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Largeur à maturité 60 cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-fleurel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-10","9-11","8-10","9-10","3-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Dahlia group page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264590","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 7 to 10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dahlia genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/dahlia-fleurel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 9 through 11","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/fleurel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 8, 9, 10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/dahlia-fleurel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones Hardy 9-10, Suitable 3-10","zones":[9,10]},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/fleurel-dahlia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3-10","zones":[3,10]},{"name":"K. van Bourgondien","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/fleurel-giant-dinner-plate-dahlias","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-10","zones":[3,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-fleurel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Dahlia group page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264590","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dahlia genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dahlia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/fleurel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun, Part Shade"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/dahlia-fleurel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full Sun"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/fleurel-dahlia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Full Sun"},{"name":"K. van Bourgondien","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/fleurel-giant-dinner-plate-dahlias","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun"},{"name":"Pike Nurseries Plant Library (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.pikenursery.com/12291001/Plant/17824/Fleurel_Dahlia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in full sun to partial shade."},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/147823/dahlia-fleurel-fim/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"Roots Plants","url":"https://www.rootsplants.co.uk/products/dahlia-fluerel","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"For best blooming, plant in full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-fleurel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/dahlia-fleurel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant No","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-fleurel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/dahlia-fleurel","https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/dahlia-fleurel"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/dahlia-fleurel","https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/fleurel-giant-dinner-plate-dahlias"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/dahlia-fleurel","https://plants.pikenursery.com/12291001/Plant/17824/Fleurel_Dahlia"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/dahlia-fleurel","https://www.jparkers.co.uk/3-dahlia-fleurel-1008745"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/dahlia-fleurel","https://www.rootsplants.co.uk/products/dahlia-fluerel"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/dahlia-fleurel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plant Features: Big Blooms, Great for Cut Flowers","claim":true},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/dahlia-fleurel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"excellent cut flower for bouquets","claim":true},{"name":"K. van Bourgondien","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/fleurel-giant-dinner-plate-dahlias","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Suggested Uses: Borders, Bouquets, Cut Flowers, Perennializing, Showy Flowers, Deer Resistant","claim":true},{"name":"Pike Nurseries Plant Library (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.pikenursery.com/12291001/Plant/17824/Fleurel_Dahlia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true},{"name":"J. Parker's Dutch Bulbs","url":"https://www.jparkers.co.uk/3-dahlia-fleurel-1008745","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Roots Plants","url":"https://www.rootsplants.co.uk/products/dahlia-fluerel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"An ideal choice for cutting gardens","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 6 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 6","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-fleurel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-fleurel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Pike Nurseries Plant Library (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.pikenursery.com/12291001/Plant/17824/Fleurel_Dahlia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting bees and butterflies to your yard.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-karma-choc","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Grows 36\" tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"3½'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-karma-choc","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-karma-choc","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/dahlia-karma-chocolate","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 9 through 11","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-karma-choc","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-karma-choc","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-karma-choc","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/dahlia-karma-chocolate","https://www.dahlias.com/karma-choc"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/dahlia-karma-chocolate","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bred in Holland for the cut flower market, these 4 to 5\" blossoms have sturdy stems and are long-lasting in a vase.","claim":true},{"name":"Swan Island Dahlias","url":"https://www.dahlias.com/karma-choc","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent Cut Flower","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-karma-choc","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-karma-choc","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-ottos-thrill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"40-44\" tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"4'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-ottos-thrill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-ottos-thrill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-dahlia-flower-bulbs-ottos-thrill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones 3 to 10","zones":[3,10]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-ottos-thrill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-dahlia-flower-bulbs-ottos-thrill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-ottos-thrill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-ottos-thrill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-dahlia-flower-bulbs-ottos-thrill","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-ottos-thrill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dahlia-ottos-thrill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-dahlia-flower-bulbs-ottos-thrill","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dames-de-chenonceau-rose","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.8,0.89],"union":[0.73,1],"proposed":0.85,"margin":20,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Georges Delbard (breeder)","url":"https://www.georgesdelbard.com/product/rosier-dames-de-chenonceau","country":"FR","form":"shrub","value":"De 80 à 100 cm","metres":[0.8,1],"band":[0.8,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Rose Farm Canada","url":"https://rosefarmcanada.com/product/rosa-dames-de-chenonceau/","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"up to 32 inches in height","metres":0.81,"band":[0.73,0.89],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.73 to 1 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dames-de-chenonceau-rose","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Rose Farm Canada","url":"https://rosefarmcanada.com/product/rosa-dames-de-chenonceau/","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"spreading 20 to 24 inches wide","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dames-de-chenonceau-rose","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Rose Farm Canada","url":"https://rosefarmcanada.com/product/rosa-dames-de-chenonceau/","country":"CA","form":"floribunda","value":"USDA hardiness zones 6b through 9b","zones":[6,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dames-de-chenonceau-rose","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Rose Farm Canada","url":"https://rosefarmcanada.com/product/rosa-dames-de-chenonceau/","country":"CA","form":"floribunda","value":"preferring full sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dames-de-chenonceau-rose","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.georgesdelbard.com/product/rosier-dames-de-chenonceau","https://rosefarmcanada.com/product/rosa-dames-de-chenonceau/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Georges Delbard (breeder)","url":"https://www.georgesdelbard.com/product/rosier-dames-de-chenonceau","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Variété parfumée","claim":true},{"name":"Rose Farm Canada","url":"https://rosefarmcanada.com/product/rosa-dames-de-chenonceau/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"mild to strong fragrance with notes of anise, citrus, and fruit","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dames-de-chenonceau-rose","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dames-de-chenonceau-rose","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dames-de-chenonceau-rose","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dames-de-chenonceau-rose","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"botanicalName","current":"Rosa 'Dames de Chenonceau'","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/204220/rosa-dames-de-chenonceau-delpabra-(s)/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Listed: Rosa Dames de Chenonceau ('Delpabra') (S), synonym Rosa 'Delpabra', family Rosaceae, name classified as a trade name"},{"name":"Breeder (Georges Delbard)","url":"https://www.georgesdelbard.com/product/rosier-dames-de-chenonceau","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sold by the raiser as Rosier Dames de Chenonceau(R)"}],"note":"name resolves as Rosa Dames de Chenonceau ('Delpabra') (S)","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"darcey-bussell","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.1,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.34],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US, the breeder)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/darcey-bussell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/darcey-bussel","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4' x 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/darcey-bussell-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/darcey-bussell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: ~3–4′","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"darcey-bussell","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.61,1.34],"split":[{"range":[0.61,1],"sources":["Grace Rose Farm","Menagerie Farm & Flower"]},{"range":[1.1,1.34],"sources":["David Austin Roses (US, the breeder)","Heirloom Roses"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US, the breeder)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/darcey-bussell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/darcey-bussel","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4' x 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/darcey-bussell-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/darcey-bussell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: ~2–3′","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"darcey-bussell","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US, the breeder)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/darcey-bussell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/darcey-bussel","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/darcey-bussell-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Suitable Zones: 5-10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/darcey-bussell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zones: USDA Zones 5–11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"darcey-bussell","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US, the breeder)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/darcey-bussell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/darcey-bussel","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/darcey-bussell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light Requirements: Full sun to partial shade","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"darcey-bussell","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["light","strong","light"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/darcey-bussell","https://heirloomroses.com/products/darcey-bussel"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/darcey-bussell","https://menagerieflower.com/products/darcey-bussell-rose-david-austin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/darcey-bussell","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/darcey-bussell"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US, the breeder)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/darcey-bussell","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There is a light-medium fruity scent.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/darcey-bussel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lightly Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/darcey-bussell-rose-david-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"have a strong old rose fragrance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/darcey-bussell","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Light-to-medium fruity scent","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"darcey-bussell","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://menagerieflower.com/products/darcey-bussell-rose-david-austin","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/darcey-bussell"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/darcey-bussell-rose-david-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A lovely rose for Fall and Winter arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/darcey-bussell","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vase Life: Very good","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"darcey-bussell","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"darcey-bussell","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"daylily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.38,0.91],"union":[0.2,1.52],"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1177: Daylily","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/daylily/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Daylilies can range in height from 8 inches to 5 feet, and flower size can be as small as 2 inches or as large as 8 inches.","metres":[0.2,1.52],"band":[0.2,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension: Daylilies","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/daylilies","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Daylilies typically grow one to four feet high.","metres":[0.3,1.22],"band":[0.3,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers: Daylily","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 12 Inches to 4 Feet","metres":[0.3,1.22],"band":[0.3,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers: Daylily (Hemerocallis sp.)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=727&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 12 Inches - 4 Feet","metres":[0.3,1.22],"band":[0.3,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"RHS growing guide: How to grow hemerocallis","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/hemerocallis/growing-guide","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"plants range in height from 20cm (8in) up to 1.5m (5ft), for the front, middle or back of borders","metres":[0.2,1.5],"band":[0.2,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension Bulletin 944: Flowering Perennials for Georgia Gardens (Hemerocallis species and hybrids)","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/B944/flowering-perennials-for-georgia-gardens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing from 1 to 4 feet high, a rainbow of colors is now available.","metres":[0.3,1.22],"band":[0.3,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension G6650: Flowering Perennials - Characteristics and Culture (Daylily row)","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/publications/g6650","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Daylily (Hemerocallis hybrids) 15–36","metres":[0.38,0.91],"band":[0.38,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension, Southern Gardening: Beautiful array of daylilies display their variety in May","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/news/southern-gardening/2022/beautiful-array-daylilies-display-their-variety-may","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They also come in different sizes from 12 inches to over 40 inches tall.","metres":[0.3,1.02],"band":[0.3,1.02],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":13,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.3,1],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"American Meadows: How to Grow Daylilies","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/blogs/perennials/how-to-grow-daylilies","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Daylilies will eventually expand to form large clumps up to three feet in diameter.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":13,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers: Daylily","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 3 - 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers: Daylily (Hemerocallis sp.)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=727&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 3 - 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":13,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hemerocallis fulva)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=k430","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"hemerocallis fulva"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis hybrida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis-hybrida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Daylilies grow best in full sun to partial shade and in loamy soil with good drainage and average fertility.","level":"species","taxon":"hemerocallis hybrida"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension: Daylilies","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/daylilies","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Best in full sun, but will tolerate light shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers: Daylily","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun, Partial Sun/Shade","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers: Daylily (Hemerocallis sp.)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=727&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Will grow in moist well drained soil in a sun to partial shade situation.","level":"genus"},{"name":"RHS growing guide: How to grow hemerocallis","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/hemerocallis/growing-guide","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Hemerocallis perform best in full sun, but are fine in partial shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"American Daylily Society, Frequently Asked Questions","url":"https://daylilies.org/resources/faq/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most daylilies do best in full sun. They will tolerate part-shade conditions, but require a minimum of six hours of direct sun per day.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery: Getting Started With Daylilies, A Beginner's Guide","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/blogs/marketing/getting-started-with-daylilies-a-beginners-guide","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Daylilies thrive in full sun to partial shade, so it's essential to select a location in your garden that receives at least 6 hours of direct sunlight each day.","level":"genus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#fragrant flowers","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1177: Daylily","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/daylily/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lemon yellow fragrant flowers on tall scapes open at dusk and fill the garden with their sweet perfume.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension: Daylilies","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/daylilies","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Many of these night-blooming plants are delightfully fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers: Daylily","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/daylily","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Some offer fragrant flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"RHS growing guide: How to grow hemerocallis","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/hemerocallis/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There are early-season, mid- and late-season cultivars, some are fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"daylily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Illinois Extension, Hort in the Home Landscape: Using Cut Flowers to Bring the Garden Indoors","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/hort-home-landscape/2017-06-09-using-cut-flowers-bring-garden-indoors","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Daylilies, for example, have a very accurate name; the flower only lasts for a day, making it a poor choice for a cut flower garden.","claim":false,"level":"genus"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought Salt","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hemerocallis fulva)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=k430","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Drought, Erosion, Clay Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hemerocallis fulva"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis hybrida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis-hybrida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are drought, heat, and salt resistant and tolerate urban conditions, too.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hemerocallis hybrida"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1177: Daylily","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/daylily/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Although daylilies are drought-tolerant once established, consistent watering while budding and flowering produces better-quality flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension: Daylilies","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/daylilies","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Daylilies tolerate drought, but they perform best in moist, well-drained soils.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"RHS growing guide: How to grow hemerocallis","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/hemerocallis/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, hemerocallis tend to be drought tolerant as they have an extensive root system.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"American Daylily Society, Frequently Asked Questions","url":"https://daylilies.org/resources/faq/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant when necessary, with relatively few pest and disease problems in most gardens.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery: Getting Started With Daylilies, A Beginner's Guide","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/blogs/marketing/getting-started-with-daylilies-a-beginners-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"While daylilies are relatively drought-tolerant, they still require consistent moisture, especially during their active growing season.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are also useful in a butterfly or childrens' garden, as they provide a nectar source for butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hemerocallis fulva)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=k430","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hemerocallis fulva"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis hybrida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis-hybrida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hemerocallis hybrida"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"daylily-bela-lugosi","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.75,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.77,0.84],"union":[0.54,0.95],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"American Daylily Society, cultivar registration","url":"https://daylilydatabase.org/detail.php?id=781&name=Bela%20Lugosi","country":"US","form":null,"value":"scape height 33 in, (84 cm)","metres":0.84,"band":[0.76,0.92],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hemerocallis-bela-lugosi-bela-lugosi-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It stands 29-33 inches high","metres":[0.74,0.84],"band":[0.74,0.84],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMBEL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 33.0 Inches","metres":0.84,"band":[0.76,0.92],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Bela-Lugosi","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 34 Inches","metres":0.86,"band":[0.77,0.95],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bela-lugosi-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 28 - 34 Inches","metres":[0.71,0.86],"band":[0.71,0.86],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Kiefer Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/hemerocallis-bela-lugosi/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 33\"","metres":0.84,"band":[0.76,0.92],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/bela-lugosi-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height (Range) 25\" - 36\"","metres":[0.64,0.91],"band":[0.64,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Longfellow's Greenhouses (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"http://plants.longfellowsgreenhouses.com/12100007/Plant/4673/Bela_Lugosi_Daylily/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Bela Lugosi Daylily will grow to be about 30 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 3 feet.","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/hemerocallis-bela-lugosi/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Height: 60cm Spread: 45cm","metres":0.6,"band":[0.54,0.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":2,"cultivar":10},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"daylily-bela-lugosi","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.3,1],"split":[{"range":[0.3,0.61],"sources":["Gertens","BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","Pleasant Run Nursery","Walters Gardens","Plant Addicts","Kiefer Nursery"]},{"range":[0.82,1],"sources":["Longfellow's Greenhouses (NetPS Plant Finder)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMBEL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Bela-Lugosi","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18 Inches","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bela-lugosi-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 18 - 24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Kiefer Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/hemerocallis-bela-lugosi/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 18 to 24\"","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/bela-lugosi-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread (Range) 12\" - 24\"","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Longfellow's Greenhouses (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"http://plants.longfellowsgreenhouses.com/12100007/Plant/4673/Bela_Lugosi_Daylily/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Bela Lugosi Daylily will grow to be about 30 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 3 feet.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/hemerocallis-bela-lugosi/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Height: 60cm Spread: 45cm","metres":0.45,"band":[0.41,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":2,"cultivar":10},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"daylily-bela-lugosi","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","3-8","3-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hemerocallis-bela-lugosi-bela-lugosi-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMBEL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bela-lugosi-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Kiefer Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/hemerocallis-bela-lugosi/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 10a, 10b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/bela-lugosi-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":2,"cultivar":10},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"daylily-bela-lugosi","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hemerocallis-bela-lugosi-bela-lugosi-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"it is easy to grow and does well in full sun to part shade in moderate soils.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMBEL","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bela-lugosi-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Partial Sun to Full Sun (At Least 5 Hours of Direct Sunlight)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Kiefer Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/hemerocallis-bela-lugosi/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Part-sun, Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/bela-lugosi-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Preference Full-Sun, Part-Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Longfellow's Greenhouses (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"http://plants.longfellowsgreenhouses.com/12100007/Plant/4673/Bela_Lugosi_Daylily/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in full sun to partial shade.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/perennials/daylilies/bella-lugosi-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/hemerocallis-bela-lugosi/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure: Full sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"daylily-bela-lugosi","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#fragrant flowers","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"daylily-bela-lugosi","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Bela-Lugosi","https://plantaddicts.com/bela-lugosi-daylily"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Bela-Lugosi","http://plants.longfellowsgreenhouses.com/12100007/Plant/4673/Bela_Lugosi_Daylily/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Bela-Lugosi","https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/hemerocallis-bela-lugosi/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Bela-Lugosi","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attributes • Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bela-lugosi-daylily","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features: Attracts Pollinators, Cut Flowers, Low Maintenance, Award Winner","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Longfellow's Greenhouses (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"http://plants.longfellowsgreenhouses.com/12100007/Plant/4673/Bela_Lugosi_Daylily/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/hemerocallis-bela-lugosi/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"make excellent cut flowers (the developing flower buds are just as attractive as the blooms themselves)","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"daylily-bela-lugosi","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Daylily)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/daylily/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Although daylilies are drought-tolerant once established, consistent watering while budding and flowering produces better-quality flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Bela-Lugosi","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bela-lugosi-daylily","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates: Drought","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"daylily-bela-lugosi","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and birds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hemerocallis-bela-lugosi-bela-lugosi-daylily","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMBEL","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bela-lugosi-daylily","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Longfellow's Greenhouses (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"http://plants.longfellowsgreenhouses.com/12100007/Plant/4673/Bela_Lugosi_Daylily/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies to your yard.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"daylily-chicago-apache","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.68,0.73],"union":[0.59,0.84],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Chicago-Apache","country":"US","form":null,"value":"30 Inches","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/hemerocallis-chicago-apache-hem3640","country":"US","form":null,"value":"26\"","metres":0.66,"band":[0.59,0.73],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-chicago-apache","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Chicago-Apache","country":"US","form":null,"value":"24 Inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-chicago-apache","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/hemerocallis-chicago-apache-hem3640","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3–9","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-chicago-apache","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/hemerocallis-chicago-apache-hem3640","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-chicago-apache","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-chicago-apache","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Chicago-Apache","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-chicago-apache","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Chicago-Apache","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-chicago-apache","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Chicago-Apache","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-happy-returns","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.45,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.41,0.46],"union":[0.3,0.51],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246538&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"American Daylily Society cultivar database (registration record)","url":"https://daylilydatabase.org/detail.php?id=24752","country":"US","form":null,"value":"scape height 18 in, (46 cm)","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":2,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"daylily-happy-returns","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246538&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":2,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"daylily-happy-returns","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246538&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":2,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"daylily-happy-returns","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246538&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/daylilies","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Best in full sun, but will tolerate light shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"daylily-happy-returns","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246538&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"American Daylily Society cultivar database (registration record)","url":"https://daylilydatabase.org/detail.php?id=24752","country":null,"form":null,"value":"fragrance Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Play Value: Attractive Flowers Attracts Pollinators Fragrance","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"daylily-happy-returns","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"daylily-happy-returns","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/daylily/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Daylilies are tolerant of drought and flooding, immune to heat stress, tolerant of most soils and grow well in full sun or light shade.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/daylilies","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Daylilies tolerate drought, but they perform best in moist, well-drained soils.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought Salt","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"daylily-happy-returns","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246538&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and birds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"daylily-joan-senior","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.59,0.6],"union":[0.46,1],"voices":11,"distinctPublishers":11,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246621","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Daylily Society (AHS) cultivar registry","url":"https://daylilies.org/cultivar/joan-senior/?id=26829","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Scape Height: 25 inches (63.50 cm)","metres":0.64,"band":[0.58,0.7],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/98330/hemerocallis-joan-senior/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMJOS","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 30.0 Inches","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-joan-senior.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Height 55-60 cm 21-23 inches","metres":[0.55,0.6],"band":[0.55,0.6],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-daylily-reblooming-joan-senior","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 24-26\" tall","metres":[0.61,0.66],"band":[0.61,0.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/hemerocallis-joan-senior-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Joan Senior Daylily will grow to be about 18 inches tall at maturity extending to 32 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.","metres":[0.46,0.81],"band":[0.46,0.81],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/daylily-joan-senior","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: Grows 26\" tall","metres":0.66,"band":[0.59,0.73],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Joan-Senior-Daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 20-25 in","metres":[0.51,0.64],"band":[0.51,0.64],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Joan-Senior","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24 Inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/hemerocallis-joan-senior/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height: 75cm Spread: 75cm","metres":0.75,"band":[0.68,0.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-joan-senior","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.55,0.56],"union":[0.3,1],"voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246621","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/98330/hemerocallis-joan-senior/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMJOS","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-joan-senior.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Spread 60-90 cm 23-35 inches","metres":[0.6,0.9],"band":[0.6,0.9],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-daylily-reblooming-joan-senior","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 12-24\" wide","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/hemerocallis-joan-senior-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Joan Senior Daylily will grow to be about 18 inches tall at maturity extending to 32 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Joan-Senior-Daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 20-24 in","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Joan-Senior","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 20 Inches","metres":0.51,"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/hemerocallis-joan-senior/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height: 75cm Spread: 75cm","metres":0.75,"band":[0.68,0.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-joan-senior","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","5-11","2-9","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246621","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hemerocallis-joan-senior-joan-senior-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5 - 11","zones":[5,11]},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMJOS","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-joan-senior.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 2-9","zones":[2,9]},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-daylily-reblooming-joan-senior","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones Zone 3 Zone 4 Zone 5 Zone 6 Zone 7 Zone 8 Zone 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/hemerocallis-joan-senior-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/daylily-joan-senior","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3 through 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Joan-Senior-Daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-joan-senior","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246621","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hemerocallis-joan-senior-joan-senior-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/98330/hemerocallis-joan-senior/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMJOS","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-joan-senior.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun or Partial Shade"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-daylily-reblooming-joan-senior","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun Half Sun / Half Shade"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/hemerocallis-joan-senior-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in full sun to partial shade."},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Joan-Senior-Daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers a well drained soil in full sun to partial shade."},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/hemerocallis-joan-senior/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure: Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-joan-senior","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-joan-senior.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This outstanding selection has fragrant, creamy-white flowers, large and ruffled.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-joan-senior","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-joan-senior.html","https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-daylily-reblooming-joan-senior"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-joan-senior.html","https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Joan-Senior"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-joan-senior.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Containers Cut Flower Deer Resistant","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-daylily-reblooming-joan-senior","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Easy To Grow Cut Flowers Container Planting","claim":true},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Joan-Senior","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attributes • Cut Flower","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-joan-senior","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-joan-senior.html","https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Joan-Senior-Daylily"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-joan-senior.html","https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Joan-Senior"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-joan-senior.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer Resistant Drought Tolerant Rabbit Resistant","claim":true},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Joan-Senior-Daylily","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Very drought tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Joan-Senior","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Clay Soil Tolerant • Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-joan-senior","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246621","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hemerocallis-joan-senior-joan-senior-daylily","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The 6-inch flowers stay open for at least 16 hours before closing and attract butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMJOS","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-joan-senior.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-daylily-reblooming-joan-senior","country":null,"form":null,"value":"enjoy the sight of pollinators dipping into blossoms in spring","claim":true},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/hemerocallis-joan-senior-daylily","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies to your yard.","claim":true},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hemerocallis-Joan-Senior","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wildlife • Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-pardon-me","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.45,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.41,0.46],"union":[0.3,0.51],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246909&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"American Daylily Society (registration record)","url":"https://daylilies.org/cultivar/pardon-me/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Scape Height: 18 inches (45.72 cm)","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Oakes Daylilies (daylily specialist grower)","url":"https://oakesdaylilies.com/products/pardon-me-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height 18\"","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"cultivar":3,"genus":4},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"daylily-pardon-me","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246909&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":3,"genus":4},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.38},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"daylily-pardon-me","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","2-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246909&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Oakes Daylilies (daylily specialist grower)","url":"https://oakesdaylilies.com/products/pardon-me-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone Range: 2 to 8","zones":[2,8],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":3,"genus":4},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"daylily-pardon-me","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246909&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/daylilies","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Best in full sun, but will tolerate light shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"Oakes Daylilies (daylily specialist grower)","url":"https://oakesdaylilies.com/products/pardon-me-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Daylilies love sun, full sun if possible, but will tolerate part-shade conditions.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun, Partial Sun/Shade","level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"daylily-pardon-me","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246909&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Play Value: Attractive Flowers Attracts Pollinators Fragrance","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"American Daylily Society (registration record)","url":"https://daylilies.org/cultivar/pardon-me/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/daylily/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"'Pardon Me' has fragrant bright red flowers with yellow throat, midseason, 3-inch flowers, rebloomer, 18 inches high.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"Oakes Daylilies (daylily specialist grower)","url":"https://oakesdaylilies.com/products/pardon-me-daylily","country":null,"form":null,"value":"An additional bonus is that, as a fragrant daylily, Pardon Me offers a subtle, gentle scent to the garden.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"daylily-pardon-me","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"daylily-pardon-me","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought Salt","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/daylily/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Daylilies are tolerant of drought and flooding, immune to heat stress, tolerant of most soils and grow well in full sun or light shade.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/daylilies","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Daylilies tolerate drought, but they perform best in moist, well-drained soils.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"daylily-pardon-me","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246909&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and birds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"daylily-stella-de-oro","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.27,0.3],"union":[0.23,0.46],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246299&isprofile=0&basic=Stella+de+Oro","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"American Daylily Society (AHS) cultivar registration","url":"https://daylilies.org/cultivar/stella-de-oro/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Scape Height: 11 inches (27.94 cm)","metres":0.28,"band":[0.25,0.31],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/43382/hemerocallis-stella-de-oro/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"'Stella de Oro' is a compact deciduous perennial, to 30cm tall, with fragrant, rounded, canary yellow flowers with orange throat, to 7cm wide","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens, Inc.","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMSDO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 15.0 Inches","metres":0.38,"band":[0.34,0.42],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/stella-de-oro-daylily.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height at Maturity: 15\"","metres":0.38,"band":[0.34,0.42],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/stella-de-oro-daylily-hemerocallis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 12-18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery plant guide","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/stella-de-oro-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing to a height and spread of 0.75 to 1 foot, this compact perennial is ideal for smaller spaces or as a dense groundcover in sunny to partially shaded areas.","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":5},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"daylily-stella-de-oro","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.46,0.5],"union":[0.1,0.61],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246299&isprofile=0&basic=Stella+de+Oro","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/43382/hemerocallis-stella-de-oro/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens, Inc.","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMSDO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/stella-de-oro-daylily.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width at Maturity: 18-24\"","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/stella-de-oro-daylily-hemerocallis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 16-24 inches","metres":[0.41,0.61],"band":[0.41,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery plant guide","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/stella-de-oro-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing to a height and spread of 0.75 to 1 foot, this compact perennial is ideal for smaller spaces or as a dense groundcover in sunny to partially shaded areas.","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":5},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"daylily-stella-de-oro","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-10","3-9","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246299&isprofile=0&basic=Stella+de+Oro","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 10","zones":[3,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens, Inc.","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMSDO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/stella-de-oro-daylily.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zones: 4a-9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery plant guide","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/stella-de-oro-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Thriving in USDA Zones 3 to 10, daylilies produce an abundance of showy yellow flowers with deeper throats from May to August.","zones":[3,10],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":5},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"daylily-stella-de-oro","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246299&isprofile=0&basic=Stella+de+Oro","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in full sun to partial shade in well-drained soil high in organic matter.","level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/43382/hemerocallis-stella-de-oro/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Grow in fertile, moist but well-drained soil preferably in full sun.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens, Inc.","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMSDO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/stella-de-oro-daylily.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs: Full Sun to Light Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/stella-de-oro-daylily-hemerocallis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/daylilies","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Best in full sun, but will tolerate light shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Landscaping plant guide","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/landscaping/daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Tolerates a wide range of soils in full sun to light shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery plant guide","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/stella-de-oro-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Choose a spot with full sun for the best flowering, although daylilies will tolerate part shade.","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"daylily-stella-de-oro","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246299&isprofile=0&basic=Stella+de+Oro","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"American Daylily Society (AHS) cultivar registration","url":"https://daylilies.org/cultivar/stella-de-oro/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#fragrant flowers","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/43382/hemerocallis-stella-de-oro/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"'Stella de Oro' is a compact deciduous perennial, to 30cm tall, with fragrant, rounded, canary yellow flowers with orange throat, to 7cm wide","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens, Inc.","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMSDO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"bright gold complete self with mild pie crust edging and a subtle fragrance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/stella-de-oro-daylily.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers: No","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery plant guide","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/stella-de-oro-daylily","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Daylily ( Hemerocallis ) is a tough, adaptable herbaceous perennial known for its stunning, fragrant blooms and grass-like foliage.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"daylily-stella-de-oro","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery plant guide","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/stella-de-oro-daylily","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Daylilies’ showy blooms make excellent cut flowers, adding a touch of beauty to indoor arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"daylily-stella-de-oro","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens, Inc.","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMSDO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Daylilies can survive many harsh conditions that other plants cannot including: polluted city environments, slopes, poor and dry soils, near pavement that is salted in winter, and under Black Walnut trees (not affected by juglone).","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/stella-de-oro-daylily.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"When established, daylilies are moderately drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/stella-de-oro-daylily-hemerocallis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"While drought-tolerant, watering Stella De Oro Daylily during drought will keep the foliage full and attractive.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/daylily/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Although daylilies are drought-tolerant once established, consistent watering while budding and flowering produces better-quality flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/daylilies","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Daylilies tolerate drought, but they perform best in moist, well-drained soils.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"daylily-stella-de-oro","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246299&isprofile=0&basic=Stella+de+Oro","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hemerocallis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and birds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hemerocallis"},{"name":"Walters Gardens, Inc.","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMSDO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/stella-de-oro-daylily.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies, Hummingbirds, Visual Attention","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/stella-de-oro-daylily-hemerocallis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The canary yellow flowers will attract hummingbirds and butterflies, although this plant is not of significant importance to any particular animal species.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery plant guide","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/stella-de-oro-daylily","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Daylilies attract butterflies and are tolerant of rabbits, erosion, and air pollution, making them a practical and beautiful addition to any garden.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"daylily-strawberry-candy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.59,0.66],"union":[0.56,0.73],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMSTC","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 26.0 Inches","metres":0.66,"band":[0.59,0.73],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-daylily-reblooming-strawberry-candy","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 22-26\" tall","metres":[0.56,0.66],"band":[0.56,0.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Oakes Daylilies","url":"https://oakesdaylilies.com/products/strawberry-candy-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height 26\"","metres":0.66,"band":[0.59,0.73],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-strawberry-candy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMSTC","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-daylily-reblooming-strawberry-candy","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 12-24\" wide","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-strawberry-candy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page, Hemerocallis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hemerocallis-strawberry-candy-strawberry-candy-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMSTC","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-daylily-reblooming-strawberry-candy","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones Zone 3 Zone 4 Zone 5 Zone 6 Zone 7 Zone 8 Zone 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Oakes Daylilies","url":"https://oakesdaylilies.com/products/strawberry-candy-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone Range: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-strawberry-candy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page, Hemerocallis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hemerocallis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hemerocallis-strawberry-candy-strawberry-candy-daylily","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMSTC","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-daylily-reblooming-strawberry-candy","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun Half Sun / Half Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-strawberry-candy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-strawberry-candy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-strawberry-candy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"daylily-strawberry-candy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hemerocallis-strawberry-candy-strawberry-candy-daylily","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Interest: Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HMSTC","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds Bee Friendly","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.3,2.01],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Delphinium","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delphinium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden: Growing Delphiniums","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/1997/6-13-1997/delphinium.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Some delphiniums grow up to 6 feet tall, making them excellent background plants. Others are much shorter.","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Nebraska Extension in Lancaster County, Delphiniums - A Beautiful Garden Flower","url":"https://lancaster.unl.edu/delphiniums-beautiful-garden-flower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Some perennial delphiniums grow up to 5-6 feet tall, making them good background plants. Medium-sized plants, growing 2-3 feet tall are a good choice for the middle or front of the perennial border.","metres":[0.61,1.83],"band":[0.61,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"species":3,"cultivar":3,"genus":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Delphinium","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delphinium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":3,"cultivar":3,"genus":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Delphinium","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delphinium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"species":3,"cultivar":3,"genus":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Delphinium elatum","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299459","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"delphinium elatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Delphinium (Pacific Hybrids)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b219","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Delphinium","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delphinium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Hybrid Bee Delphinium (Delphinium x elatum)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/hybrid-bee-delphinium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"delphinium elatum"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden: Growing Delphiniums","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/1997/6-13-1997/delphinium.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Delphiniums perform best in well-drained soils in full sun.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Nebraska Extension in Lancaster County, Delphiniums - A Beautiful Garden Flower","url":"https://lancaster.unl.edu/delphiniums-beautiful-garden-flower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Delphiniums perform best in fertile, humus rich, well-drained soils in full sun.","level":"genus"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum, Delphinium","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/delphinium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily)","level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder, Delphinium elatum 'Million Dollar Blue'","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/delphinium-elatum-million-dollar-blue-million-dollar-blue-larkspur","country":"US","form":null,"value":"prefers full sun or light shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"delphinium elatum"},{"name":"Walters Gardens, Delphinium New Zealand 'Stars'","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DELNS","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"PerennialReference.com (Hallson Gardens), Delphinium","url":"https://www.perennialreference.com/perennials/delphinium.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade","level":"genus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Delphinium","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delphinium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"genus"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Delphinium (Pacific Hybrids)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b219","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Delphinium","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delphinium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden: Growing Delphiniums","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/1997/6-13-1997/delphinium.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are good cut flowers and will last about 6 to 8 days in a vase.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Nebraska Extension in Lancaster County, Delphiniums - A Beautiful Garden Flower","url":"https://lancaster.unl.edu/delphiniums-beautiful-garden-flower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are excellent cut flowers and will last about 6 to 8 days in a vase.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, Delphinium","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/delphinium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They flower in early summer and are perfect for beds and borders and make a glorious cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Walters Gardens, Delphinium New Zealand 'Stars'","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DELNS","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Border Plant Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["delphinium elatum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (delphinium elatum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (delphinium elatum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"delphinium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Delphinium","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delphinium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Nebraska Extension in Lancaster County, Delphiniums - A Beautiful Garden Flower","url":"https://lancaster.unl.edu/delphiniums-beautiful-garden-flower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Keep plants well-watered and mulched during typical summer dry periods.","claim":false,"level":"genus"},{"name":"PerennialReference.com (Hallson Gardens), Delphinium","url":"https://www.perennialreference.com/perennials/delphinium.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants may be short-lived, especially if they are grown in hot, dry conditions.","claim":false,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["delphinium elatum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (delphinium elatum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (delphinium elatum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Delphinium (Pacific Hybrids)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b219","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Delphinium","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delphinium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum, Delphinium","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/delphinium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The blooms attract both hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Walters Gardens, Delphinium New Zealand 'Stars'","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DELNS","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["delphinium elatum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (delphinium elatum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (delphinium elatum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"delphinium-black-knight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"edge","consensus":[1.6,1.83],"union":[1.52,1.96],"edge":[1.47,1.96],"edgeMargin":1.3,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DELBK","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5.0-6.0 Feet","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/delphinium/delphinium-black-knight.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HEIGHT 70 inches","metres":1.78,"band":[1.6,1.96],"role":"scored"}],"withdrawnFromV2":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":1.72},"note":"the catalog value sits 1.3% outside the sources' union (1.52 to 1.96 m) and inside the 3% margin v3 allows at a stated range edge (1.47 to 1.96 m), so v2's proposal of 1.72 m is withdrawn rather than applied; 1 of these 2 scored sources publish a range, and a range edge is a figure converted and rounded from another unit rather than a measurement to the centimetre","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-black-knight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DELBK","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-black-knight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-7","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299459","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 7","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Delphinium elatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delphinium-elatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening (Delphinium, Elatum Group)","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene645f.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones: 3 to 7","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DELBK","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/delphinium/delphinium-black-knight.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA ZONES 3 - 8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-black-knight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299459","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Delphinium elatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delphinium-elatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening (Delphinium, Elatum Group)","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene645f.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: full sun"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DELBK","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/delphinium/delphinium-black-knight.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ENVIRONMENT Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-black-knight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-black-knight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299459","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Delphinium elatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delphinium-elatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It has showy blue flowers that appear on racemes in the spring and make excellent cut flowers.","claim":true},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening (Delphinium, Elatum Group)","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene645f.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special uses: cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DELBK","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Border Plant Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Mass Planting Specimen Focal Point","claim":true},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/delphinium/delphinium-black-knight.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-black-knight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-black-knight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299459","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Delphinium elatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delphinium-elatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DELBK","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/delphinium/delphinium-black-knight.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds and bees will visit often!","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-blue-bird","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.5,1.83],"union":[1.22,2.5],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Ball Seed (Ball Horticultural) PlantInfo","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=022101071000626","country":"US","form":null,"value":"54 - 72\"","metres":[1.37,1.83],"band":[1.37,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/44259/delphinium-blue-bird-group/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/delphinium/pacific-giant-blue-bird-delphinium-seeds.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants grow 4-7 ft. tall","metres":[1.22,2.13],"band":[1.22,2.13],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-blue-bird","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.25,1],"split":[{"range":[0.25,0.3],"sources":["Ball Seed (Ball Horticultural) PlantInfo"]},{"range":[0.5,1],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Ball Seed (Ball Horticultural) PlantInfo","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=022101071000626","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10 - 12\"","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/44259/delphinium-blue-bird-group/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-blue-bird","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Ball Seed (Ball Horticultural) PlantInfo","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=022101071000626","country":"US","form":"Delphinium Pacific Giants Blue Bird","value":"3a - 8b","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-blue-bird","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/44259/delphinium-blue-bird-group/details","country":"UK","form":"Delphinium Blue Bird Group","value":"Full sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-blue-bird","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-blue-bird","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Ball Seed (Ball Horticultural) PlantInfo","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=022101071000626","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Perfect for cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/44259/delphinium-blue-bird-group/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/delphinium/pacific-giant-blue-bird-delphinium-seeds.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"excellent for cutting","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-blue-bird","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-blue-bird","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Ball Seed (Ball Horticultural) PlantInfo","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=022101071000626","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-king-arthur","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/delphinium-king-arthur.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"120-180","metres":[1.2,1.8],"band":[1.2,1.8],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-king-arthur","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/delphinium-king-arthur.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"45-60","metres":[0.45,0.6],"band":[0.45,0.6],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-king-arthur","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/delphinium-king-arthur.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"2-9","zones":[2,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-king-arthur","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/delphinium-king-arthur.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-king-arthur","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-king-arthur","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/delphinium-king-arthur.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-king-arthur","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-king-arthur","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/delphinium-king-arthur.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-summer-skies","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/delphinium-summer-skies.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"120-180 cm","metres":[1.2,1.8],"band":[1.2,1.8],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-summer-skies","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/delphinium-summer-skies.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"45-60 cm","metres":[0.45,0.6],"band":[0.45,0.6],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-summer-skies","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/delphinium-summer-skies.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 2-9","zones":[2,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-summer-skies","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/delphinium-summer-skies.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-summer-skies","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-summer-skies","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-summer-skies","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"delphinium-summer-skies","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/delphinium-summer-skies.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"desdemona","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.34],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US, the breeder)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/desdemona","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/desdemona","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4' x 3'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/desdemona-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/desdemona","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"desdemona","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.61,1],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US, the breeder)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/desdemona","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3ft","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/desdemona","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4' x 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/desdemona-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/desdemona","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 2-3'","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"desdemona","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/desdemona","https://heirloomroses.com/products/desdemona"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/desdemona","https://menagerieflower.com/products/desdemona-rose-david-austin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/desdemona","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/desdemona"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US, the breeder)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/desdemona","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/desdemona","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/desdemona-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Suitable Zones: 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/desdemona","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zones: 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[5,11]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"desdemona","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US, the breeder)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/desdemona","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/desdemona","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/desdemona","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"desdemona","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["strong","strong","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/desdemona","https://heirloomroses.com/products/desdemona"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/desdemona","https://menagerieflower.com/products/desdemona-rose-david-austin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/desdemona","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/desdemona"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US, the breeder)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/desdemona","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The strong Old Rose fragrance has hints of almond blossom, cucumber and lemon zest.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/desdemona","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Exceptionally Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/desdemona-rose-david-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong - Old Rose","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/desdemona","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong - Old Rose","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"desdemona","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/desdemona","https://heirloomroses.com/products/desdemona"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/desdemona","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/desdemona"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US, the breeder)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/desdemona","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Location Cutting Mixed Border","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/desdemona","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets and floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/desdemona","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vase Life: 1-2 Days","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"desdemona","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"desdemona","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"dianthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Dianthus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 4 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.1,0.91],"band":[0.1,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":10,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Dianthus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Dianthus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"SPLIT"},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Dianthus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dianthus plumarius)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-plumarius/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"dianthus plumarius"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dianthus gratianopolitanus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-gratianopolitanus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"dianthus gratianopolitanus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Dianthus gratianopolitanus)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279029&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"dianthus gratianopolitanus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Dianthus deltoides)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279080&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"dianthus deltoides"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Dianthus barbatus)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279027","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"dianthus barbatus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Dianthus chinensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a574","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"dianthus chinensis"},{"name":"Illinois Extension (Maiden Pink Dianthus, Dianthus deltoides)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/maiden-pink-dianthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"dianthus deltoides"},{"name":"Illinois Extension (Garden Pink, Dianthus chinensis)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/garden-pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun, Partial Sun/Shade","level":"species","taxon":"dianthus chinensis"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Dianthus gratianopolitanus 'Firewitch')","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/dianthus-gratianopolitanus-firewitch/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dianthus grows best in loose, well-drained, neutral to slightly alkaline soils in full sun.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"dianthus gratianopolitanus"},{"name":"RHS (Dianthus plumarius)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/5734/dianthus-plumarius/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"dianthus plumarius"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Dianthus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are 5-parted, fragrant, pink-lilac, pink-purple or white, often with picotee margins.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dianthus plumarius)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-plumarius/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dianthus plumarius"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dianthus gratianopolitanus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-gratianopolitanus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dianthus gratianopolitanus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Dianthus gratianopolitanus)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279029&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dianthus gratianopolitanus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Dianthus deltoides)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279080&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dianthus deltoides"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Dianthus barbatus)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279027","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dianthus barbatus"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Dianthus gratianopolitanus 'Firewitch')","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/dianthus-gratianopolitanus-firewitch/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"has spicy clove-scented flowers (the sweet fragrance of carnations)","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"dianthus gratianopolitanus"},{"name":"RHS (Dianthus plumarius)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/5734/dianthus-plumarius/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"upright flower stems carry small sprays of highly-scented, saucer-shaped flowers with fringed petals","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dianthus plumarius"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Dianthus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dianthus plumarius)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-plumarius/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dianthus plumarius"},{"name":"Illinois Extension (Garden Pink, Dianthus chinensis)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/garden-pink","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Taller varieties good as cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dianthus chinensis"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Dianthus gratianopolitanus 'Firewitch')","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/dianthus-gratianopolitanus-firewitch/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"make excellent cut and dried flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"dianthus gratianopolitanus"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"dianthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Dianthus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dianthus gratianopolitanus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-gratianopolitanus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Humidity Rabbits","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dianthus gratianopolitanus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Dianthus gratianopolitanus)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279029&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates heat, humidity and occasional episodes of drought better than most other species of dianthus","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dianthus gratianopolitanus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Dianthus chinensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a574","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dianthus chinensis"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Dianthus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and other insect pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dianthus plumarius)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-plumarius/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds are attracted to the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dianthus plumarius"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dianthus gratianopolitanus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-gratianopolitanus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees, butterflies, and moths","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dianthus gratianopolitanus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Dianthus barbatus)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279027","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dianthus barbatus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Dianthus chinensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a574","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dianthus chinensis"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Dianthus gratianopolitanus 'Firewitch')","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/dianthus-gratianopolitanus-firewitch/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are attractive to butterflies and make excellent cut and dried flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"dianthus gratianopolitanus"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"dianthus-frosty-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.25,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.15,0.17],"union":[0,0.33],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=297738&isprofile=1&gen=Dianthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.50 to 0.75 feet","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DIAFF","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6.0 Inches","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/dianthus-frosty-fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 6-9 Inches","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/frosty-fire-dianthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 1 ft","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Greenwood Nursery","url":"https://www.greenwoodnursery.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Reaches a height of 6-12 inches, making it ideal for compact gardens.","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Dianthus-allwoodii-Frosty-Fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4-6 Inches","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Wasson Nursery","url":"https://shop.wassonnursery.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire-1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 - 6 inches","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Van Berkum Nursery","url":"https://www.vanberkumnursery.com/plants/dianthus-xallwoodii-frosty-fire/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0-8\"","metres":[0,0.2],"band":[0,0.2],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Flowerland","url":"https://shop.myflowerland.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire-8820.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Frosty Fire Pinks will grow to be only 6 inches tall at maturity extending to 8 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 10 inches.","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-frosty-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.23,0.25],"union":[0.21,0.46],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=297738&isprofile=1&gen=Dianthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DIAFF","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 9.0 Inches","metres":0.23,"band":[0.21,0.25],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/dianthus-frosty-fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 9-12 Inches","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/frosty-fire-dianthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 1 ft","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Dianthus-allwoodii-Frosty-Fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 9 Inches","metres":0.23,"band":[0.21,0.25],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Wasson Nursery","url":"https://shop.wassonnursery.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire-1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12 - 18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Flowerland","url":"https://shop.myflowerland.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire-8820.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Frosty Fire Pinks will grow to be only 6 inches tall at maturity extending to 8 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 10 inches.","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-frosty-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-9","4-9","2-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=297738&isprofile=1&gen=Dianthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DIAFF","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/dianthus-frosty-fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/frosty-fire-dianthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 4a - to 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Greenwood Nursery","url":"https://www.greenwoodnursery.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Planting Zone 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Dianthus-allwoodii-Frosty-Fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 2-8","zones":[2,8]},{"name":"Wasson Nursery","url":"https://shop.wassonnursery.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire-1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Van Berkum Nursery","url":"https://www.vanberkumnursery.com/plants/dianthus-xallwoodii-frosty-fire/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 4-9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-frosty-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=297738&isprofile=1&gen=Dianthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DIAFF","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/dianthus-frosty-fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/frosty-fire-dianthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full sun"},{"name":"Greenwood Nursery","url":"https://www.greenwoodnursery.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Thrives in full sun but tolerates partial shade."},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Dianthus-allwoodii-Frosty-Fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"Wasson Nursery","url":"https://shop.wassonnursery.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire-1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun"},{"name":"Van Berkum Nursery","url":"https://www.vanberkumnursery.com/plants/dianthus-xallwoodii-frosty-fire/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Sun / Part Shade"},{"name":"Flowerland","url":"https://shop.myflowerland.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire-8820.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-frosty-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=297738&isprofile=1&gen=Dianthus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/frosty-fire-dianthus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Yes","claim":true},{"name":"Greenwood Nursery","url":"https://www.greenwoodnursery.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Spicy-scented double blooms enhance the sensory appeal of your garden.","claim":true},{"name":"Van Berkum Nursery","url":"https://www.vanberkumnursery.com/plants/dianthus-xallwoodii-frosty-fire/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Highly fragrant!","claim":true},{"name":"Flowerland","url":"https://shop.myflowerland.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire-8820.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"stunning fragrant double red frilly flowers","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-frosty-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DIAFF","https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Dianthus-allwoodii-Frosty-Fire"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DIAFF","https://shop.wassonnursery.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire-1"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DIAFF","https://shop.myflowerland.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire-8820.html"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DIAFF","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Dianthus-allwoodii-Frosty-Fire","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true},{"name":"Wasson Nursery","url":"https://shop.wassonnursery.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire-1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The blooms are a lovely addition to small, fresh cut bouquets.","claim":true},{"name":"Flowerland","url":"https://shop.myflowerland.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire-8820.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-frosty-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DIAFF","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/dianthus-frosty-fire","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/frosty-fire-dianthus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought resistant, Deer-resistant, Fragrant, Evergreen, Cold hardy, Attracts pollinators, Flowering","claim":true},{"name":"Flowerland","url":"https://shop.myflowerland.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire-8820.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It prefers to grow in average to moist conditions, and shouldn't be allowed to dry out.","claim":false}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-frosty-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=297738&isprofile=1&gen=Dianthus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DIAFF","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/dianthus-frosty-fire","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees","claim":true},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/frosty-fire-dianthus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought resistant, Deer-resistant, Fragrant, Evergreen, Cold hardy, Attracts pollinators, Flowering","claim":true},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Dianthus-allwoodii-Frosty-Fire","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Wasson Nursery","url":"https://shop.wassonnursery.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire-1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees; Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Flowerland","url":"https://shop.myflowerland.com/products/dianthus-frosty-fire-8820.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting bees and butterflies to your yard","claim":true}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-maiden-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.18,0.22],"union":[0.08,0.5],"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279080","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.50 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-deltoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Cornell Home Gardening (Cornell University)","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene7e26.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.25 to 1 feet","metres":[0.08,0.3],"band":[0.08,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension HortAnswers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=719&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 6-12 Inches","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Illinois Extension (Flowers)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/maiden-pink-dianthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 6 to 12 Inches","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/5711/dianthus-deltoides/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/maiden-pink-dianthus-deltoides","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height : 6 to 12 inches","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Everwilde Farms","url":"https://www.everwilde.com/store/Dianthus-deltoides-WildFlower-Seed.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12 Inches","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/dianthus/maiden-pink-flower-seed.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HEIGHT 8 inches","metres":0.2,"band":[0.18,0.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-maiden-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.15,0.46],"union":[0.1,0.61],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279080","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.15,0.61],"band":[0.15,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-deltoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.15,0.61],"band":[0.15,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Cornell Home Gardening (Cornell University)","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene7e26.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1 to 1.5 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/5711/dianthus-deltoides/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/maiden-pink-dianthus-deltoides","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Width : 6 to 12 inches","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-maiden-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-9","3-10","1-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279080","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-deltoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Cornell Home Gardening (Cornell University)","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene7e26.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension HortAnswers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=719&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 3 - 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Illinois Extension (Flowers)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/maiden-pink-dianthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 3 - 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/maiden-pink-dianthus-deltoides","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones : 10, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[3,10]},{"name":"Everwilde Farms","url":"https://www.everwilde.com/store/Dianthus-deltoides-WildFlower-Seed.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11","zones":[1,11]},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/dianthus/maiden-pink-flower-seed.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA ZONES 3 - 9","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-maiden-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279080","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-deltoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Cornell Home Gardening (Cornell University)","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene7e26.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers full sun but tolerates very light shade."},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension HortAnswers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=719&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Full Sun"},{"name":"Illinois Extension (Flowers)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/maiden-pink-dianthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/5711/dianthus-deltoides/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/maiden-pink-dianthus-deltoides","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full Sun"},{"name":"Everwilde Farms","url":"https://www.everwilde.com/store/Dianthus-deltoides-WildFlower-Seed.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/dianthus/maiden-pink-flower-seed.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ENVIRONMENT Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-maiden-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279080","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-deltoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#fragrant flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/maiden-pink-dianthus-deltoides","country":null,"form":null,"value":"usually single and without fragrance","claim":false},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/dianthus/maiden-pink-flower-seed.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"1 inch fragrant blooms of pink and red hues","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-maiden-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-maiden-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-deltoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#drought tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Cornell Home Gardening (Cornell University)","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene7e26.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"tolerates droughty soil","claim":true},{"name":"Everwilde Farms","url":"https://www.everwilde.com/store/Dianthus-deltoides-WildFlower-Seed.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"mature plants are drought tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-maiden-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-deltoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees, butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Everwilde Farms","url":"https://www.everwilde.com/store/Dianthus-deltoides-WildFlower-Seed.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant attracts bees and butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.25,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.12,0.3],"split":[{"range":[0.12,0.22],"sources":["Penn State Flower Trials (2020)","Penn State Flower Trials (2021)","Blue Sky Nursery (Lincoln, Ontario)","Darwin Perennials (Ball Horticultural, North American introducer)","Ball Seed Plant Information","Bloomables (Star Roses and Plants consumer brand)","Log House Plants (Cottage Grove, Oregon)","Goode Greenhouses (Des Moines, Iowa)","Bachman's Wholesale Nursery","SiteOne Landscape Supply","Proctors Nursery (Wiltshire, England)"]},{"range":[0.25,0.3],"sources":["Ladd's Garden Center (South Windham, Connecticut)","Garden Center Marketing plant database"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Darwin Perennials (Ball Horticultural, North American introducer)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6 - 8\" (15 - 20cm)","metres":[0.15,0.2],"band":[0.15,0.2],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ball Seed Plant Information","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=022508168036585","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6 - 8\" (15 - 20cm)","metres":[0.15,0.2],"band":[0.15,0.2],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Bloomables (Star Roses and Plants consumer brand)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/mountain-frost-ruby-snow-dianthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size/Habit 6-8\" h x 10-12\" w","metres":[0.15,0.2],"band":[0.15,0.2],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Penn State Flower Trials (2021)","url":"https://agsci.psu.edu/flower-trials/Trial-Year/2021/Plant-Name/Dianthus-Mountain-Ruby-Snow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6 inches","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Penn State Flower Trials (2020)","url":"https://agsci.psu.edu/flower-trials/Trial-Year/2020/Plant-Name/Dianthus-Mountain-Ruby-Snow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5 inches","metres":0.13,"band":[0.12,0.14],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Bachman's Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.bachmanswholesale.com/Dianthus-Mountain-Frost-Ruby-Snow-1-Container","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8\"","metres":0.2,"band":[0.18,0.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Blue Sky Nursery (Lincoln, Ontario)","url":"https://blueskynursery.ca/products/dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby-snow/","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"0.5 ft tall x 1 ft spread","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Log House Plants (Cottage Grove, Oregon)","url":"https://loghouseplants.com/plants/shop/dianthus-x-hybrida-mountain-frost-ruby-snow-pinks/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 6-8 inches tall with a 10-12 inch spread.","metres":[0.15,0.2],"band":[0.15,0.2],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ladd's Garden Center (South Windham, Connecticut)","url":"https://www.laddsgardencenter.com/Plant-Name/Dianthus-China-Pinks-Cheddar-Pinks-Mountain-Frost-Ruby-Snow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10 - 12 in","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Garden Center Marketing plant database","url":"https://www.gardencentermarketing.com/plantname/Dianthus-Mountain-Frost-Ruby-snow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10-12 in","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/97241b-dianthus-x-hybrida-mountain-frost-ruby-snow-pinks/p/1068464","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growth Height Max 8 in.","metres":0.2,"band":[0.18,0.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proctors Nursery (Wiltshire, England)","url":"https://proctorsnursery.co.uk/product/dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby-snow/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height 20cm.","metres":0.2,"band":[0.18,0.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Goode Greenhouses (Des Moines, Iowa)","url":"https://www.goodegreenhouses.com/plant_catalog/dianthus_mountain_frost_ruby_snow/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 6-8\"","metres":[0.15,0.2],"band":[0.15,0.2],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.27,0.3],"union":[0.15,0.33],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Darwin Perennials (Ball Horticultural, North American introducer)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 10 - 12\" (25 - 30cm)","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ball Seed Plant Information","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=022508168036585","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 10 - 12\" (25 - 30cm)","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Bloomables (Star Roses and Plants consumer brand)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/mountain-frost-ruby-snow-dianthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size/Habit 6-8\" h x 10-12\" w","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Penn State Flower Trials (2021)","url":"https://agsci.psu.edu/flower-trials/Trial-Year/2021/Plant-Name/Dianthus-Mountain-Ruby-Snow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 12 inches","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Penn State Flower Trials (2020)","url":"https://agsci.psu.edu/flower-trials/Trial-Year/2020/Plant-Name/Dianthus-Mountain-Ruby-Snow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 7 inches","metres":0.18,"band":[0.16,0.2],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Bachman's Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.bachmanswholesale.com/Dianthus-Mountain-Frost-Ruby-Snow-1-Container","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 12\"","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Blue Sky Nursery (Lincoln, Ontario)","url":"https://blueskynursery.ca/products/dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby-snow/","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"0.5 ft tall x 1 ft spread","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Log House Plants (Cottage Grove, Oregon)","url":"https://loghouseplants.com/plants/shop/dianthus-x-hybrida-mountain-frost-ruby-snow-pinks/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 6-8 inches tall with a 10-12 inch spread.","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ladd's Garden Center (South Windham, Connecticut)","url":"https://www.laddsgardencenter.com/Plant-Name/Dianthus-China-Pinks-Cheddar-Pinks-Mountain-Frost-Ruby-Snow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 10 - 12 in","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Garden Center Marketing plant database","url":"https://www.gardencentermarketing.com/plantname/Dianthus-Mountain-Frost-Ruby-snow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 10-12 in","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/97241b-dianthus-x-hybrida-mountain-frost-ruby-snow-pinks/p/1068464","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growth Width Max 8 in.","metres":0.2,"band":[0.18,0.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"ServeScape (Atlanta, Georgia)","url":"https://servescape.com/products/dianthus-kond1400k6-mountain-frost%E2%84%A2-ruby-snow-dianthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.5' -1 '","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"The Succulent Spot","url":"https://www.succulentspot.com/product/dianthus-kond1400k6-mountain-frost-ruby-snow-dianthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.5 -1 '","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proctors Nursery (Wiltshire, England)","url":"https://proctorsnursery.co.uk/product/dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby-snow/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Spread 30cm.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Darwin Perennials (Ball Horticultural, North American introducer)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4b - 9a","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Ball Seed Plant Information","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=022508168036585","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4b - 9a","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Bloomables (Star Roses and Plants consumer brand)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/mountain-frost-ruby-snow-dianthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 4b-9a","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Ladd's Garden Center (South Windham, Connecticut)","url":"https://www.laddsgardencenter.com/Plant-Name/Dianthus-China-Pinks-Cheddar-Pinks-Mountain-Frost-Ruby-Snow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Garden Center Marketing plant database","url":"https://www.gardencentermarketing.com/plantname/Dianthus-Mountain-Frost-Ruby-snow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/97241b-dianthus-x-hybrida-mountain-frost-ruby-snow-pinks/p/1068464","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone Maximum Zone 9b Hardiness Zone Minimum Zone 4a","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"ServeScape (Atlanta, Georgia)","url":"https://servescape.com/products/dianthus-kond1400k6-mountain-frost%E2%84%A2-ruby-snow-dianthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 5 - 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"The Succulent Spot","url":"https://www.succulentspot.com/product/dianthus-kond1400k6-mountain-frost-ruby-snow-dianthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 5 - 9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Bloomables (Star Roses and Plants consumer brand)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/mountain-frost-ruby-snow-dianthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Full Sun"},{"name":"LSU AgCenter Hammond Research Station trials","url":"https://app.lsuagcenter.com/hammondtrials/VarietyTrial/Details/137","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Conditions Full Sun"},{"name":"Blue Sky Nursery (Lincoln, Ontario)","url":"https://blueskynursery.ca/products/dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby-snow/","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun"},{"name":"Log House Plants (Cottage Grove, Oregon)","url":"https://loghouseplants.com/plants/shop/dianthus-x-hybrida-mountain-frost-ruby-snow-pinks/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant. Attracts bees and butterflies. Full sun."},{"name":"Ladd's Garden Center (South Windham, Connecticut)","url":"https://www.laddsgardencenter.com/Plant-Name/Dianthus-China-Pinks-Cheddar-Pinks-Mountain-Frost-Ruby-Snow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"ServeScape (Atlanta, Georgia)","url":"https://servescape.com/products/dianthus-kond1400k6-mountain-frost%E2%84%A2-ruby-snow-dianthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Full Sun , Part Sun"},{"name":"The Succulent Spot","url":"https://www.succulentspot.com/product/dianthus-kond1400k6-mountain-frost-ruby-snow-dianthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Full Sun, PartSun"},{"name":"Proctors Nursery (Wiltshire, England)","url":"https://proctorsnursery.co.uk/product/dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby-snow/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun, tolerates partial shade"},{"name":"Goode Greenhouses (Des Moines, Iowa)","url":"https://www.goodegreenhouses.com/plant_catalog/dianthus_mountain_frost_ruby_snow/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as ball-horticultural","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=022508168036585"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","https://www.bloomables.com/plants/mountain-frost-ruby-snow-dianthus/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","https://www.bachmanswholesale.com/Dianthus-Mountain-Frost-Ruby-Snow-1-Container"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","https://blueskynursery.ca/products/dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby-snow/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","https://www.laddsgardencenter.com/Plant-Name/Dianthus-China-Pinks-Cheddar-Pinks-Mountain-Frost-Ruby-Snow"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","https://servescape.com/products/dianthus-kond1400k6-mountain-frost%E2%84%A2-ruby-snow-dianthus"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Darwin Perennials (Ball Horticultural, North American introducer)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Characteristics: Attracts Butterflies, Deer Resistant, Drought Tolerant, Fragrant Flowers, Low Maintenance, Frost Tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Ball Seed Plant Information","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=022508168036585","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Characteristics: Attracts Butterflies, Deer Resistant, Drought Tolerant, Fragrant Flowers, Low Maintenance, Frost Tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Bloomables (Star Roses and Plants consumer brand)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/mountain-frost-ruby-snow-dianthus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Bachman's Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.bachmanswholesale.com/Dianthus-Mountain-Frost-Ruby-Snow-1-Container","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long-blooming, fragrant, white flowers with a red eye emerge above strong silvery-blue foliage. Drought-tolerant.","claim":true},{"name":"Blue Sky Nursery (Lincoln, Ontario)","url":"https://blueskynursery.ca/products/dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby-snow/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Ladd's Garden Center (South Windham, Connecticut)","url":"https://www.laddsgardencenter.com/Plant-Name/Dianthus-China-Pinks-Cheddar-Pinks-Mountain-Frost-Ruby-Snow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"ServeScape (Atlanta, Georgia)","url":"https://servescape.com/products/dianthus-kond1400k6-mountain-frost%E2%84%A2-ruby-snow-dianthus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Clusters of fragrant, near white flowers with a bold red eye bloom from spring into fall if deadheaded.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 7 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as ball-horticultural; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 7","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Ladd's Garden Center (South Windham, Connecticut)","url":"https://www.laddsgardencenter.com/Plant-Name/Dianthus-China-Pinks-Cheddar-Pinks-Mountain-Frost-Ruby-Snow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as ball-horticultural","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=022508168036585"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","https://www.bachmanswholesale.com/Dianthus-Mountain-Frost-Ruby-Snow-1-Container"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","https://blueskynursery.ca/products/dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby-snow/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","https://loghouseplants.com/plants/shop/dianthus-x-hybrida-mountain-frost-ruby-snow-pinks/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Darwin Perennials (Ball Horticultural, North American introducer)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Characteristics: Attracts Butterflies, Deer Resistant, Drought Tolerant, Fragrant Flowers, Low Maintenance, Frost Tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Ball Seed Plant Information","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=022508168036585","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Characteristics: Attracts Butterflies, Deer Resistant, Drought Tolerant, Fragrant Flowers, Low Maintenance, Frost Tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Bachman's Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.bachmanswholesale.com/Dianthus-Mountain-Frost-Ruby-Snow-1-Container","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long-blooming, fragrant, white flowers with a red eye emerge above strong silvery-blue foliage. Drought-tolerant.","claim":true},{"name":"Blue Sky Nursery (Lincoln, Ontario)","url":"https://blueskynursery.ca/products/dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby-snow/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Log House Plants (Cottage Grove, Oregon)","url":"https://loghouseplants.com/plants/shop/dianthus-x-hybrida-mountain-frost-ruby-snow-pinks/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant. Attracts bees and butterflies. Full sun.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as ball-horticultural; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as ball-horticultural","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=022508168036585"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","https://www.bloomables.com/plants/mountain-frost-ruby-snow-dianthus/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","https://app.lsuagcenter.com/hammondtrials/VarietyTrial/Details/137"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","https://blueskynursery.ca/products/dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby-snow/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","https://loghouseplants.com/plants/shop/dianthus-x-hybrida-mountain-frost-ruby-snow-pinks/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","https://www.laddsgardencenter.com/Plant-Name/Dianthus-China-Pinks-Cheddar-Pinks-Mountain-Frost-Ruby-Snow"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Darwin Perennials (Ball Horticultural, North American introducer)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=022508168036585","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Characteristics: Attracts Butterflies, Deer Resistant, Drought Tolerant, Fragrant Flowers, Low Maintenance, Frost Tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Ball Seed Plant Information","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=022508168036585","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Characteristics: Attracts Butterflies, Deer Resistant, Drought Tolerant, Fragrant Flowers, Low Maintenance, Frost Tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Bloomables (Star Roses and Plants consumer brand)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/mountain-frost-ruby-snow-dianthus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features Attracts Pollinators","claim":true},{"name":"LSU AgCenter Hammond Research Station trials","url":"https://app.lsuagcenter.com/hammondtrials/VarietyTrial/Details/137","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator : Plant attracts pollinators (i.e. butterflies and bees).","claim":true},{"name":"Blue Sky Nursery (Lincoln, Ontario)","url":"https://blueskynursery.ca/products/dianthus-mountain-frost-ruby-snow/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Log House Plants (Cottage Grove, Oregon)","url":"https://loghouseplants.com/plants/shop/dianthus-x-hybrida-mountain-frost-ruby-snow-pinks/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant. Attracts bees and butterflies. Full sun.","claim":true},{"name":"Ladd's Garden Center (South Windham, Connecticut)","url":"https://www.laddsgardencenter.com/Plant-Name/Dianthus-China-Pinks-Cheddar-Pinks-Mountain-Frost-Ruby-Snow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 7 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as ball-horticultural; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 7","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-white-pinks","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.25,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-white-pinks","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-white-pinks","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-10","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening, Flower Growing Guide: Border Pinks (Dianthus sp., synonym Dianthus plumarius cultivars)","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scenefea8.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones: 4 to 10","zones":[4,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page: Dianthus plumarius, common names Pinks / Garden Pink / Cottage Pink)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-plumarius/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-white-pinks","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening, Flower Growing Guide: Border Pinks (Dianthus sp., synonym Dianthus plumarius cultivars)","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scenefea8.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page: Dianthus plumarius, common names Pinks / Garden Pink / Cottage Pink)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-plumarius/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-white-pinks","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening, Flower Growing Guide: Border Pinks (Dianthus sp., synonym Dianthus plumarius cultivars)","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scenefea8.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"fragrant - Flowers usually have spicy scents, often resembling cloves or cinnamon.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page: Dianthus plumarius, common names Pinks / Garden Pink / Cottage Pink)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-plumarius/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Long Bloom Season Showy","claim":true},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension G6650, Flowering Perennials: Characteristics and Culture (table row: Pink, Cottage)","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/publications/g6650","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Very fragrant. Bluish gray foliage. Edging plant.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-white-pinks","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page: Dianthus plumarius, common names Pinks / Garden Pink / Cottage Pink)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-plumarius/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Long Bloom Season Showy","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-white-pinks","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening, Flower Growing Guide: Border Pinks (Dianthus sp., synonym Dianthus plumarius cultivars)","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scenefea8.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"tolerates droughty soil","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page: Dianthus plumarius, common names Pinks / Garden Pink / Cottage Pink)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-plumarius/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Although not truly drought tolerant, they are tolerant of dry soil and prefer to dry between waterings.","claim":false}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dianthus-white-pinks","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page: Dianthus plumarius, common names Pinks / Garden Pink / Cottage Pink)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dianthus-plumarius/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds are attracted to the flowers.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.3,1.52],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275980","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anethum-graveolens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 6 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.76,1.52],"band":[0.76,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/dill-anethum-graveolens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dill plants grow 18 inches to 4 feet tall and resemble fennel.","metres":[0.46,1.22],"band":[0.46,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/herb-garden-plants-dill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height and Width: Height is 1-4 feet; width is 12-24 inches.","metres":[0.3,1.22],"band":[0.3,1.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.3,0.91],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275980","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anethum-graveolens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/herb-garden-plants-dill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height and Width: Height is 1-4 feet; width is 12-24 inches.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,11],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[2,11],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275980","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anethum-graveolens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[2,11]}],"note":"every source states 2-11; catalog states 3-11","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275980","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anethum-graveolens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/dill-anethum-graveolens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"As with most herbs, it does best in full sun."},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/herb-garden-plants-dill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light and Soil: Full sun; rich, moist but not constantly wet, well-drained soil with a pH of 6.5."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275980","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anethum-graveolens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant yellow flowers appear in midsummer and the aromatic leaves are attractive.","claim":true},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/herb-garden-plants-dill","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tiny, scented, yellow flowers grow in flattened, terminal umbels","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275980","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants appreciate consistent soil moisture. Soils should not be allowed to dry out.","claim":false},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anethum-graveolens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Consistent watering is best and prevents the plant from bolting","claim":false}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275980","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dill attracts a number of beneficial insects to the garden (e.g., bees, wasps, butterflies, lacewings, tachinid flies, hover flies and lady beetles).","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anethum-graveolens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Larval host to the black swallowtail butterfly. Attracts beneficial insects such as bees, wasps, hover flies and butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/dill-anethum-graveolens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"it is a larval host of the black swallowtail butterfly","claim":true},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/herb-garden-plants-dill","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Like other members of its family, dill attracts beneficial insects, bees, and other pollinators to the garden, and it is a host plant for the black swallowtail butterfly caterpillar.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dogwood-tree","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":12,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 15.00 to 30.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 15 ft. 0 in. - 25 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: About 20 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page's figure is a 18 to 18 year size and this row's is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 20 to 30 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Broadleaf deciduous tree/shrub, 20-25 ft (6-7.6 m) tall\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Heights on good sites of 9 to 12 in (30 to 40 ft) are common\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature height 20-40 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"flowering dogwood is a 20-40 ft., sometimes taller, single- or multi-trunked tree with a spreading crown\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"At maturity, to 40 feet tall; to 35 feet wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Max Height 4-8 metres\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"They tend to grow 15 to 25 feet tall with an equal spread.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 12 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dogwood-tree","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":9,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 15.00 to 30.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 15 ft. 0 in. - 30 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: About 20 feet or wider\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"In the sun, the same tree may only grow 15 to 20 feet tall and wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 25 to 30 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature width 20 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"At maturity, to 40 feet tall; to 35 feet wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Max Spread 4-8 metres\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"They tend to grow 15 to 25 feet tall with an equal spread.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dogwood-tree","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c280","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cornus-florida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"Virginia Cooperative Extension, Virginia Tech, publication 3010-1484","url":"https://www.pubs.ext.vt.edu/content/pubs_ext_vt_edu/en/3010/3010-1484/3010-1484.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center, Dogwood","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/dogwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"For USDA zones 5 to 9.","zones":[5,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, ENH344/ST185","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/ST185","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA hardiness zones: 5A through 9A","zones":[5,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/flowering-dogwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8, Zone 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dogwood-tree","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c280","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cornus-florida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Locate flowering dogwood in a site that receives full sun to partial shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Virginia Cooperative Extension, Virginia Tech, publication 3010-1484","url":"https://www.pubs.ext.vt.edu/content/pubs_ext_vt_edu/en/3010/3010-1484/3010-1484.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center, Dogwood","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/dogwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Although it prefers partial shade, especially in the afternoon, it will tolerate full sun.","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, ENH344/ST185","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/ST185","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: full sun, partial sun, or partial shade, shade tolerant","level":"species"},{"name":"Oregon State University, Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/cornus-florida","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to part shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/flowering-dogwood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily), Full shade (4 hrs or less of light daily)","level":"species"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Native Plant Information Network","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=cofl2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/21060/cornus-florida/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Edge of the Woods Native Plant Nursery","url":"https://edgeofthewoodsnursery.com/species-spotlight-cornus-florida-flowering-dogwood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"dogwoods perform best when planted in rich, moist, slightly acidic to neutral, well-drained soils in full sun to part shade","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dogwood-tree","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Native Plant Information Network","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=cofl2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers: yes","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dogwood-tree","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dogwood-tree","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Virginia Cooperative Extension, Virginia Tech, publication 3010-1484","url":"https://www.pubs.ext.vt.edu/content/pubs_ext_vt_edu/en/3010/3010-1484/3010-1484.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"one should irrigate flowering dogwoods during drought periods","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center, Dogwood","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/dogwood/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dogwoods do not tolerate extremely wet or dry soils, and should be watered deeply (1 to 2 inches per week) during dry periods","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"Oregon State University, Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/cornus-florida","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is essential to avoid putting this plant under stress, i.e. heat, drought, cold, for it predisposes it to insect and disease attack.","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/flowering-dogwood/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance Sensitive","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"4 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"dogwood-tree","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c280","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cornus-florida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are visited by butterflies and specialized bees","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/flowering-dogwood/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Game birds, Insect pollinators, Small mammals, Songbirds","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Native Plant Information Network","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=cofl2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Value to Native Bees","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation, Field Guide","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/flowering-dogwood","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dogwoods are larval food plants for several groups of butterflies and moths, including the spring azure, dogwood thyatirid, one-spotted variant, friendly probole, and false crocus geometer.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Edge of the Woods Native Plant Nursery","url":"https://edgeofthewoodsnursery.com/species-spotlight-cornus-florida-flowering-dogwood","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Several native bees and pollinating flies are attracted dogwood blooms’ nectar and pollen including halictid and andrenid bees, as well as bee flies and syrphid flies.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"dolly-parton-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.22,1.52],"union":[1.22,1.83],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/dolly-parton","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4' - 5' x 4'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Palatine Fruit and Roses","url":"https://www.palatineroses.com/products/dolly-parton","country":"CA","form":"shrub","value":"Plant Height 4' - 5'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Witherspoon Rose Culture","url":"https://www.witherspoonrose.com/products/dolly-parton","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4-5'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/products/dolly-parton","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height 4-6ft","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://www.roguevalleyroses.com/products/dolly-parton","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4-5 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"dolly-parton-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.34],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/dolly-parton","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4' - 5' x 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/products/dolly-parton","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width 3-4ft","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"dolly-parton-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["6-10","5-10","7-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/dolly-parton","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 6-10","zones":[6,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Palatine Fruit and Roses","url":"https://www.palatineroses.com/products/dolly-parton","country":"CA","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zones USDA 5 - 10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://www.roguevalleyroses.com/products/dolly-parton","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone: 7-9","zones":[7,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"dolly-parton-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/dolly-parton","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sun Requires 6+ hours of direct sunlight to thrive.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Witherspoon Rose Culture","url":"https://www.witherspoonrose.com/products/dolly-parton","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Sun Requirements: Full Sun 6+ Hours","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"dolly-parton-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["strong","strong","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/dolly-parton","https://www.palatineroses.com/products/dolly-parton"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/dolly-parton","https://www.witherspoonrose.com/products/dolly-parton"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/dolly-parton","https://www.highcountryroses.com/products/dolly-parton"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/dolly-parton","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Just one or two blooms will fill a room with intoxicating fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Palatine Fruit and Roses","url":"https://www.palatineroses.com/products/dolly-parton","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The highly fragrant and very large, full blooms are born mostly solitary and are elegant in form.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Witherspoon Rose Culture","url":"https://www.witherspoonrose.com/products/dolly-parton","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Comments: Cheerful and larger than life, blooms are long-lasting and sweet smelling","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/products/dolly-parton","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The resulting rose is cheerful and extravagantly fragrant with a vibrant lipstick-red color.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"dolly-parton-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/dolly-parton","https://www.palatineroses.com/products/dolly-parton"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/dolly-parton","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets and floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Palatine Fruit and Roses","url":"https://www.palatineroses.com/products/dolly-parton","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Usage Cut Rose , Garden Rose","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"dolly-parton-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"dolly-parton-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"don-juan-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[2.74,3.05],"union":[1.52,4.27],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-don-juan/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8 ft. 0 in. - 14 ft. 0 in.","metres":[2.44,4.27],"band":[2.44,4.27],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252116&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8.00 to 10.00 feet","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/don-juan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 9' - 10' x 6'","metres":[2.74,3.05],"band":[2.74,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/don-juan/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6-8 Feet","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/climbers-ramblers/don-juan/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 8-10ft","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed and Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/don-juan-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 12-14 ft. tall","metres":[3.66,4.27],"band":[3.66,4.27],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/don-juan-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 5 - 12 feet","metres":[1.52,3.66],"band":[1.52,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/don-juan-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 12-14 Feet","metres":[3.66,4.27],"band":[3.66,4.27],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"don-juan-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.91,4.27],"split":[{"range":[0.91,2.44],"sources":["Spring Hill Nursery","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","High Country Roses","NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","Heirloom Roses"]},{"range":[3.66,4.27],"sources":["Plant Addicts"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-don-juan/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 4 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,2.44],"band":[1.22,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252116&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/don-juan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 9' - 10' x 6'","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/climbers-ramblers/don-juan/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 4-6ft","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/don-juan-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 36 - 48 inches","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/don-juan-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 12-14 Feet","metres":[3.66,4.27],"band":[3.66,4.27],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"don-juan-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","5-10","6-9","5-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-don-juan/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252116&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/don-juan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 5-10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/don-juan/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 6-9","zones":[6,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed and Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/don-juan-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/don-juan-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/don-juan-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"don-juan-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-don-juan/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252116&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/don-juan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade or Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed and Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/don-juan-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/don-juan-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/don-juan-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs Full Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"don-juan-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","strengths":["strong"],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-don-juan/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The large 4-5 inch double flowers have 26-40 petals and are very fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252116&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/don-juan","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Very Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/climbers-ramblers/don-juan/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Strong","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed and Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/don-juan-climbing-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant, Red Climber","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/don-juan-climbing-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"One of the only fragrant red climbers in the world!","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/don-juan-climbing-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Trim the flowers to display in an arrangement and enjoy the sweet fragrance inside.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"don-juan-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-don-juan/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/don-juan","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Don Juan makes an excellent cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/don-juan/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Uses: Good for cutting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/don-juan-climbing-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tight clusters of vivid red blooms excite in the garden and in floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/don-juan-climbing-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Trim the flowers to display in an arrangement and enjoy the sweet fragrance inside.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"don-juan-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"don-juan-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-don-juan/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Attracts butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252116&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"double-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.1,1.34],"union":[0.91,1.83],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252118&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Weeks Roses (introducer)","url":"https://www.weeksroses.com/varieties/p/double-delight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: 3-5 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/double-delight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 4' X 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/double-delight/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/hybrid-teas-grandifloras/double-delight/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 3-4ft","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-hybrid-tea-double-delight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 4-5 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Otto and Sons Nursery","url":"https://ottoandsonsnursery.com/product/r-double-delight/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height Ht 04' - 6'","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/double-delight-hybrid-tea-rose-jumbo","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 36 - 48 inches","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"double-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.61,1.52],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252118&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/double-delight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 4' X 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/hybrid-teas-grandifloras/double-delight/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 2-3ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-hybrid-tea-double-delight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 2-3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Otto and Sons Nursery","url":"https://ottoandsonsnursery.com/product/r-double-delight/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width Width 03' - 4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/double-delight-hybrid-tea-rose-jumbo","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24 - 36 inches","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"double-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","7-10","3-9","4-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252118&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Weeks Roses (introducer)","url":"https://www.weeksroses.com/varieties/p/double-delight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 7b-10b","zones":[7,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/double-delight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 7-10","zones":[7,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/double-delight/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-hybrid-tea-double-delight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/double-delight-hybrid-tea-rose-jumbo","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 4-10","zones":[4,10],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"double-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252118&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/double-delight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun Requires 6+ hours of direct sunlight to thrive.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-hybrid-tea-double-delight","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Otto and Sons Nursery","url":"https://ottoandsonsnursery.com/product/r-double-delight/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure 2 -Full Sun/ Part Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/double-delight-hybrid-tea-rose-jumbo","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"double-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","strengths":["strong","strong","strong","strong"],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252118&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Weeks Roses (introducer)","url":"https://www.weeksroses.com/varieties/p/double-delight","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong spicy rose","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/double-delight","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Exceptionally Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/double-delight/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is one of the easiest Hybrid Teas to grow and one of the most fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/hybrid-teas-grandifloras/double-delight/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Strong","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-hybrid-tea-double-delight","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This variety of hybrid tea rose is know for its outstanding fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Otto and Sons Nursery","url":"https://ottoandsonsnursery.com/product/r-double-delight/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Very Strong Spice Fragrance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/double-delight-hybrid-tea-rose-jumbo","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Double Delight Hybrid Tea Rose offers eye-catching, bi-color impact, a sweet, fruity fragrance, and excellent flower performance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"double-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/double-delight","https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/double-delight/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/double-delight","https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-hybrid-tea-double-delight"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/double-delight","https://ottoandsonsnursery.com/product/r-double-delight/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/double-delight","https://springhillnursery.com/products/double-delight-hybrid-tea-rose-jumbo"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/double-delight","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets and floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/double-delight/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Uses: Good for cutting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-hybrid-tea-double-delight","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses* • Accent Plant • Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Otto and Sons Nursery","url":"https://ottoandsonsnursery.com/product/r-double-delight/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Rose Good Cut Rose","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/double-delight-hybrid-tea-rose-jumbo","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Double Delight sprouts tall, strong stems that can weather any storm and look lovely in a vase.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"double-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Otto and Sons Nursery","url":"https://ottoandsonsnursery.com/product/r-double-delight/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Coastal, Shade & Hot n' Dry Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"double-delight","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252118&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-hybrid-tea-double-delight","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees • Attracts Butterflies • Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"douglas-fir","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":18,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":20,"sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 40.00 to 80.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 40 ft. 0 in. - 80 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature height 40-80 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Conifer, evergreen tree, 80-200 ft (24-61 m)\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 20 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"douglas-fir","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":20,"sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 12.00 to 20.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 12 ft. 0 in. - 20 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature width 12-20 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 20 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"douglas-fir","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,6],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285009","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 6","zones":[4,6]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pseudotsuga-menziesii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b","zones":[4,6]},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/douglas-fir/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago)","zones":[4,6]},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/pseudotsuga-menziesii","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy to USDA Zone 5-6 (Pacific Coast type, P. menziesii var. menziesii ) or Zone 4 ( Rocky Mountain type, P. menziesii var. glauca )","zones":[4,6]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"douglas-fir","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285009","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pseudotsuga-menziesii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/douglas-fir/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"douglas-fir","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285009","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Needles are fragrant when bruised.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pseudotsuga-menziesii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are fragrant when bruised or crushed.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"douglas-fir","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"douglas-fir","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285009","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Does best in locations with abundant air and soil moisture.","claim":false},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pseudotsuga-menziesii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Keep it well watered since it is intolerant to drought.","claim":false},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/douglas-fir/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance Sensitive","claim":false}],"note":"3 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"douglas-fir","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pseudotsuga-menziesii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Landscape Theme: Butterfly Garden Pollinator Garden","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"drift-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.46],"union":[0.3,0.91],"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Meilland International (breeder)","url":"https://meilland.com/catalogue/pink-drift-meijocos/","country":"FR","form":null,"value":"Hauteur : 30 / 40 cm","metres":[0.3,0.4],"band":[0.3,0.4],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pink-drift-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 12-18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-drift-pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 12-18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder (served by Oakland Nursery)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/5121/Pink_Drift_Rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18 inches","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/pink-drift-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 1.5 ft","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grimm's Gardens","url":"https://www.grimmsgardens.com/shop/rose-pink-drift-2079","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Rosa 'Meijocos' grows to a height of 12 to 18 inches, with a spread of 30 to 36 inches.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/pink-drift-groundcover-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Its compact size, reaching up to 18 inches in height and spreading 3 feet wide, makes it ideal for small spaces, pathways, containers, or as a colorful groundcover.","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stadler Nurseries","url":"https://www.stadlergardencenters.com/product/rose-drift-pink/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"12-24\" tall by 24-36\" wide","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/drift-roses/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Individual plants will grow two to three feet wide and just one and a half feet tall.","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Calhoun County","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/calhounco/2026/05/21/drift-roses-make-perfect-landscape-plants/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"they are exceptionally disease-tolerant, usually don't require pruning, and are compact (2-3' high and 3-5' wide)","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Georgia CAES Field Report","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/news/landscapes-are-a-drift-with-colorful-roses/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They typically reach 2 to 3 feet tall with a spread of 3 to 4 feet.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"LSU AgCenter, Louisiana Super Plants","url":"https://www.lsuagcenter.com/articles/page1574728237374","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: Height: 2 to 3 feet; width: 3 to 4 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"LSU AgCenter, Hammond Research Station","url":"https://www.lsuagcenter.com/portals/our_offices/research_stations/hammond/features/super_plants/fall/fall-2013/drift-rose--summerflowering-shrub","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 14-16\" tall by 12-14\" wide","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Valdosta State University, Department of Biology campus plants","url":"https://www.valdosta.edu/biology/campus-plants/driftrose.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 2 feet tall","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":9,"unstated":5,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"drift-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.3,1.52],"split":[{"range":[0.3,0.36],"sources":["LSU AgCenter, Hammond Research Station"]},{"range":[0.61,1.52],"sources":["Sooner Plant Farm","Stadler Nurseries","UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","Grimm's Gardens","Plant Addicts","NetPS Plant Finder (served by Oakland Nursery)","The Tree Center","Patuxent Nursery","University of Georgia CAES Field Report","LSU AgCenter, Louisiana Super Plants","UF/IFAS Extension Calhoun County"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pink-drift-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 3 Feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-drift-pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 24-36 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder (served by Oakland Nursery)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/5121/Pink_Drift_Rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/pink-drift-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 3 ft","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grimm's Gardens","url":"https://www.grimmsgardens.com/shop/rose-pink-drift-2079","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Rosa 'Meijocos' grows to a height of 12 to 18 inches, with a spread of 30 to 36 inches.","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/pink-drift-groundcover-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Its compact size, reaching up to 18 inches in height and spreading 3 feet wide, makes it ideal for small spaces, pathways, containers, or as a colorful groundcover.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stadler Nurseries","url":"https://www.stadlergardencenters.com/product/rose-drift-pink/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"12-24\" tall by 24-36\" wide","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/drift-roses/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Individual plants will grow two to three feet wide and just one and a half feet tall.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Calhoun County","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/calhounco/2026/05/21/drift-roses-make-perfect-landscape-plants/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"they are exceptionally disease-tolerant, usually don't require pruning, and are compact (2-3' high and 3-5' wide)","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Georgia CAES Field Report","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/news/landscapes-are-a-drift-with-colorful-roses/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They typically reach 2 to 3 feet tall with a spread of 3 to 4 feet.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"LSU AgCenter, Louisiana Super Plants","url":"https://www.lsuagcenter.com/articles/page1574728237374","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: Height: 2 to 3 feet; width: 3 to 4 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"LSU AgCenter, Hammond Research Station","url":"https://www.lsuagcenter.com/portals/our_offices/research_stations/hammond/features/super_plants/fall/fall-2013/drift-rose--summerflowering-shrub","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 14-16\" tall by 12-14\" wide","metres":[0.3,0.36],"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":9,"unstated":5,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"drift-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-11","4-9","4-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pink-drift-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones 4 to 11","zones":[4,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-drift-pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/pink-drift-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In: Zones 4-10","zones":[4,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grimm's Gardens","url":"https://www.grimmsgardens.com/shop/rose-pink-drift-2079","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is recommended for USDA planting zones 4 to 11.","zones":[4,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/pink-drift-groundcover-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Pink Drift Rose thrives in USDA zones 4-11 and prefers full sun to achieve its best flowering performance.","zones":[4,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stadler Nurseries","url":"https://www.stadlergardencenters.com/product/rose-drift-pink/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 10","zones":[4,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/drift-roses/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They are best suited for planting in USDA hardiness zones 4-10.","zones":[4,10]},{"name":"LSU AgCenter, Louisiana Super Plants","url":"https://www.lsuagcenter.com/articles/page1574728237374","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Drift roses are labeled for use in hardiness zones 4 to 11, and they thrive throughout the entire state of Louisiana.","zones":[4,11]},{"name":"Valdosta State University, Department of Biology campus plants","url":"https://www.valdosta.edu/biology/campus-plants/driftrose.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plants Hardiness Zones : 4-11","zones":[4,11],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":9,"unstated":5,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"drift-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pink-drift-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Pink Drift Rose in full sun with at least 6 hours of direct light each day.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-drift-pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder (served by Oakland Nursery)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/5121/Pink_Drift_Rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/pink-drift-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs : Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grimm's Gardens","url":"https://www.grimmsgardens.com/shop/rose-pink-drift-2079","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It tends to grow best in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/pink-drift-groundcover-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Plant in full sun for optimal growth and flowering. Ensure the rose receives at least six hours of direct sunlight daily.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stadler Nurseries","url":"https://www.stadlergardencenters.com/product/rose-drift-pink/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Calhoun County","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/calhounco/2026/05/21/drift-roses-make-perfect-landscape-plants/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"First, they require full sun. Give them at least 6 hours a day; more is better."},{"name":"LSU AgCenter, Louisiana Super Plants","url":"https://www.lsuagcenter.com/articles/page1574728237374","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full sun to part sun. Eight hours of direct sunlight is recommended."},{"name":"LSU AgCenter, Hammond Research Station","url":"https://www.lsuagcenter.com/portals/our_offices/research_stations/hammond/features/super_plants/fall/fall-2013/drift-rose--summerflowering-shrub","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Valdosta State University, Department of Biology campus plants","url":"https://www.valdosta.edu/biology/campus-plants/driftrose.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Roses require full sun and organically rich, well-drained, acidic to neutral soils.","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"drift-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://plantaddicts.com/pink-drift-rose","https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/5121/Pink_Drift_Rose/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://plantaddicts.com/pink-drift-rose","https://www.stadlergardencenters.com/product/rose-drift-pink/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pink-drift-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pink Drift Rose is lightly fragrant and produces small flowers in steady flushes through the growing season.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder (served by Oakland Nursery)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/5121/Pink_Drift_Rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"covered in stunning lightly-scented semi-double pink flowers with white streaks at the ends of the branches from late spring to mid fall","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stadler Nurseries","url":"https://www.stadlergardencenters.com/product/rose-drift-pink/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vibrant deep pink blossoms with a lighter pink center are wonderfully fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"drift-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-drift-pink","https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/5121/Pink_Drift_Rose/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-drift-pink","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder (served by Oakland Nursery)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/5121/Pink_Drift_Rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"drift-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pink-drift-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Established plants tolerate short dry periods, but steady moisture supports better reblooming during summer heat.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-drift-pink","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/pink-drift-groundcover-rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought-tolerant, disease-resistant, and attracts pollinators while offering continuous seasonal color and low maintenance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Calhoun County","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/calhounco/2026/05/21/drift-roses-make-perfect-landscape-plants/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Though they're extremely drought tolerant once established, Drift® Roses can seriously suffer from drought until then.","claim":true},{"name":"LSU AgCenter, Louisiana Super Plants","url":"https://www.lsuagcenter.com/articles/page1574728237374","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates heat, humidity and drought well with long-lasting, dense, colorful blooms.","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"drift-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://plantaddicts.com/pink-drift-rose","https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-drift-pink"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://plantaddicts.com/pink-drift-rose","https://www.grimmsgardens.com/shop/rose-pink-drift-2079"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://plantaddicts.com/pink-drift-rose","https://patuxentnursery.com/product/pink-drift-groundcover-rose/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://plantaddicts.com/pink-drift-rose","https://www.stadlergardencenters.com/product/rose-drift-pink/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pink-drift-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features : Disease Resistant, Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-drift-pink","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grimm's Gardens","url":"https://www.grimmsgardens.com/shop/rose-pink-drift-2079","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great for attracting butterflies!","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/pink-drift-groundcover-rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Additionally, Pink Drift® attracts pollinators such as bees and butterflies, contributing to a healthy garden ecosystem.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stadler Nurseries","url":"https://www.stadlergardencenters.com/product/rose-drift-pink/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Blooms will bring butterflies and pollinators to your garden.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dusty-miller","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.35,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/dusty-miller-senecio-cineraria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"When grown as an annual it normally forms a rounded mound 8-15 inches tall.","metres":[0.2,0.38],"band":[0.2,0.38],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jacobaea maritima"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":8,"genus":1,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 6 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"In St. Louis, it usually grows in a rounded clump to 6-15\" tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.5 to 1 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"grows just six to twelve inches tall, making it perfect for edging borders or beds, or for planting in container gardens.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 6-12 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Growth Habit: Evergreen, mostly herbaceous, short-lived perennial subshrub, mounding 1- to 2-feet tall (when not in bloom).\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dusty-miller","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8,"genus":1,"cultivar":3},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 8 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.50 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.5 to 1 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dusty-miller","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[7,10],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/jacobaea-maritima/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[7,10],"level":"species","taxon":"jacobaea maritima"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a608","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 7 to 10","zones":[7,10],"level":"species","taxon":"jacobaea maritima"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":8,"genus":1,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source states 7-10; catalog states 8-11; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dusty-miller","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a608","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"jacobaea maritima"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/dusty-miller-senecio-cineraria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"dusty miller is heat and drought tolerant and grows best in full sun","level":"species","taxon":"jacobaea maritima"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension EDIS FPS544","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP544","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dusty miller should be grown in full sun or very light shade in well-drained soil and occasionally trimmed if plants become leggy.","level":"species","taxon":"senecio cineraria"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=766&PlantTypeID=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to very light shade in very well-drained soil","level":"species","taxon":"senecio cineraria"},{"name":"Arizona State University Campus Arboretum plant database","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/seneciocineraria.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full to partial sun","level":"species","taxon":"senecio cineraria"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/dusty-miller.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Silverdust Dusty Miller needs full sun and good drainage.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"jacobaea maritima"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/cineraria/cineraria-dusty-miller-silverdust.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"our annual flowering plants grow in both full sun and partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"cineraria maritima"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dusty-miller","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/jacobaea-maritima/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"jacobaea maritima"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dusty-miller","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/jacobaea-maritima/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant is sometimes offered as a florist plant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jacobaea maritima"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/dusty-miller-senecio-cineraria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dusty miller foliage can also be used as a filler in cut flower arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jacobaea maritima"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/dusty-miller.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent filler for fresh cut bouquets and mixed container plantings.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"jacobaea maritima"},{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/dusty-miller/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dusty miller is a tender perennial grown for its silvery foliage, which is popular as a cut-flower filler for fresh or dried bouquets.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"John Scheepers Kitchen Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.kitchengardenseeds.com/seed-index/flowers/bedding/dusty-miller/dusty-miller-silverdust.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It serves as a stunning contrast to milder colors and fills out a bed, container planting or bouquet beautifully.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"senecio cineraria"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"dusty-miller","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/jacobaea-maritima/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It prefers light, well-drained soil in sun or shade and is drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jacobaea maritima"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/dusty-miller-senecio-cineraria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dusty miller is heat and drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jacobaea maritima"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension EDIS FPS544","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP544","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants are fairly drought tolerant and should not be over-watered.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"senecio cineraria"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["jacobaea maritima"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (jacobaea maritima), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (jacobaea maritima) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dusty-miller","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/353574/jacobaea-maritima/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Although primarily known as being toxic to horses and cattle, it is also a valuable food source for pollinators","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"jacobaea"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dutch-iris","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.55,0.56],"union":[0.46,1],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/iris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dutch iris bloom in early summer in deep and light blue, purple, yellow and white on 24 inch tall stems.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Georgia CAES Field Report","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/news/dutch-iris-competes-for-garden-attention/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In Savannah our plants are vigorous, reaching 36 inches","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/spring-flowering-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Habit: upright; 1-1/2 to 2 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/154520/iris-x-hollandica/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/hiris.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dutch Iris grow from 18\" to 22\" tall with long, slender foliage","metres":[0.46,0.56],"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"Van Zyverden","url":"https://www.vanzyverden.com/garden-guides/spring-planting/bulbs/dutch-iris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: 18-24\"","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"Netherland Bulb Company","url":"https://www.netherlandbulb.com/plant/Iris-Hollandica-Dutch-Iris-Mixture","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 20-24 In","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dutch-iris","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/154520/iris-x-hollandica/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dutch-iris","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["6-9","5-8","5-9","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/iris-x-hollandica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[6,9],"level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"University of Georgia CAES Field Report","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/news/dutch-iris-competes-for-garden-attention/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most references suggest a cold hardiness of zones 6 through 9","zones":[6,9],"level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/hiris.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Iris hollandica is good for horticultural zones 5 through 8.","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"Easy To Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/pages/dutch-iris-planting-guide","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones Zones 6-9","zones":[6,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"Van Zyverden","url":"https://www.vanzyverden.com/garden-guides/spring-planting/bulbs/dutch-iris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow as Perennial in zones 5-9. Grow as Annual elsewhere.","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"Netherland Bulb Company","url":"https://www.netherlandbulb.com/plant/Iris-Hollandica-Dutch-Iris-Mixture","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-10","zones":[5,10],"level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dutch-iris","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/iris-x-hollandica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/spring-flowering-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: full sun; well-drained soil; dry, warm soil in summer is ideal; good for forcing indoors","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/154520/iris-x-hollandica/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/hiris.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dutch Iris prefer full sunlight but can handle filtered sunlight or part-day sunlight.","level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"Easy To Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/pages/dutch-iris-planting-guide","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Quantity Full Sun","level":"species"},{"name":"Van Zyverden","url":"https://www.vanzyverden.com/garden-guides/spring-planting/bulbs/dutch-iris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"Netherland Bulb Company","url":"https://www.netherlandbulb.com/plant/Iris-Hollandica-Dutch-Iris-Mixture","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"De Vroomen Garden Products","url":"https://www.devroomen.com/product/iris-dutch-white-excelsior-capper-15-x-10","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They thrive in full sun to partial shade conditions and prefer neutral to slightly alkaline soil.","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dutch-iris","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dutch-iris","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/iris-x-hollandica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are showy in the garden and are prized as cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"University of Georgia CAES Field Report","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/news/dutch-iris-competes-for-garden-attention/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"I quickly came to realize this is the most famous iris that florists use in cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/spring-flowering-bulbs","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dutch Iris is a common cut flower used by florists","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/154520/iris-x-hollandica/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/hiris.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Don't forget that Dutch Iris make phenomenally good cut flowers!","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"Easy To Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/pages/dutch-iris-planting-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Easy to grow and they make excellent cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Van Zyverden","url":"https://www.vanzyverden.com/garden-guides/spring-planting/bulbs/dutch-iris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long-lasting cut flowers perfect for bouquets & arrangements","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"Netherland Bulb Company","url":"https://www.netherlandbulb.com/plant/Iris-Hollandica-Dutch-Iris-Mixture","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are stunning as a cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"iris hollandica"},{"name":"De Vroomen Garden Products","url":"https://www.devroomen.com/product/iris-dutch-white-excelsior-capper-15-x-10","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cutting flower with strong stems and impressive vase life","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dutch-iris","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dutch-iris","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dwarf-alberta-spruce","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[1.1,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.34],"proposed":1.16,"margin":123.9,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-laxa-conica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub is dense, compact, cone-shaped, grows 3 to 4 feet tall, and 1.5 feet wide after 10 years.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea laxa"},{"name":"American Conifer Society","url":"https://conifersociety.org/conifers/picea-glauca-conica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"After 10 years of growth, a mature specimen will measure 4 feet (1.3 m) tall and two-thirds as wide, an annual growth rate of around 4 inches (10 cm).","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea glauca"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":10},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 10.00 to 13.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Conifer, evergreen tree, dwarf, 10-12 ft (3-4 m), slow growing, become broadly conical with time.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Dwarf Alberta spruce, a conifer with extremely tiny light green needles, grows into a perfectly symmetrical cone over time to 12 feet tall x 8 feet wide (very old plants).\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Max Height 1.5-2.5 metres\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Height : 6-8 ft.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height : 6-8 Feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Height: 6-8 ft\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.91 to 1.34 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dwarf-alberta-spruce","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.41,0.89],"split":[{"range":[0.41,0.51],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox"]},{"range":[0.73,0.89],"sources":["American Conifer Society"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-laxa-conica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub is dense, compact, cone-shaped, grows 3 to 4 feet tall, and 1.5 feet wide after 10 years.","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea laxa"},{"name":"American Conifer Society","url":"https://conifersociety.org/conifers/picea-glauca-conica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"After 10 years of growth, a mature specimen will measure 4 feet (1.3 m) tall and two-thirds as wide, an annual growth rate of around 4 inches (10 cm).","metres":0.81,"band":[0.73,0.89],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea glauca"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":10},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 7.00 to 10.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Dwarf Alberta spruce, a conifer with extremely tiny light green needles, grows into a perfectly symmetrical cone over time to 12 feet tall x 8 feet wide (very old plants).\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Max Spread 1-1.5 metres\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Width : 4-5 ft.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread : 4-5 Feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Width: 4-5 ft\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dwarf-alberta-spruce","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,6],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-6","2-8","2-6","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-laxa-conica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It may be planted in USDA Hardiness Zones 3 to 6.","zones":[3,6],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea laxa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252800","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 6","zones":[3,6],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea glauca"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/picea-glauca-conica-dwarf-alberta-spruce","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 2 - 8","zones":[2,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea glauca"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/dwarf-alberta-spruce","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In Zones : 2-6 outdoors","zones":[2,6],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea glauca"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/dwarf-alberta-spruce/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones : 2-8","zones":[2,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea glauca"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/dwarf-alberta-spruce/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In: Zones 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea glauca"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":10},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dwarf-alberta-spruce","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-laxa-conica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea laxa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252800","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea glauca"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/picea-glauca-conica-dwarf-alberta-spruce","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea glauca"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/83270/picea-glauca-var-albertiana-conica/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea glauca"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/dwarf-alberta-spruce","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight : Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea glauca"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/dwarf-alberta-spruce/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure : Partial Shade to Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea glauca"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/dwarf-alberta-spruce/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs : Full Sun, Partial Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea glauca"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dwarf-alberta-spruce","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-laxa-conica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The needles, which are fragrant when crushed, have a white waxy coating.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea laxa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252800","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Needles (to 1/2\" long) are aromatic when crushed.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea glauca"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"dwarf-alberta-spruce","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dwarf-alberta-spruce","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-laxa-conica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is tolerant of wet sites, wind, heat, cold, drought, and partial shade.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"picea laxa"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"dwarf-alberta-spruce","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"earth-angel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.5,1.52],"union":[0.61,2.15],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/parfuma-earth-angel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 5' x 4'","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/floribundas-small-landscape-shrubs/earth-angel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 2-3ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Edmunds' Roses","url":"https://www.edmundsroses.com/product/E24384","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 3-5'","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/gardening/l.php?l=2.69538.1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Height: 5' to 7' (150 to 215cm).","metres":[1.5,2.15],"band":[1.5,2.15],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Bloomables (Star Roses and Plants)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/parfuma-earth-angel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size/Habit Bushy, 5' h x 4' w","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Hoerr Nursery plant database (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.hoerrnursery.com/12120040/Plant/31704/Earth_Angel_Parfuma_Rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"earth-angel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.45,1.34],"split":[{"range":[0.45,0.55],"sources":["HelpMeFind Roses"]},{"range":[0.61,1],"sources":["High Country Roses","Hoerr Nursery plant database (NetPS Plant Finder)"]},{"range":[1.1,1.34],"sources":["Heirloom Roses","Bloomables (Star Roses and Plants)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/parfuma-earth-angel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 5' x 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/floribundas-small-landscape-shrubs/earth-angel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 2-3ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/gardening/l.php?l=2.69538.1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Width: 20\" (50cm).","metres":0.5,"band":[0.45,0.55],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Bloomables (Star Roses and Plants)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/parfuma-earth-angel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size/Habit Bushy, 5' h x 4' w","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Hoerr Nursery plant database (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.hoerrnursery.com/12120040/Plant/31704/Earth_Angel_Parfuma_Rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 3 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"earth-angel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/parfuma-earth-angel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Edmunds' Roses","url":"https://www.edmundsroses.com/product/E24384","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Bloomables (Star Roses and Plants)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/parfuma-earth-angel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 5-10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"earth-angel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/parfuma-earth-angel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun Requires 6+ hours of direct sunlight to thrive.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Edmunds' Roses","url":"https://www.edmundsroses.com/product/E24384","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Bloomables (Star Roses and Plants)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/parfuma-earth-angel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Hoerr Nursery plant database (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.hoerrnursery.com/12120040/Plant/31704/Earth_Angel_Parfuma_Rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"earth-angel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["strong","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/parfuma-earth-angel","https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/floribundas-small-landscape-shrubs/earth-angel/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/parfuma-earth-angel","https://www.edmundsroses.com/product/E24384"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/parfuma-earth-angel","https://www.helpmefind.com/gardening/l.php?l=2.69538.1"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/parfuma-earth-angel","https://www.bloomables.com/plants/parfuma-earth-angel/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/parfuma-earth-angel","https://plants.hoerrnursery.com/12120040/Plant/31704/Earth_Angel_Parfuma_Rose"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/parfuma-earth-angel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"is an exceptionally fragrant peony-shaped rose with bright, glossy green foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/floribundas-small-landscape-shrubs/earth-angel/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Exceptionally fragrant peony-shaped flowers opening from dark pink buds.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Edmunds' Roses","url":"https://www.edmundsroses.com/product/E24384","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Strong, sweet and fruity","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/gardening/l.php?l=2.69538.1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Strong, apple, lemon, rose, sweet fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Bloomables (Star Roses and Plants)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/parfuma-earth-angel/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uniquely shaped, fragrant blooms","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Hoerr Nursery plant database (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.hoerrnursery.com/12120040/Plant/31704/Earth_Angel_Parfuma_Rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"exceptionally fragrant blooms repeat all season long and make splendid cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 6 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 6","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"earth-angel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/parfuma-earth-angel","https://plants.hoerrnursery.com/12120040/Plant/31704/Earth_Angel_Parfuma_Rose"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/parfuma-earth-angel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets and floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Hoerr Nursery plant database (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.hoerrnursery.com/12120040/Plant/31704/Earth_Angel_Parfuma_Rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"earth-angel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"earth-angel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Hoerr Nursery plant database (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.hoerrnursery.com/12120040/Plant/31704/Earth_Angel_Parfuma_Rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting bees to your yard.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":18,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[9.14,13.41],"split":[{"range":[9.14,10.36],"sources":["Kansas Forest Service, Kansas State University"]},{"range":[10.97,13.41],"sources":["Towson University Glen Arboretum"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Kansas Forest Service, Kansas State University","url":"https://www.kansasforests.org/forestry/treespecies/evergreens/easternwhitepine.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Average Height in 20 Yrs: -Eastern 30-34 ft.","metres":[9.14,10.36],"band":[9.14,10.36],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Towson University Glen Arboretum","url":"https://wp.towson.edu/glenarboretum/home/eastern-white-pine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"An incredibly fast-growing tree that can reach 40 feet in 20 years or less.","metres":12.19,"band":[10.97,13.41],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":16},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":20,"sourcesDropped":13,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 50.00 to 80.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 50 ft. 0 in. - 80 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"reaches 50 to 80 feet in height and 20 to 40 feet in spread\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Height 50-80 Feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 50-80 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"With age, white pine can become 150 ft high and over three feet in diameter.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"50-70'\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"A large tree with a very straight trunk often reaching well over 100 feet in height.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature height 50-80 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Size Notes: Up to about 200 feet tall.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height ranges from 80 to 100 feet, with a trunk diameter up to 42 inches.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: to 100 feet; spread to 65 feet.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 50-80'\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 13 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 20 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":16},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":20,"sourcesDropped":10,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 20.00 to 40.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 20 ft. 0 in. - 40 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"reaches 50 to 80 feet in height and 20 to 40 feet in spread\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 40-50 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"It reaches a mature height of 50 to 80 feet and a spread of 20 to 30 feet.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"30-50'\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature width 20-40 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"The tree grows to a maximum canopy spread of 40 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: to 100 feet; spread to 65 feet.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 20-40'\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 20 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","5-7","3-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285004","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pinus-strobus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=245&PlantTypeID=7","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 3 - 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Forestry (Iowa Trees)","url":"https://naturalresources.extension.iastate.edu/forestry/iowa_trees/trees/white_pine.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness: Zones 5 through 7","zones":[5,7],"level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/eastern-white-pine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 3, Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7","zones":[3,7],"level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/pinus-strobus-eastern-white-pine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species"},{"name":"Iowa DNR State Forest Nursery","url":"https://nursery.iowadnr.gov/White-Pine-Eastern_p_127.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":16},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285004","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pinus-strobus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It prefers full sun; moist, well-drained, fertile sandy loams; and cool, humid climates.","level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/pine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows best on fertile, moist, well-drained soil and in full sun.","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=245&PlantTypeID=7","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun; fertile, moist, but well-drained soils; prefers acid soil.","level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/eastern-white-pine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily)","level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/pinus-strobus-eastern-white-pine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Native Plant Database","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PIST","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade , Shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Iowa DNR State Forest Nursery","url":"https://nursery.iowadnr.gov/White-Pine-Eastern_p_127.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: full sun","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Towson University Glen Arboretum","url":"https://wp.towson.edu/glenarboretum/home/eastern-white-pine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"used a lot as Christmas trees and many people enjoy the smell","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Kansas Forest Service, Kansas State University","url":"https://www.kansasforests.org/forestry/treespecies/evergreens/easternwhitepine.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerance: Low","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"Nebraska Forest Service, University of Nebraska-Lincoln","url":"https://nfs.unl.edu/pine-eastern-white/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Although the tree is tolerant of moderate drought, it will likely suffer in severe droughts if not sited properly or watered.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/eastern-white-pine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance Moderately sensitive","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pinus-strobus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"it will attract butterflies and other pollinators, songbirds, and small mammals","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine-fastigiata","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":12,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":20,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"30.00 to 40.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"40 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 20 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine-fastigiata","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":20,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"7.00 to 10.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"15 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 20 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine-fastigiata","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252893","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 to 8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine-fastigiata","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252893","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/1098/Columnar_White_Pine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine-fastigiata","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine-fastigiata","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine-fastigiata","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine-fastigiata","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine-nana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["the page's figure is a 10 to 10 year size and this row's is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 7 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine-nana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 3.00 to 10.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page's figure is a 10 to 10 year size and this row's is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine-nana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261617","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pinus-strobus-nana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine-nana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261617","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pinus-strobus-nana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine-nana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine-nana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine-nana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eastern-white-pine-nana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"echeveria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Perennial","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0 ft. 1 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"echeveria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Perennial","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0 ft. 2 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"echeveria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"echeveria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echeveria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"echeveria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echeveria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"unscented flowers","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"echeveria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"echeveria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"echeveria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echeveria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attracting bumble bees and hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"echinops","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":17,"levels":{"species":10,"cultivar":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 17 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"echinops","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":14,"levels":{"species":10,"cultivar":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 14 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"echinops","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":14,"levels":{"species":10,"cultivar":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 14 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"echinops","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277311&isprofile=0&basic=Echinops","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277649&isprofile=0&basic=Echinops","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"echinops bannaticus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277425&isprofile=0&basic=Echinops","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"echinops sphaerocephalus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255135&isprofile=0&basic=Echinops","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinops-ritro/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/globe-thistle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=723&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/echinops-ritro-small-globe-thistle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/echinops-bannaticus-blue-glow-blue-glow-globe-thistle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops bannaticus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/105703/echinops-ritro-l/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/52840/echinops-ritro-veitchs-blue/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHBG","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops bannaticus"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/echinops-ritro.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/globe-thistle-blue-glow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States","level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops bannaticus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"echinops","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["echinops ritro"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (echinops ritro), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (echinops ritro) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"echinops","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277311&isprofile=0&basic=Echinops","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277649&isprofile=0&basic=Echinops","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops bannaticus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277425&isprofile=0&basic=Echinops","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops sphaerocephalus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinops-ritro/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension, Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/plants-that-tolerate-drought/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers dry well and keep blue color.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/echinops-ritro-small-globe-thistle","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The stiff stems are good for cut and dried flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/52840/echinops-ritro-veitchs-blue/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"flowering may be repeated in autumn. Good for cutting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHBG","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Echinops makes a great cut flower or dried everlasting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops bannaticus"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/echinops-ritro.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cutting fresh or drying.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery, genus Echinops","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/genus/echinops","country":null,"form":null,"value":"in a vase as a fresh or dried cut flower, their impressive profile brings intriguing definition to surrounding softer forms.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"echinops"},{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/plant/p-0936","country":null,"form":null,"value":"in a vase as a fresh or dried cut flower, their impressive profile brings intriguing definition to surrounding softer forms.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops bannaticus"},{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/plant/P-1911","country":null,"form":null,"value":"in a vase as a fresh or dried cut flower, their impressive profile brings intriguing definition to surrounding softer forms.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/globe-thistle-blue-glow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers • Dried Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops bannaticus"}],"note":"13 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"echinops","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277311&isprofile=0&basic=Echinops","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277425&isprofile=0&basic=Echinops","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops sphaerocephalus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255135&isprofile=0&basic=Echinops","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinops-ritro/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, these plants are drought-tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/globe-thistle","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=723&PlantTypeID=2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension, Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/plants-that-tolerate-drought/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These plants are drought tolerant once established","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/echinops-ritro-small-globe-thistle","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Small globe thistle is an excellent, drought-tolerant, back-of-the-border anchor plant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/echinops-bannaticus-blue-glow-blue-glow-globe-thistle","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant thrives in full sun, dry soil, and the heat of midsummer.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops bannaticus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/105703/echinops-ritro-l/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/52840/echinops-ritro-veitchs-blue/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHBG","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Border Plant Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Drought Tolerant Mass Planting Salt Tolerant Specimen Focal Point","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops bannaticus"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/globe-thistle-blue-glow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant • Low Water Use","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops bannaticus"}],"note":"13 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"echinops","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277311&isprofile=0&basic=Echinops","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277425&isprofile=0&basic=Echinops","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops sphaerocephalus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255135&isprofile=0&basic=Echinops","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/echinops-ritro/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The blooms are very attractive to bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/echinops-ritro-small-globe-thistle","country":null,"form":null,"value":"it is also a favorite of bees and butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/echinops-bannaticus-blue-glow-blue-glow-globe-thistle","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops bannaticus"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ECHBG","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bumblebees and nocturnal moths delight in their sweet nectar.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops bannaticus"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/echinops-ritro.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery, genus Echinops","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/genus/echinops","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees and butterflies adore Echinops","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"echinops"},{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/plant/p-0936","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees and butterflies adore Echinops","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops bannaticus"},{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/plant/P-1911","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees and butterflies adore Echinops","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops ritro"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/globe-thistle-blue-glow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees • Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"echinops bannaticus"}],"note":"12 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"eden-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[3.29,3.36],"union":[2.44,4.03],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/eden-climber","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Size 10' X 6'","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/eden","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Height: 10ft","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/eden-climber-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Height: 10-12 feet","metres":[3.05,3.66],"band":[3.05,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Antique Rose Emporium","url":"https://www.antiqueroseemporium.com/products/eden-climber","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Mature Height: 12ft","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/eden-rose/","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Height: 8-12 Feet","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"eden-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1.1,2.01],"split":[{"range":[1.1,1.34],"sources":["Menagerie Farm and Flower"]},{"range":[1.65,2.01],"sources":["Heirloom Roses"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/eden-climber","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Size 10' X 6'","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/eden-climber-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Spread: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"eden-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-10","5-11","3-11","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/eden-climber","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zone 5-10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/eden","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/eden-climber-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Suitable Zones: 3-11","zones":[3,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Antique Rose Emporium","url":"https://www.antiqueroseemporium.com/products/eden-climber","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Climate Zones: zone 5, zone 6, zone 7, zone 8, zone 9, zone 10, zone 11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/eden-rose/","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zone: 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"eden-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/eden-climber","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Partial Shade or Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/eden","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Roses require full sun and organically rich, well-drained, acidic to neutral soils.","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"eden-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"strengths":["light","light","medium"],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/eden-climber","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Lightly Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/eden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There is a slight fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/eden-climber-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Mild","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Antique Rose Emporium","url":"https://www.antiqueroseemporium.com/products/eden-climber","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant: Yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/eden-rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are often fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"eden-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/eden-rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Can be used for cut flower, garden, landscape or pillar.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"eden-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"eden-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"elephant-ear","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":4,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Most varieties fall within the 3' to 5' tall range.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"elephant-ear","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":4,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"elephant-ear","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Colocasia","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/colocasia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b, 12a, 12b","zones":[8,12],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":4,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"elephant-ear","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Colocasia","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/colocasia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Colocasia esculenta","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a442","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"colocasia esculenta"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Colocasia esculenta","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/colocasia-esculenta/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plant grows best in part shade or filtered sun and moist, rich soil.","level":"species","taxon":"colocasia esculenta"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture: Elephant Ears, Colocasia, Alocasia and Xanthosoma","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/elephant-ears-colocasia-alocasia-and-xanthosoma/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Many types of elephant ears can be grown in partial shade, but the darker colored varieties are best grown in full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, Colocasia esculenta","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/4248/colocasia-esculenta/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"colocasia esculenta"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Plants: Colocasia","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/plants/colocasia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Colocasia prefers full sun to light shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, ILRiverHort: Giant Elephant Ears Accent the Garden","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/ilriverhort/2015-09-21-giant-elephant-ears-accent-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"All elephant ears prefer full sun and typically like a lot of water.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County, Fact sheet: Black elephant ear","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/05/30/fact-sheet-black-elephant-ear/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Site Requirements: Shade to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"colocasia esculenta"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"elephant-ear","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture: Elephant Ears, Colocasia, Alocasia and Xanthosoma","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/elephant-ears-colocasia-alocasia-and-xanthosoma/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers can be large, fragrant and attractive, but are normally hidden underneath the foliage.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery, Cool Colocasias: Types of Elephant Ears for the Garden","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/blogs/articles/elephant-ears-bulbs-colocasia-plant","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the inflorescences are large, quite attractive and frequently fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"elephant-ear","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"elephant-ear","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["colocasia esculenta"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (colocasia esculenta), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (colocasia esculenta) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"elephant-ear","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"elephant-ear-black-magic","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":8,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 3.00 to 6.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"makes a giant clump to 5-6' tall with a similar spread\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: Grows 60\" tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 4′-6′\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 60\" to 72\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant Height Up to 72 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 36-48\" tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Grows to 6' tall with a similar spread.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"elephant-ear-black-magic","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 3.00 to 6.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"makes a giant clump to 5-6' tall with a similar spread\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Grows to 6' tall with a similar spread.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"elephant-ear-black-magic","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["8-10","8-11","7-10","9-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244408","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8 to 10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/colocasia-esculenta/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[8,11]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/colocasia-esculenta-black-magic","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 7b to 10b","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/elephant-ear-black-magic","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 9 through 11","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/esculenta-black-magic/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 7, 8, 9, 10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/black-magic-elephant-ear","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 8 to 10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/black-magic-elephant-ears-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 8, 9, 10, 11","zones":[8,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"elephant-ear-black-magic","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244408","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/colocasia-esculenta/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/colocasia-esculenta-black-magic","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Sun to Part Sun"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/esculenta-black-magic/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun, Part Shade"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/black-magic-elephant-ear","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun, Partial Shade"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/black-magic-elephant-ears-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement Partial Shade"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/black-magic-elephant-ears","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun, Partial Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"elephant-ear-black-magic","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"elephant-ear-black-magic","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"elephant-ear-black-magic","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244408","country":null,"form":null,"value":"provide regular moisture, especially during dry summer periods, and do not allow soils to dry out","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"elephant-ear-black-magic","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"emily-bronte","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.3,1.34],"union":[0.91,1.54],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/emily-bronte","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/emily-bronte","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4' x 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/emily-bronte-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mature Height 3-5 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rosarium Lottum","url":"https://rosariumlottum.com/en/product/emily-bronteausearnshaw/","country":"NL","form":"shrub","value":"Height 100-150 cm","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/emily-bronte","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height : 3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"United States Plant Patent PP31,400 (Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP31400P2/en","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Mature plant: Height: 1 m 40 cm. Width: 1 m 20 cm.","metres":1.4,"band":[1.26,1.54],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Belle Epoque Rozenkwekerij","url":"https://belle-epoque.nl/products/emily-bronte-ausearnshaw","country":"NL","form":"shrub","value":"Hoogte 130-140 cm","metres":[1.3,1.4],"band":[1.3,1.4],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"emily-bronte","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"edge","consensus":[1.17,1.18],"union":[0.91,1.43],"edge":[0.88,1.43],"edgeMargin":1.1,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/emily-bronte","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3 1/2ft","metres":1.07,"band":[0.96,1.18],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/emily-bronte","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4' x 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/emily-bronte-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mature Spread 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/emily-bronte","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width : 3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"United States Plant Patent PP31,400 (Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP31400P2/en","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Mature plant: Height: 1 m 40 cm. Width: 1 m 20 cm.","metres":1.2,"band":[1.08,1.32],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Belle Epoque Rozenkwekerij","url":"https://belle-epoque.nl/products/emily-bronte-ausearnshaw","country":"NL","form":"shrub","value":"Ze bereikt een elegante hoogte van circa 140 cm en een breedte van 130 cm","metres":1.3,"band":[1.17,1.43],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV2":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":1.17},"note":"the catalog value sits 1.1% outside the sources' union (0.91 to 1.43 m) and inside the 3% margin v3 allows at a stated range edge (0.88 to 1.43 m), so v2's proposal of 1.17 m is withdrawn rather than applied; 2 of these 6 scored sources publish a range, and a range edge is a figure converted and rounded from another unit rather than a measurement to the centimetre; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"emily-bronte","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/emily-bronte","https://heirloomroses.com/products/emily-bronte"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/emily-bronte","https://plantaddicts.com/emily-bronte-rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/emily-bronte","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/emily-bronte"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/emily-bronte","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/emily-bronte","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/emily-bronte-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"USDA Hardiness Zones 5 to 11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/emily-bronte","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zones : 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[5,11]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"emily-bronte","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/emily-bronte","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/emily-bronte","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Partial Shade or Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/emily-bronte-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light Exposure Part Sun to Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/emily-bronte","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light Requirements : Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"emily-bronte","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["strong","strong","strong","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/emily-bronte","https://heirloomroses.com/products/emily-bronte"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/emily-bronte","https://plantaddicts.com/emily-bronte-rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/emily-bronte","https://rosariumlottum.com/en/product/emily-bronteausearnshaw/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/emily-bronte","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/emily-bronte"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/emily-bronte","https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP31400P2/en"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/emily-bronte","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The strong Tea scent becomes more Old Rose, with delicious hints of lemon and grapefruit.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/emily-bronte","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Exceptionally Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/emily-bronte-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rosarium Lottum","url":"https://rosariumlottum.com/en/product/emily-bronteausearnshaw/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"strong Tea scent becomes more Old Rose, with delicious hints of lemon and grapefruit","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/emily-bronte","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance : Strong - Tea, Old Rose, Lemon, Grapefruit","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"United States Plant Patent PP31,400 (Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP31400P2/en","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Strong. Character of fragrance: Tea developing to Old Rose.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 6 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 6","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"emily-bronte","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/emily-bronte-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Garden","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/emily-bronte","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vase Life : 4-5 days","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"emily-bronte","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"emily-bronte","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/emily-bronte-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This redolent hybrid attracts pollinators including bees.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"emperor","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"10.00 to 15.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"reaches 15 ft. tall and wide\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"emperor","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":4.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"10.00 to 15.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"reaches 15 ft. tall and wide\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"emperor","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","5-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=267961","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Monrovia (introducer of Emperor I)","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/emperor-ir-japanese-maple.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5-8","zones":[5,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"emperor","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=267961","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Monrovia (introducer of Emperor I)","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/emperor-ir-japanese-maple.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Filtered sun, Full sun, Partial sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"emperor","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"emperor","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"emperor","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia (introducer of Emperor I)","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/emperor-ir-japanese-maple.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Keep soil consistently moist but not soggy.","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"emperor","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"epimedium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.2,0.25],"union":[0.2,0.38],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/epimedium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 8 in. - 0 ft. 10 in.","metres":[0.2,0.25],"band":[0.2,0.25],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/landscaping/barrenwort","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 12–15 inches tall.","metres":[0.3,0.38],"band":[0.3,0.38],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Piedmont Master Gardeners","url":"https://www.piedmontmastergardeners.org/article/epimedium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Low-growing Epimediums average 8 to 12 in. in height.","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"genus":3,"cultivar":2,"species":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"epimedium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/epimedium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"genus":3,"cultivar":2,"species":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"epimedium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[5,8],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/epimedium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[5,8],"level":"genus"},{"name":"Piedmont Master Gardeners","url":"https://www.piedmontmastergardeners.org/article/epimedium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They grow best in a shady or semi-shady area in gardening zones 5 – 8.","zones":[5,8],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"genus":3,"cultivar":2,"species":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source states 5-8; catalog states 4-8; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"epimedium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/epimedium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most Epimediums prefer shade to part shade in moist but well-drained fertile soils.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264472&isprofile=0&gen=Epimedium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277770&isprofile=0&basic=epimedium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"epimedium grandiflorum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c640","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"epimedium rubrum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"http://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c660","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"epimedium youngianum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/epimedium-x-rubrum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"epimedium rubrum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/epimedium-x-perralchicum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"epimedium perralchicum"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/epimedium-pink-elf-barrenwort","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Partial Shade Full Shade","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"epimedium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"epimedium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"epimedium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/epimedium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deep shade and drought conditions are not an issue for established plants.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/landscaping/barrenwort","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Will tolerate dry shade and tree roots once it gets established.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Piedmont Master Gardeners","url":"https://www.piedmontmastergardeners.org/article/epimedium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is long-lived, tough as nails, low maintenance, deer resistant, and drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264472&isprofile=0&gen=Epimedium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Also tolerates drought and dry shade (rhizomes hold moisture) once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277770&isprofile=0&basic=epimedium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Also tolerates drought and dry shade (rhizomes hold moisture) once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"epimedium grandiflorum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c640","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Heavy Shade, Erosion, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"epimedium rubrum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"http://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c660","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Heavy Shade, Erosion, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"epimedium youngianum"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"epimedium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"eustacia-vye","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.32],"union":[1.08,1.34],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/eustacia-vye","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/gardening/l.php?l=2.83178.1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Height: 4' (120cm). Width: 4' (120cm).","metres":1.2,"band":[1.08,1.32],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/eustacia-vye","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height: 4ft (125cm)","metres":1.25,"band":[1.13,1.38],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":3},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"eustacia-vye","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.82,1.32],"split":[{"range":[0.82,1],"sources":["David Austin Roses (US site)"]},{"range":[1.08,1.32],"sources":["HelpMeFind Roses"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/eustacia-vye","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3ft","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/gardening/l.php?l=2.83178.1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Height: 4' (120cm). Width: 4' (120cm).","metres":1.2,"band":[1.08,1.32],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/eustacia-vye","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Width: 3ft (90cm)","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":3},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"eustacia-vye","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/eustacia-vye","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 4-11","zones":[4,11],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":3},"reasons":[]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"eustacia-vye","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/eustacia-vye","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sunlight Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"eustacia-vye","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["strong","strong","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/eustacia-vye","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/eustacia-vye"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/eustacia-vye","https://www.helpmefind.com/gardening/l.php?l=2.83178.1"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/eustacia-vye","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They have a delicious strong fruity fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/eustacia-vye","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They have a delicious strong fruity fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/gardening/l.php?l=2.83178.1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Strong, fruity fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"eustacia-vye","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"eustacia-vye","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"eustacia-vye","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"feather-reed-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1.52],"union":[0.91,1.52],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269735","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/calamagrostis-x-acutiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=598&PlantTypeID=3","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3-5 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"feather-reed-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269735","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/calamagrostis-x-acutiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"feather-reed-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","4-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269735","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/calamagrostis-x-acutiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone","zones":[4,11]},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=598&PlantTypeID=3","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5 - 9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"feather-reed-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269735","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/calamagrostis-x-acutiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=598&PlantTypeID=3","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"feather-reed-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"feather-reed-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"feather-reed-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/calamagrostis-x-acutiflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"feather-reed-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/calamagrostis-x-acutiflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"feather-reed-grass-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243337&isprofile=0&basic=Overdam","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2.50 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"feather-reed-grass-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243337&isprofile=0&basic=Overdam","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"feather-reed-grass-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243337&isprofile=0&basic=Overdam","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"feather-reed-grass-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243337&isprofile=0&basic=Overdam","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"feather-reed-grass-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"feather-reed-grass-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243337&isprofile=0&basic=Overdam","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"feather-reed-grass-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"feather-reed-grass-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"floribunda-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Rosa (Rose, Roses)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grow 1 to 8 feet tall and 2 to 6 feet wide depending upon the cultivar, species, or hybrid","metres":[0.3,2.44],"band":[0.3,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":5,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"floribunda-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Rosa (Rose, Roses)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grow 1 to 8 feet tall and 2 to 6 feet wide depending upon the cultivar, species, or hybrid","metres":[0.61,1.83],"band":[0.61,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":5,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"floribunda-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":5,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"floribunda-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Rosa (Rose, Roses)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Roses require full sun and organically rich, well-drained, acidic to neutral soils.","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension, G6600 Roses: Selecting and Planting","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/publications/g6600","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Roses grow best in full sunlight. If full sun is not possible, locate them where they get a minimum of six hours of bright sunlight each day.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Rosa 'Korbin' ICEBERG","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252207","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Rosa EUROPEANA","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252136","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"floribunda-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"strengths":["light","light"],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Rosa (Rose, Roses)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are often fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions, Roses","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/roses/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Roses are longtime landscape favorites because of their rich fragrance and beautiful color.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, How to grow roses","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/roses/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Some roses have a fruity fragrance while others have a musk or tea scent","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Rosa 'Korbin' ICEBERG","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252207","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Mild fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Rosa EUROPEANA","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252136","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Light fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"floribunda-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Rosa (Rose, Roses)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Grow roses in cottage or cutting gardens or use them at the back of a border.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension, G6600 Roses: Selecting and Planting","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/publications/g6600","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are useful as landscape plants and prized as cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions, Roses","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/roses/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gardeners love roses in part because they can be brought inside and enjoyed as beautiful cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"floribunda-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"floribunda-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Rosa (Rose, Roses)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#bee friendly","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Rosa 'Korbin' ICEBERG","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252207","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Rosa EUROPEANA","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252136","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"flowering-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center, Ornamental Cherry, Plum, Apricot & Almond","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/ornamental-cherry-plum-apricot-almond/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It may grow about 10 feet in 10 years, but is short-lived.","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":7,"genus":1,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 15.00 to 25.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 15 ft. 0 in. - 25 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Broadleaf deciduous tree, 20-35 ft (6-11 cm), many clones, variable habits.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature height 15-20 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"flowering-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":7,"genus":1,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 15.00 to 25.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 15 ft. 0 in. - 25 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"The Japanese cherry will grow 15 to 25 feet tall and 15 to 25 feet wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature width 15-20 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"flowering-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","5-9","5-6"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a915","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/prunus-serrulata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[5,8],"level":"species"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension, TreeBrowser","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/treebrowser/catalog/cherry-japanese-oriental","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 5- 9.","zones":[5,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-flowering-cherry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago)","zones":[5,6],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":7,"genus":1,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"flowering-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a915","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/prunus-serrulata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center, Ornamental Cherry, Plum, Apricot & Almond","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/ornamental-cherry-plum-apricot-almond/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They prefer moist, fast-draining, well-aerated soil and require full sun.","level":"species"},{"name":"Oregon State University, Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/prunus-serrulata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun or part shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension, Ornamental Cherry Trees","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/ornamental-cherry-trees-identify-and-manage-problems","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Select a site that receives full sun or at least 6-8 hours of sunlight each day.","level":"genus","taxon":"prunus"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer, Purdue University","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/521/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-flowering-cherry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily)","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"flowering-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a915","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It features non-fragrant white flowers in spring","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"Trees and Shrubs Online (Bean's Trees and Shrubs Hardy in the British Isles), International Dendrology Society","url":"https://treesandshrubsonline.org/articles/prunus/prunus-serrulata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"easily distinguished by its gaunt, flat-topped habit, and its rather small, scentless flowers","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"flowering-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"flowering-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center, Ornamental Cherry, Plum, Apricot & Almond","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/ornamental-cherry-plum-apricot-almond/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"keeping the trees healthy with adequate irrigation during extended drought","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer, Purdue University","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/521/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It can tolerate part shade (at the expense of blooms), as well as heat, humidity, and even some drier soils (once it is established).","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-flowering-cherry/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance Moderately sensitive","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"flowering-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/prunus-serrulata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#butterfly friendly #larval host plant #fall interest #pink flowers #pollinator plant","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension, Ornamental Cherry Trees","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/ornamental-cherry-trees-identify-and-manage-problems","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Prunus and Malus species are especially valuable to native wildlife; they support high numbers of native butterfly and moth species (Tallamy, 2007).","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"prunus"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-flowering-cherry/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Insect pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"foam-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/foamflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Foamflowers are relatively low growers, reaching 6 to 12 inches in foliage height.","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"tiarella"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":11,"levels":{"species":11,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 11 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"foam-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":11,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"foam-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/foamflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"tiarella"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"species":11,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"foam-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286882&isprofile=0&basic=Tiarella","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"tiarella cordifolia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tiarella-cordifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Foamflower is best grown in shade, from dappled shade to full shade.","level":"species","taxon":"tiarella cordifolia"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/foamflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Part to Full Shade","level":"genus","taxon":"tiarella"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/foamflower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Partial Sun/Shade","level":"species","taxon":"tiarella cordifolia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=884&PlantTypeID=14","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial to full shade; moist, well drained soils.","level":"species","taxon":"tiarella cordifolia"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/foamflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Foamflower thrives in average to moist, well-drained soils in partial to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"tiarella cordifolia"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/tiarella-cordifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Shade to Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"tiarella cordifolia"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/tiarella-cordifolia.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Partial Shade or Full Shade","level":"species","taxon":"tiarella cordifolia"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"foam-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"foam-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"foam-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/foamflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Watering: Water regularly, not drought tolerant","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"tiarella"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["tiarella cordifolia"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (tiarella cordifolia), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (tiarella cordifolia) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"foam-flower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["tiarella cordifolia"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (tiarella cordifolia), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (tiarella cordifolia) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"foamy-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/x-heucherella/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foamy-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/x-heucherella/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foamy-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/x-heucherella/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[4,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foamy-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/x-heucherella/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"UT Gardens, the State Botanical Garden of Tennessee","url":"https://utgardens.tennessee.edu/june-2017-plant-of-the-month-foamy-bells/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light shade to part sun is going to be a good choice for most Tennessee gardens"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foamy-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foamy-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foamy-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foamy-bells","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/x-heucherella/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Birds, butterflies and hummingbirds are attracted to this plant.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"forsythia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[2.75,3.05],"union":[0.91,3.36],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/forsythia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,3.05],"band":[0.91,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/forsythia-forsythia-spp/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Depending on the type, they can grow 8 to 10 feet tall and 10 to 12 feet across and have upright or graceful, arching branches for a rounded, mounded or upright habit.","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/growing-forsythias-home-landscape","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Many cultivars (varieties) have spreading, arching growth habits and can reach 8 to 10 feet.","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Maine Cooperative Extension, Signs of the Seasons","url":"https://extension.umaine.edu/signs-of-the-seasons/indicator-species/forsythia-fact-sheet/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Forsythia is a deciduous shrub with upward and arching shoots that may be 10 feet tall and 15 feet wide.","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/forsythia/growing-guide","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Most will eventually grow to about 2m (6½ft) tall and wide","metres":2,"band":[1.8,2.2],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"forsythia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1.22,5.03],"split":[{"range":[1.22,2.2],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","Royal Horticultural Society"]},{"range":[3.05,3.66],"sources":["University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture"]},{"range":[4.11,5.03],"sources":["University of Maine Cooperative Extension, Signs of the Seasons"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/forsythia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 4 ft. 0 in. - 7 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,2.13],"band":[1.22,2.13],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/forsythia-forsythia-spp/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Depending on the type, they can grow 8 to 10 feet tall and 10 to 12 feet across and have upright or graceful, arching branches for a rounded, mounded or upright habit.","metres":[3.05,3.66],"band":[3.05,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Maine Cooperative Extension, Signs of the Seasons","url":"https://extension.umaine.edu/signs-of-the-seasons/indicator-species/forsythia-fact-sheet/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Forsythia is a deciduous shrub with upward and arching shoots that may be 10 feet tall and 15 feet wide.","metres":4.57,"band":[4.11,5.03],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/forsythia/growing-guide","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Most will eventually grow to about 2m (6½ft) tall and wide","metres":2,"band":[1.8,2.2],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 3 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"forsythia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/forsythia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[5,8],"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/forsythia-forsythia-spp/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness varies by species, with most hardy to zones 5a to 8b, but many of the hybrids are hardier than the parents, surviving to zone 4a or even 3a.","zones":[5,8],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"forsythia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/forsythia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=291997","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"forsythia intermedia"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/forsythia-forsythia-spp/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow forsythia in full sun and almost any type of soil","level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/growing-forsythias-home-landscape","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Forsythias grow and bloom best in full sun. They will grow in partial shade but won't bloom as heavily.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/forsythia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Forsythia should be planted in full sun for maximum flowering.","level":"species","taxon":"forsythia intermedia"},{"name":"Cornell University Woody Plants Database","url":"https://woodyplants.cals.cornell.edu/plant/96","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"forsythia intermedia"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/border-forsythia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"forsythia intermedia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, The Garden Scoop","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/garden-scoop/2021-04-03-forsythia-spring","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Forsythia works nicely in a landscape setting as a hedge or mass planting and requires full sun to ensure a good flowering display.","level":"species","taxon":"forsythia intermedia"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"forsythia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"forsythia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/forsythia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stems and flowers are often cut and brought indoors to show that winter will soon be over.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["forsythia intermedia"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (forsythia intermedia), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (forsythia intermedia) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"forsythia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/forsythia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Forsythia is a forgiving plant and tolerates average to poor garden soils, urban conditions, and drought.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/forsythia/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, forsythias are fairly drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["forsythia intermedia"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (forsythia intermedia), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (forsythia intermedia) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"forsythia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["forsythia intermedia"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (forsythia intermedia), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (forsythia intermedia) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.82,1],"union":[0.61,1.83],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=e500","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2.50 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.76,1.52],"band":[0.76,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pennisetum-alopecuroides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.83],"band":[0.61,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/pennisetum-alopecuroides-fountain-grass","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This clump-forming ornamental grass grows to a height of about three feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.76,1.22],"union":[0.61,1.52],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=e500","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2.50 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.76,1.52],"band":[0.76,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pennisetum-alopecuroides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[6,9],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=e500","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6 to 9","zones":[6,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pennisetum-alopecuroides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone","zones":[6,9]}],"note":"every source states 6-9; catalog states 5-9","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=e500","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pennisetum-alopecuroides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/pennisetum-alopecuroides-fountain-grass","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=e500","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pennisetum-alopecuroides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Garden","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=e500","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of drought once established.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pennisetum-alopecuroides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant Garden","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Grass","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"3.00 to 5.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"2'6\" - 3'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"reaches 2 to 4 ft. tall, 2 to 3 ft. wide\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Grass","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"2.00 to 4.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"12\" - 2'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"reaches 2 to 4 ft. tall, 2 to 3 ft. wide\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["9-10","9-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c257","country":"US","form":null,"value":"9 to 10","zones":[9,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Cenchrus setaceus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cenchrus-setaceus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c257","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Graceful Grasses Purple Fountain Grass)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/pennisetum/graceful-grasses-purple-fountain-grass-pennisetum-setaceum-rubrum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Sun to Sun"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/purple-fountain-grass.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Cenchrus setaceus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cenchrus-setaceus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (Graceful Grasses Purple Fountain Grass)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/pennisetum/graceful-grasses-purple-fountain-grass-pennisetum-setaceum-rubrum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/purple-fountain-grass.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"tolerates moderate drought","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Cenchrus setaceus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cenchrus-setaceus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass-dwarf","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.25,0.46],"union":[0.25,0.46],"proposed":0.36,"margin":8.7,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251865","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/little-bunny-dwarf-fountain-grass.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Slowly reaches 10 to 12 in. tall and wide.","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.25 to 0.46 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass-dwarf","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.25,0.61],"split":[{"range":[0.25,0.3],"sources":["Monrovia"]},{"range":[0.46,0.61],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251865","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/little-bunny-dwarf-fountain-grass.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Slowly reaches 10 to 12 in. tall and wide.","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass-dwarf","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251865","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/pennisetum-alopecuroides-little-bunny-miniature-fountain-grass","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5 - 9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass-dwarf","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251865","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/little-bunny-dwarf-fountain-grass.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/pennisetum-alopecuroides-little-bunny-miniature-fountain-grass","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass-dwarf","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass-dwarf","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251865","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass-dwarf","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251865","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of drought once established.","claim":true},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/little-bunny-dwarf-fountain-grass.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant when established.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fountain-grass-dwarf","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"four-oclock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":8,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 6 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The shrub-like, erect and spreading, multi-branched plants grow 2-3 feet tall and wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plants form a bushy, shrub-like mass 1-1/2 to 3 ft high.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Erect perennial herbs 4-10 dm tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mirabilis jalapa is a PERENNIAL growing to 0.6 m (2ft) by 0.5 m (1ft 8in) at a fast rate.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Four O'Clocks are bushy, upright plants to 2 ft. tall which produce fragrant 2 in. trumpet-shaped flowers in a wide range of attractive colors.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Four o'clocks form shrubby bushes growing up to 3 feet (91 cm) wide and just as tall in a single year from seed.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"four-oclock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The shrub-like, erect and spreading, multi-branched plants grow 2-3 feet tall and wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mirabilis jalapa is a PERENNIAL growing to 0.6 m (2ft) by 0.5 m (1ft 8in) at a fast rate.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Four o'clocks form shrubby bushes growing up to 3 feet (91 cm) wide and just as tall in a single year from seed.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"four-oclock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["9-11","9-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Mirabilis jalapa","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282898","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 9 to 11","zones":[9,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Mirabilis jalapa","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mirabilis-jalapa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[9,10],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"four-oclock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Mirabilis jalapa","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282898","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Mirabilis jalapa","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mirabilis-jalapa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture: Four O'Clocks, Mirabilis jalapa","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/four-oclocks-mirabilis-jalapa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow four o'clocks in full sun.","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions: Four O'Clocks","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/four-oclocks/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Four o'clocks (Mirabilis jalapa) do best in full sun and bloom late spring, throughout the summer, until fall.","level":"species"},{"name":"Plants For A Future database, Mirabilis jalapa","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Mirabilis+jalapa","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Prefers a fertile well-drained soil in full sun or part day shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds, Four O'Clock Seeds, Mirabilis jalapa","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/four-o-clock.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun to part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Floral Encounters, Four oclock seeds (Mirabilis jalapa)","url":"https://www.floralencounters.com/Seeds/seed_detail.jsp?grow=Four+o+clock&productid=1044","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They prefer full sun to look their best but can tolerate some shade.","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"four-oclock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","strengths":["strong"],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Mirabilis jalapa","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282898","country":null,"form":null,"value":"features fragrant, funnel-shaped, tubular flowers","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Mirabilis jalapa","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mirabilis-jalapa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant's fragrant flowers open in the afternoon or early evening and are pollinated by hummingbirds and moths, making it a perfect addition to a nighttime or pollinator garden.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture: Four O'Clocks, Mirabilis jalapa","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/four-oclocks-mirabilis-jalapa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"may have a strong, sweet-smelling fragrance when open (but sometimes lack a noticeable scent).","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension Bulletin B954, Flowering Annuals for Georgia Gardens","url":"https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=B954","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers, which open in late afternoon, are fragrant and white, red, yellow, pink, or striped.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions: Four O'Clocks","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/four-oclocks/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Native to Peru and cultivated for hundreds of years, this drought-tolerant plant has fragrant and colorful blooms.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Plants For A Future database, Mirabilis jalapa","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Mirabilis+jalapa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are sweetly scented and do not open until the afternoon","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds, Four O'Clock Seeds, Mirabilis jalapa","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/four-o-clock.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are fragrant, open in response to temperature.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Floral Encounters, Four oclock seeds (Mirabilis jalapa)","url":"https://www.floralencounters.com/Seeds/seed_detail.jsp?grow=Four+o+clock&productid=1044","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are very fragrant and attract humming birds, moths and other nocturnal pollinators with long tongues.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"four-oclock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"four-oclock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Mirabilis jalapa","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mirabilis-jalapa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Moderate drought tolerance.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension Bulletin B954, Flowering Annuals for Georgia Gardens","url":"https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=B954","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Annuals for Hot, Dry Locations cosmos creeping zinnia four-o'clock portulaca","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions: Four O'Clocks","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/four-oclocks/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Native to Peru and cultivated for hundreds of years, this drought-tolerant plant has fragrant and colorful blooms.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds, Four O'Clock Seeds, Mirabilis jalapa","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/four-o-clock.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants resist drought, rabbits and deer.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Floral Encounters, Four oclock seeds (Mirabilis jalapa)","url":"https://www.floralencounters.com/Seeds/seed_detail.jsp?grow=Four+o+clock&productid=1044","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are fairly drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"four-oclock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Mirabilis jalapa","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282898","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Mirabilis jalapa","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mirabilis-jalapa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are visited by hummingbirds and moths","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture: Four O'Clocks, Mirabilis jalapa","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/four-oclocks-mirabilis-jalapa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds and butterflies are also attracted to the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions: Four O'Clocks","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/four-oclocks/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The trumpet-shaped flowers open in the evening and wilt the next morning, and attract hummingbirds and moths.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds, Four O'Clock Seeds, Mirabilis jalapa","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/four-o-clock.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract butterflies, spectacular moths, and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Floral Encounters, Four oclock seeds (Mirabilis jalapa)","url":"https://www.floralencounters.com/Seeds/seed_detail.jsp?grow=Four+o+clock&productid=1044","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds love the flowers as do sphinx moths and other long tongued pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"foxglove","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.22,1.83],"union":[0.3,2],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Foxglove, Digitalis species)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/foxglove/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Cultivars of foxglove can range from 2 to 3 feet to 5 to 6 feet tall.","metres":[0.61,1.83],"band":[0.61,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"RHS Growing Guide (How to grow foxgloves, genus Digitalis)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/foxglove/growing-guide","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"The flower spikes come in all sizes, from a mere 30cm (1ft) up to 2m (8ft) or more.","metres":[0.3,2],"band":[0.3,2],"role":"scored","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension Bulletin 944, Flowering Perennials for Georgia Gardens (Foxglove)","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/B944/flowering-perennials-for-georgia-gardens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"foxgloves may grow 4 to 6 feet tall","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":7,"genus":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":7,"genus":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Foxglove, Digitalis species)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/foxglove/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Foxgloves are hardy in USDA planting zones 4 to 9.","zones":[4,9],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":7,"genus":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Digitalis purpurea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/digitalis-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Digitalis purpurea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c530","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Digitalis grandiflora)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287003","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade","level":"species","taxon":"digitalis grandiflora"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (common foxglove, Digitalis purpurea)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/common-foxglove-digitalis-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow common foxglove in full sun to light shade.","level":"species","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension Bulletin 944, Flowering Perennials for Georgia Gardens (Foxglove)","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/B944/flowering-perennials-for-georgia-gardens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They grow best in full sun but will tolerate light shade.","level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service, Plant of the Week (Foxglove)","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/foxglove.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows in full sun or medium shade","level":"species","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Digitalis ferruginea, rusty foxglove)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/digitalis-ferruginea-rusty-foxglove","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"digitalis ferruginea"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (Foxglove, Digitalis)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/foxglove.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part shade to light shade, rich, moist soil.","level":"genus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Foxglove, Digitalis species)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/foxglove/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flower spikes to use in bouquets.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (Foxglove, Digitalis)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/foxglove.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tubular flowers attract bees and hummingbirds, are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["digitalis purpurea"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (digitalis purpurea), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (digitalis purpurea) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"foxglove","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Digitalis purpurea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/digitalis-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It prefers moist, well-drained soil high in organic matter that should not be allowed to dry out, as periods of drought stress will limit flower production.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Digitalis purpurea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c530","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soil must not be allowed to dry out.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Digitalis grandiflora)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287003","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Prefers organically rich soils with consistent and regular moisture.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"digitalis grandiflora"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (common foxglove, Digitalis purpurea)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/common-foxglove-digitalis-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Although it prefers light, moist soils high in organic matter, it will grow in almost any type of soil that is not too dry or too wet.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"}],"note":"4 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Foxglove, Digitalis species)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/foxglove/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds and other pollinators often visit the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"RHS Growing Guide (How to grow foxgloves, genus Digitalis)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/foxglove/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nectar-rich flowers attract bees","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (Foxglove, Digitalis)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/foxglove.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tubular flowers attract bees and hummingbirds, are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["digitalis purpurea"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (digitalis purpurea), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (digitalis purpurea) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"foxglove-camelot-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.39,1.5],"split":[{"range":[0.39,0.47],"sources":["Penn State Flower Trials, Southeast Agricultural Research and Extension Center (2022)"]},{"range":[0.91,1.5],"sources":["Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","Spring Hill Nurseries","Pleasant Run Nursery","Royal Horticultural Society","Ball Horticultural Company (Ball Seed plant information, breeder side)","Dallas Arboretum Trial Gardens","Oakland Nursery (NetPS Plant Finder database)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Penn State Flower Trials, Southeast Agricultural Research and Extension Center (2022)","url":"https://agsci.psu.edu/flower-trials/trial-year/2022/plant-name/digitalis-camelot-rose-seed","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 17 inches","metres":0.43,"band":[0.39,0.47],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ball Horticultural Company (Ball Seed plant information, breeder side)","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=023104183004669","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 42 - 48\" (107 - 122cm)","metres":[1.07,1.22],"band":[1.07,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DIGCR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.0-4.0 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/216400/digitalis-purpurea-camelot-rose-camelot-series/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Dallas Arboretum Trial Gardens","url":"https://www.dallasplanttrials.org/index.cfm/fuseaction/articles.detail/articleID/102/index.htm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"come spring you have 4 ft. tall spikes of flowers to wow your neighbors","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Digitalis-purpurea-Camelot-Rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 40 Inches","metres":1.02,"band":[0.92,1.12],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nurseries","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/camelot-rose-foxglove","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 36 - 48 inches","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Oakland Nursery (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/3251/Camelot_Rose_Foxglove/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Flower Height: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-camelot-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.45],"union":[0.1,0.76],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Penn State Flower Trials, Southeast Agricultural Research and Extension Center (2022)","url":"https://agsci.psu.edu/flower-trials/trial-year/2022/plant-name/digitalis-camelot-rose-seed","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 7 inches","metres":0.18,"band":[0.16,0.2],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ball Horticultural Company (Ball Seed plant information, breeder side)","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=023104183004669","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 15 - 24\" (38 - 61cm)","metres":[0.38,0.61],"band":[0.38,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DIGCR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24.0-30.0 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/216400/digitalis-purpurea-camelot-rose-camelot-series/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Digitalis-purpurea-Camelot-Rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 16 Inches","metres":0.41,"band":[0.37,0.45],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nurseries","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/camelot-rose-foxglove","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24 - 30 inches","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Oakland Nursery (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/3251/Camelot_Rose_Foxglove/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"with a spread of 18 inches","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-camelot-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[4,9],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Digitalis purpurea, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/digitalis-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Ball Horticultural Company (Ball Seed plant information, breeder side)","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=023104183004669","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4a - 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DIGCR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Spring Hill Nurseries","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/camelot-rose-foxglove","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 4-9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"every source states 4-9; catalog states 4-8","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-camelot-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Digitalis purpurea, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/digitalis-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Ball Horticultural Company (Ball Seed plant information, breeder side)","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=023104183004669","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Partial Sun, Sun"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DIGCR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/216400/digitalis-purpurea-camelot-rose-camelot-series/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Partial shade"},{"name":"Denver Botanic Gardens, Gardens Navigator","url":"http://navigate.botanicgardens.org/weboi/oecgi2.exe/INET_ECM_DispPl?NAMENUM=49447","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial sun | Partial shade"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Digitalis-purpurea-Camelot-Rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade/Shade Tolerant"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nurseries","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/camelot-rose-foxglove","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun, Partial Shade"},{"name":"Oakland Nursery (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/3251/Camelot_Rose_Foxglove/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in full sun to partial shade."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-camelot-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Ball Horticultural Company (Ball Seed plant information, breeder side)","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=023104183004669","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Very large flower spikes hold bell-shaped, scented blooms.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-camelot-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=023104183004669","http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DIGCR"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=023104183004669","https://www.dallasplanttrials.org/index.cfm/fuseaction/articles.detail/articleID/102/index.htm"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=023104183004669","https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Digitalis-purpurea-Camelot-Rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=023104183004669","https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/3251/Camelot_Rose_Foxglove/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Ball Horticultural Company (Ball Seed plant information, breeder side)","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=023104183004669","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good cut flower.","claim":true},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DIGCR","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Border Plant Container Cut Flower Mass Planting Specimen Focal Point","claim":true},{"name":"Dallas Arboretum Trial Gardens","url":"https://www.dallasplanttrials.org/index.cfm/fuseaction/articles.detail/articleID/102/index.htm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The sturdy stems also make excellent cut flowers.","claim":true},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Digitalis-purpurea-Camelot-Rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true},{"name":"Oakland Nursery (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/3251/Camelot_Rose_Foxglove/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-camelot-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-camelot-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Digitalis purpurea, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/digitalis-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nectar attracts bumblebees and hummingbirds.","claim":true},{"name":"Ball Horticultural Company (Ball Seed plant information, breeder side)","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=023104183004669","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dramatic flowers attract hummingbirds to the garden.","claim":true},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=DIGCR","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Digitalis-purpurea-Camelot-Rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true},{"name":"Spring Hill Nurseries","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/camelot-rose-foxglove","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Foxglove attracts hummingbirds and butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Oakland Nursery (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/3251/Camelot_Rose_Foxglove/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting hummingbirds to your yard","claim":true}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-camelot-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.07,1.22],"union":[0.61,1.22],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/digitalis-foxglove/camelot-white-pelleted-f1-digitalis-seed-4240P.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: 28-40\"","metres":[0.71,1.02],"band":[0.71,1.02],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/foxglove/camelot-white-foxglove-seeds.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants are vigorous growers, up to 42-48 in. tall.","metres":[1.07,1.22],"band":[1.07,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder (Mischler's Florist)","url":"https://plants.mischlersflorist.com/12130038/Plant/3252/Camelot_White_Foxglove","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Camelot White Foxglove will grow to be about 24 inches tall at maturity extending to 4 feet tall with the flowers, with a spread of 18 inches.","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Digitalis-Purpurea-Camelot-White","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3-4 ft","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Premier Growers, Inc.","url":"https://premiergrowersinc.com/product/foxglove-camelot-white/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 42-48″","metres":[1.07,1.22],"band":[1.07,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":2,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"foxglove-camelot-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.51],"union":[0.3,0.76],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder (Mischler's Florist)","url":"https://plants.mischlersflorist.com/12130038/Plant/3252/Camelot_White_Foxglove","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Camelot White Foxglove will grow to be about 24 inches tall at maturity extending to 4 feet tall with the flowers, with a spread of 18 inches.","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Digitalis-Purpurea-Camelot-White","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1-2 ft","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Premier Growers, Inc.","url":"https://premiergrowersinc.com/product/foxglove-camelot-white/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 24-30″","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":2,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"foxglove-camelot-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/digitalis-foxglove/camelot-white-pelleted-f1-digitalis-seed-4240P.html","https://www.hickoryhollownursery.com/catalog/digitalis-purpurea-camelot-white/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/digitalis-foxglove/camelot-white-pelleted-f1-digitalis-seed-4240P.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 4-8.","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Hickory Hollow Nursery and Garden Center","url":"https://www.hickoryhollownursery.com/catalog/digitalis-purpurea-camelot-white/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4-8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":2,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"foxglove-camelot-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/digitalis-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286969","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/digitalis-foxglove/camelot-white-pelleted-f1-digitalis-seed-4240P.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun/Part Shade.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/foxglove/camelot-white-foxglove-seeds.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part shade to light shade, rich, moist soil.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder (Mischler's Florist)","url":"https://plants.mischlersflorist.com/12130038/Plant/3252/Camelot_White_Foxglove","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in full sun to partial shade.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Digitalis-Purpurea-Camelot-White","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Premier Growers, Inc.","url":"https://premiergrowersinc.com/product/foxglove-camelot-white/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun, Partial Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Hickory Hollow Nursery and Garden Center","url":"https://www.hickoryhollownursery.com/catalog/digitalis-purpurea-camelot-white/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs: Full Sun to Part Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"foxglove-camelot-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/digitalis-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"foxglove-camelot-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/digitalis-foxglove/camelot-white-pelleted-f1-digitalis-seed-4240P.html","https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/foxglove/camelot-white-foxglove-seeds.html"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/digitalis-foxglove/camelot-white-pelleted-f1-digitalis-seed-4240P.html","https://plants.mischlersflorist.com/12130038/Plant/3252/Camelot_White_Foxglove"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/digitalis-foxglove/camelot-white-pelleted-f1-digitalis-seed-4240P.html","https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Digitalis-Purpurea-Camelot-White"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/digitalis-foxglove/camelot-white-pelleted-f1-digitalis-seed-4240P.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"High-quality side shoots make abundant cut flowers and fill out the plants in garden beds.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/foxglove/camelot-white-foxglove-seeds.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tubular flowers attract bees and hummingbirds, are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder (Mischler's Florist)","url":"https://plants.mischlersflorist.com/12130038/Plant/3252/Camelot_White_Foxglove","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Digitalis-Purpurea-Camelot-White","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"foxglove-camelot-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/digitalis-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It prefers moist, well-drained soil high in organic matter that should not be allowed to dry out, as periods of drought stress will limit flower production.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286969","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soil must not be allowed to dry out.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"foxglove-camelot-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/digitalis-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nectar attracts bumblebees and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286969","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/foxglove/camelot-white-foxglove-seeds.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tubular flowers attract bees and hummingbirds, are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder (Mischler's Florist)","url":"https://plants.mischlersflorist.com/12130038/Plant/3252/Camelot_White_Foxglove","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies and hummingbirds to your yard, but is not particularly attractive to deer who tend to leave it alone in favor of tastier treats.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Digitalis-Purpurea-Camelot-White","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"},{"name":"Hickory Hollow Nursery and Garden Center","url":"https://www.hickoryhollownursery.com/catalog/digitalis-purpurea-camelot-white/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies and Hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"digitalis purpurea"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"foxglove-dalmatian-peach","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.41,1],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/324556/digitalis-purpurea-dalmatian-peach-dalmatian-series/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"PanAmerican Seed (breeder of the Dalmatian F1 series)","url":"https://www.panamseed.com/Products/023105668003951/digitalis-dalmatian-peach/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height : 16 - 20\" (41 - 51cm)","metres":[0.41,0.51],"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DIGPE","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.0-3.0 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/digitalis/dalmatian-peach-foxglove-digitalis-hybrida","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Garden Height: 24 - 36 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/digitalis-foxglove/dalmatian-peach-pelleted-f1-digitalis-seed-4711P.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: 24-36\"","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-foxglove-dalmatian-peach","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 24-36\" tall","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Hortech","url":"https://hortech.com/plant/digitalis-purpurea-dalmatian-peach/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Max Height: 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Digitalis-purpurea-Dalmatian-Peach-Foxglove","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2-3 ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-dalmatian-peach","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.33],"union":[0.1,0.61],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/324556/digitalis-purpurea-dalmatian-peach-dalmatian-series/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"PanAmerican Seed (breeder of the Dalmatian F1 series)","url":"https://www.panamseed.com/Products/023105668003951/digitalis-dalmatian-peach/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width : 12 - 14\" (30 - 36cm)","metres":[0.3,0.36],"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DIGPE","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.0 Feet","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/digitalis/dalmatian-peach-foxglove-digitalis-hybrida","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12 Inches","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-foxglove-dalmatian-peach","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 10-12\" wide","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Digitalis-purpurea-Dalmatian-Peach-Foxglove","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1-2 ft","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-dalmatian-peach","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-9","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c530","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/digitalis-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"PanAmerican Seed (breeder of the Dalmatian F1 series)","url":"https://www.panamseed.com/Products/023105668003951/digitalis-dalmatian-peach/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone : 5a - 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DIGPE","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/digitalis/dalmatian-peach-foxglove-digitalis-hybrida","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b , 9a , 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/digitalis-foxglove/dalmatian-peach-pelleted-f1-digitalis-seed-4711P.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HARDINESS ZONES: Zones 4-8.","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-foxglove-dalmatian-peach","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ZONES 4-9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Digitalis-purpurea-Dalmatian-Peach-Foxglove","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-dalmatian-peach","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c530","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/digitalis-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/324556/digitalis-purpurea-dalmatian-peach-dalmatian-series/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DIGPE","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)"},{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/digitalis-foxglove/dalmatian-peach-pelleted-f1-digitalis-seed-4711P.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"LIGHT PREFERENCE: Sun/Part Shade."},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-foxglove-dalmatian-peach","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun Half Sun / Half Shade"},{"name":"Hortech","url":"https://hortech.com/plant/digitalis-purpurea-dalmatian-peach/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun Light Shade"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Digitalis-purpurea-Dalmatian-Peach-Foxglove","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Thrives in sun or part shade."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-dalmatian-peach","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-dalmatian-peach","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DIGPE","https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/digitalis/dalmatian-peach-foxglove-digitalis-hybrida"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DIGPE","https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/digitalis-foxglove/dalmatian-peach-pelleted-f1-digitalis-seed-4711P.html"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DIGPE","https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-foxglove-dalmatian-peach"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DIGPE","https://hortech.com/plant/digitalis-purpurea-dalmatian-peach/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DIGPE","https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Digitalis-purpurea-Dalmatian-Peach-Foxglove"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DIGPE","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Mass Planting","claim":true},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/digitalis/dalmatian-peach-foxglove-digitalis-hybrida","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: Cut Flower","claim":true},{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/digitalis-foxglove/dalmatian-peach-pelleted-f1-digitalis-seed-4711P.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"USES: Excellent cut flower.","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-foxglove-dalmatian-peach","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A graceful cut flower, harvest stems when just the lowest blooms are open.","claim":true},{"name":"Hortech","url":"https://hortech.com/plant/digitalis-purpurea-dalmatian-peach/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great for cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Digitalis-purpurea-Dalmatian-Peach-Foxglove","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great cut flowers","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 6 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 6","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-dalmatian-peach","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-dalmatian-peach","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c530","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/digitalis-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nectar attracts bumblebees and hummingbirds.","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=DIGPE","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Hummingbirds Bee Friendly","claim":true},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/digitalis/dalmatian-peach-foxglove-digitalis-hybrida","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees, Hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-foxglove-dalmatian-peach","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds and bees adore these early season blooms.","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-grandiflora-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.68,0.76],"union":[0.46,1.1],"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287003&isprofile=0&basic=Digitalis%20grandiflora","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/yellow-foxglove-digitalis-grandiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"the flower spikes will reach 2-3 feet tall","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening, Flower Growing Guides","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene0430.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.5 to 3 feet","metres":[0.46,0.91],"band":[0.46,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/digitalis-grandiflora.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Height 60-90 cm 23-35 inches","metres":[0.6,0.9],"band":[0.6,0.9],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, plant page","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/5856/digitalis-grandiflora/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Beth Chatto's Plants & Gardens","url":"https://www.bethchatto.co.uk/a-z-plants/digitalis-grandiflora.htm","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height 1m","metres":1,"band":[0.9,1.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Van Berkum Nursery","url":"https://www.vanberkumnursery.com/plants/digitalis-grandiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18-30\"","metres":[0.46,0.76],"band":[0.46,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Claire Austin Hardy Plants","url":"https://www.claireaustin-hardyplants.co.uk/products/digitalis-grandiflora","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height x Spread: 75cm x 45cm","metres":0.75,"band":[0.68,0.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-grandiflora-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.44],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287003&isprofile=0&basic=Digitalis%20grandiflora","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening, Flower Growing Guides","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene0430.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1 to 1.5 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/digitalis-grandiflora.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Spread 30-45 cm 12-18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.45],"band":[0.3,0.45],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, plant page","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/5856/digitalis-grandiflora/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Beth Chatto's Plants & Gardens","url":"https://www.bethchatto.co.uk/a-z-plants/digitalis-grandiflora.htm","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Spread 40cm","metres":0.4,"band":[0.36,0.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Claire Austin Hardy Plants","url":"https://www.claireaustin-hardyplants.co.uk/products/digitalis-grandiflora","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height x Spread: 75cm x 45cm","metres":0.45,"band":[0.41,0.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-grandiflora-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","2-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287003&isprofile=0&basic=Digitalis%20grandiflora","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/yellow-foxglove-digitalis-grandiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"hardy in zones 3a-8b","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening, Flower Growing Guides","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene0430.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/digitalis-grandiflora.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 2-9","zones":[2,9]},{"name":"Van Berkum Nursery","url":"https://www.vanberkumnursery.com/plants/digitalis-grandiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 3-8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-grandiflora-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287003&isprofile=0&basic=Digitalis%20grandiflora","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/yellow-foxglove-digitalis-grandiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant it in full sun or partial shade"},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening, Flower Growing Guides","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene0430.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: part shade"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/digitalis-grandiflora.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun or Partial Shade"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, plant page","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/5856/digitalis-grandiflora/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full shade, Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"Van Berkum Nursery","url":"https://www.vanberkumnursery.com/plants/digitalis-grandiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Shade / Part Sun"},{"name":"Claire Austin Hardy Plants","url":"https://www.claireaustin-hardyplants.co.uk/products/digitalis-grandiflora","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"How Much Sun: Sun/Partial Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-grandiflora-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-grandiflora-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/yellow-foxglove-digitalis-grandiflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It makes a good cut flower if picked when the blooms are half open.","claim":true},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening, Flower Growing Guides","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene0430.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special uses: cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/digitalis-grandiflora.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-grandiflora-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/yellow-foxglove-digitalis-grandiflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established it is relatively drought tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-grandiflora-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/digitalis-grandiflora.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-suttons-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.82,1.98],"split":[{"range":[0.82,1.34],"sources":["SiteOne Landscape Supply","Select Seeds","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Diane's Flower Seeds","Sarah Raven","Digging Dog Nursery"]},{"range":[1.62,1.98],"sources":["Mr Fothergill's Seeds"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263646","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/foxglove-suttons-apricot-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Size 3-3.5' h x 1-1.5' w","metres":[0.91,1.07],"band":[0.91,1.07],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/plant/P-0196","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 4' 0\" high x 2' 0\" wide.","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/74662b-digitalis-purpurea-suttons-apricot-foxglove/p/998063","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growth Height Max 36 in.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Diane's Flower Seeds","url":"https://www.dianeseeds.com/digitalis-purpurea-suttons-apricot.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"height 3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sarah Raven","url":"https://www.sarahraven.com/products/digitalis-purpurea-suttons-apricot","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height 1.2m (4ft)","metres":1.2,"band":[1.08,1.32],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Mr Fothergill's Seeds","url":"https://mr-fothergills.co.uk/products/rhs-foxglove-sutton-s-apricot","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: 180cm","metres":1.8,"band":[1.62,1.98],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-suttons-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.3,0.67],"split":[{"range":[0.3,0.51],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Select Seeds","Sarah Raven","SiteOne Landscape Supply"]},{"range":[0.55,0.67],"sources":["Digging Dog Nursery"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263646","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/foxglove-suttons-apricot-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Size 3-3.5' h x 1-1.5' w","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/plant/P-0196","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 4' 0\" high x 2' 0\" wide.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/74662b-digitalis-purpurea-suttons-apricot-foxglove/p/998063","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growth Width Max 18 in.","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sarah Raven","url":"https://www.sarahraven.com/products/digitalis-purpurea-suttons-apricot","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Spread 45cm (18in)","metres":0.45,"band":[0.41,0.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-suttons-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263646","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/digitalis-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/foxglove/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Foxgloves are hardy in USDA planting zones 4 to 9.","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/foxglove-suttons-apricot-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Perennial Hardiness Zone 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/74662b-digitalis-purpurea-suttons-apricot-foxglove/p/998063","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone Maximum Zone 9 Hardiness Zone Minimum Zone 4","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Diane's Flower Seeds","url":"https://www.dianeseeds.com/digitalis-purpurea-suttons-apricot.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy in zones 4-9.","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-suttons-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263646","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/digitalis-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/foxglove-suttons-apricot-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to partial shade"},{"name":"Diane's Flower Seeds","url":"https://www.dianeseeds.com/digitalis-purpurea-suttons-apricot.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade."},{"name":"Sarah Raven","url":"https://www.sarahraven.com/products/digitalis-purpurea-suttons-apricot","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Aspect Part Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-suttons-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-suttons-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/foxglove/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flower spikes to use in bouquets.","claim":true},{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/foxglove-suttons-apricot-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great Cut Flower","claim":true},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/74662b-digitalis-purpurea-suttons-apricot-foxglove/p/998063","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Landscape use: Accent, Border, Cut Flower and Foliage, Mass Planting","claim":true},{"name":"Diane's Flower Seeds","url":"https://www.dianeseeds.com/digitalis-purpurea-suttons-apricot.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It makes a wonderful cut flower","claim":true},{"name":"Sarah Raven","url":"https://www.sarahraven.com/products/digitalis-purpurea-suttons-apricot","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Foxgloves make some of the very best cottage garden early summer garden plants and cut flowers.","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-suttons-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"foxglove-suttons-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263646","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/digitalis-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nectar attracts bumblebees and hummingbirds.","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/foxglove/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds and other pollinators often visit the flowers.","claim":true},{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/foxglove-suttons-apricot-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees","claim":true},{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/plant/P-0196","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Coveted by bumblebees, hummingbirds and gardeners alike","claim":true},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/74662b-digitalis-purpurea-suttons-apricot-foxglove/p/998063","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts hummingbirds and bees to the garden","claim":true},{"name":"Sarah Raven","url":"https://www.sarahraven.com/products/digitalis-purpurea-suttons-apricot","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees and butterflies love them too.","claim":true},{"name":"Mr Fothergill's Seeds","url":"https://mr-fothergills.co.uk/products/rhs-foxglove-sutton-s-apricot","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive To Pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"freesia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"freesia bulbs grow one to two feet tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"freesia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":5},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.50 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"freesia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,10],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Freesia (genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/freesia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They also prefer mild, frost-free climates and are hardy in zones 9 to 10.","zones":[9,10],"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Freesia (group)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264594","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 9 to 10","zones":[9,10],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"freesia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Freesia (genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/freesia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Freesias prefer full sun to partial shade","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Freesia (group)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264594","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"genus"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension, Freesia (Freesia x hybrida) for the Farmer Florist","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/publications/freesia-freesia-hybrida-for-the-farmer-florist","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant corms in areas that receive full sun, but this plant can tolerate some morning shade in areas at the warmer end of the hardiness range.","level":"species","taxon":"freesia hybrida"},{"name":"UC Statewide IPM Program (UC ANR), Freesia","url":"https://ipm.ucanr.edu/home-and-landscape/freesia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Freesias will do well in full sun, but will also tolerate areas with partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"freesia hybrida"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica, Freesia refracta","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/freesia-refracta","country":"ZA","form":null,"value":"Freesia refracta is best in a winter-rainfall or Mediterranean-type climate with full sun to very light semi-shade and well-drained soil.","level":"species","taxon":"freesia refracta"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica, Freesia grandiflora","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/freesia-grandiflora","country":"ZA","form":null,"value":"performs well in full sun or partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"freesia grandiflora"},{"name":"Eden Brothers, Freesia Bulbs collection","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/collections/freesia-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"While the majority of flowering plants need full sun to bloom, freesia bulbs can tolerate partial shade and still put on a powerful display.","level":"genus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"freesia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Freesia (genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/freesia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Freesia is a genus of fragrant, herbaceous perennials that are grown from conical-shaped corms.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Freesia (group)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264594","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Freesias are noted for their fragrance and bright flower colors.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension, Freesia (Freesia x hybrida) for the Farmer Florist","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/publications/freesia-freesia-hybrida-for-the-farmer-florist","country":null,"form":null,"value":"a bouquet of freesias will fill any room with their sweet, baby powder fragrance","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"freesia hybrida"},{"name":"UC Statewide IPM Program (UC ANR), Freesia","url":"https://ipm.ucanr.edu/home-and-landscape/freesia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Freesias are fragrant perennial plants, grown from corms.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"freesia hybrida"},{"name":"RHS growing guide: How to grow freesias","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/freesia/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Popular cut flower with captivating scent","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica, Freesia leichtlinii subsp. alba","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/freesia-leichtlinii-subsp-alba","country":null,"form":null,"value":"have the strongest and sweetest fragrance of all the freesias, that includes the wild species and the hybrids","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"freesia leichtlinii"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica, Freesia refracta","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/freesia-refracta","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It adds beautiful colour and a strong rose or violet scent indoors as a pot plant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"freesia refracta"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica, Freesia grandiflora","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/freesia-grandiflora","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Freesias are most well known as plants cultivated for their flowers, which are usually fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"freesia grandiflora"},{"name":"Eden Brothers, Freesia Bulbs collection","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/collections/freesia-bulbs","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There’s hardly a flower more colorful or fragrant than freesia","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"freesia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Freesia (genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/freesia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Freesia blooms make a good cut flower and are a favorite of florists","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Freesia (group)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264594","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Winter flowering house plant or greenhouse plant that makes a good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension, Freesia (Freesia x hybrida) for the Farmer Florist","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/publications/freesia-freesia-hybrida-for-the-farmer-florist","country":null,"form":null,"value":"For an ample supply of cut flowers all season long, plant corms in succession, with 7 to 14 days between plantings.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"freesia hybrida"},{"name":"RHS growing guide: How to grow freesias","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/freesia/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"they are great for long-lasting cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica, Freesia leichtlinii subsp. alba","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/freesia-leichtlinii-subsp-alba","country":null,"form":null,"value":"over 110 million stems are sold as cutflowers in the United Kingdom every year","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"freesia leichtlinii"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica, Freesia refracta","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/freesia-refracta","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the many hybrids and cultivars produced are commonly used as decorative plants and cut flowers worldwide","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"freesia refracta"},{"name":"Eden Brothers, Freesia Bulbs collection","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/collections/freesia-bulbs","country":null,"form":null,"value":"freesia flowers create a gorgeous cut flower arrangement","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"freesia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["freesia hybrida"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (freesia hybrida), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (freesia hybrida) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"freesia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Freesia (genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/freesia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica, Freesia leichtlinii subsp. alba","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/freesia-leichtlinii-subsp-alba","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Freesia leichtlinii subsp. alba is mostly pollinated by solitary bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"freesia leichtlinii"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica, Freesia grandiflora","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/freesia-grandiflora","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"freesia grandiflora"},{"name":"Eden Brothers, Freesia Bulbs collection","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/collections/freesia-bulbs","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant flowers attract pollinators","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"freesia-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 35 cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Grows to 40cm high\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Grows 12-24\" tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"freesia-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 15 cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant Type: Bulb Size: 25-40cm H x 7-10cm W\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"freesia-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,10],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264594&isprofile=0&basic=Freesia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 9 to 10","zones":[9,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/freesia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[9,10]},{"name":"Easy To Grow Bulbs (Freesia planting guide)","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/pages/freesia-planting-guide","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy in zones 9 and 10, Freesia should be planted in the fall for warmer climates to give their roots time to get established.","zones":[9,10]},{"name":"Van Zyverden brand listing (Walmart.com)","url":"https://www.walmart.com/ip/Van-Zyverden-Freesias-Purple-Rain-Set-of-25-Bulbs-Purple-Partial-Sun-Easy-to-Grow-1-lb/593974131","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA hardiness zones 9-10","zones":[9,10]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"freesia-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264594&isprofile=0&basic=Freesia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/freesia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Easy To Grow Bulbs (Freesia planting guide)","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/pages/freesia-planting-guide","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Give your Freesia a spot where it will receive full sun for at least eight hours every day."},{"name":"The Plant Company (NZ)","url":"https://www.theplantcompany.co.nz/shop/product/bulbs/freesia-purple-rain","country":"NZ","form":null,"value":"This perennial typically grows to 35 cm tall and 15 cm wide, performing best when positioned in full sun on a well-drained site."},{"name":"Garden Express (AU)","url":"https://www.gardenexpress.com.au/product/freesia-purple-rain/","country":"AU","form":null,"value":"Positioning: Prefers full sun but tolerates very light shade for part of the day"},{"name":"Mr Fothergill's Australia","url":"https://www.mrfothergills.com.au/products/freesia-double-purple-rain","country":"AU","form":null,"value":"Plant: 3-5cm deep 5-8cm apart in full sun or part shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"freesia-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264594&isprofile=0&basic=Freesia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/freesia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true},{"name":"The Plant Company (NZ)","url":"https://www.theplantcompany.co.nz/shop/product/bulbs/freesia-purple-rain","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fragrant and showy blooms are borne on slender stems from spring above the lush, dark green foliage.","claim":true},{"name":"Garden Express (AU)","url":"https://www.gardenexpress.com.au/product/freesia-purple-rain/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Double Freesias make beautifully scented cut flowers and are perfect for pots and containers.","claim":true},{"name":"Mr Fothergill's Australia","url":"https://www.mrfothergills.com.au/products/freesia-double-purple-rain","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Purple rain has perfect form, with large flower heads that are highly perfumed. Ideal for cut flowers.","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"freesia-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/freesia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Freesia blooms make a good cut flower and are a favorite of florists, often used in wedding bouquets.","claim":true},{"name":"Garden Express (AU)","url":"https://www.gardenexpress.com.au/product/freesia-purple-rain/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Double Freesias make beautifully scented cut flowers and are perfect for pots and containers.","claim":true},{"name":"Van Zyverden brand listing (Walmart.com)","url":"https://www.walmart.com/ip/Van-Zyverden-Freesias-Purple-Rain-Set-of-25-Bulbs-Purple-Partial-Sun-Easy-to-Grow-1-lb/593974131","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Delightful cut flower","claim":true},{"name":"Mr Fothergill's Australia","url":"https://www.mrfothergills.com.au/products/freesia-double-purple-rain","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Purple rain has perfect form, with large flower heads that are highly perfumed. Ideal for cut flowers.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"freesia-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"freesia-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/freesia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees and butterflies.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.91,1],"union":[0.3,1.5],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/fritillaria-imperialis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263696&isprofile=0&basic=Fritillaria+imperialis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension, B918 Flowering Bulbs for Georgia Gardens","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/B918/flowering-bulbs-for-georgia-gardens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Fritillaria imperialis Crown Imperial H F 6″ 10″ mid 3′","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant guide (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/crown-imperial-fritillaria-imperialis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height : 1 to 3 feet","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Plants For A Future (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Fritillaria+imperialis","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Fritillaria imperialis is a BULB growing to 1 m (3ft 3in) by 0.3 m (1ft) at a slow rate.","metres":1,"band":[0.9,1.1],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"RHS Plant Profile (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/7383/fritillaria-imperialis/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden, Smart Gardener: Fritillaria","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plantinfo/smartgardener/fritillaria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"On a stalk up to 3 feet tall, a flashy cluster of orange bells is surmounted by an odd-looking topknot of green leaves.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/fritillaria-imperialis-2/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height: 1m Spread: 30cm","metres":1,"band":[0.9,1.1],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":8,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.33],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/fritillaria-imperialis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263696&isprofile=0&basic=Fritillaria+imperialis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant guide (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/crown-imperial-fritillaria-imperialis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Width : 6 to 12 inches","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"Plants For A Future (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Fritillaria+imperialis","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Fritillaria imperialis is a BULB growing to 1 m (3ft 3in) by 0.3 m (1ft) at a slow rate.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"RHS Plant Profile (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/7383/fritillaria-imperialis/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/fritillaria-imperialis-2/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height: 1m Spread: 30cm","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8,"cultivar":3},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","5-9","7-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/fritillaria-imperialis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[5,8],"level":"species"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263696&isprofile=0&basic=Fritillaria+imperialis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species"},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant guide (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/crown-imperial-fritillaria-imperialis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones : 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"Plants For A Future (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Fritillaria+imperialis","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"USDA hardiness 7-9","zones":[7,9],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":8,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/fritillaria-imperialis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263696&isprofile=0&basic=Fritillaria+imperialis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant guide (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/crown-imperial-fritillaria-imperialis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full Sun","level":"species"},{"name":"RHS Plant Profile (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/7383/fritillaria-imperialis/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden, Smart Gardener: Fritillaria","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plantinfo/smartgardener/fritillaria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It requires full sun and \"impeccable drainage,\" Selinger says, even more than most of our spring bulbs","level":"species"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/fritillaria-imperialis-2/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure: Dappled shade, full sun","level":"species"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs (Fritillaria imperialis 'Red Beauty')","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/fritillaria-imperialis-red-beauty/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"fritillaria imperialis"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms (Rubra Red Fritillaria, cultivar 'Rubra Maxima')","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/fall-planting-bulbs/fritillaria/rubra-red-fritillaria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/fritillaria-imperialis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fragrance is said by some to smell of garlic, others feel it is closer to a fox and the odour is said to repel other wildlife.","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263696&isprofile=0&basic=Fritillaria+imperialis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"All parts of the plant have a skunky odor.","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"Plants For A Future (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Fritillaria+imperialis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers smell of wet fur and garlic[245].","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["fritillaria imperialis"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (fritillaria imperialis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (fritillaria imperialis) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/fritillaria-imperialis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, the plant is drought-tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Plants For A Future (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Fritillaria+imperialis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Succeeds in drier soils and is drought tolerant once established[190].","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Fritillaria+imperialis","https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/fritillaria-imperialis-2/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Plants For A Future (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Fritillaria+imperialis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The species is hermaphrodite (has both male and female organs) and is pollinated by Bees.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine (Fritillaria imperialis)","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/fritillaria-imperialis-2/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fritillaria 'Imperialis' is known for attracting bees. It has nectar/pollen rich flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria-lutea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245805&isprofile=1&basic=Fritillaria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria-lutea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245805&isprofile=1&basic=Fritillaria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria-lutea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245805&isprofile=1&basic=Fritillaria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/fritillaria-imperialis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[5,8]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria-lutea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245805&isprofile=1&basic=Fritillaria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/fritillaria-imperialis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria-lutea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245805&isprofile=1&basic=Fritillaria","country":null,"form":null,"value":"All parts of the plant have a skunky odor.","claim":null,"contradicted":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/fritillaria-imperialis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy, fragrant, blooms appear in mid-spring, April/May, and into June.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 source(s) were filed as stating this trait but their own words contradict it, so they count for neither side","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria-lutea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria-lutea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria-lutea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria-meleagris-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/flower-bulbs-index/fritillaria/fritillaria-meleagris-alba.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8\"","metres":0.2,"band":[0.18,0.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria-meleagris-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.08,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria-meleagris-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/flower-bulbs-index/fritillaria/fritillaria-meleagris-alba.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 3-8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria-meleagris-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/flower-bulbs-index/fritillaria/fritillaria-meleagris-alba.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full to partial sunlight"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria-meleagris-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria-meleagris-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria-meleagris-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fritillaria-meleagris-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fuchsia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height: 18 - 24 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fuchsia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fuchsia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Fuchsia (group)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264595","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"SPLIT"},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fuchsia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Fuchsia (group)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264595","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Fuchsia x hybrida","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/fuchsia-x-hybrida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"fuchsia hybrida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Fuchsia triphylla","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/fuchsia-triphylla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"fuchsia triphylla"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Fuchsia magellanica","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/fuchsia-magellanica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"fuchsia magellanica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Fuchsia 'Gartenmeister'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245823","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers: Fuchsia","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/fuchsia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Shade","level":"genus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center, HGIC 1557 Fuchsia","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/fuchsia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Outdoors, locate the plant on a shaded porch or other site receiving partial shade or protection from the hot afternoon sun as hybrid fuchsias dislike heat and humidity.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants, Fuchsia magellanica","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/fuchsia-magellanica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun part shade.","level":"species","taxon":"fuchsia magellanica"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fuchsia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fuchsia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fuchsia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture Cooperative Extension Service, Plant of the Week: Fuchsia","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/fuchsia.aspx","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They should never be allowed to wilt but should not stand in water either.","claim":false,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["fuchsia hybrida"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (fuchsia hybrida), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (fuchsia hybrida) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"fuchsia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Fuchsia (group)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264595","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds are attracted to the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Fuchsia x hybrida","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/fuchsia-x-hybrida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds are attracted to the nectar in the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"fuchsia hybrida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Fuchsia triphylla","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/fuchsia-triphylla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"fuchsia triphylla"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, Fuchsia magellanica","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/fuchsia-magellanica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds and bees are attracted to the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"fuchsia magellanica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Fuchsia 'Gartenmeister'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=245823","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The blooms are highly attractive to hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"gaillardia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gaillardia, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gaillardia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"gaillardia"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":5,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gaillardia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gaillardia, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gaillardia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"gaillardia"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":5,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gaillardia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gaillardia, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gaillardia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"gaillardia"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":5,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gaillardia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gaillardia, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gaillardia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"gaillardia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gaillardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a579","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"gaillardia grandiflora"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Blanket flower, Gaillardia spp.)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/blanket-flower-gaillardia-spp/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow all types of gaillardias in full sun and well-drained soils","level":"genus","taxon":"gaillardia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers (Blanket Flower, Galardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/blanket-flower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"gaillardia grandiflora"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Blanket Flower, Galardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=724&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"gaillardia grandiflora"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gaillardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gaillardia-x-grandiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"gaillardia grandiflora"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gaillardia aristata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gaillardia-aristata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"gaillardia aristata"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension EDIS FP217 (Gaillardia pulchella 'Red Plume')","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP217","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"gaillardia pulchella"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gaillardia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gaillardia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gaillardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a579","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gaillardia grandiflora"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Blanket flower, Gaillardia spp.)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/blanket-flower-gaillardia-spp/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The taller cultivars make nice cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gaillardia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gaillardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gaillardia-x-grandiflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use in a cottage, cutting, pollinator or drought-tolerant garden.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gaillardia grandiflora"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension EDIS FP217 (Gaillardia pulchella 'Red Plume')","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP217","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: container or above-ground planter; cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gaillardia pulchella"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"gaillardia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gaillardia, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gaillardia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are drought tolerant once established and require very little fertilizer.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gaillardia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gaillardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a579","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gaillardia grandiflora"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Blanket flower, Gaillardia spp.)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/blanket-flower-gaillardia-spp/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, they are drought tolerant and do not require much fertilization.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gaillardia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers (Blanket Flower, Galardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/blanket-flower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought, heat, and salt tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gaillardia grandiflora"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Blanket Flower, Galardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=724&PlantTypeID=2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought, heat and salt tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gaillardia grandiflora"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gaillardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gaillardia-x-grandiflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They can survive some drought once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gaillardia grandiflora"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gaillardia aristata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gaillardia-aristata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#dry soils tolerant #drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gaillardia aristata"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension EDIS FP217 (Gaillardia pulchella 'Red Plume')","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP217","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance: high","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gaillardia pulchella"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gaillardia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gaillardia, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gaillardia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees and butterflies visit the flowers","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gaillardia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gaillardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a579","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gaillardia grandiflora"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Blanket flower, Gaillardia spp.)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/blanket-flower-gaillardia-spp/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"flowers that butterflies and native bees love to visit","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gaillardia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gaillardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gaillardia-x-grandiflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees and butterflies will visit the flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gaillardia grandiflora"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gaillardia aristata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gaillardia-aristata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract pollinators like bees and butterflies, and the seed heads attract birds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gaillardia aristata"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension EDIS FP217 (Gaillardia pulchella 'Red Plume')","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP217","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These showy flowers are attractive to butterflies and command attention in the landscape.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gaillardia pulchella"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"gaillardia-goblin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.27,0.3],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=GAIGO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12.0 Inches","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/82034/gaillardia-goblin/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-gaillardia-goblin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 8-12\" tall","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Colorado Springs Utilities Water Wise Demonstration Garden","url":"https://www.csu.org/water-wise-plants/goblin-blanket-flower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 12 to 18 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Gaillardia-grandiflora-Goblin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 9-12 Inches","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gaillardia-goblin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.34,0.38],"union":[0.1,0.61],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=GAIGO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 15.0 Inches","metres":0.38,"band":[0.34,0.42],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/82034/gaillardia-goblin/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-gaillardia-goblin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 10-12\" wide","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Colorado Springs Utilities Water Wise Demonstration Garden","url":"https://www.csu.org/water-wise-plants/goblin-blanket-flower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 18 to 24 in.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Gaillardia-grandiflora-Goblin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12-15 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.38],"band":[0.3,0.38],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gaillardia-goblin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-10","7-10","3-9","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page, Gaillardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263710","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 10","zones":[3,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Gaillardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gaillardia-x-grandiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=GAIGO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10","zones":[3,10]},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-gaillardia-goblin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones Zone 3 Zone 4 Zone 5 Zone 6 Zone 7 Zone 8 Zone 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Colorado Springs Utilities Water Wise Demonstration Garden","url":"https://www.csu.org/water-wise-plants/goblin-blanket-flower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Cold Hardiness USDA zones 3-9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Gaillardia-grandiflora-Goblin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gaillardia-goblin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page, Gaillardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263710","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Gaillardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gaillardia-x-grandiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=GAIGO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/82034/gaillardia-goblin/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-gaillardia-goblin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Gaillardia-grandiflora-Goblin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers full sun and requires well-drained soil."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gaillardia-goblin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gaillardia-goblin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=GAIGO","https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-gaillardia-goblin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=GAIGO","https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Gaillardia-grandiflora-Goblin"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=GAIGO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Dried Flower Drought Tolerant Easy To Grow Mass Planting Salt Tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-gaillardia-goblin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers Container Planting Deer Resistant","claim":true},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Gaillardia-grandiflora-Goblin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gaillardia-goblin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=GAIGO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Though they will perform best in moist soils, they are highly drought tolerant.","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/82034/gaillardia-goblin/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-gaillardia-goblin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates Dry Sites Salt","claim":true},{"name":"Colorado Springs Utilities Water Wise Demonstration Garden","url":"https://www.csu.org/water-wise-plants/goblin-blanket-flower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought-tolerant and adaptable to many landscape situations in the Pikes Peak area.","claim":true},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Gaillardia-grandiflora-Goblin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought and heat tolerant.","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gaillardia-goblin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=GAIGO","https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-gaillardia-goblin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=GAIGO","https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Gaillardia-grandiflora-Goblin"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=GAIGO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-gaillardia-goblin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bee Friendly Attracts Butterflies Attracts Birds","claim":true},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Gaillardia-grandiflora-Goblin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to butterflies.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gaillardia-oranges-and-lemons","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.27,0.8],"split":[{"range":[0.27,0.61],"sources":["Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database)","Kiefer Landscaping & Nursery","Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","Plant Delights Nursery","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Salt Lake City GardenWise (Salt Lake City Public Utilities plant database)","NVK Nurseries"]},{"range":[0.7,0.8],"sources":["USPTO Plant Patent PP17,092 (breeder's own filing, via Google Patents)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=267904","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"USPTO Plant Patent PP17,092 (breeder's own filing, via Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP17092","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Dimensions of new variety at maturity: Height approximately 700 mm to 800 mm; width (spread) approximately 600 mm.","metres":[0.7,0.8],"band":[0.7,0.8],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/gaillardia-grandiflora-oranges-and-lemons-pp-17092","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18\" tall","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/gaillardia-oranges-and-lemons.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Height 40-45 cm 16-18 inches","metres":[0.4,0.45],"band":[0.4,0.45],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Gaillardia-x-grandiflora-Oranges-and-Lemons","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"HEIGHT: 50-60 cm","metres":[0.5,0.6],"band":[0.5,0.6],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Kiefer Landscaping & Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/gaillardia-oranges-lemons/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 1 to 2 ft.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/3544/Oranges_And_Lemons_Blanket_Flower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: 12 inches","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Salt Lake City GardenWise (Salt Lake City Public Utilities plant database)","url":"https://www.slcgardenwise.com/eplant.php?plantnum=25503&return=c_p702","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows about 18 to 24 inches tall and wide","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gaillardia-oranges-and-lemons","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.55,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.67],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=267904","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"USPTO Plant Patent PP17,092 (breeder's own filing, via Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP17092","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Dimensions of new variety at maturity: Height approximately 700 mm to 800 mm; width (spread) approximately 600 mm.","metres":0.6,"band":[0.54,0.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/gaillardia-grandiflora-oranges-and-lemons-pp-17092","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The 2' wide x 18\" tall clumps","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/gaillardia-oranges-and-lemons.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Spread 30-45 cm 12-18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.45],"band":[0.3,0.45],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Gaillardia-x-grandiflora-Oranges-and-Lemons","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"SPREAD: 40-50 cm","metres":[0.4,0.5],"band":[0.4,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Kiefer Landscaping & Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/gaillardia-oranges-lemons/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 1 to 2 ft.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Salt Lake City GardenWise (Salt Lake City Public Utilities plant database)","url":"https://www.slcgardenwise.com/eplant.php?plantnum=25503&return=c_p702","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows about 18 to 24 inches tall and wide","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gaillardia-oranges-and-lemons","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","7-10","5-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=267904","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (SPECIES page, Gaillardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gaillardia-x-grandiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/gaillardia-grandiflora-oranges-and-lemons-pp-17092","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 5a to 8b","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/gaillardia-oranges-and-lemons.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Kiefer Landscaping & Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/gaillardia-oranges-lemons/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 5a 5b 6a 6b 7a 7b 8a 8b 9a 9b","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gaillardia-oranges-and-lemons","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=267904","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"USPTO Plant Patent PP17,092 (breeder's own filing, via Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP17092","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Light requirements: Sun to part shade."},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (SPECIES page, Gaillardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gaillardia-x-grandiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/gaillardia-oranges-and-lemons.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Gaillardia-x-grandiflora-Oranges-and-Lemons","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Grows best in an average to dry, well-drained soil, in full sun."},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/3544/Oranges_And_Lemons_Blanket_Flower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight."},{"name":"Salt Lake City GardenWise (Salt Lake City Public Utilities plant database)","url":"https://www.slcgardenwise.com/eplant.php?plantnum=25503&return=c_p702","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow in well drained soil in full sun."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gaillardia-oranges-and-lemons","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Kiefer Landscaping & Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/gaillardia-oranges-lemons/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance No","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gaillardia-oranges-and-lemons","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=267904","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"USPTO Plant Patent PP17,092 (breeder's own filing, via Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP17092","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Designated use: Border plant and cut flower.","claim":true},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/gaillardia-oranges-and-lemons.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cutting.","claim":true},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Gaillardia-x-grandiflora-Oranges-and-Lemons","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cut flower","claim":true},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/3544/Oranges_And_Lemons_Blanket_Flower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"excellent cut flower","claim":true},{"name":"Salt Lake City GardenWise (Salt Lake City Public Utilities plant database)","url":"https://www.slcgardenwise.com/eplant.php?plantnum=25503&return=c_p702","country":null,"form":null,"value":"both flowers and seed heads make nice cut flowers","claim":true}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gaillardia-oranges-and-lemons","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=267904","country":null,"form":null,"value":"tolerate some dry soils and drought once established","claim":true},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/gaillardia-oranges-and-lemons.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established.","claim":true},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Gaillardia-x-grandiflora-Oranges-and-Lemons","country":null,"form":null,"value":"they are quite drought and heat tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/3544/Oranges_And_Lemons_Blanket_Flower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is considered to be drought-tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gaillardia-oranges-and-lemons","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=267904","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (SPECIES page, Gaillardia x grandiflora)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gaillardia-x-grandiflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract butterflies and bees.","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/gaillardia-grandiflora-oranges-and-lemons-pp-17092","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterfly Attracting Plants","claim":true},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Valleybrook International Ventures)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/gaillardia-oranges-and-lemons.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Gaillardia-x-grandiflora-Oranges-and-Lemons","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/3544/Oranges_And_Lemons_Blanket_Flower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting bees and butterflies to your yard","claim":true},{"name":"Salt Lake City GardenWise (Salt Lake City Public Utilities plant database)","url":"https://www.slcgardenwise.com/eplant.php?plantnum=25503&return=c_p702","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wildlife Birds, Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gardenia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":4,"genus":4,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 4 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 5.00 to 6.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"an evergreen shrub that typically grows to a height of 3 to 8 feet, depending upon the cultivar. Spread is usually about the same as the height.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Gardenia jasminoides / CAPE JASMINE Georgia's Hardy Zone: 7b, 8 Texture: medium Form: rounded Normal Georgia Height: 4-6′\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gardenia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":4,"genus":4,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 4 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 5.00 to 6.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"an evergreen shrub that typically grows to a height of 3 to 8 feet, depending upon the cultivar. Spread is usually about the same as the height.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gardenia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-11","8-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia-jasminoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[7,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286686","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8 to 11","zones":[8,11],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":4,"genus":4,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gardenia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia-jasminoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Gardenias prefer bright indirect sunlight or partial shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286686","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/gardenia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They are best planted in light to partial shade, preferably with morning sun and afternoon shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension EDIS, Gardenias at a Glance (EP338)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/EP338","country":"US","form":null,"value":"For best flower production, plant gardenias in full sun, partial shade, or shifting shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"gardenia"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/gardenias/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant your gardenia in full sun or partial shade","level":"genus","taxon":"gardenia"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension EDIS, Gardenia jasminoides 'Prostrata' Dwarf Gardenia (FP223)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP223","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in part shade/part sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Southern Living Plant Collection, Jubilation Gardenia","url":"https://southernlivingplants.com/the-collection/plant/jubilation-gardenia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun to Part Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees, Frost Proof Gardenia","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/frost-proof-gardenia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight : Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gardenia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia-jasminoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is renowned for its fragrant, showy, creamy white flowers, and its lustrous dark, emerald green foliage.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286686","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is particularly noted for its extremely fragrant white flowers","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/gardenia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are waxy, white, and very fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension, Landscape Plants for Georgia (B 625)","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/B625/landscape-plants-for-georgia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Class: broad-leaved evergreen Remarks: Fragrant white flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension EDIS, Gardenias at a Glance (EP338)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/EP338","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gardenias are prized for their very fragrant white flowers and glossy, dark green leaves","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gardenia"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/gardenias/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Probably the most distinguishing characteristic of the gardenia is its sweet scent.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gardenia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox, Gardenia genus entry","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The showy fragrant flowers can occur singly or in clusters and are usually white or yellow.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gardenia"},{"name":"Purdue University Horticulture and Landscape Architecture, Purdue Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://www.purdue.edu/hla/sites/yardandgarden/gardenia-a-gardeners-challenge/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"you'll be rewarded with elegant white blossoms and sweet fragrance that simply cannot be matched by other plants.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gardenia"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["gardenia jasminoides"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (gardenia jasminoides), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (gardenia jasminoides) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gardenia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia-jasminoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286686","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["gardenia jasminoides"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (gardenia jasminoides), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (gardenia jasminoides) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"gardenia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia-jasminoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are moderately drought-tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/gardenia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gardenias should be watered weekly during periods of drought in summer.","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["gardenia jasminoides"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (gardenia jasminoides), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (gardenia jasminoides) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gardenia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia-jasminoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gardenia hips attract birds and other wildlife. Attracts pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gardenia-august-beauty","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":3,"genus":1,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height at Maturity: 6-8'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height : 4-6 ft.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height : 4 - 6 Feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Growing 4 to 6 feet tall and 3 to 4 feet wide with bushy growth habit\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 5 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature height 5 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"gardenia-august-beauty","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":3,"genus":1,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width at Maturity: 4-6'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Width : 3-4 ft.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread : 4 - 6 Feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Growing 4 to 6 feet tall and 3 to 4 feet wide with bushy growth habit\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread 3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"gardenia-august-beauty","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["8-11","7-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/august-beauty-gardenia.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zones: 8a-11 (7B?)","zones":[8,11],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/august-beauty-gardenia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In Zones : 8-11 outdoors","zones":[8,11],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/august-beauty-gardenia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones : 8-11","zones":[8,11],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Trees and Plants","url":"https://www.treesandplants.com/products/august-beauty-gardenia-shrub","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones : 7, 8, 9","zones":[7,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":3,"genus":1,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"gardenia-august-beauty","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286686","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade","level":"species","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia-jasminoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Gardenias prefer bright indirect sunlight or partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/gardenia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They are best planted in light to partial shade, preferably with morning sun and afternoon shade.","level":"species","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension, Gardenias at a Glance (CIR1098/EP338)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/EP338","country":"US","form":null,"value":"For best flower production, plant gardenias in full sun, partial shade, or shifting shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"gardenia"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/august-beauty-gardenia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight : Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/august-beauty-gardenia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure : Partial Shade to Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Trees and Plants","url":"https://www.treesandplants.com/products/august-beauty-gardenia-shrub","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full sun to partial shade (more shade equals fewer flowers)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Walton's Garden Center","url":"https://plants.waltonsgarden.com/12210007/Plant/9125/August_Beauty_Gardenia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub does best in partial shade to full shade.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/shade-shrubs/august-beauty-gardenia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub does best in full sun to partial shade.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"gardenia-august-beauty","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286686","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia-jasminoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is renowned for its fragrant, showy, creamy white flowers, and its lustrous dark, emerald green foliage.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/gardenia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are waxy, white, and very fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension, Gardenias at a Glance (CIR1098/EP338)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/EP338","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gardenias are prized for their very fragrant white flowers and glossy, dark green leaves","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gardenia"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/august-beauty-gardenia.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers: Yes - extremely fragrant!","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/august-beauty-gardenia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant white blooms from spring to fall","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/august-beauty-gardenia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features : Showy, Fragrant Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Trees and Plants","url":"https://www.treesandplants.com/products/august-beauty-gardenia-shrub","country":null,"form":null,"value":"sweetly fragrant, velvety white blooms","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Walton's Garden Center","url":"https://plants.waltonsgarden.com/12210007/Plant/9125/August_Beauty_Gardenia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"August Beauty Gardenia features showy fragrant double white flowers at the ends of the branches from early to late summer.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/shade-shrubs/august-beauty-gardenia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A prolific bloomer with large, sweetly fragrant, elegant white flowers contrasted by deep green foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"}],"note":"10 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"gardenia-august-beauty","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286686","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia-jasminoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#cutting garden","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/august-beauty-gardenia.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting and use in indoor arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/august-beauty-gardenia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting, floating in a shallow bowl, or bringing into a room for fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Trees and Plants","url":"https://www.treesandplants.com/products/august-beauty-gardenia-shrub","country":null,"form":null,"value":"velvety white blooms that are superb for corsages, wedding bouquets, or elegant centerpieces","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Walton's Garden Center","url":"https://plants.waltonsgarden.com/12210007/Plant/9125/August_Beauty_Gardenia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/shade-shrubs/august-beauty-gardenia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"gardenia-august-beauty","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia-jasminoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are moderately drought-tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/gardenia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gardenias should be watered weekly during periods of drought in summer.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/august-beauty-gardenia.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought (when established)","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Walton's Garden Center","url":"https://plants.waltonsgarden.com/12210007/Plant/9125/August_Beauty_Gardenia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It may require supplemental watering during periods of drought or extended heat.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"}],"note":"2 source(s) state this trait and 2 deny it","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"gardenia-august-beauty","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia-jasminoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Walton's Garden Center","url":"https://plants.waltonsgarden.com/12210007/Plant/9125/August_Beauty_Gardenia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting bees and butterflies to your yard.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/shade-shrubs/august-beauty-gardenia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting bees and butterflies to your yard.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gardenia jasminoides"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"gardenia-crown-jewel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.67],"union":[0.51,0.91],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275071","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia-jasminoides-crown-jewel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/gardenia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This cultivar has a spreading habit, and grows to 2 feet tall and 4 feet wide.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"PlantHaven (introducer / patent licensor)","url":"https://planthaven.com/plant/gardenia-crown-jewel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 20 to 24-inches","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Briggs Nursery (wholesale propagator)","url":"https://www.briggsnursery.com/plant/gardenia-jasminoides-crown-jewel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"will grow only 2-3 feet in height and 5 feet in width","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Taylor's Nursery","url":"https://taylorsnursery.com/plant-name/Gardenia-jasminoides-Crown-Jewel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2-3 ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Logee's Plants","url":"https://www.logees.com/products/gardenia-crown-jewel-pp","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In the garden, its dwarf growth habit usually reaches only 2' high but it often spreads to 4' wide.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gardenia-crown-jewel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.51,1.67],"split":[{"range":[0.51,0.61],"sources":["PlantHaven (introducer / patent licensor)"]},{"range":[0.91,1.67],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden","Taylor's Nursery","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","Logee's Plants","Briggs Nursery (wholesale propagator)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275071","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia-jasminoides-crown-jewel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/gardenia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This cultivar has a spreading habit, and grows to 2 feet tall and 4 feet wide.","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"PlantHaven (introducer / patent licensor)","url":"https://planthaven.com/plant/gardenia-crown-jewel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 20 to 24-inches","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Briggs Nursery (wholesale propagator)","url":"https://www.briggsnursery.com/plant/gardenia-jasminoides-crown-jewel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"will grow only 2-3 feet in height and 5 feet in width","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Taylor's Nursery","url":"https://taylorsnursery.com/plant-name/Gardenia-jasminoides-Crown-Jewel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3-4 ft","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Logee's Plants","url":"https://www.logees.com/products/gardenia-crown-jewel-pp","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In the garden, its dwarf growth habit usually reaches only 2' high but it often spreads to 4' wide.","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gardenia-crown-jewel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-10","6-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275071","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 7 to 10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia-jasminoides-crown-jewel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[6,10]},{"name":"PlantHaven (introducer / patent licensor)","url":"https://planthaven.com/plant/gardenia-crown-jewel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone 7-10 (0°F or -18°C)","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Taylor's Nursery","url":"https://taylorsnursery.com/plant-name/Gardenia-jasminoides-Crown-Jewel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 7-10","zones":[7,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gardenia-crown-jewel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":"part-shade","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275071","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia-jasminoides-crown-jewel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/gardenia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They are best planted in light to partial shade, preferably with morning sun and afternoon shade."}],"note":"catalog value \"part-sun\" is outside every source's stated range","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gardenia-crown-jewel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275071","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia-jasminoides-crown-jewel/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In summer, white, intensely sweet, fragrant flowers will bloom on both old and new wood.","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/gardenia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It has a heavy bloom set with double, fragrant flowers, and very good cold hardiness.","claim":true},{"name":"PlantHaven (introducer / patent licensor)","url":"https://planthaven.com/plant/gardenia-crown-jewel/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"is a highly fragrant, white dwarf that blooms twice a year, survives cold winters and flowers prolifically","claim":true},{"name":"Briggs Nursery (wholesale propagator)","url":"https://www.briggsnursery.com/plant/gardenia-jasminoides-crown-jewel/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"with white, intensely sweet, fragrant flowers in summer","claim":true},{"name":"Taylor's Nursery","url":"https://taylorsnursery.com/plant-name/Gardenia-jasminoides-Crown-Jewel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It provides profuse, fragrant, double flowers in summer.","claim":true},{"name":"Logee's Plants","url":"https://www.logees.com/products/gardenia-crown-jewel-pp","country":null,"form":null,"value":"selected for its fragrant double blooms and cold hardiness to zone 6 with protection","claim":true}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gardenia-crown-jewel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia-jasminoides-crown-jewel/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"Taylor's Nursery","url":"https://taylorsnursery.com/plant-name/Gardenia-jasminoides-Crown-Jewel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gardenia-crown-jewel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/gardenia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gardenias should be watered weekly during periods of drought in summer.","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gardenia-crown-jewel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gardenia-jasminoides-crown-jewel/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees, moths, and songbirds are attracted to this plant.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gaura","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1,1.22],"union":[0.61,1.52],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/oenothera-lindheimeri/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=453230&isprofile=0&basic=Oenothera%20lindheimeri","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Native Plant Database","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=OELI2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"An upright to widely spreading, soft-hairy, 2-5 ft. perennial with delicate white flowers in elongated terminal and axillary clusters.","metres":[0.61,1.52],"band":[0.61,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/386413/oenothera-lindheimeri-g/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/gaura-gaura-lindheimeri/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The graceful flower stems grow 3 to 4 feet tall, with clusters of small flowers opening sequentially along the open terminal panicles.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/oenotheralindheimeri.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"upright to 4-feet tall, but mostly 2- to 3-feet tall","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/gaura-lindheimeri/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 3 - 4 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"gaura lindheimeri"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"gaura","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.5,0.61],"union":[0.3,1.22],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/oenothera-lindheimeri/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=453230&isprofile=0&basic=Oenothera%20lindheimeri","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/386413/oenothera-lindheimeri-g/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/gaura-lindheimeri/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 3 - 4 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"gaura lindheimeri"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"gaura","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","5-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/oenothera-lindheimeri/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=453230&isprofile=0&basic=Oenothera%20lindheimeri","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/gaura-gaura-lindheimeri/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This species is hardy in zones 5b-9a.","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/oenotheralindheimeri.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden, Plant Information profile","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plantinfo/plant_profiles/gaura","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Since Chicago represents the coldest end of this plant's hardiness (zones 5 to 9), it makes sense to mulch over winter.","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"gaura lindheimeri"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/gaura-lindheimeri/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: Zones 5 - 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"gaura lindheimeri"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"gaura","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":11,"distinctPublishers":11,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/oenothera-lindheimeri/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=453230&isprofile=0&basic=Oenothera%20lindheimeri","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Native Plant Database","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=OELI2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade","level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/386413/oenothera-lindheimeri-g/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/gaura-gaura-lindheimeri/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow gaura in full sun","level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/oenotheralindheimeri.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun to partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden, Plant Information profile","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plantinfo/plant_profiles/gaura","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Gaura must be grown in full sun, in soil that drains rapidly.","level":"species","taxon":"gaura lindheimeri"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/gaura-lindheimeri/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"gaura lindheimeri"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/gaura.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow Gaura: Full sun.","level":"species","taxon":"gaura lindheimeri"},{"name":"Proven Winners, STRATOSPHERE WHITE Oenothera lindheimeri 'Gautalwhi'","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/gaura/stratosphere-white-butterfly-flower-gaura-lindheimeri","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Sun to Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Mountain States Wholesale Nursery, Gaura lindheimeri 'Whirling Butterflies'","url":"https://mswn.com/plants/gaura-lindheimeri-whirling-butterflies-white-gaura/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in full sun in middle to high deserts, but provide some afternoon protection in the hottest zones.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"gaura lindheimeri"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"gaura","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/oenothera-lindheimeri/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Native Plant Database","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=OELI2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower \"fragrance\" has sometimes been compared to cat urine.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"gaura","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"gaura","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/oenothera-lindheimeri/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The taproot helps make it drought and heat tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=453230&isprofile=0&basic=Oenothera%20lindheimeri","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A taprooted plant which tolerates heat, humidity and some drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/gaura-gaura-lindheimeri/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established it tolerates drought, although adequate moisture will promote better flowering.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/oenotheralindheimeri.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Watering: Needs regular water despite claims of being able to withstand some Phoenix drought.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden, Plant Information profile","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plantinfo/plant_profiles/gaura","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The plant forms a strong taproot that allows it to withstand heat and drought once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gaura lindheimeri"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/gaura.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gaura loves hot weather and tolerates drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gaura lindheimeri"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["oenothera lindheimeri"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (oenothera lindheimeri), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (oenothera lindheimeri) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"gaura","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/oenothera-lindheimeri/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts pollinators such as hummingbirds, bumblebees, long-tongued bees, and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/gaura-gaura-lindheimeri/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are readily visited by many types of long-tongue bees and bumblebees, and may also attract butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/oenotheralindheimeri.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"oenothera lindheimeri"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/gaura.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gaura lindheimeri"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"gazania","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.25,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":6,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.50 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gazania","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":6,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.50 to 0.75 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gazania","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gazania, the genus group entry, titled \"Gazania (group)\")","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264597","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 9 to 11","zones":[9,11],"level":"genus","taxon":"gazania"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":6,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gazania","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gazania, the genus group entry, titled \"Gazania (group)\")","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264597","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"gazania"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gazania rigens)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277558","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"gazania rigens"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gazania linearis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256532","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"gazania linearis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gazania rigens)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gazania-rigens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"gazania rigens"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers: Gazania (genus entry in the Annuals series)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/gazania","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"gazania rigens"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Gazania, Gazania rigens)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=15&PlantTypeID=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"gazania rigens"},{"name":"RHS Plants (Gazania rigens, rigid treasure flower)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/86144/gazania-rigens/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"gazania rigens"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gazania","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gazania","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gazania","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gazania, the genus group entry, titled \"Gazania (group)\")","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264597","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gazania"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gazania rigens)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277558","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gazania rigens"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gazania linearis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256532","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gazania linearis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gazania rigens)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gazania-rigens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gazania rigens"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers: Gazania (genus entry in the Annuals series)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/gazania","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of drought conditions.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gazania rigens"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Gazania, Gazania rigens)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=15&PlantTypeID=1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of drought conditons.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gazania rigens"},{"name":"UGA Cooperative Extension Bulletin B954, Flowering Annuals for Georgia Gardens (Gazania entry)","url":"https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=B954&title=flowering-annuals-for-georgia-gardens","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gazania is a good choice for hot, dry locations.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gazania rigens"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gazania","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["gazania rigens"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (gazania rigens), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (gazania rigens) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gazania-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.25,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0.50 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gazania-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0.50 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gazania-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277558","country":"US","form":null,"value":"9 to 11","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gazania-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277558","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gazania-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gazania-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gazania-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277558","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gazania-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gazania-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.25,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.50 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Gazanias grow from about six to nine inches tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gazania-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.50 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gazania-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a517","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 9 to 11","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gazania-rigens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gazania-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a517","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gazania-rigens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"University of North Florida Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.unf.edu/botanical-garden/plants/gazania-rigens.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: full sun to part shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gazania-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gazania-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gazania-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a517","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gazania-rigens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#drought tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"University of North Florida Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.unf.edu/botanical-garden/plants/gazania-rigens.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water: very drought tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gazania-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gazania-rigens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator Garden","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gentle-hermione","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.31],"union":[1.07,1.34],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4' x 3'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/gentle-hermione-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/gentle-hermoine","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.40463.0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: up to 47\" (up to 120cm).","metres":1.19,"band":[1.07,1.31],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gentle-hermione","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4ft (125cm)","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gentle-hermione","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.98],"union":[0.8,1],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3ft","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4' x 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/gentle-hermione-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/gentle-hermoine","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.40463.0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: up to 35\" (up to 90cm).","metres":0.89,"band":[0.8,0.98],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gentle-hermione","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 4 1/2ft (140cm)","metres":1.37,"band":[1.23,1.51],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gentle-hermione","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zone Zone 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/gentle-hermione-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Suitable Zones: 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/gentle-hermoine","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zones: 5–11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.40463.0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"USDA zone 4b through 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gentle-hermione","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gentle-hermione","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sun Requires 6+ hours of direct sunlight to thrive.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/gentle-hermoine","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Roses require full sun and organically rich, well-drained, acidic to neutral soils.","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gentle-hermione","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["strong","strong","strong","strong","strong","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gentle-hermione"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","https://heirloomroses.com/products/gentle-hermione"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","https://menagerieflower.com/products/gentle-hermione-rose-david-austin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/gentle-hermoine"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.40463.0"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong,Myrrh","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gentle-hermione","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong,Myrrh","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Very Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/gentle-hermione-rose-david-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong - Myrrh","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/gentle-hermoine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong Myrrh","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.40463.0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Strong, myrrh, old rose fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 6 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 6","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gentle-hermione","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gentle-hermione","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/gentle-hermoine"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gentle-hermione","https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.40463.0"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gentle-hermione","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Location Attracting Bees Borders Cutting Wild Areas","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/gentle-hermoine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vase Life: 3–5 days","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.40463.0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Can be used for cut flower or garden.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gentle-hermione","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gentle-hermione","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gentle-hermione"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","https://heirloomroses.com/products/gentle-hermione"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Location Attracting Bees Mixed Border","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gentle-hermione","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Location Attracting Bees Borders Cutting Wild Areas","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/gentle-hermione","country":null,"form":null,"value":"has a strong, myrrh scent and is a favorite of pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"geranium-annual","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"geranium-annual","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"geranium-annual","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"geranium-annual","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Pelargonium, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pelargonium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"pelargonium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Pelargonium x hortorum, zonal geranium)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263626","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"pelargonium hortorum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Pelargonium x hybridum, zonal pelargonium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pelargonium-x-hybridum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"pelargonium hybridum"},{"name":"RHS (Pelargonium x hortorum, zonal geranium)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/160286/pelargonium-hortorum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"pelargonium hortorum"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Geranium, Pelargonium x hortorum)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=19&PlantTypeID=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun in moist, fertile, well-drained soil.","level":"species","taxon":"pelargonium hortorum"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Americana Cherry Rose zonal geranium, Pelargonium zonale)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/pelargonium/americana-cherry-rose-zonal-geranium-pelargonium-zonale","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Sun to Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"pelargonium zonale"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (growing geraniums as annual flowers in Minnesota)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/flowers/growing-geraniums-minnesota","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Geraniums grow well in full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"pelargonium"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"geranium-annual","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Pelargonium, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pelargonium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"pelargonium"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (growing geraniums as annual flowers in Minnesota)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/flowers/growing-geraniums-minnesota","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Some geranium varieties, “scented geraniums”, have scented leaves with aromas including lemon, orange, lime, peppermint, pineapple, nutmeg, rose and many others.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"pelargonium"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["pelargonium hybridum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (pelargonium hybridum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (pelargonium hybridum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"geranium-annual","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"geranium-annual","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Pelargonium, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pelargonium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, plants are drought-tolerant, but they grow and flower more luxuriantly with moderate moisture.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"pelargonium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Pelargonium x hybridum, zonal pelargonium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pelargonium-x-hybridum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, plants are drought-tolerant, but they grow and flower more luxuriantly with moderate moisture.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"pelargonium hybridum"},{"name":"RHS (Pelargonium x hortorum, zonal geranium)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/160286/pelargonium-hortorum/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"pelargonium hortorum"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Americana Cherry Rose zonal geranium, Pelargonium zonale)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/pelargonium/americana-cherry-rose-zonal-geranium-pelargonium-zonale","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant, once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"pelargonium zonale"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (growing geraniums as annual flowers in Minnesota)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/flowers/growing-geraniums-minnesota","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Because they tolerate drier soil, annual geraniums are great plants for garden beds, and for outdoor containers such as window boxes, pots, and other kinds of planters which tend to dry out faster.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"pelargonium"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"geranium-annual","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Pelargonium, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pelargonium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator Garden","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"pelargonium"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["pelargonium hybridum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (pelargonium hybridum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (pelargonium hybridum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"geranium-annual-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"geranium-annual-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"geranium-annual-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a537","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10 to 11","zones":[10,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"geranium-annual-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a537","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pelargonium-x-hybridum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"geranium-annual-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"geranium-annual-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"geranium-annual-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"geranium-annual-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gerbera","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Gerbera daisies typically grow 6 to 18 inches tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 12 - 18 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"These plants form dense, 12-inch tall clumps of long, slightly \"fuzzy\" leaves.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gerbera","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 3 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.75 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Each flower is attached to a leafless stem that rises about 6 inches above the plant's foliage, which is a tall 12-inch-wide clump of long, slightly \"fuzzy\" leaves.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 12 - 18 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gerbera","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["8-10","8-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gerbera jamesonii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gerbera-jamesonii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[8,10],"level":"species","taxon":"gerbera jamesonii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gerbera jamesonii)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=291914","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8 to 10","zones":[8,10],"level":"species","taxon":"gerbera jamesonii"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Gerbera daisy, Gerbera jamesonii)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/gerbera-daisy/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 8 to 10","zones":[8,10],"level":"species","taxon":"gerbera jamesonii"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database, Herbaceous Plant Finder (Gerbera jamesonii)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Gerbera_jamesonii.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: zones 8 - 11","zones":[8,11],"level":"species","taxon":"gerbera jamesonii"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gerbera","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gerbera jamesonii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gerbera-jamesonii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"gerbera jamesonii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gerbera jamesonii)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=291914","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"gerbera jamesonii"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica (Gerbera jamesonii)","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/gerbera-jamesonii","country":"ZA","form":null,"value":"Aspect: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"gerbera jamesonii"},{"name":"RHS Plant Finder (Gerbera jamesonii)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/70682/gerbera-jamesonii/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"gerbera jamesonii"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Gerbera jamesonii Joybera Orange, a named cultivar)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/gerbera/joybera-orange-gerbera-jamesonii","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Sun to Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"gerbera jamesonii"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gerbera","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gerbera","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gerbera jamesonii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gerbera-jamesonii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Garden","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gerbera jamesonii"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Gerbera daisy, Gerbera jamesonii)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/gerbera-daisy/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gerberas produce flowers from late spring through autumn in the garden, and their blooms make long-lasting cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gerbera jamesonii"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica (Gerbera jamesonii)","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/gerbera-jamesonii","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is one of the most popular ornamental flowers in the world, both as a cut flower and as a pot plant, and therefore is of considerable economic importance.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gerbera jamesonii"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database, Herbaceous Plant Finder (Gerbera jamesonii)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Gerbera_jamesonii.php","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Additional Notes: long-lasting cut flower","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gerbera jamesonii"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions (Gerbera daisy, Gerbera jamesonii)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/gerbera-daisy/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Not only will gerberas produce flowers for a good period of time in the garden, their blooms make long-lasting cut flowers that can be used to decorate your home.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gerbera jamesonii"},{"name":"RHS Plant Finder (Gerbera jamesonii)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/70682/gerbera-jamesonii/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gerbera jamesonii"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["gerbera jamesonii"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (gerbera jamesonii), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (gerbera jamesonii) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gerbera","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gerbera","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica (Gerbera jamesonii)","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/gerbera-jamesonii","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract bees and other insects, which pollinate them.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gerbera jamesonii"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gerbera-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Gerbera daisies typically grow 6 to 18 inches tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gerbera-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.75 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 3 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"a tall 12-inch-wide clump\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gerbera-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[8,10],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=291914&isprofile=0&basic=Gerbera+jamesonii","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8 to 10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gerbera-jamesonii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (HGIC 1199)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/gerbera-daisy/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 8 to 10","zones":[8,10]}],"note":"every source states 8-10; catalog states 8-11","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gerbera-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=291914&isprofile=0&basic=Gerbera+jamesonii","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gerbera-jamesonii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/gerbera-jamesonii","country":"ZA","form":null,"value":"Aspect: Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gerbera-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gerbera-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gerbera-jamesonii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (HGIC 1199)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/gerbera-daisy/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"their blooms make long-lasting cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/gerbera-daisy/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"their blooms make long-lasting cut flowers that can be used to decorate your home","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gerbera-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gerbera-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gertrude-jekyll","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"forms":{"shrub":[0.99,1.67],"climber":[2.25,3.36]},"catalogForm":"shrub","catalogFormAgreement":"full","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gertrude-jekyll"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","https://heirloomroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll"]},{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are davidaustinroses.com","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll-climbing-rose"]},{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gertrude-jekyll-climbing-rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll-climbing-rose","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/gertrude-jekyl"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"5ft","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gertrude-jekyll","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"3 1/2ft (110cm)","metres":1.1,"band":[0.99,1.21],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"5' x 3'-4' (size)","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - climbing page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"10ft","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"other-form"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - climbing page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gertrude-jekyll-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"8ft (2.5m)","metres":2.5,"band":[2.25,2.75],"role":"other-form"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/gertrude-jekyl","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"10'","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"other-form"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"DUAL-FORM"},"note":"DUAL-FORM withdrawn: the 6 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first; both pages are davidaustinroses.com. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 6","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gertrude-jekyll","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.96,1.18],"union":[0.91,1.22],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"3 1/2ft","metres":1.07,"band":[0.96,1.18],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"3'-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gertrude-jekyll","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"3ft (90cm)","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"regional-note"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/gertrude-jekyl","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"other-form"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gertrude-jekyll","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are davidaustinroses.com","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll-climbing-rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","https://heirloomroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/gertrude-jekyl"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zones 4-11"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - climbing page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zones 4-11"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 4-11"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/gertrude-jekyl","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"4-11"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[4,11]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are davidaustinroses.com; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gertrude-jekyll","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight / Partial Shade (listed under growing conditions; all aspects North, East, South, West)"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - climbing page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight / Partial Shade (North, East, South, West facing)"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gertrude-jekyll","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"North, East, South, West Facing; Full Sunlight; Partial Shade"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - climbing page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gertrude-jekyll-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"North, East, South, West Facing; Full Sunlight; Partial Shade"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Partial Shade or Full Sun - 'Tolerates some shade, needing only 4+ hours of direct sun to thrive'"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/gertrude-jekyl","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sun to Partial Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gertrude-jekyll","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Strong, Old Rose"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - climbing page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Strong, Old Rose ... often described as being the quintessential Old Rose fragrance"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gertrude-jekyll","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Strong, Old Rose"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - climbing page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gertrude-jekyll-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Strong, Old Rose; 'often described as being the quintessential Old Rose fragrance'"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Very Fragrant; 'wonderfully strong, old rose perfume with notes of musk and myrrh'"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/gertrude-jekyl","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Very Strong, Classic Old Rose"}],"note":"sources rate it strong","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gertrude-jekyll","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Cutting (listed among the Location suitability options)"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/gertrude-jekyll","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Cutting (listed under Location uses)"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/gertrude-jekyll","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Cutting - 'Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets and floral arrangements'"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/gertrude-jekyl","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Vase life 3-5 days (published as a cut-flower spec)"}],"note":"4 sources state it but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"ginkgo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":25,"sourcesDropped":11,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 50 ft. 0 in. - 80 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 25 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 50.00 to 80.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 25 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 50-80 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 25 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"reaches 50+ ft (15+ m) tall\", and this row's size is its size at 25 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature height 50-80 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 25 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"A deciduous tree to 25m, conical when young, becoming more irregular with age.\", and this row's size is its size at 25 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Height 50-80 Feet\", and this row's size is its size at 25 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Height : 40-70 ft.\", and this row's size is its size at 25 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Size: Typically grows 70-110 feet (21-33 meters) tall and has a slow growth rate.\", and this row's size is its size at 25 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height 50-80'\", and this row's size is its size at 25 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 11 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 25 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ginkgo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":10,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":25,"sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 30 ft. 0 in. - 40 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 25 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 30.00 to 40.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 25 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 30-40 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 25 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Max Spread 4-8 metres\", and this row's size is its size at 25 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Width : 30-40 ft.\", and this row's size is its size at 25 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread 30-40'\", and this row's size is its size at 25 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 25 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ginkgo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","3-8","4-8","4-9","5-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ginkgo-biloba/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=z990","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/ginkgo-maidenhair-tree-care-growing-guide/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 4 to 8b","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/ginkgo/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8, Zone 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=213&PlantTypeID=7","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 5 - 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/ginkgo-tree","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In Zones : 3-9 outdoors","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/ginkgo-tree","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In Zones : 3-9 outdoors","zones":[3,9],"level":"species"},{"name":"Cold Stream Farm","url":"https://www.coldstreamfarm.net/product/ginkgo-ginkgo-biloba/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Great Plains Nursery","url":"https://greatplainsnursery.com/product/ginkgo-ginkgo-biloba/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ginkgo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ginkgo-biloba/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=z990","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/ginkgo-maidenhair-tree-care-growing-guide/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full sun to partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/ginkgo/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/7990/ginkgo-biloba/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=213&PlantTypeID=7","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/ginkgo-tree","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight : Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/ginkgo-tree","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The tree is a sun-lover and needs at least 4 or 5 hours of full sun every day.","level":"species"},{"name":"Cold Stream Farm","url":"https://www.coldstreamfarm.net/product/ginkgo-ginkgo-biloba/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ginkgos thrive in moist, well-drained soils that lean towards sandy, ideally in full sun.","level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Great Plains Nursery","url":"https://greatplainsnursery.com/product/ginkgo-ginkgo-biloba/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ginkgo, also called Maidenhair tree, prefers full sun, medium moisture, sandy, well-drained soils but is tolerant of many environmental conditions including alkaline, acidic, saline, clay, and compacted soils, air pollution, heat, deer, and urban conditions.","level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ginkgo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ginkgo-biloba/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Seeds from female trees are messy and have foul-smelling flesh, so planting grafted male trees is often preferable.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=z990","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nurseries typically sell only male trees because female trees produce seeds encased in fleshy, fruit-like cone which, at maturity in autumn, are messy and emit a noxious, foul odor upon falling to the ground and splitting open.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/ginkgo-maidenhair-tree-care-growing-guide/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The mature ovules or seeds produce a foul-smelling aroma when the pulp decays or is crushed underfoot.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/ginkgo-biloba","country":null,"form":null,"value":"it is plum-shaped (ca. 2.5 cm diam.), green then tan or orange, extremely messy and malodorous when ripe.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/ginkgo/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Only male trees should be purchased, as the females produce seeds with a soft, fruitlike covering that can be messy and have a potent odor.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/7990/ginkgo-biloba/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Unpleasantly scented dull yellow fruits in autumn on female plants","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=213&PlantTypeID=7","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Select male cultivars as the fruit produced by the females has a rancid odor.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Virginia Tech Dendrology Fact Sheet","url":"https://dendro.cnre.vt.edu/dendrology/syllabus/factsheet.cfm?ID=122","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Actually a naked seed; 1 inch long, with a fleshy covering that develops a strong, unpleasant odor when it drops to the ground, inner hard seed is edible, maturing in the fall after the first frost.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Cold Stream Farm","url":"https://www.coldstreamfarm.net/product/ginkgo-ginkgo-biloba/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Female flowers develop into fleshy fruits that surround the seeds, maturing in fall and emitting an unpleasant odor when they fall and split open (Missouri Botanical Garden).","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"}],"note":"9 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ginkgo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ginkgo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ginkgo-biloba/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The ginkgo tree is tolerant of drought, heat and air pollution and is moderately salt-tolerant, which makes it an excellent choice for urban settings, streetscapes, recreational play areas and walkways.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/ginkgo-maidenhair-tree-care-growing-guide/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Watering: Drought-tolerant once established","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/ginkgo/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Ginkgo tolerates salt, heat, drought, and alkaline soil.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=213&PlantTypeID=7","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Full sun; moist, well drained soil; tolerates drought, heat, air pollution and salt.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/ginkgo-tree","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Adaptable to many different types of soil, our Ginkgo is also resistant to pests and will be drought resistant in maturity.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ginkgo biloba"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/ginkgo-tree","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Very tolerant of poor growing conditions- including poor soil, air pollution, and infrequent watering.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ginkgo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"gladiolus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.46,0.91],"union":[0.3,1.83],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gladiolus, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gladiolus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,1.83],"band":[0.3,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gladiolus (group), the genus-wide group profile)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264598&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.50 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.46,1.83],"band":[0.46,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"},{"name":"K-State Research and Extension 4-H Horticulture Judging (Gladiolus, the genus)","url":"https://extension.k-state.edu/hort-judging/flowers-foliages/gladiolus.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The flower stalks may be 18-36\" tall","metres":[0.46,0.91],"band":[0.46,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":6,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gladiolus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.3,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.61],"proposed":0.45,"margin":33.3,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gladiolus, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gladiolus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gladiolus (group), the genus-wide group profile)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264598&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":6,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.3 to 0.61 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gladiolus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-10","8-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gladiolus, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gladiolus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[7,10],"level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gladiolus (group), the genus-wide group profile)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264598&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"7 to 10","zones":[7,10],"level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension (Gladiolus for the Farmer Florist, the genus)","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/publications/gladiolus-for-the-farmer-florist","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most are perennials in USDA planting zones 8–10.","zones":[8,10],"level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":6,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gladiolus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gladiolus, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gladiolus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gladiolus (group), the genus-wide group profile)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264598&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gladiolus 'Atom', one cultivar)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=445828","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension (Gladiolus for the Farmer Florist, the genus)","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/publications/gladiolus-for-the-farmer-florist","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in an area that receives full sun and is spaced away from buildings and obstructions as they require good circulation.","level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Summer- and Fall-Flowering Bulbs, its Gladiolus species section)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/summer-and-fall-flowering-bulbs/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plants grow and flower best in full sun and moist, well-drained soil.","level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension G6620 (Summer Flowering Bulbs: Gladiolus, the genus)","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/publications/g6620","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Select a spot in full sun with good drainage.","level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gladiolus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gladiolus, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gladiolus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are fragrant and are excellent cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gladiolus (group), the genus-wide group profile)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264598&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension (Gladiolus for the Farmer Florist, the genus)","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/publications/gladiolus-for-the-farmer-florist","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These flowers are not necessarily prized for fragrance; there really is none.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"gladiolus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gladiolus, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gladiolus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are fragrant and are excellent cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gladiolus (group), the genus-wide group profile)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264598&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gladiolus 'Atom', one cultivar)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=445828","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension (Gladiolus for the Farmer Florist, the genus)","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/publications/gladiolus-for-the-farmer-florist","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gladioli are mainly grown to use as cut flowers rather than for landscape effect.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Summer- and Fall-Flowering Bulbs, its Gladiolus species section)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/summer-and-fall-flowering-bulbs/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Often grown as cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension G6620 (Summer Flowering Bulbs: Gladiolus, the genus)","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/publications/g6620","country":null,"form":null,"value":"their chief value is for cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gladiolus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gladiolus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gladiolus, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gladiolus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"gladiolus"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gladiolus-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.07,1.52],"union":[0.3,1.83],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264598","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.46,1.83],"band":[0.46,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gladiolus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,1.83],"band":[0.3,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension, Flowering Bulbs for Georgia Gardens (B918)","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/B918/flowering-bulbs-for-georgia-gardens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Gladiolus x hortulanus Gladiolus SH S 3-6″ 6″ see text 1-5′","metres":[0.3,1.52],"band":[0.3,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/blogs/spring-planted-bulbs-all-about/all-about-gladiolus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"produce elegant, 3-foot flower spikes","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/gladiolus_cutflower_mixture_","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 36 - 48 inches","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-gladiolus-flower-bulbs-rainbow-mix","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 48-60\" tall","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Easy to Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/gladiolus-glorious-glads-mix","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 42-60\"","metres":[1.07,1.52],"band":[1.07,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gladiolus-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.14,0.61],"split":[{"range":[0.14,0.17],"sources":["Easy to Grow Bulbs"]},{"range":[0.3,0.61],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264598","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gladiolus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Easy to Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/gladiolus-glorious-glads-mix","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 6\"","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gladiolus-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-10","8-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264598","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 7 to 10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gladiolus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/blogs/spring-planted-bulbs-all-about/all-about-gladiolus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Gladiolas are winter hardy in zones 7-10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-gladiolus-flower-bulbs-rainbow-mix","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone Zone 8 Zone 9 Zone 10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"Easy to Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/gladiolus-glorious-glads-mix","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8-10, elsewhere lift bulbs in fall and store indoors","zones":[8,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gladiolus-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264598","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gladiolus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/summer-and-fall-flowering-bulbs/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plants grow and flower best in full sun and moist, well-drained soil."},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension, Summer Flowering Bulbs: Gladiolus (G6620)","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/publications/g6620","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Select a spot in full sun with good drainage."},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/blogs/spring-planted-bulbs-all-about/all-about-gladiolus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Gladiolus grow best in full sun, though they will also flower in partial shade."},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/gladiolus_cutflower_mixture_","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-gladiolus-flower-bulbs-rainbow-mix","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun"},{"name":"Easy to Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/gladiolus-glorious-glads-mix","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gladiolus-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264598","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gladiolus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are fragrant and are excellent cut flowers.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gladiolus-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264598","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gladiolus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are fragrant and are excellent cut flowers.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension, Flowering Bulbs for Georgia Gardens (B918)","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/B918/flowering-bulbs-for-georgia-gardens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gladiolus is best grown as a cut flower.","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/summer-and-fall-flowering-bulbs/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Often grown as cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension, Summer Flowering Bulbs: Gladiolus (G6620)","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/publications/g6620","country":null,"form":null,"value":"their chief value is for cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-gladiolus-flower-bulbs-rainbow-mix","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Advantages Attracts Hummingbirds Easy To Grow Cut Flowers Deer Resistant","claim":true},{"name":"Easy to Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/gladiolus-glorious-glads-mix","country":null,"form":null,"value":"An easy to grow summer favorite in gardens and as cut flowers.","claim":true}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gladiolus-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264598","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Provide consistent moisture during the growing season, especially during dry summer periods, and do not allow soils to dry out.","claim":false},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gladiolus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They thrive in damp borders so do not allow soils to dry out.","claim":false}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gladiolus-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gladiolus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/spring-gladiolus-flower-bulbs-rainbow-mix","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"glory-of-the-snow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.12,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Van Engelen Inc. bulb catalog (The Glorious Chionodoxa Mixture, a genus-level mixture)","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/flower-bulbs-index/chionodoxa/the-glorious-chionodoxa-mixture.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5\" to 6\"","metres":[0.13,0.15],"band":[0.13,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"chionodoxa"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"glory-of-the-snow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.08,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"glory-of-the-snow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Van Engelen Inc. bulb catalog (The Glorious Chionodoxa Mixture, a genus-level mixture)","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/flower-bulbs-index/chionodoxa/the-glorious-chionodoxa-mixture.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"genus","taxon":"chionodoxa"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens growing guide (All About Chionodoxa, the genus)","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/blogs/all-about-fall-planted-bulbs/all-about-chionodoxa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The bulbs are winter hardy in growing zones 4-9.","zones":[4,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"chionodoxa"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"glory-of-the-snow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Chionodoxa forbesii)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244278","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"chionodoxa forbesii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Scilla luciliae, formerly Chionodoxa luciliae)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scilla-luciliae/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"scilla luciliae"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Chionodoxa luciliae)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=290643","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"chionodoxa luciliae"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Scilla luciliae, glory of the snow)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/scilla-luciliae-glory-snow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"scilla luciliae"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Glory-of-the-Snow, Chionodoxa forbesii)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/glory-of-the-snow-chionodoxa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Chionodoxa in the fall, locating them in full to partial sun in well-drained soil.","level":"species","taxon":"chionodoxa forbesii"},{"name":"Van Engelen Inc. bulb catalog (The Glorious Chionodoxa Mixture, a genus-level mixture)","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/flower-bulbs-index/chionodoxa/the-glorious-chionodoxa-mixture.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full to partial sunlight.","level":"genus","taxon":"chionodoxa"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens growing guide (All About Chionodoxa, the genus)","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/blogs/all-about-fall-planted-bulbs/all-about-chionodoxa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"For best results, plant chionodoxa bulbs in full sun or in an area that has at least half day sun during early spring - before the trees leaf out.","level":"genus","taxon":"chionodoxa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"glory-of-the-snow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Scilla, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scilla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"scilla"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["scilla luciliae"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (scilla luciliae), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (scilla luciliae) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"glory-of-the-snow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Chionodoxa forbesii)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244278","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"chionodoxa forbesii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Scilla luciliae, formerly Chionodoxa luciliae)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scilla-luciliae/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"scilla luciliae"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Chionodoxa luciliae)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=290643","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"chionodoxa luciliae"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Glory-of-the-Snow, Chionodoxa forbesii)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/glory-of-the-snow-chionodoxa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers sprays can be cut for tiny bouquets.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"chionodoxa forbesii"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"glory-of-the-snow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["scilla luciliae"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (scilla luciliae), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (scilla luciliae) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"glory-of-the-snow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["scilla luciliae"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (scilla luciliae), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (scilla luciliae) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"glory-of-the-snow-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.12,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.13,0.15],"union":[0.08,0.5],"voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244279","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.25 to 0.50 feet","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/chionodoxa-luciliae-alba.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5\" to 6\".","metres":[0.13,0.15],"band":[0.13,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"John Scheepers","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/chionodoxa-luciliae-alba.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5\" to 6\".","metres":[0.13,0.15],"band":[0.13,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/chionodoxa-lucilea-alba-glory-of-the-snow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5 Inches","metres":0.13,"band":[0.12,0.14],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fedco Bulbs","url":"https://fedcoseeds.com/bulbs/alba-chionodoxa-6461","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 4-8\"","metres":[0.1,0.2],"band":[0.1,0.2],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ruigrok Flowerbulbs","url":"https://ruigrokflowerbulbs.com/product/chionodoxa-luciliae-alba/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 4 Inches","metres":0.1,"band":[0.09,0.11],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Anglia Bulb Company","url":"https://www.angliabulbs.com/product/chionodoxa-luciliae-alba/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"They only grow to a height of 10-15 cm","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Boston Bulbs Wholesale","url":"https://www.bostonbulbswholesale.co.uk/miscellaneous-flower-bulbs/chionodoxa-luciliae-alba-339.html","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height 15cm","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/3741/chionodoxa-luciliae-alba/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/scilla-luciliae-alba-alba-glory-snow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows from 3 to 11 inches in height.","metres":[0.08,0.28],"band":[0.08,0.28],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/chionodoxa-luciliae-alba-bulbs-uk","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Established height 10-20cm","metres":[0.1,0.2],"band":[0.1,0.2],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Squak Mountain Nursery (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.squakmtnursery.com/12230001/Plant/28583/White_Glory_of_the_Snow/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"will grow to be only 4 inches tall at maturity extending to 6 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 6 inches","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/luciliae-alba/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5″-10″","metres":[0.13,0.25],"band":[0.13,0.25],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"glory-of-the-snow-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.08,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.08,0.1],"union":[0,0.17],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244279","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.25 to 0.50 feet","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/3741/chionodoxa-luciliae-alba/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0-0.1 metre","metres":[0,0.1],"band":[0,0.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/chionodoxa-luciliae-alba-bulbs-uk","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Established spread 5-10cm","metres":[0.05,0.1],"band":[0.05,0.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Squak Mountain Nursery (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.squakmtnursery.com/12230001/Plant/28583/White_Glory_of_the_Snow/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 6 inches","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"glory-of-the-snow-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244279","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scilla-luciliae/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/chionodoxa-luciliae-alba.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 3-8.","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"John Scheepers","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/chionodoxa-luciliae-alba.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 3-8.","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/chionodoxa-lucilea-alba-glory-of-the-snow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 3-8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Fedco Bulbs","url":"https://fedcoseeds.com/bulbs/alba-chionodoxa-6461","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 3-8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/scilla-luciliae-alba-alba-glory-snow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/luciliae-alba/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"glory-of-the-snow-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244279","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scilla-luciliae/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/chionodoxa-luciliae-alba.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full to partial sunlight."},{"name":"John Scheepers","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/chionodoxa-luciliae-alba.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full to partial sunlight."},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/chionodoxa-lucilea-alba-glory-of-the-snow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full Sun/Partial Shade"},{"name":"Ruigrok Flowerbulbs","url":"https://ruigrokflowerbulbs.com/product/chionodoxa-luciliae-alba/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Chionodoxa bulbs perform best in full sun but will tolerate some shade"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/3741/chionodoxa-luciliae-alba/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/scilla-luciliae-alba-alba-glory-snow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade"},{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/chionodoxa-luciliae-alba-bulbs-uk","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full sun Dappled shade Partial shade Full shade"},{"name":"Squak Mountain Nursery (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.squakmtnursery.com/12230001/Plant/28583/White_Glory_of_the_Snow/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in full sun to partial shade."},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/luciliae-alba/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun, Part Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"glory-of-the-snow-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"glory-of-the-snow-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244279","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scilla-luciliae/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"Fedco Bulbs","url":"https://fedcoseeds.com/bulbs/alba-chionodoxa-6461","country":null,"form":null,"value":"wonderful in a mini-vase","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"glory-of-the-snow-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scilla-luciliae/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"glory-of-the-snow-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scilla-luciliae/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinators are attracted to the flowers.","claim":true},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/chionodoxa-lucilea-alba-glory-of-the-snow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Loved by pollinators","claim":true},{"name":"Boston Bulbs Wholesale","url":"https://www.bostonbulbswholesale.co.uk/miscellaneous-flower-bulbs/chionodoxa-luciliae-alba-339.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"RHS - Perfect for Bees Yes","claim":true},{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/chionodoxa-luciliae-alba-bulbs-uk","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Loved by pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"goatsbeard","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.65,1.67],"union":[0.91,2.01],"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aruncus-dioicus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j430","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ARDI8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size Notes: Up to about 6 feet tall.","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/goatsbeard-6-15-07.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Goatsbeard grows as an herbaceous perennial reaching 5 to 6 feet tall with a similar spread given enough time and good growing conditions.","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"University of Tennessee Institute of Agriculture, Tennessee Smart Yards","url":"https://tnyards.utk.edu/?p=962","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3-6 ft. height, blooms late spring to early summer, white flowers.","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/goats-beard","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: to 5 feet.","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/goats-beard-aruncus-dioicus.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 4' - 6'","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/goatsbeard-aruncus-dioicus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 4-6 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Sugar Creek Gardens","url":"https://www.sugarcreekgardens.com/aruncus-dioicus-goats-beard/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 48-60\"","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Tripple Brook Farm","url":"https://tripplebrookfarm.com/product/aruncus-dioicus-goatsbeard/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Perennial • 4-6′ • USDA Zones 3-8","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"goatsbeard","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.61,1.83],"split":[{"range":[0.61,1.34],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Sugar Creek Gardens","Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase"]},{"range":[1.52,1.83],"sources":["University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aruncus-dioicus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j430","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/goatsbeard-6-15-07.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Goatsbeard grows as an herbaceous perennial reaching 5 to 6 feet tall with a similar spread given enough time and good growing conditions.","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/goatsbeard-aruncus-dioicus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Sugar Creek Gardens","url":"https://www.sugarcreekgardens.com/aruncus-dioicus-goats-beard/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 34-48\"","metres":[0.86,1.22],"band":[0.86,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"goatsbeard","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-7","4-8","4-7","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aruncus-dioicus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[3,7],"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j430","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/goatsbeard-6-15-07.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They grow best in zones 4 to 7","zones":[4,7],"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/goatsbeard-aruncus-dioicus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This clump-forming woodland plant is hardy in zones 3-8.","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/goats-beard-aruncus-dioicus.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Sugar Creek Gardens","url":"https://www.sugarcreekgardens.com/aruncus-dioicus-goats-beard/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 3-7","zones":[3,7],"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Tripple Brook Farm","url":"https://tripplebrookfarm.com/product/aruncus-dioicus-goatsbeard/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Perennial • 4-6′ • USDA Zones 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"goatsbeard","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aruncus-dioicus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Goat's beard prefers moist, fertile, organically rich soils that are not allowed to dry out in full sun to part shade.","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j430","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ARDI8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade , Shade","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/goatsbeard-6-15-07.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Woodland plants such as goatsbeard should be planted in partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/goatsbeard-aruncus-dioicus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Goatsbeard grows best in moist, rich soil in partial shade, although it will do fine in full sun if given consistent moisture.","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/goatsbeard-aruncus-dioicus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Sugar Creek Gardens","url":"https://www.sugarcreekgardens.com/aruncus-dioicus-goats-beard/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Part Shade , Shade , Sun","level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"goatsbeard","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aruncus-dioicus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"goatsbeard","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aruncus-dioicus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/goatsbeard-aruncus-dioicus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers - which make good cut flowers - are at their peak for about 10 days.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"goatsbeard","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aruncus-dioicus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Goat's beard prefers moist, fertile, organically rich soils that are not allowed to dry out in full sun to part shade.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j430","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Foliage decline can occur rapidly if soils are permitted to dry out.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ARDI8","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water Use: Medium , High","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/goatsbeard-6-15-07.aspx","country":null,"form":null,"value":"But if dry shade is all that's available, they will tolerate it, but expect plants to be smaller.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/goatsbeard-aruncus-dioicus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This low maintenance plant needs little care other than watering when the soil becomes dry.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/goats-beard-aruncus-dioicus.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It can be planted in sunny areas provided the soil is consistently moist.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/goatsbeard-aruncus-dioicus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Foliage decline can rapidly occur with inadequate moisture.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Sugar Creek Gardens","url":"https://www.sugarcreekgardens.com/aruncus-dioicus-goats-beard/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It can be grown in full sun but will require consistent moisture.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"}],"note":"7 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"goatsbeard","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aruncus-dioicus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract pollinators like butterflies and bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ARDI8","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"University of Tennessee Institute of Agriculture, Tennessee Smart Yards","url":"https://tnyards.utk.edu/?p=962","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It needs lots of space. Attracts bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/goats-beard","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This is the only food plant for caterpillars of the slate-gray azure butterfly (Celastrina ebenina), which lives in shaded forests in the eastern Ozarks.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/goats-beard-aruncus-dioicus.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Benefits Pollinators, Host Plant, Deer Resistant, Black Walnut Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/goatsbeard-aruncus-dioicus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The majority of visitors to Goatsbeard are butterflies, moths, flies, beetles, and ants, all of which feed on nectar.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"},{"name":"Sugar Creek Gardens","url":"https://www.sugarcreekgardens.com/aruncus-dioicus-goats-beard/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The enormous plumes of creamy white blossoms attract a vast number of butterflies and other beneficial insects.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aruncus dioicus"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"gold-medal-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.37,1.5],"union":[1.2,1.67],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/gold-medal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 4' - 5' x 3'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Dammann's Garden Company plant library (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.dammannsgardenco.com/12130021/Plant/3986/Gold_Medal_Rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5 feet","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Monrosier (Roseraie de Saint Vincent, France)","url":"https://www.monrosier.com/rosiers-a-grandes-fleurs/1186-rosier-gold-medal-.html","country":"FR","form":null,"value":"Hauteur : 120/150 cm","metres":[1.2,1.5],"band":[1.2,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gold-medal-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.82,1.34],"split":[{"range":[0.82,1],"sources":["Heirloom Roses"]},{"range":[1.1,1.34],"sources":["Dammann's Garden Company plant library (NetPS Plant Finder)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/gold-medal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 4' - 5' x 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Dammann's Garden Company plant library (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.dammannsgardenco.com/12130021/Plant/3986/Gold_Medal_Rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gold-medal-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["6-10","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/gold-medal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 6-10","zones":[6,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Certified Nurseries","url":"https://www.certifiednurseries.com/product/gold-medal/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gold-medal-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/gold-medal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun Requires 6+ hours of direct sunlight to thrive.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Dammann's Garden Company plant library (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.dammannsgardenco.com/12130021/Plant/3986/Gold_Medal_Rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gold-medal-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["light"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/gold-medal","https://www.certifiednurseries.com/product/gold-medal/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/gold-medal","https://plants.dammannsgardenco.com/12130021/Plant/3986/Gold_Medal_Rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/gold-medal","https://www.monrosier.com/rosiers-a-grandes-fleurs/1186-rosier-gold-medal-.html"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/gold-medal","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Lightly Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Certified Nurseries","url":"https://www.certifiednurseries.com/product/gold-medal/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Light Fruity","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Dammann's Garden Company plant library (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.dammannsgardenco.com/12130021/Plant/3986/Gold_Medal_Rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"is draped in stunning fragrant double gold flowers with peach edges at the ends of the branches from early summer to early fall","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Monrosier (Roseraie de Saint Vincent, France)","url":"https://www.monrosier.com/rosiers-a-grandes-fleurs/1186-rosier-gold-medal-.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fleurs au parfum léger mais bien présent.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gold-medal-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/gold-medal","https://plants.dammannsgardenco.com/12130021/Plant/3986/Gold_Medal_Rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/gold-medal","https://www.monrosier.com/rosiers-a-grandes-fleurs/1186-rosier-gold-medal-.html"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/gold-medal","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets and floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Dammann's Garden Company plant library (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.dammannsgardenco.com/12130021/Plant/3986/Gold_Medal_Rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Monrosier (Roseraie de Saint Vincent, France)","url":"https://www.monrosier.com/rosiers-a-grandes-fleurs/1186-rosier-gold-medal-.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Longue tige : idéale pour des fleurs coupées et pour confectionner de jolis et lumineux bouquets.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gold-medal-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"gold-medal-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"golden-celebration","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.37,1.51],"union":[1.22,1.67],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/golden-celebration","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4 1/2ft","metres":1.37,"band":[1.23,1.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/golden-celebration","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4' - 5' x 4' - 5'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/golden-celebration-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5 feet","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/golden-celebration","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4ft (125cm)","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm (climbing product page)","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/golden-celebration","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Height: 8'","metres":2.44,"band":[2.2,2.68],"role":"other-form","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"golden-celebration","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.23,1.34],"union":[1.1,1.52],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/golden-celebration","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 4 1/2ft","metres":1.37,"band":[1.23,1.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/golden-celebration","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4' - 5' x 4' - 5'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/golden-celebration-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/golden-celebration","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 4ft (125cm)","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm (climbing product page)","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/golden-celebration","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Width: 3–4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"other-form","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"golden-celebration","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","5-8","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/golden-celebration","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/golden-celebration","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zone Zone 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/golden-celebration-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Suitable Zones: 5-8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm (climbing product page)","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/golden-celebration","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Hardiness Zones: 5–9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"golden-celebration","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/golden-celebration","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/golden-celebration","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm (climbing product page)","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/golden-celebration","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Roses require full sun and organically rich, well-drained, acidic to neutral soils.","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"golden-celebration","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["strong","strong","strong","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/golden-celebration","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/golden-celebration"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/golden-celebration","https://heirloomroses.com/products/golden-celebration"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/golden-celebration","https://menagerieflower.com/products/golden-celebration-rose-david-austin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/golden-celebration","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/golden-celebration"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/golden-celebration","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong,Tea","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/golden-celebration","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong,Tea","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/golden-celebration","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Very Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/golden-celebration-rose-david-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong Tea","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm (climbing product page)","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/golden-celebration","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong, Tea with Fruity Notes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"golden-celebration","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Grace Rose Farm (climbing product page)","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/golden-celebration","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vase Life: 4–6 days","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"golden-celebration","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"golden-celebration","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/golden-celebration","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/golden-celebration"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/golden-celebration","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Location Attracting Bees Mixed Border","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/golden-celebration","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Location Attracting Bees Borders Pots & Containers Rose Hedges Rose Hips","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"goldenrod","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.3,2.44],"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,2.44],"band":[0.3,2.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago canadensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago-canadensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.83],"band":[0.61,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago speciosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago-speciosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 7 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,2.13],"band":[0.61,2.13],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago rugosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago-rugosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"with 2-5 foot stems","metres":[0.61,1.52],"band":[0.61,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago canadensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277473","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago speciosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g690","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago rigida)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=f610","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers (Goldenrod, Solidago rugosa)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/goldenrod","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 2 to 4 Feet","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Solidago rugosa)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=746&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2-4 Feet","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Solidago canadensis var. canadensis)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=SOCAC3","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size Notes: Up to about 6 feet tall.","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden, Plant Profile: Goldenrod","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/goldenrod","country":"US","form":null,"value":"the shortest being S. brachystachys (under 12 inches) and the tallest topping out at 4 to 6 feet","metres":[0.3,1.83],"band":[0.3,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Solidago nemoralis)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/solidago-nemoralis-old-field-goldenrod","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Solidago nemoralis is one of the shortest Goldenrods, reaching 2' at most.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery (Solidago speciosa)","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/showy-goldenrod-solidago-speciosa.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2' - 4'","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Solidago rugosa 'Fireworks')","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/fireworks-goldenrod-solidago-rugosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"the slowly expanding clump grows 3 to 4 feet tall","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"goldenrod","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.3,1.83],"split":[{"range":[0.3,0.91],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago, genus page)","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago rigida)","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago speciosa)","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago speciosa)"]},{"range":[1.22,1.83],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago canadensis)","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago canadensis)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago canadensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago-canadensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 4 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago speciosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago-speciosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago canadensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277473","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago speciosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g690","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago rigida)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=f610","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.46,0.76],"band":[0.46,0.76],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"goldenrod","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-8","3-9","3-8","5-9","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[2,8]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago canadensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277473","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago speciosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g690","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago rigida)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=f610","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago canadensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago-canadensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5a, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago speciosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago-speciosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago rugosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago-rugosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers (Goldenrod, Solidago rugosa)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/goldenrod","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 2 - 8","zones":[2,8]},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Solidago rugosa)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=746&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2 - 8","zones":[2,8]},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Solidago nemoralis)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/solidago-nemoralis-old-field-goldenrod","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3-9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Prairie Nursery (Solidago speciosa)","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/showy-goldenrod-solidago-speciosa.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"goldenrod","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago canadensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277473","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago speciosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g690","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago rigida)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=f610","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago canadensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago-canadensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago speciosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago-speciosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago rugosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago-rugosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers (Goldenrod, Solidago rugosa)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/goldenrod","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Solidago rugosa)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=746&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery (Solidago speciosa)","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/showy-goldenrod-solidago-speciosa.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Solidago rugosa 'Fireworks')","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/fireworks-goldenrod-solidago-rugosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"in full sun or partial shade in average garden soil"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"goldenrod","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"goldenrod","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Solidago rugosa 'Fireworks')","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/fireworks-goldenrod-solidago-rugosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is also good as a cut flower and is relatively attractive to butterflies and many pollinating insects","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"goldenrod","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"tolerates poor, dry soils, clay and drought","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago speciosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g690","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago speciosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago-speciosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy goldenrod tolerates drought and clay soil well","claim":true},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers (Goldenrod, Solidago rugosa)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/goldenrod","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of tough sites and dry soils. Attracts butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Solidago rugosa)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=746&PlantTypeID=2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of tough sites and dry soils.","claim":true},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Solidago rugosa 'Fireworks')","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/fireworks-goldenrod-solidago-rugosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"somewhat drought tolerant once established","claim":true}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"goldenrod","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It also attracts butterflies, bees, and wasps.","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago canadensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277473","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Goldenrods are attractive to bees and butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago speciosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g690","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to bees and butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Solidago rigida)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=f610","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago canadensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago-canadensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The pollen and nectar are attractive to many pollinators including monarch butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago speciosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago-speciosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to butterflies, bees, and other pollinators.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Solidago rugosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/solidago-rugosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to butterflies, bees, and other pollinators.","claim":true},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers (Goldenrod, Solidago rugosa)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/goldenrod","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of tough sites and dry soils. Attracts butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Solidago rugosa)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=746&PlantTypeID=2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attacts butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Solidago canadensis var. canadensis)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=SOCAC3","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Prairie Nursery (Solidago speciosa)","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/showy-goldenrod-solidago-speciosa.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Birds, Butterflies, Pollinators, Host Plant, Deer Resistant","claim":true},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Solidago rugosa 'Fireworks')","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/fireworks-goldenrod-solidago-rugosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is also good as a cut flower and is relatively attractive to butterflies and many pollinating insects","claim":true}],"note":"12 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gomphrena","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gomphrena","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gomphrena","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gomphrena","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gomphrena globosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gomphrena-globosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gomphrena globosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275664","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gomphrena haageana)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275662","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena haageana"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Globe amaranth, Gomphrena globosa)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/globe-amaranth-gomphrena-globosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This annual does best in full sun","level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers (Gomphrena)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/gomphrena","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Gomphrena globosa)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/annual-globe-amaranth-gomphrena-globosa-in-south-carolina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full sun to partial shade (6 to 8 hours of direct sunlight)","level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, FPS-234 (Gomphrena globosa)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP234","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in full sun","level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension, Gomphrena Cut Flower Production in Utah (Gomphrena sp.)","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/productionhort/research/gomphrena-cut-flower-production-in-utah","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Optimal conditions include loamy, well-drained soil with full sun.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gomphrena","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gomphrena","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gomphrena globosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gomphrena-globosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Globe amaranth is grown for its charming flowers; it is often used in flower beds or borders, cutting gardens, cottage gardens, on patios, and in containers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gomphrena globosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275664","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long lasting fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gomphrena haageana)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275662","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long lasting fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena haageana"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Globe amaranth, Gomphrena globosa)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/globe-amaranth-gomphrena-globosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They do well as both a fresh cut flower and a dried flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers (Gomphrena)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/gomphrena","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cut flower and dries well also.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, FPS-234 (Gomphrena globosa)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP234","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers can be dried for indoor use if cut just before they are fully opened.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension, Gomphrena Cut Flower Production in Utah (Gomphrena sp.)","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/productionhort/research/gomphrena-cut-flower-production-in-utah","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The versatility of selling gomphrena as both a fresh and dried cut flower increases its value for Utah growers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gomphrena","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gomphrena globosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gomphrena-globosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought-tolerant once it is established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gomphrena globosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275664","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Clay Soil, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gomphrena haageana)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275662","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Clay Soil, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena haageana"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Globe amaranth, Gomphrena globosa)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/globe-amaranth-gomphrena-globosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"prefers moist soil but tolerates dry conditions once established","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers (Gomphrena)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/gomphrena","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant, only needing water when very dry conditions persist.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Gomphrena globosa)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/annual-globe-amaranth-gomphrena-globosa-in-south-carolina/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The plants have good drought tolerance, but they do benefit from regular watering during the growing season.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, FPS-234 (Gomphrena globosa)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP234","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance: moderate","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension, Gomphrena Cut Flower Production in Utah (Gomphrena sp.)","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/productionhort/research/gomphrena-cut-flower-production-in-utah","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants are heat and drought tolerant and highly productive by late summer.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"gomphrena","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Gomphrena globosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/gomphrena-globosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies, bees, and other beneficial insects.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gomphrena globosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275664","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Gomphrena haageana)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275662","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena haageana"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Globe amaranth, Gomphrena globosa)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/globe-amaranth-gomphrena-globosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies are attracted to the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Gomphrena globosa)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/annual-globe-amaranth-gomphrena-globosa-in-south-carolina/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator Benefits: Attracts hummingbirds, butterflies, bees, and other pollinating insects","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"gomphrena globosa"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"gomphrena-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"24 - 26\" (61 - 66cm)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"18-28\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gomphrena-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"8 - 10\" (20 - 25cm)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gomphrena-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gomphrena-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Urban Farmer Seeds","url":"https://www.ufseeds.com/product/qis-orange-gomphrena-seeds/GOQO.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gomphrena-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gomphrena-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.panamseed.com/Products/029801222003789/gomphrena-qis-orange","https://www.ufseeds.com/product/qis-orange-gomphrena-seeds/GOQO.html"]}],"sources":[{"name":"PanAmerican Seed","url":"https://www.panamseed.com/Products/029801222003789/gomphrena-qis-orange","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Can be used as a first-class professional cut flower for greenhouse and outdoor production.","claim":true},{"name":"Urban Farmer Seeds","url":"https://www.ufseeds.com/product/qis-orange-gomphrena-seeds/GOQO.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"excellent for fresh bouquets or dried arrangements","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gomphrena-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gomphrena-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gomphrena-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"18–28\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1.5-2' h x 1' w\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gomphrena-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1.5-2' h x 1' w\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gomphrena-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a582","country":"US","form":null,"value":"9 to 11","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gomphrena-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/globe-amaranth-strawberry-fields-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a582","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gomphrena-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gomphrena-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/gomphrena-globe-amaranth/strawberry-fields-gomphrena-seed-1512.html","https://www.selectseeds.com/products/globe-amaranth-strawberry-fields-seeds"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/gomphrena-globe-amaranth/strawberry-fields-gomphrena-seed-1512.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Variety good for fresh cut-flower displays","claim":true},{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/globe-amaranth-strawberry-fields-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great Cut Flower","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gomphrena-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/globe-amaranth-strawberry-fields-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Heat or Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"gomphrena-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/globe-amaranth-strawberry-fields-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"graham-thomas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"forms":{"shrub":[1.13,1.38],"climber":[3.29,4.13]},"catalogForm":"shrub","catalogFormAgreement":"full","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/graham-thomas","https://eu.davidaustinroses.com/products/graham-thomas"]},{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/graham-thomas","https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/graham-thomas-climbing-rose"]},{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are davidaustinroses.co.uk","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/graham-thomas","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/graham-thomas-climbing-rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/graham-thomas-climbing-rose","https://menagerieflower.com/products/graham-thomas-rose-david-austin"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/graham-thomas","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"4ft (125cm)","metres":1.25,"band":[1.13,1.38],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (EU storefront) - shrub page","url":"https://eu.davidaustinroses.com/products/graham-thomas","country":"EU","form":"shrub","value":"125cm","metres":1.25,"band":[1.13,1.38],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-graham-thomas%C2%AE-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Approximately 4-5 ft (up to 8-10 ft as a climber in warm climates)","metres":[1.22,3.05],"band":[1.22,3.05],"role":"unstated-form"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-graham-thomas-ausmas/","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Height: 4 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,3.05],"band":[1.22,3.05],"role":"unstated-form"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - climbing page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/graham-thomas-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"12ft","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"other-form"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - climbing page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/graham-thomas-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"12ft (3.75m)","metres":3.75,"band":[3.38,4.13],"role":"other-form"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/graham-thomas-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"12 feet","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"other-form"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"DUAL-FORM"},"note":"DUAL-FORM withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses; both pages are davidaustinroses.co.uk; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"graham-thomas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.22,1.34],"union":[1.1,2.44],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/graham-thomas","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"4ft (125cm)","metres":1.25,"band":[1.13,1.38],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (EU storefront) - shrub page","url":"https://eu.davidaustinroses.com/products/graham-thomas","country":"EU","form":"shrub","value":"125cm","metres":1.25,"band":[1.13,1.38],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-graham-thomas%C2%AE-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Approximately 4 ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-graham-thomas-ausmas/","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Width: 4 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,2.44],"band":[1.22,2.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/graham-thomas-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"other-form"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"graham-thomas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","5-8","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - climbing page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/graham-thomas-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zones 5-11"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/graham-thomas-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Suitable Zones: 5-8"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/graham-thomas","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 5-10"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-graham-thomas-ausmas/","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b"}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"graham-thomas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - climbing page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/graham-thomas-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/graham-thomas","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"East, South, West Facing; Full Sunlight"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (EU storefront) - shrub page","url":"https://eu.davidaustinroses.com/products/graham-thomas","country":"EU","form":"shrub","value":"East, South, West Facing; Full Sunlight"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - climbing page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/graham-thomas-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"East, South, West Facing; Full Sunlight"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/graham-thomas","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Partial Shade or Full Sun - tolerates some shade, needs '4+ hours of direct sun'"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-graham-thomas%C2%AE-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Full sun for best flowering and color"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-graham-thomas-ausmas/","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"graham-thomas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - climbing page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/graham-thomas-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Light, Tea (with hints of violets)"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/graham-thomas","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Light, Tea (with 'a cool violet character')"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (EU storefront) - shrub page","url":"https://eu.davidaustinroses.com/products/graham-thomas","country":"EU","form":"shrub","value":"Light, Tea (with 'a cool violet character')"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - climbing page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/graham-thomas-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Light,Tea (with 'hints of violets')"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/graham-thomas-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Strong - Tea"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/graham-thomas","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Moderately Fragrant; 'mild tea fragrance'"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-graham-thomas%C2%AE-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Moderate, fresh tea fragrance with hints of violet"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-graham-thomas-ausmas/","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"strong tea fragrance"}],"note":"sources rate it light/strong/medium","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"graham-thomas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.thornless","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-graham-thomas-ausmas/","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Stems with prickles; tagged 'Spines/Thorns'","polarity":"has-thorns"}],"note":"no source describes reduced thorniness; 1 source(s) mention thorns or prickles as present","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"grape-hyacinth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.15,0.17],"union":[0.14,0.23],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Muscari, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/muscari/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 0 ft. 9 in.","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"muscari"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden, Minor Bulbs (Muscari spp.)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/minor-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"produces urn-shaped flowers (which somewhat resemble grapes) on 6- to 9-inch spikes.","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"muscari"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center, Spring Flowering Bulbs (Muscari species)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/spring-flowering-bulbs/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most grow to about 6 inches.","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"muscari"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"grape-hyacinth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.08,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Muscari, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/muscari/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 2 in. - 0 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.05,0.15],"band":[0.05,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"muscari"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"grape-hyacinth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Muscari, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/muscari/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8],"level":"genus","taxon":"muscari"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"grape-hyacinth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Muscari, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/muscari/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grape hyacinths prefer full sun to partial shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"muscari"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Muscari armeniacum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282356","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"muscari armeniacum"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Muscari, genus growing guide)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/muscari","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"They thrive in full sun, but can be grown under deciduous trees and shrubs as they are dormant in summer when there is shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"muscari"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden, Minor Bulbs (Muscari spp.)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/minor-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The grape hyacinths prefer full sun and are best utilized for edging beds and in naturalized areas.","level":"genus","taxon":"muscari"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Muscari armeniacum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/muscari-armeniacum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in full sun to partial shade, under cool and moist conditions, and grows easily in average, well-drained soils.","level":"species","taxon":"muscari armeniacum"},{"name":"Van Engelen Inc. wholesale flower bulbs (Muscari armeniacum)","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/flower-bulbs-index/muscari/muscari-armeniacum.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full to partial sunlight.","level":"species","taxon":"muscari armeniacum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"grape-hyacinth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"taxon-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Muscari, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/muscari/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They have grass-like foliage and clusters of tiny fragrant bell-shaped flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"muscari"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center, Spring Flowering Bulbs (Muscari species)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/spring-flowering-bulbs/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fragrant purple flower clusters resemble tiny clusters of grapes.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"muscari"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":4,"covered":["muscari armeniacum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (muscari armeniacum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"this came out more confident than v6 only once the distinct-taxa rule removed the claim(s) that disagreed, so it is a disagreement about which taxa were speaking rather than a finding; v6 recorded INSUFFICIENT and true is not proposed; 4 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (muscari armeniacum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"grape-hyacinth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Muscari, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/muscari/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#cutting garden","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"muscari"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":4,"covered":["muscari armeniacum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (muscari armeniacum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 4 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (muscari armeniacum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"grape-hyacinth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["muscari armeniacum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (muscari armeniacum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (muscari armeniacum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"grape-hyacinth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Muscari, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/muscari/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees, butterflies, and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"muscari"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hardy-geranium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.46,1],"split":[{"range":[0.46,0.61],"sources":["Illinois Extension Flowers (Cranesbill, Hardy Geranium, Geranium sp.)"]},{"range":[0.82,1],"sources":["Utah State University Extension (Perennial Geranium or Cranesbill, Geranium spp., in Which Perennials are Made for the Shade)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Illinois Extension Flowers (Cranesbill, Hardy Geranium, Geranium sp.)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/cranesbill-hardy-geranium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 18 to 24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"geranium"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension (Perennial Geranium or Cranesbill, Geranium spp., in Which Perennials are Made for the Shade)","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/archive/which-perennials-are-made-for-the-shade","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Depending on the species, they grow to 3 feet high and wide.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"geranium"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":6,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hardy-geranium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Utah State University Extension (Perennial Geranium or Cranesbill, Geranium spp., in Which Perennials are Made for the Shade)","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/archive/which-perennials-are-made-for-the-shade","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Depending on the species, they grow to 3 feet high and wide.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"geranium"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":6,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hardy-geranium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Illinois Extension Flowers (Cranesbill, Hardy Geranium, Geranium sp.)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/cranesbill-hardy-geranium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 5 - 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"genus","taxon":"geranium"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":6,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hardy-geranium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Illinois Extension Flowers (Cranesbill, Hardy Geranium, Geranium sp.)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/cranesbill-hardy-geranium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun, Partial Sun/Shade","level":"genus","taxon":"geranium"},{"name":"Nebraska Extension in Lancaster County (Perennial Geraniums Make Great Groundcover Plants, the Geranium genus)","url":"https://lancaster.unl.edu/perennial-geraniums-make-great-groundcover-plants/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most perform best in full sun to partial shade and prefer average, well-drained soil.","level":"genus","taxon":"geranium"},{"name":"University of Tennessee Institute of Agriculture, UT Gardens (Hardy Geraniums, the genus)","url":"https://utianews.tennessee.edu/hardy-geraniums-stand-out-under-trees-and-scrubs-trouble-areas-and-partial-shade-gardens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most of the hardy geraniums we grow in Knoxville prefer partial shade and good drainage.","level":"genus","taxon":"geranium"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden (Growing Perennial Geraniums in Iowa, cranesbills as a group)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/growing-perennial-geraniums-iowa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Cranesbills are reliable bloomers in sites in full sun to part shade with well-drained soils.","level":"genus","taxon":"geranium"},{"name":"Portland Nursery Plant Library (Hardy Geranium: Cranesbill, the genus)","url":"https://portlandnursery.com/plant-library/perennials/hardy-geranium-cranesbill/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Geraniums are known for the breadth of conditions they can tolerate, from full sun to dry shade, as well as the ease with which they can be grown.","level":"genus","taxon":"geranium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Geranium sanguineum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/geranium-sanguineum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"geranium sanguineum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Geranium maculatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280854","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"geranium maculatum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hardy-geranium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hardy-geranium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hardy-geranium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"University of Tennessee Institute of Agriculture, UT Gardens (Hardy Geraniums, the genus)","url":"https://utianews.tennessee.edu/hardy-geraniums-stand-out-under-trees-and-scrubs-trouble-areas-and-partial-shade-gardens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Several species of hardy geraniums are very easy to grow and drought-tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"geranium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Geranium sanguineum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/geranium-sanguineum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bloody cranesbill prefers moist but well-drained soil in full sun but tolerates part shade and some drought once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"geranium sanguineum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Geranium maculatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280854","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"geranium maculatum"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hardy-geranium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"University of Tennessee Institute of Agriculture, UT Gardens (Hardy Geraniums, the genus)","url":"https://utianews.tennessee.edu/hardy-geraniums-stand-out-under-trees-and-scrubs-trouble-areas-and-partial-shade-gardens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They attract bees and butterflies and are deer and rabbit resistant.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"geranium"},{"name":"Portland Nursery Plant Library (Hardy Geranium: Cranesbill, the genus)","url":"https://portlandnursery.com/plant-library/perennials/hardy-geranium-cranesbill/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees, butterflies and birds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"geranium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Geranium sanguineum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/geranium-sanguineum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees and butterflies will visit the blooms.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"geranium sanguineum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Geranium maculatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280854","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"geranium maculatum"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"hardy-geranium-rozanne","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.41,0.51],"union":[0.3,0.66],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254303","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/geranium-rozanne/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (North American introducer and licensed grower)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=GERRO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18.0-20.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/153768/geranium-rozanne-gerwat-pbr/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"A vigorous spreading perennial to 60cm tall","metres":0.6,"band":[0.54,0.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Geranium--Rozanne","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 15-18 Inches","metres":[0.38,0.46],"band":[0.38,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Farm Marketplace","url":"https://www.perennialfarmmarketplace.com/products/geranium-x-rozanne","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows about 20\" tall and 24\" wide.","metres":0.51,"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Gertens (licensed plant database storefront)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/2351/Rozanne_Geranium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Rozanne Geranium will grow to be about 18 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 30 inches.","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored"},{"name":"MyGardenLife plant library","url":"https://mygardenlife.com/plant-library/cranesbill-rozanne-geranium-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18-20\" / 46-51cm","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-geranium-rozanne","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.55,0.61],"union":[0.3,1],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254303","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/geranium-rozanne/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (North American introducer and licensed grower)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=GERRO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24.0-36.0 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/153768/geranium-rozanne-gerwat-pbr/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Geranium--Rozanne","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 15-20 Inches","metres":[0.38,0.51],"band":[0.38,0.51],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Farm Marketplace","url":"https://www.perennialfarmmarketplace.com/products/geranium-x-rozanne","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows about 20\" tall and 24\" wide.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Gertens (licensed plant database storefront)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/2351/Rozanne_Geranium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Rozanne Geranium will grow to be about 18 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 30 inches.","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-geranium-rozanne","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[5,8],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254303","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/geranium-rozanne/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Walters Gardens (North American introducer and licensed grower)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=GERRO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 5,6,7,8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Geranium--Rozanne","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Perennial Farm Marketplace","url":"https://www.perennialfarmmarketplace.com/products/geranium-x-rozanne","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 5-8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"MyGardenLife plant library","url":"https://mygardenlife.com/plant-library/cranesbill-rozanne-geranium-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[5,8]}],"note":"every source states 5-8; catalog states 4-8","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-geranium-rozanne","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254303","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/geranium-rozanne/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They tolerate full sun or partial shade, though flower best in full sun."},{"name":"Walters Gardens (North American introducer and licensed grower)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=GERRO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/153768/geranium-rozanne-gerwat-pbr/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"Perennial Farm Marketplace","url":"https://www.perennialfarmmarketplace.com/products/geranium-x-rozanne","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade"},{"name":"Gertens (licensed plant database storefront)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/2351/Rozanne_Geranium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in full sun to partial shade."},{"name":"MyGardenLife plant library","url":"https://mygardenlife.com/plant-library/cranesbill-rozanne-geranium-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Sun to Part Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-geranium-rozanne","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-geranium-rozanne","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-geranium-rozanne","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254303","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Established plants have some drought tolerance.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/geranium-rozanne/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Established plants show some drought tolerance","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-geranium-rozanne","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254303","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/geranium-rozanne/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens (North American introducer and licensed grower)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=GERRO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Bee Friendly","claim":true},{"name":"MyGardenLife plant library","url":"https://mygardenlife.com/plant-library/cranesbill-rozanne-geranium-hybrid","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1.83],"union":[0.61,2.44],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282590","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 7.00 feet","metres":[0.91,2.13],"band":[0.91,2.13],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-moscheutos/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.83],"band":[0.61,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/hardy-hibiscus-hibiscus-moscheutos-how-to-grow-and-care-for-hardy-hibiscus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plants range in height from 2 to 8 feet and in width from 3 to 6 feet, depending on the cultivar.","metres":[0.61,2.44],"band":[0.61,2.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/rose-mallow-hibiscus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 2 to 8 Feet","metres":[0.61,2.44],"band":[0.61,2.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=HIMO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This is a 3-8 ft., shrubby perennial with numerous sturdy stems arising from a single crown.","metres":[0.91,2.44],"band":[0.91,2.44],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.61,1.83],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282590","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-moscheutos/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.52],"band":[0.61,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/hardy-hibiscus-hibiscus-moscheutos-how-to-grow-and-care-for-hardy-hibiscus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plants range in height from 2 to 8 feet and in width from 3 to 6 feet, depending on the cultivar.","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282590","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-moscheutos/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/hardy-hibiscus-hibiscus-moscheutos-how-to-grow-and-care-for-hardy-hibiscus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy hibiscus can be planted in USDA planting zones 4 through 9.","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/rose-mallow-hibiscus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 4 - 9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282590","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-moscheutos/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/hardy-hibiscus-hibiscus-moscheutos-how-to-grow-and-care-for-hardy-hibiscus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in full sun. It can also be grown in afternoon shade."},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/rose-mallow-hibiscus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun, Partial Sun/Shade"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=HIMO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282590","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf scorch will occur if soils are allowed to dry out.","claim":false},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-moscheutos/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf scorch can occur if soils dry out.","claim":false},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/rose-mallow-hibiscus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Prefer rich moist soils that stay consistently moist and will grow in areas that are wet.","claim":false},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=HIMO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerance: Low","claim":false}],"note":"4 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282590","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The blooms are attractive to butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-moscheutos/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its flowers are attractive to hummingbirds, butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/hardy-hibiscus-hibiscus-moscheutos-how-to-grow-and-care-for-hardy-hibiscus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hardy hibiscus attracts hummingbirds, butterflies, bees and other pollinators.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-cranberry-crush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.34],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273480","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/hibiscus/summerific-cranberry-crush-rose-mallow-hibiscus-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-cranberry-crush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1.52],"union":[0.91,1.52],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273480","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/hibiscus/summerific-cranberry-crush-rose-mallow-hibiscus-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4' - 5'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-cranberry-crush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273480","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-cranberry-crush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273480","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/hibiscus/summerific-cranberry-crush-rose-mallow-hibiscus-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Sun to Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-cranberry-crush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-cranberry-crush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-cranberry-crush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-cranberry-crush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273480","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-lord-baltimore","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.37,1.5],"union":[1.2,2.13],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248556&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hibiscus-moscheutos-lord-baltimore-lord-baltimore-rose-mallow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"At maturity it stands 4 – 5 feet high","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/hibiscus-lord-baltimore.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"120-150 cm","metres":[1.2,1.5],"band":[1.2,1.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Greenleaf Nursery","url":"https://www.greenleafnursery.com/plant/LORD-BALTIMORE-HARDY-HIBISCUS","country":"US","form":null,"value":"can attain 4 to 5 feet in height and width","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/hardy-hibiscus-lord-baltimore","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 4-5 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Hibiscus-x-Lord-Baltimore","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 48-60 Inches","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/hibiscus-lord-baltimore","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height:\n4 to 5 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Homestead Gardens (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.homesteadgardens.com/12170008/Plant/4828/Lord_Baltimore_Hibiscus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lord Baltimore Hibiscus will grow to be about 5 feet tall at maturity, with a spread of 3 feet.","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Almost Eden Plants","url":"https://www.almostedenplants.com/shopping/products/11017-lord-baltimore-perennial-hibiscus-hardy-hibiscus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows To: 5-7'H x 5-7'W","metres":[1.52,2.13],"band":[1.52,2.13],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-lord-baltimore","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.22,1.52],"union":[0.61,2.13],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248556&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/hibiscus-lord-baltimore.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"90-120 cm","metres":[0.9,1.2],"band":[0.9,1.2],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Greenleaf Nursery","url":"https://www.greenleafnursery.com/plant/LORD-BALTIMORE-HARDY-HIBISCUS","country":"US","form":null,"value":"can attain 4 to 5 feet in height and width","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/hardy-hibiscus-lord-baltimore","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 4-5 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Hibiscus-x-Lord-Baltimore","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 48-60 Inches","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/hibiscus-lord-baltimore","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width:\n3 to 4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Homestead Gardens (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.homesteadgardens.com/12170008/Plant/4828/Lord_Baltimore_Hibiscus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lord Baltimore Hibiscus will grow to be about 5 feet tall at maturity, with a spread of 3 feet.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Almost Eden Plants","url":"https://www.almostedenplants.com/shopping/products/11017-lord-baltimore-perennial-hibiscus-hardy-hibiscus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows To: 5-7'H x 5-7'W","metres":[1.52,2.13],"band":[1.52,2.13],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-lord-baltimore","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","4-9","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248556&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/muenchhusia-hybrid/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hibiscus-moscheutos-lord-baltimore-lord-baltimore-rose-mallow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is hardy in zones 5 -9.","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/hibiscus-lord-baltimore.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/hardy-hibiscus-lord-baltimore","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Hibiscus-x-Lord-Baltimore","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-10","zones":[5,10]},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/hibiscus-lord-baltimore","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growzone: 5-9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Almost Eden Plants","url":"https://www.almostedenplants.com/shopping/products/11017-lord-baltimore-perennial-hibiscus-hardy-hibiscus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5,6,7,8,9,10","zones":[5,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-lord-baltimore","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248556&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/muenchhusia-hybrid/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hibiscus-moscheutos-lord-baltimore-lord-baltimore-rose-mallow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/hibiscus-lord-baltimore.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Will tolerate average to wet conditions in full sun."},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/hardy-hibiscus-lord-baltimore","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/hibiscus-lord-baltimore","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun; tolerates light part sun"},{"name":"Homestead Gardens (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.homesteadgardens.com/12170008/Plant/4828/Lord_Baltimore_Hibiscus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in full sun to partial shade."},{"name":"Almost Eden Plants","url":"https://www.almostedenplants.com/shopping/products/11017-lord-baltimore-perennial-hibiscus-hardy-hibiscus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Outdoor Light: Full sun, Mostly sunny, Part shade, Part sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-lord-baltimore","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-lord-baltimore","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-lord-baltimore","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248556&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf scorch will occur if soils are allowed to dry out.","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-lord-baltimore","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248556&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/muenchhusia-hybrid/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers rich in nectar attract pollinators like hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/hibiscus-lord-baltimore.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/hardy-hibiscus-lord-baltimore","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Hibiscus-x-Lord-Baltimore","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/hibiscus-lord-baltimore","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees, butterflies, hummingbirds, and pollinators","claim":true},{"name":"Homestead Gardens (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.homesteadgardens.com/12170008/Plant/4828/Lord_Baltimore_Hibiscus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies and hummingbirds to your yard.","claim":true}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-luna-pink-swirl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,0.9],"union":[0.6,0.91],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=295322&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/hibiscus-moscheutos-luna-pink-swirl.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"60-90 cm","metres":[0.6,0.9],"band":[0.6,0.9],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-luna-pink-swirl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.45,0.91],"split":[{"range":[0.45,0.6],"sources":["Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (perennials.com)"]},{"range":[0.61,0.91],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=295322&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/hibiscus-moscheutos-luna-pink-swirl.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"45-60 cm","metres":[0.45,0.6],"band":[0.45,0.6],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-luna-pink-swirl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=295322&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/hibiscus-moscheutos-luna-pink-swirl.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5-9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-luna-pink-swirl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=295322&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/hibiscus-moscheutos-luna-pink-swirl.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-luna-pink-swirl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-luna-pink-swirl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-luna-pink-swirl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hardy-hibiscus-luna-pink-swirl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=295322&isprofile=0&pt=8","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/hibiscus-moscheutos-luna-pink-swirl.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"harlow-carr","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"consensus":[1.1,1.34],"union":[1.1,1.34],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/harlow-carr","https://heirloomroses.com/products/harlow-carr"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/harlow-carr","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height 4ft (measurements refer to a 3-year-old established rose)","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/harlow-carr","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4' x 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/harlow-carr","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"3ft (90cm) at 3 years, pruned annually","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"regional-note"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - Standard Tree Rose form","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/harlow-carr-standard-rose","country":"UK","form":"unstated","value":"6ft (180cm)","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"regional-note"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"harlow-carr","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.82,1.34],"split":[{"range":[0.82,1],"sources":["David Austin Roses (US)"]},{"range":[1.1,1.34],"sources":["Heirloom Roses"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/harlow-carr","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width 3ft (measurements refer to a 3-year-old established rose)","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/harlow-carr","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4' x 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/harlow-carr","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"3ft (90cm) at 3 years, pruned annually","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"harlow-carr","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-11","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/harlow-carr","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zones 4-11"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/harlow-carr","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 5-10"}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"harlow-carr","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/harlow-carr","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"\"Full Sunlight\"; \"East, South, West Facing\""},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/harlow-carr","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"\"East, South, West Facing\"; \"Full Sunlight\"; also listed as suitable for \"Partial Shade\""},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/harlow-carr","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"\"Full Sun\" - \"Requires 6+ hours of direct sunlight to thrive\""},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - Standard Tree Rose form","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/harlow-carr-standard-rose","country":"UK","form":"unstated","value":"\"East, South, West Facing\"; \"Full Sunlight\""}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"harlow-carr","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/harlow-carr","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Strong, pure Old Rose fragrance"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/harlow-carr","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Strong, pure Old Rose fragrance"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/harlow-carr","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"\"Very Fragrant\" with \"strong old rose fragrance\""},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - Standard Tree Rose form","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/harlow-carr-standard-rose","country":"UK","form":"unstated","value":"Strong, Old Rose, described as \"reminiscent of rose-based cosmetics\""}],"note":"sources rate it strong","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"harlow-carr","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/harlow-carr","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Listed under suitable locations/uses as \"Cutting\""},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/harlow-carr","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Listed under uses as \"Cutting\""},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/harlow-carr","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"The shallow-cupped blooms in rose pink make excellent cut flowers"}],"note":"3 sources state it but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"harlow-carr","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.thornless","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/harlow-carr","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Not stated in the specs. A customer REVIEW (not the vendor's spec) says \"The canes are bendable but very thorny\" - recorded only because it is the sole thorn comment found; treat as anecdote, not a source claim.","polarity":"has-thorns"}],"note":"no source describes reduced thorniness; 1 source(s) mention thorns or prickles as present","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"helenium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helenium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 15 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,4.57],"band":[0.61,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"helenium"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":19,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":13,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 19 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"helenium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helenium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"helenium"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":13,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":13,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 13 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"helenium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helenium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"helenium"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":17,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":13,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 17 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"helenium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helenium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"helenium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helenium-autumnale/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helenium-flexuosum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"helenium flexuosum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277198&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277604&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"helenium flexuosum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277197&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"helenium amarum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248711&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248710&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=439293&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=443008&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/helenium-helenium-autumnale/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Helenium grows best in full sun in fertile, moist soil","level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=842&PlantTypeID=14","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun; moist, well drained to wet sites; avoid dry sites.","level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=926&PlantTypeID=14","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun; moist, well drained to wet sites; avoid dry sites.","level":"species","taxon":"helenium nudiflorum"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/helenium-autumnale-sneezeweed","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, RHS Genus Guide","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/helenium","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Heleniums thrive in most soil types, and prefer full sun.","level":"genus","taxon":"helenium"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Helenium-autumnale-","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure • Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Helenium--Mardi-Gras","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure • Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/helenium-autumnale/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"helenium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helenium/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helenium-autumnale/"]},{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helenium/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helenium-flexuosum/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helenium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"helenium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helenium-autumnale/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helenium-flexuosum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium flexuosum"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["helenium amarum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (helenium amarum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are ncsu.edu. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (helenium amarum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"helenium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helenium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They can be planted in mass or in borders of cottage and cutting gardens or in naturalized areas.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"helenium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helenium-flexuosum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium flexuosum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248711&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248710&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/helenium-helenium-autumnale/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are frequently visited by butterflies, bees and other beneficial insects and are excellent for cutting","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Helenium-autumnale-","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great for cut flowers and the avid butterfly gardener.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Helenium--Mardi-Gras","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great as a cut flower, its long stems are sturdy and vase life is long.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/helenium-autumnale/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bog, Clay Soil, Coastal, Cut Flower, Dried Flower, Drought Tolerant, East-Coast Native, Naturalizing, Rain Garden","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"helenium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277198&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Intolerant of dry soils.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277604&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Intolerant of dry soils.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium flexuosum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277197&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium amarum"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=842&PlantTypeID=14","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Full sun; moist, well drained to wet sites; avoid dry sites.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=926&PlantTypeID=14","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Full sun; moist, well drained to wet sites; avoid dry sites.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium nudiflorum"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/helenium-autumnale/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants thrive in wet or evenly moist soil but will tolerate a bit of drought after establishment.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"}],"note":"2 source(s) state this trait and 4 deny it","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"helenium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helenium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use these colorful plants in pollinator gardens for late-season bees.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"helenium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helenium-autumnale/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use this plant in the native and pollinator garden, in naturalized areas and along ponds, bogs and streams.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helenium-flexuosum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract pollinators and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium flexuosum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277198&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277604&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium flexuosum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277197&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium amarum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248711&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248710&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=439293&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=443008&isprofile=0&basic=Helenium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/helenium-helenium-autumnale/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Because plants bloom into the fall, they make excellent late season pollinator plants.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=HEAU","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Value to Native Bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/helenium-autumnale-sneezeweed","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/helenium-autumnale-sneezeweed","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sneezeweed is one of the host plants of the Dainty Sulphur","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Helenium-autumnale-","country":null,"form":null,"value":"For Animals • Caution: Toxic • Deer Resistant • Pollinator-friendly","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Helenium--Mardi-Gras","country":null,"form":null,"value":"For Animals • Caution: Toxic • Deer Resistant • Pollinator-friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/helenium-autumnale/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The blooms are visited by throngs of pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helenium autumnale"},{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/plant/P-0431","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the pollinator-friendly blooms make quite a splash amid companions","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"18 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hellebore","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.3,0.33],"union":[0.23,0.61],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Helleborus, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helleborus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hellebores typically grow to 12 to 15 inches tall.","metres":[0.3,0.38],"band":[0.3,0.38],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden plant profile (Hellebores, the genus)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/hellebores2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants range in size from about 9 to 18 inches tall and 12 to 24 inches wide.","metres":[0.23,0.46],"band":[0.23,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"},{"name":"Penn State Extension Master Gardener, Betts Demonstration Garden (Hellebore, the genus)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/programs/master-gardener/counties/warren/demonstration-gardens/betts-demonstration-garden/hellebore","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hellebores mature to 1-2 feet tall.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"},{"name":"American Meadows growing guide (How to Grow Lenten Rose; its size sentence is written about hellebores generally)","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/blogs/perennials/how-to-grow-lenten-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hellebores spread in a soft mound of evergreen, palmate foliage approximately 18” wide and 12” high.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hellebore","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.41,0.51],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden plant profile (Hellebores, the genus)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/hellebores2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants range in size from about 9 to 18 inches tall and 12 to 24 inches wide.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"},{"name":"American Meadows growing guide (How to Grow Lenten Rose; its size sentence is written about hellebores generally)","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/blogs/perennials/how-to-grow-lenten-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hellebores spread in a soft mound of evergreen, palmate foliage approximately 18” wide and 12” high.","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hellebore","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Helleborus, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helleborus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[5,8],"level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"},{"name":"Penn State Extension Master Gardener, Betts Demonstration Garden (Hellebore, the genus)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/programs/master-gardener/counties/warren/demonstration-gardens/betts-demonstration-garden/hellebore","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They grow well in zones 3-9.","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hellebore","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Helleborus foetidus, stinking hellebore)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286237","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"helleborus foetidus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden plant profile (Hellebores, the genus)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/hellebores2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They grow in part- to full-shade areas and prefer moist, well-drained soil with plenty of organic matter.","level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"},{"name":"Penn State Extension Master Gardener, Betts Demonstration Garden (Hellebore, the genus)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/programs/master-gardener/counties/warren/demonstration-gardens/betts-demonstration-garden/hellebore","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They like part shade to full shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Lenten Rose, Helleborus x hybridus)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/lenten-rose-helleborus-xhybridus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lenten rose does best in partial to full sun.","level":"species","taxon":"helleborus hybridus"},{"name":"American Meadows growing guide (How to Grow Lenten Rose; its size sentence is written about hellebores generally)","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/blogs/perennials/how-to-grow-lenten-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Choose a well-drained site in sun or part-shade and plant your hellebore in early fall or spring.","level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hellebore","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["helleborus foetidus"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (helleborus foetidus), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (helleborus foetidus) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hellebore","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Illinois Extension, Plant of the Week (Helleborus, written up as Helleborus orientalis)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/hort-home-landscape/2016-03-28-plant-week-helleborus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Helleborus orientalis, is one of my absolute favorite cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helleborus orientalis"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Lenten Rose, Helleborus x hybridus)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/lenten-rose-helleborus-xhybridus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Blooms make good cut flowers, and their seed heads add interest in dried arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helleborus hybridus"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"hellebore","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Hellebore, the genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hellebore/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hellebores are drought tolerant once established but will require water during long dry periods.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden plant profile (Hellebores, the genus)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/hellebores2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once they’re established, they are tough plants that withstand drought and neglect.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"},{"name":"American Meadows growing guide (How to Grow Lenten Rose; its size sentence is written about hellebores generally)","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/blogs/perennials/how-to-grow-lenten-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"once established, hellebores can tolerate dry conditions","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["helleborus hybridus"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (helleborus hybridus), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (helleborus hybridus) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hellebore","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Hellebore, the genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hellebore/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hellebores are an early pollen source for bees and other insects.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"},{"name":"Penn State Extension Master Gardener, Betts Demonstration Garden (Hellebore, the genus)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/programs/master-gardener/counties/warren/demonstration-gardens/betts-demonstration-garden/hellebore","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees are attracted to hellebores for their rich nectar.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"},{"name":"American Meadows growing guide (How to Grow Lenten Rose; its size sentence is written about hellebores generally)","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/blogs/perennials/how-to-grow-lenten-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"When there is very little forage for bees, but we have unseasonably warm winters, hellebores can provide both pollen and nectar for hungry scout bees.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"hellebore-christmas-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.23,0.3],"union":[0.1,0.51],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helleborus-niger/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 9 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286220&isprofile=0&basic=Helleborus+niger","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hellebore/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These evergreen perennials grow 9 to 12 inches tall and 12 to 18 inches wide.","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/8575/helleborus-niger/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/66263b-helleborus-niger-christmas-rose/p/818049","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growth Height Max 18 in.","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"species":6,"genus":6,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hellebore-christmas-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.46],"union":[0.1,0.51],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helleborus-niger/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286220&isprofile=0&basic=Helleborus+niger","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hellebore/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These evergreen perennials grow 9 to 12 inches tall and 12 to 18 inches wide.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/8575/helleborus-niger/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/66263b-helleborus-niger-christmas-rose/p/818049","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growth Width Max 18 in.","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":6,"genus":6,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hellebore-christmas-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[3,8],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helleborus-niger/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286220&isprofile=0&basic=Helleborus+niger","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hellebore/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is hardy in USDA planting zones 3 to 8, which includes most of South Carolina.","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"SiteOne Landscape Supply","url":"https://www.siteone.com/en/66263b-helleborus-niger-christmas-rose/p/818049","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone Maximum Zone 8 Hardiness Zone Minimum Zone 3","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/helleborus-niger-christmas-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"species":6,"genus":6,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source states 3-8; catalog states 4-9; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hellebore-christmas-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helleborus-niger/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in partial to full shade with organically enriched soil.","level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286220&isprofile=0&basic=Helleborus+niger","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hellebore/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The soil should be well-drained, especially in winter, and part shade is preferred.","level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"University of Vermont Extension","url":"https://www.uvm.edu/extension/news/growing-hellebores","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They prefer to grow in locations offering partial shade to partial sun.","level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/8575/helleborus-niger/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/helleborus/snowbells-christmas-rose-helleborus-niger","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade to Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"University of Washington Botanic Gardens","url":"https://botanicgardens.uw.edu/about/blog/2009/01/01/january-2009-plant-profile-helleborus-niger-josef-lemper/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Part Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"Penn State Extension Master Gardener, Warren County","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/programs/master-gardener/counties/warren/demonstration-gardens/betts-demonstration-garden/hellebore","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They like part shade to full shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/helleborus-niger-christmas-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Partial Shade Full Shade","level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden plant profile: Hellebores","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/hellebores2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They grow in part- to full-shade areas and prefer moist, well-drained soil with plenty of organic matter.","level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/helleborus-niger-praecox.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Partial Shade or Full Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"helleborus niger"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hellebore-christmas-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helleborus-niger/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"The Arboretum at Penn State","url":"https://arboretum.psu.edu/about/news/bloom-highlight-helleborus-sp-lenten-rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Not that hellebores are known specifically for their perfumed fragrance, but this one is slightly malodorous.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"},{"name":"Heuger, Helleborus Gold Collection","url":"https://www.helleborus.de/us/plant-facts/botany","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower scent is unobtrusive, if existent at all in Helleborus species.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"}],"note":"3 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hellebore-christmas-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helleborus-niger/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are an excellent cut flower and are attractive when set floating in a bowl of water.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286220&isprofile=0&basic=Helleborus+niger","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/8575/helleborus-niger/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["helleborus niger"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (helleborus niger), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (helleborus niger) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"hellebore-christmas-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helleborus-niger/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hellebore/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hellebores are drought tolerant once established but will require water during long dry periods.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden plant profile: Hellebores","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/hellebores2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once they’re established, they are tough plants that withstand drought and neglect.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["helleborus niger"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (helleborus niger), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (helleborus niger) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hellebore-christmas-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hellebore/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hellebores are an early pollen source for bees and other insects.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helleborus niger"},{"name":"University of Vermont Extension","url":"https://www.uvm.edu/extension/news/growing-hellebores","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hellebores begin blooming in early spring, so they’re a first source of nectar for pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"},{"name":"Penn State Extension Master Gardener, Warren County","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/programs/master-gardener/counties/warren/demonstration-gardens/betts-demonstration-garden/hellebore","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees are attracted to hellebores for their rich nectar.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"helleborus"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["helleborus niger"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (helleborus niger), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (helleborus niger) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"hellebore-ivory-prince","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.35,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.3,0.46],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d652","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HELIP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"12.0-18.0 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hellebore-ivory-prince","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d652","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HELIP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"18.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hellebore-ivory-prince","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d652","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HELIP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hellebore-ivory-prince","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d652","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HELIP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hellebore-ivory-prince","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hellebore-ivory-prince","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HELIP","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hellebore-ivory-prince","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HELIP","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hellebore-ivory-prince","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HELIP","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bee Friendly","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hellebore-pink-frost","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.32,0.38],"union":[0.3,0.46],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=445177&isprofile=1&basic=Helleborus+%27Coseh+710%27+PINK+FROST","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/helleborus-ballardiae-hgc-pink-frost.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 30-40 cm 12-16 inches","metres":[0.3,0.4],"band":[0.3,0.4],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/helleborus-ballardiae-pink-frost-pp-21063","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 14\" tall","metres":0.36,"band":[0.32,0.4],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Helleborus-x-Pink-Frost","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12-15 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.38],"band":[0.3,0.38],"role":"scored"},{"name":"James Greenhouses","url":"https://www.jamesgreenhouses.com/plants/helleborus-pink-frost/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"height: 14\"","metres":0.36,"band":[0.32,0.4],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hellebore-pink-frost","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.46,0.6],"union":[0.45,0.61],"proposed":0.53,"margin":11.1,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=445177&isprofile=1&basic=Helleborus+%27Coseh+710%27+PINK+FROST","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/helleborus-ballardiae-hgc-pink-frost.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 45-60 cm 18-23 inches","metres":[0.45,0.6],"band":[0.45,0.6],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Helleborus-x-Pink-Frost","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18-24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.45 to 0.61 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hellebore-pink-frost","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","5-9","5-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=445177&isprofile=1&basic=Helleborus+%27Coseh+710%27+PINK+FROST","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/helleborus-ballardiae-hgc-pink-frost.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 5-9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/helleborus-ballardiae-pink-frost-pp-21063","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 5a to 8b, at least","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Helleborus-x-Pink-Frost","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"James Greenhouses","url":"https://www.jamesgreenhouses.com/plants/helleborus-pink-frost/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"hardiness zone: 5 - 9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hellebore-pink-frost","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=445177&isprofile=1&basic=Helleborus+%27Coseh+710%27+PINK+FROST","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/helleborus-ballardiae-hgc-pink-frost.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Partial Shade"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/helleborus-ballardiae-pink-frost-pp-21063","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Part Sun to Light Shade"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Helleborus-x-Pink-Frost","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers light to full shade and humus-rich, moist but not wet, well-drained soil. Will tolerate morning sun."},{"name":"James Greenhouses","url":"https://www.jamesgreenhouses.com/plants/helleborus-pink-frost/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"light: partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hellebore-pink-frost","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hellebore-pink-frost","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennials.com/plants/helleborus-ballardiae-hgc-pink-frost.html","https://www.plantdelights.com/products/helleborus-ballardiae-pink-frost-pp-21063"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennials.com/plants/helleborus-ballardiae-hgc-pink-frost.html","https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Helleborus-x-Pink-Frost"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/helleborus-ballardiae-hgc-pink-frost.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/helleborus-ballardiae-pink-frost-pp-21063","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower Plants","claim":true},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Helleborus-x-Pink-Frost","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hellebore-pink-frost","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennials.com/plants/helleborus-ballardiae-hgc-pink-frost.html","https://www.plantdelights.com/products/helleborus-ballardiae-pink-frost-pp-21063"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennials.com/plants/helleborus-ballardiae-hgc-pink-frost.html","https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Helleborus-x-Pink-Frost"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/helleborus-ballardiae-hgc-pink-frost.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/helleborus-ballardiae-pink-frost-pp-21063","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant Plants","claim":true},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Helleborus-x-Pink-Frost","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once estabished.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hellebore-pink-frost","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennials.com/plants/helleborus-ballardiae-hgc-pink-frost.html","https://www.plantdelights.com/products/helleborus-ballardiae-pink-frost-pp-21063"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/helleborus-ballardiae-hgc-pink-frost.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/helleborus-ballardiae-pink-frost-pp-21063","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pink Frost lenten rose is great for attractive honeybees to the winter garden when temperatures allow.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hemlock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":20,"sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 40.00 to 70.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 40 ft. 0 in. - 70 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page's figure is a final size and this row's is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Conifer, evergreen tree, 40-80 ft (12-25 m) tall\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height is usually 40-70 ft., but can reach 100 ft. or more.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 20 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hemlock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":20,"sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 25.00 to 35.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 25 ft. 0 in. - 35 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 20 years","the page's figure is a final size and this row's is its size at 20 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 20 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hemlock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285010","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 7","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tsuga-canadensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[3,7]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hemlock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285010","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tsuga-canadensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Purdue University)","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/689/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade Partial Shade to Full Shade Shade Sun"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=TSCA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade , Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hemlock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=TSCA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Foliage: yes","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hemlock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hemlock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285010","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Intolerant of drought and should be watered regularly in prolonged dry spells, particularly when plants are young.","claim":false},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tsuga-canadensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It grows best in areas with cooler summers and doesn't tolerate drought.","claim":false},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=TSCA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sunscorch kills back branches, and drought kills the tree.","claim":false}],"note":"3 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hemlock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=TSCA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds , Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hemlock-jeddeloh","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"It typically matures to 15\" tall and 20\" wide during the first 10 years, eventually maturing over time to 2-3' tall and to 3-4' wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page's figure is a 10 to 10 year size and this row's is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page's figure is a final size and this row's is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hemlock-jeddeloh","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"It typically matures to 15\" tall and 20\" wide during the first 10 years, eventually maturing over time to 2-3' tall and to 3-4' wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page's figure is a 10 to 10 year size and this row's is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page's figure is a final size and this row's is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hemlock-jeddeloh","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-7","3-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254066&isprofile=0&pt=9","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 7","zones":[4,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tsuga-canadensis-jeddeloh/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[3,7]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hemlock-jeddeloh","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254066&isprofile=0&pt=9","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tsuga-canadensis-jeddeloh/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/692/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun to Partial Shade Partial Shade to Full Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hemlock-jeddeloh","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hemlock-jeddeloh","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hemlock-jeddeloh","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254066&isprofile=0&pt=9","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Intolerant of drought and should be watered regularly in prolonged dry spells, particularly when plants are young.","claim":false},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tsuga-canadensis-jeddeloh/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Environmental problems include sunscorch in hot weather and sensitivity to drought.","claim":false},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/692/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Does not tolerate long periods of drought.","claim":false}],"note":"3 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hemlock-jeddeloh","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"heritage-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"edge","consensus":[1.37,1.52],"union":[1.22,2.44],"edge":[1.18,2.51],"edgeMargin":1.6,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/heritage","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"5ft","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/heritage","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4' - 5' x 4'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/heritage-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4-8 feet","metres":[1.22,2.44],"band":[1.22,2.44],"role":"scored"}],"withdrawnFromV2":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":1.45},"note":"the catalog value sits 1.6% outside the sources' union (1.22 to 2.44 m) and inside the 3% margin v3 allows at a stated range edge (1.18 to 2.51 m), so v2's proposal of 1.45 m is withdrawn rather than applied; 2 of these 3 scored sources publish a range, and a range edge is a figure converted and rounded from another unit rather than a measurement to the centimetre","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"heritage-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"consensus":[1.1,1.34],"union":[1.1,1.34],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/heritage","https://heirloomroses.com/products/heritage"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/heritage","https://menagerieflower.com/products/heritage-rose-david-austin"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/heritage","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/heritage","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4' - 5' x 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/heritage-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"heritage-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","5-10","3-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/heritage","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zones 5-11"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/heritage","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 5-10"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/heritage-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable Zones: 3-7"}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"heritage-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/heritage","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/heritage","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Performs well in partial shade; tolerates 4+ hours of direct sun to thrive"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"heritage-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/heritage","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Strong, Myrrh - with overtones of fruit, honey and carnation"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/heritage","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Exceptionally Fragrant - a strong heady fragrance with a touch of lemon"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/heritage-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Strong- Honey & Myrrh"}],"note":"sources rate it strong","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"heritage-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/heritage","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"makes a great cut flower; Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets"}],"note":"only 1 source mentions it","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"heritage-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.thornless","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/heritage","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Few thorns; Minimal thorns or bristles, making it easier to handle","polarity":"few-thorns"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/heritage-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"nearly thornless","polarity":"thornless"}],"note":"2 sources describe reduced thorniness (1 of them call it thornless) but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"holly-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.55,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.67],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285815","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyrtomium-falcatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 5 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.43,0.61],"band":[0.43,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/holly-fern/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"this plant can grow to be about two feet tall and three feet wide","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/cyrtomium-falcatum-japanese-holly-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24\" tall","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"holly-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.61,1.34],"split":[{"range":[0.61,1],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions"]},{"range":[1.1,1.34],"sources":["Plant Delights Nursery"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285815","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyrtomium-falcatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/holly-fern/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"this plant can grow to be about two feet tall and three feet wide","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/cyrtomium-falcatum-japanese-holly-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The easy-to-grow 4' wide tough-as-nails clumps are composed of outward arching fronds of glossy evergreen leaves.","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"holly-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["6-10","7-10","6-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285815","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 6 to 10","zones":[6,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyrtomium-falcatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/holly-fern/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It can be grown outdoors in USDA zones 6-11.","zones":[6,11]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/cyrtomium-falcatum-japanese-holly-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 7a to 10b, possibly colder","zones":[7,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"holly-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285815","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyrtomium-falcatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/holly-fern/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant your holly fern in partial to full shade."},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/cyrtomium-falcatum-japanese-holly-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Part Sun to Light Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"holly-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyrtomium-falcatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"holly-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/holly-fern/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fronds can also be used in cut flower arrangements.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"holly-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cyrtomium-falcatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#drought intolerant","claim":false},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/holly-fern/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Holly fern, named for the pointy tips on its leathery leaves, is a drought-resistant plant native to Africa and Asia.","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/hardy-evergreen-ferns-christmas-fern-japanese-tassel-fern-japanese-holly-fern/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Both the Tassel Fern that we just looked at and the Holly Fern, because they have the leathery foliage it makes them very tolerant of dry conditions.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"holly-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.52,1.79],"union":[0.61,2.5],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alcea-rosea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.52,2.44],"band":[1.52,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257276","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5.00 to 8.00 feet","metres":[1.52,2.44],"band":[1.52,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/57087/alcea-rosea/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers (Hollyhock, Alcea rosea)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/hollyhock","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 2 - 6 Feet","metres":[0.61,1.83],"band":[0.61,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Hollyhock, Alcea rosea)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=2&PlantTypeID=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2-6 Feet","metres":[0.61,1.83],"band":[0.61,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Everwilde Farms seed store (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.everwilde.com/store/Alcea-rosea-WildFlower-Seed.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 64 Inches","metres":1.63,"band":[1.47,1.79],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":6,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hollyhock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.5,0.61],"union":[0.3,1],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alcea-rosea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257276","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/57087/alcea-rosea/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":6,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hollyhock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","2-10","1-12"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alcea-rosea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257276","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 10","zones":[2,10],"level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Everwilde Farms seed store (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.everwilde.com/store/Alcea-rosea-WildFlower-Seed.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12","zones":[1,12],"level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":6,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hollyhock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alcea-rosea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257276","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Alcea rosea (single), the single-flowered seed strain)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243545","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/57087/alcea-rosea/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers (Hollyhock, Alcea rosea)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/hollyhock","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Hollyhock, Alcea rosea)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=2&PlantTypeID=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Everwilde Farms seed store (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.everwilde.com/store/Alcea-rosea-WildFlower-Seed.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hollyhock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hollyhock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers (Hollyhock, Alcea rosea)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/hollyhock","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Often used as background plant or specimen plants in the cutting garden.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Everwilde Farms seed store (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.everwilde.com/store/Alcea-rosea-WildFlower-Seed.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"hollyhock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Everwilde Farms seed store (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.everwilde.com/store/Alcea-rosea-WildFlower-Seed.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"these plants do not tolerate dry soil","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hollyhock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alcea-rosea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attacts bees, butterflies and hummingbird.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257276","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Everwilde Farms seed store (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.everwilde.com/store/Alcea-rosea-WildFlower-Seed.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attracts hummingbirds, butterflies, and bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["alcea rosea"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (alcea rosea), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (alcea rosea) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"hollyhock-chaters-double","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.65,1.83],"union":[1.22,2.5],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/152935/alcea-rosea-chaters-double-group-yellow-flowered-d/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"True Leaf Market","url":"https://trueleafmarket.com/products/hollyhock-chaters-double-mixture-flower-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Chater's Double Mixture seeds promise hardy 72-96 inch tall hollyhocks bursting with huge 5-inch blooms.","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Hollyhock-Rosea-Chaters-Double-Yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4-6 ft","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Brecks","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height/Habit 5 - 7 feet","metres":[1.52,2.13],"band":[1.52,2.13],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/plantname/alcea-double-charters-golden-yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 72\" tall","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature height 4 feet (6 feet with the flowers)","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/double-hollyhocks","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 4 - 7 feet","metres":[1.22,2.13],"band":[1.22,2.13],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/hollyhock/hollyhock-seeds-double-yellow.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It will bloom from early to midsummer reaching a height of 5 to 7 feet tall and 1 to 2 feet wide and grows best in full sun.","metres":[1.52,2.13],"band":[1.52,2.13],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-chaters-double","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.3,0.5],"union":[0.1,0.67],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/152935/alcea-rosea-chaters-double-group-yellow-flowered-d/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Hollyhock-Rosea-Chaters-Double-Yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12-18 in","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 24 inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/double-hollyhocks","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18 - 24 inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/hollyhock/hollyhock-seeds-double-yellow.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"reaching a height of 5 to 7 feet tall and 1 to 2 feet wide","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-chaters-double","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-10","5-9","2-8","3-9","2-9","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257276","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 10","zones":[2,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alcea-rosea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Botanical Interests","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/chatersdouble-hollyhock-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[2,8]},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Hollyhock-Rosea-Chaters-Double-Yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Brecks","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3-9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/plantname/alcea-double-charters-golden-yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 2 through 9","zones":[2,9]},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/double-hollyhocks","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 3-9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/hollyhock/hollyhock-seeds-double-yellow.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Our easy-to-grow seeds suit USDA Zones 4-9, requiring full sun and well-drained soil.","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-chaters-double","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/152935/alcea-rosea-chaters-double-group-yellow-flowered-d/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257276","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alcea-rosea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=2&PlantTypeID=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun, and well-drained soil."},{"name":"Botanical Interests","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/chatersdouble-hollyhock-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Required Full sun"},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Hollyhock-Rosea-Chaters-Double-Yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"Brecks","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirements full sun"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/double-hollyhocks","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/hollyhock/hollyhock-seeds-double-yellow.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows best in full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-chaters-double","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-chaters-double","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Hollyhock-Rosea-Chaters-Double-Yellow","https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Hollyhock-Rosea-Chaters-Double-Yellow","https://springhillnursery.com/products/double-hollyhocks"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Hollyhock-Rosea-Chaters-Double-Yellow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/double-hollyhocks","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cut flowers.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-chaters-double","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Botanical Interests","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/chatersdouble-hollyhock-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fairly drought tolerant but performs best with ample moisture and rich soil.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-chaters-double","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257276","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alcea-rosea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attacts bees, butterflies and hummingbird.","claim":true},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Hollyhock-Rosea-Chaters-Double-Yellow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Brecks","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attract Bees","claim":true},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting hummingbirds to your yard","claim":true},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/hollyhock/hollyhock-seeds-double-yellow.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds, butterflies and bees are attracted to the flowers","claim":true}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-chaters-double","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"botanicalName","current":"Alcea rosea 'Chater's Double'","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"IPNI (Kew)","url":"https://www.ipni.org/n/558713-1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Alcea rosea L., Sp. Pl. 2: 687 (1753). Published name, family Malvaceae; the IPNI API record for this id carries inPowo: true."},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/152935/alcea-rosea-chaters-double-group-yellow-flowered-d/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Accepted at cultivar-group rank as Alcea rosea Chater's Double Group (page is the yellow-flowered member of that Group; RHS also lists the synonym Alcea 'Chater's Golden Yellow')."},{"name":"POWO","url":"https://powo.science.kew.org/taxon/urn:lsid:ipni.org:names:558713-1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Not reachable: HTTP 403 on four attempts, including the plantsoftheworldonline.org mirror and the /api/2/search endpoint. Species resolved through IPNI (Kew) instead."}],"note":"name resolves as Alcea rosea Chater's Double Group","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-nigra","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.65,1.67],"union":[1.22,2.5],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Alcea rosea 'Nigra')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243543","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5.00 to 8.00 feet","metres":[1.52,2.44],"band":[1.52,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Alcea rosea 'Nigra')","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/66646/alcea-rosea-nigra/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database, Black Hollyhock)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/5779/Black_Hollyhock/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Black Hollyhock will grow to be about 4 feet tall at maturity extending to 6 feet tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials / perennials.com (Alcea rosea 'Nigra')","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/alcea-rosea-nigra.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 150-210 cm","metres":[1.5,2.1],"band":[1.5,2.1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"SeedTerra (Hollyhock Nigra Seeds - Alcea Rosea)","url":"https://seedterra.com/hollyhock-nigra-seeds---alcea-rosea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 60-72 Inches","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Bloom Outlet (Alcea rosea var. 'Nigra' Chocolate Black Hollyhock)","url":"https://bloomoutlet.com/alcea-rosea-var-nigra-chocolate-black-hollyhock-flower-seeds/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: 6 feet (180cm)","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"HarvestNest Seeds (Hollyhock Nigra Seeds)","url":"https://harvestnestseeds.com/products/hollyhock-nigra-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: Up to 60 inches (can grow taller in ideal conditions)","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":7},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-nigra","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.3,1],"split":[{"range":[0.3,0.45],"sources":["Heritage Perennials / perennials.com (Alcea rosea 'Nigra')"]},{"range":[0.46,1],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Alcea rosea 'Nigra')","Royal Horticultural Society (Alcea rosea 'Nigra')","Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database, Black Hollyhock)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Alcea rosea 'Nigra')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243543","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Alcea rosea 'Nigra')","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/66646/alcea-rosea-nigra/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database, Black Hollyhock)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/5779/Black_Hollyhock/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Black Hollyhock will grow to be about 4 feet tall at maturity extending to 6 feet tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials / perennials.com (Alcea rosea 'Nigra')","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/alcea-rosea-nigra.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 30-45 cm","metres":[0.3,0.45],"band":[0.3,0.45],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":7},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-nigra","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-9","3-10","3-9","1-13"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Alcea rosea 'Nigra')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243543","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 9","zones":[2,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials / perennials.com (Alcea rosea 'Nigra')","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/alcea-rosea-nigra.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 2-9","zones":[2,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"SeedTerra (Hollyhock Nigra Seeds - Alcea Rosea)","url":"https://seedterra.com/hollyhock-nigra-seeds---alcea-rosea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones: 3-10","zones":[3,10],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Bloom Outlet (Alcea rosea var. 'Nigra' Chocolate Black Hollyhock)","url":"https://bloomoutlet.com/alcea-rosea-var-nigra-chocolate-black-hollyhock-flower-seeds/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"HarvestNest Seeds (Hollyhock Nigra Seeds)","url":"https://harvestnestseeds.com/products/hollyhock-nigra-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 1-13","zones":[1,13],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"species":7},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-nigra","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":11,"distinctPublishers":11,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Alcea rosea 'Nigra')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243543","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257276","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alcea-rosea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plant prefers full sun to light shade in moist well-drained sandy to clay loams rich in organic matter.","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Alcea rosea 'Nigra')","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/66646/alcea-rosea-nigra/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/57087/alcea-rosea/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database, Black Hollyhock)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/5779/Black_Hollyhock/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials / perennials.com (Alcea rosea 'Nigra')","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/alcea-rosea-nigra.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Hollyhock, Alcea rosea)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=2&PlantTypeID=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun, and well-drained soil.","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Good Growing (How to grow and care for hollyhocks)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/good-growing/2023-05-26-how-grow-and-care-hollyhocks","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They grow best in a location with full sun and well-drained soil.","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database (Hollyhocks, Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Alcea_rosea.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun:\nfull sun","level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"SeedTerra (Hollyhock Nigra Seeds - Alcea Rosea)","url":"https://seedterra.com/hollyhock-nigra-seeds---alcea-rosea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Environment: Sun/Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Bloom Outlet (Alcea rosea var. 'Nigra' Chocolate Black Hollyhock)","url":"https://bloomoutlet.com/alcea-rosea-var-nigra-chocolate-black-hollyhock-flower-seeds/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"HarvestNest Seeds (Hollyhock Nigra Seeds)","url":"https://harvestnestseeds.com/products/hollyhock-nigra-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Herboo (Hollyhock 'Nigra' Seeds)","url":"https://www.herboo.com/products/hollyhock-nigra-seeds","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, well-drained soil, support tall stems","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-nigra","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-nigra","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database, Black Hollyhock)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/5779/Black_Hollyhock/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials / perennials.com (Alcea rosea 'Nigra')","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/alcea-rosea-nigra.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Hollyhock, Alcea rosea)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=2&PlantTypeID=1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Often used as background plant or specimen plants in the cutting garden.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database (Hollyhocks, Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Alcea_rosea.php","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hollyhocks provides large, showy blooms and a strong vertical accent to both the landscape and cut-flower arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"SeedTerra (Hollyhock Nigra Seeds - Alcea Rosea)","url":"https://seedterra.com/hollyhock-nigra-seeds---alcea-rosea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hollyhock Nigra looks best in the back of a sunny border, and this biennial flower is often planted in cutting and cottage gardens, along fences and walls.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Bloom Outlet (Alcea rosea var. 'Nigra' Chocolate Black Hollyhock)","url":"https://bloomoutlet.com/alcea-rosea-var-nigra-chocolate-black-hollyhock-flower-seeds/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"USES: Mixed borders, Perennial gardens, Bee and butterfly gardens, Cottage gardens, Walls, Fences, Border backgrounds, Hummingbird gardens, Wildflower Gardens, Informal gardens, Coastal gardens, Cut flowers, Landscaping","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"HarvestNest Seeds (Hollyhock Nigra Seeds)","url":"https://harvestnestseeds.com/products/hollyhock-nigra-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Perfect for cottage gardens, cut flower arrangements, pollinator habitats, and classic border plantings, Nigra Hollyhock delivers show-stopping beauty year after year.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Herboo (Hollyhock 'Nigra' Seeds)","url":"https://www.herboo.com/products/hollyhock-nigra-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These biennial flowers thrive in full sun with regular watering and are excellent as cut flowers or garden accents.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"hollyhock-nigra","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database, Black Hollyhock)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/5779/Black_Hollyhock/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It prefers to grow in average to moist conditions, and shouldn't be allowed to dry out.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Hollyhock, Alcea rosea)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=2&PlantTypeID=1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Environmental Damage Drought","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database (Hollyhocks, Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Alcea_rosea.php","country":null,"form":null,"value":"drought-tolerant once established","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-nigra","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Alcea rosea 'Nigra')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243543","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257276","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Alcea rosea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alcea-rosea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#hummingbird friendly #spring interest #butterfly friendly","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Oakland Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder database, Black Hollyhock)","url":"https://plants.oaklandnursery.com/12130001/Plant/5779/Black_Hollyhock/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting hummingbirds to your yard, but is not particularly attractive to deer who tend to leave it alone in favor of tastier treats.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials / perennials.com (Alcea rosea 'Nigra')","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/alcea-rosea-nigra.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to both butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"SeedTerra (Hollyhock Nigra Seeds - Alcea Rosea)","url":"https://seedterra.com/hollyhock-nigra-seeds---alcea-rosea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowering Alcea Rosea Nigra creates a dramatic effect as a background plant blooming in summer and attracting hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Bloom Outlet (Alcea rosea var. 'Nigra' Chocolate Black Hollyhock)","url":"https://bloomoutlet.com/alcea-rosea-var-nigra-chocolate-black-hollyhock-flower-seeds/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"USES: Mixed borders, Perennial gardens, Bee and butterfly gardens, Cottage gardens, Walls, Fences, Border backgrounds, Hummingbird gardens, Wildflower Gardens, Informal gardens, Coastal gardens, Cut flowers, Landscaping","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"HarvestNest Seeds (Hollyhock Nigra Seeds)","url":"https://harvestnestseeds.com/products/hollyhock-nigra-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees, butterflies & hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"},{"name":"Herboo (Hollyhock 'Nigra' Seeds)","url":"https://www.herboo.com/products/hollyhock-nigra-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Perfect for adding a dramatic touch to cottage gardens, these flowers also attract pollinators and make beautiful cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"alcea rosea"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"hollyhock-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/chaters-double-violet-hollyhock","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5 - 7 feet","metres":[1.52,2.13],"band":[1.52,2.13],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/chaters-double-violet-hollyhock","country":"US","form":"Chater's Double Violet, the exact cultivar this row names","value":"3-9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alcea-rosea/","country":"US","form":"Alcea rosea, the plain species (recorded for sun and zones only)","value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/chaters-double-violet-hollyhock","country":"US","form":"Chater's Double Violet, the exact cultivar this row names","value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alcea-rosea/","country":"US","form":"Alcea rosea, the plain species (recorded for sun and zones only)","value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/chaters-double-violet-hollyhock","country":null,"form":null,"value":"is ambrosia for butterflies, honeybees and hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alcea-rosea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attacts bees, butterflies and hummingbird","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.65,1.83],"union":[1.22,2.5],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"RHS (Alcea rosea Chater's Double Group yellow-flowered)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/152935/alcea-rosea-chater-s-double-group-yellow-flowered-(d)/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Hollyhock-Rosea-Chaters-Double-Yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4-6 ft","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Chater's Double Yellow Hollyhock will grow to be about 4 feet tall at maturity extending to 6 feet tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 5 - 7 feet","metres":[1.52,2.13],"band":[1.52,2.13],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/plantname/alcea-double-charters-golden-yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 72\" tall","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/hollyhock/hollyhock-seeds-double-yellow.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It will bloom from early to midsummer reaching a height of 5 to 7 feet tall and 1 to 2 feet wide and grows best in full sun.","metres":[1.52,2.13],"band":[1.52,2.13],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.1,0.67],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"RHS (Alcea rosea Chater's Double Group yellow-flowered)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/152935/alcea-rosea-chater-s-double-group-yellow-flowered-(d)/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Hollyhock-Rosea-Chaters-Double-Yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12-18 in","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Chater's Double Yellow Hollyhock will grow to be about 4 feet tall at maturity extending to 6 feet tall with the flowers, with a spread of 24 inches.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/hollyhock/hollyhock-seeds-double-yellow.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It will bloom from early to midsummer reaching a height of 5 to 7 feet tall and 1 to 2 feet wide and grows best in full sun.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-10","5-9","3-9","2-9","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257276","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 10","zones":[2,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alcea-rosea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Hollyhock-Rosea-Chaters-Double-Yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3-9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/plantname/alcea-double-charters-golden-yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 2 through 9","zones":[2,9]},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/hollyhock/hollyhock-seeds-double-yellow.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA ZONES 4 - 9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257276","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alcea-rosea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"RHS (Alcea rosea Chater's Double Group yellow-flowered)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/152935/alcea-rosea-chater-s-double-group-yellow-flowered-(d)/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Hollyhock-Rosea-Chaters-Double-Yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight."},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/plantname/alcea-double-charters-golden-yellow","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow in Full Sun for Best Performance"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/hollyhock/hollyhock-seeds-double-yellow.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It will bloom from early to midsummer reaching a height of 5 to 7 feet tall and 1 to 2 feet wide and grows best in full sun."},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=2&PlantTypeID=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun, and well-drained soil."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Hollyhock-Rosea-Chaters-Double-Yellow","https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Hollyhock-Rosea-Chaters-Double-Yellow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hollyhock-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257276","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alcea-rosea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attacts bees, butterflies and hummingbird.","claim":true},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Hollyhock-Rosea-Chaters-Double-Yellow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting hummingbirds to your yard","claim":true},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/chaters-double-yellow-hollyhock","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attract Bees","claim":true},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/plantname/alcea-double-charters-golden-yellow","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/hollyhock/hollyhock-seeds-double-yellow.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds, butterflies and bees are attracted to the flowers","claim":true}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lonicera, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lonicera/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5 ft. 0 in. - 15 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.52,4.57],"band":[1.52,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"lonicera"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":4,"cultivar":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lonicera, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lonicera/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,3.05],"band":[0.61,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"lonicera"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":4,"cultivar":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lonicera, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lonicera/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"lonicera"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":4,"cultivar":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lonicera, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lonicera/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Depending on the species, they can grow in sun or part shade","level":"genus","taxon":"lonicera"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lonicera alseuosmoides, honeysuckle vine)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=290683","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"lonicera alseuosmoides"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lonicera sempervirens, trumpet honeysuckle)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d990","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"lonicera sempervirens"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lonicera caerulea, sweetberry honeysuckle)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278931","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"lonicera caerulea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lonicera caerulea 'Kiev #8' BLUE VELVET)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273402","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lonicera caerulea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lonicera caerulea 'Blue Moon', honeyberry)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=361161","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lonicera caerulea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lonicera caerulea 'Borealis', honeyberry)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=445508","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lonicera caerulea"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension, Vines in the Landscape (Lonicera x heckrottii 'Goldflame')","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/vines-in-the-landscape-goldflame-honeysuckle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The vine grows well in full sun and well-drained soil, attracting hummingbirds and butterflies throughout the blooming season.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lonicera heckrottii"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Native Plant Database (Lonicera sempervirens)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=lose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade","level":"species","taxon":"lonicera sempervirens"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"taxon-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lonicera, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lonicera/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Honeysuckles produce attractive, sometimes fragrant, flowers","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lonicera"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lonicera alseuosmoides, honeysuckle vine)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=290683","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lonicera alseuosmoides"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lonicera caerulea 'Kiev #8' BLUE VELVET)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273402","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Small, funnel-shaped, slightly fragrant, white flowers bloom in early spring","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"lonicera caerulea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lonicera caerulea 'Blue Moon', honeyberry)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=361161","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Small, funnel-shaped, slightly fragrant white flowers bloom in early spring","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"lonicera caerulea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lonicera caerulea 'Borealis', honeyberry)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=445508","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"lonicera caerulea"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension, Vines in the Landscape (Lonicera x heckrottii 'Goldflame')","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/vines-in-the-landscape-goldflame-honeysuckle","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It produces fragrant, tubular rose-pink flowers with a yellow interior and attracts hummingbirds, bees, and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"lonicera heckrottii"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["lonicera sempervirens"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (lonicera sempervirens), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"this came out more confident than v6 only once the distinct-taxa rule removed the claim(s) that disagreed, so it is a disagreement about which taxa were speaking rather than a finding; v6 recorded INSUFFICIENT; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (lonicera sempervirens) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lonicera, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lonicera/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Most species prefer moist conditions but may be drought-tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lonicera"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lonicera alseuosmoides, honeysuckle vine)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=290683","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lonicera alseuosmoides"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lonicera caerulea, sweetberry honeysuckle)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278931","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Shrubs will show some drought tolerance only after root systems are well-established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lonicera caerulea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lonicera caerulea 'Kiev #8' BLUE VELVET)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273402","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Shrubs will show some drought tolerance only after root systems are well-established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"lonicera caerulea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lonicera caerulea 'Blue Moon', honeyberry)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=361161","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Shrubs will show some drought tolerance only after root systems are well-established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"lonicera caerulea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lonicera caerulea 'Borealis', honeyberry)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=445508","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Shrubs will show some drought tolerance only after root systems are well-established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"lonicera caerulea"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension, Vines in the Landscape (Lonicera x heckrottii 'Goldflame')","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/vines-in-the-landscape-goldflame-honeysuckle","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, the vine is moderately drought-tolerant and low maintenance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"lonicera heckrottii"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lonicera, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lonicera/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are attractive to pollinators; berries are consumed by birds and other animals.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lonicera"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lonicera sempervirens, trumpet honeysuckle)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d990","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are attractive to hummingbirds, butterflies and bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lonicera sempervirens"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension, Vines in the Landscape (Lonicera x heckrottii 'Goldflame')","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/vines-in-the-landscape-goldflame-honeysuckle","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It produces fragrant, tubular rose-pink flowers with a yellow interior and attracts hummingbirds, bees, and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"lonicera heckrottii"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Native Plant Database (Lonicera sempervirens)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=lose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract hummingbirds, bees, and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lonicera sempervirens"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"honeysuckle-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b839","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10.00 to 15.00 feet","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b839","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b839","country":"US","form":"vine","value":"5 to 9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b839","country":"US","form":"vine","value":"Full sun to part shade"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b839","country":null,"form":null,"value":"extremely fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b839","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[4,4.57],"union":[2.44,8],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/lonicera/scentsation-honeysuckle-lonicera-periclymenum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8' - 10'","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/178009/lonicera-periclymenum-scentsation-pbr/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 4-8 metres","metres":[4,8],"band":[4,8],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Lonicera-periclymenum-Scentsation-Honeysuckle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10-15 ft","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Green Promise Farms","url":"https://greenpromisefarms.com/products/proven-winners-lonicera-periclymenum-scentsation-honeysuckle-vine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature height is 10-15ft","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Factory Direct","url":"https://plantfactorydirect.com/products/scentsation-honeysuckle-lonicera-periclymenum-scentsation","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Size: 8-10' tall × 5-6' wide","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.5,1.83],"split":[{"range":[0.5,1.22],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society","Proven Winners (introducer)"]},{"range":[1.52,1.83],"sources":["Prides Corner Farms","Green Promise Farms","Plant Factory Direct"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/lonicera/scentsation-honeysuckle-lonicera-periclymenum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2' - 4'","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/178009/lonicera-periclymenum-scentsation-pbr/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Lonicera-periclymenum-Scentsation-Honeysuckle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 5-6 ft","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Green Promise Farms","url":"https://greenpromisefarms.com/products/proven-winners-lonicera-periclymenum-scentsation-honeysuckle-vine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"mature spread is 5-6ft","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Factory Direct","url":"https://plantfactorydirect.com/products/scentsation-honeysuckle-lonicera-periclymenum-scentsation","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8-10' tall × 5-6' wide","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/lonicera/scentsation-honeysuckle-lonicera-periclymenum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b , 9a , 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lonicera-periclymenum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=372017","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Lonicera-periclymenum-Scentsation-Honeysuckle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Green Promise Farms","url":"https://greenpromisefarms.com/products/proven-winners-lonicera-periclymenum-scentsation-honeysuckle-vine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"For best results, plant in USDA Zones 4-9.","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Plant Factory Direct","url":"https://plantfactorydirect.com/products/scentsation-honeysuckle-lonicera-periclymenum-scentsation","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4-9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/178009/lonicera-periclymenum-scentsation-pbr/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lonicera-periclymenum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=372017","country":"US","form":null,"value":"easily grown in humusy, organically rich, medium moisture, well-drained soils in full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Lonicera-periclymenum-Scentsation-Honeysuckle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure • Full Sun"},{"name":"Green Promise Farms","url":"https://greenpromisefarms.com/products/proven-winners-lonicera-periclymenum-scentsation-honeysuckle-vine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows well in full sun."},{"name":"Plant Factory Direct","url":"https://plantfactorydirect.com/products/scentsation-honeysuckle-lonicera-periclymenum-scentsation","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/lonicera/scentsation-honeysuckle-lonicera-periclymenum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"a highly fragrant honeysuckle vine with extremely fragrant yellow flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/178009/lonicera-periclymenum-scentsation-pbr/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"abundant, exceptionally fragrant, creamy-white to yellow flowers from summer to autumn","claim":true},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Lonicera-periclymenum-Scentsation-Honeysuckle","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Extremely fragrant yellow flowers mid spring to late summer","claim":true},{"name":"Green Promise Farms","url":"https://greenpromisefarms.com/products/proven-winners-lonicera-periclymenum-scentsation-honeysuckle-vine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Incredibly fragrant yellow flowers grace this plant mid Spring through Summer.","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Factory Direct","url":"https://plantfactorydirect.com/products/scentsation-honeysuckle-lonicera-periclymenum-scentsation","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Very intense, sweet","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"honeysuckle-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Factory Direct","url":"https://plantfactorydirect.com/products/scentsation-honeysuckle-lonicera-periclymenum-scentsation","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Features: Pollinator-friendly, deer-resistant, pet-friendly, heat-tolerant, non-invasive","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.76],"union":[0.1,1.22],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hosta, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hosta/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 4 in. - 2 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.1,0.76],"band":[0.1,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Hosta)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hosta/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most hostas range between 1 and 2½ feet tall.","metres":[0.3,0.76],"band":[0.3,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers (Plantain Lily, Hosta)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/plantain-lily-hosta","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 6 Inches to 4 Feet","metres":[0.15,1.22],"band":[0.15,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Growing hostas in Minnesota)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/growing-hostas-minnesota","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Depending on growing conditions and variety, individual plants range in size from six inches high and a foot or less across to 3 to 4 feet high and 5 to 6 feet across.","metres":[0.15,1.22],"band":[0.15,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Profile (Hosta)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/hosta","country":"US","form":null,"value":"There are hostas as large as 4 feet tall and 7 feet across, and others that are rock garden size, only 4 inches high.","metres":[0.1,1.22],"band":[0.1,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":7,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hosta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.15,2.34],"split":[{"range":[0.15,1.83],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hosta, genus entry)","University of Minnesota Extension (Growing hostas in Minnesota)"]},{"range":[1.92,2.34],"sources":["Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Profile (Hosta)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hosta, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hosta/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.15,0.91],"band":[0.15,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Growing hostas in Minnesota)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/growing-hostas-minnesota","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Depending on growing conditions and variety, individual plants range in size from six inches high and a foot or less across to 3 to 4 feet high and 5 to 6 feet across.","metres":[0.3,1.83],"band":[0.3,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Profile (Hosta)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/hosta","country":"US","form":null,"value":"There are hostas as large as 4 feet tall and 7 feet across, and others that are rock garden size, only 4 inches high.","metres":2.13,"band":[1.92,2.34],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":7,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hosta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hosta, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hosta/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers (Plantain Lily, Hosta)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/plantain-lily-hosta","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":7,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hosta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hosta plantaginea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281890","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"hosta plantaginea"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers (Plantain Lily, Hosta)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/plantain-lily-hosta","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Shade, Full Sun, Partial Sun/Shade","level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Growing hostas in Minnesota)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/growing-hostas-minnesota","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hostas thrive in sites where filtered or dappled shade is available for much of the day, but they can survive in deep shade (less than 4 hours of sun a day).","level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden (All About Hostas)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-hostas","country":"US","form":null,"value":"All hostas grow best in full to part shade, although sun tolerance can vary by leaf color.","level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension, Circular C955 (Growing Hostas)","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/C955/growing-hostas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement can range from partial sun to dense shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hosta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"taxon-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hosta, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hosta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#fragrant flowers","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Hosta)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hosta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hosta flowers may be white or lavender, and some are quite fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers (Plantain Lily, Hosta)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/plantain-lily-hosta","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Spikes of flowers that often fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Growing hostas in Minnesota)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/growing-hostas-minnesota","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Some flowers are very fragrant and attractive to hummingbirds and bees.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Profile (Hosta)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/hosta","country":null,"form":null,"value":"both of these varieties are wonderfully fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden (All About Hostas)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-hostas","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They can be beautiful, occasionally fragrant, and even attract pollinators and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension, Circular C955 (Growing Hostas)","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/C955/growing-hostas/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Besides the wonderful foliage hostas produce, many display fragrant flowers from early summer to fall, depending on the cultivar.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["hosta plantaginea"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (hosta plantaginea), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"this came out more confident than v6 only once the distinct-taxa rule removed the claim(s) that disagreed, so it is a disagreement about which taxa were speaking rather than a finding; v6 recorded INSUFFICIENT and true is not proposed; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (hosta plantaginea) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hosta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["hosta plantaginea"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (hosta plantaginea), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (hosta plantaginea) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hosta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hosta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"taxon-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hosta, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hosta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds are attracted to its flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Growing hostas in Minnesota)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/growing-hostas-minnesota","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Some flowers are very fragrant and attractive to hummingbirds and bees.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden (All About Hostas)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-hostas","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They can be beautiful, occasionally fragrant, and even attract pollinators and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["hosta plantaginea"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (hosta plantaginea), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"this came out more confident than v6 only once the distinct-taxa rule removed the claim(s) that disagreed, so it is a disagreement about which taxa were speaking rather than a finding; v6 recorded INSUFFICIENT and true is not proposed; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (hosta plantaginea) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hosta-august-moon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.56],"union":[0.3,0.56],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248603","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HSAUM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"20.0 Inches","metres":0.51,"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-august-moon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.61,1.18],"split":[{"range":[0.61,0.91],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder"]},{"range":[0.96,1.18],"sources":["Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248603","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HSAUM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"42.0 Inches","metres":1.07,"band":[0.96,1.18],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-august-moon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248603","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HSAUM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3,4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-august-moon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248603","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HSAUM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-august-moon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-august-moon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-august-moon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-august-moon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HSAUM","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-francee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.55,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.32,0.4],"union":[0.3,0.67],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248653&isprofile=0&basic=Francee","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hosta/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 24 inches tall by 36 inches wide.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/hosta-types-and-cultivars-iowa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Francee 14 36 9in long; 6in wide; dark green with white margins lavender 1986","metres":0.36,"band":[0.32,0.4],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HSFRA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 14.0 Inches","metres":0.36,"band":[0.32,0.4],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=HSFRA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 14.0 Inches","metres":0.36,"band":[0.32,0.4],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hosta-Francee","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 20 Inches","metres":0.51,"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/francee-hosta","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 21 - 24 Inches","metres":[0.53,0.61],"band":[0.53,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center","url":"https://www.gertens.com/francee-hosta","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: 18 inches","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":9,"genus":4},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hosta-francee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.3,1.4],"split":[{"range":[0.3,1],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Plant Addicts","Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","Walters Gardens","Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)"]},{"range":[1.14,1.4],"sources":["Pleasant Run Nursery"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248653&isprofile=0&basic=Francee","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hosta/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 24 inches tall by 36 inches wide.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/hosta-types-and-cultivars-iowa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Francee 14 36 9in long; 6in wide; dark green with white margins lavender 1986","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HSFRA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 36.0 Inches","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=HSFRA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 36.0 Inches","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hosta-Francee","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 50 Inches","metres":1.27,"band":[1.14,1.4],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/francee-hosta","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 30 - 36 Inches","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":9,"genus":4},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hosta-francee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248653&isprofile=0&basic=Francee","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HSFRA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=HSFRA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/francee-hosta","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 3 - 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":9,"genus":4},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hosta-francee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248653&isprofile=0&basic=Francee","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hosta)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hosta/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/growing-hostas-minnesota","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hostas thrive in sites where filtered or dappled shade is available for much of the day, but they can survive in deep shade (less than 4 hours of sun a day).","level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=730&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Does better in light filtered sun while there are a few that will tolerate full sun with moisture.","level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"University of Georgia Cooperative Extension, Growing Hostas (C955)","url":"https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=C955&title=Growing+Hostas","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement can range from partial sun to dense shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HSFRA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=HSFRA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hosta-Francee","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade/Shade Tolerant","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/francee-hosta","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Full Shade to Partial Shade (0 - 4 Hours Of Direct Sunlight)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gertens Garden Center","url":"https://www.gertens.com/francee-hosta","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hosta-francee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hosta)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hosta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hosta-francee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hosta)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hosta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hosta-Francee","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/francee-hosta","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features: Attracts Pollinators, Cut Flowers, Foliage Interest","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"hosta-francee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248653&isprofile=0&basic=Francee","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Full size and quality form are best achieved with consistent moisture.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HSFRA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water Requirements: Average Water Needs Consistent Water Needs","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=HSFRA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water Requirements: Average Water Needs Consistent Water Needs","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hosta-Francee","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dry Shade Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/francee-hosta","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates: Heat, Drought","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"2 source(s) state this trait and 3 deny it","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hosta-francee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=248653&isprofile=0&basic=Francee","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hosta)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hosta/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds are attracted to its flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hosta"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=HSFRA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource (Walters Gardens)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=HSFRA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Hosta-Francee","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/francee-hosta","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees, Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/hosta-francee/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lavender flowers bloom in late summer, attracting pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hosta fortunei"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"hosta-june","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=247564","country":"US","form":null,"value":"0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-june","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.7,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.61,1],"split":[{"range":[0.61,0.76],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder"]},{"range":[0.82,1],"sources":["Plant Delights Nursery"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=247564","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/hosta-june","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3' wide clumps","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-june","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[3,8],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=247564","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/hosta-june","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a to 8b","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"every source states 3-8; catalog states 3-9","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-june","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=247564","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/hosta-june","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Sun to Light Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-june","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-june","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=247564","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-june","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-june","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=247564","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-krossa-regal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.91,1],"union":[0.82,1.83],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=247567","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/hosta-krossa-regal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 36\" tall","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-krossa-regal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.65,1.83],"union":[0.91,2.01],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=247567","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/hosta-krossa-regal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The 6' wide clump is topped with lavender flowers on 6' bloom stalks","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-krossa-regal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[3,8],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=247567","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hosta-krossa-regal-krossa-regal-hosta","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/hosta-krossa-regal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3a to 8b","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"every source states 3-8; catalog states 3-9","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-krossa-regal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=247567","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hosta-krossa-regal-krossa-regal-hosta","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Partial Shade Full Shade"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/hosta-krossa-regal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Part Sun to Light Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-krossa-regal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-krossa-regal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-krossa-regal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hosta-krossa-regal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=247567","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.25,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.23,0.28],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hyacinthus orientalis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hyacinthus-orientalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 8 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hyacinthus orientalis, the species)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281784","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.50 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"},{"name":"RHS Plants (Hyacinthus orientalis, common hyacinth)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/53644/hyacinthus-orientalis/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"},{"name":"UGA Cooperative Extension, Flowering Bulbs for Georgia Gardens B918 (Hyacinthus orientalis row of the spring-flowering bulb table)","url":"https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=B918&title=Flowering+Bulbs+for+Georgia+Gardens","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hyacinthus orientalis Hyacinth H F 4″ 5″ mid* 10″","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":5,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hyacinth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.12,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.08,0.1],"union":[0,0.15],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hyacinthus orientalis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hyacinthus-orientalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 3 in. - 0 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hyacinthus orientalis, the species)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281784","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.25 to 0.50 feet","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"},{"name":"RHS Plants (Hyacinthus orientalis, common hyacinth)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/53644/hyacinthus-orientalis/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0-0.1 metre","metres":[0,0.1],"band":[0,0.1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":5,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hyacinth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hyacinthus orientalis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hyacinthus-orientalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hyacinthus orientalis, the species)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281784","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":5,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hyacinth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hyacinthus orientalis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hyacinthus-orientalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hyacinth grows in organically rich, medium moisture, well-drained soils in full sun to partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hyacinthus orientalis, the species)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281784","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"},{"name":"RHS Plants (Hyacinthus orientalis, common hyacinth)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/53644/hyacinthus-orientalis/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC, Spring-Flowering Bulbs (its Hyacinths section)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/spring-flowering-bulbs/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant hyacinth bulbs in full sun 3 to 6 inches apart and 4 to 6 inches deep.","level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hyacinthus orientalis 'Blue Jacket')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260636","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hyacinthus orientalis 'Woodstock')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256071","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hyacinth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hyacinthus orientalis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hyacinthus-orientalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"funnel-shaped, variously colored, incredibly fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hyacinthus orientalis, the species)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281784","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"},{"name":"RHS Plants (Hyacinthus orientalis, common hyacinth)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/53644/hyacinthus-orientalis/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In spring, produces a dense cylindrical spike of fragrant, waxy, tubular bell-shaped flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"},{"name":"UGA Cooperative Extension, Flowering Bulbs for Georgia Gardens B918 (Hyacinthus orientalis row of the spring-flowering bulb table)","url":"https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=B918&title=Flowering+Bulbs+for+Georgia+Gardens","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Few flowers can boast the extensive color range and fragrance of hyacinths.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC, Spring-Flowering Bulbs (its Hyacinths section)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/spring-flowering-bulbs/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Few flowers can surpass the extensive color range and fragrance of hyacinths.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["hyacinthus orientalis"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (hyacinthus orientalis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (hyacinthus orientalis) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hyacinth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hyacinth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hyacinthus orientalis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hyacinthus-orientalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It tolerates drought, but soils should be kept moist immediately after planting to encourage root growth","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hyacinth","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Hyacinthus orientalis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hyacinthus-orientalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers, which attract bees, are pungently sweet","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hyacinthus orientalis"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-anna-marie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.25,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.18,0.22],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/78826/hyacinthus-orientalis-anna-marie/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Homestead Gardens plant database","url":"https://plants.homesteadgardens.com/12170008/Plant/3258/Anna_Marie_Hyacinth/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"about 8 inches tall at maturity","metres":0.2,"band":[0.18,0.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-anna-marie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.12,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0,0.17],"split":[{"range":[0,0.1],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)"]},{"range":[0.14,0.17],"sources":["Homestead Gardens plant database"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/78826/hyacinthus-orientalis-anna-marie/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"0-0.1 metre","metres":[0,0.1],"band":[0,0.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Homestead Gardens plant database","url":"https://plants.homesteadgardens.com/12170008/Plant/3258/Anna_Marie_Hyacinth/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6 inches","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-anna-marie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-anna-marie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/78826/hyacinthus-orientalis-anna-marie/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"Homestead Gardens plant database","url":"https://plants.homesteadgardens.com/12170008/Plant/3258/Anna_Marie_Hyacinth/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun to partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-anna-marie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/78826/hyacinthus-orientalis-anna-marie/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"fragrant, single pale pink flowers with darker centres, becoming salmon-pink with age","claim":true},{"name":"Homestead Gardens plant database","url":"https://plants.homesteadgardens.com/12170008/Plant/3258/Anna_Marie_Hyacinth/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Beautifully fragrant flower spikes","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-anna-marie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Homestead Gardens plant database","url":"https://plants.homesteadgardens.com/12170008/Plant/3258/Anna_Marie_Hyacinth/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"flowers are excellent for cutting","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-anna-marie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-anna-marie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-blue-jacket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.25,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.23,0.25],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260636","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.50 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/hyacinthus-orientalis-blue-jacket.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8\" to 12\".","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Colorblends","url":"https://www.colorblends.com/wholesale/hyacinths/hyacinth-blue-jacket/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 8-10 inches","metres":[0.2,0.25],"band":[0.2,0.25],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/orientalis-blue-jacket/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 7″-11″","metres":[0.18,0.28],"band":[0.18,0.28],"role":"scored"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/hyacinth-blue-jacket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10 Inches.","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/hyacinth-blue-jacket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 10\" tall","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Van Bourgondien","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/_blue_jacket_hyacinth","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 8 - 12 inches","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/62630/hyacinthus-orientalis-blue-jacket/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder (via Gertens)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/9275/Blue_Jacket_Hyacinth/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"will grow to be about 9 inches tall at maturity extending to 12 inches tall with the flowers","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/blue-jacket-hyacinth-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 8-12 Inches","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Easy To Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/hyacinth-blue-jacket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8-10\"","metres":[0.2,0.25],"band":[0.2,0.25],"role":"scored"},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Hyacinthus-Orientalis-Blue-Jacket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 10 Inches","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-blue-jacket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.12,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0,0.25],"split":[{"range":[0,0.2],"sources":["RHS","Easy To Grow Bulbs","Missouri Botanical Garden","Plant Addicts","ADR Bulbs"]},{"range":[0.21,0.25],"sources":["NetPS Plant Finder (via Gertens)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260636","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.25 to 0.50 feet","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/62630/hyacinthus-orientalis-blue-jacket/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0-0.1 metre","metres":[0,0.1],"band":[0,0.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder (via Gertens)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/9275/Blue_Jacket_Hyacinth/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"with a spread of 9 inches","metres":0.23,"band":[0.21,0.25],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/blue-jacket-hyacinth-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 4-6 Inches","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Easy To Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/hyacinth-blue-jacket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3-4\"","metres":[0.08,0.1],"band":[0.08,0.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Hyacinthus-Orientalis-Blue-Jacket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 6-8 Inches","metres":[0.15,0.2],"band":[0.15,0.2],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-blue-jacket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260636","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hyacinthus-orientalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/hyacinthus-orientalis-blue-jacket.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 4-8.","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Colorblends","url":"https://www.colorblends.com/wholesale/hyacinths/hyacinth-blue-jacket/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Suitable for USDA zones 4a to 8b in the South, 10b on the West Coast.","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/orientalis-blue-jacket/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/hyacinth-blue-jacket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 4-8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/hyacinth-blue-jacket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4 through 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Van Bourgondien","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/_blue_jacket_hyacinth","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 4-9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/blue-jacket-hyacinth-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Easy To Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/hyacinth-blue-jacket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 - 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Hyacinthus-Orientalis-Blue-Jacket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 4-8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-blue-jacket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":12,"distinctPublishers":12,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260636","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hyacinthus-orientalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/hyacinthus-orientalis-blue-jacket.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full to partial sunlight."},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/orientalis-blue-jacket/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun, Part Shade"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/hyacinth-blue-jacket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full Sun/Partial Shade"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/hyacinth-blue-jacket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Sun to Part Shade"},{"name":"Van Bourgondien","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/_blue_jacket_hyacinth","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun, Half Sun / Half Shade"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/62630/hyacinthus-orientalis-blue-jacket/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder (via Gertens)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/9275/Blue_Jacket_Hyacinth/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in full sun to partial shade."},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/blue-jacket-hyacinth-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs Full Sun (6+ Hours Direct Sun)"},{"name":"Easy To Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/hyacinth-blue-jacket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun to Partial Shade"},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Hyacinthus-Orientalis-Blue-Jacket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Location : Full sun to partial shade."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-blue-jacket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260636","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/hyacinth-blue-jacket","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Yes","claim":true},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/hyacinth-blue-jacket","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Richly Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Van Bourgondien","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/_blue_jacket_hyacinth","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This fragrant hyacinth also adds plenty of charm in the garden.","claim":true},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/62630/hyacinthus-orientalis-blue-jacket/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"stiff spikes of fragrant, single deep blue flowers with a dark purple stripe on each petal","claim":true},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder (via Gertens)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/9275/Blue_Jacket_Hyacinth/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"masses of beautiful spikes of fragrant blue bell-shaped flowers with violet overtones","claim":true},{"name":"Easy To Grow Bulbs","url":"https://www.easytogrowbulbs.com/products/hyacinth-blue-jacket","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A fragrant favorite along borders or in containers.","claim":true},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Hyacinthus-Orientalis-Blue-Jacket","country":null,"form":null,"value":"release a strong, sweet fragrance that draws in bees and early pollinators as a valuable nectar source","claim":true}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-blue-jacket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/hyacinth-blue-jacket","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Big Blooms, Great for Cut Flowers, Deer Resistant, Fragrant, Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-blue-jacket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hyacinthus-orientalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#drought tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-blue-jacket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hyacinthus-orientalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attracts polinators","claim":true},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/hyacinth-blue-jacket","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Loved by pollinators","claim":true},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/hyacinth-blue-jacket","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Big Blooms, Great for Cut Flowers, Deer Resistant, Fragrant, Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Van Bourgondien","url":"https://www.dutchbulbs.com/products/_blue_jacket_hyacinth","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Growing 8-12\" tall, it blooms in early to mid-spring and attracts pollinators.","claim":true},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Hyacinthus-Orientalis-Blue-Jacket","country":null,"form":null,"value":"release a strong, sweet fragrance that draws in bees and early pollinators as a valuable nectar source","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-splendid-cornelia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.25,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/165760/hyacinthus-orientalis-splendid-cornelia/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-splendid-cornelia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.12,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/165760/hyacinthus-orientalis-splendid-cornelia/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-splendid-cornelia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-splendid-cornelia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/165760/hyacinthus-orientalis-splendid-cornelia/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-splendid-cornelia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/165760/hyacinthus-orientalis-splendid-cornelia/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-splendid-cornelia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-splendid-cornelia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hyacinth-splendid-cornelia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"hybrid-tea-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.22,1.83],"union":[0.3,2.44],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grow 1 to 8 feet tall and 2 to 6 feet wide depending upon the cultivar, species, or hybrid","metres":[0.3,2.44],"band":[0.3,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden encyclopedia (Rose, Rosa sp.)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/encyclopedia/rose-rosa-sp","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 2’ to 6’ tall, depending on variety","metres":[0.61,1.83],"band":[0.61,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden (Rose Types and Cultivars, hybrid tea section)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/rose-types-and-cultivars","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Shrubs are vigorous growers reaching heights of 2.5 to 6 feet tall.","metres":[0.76,1.83],"band":[0.76,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Growing Roses, hybrid tea class)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/growing-roses/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hybrid tea roses typically grow to 4 to 6 feet tall","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":5,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hybrid-tea-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grow 1 to 8 feet tall and 2 to 6 feet wide depending upon the cultivar, species, or hybrid","metres":[0.61,1.83],"band":[0.61,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":5,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hybrid-tea-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-7","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden encyclopedia (Rose, Rosa sp.)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/encyclopedia/rose-rosa-sp","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness: zones 4 to 7; although many cultivars (particularly hybrid teas, grandifloras and floribundas) are not winter hardy in Iowa","zones":[4,7],"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension, Roses in Georgia: Selecting and Growing Techniques (C1001)","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/C1001/roses-in-georgia-selecting-and-growing-techniques/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Below are a few cultivars that grow well in USDA Hardiness Zones 5 to 10 and AHS Heat Zones 5 to 12.","zones":[5,10],"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":5,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hybrid-tea-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Roses require full sun and organically rich, well-drained, acidic to neutral soils.","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden encyclopedia (Rose, Rosa sp.)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/encyclopedia/rose-rosa-sp","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in full sun and well-drained, moist soil.","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rosa 'Mister Lincoln', a hybrid tea rose)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252281","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rosa 'Dainty Bess', a hybrid tea rose)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252108","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hybrid-tea-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are often fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden encyclopedia (Rose, Rosa sp.)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/encyclopedia/rose-rosa-sp","country":null,"form":null,"value":"roses are both beautiful and fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Growing Roses, hybrid tea class)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/growing-roses/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Many are highly valued for their fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rosa 'Mister Lincoln', a hybrid tea rose)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252281","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rosa 'Dainty Bess', a hybrid tea rose)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252108","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hybrid-tea-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Grow roses in cottage or cutting gardens or use them at the back of a border.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Growing Roses, hybrid tea class)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/growing-roses/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The blooms are produced all season long and last well when cut.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden (Rose Types and Cultivars, hybrid tea section)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/rose-types-and-cultivars","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This makes them great to grow as cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension, Roses in Georgia: Selecting and Growing Techniques (C1001)","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/C1001/roses-in-georgia-selecting-and-growing-techniques/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are the best to use for cut flower arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rosa 'Mister Lincoln', a hybrid tea rose)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252281","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A good cut rose due to fragrance and large bloom size.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hybrid-tea-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hybrid-tea-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#bee friendly","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rosa 'Mister Lincoln', a hybrid tea rose)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252281","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rosa 'Dainty Bess', a hybrid tea rose)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252108","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.22,1.52],"union":[0.91,3.66],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-macrophylla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286874","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/hydrangea-macrophylla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Broadleaf, deciduous shrub, growing to 7 ft tall with spread of 8 ft (2 × 2.5 ft)","metres":2.13,"band":[1.92,2.34],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Bigleaf Hydrangea, Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=401","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 3-6 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Big-leaved hydrangea, Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/big-leaved-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Big-leaved hydrangeas typically grow 3 to 5 feet high and 3 to 5 feet wide.","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"UMass Extension Landscape, Nursery and Urban Forestry Program (Growing Hydrangeas, bigleaf hydrangea section)","url":"https://www.umass.edu/agriculture-food-environment/landscape/fact-sheets/growing-hydrangeas","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing between 3' and 6' high with an equal spread","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Hydrangea Care in South Carolina)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hydrangea-care-in-south-carolina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hydrangeas are deciduous shrubs that grow from 4 to 12 feet in height, depending on the variety.","metres":[1.22,3.66],"band":[1.22,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.91,2.68],"split":[{"range":[0.91,1.83],"sources":["The Morton Arboretum (Big-leaved hydrangea, Hydrangea macrophylla)","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hydrangea macrophylla)","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hydrangea macrophylla)","University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Bigleaf Hydrangea, Hydrangea macrophylla)","UMass Extension Landscape, Nursery and Urban Forestry Program (Growing Hydrangeas, bigleaf hydrangea section)"]},{"range":[2.2,2.68],"sources":["Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Hydrangea macrophylla)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-macrophylla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286874","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/hydrangea-macrophylla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Broadleaf, deciduous shrub, growing to 7 ft tall with spread of 8 ft (2 × 2.5 ft)","metres":2.44,"band":[2.2,2.68],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Bigleaf Hydrangea, Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=401","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 3-6 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Big-leaved hydrangea, Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/big-leaved-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Big-leaved hydrangeas typically grow 3 to 5 feet high and 3 to 5 feet wide.","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"UMass Extension Landscape, Nursery and Urban Forestry Program (Growing Hydrangeas, bigleaf hydrangea section)","url":"https://www.umass.edu/agriculture-food-environment/landscape/fact-sheets/growing-hydrangeas","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing between 3' and 6' high with an equal spread","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["6-11","6-9","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-macrophylla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[6,11],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286874","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 6 to 9","zones":[6,9],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Bigleaf Hydrangea, Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=401","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 6 - 9","zones":[6,9],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Big-leaved hydrangea, Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/big-leaved-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8, Zone 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-macrophylla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Bigleaf hydrangea performs best in areas with dappled sunlight, partial shade, or deep shade.","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286874","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/hydrangea-macrophylla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to part shade, best in moist, well-drained soil amended with organic matter","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Bigleaf Hydrangea, Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=401","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to partial shade; moist, well-drained soil is preferred.","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Big-leaved hydrangea, Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/big-leaved-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Big-leaved hydrangeas grow best in part shade.","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"UMass Extension Landscape, Nursery and Urban Forestry Program (Growing Hydrangeas, bigleaf hydrangea section)","url":"https://www.umass.edu/agriculture-food-environment/landscape/fact-sheets/growing-hydrangeas","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hydrangeas may be grown in either full sun or light dappled shade.","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-macrophylla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286874","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Big-leaved hydrangea, Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/big-leaved-hydrangea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The plants are drought sensitive, so be sure to water during dry periods.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"},{"name":"UMass Extension Landscape, Nursery and Urban Forestry Program (Growing Hydrangeas, bigleaf hydrangea section)","url":"https://www.umass.edu/agriculture-food-environment/landscape/fact-sheets/growing-hydrangeas","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are not very drought tolerant and will not thrive in very dry, sandy soils.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hydrangea macrophylla)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-macrophylla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea macrophylla"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-magical-candle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.22,1.5],"union":[1,2.44],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=442969&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/306261/hydrangea-paniculata-magical-candle-bokraflame-pbr-magical-series/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Plants Nouveau (US introducer of the Magical series for Kolster B.V.)","url":"https://www.plantsnouveau.com/plants/shrubs/hydrangea-magical-candle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 4-5' tall by 4-5' wide","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/magical-candle-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 - 5 feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Cornell University Woody Plants Database","url":"https://woodyplants.cals.cornell.edu/plant/482","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5-8'","metres":[1.52,2.44],"band":[1.52,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-magical-candle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.22,1.5],"union":[1,1.52],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=442969&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/306261/hydrangea-paniculata-magical-candle-bokraflame-pbr-magical-series/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Plants Nouveau (US introducer of the Magical series for Kolster B.V.)","url":"https://www.plantsnouveau.com/plants/shrubs/hydrangea-magical-candle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 4-5' tall by 4-5' wide","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/magical-candle-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4 - 5 feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-magical-candle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=442969&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Plants Nouveau (US introducer of the Magical series for Kolster B.V.)","url":"https://www.plantsnouveau.com/plants/shrubs/hydrangea-magical-candle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/magical-candle-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-magical-candle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=442969&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/306261/hydrangea-paniculata-magical-candle-bokraflame-pbr-magical-series/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full shade, Partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Plants Nouveau (US introducer of the Magical series for Kolster B.V.)","url":"https://www.plantsnouveau.com/plants/shrubs/hydrangea-magical-candle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/magical-candle-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Cornell University Woody Plants Database","url":"https://woodyplants.cals.cornell.edu/plant/482","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun, Part shade, Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-magical-candle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-magical-candle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=442969&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are held on sturdy, upright stems and make excellent fresh cut or dried flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Plants Nouveau (US introducer of the Magical series for Kolster B.V.)","url":"https://www.plantsnouveau.com/plants/shrubs/hydrangea-magical-candle","country":null,"form":null,"value":"make excellent cut flowers for fresh or dried arrangements","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/magical-candle-hydrangea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use for fresh cuts, dried arrangements, home","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-magical-candle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-magical-candle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators and small mammals use this plant for cover.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-oakleaf","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[2.2,2.44],"union":[1,3.05],"voices":11,"distinctPublishers":11,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-quercifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,2.44],"band":[1.22,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286892","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6.00 to 8.00 feet","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/oak-leaved-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Oak-leaved hydrangea grows 4 to 6 feet high and wide at maturity in an upright and irregular form.","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hydrangea-quercifolia-oakleaf-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Oakleaf hydrangea, native to the southeast United States is a stiffly upright shrub that can attain heights of 4 to 6 feet.","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/oakleaf-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These large shrubs can reach 6 to 10 feet tall and spread 3 to 5 feet.","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"UF/IFAS EDIS FPS-259 Hydrangea quercifolia Oakleaf Hydrangea","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP259","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height : 6 to 10 feet","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Alabama Cooperative Extension System","url":"https://www.aces.edu/blog/topics/lawn-garden/hydrangeas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: From 4 to 6 feet high and wide or wider. (Unmanaged plants may reach 8 feet in height.)","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension Service","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/publications/hydrangeas-for-mississippi-gardens","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub grows to 6 to 10 feet tall and has deeply lobed, oak-like, 8-inch leaves, which turn reddish bronze in fall.","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1067","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This deciduous shrub grows to approximately 6 feet tall, featuring deeply lobed, oak-like leaves that can reach up to 8 inches in length.","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"UConn Plant Database","url":"https://plantdatabase.uconn.edu/detail.php?pid=208","country":"US","form":null,"value":"most plants are 4' to 8' tall, but can reach 12'","metres":[1.22,2.44],"band":[1.22,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"UConn Home Garden Education Center hydrangea factsheet","url":"https://homegarden.cahnr.uconn.edu/factsheets/hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It can grow to 8' tall.","metres":2.44,"band":[2.2,2.68],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/8949/hydrangea-quercifolia/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms Nursery","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/oakleaf-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height : 6-8 ft.","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":14},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-oakleaf","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.65,2.01],"union":[0.91,3.05],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-quercifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 4 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,3.05],"band":[1.22,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286892","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 6.00 to 8.00 feet","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/oak-leaved-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Oak-leaved hydrangea grows 4 to 6 feet high and wide at maturity in an upright and irregular form.","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/oakleaf-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These large shrubs can reach 6 to 10 feet tall and spread 3 to 5 feet.","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"UF/IFAS EDIS FPS-259 Hydrangea quercifolia Oakleaf Hydrangea","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP259","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread : 6 to 8 feet","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Alabama Cooperative Extension System","url":"https://www.aces.edu/blog/topics/lawn-garden/hydrangeas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: From 4 to 6 feet high and wide or wider. (Unmanaged plants may reach 8 feet in height.)","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/8949/hydrangea-quercifolia/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms Nursery","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/oakleaf-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width : 6 ft.","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":14},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-oakleaf","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","6-9","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-quercifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286892","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/oak-leaved-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8, Zone 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hydrangea-quercifolia-oakleaf-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5 - 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/oakleaf-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Oakleaf hydrangea is suited for USDA Hardiness Zones 5a-9b.","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"UF/IFAS EDIS FPS-259 Hydrangea quercifolia Oakleaf Hydrangea","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP259","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA hardiness zones: 5B through 9 (Figure 5)","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Alabama Cooperative Extension System","url":"https://www.aces.edu/blog/topics/lawn-garden/hydrangeas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness: Ranges from Zones 5 to 9.","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Piedmont Master Gardeners (Virginia Cooperative Extension)","url":"https://www.piedmontmastergardeners.org/article/oakleaf-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is hardy to zones 6 through 9 with some cultivars hardy to zone 5.","zones":[6,9],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms Nursery","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/oakleaf-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In Zones : 4-9 outdoors","zones":[4,9],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":14},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-oakleaf","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-quercifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286892","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/oak-leaved-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hydrangea-quercifolia-oakleaf-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/oakleaf-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Pick a spot that has partial to almost full shade.","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"UF/IFAS EDIS FPS-259 Hydrangea quercifolia Oakleaf Hydrangea","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP259","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in full sun","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Alabama Cooperative Extension System","url":"https://www.aces.edu/blog/topics/lawn-garden/hydrangeas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ideally suited to shaded locations; cool, well-drained, fertile soil; some cultivars tolerate sun better than others; part shade recommended","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Piedmont Master Gardeners (Virginia Cooperative Extension)","url":"https://www.piedmontmastergardeners.org/article/oakleaf-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight - This shrub can thrive in full to partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"UConn Plant Database","url":"https://plantdatabase.uconn.edu/detail.php?pid=208","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full to partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"UConn Home Garden Education Center hydrangea factsheet","url":"https://homegarden.cahnr.uconn.edu/factsheets/hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Oakleaf hydrangea does well in full sun or partial shade and is the best choice for hot climates.","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/8949/hydrangea-quercifolia/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms Nursery","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/oakleaf-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight : Partial Shade","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-oakleaf","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-quercifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fragrant flowers fade to pink, then tan in the fall.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/oak-leaved-hydrangea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy, fragrant, panicle clusters bloom in midsummer and last into fall, opening white, gradually changing to pink and then brown.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"hydrangea-oakleaf","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-quercifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286892","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms Nursery","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/oakleaf-hydrangea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It looks great in cut bouquets with the colorful leaves in the fall","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"hydrangea-oakleaf","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-quercifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Piedmont Master Gardeners (Virginia Cooperative Extension)","url":"https://www.piedmontmastergardeners.org/article/oakleaf-hydrangea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established, it does appreciate water during very dry conditions.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms Nursery","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/oakleaf-hydrangea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Oakleaf Hydrangeas can even grow in dry soil, so you don't have to constantly water your plants.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-oakleaf","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-quercifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its flowers are attractive to butterflies and other insects. Songbirds eat the seeds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/oakleaf-hydrangea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers and seeds attract pollinators and birds, making these plants excellent for wildlife sightings.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea quercifolia"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"hydrangea-panicle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[3.05,4],"union":[0.61,7.62],"voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8 ft. 0 in. - 25 ft. 0 in.","metres":[2.44,7.62],"band":[2.44,7.62],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286891","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8.00 to 15.00 feet","metres":[2.44,4.57],"band":[2.44,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hydrangea-care-in-south-carolina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"A larger hydrangea that can grow as a 10 to 15 ft shrub or a 25 ft small tree.","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Large, broadleaf, deciduous shrub or small tree, 7-25 ft (2.1-7.6 m) tall, shoots pubescent then glabrous.","metres":[2.13,7.62],"band":[2.13,7.62],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=358&PlantTypeID=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 10-15 Feet","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/panicled-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It ranges in size from dwarf (2 to 3 feet high) to tree-like (15 to 20 feet), depending upon the cultivar.","metres":[0.61,6.1],"band":[0.61,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/hydrangeas-iowa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This is the largest of the shrub-type hydrangeas, sometimes reaching 15 feet or more in height.","metres":4.57,"band":[4.11,5.03],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Rutgers NJAES Cooperative Extension FS1152","url":"https://njaes.rutgers.edu/fs1152/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"If left unpruned, this species becomes a large plant and even approaches small tree status of 15-20' in height with an equal spread.","metres":[4.57,6.1],"band":[4.57,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/8944/hydrangea-paniculata/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 2.5-4 metres","metres":[2.5,4],"band":[2.5,4],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"UConn Plant Database","url":"https://plantdatabase.uconn.edu/detail.php?pid=211","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10' to 20' tall with an equal spread","metres":[3.05,6.1],"band":[3.05,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-panicle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[3.05,3.66],"union":[1.5,7.62],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 6 ft. 0 in. - 25 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.83,7.62],"band":[1.83,7.62],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286891","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 6.00 to 12.00 feet","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=358&PlantTypeID=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width 10-15 Feet","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Rutgers NJAES Cooperative Extension FS1152","url":"https://njaes.rutgers.edu/fs1152/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"If left unpruned, this species becomes a large plant and even approaches small tree status of 15-20' in height with an equal spread.","metres":[4.57,6.1],"band":[4.57,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/8944/hydrangea-paniculata/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"UConn Plant Database","url":"https://plantdatabase.uconn.edu/detail.php?pid=211","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10' to 20' tall with an equal spread","metres":[3.05,6.1],"band":[3.05,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-panicle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286891","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=358&PlantTypeID=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 4 - 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/panicled-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 3, Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/panicle-hydrangeas","country":"US","form":null,"value":"they grow over so much of North America, from chilly USDA zone 3 through balmy USDA zone 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-panicle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286891","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to part shade, best in rich, well-drained, moist soil.","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=358&PlantTypeID=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to partial shade; moist, well-drained soil is preferred.","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/panicled-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/hydrangeas-iowa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Panicle hydrangeas perform best in moist, well-drained soils in full sun to partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/8944/hydrangea-paniculata/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"UConn Plant Database","url":"https://plantdatabase.uconn.edu/detail.php?pid=211","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun to partial shade; best in full sun","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-panicle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/panicled-hydrangea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy, long-pointed, panicle-type flower clusters bloom in midsummer and last into fall with a mild fruity fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Go Botany, Native Plant Trust","url":"https://gobotany.nativeplanttrust.org/species/hydrangea/paniculata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the plant does not have much of an odor, or it has an unpleasant or repellant odor","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"UConn Plant Database","url":"https://plantdatabase.uconn.edu/detail.php?pid=211","country":null,"form":null,"value":"strong scent","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"hydrangea-panicle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/panicle-hydrangeas","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Yes! In fact, they're outstanding as cut flowers, both fresh and dried.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"UConn Plant Database","url":"https://plantdatabase.uconn.edu/detail.php?pid=211","country":null,"form":null,"value":"for cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"hydrangea-panicle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=358&PlantTypeID=8","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerance Dry Sites","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/panicled-hydrangea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Avoid extremely dry sites.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/panicle-hydrangeas","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once they are established, they can survive dry conditions, however, too much hot, dry weather can compromise blooming, so regular watering is recommended for the most and best looking flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-panicle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators and small mammals use this plant for cover.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/panicled-hydrangea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant attracts monarch butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Go Botany, Native Plant Trust","url":"https://gobotany.nativeplanttrust.org/species/hydrangea/paniculata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the masses of showy flowers that attract pollinators but do not produce seed","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"hydrangea-phantom","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.83,2.01],"union":[1.22,3.05],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=443856&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6.00 to 10.00 feet","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Cornell University Woody Plants Database","url":"https://woodyplants.cals.cornell.edu/plant/491","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4-8'","metres":[1.22,2.44],"band":[1.22,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/phantom-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6 - 10 feet","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Hydrangeas Plus (specialist hydrangea nursery)","url":"https://hydrangeasplus.com/products/hydrangea-paniculata-phantom","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Size (feet): 6 x 6","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/phantom-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 6-8 ft","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-phantom","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.83,2.01],"union":[1.22,3.05],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=443856&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 6.00 to 10.00 feet","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/phantom-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 6 - 10 feet","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Hydrangeas Plus (specialist hydrangea nursery)","url":"https://hydrangeasplus.com/products/hydrangea-paniculata-phantom","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Size (feet): 6 x 6","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/phantom-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 4-6 ft","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-phantom","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=443856&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/phantom-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 4-8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/phantom-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In: Zones 4-8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-phantom","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=443856&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Cornell University Woody Plants Database","url":"https://woodyplants.cals.cornell.edu/plant/491","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun, Part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/phantom-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/phantom-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs : Full Sun, Partial Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to part shade, best in rich, well-drained, moist soil.","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-phantom","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-phantom","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=443856&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/phantom-hydrangea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Blooms are excellent for cut flower arrangements or drying.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Hydrangeas Plus (specialist hydrangea nursery)","url":"https://hydrangeasplus.com/products/hydrangea-paniculata-phantom","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flower use: yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-phantom","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-phantom","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://springhillnursery.com/products/phantom-hydrangea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators and small mammals use this plant for cover.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"hydrangea-quick-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.83,2.01],"union":[1.22,2.44],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=442966&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6.00 to 8.00 feet","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Proven Winners ColorChoice (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/hydrangea/quick-fire-panicle-hydrangea-hydrangea-paniculata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6' - 8'","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Cornell University Woody Plants Database","url":"https://woodyplants.cals.cornell.edu/plant/575","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: Shrub 4 to 8 feet","metres":[1.22,2.44],"band":[1.22,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/quick-fire-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 6-8 ft","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/quick-fire-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 6-8 ft","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Hydrangeas Plus (specialist hydrangea nursery)","url":"https://hydrangeasplus.com/products/hydrangea-paniculata-quick-firea%C2%AE","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Size (feet): 6 x 6","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-quick-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.83,2.01],"union":[1.22,2.44],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=442966&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Proven Winners ColorChoice (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/hydrangea/quick-fire-panicle-hydrangea-hydrangea-paniculata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 6' - 8'","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/quick-fire-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 6-8 ft","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/quick-fire-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 6-8 ft","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Hydrangeas Plus (specialist hydrangea nursery)","url":"https://hydrangeasplus.com/products/hydrangea-paniculata-quick-firea%C2%AE","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Size (feet): 6 x 6","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-quick-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=442966&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Proven Winners ColorChoice (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/hydrangea/quick-fire-panicle-hydrangea-hydrangea-paniculata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3a , 3b , 4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b , 9a , 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/quick-fire-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In: Zones 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/quick-fire-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3a - to 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-quick-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=442966&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Proven Winners ColorChoice (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/hydrangea/quick-fire-panicle-hydrangea-hydrangea-paniculata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Sun to Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Cornell University Woody Plants Database","url":"https://woodyplants.cals.cornell.edu/plant/575","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun, Part shade, Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/quick-fire-hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs : Full Sun, Partial Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/quick-fire-hydrangea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full sun, Partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to part shade, best in rich, well-drained, moist soil.","level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-quick-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/quick-fire-hydrangea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cold hardy, Disease resistant, Flowering, Fragrant, Attracts pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-quick-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=442966&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Proven Winners ColorChoice (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/hydrangea/quick-fire-panicle-hydrangea-hydrangea-paniculata","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/quick-fire-hydrangea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long-lasting cut or dried flower arrangements","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Hydrangeas Plus (specialist hydrangea nursery)","url":"https://hydrangeasplus.com/products/hydrangea-paniculata-quick-firea%C2%AE","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flower use: yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-quick-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.thetreecenter.com/quick-fire-hydrangea/","https://naturehills.com/products/quick-fire-hydrangea"]}],"sources":[{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/quick-fire-hydrangea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"this plant is much more drought-resistant than most other hydrangeas","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/quick-fire-hydrangea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, it is quite drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"hydrangea-quick-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners ColorChoice (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/hydrangea/quick-fire-panicle-hydrangea-hydrangea-paniculata","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/quick-fire-hydrangea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-paniculata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators and small mammals use this plant for cover.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hydrangea paniculata"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"ice-plant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.03,0.17],"split":[{"range":[0.03,0.08],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Delosperma, genus entry)"]},{"range":[0.14,0.17],"sources":["Texas Tech University Plant Database, Herbaceous Plant Finder (Hardy Ice Plant)","Colorado State University Extension, Pueblo County (Delosperma sp. - Ice Plant)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Delosperma, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delosperma/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 1 in. - 0 ft. 3 in.","metres":[0.03,0.08],"band":[0.03,0.08],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"delosperma"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database, Herbaceous Plant Finder (Hardy Ice Plant)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Delosperma_cooperi.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6 inches","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"delosperma"},{"name":"Colorado State University Extension, Pueblo County (Delosperma sp. - Ice Plant)","url":"https://pueblo.extension.colostate.edu/uncommon-summer-blooming-xeric-plants-to-consider-for-your-dryscape/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Landscape specimens grow to a height of up to 6 inches, spreading to 36 inches.","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"delosperma"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":13,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":7,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 13 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ice-plant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.27,1],"split":[{"range":[0.27,0.33],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Delosperma, genus entry)","Texas Tech University Plant Database, Herbaceous Plant Finder (Hardy Ice Plant)"]},{"range":[0.82,1],"sources":["Colorado State University Extension, Pueblo County (Delosperma sp. - Ice Plant)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Delosperma, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delosperma/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"delosperma"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database, Herbaceous Plant Finder (Hardy Ice Plant)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Delosperma_cooperi.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12 inches","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"delosperma"},{"name":"Colorado State University Extension, Pueblo County (Delosperma sp. - Ice Plant)","url":"https://pueblo.extension.colostate.edu/uncommon-summer-blooming-xeric-plants-to-consider-for-your-dryscape/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Landscape specimens grow to a height of up to 6 inches, spreading to 36 inches.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"delosperma"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":12,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":7,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 12 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ice-plant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Delosperma, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delosperma/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[5,8],"level":"genus","taxon":"delosperma"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database, Herbaceous Plant Finder (Hardy Ice Plant)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Delosperma_cooperi.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: zones 5 - 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"delosperma"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":12,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":7,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 12 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ice-plant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Delosperma, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delosperma/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"delosperma"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Delosperma cooperi)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delosperma-cooperi/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"delosperma cooperi"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Delosperma nubigenum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delosperma-nubigenum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"delosperma nubigenum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma cooperi)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275479","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"delosperma cooperi"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma cooperi 'Jewel of Desert Peridot')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=439364","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"delosperma cooperi"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma cooperi 'WOWDAY2' WHEELS OF WONDER FIRE WONDER)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=444148","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"delosperma cooperi"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma floribundum 'Starburst')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256464","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"delosperma floribundum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma 'John Proffitt')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256465","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma 'Kelaidis')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264022","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"delosperma cooperi"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma nubigenum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275482","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"delosperma nubigenum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma 'Orange Crush')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=439690","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma rogersii 'Mini Wine')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293307","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"delosperma rogersii"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database, Herbaceous Plant Finder (Hardy Ice Plant)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Delosperma_cooperi.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"delosperma"},{"name":"Portland Nursery plant library (Delosperma: Ice Plant)","url":"https://www.portlandnursery.com/groundcovers/delosperma","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun is ideal, but a few hours of shade is tolerable.","level":"genus","taxon":"delosperma"},{"name":"Mountain Crest Gardens (Delosperma cooperi, Trailing Ice Plant)","url":"https://mountaincrestgardens.com/delosperma-cooperi-trailing-ice-plant/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Delosperma are easy, frost hardy plants that thrive outdoors with full sun and great drainage.","level":"species","taxon":"delosperma cooperi"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Delosperma cooperi)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/67143/delosperma-cooperi/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"delosperma cooperi"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ice-plant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ice-plant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ice-plant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Delosperma, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delosperma/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They bloom June through October, and the plant is very drought and heat-tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"delosperma"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Delosperma cooperi)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delosperma-cooperi/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is tolerant of heat, moderately salt-tolerant and very drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"delosperma cooperi"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Delosperma nubigenum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delosperma-nubigenum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good drought tolerance and moderately salt tolerant with the ability of being grown in colder climates.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"delosperma nubigenum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma cooperi)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275479","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"delosperma cooperi"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma cooperi 'Jewel of Desert Peridot')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=439364","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"delosperma cooperi"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma cooperi 'WOWDAY2' WHEELS OF WONDER FIRE WONDER)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=444148","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"delosperma cooperi"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma floribundum 'Starburst')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256464","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"delosperma floribundum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma 'John Proffitt')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256465","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma 'Kelaidis')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264022","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"delosperma cooperi"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma nubigenum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275482","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"delosperma nubigenum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma 'Orange Crush')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=439690","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma rogersii 'Mini Wine')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293307","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"delosperma rogersii"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database, Herbaceous Plant Finder (Hardy Ice Plant)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Delosperma_cooperi.php","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water: low water requirement drought-tolerant","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"delosperma"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture Cooperative Extension Service, Plant of the Week (Ice Plant)","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/ice-plants-7-26-13.aspx","country":null,"form":null,"value":"more water may be needed than you would think necessary for this drought tolerant species","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"delosperma cooperi"},{"name":"Portland Nursery plant library (Delosperma: Ice Plant)","url":"https://www.portlandnursery.com/groundcovers/delosperma","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Though drought tolerant, all species would prefer regular watering during the blooming season.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"delosperma"},{"name":"Mountain Crest Gardens (Delosperma cooperi, Trailing Ice Plant)","url":"https://mountaincrestgardens.com/delosperma-cooperi-trailing-ice-plant/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"mature Delosperma can tolerate several months of drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"delosperma cooperi"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Delosperma cooperi)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/67143/delosperma-cooperi/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"delosperma cooperi"}],"note":"17 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ice-plant","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Delosperma, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delosperma/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"delosperma"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Delosperma nubigenum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/delosperma-nubigenum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"delosperma nubigenum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Delosperma cooperi 'Jewel of Desert Peridot')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=439364","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"delosperma cooperi"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Database, Herbaceous Plant Finder (Hardy Ice Plant)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Delosperma_cooperi.php","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its resilience to heat and drought make it a tough landscape plant, while its showy flowers make it attractive to pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"delosperma"},{"name":"Colorado State University Extension, Pueblo County (Delosperma sp. - Ice Plant)","url":"https://pueblo.extension.colostate.edu/uncommon-summer-blooming-xeric-plants-to-consider-for-your-dryscape/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It interfaces with wildlife through attracting butterflies, but it is deer and rabbit resistant.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"delosperma"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"iceberg-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.22],"union":[0.5,1.67],"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252207","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-iceberg-schneewittchen-korbin/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/70467/rosa-iceberg-korbin-f/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/roses/roses-types","country":"US","form":null,"value":"'Iceberg': Pure white, double flowers carried in large clusters on upright plants growing to about 3 feet tall.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/floribundas-small-landscape-shrubs/iceberg/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 3-4ft","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/iceberg-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 3-4 ft","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Antique Rose Emporium","url":"https://www.antiqueroseemporium.com/products/iceberg","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/iceberg-floribunda-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 4 - 5 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Palatine Roses","url":"https://palatinefruit.com/product/iceberg-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"this gorgeous shrub rose has glossy light green leaves and grows upwards of 5′ tall","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/rosa-iceberg-shrub-roses/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height & Spread: 3-4' x 3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/roses/iceberg-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature height 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"iceberg-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1],"union":[0.5,1.22],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252207","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-iceberg-schneewittchen-korbin/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/70467/rosa-iceberg-korbin-f/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/floribundas-small-landscape-shrubs/iceberg/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 3-4ft","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/iceberg-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 3-4 ft","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/iceberg-floribunda-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 3 - 4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/rosa-iceberg-shrub-roses/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height & Spread: 3-4' x 3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/roses/iceberg-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"iceberg-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","5-11","5-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252207","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-iceberg-schneewittchen-korbin/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/iceberg-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 5a - to 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Antique Rose Emporium","url":"https://www.antiqueroseemporium.com/products/iceberg","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Climate Zones: zone 5, zone 6, zone 7, zone 8, zone 9, zone 10, zone 11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/iceberg-floribunda-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 5 - 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"iceberg-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252207","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-iceberg-schneewittchen-korbin/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in full sun to partial shade in well-drained fertile soil.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/70467/rosa-iceberg-korbin-f/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/iceberg-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/iceberg-floribunda-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Full Sun (At Least 6 Hours Of Direct Sunlight)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/rosa-iceberg-shrub-roses/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/roses/iceberg-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirements full sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"iceberg-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"strengths":["light"],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252207","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-iceberg-schneewittchen-korbin/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Abundant clusters of semi-double mildly fragrant white blooms are produced spring through frost.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/70467/rosa-iceberg-korbin-f/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A free-flowering bushy small shrub with glossy light green foliage and clusters of slightly fragrant, double white flowers to 8cm wide in summer and autumn.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/floribundas-small-landscape-shrubs/iceberg/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pure white, double blooms in clusters, freely flowering and fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/iceberg-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Antique Rose Emporium","url":"https://www.antiqueroseemporium.com/products/iceberg","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant: Yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/iceberg-floribunda-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"near a walkway to enjoy its subtle honey fragrance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/rosa-iceberg-shrub-roses/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The pleasantly fragrant blooms appear in clusters and will reappear throughout the growing season.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/roses/iceberg-rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Iceberg Rose is bathed in stunning fragrant pink flowers at the ends of the branches from early summer to mid fall.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"iceberg-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-iceberg-schneewittchen-korbin/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Long Bloom Season Showy","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/70467/rosa-iceberg-korbin-f/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Suggested planting locations and garden types City and courtyard gardens Cottage and informal garden Cut flowers Flower borders and beds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/iceberg-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Any garden becomes a pollinator garden and cut flower border with a creamy white flush of blooms!","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Antique Rose Emporium","url":"https://www.antiqueroseemporium.com/products/iceberg","country":null,"form":null,"value":"clustered blooms of white may appear light pink in the cooler months and are wonderful for cutting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/iceberg-floribunda-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features: Attracts Pollinators, Cut Flowers, Fragrant, Low Maintenance, Continuous Blooming or Rebloomer","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/roses/iceberg-rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"iceberg-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"iceberg-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252207","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/iceberg-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cold hardy, Low Maintenance, Flowering, Reblooming, Disease resistant, Attracts pollinators, Heat Tolerant, Container Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/iceberg-floribunda-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/rosa-iceberg-shrub-roses/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracting birds and butterflies as well as homo sapiens, it does best in Sunset Western Garden zones 4-24 in full sun to partial shade.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"impatiens","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":3,"genus":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.50 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plants commonly grow 12 to 18 inches tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"impatiens","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":3,"genus":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.50 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"impatiens","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"CONVENTION","wouldPropose":[10,11],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Impatiens walleriana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/impatiens-walleriana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[10,11],"level":"species","taxon":"impatiens walleriana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Impatiens walleriana)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263721","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11],"level":"species","taxon":"impatiens walleriana"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":3,"genus":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source states 10-11 and this row deliberately stores no zones, which is the library's way of saying \"grown everywhere\" (docs/CATALOG-AUDIT.md records the two zone conventions for annuals as expected). Nothing is proposed: writing a zone range onto a zone-less row would remove it from every zone filter outside that range, and this is one library-wide decision rather than a per-plant error; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"impatiens","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Impatiens walleriana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/impatiens-walleriana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Impatiens perform best in part shade to full shade.","level":"species","taxon":"impatiens walleriana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Impatiens walleriana)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263721","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"impatiens walleriana"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Impatiens, including the Impatiens walleriana section)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/impatiens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Many older types of impatiens thrive in filtered or partial shade and must have protection from hot afternoon sun to maintain their colors.","level":"genus","taxon":"impatiens"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Impatiens sp.)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=17&PlantTypeID=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Sun/Shade","level":"genus","taxon":"impatiens"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Impatiens walleriana Beacon Bright Red)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/impatiens/beacon-bright-red-walleriana-impatiens-impatiens-walleriana","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Shade to Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"impatiens walleriana"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden (Impatiens walleriana)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/growing-impatiens-home-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Impatiens perform best in moist, well-drained soils in partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"impatiens walleriana"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"impatiens","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"impatiens","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"impatiens","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Impatiens walleriana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/impatiens-walleriana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant has low drought tolerance and is hardy in zones 10 to 11.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"impatiens walleriana"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"impatiens","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Impatiens walleriana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/impatiens-walleriana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and pollinators. Deer like to browse the plants.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"impatiens walleriana"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"impatiens-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0.5 to 2 feet tall and equally as wide\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0.50 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"impatiens-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0.5 to 2 feet tall and equally as wide\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0.50 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"impatiens-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"CONVENTION","wouldPropose":[10,11],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/impatiens-walleriana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a586","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10 to 11","zones":[10,11]}],"note":"every source states 10-11 and this row deliberately stores no zones, which is the library's way of saying \"grown everywhere\" (docs/CATALOG-AUDIT.md records the two zone conventions for annuals as expected). Nothing is proposed: writing a zone range onto a zone-less row would remove it from every zone filter outside that range, and this is one library-wide decision rather than a per-plant error","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"impatiens-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/impatiens-walleriana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Impatiens perform best in part shade to full shade. They may grow in partly sunny areas when they have adequate water, but too much sun may scorch the leaves."},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a586","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part shade to full shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"impatiens-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"impatiens-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"impatiens-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/impatiens-walleriana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant has low drought tolerance","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"impatiens-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/impatiens-walleriana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"iris-bearded","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.3,1.22],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Iris germanica)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281085","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Iris x germanica)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/iris-x-germanica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,1.22],"band":[0.3,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Iris germanica)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/9256/iris-germanica/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":2},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"iris-bearded","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.5],"union":[0.1,0.61],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Iris germanica)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281085","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Iris x germanica)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/iris-x-germanica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Iris germanica)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/9256/iris-germanica/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":2},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"iris-bearded","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[3,10],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Iris germanica)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281085","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 10","zones":[3,10],"level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"},{"name":"Penn State Extension (German bearded iris, Iris x germanica)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/german-bearded-iris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is an herbaceous perennial flower that thrives in USDA Plant Hardiness Zones 3-10.","zones":[3,10],"level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":2},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source states 3-10; catalog states 3-9","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"iris-bearded","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Iris germanica)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281085","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Iris x germanica)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/iris-x-germanica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Iris germanica)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/9256/iris-germanica/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"},{"name":"Penn State Extension (German bearded iris, Iris x germanica)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/german-bearded-iris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This iris prefers a site in full sun.","level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension (Growing Iris, bearded iris)","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/growing-iris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Irises need full sunshine.","level":"genus","taxon":"iris"},{"name":"Illinois Extension (Growing irises, bearded iris)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/prairies-perennials/2020-05-28-growing-irises-how-plant-grow-and-care-iris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They grow best in well-drained soil in a full sun location.","level":"genus","taxon":"iris"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"iris-bearded","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Iris germanica)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281085","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Iris x germanica)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/iris-x-germanica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"With a generally tall stature, this showy iris has large fragrant blooms rising as much as 3 feet above the leaves on single naked stems.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Iris germanica)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/9256/iris-germanica/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Large, showy, fragrant flowers come in a wide range of colours and shades and appear from May to June","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"iris-bearded","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Iris x germanica)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/iris-x-germanica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bearded iris makes a great addition to a cutting garden, mass planted in a naturalized area or woodland garden, in the middle of a border, or alongside a walkway or patio.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"},{"name":"Penn State Extension (German bearded iris, Iris x germanica)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/german-bearded-iris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Add cultivars to a cutting garden, as German bearded irises make great cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"iris-bearded","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Iris germanica)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281085","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Iris x germanica)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/iris-x-germanica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are quite drought tolerant and very resistant to browsing by deer.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"},{"name":"Penn State Extension (German bearded iris, Iris x germanica)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/german-bearded-iris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, the German iris is drought-tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension (Growing Iris, bearded iris)","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/growing-iris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bearded irises live through severe droughts and cold.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"iris"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Bearded Iris, Iris germanica)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/bearded-iris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Also remember that irises are extremely drought tolerant and care should be taken not to overwater them.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"iris-bearded","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Penn State Extension (German bearded iris, Iris x germanica)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/german-bearded-iris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinators love it!","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"iris germanica"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ironweed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,3.05],"union":[0.51,3.66],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center, Ironweed","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/ironweed/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Depending on the species, ironweed can reach 3 to 12 feet tall with a spread of 3 to 6 feet.","metres":[0.91,3.66],"band":[0.91,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"vernonia"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide, Ironweeds (Vernonia spp.)","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/ironweeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: prairie ironweed ( V. fasciculata ) may flower at only 20 inches tall, but tall ironweed ( V. gigantea ) can reach nearly 10 feet.","metres":[0.51,3.05],"band":[0.51,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"vernonia"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":28,"levels":{"species":25,"cultivar":4,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 28 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ironweed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center, Ironweed","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/ironweed/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Depending on the species, ironweed can reach 3 to 12 feet tall with a spread of 3 to 6 feet.","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"vernonia"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":18,"levels":{"species":25,"cultivar":4,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 18 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ironweed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":23,"levels":{"species":25,"cultivar":4,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 23 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ironweed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia noveboracensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-noveboracensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"vernonia noveboracensis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia lettermannii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-lettermannii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"vernonia lettermannii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia gigantea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-gigantea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"vernonia gigantea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia angustifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-angustifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"vernonia angustifolia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia glauca)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-glauca/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"vernonia glauca"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia lettermannii 'Iron Butterfly')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-lettermannii-iron-butterfly/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"vernonia lettermannii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia arkansana)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277605&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"vernonia arkansana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia baldwinii)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277584&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"vernonia baldwinii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia fasciculata)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277257&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"vernonia fasciculata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia gigantea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277606&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"vernonia gigantea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia lettermanii)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=365809&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"vernonia lettermanii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia lettermanii 'Iron Butterfly')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=440996&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"vernonia lettermanii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia missurica)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277486&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"vernonia missurica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia noveboracensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277487&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"vernonia noveboracensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia 'Prairie Princess')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=458454&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia 'Southern Cross')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299917&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Vernonia gigantea)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=VEGI","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade , Shade","level":"species","taxon":"vernonia gigantea"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center, Ironweed","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/ironweed/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant ironweed in moist, organically rich soil in full sun to partial shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"vernonia"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension Home & Garden Information Center, New York Ironweed","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/new-york-ironweed","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: full sun to partial sun","level":"species","taxon":"vernonia noveboracensis"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Vernonia fasciculata)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=892&PlantTypeID=14","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun; moist, well drained to wet soils.","level":"species","taxon":"vernonia fasciculata"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service, Plant of the Week: Vernonia lettermannii","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/Vernonia-lettermannii-Threadleaf-Ironweed-08-19-2016.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It should be grown in full sun in any reasonable garden soil.","level":"species","taxon":"vernonia lettermannii"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery (Vernonia fasciculata)","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/ironweed-vernonia-fasciculata.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"vernonia fasciculata"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Vernonia noveboracensis)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/vernonia-noveboracensis.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"vernonia noveboracensis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ironweed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-noveboracensis/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-lettermannii/"]},{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-noveboracensis/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-gigantea/"]},{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-noveboracensis/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-angustifolia/"]},{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-noveboracensis/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-glauca/"]},{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-noveboracensis/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-lettermannii-iron-butterfly/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia noveboracensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-noveboracensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia noveboracensis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia lettermannii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-lettermannii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia lettermannii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia gigantea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-gigantea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia gigantea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia angustifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-angustifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia angustifolia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia glauca)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-glauca/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia glauca"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia lettermannii 'Iron Butterfly')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-lettermannii-iron-butterfly/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"vernonia lettermannii"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 6 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are ncsu.edu. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 6","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ironweed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia noveboracensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-noveboracensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia noveboracensis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia lettermannii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-lettermannii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia lettermannii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia glauca)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-glauca/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia glauca"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension Home & Garden Information Center, New York Ironweed","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/new-york-ironweed","country":null,"form":null,"value":"After seed dispersal, the stems are beautiful in dried arrangements or useful as light-weight garden stakes.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia noveboracensis"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Vernonia noveboracensis)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/vernonia-noveboracensis.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia noveboracensis"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"ironweed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia lettermannii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-lettermannii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, it will tolerate occasional flooding and drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia lettermannii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia angustifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-angustifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It needs well-drained sandy soil and is drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia angustifolia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia glauca)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-glauca/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought Insect Pests","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia glauca"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia lettermannii 'Iron Butterfly')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-lettermannii-iron-butterfly/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant once established and poor soil tolerant so do not over-fertilize.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"vernonia lettermannii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia baldwinii)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277584&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia baldwinii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia lettermanii)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=365809&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia lettermanii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia lettermanii 'Iron Butterfly')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=440996&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"vernonia lettermanii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia 'Prairie Princess')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=458454&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil, Black Walnut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia 'Southern Cross')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299917&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil, Black Walnut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Toadshade Wildflower Farm (Vernonia noveboracensis)","url":"https://www.toadshade.com/Vernonia-noveboracensis.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"drought and clay tolerant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia noveboracensis"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["vernonia fasciculata"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (vernonia fasciculata), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"10 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (vernonia fasciculata) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ironweed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia noveboracensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-noveboracensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to butterflies, bees and other pollinators. Songbirds eat the seeds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia noveboracensis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia lettermannii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-lettermannii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia lettermannii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia gigantea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-gigantea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia gigantea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia angustifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-angustifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Hummingbirds Pollinators Specialized Bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia angustifolia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia glauca)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-glauca/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Provides an excellent source of nectar for butterflies and bees in late summer and early fall.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia glauca"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Vernonia lettermannii 'Iron Butterfly')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vernonia-lettermannii-iron-butterfly/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"vernonia lettermannii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia arkansana)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277605&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are very attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia arkansana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia baldwinii)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277584&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are very attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia baldwinii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia fasciculata)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277257&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are very attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia fasciculata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia gigantea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277606&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are very attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia gigantea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia lettermanii)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=365809&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Highly attractive to hummingbirds, butterflies, and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia lettermanii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia lettermanii 'Iron Butterfly')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=440996&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"vernonia lettermanii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia missurica)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277486&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are very attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia missurica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia 'Prairie Princess')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=458454&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Vernonia 'Southern Cross')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299917&isprofile=0&basic=Vernonia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Vernonia noveboracensis)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=VENO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds , Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia noveboracensis"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Vernonia gigantea)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=VEGI","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use Wildlife: Bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia gigantea"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center, Vernonia trial report","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/vernonia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Ironweeds are hubs of ecological activity and can boost the garden’s capacity to provide pollen and nectar to late season pollinators, to host caterpillars and other insects, and to feed winter birds with their seeds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"vernonia"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center, Ironweed","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/ironweed/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Ironweed is a host plant for American Lady Butterflies and Crossline Skippers and a nectar source for Fiery Skippers, Swallowtails, and Monarchs.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"vernonia"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide, Ironweeds (Vernonia spp.)","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/ironweeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The large, flat-topped clusters of intense purple flowers attract a wide array of bees, beetles, flies, butterflies, skippers, and other insects.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"vernonia"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide, Missouri Ironweed","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/missouri-ironweed","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The large, flat-topped clusters of intense purple flowers attract a wide array of bees, beetles, flies, butterflies, skippers, and other insects.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia missurica"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension Home & Garden Information Center, New York Ironweed","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/new-york-ironweed","country":null,"form":null,"value":"An excellent choice for the pollinator garden, attracting a nice diversity of bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia noveboracensis"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service, Plant of the Week: Vernonia lettermannii","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/Vernonia-lettermannii-Threadleaf-Ironweed-08-19-2016.aspx","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies, skippers and moths all favor the plant when in bloom.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia lettermannii"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery (Vernonia fasciculata)","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/ironweed-vernonia-fasciculata.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The intense purple bloom color stands out in the late summer landscape, attracting many butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia fasciculata"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Vernonia fasciculata)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/vernonia-fasciculata-common-ironweed","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Ironweed is a host plant for the American Painted Lady butterfly and is listed by the Xerces Society as having special value to native bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia fasciculata"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Vernonia gigantea)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/vernonia-gigantea-tall-ironweed","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plant Ironweed to attract pollinators because it serves as a late-season nectar source.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia gigantea"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Vernonia missurica)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/vernonia-missurica-missouri-ironweed","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a great way to attract pollinators because it serves as a late-season nectar source.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia missurica"},{"name":"Toadshade Wildflower Farm (Vernonia noveboracensis)","url":"https://www.toadshade.com/Vernonia-noveboracensis.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attracts butterflies and native bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia noveboracensis"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (Vernonia noveboracensis)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/vernonia-noveboracensis.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vernonia noveboracensis"}],"note":"29 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":12,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 40.00 to 70.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 40 ft. 0 in. - 70 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page's figure is a 10 to 10 year size and this row's is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"slowly moderate to eventually towering upwards of 60- to 80-feet tall\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 10.00 to 20.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-10","7-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279588&isprofile=0&basic=Cupressus+sempervirens","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 7 to 10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cupressus-sempervirens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants","url":"https://www.public.asu.edu/~camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/cupressussempervirens.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA 7-11 (semi arid and arid regions only)","zones":[7,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279588&isprofile=0&basic=Cupressus+sempervirens","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cupressus-sempervirens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants","url":"https://www.public.asu.edu/~camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/cupressussempervirens.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279588&isprofile=0&basic=Cupressus+sempervirens","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Foliage is aromatic when crushed.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cupressus-sempervirens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The scale-like leaves are a dark blue-green, with a delightful fragrance when crushed.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279588&isprofile=0&basic=Cupressus+sempervirens","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates some drought once established.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cupressus-sempervirens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Becoming highly drought tolerant as the plant ages, young plants should receive adequate watering until established.","claim":true},{"name":"American Conifer Society conifer database","url":"https://conifersociety.org/conifers/cupressus-sempervirens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The species is also tolerant to drought, air currents, wind dust, sleet and atmospheric gases.","claim":true},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/cupressus-sempervirens","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sun, drought tolerant.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress-glauca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":12,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"40.00 to 60.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"60 to 80 ft. tall\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress-glauca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"5.00 to 10.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"4 to 6 ft. wide\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress-glauca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244175","country":"US","form":null,"value":"7 to 10","zones":[7,10]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress-glauca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244175","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/blue-italian-cypress.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress-glauca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress-glauca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress-glauca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244175","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates some drought once established","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress-glauca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress-tiny-tower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/cupressus-sempervirens-tiny-tower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Very slow growth; 8 feet high after 10 years.","metres":2.44,"band":[2.2,2.68],"role":"scored"}],"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"very slow growing to 25 to 30 ft tall and 3 ft wide\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 20-25′\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 30 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress-tiny-tower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"very slow growing to 25 to 30 ft tall and 3 ft wide\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Width: 2 - 3 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 3′\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 3 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress-tiny-tower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Cupressus sempervirens)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cupressus-sempervirens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/cupressus-sempervirens-tiny-tower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: Zones 7 - 10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Mid Valley Trees","url":"https://midvalleytrees.com/product/tiny-tower-italian-cypress/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 7-10","zones":[7,10]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress-tiny-tower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Cupressus sempervirens)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cupressus-sempervirens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/cupressus-sempervirens-tiny-tower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs: Full Sun"},{"name":"Mid Valley Trees","url":"https://midvalleytrees.com/product/tiny-tower-italian-cypress/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure: Full Sun"},{"name":"Roger's Gardens (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.rogersgardens.com/12290002/Plant/24869/Tiny_Tower_Italian_Cypress","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This tree should only be grown in full sunlight."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress-tiny-tower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress-tiny-tower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress-tiny-tower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/cupressus-sempervirens-tiny-tower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Only needs occasionally watering once established.","claim":true},{"name":"Mid Valley Trees","url":"https://midvalleytrees.com/product/tiny-tower-italian-cypress/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistant to pests and disease, drought tolerant once established.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"italian-cypress-tiny-tower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"jacobs-ladder","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":21,"levels":{"species":14,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 21 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"jacobs-ladder","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":14,"levels":{"species":14,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 14 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"jacobs-ladder","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":15,"levels":{"species":14,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 15 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"jacobs-ladder","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Polemonium caeruleum","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285421","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"polemonium caeruleum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Polemonium reptans","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285442","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade","level":"species","taxon":"polemonium reptans"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Polemonium reptans 'Stairway to Heaven'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=358477","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"polemonium reptans"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Polemonium 'Heaven Scent'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=371954","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Polemonium 'Lace Towers'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261656","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Polemonium caeruleum 'Snow and Sapphires'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250038","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"polemonium caeruleum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Polemonium 'Bressingham Purple'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256553","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Polemonium caeruleum 'Blanjou' BRISE D'ANJOU","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252569","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"polemonium caeruleum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Polemonium yezoense 'Kaleidoscope'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=444063","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"polemonium yezoense"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Polemonium reptans","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/polemonium-reptans/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"polemonium reptans"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide - Polemonium reptans","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/jacobs-ladder","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Jacob's ladder is a good native plant for flower gardens; it prefers rich, medium-moist soil and partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"polemonium reptans"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum - Polemonium reptans","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/jacobs-ladder/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily), Full shade (4 hrs or less of light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"polemonium reptans"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers - Polemonium reptans","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=870&PlantTypeID=14","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Partial Sun/Shade","level":"species","taxon":"polemonium reptans"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery - Polemonium reptans","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/polemonium-reptans/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Shade to Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"polemonium reptans"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center - Polemonium reptans","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/jacobs-ladder/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Jacob's-ladder thrives in partial shade in moist, well-drained soils.","level":"species","taxon":"polemonium reptans"},{"name":"RHS - Polemonium caeruleum","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/13380/polemonium-caeruleum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"polemonium caeruleum"},{"name":"RHS - Polemonium reptans","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/13391/polemonium-reptans/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"polemonium reptans"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"jacobs-ladder","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are missouribotanicalgarden.org","urls":["https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=371954","https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261656"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Polemonium 'Heaven Scent'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=371954","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Polemonium 'Lace Towers'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261656","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["polemonium caeruleum","polemonium reptans"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (polemonium caeruleum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus","this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (polemonium reptans), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are missouribotanicalgarden.org. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover 2 taxa and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"jacobs-ladder","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"jacobs-ladder","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":4,"covered":["polemonium reptans"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (polemonium reptans), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 4 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (polemonium reptans) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"jacobs-ladder","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":6,"covered":["polemonium reptans"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (polemonium reptans), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 6 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (polemonium reptans) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"james-galway","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[3.29,3.66],"union":[2.44,4.03],"proposed":3.48,"margin":38.5,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/james-galway-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"12ft","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/james-galway","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"8' - 12' x 4' - 5'","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/james-galway","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Approximately 10-12+ ft when trained","metres":[3.05,3.66],"band":[3.05,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/james-galway-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"12 feet","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/james-galway-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"12ft (3.75m)","metres":3.75,"band":[3.38,4.13],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (2.44 to 4.03 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"james-galway","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.82,1.52],"split":[{"range":[0.82,1],"sources":["Menagerie Farm & Flower"]},{"range":[1.22,1.52],"sources":["Heirloom Roses","Grace Rose Farm"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/james-galway","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"8' - 12' x 4' - 5'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/james-galway","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Approximately 4-5 ft","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/james-galway-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"james-galway","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-11","5-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/james-galway-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zones 4-11"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/james-galway","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zone 4-11"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/james-galway","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"5-11"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/james-galway-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"5-11"}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"james-galway","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/james-galway-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight / Partial Shade"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/james-galway-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"North, East, South, West Facing; Full Sunlight / Partial Shade"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/james-galway","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Partial Shade or Full Sun - Tolerates some shade, needing only 4+ hours of direct sun to thrive"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/james-galway","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"james-galway","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/james-galway-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Light-medium, Old Rose"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/james-galway-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Light-medium, Old Rose"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/james-galway","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Moderately Fragrant, a delicious, old rose fragrance"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/james-galway","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Medium Old Rose fragrance"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/james-galway-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Mild - Old Rose"}],"note":"sources rate it medium/light","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"james-galway","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.thornless","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/james-galway","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Nearly Thornless - long, slightly arching, almost thorn-less growth","polarity":"thornless"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/james-galway","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Nearly thornless canes","polarity":"thornless"}],"note":"2 sources describe reduced thorniness (2 of them call it thornless) but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"james-l-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/james-l-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/james-l-austin","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4ft (125cm)","metres":1.25,"band":[1.13,1.38],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":2},"reasons":[]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) remain once the same publisher's non-US figure is set aside","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"james-l-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/james-l-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3ft","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/james-l-austin","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3 1/2ft (110cm)","metres":1.1,"band":[0.99,1.21],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":2},"reasons":[]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) remain once the same publisher's non-US figure is set aside","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"james-l-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/james-l-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":2},"reasons":[]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"james-l-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/james-l-austin","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/james-l-austin"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/james-l-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/james-l-austin","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"james-l-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["light","light"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/james-l-austin","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/james-l-austin"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/james-l-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There is a light-medium strength fruity fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/james-l-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There is a light-medium strength fruity fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"james-l-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"james-l-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"james-l-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"japanese-anemone","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.76],"union":[0.46,1.83],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286105","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.46,0.76],"band":[0.46,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eriocapitella hupehensis, syn. Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eriocapitella-hupehensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.46,0.76],"band":[0.46,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"eriocapitella hupehensis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Japanese anemone, Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-anemone/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Large, rounded mounds of foliage topped by branching, wiry flower stems reaching 2 to 4 feet high and 2 feet wide","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"RHS (Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/1231/anemone-hupehensis/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Anemone x hybrida)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/anemone-honorine-jobert/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The glossy basal foliage only grows 12 to 18 inches tall, but when in bloom the plants are typically 3 to 4 feet tall.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone hybrida"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Anemone x hybrida)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=703&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 2-3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone hybrida"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide (Anemone hupehensis var. japonica)","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/japanese-anemone-anemone-hupehensis-var-japonica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height : 3 to 6 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"species":8,"genus":2,"cultivar":5},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"japanese-anemone","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.3,1],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286105","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eriocapitella hupehensis, syn. Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eriocapitella-hupehensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"eriocapitella hupehensis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Japanese anemone, Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-anemone/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Large, rounded mounds of foliage topped by branching, wiry flower stems reaching 2 to 4 feet high and 2 feet wide","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"RHS (Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/1231/anemone-hupehensis/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide (Anemone hupehensis var. japonica)","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/japanese-anemone-anemone-hupehensis-var-japonica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Width : 1 to 3 feet","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":8,"genus":2,"cultivar":5},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"japanese-anemone","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","5-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286105","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eriocapitella hupehensis, syn. Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eriocapitella-hupehensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"eriocapitella hupehensis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Japanese anemone, Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-anemone/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Anemone x hybrida)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/anemone-honorine-jobert/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants are hardy in zones 4a to 8b.","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"anemone hybrida"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Anemone x hybrida)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=703&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 4 - 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"anemone hybrida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eriocapitella x hybrida, syn. Anemone x hybrida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eriocapitella-x-hybrida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"eriocapitella hybrida"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide (Anemone hupehensis var. japonica)","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/japanese-anemone-anemone-hupehensis-var-japonica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones : 5, 6, 7","zones":[5,7],"level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":8,"genus":2,"cultivar":5},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"japanese-anemone","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":12,"distinctPublishers":12,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286105","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eriocapitella hupehensis, syn. Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eriocapitella-hupehensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"eriocapitella hupehensis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Japanese anemone, Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-anemone/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"RHS (Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/1231/anemone-hupehensis/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden plant profile (Anemones, Fall-blooming)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/anemones-fall-blooming","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They do tolerate partial shade but not poor drainage, whether in summer or winter, so site your plants carefully.","level":"genus","taxon":"anemone"},{"name":"Lurie Garden (Anemone hupehensis var. japonica 'Splendens')","url":"https://www.luriegarden.org/plants/japanese-anemone/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Anemone hupehensis var. japonica 'Splendens' (Japanese anemone 'Splendens') grows best in full-sun to part-shade, although too much shade can cause taller plants to flop.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Anemone x hybrida)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/anemone-honorine-jobert/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Windflower grows best in full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"anemone hybrida"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Anemone x hybrida)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=703&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers miost well drained soils in a partial shade location.","level":"species","taxon":"anemone hybrida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eriocapitella x hybrida, syn. Anemone x hybrida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eriocapitella-x-hybrida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"eriocapitella hybrida"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide (Anemone hupehensis var. japonica)","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/japanese-anemone-anemone-hupehensis-var-japonica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"US Perennials (Anemone hupehensis var. japonica 'Pamina')","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/anemone-hupehensis-var-japonica-pamina-japanese-anemone-pamina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (in cooler areas), otherwise half shade to light (dappled shade).","level":"cultivar","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"Perennial Resource / Walters Gardens (Anemone hupehensis var. japonica 'Pamina')","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ANEPA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm (Anemone hupehensis 'September Charm')","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/anemone-september-charm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It likes moist soil and part-sun to full sun.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"japanese-anemone","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"japanese-anemone","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Japanese anemone, Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-anemone/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are good for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"RHS (Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/1231/anemone-hupehensis/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife gardens Cut flowers Flower borders and beds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Anemone x hybrida)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/anemone-honorine-jobert/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are visited by bees and butterflies and the inflorescences make good cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anemone hybrida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eriocapitella x hybrida, syn. Anemone x hybrida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eriocapitella-x-hybrida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eriocapitella hybrida"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["anemone hupehensis"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (anemone hupehensis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (anemone hupehensis) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"japanese-anemone","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286105","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soils must not be allowed to dry out.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Japanese anemone, Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-anemone/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Alkaline soil, clay soil, Occasional drought, Occasional flooding","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Anemone x hybrida)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/anemone-honorine-jobert/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It does not tolerate dry soil, but also doesn't like wet soils, especially in winter.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"anemone hybrida"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine (Japanese anemones)","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/how-to/grow-plants/japanese-anemones-grow-guide/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They thrive in shade, cope with dry soil and work well in pots.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"anemone"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["anemone hupehensis"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (anemone hupehensis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 source(s) state this trait and 2 deny it; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (anemone hupehensis) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"japanese-anemone","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Japanese anemone, Anemone hupehensis)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-anemone/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies and bees are attracted to this plant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anemone hupehensis"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Anemone x hybrida)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/anemone-honorine-jobert/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are visited by bees and butterflies and the inflorescences make good cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anemone hybrida"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine (Japanese anemones)","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/how-to/grow-plants/japanese-anemones-grow-guide/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They provide nectar and pollen to late-flying pollinators, particularly bumblebees","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"anemone"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":4,"covered":["anemone hupehensis"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (anemone hupehensis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 4 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (anemone hupehensis) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.3,0.51],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285349","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hakonechloa-macra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Horticulture Extension","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/japanese-forest-grass-hakonechloa-macra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Clumps typically are 12-20 inches in a mound often wider than tall.","metres":[0.3,0.51],"band":[0.3,0.51],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285349","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hakonechloa-macra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285349","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hakonechloa-macra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285349","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hakonechloa-macra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.46],"union":[0.1,0.65],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b168","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hakonechloa-macra-aureola-golden-japanese-forest-grass","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This clump-forming ornamental grass grows to a height of 18 inches","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/hakonechloa-macra-aureola.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"30-65 cm","metres":[0.3,0.65],"band":[0.3,0.65],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/91600/hakonechloa-macra-aureola/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.45,0.46],"union":[0.1,0.6],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b168","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/hakonechloa-macra-aureola.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"45-60 cm","metres":[0.45,0.6],"band":[0.45,0.6],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/91600/hakonechloa-macra-aureola/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b168","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hakonechloa-macra-aureola/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hakonechloa-macra-aureola-golden-japanese-forest-grass","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5 - 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/hakonechloa-macra-aureola.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5-9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b168","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hakonechloa-macra-aureola/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hakonechloa-macra-aureola-golden-japanese-forest-grass","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/hakonechloa-macra-aureola.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade or Full Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/hakonechloa-macra-aureola.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.45],"union":[0.1,0.51],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Hakonechloa macra 'Albostriata')","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/168840/hakonechloa-macra-albostriata/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Resource / Walters Gardens (Hakonechloa macra 'Albostriata')","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/hakonechloa-macra-albostriata.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 30-45 cm 12-18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.45],"band":[0.3,0.45],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery (Hakonechloa macra 'Albovariegata', archive page)","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/hakonechloa-macra-albovariegata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18\" tall","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.1,1],"split":[{"range":[0.1,0.6],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society (Hakonechloa macra 'Albostriata')","Perennial Resource / Walters Gardens (Hakonechloa macra 'Albostriata')"]},{"range":[0.82,1],"sources":["Plant Delights Nursery (Hakonechloa macra 'Albovariegata', archive page)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Hakonechloa macra 'Albostriata')","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/168840/hakonechloa-macra-albostriata/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Perennial Resource / Walters Gardens (Hakonechloa macra 'Albostriata')","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/hakonechloa-macra-albostriata.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 30-60 cm 12-23 inches","metres":[0.3,0.6],"band":[0.3,0.6],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery (Hakonechloa macra 'Albovariegata', archive page)","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/hakonechloa-macra-albovariegata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The graceful habit to 18\" tall x 3' wide (when happy)","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (species page, Hakonechloa macra)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285349","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Hakonechloa macra)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hakonechloa-macra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Hakonechloa macra 'Albo-Striata')","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hakonechloa-macra-albo-striata-japanese-forest-grass","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5 - 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Perennial Resource / Walters Gardens (Hakonechloa macra 'Albostriata')","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/hakonechloa-macra-albostriata.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 5-9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery (Hakonechloa macra 'Albovariegata', archive page)","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/hakonechloa-macra-albovariegata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 4a to 8b","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (species page, Hakonechloa macra)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285349","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Hakonechloa macra)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hakonechloa-macra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Hakonechloa macra 'Albo-Striata')","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/hakonechloa-macra-albo-striata-japanese-forest-grass","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Partial Shade Full Shade"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Hakonechloa macra 'Albostriata')","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/168840/hakonechloa-macra-albostriata/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"Perennial Resource / Walters Gardens (Hakonechloa macra 'Albostriata')","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/hakonechloa-macra-albostriata.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Partial Shade or Full Shade"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery (Hakonechloa macra 'Albovariegata', archive page)","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/hakonechloa-macra-albovariegata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Part Sun to Light Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Perennial Resource / Walters Gardens (Hakonechloa macra 'Albostriata')","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/hakonechloa-macra-albostriata.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plant Uses & Characteristics Accent: Good Texture/Form Alpine & Rock Border Containers Cut Flower Edging Specimen Woodland","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (species page, Hakonechloa macra)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285349","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Best grown in humusy, consistently moist, well-drained soils in part shade.","claim":false},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Hakonechloa macra)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hakonechloa-macra/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This grass will not grow in poorly drained soil, heavy clay, or very dry soils.","claim":false}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-forest-grass-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-maple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Maple, Acer species, in its Japanese maple section)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/maple/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growth Rate: The growth rate is slow (10 to 15 feet in 15 years), although it increases in size somewhat more rapidly in youth than in later years.","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"acer palmatum"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 15 ft. 0 in. - 25 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 10.00 to 25.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Broadleaf deciduous tree or shrub, 15-25 ft (4.5-7.6 m)\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature height 15-25 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Max Height 4-8 metres\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"The plant grows 15 to 25 feet in height with a spread exceeding its height\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"japanese-maple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":4.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 10 ft. 0 in. - 25 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 10.00 to 25.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature width 15-35 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Max Spread 4-8 metres\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"japanese-maple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Acer palmatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/acer-palmatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"acer palmatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Acer palmatum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275408","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"acer palmatum"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Japanese maple, Acer palmatum)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-maple/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"acer palmatum"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Acer palmatum)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=342&PlantTypeID=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 5 - 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"acer palmatum"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Acer palmatum)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/acer-palmatum-japanese-maple","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5 - 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"acer palmatum"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"japanese-maple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Acer palmatum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275408","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"acer palmatum"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Acer palmatum)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/acer-palmatum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to part shade, well-drained soil; protect from winds.","level":"species","taxon":"acer palmatum"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Japanese maple, Acer palmatum)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-maple/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"acer palmatum"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Acer palmatum)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=342&PlantTypeID=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Partial Sun/Shade","level":"species","taxon":"acer palmatum"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Acer palmatum)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/225/acer-palmatum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"acer palmatum"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Acer palmatum)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/acer-palmatum-japanese-maple","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"acer palmatum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"japanese-maple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"japanese-maple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"japanese-maple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Acer palmatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/acer-palmatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Young leaves of this species are sensitive to frost and are not drought tolerant.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"acer palmatum"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Japanese maple, Acer palmatum)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-maple/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance Moderately sensitive","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"acer palmatum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Maple, Acer species, in its Japanese maple section)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/maple/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"During dry weather provide irrigation, as this tree is sensitive to drought.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"acer palmatum"}],"note":"3 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"japanese-maple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Acer palmatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/acer-palmatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"acer palmatum"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"japanese-painted-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.46],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/athyrium-niponicum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242044","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/athyrium-niponicum-var-pictum-japanese-painted-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows to a maximum height of 18 inches with a similar spread.","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Athyrium-niponicum-var-pictum-","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12-18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-painted-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.51],"union":[0.41,0.61],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/athyrium-niponicum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242044","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/athyrium-niponicum-var-pictum-japanese-painted-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows to a maximum height of 18 inches with a similar spread.","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Athyrium-niponicum-var-pictum-","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18-24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-painted-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/athyrium-niponicum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242044","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/athyrium-niponicum-var-pictum-japanese-painted-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Athyrium-niponicum-var-pictum-","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-painted-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/athyrium-niponicum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242044","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/athyrium-niponicum-var-pictum-japanese-painted-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It requires partial shade to full shade with moderate moisture."},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Athyrium-niponicum-var-pictum-","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is best in partial or full shade. Full sun is possible with ample moisture."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-painted-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-painted-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-painted-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242044","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soil must not be allowed to dry out.","claim":false},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Athyrium-niponicum-var-pictum-","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Athyrium tolerates dry periods after it is established.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"japanese-painted-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"jasmine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[3.05,13.41],"split":[{"range":[3.05,9.14],"sources":["Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center, Jasmine factsheet (Jasminum officinale section)","Woodlanders Nursery (Jasminum officinale, white jasmine)","Royal Horticultural Society (Jasminum officinale, common jasmine)","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Jasminum officinale)"]},{"range":[10.97,13.41],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Jasminum officinale)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Jasminum officinale)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282951","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 20.00 to 30.00 feet","metres":[6.1,9.14],"band":[6.1,9.14],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Jasminum officinale)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/jasminum-officinale/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Common jasmine can reach as much as 40 feet and spread to as much as 15 feet.","metres":12.19,"band":[10.97,13.41],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Jasminum officinale, common jasmine)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/9454/jasminum-officinale/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 4-8 metres","metres":[4,8],"band":[4,8],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center, Jasmine factsheet (Jasminum officinale section)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/jasmine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height/Spread: Common jasmine grows to a height of 10 to 15 feet as a lanky, semi-vining shrub.","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"Woodlanders Nursery (Jasminum officinale, white jasmine)","url":"https://woodlanders.net/products/jasminum-officinale","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Matures 10–15 Feet","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":5,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"jasmine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[4.11,4.57],"union":[1.5,5.03],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Jasminum officinale)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282951","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 7.00 to 15.00 feet","metres":[2.13,4.57],"band":[2.13,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Jasminum officinale)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/jasminum-officinale/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Common jasmine can reach as much as 40 feet and spread to as much as 15 feet.","metres":4.57,"band":[4.11,5.03],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Jasminum officinale, common jasmine)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/9454/jasminum-officinale/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":5,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"jasmine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-10","8-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Jasminum officinale)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282951","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 7 to 10","zones":[7,10],"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Jasminum officinale)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/jasminum-officinale/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[7,10],"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"Woodlanders Nursery (Jasminum officinale, white jasmine)","url":"https://woodlanders.net/products/jasminum-officinale","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 8–10","zones":[8,10],"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":5,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"jasmine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Jasminum officinale)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282951","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Jasminum officinale)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/jasminum-officinale/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Jasmine grows in full sun to partial shade and is drought and pollution tolerant.","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Jasminum officinale, common jasmine)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/9454/jasminum-officinale/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center, Jasmine factsheet (Jasminum officinale section)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/jasmine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"All jasmines prefer full sun to partial shade and a warm site.","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"Woodlanders Nursery (Jasminum officinale, white jasmine)","url":"https://woodlanders.net/products/jasminum-officinale","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light. Full sun to part shade; heaviest bloom in full sun.","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Jasminum officinale 'Frojas' FIONA SUNRISE)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=452201","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"Xera Plants (Jasminum officinale 'Grandiflorum')","url":"https://xeraplants.com/plants/jasminum-officinale-grandiflorum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun exposure: Full Sun , Part Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"jasminum officinale"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"jasmine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Jasminum officinale)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282951","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Jasminum officinale)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/jasminum-officinale/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Common jasmine is so fragrant that a single vine can perfume an entire garden or room.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Jasminum officinale, common jasmine)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/9454/jasminum-officinale/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Very fragrant, white flowers 2cm in width open in terminal clusters of 3 to 10 in summer and early autumn","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center, Jasmine factsheet (Jasminum officinale section)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/jasmine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The very fragrant, white flowers are up to 1 inch in diameter and they are present all summer and into fall.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"Woodlanders Nursery (Jasminum officinale, white jasmine)","url":"https://woodlanders.net/products/jasminum-officinale","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This fragrant jasmine spreads by twining and produces scented flowers during the warmer months.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["jasminum officinale"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (jasminum officinale), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (jasminum officinale) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"jasmine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"jasmine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Jasminum officinale)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/jasminum-officinale/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Jasmine grows in full sun to partial shade and is drought and pollution tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"jasmine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Jasminum officinale)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282951","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Jasminum officinale)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/jasminum-officinale/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fragrant, pink to white blooms, attractive to both butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center, Jasmine factsheet (Jasminum officinale section)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/jasmine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Landscape Use: Plant jasmine near the house or near a walk so its intense fragrance can be enjoyed and so you can watch hummingbirds and butterflies come to the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum officinale"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["jasminum officinale"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (jasminum officinale), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (jasminum officinale) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"jasmine-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[3.05,6.1],"union":[0.91,6.1],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276136","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 20.00 feet","metres":[0.91,6.1],"band":[0.91,6.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/trachelospermum-jasminoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 20 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,6.1],"band":[0.91,6.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/trachelospermum-jasminoides","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Broadleaf evergreen twining vine/ground cover, 10-20 ft (3-6 m) tall when supported, about 2 ft tall as a ground cover.","metres":[3.05,6.1],"band":[3.05,6.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Jasmine factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/jasmine/","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Mature Height/Spread: When supported, this twining vine reaches up to 20 feet.","metres":6.1,"band":[5.49,6.71],"role":"other-form"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"jasmine-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.91,8.38],"split":[{"range":[0.91,1.83],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","Missouri Botanical Garden"]},{"range":[6.86,8.38],"sources":["Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276136","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/trachelospermum-jasminoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/trachelospermumjasminoides.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"spreading to 25 feet","metres":7.62,"band":[6.86,8.38],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"jasmine-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["8-10","8-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276136","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8 to 10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/trachelospermum-jasminoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Vine Selections for Landscaping)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/vine-selections-for-landscaping/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade; Humus-rich, moist, well-drained soil; Zones: 8-10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/trachelospermumjasminoides.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA 8 (borderline 7)-11","zones":[8,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"jasmine-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276136","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/trachelospermum-jasminoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/trachelospermum-jasminoides","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun, partial shade in hot areas."},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Jasmine factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/jasmine/","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Confederate jasmine prefers sun to partial shade."},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Vine Selections for Landscaping)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/vine-selections-for-landscaping/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade; Humus-rich, moist, well-drained soil; Zones: 8-10"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/trachelospermumjasminoides.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In Phoenix, partial shade with an eastern exposure is best, do not plant in western exposures or in reflected light situations. It can grow in full shade, but flowering is suppressed."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"jasmine-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276136","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Axillary and terminal clusters of salverform, sweetly fragrant, starry, creamy white flowers appear in late spring with sporadic additional bloom in summer.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/trachelospermum-jasminoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are very fragrant like jasmine but are not part of the jasmine genus.","claim":true},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/trachelospermum-jasminoides","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers white, 2.5 cm wide, five petals, pin-wheel shape, in small clusters, fragrant, bloom in summer.","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Jasmine factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/jasmine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"is highly prized for its heavily scented clusters of phlox-like flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Vine Selections for Landscaping)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/vine-selections-for-landscaping/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Creamy-white, fragrant flowers in May to June","claim":true},{"name":"Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/trachelospermumjasminoides.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"VERY FRAGRANT (the knock your socks off kind) axillary flowers to 1.5 inches across","claim":true}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"jasmine-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"jasmine-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/trachelospermum-jasminoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, it is drought-tolerant.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"jasmine-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276136","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to bees.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/trachelospermum-jasminoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to bees.","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Jasmine factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/jasmine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The 1-inch white flowers appear in small clusters on short side branches and they are attractive to bees.","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Vine Selections for Landscaping)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/vine-selections-for-landscaping/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Blooms on old growth; Attracts bees and other pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"jasmine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.91,5.03],"split":[{"range":[0.91,1.34],"sources":["Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC - Winter Jasmine","Oregon State University Landscape Plants","Colesville Nursery","Virginia Tech Dendrology Fact Sheet"]},{"range":[1.5,2.5],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society"]},{"range":[2.7,5.03],"sources":["BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Plants For A Future","Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC - Jasmine factsheet"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/jasminum-nudiflorum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10 ft. 0 in. - 15 ft. 0 in.","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a152","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10.00 to 15.00 feet","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC - Winter Jasmine","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/winter-jasmine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Left to its own devices, it is a sprawling, mounding shrub that reaches 3 to 4 feet tall and up to 7 feet wide.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC - Jasmine factsheet","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/jasmine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"When trained on a trellis or wall it can grow to 15 feet tall.","metres":4.57,"band":[4.11,5.03],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Virginia Tech Dendrology Fact Sheet","url":"http://dendro.cnre.vt.edu/dendrology/syllabus/factsheet.cfm?ID=958","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Form: Sprawling, arching shrub, up to 4 feet tall unless allowed to climb and supported; works well cascading down embankments and over walls.","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/jasminum-nudiflorum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Broadleaf deciduous shrub, 3-4 ft tall and 4-7 ft wide","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Plants For A Future","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Jasminum+nudiflorum","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Jasminum nudiflorum is a deciduous Shrub growing to 3.6 m (11ft) by 4.5 m (14ft) at a medium rate.","metres":3.6,"band":[3.24,3.96],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/9452/jasminum-nudiflorum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/jasminum-nudiflorum/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Height: 3m","metres":3,"band":[2.7,3.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/Jasminum-nudiflorum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3-4 ft","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 3 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"jasmine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.91,4.95],"split":[{"range":[0.91,2.5],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Oregon State University Landscape Plants","Royal Horticultural Society","Colesville Nursery","Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC - Winter Jasmine","Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC - Jasmine factsheet"]},{"range":[2.7,3.3],"sources":["BBC Gardeners' World Magazine"]},{"range":[4.05,4.95],"sources":["Plants For A Future"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/jasminum-nudiflorum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a152","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC - Winter Jasmine","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/winter-jasmine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Left to its own devices, it is a sprawling, mounding shrub that reaches 3 to 4 feet tall and up to 7 feet wide.","metres":2.13,"band":[1.92,2.34],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC - Jasmine factsheet","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/jasmine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This deciduous viney shrub grows to 4 feet high when unsupported, and 7 feet wide.","metres":2.13,"band":[1.92,2.34],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/jasminum-nudiflorum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Broadleaf deciduous shrub, 3-4 ft tall and 4-7 ft wide","metres":[1.22,2.13],"band":[1.22,2.13],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Plants For A Future","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Jasminum+nudiflorum","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Jasminum nudiflorum is a deciduous Shrub growing to 3.6 m (11ft) by 4.5 m (14ft) at a medium rate.","metres":4.5,"band":[4.05,4.95],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/9452/jasminum-nudiflorum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/jasminum-nudiflorum/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3m","metres":3,"band":[2.7,3.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/Jasminum-nudiflorum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 6-7 ft","metres":[1.83,2.13],"band":[1.83,2.13],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 3 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"jasmine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["6-10","6-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/jasminum-nudiflorum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[6,10],"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a152","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 6 to 10","zones":[6,10],"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Plants For A Future","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Jasminum+nudiflorum","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"USDA hardiness 6-11","zones":[6,11],"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/Jasminum-nudiflorum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 6-10","zones":[6,10],"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"jasmine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/jasminum-nudiflorum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Winter jasmine prefers full sun to partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a152","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC - Winter Jasmine","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/winter-jasmine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in well-drained soil in full sun to light shade.","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC - Jasmine factsheet","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/jasmine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"All jasmines prefer full sun to partial shade and a warm site.","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Plants For A Future","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Jasminum+nudiflorum","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"It can grow in full shade (deep woodland) semi-shade (light woodland) or no shade.","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/9452/jasminum-nudiflorum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/jasminum-nudiflorum/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Dappled shade, full sun","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/Jasminum-nudiflorum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Sun","level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"jasmine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/jasminum-nudiflorum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are bright yellow, non-fragrant, funnel to tubular-shaped, 6-petaled, 1 to 2 inches long, and 1 inch across.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a152","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Non-fragrant, bright yellow flowers bloom along the stems in late winter before the leaves.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC - Jasmine factsheet","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/jasmine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are unscented, yellow, 1 inch wide, and they appear in winter or early spring before the leaves unfold.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Virginia Tech Dendrology Fact Sheet","url":"http://dendro.cnre.vt.edu/dendrology/syllabus/factsheet.cfm?ID=958","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Bright yellow, unscented, funnel shaped with 6 petals, 1 inch across appearing in large numbers for long period throughout the winter.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Plants For A Future","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Jasminum+nudiflorum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers have a delicate mossy perfume","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"}],"note":"4 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"jasmine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/jasminum-nudiflorum/","https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/Blog-Post/Jasminum-nudiflorum"]}],"sources":[{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/jasminum-nudiflorum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It makes an excellent cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/Blog-Post/Jasminum-nudiflorum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The profuse yellow blooms that typically appear from January to March make excellent cut flowers in fresh, seasonal arrangements","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"jasmine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/jasminum-nudiflorum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Diseases Drought Heavy Shade Insect Pests","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC - Winter Jasmine","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/winter-jasmine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It also tolerates our summer heat and is drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"jasmine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC - Winter Jasmine","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/winter-jasmine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good nectar source for honeybees on warm winter days.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/Blog-Post/Jasminum-nudiflorum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Early pollinators that find themselves awake due to warm winter days will benefit from the source of nectar when not much else is available.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"jasminum nudiflorum"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"jeanne-moreau","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.85,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.8,0.9],"union":[0.77,0.94],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Meilland International (breeder catalogue, French)","url":"https://meilland.com/catalogue/jeanne-moreau-meidiaphaz/","country":"FR","form":"shrub","value":"Hauteur : 80 / 90 cm","metres":[0.8,0.9],"band":[0.8,0.9],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Meilland Richardier (Meilland's own mail-order arm, French)","url":"https://www.meillandrichardier.com/rosier-jeanne-moreau-r-meidiaphaz.html","country":"FR","form":"shrub","value":"Hauteur : 85 cm","metres":0.85,"band":[0.77,0.94],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Promesse de Fleurs (French horticultural retailer)","url":"https://www.promessedefleurs.com/rosiers/rosiers-par-variete/rosiers-the-grandes-fleurs/rosier-a-grandes-fleurs-jeanne-moreau-meidiaphaz.html","country":"FR","form":"shrub","value":"Hauteur à maturité 85 cm","metres":0.85,"band":[0.77,0.94],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":3},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"jeanne-moreau","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.45,0.55],"union":[0.45,0.55],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.meillandrichardier.com/rosier-jeanne-moreau-r-meidiaphaz.html","https://www.promessedefleurs.com/rosiers/rosiers-par-variete/rosiers-the-grandes-fleurs/rosier-a-grandes-fleurs-jeanne-moreau-meidiaphaz.html"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Meilland Richardier (Meilland's own mail-order arm, French)","url":"https://www.meillandrichardier.com/rosier-jeanne-moreau-r-meidiaphaz.html","country":"FR","form":"shrub","value":"Largeur adulte : 50 cm","metres":0.5,"band":[0.45,0.55],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Promesse de Fleurs (French horticultural retailer)","url":"https://www.promessedefleurs.com/rosiers/rosiers-par-variete/rosiers-the-grandes-fleurs/rosier-a-grandes-fleurs-jeanne-moreau-meidiaphaz.html","country":"FR","form":"shrub","value":"Largeur à maturité 50 cm","metres":0.5,"band":[0.45,0.55],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":3},"reasons":[]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"jeanne-moreau","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":3},"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"jeanne-moreau","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"jeanne-moreau","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://meilland.com/catalogue/jeanne-moreau-meidiaphaz/","https://www.meillandrichardier.com/rosier-jeanne-moreau-r-meidiaphaz.html"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://meilland.com/catalogue/jeanne-moreau-meidiaphaz/","https://www.promessedefleurs.com/rosiers/rosiers-par-variete/rosiers-the-grandes-fleurs/rosier-a-grandes-fleurs-jeanne-moreau-meidiaphaz.html"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Meilland International (breeder catalogue, French)","url":"https://meilland.com/catalogue/jeanne-moreau-meidiaphaz/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Parfum : Puissant, rose de mai, note citronnée, menthe, verveine citron","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Meilland Richardier (Meilland's own mail-order arm, French)","url":"https://www.meillandrichardier.com/rosier-jeanne-moreau-r-meidiaphaz.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Parfum : Parfum intense","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Promesse de Fleurs (French horticultural retailer)","url":"https://www.promessedefleurs.com/rosiers/rosiers-par-variete/rosiers-the-grandes-fleurs/rosier-a-grandes-fleurs-jeanne-moreau-meidiaphaz.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"au parfum puissant mêlant rose de mai, citron, menthe et verveine citronnée","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"jeanne-moreau","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://meilland.com/catalogue/jeanne-moreau-meidiaphaz/","https://www.meillandrichardier.com/rosier-jeanne-moreau-r-meidiaphaz.html"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://meilland.com/catalogue/jeanne-moreau-meidiaphaz/","https://www.promessedefleurs.com/rosiers/rosiers-par-variete/rosiers-the-grandes-fleurs/rosier-a-grandes-fleurs-jeanne-moreau-meidiaphaz.html"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Meilland International (breeder catalogue, French)","url":"https://meilland.com/catalogue/jeanne-moreau-meidiaphaz/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Usages : Isolé, Murs et clôtures, bouquets","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Meilland Richardier (Meilland's own mail-order arm, French)","url":"https://www.meillandrichardier.com/rosier-jeanne-moreau-r-meidiaphaz.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Utilisation idéale pour : Massif, Isolé, Fleurs coupées, Petits jardins et jardins de ville, Balcons et terrasses","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Promesse de Fleurs (French horticultural retailer)","url":"https://www.promessedefleurs.com/rosiers/rosiers-par-variete/rosiers-the-grandes-fleurs/rosier-a-grandes-fleurs-jeanne-moreau-meidiaphaz.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fleur à bouquets","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"jeanne-moreau","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"jeanne-moreau","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"joe-pye-weed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.22,1.52],"union":[0.91,2.13],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1191, Joe-Pye Weed","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/joe-pye-weed/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These native perennial plants grow to 4 - 6 feet tall","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"eutrochium"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1874, Rain Garden Plants: (Eutrochium spp.)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rain-garden-plants-eutrochium-spp-joe-pye-weed/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"growing to an average height of 3 to 5 (occasionally 6) feet under dried soil conditions","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"eutrochium"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide, Joe-Pye Weeds","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/joe-pye-weeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: our most common species, green-stemmed Joe-Pye weed, typically grows 3-7 feet tall (to 13 feet under cultivation).","metres":[0.91,2.13],"band":[0.91,2.13],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"eutrochium"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":16,"levels":{"species":16,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 16 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"joe-pye-weed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"species":16,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"joe-pye-weed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"split":["4-8","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are clemson.edu","urls":["https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/joe-pye-weed/","https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rain-garden-plants-eutrochium-spp-joe-pye-weed/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1191, Joe-Pye Weed","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/joe-pye-weed/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Joe-Pye weeds are cold hardy plants and grow well in USDA Zones 4 to 8.","zones":[4,8],"level":"genus","taxon":"eutrochium"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1874, Rain Garden Plants: (Eutrochium spp.)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rain-garden-plants-eutrochium-spp-joe-pye-weed/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3 - 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"eutrochium"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":13,"levels":{"species":16,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"SPLIT"},"note":"SPLIT withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are clemson.edu. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2; 13 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"joe-pye-weed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eutrochium purpureum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eutrochium-purpureum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The Joe-Pye Weed prefers full sun to partial shade and moist, well-drained to occasionally wet soils but is intolerant to dry soils.","level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium purpureum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eutrochium maculatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eutrochium-maculatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium maculatum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eutrochium fistulosum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eutrochium-fistulosum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It prefers full sun to partial shade and neutral to slightly acid soils.","level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium fistulosum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eutrochium dubium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eutrochium-dubium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant grows 3 to 6 feet tall in moist, humus-rich to sandy or gravelly soils and in full sun to partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium dubium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Eutrochium purpureum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292660","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium purpureum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Eutrochium maculatum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292659","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium maculatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Eutrochium fistulosum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257404","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium fistulosum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Eutrochium dubium)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=363936","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium dubium"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1874, Rain Garden Plants: (Eutrochium spp.)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rain-garden-plants-eutrochium-spp-joe-pye-weed/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun to part shade","level":"genus","taxon":"eutrochium"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Joe Pye Weed, Bonset","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/joe-pye-weed-bonset","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"eupatorium maculatum"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension, Hollow Joe-Pye Weed","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/hollow-joe-pye-weed","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part sun","level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium fistulosum"},{"name":"Penn State Extension, Rain Garden Plants: Coastal Plain Joe Pye Weed","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/rain-garden-plants-coastal-plain-joe-pye-weed","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Sun/partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium dubium"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Eutrochium purpureum)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=EUPU21","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade , Shade","level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium purpureum"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Eutrochium purpureum, Sweet Joe Pye Weed)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/eutrochium-purpureum-sweet-joe-pye-weed","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant it in moist to well-drained garden soil in partial to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium purpureum"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries (Eupatorium fistulosum)","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Eupatorium-fistulosum-","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows well in full sun to light shade and tolerates soils containing anything from loam to sand to gravel.","level":"species","taxon":"eupatorium fistulosum"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Eupatorium purpureum)","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/eupatorium-purpureum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"eupatorium purpureum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"joe-pye-weed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eutrochium purpureum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eutrochium-purpureum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They have a vanilla scent and bloom from summer to early fall.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium purpureum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eutrochium maculatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eutrochium-maculatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium maculatum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eutrochium fistulosum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eutrochium-fistulosum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium fistulosum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eutrochium dubium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eutrochium-dubium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium dubium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Eutrochium purpureum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292660","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium purpureum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Eutrochium maculatum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292659","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium maculatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Eutrochium fistulosum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257404","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tiny, vanilla-scented, dull pinkish-purple flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium fistulosum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Eutrochium dubium)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=363936","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium dubium"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1191, Joe-Pye Weed","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/joe-pye-weed/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are mildly fragrant and very attractive to butterflies and other beneficial insects.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"eutrochium"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1874, Rain Garden Plants: (Eutrochium spp.)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rain-garden-plants-eutrochium-spp-joe-pye-weed/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The leaves of Joe-Pye weed ( E. purpureum ) have a faint vanilla scent when crushed.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"eutrochium"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide, Joe-Pye Weeds","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/joe-pye-weeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Green-stemmed Joe-Pye weed can be grown as a showy, fragrant native ornamental plant in landscapes and in rain gardens.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"eutrochium"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Eutrochium purpureum)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=EUPU21","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers: yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium purpureum"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Eutrochium purpureum, Sweet Joe Pye Weed)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/eutrochium-purpureum-sweet-joe-pye-weed","country":null,"form":null,"value":"its vanilla-scented flowers are irresistible for Monarchs, Swallowtails and many other butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium purpureum"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Eupatorium purpureum)","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/eupatorium-purpureum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The vanilla scented blooms are frequented by butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eupatorium purpureum"}],"note":"14 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"joe-pye-weed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eutrochium fistulosum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eutrochium-fistulosum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium fistulosum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Eutrochium fistulosum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257404","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium fistulosum"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Eutrochium purpureum, Sweet Joe Pye Weed)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/eutrochium-purpureum-sweet-joe-pye-weed","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sweet Joe Pye Weed is deer-resistant and makes a wonderful cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium purpureum"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Eupatorium purpureum)","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/eupatorium-purpureum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bog, Clay Soil, Cut Flower, Dried Flower, Drought Tolerant, East-Coast Native, Long Blooming, Naturalizing, Rain Garden","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eupatorium purpureum"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"joe-pye-weed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eutrochium purpureum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eutrochium-purpureum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"If the soil becomes too dry, the leaves will appear scorched.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium purpureum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eutrochium dubium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eutrochium-dubium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This is a wetland species and the leaves may scorch if the soil is allowed to dry out.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium dubium"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1191, Joe-Pye Weed","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/joe-pye-weed/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They can tolerate more drought in subsequent years, but do thrive in drainage ditches that are more moist than the typical surrounding soils.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"eutrochium"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1874, Rain Garden Plants: (Eutrochium spp.)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rain-garden-plants-eutrochium-spp-joe-pye-weed/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Moisture timing: Tolerates dry soil conditions (produces smaller plants), but prefers consistently moist soils","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"eutrochium"},{"name":"Penn State Extension, Rain Garden Plants: Coastal Plain Joe Pye Weed","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/rain-garden-plants-coastal-plain-joe-pye-weed","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaves may scorch (turn brown and deform) if soil dries out.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium dubium"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["eupatorium purpureum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (eupatorium purpureum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 source(s) state this trait and 3 deny it; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (eupatorium purpureum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"joe-pye-weed","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eutrochium purpureum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eutrochium-purpureum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract butterflies, skippers, moths, and bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium purpureum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eutrochium maculatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eutrochium-maculatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tiny dusky-pink flowers appear in large clusters and attract many bees and butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium maculatum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eutrochium fistulosum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eutrochium-fistulosum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower nectar is attractive to various pollinators, especially honeybees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium fistulosum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eutrochium dubium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eutrochium-dubium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The large dome-shaped clusters of flowers appear in late summer to early fall and attract many pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium dubium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Eutrochium purpureum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292660","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are very attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium purpureum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Eutrochium maculatum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292659","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium maculatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Eutrochium fistulosum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257404","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are very attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium fistulosum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Eutrochium dubium)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=363936","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium dubium"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1191, Joe-Pye Weed","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/joe-pye-weed/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"flowers are fragrant and attract many pollinating insects, especially butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"eutrochium"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1874, Rain Garden Plants: (Eutrochium spp.)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rain-garden-plants-eutrochium-spp-joe-pye-weed/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These flowers are invariably covered with pollinators and nectar sippers from July through September","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"eutrochium"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide, Joe-Pye Weeds","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/joe-pye-weeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Joe-Pye weeds attract a wide array of pollinators","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"eutrochium"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Joe Pye Weed, Bonset","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/joe-pye-weed-bonset","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eupatorium maculatum"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension, Hollow Joe-Pye Weed","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/hollow-joe-pye-weed","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Large flowering domes provide a huge surface over which a wide array of pollinators spend their summer hours sipping on nectar and basking in the sun.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium fistulosum"},{"name":"Penn State Extension, Rain Garden Plants: Coastal Plain Joe Pye Weed","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/rain-garden-plants-coastal-plain-joe-pye-weed","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract pollinators, and seeds provide food for birds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium dubium"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Eutrochium purpureum)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=EUPU21","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use Wildlife: An important source of honey, attracting pollinators by the score.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium purpureum"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Eutrochium fistulosum)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=EUFI14","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use Wildlife: An important source of honey, attracting pollinators by the score. Seeds eaten by Swamp Sparrow.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium fistulosum"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Eutrochium purpureum, Sweet Joe Pye Weed)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/eutrochium-purpureum-sweet-joe-pye-weed","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A butterfly favorite, it is easy to grow and its vanilla-scented flowers are irresistible for Monarchs, Swallowtails and many other butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eutrochium purpureum"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries (Eupatorium fistulosum)","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Eupatorium-fistulosum-","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is an important pollen and nectar plant and attracts butterflies, particularly the swallowtail butterfly, and other pollinators by the dozens.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eupatorium fistulosum"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Eupatorium purpureum)","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/eupatorium-purpureum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wildlife Butterflies, Pollinators, Songbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eupatorium purpureum"}],"note":"19 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"jubilee-celebration","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.31],"union":[1.07,1.34],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/jubilee-celebration","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height 4ft (3-year-old established plant, pruned annually)","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/jubilee-celebration-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.37260","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"up to 47\" (up to 120cm)","metres":1.19,"band":[1.07,1.31],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/jubilee-celebration","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"4ft (125cm)","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"regional-note"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - Standard Tree Rose form","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/jubilee-celebration-standard-rose","country":"UK","form":"unstated","value":"6ft (180cm)","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"jubilee-celebration","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"consensus":[1.1,1.34],"union":[1.1,1.34],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/jubilee-celebration","https://menagerieflower.com/products/jubilee-celebration-bare-root-rose-david-austin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/jubilee-celebration","https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.37260"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/jubilee-celebration","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width 4ft (3-year-old established plant, pruned annually)","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/jubilee-celebration-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.37260","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4' (120cm)","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/jubilee-celebration","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"4ft (125cm)","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"regional-note"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"jubilee-celebration","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/jubilee-celebration","https://menagerieflower.com/products/jubilee-celebration-bare-root-rose-david-austin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/jubilee-celebration","https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.37260"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/jubilee-celebration","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zones 5-11"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/jubilee-celebration-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"5-11"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.37260","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"zone 5a through 11"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[5,11]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"jubilee-celebration","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/jubilee-celebration","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/jubilee-celebration"]},{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/jubilee-celebration","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/jubilee-celebration-standard-rose"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/jubilee-celebration","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"\"Full Sunlight\"; \"East, South, West Facing\""},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/jubilee-celebration","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"\"East, South, West Facing\"; \"Full Sunlight\""},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - Standard Tree Rose form","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/jubilee-celebration-standard-rose","country":"UK","form":"unstated","value":"\"East, South, West Facing\"; \"Full Sunlight\""}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"jubilee-celebration","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/jubilee-celebration","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Strong, Fruity, with \"hints of fresh lemon and raspberry\""},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/jubilee-celebration","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Strong, Fruity, with \"hints of fresh lemon and raspberry\""},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/jubilee-celebration-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Strong - Lemon & Raspberry"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.37260","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Strong, lemon, raspberry fragrance"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - Standard Tree Rose form","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/jubilee-celebration-standard-rose","country":"UK","form":"unstated","value":"Strong, Fruity, with \"hints of fresh lemon and raspberry\""}],"note":"sources rate it strong","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"jubilee-celebration","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.37260","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Can be used for cut flower, garden or landscape"}],"note":"only 1 source mentions it","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"julia-child-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.91,1],"union":[0.61,1.22],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-julia-childtm-wekvossutono/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=680&PlantTypeID=4","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Weeks Roses (breeder)","url":"https://www.weeksroses.com/varieties/p/julia-child","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: 3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/julia-child","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 3' - 4' x 3' - 4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/floribundas-small-landscape-shrubs/julia-child/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 3-4ft","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/julia-child-floribunda-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-floribunda-julia-child","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 2-3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Otto and Sons Nursery","url":"https://ottoandsonsnursery.com/product/r-julia-child/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height Ht 03' - 4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"julia-child-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.61,1.22],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-julia-childtm-wekvossutono/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=680&PlantTypeID=4","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 3-4 Feet (width 3')","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/julia-child","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 3' - 4' x 3' - 4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/floribundas-small-landscape-shrubs/julia-child/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 2-3ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/julia-child-floribunda-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-floribunda-julia-child","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 2-3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Otto and Sons Nursery","url":"https://ottoandsonsnursery.com/product/r-julia-child/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width Width 02' - 3'","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"julia-child-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-10","5-9","6-9","6-10","5-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-julia-childtm-wekvossutono/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=680&PlantTypeID=4","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 5 - 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Weeks Roses (breeder)","url":"https://www.weeksroses.com/varieties/p/julia-child","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 6b-9b","zones":[6,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/julia-child","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 6-10","zones":[6,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/julia-child-floribunda-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-floribunda-julia-child","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"julia-child-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-julia-childtm-wekvossutono/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=680&PlantTypeID=4","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/julia-child","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun Requires 6+ hours of direct sunlight to thrive.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/julia-child-floribunda-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-floribunda-julia-child","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Otto and Sons Nursery","url":"https://ottoandsonsnursery.com/product/r-julia-child/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure 1 -Full Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"julia-child-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","strengths":["strong","strong","medium","strong","strong","strong"],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-julia-childtm-wekvossutono/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sporting 26-40 ruffled petals, the fully double buttery yellow flowers bloom continuously from late spring into fall with a delicious licorice-clove scent.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=680&PlantTypeID=4","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Very strong licorice-spice scent.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Weeks Roses (breeder)","url":"https://www.weeksroses.com/varieties/p/julia-child","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong licorice candy & spice","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/julia-child","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Moderately Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/shop/modern-roses/floribundas-small-landscape-shrubs/julia-child/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Strong","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/julia-child-floribunda-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features: Attracts Pollinators, Cut Flowers, Fragrant, Low Maintenance, Continuous Blooming or Rebloomer","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-floribunda-julia-child","country":null,"form":null,"value":"a strong scent of sweet licorice and spice","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Otto and Sons Nursery","url":"https://ottoandsonsnursery.com/product/r-julia-child/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Strong Licorice Fragrance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"julia-child-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-julia-childtm-wekvossutono/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use in the pollinator, cutting or cottage gardens.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/julia-child","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets and floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/julia-child-floribunda-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features: Attracts Pollinators, Cut Flowers, Fragrant, Low Maintenance, Continuous Blooming or Rebloomer","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-floribunda-julia-child","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses* • Accent Plant • Border Plant • Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"julia-child-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=680&PlantTypeID=4","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pests and Problems Environmental Damage Drought","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-floribunda-julia-child","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Preferred Soil Conditions* • Adapts Well to Most Soil Types • Average • Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Otto and Sons Nursery","url":"https://ottoandsonsnursery.com/product/r-julia-child/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Coastal & Hot n' Dry Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"julia-child-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-julia-childtm-wekvossutono/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Attracts butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/julia-child-floribunda-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-floribunda-julia-child","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees • Attracts Butterflies • Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"juliet-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.07,1.21],"union":[0.99,1.22],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses - 'AUSjameson'","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.62564.1","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"up to 43\" (up to 110cm)","metres":1.1,"band":[0.99,1.21],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Highgarden Roses - AUSjameson English Wedding Florist Shrub Rose (own root)","url":"https://highgardenroses.com/products/english-wedding-shrub-rose-ausjameson","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"3 1/2'-4'","metres":[1.07,1.22],"band":[1.07,1.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"juliet-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses - 'AUSjameson'","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.62564.1","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"up to 30\" (up to 75cm)","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"juliet-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Highgarden Roses - AUSjameson English Wedding Florist Shrub Rose (own root)","url":"https://highgardenroses.com/products/english-wedding-shrub-rose-ausjameson","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: 5-10"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"juliet-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"juliet-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Wedding and Event Roses (breeder, cut-flower division)","url":"https://www.davidaustin.com/rose/juliet-rose/","country":"UK","form":"unstated","value":"light scent with a hint of tea"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses - 'AUSjameson'","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.62564.1","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mild, tea fragrance"},{"name":"Highgarden Roses - AUSjameson English Wedding Florist Shrub Rose (own root)","url":"https://highgardenroses.com/products/english-wedding-shrub-rose-ausjameson","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mild"},{"name":"Alexandra Farms - Juliet (Ausjameson) English Garden Rose","url":"https://www.alexandrafarms.com/juliet","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"A hint of tea (intensity rating 1 of 5)"}],"note":"sources rate it light; too weak to propose adding the tag","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"juliet-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Wedding and Event Roses (breeder, cut-flower division)","url":"https://www.davidaustin.com/rose/juliet-rose/","country":"UK","form":"unstated","value":"Our signature bloom and wedding favourite - the entire page is a cut-flower / wedding-rose listing"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses - 'AUSjameson'","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.62564.1","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Can be used for cut flower"},{"name":"Alexandra Farms - Juliet (Ausjameson) English Garden Rose","url":"https://www.alexandrafarms.com/juliet","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Vase Life: 10 Days; Days to Open: Up to 4 days - the page is a cut-flower production listing"}],"note":"3 sources state it but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"juniper","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Size: Large shrubs can grow to about 15 feet tall, and trees up to 60 feet tall; 6 to 20 feet wide\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Size: 6 inches to 6 feet tall; 6 to 20 feet wide\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"juniper","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Size: Large shrubs can grow to about 15 feet tall, and trees up to 60 feet tall; 6 to 20 feet wide\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Size: 6 inches to 6 feet tall; 6 to 20 feet wide\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"juniper","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Juniperus, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"juniperus"},{"name":"Clemson HGIC (Growing and Using Juniper (Juniperus spp.): Large Shrubs and Trees)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/juniper/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: Most species are adapted to zones 3 to 9 (cultivar dependent)","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"juniperus"},{"name":"Clemson HGIC (Growing and Using Juniper (Juniperus spp.): Groundcovers and Small Shrubs)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/growing-and-using-juniper-juniperus-spp-groundcovers-and-small-shrubs-2/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: Most species are adapted to zones 3 to 9 (cultivar dependent)","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"juniperus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"juniper","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Juniperus, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"juniperus"},{"name":"Clemson HGIC (Growing and Using Juniper (Juniperus spp.): Large Shrubs and Trees)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/juniper/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"juniperus"},{"name":"Clemson HGIC (Growing and Using Juniper (Juniperus spp.): Groundcovers and Small Shrubs)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/growing-and-using-juniper-juniperus-spp-groundcovers-and-small-shrubs-2/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"juniperus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Juniperus chinensis, the species)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279597","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"juniperus chinensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Juniperus virginiana, the species)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279605","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"juniperus virginiana"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Chinese juniper, Juniperus chinensis)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/chinese-juniper/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"juniperus chinensis"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Juniperus chinensis, the species)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/juniperus-chinensis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun and partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"juniperus chinensis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"juniper","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Juniperus, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#fragrant leaves","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"juniperus"},{"name":"Clemson HGIC (Growing and Using Juniper (Juniperus spp.): Groundcovers and Small Shrubs)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/growing-and-using-juniper-juniperus-spp-groundcovers-and-small-shrubs-2/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pfitzer juniper foliage is generally scale-like and fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"juniperus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["juniperus virginiana"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (juniperus virginiana), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (juniperus virginiana) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"juniper","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"juniper","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","nearMiss":["drought"],"derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Juniperus, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"juniperus"},{"name":"Clemson HGIC (Growing and Using Juniper (Juniperus spp.): Large Shrubs and Trees)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/juniper/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Adapted to heat, drought, and poor soils of the Southeast.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"juniperus"},{"name":"Clemson HGIC (Growing and Using Juniper (Juniperus spp.): Groundcovers and Small Shrubs)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/growing-and-using-juniper-juniperus-spp-groundcovers-and-small-shrubs-2/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Adapted to heat, drought, and poor soils of the Southeast.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"juniperus"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension, CAES Field Report (Junipers, circular C956, the genus)","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/C956/junipers/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are one of the most drought tolerant plants in our landscape and can actually suffer from over-watering.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"juniperus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Juniperus chinensis, the species)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279597","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of some drought once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"juniperus chinensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Juniperus virginiana, the species)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279605","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It has the best drought resistance of any conifer native to the eastern U.S.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"juniperus virginiana"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Chinese juniper, Juniperus chinensis)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/chinese-juniper/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates dry soil once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"juniperus chinensis"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Juniperus chinensis, the species)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/juniperus-chinensis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Best on moist, well-drained, but tolerates dry soils once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"juniperus chinensis"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the row carries [\"drought\"], which nothing in the product reads: hasTag is an equality test against \"drought tolerant\"; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"juniper","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Juniperus, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"juniperus"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-pacific","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.3,0.46],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-conferta-blue-pacific/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"After 10 years, a mature specimen will measure 1 to 1.5 feet tall and 6 feet wide with an annual growth rate of 6 to 8 inches, significantly more outward than up.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Conifer Society conifer database","url":"https://conifersociety.org/conifers/juniperus-conferta-blue-pacific/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"After 10 years of growth a mature specimen will measure 1 to 1.5 feet (30 - 45 cm) tall and 6 feet (2 m) wide, an average growth rate of 6 to 8 inches (15 - 20 cm), significantly more outward than up.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 0.50 to 1.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-pacific","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[1.65,2.01],"union":[1.65,2.01],"proposed":1.83,"margin":9.1,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-conferta-blue-pacific/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"After 10 years, a mature specimen will measure 1 to 1.5 feet tall and 6 feet wide with an annual growth rate of 6 to 8 inches, significantly more outward than up.","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Conifer Society conifer database","url":"https://conifersociety.org/conifers/juniperus-conferta-blue-pacific/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"After 10 years of growth a mature specimen will measure 1 to 1.5 feet (30 - 45 cm) tall and 6 feet (2 m) wide, an average growth rate of 6 to 8 inches (15 - 20 cm), significantly more outward than up.","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"}],"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 4.00 to 6.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (1.65 to 2.01 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-pacific","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[6,9],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249865","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 6 to 9","zones":[6,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-conferta-blue-pacific/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[6,9]}],"note":"every source states 6-9; catalog states 5-9","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-pacific","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249865","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-conferta-blue-pacific/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-pacific","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249865","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant, Evergreen","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-conferta-blue-pacific/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-pacific","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-pacific","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249865","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Erosion, Urban Conditions","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-conferta-blue-pacific/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant prefers full sun and tolerates drought, shade, sandy soils, and salt.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-pacific","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-point","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"may reach 12 ft (3.6 m) high and 8 ft (2.4 m) wide\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-point","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"may reach 12 ft (3.6 m) high and 8 ft (2.4 m) wide\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-point","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/juniperus-chinensis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy to USDA Zone 3-9, depending upon cultivar.","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-point","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/juniperus-chinensis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun and partial shade."}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-point","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-point","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-point","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/juniperus-chinensis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Best on moist, well-drained, but tolerates dry soils once established.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-point","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-rug","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Conifer Society Conifer Database","url":"https://conifersociety.org/conifers/juniperus-horizontalis-wiltonii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"After 10 years of growth, a mature specimen will measure 6 to 10 feet (2 - 3 m) wide, but only a couple of inches (2 - 3 cm) high, an annual lateral growth rate of 7 to 10 inches (18 - 25 cm).","metres":[0.02,0.03],"band":[0.02,0.03],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"genus":1,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 0.25 to 0.50 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 0 ft. 4 in. - 0 ft. 6 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page's figure is a final size and this row's is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"This low-growing, creeping evergreen shrub reaches about 6 inches in height with full sun.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"It reaches 3-6 inches in height and spreads 4-6 feet within the first five years, eventually maturing to 3-6 inches tall with a 6-8 foot spread.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Striking silver-blue foliage spreads 6 to 8 ft. wide while staying just 6 inches tall.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-rug","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Conifer Society Conifer Database","url":"https://conifersociety.org/conifers/juniperus-horizontalis-wiltonii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"After 10 years of growth, a mature specimen will measure 6 to 10 feet (2 - 3 m) wide, but only a couple of inches (2 - 3 cm) high, an annual lateral growth rate of 7 to 10 inches (18 - 25 cm).","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"genus":1,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 6.00 to 8.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 4 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 6 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page's figure is a final size and this row's is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"It reaches 3-6 inches in height and spreads 4-6 feet within the first five years, eventually maturing to 3-6 inches tall with a 6-8 foot spread.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Striking silver-blue foliage spreads 6 to 8 ft. wide while staying just 6 inches tall.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-rug","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249878","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Juniperus horizontalis 'Wiltonii')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-horizontalis-wiltonii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Juniperus horizontalis 'Blue Rug')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-horizontalis-blue-rug/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/juniperus-horizontalis-wiltonii-blue-rug-juniper","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"},{"name":"Scenic Hill Farm Nursery","url":"https://scenichillfarmnursery.com/products/blue-rug-juniper-juniperus-horizontalis-wiltonii","country":"US","form":null,"value":"A hardy, low-growing evergreen shrub ideal for USDA Zones 3-9.","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"},{"name":"Perfect Plants Nursery","url":"https://myperfectplants.com/products/blue-rug-juniper-shrub","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Juniperus horizontalis 'wiltonii' grows best in USDA hardiness zone 3 to 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"cultivar":8,"genus":1,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-rug","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249878","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Juniperus horizontalis 'Wiltonii')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-horizontalis-wiltonii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Juniperus horizontalis 'Blue Rug')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-horizontalis-blue-rug/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (HGIC 1107)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/growing-and-using-juniper-juniperus-spp-groundcovers-and-small-shrubs-2/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"juniperus"},{"name":"UConn Plant Database","url":"https://plantdatabase.uconn.edu/detail.php?pid=229","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun","level":"species","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/juniperus-horizontalis-wiltonii-blue-rug-juniper","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"},{"name":"Scenic Hill Farm Nursery","url":"https://scenichillfarmnursery.com/products/blue-rug-juniper-juniperus-horizontalis-wiltonii","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Thriving in full sun, it adapts well to a range of soil pH levels and prefers well-draining soils, from sandy to rocky types, tolerating poor, dry conditions.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"},{"name":"Perfect Plants Nursery","url":"https://myperfectplants.com/products/blue-rug-juniper-shrub","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in full sun or partial shade for best foliage color, density, and overall health.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-rug","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-horizontalis-wiltonii/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-horizontalis-blue-rug/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Juniperus horizontalis 'Wiltonii')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-horizontalis-wiltonii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Juniperus horizontalis 'Blue Rug')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-horizontalis-blue-rug/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are ncsu.edu. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-rug","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-rug","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","nearMiss":["drought"],"derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249878","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Erosion, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Juniperus horizontalis 'Wiltonii')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-horizontalis-wiltonii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought and deer tolerant, wind tolerant, fairly salt tolerant, and grows well in coastal conditions.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Juniperus horizontalis 'Blue Rug')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-horizontalis-blue-rug/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (HGIC 1107)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/growing-and-using-juniper-juniperus-spp-groundcovers-and-small-shrubs-2/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Adapted to heat, drought, and poor soils of the Southeast.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"juniperus"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/322/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"},{"name":"Scenic Hill Farm Nursery","url":"https://scenichillfarmnursery.com/products/blue-rug-juniper-juniperus-horizontalis-wiltonii","country":null,"form":null,"value":"With slow growth and excellent drought, wind, and salt tolerance, it's a great choice for coastal gardens, erosion control, and rock gardens.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"},{"name":"Perfect Plants Nursery","url":"https://myperfectplants.com/products/blue-rug-juniper-shrub","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought-tolerant, salt-tolerant, and virtually maintenance-free for year-round color and coverage.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus horizontalis"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the row carries [\"drought\"], which nothing in the product reads: hasTag is an equality test against \"drought tolerant\"; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-rug","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Conifer Society Conifer Database","url":"https://conifersociety.org/conifers/juniperus-squamata-blue-star/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"After 10 years of growth, a mature specimen will measure 20 inches (50 cm) tall and 28 inches (70 cm) wide, an annual growth rate of 2 to 3 inches (5 - 7.5 cm).","metres":0.51,"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":12,"species":1,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":11,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 1.00 to 3.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Conifer, evergreen, rounded, squat shrub (dwarf), 3 ft (1 m) tall by 4 ft (1.2 m), mounded.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page's figure is a final size and this row's is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"'Blue Star'- dense habit, blue star-like leaves, 24\" tall\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Garden Size: 2'H x 3'W\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Height: 1 - 3 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 2-3 ft\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Height: 1-3 ft\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Plant Height : 1 to 3 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 11 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Conifer Society Conifer Database","url":"https://conifersociety.org/conifers/juniperus-squamata-blue-star/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"After 10 years of growth, a mature specimen will measure 20 inches (50 cm) tall and 28 inches (70 cm) wide, an annual growth rate of 2 to 3 inches (5 - 7.5 cm).","metres":0.71,"band":[0.64,0.78],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":12,"species":1,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":10,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 1.00 to 4.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Conifer, evergreen, rounded, squat shrub (dwarf), 3 ft (1 m) tall by 4 ft (1.2 m), mounded.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page's figure is a final size and this row's is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Garden Size: 2'H x 3'W\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Width: 3 - 4 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 3-4 ft\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Width: 1-4 ft\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Plant Width : 1 to 3 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-9","5-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249904","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-squamata-blue-star/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/juniperus-squamata-blue-star/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: Zones 4 - 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/Juniperus-squamata-Blue-Star","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5 - 7","zones":[5,7],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/blue-star-juniper-shrub/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In: Zones 4-8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/singleseed-juniper-juniperus-squamata-blue-star","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones : 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":12,"species":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249904","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-squamata-blue-star/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"Cornell University Woody Plants Database (Juniperus squamata species entry)","url":"https://woodyplants.cals.cornell.edu/plant/354","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/99002/juniperus-squamata-blue-star/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"Iseli Nursery","url":"https://www.iselinursery.com/plant/juniperus-squamata-blue-star/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/juniperus-squamata-blue-star/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs: Full Sun, Filtered Sun, Partial Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/Juniperus-squamata-Blue-Star","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun Partial Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/blue-star-juniper-shrub/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs : Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/singleseed-juniper-juniperus-squamata-blue-star","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (HGIC 1068, genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/juniper/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"juniperus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-squamata-blue-star/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/99002/juniperus-squamata-blue-star/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249904","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Erosion, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-squamata-blue-star/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought-tolerant and relatively tolerant of hot and humid conditions.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/juniperus-squamata-blue-star","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sun; adaptable, tolerates dry soils","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21241","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/99002/juniperus-squamata-blue-star/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/blue-star-juniper-shrub/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This little beauty will also tolerate poor and rocky soil, drought, urban conditions and even deer.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/singleseed-juniper-juniperus-squamata-blue-star","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerance : Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus squamata"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (HGIC 1068, genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/juniper/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Adapted to heat, drought, and poor soils of the Southeast.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"juniperus"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"juniper-blue-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"juniper-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"'Gold Coast' is a compact, spreading, evergreen shrub that typically grows 2-3' tall and 3-4' wide over the first 10 years.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Evergreen, spreading shrub, 3 ft tall by 5 ft wide\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"'Gold Coast' is a compact, spreading, evergreen shrub that typically grows 2-3' tall and 3-4' wide over the first 10 years.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Evergreen, spreading shrub, 3 ft tall by 5 ft wide\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263281","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Juniperus chinensis species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-chinensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263281","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-x-pfitzeriana-gold-coast/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Juniperus chinensis species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-chinensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263281","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of some drought once established.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-x-pfitzeriana-gold-coast/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Diseases Dry Soil Erosion","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-sea-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 4.00 to 6.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 4 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-sea-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 6.00 to 8.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 6 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-sea-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261524","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-chinensis-sea-green/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-sea-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261524","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-chinensis-sea-green/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-sea-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261524","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant, Evergreen","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-sea-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-sea-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261524","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of some drought once established.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-chinensis-sea-green/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This Juniperus like others is deer, drought, air pollution, salt, and erosion resistant but also purportedly resistant to Cedar Apple Rust prevalent to other junipers.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-sea-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-skyrocket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[3.29,5.03],"split":[{"range":[3.29,4.03],"sources":["Conifer Kingdom"]},{"range":[4.11,5.03],"sources":["American Conifer Society Conifer Database"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"American Conifer Society Conifer Database","url":"https://conifersociety.org/conifers/juniperus-scopulorum-skyrocket/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"it has become the most popular upright juniper growing 15 feet (3 m) tall and 2 feet (60 cm) wide after 10 years","metres":4.57,"band":[4.11,5.03],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"Conifer Kingdom","url":"https://www.coniferkingdom.com/juniperus-scopulorum-skyrocket-rocky-mountain-juniper/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It has a fast growth rate of 12″+ per year and has a 10 year size of about 12’H x 3’W.","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":2,"cultivar":10},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":8,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"'Skyrocket' - very narrow spire, to 25 ft (7.5 m), only 2-3 ft (0.6-0.9 m) wide, blue-gray foliage; male.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height:\n20 - 30 feet tall\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Growing 25 to 30 feet tall by 6 to 8 feet wide at maturity\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Height:\n15-20 ft\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 15 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 15-18 ft\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Height: 15-18 Feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Height : 15 ft.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"juniper-skyrocket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.55,1],"split":[{"range":[0.55,0.67],"sources":["American Conifer Society Conifer Database"]},{"range":[0.82,1],"sources":["Conifer Kingdom"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"American Conifer Society Conifer Database","url":"https://conifersociety.org/conifers/juniperus-scopulorum-skyrocket/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"it has become the most popular upright juniper growing 15 feet (3 m) tall and 2 feet (60 cm) wide after 10 years","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"Conifer Kingdom","url":"https://www.coniferkingdom.com/juniperus-scopulorum-skyrocket-rocky-mountain-juniper/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It has a fast growth rate of 12″+ per year and has a 10 year size of about 12’H x 3’W.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":2,"cultivar":10},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":8,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"'Skyrocket' - very narrow spire, to 25 ft (7.5 m), only 2-3 ft (0.6-0.9 m) wide, blue-gray foliage; male.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread:\n2 - 3 feet wide\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Growing 25 to 30 feet tall by 6 to 8 feet wide at maturity\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Width:\n2-4 ft\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 24 inches\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 2-3 ft\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Spread: 2-3 Feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Width : 2-3 ft.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"juniper-skyrocket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-7","3-9","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Resources, Woody Plant Finder","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/woody-info/Juniperus_scopulorumSkyrocket.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone:\nzones 3 - 7","zones":[3,7],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/skyrocket-juniper.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zones: 3a-9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/skyrocket-juniper/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In:\nZones 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus virginiana"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/JUNIPERUS-SCOPULORUM-SKYROCKET","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-7","zones":[3,7],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"Conifer Kingdom","url":"https://www.coniferkingdom.com/juniperus-scopulorum-skyrocket-rocky-mountain-juniper/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Skyrocket Juniper is an easy-care plant that tolerates various conditions in USDA hardiness zones 4 to 9.","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/juniper-skyrocket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/juniperskyrocket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In Zones : 4-9 outdoors","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":2,"cultivar":10},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"juniper-skyrocket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-scopulorum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"American Conifer Society Conifer Database","url":"https://conifersociety.org/conifers/juniperus-scopulorum-skyrocket/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Once established, 'Skyrocket' is drought tolerant and is often used as a screen or windbreak for full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/skyrocket-juniper.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs: Full Sun or Part Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/skyrocket-juniper/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs :\nFull Sun, Partial Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus virginiana"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/sky-rocket-juniper","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"Colesville Nursery","url":"https://www.colesvillenursery.com/Plant-Name/JUNIPERUS-SCOPULORUM-SKYROCKET","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure\n\nFull Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"Conifer Kingdom","url":"https://www.coniferkingdom.com/juniperus-scopulorum-skyrocket-rocky-mountain-juniper/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun brings out its best color, and it grows in any soil","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/juniperskyrocket","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight : Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"juniper-skyrocket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-scopulorum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/skyrocket-juniper.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Foliage: Yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"juniper-skyrocket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"juniper-skyrocket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-scopulorum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought, salt spray, erosion, dry soil, and air pollution tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"American Conifer Society Conifer Database","url":"https://conifersociety.org/conifers/juniperus-scopulorum-skyrocket/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, 'Skyrocket' is drought tolerant and is often used as a screen or windbreak for full sun","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Juniperus scopulorum)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/juniperus-scopulorum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sun. Can withstand drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Resources, Woody Plant Finder","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/woody-info/Juniperus_scopulorumSkyrocket.php","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water:\ndrought-tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/skyrocket-juniper.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"High drought tolerance when established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/skyrocket-juniper/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Highly tolerant of sun and drought, yet super hardy in the coldest areas, this is the ideal choice for any climate.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus virginiana"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/sky-rocket-juniper","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is considered to be drought-tolerant, and thus makes an ideal choice for xeriscaping or the moisture-conserving landscape.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"Conifer Kingdom","url":"https://www.coniferkingdom.com/juniperus-scopulorum-skyrocket-rocky-mountain-juniper/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, it is very drought tolerant and also does well in poor soil conditions.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/juniper-skyrocket","country":null,"form":null,"value":"'Skyrocket' is a fairly fast grower and like most junipers tolerates drier conditions.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/juniperskyrocket","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Thrives in a variety of climates with high drought tolerance and minimal maintenance needs","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"}],"note":"10 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"juniper-skyrocket","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/juniperus-scopulorum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Songbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"juniperus scopulorum"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"juniper-spartan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":4.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"15.00 to 20.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Grows 15 ft. tall, 5 ft. wide in natural form.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-spartan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"4.00 to 5.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Grows 15 ft. tall, 5 ft. wide in natural form.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-spartan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249855","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/spartan-juniper.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4-9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-spartan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249855","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/spartan-juniper.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-spartan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-spartan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-spartan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249855","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of some drought once established.","claim":true},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/spartan-juniper.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Waterwise","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"juniper-spartan","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"knockout-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.61,2.01],"split":[{"range":[0.61,1.52],"sources":["University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa Knock Out Group)","UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County fact sheet","Star Roses and Plants (The Knock Out Family of Roses)","Sooner Plant Farm","Mortellaro's Nursery","Valdosta State University Campus Plants"]},{"range":[1.65,2.01],"sources":["University of Missouri Extension G6600","Pleasant Run Nursery"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252230","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa Knock Out Group)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-knock-out-group/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=651&PlantTypeID=4","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2-4 Feet","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County fact sheet","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/05/28/fact-sheet-knock-rose-radrazz/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height x width: 3-4' x 3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Valdosta State University Campus Plants","url":"https://www.valdosta.edu/biology/campus-plants/knockoutrose.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size : 4 ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Star Roses and Plants (The Knock Out Family of Roses)","url":"https://www.knockoutroses.com/the-knock-out-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"mature size: On average 3-4' h x 3-4' w","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension G6600","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/publications/g6600","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants of 'Knock Out' are medium-sized, bushy shrubs that achieve a mature height of six feet with an equal spread.","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-knock-out-original","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.westonnurseries.com/12130019/Plant/3978/Knock_Out_Rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Rosa-Knock-Out","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6 Feet","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mortellaro's Nursery","url":"https://www.mortellaros.com/plant/Rosa-chinensis-Radrazz","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3-5 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"unstated":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"knockout-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.82,2.01],"split":[{"range":[0.82,1.52],"sources":["University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa Knock Out Group)","UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County fact sheet","Star Roses and Plants (The Knock Out Family of Roses)","Sooner Plant Farm","Mortellaro's Nursery","Pleasant Run Nursery"]},{"range":[1.65,2.01],"sources":["University of Missouri Extension G6600"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252230","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa Knock Out Group)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-knock-out-group/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=651&PlantTypeID=4","country":"US","form":null,"value":"(width 3 feet)","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County fact sheet","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/05/28/fact-sheet-knock-rose-radrazz/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height x width: 3-4' x 3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Star Roses and Plants (The Knock Out Family of Roses)","url":"https://www.knockoutroses.com/the-knock-out-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"mature size: On average 3-4' h x 3-4' w","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension G6600","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/publications/g6600","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants of 'Knock Out' are medium-sized, bushy shrubs that achieve a mature height of six feet with an equal spread.","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-knock-out-original","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.westonnurseries.com/12130019/Plant/3978/Knock_Out_Rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Rosa-Knock-Out","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4 Feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mortellaro's Nursery","url":"https://www.mortellaros.com/plant/Rosa-chinensis-Radrazz","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3-5 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"unstated":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"knockout-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","4-11","4-9","4-10","5-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252230","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa Knock Out Group)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-knock-out-group/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[4,11]},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=651&PlantTypeID=4","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 - 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County fact sheet","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/05/28/fact-sheet-knock-rose-radrazz/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: USDA 4-10","zones":[4,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Valdosta State University Campus Plants","url":"https://www.valdosta.edu/biology/campus-plants/knockoutrose.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plants Hardiness Zones : 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Star Roses and Plants (The Knock Out Family of Roses)","url":"https://www.knockoutroses.com/the-knock-out-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"zone: 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-knock-out-original","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mortellaro's Nursery","url":"https://www.mortellaros.com/plant/Rosa-chinensis-Radrazz","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In USDA Zones 5-9, Knock Out Roses are cold-hardy, but in areas with severe freezes, mulching around the base provides added root protection.","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"unstated":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"knockout-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252230","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa Knock Out Group)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-knock-out-group/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Roses require full sun and organically rich, well-drained, acidic to neutral soils.","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Valdosta State University Campus Plants","url":"https://www.valdosta.edu/biology/campus-plants/knockoutrose.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-knock-out-original","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.westonnurseries.com/12130019/Plant/3978/Knock_Out_Rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mortellaro's Nursery","url":"https://www.mortellaros.com/plant/Rosa-chinensis-Radrazz","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These roses perform best in full sun and well-drained soils, and they tolerate a wide range of soil types including alkaline soils common in Central Texas.","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"knockout-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252230","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa Knock Out Group)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-knock-out-group/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are often fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=651&PlantTypeID=4","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are red, single 3-inch wide (petal count 5-11) with a slight fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County fact sheet","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/05/28/fact-sheet-knock-rose-radrazz/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Light tea rose, slightly spicy","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Star Roses and Plants (The Knock Out Family of Roses)","url":"https://www.knockoutroses.com/the-knock-out-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"scent: Subtle sweet","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.westonnurseries.com/12130019/Plant/3978/Knock_Out_Rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"is smothered in stunning lightly-scented semi-double cherry red flowers at the ends of the branches from late spring to early fall","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Rosa-Knock-Out","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant - Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mortellaro's Nursery","url":"https://www.mortellaros.com/plant/Rosa-chinensis-Radrazz","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Knock Out Roses are deer-resistant and attract bees and pollinators, though their fragrance is mild compared to traditional rose varieties.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"knockout-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa Knock Out Group)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-knock-out-group/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-knock-out-original","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Weston Nurseries (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.westonnurseries.com/12130019/Plant/3978/Knock_Out_Rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"knockout-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County fact sheet","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/05/28/fact-sheet-knock-rose-radrazz/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hardy, drought tolerant upon establishment, this rose is a carefree, show-stopping Star","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Star Roses and Plants (The Knock Out Family of Roses)","url":"https://www.knockoutroses.com/the-knock-out-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Black spot resistant, drought-tolerant and self-cleaning.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-knock-out-original","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mortellaro's Nursery","url":"https://www.mortellaros.com/plant/Rosa-chinensis-Radrazz","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, they are drought-tolerant and only require moderate supplemental watering during extended dry periods.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"knockout-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252230","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa Knock Out Group)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-knock-out-group/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This rose variety is attractive to pollinators.","claim":true},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/rose-knock-out-original","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mortellaro's Nursery","url":"https://www.mortellaros.com/plant/Rosa-chinensis-Radrazz","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Knock Out Roses are deer-resistant and attract bees and pollinators, though their fragrance is mild compared to traditional rose varieties.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"lady-emma-hamilton","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.13,1.34],"union":[1.1,1.38],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-emma-hamilton","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.40471","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: up to 4' (up to 120cm).","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"United States Plant Patent PP17,709 (Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP17709P2/en","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 1.25 m. Width: 0.9 m.","metres":1.25,"band":[1.13,1.38],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/lady-emma-hamilton","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 3ft (90cm)","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":4,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"lady-emma-hamilton","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.81,1.34],"split":[{"range":[0.81,1],"sources":["United States Plant Patent PP17,709 (Google Patents)","HelpMeFind Roses"]},{"range":[1.1,1.34],"sources":["David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-emma-hamilton","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.40471","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: up to 3' (up to 90cm).","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"United States Plant Patent PP17,709 (Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP17709P2/en","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 1.25 m. Width: 0.9 m.","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/lady-emma-hamilton","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3ft (90cm)","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":4,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"lady-emma-hamilton","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-11","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-emma-hamilton","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 7-11","zones":[7,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.40471","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"USDA zone 5b through 9b.","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":4,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"lady-emma-hamilton","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-emma-hamilton","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/lady-emma-hamilton","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"lady-emma-hamilton","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["strong","strong","strong","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-emma-hamilton","https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.40471"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-emma-hamilton","https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP17709P2/en"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-emma-hamilton","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers have a strong, delicious, fruity fragrance with hints of pear, grape and citrus fruits.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.40471","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Strong, fruity, geranium, tea fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"United States Plant Patent PP17,709 (Google Patents)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP17709P2/en","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Very strong and complex fruity fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"lady-emma-hamilton","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/lady-emma-hamilton","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Borders Cutting Pots & Containers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.40471","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Can be used for cut flower, garden or shrub.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Garden","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"lady-emma-hamilton","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"lady-emma-hamilton","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"lady-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.3,1],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285648","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/athyrium-filix-femina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ATFI","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2-3 ft. tall","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/athyrium-filix-femina","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 36\" tall","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lady-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.76],"union":[0.3,0.91],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285648","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.76],"band":[0.3,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/athyrium-filix-femina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lady-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","3-7","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285648","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/athyrium-filix-femina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/athyrium-filix-femina","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3a to 8b","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lady-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285648","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/athyrium-filix-femina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ATFI","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade , Shade"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/athyrium-filix-femina","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Part Sun to Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lady-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lady-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lady-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285648","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates drier soils than many other ferns.","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/athyrium-filix-femina","country":null,"form":null,"value":"adaptable to moist sunny gardens as well as dry shade","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lady-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lady-of-shalott","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.4,"outcome":"DUAL-FORM","agreement":null,"forms":{"shrub":[1,1.83],"climber":[2.2,2.68]},"catalogForm":"shrub","catalogFormAgreement":"full","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 5ft","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/lady-of-shalott","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4ft (125cm)","metres":1.25,"band":[1.13,1.38],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"5' x 4'","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/lady-of-shalott-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 5 feet","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/lady-of-shalot-climbing-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 5-6'","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rosarium Lottum (Netherlands)","url":"https://rosariumlottum.com/en/product/lady-of-shalott-ausnyson/","country":"NL","form":"shrub","value":"100-150 cm ( Busch Rose ) or as a small climbing Rose (200-300 cm )","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store) - climbing page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott-english-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Height: 8ft","metres":2.44,"band":[2.2,2.68],"role":"other-form","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources describe this rose in both trained forms at different sizes and the catalog holds the shrub; 6 shrub source(s) put the catalogued value inside their range, so the finding is the climbing form the schema cannot hold","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"lady-of-shalott","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.34],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"5' x 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/lady-of-shalott-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Spread: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/lady-of-shalot-climbing-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/lady-of-shalott","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 4ft (125cm)","metres":1.25,"band":[1.13,1.38],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"lady-of-shalott","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are davidaustinroses.com","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott-english-climbing-rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","https://heirloomroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","https://menagerieflower.com/products/lady-of-shalott-rose-david-austin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/lady-of-shalot-climbing-potted-rose-bush"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 4-11","zones":[4,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store) - climbing page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott-english-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 4-11","zones":[4,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 4-11","zones":[4,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/lady-of-shalott-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable Zones: 4-11","zones":[4,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/lady-of-shalot-climbing-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zones: 4-11","zones":[4,11],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7},"reasons":[]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[4,11]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are davidaustinroses.com; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"lady-of-shalott","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store) - climbing page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott-english-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/lady-of-shalott","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Partial Shade or Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/lady-of-shalot-climbing-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"lady-of-shalott","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["medium","medium","medium","medium","strong","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are davidaustinroses.com","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott-english-climbing-rose"]},{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/lady-of-shalott"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","https://heirloomroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","https://menagerieflower.com/products/lady-of-shalott-rose-david-austin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/lady-of-shalot-climbing-potted-rose-bush"]},{"tier":4,"why":"both carry the same 79 character sentence, so one is reprinting the other","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","https://rosariumlottum.com/en/product/lady-of-shalott-ausnyson/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store) - shrub page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There is a pleasant, warm Tea fragrance, with hints of spiced apple and cloves.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store) - climbing page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott-english-climbing-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"with hints of spiced apple and cloves","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/lady-of-shalott","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There is a pleasant, warm Tea fragrance, with hints of spiced apple and cloves.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Very Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/lady-of-shalott-rose-david-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Medium - Tea","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/lady-of-shalot-climbing-potted-rose-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong, apple, clove, tea fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rosarium Lottum (Netherlands)","url":"https://rosariumlottum.com/en/product/lady-of-shalott-ausnyson/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There is a pleasant, warm Tea fragrance, with hints of spiced apple and cloves.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 7 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are davidaustinroses.com; both publish as david-austin-roses; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first; both carry the same 79 character sentence, so one is reprinting the other. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 7","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"lady-of-shalott","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/lady-of-shalot-climbing-potted-rose-bush"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets and floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/lady-of-shalot-climbing-potted-rose-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vase Life: 4-6 days","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"lady-of-shalott","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"lady-of-shalott","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/lady-of-shalott","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees, butterflies, and other beneficial insects that support a healthy garden.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"ladys-mantle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.46],"union":[0.1,0.51],"voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alchemilla-mollis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b210","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/ladys-mantle-alchemilla-mollis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants spread very slowly by rhizomes, forming mounds 12-15\" tall that spread to two feet or more.","metres":[0.3,0.38],"band":[0.3,0.38],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/ladys-mantle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 12 to 18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/alchemilla-mollis-ladys-mantle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant forms a dense mound in the garden, growing about 12 inches in height.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/ladys-mantle/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lady's mantle has a mounded form and grows up to 18 inches high when in flower.","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/774/alchemilla-mollis/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ALCMO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 15.0-18.0 Inches","metres":[0.38,0.46],"band":[0.38,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Perennials.com plant profile","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/alchemilla-mollis.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 30-45 cm 12-18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ladys-mantle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.46,0.5],"union":[0.1,0.76],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alchemilla-mollis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b210","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.46,0.76],"band":[0.46,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/ladys-mantle-alchemilla-mollis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants spread very slowly by rhizomes, forming mounds 12-15\" tall that spread to two feet or more.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/774/alchemilla-mollis/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ALCMO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Perennials.com plant profile","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/alchemilla-mollis.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 45-60 cm 18-23 inches","metres":[0.46,0.58],"band":[0.46,0.58],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ladys-mantle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-7","2-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alchemilla-mollis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b210","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/ladys-mantle-alchemilla-mollis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is hardy in zone 3-8.","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/ladys-mantle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 3 - 7","zones":[3,7],"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/alchemilla-mollis-ladys-mantle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/ladys-mantle/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones Zone 3, Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ALCMO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7","zones":[3,7],"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Perennials.com plant profile","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/alchemilla-mollis.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 2-9","zones":[2,9],"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ladys-mantle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alchemilla-mollis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It can grow in full sun, part shade, and shade making it perfect for underplanting shrubs and trees.","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b210","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/ladys-mantle-alchemilla-mollis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"An easy-care perennial, it does well in sun or partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/ladys-mantle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Partial Sun/Shade","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/alchemilla-mollis-ladys-mantle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/ladys-mantle/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/774/alchemilla-mollis/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full shade, Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ALCMO","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Alchemilla-mollis-Auslese","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Alchemilla mollis 'Auslese' prefers full sun to part shade and has a wonderfully uniform habit.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ladys-mantle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ladys-mantle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alchemilla-mollis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It can be grown for cutting and drying and is the archetypical cottage garden plant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b210","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/ladys-mantle-alchemilla-mollis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut stems make good fillers in cut flower arrangements, but fresh and dried.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/774/alchemilla-mollis/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ALCMO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They work well as a filler in cut flower bouquets or can be dried for fall and winter arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Perennials.com plant profile","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/alchemilla-mollis.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sprays of chartreuse flowers are a nice filler for cut arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["alchemilla mollis"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (alchemilla mollis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (alchemilla mollis) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"ladys-mantle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alchemilla-mollis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lady's Mantle does well in all types of soil as long as there is moisture and has no real preference for acidic or alkaline soils.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b210","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In hot summer climates such as St. Louis, leaves may scorch in full sun exposures or if soils are permitted to dry out.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/ladys-mantle-alchemilla-mollis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is not drought tolerant and should be watered when soil moisture is lacking.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/ladys-mantle","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Prefers a moist soil in a lightly shaded location.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/ladys-mantle/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soil should be consistently moist.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/774/alchemilla-mollis/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Will tolerate any soil so long as there is some moisture; suitable for sun or shade.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ALCMO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"During active growth keep the soil consistently moist.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["alchemilla mollis"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (alchemilla mollis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"7 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (alchemilla mollis) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ladys-mantle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/alchemilla-mollis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Attracts butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/alchemilla-mollis-ladys-mantle","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ALCMO","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"},{"name":"Perennials.com plant profile","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/alchemilla-mollis.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"alchemilla mollis"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"lambs-ear","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.3,0.33],"union":[0.15,0.46],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281603","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.75 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.23,0.46],"band":[0.23,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/stachys-byzantina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/stachys-byzantina.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 30-45 cm 12-18 inches","metres":[0.3,0.45],"band":[0.3,0.45],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Resources, Herbaceous Plant Finder","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Stachys_byzantina.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 foot","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Waterwise Garden Planner","url":"https://waterwisegardenplanner.org/plants/stachys-byzantina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants reach 6-12 in. tall and can spread 2-3 ft. and more with surface runners.","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Martin Garden Center","url":"https://www.martinnursery.com/lambs-ears-stachys/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plant typically grows in compact, low mounds, reaching a height of 12 to 18 inches.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":4},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lambs-ear","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.3,0.91],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281603","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/stachys-byzantina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/stachys-byzantina.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 30-60 cm 12-23 inches","metres":[0.3,0.6],"band":[0.3,0.6],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Resources, Herbaceous Plant Finder","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Stachys_byzantina.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1 - 3 feet","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Waterwise Garden Planner","url":"https://waterwisegardenplanner.org/plants/stachys-byzantina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants reach 6-12 in. tall and can spread 2-3 ft. and more with surface runners.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":4},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lambs-ear","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-9","3-9","5-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281603","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/stachys-byzantina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/stachys-byzantina.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Resources, Herbaceous Plant Finder","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Stachys_byzantina.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: zones 5 - 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/stachys-byzantina-lambs-ears","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4 - 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Martin Garden Center","url":"https://www.martinnursery.com/lambs-ears-stachys/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is particularly well-adapted to USDA hardiness zones 4 to 8.","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":4},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lambs-ear","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281603","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/stachys-byzantina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lamb's ear grows well in average, dry to medium, very well-drained soils in full sun to partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Stachys byzantina 'Big Ears')","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/stachys-byzantina-big-ears/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It prefers full sun and well-drained soils.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Stachys byzantina 'Cotton Boll')","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/lambs-ear-stachys-byzantina-cotton-boll/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"'Cotton Boll' is easy to grow in well-drained soils in full sun in cool climates and light shade in hot climates.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/stachys-byzantina.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun or Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Landscaping ground covers (Stachys byzantina 'Helen von Stein')","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/landscaping/lambs-ear","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers full sun in well-drained soil.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/stachys-byzantina-lambs-ears","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Martin Garden Center","url":"https://www.martinnursery.com/lambs-ears-stachys/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"However, it truly shines when exposed to full sunlight.","level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lambs-ear","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/stachys-byzantina/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#fragrant leaves","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lambs-ear","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/stachys-byzantina.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["stachys byzantina"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (stachys byzantina), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (stachys byzantina) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lambs-ear","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281603","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants are generally drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/stachys-byzantina/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The plant is deer-resistant and moderately drought-tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/stachys-byzantina.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Plant Resources, Herbaceous Plant Finder","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/herbaceous-info/Stachys_byzantina.php","country":null,"form":null,"value":"drought-tolerant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Martin Garden Center","url":"https://www.martinnursery.com/lambs-ears-stachys/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its drought tolerance and ability to thrive in poor soils make it a favorite for rock gardens and borders.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["stachys byzantina"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (stachys byzantina), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (stachys byzantina) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lambs-ear","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/stachys-byzantina/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"http://www.perennials.com/plants/stachys-byzantina.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Waterwise Garden Planner","url":"https://waterwisegardenplanner.org/plants/stachys-byzantina/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Borders, Attracts butterflies, Residential spaces","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"},{"name":"Martin Garden Center","url":"https://www.martinnursery.com/lambs-ears-stachys/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These charming blooms also attract pollinators like bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"stachys byzantina"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"lamium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.15,0.2],"union":[0.08,0.8],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lamium-maculatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 3 in. - 0 ft. 9 in.","metres":[0.08,0.23],"band":[0.08,0.23],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lamium maculatum"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/spotted-deadnettle-lamium-maculatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is low-growing (6 to 8 inches tall), with a spreading habit.","metres":[0.15,0.2],"band":[0.15,0.2],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lamium maculatum"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/9812/lamium-maculatum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lamium maculatum"},{"name":"Go Botany, Native Plant Trust","url":"https://gobotany.nativeplanttrust.org/species/lamium/maculatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant height 15-80 cm","metres":[0.15,0.8],"band":[0.15,0.8],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lamium maculatum"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"species":4,"cultivar":9},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lamium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.5,0.61],"union":[0.3,1],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lamium-maculatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lamium maculatum"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/9812/lamium-maculatum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lamium maculatum"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"species":4,"cultivar":9},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lamium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lamium-maculatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"lamium maculatum"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/spotted-deadnettle-lamium-maculatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"hardy in zones 3a to 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"lamium maculatum"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"species":4,"cultivar":9},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lamium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/spotted-deadnettle-lamium-maculatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lamium maculatum grows best in part shade (especially silver leaf types which often need more light to maintain leaf color) or shade in moist, humus-rich, well-drained soil, but in our climate will even grow in full sun.","level":"species","taxon":"lamium maculatum"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/9812/lamium-maculatum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full shade, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"lamium maculatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Lamium maculatum 'White Nancy'","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249391","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamium maculatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Lamium maculatum 'Beedham's White'","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249388","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamium maculatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Lamium maculatum 'Cosmopolitan'","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269227","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamium maculatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Lamium maculatum 'Checkin' PINK CHABLIS","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=366170","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamium maculatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Lamium maculatum 'Red Nancy'","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249390","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamium maculatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder, Lamium maculatum 'Elisabeth de Haas'","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257095","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamium maculatum"},{"name":"Perennial Resource / Walters Gardens, Lamium maculatum 'Purple Dragon'","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/lamium-maculatum-purple-dragon.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Partial Shade or Full Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamium maculatum"},{"name":"Perennial Resource / Walters Gardens, Lamium maculatum 'Beacon Silver'","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/lamium-maculatum-beacon-silver.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Partial Shade or Full Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamium maculatum"},{"name":"Claire Austin Hardy Plants, Lamium maculatum 'White Nancy'","url":"https://www.claireaustin-hardyplants.co.uk/products/lamium-maculatum-white-nancy","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"How Much Sun: Sun/Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"lamium maculatum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lamium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lamium-maculatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Can have an unpleasant scent when crushed.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"lamium maculatum"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/spotted-deadnettle-lamium-maculatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The downy to softly hairy leaves, which are unpleasantly scented when bruised, are green with a white or silver stripe down the midvein.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"lamium maculatum"}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lamium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lamium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lamium-maculatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It will tolerate dry soil.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lamium maculatum"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/spotted-deadnettle-lamium-maculatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"it is drought tolerant and will grow in dry shade","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lamium maculatum"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":8,"covered":["lamium maculatum"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (lamium maculatum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 8 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (lamium maculatum) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lamium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/spotted-deadnettle-lamium-maculatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract bees, especially bumblebees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lamium maculatum"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lantana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":4,"genus":4},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 3.00 to 4.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height: 12 - 24 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 1-1.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lantana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":4,"genus":4},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 1-1.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lantana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-11","10-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lantana camara)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lantana-camara/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[7,11],"level":"species","taxon":"lantana camara"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lantana camara)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287443","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11],"level":"species","taxon":"lantana camara"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":4,"genus":4},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lantana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lantana camara)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lantana-camara/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"lantana camara"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lantana camara)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287443","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"lantana camara"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Lantana, centred on Lantana camara)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/lantana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow lantana in full sun.","level":"genus","taxon":"lantana"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers (Lantana, in the annuals section)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/lantana","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"lantana camara"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Lantana camara)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/99415/lantana-camara/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"lantana camara"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Lantana, genus article covering Lantana camara)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/lantana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lantana does best in full sun and hot temperatures in well drained soil","level":"genus","taxon":"lantana"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Lantana, grown as an annual in Minnesota)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/flowers/lantana","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They require full sun and a well-drained soil.","level":"genus","taxon":"lantana"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions (Lantana)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/lantana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"All lantana enjoy full sun.","level":"genus","taxon":"lantana"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lantana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lantana camara)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lantana-camara/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Simple, opposite or whorled, toothed, ovate, fragrant when crushed","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lantana camara"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lantana camara)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287443","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lantana camara"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Lantana, centred on Lantana camara)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/lantana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Crushed leaves have a pungent scent, so you may want to locate where the plant it will not spread across walks if the odor offends you.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"lantana"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Lantana, grown as an annual in Minnesota)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/flowers/lantana","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The foliage of lantanas has a distinct, pungent aroma and should be handled with care as the leaves can cause a rash.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lantana"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"lantana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lantana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lantana camara)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lantana-camara/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It prefers full sun in moist, well-drained soil but will tolerate poor soil and drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lantana camara"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lantana camara)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287443","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lantana camara"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Lantana, centred on Lantana camara)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/lantana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"While established lantanas are drought tolerant, performance, bloom, and growth rate will be reduced if they are too dry for a long period.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lantana"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Lantana, genus article covering Lantana camara)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/lantana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is easy to grow and is heat, drought and sun tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lantana"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions (Lantana)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/lantana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is heat, salt, and drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lantana"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lantana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lantana camara)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lantana-camara/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lantana flowers are very attractive to butterflies, berries are eaten by birds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lantana camara"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lantana camara)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287443","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lantana camara"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Lantana, centred on Lantana camara)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/lantana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lantana"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers (Lantana, in the annuals section)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/lantana","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They attract butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lantana camara"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Lantana, genus article covering Lantana camara)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/lantana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lantana is attractive to butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lantana"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Lantana, grown as an annual in Minnesota)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/flowers/lantana","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are very attractive to butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lantana"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions (Lantana)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/lantana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees and butterflies flock to the bright mounds of color.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lantana"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lantana-bandana-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1-2 Feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"14-16 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lantana-bandana-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1-2 Feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"14-16 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lantana-bandana-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-11","9-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bandana-cherry-lantana","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10-11","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"Lucas Greenhouses","url":"https://www.lucasgreenhouses.com/plant/Lantana-camara-Bandana-Cherry","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 9 - 11","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lantana-bandana-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bandana-cherry-lantana","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun (6+ Hours Direct Sun)"},{"name":"Lucas Greenhouses","url":"https://www.lucasgreenhouses.com/plant/Lantana-camara-Bandana-Cherry","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lantana-bandana-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bandana-cherry-lantana","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lantana-bandana-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lantana-bandana-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bandana-cherry-lantana","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant: Yes","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lantana-bandana-cherry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bandana-cherry-lantana","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lantana-confetti","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 2' - 3'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 24-36″\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height & Spread: 2-3' x 6-8'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Size: 3' x 8'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height: 3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 2-3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Confetti Lantana will grow to be about 24 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 3 feet.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lantana-confetti","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 6' - 8'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 60-72″\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height & Spread: 2-3' x 6-8'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Size: 3' x 8'\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Width: 8 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 3-6 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Confetti Lantana will grow to be about 24 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 3 feet.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lantana-confetti","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-11","7-11","9-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lantana camara, species page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287443","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lantana camara, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lantana-camara/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[7,11]},{"name":"Riverbend Nursery (wholesale, Virginia)","url":"https://riverbendnursery.com/products/lantana-camara-confetti","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 9 - 11","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"New Garden Plants (retail nursery, Ohio)","url":"https://www.newgardenplants.com/confetti","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zone 7, 8, 9, 10, 11","zones":[7,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lantana-confetti","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lantana camara, species page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287443","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lantana camara, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lantana-camara/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension Horticulture (Lantana, genus article)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/lantana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lantana does best in full sun and hot temperatures in well drained soil"},{"name":"Riverbend Nursery (wholesale, Virginia)","url":"https://riverbendnursery.com/products/lantana-camara-confetti","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Full Sun , Partial Sun"},{"name":"Premier Growers, Inc. (wholesale grower)","url":"https://premiergrowersinc.com/product/lantana-confetti/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lighting Condition Full Sun"},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms (wholesale grower, California)","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/lantana-camara-confetti/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun"},{"name":"Sierra Vista Growers (New Mexico)","url":"https://sierravistagrowers.net/shrubs/lantana-confetti/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure:: Full sun"},{"name":"Armstrong Garden Centers (Monrovia product data)","url":"https://shop.armstronggarden.com/products/lan-confetti-tm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full Sun"},{"name":"New Garden Plants (retail nursery, Ohio)","url":"https://www.newgardenplants.com/confetti","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun-Shade Full Sun"},{"name":"Fernwood Garden Center plant database","url":"https://plants.fernwoodgardencenter.com/12170020/Plant/13189/Confetti_Lantana","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in full sun to partial shade."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lantana-confetti","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"New Garden Plants (retail nursery, Ohio)","url":"https://www.newgardenplants.com/confetti","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lantana-confetti","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lantana-confetti","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lantana camara, species page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287443","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension Horticulture (Lantana, genus article)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/lantana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is easy to grow and is heat, drought and sun tolerant.","claim":true},{"name":"Riverbend Nursery (wholesale, Virginia)","url":"https://riverbendnursery.com/products/lantana-camara-confetti","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established.","claim":true},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms (wholesale grower, California)","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/lantana-camara-confetti/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Birds/Butterflies/Bees / Deer Resistant / Desert Conditions / Drought Resistant / Seacoast Conditions","claim":true},{"name":"Sierra Vista Growers (New Mexico)","url":"https://sierravistagrowers.net/shrubs/lantana-confetti/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Heat and drought tolerant.","claim":true},{"name":"Armstrong Garden Centers (Monrovia product data)","url":"https://shop.armstronggarden.com/products/lan-confetti-tm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates heat and drought, when established in the landscape.","claim":true},{"name":"New Garden Plants (retail nursery, Ohio)","url":"https://www.newgardenplants.com/confetti","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant Butterfly Magnet!","claim":true},{"name":"Fernwood Garden Center plant database","url":"https://plants.fernwoodgardencenter.com/12170020/Plant/13189/Confetti_Lantana","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is considered to be drought-tolerant, and thus makes an ideal choice for a low-water garden or xeriscape application.","claim":true}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lantana-confetti","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lantana camara, species page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287443","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Boething Treeland Farms (wholesale grower, California)","url":"https://www.boethingtreeland.com/plants/lantana-camara-confetti/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Birds/Butterflies/Bees / Deer Resistant / Desert Conditions / Drought Resistant / Seacoast Conditions","claim":true},{"name":"Sierra Vista Growers (New Mexico)","url":"https://sierravistagrowers.net/shrubs/lantana-confetti/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"New Garden Plants (retail nursery, Ohio)","url":"https://www.newgardenplants.com/confetti","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and birds","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"larkspur","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":2,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"PLANT HEIGHT: 36-48\".\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Stems are typically 3 to 5 ft. tall, with green, lacy foliage.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"larkspur","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":2,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"larkspur","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":2,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"larkspur","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Consolida ajacis, giant larkspur)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263223","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"consolida ajacis"},{"name":"RHS Plant Finder (Consolida ajacis, larkspur)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/25953/consolida-ajacis/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"consolida ajacis"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service, Plant of the Week (larkspur, Consolida ajacis)","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/larkspur-6-12-09.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They must have full sun.","level":"species","taxon":"consolida ajacis"},{"name":"Dallas County Master Gardeners Association, Texas A&M AgriLife (Consolida ajacis, Larkspur)","url":"https://dallascountymastergardeners.org/consolida-ajacis-larkspur/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Requirement : Full Sun (6+ hours)","level":"species","taxon":"consolida ajacis"},{"name":"Jersey-Friendly Yards plant database, Barnegat Bay Partnership (Consolida ajacis)","url":"https://jerseyyards.org/plant/consolida-ajacis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Optimal Light: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"consolida ajacis"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds, larkspur genus page (Larkspur, Consolida)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/larkspur.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"consolida ajacis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"larkspur","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"larkspur","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds Grower's Library, key growing information (Larkspur, Consolida spp)","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/growers-library/flowers/larkspur-consolida/larkspur-key-growing-information.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cut or dried flower.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"consolida"},{"name":"Cornell University High Tunnels, cut flower crops (Larkspur, Consolida)","url":"https://blogs.cornell.edu/hightunnels/flowers/cut-flowers/cut-flower-crops/larkspur","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vase life at room temperature: 5 to 7 days.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"consolida"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":5,"covered":["consolida ajacis"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (consolida ajacis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; 5 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (consolida ajacis) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"larkspur","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["consolida ajacis"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (consolida ajacis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (consolida ajacis) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"larkspur","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["consolida ajacis"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (consolida ajacis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (consolida ajacis) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"larkspur-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"2.00 to 4.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"strong stems growing about 3 feet tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"larkspur-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1.00 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"larkspur-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263223","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2 to 11","zones":[2,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"larkspur-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263223","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/larkspur-6-12-09.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They must have full sun."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"larkspur-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"larkspur-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263223","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cut flower for fresh or dried arrangements.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/larkspur-6-12-09.aspx","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They also make good cut flowers.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"larkspur-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"larkspur-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.91],"union":[0.3,0.91],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/lavender","country":"US","form":null,"value":"perennial plant growing 1 ½ to 3 feet tall","metres":[0.46,0.91],"band":[0.46,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/blogs/perennials/how-to-grow-lavender","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lavender plants range from 1 to 3 feet tall and wide and do not require staking.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.91],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/blogs/perennials/how-to-grow-lavender","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lavender plants range from 1 to 3 feet tall and wide and do not require staking.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening Flower Growing Guide","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene9108.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening Flower Growing Guide","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene9108.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: full sun Does not grow well in even partial shade."},{"name":"Colorado State University Extension","url":"https://extension.colostate.edu/resource/growing-lavender-in-colorado/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lavender grows best in full sun and slightly alkaline soils, which makes it a perfect plant for Colorado."},{"name":"UC Statewide IPM Program (UC ANR)","url":"https://ipm.ucanr.edu/home-and-landscape/cultural-tips-for-growing-lavender/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lavender grows best if the plant receives full sun for 6 hours or more each day."},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/lavender/growing-guide","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Thrives in full sun and is drought tolerant"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/blogs/perennials/how-to-grow-lavender","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Lavender needs full sun and well-drained soil to grow best."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The entire plant is fragrant, and the showy summer flowers are bee magnets.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/lavender","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lavender is one of the most popular herbs for the fragrance of its dried flowers and the oil distilled from them.","claim":true},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening Flower Growing Guide","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene9108.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"fragrant - All parts are strongly aromatic with a pleasant, penetrating balsamic scent.","claim":true},{"name":"Colorado State University Extension","url":"https://extension.colostate.edu/resource/growing-lavender-in-colorado/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Prized for its fragrance, medicinal properties, and beautiful color, lavender has been one of the most popular herbs for centuries.","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/lavender/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lavender is prized for its richly fragrant flowers and aromatic foliage.","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/blogs/perennials/how-to-grow-lavender","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Since lavender is very fragrant, many pests, such as deer and beetles, avoid this plant.","claim":true}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening Flower Growing Guide","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene9108.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special uses: cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/blogs/perennials/how-to-grow-lavender","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lavender is used in foods, medicines, cosmetics, sachets, and potpourris, as well as in fresh and dried flower arrangements.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Rabbits","claim":true},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening Flower Growing Guide","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene9108.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, the plants are drought-tolerant.","claim":true},{"name":"Colorado State University Extension","url":"https://extension.colostate.edu/resource/growing-lavender-in-colorado/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Even though lavender is drought tolerant, adequate supplemental irrigation is required for optimum establishment","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/lavender/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"lavender is drought tolerant so rarely needs watering when grown in the ground","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/blogs/perennials/how-to-grow-lavender","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, lavender is drought tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good nectar plant for bees and butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening Flower Growing Guide","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene9108.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: beneficial insects - Bees.","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/lavender/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are very attractive to bees and other pollinating insects","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/blogs/perennials/how-to-grow-lavender","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lavender is visited by many pollinators throughout the season.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-edelweiss","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.1,0.91],"split":[{"range":[0.1,0.5],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society"]},{"range":[0.61,0.91],"sources":["High Country Gardens","Mountain Valley Growers","Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","Lone Wolf Lavender (grower variety page)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/218197/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-edelweiss","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 24-36\" tall","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Mountain Valley Growers","url":"https://mountainvalleygrowers.com/organic-plants/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss-edelweiss-white-lavender/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 2 feet, 3 feet with bloom","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 2 - 3 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Lone Wolf Lavender (grower variety page)","url":"https://lonewolflavender.com/lavender-varieties/edelweiss/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This cultivar typically reaches about 24 to 36 inches in height and spreads similarly, forming a bushy and robust plant that is both visually appealing and aromatic.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-edelweiss","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.7,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.1,0.91],"split":[{"range":[0.1,0.5],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society"]},{"range":[0.61,0.91],"sources":["High Country Gardens","Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","Lone Wolf Lavender (grower variety page)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/218197/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-edelweiss","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 24-30\" wide","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 2 - 3 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Lone Wolf Lavender (grower variety page)","url":"https://lonewolflavender.com/lavender-varieties/edelweiss/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This cultivar typically reaches about 24 to 36 inches in height and spreads similarly, forming a bushy and robust plant that is both visually appealing and aromatic.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-edelweiss","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","5-10","5-11","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Lavandula x intermedia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-edelweiss","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 5 Zone 6 Zone 7 Zone 8 Zone 9 Zone 10","zones":[5,10]},{"name":"Mountain Valley Growers","url":"https://mountainvalleygrowers.com/organic-plants/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss-edelweiss-white-lavender/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Perennial in Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11]},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: Zones 5 - 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Lone Wolf Lavender (grower variety page)","url":"https://lonewolflavender.com/lavender-varieties/edelweiss/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10","zones":[5,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-edelweiss","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Lavandula x intermedia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/218197/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-edelweiss","country":"US","form":null,"value":"For best results, grow in well-drained soil in full sun."},{"name":"Mountain Valley Growers","url":"https://mountainvalleygrowers.com/organic-plants/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss-edelweiss-white-lavender/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Characteristics Full Sun, Evergreen, Water Conserving"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs: Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-edelweiss","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/218197/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Spikes of scented, white flowers are produced in summer","claim":true},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-edelweiss","country":null,"form":null,"value":"'Edelweiss' is strongly fragrant, making it an excellent source of dried flower stems and dried flowers for crafts.","claim":true},{"name":"Mountain Valley Growers","url":"https://mountainvalleygrowers.com/organic-plants/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss-edelweiss-white-lavender/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The intensely fragrant flowering stems of Edelweiss Lavender can be harvested for fresh crafts like Wreath Making or potpourri.","claim":true},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pale pink to bright white flowers and linear, bright green foliage are aromatic.","claim":true},{"name":"Lone Wolf Lavender (grower variety page)","url":"https://lonewolflavender.com/lavender-varieties/edelweiss/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"forming a bushy and robust plant that is both visually appealing and aromatic","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-edelweiss","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-edelweiss","https://mountainvalleygrowers.com/organic-plants/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss-edelweiss-white-lavender/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-edelweiss","https://devilmountainnursery.com/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-edelweiss","https://lonewolflavender.com/lavender-varieties/edelweiss/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-edelweiss","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Mountain Valley Growers","url":"https://mountainvalleygrowers.com/organic-plants/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss-edelweiss-white-lavender/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses Butterfly, Culinary, Dried Flower, Fragrant, Ornamental","claim":true},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Thin flower spikes bloom on very long stems in summer, good for drying.","claim":true},{"name":"Lone Wolf Lavender (grower variety page)","url":"https://lonewolflavender.com/lavender-varieties/edelweiss/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The bright white flowers are ideal for creating fresh floral arrangements, where they can add a light, airy touch.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-edelweiss","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/218197/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-edelweiss","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water Tolerance Low-Water","claim":true},{"name":"Mountain Valley Growers","url":"https://mountainvalleygrowers.com/organic-plants/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss-edelweiss-white-lavender/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Full Sun, Evergreen, Water Conserving","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-edelweiss","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-edelweiss","https://mountainvalleygrowers.com/organic-plants/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss-edelweiss-white-lavender/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-edelweiss","https://devilmountainnursery.com/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-edelweiss","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bee Friendly","claim":true},{"name":"Mountain Valley Growers","url":"https://mountainvalleygrowers.com/organic-plants/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss-edelweiss-white-lavender/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lavenders are great bee and beneficial insect plants.","claim":true},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/lavandula-x-intermedia-edelweiss/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts birds, bees and butterflies.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-french","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Herb","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"reaching a height of up to 3ft\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 2-3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height 3-5 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height 2-3 Feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-french","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Herb","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"and a spread of 3ft wide\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 4-5 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread 2-3 Feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-french","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,9],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[8,11],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"University of Arizona Campus Arboretum","url":"https://apps.cals.arizona.edu/arboretum/taxon.aspx?id=1257","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant thrives in USDA zones 8-11","zones":[8,11]},{"name":"Mountain Valley Growers","url":"https://mountainvalleygrowers.com/organic-plants/lavandula-dentata-french-lavender/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Perennial in Zones 8-11","zones":[8,11]},{"name":"Woodlanders","url":"https://woodlanders.net/products/lavendula-dentata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 8-11","zones":[8,11]}],"note":"every source states 8-11; catalog states 8-9","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-french","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"San Marcos Growers","url":"https://www.smgrowers.com/products/plants/plantdisplay.asp?plant_id=940","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun"},{"name":"Mountain Valley Growers","url":"https://mountainvalleygrowers.com/organic-plants/lavandula-dentata-french-lavender/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun, Evergreen, Water Conserving"},{"name":"Woodlanders","url":"https://woodlanders.net/products/lavendula-dentata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light. Full sun; intolerant of shade."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-french","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"University of Arizona Campus Arboretum","url":"https://apps.cals.arizona.edu/arboretum/taxon.aspx?id=1257","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are highly aromatic, possessing the classic lavender scent of other species in the genus","claim":true},{"name":"San Marcos Growers","url":"https://www.smgrowers.com/products/plants/plantdisplay.asp?plant_id=940","country":null,"form":null,"value":"pungently aromatic gray-green toothed-margined leaves","claim":true},{"name":"Mountain Valley Growers","url":"https://mountainvalleygrowers.com/organic-plants/lavandula-dentata-french-lavender/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Culinary, Dried Flower, Fragrant, Ornamental","claim":true},{"name":"Woodlanders","url":"https://woodlanders.net/products/lavendula-dentata","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance. Clean and aromatic, part lavender and part pine resin","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-french","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-french","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"University of Arizona Campus Arboretum","url":"https://apps.cals.arizona.edu/arboretum/taxon.aspx?id=1257","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant prefers hot and dry conditions, and is drought and heat tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"San Marcos Growers","url":"https://www.smgrowers.com/products/plants/plantdisplay.asp?plant_id=940","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Summer Dry: Yes","claim":true},{"name":"Mountain Valley Growers","url":"https://mountainvalleygrowers.com/organic-plants/lavandula-dentata-french-lavender/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Full Sun, Evergreen, Water Conserving","claim":true},{"name":"Woodlanders","url":"https://woodlanders.net/products/lavendula-dentata","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The lavender is evergreen, drought-tolerant, and deer-resistant","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-french","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"University of Arizona Campus Arboretum","url":"https://apps.cals.arizona.edu/arboretum/taxon.aspx?id=1257","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the plant itself attracts many pollinators with its lovely flowers, being especially enticing to bees and butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Woodlanders","url":"https://woodlanders.net/products/lavendula-dentata","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the bees and butterflies work the flowers for much of the year","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-grosso","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials / Perennials.com plant profile","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/lavandula-intermedia-grosso.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"23-29 inches","metres":[0.58,0.74],"band":[0.58,0.74],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-grosso","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials / Perennials.com plant profile","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/lavandula-intermedia-grosso.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"18-23 inches","metres":[0.46,0.58],"band":[0.46,0.58],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-grosso","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","5-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials / Perennials.com plant profile","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/lavandula-intermedia-grosso.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5-9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species-level page for Lavandula x intermedia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone","zones":[5,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-grosso","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials / Perennials.com plant profile","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/lavandula-intermedia-grosso.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species-level page for Lavandula x intermedia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-grosso","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials / Perennials.com plant profile","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/lavandula-intermedia-grosso.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species-level page for Lavandula x intermedia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Both the flowers and the leaves are highly aromatic.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-grosso","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials / Perennials.com plant profile","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/lavandula-intermedia-grosso.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for fresh cutting","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species-level page for Lavandula x intermedia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its blooms are suitable for cut flowers and also dried.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-grosso","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials / Perennials.com plant profile","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/lavandula-intermedia-grosso.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-grosso","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials / Perennials.com plant profile","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/lavandula-intermedia-grosso.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species-level page for Lavandula x intermedia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies, bees, and moths.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-hidcote","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.45,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.3,0.46],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249421","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/lavender-hidcote","country":"US","form":null,"value":"12-18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-hidcote","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.45,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.3,0.46],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249421","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/lavender-hidcote","country":"US","form":null,"value":"12-18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-hidcote","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[5,8],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249421","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/lavender-hidcote","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5-8","zones":[5,8]}],"note":"every source states 5-8; catalog states 5-9","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-hidcote","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249421","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/lavender-hidcote","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-hidcote","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249421","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/lavender-hidcote","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-hidcote","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249421","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-hidcote","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249421","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought","claim":true},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/lavender-hidcote","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-hidcote","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249421","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/lavender-hidcote","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-hidcote-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.45,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.5,0.6],"union":[0.4,1],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Red Butte Garden and Arboretum (University of Utah)","url":"https://redbuttegarden.org/plants/species/2658/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 2'h x 2'w","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/67017/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Dancing Oaks Nursery and Gardens","url":"https://dancingoaks.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink-pink-english-lavender","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature size: 1.5-2 feet T & W","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Charsaw Farms","url":"https://charsawfarms.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height × Width: ~18–24 in. × 18–24 in.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ballyrobert Gardens","url":"https://www.ballyrobertgardens.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Height: 40 - 60 cm (1.3 - 2 ft)","metres":[0.4,0.6],"band":[0.4,0.6],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Hooks Green Herbs","url":"https://www.hooksgreenherbs.com/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink-lavender-hidcote-pink-buy-herb-plant-online/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Height 50cm","metres":0.5,"band":[0.45,0.55],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Great Lakes Lavender Farm","url":"https://greatlakeslavenderfarm.com/shop/plants/hidcote-pink-lavender-plants-plugs-lavandula-angustifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: Grows to a height of 30 to 36 inches, ideal for mid-height garden accents.","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-hidcote-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.45,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.55,0.6],"union":[0.4,1],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Red Butte Garden and Arboretum (University of Utah)","url":"https://redbuttegarden.org/plants/species/2658/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 2'h x 2'w","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/67017/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Dancing Oaks Nursery and Gardens","url":"https://dancingoaks.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink-pink-english-lavender","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature size: 1.5-2 feet T & W","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Charsaw Farms","url":"https://charsawfarms.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height × Width: ~18–24 in. × 18–24 in.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ballyrobert Gardens","url":"https://www.ballyrobertgardens.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Spread: 40 - 60 cm (1.3 - 2 ft)","metres":[0.4,0.6],"band":[0.4,0.6],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Hooks Green Herbs","url":"https://www.hooksgreenherbs.com/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink-lavender-hidcote-pink-buy-herb-plant-online/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Spread 90cm","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-hidcote-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","5-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Red Butte Garden and Arboretum (University of Utah)","url":"https://redbuttegarden.org/plants/species/2658/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness: 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (species page, Lavandula angustifolia)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281393","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Lavandula angustifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-angustifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Charsaw Farms","url":"https://charsawfarms.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness: USDA Zones 5–9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Great Lakes Lavender Farm","url":"https://greatlakeslavenderfarm.com/shop/plants/hidcote-pink-lavender-plants-plugs-lavandula-angustifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: Thrives in zones 5 to 9, making it adaptable to a variety of climates.","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-hidcote-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Red Butte Garden and Arboretum (University of Utah)","url":"https://redbuttegarden.org/plants/species/2658/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/67017/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (species page, Lavandula angustifolia)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281393","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Lavandula angustifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-angustifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Charsaw Farms","url":"https://charsawfarms.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun (6–8+ hours)"},{"name":"Ballyrobert Gardens","url":"https://www.ballyrobertgardens.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position: Full sun, partial shade"},{"name":"Hooks Green Herbs","url":"https://www.hooksgreenherbs.com/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink-lavender-hidcote-pink-buy-herb-plant-online/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Aspect/Site Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-hidcote-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","strengths":["strong"],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/67017/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"sweetly fragrant, mid mauve-pink flowers around midsummer","claim":true},{"name":"Dancing Oaks Nursery and Gardens","url":"https://dancingoaks.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink-pink-english-lavender","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Properties/conditions: deer-resistant drought-tolerant evergreen fragrant intermittent water pollinator-friendly sun well-draining soil","claim":true},{"name":"Charsaw Farms","url":"https://charsawfarms.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Sweet, classic English lavender","claim":true},{"name":"Ballyrobert Gardens","url":"https://www.ballyrobertgardens.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It produces dense spikes of fragrant, pink summer flowers above slender, aromatic, silvery-grey leaves.","claim":true},{"name":"Hooks Green Herbs","url":"https://www.hooksgreenherbs.com/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink-lavender-hidcote-pink-buy-herb-plant-online/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a strongly aromatic shrub growing 30-50cm tall, and is well-recognised for its beautiful scented flowers and grey-green foliage.","claim":true},{"name":"Great Lakes Lavender Farm","url":"https://greatlakeslavenderfarm.com/shop/plants/hidcote-pink-lavender-plants-plugs-lavandula-angustifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Known for its strong and sweet fragrance, Hidcote Pink is perfect for both ornamental and culinary use.","claim":true}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-hidcote-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://charsawfarms.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink","https://www.ballyrobertgardens.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Charsaw Farms","url":"https://charsawfarms.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hidcote Pink lavender is excellent for cutting and drying, holding its fragrance well in fresh bouquets and dried arrangements.","claim":true},{"name":"Ballyrobert Gardens","url":"https://www.ballyrobertgardens.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other features: Royal Horticultural Society Award of Garden Merit (RHS AGM), Bees and Butterflies, Cut Flowers or Dried Flowers, Scented, Suitable for Container","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-hidcote-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/67017/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true},{"name":"Dancing Oaks Nursery and Gardens","url":"https://dancingoaks.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink-pink-english-lavender","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Properties/conditions: deer-resistant drought-tolerant evergreen fragrant intermittent water pollinator-friendly sun well-draining soil","claim":true},{"name":"Charsaw Farms","url":"https://charsawfarms.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Additional traits: Drought tolerant, deer resistant, pollinator friendly","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-hidcote-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://dancingoaks.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink-pink-english-lavender","https://charsawfarms.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://dancingoaks.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink-pink-english-lavender","https://www.ballyrobertgardens.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://dancingoaks.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink-pink-english-lavender","https://www.hooksgreenherbs.com/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink-lavender-hidcote-pink-buy-herb-plant-online/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Dancing Oaks Nursery and Gardens","url":"https://dancingoaks.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink-pink-english-lavender","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Properties/conditions: deer-resistant drought-tolerant evergreen fragrant intermittent water pollinator-friendly sun well-draining soil","claim":true},{"name":"Charsaw Farms","url":"https://charsawfarms.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Additional traits: Drought tolerant, deer resistant, pollinator friendly","claim":true},{"name":"Ballyrobert Gardens","url":"https://www.ballyrobertgardens.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other features: Royal Horticultural Society Award of Garden Merit (RHS AGM), Bees and Butterflies, Cut Flowers or Dried Flowers, Scented, Suitable for Container","claim":true},{"name":"Hooks Green Herbs","url":"https://www.hooksgreenherbs.com/lavandula-angustifolia-hidcote-pink-lavender-hidcote-pink-buy-herb-plant-online/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are also particularly attractive to bees.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-munstead","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.45,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249422","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/99904/lavandula-angustifolia-munstead/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-lavender-munstead","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 12-18\" tall","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-munstead","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.45,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.3,1],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249422","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/99904/lavandula-angustifolia-munstead/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-lavender-munstead","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 12-24\" wide","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-munstead","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249422","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-angustifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-lavender-munstead","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones Zone 5 Zone 6 Zone 7 Zone 8 Zone 9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-munstead","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249422","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-angustifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/99904/lavandula-angustifolia-munstead/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-lavender-munstead","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-munstead","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249422","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/99904/lavandula-angustifolia-munstead/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"spikes of small, highly-fragrant, blue-purple flowers in mid to late summer","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-lavender-munstead","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers Dried Flowers Fragrant Container Planting","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-munstead","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249422","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-lavender-munstead","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers Dried Flowers Fragrant Container Planting","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-munstead","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249422","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/99904/lavandula-angustifolia-munstead/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-lavender-munstead","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates Dry Sites","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-munstead","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249422","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-lavender-munstead","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attracting butterflies and native bees to its flowers","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-nana-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.34,0.42],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/90292/lavandula-angustifolia-nana-alba/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/plant/S-0860","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 12\" - 18\" high x 15\" - 2' 0\" wide.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Van Hevelingen Nursery","url":"https://www.vhherbs.com/plant-selection/by-genus/genus-lavandula/lavandula-angustifolia-dwarf-white-nana-alba","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: to 15 in","metres":0.38,"band":[0.34,0.42],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Native Sons Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.nativeson.com/product/lavandula-angustifolia-nana-alba-0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12-18\"","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-nana-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.5],"union":[0.1,0.61],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/90292/lavandula-angustifolia-nana-alba/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/plant/S-0860","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 12\" - 18\" high x 15\" - 2' 0\" wide.","metres":[0.38,0.61],"band":[0.38,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Van Hevelingen Nursery","url":"https://www.vhherbs.com/plant-selection/by-genus/genus-lavandula/lavandula-angustifolia-dwarf-white-nana-alba","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: to 18 in","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Native Sons Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.nativeson.com/product/lavandula-angustifolia-nana-alba-0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 8-12\"","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-nana-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Lavandula angustifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-angustifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Charsaw Farms","url":"https://charsawfarms.com/products/lavandula-angustifolia-nana-alba-dwarf-white-lavender","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones: 5-9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-nana-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Lavandula angustifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-angustifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/90292/lavandula-angustifolia-nana-alba/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"Van Hevelingen Nursery","url":"https://www.vhherbs.com/plant-selection/by-genus/genus-lavandula/lavandula-angustifolia-dwarf-white-nana-alba","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Position: full sun and well-draining soil"},{"name":"Native Sons Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.nativeson.com/product/lavandula-angustifolia-nana-alba-0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-nana-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.diggingdog.com/plant/S-0860","https://www.vhherbs.com/plant-selection/by-genus/genus-lavandula/lavandula-angustifolia-dwarf-white-nana-alba"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/plant/S-0860","country":null,"form":null,"value":"a highly scented flurry of chubby pearlescent blooms with green calyces","claim":true},{"name":"Van Hevelingen Nursery","url":"https://www.vhherbs.com/plant-selection/by-genus/genus-lavandula/lavandula-angustifolia-dwarf-white-nana-alba","country":null,"form":null,"value":"compact growth and sweetly fragrant, pure white flower spikes on short stems held just above the foliage","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-nana-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/plant/S-0860","country":null,"form":null,"value":"as well as jams, ice cream and fresh or dried arrangements","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-nana-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/90292/lavandula-angustifolia-nana-alba/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true},{"name":"Van Hevelingen Nursery","url":"https://www.vhherbs.com/plant-selection/by-genus/genus-lavandula/lavandula-angustifolia-dwarf-white-nana-alba","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought: adapted to 3 months of summer drought","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-nana-alba","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Native Sons Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.nativeson.com/product/lavandula-angustifolia-nana-alba-0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-phenomenal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.81],"union":[0.46,0.81],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=364524","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=LAVPH","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.0-2.5 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/lavandula/phenomenal-lavender-lavandula-x-intermedia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18\" - 2'","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-intermedia-phenomenal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 30-32\" tall","metres":[0.76,0.81],"band":[0.76,0.81],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Lavandula-x-intermedia-Phenomenal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Tall: 24-32 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.81],"band":[0.61,0.81],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-phenomenal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.46,1.37],"split":[{"range":[0.46,0.81],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","High Country Gardens","Saunders Brothers"]},{"range":[0.82,1],"sources":["Proven Winners"]},{"range":[1.22,1.37],"sources":["Walters Gardens"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=364524","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=LAVPH","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4.0-4.5 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.37],"band":[1.22,1.37],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/lavandula/phenomenal-lavender-lavandula-x-intermedia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-intermedia-phenomenal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 24-32\" wide","metres":[0.61,0.81],"band":[0.61,0.81],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Lavandula-x-intermedia-Phenomenal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Wide: 24-32 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.81],"band":[0.61,0.81],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 3 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-phenomenal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","4-9","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=364524","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Lavandula x intermedia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=LAVPH","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/lavandula/phenomenal-lavender-lavandula-x-intermedia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b , 9a , 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-intermedia-phenomenal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones Zone 5 Zone 6 Zone 7 Zone 8 Zone 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Lavandula-x-intermedia-Phenomenal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-phenomenal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=364524","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Lavandula x intermedia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=LAVPH","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-intermedia-phenomenal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-phenomenal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=364524","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Lavandula x intermedia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Edible Fragrant Good Cut Good Dried","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=LAVPH","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Border Plant Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Drought Tolerant Fragrant Flowers Fragrant Foliage Mass Planting Specimen Focal Point","claim":true},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/lavandula/phenomenal-lavender-lavandula-x-intermedia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features fragrant Fragrant Foliage","claim":true},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-intermedia-phenomenal","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Exceptional fragrance provides a calming effect in the garden while helping to attract pollinators and keep browsing deer and rabbits at bay","claim":true},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Lavandula-x-intermedia-Phenomenal","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Phenomenal® is aptly named for superior fragrance, uniform mounding plant habit, resistance to disease and extreme tolerance to heat and humidity.","claim":true}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-phenomenal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Lavandula x intermedia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Edible Fragrant Good Cut Good Dried","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=LAVPH","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Border Plant Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Drought Tolerant Fragrant Flowers Fragrant Foliage Mass Planting Specimen Focal Point","claim":true},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-intermedia-phenomenal","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers Dried Flowers Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Lavandula-x-intermedia-Phenomenal","country":null,"form":null,"value":"An excellent selection for all the wonderful things Lavender offers: cut flowers, dried flowers, fragrant oils, and culinary interest.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-phenomenal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=364524","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Lavandula x intermedia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#drought tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=LAVPH","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Border Plant Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Drought Tolerant Fragrant Flowers Fragrant Foliage Mass Planting Specimen Focal Point","claim":true},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-intermedia-phenomenal","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-phenomenal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=364524","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Lavandula x intermedia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies, bees, and moths.","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=LAVPH","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Bee Friendly","claim":true},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-intermedia-phenomenal","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bee Friendly Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Saunders Brothers","url":"https://www.saundersbrothers.com/plant/Lavandula-x-intermedia-Phenomenal","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife • Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-provence","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.3,0.91],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256683&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia-provence/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21259/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Height: 2-3 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-provence","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.3,0.91],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256683&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia-provence/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21259/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Spread: 2-3 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-provence","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256683&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-intermedia-provence","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ZONES 5-9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-provence","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256683&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia-provence/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-intermedia-provence","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in full sun with good air circulation."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-provence","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256683&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia-provence/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21259/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"'Provence' has beautiful, fragrant light purple flowers and foliage.","claim":true},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-intermedia-provence","country":null,"form":null,"value":"is an intensely fragrant lavender","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-provence","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256683&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for a cutting garden.","claim":true},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-intermedia-provence","country":null,"form":null,"value":"it makes a wonderful cut flower with long stems and lavender-blue flower spikes","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-provence","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256683&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia-provence/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is tolerant of deer and rabbit browsing, dry soils, and drought.","claim":true},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21259/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-intermedia-provence","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought resistant perennial plant (xeric).","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-provence","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256683&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-x-intermedia-provence/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees and butterflies nectar at the flowers.","claim":true},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-intermedia-provence","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-royal-velvet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.76],"union":[0.5,1],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257774&isprofile=0&gen=lavandula","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/178590/lavandula-angustifolia-royal-velvet/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-angustifolia-royal-velvet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 24-36\" tall","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Great Lakes Lavender Farm","url":"https://greatlakeslavenderfarm.com/shop/plants/royal-velvet-lavender-plants-plugs-lavandula-angustifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: Reaches a moderate height of 24-30 inches, ideal for garden borders or container planting.","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-royal-velvet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.55,0.61],"union":[0.46,1],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257774&isprofile=0&gen=lavandula","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/178590/lavandula-angustifolia-royal-velvet/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-angustifolia-royal-velvet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 24\" wide","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-royal-velvet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","5-9","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257774&isprofile=0&gen=lavandula","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-angustifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-angustifolia-royal-velvet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 5-10","zones":[5,10]},{"name":"Great Lakes Lavender Farm","url":"https://greatlakeslavenderfarm.com/shop/plants/royal-velvet-lavender-plants-plugs-lavandula-angustifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: Thrives in zones 5-9, making it adaptable to various climates.","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-royal-velvet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257774&isprofile=0&gen=lavandula","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-angustifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/178590/lavandula-angustifolia-royal-velvet/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-angustifolia-royal-velvet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-royal-velvet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257774&isprofile=0&gen=lavandula","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/178590/lavandula-angustifolia-royal-velvet/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long spikes of fragrant purple flowers, opening from dark purple buds, are borne on tall slender stems in summer","claim":true},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-angustifolia-royal-velvet","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Great Lakes Lavender Farm","url":"https://greatlakeslavenderfarm.com/shop/plants/royal-velvet-lavender-plants-plugs-lavandula-angustifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It's a top choice for bouquet production due to its richly colored blooms and long-lasting fragrance.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-royal-velvet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/178590/lavandula-angustifolia-royal-velvet/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This cultivar holds its colour well when cut for drying","claim":true},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-angustifolia-royal-velvet","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Low Maintenance Cut Flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Great Lakes Lavender Farm","url":"https://greatlakeslavenderfarm.com/shop/plants/royal-velvet-lavender-plants-plugs-lavandula-angustifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Length: Produces sturdy, 12-14 inch stems, perfect for cutting and crafting.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-royal-velvet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257774&isprofile=0&gen=lavandula","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/178590/lavandula-angustifolia-royal-velvet/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-angustifolia-royal-velvet","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soil Moisture Waterwise","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-royal-velvet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257774&isprofile=0&gen=lavandula","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-lavandula-angustifolia-royal-velvet","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bee Friendly Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-spanish","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.46,1],"split":[{"range":[0.46,0.61],"sources":["University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture Cooperative Extension Service"]},{"range":[0.82,1],"sources":["UC Master Gardeners of San Luis Obispo County (UC ANR)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture Cooperative Extension Service","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/lavender-spanish-5-4-12.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows as an 18- to 24-inch-tall and 2- to 3-foot-wide mounded, evergreen semiwoody shrub","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"UC Master Gardeners of San Luis Obispo County (UC ANR)","url":"https://ucanr.edu/blog/uc-master-gardeners-diggin-it-slo/article/lavender","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: grows to 3 feet in height and width.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-spanish","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.61,1],"proposed":0.87,"margin":18,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture Cooperative Extension Service","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/lavender-spanish-5-4-12.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows as an 18- to 24-inch-tall and 2- to 3-foot-wide mounded, evergreen semiwoody shrub","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"UC Master Gardeners of San Luis Obispo County (UC ANR)","url":"https://ucanr.edu/blog/uc-master-gardeners-diggin-it-slo/article/lavender","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: grows to 3 feet in height and width.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.61 to 1 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-spanish","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["8-9","7-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-stoechas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[8,9]},{"name":"UC Master Gardeners of San Luis Obispo County (UC ANR)","url":"https://ucanr.edu/blog/uc-master-gardeners-diggin-it-slo/article/lavender","country":"US","form":null,"value":"hardy in zones 7 to 9.","zones":[7,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-spanish","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-stoechas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture Cooperative Extension Service","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/lavender-spanish-5-4-12.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The secret seems to be to provide a full sun location with really sharp drainage and good air circulation around the plant during the summer."},{"name":"UC Master Gardeners of San Luis Obispo County (UC ANR)","url":"https://ucanr.edu/blog/uc-master-gardeners-diggin-it-slo/article/lavender","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: full sun."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-spanish","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-stoechas/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Silvery highly fragrant leaves are similar to rosemary.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Arkansas Division of Agriculture Cooperative Extension Service","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/lavender-spanish-5-4-12.aspx","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its fragrant, gray-pubescent, linear leaves are about an inch long","claim":true},{"name":"UC Master Gardeners of San Luis Obispo County (UC ANR)","url":"https://ucanr.edu/blog/uc-master-gardeners-diggin-it-slo/article/lavender","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It matures into a thick bushy shrub and is often planted along paths to scent the air as walkers pass by.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-spanish","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-spanish","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-stoechas/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Dry Soil Heat Poor Soil Rabbits","claim":true},{"name":"UC Master Gardeners of San Luis Obispo County (UC ANR)","url":"https://ucanr.edu/blog/uc-master-gardeners-diggin-it-slo/article/lavender","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lavender is a drought tolerant plant. Once established, lavender will need little supplemental watering.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lavender-spanish","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lavandula-stoechas/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nectar from flowers attracts bees and butterflies.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lemon-balm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.91],"union":[0.46,0.91],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/melissa-officinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c857","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lemon-balm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.91],"union":[0.46,0.91],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/melissa-officinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1 ft. 6 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.46,0.91],"band":[0.46,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c857","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.50 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.91],"band":[0.46,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lemon-balm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/melissa-officinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c857","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 to 7","zones":[3,7]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lemon-balm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/melissa-officinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c857","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lemon-balm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/melissa-officinalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c857","country":null,"form":null,"value":"lemon-scented leaves","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lemon-balm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lemon-balm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/melissa-officinalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lemon-balm","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/melissa-officinalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees love them.","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c857","country":null,"form":null,"value":"honey bees love them","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"liatris","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,1.52],"union":[0.3,1.52],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,1.52],"band":[0.3,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"liatris"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture - Liatris","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/liatris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"flower spike height varies from 1 to 5 feet","metres":[0.3,1.52],"band":[0.3,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"liatris"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":10,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":10},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"liatris","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"liatris"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":10},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"liatris","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"liatris"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":10},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"liatris","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Soil conditions depend on the species and most prefer full sun to light shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"liatris"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture - Liatris","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/liatris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Liatris performs best when grown in full sun but it will tolerate some shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"liatris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris spicata","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277448&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"liatris spicata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris pycnostachya","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277446&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"liatris pycnostachya"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris aspera","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277341&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"liatris aspera"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris microcephala","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277444&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"liatris microcephala"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris ligulistylis","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277216&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"liatris ligulistylis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris spicata","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris-spicata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows well in full sun to partial shade and also tolerates summer heat and humidity.","level":"species","taxon":"liatris spicata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris aspera","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris-aspera/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant will adapt to most well-drained soils but prefers an acidic sandy or rocky soil in full sun to partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"liatris aspera"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris pycnostachya","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris-pycnostachya/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow this plant in full sun in average well-drained moist to occasionally dry soil.","level":"species","taxon":"liatris pycnostachya"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris ligulistylis","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris-ligulistylis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Meadow Blazing Star is easily grown in dry to medium, well-drained soils in full sun and prefers dry, sandy or rocky, alkaline soils.","level":"species","taxon":"liatris ligulistylis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"liatris","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"liatris"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"liatris","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Garden","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"liatris"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture - Liatris","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/liatris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are very attractive to butterflies, bees, and other insects and also make great cut flowers, both fresh and dried.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"liatris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris spicata","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277448&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris spicata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris pycnostachya","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277446&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris pycnostachya"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris aspera","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277341&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers open somewhat at the same time, which makes this species a particularly good fresh cut flower for floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris aspera"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris microcephala","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277444&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris microcephala"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris ligulistylis","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277216&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Within an inflorescence, flower heads bloom somewhat at the same time, which makes this species a good fresh cut flower for floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris ligulistylis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris spicata","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris-spicata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#dried arrangements #cutting garden","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris spicata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris aspera","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris-aspera/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#corm #cutting garden","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris aspera"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris ligulistylis","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris-ligulistylis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#cutting garden","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris ligulistylis"}],"note":"10 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"liatris","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"liatris"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture - Liatris","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/liatris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, Liatris is fairly drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"liatris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris spicata","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277448&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Clay Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris spicata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris pycnostachya","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277446&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Clay Soil, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris pycnostachya"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris aspera","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277341&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris aspera"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris microcephala","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277444&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris microcephala"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris ligulistylis","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277216&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris ligulistylis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris pycnostachya","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris-pycnostachya/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It may also be found in damp prairies and tolerates poor soils, drought and heat conditions.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris pycnostachya"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris ligulistylis","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris-ligulistylis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris ligulistylis"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"liatris","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract various pollinators","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"liatris"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture - Liatris","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/liatris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Liatris flowers are attractive to bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"liatris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris spicata","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277448&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are attractive to hummingbirds, butterflies, and other pollinators, and the small seeds are attractive to songbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris spicata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris pycnostachya","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277446&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are attractive to hummingbirds, butterflies, and other pollinators, and the small seeds are attractive to songbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris pycnostachya"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris aspera","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277341&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are attractive to hummingbirds, butterflies, and other pollinators, and the small seeds are attractive to songbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris aspera"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris microcephala","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277444&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are attractive to hummingbirds, butterflies, and other pollinators, and the small seeds are attractive to songbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris microcephala"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Liatris ligulistylis","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277216&isprofile=0&basic=Liatris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are attractive to hummingbirds, butterflies, and other pollinators, and the small seeds are attractive to songbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris ligulistylis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris spicata","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris-spicata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its flowers are attractive to butterflies, bees, and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris spicata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris aspera","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris-aspera/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It blooms late summer into fall with spikes of showy purple composite flowers that butterflies love.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris aspera"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris pycnostachya","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris-pycnostachya/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract hummingbirds and butterflies and birds will eat the seeds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris pycnostachya"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Liatris ligulistylis","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/liatris-ligulistylis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts birds to the seeds and butterflies and hummingbirds to the flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris ligulistylis"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center - Liatris spicata","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=LISP","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use Wildlife: Butterflies frequent Liatris spp.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"liatris spicata"}],"note":"12 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ligularia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":17,"levels":{"cultivar":14,"species":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 17 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ligularia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":18,"levels":{"cultivar":14,"species":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 18 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ligularia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":19,"levels":{"cultivar":14,"species":5},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 19 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ligularia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Ligularia 'Bottle Rocket'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299840&isprofile=0&basic=Ligularia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Ligularia 'Britt Marie Crawford'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=268923&isprofile=0&basic=Ligularia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Ligularia dentata","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277343&isprofile=0&basic=Ligularia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"ligularia dentata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Ligularia dentata 'Desdemona'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244812&isprofile=0&basic=Ligularia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"ligularia dentata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Ligularia dentata 'Othello'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244813&isprofile=0&basic=Ligularia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"ligularia dentata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Ligularia 'Osiris Fantaisie'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=270668&isprofile=0&basic=Ligularia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Ligularia przewalskii","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=291384&isprofile=0&basic=Ligularia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"ligularia przewalskii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Ligularia sibirica","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277218&isprofile=0&basic=Ligularia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"ligularia sibirica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Ligularia 'The Rocket'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261541&isprofile=0&basic=Ligularia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Ligularia stenocephala","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ligularia-stenocephala/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"ligularia stenocephala"},{"name":"Proven Winners - 'Bottle Rocket' Ligularia hybrid","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/ligularia/bottle-rocket-ligularia-hybrid","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade to Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners - Britt-Marie-Crawford Bigleaf Ligularia (Ligularia dentata)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/ligularia/britt-marie-crawford-bigleaf-ligularia-ligularia-dentata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade to Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"ligularia dentata"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com) - Ligularia 'The Rocket'","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/ligularia-the-rocket.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun or Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com) - Ligularia 'Bottle Rocket'","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/ligularia-bottle-rocket.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun or Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com) - Ligularia wilsoniana","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/ligularia-wilsoniana.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun or Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"ligularia wilsoniana"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com) - Ligularia przewalskii 'Dragon Wings'","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/ligularia-przewalskii-dragon-wings.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"ligularia przewalskii"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com) - Ligularia dentata 'Othello'","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/ligularia-dentata-othello.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun or Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"ligularia dentata"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries - Ligularia 'Britt-Marie Crawford'","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/ligularia-britt-marie-crawford/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun , Part Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"ligularia dentata"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries - Ligularia 'Dragon Wings'","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/ligularia-dragon-wings/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun , Part Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"ligularia przewalskii"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ligularia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["ligularia stenocephala"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (ligularia stenocephala), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (ligularia stenocephala) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ligularia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Ligularia stenocephala","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ligularia-stenocephala/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ligularia stenocephala"},{"name":"Proven Winners - 'Bottle Rocket' Ligularia hybrid","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/ligularia/bottle-rocket-ligularia-hybrid","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners - Britt-Marie-Crawford Bigleaf Ligularia (Ligularia dentata)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/ligularia/britt-marie-crawford-bigleaf-ligularia-ligularia-dentata","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"ligularia dentata"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com) - Ligularia 'The Rocket'","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/ligularia-the-rocket.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Both the flowers and leaves are great for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com) - Ligularia 'Bottle Rocket'","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/ligularia-bottle-rocket.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Both the flowers and leaves are great for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com) - Ligularia wilsoniana","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/ligularia-wilsoniana.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Both the flowers and leaves are great for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ligularia wilsoniana"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com) - Ligularia przewalskii 'Dragon Wings'","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/ligularia-przewalskii-dragon-wings.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Both the flowers and leaves are great for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"ligularia przewalskii"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com) - Ligularia dentata 'Othello'","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/ligularia-dentata-othello.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Both the flowers and leaves are great for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"ligularia dentata"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"ligularia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Ligularia 'Bottle Rocket'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299840&isprofile=0&basic=Ligularia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Must have moist soils that never dry out.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Ligularia 'Britt Marie Crawford'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=268923&isprofile=0&basic=Ligularia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Must have moist soils that never dry out.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Ligularia dentata","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277343&isprofile=0&basic=Ligularia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Must have moist soils that never dry out.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ligularia dentata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Ligularia dentata 'Desdemona'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244812&isprofile=0&basic=Ligularia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Must have moist soils that never dry out.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"ligularia dentata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Ligularia dentata 'Othello'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244813&isprofile=0&basic=Ligularia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Must have moist soils that never dry out.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"ligularia dentata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Ligularia 'Osiris Fantaisie'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=270668&isprofile=0&basic=Ligularia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Must have moist soils that never dry out.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Ligularia przewalskii","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=291384&isprofile=0&basic=Ligularia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants must have moist soils that never dry out.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ligularia przewalskii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Ligularia sibirica","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277218&isprofile=0&basic=Ligularia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soils should not be allowed to dry out and plants benefit from regular, deep waterings in hot summers.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ligularia sibirica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder - Ligularia 'The Rocket'","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261541&isprofile=0&basic=Ligularia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Must have moist soils that never dry out.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners - 'Bottle Rocket' Ligularia hybrid","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/ligularia/bottle-rocket-ligularia-hybrid","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Required constant moisture.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners - Britt-Marie-Crawford Bigleaf Ligularia (Ligularia dentata)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/ligularia/britt-marie-crawford-bigleaf-ligularia-ligularia-dentata","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Prefers consistent moisture.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"ligularia dentata"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com) - Ligularia 'The Rocket'","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/ligularia-the-rocket.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sometimes called Elephant Ears, this is a bold specimen perennial that needs a moist location.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com) - Ligularia 'Bottle Rocket'","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/ligularia-bottle-rocket.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sometimes called Elephant Ears, this is a bold specimen perennial that needs a moist location.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com) - Ligularia wilsoniana","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/ligularia-wilsoniana.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sometimes called Elephant Ears, this is a bold specimen perennial that needs a moist location.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ligularia wilsoniana"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com) - Ligularia przewalskii 'Dragon Wings'","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/ligularia-przewalskii-dragon-wings.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sometimes called Elephant Ears, this is a bold specimen perennial that needs a moist location.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"ligularia przewalskii"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com) - Ligularia dentata 'Othello'","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/ligularia-dentata-othello.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sometimes called Elephant Ears, this is a bold specimen perennial that needs a moist location.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"ligularia dentata"},{"name":"Terra Nova Nurseries - Ligularia 'Dragon Wings'","url":"https://www.terranovanurseries.com/product/ligularia-dragon-wings/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Best if protected from the hottest sun and kept evenly moist.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"ligularia przewalskii"}],"note":"17 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"ligularia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Ligularia stenocephala","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ligularia-stenocephala/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ligularia stenocephala"},{"name":"Proven Winners - 'Bottle Rocket' Ligularia hybrid","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/ligularia/bottle-rocket-ligularia-hybrid","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners - Britt-Marie-Crawford Bigleaf Ligularia (Ligularia dentata)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/ligularia/britt-marie-crawford-bigleaf-ligularia-ligularia-dentata","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"ligularia dentata"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com) - Ligularia 'The Rocket'","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/ligularia-the-rocket.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com) - Ligularia 'Bottle Rocket'","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/ligularia-bottle-rocket.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com) - Ligularia dentata 'Othello'","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/ligularia-dentata-othello.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"ligularia dentata"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"lilac","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[3.66,4.57],"union":[2.44,4.88],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282932","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12.00 to 16.00 feet","metres":[3.66,4.88],"band":[3.66,4.88],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/syringa-vulgaris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8 ft. 0 in. - 16 ft. 0 in.","metres":[2.44,4.88],"band":[2.44,4.88],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Urban Forestry Outreach and Research, tree and shrub selector (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/common-lilac-syringa-vulgaris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8 to 15 ft","metres":[2.44,4.57],"band":[2.44,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/?p=11977","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Height: 8-15 feet","metres":[2.44,4.57],"band":[2.44,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Syringa vulgaris, Common Lilac)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=456","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 8-15 Feet","metres":[2.44,4.57],"band":[2.44,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/syringa-vulgaris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Deciduous shrub, 10-15(20) ft [3-4.5(6) m], upright, leggy, irregular outline.","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":6},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lilac","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[2.44,3.66],"union":[1.83,3.66],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282932","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 8.00 to 12.00 feet","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/syringa-vulgaris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 6 ft. 0 in. - 12 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Urban Forestry Outreach and Research, tree and shrub selector (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/common-lilac-syringa-vulgaris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 6 to 12 ft","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/?p=11977","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Spread: 6-12 feet","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Syringa vulgaris, Common Lilac)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=456","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 6-12 Feet","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":6},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lilac","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282932","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 7","zones":[3,7],"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/syringa-vulgaris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a","zones":[3,7],"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Urban Forestry Outreach and Research, tree and shrub selector (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/common-lilac-syringa-vulgaris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 to 7","zones":[3,7],"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Syringa vulgaris, Common Lilac)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=456","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 7","zones":[3,7],"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":6},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lilac","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282932","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/syringa-vulgaris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Urban Forestry Outreach and Research, tree and shrub selector (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/common-lilac-syringa-vulgaris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Common lilac does best in full sun so avoid shady sites.","level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Syringa vulgaris, Common Lilac)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=456","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun; moist, well-drained soils are best; tolerates alkaline soils.","level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lilac","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282932","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/syringa-vulgaris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The pungently sweet fragrance is delightful but can be overpowering to some individuals.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Urban Forestry Outreach and Research, tree and shrub selector (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/common-lilac-syringa-vulgaris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The well-known and very fragrant purple flowers bloom in May.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/?p=11977","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Multi-Colored (Extremely fragrant, white, pink, reddish, or purple","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Syringa vulgaris, Common Lilac)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=456","country":null,"form":null,"value":"flowers are very fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/syringa-vulgaris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"terminal, upright clusters, lavender (common) or white, very fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lilac","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282932","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/syringa-vulgaris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It makes excellent cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Urban Forestry Outreach and Research, tree and shrub selector (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/common-lilac-syringa-vulgaris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a great cut flower for bouquets.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"lilac","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lilac","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282932","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/syringa-vulgaris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lilac attracts hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Urban Forestry Outreach and Research, tree and shrub selector (Syringa vulgaris)","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/common-lilac-syringa-vulgaris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract birds, butterflies, and other insect pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"lilac-bloomerang-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.22,1.52],"union":[0.91,1.52],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269258","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/syringa/bloomerang-purple-reblooming-lilac-syringa-x","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4' - 5'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bloomerang-purple-lilac/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height : 4-5 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/bloomerang-purple-lilac/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 4-5 ft","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lilac-bloomerang-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.22,1.52],"union":[0.91,1.52],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269258","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/syringa/bloomerang-purple-reblooming-lilac-syringa-x","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4' - 5'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bloomerang-purple-lilac/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread : 4-5 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/bloomerang-purple-lilac/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 4-5 ft","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lilac-bloomerang-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-7","3-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269258","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 7","zones":[4,7]},{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/syringa/bloomerang-purple-reblooming-lilac-syringa-x","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3a , 3b , 4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Syringa Bloomerang Group)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/syringa-bloomerang-group/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bloomerang-purple-lilac/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones : 3-7","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/bloomerang-purple-lilac/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In: Zones 3-7","zones":[3,7]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lilac-bloomerang-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269258","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Syringa Bloomerang Group)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/syringa-bloomerang-group/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bloomerang-purple-lilac/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure : Full Sun"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/bloomerang-purple-lilac/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs : Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lilac-bloomerang-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269258","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/syringa/bloomerang-purple-reblooming-lilac-syringa-x","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Star-like flowers are a beautiful shade of classic lilac purple and are sweetly scented","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Syringa Bloomerang Group)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/syringa-bloomerang-group/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Description: Fragrant purple-pink flowers arranged in dense, terminal clusters","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bloomerang-purple-lilac/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its green foliage is paired with fragrant lilac blooms.","claim":true},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/bloomerang-purple-lilac/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stunning fragrance fills the air","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lilac-bloomerang-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269258","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/syringa/bloomerang-purple-reblooming-lilac-syringa-x","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: Cut Flower","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Syringa Bloomerang Group)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/syringa-bloomerang-group/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bloomerang-purple-lilac/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"plant for cut flowers","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lilac-bloomerang-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lilac-bloomerang-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269258","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/syringa/bloomerang-purple-reblooming-lilac-syringa-x","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Syringa Bloomerang Group)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/syringa-bloomerang-group/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Attracts hummingbirds and butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/bloomerang-purple-lilac/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies love this lilac","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lilac-madame-lemoine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Van den Berk Nurseries","url":"https://www.vdberk.co.uk/trees/syringa-vulgaris-mme-lemoine/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"'Mme Lemoine' is a large shrub to small tree reaching 2-3 m in height.","metres":[2,3],"band":[2,3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":4,"cultivar":1,"genus":1,"unstated":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lilac-madame-lemoine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Van den Berk Nurseries","url":"https://www.vdberk.co.uk/trees/syringa-vulgaris-mme-lemoine/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Width 2-3m","metres":[2,3],"band":[2,3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":4,"cultivar":1,"genus":1,"unstated":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lilac-madame-lemoine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":4,"cultivar":1,"genus":1,"unstated":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lilac-madame-lemoine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282932","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/syringa-vulgaris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/trees-and-shrubs/lilacs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6+ hours); less sun reduces flowering and increases powdery mildew","level":"genus","taxon":"syringa"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/common-lilac/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"Trees and Shrubs Online (Bean's Trees and Shrubs Hardy in the British Isles)","url":"https://www.treesandshrubsonline.org/articles/syringa/the-garden-lilacs/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"The lilacs of this group need full sun or the lightest shade, and thrive best in areas where the summers are warmer than the average."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lilac-madame-lemoine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282932","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/syringa-vulgaris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The pungently sweet fragrance is delightful but can be overpowering to some individuals.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"Van den Berk Nurseries","url":"https://www.vdberk.co.uk/trees/syringa-vulgaris-mme-lemoine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They have a strong and pleasant fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/trees-and-shrubs/lilacs","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are primarily grown for their fragrant flowers ranging from white to pink to deep purple.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"syringa"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/syringa-vulgaris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers borne in large (10-20 cm long), terminal, upright clusters, lavender (common) or white, very fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/common-lilac/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The common lilac is an old-fashioned, long-lived, and well-loved lilac best known for its fragrant flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lilac-madame-lemoine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282932","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/syringa-vulgaris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It makes excellent cut flowers, but after its spectacular mid- to late-spring bloom, the shrub is of little interest in the landscape.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"lilac-madame-lemoine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/common-lilac/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other tolerances Alkaline soil, Occasional drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lilac-madame-lemoine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282932","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/syringa-vulgaris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lilac attracts hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"Van den Berk Nurseries","url":"https://www.vdberk.co.uk/trees/syringa-vulgaris-mme-lemoine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"valuable for butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/trees-and-shrubs/lilacs","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lilacs also provide habitat for small birds and pollinating insects.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"syringa"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/common-lilac/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract birds and butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"syringa vulgaris"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"lilac-wedgwood-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2.5,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[1.65,1.83],"union":[1.22,2.01],"proposed":1.74,"margin":24.4,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253924","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Gertens plant database (Wedgewood Blue Lilac)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/1475/Wedgewood_Blue_Lilac/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6 feet","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"},{"name":"BackyardGardener plant record (Syringa vulgaris 'Wedgewood Blue')","url":"https://www.backyardgardener.com/plantname/syringa-vulgaris-wedgewood-blue-common-lilac/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Wedgewood Blue is a compact variety that grows to 6 feet tall and wide","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (1.22 to 2.01 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lilac-wedgwood-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.65,1.83],"union":[1.22,2.34],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253924","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Gertens plant database (Wedgewood Blue Lilac)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/1475/Wedgewood_Blue_Lilac/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 7 feet","metres":2.13,"band":[1.92,2.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"BackyardGardener plant record (Syringa vulgaris 'Wedgewood Blue')","url":"https://www.backyardgardener.com/plantname/syringa-vulgaris-wedgewood-blue-common-lilac/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Wedgewood Blue is a compact variety that grows to 6 feet tall and wide","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lilac-wedgwood-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-7","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253924","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 7","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Syringa vulgaris, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/syringa-vulgaris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"BackyardGardener plant record (Syringa vulgaris 'Wedgewood Blue')","url":"https://www.backyardgardener.com/plantname/syringa-vulgaris-wedgewood-blue-common-lilac/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension, Lilacs (genus/species page)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/trees-and-shrubs/lilacs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy in zones 3 to 7 unless otherwise indicated.","zones":[3,7]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lilac-wedgwood-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253924","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Syringa vulgaris, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/syringa-vulgaris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Gertens plant database (Wedgewood Blue Lilac)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/1475/Wedgewood_Blue_Lilac/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub should only be grown in full sunlight."},{"name":"BackyardGardener plant record (Syringa vulgaris 'Wedgewood Blue')","url":"https://www.backyardgardener.com/plantname/syringa-vulgaris-wedgewood-blue-common-lilac/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Range: Sun to Full Sun"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension, Lilacs (genus/species page)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/trees-and-shrubs/lilacs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6+ hours); less sun reduces flowering and increases powdery mildew"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lilac-wedgwood-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253924","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soft lavender-blue, sweetly fragrant, single flowers are arranged in dense, arching, wisteria-like, terminal clusters (panicles)","claim":true},{"name":"Gertens plant database (Wedgewood Blue Lilac)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/1475/Wedgewood_Blue_Lilac/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A breathtaking spring blooming shrub featuring excruciatingly fragrant true blue flowers in upright panicles","claim":true},{"name":"BackyardGardener plant record (Syringa vulgaris 'Wedgewood Blue')","url":"https://www.backyardgardener.com/plantname/syringa-vulgaris-wedgewood-blue-common-lilac/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Characteristics: fragrant, old fashioned/heritage, showy, single,","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lilac-wedgwood-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253924","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lilac-wedgwood-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Gertens plant database (Wedgewood Blue Lilac)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/1475/Wedgewood_Blue_Lilac/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is very adaptable to both dry and moist locations, and should do just fine under average home landscape conditions.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lilac-wedgwood-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253924","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Gertens plant database (Wedgewood Blue Lilac)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/1475/Wedgewood_Blue_Lilac/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies to your yard","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lily-asiatic","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lilium, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,1.83],"band":[0.3,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":2,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lily-asiatic","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lilium, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 8 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.2,0.61],"band":[0.2,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":2,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lily-asiatic","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lilium, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens, All About Lilies (the Lilium genus)","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/article/all-about-lilies","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most lilies will survive the winter outdoors in hardiness zones 4-9.","zones":[4,9],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":2,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lily-asiatic","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lilium, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lilium - Asiatic hybrids)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium-asiatic-hybrids/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lilium 'Connecticut King', an Asiatic hybrid)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244727","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Lilium Asiatic hybrids (I))","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/70679/lilium-asiatic-hybrids-(i)/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"J.W. Jung Seed Company garden guide (Asiatic Hybrid Lilies)","url":"https://www.jungseed.com/category/lilies-garden-guide","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Asiatic lilies in organically rich soils with excellent drainage in a full sun location.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens, All About Lilies (the Lilium genus)","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/article/all-about-lilies","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lilies perform best in full sun, though they will also grow in partial shade.","level":"genus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lily-asiatic","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lilium, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are easy to grow, are usually short in stature (less than 3 feet tall) but have no fragrance.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lilium - Asiatic hybrids)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium-asiatic-hybrids/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are usually the first to bloom, have no scent and have the widest color range of the lilies.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lilium 'Connecticut King', an Asiatic hybrid)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244727","country":null,"form":null,"value":"which are known for their large, often non-fragrant flowers","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Lilium Asiatic hybrids (I))","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/70679/lilium-asiatic-hybrids-(i)/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Most are unfragranced","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens, All About Lilies (the Lilium genus)","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/article/all-about-lilies","country":null,"form":null,"value":"big blooms, amazing colors and wonderful fragrance","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Plant of the Week: Asiatic Lilies","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/hort-home-landscape/2017-06-13-plant-week-asiatic-lilies","country":null,"form":null,"value":"One of the earliest and easiest to grow of all the lilies, Asiatics are beautiful, but generally lack the heavy fragrance that others, like Oriental lilies, can possess.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lily-asiatic","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lilium, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Makes beautiful cut flowers and comes in many different colors.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lilium - Asiatic hybrids)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium-asiatic-hybrids/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lilium 'Connecticut King', an Asiatic hybrid)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244727","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Costa Farms plant finder (Lily, Asiatic)","url":"https://costafarms.com/blogs/plant-finder/lily-asiatic","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Asiatic lily flowers appear in clusters at the very top of the plant which makes them ideal for cutting gardens.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens, All About Lilies (the Lilium genus)","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/article/all-about-lilies","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lilies are long lasting cut flowers and many of them will add fragrance as well as beauty to your summer arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Plant of the Week: Asiatic Lilies","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/hort-home-landscape/2017-06-13-plant-week-asiatic-lilies","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Asiatic lilies are best cut for enjoying in a vase, just as the flowers start to show color and open up.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"lily-asiatic","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lily-asiatic","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lilium, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lilium - Asiatic hybrids)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium-asiatic-hybrids/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Costa Farms plant finder (Lily, Asiatic)","url":"https://costafarms.com/blogs/plant-finder/lily-asiatic","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"lily-of-valley","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.18,0.2],"union":[0.1,0.3],"voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/convallaria-majalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 0 ft. 10 in.","metres":[0.15,0.25],"band":[0.15,0.25],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282052","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.50 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/lily-of-the-valley/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lily of the valley grows 6 to 8 inches tall.","metres":[0.15,0.2],"band":[0.15,0.2],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC, Ground Covers factsheet","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/groundcovers/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8 inches","metres":0.2,"band":[0.18,0.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/convallaria-majalis.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4-6 inches","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/convallaria-majalis/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Height: 23cm","metres":0.23,"band":[0.21,0.25],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://www.brentandbeckysbulbs.com/products/convallaria-majalis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6″-9″","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/lily-of-the-valley","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 6 to 12 inches","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/lily-of-the-valley/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 4\" to 8\"","metres":[0.1,0.2],"band":[0.1,0.2],"role":"scored","level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lily-of-valley","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.27,0.3],"union":[0.1,0.58],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/convallaria-majalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 4 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.1,0.3],"band":[0.1,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282052","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/convallaria-majalis.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"12-23 inches","metres":[0.3,0.58],"band":[0.3,0.58],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/convallaria-majalis/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Spread: 30cm","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/lily-of-the-valley","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 9 to 12 inches","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lily-of-valley","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,7],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-7","3-8","2-8","2-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/convallaria-majalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[3,7],"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282052","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/lily-of-the-valley/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 2, Zone 3, Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8","zones":[2,8],"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/convallaria-majalis.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 2-9","zones":[2,9],"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://www.brentandbeckysbulbs.com/products/convallaria-majalis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/lily-of-the-valley","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growzone: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/lily-of-the-valley/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lily-of-valley","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/convallaria-majalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in dappled to partial shade to full shade areas in moist organically rich soil.","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282052","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/lily-of-the-valley/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily), Full shade (4 hrs or less of light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/convallaria-majalis.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade or Full Shade","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/convallaria-majalis/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Dappled shade, full shade","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://www.brentandbeckysbulbs.com/products/convallaria-majalis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part Shade, Shade","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/lily-of-the-valley","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/lily-of-the-valley/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade, Full Shade","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lily-of-valley","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/convallaria-majalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"delicate, fragrant bell shaped white flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282052","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/lily-of-the-valley/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are tiny white, bell-shaped, waxy and appear on erect green stalks in spring. They are very fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC, Ground Covers factsheet","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/groundcovers/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dark green leaves turn yellow in fall. Fragrant, white, bell-shaped flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/convallaria-majalis.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"bearing short spikes of fragrant white bells in late spring","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/convallaria-majalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Scented flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://www.brentandbeckysbulbs.com/products/convallaria-majalis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Features: Critter resistant, shade loving ground cover with an intoxicating fragrance","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/lily-of-the-valley","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bloom Time / Color: Spring; white, bell-shaped, very fragrant flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/lily-of-the-valley/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These enchanting intensely fragrant, late spring bloomers make a fine ground cover where they get shade or part shade.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lily-of-valley","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/convallaria-majalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers make an excellent addition to bouquets, so consider planting these in the front of a cutting garden.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282052","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Popular cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/convallaria-majalis.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://www.brentandbeckysbulbs.com/products/convallaria-majalis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"is well worth the effort as it provides an abundance of cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/lily-of-the-valley","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers also make lovely small-cut stems for indoor enjoyment","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/lily-of-the-valley/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good as Cut Flowers, Naturalizing, Perennializing, Pleasantly Scented","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"lily-of-valley","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/convallaria-majalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is tolerant of summer drought and heavy clay or dry soils and is resistant to browsing by deer and rabbits.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282052","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates a wide range of soil conditions, including dry and clay soils.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/lily-of-the-valley/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is tolerant of most soil types, but grows best in well-drained loamy soil, and is tolerant of drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/convallaria-majalis.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of poor soils, even dry shade, but prefers a rich, moist soil.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/lily-of-the-valley","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer and rabbit resistant; drought tolerance improves once established","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lily-of-valley","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.perennials.com/plants/convallaria-majalis.html","https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/lily-of-the-valley"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/convallaria-majalis.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/lily-of-the-valley","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Early-season flowers can support pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"convallaria majalis"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lisianthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lisianthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lisianthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lisianthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Eustoma grandiflorum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280810","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"eustoma grandiflorum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Eustoma grandiflorum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eustoma-grandiflorum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"eustoma grandiflorum"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society plant profile (Eustoma grandiflorum)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/57097/eustoma-grandiflorum/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"eustoma grandiflorum"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions (Lisianthus, Eustoma grandiflorum)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/lisianthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lisianthus grows in partial sun with shade in most types of soil","level":"species","taxon":"eustoma grandiflorum"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (Lisianthus, Eustoma grandiflorum)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/lisianthus.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun or part shade. Light shade in hottest climates.","level":"species","taxon":"eustoma grandiflorum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lisianthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["eustoma grandiflorum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (eustoma grandiflorum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (eustoma grandiflorum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lisianthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":5,"covered":["eustoma grandiflorum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (eustoma grandiflorum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 5 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (eustoma grandiflorum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lisianthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["eustoma grandiflorum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (eustoma grandiflorum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (eustoma grandiflorum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lisianthus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lisianthus-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"this flowering plant grows to about 15 inches tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lisianthus-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 9 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lisianthus-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eustoma-grandiflorum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"will survive the winter temperatures of USDA Zones 8-10","zones":[8,10]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lisianthus-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eustoma-grandiflorum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/lisianthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows in partial sun with shade in most types of soil"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lisianthus-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lisianthus-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eustoma-grandiflorum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lisianthus is an excellent cut flower.","claim":true},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/lisianthus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lisianthus blossoms make excellent cut flowers, and are popular for wedding bouquets.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lisianthus-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eustoma-grandiflorum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The plant is noted for good drought tolerance.","claim":true},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/lisianthus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established the plants have good drought tolerance","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lisianthus-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lisianthus-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"this flowering plant grows to about 15 inches tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Size Notes: Up to about 3 feet tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1–3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 75cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lisianthus-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.75 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 9 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1–3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 30cm\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lisianthus-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[8,10],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280810","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8 to 10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eustoma-grandiflorum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"The Old Farmer's Almanac","url":"https://www.almanac.com/plant/lisianthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lisianthus are hardy in USDA Zones 8 to 10.","zones":[8,10]}],"note":"every source states 8-10; catalog states 8-11","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lisianthus-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280810","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eustoma-grandiflorum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/lisianthus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lisianthus grows in partial sun with shade in most types of soil"},{"name":"The Old Farmer's Almanac","url":"https://www.almanac.com/plant/lisianthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/eustoma-grandiflorum/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lisianthus-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lisianthus-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280810","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cut flower.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eustoma-grandiflorum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lisianthus is an excellent cut flower.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/lisianthus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lisianthus blossoms make excellent cut flowers, and are popular for wedding bouquets.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lisianthus-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eustoma-grandiflorum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The plant is noted for good drought tolerance.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/lisianthus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established the plants have good drought tolerance","claim":true},{"name":"The Old Farmer's Almanac","url":"https://www.almanac.com/plant/lisianthus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lisianthus are drought tolerant once established and will continue to blossom for many weeks, often until frost.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lisianthus-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"little-bluestem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.82,1],"union":[0.3,1.52],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285323","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/schizachyrium-scoparium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/little-bluestem-schizachyrium-scoparium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Little bluestem clumps grow 1-2 feet high, until late summer when the stems elongate into flowering stems which may reach 5 feet.","metres":[0.3,1.52],"band":[0.3,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/schizachyrium-scoparium-little-bluestem","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It can grow to 3 feet tall","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"little-bluestem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.46,0.61],"union":[0.46,0.91],"proposed":0.54,"margin":13,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285323","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/schizachyrium-scoparium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 6 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.46,0.91],"band":[0.46,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.46 to 0.91 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"little-bluestem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285323","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/schizachyrium-scoparium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/schizachyrium-scoparium-little-bluestem","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 9","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"little-bluestem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285323","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/schizachyrium-scoparium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/little-bluestem-schizachyrium-scoparium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Little bluestem grows best in full sun"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/schizachyrium-scoparium-little-bluestem","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=SCSC","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"little-bluestem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"little-bluestem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/schizachyrium-scoparium-little-bluestem","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The stems and heads are suitable for drying.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"little-bluestem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285323","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good drought resistance once established.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/schizachyrium-scoparium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, it has excellent drought resistance.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/little-bluestem-schizachyrium-scoparium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, it is a drought-resistant, easy-care addition to the home landscape.","claim":true},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/schizachyrium-scoparium-little-bluestem","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This grass is native throughout most of North America and is tolerant of dry conditions.","claim":true},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=SCSC","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerance: High","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"little-bluestem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/schizachyrium-scoparium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"little bluestem is a larval host plant to various butterflies and moths, making it a great choice for a pollinator garden","claim":true},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=SCSC","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds , Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"little-bluestem-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.68,0.84],"union":[0.55,0.91],"proposed":0.76,"margin":9.9,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=272432","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Cavano's Perennials","url":"https://cavanos.com/product/schizachyrium-scoparium-blaze-little-bluestem/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24-36\"","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Schizachyrium-scoparium-Blaze","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 30 Inches","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/26309/Blaze_Little_Bluestem/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: 24 inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"R&D Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.rdwholesalenursery.com/Plant-Name/Schizachyrium-scoparium-Blaze-Blaze-Little-Bluestem","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24-36 in","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.55 to 0.91 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"little-bluestem-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.46,0.51],"union":[0.38,0.67],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=272432","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Cavano's Perennials","url":"https://cavanos.com/product/schizachyrium-scoparium-blaze-little-bluestem/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18-24\"","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Schizachyrium-scoparium-Blaze","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 20 Inches","metres":0.51,"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/26309/Blaze_Little_Bluestem/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 24 inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"R&D Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.rdwholesalenursery.com/Plant-Name/Schizachyrium-scoparium-Blaze-Blaze-Little-Bluestem","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 15-20 in","metres":[0.38,0.51],"band":[0.38,0.51],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"little-bluestem-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=272432","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/schizachyrium-scoparium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/schizachyrium-scoparium-blaze-blaze-little-bluestem","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Cavano's Perennials","url":"https://cavanos.com/product/schizachyrium-scoparium-blaze-little-bluestem/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"R&D Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.rdwholesalenursery.com/Plant-Name/Schizachyrium-scoparium-Blaze-Blaze-Little-Bluestem","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"little-bluestem-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=272432","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/schizachyrium-scoparium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/schizachyrium-scoparium-blaze-blaze-little-bluestem","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension (species page)","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/little-bluestem-in-the-landscape","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun/Shade Preference: full sun"},{"name":"Cavano's Perennials","url":"https://cavanos.com/product/schizachyrium-scoparium-blaze-little-bluestem/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure: full sun"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/26309/Blaze_Little_Bluestem/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight."},{"name":"R&D Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.rdwholesalenursery.com/Plant-Name/Schizachyrium-scoparium-Blaze-Blaze-Little-Bluestem","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"little-bluestem-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"little-bluestem-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"little-bluestem-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=272432","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good drought resistance once established.","claim":true},{"name":"Cavano's Perennials","url":"https://cavanos.com/product/schizachyrium-scoparium-blaze-little-bluestem/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Notes: drought tolerant, deer tolerant, dry soil, rocky soil, urban conditions","claim":true},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/26309/Blaze_Little_Bluestem/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is considered to be drought-tolerant, and thus makes an ideal choice for a low-water garden or xeriscape application.","claim":true},{"name":"R&D Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.rdwholesalenursery.com/Plant-Name/Schizachyrium-scoparium-Blaze-Blaze-Little-Bluestem","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought resistant","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"little-bluestem-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lobelia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":7},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 0 ft. 9 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.50 to 0.75 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 to 1 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Edging lobelia is a trailing annual growing 6 inches tall with clumps spreading 12 to 16 inches across.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Growth Habit: Evergreen, herbaceous annual or short-lived perennial, matting to trailing to 6-inches high with a 12-inches spread.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lobelia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.25,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":7},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.50 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1 to 2 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Edging lobelia is a trailing annual growing 6 inches tall with clumps spreading 12 to 16 inches across.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Growth Habit: Evergreen, herbaceous annual or short-lived perennial, matting to trailing to 6-inches high with a 12-inches spread.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lobelia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-11","9-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lobelia erinus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lobelia-erinus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[10,11],"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia erinus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lobelia erinus)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278852","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11],"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia erinus"},{"name":"Proven Winners growing guide (annual lobelia, Lobelia erinus)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/lobelia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy in USDA zones 9-11, this lobelia type is a tender perennial grown as an annual in most regions.","zones":[9,11],"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia erinus"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":7},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lobelia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lobelia erinus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lobelia-erinus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia erinus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lobelia erinus)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278852","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia erinus"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, EDIS FPS-351 (Lobelia erinus, edging lobelia)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp351","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in full sun","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia erinus"},{"name":"Proven Winners growing guide (annual lobelia, Lobelia erinus)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/lobelia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lobelia plant performs best with full sun to partial shade and rich, well-draining soil.","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia erinus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Lobelia erinus, trailing lobelia)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/142728/lobelia-erinus/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia erinus"},{"name":"Arizona State University plant files, Chris Martin (Lobelia erinus)","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/lobeliaerinus.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun to partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"lobelia erinus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lobelia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lobelia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lobelia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lobelia erinus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lobelia-erinus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It should be consistently watered and does not tolerate drought.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia erinus"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service, Plant of the Week (edging lobelia, Lobelia erinus)","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/lobelia-edging-1-25-08.aspx","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Edging lobelia has little or no drought tolerance but is easy to overwater.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia erinus"}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lobelia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lobelia erinus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lobelia-erinus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia erinus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lobelia erinus)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278852","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia erinus"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, EDIS FPS-351 (Lobelia erinus, edging lobelia)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp351","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: container or above-ground planter; mass planting; border; attracts butterflies; cascading down a wall","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia erinus"},{"name":"Proven Winners growing guide (annual lobelia, Lobelia erinus)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/lobelia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The small two-lipped tubular flowers are attractive to hummingbirds, bees and other insect pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobelia erinus"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"lobelia-sky-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.50 to 0.75 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0 ft. 6 in. - 0 ft. 9 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lobelia-sky-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.25,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.50 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lobelia-sky-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"CONVENTION","wouldPropose":[10,11],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278852","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lobelia-erinus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[10,11]}],"note":"every source states 10-11 and this row deliberately stores no zones, which is the library's way of saying \"grown everywhere\" (docs/CATALOG-AUDIT.md records the two zone conventions for annuals as expected). Nothing is proposed: writing a zone range onto a zone-less row would remove it from every zone filter outside that range, and this is one library-wide decision rather than a per-plant error","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lobelia-sky-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278852","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lobelia-erinus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lobelia-sky-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lobelia-sky-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lobelia-sky-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lobelia-sky-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278852","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to butterflies.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lobelia-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0 ft. 6 in. - 0 ft. 9 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0.50 to 0.75 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lobelia-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.25,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0.50 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lobelia-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278852&isprofile=0&basic=Lobelia%20erinus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10 to 11","zones":[10,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lobelia-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lobelia-erinus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278852&isprofile=0&basic=Lobelia%20erinus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lobelia-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lobelia-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lobelia-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lobelia-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278852&isprofile=0&basic=Lobelia%20erinus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to butterflies.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"louise-clements","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"botanicalName","current":"Rosa 'Louise Clements'","outcome":"NAME-UNVERIFIED","sources":[],"note":"the botanical name could not be confirmed against a registry, so no trait was checked","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"lungwort","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":12,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":6,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 12 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lungwort","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":12,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":6,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 12 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lungwort","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":10,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":6,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lungwort","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278004&isprofile=0&basic=Pulmonaria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"pulmonaria saccharata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=359968&isprofile=0&basic=Pulmonaria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"pulmonaria officinalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278014&isprofile=0&basic=Pulmonaria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"pulmonaria longifolia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277975&isprofile=0&basic=Pulmonaria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"pulmonaria rubra"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pulmonaria-officinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"pulmonaria officinalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pulmonaria-longifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"pulmonaria longifolia"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pulmonaria-saccharata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"pulmonaria saccharata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pulmonaria-raspberry-splash/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"RHS Plant Profile: Pulmonaria 'Diana Clare'","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/135762/pulmonaria-diana-clare/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full shade, Partial shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"RHS Plant Profile: Pulmonaria 'Blue Ensign'","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/90767/pulmonaria-blue-ensign/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full shade, Partial shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/pulmonaria-saccharata-mrs-moon.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Partial Shade or Full Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"pulmonaria saccharata"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/pulmonaria-longifolia-bertram-anderson.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Partial Shade or Full Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"pulmonaria longifolia"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lungwort","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lungwort","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are perennials.com","urls":["https://www.perennials.com/plants/pulmonaria-saccharata-mrs-moon.html","https://www.perennials.com/plants/pulmonaria-longifolia-bertram-anderson.html"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/pulmonaria-saccharata-mrs-moon.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"pulmonaria saccharata"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/pulmonaria-longifolia-bertram-anderson.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"pulmonaria longifolia"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are perennials.com. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lungwort","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"RHS Genus Guide: Pulmonaria","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/pulmonaria","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Very dry soil can cause leaves to wither, especially in full sun, and plants can suffer during prolonged periods of drought in summer.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"pulmonaria"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lungwort","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pulmonaria-officinalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees, flies, butterflies, moth caterpillars, and some wildlife are attracted to this plant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"pulmonaria officinalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pulmonaria-longifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"pulmonaria longifolia"},{"name":"RHS Genus Guide: Pulmonaria","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/pulmonaria","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They also offer bees a useful source of nectar early in the year.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"pulmonaria"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"lupine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.25,1.22],"split":[{"range":[0.25,0.61],"sources":["Utah State University Extension, Range Plants of Utah (Lupine, Lupinus)"]},{"range":[0.81,1.22],"sources":["RHS Plant Guide (Lupin, the Lupinus genus)","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lupinus, genus entry)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lupinus, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lupinus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"},{"name":"RHS Plant Guide (Lupin, the Lupinus genus)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/lupins","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"These reach 90cm (3ft) tall, rising above clumps of softly hairy green leaves divided into finger-like leaflets.","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension, Range Plants of Utah (Lupine, Lupinus)","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/rangeplants/forbs-herbaceous/lupine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"A complex group of erect to ascending forbs, 10 to 24 inches tall, with 1 to several stems growing from a shortly branching taproot.","metres":[0.25,0.61],"band":[0.25,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":1,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lupine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lupinus, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lupinus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":1,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lupine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lupinus, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lupinus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":1,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lupine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lupinus, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lupinus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lupinus x hybrida, hybrid garden lupines)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264504","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"lupinus hybrida"},{"name":"American Meadows, How To Grow Lupine (Lupinus, genus guide)","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/blogs/wildflower-seeds/how-to-grow-lupine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun is preferred. Lupine can grow in part shade, but flowering will be lessened.","level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lupinus 'The Governor', a Russell Hybrid)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=272340","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource / Walters Gardens (Lupinus Russell Hybrids - Mixed)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=LUPRH","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Washington Botanic Gardens plant profile (Lupinus 'The Governor')","url":"https://botanicgardens.uw.edu/may-2010-plant-profile-lupinus-the-governor","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lupine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lupinus, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lupinus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The plants bloom from spring into summer with fragrant purple and yellow blossoms along an erect stalk.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"},{"name":"RHS Plant Guide (Lupin, the Lupinus genus)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/lupins","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The shrubs are less commonly grown but have the advantage of delicately scented flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lupinus 'The Governor', a Russell Hybrid)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=272340","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"lupine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lupinus, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lupinus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"},{"name":"RHS Plant Guide (Lupin, the Lupinus genus)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/lupins","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They make brilliant cut flowers too.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"},{"name":"Perennial Resource / Walters Gardens (Lupinus Russell Hybrids - Mixed)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=LUPRH","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Border Plant Cut Flower Cut Foliage Mass Planting Salt Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Washington Botanic Gardens plant profile (Lupinus 'The Governor')","url":"https://botanicgardens.uw.edu/may-2010-plant-profile-lupinus-the-governor","country":null,"form":null,"value":"when used as a group in both the garden and in cut flower arrangements","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["lupinus hybrida"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (lupinus hybrida), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (lupinus hybrida) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"lupine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lupinus, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lupinus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant Garden","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"},{"name":"RHS Plant Guide (Lupin, the Lupinus genus)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/lupins","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Heavy, wet soil is not appreciated by lupins, and they dislike drought when growth begins in spring.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"lupine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lupinus, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lupinus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator Garden","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"},{"name":"American Meadows, How To Grow Lupine (Lupinus, genus guide)","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/blogs/wildflower-seeds/how-to-grow-lupine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lupines attract bees and butterflies of all sorts with their multi- and bi-colored flowers, and are a great choice for pollinator gardens.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lupinus 'The Governor', a Russell Hybrid)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=272340","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Perennial Resource / Walters Gardens (Lupinus Russell Hybrids - Mixed)","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=LUPRH","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["lupinus hybrida"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (lupinus hybrida), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (lupinus hybrida) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"lupine-gallery-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-lupine-gallery-blue","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 18-24\" tall","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/gallery-blue-lupine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 18 - 24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/lupine-gallery-blue","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 1-2 ft Tall, 1 ft Wide","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Lupinus-Gallery-Blue","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18-24 in","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pondside Nursery","url":"https://pondsidenursery.com/products/lupinus-gallery-blue","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 14 - 16 Inches","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lupine-gallery-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.18,0.61],"split":[{"range":[0.18,0.23],"sources":["Pondside Nursery"]},{"range":[0.27,0.33],"sources":["Nature Hills Nursery"]},{"range":[0.38,0.61],"sources":["Plant Addicts","American Meadows"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-lupine-gallery-blue","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 18-24\" wide","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/gallery-blue-lupine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 15 - 18 Inches","metres":[0.38,0.46],"band":[0.38,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/lupine-gallery-blue","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 1-2 ft Tall, 1 ft Wide","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pondside Nursery","url":"https://pondsidenursery.com/products/lupinus-gallery-blue","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 7 - 9 Inches","metres":[0.18,0.23],"band":[0.18,0.23],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 3 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lupine-gallery-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Lupinus x hybrida, hybrid-group page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264504","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-lupine-gallery-blue","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones Zone 4 Zone 5 Zone 6 Zone 7 Zone 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/gallery-blue-lupine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 4 - 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/lupine-gallery-blue","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Cold Hardy: Thrives in Zones 4-8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Lupinus-Gallery-Blue","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Pondside Nursery","url":"https://pondsidenursery.com/products/lupinus-gallery-blue","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4-8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lupine-gallery-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Lupinus x hybrida, hybrid-group page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264504","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-lupine-gallery-blue","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/gallery-blue-lupine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Full Sun (At Least 6 Hours Of Direct Sunlight)"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/lupine-gallery-blue","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full sun"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Lupinus-Gallery-Blue","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"Pondside Nursery","url":"https://pondsidenursery.com/products/lupinus-gallery-blue","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun to Part Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lupine-gallery-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lupine-gallery-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Lupinus x hybrida, hybrid-group page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264504","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cut flowers.","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-lupine-gallery-blue","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Mass Plantings Cut Flowers Deer Resistant","claim":true},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Lupinus-Gallery-Blue","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lupine-gallery-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/lupine-gallery-blue","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once mature, Gallery Blue is moderately drought tolerant, but inconsistent watering during the heat of summer can cause the foliage to go dormant early or result in smaller flower spikes.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lupine-gallery-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Lupinus x hybrida, hybrid-group page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264504","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-lupine-gallery-blue","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bee Friendly Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/gallery-blue-lupine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies, hummingbirds and native bees are all attracted to the tasty nectar.","claim":true},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/lupine-gallery-blue","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies, Attracts pollinators","claim":true},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Lupinus-Gallery-Blue","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"lupine-the-chatelaine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.9,0.99],"union":[0.72,1.1],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Claire Austin Hardy Plants","url":"https://www.claireaustin-hardyplants.co.uk/products/lupinus-the-chatelaine","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Height x Spread: 90cm x 80cm","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proctors Nursery","url":"https://proctorsnursery.co.uk/product/lupinus-the-chatelaine/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Height 90cm.","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"J Parkers","url":"https://www.jparkers.co.uk/lupin-the-chatelaine/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 100 cm","metres":1,"band":[0.9,1.1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Lageschaar Vaste Planten","url":"https://www.lageschaar.nl/overige-planten/lupinus-the-chatelaine","country":"NL","form":null,"value":"Bloemhoogte 80 cm","metres":0.8,"band":[0.72,0.88],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plantencentrum van den Beuken","url":"https://www.plantencentrumvandenbeuken.nl/assortiment/vaste-planten/lupinus-the-chatelaine/","country":"NL","form":null,"value":"Hoogte: 100 cm","metres":1,"band":[0.9,1.1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fleurs des Cevennes","url":"https://www.fleursdescevennes.fr/produit/lupin-rose-a-etendard-blanc/","country":"FR","form":null,"value":"Hauteur: 90cm","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":2,"genus":1,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lupine-the-chatelaine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.45,0.88],"split":[{"range":[0.45,0.55],"sources":["J Parkers"]},{"range":[0.68,0.88],"sources":["Proctors Nursery","Claire Austin Hardy Plants"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Claire Austin Hardy Plants","url":"https://www.claireaustin-hardyplants.co.uk/products/lupinus-the-chatelaine","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Height x Spread: 90cm x 80cm","metres":0.8,"band":[0.72,0.88],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proctors Nursery","url":"https://proctorsnursery.co.uk/product/lupinus-the-chatelaine/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Spread 75cm.","metres":0.75,"band":[0.68,0.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"J Parkers","url":"https://www.jparkers.co.uk/lupin-the-chatelaine/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 50 cm","metres":0.5,"band":[0.45,0.55],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":2,"genus":1,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lupine-the-chatelaine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":2,"genus":1,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lupine-the-chatelaine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264504&isprofile=0&basic=Lupinus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"lupinus hybrida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lupinus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"},{"name":"Claire Austin Hardy Plants","url":"https://www.claireaustin-hardyplants.co.uk/products/lupinus-the-chatelaine","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"How Much Sun: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proctors Nursery","url":"https://proctorsnursery.co.uk/product/lupinus-the-chatelaine/","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun/partial shade.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/lupine.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"lupinus polyphyllus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lupine-the-chatelaine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lupinus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"},{"name":"J Parkers","url":"https://www.jparkers.co.uk/lupin-the-chatelaine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies Fragrant Summer flowering time","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"lupine-the-chatelaine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264504&isprofile=0&basic=Lupinus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Mixed perennial borders, cottage gardens. Excellent cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lupinus hybrida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lupinus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"},{"name":"J Parkers","url":"https://www.jparkers.co.uk/lupin-the-chatelaine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"lupine-the-chatelaine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lupinus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant Garden","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"lupine-the-chatelaine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264504&isprofile=0&basic=Lupinus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lupinus hybrida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lupinus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lupinus"},{"name":"J Parkers","url":"https://www.jparkers.co.uk/lupin-the-chatelaine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/perennials/lupine.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nectar rich flowers attract butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lupinus polyphyllus"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"maiden-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.52,1.83],"union":[1.22,4],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285333","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.00 to 9.00 feet","metres":[1.22,2.74],"band":[1.22,2.74],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/miscanthus-sinensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 ft. 0 in. - 12 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,3.66],"band":[1.22,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension EDIS (FP405, Miscanthus sinensis Maiden Grass)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP405","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5 to 6 feet","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/95355/miscanthus-sinensis/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 2.5-4 metres","metres":[2.5,4],"band":[2.5,4],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.52,1.83],"union":[0.91,3.05],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285333","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/miscanthus-sinensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 4 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension EDIS (FP405, Miscanthus sinensis Maiden Grass)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP405","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 5 to 10 feet","metres":[1.52,3.05],"band":[1.52,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/95355/miscanthus-sinensis/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285333","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/miscanthus-sinensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension EDIS (FP405, Miscanthus sinensis Maiden Grass)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP405","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA hardiness zones: 4 through 9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285333","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/miscanthus-sinensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension EDIS (FP405, Miscanthus sinensis Maiden Grass)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP405","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in full sun"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/95355/miscanthus-sinensis/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285333","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/miscanthus-sinensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut Good Dried","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285333","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Erosion, Dry Soil, Black Walnut, Urban Conditions","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/miscanthus-sinensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Dry Soil Humidity Salt Wet Soil Wind","claim":true},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension EDIS (FP405, Miscanthus sinensis Maiden Grass)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP405","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This ornamental grass is quite drought tolerant.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/miscanthus-sinensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Play Value: Attracts Pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.52,1.83],"union":[1,2.13],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250965","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.00 to 7.00 feet","metres":[1.22,2.13],"band":[1.22,2.13],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=MISGM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5.0-6.0 Feet","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/80383/miscanthus-sinensis-gracillimus-/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.91,1],"union":[0.5,1.83],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250965","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=MISGM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.0-4.0 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/80383/miscanthus-sinensis-gracillimus-/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250965","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/miscanthus-sinensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=MISGM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 5,6,7,8,9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250965","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/miscanthus-sinensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=MISGM","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/80383/miscanthus-sinensis-gracillimus-/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250965","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=MISGM","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Border Plant Container Cut Foliage Dried Flower Easy To Grow Mass Planting Salt Tolerant Specimen Focal Point","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250965","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Dry Soil, Black Walnut, Urban Conditions","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.22,1.52],"union":[0.91,1.83],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292001&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/miscanthus-purpurascens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FPS408)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP408","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 to 4 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=MISPU","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.0-6.0 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.55,1.83],"split":[{"range":[0.55,0.67],"sources":["Walters Gardens"]},{"range":[0.76,1.83],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden","University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FPS408)","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292001&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.50 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/miscanthus-purpurascens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FPS408)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP408","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3 to 5 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=MISPU","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.0 Feet","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","4-8","7-9","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292001&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/miscanthus-purpurascens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FPS408)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP408","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA hardiness zones: 7 through 9","zones":[7,9]},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=MISPU","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292001&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/miscanthus-purpurascens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FPS408)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP408","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in full sun"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=MISPU","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292001&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/miscanthus-purpurascens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292001&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Dry Soil, Black Walnut, Urban Conditions","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FPS408)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP408","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This ornamental grass is quite drought tolerant.","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=MISPU","country":null,"form":null,"value":"it is not drought-tolerant and suffers in extreme heat","claim":false}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maiden-grass-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maidenhair-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC, Maidenhair Fern","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/maidenhair-fern/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is cold hardy from USDA planting zones 3 through 8 and will be 1 to 3 feet tall and wide.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maidenhair-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC, Maidenhair Fern","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/maidenhair-fern/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is cold hardy from USDA planting zones 3 through 8 and will be 1 to 3 feet tall and wide.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maidenhair-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC, Maidenhair Fern","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/maidenhair-fern/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is cold hardy from USDA planting zones 3 through 8 and will be 1 to 3 feet tall and wide.","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maidenhair-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-shade","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC, Maidenhair Fern","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/maidenhair-fern/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Both species of maidenhair ferns grow best in organically rich, moist, well-drained soil in part to full shade."}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maidenhair-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maidenhair-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maidenhair-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC, Maidenhair Fern","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/maidenhair-fern/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fronds will turn brown if kept too dry or in too much sun.","claim":false},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Adiantum, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/adiantum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#drought intolerant","claim":false}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"maidenhair-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":4,"cultivar":1,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Climber","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mandevilla can grow up to 10 feet in a season.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"mandevilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":4,"cultivar":1,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Climber","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"mandevilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Mandevilla, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mandevilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[10,11],"level":"genus","taxon":"mandevilla"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":4,"cultivar":1,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"mandevilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Mandevilla, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mandevilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"mandevilla"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Mandevilla 'Red Velvet')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260909","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Mandevilla x amabilis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263927","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"mandevilla amabilis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Mandevilla boliviensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276097","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"mandevilla boliviensis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Mandevilla, its Annual Vine entry for the genus)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/mandevilla-annual-vine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily)","level":"genus","taxon":"mandevilla"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Mandevilla x amoena)","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21444","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"mandevilla amoena"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Mandevilla, the genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/mandevilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Outdoors, grow mandevillas in partial shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"mandevilla"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions (Mandevilla, the genus page)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/mandevilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mandevilla needs to be planted in full sun in order to flower well.","level":"genus","taxon":"mandevilla"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"mandevilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Mandevilla, the genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/mandevilla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Quantities of fragrant flowers compensate for sparse foliage and for the care mandevillas require.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"mandevilla"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"mandevilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"mandevilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["mandevilla amoena"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (mandevilla amoena), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (mandevilla amoena) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"mandevilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Mandevilla, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mandevilla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"When planted outdoors the tubular showy flowers attract hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"mandevilla"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Climber","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 72 to 96-inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 15 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 72-96 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 8 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Climber","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 24 to 36-inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 20 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 24-36 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"it can grow to be around 8 feet tall at maturity, with a spread of 24 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sun-parasol-apricot-mandevilla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 10-11","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Mandevilla, genus page: zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mandevilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Mandevilla x amabilis, species page: zones and sun only)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263927","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sun-parasol-apricot-mandevilla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Partial Sun to Full Sun"},{"name":"Dickman Farms plant database","url":"http://plants.dickmanfarms.com/12130016/Plant/25023/Sun_Parasol_Apricot_Mandevilla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in full sun to partial shade."},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Mandevilla, genus page: zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mandevilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Mandevilla x amabilis, species page: zones and sun only)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263927","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sun-parasol-apricot-mandevilla","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant: No","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Suntory Flowers (breeder, SUN PARASOL Apricot variety page)","url":"https://www.suntoryflowers.com/variety/sun-parasol-apricot/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Usage: Container Gardens, Hanging Baskets, Pollinator Plant","claim":true},{"name":"Dickman Farms plant database","url":"http://plants.dickmanfarms.com/12130016/Plant/25023/Sun_Parasol_Apricot_Mandevilla","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies and hummingbirds to your yard","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Mandevilla, genus page: zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mandevilla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"When planted outdoors the tubular showy flowers attract hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Climber","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Moderate growing, bushy vine; twining stems reach 10 to 15 ft. long.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Climber","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/sun-parasol-crimson-mandevilla.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone 10-11","zones":[10,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/sun-parasol-crimson-mandevilla.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Climber","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 12 to 24-inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Garden Height: 12 - 24 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height: 1 - 2 Feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 24 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 6-8 ft\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Climber","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 24 to 36-inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 24 - 36 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Spread: 2 - 4 Feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["9-11","10-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (Sun Parasol Original Sunbeam Mandevilla)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/mandevilla/sun-parasol-original-sunbeam-mandevilla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 9a , 9b , 10a , 10b , 11a , 11b","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sun-parasol-sunbeam-mandevilla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 9 - 11","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Mandevilla, genus page: zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mandevilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"GardenCenterMarketing plant library (Mandevilla 'Sunbeam' PP20223, Sun Parasol 'Sunbeam')","url":"https://www.gardencentermarketing.com/plantname/Mandevilla-Sun-Parasol-Sunbeam","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10-11","zones":[10,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sun-parasol-sunbeam-mandevilla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Partial Sun to Full Sun (At Least 5 Hours of Direct Sunlight)"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Mandevilla, genus page: zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mandevilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions (Mandevilla, genus page: sun only)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/mandevilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mandevilla needs to be planted in full sun in order to flower well."},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Mandevilla factsheet, genus page: sun only)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/mandevilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Outdoors, grow mandevillas in partial shade."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mandevilla-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Suntory Flowers (breeder, SUN PARASOL XP Sunbeam)","url":"https://suntoryflowers.com/variety/sun-parasol-xp-sunbeam/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Usage: Container Gardens, Gardens, Hanging Baskets, Pollinator Plant","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/sun-parasol-sunbeam-mandevilla","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees, Birds, Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Mandevilla, genus page: zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mandevilla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"When planted outdoors the tubular showy flowers attract hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"Dickman Farms Garden Center (NetPS Plant Finder entry for Mandevilla 'Sun Parasol Sunbeam')","url":"https://plants.dickmanfarms.com/12130016/Plant/34537/Sun_Parasol_Sunbeam_Mandevilla","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies and hummingbirds to your yard","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"marguerite-daisy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":3,"cultivar":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Marguerite Daisy will grow to be about 18 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 18 inches. This fast-growing annual will normally live for one full growing season, needing replacement the following year.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"marguerite-daisy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":3,"cultivar":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Marguerite Daisy will grow to be about 18 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 18 inches. This fast-growing annual will normally live for one full growing season, needing replacement the following year.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"marguerite-daisy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":3,"cultivar":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"marguerite-daisy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Argyranthemum frutescens)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277625","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"argyranthemum frutescens"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Argyranthemum foeniculaceum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/argyranthemum-foeniculaceum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"argyranthemum foeniculaceum"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Argyranthemum frutescens Golden Butterfly)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/argyranthemum/golden-butterfly-marguerite-daisy-argyranthemum-frutescens","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Sun to Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"argyranthemum frutescens"},{"name":"RHS (Argyranthemum frutescens var. canariae)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/231495/argyranthemum-frutescens-var-canariae/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"argyranthemum frutescens"},{"name":"Armstrong Garden Centers (Argyranthemum, Marguerite Daisy)","url":"https://shop.armstronggarden.com/products/argyranthemum-4in-4-inch","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full Sun","level":"genus","taxon":"argyranthemum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"marguerite-daisy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Argyranthemum frutescens)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277625","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"argyranthemum frutescens"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Argyranthemum foeniculaceum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/argyranthemum-foeniculaceum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"argyranthemum foeniculaceum"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"marguerite-daisy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Armstrong Garden Centers (Argyranthemum, Marguerite Daisy)","url":"https://shop.armstronggarden.com/products/argyranthemum-4in-4-inch","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"argyranthemum"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"marguerite-daisy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Argyranthemum foeniculaceum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/argyranthemum-foeniculaceum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This drought-tolerant plant cannot grow in shade, full sun is ideal.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"argyranthemum foeniculaceum"},{"name":"RHS (Argyranthemum frutescens var. canariae)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/231495/argyranthemum-frutescens-var-canariae/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"argyranthemum frutescens"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"marguerite-daisy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Armstrong Garden Centers (Argyranthemum, Marguerite Daisy)","url":"https://shop.armstronggarden.com/products/argyranthemum-4in-4-inch","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies to your yard.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"argyranthemum"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["argyranthemum foeniculaceum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (argyranthemum foeniculaceum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (argyranthemum foeniculaceum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"marigold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":2,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1-3 Feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height/Spread: 6 inches to 3 feet tall, varies by cultivar\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"marigold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":2,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"marigold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"CONVENTION","wouldPropose":[2,11],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tagetes, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tagetes/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[2,11],"level":"genus","taxon":"tagetes"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Marigolds)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/marigolds/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone : 2-11","zones":[2,11],"level":"genus","taxon":"tagetes"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":2,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source states 2-11 and this row deliberately stores no zones, which is the library's way of saying \"grown everywhere\" (docs/CATALOG-AUDIT.md records the two zone conventions for annuals as expected). Nothing is proposed: writing a zone range onto a zone-less row would remove it from every zone filter outside that range, and this is one library-wide decision rather than a per-plant error; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"marigold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tagetes, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tagetes/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"tagetes"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tagetes erecta, African marigold)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277371","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"tagetes erecta"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tagetes patula, French marigold)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277481","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"tagetes patula"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tagetes patula 'Strawberry Blonde')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=437749","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"tagetes patula"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Marigold, Tagetes sp.)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=768&PlantTypeID=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun","level":"genus","taxon":"tagetes"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Marigold, the genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/marigold/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Needs: Full sun (6 or more hours daily)","level":"genus","taxon":"tagetes"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Marigolds)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/flowers/marigolds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Marigolds need full sun all day to provide blooms all season long.","level":"genus","taxon":"tagetes"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Marigolds)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/marigolds/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full sun (6 – 8 hours of direct sun)","level":"genus","taxon":"tagetes"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"marigold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tagetes, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tagetes/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#fragrant leaves","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tagetes"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tagetes erecta, African marigold)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277371","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"tagetes erecta"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tagetes patula, French marigold)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277481","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"tagetes patula"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tagetes patula 'Strawberry Blonde')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=437749","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"tagetes patula"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Marigold, the genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/marigold/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The foliage is a rich dark green and is often strongly scented, making it deer resistant.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tagetes"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Marigolds)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/flowers/marigolds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Marigolds naturally repel pests such as deer or rabbits since they find their odor offensive.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"tagetes"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"marigold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tagetes, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tagetes/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#cutting garden","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tagetes"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Marigold, Tagetes sp.)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=768&PlantTypeID=1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tagetes"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Marigold, the genus factsheet)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/marigold/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses in Landscape: Borders, mass plantings, containers, cut flowers, cover crops","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tagetes"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["tagetes patula"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (tagetes patula), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (tagetes patula) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"marigold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tagetes, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tagetes/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"some cultivars are known to have good tolerance to drought","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tagetes"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Marigolds)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/flowers/marigolds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Marigolds can tolerate drought conditions better than they can tolerate being overly wet","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tagetes"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"marigold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tagetes, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tagetes/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#butterfly friendly","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tagetes"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tagetes erecta, African marigold)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277371","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"tagetes erecta"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tagetes patula, French marigold)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277481","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"tagetes patula"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tagetes patula 'Strawberry Blonde')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=437749","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"tagetes patula"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Marigold, Tagetes sp.)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=768&PlantTypeID=1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tagetes"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"marigold-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"about 16 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"12 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"SPLIT"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"marigold-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"12 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"marigold-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","2-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/tagetes-erecta-vanilla-vanilla-african-marigold","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 - 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page, Tagetes erecta)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277371","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2 to 11","zones":[2,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"marigold-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/tagetes-erecta-vanilla-vanilla-african-marigold","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"Hicks Nurseries (NetPS plant database entry for Vanilla Marigold)","url":"https://plants.hicksnurseries.com/12170001/Plant/13139/Vanilla_Marigold/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun to partial shade"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page, Tagetes erecta)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277371","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"marigold-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Hicks Nurseries (NetPS plant database entry for Vanilla Marigold)","url":"https://plants.hicksnurseries.com/12170001/Plant/13139/Vanilla_Marigold/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its fragrant ferny leaves remain dark green in color throughout the season.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"marigold-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Hicks Nurseries (NetPS plant database entry for Vanilla Marigold)","url":"https://plants.hicksnurseries.com/12170001/Plant/13139/Vanilla_Marigold/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"marigold-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"marigold-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/tagetes-erecta-vanilla-vanilla-african-marigold","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page, Tagetes erecta)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277371","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"marigold-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The marigold will grow one to two feet tall, and needs full sun.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height: 1 - 3 Feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height/Spread: 6 inches to 3 feet tall, varies by cultivar\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Marigolds can grow between 6 inches to 4 feet tall and 6 inches to 3 feet wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"marigold-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Marigolds can grow between 6 inches to 4 feet tall and 6 inches to 3 feet wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"marigold-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-11","3-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tagetes, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tagetes/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[2,11]},{"name":"Penn State Extension (Marigolds: From Folklore to the Home Garden)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/marigolds-from-folklore-to-the-home-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Marigolds grow in USDA Hardiness Zones 3 through 11","zones":[3,11]},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Marigolds, Tagetes spp.)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/marigolds/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone : 2-11","zones":[2,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"marigold-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tagetes, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tagetes/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions (Marigolds)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/marigolds/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The marigold will grow one to two feet tall, and needs full sun."},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Marigold, Tagetes sp.)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/marigold","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Marigolds)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/how-to-grow-and-care-for-marigolds-in-south-carolina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Needs: Full sun (6 or more hours daily)"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Marigolds)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/marigolds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Marigolds need full sun all day to provide blooms all season long."},{"name":"Penn State Extension (Marigolds: From Folklore to the Home Garden)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/marigolds-from-folklore-to-the-home-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Marigolds thrive in full sun and can usually withstand very hot summers."},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Marigolds, Tagetes spp.)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/marigolds/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"marigold-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"marigold-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions (Marigolds)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/marigolds/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They make great cut flowers and are most effective in mass plantings; place them at least a foot apart.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Marigold, Tagetes sp.)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/marigold","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good cut flower.","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Marigolds)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/how-to-grow-and-care-for-marigolds-in-south-carolina/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses in Landscape: Borders, mass plantings, containers, cut flowers, cover crops","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"marigold-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"marigold-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tagetes, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tagetes/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies feed on this plant.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Marigold, Tagetes sp.)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/marigold","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"martha-stewart-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.84],"union":[0.5,1],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.87483.1&tab=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 20\" to 39\" (50 to 100cm). Width: 1' to 20\" (30 to 50cm).","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Edmunds' Roses (US introducer)","url":"https://www.edmundsroses.com/product/E23968","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 21/2-3'","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Regan Nursery","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-New-2026-Martha-Stewart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3-3 ft","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms (wholesale nursery)","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Rosa-Martha-Stewart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2-3 ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stein's Garden and Home (NetPS plant database)","url":"https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/40126/Martha_Stewart_Rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Martha Stewart Rose will grow to be about 30 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 3 feet.","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"My Black Thumb (retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.myblackthumb.com/product-page/martha-stewart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Compact, Bushy, 2½–3' h x 2–3' w","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Green Valley Garden Supply","url":"https://greenvalleygardensupply.com/products/rosa-meiffable-martha-stewart™-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2' - 3'","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"martha-stewart-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.3,1],"split":[{"range":[0.3,0.5],"sources":["HelpMeFind Roses"]},{"range":[0.61,1],"sources":["Regan Nursery","Prides Corner Farms (wholesale nursery)","My Black Thumb (retail rose nursery)","Green Valley Garden Supply","Stein's Garden and Home (NetPS plant database)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.87483.1&tab=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 20\" to 39\" (50 to 100cm). Width: 1' to 20\" (30 to 50cm).","metres":[0.3,0.5],"band":[0.3,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Regan Nursery","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-New-2026-Martha-Stewart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2-3 ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms (wholesale nursery)","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Rosa-Martha-Stewart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2-3 ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stein's Garden and Home (NetPS plant database)","url":"https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/40126/Martha_Stewart_Rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Martha Stewart Rose will grow to be about 30 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 3 feet.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"My Black Thumb (retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.myblackthumb.com/product-page/martha-stewart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Compact, Bushy, 2½–3' h x 2–3' w","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Green Valley Garden Supply","url":"https://greenvalleygardensupply.com/products/rosa-meiffable-martha-stewart™-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2’ - 3'","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"martha-stewart-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-10","5-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Edmunds' Roses (US introducer)","url":"https://www.edmundsroses.com/product/E23968","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zone: 5-10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Regan Nursery","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-New-2026-Martha-Stewart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms (wholesale nursery)","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Rosa-Martha-Stewart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"My Black Thumb (retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.myblackthumb.com/product-page/martha-stewart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 5–11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Green Valley Garden Supply","url":"https://greenvalleygardensupply.com/products/rosa-meiffable-martha-stewart™-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 5 - 10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"martha-stewart-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Edmunds' Roses (US introducer)","url":"https://www.edmundsroses.com/product/E23968","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Regan Nursery","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-New-2026-Martha-Stewart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms (wholesale nursery)","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Rosa-Martha-Stewart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stein's Garden and Home (NetPS plant database)","url":"https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/40126/Martha_Stewart_Rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"My Black Thumb (retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.myblackthumb.com/product-page/martha-stewart","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Green Valley Garden Supply","url":"https://greenvalleygardensupply.com/products/rosa-meiffable-martha-stewart™-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"martha-stewart-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["strong","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.87483.1&tab=1","https://www.edmundsroses.com/product/E23968"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.87483.1&tab=1","https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-New-2026-Martha-Stewart"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.87483.1&tab=1","https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Rosa-Martha-Stewart"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.87483.1&tab=1","https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/40126/Martha_Stewart_Rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.87483.1&tab=1","https://www.myblackthumb.com/product-page/martha-stewart"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.87483.1&tab=1","https://greenvalleygardensupply.com/products/rosa-meiffable-martha-stewart™-rose"]}],"sources":[{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.87483.1&tab=1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Strong, fruity fragrance. 100 to 150 petals.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Edmunds' Roses (US introducer)","url":"https://www.edmundsroses.com/product/E23968","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fragrance has notes of citrus and sweet honeysuckle","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Regan Nursery","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-New-2026-Martha-Stewart","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Citrus and Honeysuckle scent","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms (wholesale nursery)","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Rosa-Martha-Stewart","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Richly fragrant with complex citrus, honeysuckle, and bergamot notes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stein's Garden and Home (NetPS plant database)","url":"https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/40126/Martha_Stewart_Rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"sweet and citrusy fragrance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"My Black Thumb (retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.myblackthumb.com/product-page/martha-stewart","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is beautifully scented with notes of citrus and honeysuckle.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Green Valley Garden Supply","url":"https://greenvalleygardensupply.com/products/rosa-meiffable-martha-stewart™-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Martha Stewart has a complex fragrance that mixes citrus, honeysuckle and bergamot","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 7 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 7","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"martha-stewart-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Rosa-Martha-Stewart","https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/40126/Martha_Stewart_Rose"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Prides Corner Farms (wholesale nursery)","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Rosa-Martha-Stewart","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Stein's Garden and Home (NetPS plant database)","url":"https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/40126/Martha_Stewart_Rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"martha-stewart-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"martha-stewart-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Stein's Garden and Home (NetPS plant database)","url":"https://plants.shopsteins.com/12100001/Plant/40126/Martha_Stewart_Rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting bees to your yard.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"meadow-rue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/meadow-rue/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Flower stalks range from 2 to 6 feet in height, making it possible to use them as background plants in a perennial bed.","metres":[0.61,1.83],"band":[0.61,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":14,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":14},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 14 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"meadow-rue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":10,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":14},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"meadow-rue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/meadow-rue/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They are extremely hardy and grow best in USDA planting zones 5 to 8.","zones":[5,8],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":11,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":14},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"SPLIT"},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 11 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"meadow-rue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/meadow-rue/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mine do best when planted in areas that provide part shade and protection from the hot afternoon sun.","level":"genus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Thalictrum aquilegiifolium)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286093&isprofile=1&gen=Thalictrum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum aquilegiifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Thalictrum rochebruneanum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=i920","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum rochebruneanum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Thalictrum delavayi)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286295&isprofile=1&gen=Thalictrum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum delavayi"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (Thalictrum flavum subsp. flavum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286096&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum flavum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thalictrum aquilegiifolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thalictrum-aquilegiifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows in average, medium moisture, well-drained soil in full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum aquilegiifolium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thalictrum dasycarpum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thalictrum-dasycarpum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum dasycarpum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thalictrum dioicum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thalictrum-dioicum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in average to rich well-drained soil in the full sun to dappled or partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum dioicum"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Thalictrum dasycarpum)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=954&PlantTypeID=14","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial shade and consistently moist soils.","level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum dasycarpum"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Thalictrum rochebruneanum)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/thalictrum-rochebruneanum-meadowrue","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Partial Shade Full Shade","level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum rochebruneanum"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Thalictrum dasycarpum)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=thda","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade","level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum dasycarpum"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Thalictrum aquilegiifolium)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/56533/thalictrum-aquilegiifolium/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Grow in moist, humus-rich soil in partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum aquilegiifolium"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Thalictrum rochebruneanum)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/68901/thalictrum-rochebruneanum/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum rochebruneanum"},{"name":"American Meadows (Thalictrum rochebrunianum)","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-meadow-rue-thalictrum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Choose a site with rich soil in full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum rochebrunianum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"meadow-rue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/meadow-rue/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Yellow meadow rue has tiny, slightly fragrant fluffy yellow flowers which bloom in branched cone-shaped panicles during the late spring and early summer.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["thalictrum flavum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (thalictrum flavum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV6":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (thalictrum flavum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"meadow-rue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thalictrum aquilegiifolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thalictrum-aquilegiifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum aquilegiifolium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thalictrum dasycarpum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thalictrum-dasycarpum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum dasycarpum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thalictrum dioicum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thalictrum-dioicum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum dioicum"},{"name":"American Meadows (Thalictrum rochebrunianum)","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-meadow-rue-thalictrum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the lofty blooms bring some air and lightness to summer bouquets","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum rochebrunianum"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"meadow-rue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["thalictrum dasycarpum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (thalictrum dasycarpum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (thalictrum dasycarpum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"meadow-rue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/meadow-rue/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Small sweat bees are attracted to the pollen and are frequent visitors.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thalictrum aquilegiifolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thalictrum-aquilegiifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum aquilegiifolium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thalictrum dasycarpum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thalictrum-dasycarpum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"thalictrum dasycarpum"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"michelangelo-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.25,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.22,1.32],"union":[0.4,1.52],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Meilland International catalogue (breeder)","url":"https://meilland.com/catalogue/michelangelo-meitelov/","country":"FR","form":null,"value":"Hauteur : 60 / 100 cm","metres":[0.6,1],"band":[0.6,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Meilland Richardier (the breeder's retail storefront)","url":"https://www.meillandrichardier.com/rosier-michelangelo-r-meitelov.html","country":"FR","form":null,"value":"Hauteur : 1.20 m","metres":1.2,"band":[1.08,1.32],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.26792.1&tab=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 16\" to 5' (40 to 150cm). Width: 2' to 42\" (60 to 105cm).","metres":[0.4,1.5],"band":[0.4,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Northland Rosarium (US retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.northlandrosarium.com/products/michelangelo-meitelov","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 5 Feet High x 3 Feet Wide","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"pharmaROSA (German retail rose nursery growing on own roots)","url":"https://pharmarosa.de/rozsa/michelangelo-548","country":"DE","form":null,"value":"Aufrechter, gut verzweigter Strauch mit 110–150 cm Höhe und 75–105 cm Breite","metres":[1.1,1.5],"band":[1.1,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"michelangelo-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.95,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.83],"union":[0.6,1.05],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Meilland Richardier (the breeder's retail storefront)","url":"https://www.meillandrichardier.com/rosier-michelangelo-r-meitelov.html","country":"FR","form":null,"value":"Largeur adulte : 75 cm","metres":0.75,"band":[0.68,0.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.26792.1&tab=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 16\" to 5' (40 to 150cm). Width: 2' to 42\" (60 to 105cm).","metres":[0.6,1.05],"band":[0.6,1.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Northland Rosarium (US retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.northlandrosarium.com/products/michelangelo-meitelov","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 5 Feet High x 3 Feet Wide","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"pharmaROSA (German retail rose nursery growing on own roots)","url":"https://pharmarosa.de/rozsa/michelangelo-548","country":"DE","form":null,"value":"Aufrechter, gut verzweigter Strauch mit 110–150 cm Höhe und 75–105 cm Breite","metres":[0.75,1.05],"band":[0.75,1.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"michelangelo-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"michelangelo-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"michelangelo-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["light","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://meilland.com/catalogue/michelangelo-meitelov/","https://www.meillandrichardier.com/rosier-michelangelo-r-meitelov.html"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://meilland.com/catalogue/michelangelo-meitelov/","https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.26792.1&tab=1"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://meilland.com/catalogue/michelangelo-meitelov/","https://www.northlandrosarium.com/products/michelangelo-meitelov"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://meilland.com/catalogue/michelangelo-meitelov/","https://pharmarosa.de/rozsa/michelangelo-548"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Meilland International catalogue (breeder)","url":"https://meilland.com/catalogue/michelangelo-meitelov/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"au parfum subtil rosé épicé miel","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Meilland Richardier (the breeder's retail storefront)","url":"https://www.meillandrichardier.com/rosier-michelangelo-r-meitelov.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Parfum : Parfum léger","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.26792.1&tab=1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Mild, lemon fragrance. 42 petals.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Northland Rosarium (US retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.northlandrosarium.com/products/michelangelo-meitelov","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A strong, sweet, lemony fragrance and deep green foliage make this a must rose for every garden.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"pharmaROSA (German retail rose nursery growing on own roots)","url":"https://pharmarosa.de/rozsa/michelangelo-548","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Starker, gut wahrnehmbarer Duft mit reich zitronig-honigartigem Charakter","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"michelangelo-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://meilland.com/catalogue/michelangelo-meitelov/","https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.26792.1&tab=1"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://meilland.com/catalogue/michelangelo-meitelov/","https://www.northlandrosarium.com/products/michelangelo-meitelov"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://meilland.com/catalogue/michelangelo-meitelov/","https://pharmarosa.de/rozsa/michelangelo-548"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Meilland International catalogue (breeder)","url":"https://meilland.com/catalogue/michelangelo-meitelov/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bonne tenue en vase.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.26792.1&tab=1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Can be used for beds and borders, cut flower or garden.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Northland Rosarium (US retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.northlandrosarium.com/products/michelangelo-meitelov","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Large, old-fashioned blooms of golden yellow on long stems, perfect for cutting, make this a modern masterpiece.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"pharmaROSA (German retail rose nursery growing on own roots)","url":"https://pharmarosa.de/rozsa/michelangelo-548","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Die langen, stabilen Stiele und die edel becherförmigen, reich gefüllten Blüten eignen sich hervorragend für Sträuße","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"michelangelo-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"michelangelo-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"pharmaROSA (German retail rose nursery growing on own roots)","url":"https://pharmarosa.de/rozsa/michelangelo-548","country":null,"form":null,"value":"stark gefüllte Blüten reduzieren jedoch die Attraktivität für Insektenbestäuber deutlich","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"mint","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.55,0.61],"union":[0.3,1],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281400","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mentha-spicata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mentha-x-piperita/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/herbs/mint","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They grow from 1-3 feet tall and aggressively spread by underground rhizomes.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/growing-mint-home-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Peppermint ( Mentha piperita ) produces upright stems about 2 feet or more in height.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/mint-in-the-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mint is a rapid growing perennial herb with many varieties that grow up to 3 feet tall and are quite invasive.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mint","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281400","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mentha-spicata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mentha-x-piperita/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mint","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281400","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mentha-spicata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mentha-x-piperita/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mint","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281400","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mentha-spicata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mentha-x-piperita/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/herbs/mint","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They prefer a full sun location but will tolerate light shade."},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/growing-mint-home-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plant will grow in sun or shade, but will probably be at its most productive in full sun."},{"name":"Utah State University Extension","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/mint-in-the-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mint grows best in full sun to partial shade"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/herbs/mint/grow-your-own","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Mint is happy in full sun or partial shade."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mint","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281400","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mentha-spicata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Edible Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mentha-x-piperita/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Edible Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/growing-mint-home-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dark green leaves and reddish stems have a characteristic warm, spicy scent.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mint","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mint","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281400","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Adapts to a wide range of soils except dry ones.","claim":false},{"name":"Utah State University Extension","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/mint-in-the-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Mint prefers moist soil conditions, but excess water will promote root and leaf diseases.","claim":false}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mint","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281400","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mentha-spicata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Pollinators","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/mentha-x-piperita/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Pollinators","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/herbs/mint/grow-your-own","country":null,"form":null,"value":"purple, pink or white flowers appear in summer or early autumn and are beneficial to pollinating insects.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mister-lincoln","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.22,1.34],"union":[0.91,1.83],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-mister-lincoln/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252281&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 3.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/mister-lincoln","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4'-6' x 3'","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/mister-lincoln","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/mister-lincoln-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mature Height: 4 to 6 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://www.springhillnursery.com/products/mister-lincoln-hybrid-tea-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 36 - 60 inches","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/mr-lincoln-rose-hybrid-tea","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height 4-6 ft","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/mister-lincoln/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4-5 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"mister-lincoln","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.61,1.22],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-mister-lincoln/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252281&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Spread: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/mister-lincoln","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4'-6' x 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/mister-lincoln","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3ft","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/mister-lincoln-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mature width: 3 to 4 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://www.springhillnursery.com/products/mister-lincoln-hybrid-tea-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Spread: 24 - 36 inches","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/mr-lincoln-rose-hybrid-tea","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width 2-3 ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"mister-lincoln","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","5-10","7-11","4-10","6-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-mister-lincoln/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252281&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/mister-lincoln","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 5-10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/mister-lincoln","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 7-11","zones":[7,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/mister-lincoln-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://www.springhillnursery.com/products/mister-lincoln-hybrid-tea-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zones 4-10","zones":[4,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/mr-lincoln-rose-hybrid-tea","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zone 5a - to 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/mister-lincoln/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone: 6-9","zones":[6,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"mister-lincoln","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-mister-lincoln/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252281&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/mister-lincoln","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sun Requires 6+ hours of direct sunlight to thrive.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/mister-lincoln","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/mister-lincoln-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Sunlight: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://www.springhillnursery.com/products/mister-lincoln-hybrid-tea-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/mr-lincoln-rose-hybrid-tea","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Sunlight Full sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"mister-lincoln","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","strengths":["strong","strong","strong"],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-mister-lincoln/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The velvety red high-centered flowers on long stems are 4-5 inches across, fragrant and repeat blooms summer to fall.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252281&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/mister-lincoln","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Exceptionally Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/mister-lincoln","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A classic, deep velvety-crimson rose with a strong fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/mister-lincoln-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The scent is strong, traditional, and rose-forward","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://www.springhillnursery.com/products/mister-lincoln-hybrid-tea-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"One of the top 10 most fragrant roses ever developed","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/mr-lincoln-rose-hybrid-tea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sweetly Fragrant Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"mister-lincoln","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-mister-lincoln/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Landscape Theme: Butterfly Garden Cottage Garden Cutting Garden Pollinator Garden","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252281&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A good cut rose due to fragrance and large bloom size.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/mister-lincoln","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets and floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/mister-lincoln-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Landscape Uses: Cut flower gardens, rose beds, sunny borders, patio-adjacent plantings, specimen shrub, fragrance gardens","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/mr-lincoln-rose-hybrid-tea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Perfect as cut flowers, the strong fragrance carries both indoors and outside.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"mister-lincoln","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/mister-lincoln-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance: Not reliably deer resistant; better disease performance with sun + airflow; moderate drought tolerance once established","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"mister-lincoln","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-mister-lincoln/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Attracts butterflies and bees.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252281&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/mister-lincoln-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Attracts bees and beneficial pollinators when blooming","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/mr-lincoln-rose-hybrid-tea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great Choice for Mass Planting in Butterfly Gardens","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"mock-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.61,3.05],"union":[0.61,3.05],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are umn.edu","urls":["https://extension.umn.edu/trees-and-shrubs/mockorange","https://trees.umn.edu/mock-orange-philadelphus-spp"]}],"sources":[{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Mockorange, Philadelphus spp.)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/trees-and-shrubs/mockorange","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature height: 2 to 10 feet","metres":[0.61,3.05],"band":[0.61,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"philadelphus"},{"name":"University of Minnesota UFOR Nursery & Lab (Mock orange, Philadelphus spp.)","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/mock-orange-philadelphus-spp","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 to 10 ft","metres":[0.61,3.05],"band":[0.61,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"philadelphus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are umn.edu. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"mock-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.61,3.05],"union":[0.61,3.05],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are umn.edu","urls":["https://extension.umn.edu/trees-and-shrubs/mockorange","https://trees.umn.edu/mock-orange-philadelphus-spp"]}],"sources":[{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Mockorange, Philadelphus spp.)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/trees-and-shrubs/mockorange","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature width: 2 to 10 feet","metres":[0.61,3.05],"band":[0.61,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"philadelphus"},{"name":"University of Minnesota UFOR Nursery & Lab (Mock orange, Philadelphus spp.)","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/mock-orange-philadelphus-spp","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 to 10 ft","metres":[0.61,3.05],"band":[0.61,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"philadelphus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are umn.edu. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"mock-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"split":["3-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are umn.edu","urls":["https://extension.umn.edu/trees-and-shrubs/mockorange","https://trees.umn.edu/mock-orange-philadelphus-spp"]}],"sources":[{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Mockorange, Philadelphus spp.)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/trees-and-shrubs/mockorange","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zone: 3 to 8, depending on cultivar","zones":[3,8],"level":"genus","taxon":"philadelphus"},{"name":"University of Minnesota UFOR Nursery & Lab (Mock orange, Philadelphus spp.)","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/mock-orange-philadelphus-spp","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"philadelphus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"SPLIT"},"note":"SPLIT withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are umn.edu. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"mock-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Mockorange, Philadelphus spp.)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/trees-and-shrubs/mockorange","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to light shade; best bloom occurs in full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"philadelphus"},{"name":"University of Minnesota UFOR Nursery & Lab (Mock orange, Philadelphus spp.)","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/mock-orange-philadelphus-spp","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It prefers full sun to part shade, but the best condition for flower blooming is in full sun.","level":"genus","taxon":"philadelphus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Philadelphus, genus grow guide)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/philadelphus","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Philadelphus are tolerant of most soils in full sun or light shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"philadelphus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Philadelphus coronarius)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/philadelphus-coronarius/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus coronarius"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Philadelphus x virginalis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/philadelphus-x-virginalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus virginalis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (sweet mock-orange, Philadelphus coronarius)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/sweet-mock-orange/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sweet mock-orange grows best in full sun to light shade.","level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus coronarius"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Shrub Selector (Sweet Mockorange, Philadelphus coronarius)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=352","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to partial shade; moist, well-drained soils are best; tolerates alkaline soil.","level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus coronarius"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Philadelphus 'Belle Etoile')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241482","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"mock-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Mockorange, Philadelphus spp.)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/trees-and-shrubs/mockorange","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In spring, their fragrant flowers smell like orange blossoms.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"philadelphus"},{"name":"University of Minnesota UFOR Nursery & Lab (Mock orange, Philadelphus spp.)","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/mock-orange-philadelphus-spp","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The showy fragrant white flowers bloom in early summer and some cultivars have double white blooms.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"philadelphus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Philadelphus, genus grow guide)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/philadelphus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Mainly tall, sometimes arching, shrubs with richly-scented flowers in early summer","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"philadelphus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Philadelphus coronarius)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/philadelphus-coronarius/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Blooms from May to June; very fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus coronarius"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Philadelphus x virginalis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/philadelphus-x-virginalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In June it blooms with clusters of white fragrant flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus virginalis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (sweet mock-orange, Philadelphus coronarius)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/sweet-mock-orange/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are 1 inch across, very fragrant, and appear in early summer.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus coronarius"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Shrub Selector (Sweet Mockorange, Philadelphus coronarius)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=352","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant white flowers in spring","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus coronarius"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Philadelphus 'Belle Etoile')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241482","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"mock-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"mock-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"University of Minnesota UFOR Nursery & Lab (Mock orange, Philadelphus spp.)","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/mock-orange-philadelphus-spp","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This shrub can tolerate occasional-drought and road salt.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"philadelphus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Philadelphus coronarius)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/philadelphus-coronarius/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought and wind tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus coronarius"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Philadelphus x virginalis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/philadelphus-x-virginalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is tolerant of occasional drought once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus virginalis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (sweet mock-orange, Philadelphus coronarius)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/sweet-mock-orange/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Alkaline soil, clay soil, Occasional drought, Road salt","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus coronarius"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Philadelphus 'Belle Etoile')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241482","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Clay Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"mock-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"University of Minnesota UFOR Nursery & Lab (Mock orange, Philadelphus spp.)","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/mock-orange-philadelphus-spp","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Insect pollinators are attracted to the white fragrant flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"philadelphus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Philadelphus coronarius)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/philadelphus-coronarius/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#bat friendly #moth friendly","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus coronarius"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Philadelphus x virginalis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/philadelphus-x-virginalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#bat friendly #moth friendly","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus virginalis"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"mock-orange-belle-etoile","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1,2.44],"split":[{"range":[1,1.5],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society"]},{"range":[1.52,2.44],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Dancing Oaks Nursery","Digging Dog Nursery","PlantLust"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241482&isprofile=0&basic=Philadelphus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/12650/philadelphus-x-lemoinei-belle-etoile/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"philadelphus lemoinei"},{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/plant/S-0110","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 6' 0\" - 8' 0\" high x 6' 0\" wide.","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"philadelphus lemoinei"},{"name":"PlantLust","url":"https://plantlust.com/plants/501/philadelphus-belle-etoile/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"H: 6'-8'","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Dancing Oaks Nursery","url":"https://dancingoaks.com/search/suggest.json?q=belle%20etoile&resources%5Btype%5D=product&resources%5Blimit%5D=5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature size: 5-6 feet tall","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"species":4},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"mock-orange-belle-etoile","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.65,2.01],"union":[0.91,2.5],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241482&isprofile=0&basic=Philadelphus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/12650/philadelphus-x-lemoinei-belle-etoile/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"philadelphus lemoinei"},{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/plant/S-0110","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 6' 0\" - 8' 0\" high x 6' 0\" wide.","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"philadelphus lemoinei"},{"name":"PlantLust","url":"https://plantlust.com/plants/501/philadelphus-belle-etoile/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"W: 3'-6'","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Dancing Oaks Nursery","url":"https://dancingoaks.com/search/suggest.json?q=belle%20etoile&resources%5Btype%5D=product&resources%5Blimit%5D=5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6-8 feet wide","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"species":4},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"mock-orange-belle-etoile","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241482&isprofile=0&basic=Philadelphus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Great Plant Picks (Elisabeth C. Miller Botanical Garden)","url":"https://www.greatplantpicks.org/api/plants/1138","country":"US","form":null,"value":"\"zone_low\":\"5\",\"zone_high\":\"8\"","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"PlantLust","url":"https://plantlust.com/plants/501/philadelphus-belle-etoile/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones: 5a - 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"species":4},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"mock-orange-belle-etoile","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241482&isprofile=0&basic=Philadelphus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/12650/philadelphus-x-lemoinei-belle-etoile/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun Partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"philadelphus lemoinei"},{"name":"Great Plant Picks (Elisabeth C. Miller Botanical Garden)","url":"https://www.greatplantpicks.org/api/plants/1138","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun to light or open shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Philadelphus x lemoinei)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/philadelphus-x-lemoinei/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub prefers moist well-drained soils in sun to part sun.","level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus lemoinei"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Philadelphus coronarius)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/philadelphus-coronarius/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in full sun to partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus coronarius"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (sweet mock-orange)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/sweet-mock-orange/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sweet mock-orange grows best in full sun to light shade.","level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus coronarius"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (virginal mock-orange)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/virginal-mock-orange/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Virginal mock-orange does best in full sun to part shade.","level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus virginalis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"mock-orange-belle-etoile","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241482&isprofile=0&basic=Philadelphus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/12650/philadelphus-x-lemoinei-belle-etoile/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A compact medium-sized deciduous shrub of arching growth with ovate leaves; highly-scented single white flowers to 5cm in width, tinged purple in the centre, in late spring and early summer","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"philadelphus lemoinei"},{"name":"Great Plant Picks (Elisabeth C. Miller Botanical Garden)","url":"https://www.greatplantpicks.org/api/plants/1138","country":null,"form":null,"value":"loved for its sensational, sweet fragrance, which flows through the garden like an unseen wave in late spring to early summer","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/plant/S-0110","country":null,"form":null,"value":"this artful shrub is deliciously fragrant and unmistakably choice.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"philadelphus lemoinei"},{"name":"PlantLust","url":"https://plantlust.com/plants/501/philadelphus-belle-etoile/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In May-June the white flowers have a lavender purple center. Very fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Dancing Oaks Nursery","url":"https://dancingoaks.com/search/suggest.json?q=belle%20etoile&resources%5Btype%5D=product&resources%5Blimit%5D=5","country":null,"form":null,"value":"this richly scented selection is somewhat lower growing","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gardening Express","url":"https://www.gardeningexpress.co.uk/philadelphus-belle-etoile","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In June and July this lovely mock orange is smothered with highly fragrant, single, cup-shaped flowers with distinctive splashes of purple at the centre.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Philadelphus x lemoinei)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/philadelphus-x-lemoinei/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are amazingly fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus lemoinei"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Philadelphus coronarius)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/philadelphus-coronarius/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"While it is gorgeous in bloom and its fragrance is intoxicating it is rather unremarkable the rest of the year.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus coronarius"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (sweet mock-orange)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/sweet-mock-orange/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sweet mock-orange is a large, upright shrub with delightfully sweet, fragrant white flowers in early summer.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus coronarius"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (virginal mock-orange)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/virginal-mock-orange/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fragrant flowers are four petaled, 1 1/2 inches across and bright white with many yellow stamens.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus virginalis"}],"note":"11 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"mock-orange-belle-etoile","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.greatplantpicks.org/api/plants/1138","https://plantlust.com/plants/501/philadelphus-belle-etoile/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Great Plant Picks (Elisabeth C. Miller Botanical Garden)","url":"https://www.greatplantpicks.org/api/plants/1138","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Mock orange's flowering branches can be cut for decoration, the lower leaves stripped off and stems pounded before they are placed in water.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"PlantLust","url":"https://plantlust.com/plants/501/philadelphus-belle-etoile/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: border plant , cutting garden , fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"mock-orange-belle-etoile","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241482&isprofile=0&basic=Philadelphus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Clay Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Great Plant Picks (Elisabeth C. Miller Botanical Garden)","url":"https://www.greatplantpicks.org/api/plants/1138","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, it is drought tolerant, but appreciates occasional watering during prolonged dry weather.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"PlantLust","url":"https://plantlust.com/plants/501/philadelphus-belle-etoile/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Philadelphus coronarius)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/philadelphus-coronarius/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought and wind tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus coronarius"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (sweet mock-orange)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/sweet-mock-orange/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Alkaline soil, clay soil, Occasional drought, Road salt","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus coronarius"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (virginal mock-orange)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/virginal-mock-orange/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Alkaline soil, Occasional drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus virginalis"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31"}, {"slug":"mock-orange-belle-etoile","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"PlantLust","url":"https://plantlust.com/plants/501/philadelphus-belle-etoile/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees and butterflies making it an excellent addition to pollinator gardens.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Philadelphus x lemoinei)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/philadelphus-x-lemoinei/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#bat friendly #moth friendly","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus lemoinei"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Philadelphus coronarius)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/philadelphus-coronarius/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#bat friendly #moth friendly","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"philadelphus coronarius"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-31","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-31"}}, {"slug":"molineux","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.9,1.34],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/molineux","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/molineux","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4' x 3' - 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%E2%84%A2-molineux%E2%84%A2-potted-tree-rose-copy","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3′–4′","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rosarium Lottum (Netherlands)","url":"https://rosariumlottum.com/en/product/molineux-ausmol/","country":"NL","form":null,"value":"Height 100 cm (Buschrose)","metres":1,"band":[0.9,1.1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Knight's Roses (Australia)","url":"https://knightsroses.com.au/product/molineux/","country":"AU","form":null,"value":"Approx. Height 100cm","metres":1,"band":[0.9,1.1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/molineux","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height: 3ft (90cm)","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"molineux","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.91,1],"union":[0.82,1.22],"proposed":0.96,"margin":2.4,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/molineux","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3ft","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/molineux","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4' x 3' - 4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%E2%84%A2-molineux%E2%84%A2-potted-tree-rose-copy","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3′–4′","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/molineux","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Width: 3ft (90cm)","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.82 to 1.22 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"molineux","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/molineux","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/molineux","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 5-10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%E2%84%A2-molineux%E2%84%A2-potted-tree-rose-copy","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: USDA 5–11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"molineux","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/molineux","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/molineux","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/molineux","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade or Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%E2%84%A2-molineux%E2%84%A2-potted-tree-rose-copy","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"molineux","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["light","light","light","light"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/molineux","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/molineux"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/molineux","https://heirloomroses.com/products/molineux"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/molineux","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%E2%84%A2-molineux%E2%84%A2-potted-tree-rose-copy"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/molineux","https://rosariumlottum.com/en/product/molineux-ausmol/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/molineux","https://knightsroses.com.au/product/molineux/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/molineux","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It has a light-medium musky Tea Rose scent.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/molineux","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It has a light-medium musky Tea Rose scent.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/molineux","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Exceptionally Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%E2%84%A2-molineux%E2%84%A2-potted-tree-rose-copy","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Light to medium tea and musk fragrance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rosarium Lottum (Netherlands)","url":"https://rosariumlottum.com/en/product/molineux-ausmol/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"She has a light-medium musky tea rose fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Knight's Roses (Australia)","url":"https://knightsroses.com.au/product/molineux/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Mildly Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 6 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 6","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"molineux","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%E2%84%A2-molineux%E2%84%A2-potted-tree-rose-copy","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for borders, cottage gardens, low hedges, mixed perennial plantings, cutting gardens, and formal or informal landscape compositions.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"molineux","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"molineux","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"monkshood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aconitum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"aconitum"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":10,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":10,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"monkshood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aconitum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"aconitum"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":10,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"monkshood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aconitum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[3,7],"level":"genus","taxon":"aconitum"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":11,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":10,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 11 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"monkshood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aconitum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"genus","taxon":"aconitum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286162&isprofile=0&basic=Aconitum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"aconitum napellus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286191&isprofile=0&basic=Aconitum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"aconitum carmichaelii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243342&isprofile=0&basic=Aconitum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aconitum carmichaelii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243343&isprofile=0&basic=Aconitum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/common-monkshood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Partial Sun/Shade","level":"species","taxon":"aconitum napellus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/aconitum-napellus-common-monkshood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"aconitum napellus"},{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/380/aconitum-napellus/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"aconitum napellus"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ACUN","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade","level":"species","taxon":"aconitum uncinatum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aconitum-uncinatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"aconitum uncinatum"},{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/aconitum-carmichaelii-arendsii-aco150","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"aconitum carmichaelii"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ACONA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun) Part Shade (4-6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"species","taxon":"aconitum napellus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"monkshood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"monkshood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aconitum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"aconitum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aconitum-uncinatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aconitum uncinatum"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ACONA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Cut Flower Cut Foliage Mass Planting","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aconitum napellus"},{"name":"Gertens (NetPS Plant Finder)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/2083/Common_Monkshood/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aconitum napellus"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"monkshood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286162&isprofile=0&basic=Aconitum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soils must not be allowed to dry out, but need sufficient drainage to prevent wet conditions from developing.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"aconitum napellus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286191&isprofile=0&basic=Aconitum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soils must not be allowed to dry out, but need sufficient drainage to prevent wet conditions from developing.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"aconitum carmichaelii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243342&isprofile=0&basic=Aconitum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soils must not be allowed to dry out, but need sufficient drainage to prevent wet conditions from developing.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"aconitum carmichaelii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=243343&isprofile=0&basic=Aconitum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soils must not be allowed to dry out, but need sufficient drainage to prevent wet conditions from developing.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/common-monkshood","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Moisture should be consistent but not overly wet and swampy.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"aconitum napellus"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/aconitum-napellus-common-monkshood","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Just give it good drainage and consistent moisture, especially if you're putting it in full sun.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"aconitum napellus"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ACONA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dry soil leads to stunting.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"aconitum napellus"}],"note":"7 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"monkshood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/aconitum-napellus-common-monkshood","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They attract a variety of butterflies and moths, and are the primary food source for Old World bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aconitum napellus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/aconitum-uncinatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Play Value: Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aconitum uncinatum"},{"name":"Walters Gardens","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=ACONA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"aconitum napellus"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"moonflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[4.11,4.57],"union":[3.05,5.03],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c801","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Although it will grow to 70' or more in tropical climates, it typically reaches 10-15' in a single season as an annual.","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/moonflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The vines usually grow up to 15 feet in height and 3 to 6 feet in width in a single season as an annual.","metres":4.57,"band":[4.11,5.03],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":11,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Climber","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 10 ft. 0 in. - 30 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"produces a long, slender, twining vine capable of growing a dozen or more feet high in the course of a year\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Size: to 40 ft long vine\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Size Notes: Stems twining and climbing, up to about 10 feet long, sometimes longer.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Vines grow to 10-15 ft. tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"moonflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/moonflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The vines usually grow up to 15 feet in height and 3 to 6 feet in width in a single season as an annual.","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11,"cultivar":1},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Climber","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 3.00 to 6.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"moonflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-12","9-11","8-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c801","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 12","zones":[10,12],"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ipomoea-alba/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b, 12a, 12b","zones":[10,12],"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/moonflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plant is suitable to grow in USDA Zones 11, 10A, 10B, 9A, and 9B","zones":[9,11],"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"Florida Native Plant Society","url":"https://www.fnps.org/plant/ipomoea-alba","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Suitable to Grow In: 9A,9B,10A,10B,11","zones":[9,11],"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/moonflower-flower-seed.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA ZONES 8 - 11","zones":[8,11],"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11,"cultivar":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"moonflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c801","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ipomoea-alba/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/moonflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"does best in full sun or partial shade with moist, well-drained soils","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"Florida Native Plant Society","url":"https://www.fnps.org/plant/ipomoea-alba","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full Sun, Part Sun","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/vines/moon-vine-seeds.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/moonflower-flower-seed.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ENVIRONMENT Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"moonflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c801","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ipomoea-alba/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The plant has 8-inch, heart-shaped leaves and large white trumpet-shaped flowers that open at night and provide a sweet fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/moonflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fragrant flowers reach up to 6 inches in diameter and open from spiraled tubular flower buds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"Florida Native Plant Society","url":"https://www.fnps.org/plant/ipomoea-alba","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Blooms open late in the day and remain open through the night. Fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/four-really-stinky-flowers","country":null,"form":null,"value":"moonflower ( Ipomoea alba) , and four o'clock ( Mirabilis jalapa ) exude their fragrance at night and attract night-active moths.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/vines/moon-vine-seeds.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Moon vine is a fast-growing annual twining vine which carries fragrant, pure-white, 5-6 in. wide flowers that open up in the evening.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/moonflower-flower-seed.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Moonflower seeds produce large, fragrant flowers that can be cut and arranged in vases, adding subtle fragrance and delicate beauty to indoor spaces.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"Harris Seeds","url":"https://www.harrisseeds.com/products/02996-ipomoea-moonflower-giant-white","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Huge 5\" white flowers are fragrant when they open in the evening.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"moonflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/moonflower-flower-seed.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Moonflower seeds produce large, fragrant flowers that can be cut and arranged in vases, adding subtle fragrance and delicate beauty to indoor spaces.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"moonflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"moonflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c801","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract night-flying moths.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ipomoea-alba/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nectar from flowers attracts night-flying moths.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/moonflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are pollinated by night-feeding moths such as the hummingbird moth","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"Florida Native Plant Society","url":"https://www.fnps.org/plant/ipomoea-alba","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinated by moths.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/make-a-nocturnal-or-moon-garden/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The luminous blooms attract nocturnal moths","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/four-really-stinky-flowers","country":null,"form":null,"value":"moonflower ( Ipomoea alba) , and four o'clock ( Mirabilis jalapa ) exude their fragrance at night and attract night-active moths.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/news/writers-guild-article-vibrant-working-world-nocturnal-pollinators","country":null,"form":null,"value":"enticing the hawk moth to its delicate bell-shaped white flowers glowing under the moonlight","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/moonflower-flower-seed.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The moonflower's large, fragrant blooms attract pollinators such as moths and night-flying insects.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea alba"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"morning-glory","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Oregon State University Extension, Growing annual morning glory (Ipomoea spp.)","url":"https://extension.oregonstate.edu/catalog/em-9880-growing-annual-morning-glory","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Annual morning glory vines can grow up to 15 feet long depending on the cultivar.","metres":4.57,"band":[4.11,5.03],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"ipomoea"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"morning-glory","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"morning-glory","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ipomoea, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ipomoea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[2,11],"level":"genus","taxon":"ipomoea"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":6},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"morning-glory","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ipomoea, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ipomoea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"ipomoea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ipomoea purpurea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279300","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea purpurea"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers (Morning Glory, Ipomoea tricolor)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/morning-glory","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Location: Prefers a full sun location and soil where fertility is kept to a minimum.","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea tricolor"},{"name":"Oregon State University Extension, Growing annual morning glory (Ipomoea spp.)","url":"https://extension.oregonstate.edu/catalog/em-9880-growing-annual-morning-glory","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Choose a site that receives full sun and has well-draining soil.","level":"genus","taxon":"ipomoea"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden, Annual Flowering Vines (Ipomoea purpurea paragraph)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/1997/3-28-1997/vines.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They grow best in full sun or partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ipomoea purpurea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ipomoea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ipomoea tricolor)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ipomoea-tricolor/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea tricolor"},{"name":"RHS plant profile (Ipomoea purpurea, common morning glory)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/56562/ipomoea-purpurea/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea purpurea"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"morning-glory","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["ipomoea tricolor"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (ipomoea tricolor), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (ipomoea tricolor) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"morning-glory","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"morning-glory","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"morning-glory","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ipomoea purpurea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279300","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ipomoea purpurea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ipomoea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Members of the genus Ipomea support the following specialized bees: Melitoma taurea and Cemolobus ipomoeae.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea purpurea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ipomoea tricolor)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ipomoea-tricolor/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea tricolor"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"morning-glory-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[2.75,3],"union":[1.83,4.88],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/morning-glory-crimson-rambler-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Size 6-10' h x 1' w","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/morning-glory/morning-glory-crimson-rambler.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HEIGHT 120 inches","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Urban Farmer Seeds","url":"https://www.ufseeds.com/product/crimson-rambler-ipomoea-seeds/MGCR.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height 8-12'","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Peter C. Nijssen (Nijssen Bulbs)","url":"https://www.nijssenbulbs.com/seeds/338074-ipomoea-purpurea-crimson-rambler-zaden-338074.html","country":"NL","form":null,"value":"Height: 200-300 cm.","metres":[2,3],"band":[2,3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Diane's Flower Seeds","url":"https://www.dianeseeds.com/morning-glory-crimson-rambler.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"height 8'","metres":2.44,"band":[2.2,2.68],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Jacksonville Morning Glory Vineyard (specialist grower's cultivar record)","url":"https://jmgvines.com/available-varieties/ipomoea-purpurea/crimson-rambler/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10 - 16 ft","metres":[3.05,4.88],"band":[3.05,4.88],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"morning-glory-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/morning-glory-crimson-rambler-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Size 6-10' h x 1' w","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"morning-glory-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-11","3-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279300","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ipomoea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[2,11]},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/morning-glory/morning-glory-crimson-rambler.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA ZONES 3 - 10","zones":[3,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"morning-glory-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279300","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ipomoea-purpurea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/morning-glory-crimson-rambler-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Full sun"},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/morning-glory/morning-glory-crimson-rambler.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ENVIRONMENT Full sun to partial shade"},{"name":"Urban Farmer Seeds","url":"https://www.ufseeds.com/product/crimson-rambler-ipomoea-seeds/MGCR.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun"},{"name":"Diane's Flower Seeds","url":"https://www.dianeseeds.com/morning-glory-crimson-rambler.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Or sow indoors 4 weeks early. Full sun."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"morning-glory-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"morning-glory-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"morning-glory-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"morning-glory-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279300","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ipomoea-purpurea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/morning-glory-crimson-rambler-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Urban Farmer Seeds","url":"https://www.ufseeds.com/product/crimson-rambler-ipomoea-seeds/MGCR.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Additional Characteristics Attracts Pollinators, Deer Resistant, Extended Blooms","claim":true},{"name":"Diane's Flower Seeds","url":"https://www.dianeseeds.com/morning-glory-crimson-rambler.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The vivid flowers attract hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"morning-glory-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[2.75,3.36],"union":[2.44,6.1],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Ferry-Morse","url":"https://ferrymorse.com/products/morning-glory-scarlett-ohara","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Height: 10 - 12'","metres":[3.05,3.66],"band":[3.05,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/morning_glory_scarlett_ohara_seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height Up to 120 inches","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Lake Valley Seed","url":"https://lakevalleyseed.com/product/item-199-morning-glory-scarlet-ohara/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10-20′ (3-6m)","metres":[3.05,6.1],"band":[3.05,6.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"TomorrowSeeds","url":"https://tomorrowseeds.com/products/scarlet-morning-glory","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: 8 - 10 Feet","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"MySeeds.Co","url":"https://www.myseeds.co/products/ipomoea-nil-scarlet-ohara-morning-glory-scarlet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Growth Height: 96-120 \"","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"morning-glory-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.65,1.83],"union":[0.61,2.01],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"TomorrowSeeds","url":"https://tomorrowseeds.com/products/scarlet-morning-glory","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2 - 3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"MySeeds.Co","url":"https://www.myseeds.co/products/ipomoea-nil-scarlet-ohara-morning-glory-scarlet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 36-72 \"","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Country Creek LLC","url":"https://www.organic-heirloom-seed.com/products/scarlet-o-hara-morning-glory-25-seeds-organic-beautiful-season-long-blooms","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The vines are vigorous and fast growing, spread up to six feet and climb ten plus feet in height.","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"morning-glory-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["1-10","3-11","2-12"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/morning_glory_scarlett_ohara_seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10","zones":[1,10]},{"name":"TomorrowSeeds","url":"https://tomorrowseeds.com/products/scarlet-morning-glory","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones: 3-11","zones":[3,11]},{"name":"MySeeds.Co","url":"https://www.myseeds.co/products/ipomoea-nil-scarlet-ohara-morning-glory-scarlet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 2-12","zones":[2,12]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"morning-glory-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Ferry-Morse","url":"https://ferrymorse.com/products/morning-glory-scarlett-ohara","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Best In: Full Sun|Partial Shade"},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/morning_glory_scarlett_ohara_seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement Full Sun, Partial Shade"},{"name":"TomorrowSeeds","url":"https://tomorrowseeds.com/products/scarlet-morning-glory","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun, Partial Shade"},{"name":"MySeeds.Co","url":"https://www.myseeds.co/products/ipomoea-nil-scarlet-ohara-morning-glory-scarlet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun, cannot grow in the shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"morning-glory-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"morning-glory-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Ferry-Morse","url":"https://ferrymorse.com/products/morning-glory-scarlett-ohara","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Characteristics: Attracts butterflies and hummingbirds | Cut flowers | Low maintenance","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"morning-glory-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://ferrymorse.com/products/morning-glory-scarlett-ohara","https://lakevalleyseed.com/product/item-199-morning-glory-scarlet-ohara/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://ferrymorse.com/products/morning-glory-scarlett-ohara","https://www.organic-heirloom-seed.com/products/scarlet-o-hara-morning-glory-25-seeds-organic-beautiful-season-long-blooms"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Ferry-Morse","url":"https://ferrymorse.com/products/morning-glory-scarlett-ohara","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerance: Drought","claim":true},{"name":"Lake Valley Seed","url":"https://lakevalleyseed.com/product/item-199-morning-glory-scarlet-ohara/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great for dry areas.","claim":true},{"name":"Country Creek LLC","url":"https://www.organic-heirloom-seed.com/products/scarlet-o-hara-morning-glory-25-seeds-organic-beautiful-season-long-blooms","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought-tolerant and ultra-easy, it climbs to about 6 feet.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"morning-glory-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://ferrymorse.com/products/morning-glory-scarlett-ohara","https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/morning_glory_scarlett_ohara_seeds"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://ferrymorse.com/products/morning-glory-scarlett-ohara","https://tomorrowseeds.com/products/scarlet-morning-glory"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://ferrymorse.com/products/morning-glory-scarlett-ohara","https://www.myseeds.co/products/ipomoea-nil-scarlet-ohara-morning-glory-scarlet"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Ferry-Morse","url":"https://ferrymorse.com/products/morning-glory-scarlett-ohara","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Characteristics: Attracts butterflies and hummingbirds | Cut flowers | Low maintenance","claim":true},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/morning_glory_scarlett_ohara_seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Heirloom pollinator attractor with red Summer blooms","claim":true},{"name":"TomorrowSeeds","url":"https://tomorrowseeds.com/products/scarlet-morning-glory","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Not only is this beauty a visual delight, but it also attracts pollinators like hummingbirds and bees.","claim":true},{"name":"MySeeds.Co","url":"https://www.myseeds.co/products/ipomoea-nil-scarlet-ohara-morning-glory-scarlet","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies, Humming Birds","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mugo-pine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 15.00 to 20.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 20 ft. 0 in. - 25 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"low growing form of the species, wider than tall, less than 8 ft tall x 16 ft wide (2.5 x 5 m)\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"It can vary in size from 5 to 20 feet tall and wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"grows to mature heights 10 to 18 feet (3 - 5 m) tall\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mugo-pine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 25.00 to 30.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 25 ft. 0 in. - 30 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"low growing form of the species, wider than tall, less than 8 ft tall x 16 ft wide (2.5 x 5 m)\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"It can vary in size from 5 to 20 feet tall and wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mugo-pine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,7],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-7","3-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284978","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 7","zones":[2,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pinus-mugo/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[2,7]},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/mugo-pine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones Zone 3, Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7","zones":[3,7]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mugo-pine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284978","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pinus-mugo/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/mugo-pine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mugo-pine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pinus-mugo/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mugo-pine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mugo-pine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pinus-mugo/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Pollution Salt","claim":true},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/mugo-pine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other tolerances Alkaline soil, clay soil, Dry sites","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"mugo-pine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pinus-mugo/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Because this plant supports moths and other pollinators, it is an excellent choice for a nighttime or pollinator garden.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"munstead-wood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.9,1],"union":[0.82,1.34],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/munstead-wood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3ft","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/munstead-wood-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Knight's Roses (Australia)","url":"https://knightsroses.com.au/product/munstead-wood/","country":"AU","form":null,"value":"Approx. Height 100cm","metres":1,"band":[0.9,1.1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/munstead-wood","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 1/2ft (110cm)","metres":1.1,"band":[0.99,1.21],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"munstead-wood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.96,1],"union":[0.82,1.18],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/munstead-wood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3 1/2ft","metres":1.07,"band":[0.96,1.18],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/munstead-wood-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/munstead-wood","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Width: 3 1/2ft (110cm)","metres":1.1,"band":[0.99,1.21],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"munstead-wood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/munstead-wood","https://menagerieflower.com/products/munstead-wood-rose-david-austin"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/munstead-wood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/munstead-wood-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Suitable Zones: 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[5,11]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"munstead-wood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/munstead-wood","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/munstead-wood"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/munstead-wood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/munstead-wood","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"munstead-wood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["strong","strong","strong","strong","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/munstead-wood","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/munstead-wood"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/munstead-wood","https://menagerieflower.com/products/munstead-wood-rose-david-austin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/munstead-wood","https://knightsroses.com.au/product/munstead-wood/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/munstead-wood","https://heirloomroses.com/products/munstead-wood"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/munstead-wood","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There is a strong Old Rose fragrance with fruity notes of blackberry, blueberry and damson notes.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK store)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/munstead-wood","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There is a strong Old Rose fragrance with fruity notes of blackberry, blueberry and damson notes.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/munstead-wood-rose-david-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong - Blackberry","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Knight's Roses (Australia)","url":"https://knightsroses.com.au/product/munstead-wood/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Very Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/munstead-wood","country":null,"form":null,"value":"that give off a strong old rose fragrance with warm, fruity notes of blackberry, blueberry, and damson","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"munstead-wood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://menagerieflower.com/products/munstead-wood-rose-david-austin","https://heirloomroses.com/products/munstead-wood"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/munstead-wood-rose-david-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A dark and dreamy David Austin rose, Munstead Wood is our go-to for burgundy cut roses.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/munstead-wood","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets and floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"munstead-wood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"munstead-wood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"narcissus-cheerfulness","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.36,0.41],"union":[0.3,0.46],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251050","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/narcissus-cheerfulness.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 14\" to 16\".","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-cheerfulness","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251050","country":"US","form":null,"value":"0.50 to 0.75 feet","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-cheerfulness","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251050","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/narcissus-cheerfulness.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 4-8.","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-cheerfulness","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251050","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-cheerfulness","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251050","country":null,"form":null,"value":"fragrant, creamy white, gardenia-like, double flowers with pale yellow centers","claim":true},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/narcissus-cheerfulness.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A late-flowering fragrant naturalizer circa 1923","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-cheerfulness","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251050","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent fresh cut flower.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-cheerfulness","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251050","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Rabbit, Deer, Drought","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-cheerfulness","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-dutch-master","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.45,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.44],"union":[0.3,0.53],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251062","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 1.75 feet","metres":[0.46,0.53],"band":[0.46,0.53],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Colorblends","url":"https://www.colorblends.com/wholesale/all-daffodils/dutch-master/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 16-18 inches","metres":[0.41,0.46],"band":[0.41,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/dutch-master/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 14-20 inches","metres":[0.36,0.51],"band":[0.36,0.51],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/narcissus-dutch-master-dutch-master-trumpet-daffodil","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It stands 18 - 20 inches tall","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/99309/narcissus-dutch-master-1/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"is a perennial bulb to 45cm tall, with strap-shaped leaves","metres":0.45,"band":[0.41,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Narcissi-Trumpet-Dutch-Master","country":"US","form":null,"value":"a trumpet daffodil, reaching 16 to 18 inches in height","metres":[0.41,0.46],"band":[0.41,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/dutch-master-daffodil-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 12-18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"J. Parker's Dutch Bulbs","url":"https://www.jparkers.com/narcissus-dutch-master-12-14cm/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 40cm","metres":0.4,"band":[0.36,0.44],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-dutch-master","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.15,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.1,0.11],"union":[0.09,0.53],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251062","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.75 feet","metres":[0.3,0.53],"band":[0.3,0.53],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/99309/narcissus-dutch-master-1/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Narcissi-Trumpet-Dutch-Master","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 4-6 Inches","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/dutch-master-daffodil-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 4-6 Inches","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"J. Parker's Dutch Bulbs","url":"https://www.jparkers.com/narcissus-dutch-master-12-14cm/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 10cm","metres":0.1,"band":[0.09,0.11],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-dutch-master","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-7","4-8","4-9","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251062","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 7","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page, Narcissus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Colorblends","url":"https://www.colorblends.com/wholesale/all-daffodils/dutch-master/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Suitable for USDA zones 3a to 7b in the South, 9b on the West Coast.","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/dutch-master/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/narcissus-dutch-master-dutch-master-trumpet-daffodil","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is hardy in zones 3 - 8.","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Narcissi-Trumpet-Dutch-Master","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3-8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/dutch-master-daffodil-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-dutch-master","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251062","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page, Narcissus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/dutch-master/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/narcissus-dutch-master-dutch-master-trumpet-daffodil","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/99309/narcissus-dutch-master-1/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Narcissi-Trumpet-Dutch-Master","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Location : Full sun to partial shade."},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/dutch-master-daffodil-bulbs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs Full Sun (6+ Hours Direct Sun)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-dutch-master","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Narcissi-Trumpet-Dutch-Master","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers appear in mid-spring and are lightly fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-dutch-master","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Narcissi-Trumpet-Dutch-Master","country":null,"form":null,"value":"making them excellent for naturalizing, borders, and cut arrangements","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-dutch-master","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251062","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought","claim":true},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Narcissi-Trumpet-Dutch-Master","country":null,"form":null,"value":"prefers well-drained soil and is deer-resistant, rabbit-resistant, and drought-tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-dutch-master","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/narcissus-dutch-master-dutch-master-trumpet-daffodil","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Interest: Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-february-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.27,0.3],"union":[0.2,0.46],"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251068","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/february-gold/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8″-12″","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/68672/narcissus-february-gold-6/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"A perennial to 30cm in height","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Van Engelen Wholesale Flower Bulbs","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/narcissus-february-gold.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10\" to 12\".","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/narcissus-february-gold.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10\" to 12\".","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/mini-daffodil-february-gold","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Flowering Height 12-14 inches","metres":[0.3,0.36],"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Narcissi-Miniature-February-Gold","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Narcissus 'February Gold' is a cyclamineus daffodil, reaching 8 to 12 inches in height.","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/narcissus-february-gold-february-gold-cyclamineus-daffodil","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This bulb grows to a height of 1 foot with full sun to partial shade and moderate moisture conditions.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Netherland Bulb Company","url":"https://www.netherlandbulb.com/plant/Narcissus-cyclamineus-February-Gold","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 8-12 In","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Terra Ceia Farms","url":"https://www.terraceiafarms.com/daffodil-cyclamineus-february-gold.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12-18\"","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Ashridge Nurseries","url":"https://www.ashridgetrees.co.uk/products/february-gold-daffodil-narcissus-bulbs","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height: 30cm","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":12,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"narcissus-february-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.12,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0,0.3],"split":[{"range":[0,0.1],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society"]},{"range":[0.23,0.3],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251068","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/68672/narcissus-february-gold-6/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0-0.1 metre","metres":[0,0.1],"band":[0,0.1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":12,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"narcissus-february-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-9","3-8","2-10","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251068","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/february-gold/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Van Engelen Wholesale Flower Bulbs","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/narcissus-february-gold.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/narcissus-february-gold.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/mini-daffodil-february-gold","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Narcissi-Miniature-February-Gold","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Temperature : Hardy in USDA zones 4-9, depending on species.","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/narcissus-february-gold-february-gold-cyclamineus-daffodil","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4 - 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Netherland Bulb Company","url":"https://www.netherlandbulb.com/plant/Narcissus-cyclamineus-February-Gold","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 2-10","zones":[2,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Terra Ceia Farms","url":"https://www.terraceiafarms.com/daffodil-cyclamineus-february-gold.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Harvesting History","url":"https://www.harvesting-history.com/product/cyclamineus-narcissus-february-gold/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plants are hardy from Hardiness Zone 3-8.","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":12,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"narcissus-february-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":11,"distinctPublishers":11,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251068","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Narcissus genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"genus","taxon":"narcissus"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/february-gold/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/68672/narcissus-february-gold-6/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/narcissus-february-gold.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"All Narcissi tolerate a wide range of sunlight from full sun to semi-shade.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/mini-daffodil-february-gold","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full Sun/Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Narcissi-Miniature-February-Gold","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Thriving in full sun to part shade, 'February Gold' prefers well-drained soil","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/narcissus-february-gold-february-gold-cyclamineus-daffodil","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Netherland Bulb Company","url":"https://www.netherlandbulb.com/plant/Narcissus-cyclamineus-February-Gold","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Terra Ceia Farms","url":"https://www.terraceiafarms.com/daffodil-cyclamineus-february-gold.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Planting Location: Sun - partial shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Ashridge Nurseries","url":"https://www.ashridgetrees.co.uk/products/february-gold-daffodil-narcissus-bulbs","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position: full sun to partial shade","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"narcissus-february-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Narcissus genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fragrant flowers bloom for two to three weeks between late winter and late spring.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"narcissus"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/mini-daffodil-february-gold","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Harvesting History","url":"https://www.harvesting-history.com/product/cyclamineus-narcissus-february-gold/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tags: Cyclamineus , Cyclamineus Narcissus , daffodil , deer resistant , forcing bulb , fragrant , Heirloom , Narcissus , NON-GMO , yellow","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Ashridge Nurseries","url":"https://www.ashridgetrees.co.uk/products/february-gold-daffodil-narcissus-bulbs","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Scent: None","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"narcissus-february-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Narcissus genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Daffodils are great for use in beds, borders, rock gardens, as fresh cut flowers, ground covers, and in woodland gardens.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"narcissus"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/february-gold/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Daffodils are wonderful flowers to pick for arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/68672/narcissus-february-gold-6/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Ashridge Nurseries","url":"https://www.ashridgetrees.co.uk/products/february-gold-daffodil-narcissus-bulbs","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They also work excellently as cut flowers, ideal for an Easter vase.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"narcissus-february-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251068","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Narcissus genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"While drought tolerant, the plants require moisture and good drainage during the growing season.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"narcissus"},{"name":"ADR Bulbs","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Narcissi-Miniature-February-Gold","country":null,"form":null,"value":"'February Gold' prefers well-drained soil and is deer-resistant, rabbit-resistant, and drought-tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"narcissus-february-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Narcissus genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"narcissus"},{"name":"Terra Ceia Farms","url":"https://www.terraceiafarms.com/daffodil-cyclamineus-february-gold.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A magnet for butterflies, the Daffodil Cyclamineus \"February Gold\" is worth its weight in gold","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"narcissus-jetfire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.25,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251095&isprofile=0&basic=Jetfire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-jetfire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.12,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251095&isprofile=0&basic=Jetfire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"0.50 to 0.75 feet","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-jetfire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251095&isprofile=0&basic=Jetfire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-jetfire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251095&isprofile=0&basic=Jetfire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/jetfire/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun, Part Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-jetfire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-jetfire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-jetfire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-jetfire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-mount-hood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.45,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.38,0.41],"union":[0.25,0.51],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251130","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/89401/narcissus-mount-hood-(1)/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"A robust daffodil to 45cm in height, with strap-shaped leaves and shapely, milky-white flowers 10cm across","metres":0.45,"band":[0.41,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/narcissus-mount-hood.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18\" to 20\".","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/flower-bulbs-index/narcissi/trumpet-daffodils/landscape-sized-narc-mount-hood.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 3-7. 18\" to 20\".","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/narcissus-mount-hood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: Grows 18-20\" tall","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/mount_hood_daffodil","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 16 - 18 inches","metres":[0.41,0.46],"band":[0.41,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/mount-hood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 15″-17″","metres":[0.38,0.43],"band":[0.38,0.43],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Colorblends","url":"https://www.colorblends.com/wholesale/daffodils/mount-hood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 14-16 inches","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Southern Bulb Company","url":"https://www.southernbulbs.com/daffodil-mount-hood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The 14-16\" stem from each bulb only produces one bloom, but these are large blooms that demand attention.","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/fall-planting-bulbs/daffodils/trumpet-daffodils/mount-hood-daffodil","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 10\" to 16\"","metres":[0.25,0.41],"band":[0.25,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/product/flower-bulbs/daffodil-bulbs-mount-hood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 14-16\" tall","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":11,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"narcissus-mount-hood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.15,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0,0.23],"split":[{"range":[0,0.1],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society"]},{"range":[0.15,0.23],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251130","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.50 to 0.75 feet","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/89401/narcissus-mount-hood-(1)/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0-0.1 metre","metres":[0,0.1],"band":[0,0.1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":11,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"narcissus-mount-hood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-7","3-9","3-6"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251130","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/narcissus-mount-hood.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 3-7.","zones":[3,7],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/flower-bulbs-index/narcissi/trumpet-daffodils/landscape-sized-narc-mount-hood.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 3-7.","zones":[3,7],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/narcissus-mount-hood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3 through 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/mount_hood_daffodil","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/mount-hood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"often performs better in cooler climates (whz 3-6)","zones":[3,6],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Colorblends","url":"https://www.colorblends.com/wholesale/daffodils/mount-hood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Suitable for USDA zones 3a to 8b in the South, 9b on the West Coast.","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Southern Bulb Company","url":"https://www.southernbulbs.com/daffodil-mount-hood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone(s): 3-8a","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/fall-planting-bulbs/daffodils/trumpet-daffodils/mount-hood-daffodil","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Suitable Zones 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":11,"genus":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"narcissus-mount-hood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":11,"distinctPublishers":11,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251130","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"narcissus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/89401/narcissus-mount-hood-(1)/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/narcissus-mount-hood.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"All Narcissi tolerate a wide range of sunlight from full sun to semi-shade.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/flower-bulbs-index/narcissi/trumpet-daffodils/landscape-sized-narc-mount-hood.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"All Narcissi tolerate a wide range of sunlight from full sun to semi-shade.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/narcissus-mount-hood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Sun to Part Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/mount_hood_daffodil","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/mount-hood/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/fall-planting-bulbs/daffodils/trumpet-daffodils/mount-hood-daffodil","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Daffodils perform best in full sun to light shade.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/product/flower-bulbs/daffodil-bulbs-mount-hood","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun Half Sun / Half Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (FPS423)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP423","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in part shade/part sun","level":"genus","taxon":"narcissus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/good-growing/2025-03-21-daffodils-symbol-renewal-and-hope","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Daffodils prefer sandy-loam soils in full sun to part sun location.","level":"genus","taxon":"narcissus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"narcissus-mount-hood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fragrant flowers bloom for two to three weeks between late winter and late spring.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"narcissus"},{"name":"The Southern Bulb Company","url":"https://www.southernbulbs.com/daffodil-mount-hood/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: This Narcissus has a light, sweet fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (FPS423)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP423","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower characteristic: spring flowering; pleasant fragrance; winter flowering","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"narcissus"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"narcissus-mount-hood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Daffodils are great for use in beds, borders, rock gardens, as fresh cut flowers, ground covers, and in woodland gardens.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"narcissus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/89401/narcissus-mount-hood-(1)/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Low Maintenance Cut flowers Flower borders and beds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/narcissus-mount-hood","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Big Blooms, Great for Cut Flowers, Deer Resistant, Naturalizing","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"The Southern Bulb Company","url":"https://www.southernbulbs.com/daffodil-mount-hood/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This really allows the blooms to make a bold statement in your garden and serve as cut flowers as well.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/fall-planting-bulbs/daffodils/trumpet-daffodils/mount-hood-daffodil","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good as Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/product/flower-bulbs/daffodil-bulbs-mount-hood","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Advantages Bee Friendly Naturalizes Easy To Grow Cut Flowers Container Planting Deer Resistant Squirrel Resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/blogs/good-growing/2025-03-21-daffodils-symbol-renewal-and-hope","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Daffodils make a beautiful bouquet that can brighten any mood and room.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"narcissus"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"narcissus-mount-hood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251130","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"While drought tolerant, the plants require moisture and good drainage during the growing season.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"narcissus"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (FPS423)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP423","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance: high","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"narcissus"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"narcissus-mount-hood","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/narcissus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"narcissus"},{"name":"The Southern Bulb Company","url":"https://www.southernbulbs.com/daffodil-mount-hood/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This fragrance can add an extra dimension of beauty to the flower and make it more attractive to pollinators like bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/product/flower-bulbs/daffodil-bulbs-mount-hood","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Advantages Bee Friendly Naturalizes Easy To Grow Cut Flowers Container Planting Deer Resistant Squirrel Resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"narcissus-tete-a-tete","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.18,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.18,0.2],"union":[0.1,0.23],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251190","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.50 to 0.75 feet","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Colorblends","url":"https://www.colorblends.com/wholesale/all-daffodils/tete-a-tete/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 7-9 inches","metres":[0.18,0.23],"band":[0.18,0.23],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/tete-a-tete/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5″-6″","metres":[0.13,0.15],"band":[0.13,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"John Scheepers","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/flower-bulbs-index/narcissi/miniature-narcissus/narcissus-tete-a-tete.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6\" to 8\".","metres":[0.15,0.2],"band":[0.15,0.2],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/fall-planting-bulbs/fall-flower-bulb-deals/jumbo-bags/tete-a-tete-daffodil-jumbo-pack","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 4\" to 8\"","metres":[0.1,0.2],"band":[0.1,0.2],"role":"scored"},{"name":"J Parkers","url":"https://www.jparkers.co.uk/narcissi-tete-a-tete","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 20 cm","metres":0.2,"band":[0.18,0.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-tete-a-tete","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.09,0.11],"union":[0.08,0.15],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251190","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.25 to 0.50 feet","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"J Parkers","url":"https://www.jparkers.co.uk/narcissi-tete-a-tete","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 10 cm","metres":0.1,"band":[0.09,0.11],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-tete-a-tete","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","5-8","3-9","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251190","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Colorblends","url":"https://www.colorblends.com/wholesale/all-daffodils/tete-a-tete/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Suitable for USDA zones 5a to 8b in the South, 10b on the West Coast.","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/tete-a-tete/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"John Scheepers","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/flower-bulbs-index/narcissi/miniature-narcissus/narcissus-tete-a-tete.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 4-8.","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/fall-planting-bulbs/fall-flower-bulb-deals/jumbo-bags/tete-a-tete-daffodil-jumbo-pack","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-tete-a-tete","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251190","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/tete-a-tete/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun, Part Shade"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/fall-planting-bulbs/fall-flower-bulb-deals/jumbo-bags/tete-a-tete-daffodil-jumbo-pack","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun, Partial Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-tete-a-tete","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"J Parkers","url":"https://www.jparkers.co.uk/narcissi-tete-a-tete","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Quite possibly the most renowned scented dwarf daffodil on the market today","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-tete-a-tete","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251190","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/fall-planting-bulbs/fall-flower-bulb-deals/jumbo-bags/tete-a-tete-daffodil-jumbo-pack","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer Resistant, Good as Cut Flowers, Good For Indoor Forcing, Grows Well In Containers, Naturalizing, Perennializing","claim":true},{"name":"J Parkers","url":"https://www.jparkers.co.uk/narcissi-tete-a-tete","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cut flowers","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-tete-a-tete","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251190","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"narcissus-tete-a-tete","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"nasturtium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":7,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 10.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The compact varieties remain about 12 inches tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Bush and trailing types are available ranging in height from 1 to 6 ft.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"nasturtium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":7,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Depending on the species and variety, plants either form low mounds or trail up to 3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"nasturtium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"CONVENTION","wouldPropose":[2,11],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tropaeolum, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tropaeolum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[2,11],"level":"genus","taxon":"tropaeolum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tropaeolum (group), common name nasturtium)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264612","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11],"level":"genus","taxon":"tropaeolum"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"genus":7,"species":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source states 2-11 and this row deliberately stores no zones, which is the library's way of saying \"grown everywhere\" (docs/CATALOG-AUDIT.md records the two zone conventions for annuals as expected). Nothing is proposed: writing a zone range onto a zone-less row would remove it from every zone filter outside that range, and this is one library-wide decision rather than a per-plant error","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"nasturtium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tropaeolum, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tropaeolum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"tropaeolum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tropaeolum (group), common name nasturtium)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264612","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"tropaeolum"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Nasturtium, Tropaeolum species)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/nasturtium-tropaeolum-majus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant nasturtiums in well-drained soil in full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"tropaeolum"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Tropaeolum majus, garden nasturtium)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/85362/tropaeolum-majus/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"tropaeolum majus"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Herb Gardening (Nasturtium, Tropaeolum majus and T. minus)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/herbs/nasturtium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Nasturtium prefers a full sun location but will tolerate some light shade however flowering may be reduced.","level":"genus","taxon":"tropaeolum"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension (Nasturtium)","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/nasturtium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Nasturtiums will grow in full sun but seem to do better in semi-shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"tropaeolum"},{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds Grower's Library (Nasturtium, Tropaeolum spp., key growing information)","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/growers-library/flowers/nasturtium/nasturtium-key-growing-information.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun/Part Shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"tropaeolum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"nasturtium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tropaeolum, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tropaeolum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant, showy flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tropaeolum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tropaeolum (group), common name nasturtium)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264612","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tropaeolum"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension, Bulletin B954 Flowering Annuals for Georgia Gardens (Nasturtium entry, Tropaeolum majus and T. peregrinum)","url":"https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=B954&title=Flowering+Annuals+for+Georgia+Gardens","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Annuals Grown for Fragrance","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tropaeolum"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"nasturtium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"University of Georgia Extension, Bulletin B954 Flowering Annuals for Georgia Gardens (Nasturtium entry, Tropaeolum majus and T. peregrinum)","url":"https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=B954&title=Flowering+Annuals+for+Georgia+Gardens","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Annuals for Use as Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tropaeolum"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"nasturtium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tropaeolum (group), common name nasturtium)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264612","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants have some tolerance for dry soils.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tropaeolum"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Nasturtium, Tropaeolum species)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/nasturtium-tropaeolum-majus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Although they like dry soils and will tolerate drought, water regularly during the growing season to keep plants blooming strongly.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tropaeolum"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"nasturtium","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tropaeolum, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tropaeolum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nasturtium is attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tropaeolum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tropaeolum (group), common name nasturtium)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264612","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tropaeolum"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"nasturtium-mahogany","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"nasturtium-mahogany","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"nasturtium-mahogany","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"nasturtium-mahogany","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"nasturtium-mahogany","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"nasturtium-mahogany","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"nasturtium-mahogany","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"nasturtium-mahogany","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"new-dawn-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[3.05,3.3],"union":[2.44,6.1],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-new-dawn/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10 ft. 0 in. - 15 ft. 0 in.","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252298","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8.00 to 12.00 feet","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/products/new-dawn","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Glossy green foliage on 10 to 15 foot canes that can either be trained to climb or left to trail.","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://www.roguevalleyroses.com/products/new-dawn","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 15-20 Feet","metres":[4.57,6.1],"band":[4.57,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (New Dawn Climbing Rose)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/new-dawn-climbing-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 8 - 12 Feet","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed and Nursery (New Dawn Climbing Rose)","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/product/new-dawn-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 18 - 20","metres":[5.49,6.1],"band":[5.49,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Trevor White Roses (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://www.trevorwhiteroses.co.uk/product/new-dawn/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Size: 3m x 2.4m.","metres":3,"band":[2.7,3.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"new-dawn-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.91,3.66],"split":[{"range":[0.91,2.64],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rosa 'New Dawn')","Plant Addicts (New Dawn Climbing Rose)","High Country Roses (Rosa 'New Dawn')","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa 'New Dawn')","Trevor White Roses (Rosa 'New Dawn')"]},{"range":[3.05,3.66],"sources":["Gurney's Seed and Nursery (New Dawn Climbing Rose)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-new-dawn/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 6 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252298","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/products/new-dawn","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Greater than 6ft","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (New Dawn Climbing Rose)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/new-dawn-climbing-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 3 - 6 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed and Nursery (New Dawn Climbing Rose)","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/product/new-dawn-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 10 - 12'","metres":[3.05,3.66],"band":[3.05,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Trevor White Roses (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://www.trevorwhiteroses.co.uk/product/new-dawn/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Size: 3m x 2.4m.","metres":2.4,"band":[2.16,2.64],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"new-dawn-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","5-8","4-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-new-dawn/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252298","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://www.roguevalleyroses.com/products/new-dawn","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (New Dawn Climbing Rose)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/new-dawn-climbing-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 5 - 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed and Nursery (New Dawn Climbing Rose)","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/product/new-dawn-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 4-10","zones":[4,10],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"new-dawn-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-new-dawn/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252298","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (New Dawn Climbing Rose)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/new-dawn-climbing-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Full Sun (At Least 6 Hours Of Direct Sunlight)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed and Nursery (New Dawn Climbing Rose)","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/product/new-dawn-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"new-dawn-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","strengths":["light","strong"],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-new-dawn/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The soft pink flowers are sweetly fragrant and semi-double to double, occurring heavily in June and then repeat blooming through fall.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252298","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Roses (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://www.highcountryroses.com/products/new-dawn","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Light","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://www.roguevalleyroses.com/products/new-dawn","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Large, fragrant, pale pink blooms of hybrid tea form.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (New Dawn Climbing Rose)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/new-dawn-climbing-rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features: Attracts Pollinators, Fragrant, Award Winner","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed and Nursery (New Dawn Climbing Rose)","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/product/new-dawn-climbing-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant, pale pink flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Trevor White Roses (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://www.trevorwhiteroses.co.uk/product/new-dawn/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Heavily scented.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"new-dawn-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-new-dawn/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#cutting garden","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://www.roguevalleyroses.com/products/new-dawn","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good for cutting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"new-dawn-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts (New Dawn Climbing Rose)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/new-dawn-climbing-rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Climbing Roses are not drought tolerant and will require extra irrigation during hot or dry spells.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"new-dawn-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252298","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (New Dawn Climbing Rose)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/new-dawn-climbing-rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features: Attracts Pollinators, Fragrant, Award Winner","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Trevor White Roses (Rosa 'New Dawn')","url":"https://www.trevorwhiteroses.co.uk/product/new-dawn/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"new-england-aster-barrs-pink","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.35,1.5],"union":[1,1.65],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"RHS Plant Finder","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/339971/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae-barrs-pink/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height\n1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Cambridge University Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.botanic.cam.ac.uk/the-garden/plant-list/aster-novae-angliae-barrs-pink/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"These are held on erect stems to 1.5m high","metres":1.5,"band":[1.35,1.65],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Promesse de Fleurs","url":"https://www.promessedefleurs.ie/perennials/perennials-by-variety/asters/aster-novae-angliae-barrs-pink.html","country":"IE","form":null,"value":"Height at maturity\n1.20 m","metres":1.2,"band":[1.08,1.32],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Avondale Nursery","url":"https://avondalenursery.co.uk/product/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae-barrs-pink","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Very large lilac-pink flowers. Height: 150cm","metres":1.5,"band":[1.35,1.65],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"new-england-aster-barrs-pink","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.54,0.66],"union":[0.5,1],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"RHS Plant Finder","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/339971/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae-barrs-pink/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread\n0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Promesse de Fleurs","url":"https://www.promessedefleurs.ie/perennials/perennials-by-variety/asters/aster-novae-angliae-barrs-pink.html","country":"IE","form":null,"value":"Spread at maturity\n60 cm","metres":0.6,"band":[0.54,0.66],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"new-england-aster-barrs-pink","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","3-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292654&isprofile=0&basic=Symphyotrichum+novae-angliae","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone:\n4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Prairie Nursery","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/new-england-aster-aster-novae-angliae.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone\n3, 4, 5, 6, 7","zones":[3,7]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"new-england-aster-barrs-pink","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292654&isprofile=0&basic=Symphyotrichum+novae-angliae","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light:\nFull sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)\nPartial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"RHS Plant Finder","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/339971/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae-barrs-pink/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=SYNO2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/new-england-aster-aster-novae-angliae.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure\nFull Sun, Partial"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"new-england-aster-barrs-pink","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"new-england-aster-barrs-pink","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy deep pink-purple flowers are attractive to wildlife including bees and butterflies and also make great cut flowers for arrangements.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"new-england-aster-barrs-pink","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"new-england-aster-barrs-pink","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"nearMiss":["pollinator friendly"],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292654&isprofile=0&basic=Symphyotrichum+novae-angliae","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy deep pink-purple flowers are attractive to wildlife including bees and butterflies and also make great cut flowers for arrangements.","claim":true},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=SYNO2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use Wildlife: Bees and butterflies frequent this wildflower. Nectar source for Monarch butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"Prairie Nursery","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/new-england-aster-aster-novae-angliae.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Benefits\nBirds, Butterflies, Pollinators, Host Plant, Deer Resistant","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; the row carries [\"pollinator friendly\"], which nothing in the product reads: hasTag is an equality test against \"pollinator\"","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"new-england-aster-barrs-pink","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"botanicalName","current":"Symphyotrichum novae-angliae 'Barr's Pink'","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"IPNI (Kew)","url":"https://www.ipni.org/n/981863-1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Species accepted: Symphyotrichum novae-angliae ( L. ) G.L.Nesom , Phytologia 77(3): 287 (1995). IPNI record flags inPowo true. POWO itself could not be read from this environment (see note)."},{"name":"RHS Plant Finder","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/339971/symphyotrichum-novae-angliae-barrs-pink/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Accepted: page is headed Symphyotrichum novae-angliae 'Barr's Pink' with Synonyms Aster novae-angliae 'Barr's Pink'"},{"name":"POWO","url":"https://powo.science.kew.org/taxon/urn:lsid:ipni.org:names:981863-1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Unreachable: HTTP 403 on every powo.science.kew.org and plantsoftheworldonline.org path tried, including /results, /api/2 and the taxon page"}],"note":"name resolves as Symphyotrichum novae-angliae 'Barr's Pink'","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"nicotiana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":6,"genus":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The tallest varieties can reach five feet and look good at the back of mixed beds\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"nicotiana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":6,"genus":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"nicotiana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":6,"genus":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"nicotiana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Nicotiana alata)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287165","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"nicotiana alata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Nicotiana sylvestris)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287166","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"nicotiana sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nicotiana alata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nicotiana-alata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant it in the full sun to partial shade in moist, well-drained soil that is high in organic material.","level":"species","taxon":"nicotiana alata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nicotiana sylvestris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nicotiana-sylvestris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"nicotiana sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nicotiana x sanderi)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nicotiana-x-sanderi/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows best in full sun in average, well-drained soil but will tolerate light shade.","level":"species","taxon":"nicotiana sanderi"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Nicotiana sylvestris)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/flowering-tobacco-nicotiana-sylvestris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows best in full sun but will tolerate partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"nicotiana sylvestris"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions (Flowering Tobacco, Nicotiana)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/flowering-tobacco/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They do best in full sun.","level":"genus","taxon":"nicotiana"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"nicotiana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","strengths":["strong","strong"],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Nicotiana alata)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287165","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nicotiana alata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Nicotiana sylvestris)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287166","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are strongly fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nicotiana sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nicotiana alata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nicotiana-alata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The showy fragrant tubular flowers open only at night","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nicotiana alata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nicotiana sylvestris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nicotiana-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It provides color and intoxicating fragrance into lates summer when many other blooms fade.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nicotiana sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nicotiana x sanderi)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nicotiana-x-sanderi/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Many colors, fragrant, evening-blooming","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nicotiana sanderi"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Nicotiana sylvestris)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/flowering-tobacco-nicotiana-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers emit a strong, sweet, jasmine-like scent especially in the evening to attract their sphinx moth pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nicotiana sylvestris"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Nicotiana, genus profile)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/nicotiana","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Many only open in the evening and at night, releasing a distinctive incense-like fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"nicotiana"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions (Flowering Tobacco, Nicotiana)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/flowering-tobacco/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"these plants produce trumpet-shaped flowers that are only a few inches long but will fill your garden with fragrance","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"nicotiana"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"nicotiana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Nicotiana, genus profile)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/nicotiana","country":null,"form":null,"value":"are popular with flower arrangers","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"nicotiana"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["nicotiana sylvestris"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (nicotiana sylvestris), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (nicotiana sylvestris) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"nicotiana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["nicotiana alata"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (nicotiana alata), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (nicotiana alata) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"nicotiana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Nicotiana alata)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287165","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nicotiana alata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Nicotiana sylvestris)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287166","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nicotiana sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nicotiana alata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nicotiana-alata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The intoxicating fragrance from its showy flowers attracts nighttime pollinators like moths making it an excellent addition to a moonlit garden.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nicotiana alata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Nicotiana sylvestris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/nicotiana-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts hummingbirds, butterflies and moths.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nicotiana sylvestris"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Nicotiana sylvestris)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/flowering-tobacco-nicotiana-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"to attract their sphinx moth pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"nicotiana sylvestris"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"ninebark","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.83,2.44],"union":[0.61,3.05],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286432","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5.00 to 8.00 feet","metres":[1.52,2.44],"band":[1.52,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/physocarpus-opulifolius/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.52,2.44],"band":[1.52,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (common ninebark, Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/common-ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"An upright, spreading, dense shrub with arching branches reaching 6 to 10 feet tall and wide.","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center NPIN (Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PHOP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"A 3-10 ft., mound-shaped, deciduous shrub","metres":[0.91,3.05],"band":[0.91,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide (ninebark, Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/ninebark","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 to 10 feet.","metres":[0.91,3.05],"band":[0.91,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Go Botany, Native Plant Trust (Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://gobotany.nativeplanttrust.org/species/physocarpus/opulifolius/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Atlantic ninebark is a graceful shrub with arching branches that grows from 2 to 8 feet (2.5 m) tall.","metres":[0.61,2.44],"band":[0.61,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":6,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ninebark","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.22,1.83],"union":[1.22,3.05],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286432","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/physocarpus-opulifolius/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 4 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (common ninebark, Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/common-ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"An upright, spreading, dense shrub with arching branches reaching 6 to 10 feet tall and wide.","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":6,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ninebark","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-8","2-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286432","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 8","zones":[2,8],"level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/physocarpus-opulifolius/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[2,8],"level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (common ninebark, Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/common-ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 2, Zone 3, Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7","zones":[2,7],"level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":6,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ninebark","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286432","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/physocarpus-opulifolius/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (common ninebark, Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/common-ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Best in full sun to light shade in well-drained soil.","level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center NPIN (Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PHOP","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade , Shade","level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide (ninebark, Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/ninebark","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It thrives best in full sun.","level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Physocarpus opulifolius 'Diabolo')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255943","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Physocarpus opulifolius 'Dart's Gold')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=267865","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ninebark","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ninebark","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ninebark","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286432","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Wet Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil, Black Walnut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/physocarpus-opulifolius/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Heat, drought, and soil compaction tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (common ninebark, Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/common-ninebark/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dry sites, Occasional drought, Occasional flooding","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center NPIN (Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PHOP","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Atlantic Ninebark is fast-growing, insect and disease resistant, and drought-tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Go Botany, Native Plant Trust (Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://gobotany.nativeplanttrust.org/species/physocarpus/opulifolius/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This tough shrub can tolerate a variety of clayey to droughty soils.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["physocarpus opulifolius"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (physocarpus opulifolius), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (physocarpus opulifolius) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ninebark","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/physocarpus-opulifolius/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts birds and bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center NPIN (Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PHOP","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Value to Native Bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide (ninebark, Physocarpus opulifolius)","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/ninebark","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are a good nectar source for bees, butterflies, and even beetles","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"ninebark-amber-jubilee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.65,1.83],"union":[1.52,2.13],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293651","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"First Editions (Bailey Nurseries, brand that introduces this cultivar)","url":"https://firsteditionsplants.com/product/amber-jubilee-ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 5-7'","metres":[1.52,2.13],"band":[1.52,2.13],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Jeffries Nurseries (breeder and introducer of 'Jefam')","url":"https://jeffriesnurseries.com/fe-amber-jubilee-ninebark/","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Height: 5-6′ (1.5 -1.8 m)","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/amber-jubilee-ninebark","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 5 – 6 feet","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Frisella Nursery (NetPS Plant Finder entry)","url":"https://plants.frisellanursery.com/12150019/Plant/14067/Amber_Jubilee_Ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6 feet","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ninebark-amber-jubilee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.22,1.34],"union":[0.91,1.83],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293651","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"First Editions (Bailey Nurseries, brand that introduces this cultivar)","url":"https://firsteditionsplants.com/product/amber-jubilee-ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 4-6'","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Jeffries Nurseries (breeder and introducer of 'Jefam')","url":"https://jeffriesnurseries.com/fe-amber-jubilee-ninebark/","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Spread: 5-6′ (1.5 -1.8 m)","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/amber-jubilee-ninebark","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 4 – 5 feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Frisella Nursery (NetPS Plant Finder entry)","url":"https://plants.frisellanursery.com/12150019/Plant/14067/Amber_Jubilee_Ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ninebark-amber-jubilee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,7],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-8","2-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293651","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 8","zones":[2,8]},{"name":"First Editions (Bailey Nurseries, brand that introduces this cultivar)","url":"https://firsteditionsplants.com/product/amber-jubilee-ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 2-7","zones":[2,7]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ninebark-amber-jubilee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293651","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"First Editions (Bailey Nurseries, brand that introduces this cultivar)","url":"https://firsteditionsplants.com/product/amber-jubilee-ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun"},{"name":"Jeffries Nurseries (breeder and introducer of 'Jefam')","url":"https://jeffriesnurseries.com/fe-amber-jubilee-ninebark/","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Light Needs : Full Sun to Part Shade"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/amber-jubilee-ninebark","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure: Full Sun, Partial Shade"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/physocarpus-opulifolius","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to part shade, considered tough, acid or alkaline soil, withstands dry situations."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ninebark-amber-jubilee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ninebark-amber-jubilee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ninebark-amber-jubilee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293651","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true},{"name":"First Editions (Bailey Nurseries, brand that introduces this cultivar)","url":"https://firsteditionsplants.com/product/amber-jubilee-ninebark/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Jeffries Nurseries (breeder and introducer of 'Jefam')","url":"https://jeffriesnurseries.com/fe-amber-jubilee-ninebark/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Key Features: Fall Interest, Red Branches, Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ninebark-amber-jubilee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://firsteditionsplants.com/product/amber-jubilee-ninebark/","https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/amber-jubilee-ninebark"]}],"sources":[{"name":"First Editions (Bailey Nurseries, brand that introduces this cultivar)","url":"https://firsteditionsplants.com/product/amber-jubilee-ninebark/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer Resistant Drought Tolerant Good in Damp Soil Pollinator","claim":true},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/amber-jubilee-ninebark","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator Friendly: Yes","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ninebark-diabolo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[2.75,3.05],"union":[1.22,3.36],"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255943","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.00 to 8.00 feet","metres":[1.22,2.44],"band":[1.22,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/physocarpus-opulifolius-diabolo","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Deciduous shrub, upright, 10 × 10 ft (3 × 3 m).","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/361767/physocarpus-opulifolius-monlo/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/467","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Height: 8-10 feet","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Physocarpus-opulifolius-Diabolo","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4-8 ft","metres":[1.22,2.44],"band":[1.22,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rain-garden-plantsphysocarpus-opulifolius-ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Diabolo® (‘Monlo’) – 8-10’ h x w.","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/common-ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Upright, 8 to 10 feet high, dark purple leaves, pinkish-white flower clusters in early to mid summer.","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Physocarpus-opulifolius-Diabolo-Monlo","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"HEIGHT: 175-200 cm","metres":[1.75,2],"band":[1.75,2],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Gertens (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/1051/Diabolo%C2%AE_Ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10 feet","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Physocarpus-opulifolius-Diabolo-Ninebark","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5-8 ft","metres":[1.52,2.44],"band":[1.52,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"ninebark-diabolo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[2.2,2.5],"union":[1.22,3.36],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255943","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4.00 to 8.00 feet","metres":[1.22,2.44],"band":[1.22,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/physocarpus-opulifolius-diabolo","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Deciduous shrub, upright, 10 × 10 ft (3 × 3 m).","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/361767/physocarpus-opulifolius-monlo/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/467","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Spread: 8-10 feet","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Physocarpus-opulifolius-Diabolo","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4-8 ft","metres":[1.22,2.44],"band":[1.22,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rain-garden-plantsphysocarpus-opulifolius-ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Diabolo® (‘Monlo’) – 8-10’ h x w.","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Physocarpus-opulifolius-Diabolo-Monlo","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"SPREAD: 125-150 cm","metres":[1.25,1.5],"band":[1.25,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Gertens (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/1051/Diabolo%C2%AE_Ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 8 feet","metres":2.44,"band":[2.2,2.68],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Physocarpus-opulifolius-Diabolo-Ninebark","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 6-9 ft","metres":[1.83,2.74],"band":[1.83,2.74],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"ninebark-diabolo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-7","2-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255943","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 7","zones":[3,7],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Physocarpus-opulifolius-Diabolo","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-7","zones":[3,7],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Physocarpus-opulifolius-Diabolo-Ninebark","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 2-8","zones":[2,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":4},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"ninebark-diabolo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255943","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/physocarpus-opulifolius/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/361767/physocarpus-opulifolius-monlo/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/467","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rain-garden-plantsphysocarpus-opulifolius-ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Flowers are at their most colorful in full sun conditions, but color fades in shady conditions for most cultivars.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/common-ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Physocarpus-opulifolius-Diabolo-Monlo","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Gertens (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/1051/Diabolo%C2%AE_Ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub does best in full sun to partial shade.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/ninebark-3-11-11.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This species is easily grown in full sun or light shade and tolerates a wide array of soil conditions.","level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (species page)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/physocarpus-opulifolius","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to part shade, considered tough, acid or alkaline soil, withstands dry situations.","level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"ninebark-diabolo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"ninebark-diabolo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Physocarpus-opulifolius-Diabolo-Monlo","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"ninebark-diabolo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255943","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/physocarpus-opulifolius/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Heat, drought, and soil compaction tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Physocarpus-opulifolius-Diabolo","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rain-garden-plantsphysocarpus-opulifolius-ninebark/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Ninebark is drought tolerant and grows well in harsh conditions (clay or rocky soils).","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/common-ninebark/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Occasional drought","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Gertens (NetPS Plant Finder database)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/1051/Diabolo%C2%AE_Ninebark/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is very adaptable to both dry and moist locations, and should do just fine under average home landscape conditions.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/ninebark-3-11-11.aspx","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, it has good drought tolerance.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (species page)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/physocarpus-opulifolius","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sun to part shade, considered tough, acid or alkaline soil, withstands dry situations.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"ninebark-diabolo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/physocarpus-opulifolius/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts birds and bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Physocarpus-opulifolius-Diabolo","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rain-garden-plantsphysocarpus-opulifolius-ninebark/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"a nectar source for native bees, honey bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"physocarpus opulifolius"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"ninebark-little-devil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"edge","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.22],"edge":[0.88,1.26],"edgeMargin":1.1,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293650","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"First Editions (Bailey Nurseries, the introducer)","url":"https://firsteditionsplants.com/product/little-devil-ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"}],"withdrawnFromV2":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":1.07},"note":"the catalog value sits 1.1% outside the sources' union (0.91 to 1.22 m) and inside the 3% margin v3 allows at a stated range edge (0.88 to 1.26 m), so v2's proposal of 1.07 m is withdrawn rather than applied; 2 of these 2 scored sources publish a range, and a range edge is a figure converted and rounded from another unit rather than a measurement to the centimetre","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ninebark-little-devil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"edge","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.22],"edge":[0.88,1.26],"edgeMargin":1.1,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293650","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"First Editions (Bailey Nurseries, the introducer)","url":"https://firsteditionsplants.com/product/little-devil-ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"}],"withdrawnFromV2":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":1.07},"note":"the catalog value sits 1.1% outside the sources' union (0.91 to 1.22 m) and inside the 3% margin v3 allows at a stated range edge (0.88 to 1.26 m), so v2's proposal of 1.07 m is withdrawn rather than applied; 2 of these 2 scored sources publish a range, and a range edge is a figure converted and rounded from another unit rather than a measurement to the centimetre","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ninebark-little-devil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293650","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 7","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"First Editions (Bailey Nurseries, the introducer)","url":"https://firsteditionsplants.com/product/little-devil-ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3-7","zones":[3,7]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ninebark-little-devil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293650","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"First Editions (Bailey Nurseries, the introducer)","url":"https://firsteditionsplants.com/product/little-devil-ninebark/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ninebark-little-devil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ninebark-little-devil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ninebark-little-devil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"First Editions (Bailey Nurseries, the introducer)","url":"https://firsteditionsplants.com/product/little-devil-ninebark/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ninebark-little-devil","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"northern-sea-oats","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.82,1],"union":[0.61,1.52],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285270","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.61,1.52],"band":[0.61,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.52],"band":[0.61,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CHLA5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size Notes: 2 to 4 feet tall","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/chasmanthium-latifolium-northern-sea-oats","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 48\" tall","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-oats","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"northern-sea-oats","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.76],"union":[0.3,0.76],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285270","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.76],"band":[0.3,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.76],"band":[0.3,0.76],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"northern-sea-oats","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","5-9","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285270","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/chasmanthium-latifolium-northern-sea-oats","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 4a to 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-oats","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 4-9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"northern-sea-oats","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285270","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CHLA5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade , Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"northern-sea-oats","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"northern-sea-oats","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285270","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Dried Long-lasting Showy","claim":true},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CHLA5","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use Other: Cut seed stalks decorative in dried arrangements.","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/chasmanthium-latifolium-northern-sea-oats","country":null,"form":null,"value":"great for flower arrangers!","claim":true},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-oats","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The seed stalks are beautiful all year long and are commonly used in native flower arrangements or dried arrangements.","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"northern-sea-oats","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Black Walnut Deer Drought Erosion Salt Wet Soil","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"northern-sea-oats","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Pollinators Small Mammals Songbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CHLA5","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"northern-sea-oats-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.75,0.84],"union":[0.68,0.9],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"USPTO Plant Patent PP20,643 (ItSaul Plants, the introducer), via Google Patents","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP20643P2/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Reaches about 46 cm in height with a spread of about 30 cm in a one-gallon container and matures in the garden to about 76 cm (30 inches) in height and spread.","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist-pp-20643-northern-sea-oats","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 30\" tall","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Height 75-90 cm 29-35 inches","metres":[0.75,0.9],"band":[0.75,0.9],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"northern-sea-oats-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.45,0.84],"split":[{"range":[0.45,0.6],"sources":["Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)"]},{"range":[0.68,0.84],"sources":["USPTO Plant Patent PP20,643 (ItSaul Plants, the introducer), via Google Patents"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"USPTO Plant Patent PP20,643 (ItSaul Plants, the introducer), via Google Patents","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP20643P2/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Reaches about 46 cm in height with a spread of about 30 cm in a one-gallon container and matures in the garden to about 76 cm (30 inches) in height and spread.","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Spread 45-60 cm 18-23 inches","metres":[0.45,0.6],"band":[0.45,0.6],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"northern-sea-oats-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","5-9","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285270","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"USPTO Plant Patent PP20,643 (ItSaul Plants, the introducer), via Google Patents","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP20643P2/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"U.S.D.A. Zones 4 to 9.","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist-pp-20643-northern-sea-oats","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 4a to 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 5-9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"northern-sea-oats-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285270","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist-pp-20643-northern-sea-oats","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Part Sun to Light Shade"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun or Partial Shade or Full Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"northern-sea-oats-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"northern-sea-oats-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.plantdelights.com/products/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist-pp-20643-northern-sea-oats","https://www.perennials.com/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist.html"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist-pp-20643-northern-sea-oats","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower Plants , Deer Resistant Plants","claim":true},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Useful both as a fresh or dried cutflower.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"northern-sea-oats-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.plantdelights.com/products/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist-pp-20643-northern-sea-oats","https://www.perennials.com/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist.html"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist-pp-20643-northern-sea-oats","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant Plants , Dry Shade Plants","claim":true},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dried Flower Drought Tolerant Massed","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"northern-sea-oats-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.plantdelights.com/products/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist-pp-20643-northern-sea-oats","https://www.perennials.com/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist.html"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist-pp-20643-northern-sea-oats","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator Plants , North American Native Plants","claim":true},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/chasmanthium-latifolium-river-mist.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"norway-spruce-birds-nest","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["the page's figure is a 30 to 30 year size and this row's is its size at 15 years","the page's figure is a 10 to 10 year size and this row's is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Conifer, evergreen dwarf shrub, spreading, dense, grows a flattened globe, eventually to 3+ ft (1 m) high and 4-6 ft (1.2-1.6 m) across.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"norway-spruce-birds-nest","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["the page's figure is a 30 to 30 year size and this row's is its size at 15 years","the page's figure is a 10 to 10 year size and this row's is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Conifer, evergreen dwarf shrub, spreading, dense, grows a flattened globe, eventually to 3+ ft (1 m) high and 4-6 ft (1.2-1.6 m) across.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"norway-spruce-birds-nest","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-7","3-6"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252787&isprofile=0&basic=Nidiformis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 7","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-abies-nidiformis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b","zones":[3,6]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"norway-spruce-birds-nest","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252787&isprofile=0&basic=Nidiformis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-abies-nidiformis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"norway-spruce-birds-nest","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"norway-spruce-birds-nest","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"norway-spruce-birds-nest","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252787&isprofile=0&basic=Nidiformis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Established plants have some tolerance for dryish soils.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/picea-abies-nidiformis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Established plants have some tolerance to deer, drought, and air pollution.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"norway-spruce-birds-nest","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"olivia-rose-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[1.23,1.51],"union":[1.07,1.52],"proposed":1.37,"margin":6.5,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4 1/2ft","metres":1.37,"band":[1.23,1.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4.5' x 3.5'","metres":1.37,"band":[1.23,1.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-olivia-rose-austin%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush-copy","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 3.5-5′","metres":[1.07,1.52],"band":[1.07,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/olivia-rose-austin%E2%84%A2-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.5 feet","metres":1.37,"band":[1.23,1.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/olivia-rose-austin","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 3 1/2ft (110cm)","metres":1.07,"band":[0.96,1.18],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (1.07 to 1.52 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"olivia-rose-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"edge","consensus":[0.96,1.18],"union":[0.91,1.22],"edge":[0.88,1.26],"edgeMargin":1.1,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3 1/2ft","metres":1.07,"band":[0.96,1.18],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4.5' x 3.5'","metres":1.07,"band":[0.96,1.18],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-olivia-rose-austin%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush-copy","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3-4′","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/olivia-rose-austin%E2%84%A2-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.5 feet","metres":1.07,"band":[0.96,1.18],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/olivia-rose-austin","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3 1/2ft (110cm)","metres":1.07,"band":[0.96,1.18],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"withdrawnFromV2":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":1.07},"note":"the catalog value sits 1.1% outside the sources' union (0.91 to 1.22 m) and inside the 3% margin v3 allows at a stated range edge (0.88 to 1.26 m), so v2's proposal of 1.07 m is withdrawn rather than applied; 1 of these 4 scored sources publish a range, and a range edge is a figure converted and rounded from another unit rather than a measurement to the centimetre","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"olivia-rose-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zone Zone 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-olivia-rose-austin%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush-copy","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zones: 5–10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/olivia-rose-austin%E2%84%A2-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Suitable Zones: 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"olivia-rose-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/olivia-rose-austin","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Partial Shade or Full Sun Tolerates some shade, needing only 4+ hours of direct sun to thrive.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-olivia-rose-austin%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush-copy","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Roses require full sun and organically rich, well-drained, acidic to neutral soils.","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"olivia-rose-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["light","light","strong","light"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/olivia-rose-austin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","https://heirloomroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-olivia-rose-austin%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush-copy"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","https://menagerieflower.com/products/olivia-rose-austin%E2%84%A2-bare-root-rose-david-austin"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Light-medium,Fruity","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/olivia-rose-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Light-medium,Fruity","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Lightly Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-olivia-rose-austin%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush-copy","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm and Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/olivia-rose-austin%E2%84%A2-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Light to Moderate - Fruit","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"olivia-rose-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/olivia-rose-austin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","https://heirloomroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-olivia-rose-austin%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush-copy"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Location Cutting Mixed Border Pots & Containers Rose Border Rose Hedges","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/olivia-rose-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Location Borders Cutting Pots & Containers Rose Hedges","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/olivia-rose-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets and floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-olivia-rose-austin%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush-copy","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vase Life: 5–7 days","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"olivia-rose-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"olivia-rose-austin","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"oregano","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.55,0.6],"union":[0.15,0.91],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/origanum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.15,0.91],"band":[0.15,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Origanum vulgare)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/origanum-vulgare/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Origanum vulgare)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281411","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/herbs/oregano/grow-your-own","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Plants usually reach a height and spread of 30-60cm (1-2ft), depending on the variety.","metres":[0.3,0.6],"band":[0.3,0.6],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/oregano","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Oregano, also called wild marjoram, is a hardy perennial that has sprawling stems which can grow to 2' in height.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/herbs/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows to 2 feet tall, with small rounded leaves and pale pink flowers.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Illinois Extension Herb Gardening","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/herbs/oregano","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Oregano is a loose, open plant growing from six inches to two feet tall with gray-green leaves and small purple or white flowers.","metres":[0.15,0.61],"band":[0.15,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"oregano","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.3,0.6],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/origanum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Origanum vulgare)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/origanum-vulgare/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Origanum vulgare)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281411","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/herbs/oregano/grow-your-own","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Plants usually reach a height and spread of 30-60cm (1-2ft), depending on the variety.","metres":[0.3,0.6],"band":[0.3,0.6],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"oregano","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-10","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/origanum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[3,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Origanum vulgare)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/origanum-vulgare/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Origanum vulgare)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281411","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"oregano","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/origanum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Origanum vulgare)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/origanum-vulgare/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Origanum vulgare)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281411","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/herbs/oregano/grow-your-own","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Oregano thrives in full sun, providing richly flavoured leaves and attractive flowers"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/herbs/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant oregano in full sun and well-drained soil."},{"name":"Illinois Extension Herb Gardening","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/herbs/oregano","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Oregano must be planted in a full sun location and good drainage is required for best growth and overwintering."},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/edibles/vegetables/oregano/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant oregano in full sun and well-drained soil."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"oregano","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/origanum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The leaves are aromatic, small oval to round, and either smooth or hairy.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Origanum vulgare)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/origanum-vulgare/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Edible Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Origanum vulgare)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281411","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Colorful, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/herbs/oregano/grow-your-own","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Popular for its aromatic, pungent leaves, oregano is widely used in Italian and Greek cuisine, especially when dried.","claim":true},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/edibles/vegetables/oregano/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Oregano's aromatic leaves can be snipped as needed.","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"oregano","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/origanum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cottage Garden Cutting Garden Drought Tolerant Garden","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"oregano","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/origanum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Oregano is drought, deer, poor soil, and erosion tolerant.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Origanum vulgare)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/origanum-vulgare/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In general, Oregano plants tolerate heat and drought.","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Origanum vulgare)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281411","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Erosion, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/herbs/oregano/grow-your-own","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This sun-loving Mediterranean herb is easy to grow, compact and drought tolerant.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"oregano","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/origanum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees and butterflies are attracted to their blooms.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Origanum vulgare)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/origanum-vulgare/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract a tremendous number of visitors and pollinators.","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Origanum vulgare)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281411","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/herbs/oregano/grow-your-own","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the flowers are great at attracting butterflies and bees","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"oregold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.5,1.83],"union":[0.91,2],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/pl.php?n=17413&tab=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5' to 6'7\" (150 to 200cm). Width: 4' (120cm).","metres":[1.5,2],"band":[1.5,2],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Regan Nursery","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-Oregold","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5-6 feet","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/oregold-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 3-5 ft Tall, 3-4 ft Wide","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"oregold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.34],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/pl.php?n=17413&tab=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5' to 6'7\" (150 to 200cm). Width: 4' (120cm).","metres":1.2,"band":[1.08,1.32],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Regan Nursery","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-Oregold","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4- feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/oregold-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 3-5 ft Tall, 3-4 ft Wide","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"oregold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["6-10","7-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/pl.php?n=17413&tab=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA zone 6a through 10b.","zones":[6,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Regan Nursery","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-Oregold","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 7-10b","zones":[7,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/oregold-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Heat Tolerant: Thrives in Zones 6-10","zones":[6,10],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"oregold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"oregold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["light","light","light"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/pl.php?n=17413&tab=1","https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-Oregold"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/pl.php?n=17413&tab=1","https://naturehills.com/products/oregold-rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/pl.php?n=17413&tab=1","https://www.summerwindsnursery.com/ca/plants/roses/spring-pkg-roses"]}],"sources":[{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/pl.php?n=17413&tab=1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Mild, fruity fragrance. 25 petals.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Regan Nursery","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-Oregold","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A tinge of saffron on large, rich yellow blooms enhances the cheerful appearance of this delicately scented rose.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/oregold-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sweetly Fragrant Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"SummerWinds Nursery (California garden-center chain)","url":"https://www.summerwindsnursery.com/ca/plants/roses/spring-pkg-roses","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Slight","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"oregold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/oregold-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinators will adore the blooms and Oregold is a mainstay in Cutting Gardens","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"oregold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"oregold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/oregold-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinators will adore the blooms and Oregold is a mainstay in Cutting Gardens","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"oriental-lily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.3,1.83],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,1.83],"band":[0.3,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/a/blog/know-your-lilies-asiatics-orientals-trumpets-and-more","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Heights range from 3 to 4 feet tall.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/flower-bulbs-index/lilies/oriental/the-fragrant-oriental-lily-mixture.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3' to 5'.","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/flower-bulbs/lily-flower-bulbs/oriental-lily-bulbs-mix","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lilies are easy to grow, top out at between 3 and 4 ft in height and can be planted in full or part sun.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"genus":7,"species":1,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"oriental-lily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 8 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.2,0.61],"band":[0.2,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"genus":7,"species":1,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"oriental-lily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","5-9","5-8","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/a/blog/know-your-lilies-asiatics-orientals-trumpets-and-more","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Winter hardy in zones 5-9.","zones":[5,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/flower-bulbs-index/lilies/oriental/the-fragrant-oriental-lily-mixture.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 5-8.","zones":[5,8],"level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/flower-bulbs/lily-flower-bulbs/oriental-lily-bulbs-mix","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/blogs/flower-bulbs/growing-oriental-lilies-planting-care","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They are hardy in zones 3-9 and make long-lasting cut flowers.","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"genus":7,"species":1,"cultivar":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"oriental-lily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium-speciosum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"lilium speciosum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244724","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249980","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244737","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244775","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271494","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/stargazer-lily/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It does best in full sun in the Midwest but will tolerate partial shade.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/flower-bulbs/lily-flower-bulbs/oriental-lily-bulbs-mix","country":"US","form":null,"value":"top out at between 3 and 4 ft in height and can be planted in full or part sun","level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"oriental-lily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","strengths":["strong"],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are tall plants (up to 8 feet), with alternate leaves and many, large, outward-facing, fragrant flowers in various colors, often with contrasting spots on their tepals.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244724","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are very fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249980","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant, dark raspberry flowers (to 3”) have distinctively reflexed tepals with thin white edges, protruding anthers and small green centers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244737","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are very fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244775","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271494","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It features flared, outward-facing, fragrant, deep pink flowers that bloom in July-August on rigid stems rising 36-42\" tall.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/stargazer-lily/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Oriental lilies are renowned for their delightful perfume and flamboyantmid- to late-summer blooms.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/news/lily-more-than-just-an-easter-plant","country":null,"form":null,"value":"As fragrant as the trumpet lilies are, they’re nothing when compared to the Oriental hybrids.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/types-and-divisions-garden-lilies","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are often sweetly scented and can be trumpet, bowl, recurved, or flat.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/a/blog/know-your-lilies-asiatics-orientals-trumpets-and-more","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Oriental lilies are known for their heady fragrance, which will perfume a room or an entire garden.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/flower-bulbs-index/lilies/oriental/the-fragrant-oriental-lily-mixture.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Abundant producers for lush garden display or summer flower arrangements, Orientals have large reflexing flower petals and a wonderfully sweet fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"Van Engelen Wholesale Flower Bulbs","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/flower-bulbs-index/hardy-lilies/oriental/oriental-lily-hachi.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Abundant producers for lush garden display or summer flower arrangements, Oriental Lilies have large, reflexing flower petals and a wonderfully sweet fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/flower-bulbs/lily-flower-bulbs/oriental-lily-bulbs-mix","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This mix is a big bargain, and gives you 3 bulbs of the highly fragrant Oriental Lily group.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/blogs/flower-bulbs/growing-oriental-lilies-planting-care","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The oriental/trumpet lily (aka Orienpet) is the result of hybridizing the fragrant oriental lily with the large flowered trumpet lily.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["lilium speciosum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (lilium speciosum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"14 sources state this trait and the tag is present; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (lilium speciosum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"oriental-lily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These lilies are often used as cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244724","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249980","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244737","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244775","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=271494","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Suitable for use as cut flowers in fresh arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/stargazer-lily/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The satiny flowers have a strong, pleasant fragrance, and make excellent cut flowers (and are heavily utilized by the florist trade).","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/news/lily-more-than-just-an-easter-plant","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Relatively pest-free, lilies make excellent cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/types-and-divisions-garden-lilies","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It has become one of the most recognized cut flowers and landscape plants.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/a/blog/know-your-lilies-asiatics-orientals-trumpets-and-more","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These lilies are among the world's most popular cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/flower-bulbs-index/lilies/oriental/the-fragrant-oriental-lily-mixture.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Prized by garden and floral designers alike, Oriental Lilies are a mainstay of summer perennial gardens and lavish cut flower arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"},{"name":"Van Engelen Wholesale Flower Bulbs","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/flower-bulbs-index/hardy-lilies/oriental/oriental-lily-hachi.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Prized by garden and floral designers alike, Oriental Lilies are a mainstay of summer perennial gardens and lavish cut flower arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/blogs/flower-bulbs/growing-oriental-lilies-planting-care","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Oriental Lilies make wonderful cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["lilium speciosum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (lilium speciosum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"13 sources state this trait and the tag is present; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (lilium speciosum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"oriental-lily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"oriental-lily","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lilium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lilium"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["lilium speciosum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (lilium speciosum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (lilium speciosum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"ornamental-kale","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 10 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The plants grow about a foot wide and 15” tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height: 12 - 15 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The plants can get about 18 inches tall their first year.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"These plants grow approximately 12-in. wide and 15-in. tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ornamental-kale","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The plants grow about a foot wide and 15” tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"These plants grow approximately 12-in. wide and 15-in. tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ornamental-kale","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["6-9","2-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Brassica oleracea, wild cabbage, the species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/brassica-oleracea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[6,9],"level":"species","taxon":"brassica oleracea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Brassica oleracea (Acephala Group), kale / ornamental kale)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269745","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11],"level":"species","taxon":"brassica oleracea"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ornamental-kale","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Brassica oleracea, wild cabbage, the species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/brassica-oleracea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"brassica oleracea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Brassica oleracea (Acephala Group), kale / ornamental kale)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269745","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"brassica oleracea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Brassica oleracea Ornamental Kale Group)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/brassica-oleracea-ornamental-kale-group/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"brassica oleracea"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Charlotte County blog (flowering kale and cabbage, fall colour annual)","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/charlotteco/2025/08/11/it-is-not-too-early-to-think-about-fall-color-success-with-flowering-kale-and-cabbage/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Select a full sunny area to plant","level":"species","taxon":"brassica oleracea"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ornamental-kale","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/brassica-oleracea/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/brassica-oleracea-ornamental-kale-group/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Brassica oleracea, wild cabbage, the species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/brassica-oleracea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"brassica oleracea"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Brassica oleracea Ornamental Kale Group)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/brassica-oleracea-ornamental-kale-group/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"brassica oleracea"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are ncsu.edu. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ornamental-kale","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Charlotte County blog (flowering kale and cabbage, fall colour annual)","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/charlotteco/2025/08/11/it-is-not-too-early-to-think-about-fall-color-success-with-flowering-kale-and-cabbage/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There are even long-stemmed types grown to be used as cut flowers such as ‘Sunrise’, ‘Sunset’ and ‘Crane’.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"brassica oleracea"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ornamental-kale","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ornamental-kale","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Brassica oleracea, wild cabbage, the species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/brassica-oleracea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"brassica oleracea"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ornamental-kale-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ornamental-kale-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ornamental-kale-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ornamental-kale-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ornamental-kale-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ornamental-kale-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ornamental-kale-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ornamental-kale-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":1,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"osteospermum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":1,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.75 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"osteospermum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Osteospermum (group), the genus-wide African daisy entry)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264605","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11],"level":"genus","taxon":"osteospermum"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"genus":1,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"osteospermum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Osteospermum (group), the genus-wide African daisy entry)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264605","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"osteospermum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Osteospermum 'Wildside')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269327","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Osteospermum Bright Lights Purple, the breeder's own page)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/osteospermum/bright-lights-purple-african-daisy-osteospermum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Sun to Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"osteospermum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"osteospermum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (Osteospermum 4D African Daisy, the breeder's own page)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/osteospermum/4d-african-daisy-osteospermum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"osteospermum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"osteospermum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are missouribotanicalgarden.org","urls":["https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264605","https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269327"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Osteospermum (group), the genus-wide African daisy entry)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264605","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"osteospermum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Osteospermum 'Wildside')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=269327","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are missouribotanicalgarden.org. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"14 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"14 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/169433/osteospermum-orange-symphony-symphony-series-pbr/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Pender Pines Garden Center","url":"https://plants.penderpines.com/12210001/Plant/12838/Orange_Symphony_African_Daisy/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sunlight"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Pender Pines Garden Center","url":"https://plants.penderpines.com/12210001/Plant/12838/Orange_Symphony_African_Daisy/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 10-14\" (25-36cm)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 10 - 14\" (25 - 36cm)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Size.- Height from soil level to top of plant plane: Approximately 22.6 cm.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 10-14 in\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"10″-14″ Tall & 14″-20″ Wide\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 25cm - 35cm . Width: 35cm - 50cm.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 14-20\" (36-51cm)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 14 - 20\" (36 - 51cm)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: Approximately 28.4 cm.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 14-20 in\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"10″-14″ Tall & 14″-20″ Wide\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 25cm - 35cm . Width: 35cm - 50cm.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-11","9-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264605","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/osteospermum-serenity/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: Zones 9 - 11","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"Green Things Nursery (Tucson, AZ) plant database","url":"https://greenthingsaz.com/plant_database/osteospermum-spp-african-daisy/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 10 (30°F), Zone 11 (40°F)","zones":[10,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Moose Crossing Garden Center","url":"https://www.moosecrossinggardencenter.com/plant/Osteospermum-ecklonis-SerenityPink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"Sunnyfield Greenhouse & Garden Center","url":"https://www.sunnyfield.com/product/osteospermum-serenity-pink/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Sun to Part Shade"},{"name":"Gardener's Treasures","url":"https://gardenerstreasures.com.au/product/ostoespermum-serenity-pink/","country":"AU","form":null,"value":"Plant in full sun."},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264605","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"Kwantlen Polytechnic University Plant Database","url":"https://plantdatabase.kpu.ca/Plant/oscv","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Sheltered"},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene82d7.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/osteospermum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/osteospermum-serenity/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs: Full Sun, Filtered Sun, Partial Sun, Partial Shade"},{"name":"Green Things Nursery (Tucson, AZ) plant database","url":"https://greenthingsaz.com/plant_database/osteospermum-spp-african-daisy/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Moose Crossing Garden Center","url":"https://www.moosecrossinggardencenter.com/plant/Osteospermum-ecklonis-SerenityPink","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/ Foliage","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Ball Seed PlantInfo (breeder channel)","url":"https://info.ballseed.com/PlantInfo/?phid=046104095004054","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Characteristics: Deer Resistant, Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"osteospermum-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ostrich-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.34],"union":[0.61,1.83],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285874&isprofile=0&basic=Matteuccia+struthiopteris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/onoclea-struthiopteris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Matteuccia-struthiopteris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2-3 ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/matteuccia-struthiopteris-ostrich-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ostrich-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.61,2.44],"split":[{"range":[0.61,1.22],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","Native Plant Trust Plant Finder"]},{"range":[1.52,2.44],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285874&isprofile=0&basic=Matteuccia+struthiopteris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 5.00 to 8.00 feet","metres":[1.52,2.44],"band":[1.52,2.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/onoclea-struthiopteris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Matteuccia-struthiopteris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2-4 ft","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ostrich-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-7","3-8","2-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285874&isprofile=0&basic=Matteuccia+struthiopteris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 7","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/onoclea-struthiopteris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Matteuccia-struthiopteris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 2-8","zones":[2,8]},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/matteuccia-struthiopteris-ostrich-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 2-8","zones":[2,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ostrich-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285874&isprofile=0&basic=Matteuccia+struthiopteris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/onoclea-struthiopteris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Native Plant Trust Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.nativeplanttrust.org/plant/Matteuccia-struthiopteris","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun • Part Shade • Shade"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=mast","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade , Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ostrich-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ostrich-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ostrich-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285874&isprofile=0&basic=Matteuccia+struthiopteris","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soil must never be allowed to dry out.","claim":false},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/onoclea-struthiopteris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It naturally occurs in heavy, moist soil but adapts to light, rich soil and prefers constant moisture.","claim":false}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ostrich-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pachysandra","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.15,0.2],"union":[0.15,0.33],"voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278317","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.50 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pachysandra-terminalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-pachysandra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Japanese pachysandra is a colonizing ground cover that spreads by rhizomes and grows 8 to 12 inches high.","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/pachysandra-terminalis-japanese-pachysandra","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows to 1 feet in height and spreads to an area of 1½ feet.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/groundcovers-shade","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plant reaches 6 to 12 inches tall and prefers partial to full shade.","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"UConn Plant Database, University of Connecticut","url":"https://plantdatabase.uconn.edu/detail.php?pid=298","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows 6\" to 10\" high","metres":[0.15,0.25],"band":[0.15,0.25],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=572&PlantTypeID=6","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 6-12 Inches","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"Illinois Extension Landscaping, Ground Covers","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/landscaping/japanese-spurge","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 6–8 inches tall with shiny evergreen foliage.","metres":[0.15,0.2],"band":[0.15,0.2],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/pachysandra-terminalis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Evergreen ground cover, 6-8 inches (15-20 cm) high.","metres":[0.15,0.2],"band":[0.15,0.2],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"Greenwood Nursery","url":"https://www.greenwoodnursery.com/pachysandra-terminalis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Forms a dense, compact mat 6–8 inches tall","metres":[0.15,0.2],"band":[0.15,0.2],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":10,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"pachysandra","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.46],"union":[0.3,0.51],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278317","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pachysandra-terminalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/pachysandra-terminalis-japanese-pachysandra","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows to 1 feet in height and spreads to an area of 1½ feet.","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":10,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"pachysandra","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","4-9","5-8","4-7","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278317","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pachysandra-terminalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-pachysandra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/pachysandra-terminalis-japanese-pachysandra","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5 - 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=572&PlantTypeID=6","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 4 - 7","zones":[4,7],"level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"Greenwood Nursery","url":"https://www.greenwoodnursery.com/pachysandra-terminalis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Planting Zone 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":10,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"pachysandra","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278317","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pachysandra-terminalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Pachysandra does best in part shade to full shade and is intolerant of full sun as foliage bleaches in full sun or high wind.","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/pachysandra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Both species thrive in partial shade to full shade and prefer well-drained, fertile soils.","level":"genus","taxon":"pachysandra"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-pachysandra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Japanese pachysandra must have at least partial shade to grow well.","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/pachysandra-terminalis-japanese-pachysandra","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This Asian native is familiar as a ground cover in partial- or full-shade areas.","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/groundcovers-shade","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plant reaches 6 to 12 inches tall and prefers partial to full shade.","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"UConn Plant Database, University of Connecticut","url":"https://plantdatabase.uconn.edu/detail.php?pid=298","country":"US","form":null,"value":"needs partial shade to shade","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=572&PlantTypeID=6","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial to full shade. Moist, well drained soil.","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/pachysandra-terminalis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Shade, one of the best ground covers for deep shade, yellows in sun; prefers moist, well-drained, acid soil.","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"Greenwood Nursery","url":"https://www.greenwoodnursery.com/pachysandra-terminalis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Thrives in full shade and partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"pachysandra","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pachysandra-terminalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/pachysandra/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"At the terminal ends of its stems, one- to two-inch long spikes of white, slightly fragrant flowers open in early spring.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"pachysandra"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-pachysandra/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The small, white flowers are borne in spike-like clusters in early spring. They are lightly fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"Illinois Extension Landscaping, Ground Covers","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/landscaping/japanese-spurge","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant white flowers in spring.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"pachysandra","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"pachysandra","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278317","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Heavy Shade, Erosion, Clay Soil, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pachysandra-terminalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Even though pachysandra can tolerate drought conditions, it prefers moist, slightly acidic soils that have high organic matter and are well drained.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/japanese-pachysandra/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pachysandra will not tolerate drought.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=572&PlantTypeID=6","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pests and Problems Environmental Damage Drought Drowning and Edema","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"},{"name":"Greenwood Nursery","url":"https://www.greenwoodnursery.com/pachysandra-terminalis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Is it drought tolerant? Once established, it handles dry shade well.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"}],"note":"3 source(s) state this trait and 2 deny it","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"pachysandra","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pachysandra-terminalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Attracts bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"pachysandra terminalis"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[2.44,3.66],"union":[1.83,3.66],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285194&isprofile=0&basic=Cortaderia+selloana","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8.00 to 12.00 feet","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cortaderia-selloana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6 ft. 0 in. - 12 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.22,1.83],"union":[1.22,2.06],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285194&isprofile=0&basic=Cortaderia+selloana","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cortaderia-selloana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 4 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 9 in.","metres":[1.22,2.06],"band":[1.22,2.06],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["8-10","6-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285194&isprofile=0&basic=Cortaderia+selloana","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8 to 10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cortaderia-selloana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 6a, 6b, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[6,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285194&isprofile=0&basic=Cortaderia+selloana","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cortaderia-selloana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285194&isprofile=0&basic=Cortaderia+selloana","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plumes may be cut and dried for use in indoor flower arrangements.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cortaderia-selloana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy blooms in late summer and fall and are good in cut and dried arrangements.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285194&isprofile=0&basic=Cortaderia+selloana","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates drought once established.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cortaderia-selloana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"is highly salt tolerant, drought tolerant, and is highly resistant to deer grazing","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.92,1.83],"split":[{"range":[0.92,1.12],"sources":["Plant Delights Nursery"]},{"range":[1.22,1.83],"sources":["San Marcos Growers"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/cortaderia-selloana-gold-band","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 40\" tall","metres":1.02,"band":[0.92,1.12],"role":"scored"},{"name":"San Marcos Growers","url":"https://www.smgrowers.com/products/plants/plantdisplay.asp?plant_id=700","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4-6 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"San Marcos Growers","url":"https://www.smgrowers.com/products/plants/plantdisplay.asp?plant_id=700","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 4-6 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["8-10","6-10","7-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285194","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8 to 10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cortaderia-selloana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 6a, 6b, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[6,10]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/cortaderia-selloana-gold-band","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 7a to 10b","zones":[7,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285194","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cortaderia-selloana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"San Marcos Growers","url":"https://www.smgrowers.com/products/plants/plantdisplay.asp?plant_id=700","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"San Marcos Growers","url":"https://www.smgrowers.com/products/plants/plantdisplay.asp?plant_id=700","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Summer Dry: Yes","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass-gold","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/cortaderia-selloana-gold-band","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterfly Attracting Plants","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[2.44,2.5],"union":[1.5,3.05],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/79722/cortaderia-selloana-rosea/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/cortaderia-selloana-rosea.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 240-300 cm 94-117 inches","metres":[2.4,3],"band":[2.4,3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/grass-pampas-pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 8-10 Feet","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Grass-Pampas-Pink-Cortaderia-Selloana-Rosea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8-10 ft","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1,1.22],"union":[0.9,1.8],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/79722/cortaderia-selloana-rosea/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/cortaderia-selloana-rosea.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 90-180 cm 35-70 inches","metres":[0.9,1.8],"band":[0.9,1.8],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/grass-pampas-pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["8-10","6-10","8-9","7-10","7-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (species page, Cortaderia selloana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285194&isprofile=0&basic=Cortaderia+selloana","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8 to 10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Cortaderia selloana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cortaderia-selloana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 6a, 6b, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[6,10]},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/cortaderia-selloana-rosea.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 8-9","zones":[8,9]},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/grass-pampas-pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 7-10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Grass-Pampas-Pink-Cortaderia-Selloana-Rosea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 7-9","zones":[7,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (species page, Cortaderia selloana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285194&isprofile=0&basic=Cortaderia+selloana","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Cortaderia selloana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cortaderia-selloana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/79722/cortaderia-selloana-rosea/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/cortaderia-selloana-rosea.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/grass-pampas-pink","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States"},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Grass-Pampas-Pink-Cortaderia-Selloana-Rosea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure • Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/79722/cortaderia-selloana-rosea/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Prairie planting Cut flowers Flower borders and beds","claim":true},{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/cortaderia-selloana-rosea.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent planted as a privacy screen and for drying.","claim":true},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/grass-pampas-pink","country":null,"form":null,"value":"• Cut Flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Swift Greenhouses","url":"https://www.swiftgreenhouses.com/plant/Grass-Pampas-Pink-Cortaderia-Selloana-Rosea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dried Flower/Foliage","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/79722/cortaderia-selloana-rosea/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/grass-pampas-pink","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pampas-grass-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pansy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":6,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 4 in. - 0 ft. 9 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.50 to 0.75 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Pansies reach ½ to 1 foot in height and width, while flower diameters reach up to 4 inches.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Pansies are compact, not more than 12 inches in both height and spread.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Pansy Viola x wittrockiana Sun to part shade 6–12”\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"pansy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":6,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 9 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.75 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Pansies reach ½ to 1 foot in height and width, while flower diameters reach up to 4 inches.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Pansies are compact, not more than 12 inches in both height and spread.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"pansy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"CONVENTION","wouldPropose":[6,10],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Viola x wittrockiana, pansy)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/viola-x-wittrockiana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[6,10],"level":"species","taxon":"viola wittrockiana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viola x wittrockiana, pansy)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=291362","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 6 to 10","zones":[6,10],"level":"species","taxon":"viola wittrockiana"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":6,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source states 6-10 and this row deliberately stores no zones, which is the library's way of saying \"grown everywhere\" (docs/CATALOG-AUDIT.md records the two zone conventions for annuals as expected). Nothing is proposed: writing a zone range onto a zone-less row would remove it from every zone filter outside that range, and this is one library-wide decision rather than a per-plant error; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"pansy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Viola x wittrockiana, pansy)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/viola-x-wittrockiana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Pansy prefers full sun to part shade in humus-rich soils that are consistently moist and well-drained.","level":"species","taxon":"viola wittrockiana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viola x wittrockiana, pansy)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=291362","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"viola wittrockiana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Viola, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/viola/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"viola"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension (Annual and Perennial Flowers for Mississippi Gardens, Table 1 pansy row)","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/publications/annual-and-perennial-flowers-for-mississippi-gardens","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"viola wittrockiana"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (Pansy Seeds, Viola x wittrockiana)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/pansies.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"viola wittrockiana"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"pansy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Viola x wittrockiana, pansy)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/viola-x-wittrockiana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"viola wittrockiana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viola x wittrockiana, pansy)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=291362","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"viola wittrockiana"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Pansies & Johnny-Jump-Ups, Viola x wittrockiana)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/pansies-and-johnny-jump-ups/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Some pansies have a sweet scent. They are most fragrant at early morning and dusk.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"viola wittrockiana"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"pansy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (Pansy Seeds, Viola x wittrockiana)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/pansies.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soft pastel pansies in cream, gold, peach, apricot, rose, and white shades make great cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"viola wittrockiana"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"pansy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"pansy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Viola x wittrockiana, pansy)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/viola-x-wittrockiana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are attractive to butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"viola wittrockiana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viola x wittrockiana, pansy)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=291362","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"viola wittrockiana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Viola, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/viola/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nectar from the flowers attracts butterflies and bees.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"viola"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"parsley","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.23,0.36],"union":[0.2,1.22],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276060&isprofile=0&basic=Petroselinum+crispum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/petroselinum-crispum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 8 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.2,0.91],"band":[0.2,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/yard-and-garden/growing-parsley","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Curly parsley typically grows 8 to 14 inches tall.","metres":[0.2,0.36],"band":[0.2,0.36],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/parsley-petroselinum-crispum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The rosette of leafy stems grows 12-18″ tall in the first year.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Mountain Valley Growers","url":"https://mountainvalleygrowers.com/organic-plants/petroselinum-crispum-curled-parsely","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 2 Feet (up to 4 feet if left to bloom)","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"parsley","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.23,0.3],"union":[0.2,0.3],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276060&isprofile=0&basic=Petroselinum+crispum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/petroselinum-crispum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 8 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"parsley","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-11","5-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276060&isprofile=0&basic=Petroselinum+crispum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11]},{"name":"Mountain Valley Growers","url":"https://mountainvalleygrowers.com/organic-plants/petroselinum-crispum-curled-parsely","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Biennial in Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"parsley","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276060&isprofile=0&basic=Petroselinum+crispum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/petroselinum-crispum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Mountain Valley Growers","url":"https://mountainvalleygrowers.com/organic-plants/petroselinum-crispum-curled-parsely","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Characteristics Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"parsley","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276060&isprofile=0&basic=Petroselinum+crispum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is now grown world-wide for its is aromatic edible leaves which may be used fresh or dried in soups, salads and a wide variety of other food dishes","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/petroselinum-crispum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Edible Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/parsley-petroselinum-crispum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"All plant parts have the same characteristic aroma, although it is strongest in the roots.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"parsley","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"parsley","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276060&isprofile=0&basic=Petroselinum+crispum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Do not allow soils to dry out.","claim":false},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/petroselinum-crispum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Parsley prefers consistently moist, well-drained rich soil in full sun or light shade.","claim":false},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/yard-and-garden/growing-parsley","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Do not allow the plants to dry out completely between watering in the garden.","claim":false},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/edibles/vegetables/parsley/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Keep the soil moist for best results and be sure to carefully weed.","claim":false},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/herbs/parsley","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Parsley prefers a moderately rich, moist, well-drained soil and will grow in a partially shaded area.","claim":false}],"note":"5 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"parsley","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276060&isprofile=0&basic=Petroselinum+crispum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Parsley is a larval food plant for the black swallowtail butterfly.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/petroselinum-crispum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Host plant for swallowtail butterfly.","claim":true},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/edibles/vegetables/parsley/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It will bolt and flower eventually, but the good news is that bees and other pollinators love the blooms.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"passionflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":4,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1.83,12.19],"split":[{"range":[1.83,2.44],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Passiflora incarnata)"]},{"range":[3.05,12.19],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Passiflora caerulea)","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Passiflora caerulea)","Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Passiflora incarnata)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Passiflora incarnata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284891","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6.00 to 8.00 feet","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Passiflora caerulea)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284901","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10.00 to 25.00 feet","metres":[3.05,7.62],"band":[3.05,7.62],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Passiflora caerulea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/passiflora-caerulea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10 ft. 0 in. - 40 ft. 0 in.","metres":[3.05,12.19],"band":[3.05,12.19],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Passiflora incarnata)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PAIN6","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size Notes: Climber, up to about 25 feet long.","metres":7.62,"band":[6.86,8.38],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"passionflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1.83],"union":[0.91,1.83],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Passiflora incarnata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284891","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Passiflora caerulea)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284901","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Passiflora caerulea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/passiflora-caerulea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"passionflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","7-9","6-10","7-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Passiflora incarnata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284891","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Passiflora caerulea)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284901","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 7 to 9","zones":[7,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Passiflora caerulea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/passiflora-caerulea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[6,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Passiflora incarnata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/passiflora-incarnata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions (Passion Flower)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/passion-flower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"native to Florida and hardy in zones 7B-11","zones":[7,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"passionflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Passiflora incarnata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284891","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Passiflora caerulea)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284901","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Passiflora caerulea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/passiflora-caerulea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Passiflora incarnata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/passiflora-incarnata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Passiflora incarnata)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PAIN6","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions (Passion Flower)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/passion-flower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These species perform best in full sun but can tolerate some shade."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"passionflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Passiflora incarnata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284891","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Passiflora caerulea)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284901","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Passiflora incarnata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/passiflora-incarnata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Edible Fragrant Long Bloom Season Showy","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"passionflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"passionflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Passiflora incarnata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284891","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Passiflora incarnata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/passiflora-incarnata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Heat","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions (Passion Flower)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/passion-flower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Passion flower can tolerate very dry conditions and is resistant to pests.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"passionflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Passiflora incarnata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284891","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Passiflora caerulea)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284901","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Passiflora incarnata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/passiflora-incarnata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Hummingbirds Pollinators Songbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Passiflora incarnata)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PAIN6","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions (Passion Flower)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/passion-flower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract hummingbirds and butterflies in the summer and fall.","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"passionflower-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Climber","sourcesDropped":9,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 10.00 to 12.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height 6.00 m\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 15 m\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"To 4m or more.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 20 ft – 30 ft\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"quickly grow up to 10-12 feet long\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Growing 10 to 12 feet tall and 3 to 5 feet wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 10′-12′\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height : 10 ft.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"passionflower-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Climber","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 3.00 to 5.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 m\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Growing 10 to 12 feet tall and 3 to 5 feet wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 3′-5′\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"passionflower-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-12","10-11","9-11","9-9","10-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284903","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 12","zones":[10,12]},{"name":"PlantVine","url":"https://www.plantvine.com/product/passiflora-coccinea-red-passionflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 10a, 10b, 11a","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"Top Tropicals","url":"https://toptropicals.com/catalog/uid/passiflora_coccinea.htm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 9-11","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"Greenleaf Nursery Company","url":"https://www.greenleafnursery.com/plant/Passiflora-Passiflora-coccinea-Vine-Red","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Z9 - Cold Hardy 20 to 30F","zones":[9,9]},{"name":"Hill Country Water Gardens and Nursery","url":"https://hillcountrywatergardens.com/product/red-passion-vine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 10","zones":[10,10]},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/red-passion-flower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones: 3-11 patio / 10-11 outdoors","zones":[10,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"passionflower-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284903","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NParks Flora and Fauna Web (National Parks Board, Singapore)","url":"https://www.nparks.gov.sg/florafaunaweb/flora/1/4/1465","country":"SG","form":null,"value":"Light Preference Full Sun"},{"name":"GardensOnline (Australia)","url":"https://www.gardensonline.com.au/GardenShed/PlantFinder/Show_1842.aspx","country":"AU","form":null,"value":"Light: Full Sun"},{"name":"PlantVine","url":"https://www.plantvine.com/product/passiflora-coccinea-red-passionflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Partial Sun"},{"name":"Top Tropicals","url":"https://toptropicals.com/catalog/uid/passiflora_coccinea.htm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Thrives in full sun or part shade, in fertile, moist, well-drained soils."},{"name":"Hill Country Water Gardens and Nursery","url":"https://hillcountrywatergardens.com/product/red-passion-vine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/red-passion-flower","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight : Full Sun, Partial Shade"},{"name":"Ladybird Nursery (Australia)","url":"https://ladybirdnursery.com.au/products/passiflora-coccinea-red-passionflower","country":"AU","form":null,"value":"Prefers full sun to part shade with well-drained soil."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"passionflower-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"passionflower-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"passionflower-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Hill Country Water Gardens and Nursery","url":"https://hillcountrywatergardens.com/product/red-passion-vine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Prefers consistent water, full sun, and well-drained soil","claim":false},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/red-passion-flower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"passionflower-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=284903","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds and butterflies are attracted to the flowers.","claim":true},{"name":"Useful Tropical Plants (tropical.theferns.info)","url":"https://tropical.theferns.info/viewtropical.php?id=Passiflora+coccinea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinators Bees","claim":true},{"name":"Top Tropicals","url":"https://toptropicals.com/catalog/uid/passiflora_coccinea.htm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attracting butterflies and hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Hill Country Water Gardens and Nursery","url":"https://hillcountrywatergardens.com/product/red-passion-vine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Big, showy red flowers attract hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Ladybird Nursery (Australia)","url":"https://ladybirdnursery.com.au/products/passiflora-coccinea-red-passionflower","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attract pollinators such as bees and butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peace-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.23,1.34],"union":[0.91,1.83],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252321&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/peace","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4' x 3'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://www.springhillnursery.com/products/peace-hybrid-tea-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mature Height 4.5 feet","metres":1.37,"band":[1.23,1.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/peace-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mature Height: 4 to 6 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/peace-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mature Height : 4-6 ft.","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Palatine Fruit and Roses","url":"https://palatinefruit.com/product/peace-rose/","country":"CA","form":"shrub","value":"Plant Height 3' - 4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/peace/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4-5 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"peace-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.82,1],"union":[0.61,1.22],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252321&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/peace","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4' x 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://www.springhillnursery.com/products/peace-hybrid-tea-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Spread: 36 - 48 inches","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/peace-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mature width: 3 to 4 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/peace-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mature Width : 2-3 ft.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"peace-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","5-10","4-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252321&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/peace","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 5-10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://www.springhillnursery.com/products/peace-hybrid-tea-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zones 4-10","zones":[4,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/peace-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/peace-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Growing Zones: 5-10 outdoors","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Palatine Fruit and Roses","url":"https://palatinefruit.com/product/peace-rose/","country":"CA","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zones USDA 5 - 10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/peace/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone: 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"peace-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252321&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/peace","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sun Requires 6+ hours of direct sunlight to thrive.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://www.springhillnursery.com/products/peace-hybrid-tea-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/peace-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Sunlight: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/peace-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Sunlight : Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Roses require full sun and organically rich, well-drained, acidic to neutral soils.","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"peace-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","strengths":["light","light"],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252321&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://www.heirloomroses.com/products/peace","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Very Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://www.springhillnursery.com/products/peace-hybrid-tea-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"a mildly fruity fragrance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/peace-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Mild Sweet","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/peace-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"known for its sweet fragrance that's ideal for cut flower arrangements","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Palatine Fruit and Roses","url":"https://palatinefruit.com/product/peace-rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are often fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"peace-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252321&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A good cut rose due to fragrance and large bloom size.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Spring Hill Nursery","url":"https://www.springhillnursery.com/products/peace-hybrid-tea-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Classic hybrid tea rose for exquisite bouquets","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/peace-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Landscape Uses: Cut flower gardens, rose beds, sunny borders, foundation plantings, specimen shrub, classic formal gardens","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/peace-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"known for its sweet fragrance that's ideal for cut flower arrangements","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rogue Valley Roses","url":"https://roguevalleyroses.com/rose/peace/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Uses: Good for cutting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"peace-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/peace-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance: Not reliably deer resistant; better disease performance with sun + airflow; moderate drought tolerance once established","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"peace-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252321&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/peace-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Attracts bees and beneficial pollinators when blooming","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"penstemon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":12,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":12,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 12 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"penstemon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":12,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"penstemon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":12,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":12,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 12 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"penstemon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/penstemon/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Penstemon plants tend to do best sited in full sun and well-drained soil.","level":"genus","taxon":"penstemon"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/penstemon-digitalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"penstemon digitalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/penstemon-smallii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"penstemon smallii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g590","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"penstemon digitalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=e510","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"penstemon barbatus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a127","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"penstemon grandiflorus"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PEDI","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade","level":"species","taxon":"penstemon digitalis"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Flowers)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/penstemon","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun, Partial Sun/Shade","level":"species","taxon":"penstemon barbatus"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=740&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Full Sun Partial Sun/Shade","level":"species","taxon":"penstemon barbatus"},{"name":"Colorado State University Extension","url":"https://extension.colostate.edu/resource/growing-penstemons/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most penstemons require at least six hours of full sun to produce erect stems with flowers of clear, bright colors able to withstand wind and rain.","level":"genus","taxon":"penstemon"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/husker-red-foxglove-beardtongue-penstemon-digitalis-husker-red/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Although it can tolerate partial shade, grow ‘Husker Red’ in full sun for the most intense leaf color.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"penstemon digitalis"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/plants/smalls-beardtongue/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Small’s beardtongue does best in well-drained to dry soils and partial shade to full sun locations.","level":"species","taxon":"penstemon smallii"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/firecracker-penstemon-in-the-landscape","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun/Shade Preference: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"penstemon eatonii"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/penstemon-digitalis-foxglove-beardtongue","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"penstemon digitalis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"penstemon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["penstemon digitalis"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (penstemon digitalis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (penstemon digitalis) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"penstemon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g590","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for fresh cut flower arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"penstemon digitalis"},{"name":"Colorado State University Extension","url":"https://extension.colostate.edu/resource/growing-penstemons/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Penstemons grown in containers or as cut flowers will benefit from light fertilizer applications to improve the length and vigor of flowering.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"penstemon"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/husker-red-foxglove-beardtongue-penstemon-digitalis-husker-red/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They can also be used as cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"penstemon digitalis"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/firecracker-penstemon-in-the-landscape","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use in the Landscape: Borders, accents, rock gardens; often recommended as cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"penstemon eatonii"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"penstemon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/penstemon-digitalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"penstemon digitalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/penstemon-smallii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The rosette of leaves is often evergreen through winter and the tap root makes it drought-tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"penstemon smallii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g590","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"penstemon digitalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=e510","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerant of drought and shallow, rocky soils.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"penstemon barbatus"},{"name":"Colorado State University Extension","url":"https://extension.colostate.edu/resource/growing-penstemons/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Overall, most penstemons are considered drought tolerant, though many hybrids and eastern/midwestern or alpine species will need supplemental irrigation if grown at lower elevations in Colorado.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"penstemon"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/husker-red-foxglove-beardtongue-penstemon-digitalis-husker-red/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It does best in well-drained loam, but grows well in clay soils, and it is drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"penstemon digitalis"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/firecracker-penstemon-in-the-landscape","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerance: High","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"penstemon eatonii"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"penstemon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/penstemon/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Members of the genus Penstemon are good nectar plants and support the specialized bee Osmia (Melanosmia) distincta.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"penstemon"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/penstemon-digitalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant attracts birds, hummingbirds, bees, butterflies, and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"penstemon digitalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/penstemon-smallii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Hummingbirds Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"penstemon smallii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=g590","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"penstemon digitalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=e510","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"penstemon barbatus"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PEDI","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use Wildlife: Hummingbirds and bumblebees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"penstemon digitalis"},{"name":"Colorado State University Extension","url":"https://extension.colostate.edu/resource/growing-penstemons/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Penstemons attract hummingbirds, butterflies, and bees.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"penstemon"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/husker-red-foxglove-beardtongue-penstemon-digitalis-husker-red/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"are attractive to bees and butterflies, and may be visited by hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"penstemon digitalis"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/penstemon-digitalis-foxglove-beardtongue-prairie-moon-nursery.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The tubular flowers of this plant attract long-tongued bees, including honeybees, bumblebees, Miner bees, Mason bees, and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"penstemon digitalis"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/firecracker-penstemon-in-the-landscape","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The bright red tubular flower makes it a favorite nectar source for hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"penstemon eatonii"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/penstemon-digitalis-foxglove-beardtongue","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Various bees are the principal pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"penstemon digitalis"}],"note":"11 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"pentas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":3},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"It is a tropical woody-based perennial or subshrub that grows 3-6’ tall in its native habitat, but more typically to 1-2’ tall in beds or containers in the St. Louis area.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Most pentas grow about 15 inches wide and 2 to 3 feet tall, so be sure to leave ample space for them to grow if planting in beds.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"pentas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":3},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Most pentas grow about 15 inches wide and 2 to 3 feet tall, so be sure to leave ample space for them to grow if planting in beds.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"pentas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Pentas lanceolata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pentas-lanceolata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[10,11],"level":"species","taxon":"pentas lanceolata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Pentas lanceolata)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286726","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11],"level":"species","taxon":"pentas lanceolata"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":3},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"pentas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Pentas lanceolata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pentas-lanceolata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"pentas lanceolata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Pentas lanceolata)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286726","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"pentas lanceolata"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions (Pentas lanceolata)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/pentas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"For best results, plant pentas in late spring in a site that receives full sun and has well-drained soil.","level":"species","taxon":"pentas lanceolata"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"pentas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"pentas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Pentas lanceolata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pentas-lanceolata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"pentas lanceolata"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"pentas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Pentas lanceolata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pentas-lanceolata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Popular bedding plant with moderate to high drought tolerance.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"pentas lanceolata"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"pentas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Pentas lanceolata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pentas-lanceolata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"pentas lanceolata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Pentas lanceolata)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286726","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Highly attractive to hummingbirds, butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"pentas lanceolata"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension, Gardening Solutions (Pentas lanceolata)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/pentas/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These attractive plants produce red, pink, or white flowers throughout the summer and are a great source of food for hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"pentas lanceolata"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"pentas-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 2 to 3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Most pentas grow about 15 inches wide and 2 to 3 feet tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pentas-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 2 to 3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Most pentas grow about 15 inches wide and 2 to 3 feet tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pentas-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-11","8-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286726","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pentas-lanceolata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FP465, Pentas lanceolata fact sheet)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP465","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA hardiness zones: 8B through 11","zones":[8,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pentas-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286726","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pentas-lanceolata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FP465, Pentas lanceolata fact sheet)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP465","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in part shade/part sun"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/pentas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"plant pentas in late spring in a site that receives full sun and has well-drained soil"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pentas-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pentas-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pentas-lanceolata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FP465, Pentas lanceolata fact sheet)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP465","country":null,"form":null,"value":"long-lasting as cut flowers","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pentas-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pentas-lanceolata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Popular bedding plant with moderate to high drought tolerance.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pentas-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286726","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Highly attractive to hummingbirds, butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pentas-lanceolata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FP465, Pentas lanceolata fact sheet)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP465","country":null,"form":null,"value":"these blossoms are extremely popular with butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/pentas/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"a great source of food for hummingbirds and butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pentas-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pentas-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pentas-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pentas-lanceolata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286726","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pentas-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pentas-lanceolata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286726","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pentas-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pentas-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pentas-lanceolata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pentas-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pentas-lanceolata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Popular bedding plant with moderate to high drought tolerance.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pentas-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/pentas-lanceolata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds are attracted to the red variety, their first choice in a garden.","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286726","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Highly attractive to hummingbirds, butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.91],"union":[0.3,0.91],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/paeonia-herbaceous-types/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension (G6650, Selecting Landscape Plants: Herbaceous Perennials)","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/publications/g6650","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Peony (Paeonia hybrids) 18-36","metres":[0.46,0.91],"band":[0.46,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/paeonia-herbaceous-types/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/paeonia-herbaceous-types/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/peony/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone : 3-8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/paeonia-herbaceous-types/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/peony/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full sun (6 - 8 hours of direct sun)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/paeonia-herbaceous-types/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/peony/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"celebrated for their large, fragrant blooms and exceptional longevity","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/paeonia-herbaceous-types/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/paeonia-herbaceous-types/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and pollen-eating beetles.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-coral-sunset","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.76,0.81],"union":[0.71,0.91],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255500","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.50 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/peony-coral-sunset.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"28\" to 32\" tall and 3' to 4' wide.","metres":[0.71,0.81],"band":[0.71,0.81],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-coral-sunset","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.61,1.22],"split":[{"range":[0.61,0.76],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder"]},{"range":[0.91,1.22],"sources":["Van Engelen"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255500","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/peony-coral-sunset.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"28\" to 32\" tall and 3' to 4' wide.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-coral-sunset","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255500","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/peony-coral-sunset.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 4-8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-coral-sunset","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255500","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-coral-sunset","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","strengths":["light"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/peony-coral-sunset.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A vigorous grower, it is lightly fragrant.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-coral-sunset","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255500","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cut flower.","claim":true},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/peony-coral-sunset.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Our beautiful prized display and cut flower Herbaceous Peonies have been divided and nursery-grown in the Netherlands for two years prior to export.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-coral-sunset","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-coral-sunset","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255500","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-festiva-maxima","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/paeonia-festiva-maxima-festiva-maxima-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"36 inches","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-festiva-maxima","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-festiva-maxima","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/paeonia-festiva-maxima-festiva-maxima-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 - 7","zones":[4,7]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-festiva-maxima","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/paeonia-festiva-maxima-festiva-maxima-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-festiva-maxima","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/paeonia-festiva-maxima-festiva-maxima-peony","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its pure white blooms, dotted with red at its center, are fragrant and double.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-festiva-maxima","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/paeonia-festiva-maxima-festiva-maxima-peony","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its stems are strong, making it the perfect candidate for a vase.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-festiva-maxima","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-festiva-maxima","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-kansas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.55,0.91],"split":[{"range":[0.55,0.67],"sources":["Monrovia"]},{"range":[0.76,0.91],"sources":["Prides Corner Farms"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/kansas-double-peony.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"reaches 2 ft. tall","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Paeonia-lactiflora-Kansas-Peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"30-36 in","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-kansas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.91],"union":[0.46,0.91],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/kansas-double-peony.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2 to 3 ft. wide","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Paeonia-lactiflora-Kansas-Peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"18-24 in","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-kansas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.monrovia.com/kansas-double-peony.html","https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Paeonia-lactiflora-Kansas-Peony"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/kansas-double-peony.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4-8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Paeonia-lactiflora-Kansas-Peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4-8","zones":[4,8]}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[4,8]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-kansas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/kansas-double-peony.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Paeonia-lactiflora-Kansas-Peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun or partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-kansas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","strengths":["light"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Paeonia-lactiflora-Kansas-Peony","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lightly fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-kansas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.monrovia.com/kansas-double-peony.html","https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Paeonia-lactiflora-Kansas-Peony"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/kansas-double-peony.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Choice cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Prides Corner Farms","url":"https://www.pridescorner.com/plant-name/Paeonia-lactiflora-Kansas-Peony","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-kansas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-kansas","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-karl-rosenfield","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.76,0.91],"union":[0.61,0.91],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251385","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2.50 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-peony-karl-rosenfield","country":"US","form":null,"value":"24-36\" tall","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-karl-rosenfield","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.76,0.91],"union":[0.61,0.91],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251385","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2.50 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-peony-karl-rosenfield","country":"US","form":null,"value":"24-36\" wide","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-karl-rosenfield","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251385","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-peony-karl-rosenfield","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 3-8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-karl-rosenfield","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251385","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-peony-karl-rosenfield","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-karl-rosenfield","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251385","country":null,"form":null,"value":"An old standard that features mildly fragrant, bright crimson, double flowers","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-karl-rosenfield","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251385","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cut flower.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-karl-rosenfield","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-karl-rosenfield","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251385","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"peony-sarah-bernhardt","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.86,0.91],"union":[0.5,1],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251739","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.50 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/91077/paeonia-lactiflora-sarah-bernhardt/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-peony-sarah-bernhardt","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 34-36\" tall","metres":[0.86,0.91],"band":[0.86,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height\n3 ft","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height/Habit 36 inches","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed & Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 24 - 30 inches","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sarah Bernhardt Peony will grow to be about 30 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 3 feet.","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pink-sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height\n3 Feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/sarah-bernhardt-peony/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing to a height of 2–3 feet with a similar spread, this peony forms a rounded mound of lush, deep green foliage that stays attractive throughout the growing season.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":9,"genus":2,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"peony-sarah-bernhardt","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.5,1],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251739","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.50 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/91077/paeonia-lactiflora-sarah-bernhardt/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-peony-sarah-bernhardt","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 24-36\" wide","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width\n3 ft","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed & Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 24 - 36 inches.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sarah Bernhardt Peony will grow to be about 30 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 3 feet.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pink-sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread\n2 Feet","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":9,"genus":2,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"peony-sarah-bernhardt","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251739","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-peony-sarah-bernhardt","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Cold Hardy: Thrives in Zones 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed & Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone\n3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pink-sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones\n3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/sarah-bernhardt-peony/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy in USDA zones 3–8, this plant thrives in sunny borders, cottage gardens, and mixed perennial beds.","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"cultivar":9,"genus":2,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"peony-sarah-bernhardt","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":11,"distinctPublishers":11,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251739","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/paeonia-herbaceous-types/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"paeonia"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/peony/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"paeonia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"paeonia hybrida"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/91077/paeonia-lactiflora-sarah-bernhardt/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-peony-sarah-bernhardt","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight\nFull sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed & Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pink-sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Shade to Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/sarah-bernhardt-peony/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Prefers full sun but tolerates partial shade in warmer climates.","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"peony-sarah-bernhardt","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251739","country":null,"form":null,"value":"An old standard that features very large, very fragrant, rose-pink double flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/paeonia-herbaceous-types/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#fragrant flowers","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"paeonia"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/peony/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Peonies are a perennial garden favorite, celebrated for their large, fragrant blooms and exceptional longevity.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"paeonia"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/91077/paeonia-lactiflora-sarah-bernhardt/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"erect stems bearing fragrant, rose-pink double flowers 20cm in width","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-peony-sarah-bernhardt","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The famously fragrant flowers attract a host of pollinators and are a favorite of bees.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These mammoth pink, double flowers are packed with ruffled petals and so incredibly fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants are very robust, floriferous and fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed & Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sarah Bernhardt's large pink flowers perfumes the late spring air with its sweet fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sarah Bernhardt Peony features bold fragrant shell pink flowers at the ends of the stems from late spring to early summer.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pink-sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is as well-known for its captivating aroma as it is for its size.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/sarah-bernhardt-peony/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sarah Bernhardt Peony is a classic herbaceous perennial celebrated for its beauty and fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"11 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"peony-sarah-bernhardt","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251739","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/paeonia-herbaceous-types/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Peonies are used as a specimen plant, in borders, and in the cutting garden.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"paeonia"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/91077/paeonia-lactiflora-sarah-bernhardt/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-peony-sarah-bernhardt","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Also known for its fragrance, 'Sarah Bernhardt' makes a great cut flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sarah Bernhardt is a wonderful long-lasting cut flower for your vase arrangements","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Superb cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed & Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Enjoy the showy, 6-in. flowers in the garden and cut-flower arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Gertens","url":"https://www.gertens.com/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pink-sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are favorite cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/sarah-bernhardt-peony/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Their delightful scent and stunning appearance make them highly valued for garden displays and cut flower arrangements alike.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"10 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"peony-sarah-bernhardt","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/peony/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance will increase with age of the plant.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"paeonia"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cold hardy, Low Maintenance, Flowering, Fragrant, Deer-resistant, Drought resistant, Attracts pollinators, Disease resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"peony-sarah-bernhardt","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251739","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/paeonia-herbaceous-types/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and pollen-eating beetles.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"paeonia"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/peony/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Peonies are not typically considered a top choice for pollinator gardens due to short bloom times and hybrid flower structure.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"paeonia"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-peony-sarah-bernhardt","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The famously fragrant flowers attract a host of pollinators and are a favorite of bees.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies and pollinators will adore these blooms as much as you will!","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"paeonia lactiflora"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/pink-sarah-bernhardt-peony","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sarah Bernhardt buds secrete a sweet nectar that attracts pollinators of all kinds and are a favorite of bees.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/sarah-bernhardt-peony/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"periwinkle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.15,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.08,2.01],"split":[{"range":[0.08,0.5],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","Patuxent Nursery","American Meadows","Royal Horticultural Society","Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1112"]},{"range":[1.65,2.01],"sources":["University of Missouri IPM, Fall Garden"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vinca-minor/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 3 in. - 0 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276078","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.25 to 0.50 feet","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1112","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/how-to-grow-periwinkle-vinca-spp-in-south-carolina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Vinca minor grows about 6 inches tall","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=585&PlantTypeID=6","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 3-6 Inches","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/18973/vinca-minor/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-vinca-minor","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 4-6\" tall","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/2001/5-4-2001/vinca.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Common periwinkle grows 3-6 inches tall and spreads over 2 feet.","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"University of Missouri IPM, Fall Garden","url":"https://ipm.missouri.edu/garden/newcomer_F3.cfm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"trailing vine that can reach up to 6 feet in height if given support","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/vinca-minor-periwinkle/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This perennial reaches a height of 3–6 inches and spreads 18–24 inches per plant","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"periwinkle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.15,1.5],"split":[{"range":[0.15,0.67],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","American Meadows","Patuxent Nursery","Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden"]},{"range":[1,1.5],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vinca-minor/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.15,0.46],"band":[0.15,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276078","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.50 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.15,0.46],"band":[0.15,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/18973/vinca-minor/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-vinca-minor","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread Up to 18\" wide","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/2001/5-4-2001/vinca.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Common periwinkle grows 3-6 inches tall and spreads over 2 feet.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/vinca-minor-periwinkle/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This perennial reaches a height of 3–6 inches and spreads 18–24 inches per plant","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"periwinkle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","4-8","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vinca-minor/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276078","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=585&PlantTypeID=6","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 4 - 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-vinca-minor","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ZONES 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/vinca-minor-common-periwinkle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/vinca-minor-periwinkle/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is suitable for USDA Hardiness Zones 4–9","zones":[4,9],"level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"periwinkle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vinca-minor/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"prefers full sun, partial shade, or dappled sunlight","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276078","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1112","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/how-to-grow-periwinkle-vinca-spp-in-south-carolina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Partial shade preferred; tolerant of full sun","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=585&PlantTypeID=6","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to shade. Best growth occur with at least some shade.","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/18973/vinca-minor/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full shade, Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-vinca-minor","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun Half Sun / Half Shade","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/2001/5-4-2001/vinca.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This species is a viney broadleaf evergreen and is commonly used as a groundcover in partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/vinca-minor-common-periwinkle","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/vinca-minor-periwinkle/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Vinca minor grows best in partial sun to full shade but tolerates full sun in cooler climates.","level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"periwinkle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"periwinkle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"periwinkle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vinca-minor/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Dry Soil Erosion Heavy Shade Poor Soil Salt","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276078","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Heavy Shade, Erosion, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-vinca-minor","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates Dry Sites","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/vinca-minor-periwinkle/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, Vinca minor is drought-tolerant and requires only occasional watering during extended dry periods.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"periwinkle","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/vinca-minor/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract bumblebees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"},{"name":"Patuxent Nursery","url":"https://patuxentnursery.com/product/vinca-minor-periwinkle/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vinca minor also attracts pollinators like bees, enhancing the ecological value of any garden.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"vinca minor"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"petunia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":4,"cultivar":1,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.75 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height can vary from 6 inches to 18 inches.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Some petunias will only grow to be about 6 inches tall while others can get over a foot tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"petunia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":4,"cultivar":1,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread can be from 18 inches to 4 feet.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The spread of your petunia plant will depend on the variety as well, with some varieties spreading only about 18 inches while others can spread out as much as 4 feet.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"petunia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-11","9-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Petunia (group))","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264607","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11],"level":"genus","taxon":"petunia"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Petunia)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/petunia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"However, if you live in Zones 9-11 you may be able to get them to return.","zones":[9,11],"level":"genus","taxon":"petunia"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"genus":4,"cultivar":1,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"petunia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Petunia (group))","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264607","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"genus","taxon":"petunia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Petunia 'Ustuni6001' SUPERTUNIA VISTA BUBBLEGUM)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=259868","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Petunia x hybrida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/petunia-x-hybrida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"petunia hybrida"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Petunia)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/petunia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Petunias should be planted in full sunlight.","level":"genus","taxon":"petunia"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions (Petunias)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/petunias/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Petunias will grow best in full sun and well-drained soil that is kept moist.","level":"genus","taxon":"petunia"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Petunia)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/petunia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"For the most flowers grow petunias in full sun.","level":"genus","taxon":"petunia"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"petunia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"strengths":["light"],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Petunia (group))","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264607","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Most flowers have some fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"petunia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Petunia 'Ustuni6001' SUPERTUNIA VISTA BUBBLEGUM)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=259868","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers have a slight fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Petunia)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/petunia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Many petunias, especially white and lavender cultivars have a very sweet fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"petunia"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions (Petunias)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/petunias/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"some petunias even have sweet fragrances","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"petunia"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["petunia hybrida"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (petunia hybrida), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (petunia hybrida) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"petunia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"petunia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["petunia hybrida"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (petunia hybrida), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (petunia hybrida) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"petunia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Petunia (group))","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264607","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"petunia"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Petunia)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/petunia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds love the trumpet shape of petunias, especially those with red flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"petunia"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["petunia hybrida"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (petunia hybrida), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (petunia hybrida) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"petunia-purple-wave","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"5 - 7\" (13 - 18cm)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"about 7 inches tall at maturity\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"petunia-purple-wave","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"36 - 48\" (91 - 122cm)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"spread of 3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.96},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"petunia-purple-wave","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"petunia-purple-wave","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Gertens Garden Center","url":"https://www.gertens.com/petunia-wave-purple","country":"US","form":null,"value":"should only be grown in full sunlight"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"petunia-purple-wave","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"petunia-purple-wave","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"petunia-purple-wave","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"petunia-purple-wave","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.3,2],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Phlox paniculata, the plain species)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285435","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Phlox paniculata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-paniculata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Phlox paniculata)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PHPA9","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Fall Phlox is a showy clump-former, reaching a height of 3-6 ft.","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Go Botany, Native Plant Trust (Phlox paniculata)","url":"https://gobotany.nativeplanttrust.org/species/phlox/paniculata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"30–200 cm","metres":[0.3,2],"band":[0.3,2],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":4,"cultivar":5},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"edge","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.61,0.91],"edge":[0.59,0.94],"edgeMargin":1.6,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Phlox paniculata, the plain species)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285435","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Phlox paniculata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-paniculata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":4,"cultivar":5},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV2":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.76},"note":"the catalog value sits 1.6% outside the sources' union (0.61 to 0.91 m) and inside the 3% margin v3 allows at a stated range edge (0.59 to 0.94 m), so v2's proposal of 0.76 m is withdrawn rather than applied; 2 of these 2 scored sources publish a range, and a range edge is a figure converted and rounded from another unit rather than a measurement to the centimetre; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Phlox paniculata, the plain species)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285435","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Phlox paniculata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-paniculata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":4,"cultivar":5},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Phlox paniculata, the plain species)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285435","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Phlox paniculata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-paniculata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Garden phlox prefers sun to partial shade and moist, fertile, and well-drained soils.","level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Phlox paniculata 'Barten' LILAC FLAME)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256013","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Phlox paniculata 'Barfourteen' PURPLE FLAME)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256146","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Phlox paniculata 'Balsukafus' SUPER KA-POW FUCHSIA)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=445718","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Phlox paniculata 'Barthirtysix' VOLCANO RED)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=449569","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Phlox paniculata 'Balkapowibi' KA-POW WHITE BICOLOR)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=458804","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"taxon-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Phlox paniculata, the plain species)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285435","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Phlox paniculata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-paniculata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Lavender-pink fragrant flowers with a long bloom period","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Go Botany, Native Plant Trust (Phlox paniculata)","url":"https://gobotany.nativeplanttrust.org/species/phlox/paniculata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the plant does not have much of a smell","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":4,"covered":["phlox paniculata"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (phlox paniculata), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"this came out more confident than v6 only once the distinct-taxa rule removed the claim(s) that disagreed, so it is a disagreement about which taxa were speaking rather than a finding; v6 recorded INSUFFICIENT; 4 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (phlox paniculata) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Phlox paniculata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-paniculata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Phlox paniculata, the plain species)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285435","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Intolerant of drought and needs to be watered in dry spells.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"phlox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Phlox paniculata, the plain species)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285435","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Phlox paniculata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-paniculata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It mixes well with other perennials, attracts hummingbirds, and is a good selection for a bird garden.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":5,"covered":["phlox paniculata"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (phlox paniculata), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 5 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (phlox paniculata) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"phlox-david","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.91,0.95],"union":[0.61,1.5],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-paniculata-david/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252732","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center, Phlox for Sun trial","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/phlox-for-sun/phlox-paniculata-david/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 34” x 24”","metres":0.86,"band":[0.77,0.95],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/127975/phlox-paniculata-david/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-garden-phlox-david","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 36-40\" tall","metres":[0.91,1.02],"band":[0.91,1.02],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/phlox-paniculata-david-white-phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 36\" tall","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Gilbert H. Wild & Son","url":"https://gilberthwild.com/products/david-tall-garden-phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"PHLOX p. 'David'. 36-48\" tall, 18-24\" spread, full sun-part shade, mid-late summer bloom.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":2,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"phlox-david","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.67],"union":[0.41,1],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-paniculata-david/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252732","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center, Phlox for Sun trial","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/phlox-for-sun/phlox-paniculata-david/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 34” x 24”","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/127975/phlox-paniculata-david/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-garden-phlox-david","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 18\" wide","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Gilbert H. Wild & Son","url":"https://gilberthwild.com/products/david-tall-garden-phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"PHLOX p. 'David'. 36-48\" tall, 18-24\" spread, full sun-part shade, mid-late summer bloom.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":2,"species":3},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"phlox-david","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-10","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-paniculata-david/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252732","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-garden-phlox-david","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ZONES 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/phlox-paniculata-david-white-phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3a to 10b","zones":[3,10],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Gilbert H. Wild & Son","url":"https://gilberthwild.com/products/david-tall-garden-phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 4-8.","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":2,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"phlox-david","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-paniculata-david/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252732","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Penn State Extension","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/phlox-in-the-home-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"P. paniculata likes full sun but does well in light shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"phlox"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/tall-garden-phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Tall garden phlox grow best in full sunlight, but will tolerate light shade","level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/garden-phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=742&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/127975/phlox-paniculata-david/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-garden-phlox-david","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Gilbert H. Wild & Son","url":"https://gilberthwild.com/products/david-tall-garden-phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"PHLOX p. 'David'. 36-48\" tall, 18-24\" spread, full sun-part shade, mid-late summer bloom.","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"phlox-david","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","strengths":["strong"],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-paniculata-david/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fragrant, showy white flowers are in large clusters that bloom from mid to late summer and, with deadheading, may bloom into fall.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252732","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center, Phlox for Sun trial","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/phlox-for-sun/phlox-paniculata-david/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant, pure white flowers bloom in midsummer atop 3′ tall stems.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/phlox/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"‘David’ is an excellent, fragrant white flowered selection from the wild, growing 2 to 3 feet tall.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"phlox"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/tall-garden-phlox","country":null,"form":null,"value":"many tall garden phlox are sweetly perfumed.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/127975/phlox-paniculata-david/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A bushy, upright herbaceous perennial growing to 1.1m, with dark green narrow linear leaves and fragrant white flowers clustered together at the top from mid- to late summer","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-garden-phlox-david","country":null,"form":null,"value":"delightfully fragrant flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/phlox-paniculata-david-white-phlox","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The wonderfully fragrant, clear white, giant flower heads adorn the top of the plant during the late spring and summer...a hummingbird treat.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Gilbert H. Wild & Son","url":"https://gilberthwild.com/products/david-tall-garden-phlox","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Large, showy heads of very fragrant, bright white flowers are held above sturdy lush green foliage.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"phlox-david","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-paniculata-david/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252732","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-garden-phlox-david","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Put in extra plants as a source of cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"phlox-david","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252732","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Intolerant of drought and needs to be watered in dry spells.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"phlox-david","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-paniculata-david/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Provides nectar to butterflies, skippers, hummingbird moths, sphinx moths, and hummingbirds. Deer, rabbits browse on the foliage.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=252732","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/phlox/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Phlox are highly attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"phlox"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-garden-phlox-david","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/phlox-paniculata-david-white-phlox","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The wonderfully fragrant, clear white, giant flower heads adorn the top of the plant during the late spring and summer...a hummingbird treat.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"phlox paniculata"},{"name":"Gilbert H. Wild & Son","url":"https://gilberthwild.com/products/david-tall-garden-phlox","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies, hummingbirds and is bee friendly!","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"phlox-laura","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.91,1],"union":[0.68,1.22],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255965","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center Trial Garden","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/phlox-for-sun/phlox-paniculata-laura/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 30\" x 20\"","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/phlox-paniculata-laura","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 36\" tall","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"phlox-laura","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.46,0.91],"split":[{"range":[0.46,0.56],"sources":["Mt. Cuba Center Trial Garden"]},{"range":[0.61,0.91],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255965","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center Trial Garden","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/phlox-for-sun/phlox-paniculata-laura/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 30\" x 20\"","metres":0.51,"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"phlox-laura","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255965","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/phlox-paniculata-laura","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3a to 8b","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-paniculata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"phlox-laura","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255965","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/phlox-paniculata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"phlox-laura","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","strengths":["light"],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255965","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Mt. Cuba Center Trial Garden","url":"https://mtcubacenter.org/trials/phlox-for-sun/phlox-paniculata-laura/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"FRAGRANCE mild","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/phlox-paniculata-laura","country":null,"form":null,"value":"lightly fragrant clusters of purple-violet flowers","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"phlox-laura","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255965","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut flower.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"phlox-laura","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255965","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Intolerant of drought and needs to be watered in dry spells.","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"phlox-laura","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255965","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/phlox-paniculata-laura","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterfly Attracting Plants","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"phlox-orange-perfection","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/garden-phlox-orange-perfection","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"phlox-orange-perfection","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/garden-phlox-orange-perfection","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2-3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"phlox-orange-perfection","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/garden-phlox-orange-perfection","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4-8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/phlox-paniculata-orange-perfection-orange-perfection-garden-phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 - 8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"phlox-orange-perfection","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/garden-phlox-orange-perfection","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/phlox-paniculata-orange-perfection-orange-perfection-garden-phlox","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"phlox-orange-perfection","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/garden-phlox-orange-perfection","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"phlox-orange-perfection","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"phlox-orange-perfection","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"phlox-orange-perfection","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/garden-phlox-orange-perfection","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/phlox-paniculata-orange-perfection-orange-perfection-garden-phlox","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pink-damask-daylily","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.75,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.79,0.89],"union":[0.5,1],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/89831/hemerocallis-pink-damask/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials / Perennials.com plant profile","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-pink-damask.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"31-35 inches","metres":[0.79,0.89],"band":[0.79,0.89],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pink-damask-daylily","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.58,0.89],"union":[0.5,1],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/89831/hemerocallis-pink-damask/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials / Perennials.com plant profile","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-pink-damask.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"23-35 inches","metres":[0.58,0.89],"band":[0.58,0.89],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pink-damask-daylily","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials / Perennials.com plant profile","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-pink-damask.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2-9","zones":[2,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pink-damask-daylily","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/89831/hemerocallis-pink-damask/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials / Perennials.com plant profile","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-pink-damask.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun or Partial Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pink-damask-daylily","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pink-damask-daylily","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials / Perennials.com plant profile","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-pink-damask.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pink-damask-daylily","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials / Perennials.com plant profile","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-pink-damask.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pink-damask-daylily","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"pink-damask-daylily","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"botanicalName","current":"Hemerocallis 'Pink Damask'","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/89831/hemerocallis-pink-damask/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Listed as Hemerocallis 'Pink Damask' (daylily 'Pink Damask'), a herbaceous perennial holding the RHS Award of Garden Merit"},{"name":"Heritage Perennials / Perennials.com","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/hemerocallis-pink-damask.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Independent trade listing under the identical name Hemerocallis 'Pink Damask'"}],"note":"name resolves as Hemerocallis 'Pink Damask'","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"portulaca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":6,"genus":2},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 3 in. - 0 ft. 8 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"This annual is a succulent that typically grows to 6-8” tall and spreads to 12” wide or more.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The low-growing plants form a mat up to a foot across and 3 to 8 inches high arising from the central fibrous root system.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Portulaca is a spreading succulent that grows 6 inches tall and a foot across.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"portulaca 1–3 12 – B Tender Sun\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"portulaca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":6,"genus":2},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"This annual is a succulent that typically grows to 6-8” tall and spreads to 12” wide or more.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The low-growing plants form a mat up to a foot across and 3 to 8 inches high arising from the central fibrous root system.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Portulaca is a spreading succulent that grows 6 inches tall and a foot across.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"portulaca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Portulaca grandiflora, rose moss)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285505","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11],"level":"species","taxon":"portulaca grandiflora"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":6,"genus":2},"reasons":[]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"portulaca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Portulaca grandiflora)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/portulaca-grandiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"portulaca grandiflora"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Portulaca grandiflora, rose moss)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285505","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"portulaca grandiflora"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Portulaca grandiflora)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/moss-rose-portulaca-grandiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant moss rose in full sun.","level":"species","taxon":"portulaca grandiflora"},{"name":"University of Arkansas System Division of Agriculture, Cooperative Extension Service, Plant of the Week (moss rose, Portulaca grandiflora)","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/moss-rose.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They should be planted in full sun in a well drained soil.","level":"species","taxon":"portulaca grandiflora"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Portulaca, the genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/portulaca/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"portulaca"},{"name":"Botanical Interests (Double Blend Portulaca, moss rose, seed)","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/double-blend-portulaca-moss-rose-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"portulaca grandiflora"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (Portulaca)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/portulaca.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun.","level":"genus","taxon":"portulaca"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"portulaca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"portulaca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"portulaca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Portulaca grandiflora)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/portulaca-grandiflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant has a high drought and heat tolerance and needs to be planted in well-drained sandy or rocky soils in full sun.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"portulaca grandiflora"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Portulaca grandiflora, rose moss)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285505","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"portulaca grandiflora"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Portulaca grandiflora)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/moss-rose-portulaca-grandiflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Moss rose, Portulaca grandiflora , is a drought and heat tolerant annual native to hot, dry plains in Argentina, southern Brazil, and Uruguay.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"portulaca grandiflora"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Portulaca, the genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/portulaca/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant and does well in heat and humidity.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"portulaca"},{"name":"Botanical Interests (Double Blend Portulaca, moss rose, seed)","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/double-blend-portulaca-moss-rose-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Very drought tolerant, moss roses need only occasional watering.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"portulaca grandiflora"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (Portulaca)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/portulaca.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Full Sun. Plants tolerate heat and drought, look best with occasional water.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"portulaca"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"portulaca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Portulaca, the genus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/portulaca/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"portulaca"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"portulaca-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0 ft. 3 in. - 0 ft. 8 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The low-growing plants form a mat up to a foot across and 3 to 8 inches high\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"portulaca-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The low-growing plants form a mat up to a foot across and 3 to 8 inches high\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"portulaca-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"portulaca-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/portulaca-grandiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/moss-rose-portulaca-grandiflora/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow moss rose in full sun in most soil types as long as they are well-drained"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"portulaca-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"portulaca-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"portulaca-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension (Wisconsin Horticulture)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/moss-rose-portulaca-grandiflora/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Moss rose, Portulaca grandiflora, is a drought and heat tolerant annual","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"portulaca-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"potentilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.3,1.22],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dasiphora fruticosa, the accepted name for Potentilla fruticosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dasiphora-fruticosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"dasiphora fruticosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Potentilla fruticosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286391","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"potentilla fruticosa"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Native Plant Database (Dasiphora fruticosa)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=DAFR6","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3-4 ft. high and equally as wide","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"dasiphora fruticosa"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (shrubby cinquefoil, Potentilla fruticosa)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/shrubby-cinquefoil/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Shrubby cinquefoil are 1 to 4 feet high and wide with a rounded habit and finely textured stems.","metres":[0.3,1.22],"band":[0.3,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"dasiphora fruticosa"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"potentilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.3,1.52],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dasiphora fruticosa, the accepted name for Potentilla fruticosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dasiphora-fruticosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"dasiphora fruticosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Potentilla fruticosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286391","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"potentilla fruticosa"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Native Plant Database (Dasiphora fruticosa)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=DAFR6","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3-4 ft. high and equally as wide","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"dasiphora fruticosa"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (shrubby cinquefoil, Potentilla fruticosa)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/shrubby-cinquefoil/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Shrubby cinquefoil are 1 to 4 feet high and wide with a rounded habit and finely textured stems.","metres":[0.3,1.22],"band":[0.3,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"dasiphora fruticosa"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"potentilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,7],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-7","3-7","2-6"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dasiphora fruticosa, the accepted name for Potentilla fruticosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dasiphora-fruticosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[2,7],"level":"species","taxon":"dasiphora fruticosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Potentilla fruticosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286391","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 7","zones":[3,7],"level":"species","taxon":"potentilla fruticosa"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (shrubby cinquefoil, Potentilla fruticosa)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/shrubby-cinquefoil/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 2, Zone 3, Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago)","zones":[2,6],"level":"species","taxon":"dasiphora fruticosa"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"potentilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dasiphora fruticosa, the accepted name for Potentilla fruticosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dasiphora-fruticosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"dasiphora fruticosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Potentilla fruticosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286391","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"potentilla fruticosa"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Native Plant Database (Dasiphora fruticosa)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=DAFR6","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade","level":"species","taxon":"dasiphora fruticosa"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (shrubby cinquefoil, Potentilla fruticosa)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/shrubby-cinquefoil/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"dasiphora fruticosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"potentilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"potentilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"potentilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dasiphora fruticosa, the accepted name for Potentilla fruticosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dasiphora-fruticosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It tolerates a wide range of well-drained soils and is drought-tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dasiphora fruticosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Potentilla fruticosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286391","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Established plants grow well in a wide range of conditions and have good drought tolerance.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"potentilla fruticosa"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (shrubby cinquefoil, Potentilla fruticosa)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/shrubby-cinquefoil/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Withstands poor soils, hot dry sites, and high pH soils.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dasiphora fruticosa"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"potentilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Dasiphora fruticosa, the accepted name for Potentilla fruticosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dasiphora-fruticosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and supports the following specialized bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dasiphora fruticosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Potentilla fruticosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286391","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"potentilla fruticosa"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, Native Plant Database (Dasiphora fruticosa)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=DAFR6","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"dasiphora fruticosa"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"potentilla-mckays-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.67],"union":[0.55,1],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/shrubby-cinquefoil/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"A small, mounded shrub growing 2 to 2 1/2 feet high and 2 to 3 feet wide.","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/plant/S-0841","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 2' 0\" - 3' 0\" high x 2' 0\" - 3' 0\" wide.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Trees Today Nursery (data credited to Bailey Nurseries)","url":"https://www.treestodaynursery.com/mckays-white-potentilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 24-30″","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Blue Heron Farm Nursery","url":"https://bhfnursery.com/potentilla-fruticosa-mckays-white/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3' Tall","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/mckays-white-potentilla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 2 - 3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Something Montana","url":"https://www.plantsomethingmontana.org/plant/mckays-white-potentilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height at Maturity 2 feet","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ricks Garden Center","url":"https://www.ricksgarden.com/product/mckays-white-potentilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height 24 Inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pine Lane Nursery","url":"https://www.pinelanenursery.com/catalog/product/potentilla-mckays-white/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 2'-3'","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"potentilla-mckays-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.67],"union":[0.55,1],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/shrubby-cinquefoil/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"A small, mounded shrub growing 2 to 2 1/2 feet high and 2 to 3 feet wide.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Digging Dog Nursery","url":"https://www.diggingdog.com/plant/S-0841","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 2' 0\" - 3' 0\" high x 2' 0\" - 3' 0\" wide.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Trees Today Nursery (data credited to Bailey Nurseries)","url":"https://www.treestodaynursery.com/mckays-white-potentilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 24-36″","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Blue Heron Farm Nursery","url":"https://bhfnursery.com/potentilla-fruticosa-mckays-white/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3' Wide","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/mckays-white-potentilla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 2 - 3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Something Montana","url":"https://www.plantsomethingmontana.org/plant/mckays-white-potentilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Width at Maturity 2 feet","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ricks Garden Center","url":"https://www.ricksgarden.com/product/mckays-white-potentilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Width/Spread 24 Inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Pine Lane Nursery","url":"https://www.pinelanenursery.com/catalog/product/potentilla-mckays-white/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 2'-3'","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"potentilla-mckays-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,7],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-6","2-7","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/shrubby-cinquefoil/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones Zone 2, Zone 3, Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago)","zones":[2,6]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dasiphora-fruticosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[2,7]},{"name":"Trees Today Nursery (data credited to Bailey Nurseries)","url":"https://www.treestodaynursery.com/mckays-white-potentilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 2-7","zones":[2,7]},{"name":"Blue Heron Farm Nursery","url":"https://bhfnursery.com/potentilla-fruticosa-mckays-white/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 - 7","zones":[2,7]},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/mckays-white-potentilla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 4 - 8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"potentilla-mckays-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/shrubby-cinquefoil/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily)"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dasiphora-fruticosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Trees Today Nursery (data credited to Bailey Nurseries)","url":"https://www.treestodaynursery.com/mckays-white-potentilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/mckays-white-potentilla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Partial Sun to Full Sun (At Least 5 Hours of Direct Sunlight)"},{"name":"Plant Something Montana","url":"https://www.plantsomethingmontana.org/plant/mckays-white-potentilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun"},{"name":"Ricks Garden Center","url":"https://www.ricksgarden.com/product/mckays-white-potentilla/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Requirements Full Sun , Partial Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"potentilla-mckays-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"potentilla-mckays-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"potentilla-mckays-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dasiphora-fruticosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It tolerates a wide range of well-drained soils and is drought-tolerant.","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Something Montana","url":"https://www.plantsomethingmontana.org/plant/mckays-white-potentilla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This sturdy plant stands up to drought, air pollution, and salt, and has earned a reputation of being veritably indestructible by tolerating a wide range of growing conditions.","claim":true},{"name":"Ricks Garden Center","url":"https://www.ricksgarden.com/product/mckays-white-potentilla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is considered to be drought-tolerant, and thus makes an ideal choice for a low-water garden or xeriscape application.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"potentilla-mckays-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/dasiphora-fruticosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and supports the following specialized bees","claim":true},{"name":"Ricks Garden Center","url":"https://www.ricksgarden.com/product/mckays-white-potentilla/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"primrose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"primrose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"primrose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/primula/","country":"US","form":"genus page","value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[3,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"primrose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/primula/","country":"US","form":"genus page","value":"Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"primrose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"primrose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"primrose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"primrose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/primula/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They provide nectar for early season pollinators and some are host plants to butterflies.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"princess-alexandra-of-kent","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.37,1.52],"union":[1.07,1.67],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 5ft","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 5' x 4'","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 3.5-5′","metres":[1.07,1.52],"band":[1.07,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4ft (125cm)","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"princess-alexandra-of-kent","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.1,1.22],"union":[0.82,1.34],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 5' x 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3-4′","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Spread: 3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 4ft (125cm)","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"princess-alexandra-of-kent","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-11","4-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 4-11","zones":[4,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 4-11","zones":[4,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zones: 4-11","zones":[4,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable Zones: 4-7","zones":[4,7],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"princess-alexandra-of-kent","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sun Requires 6+ hours of direct sunlight to thrive.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"princess-alexandra-of-kent","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["strong","strong","strong","strong","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","https://heirloomroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","https://menagerieflower.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent-rose-david-austin"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There is a strong and delicious fresh Tea fragrance, which changes to lemon, eventually taking on hints of blackcurrants.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There is a strong and delicious fresh Tea fragrance, which changes to lemon, eventually taking on hints of blackcurrants.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Princess Alexandra of Kent is a very fragrant, pink English Rose","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":null,"form":null,"value":"An intensely fragrant English Shrub Rose with exceptionally large, cupped blooms in glowing mid-pink.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent-rose-david-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"With a strong tea fragrance, Princess Alexandra is just the girl you need for your garden.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"princess-alexandra-of-kent","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","https://heirloomroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Location Cutting Mixed Border","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets and floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/princess-alexandra-of-kent","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vase Life: 5-7 days","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"princess-alexandra-of-kent","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"princess-alexandra-of-kent","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"queen-of-sweden","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.37,1.5],"union":[1,1.67],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/queen-of-sweden","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"5ft","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/queen-of-sweden","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4'-5' x 3'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/rosa-queen-of-sweden%E2%84%A2","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4′–5′","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS (Royal Horticultural Society)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/217438/rosa-queen-of-sweden-austiger-pbr-s/details","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"1-1.5 metres (time to ultimate height 2-5 years)","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/queen-of-sweden","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"4ft (125cm)","metres":1.25,"band":[1.13,1.38],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"queen-of-sweden","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.5,1],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/queen-of-sweden","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"3ft","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/queen-of-sweden","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4'-5' x 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/rosa-queen-of-sweden%E2%84%A2","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"2′–3′","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS (Royal Horticultural Society)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/217438/rosa-queen-of-sweden-austiger-pbr-s/details","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/queen-of-sweden","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"3ft (90cm)","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"queen-of-sweden","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-11","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/queen-of-sweden","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zones 4-11"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/queen-of-sweden","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 4-11"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/rosa-queen-of-sweden%E2%84%A2","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"USDA 5-9"}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"queen-of-sweden","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/queen-of-sweden","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight and Partial Shade"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/queen-of-sweden","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Full sunlight to partial shade; North, East, South, West Facing"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/queen-of-sweden","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Partial Shade or Full Sun, needing only 4+ hours of direct sun to thrive"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/rosa-queen-of-sweden%E2%84%A2","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full sun"},{"name":"RHS (Royal Horticultural Society)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/217438/rosa-queen-of-sweden-austiger-pbr-s/details","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Full sun, Partial shade; West-facing or South-facing or East-facing"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"queen-of-sweden","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/queen-of-sweden","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Medium, Myrrh"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/queen-of-sweden","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Medium, Myrrh; \"lovely myrrh fragrance\""},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/queen-of-sweden","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Moderately Fragrant; \"mild myrrh fragrance\""},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/rosa-queen-of-sweden%E2%84%A2","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light to medium myrrh fragrance; \"notes of myrrh with a subtle sweetness\""},{"name":"RHS (Royal Horticultural Society)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/217438/rosa-queen-of-sweden-austiger-pbr-s/details","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"\"Lightly scented\""}],"note":"sources rate it medium/light","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"queen-of-sweden","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/queen-of-sweden","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Cutting listed under Location"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/queen-of-sweden","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets and floral arrangements"}],"note":"2 sources state it but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"queen-of-sweden","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.thornless","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/queen-of-sweden","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"minimal thorns","polarity":"few-thorns"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) describe reduced thorniness","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"queen-of-the-prairie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[1.83,2.44],"union":[1.83,2.44],"proposed":2.13,"margin":18,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286417&isprofile=0&basic=Filipendula%20rubra","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6.00 to 8.00 feet","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=837&PlantTypeID=14","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6-8 Feet","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (1.83 to 2.44 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"queen-of-the-prairie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286417&isprofile=0&basic=Filipendula%20rubra","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"queen-of-the-prairie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286417&isprofile=0&basic=Filipendula%20rubra","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=837&PlantTypeID=14","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 - 9","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"queen-of-the-prairie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286417&isprofile=0&basic=Filipendula%20rubra","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=837&PlantTypeID=14","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"queen-of-the-prairie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286417&isprofile=0&basic=Filipendula%20rubra","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy, Fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"queen-of-the-prairie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"queen-of-the-prairie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=837&PlantTypeID=14","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Dry sites should be avoided.","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"queen-of-the-prairie","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ranunculus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":3,"genus":2,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height range: 30-60 cm.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ranunculus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":3,"genus":2,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ranunculus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,10],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ranunculus asiaticus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ranunculus-asiaticus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[8,10],"level":"species","taxon":"ranunculus asiaticus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ranunculus asiaticus)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286205","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8 to 10","zones":[8,10],"level":"species","taxon":"ranunculus asiaticus"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":3,"genus":2,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ranunculus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ranunculus asiaticus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ranunculus-asiaticus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"ranunculus asiaticus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ranunculus asiaticus)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286205","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"ranunculus asiaticus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ranunculus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ranunculus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ranunculus asiaticus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ranunculus-asiaticus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In a suitable climate (or in a greenhouse), these plants make spectacular blooms that are useful as cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ranunculus asiaticus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ranunculus, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ranunculus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Consider using them for beds, borders, riparian gardens, rock gardens and fresh cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"ranunculus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (Ranunculus species, fall planting article)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/add-ranunculus-to-your-fall-planting-to-do-list/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"I particularly love using the multi-layered, almost paper-like blooms in flower arrangements, as they have an excellent vase life as well.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"ranunculus"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["ranunculus asiaticus"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (ranunculus asiaticus), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (ranunculus asiaticus) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ranunculus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ranunculus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ranunculus-asiaticus/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ranunculus/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ranunculus asiaticus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ranunculus-asiaticus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ranunculus asiaticus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ranunculus, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ranunculus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Buttercup species are great pollinator plants because they bloom very early, when few other plants are flowering.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"ranunculus"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are ncsu.edu. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"ranunculus-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ranunculus-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Bulb","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ranunculus-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,10],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286205","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8 to 10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ranunculus-asiaticus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[8,10]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ranunculus-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286205","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ranunculus-asiaticus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/14341/ranunculus-asiaticus/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ranunculus-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ranunculus-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ranunculus-asiaticus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In a suitable climate (or in a greenhouse), these plants make spectacular blooms that are useful as cut flowers.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ranunculus-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"ranunculus-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ranunculus-asiaticus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"red-eden-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1.8,3.66],"split":[{"range":[1.8,2.68],"sources":["Style Roses (UK)","Northland Rosarium"]},{"range":[2.75,3.66],"sources":["Heirloom Roses","David Austin Roses (US)","Palatine Fruit & Roses","Greenheart Farms (propagator, Star broker)","Star Roses and Plants (Bloomables)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/red-eden","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Size 10' x 5'","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Palatine Fruit & Roses","url":"https://palatinefruit.com/product/red-eden-rose/","country":"CA","form":"climber","value":"this plant will grow to between 10′-12′ at maturity","metres":[3.05,3.66],"band":[3.05,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/red-eden","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Height: 10ft","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Greenheart Farms (propagator, Star broker)","url":"https://www.greenheartfarms.com/catalog/climbingroses/rededen","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Height: 10 - 12 ft.","metres":[3.05,3.66],"band":[3.05,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Star Roses and Plants (Bloomables)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/eden-climber-red/","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Size/Habit Climber, 10-12' h","metres":[3.05,3.66],"band":[3.05,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Northland Rosarium","url":"https://www.northlandrosarium.com/products/red-eden-meidrason","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"8 Feet High","metres":2.44,"band":[2.2,2.68],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Style Roses (UK)","url":"https://styleroses.co.uk/shop/red-eden-rose/","country":"GB","form":"climber","value":"Average Height: 180cm - 240cm","metres":[1.8,2.4],"band":[1.8,2.4],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"red-eden-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/red-eden","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Size 10' x 5'","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7},"reasons":[]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"red-eden-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["6-10","5-10","5-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/red-eden","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zone 6-10","zones":[6,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Palatine Fruit & Roses","url":"https://palatinefruit.com/product/red-eden-rose/","country":"CA","form":"climber","value":"Hardiness Zones USDA 5 - 10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/red-eden","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Greenheart Farms (propagator, Star broker)","url":"https://www.greenheartfarms.com/catalog/climbingroses/rededen","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"USDA Zones: 5 - 10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Star Roses and Plants (Bloomables)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/eden-climber-red/","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zones 5-10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":7},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"red-eden-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/red-eden","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"This Climber prefers full sun, not too much rain, and produces beautiful hips in the fall.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/red-eden","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Star Roses and Plants (Bloomables)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/eden-climber-red/","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Light Full Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"red-eden-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["light","light","strong","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/red-eden","https://palatinefruit.com/product/red-eden-rose/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/red-eden","https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/red-eden"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/red-eden","https://www.greenheartfarms.com/catalog/climbingroses/rededen"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/red-eden","https://www.bloomables.com/plants/eden-climber-red/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/red-eden","https://www.northlandrosarium.com/products/red-eden-meidrason"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/red-eden","https://styleroses.co.uk/shop/red-eden-rose/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/red-eden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Very Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Palatine Fruit & Roses","url":"https://palatinefruit.com/product/red-eden-rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/red-eden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It has a good fragrance and flowers throughout the summer until fall.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Greenheart Farms (propagator, Star broker)","url":"https://www.greenheartfarms.com/catalog/climbingroses/rededen","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Classic rose, mild.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Star Roses and Plants (Bloomables)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/eden-climber-red/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Northland Rosarium","url":"https://www.northlandrosarium.com/products/red-eden-meidrason","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Strong Fragrance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Style Roses (UK)","url":"https://styleroses.co.uk/shop/red-eden-rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It has a very pleasing strong fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 7 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 7","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"red-eden-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"red-eden-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"red-eden-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"redbud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":6},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 20 ft. 0 in. - 30 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"typically matures to 20-30’ tall with a slightly larger spread\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Redbuds always remain small, maturing at 20 to 30 feet in height and 15 to 35 feet in width.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Redbud is a 15-30 ft. tree with one to several picturesque, maroon-purple trunks and a wide, umbrella-like crown.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"At maturity, to 40 feet tall; to 35 feet wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"redbud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":6},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 25 ft. 0 in. - 35 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 25.00 to 35.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Redbuds always remain small, maturing at 20 to 30 feet in height and 15 to 35 feet in width.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"At maturity, to 40 feet tall; to 35 feet wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"redbud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Cercis canadensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cercis-canadensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"species","taxon":"cercis canadensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Cercis canadensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280440","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"cercis canadensis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":6},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"redbud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Cercis canadensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cercis-canadensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"cercis canadensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Cercis canadensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280440","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"cercis canadensis"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Redbud, Cercis canadensis)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/redbud/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows well in full sun but prefers some shade in the heat of summer.","level":"species","taxon":"cercis canadensis"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Cercis canadensis)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CECA4","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade , Shade","level":"species","taxon":"cercis canadensis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"redbud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Cercis canadensis)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CECA4","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers: yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cercis canadensis"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"redbud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Cercis canadensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280440","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good cut flower for forcing indoors.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cercis canadensis"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"redbud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Cercis canadensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cercis-canadensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It does not tolerate heat or drought, which can stress the tree, or wet soils.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"cercis canadensis"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Redbud, Cercis canadensis)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/redbud/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Redbuds tolerate moderate dry spells, but do better when irrigated in summer dry spells.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cercis canadensis"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"redbud","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Cercis canadensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cercis-canadensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cercis canadensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Cercis canadensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280440","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cercis canadensis"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Cercis canadensis)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CECA4","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Value to Native Bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cercis canadensis"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide (eastern redbud, Cercis canadensis)","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/eastern-redbud","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are a valuable early-spring nectar source for bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cercis canadensis"},{"name":"USDA Forest Service, Silvics of North America vol. 2 (Cercis canadensis)","url":"https://www.srs.fs.usda.gov/pubs/misc/ag_654/volume_2/cercis/canadensis.htm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollination is usually accomplished by bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"cercis canadensis"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"regent-serviceberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242786","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"regent-serviceberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242786","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"regent-serviceberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242786","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2 to 7","zones":[2,7]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"regent-serviceberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242786","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"regent-serviceberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"regent-serviceberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"regent-serviceberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"regent-serviceberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":3,"genus":5,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":3,"genus":5,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-12","10-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Begonia - Rex Types)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia-rex-types/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b, 12a, 12b","zones":[10,12],"level":"species","taxon":"begonia rex"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Begonia rex-cultorum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242218&isprofile=0&basic=Begonia+rex","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11],"level":"species","taxon":"begonia rex-cultorum"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":3,"genus":5,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Begonia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most commonly cultivated begonias prefer partial shade and a humid environment.","level":"genus","taxon":"begonia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Begonia rex-cultorum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242218&isprofile=0&basic=Begonia+rex","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"begonia rex-cultorum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Begonia rex-cultorum 'Super Curl')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=444254&isprofile=0&basic=Begonia+rex","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"begonia rex-cultorum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Begonia)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/begonia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These spectacular begonias grow best indoors or in containers placed in partial shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"begonia"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County (Fact sheet: Begonia)","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/05/29/fact-sheet-begonia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most begonias grow well in partial shade and in a moist, well-drained soil with plenty of organic matter.","level":"genus","taxon":"begonia"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height : 6-12”\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"This compact grower only reaches 6-8” tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-11","10-12"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242218","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia-rex-types/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b, 12a, 12b","zones":[10,12]},{"name":"Josh's Frogs","url":"https://joshsfrogs.com/sp/begonia-rex-red-kiss-plant924","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone : 10-11","zones":[10,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=242218","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia-rex-types/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Josh's Frogs","url":"https://joshsfrogs.com/sp/begonia-rex-red-kiss-plant924","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Lighting : Full Shade Partial Shade Full Sun"},{"name":"Logee's Plants","url":"https://www.logees.com/products/begonia-red-kiss","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Partial Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"6-14\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-10","10-12"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Logee's Plants","url":"https://www.logees.com/products/begonia-fireworks","country":"US","form":"Begonia 'Fireworks' (Begonia rex hybrid), the exact cultivar this row names","value":"10","zones":[10,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia-rex-types/","country":"US","form":"Begonia Rex Types, an informal group page covering Begonia rex and its hybrids (recorded for sun and zones only)","value":"10a, 10b, 11a, 11b, 12a, 12b","zones":[10,12]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Logee's Plants","url":"https://www.logees.com/products/begonia-fireworks","country":"US","form":"Begonia 'Fireworks' (Begonia rex hybrid), the exact cultivar this row names","value":"Partial Sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia-rex-types/","country":"US","form":"Begonia Rex Types, an informal group page covering Begonia rex and its hybrids (recorded for sun and zones only)","value":"Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rex-begonia-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.83,3.05],"union":[1.52,6.1],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rhododendron, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rhododendron/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"rhododendron"},{"name":"Clemson HGIC factsheet, How to Grow Rhododendrons in South Carolina (the genus)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/how-to-grow-rhododendrons-in-south-carolina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height & Spread: 5 to 6 feet for Carolina types; up to 20+ feet for rosebay; forms range from compact to loose","metres":[1.52,6.1],"band":[1.52,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"rhododendron"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":5,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rhododendron","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.52,2.44],"union":[1.52,6.1],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rhododendron, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rhododendron/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 5 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.52,2.44],"band":[1.52,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"rhododendron"},{"name":"Clemson HGIC factsheet, How to Grow Rhododendrons in South Carolina (the genus)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/how-to-grow-rhododendrons-in-south-carolina/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height & Spread: 5 to 6 feet for Carolina types; up to 20+ feet for rosebay; forms range from compact to loose","metres":[1.52,6.1],"band":[1.52,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"rhododendron"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":5,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rhododendron","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rhododendron, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rhododendron/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8],"level":"genus","taxon":"rhododendron"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":5,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rhododendron","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rhododendron, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rhododendron/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"genus","taxon":"rhododendron"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rhododendron catawbiense)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279982","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade","level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron catawbiense"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rhododendron maximum)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279985","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron maximum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rhododendron arborescens)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279973","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade","level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron arborescens"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rhododendron catawbiense)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rhododendron-catawbiense/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron catawbiense"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum, Trees and Plants (Catawba rhododendron, Rhododendron catawbiense)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/catawba-rhododendron/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily), Full shade (4 hrs or less of light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron catawbiense"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum, Trees and Plants (Rhododendron P.J.M., a hybrid cultivar)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/rhododendron-p-j-m/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily), Full shade (4 hrs or less of light daily)","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rhododendron","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["rhododendron arborescens"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (rhododendron arborescens), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (rhododendron arborescens) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rhododendron","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rhododendron","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rhododendron","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rhododendron, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rhododendron/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract humingbirds. Members of the genus Rhododendron support the following specialized bee: Andrena (Andrena) cornelli. Deer browse this plant.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rhododendron"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rhododendron catawbiense)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279982","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are a nectar source for butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron catawbiense"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rhododendron arborescens)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279973","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron arborescens"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rhododendron catawbiense)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rhododendron-catawbiense/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nectar from flowers attracts hummingbirds, butterflies, and bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rhododendron catawbiense"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum, Trees and Plants (Rhododendron P.J.M., a hybrid cultivar)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/rhododendron-p-j-m/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Spring flowers attract butterflies including the giant swallowtail, pipevine swallowtail, and spicebush swallowtail.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"rhododendron-capistrano","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.91,2.44],"split":[{"range":[0.91,1.52],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","American Rhododendron Society cultivar database","Rhododendrons Direct"]},{"range":[1.83,2.44],"sources":["Plant Addicts"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257096","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Rhododendron Society cultivar database","url":"https://www.rhododendron.org/descriptionH_new.asp?ID=812","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 feet in 10 years.","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Rhododendrons Direct","url":"https://www.rhododendronsdirect.com/product/capistrano/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height(potential in 10 years): Four Feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/capistrano-rhododendron","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 6 - 8 Feet","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-capistrano","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[1.52,2.44],"union":[1.52,2.44],"proposed":1.98,"margin":21.1,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257096","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 5.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/capistrano-rhododendron","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 6 - 8 Feet","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (1.52 to 2.44 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-capistrano","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257096","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/capistrano-rhododendron","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 5 - 8","zones":[5,8]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-capistrano","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257096","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/capistrano-rhododendron","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Partial Shade to Partial Sun (3 - 6 Hours Of Direct Sunlight)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-capistrano","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Rhododendron Society cultivar database","url":"https://www.rhododendron.org/descriptionH_new.asp?ID=812","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant: No","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-capistrano","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-capistrano","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/capistrano-rhododendron","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates: Drought","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-capistrano","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257096","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/capistrano-rhododendron","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-nova-zembla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.52,1.67],"union":[1.37,2.44],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253486","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5.00 to 8.00 feet","metres":[1.52,2.44],"band":[1.52,2.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/nova-zembla-rhododendron.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Moderate growing; reaches 5 ft. tall and wide.","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-nova-zembla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.52,1.67],"union":[1.37,1.83],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253486","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/nova-zembla-rhododendron.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Moderate growing; reaches 5 ft. tall and wide.","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-nova-zembla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[4,8],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253486","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/nova-zembla-rhododendron.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone 4-8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"every source states 4-8; catalog states 5-8","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-nova-zembla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253486","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/nova-zembla-rhododendron.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Partial sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-nova-zembla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-nova-zembla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-nova-zembla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-nova-zembla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253486","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/nova-zembla-rhododendron.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-yaku-princess","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://www.naturehills.com/products/yaku-princess-rhododendron","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2-3 ft","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-yaku-princess","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://www.naturehills.com/products/yaku-princess-rhododendron","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4-5 ft","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-yaku-princess","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://www.naturehills.com/products/yaku-princess-rhododendron","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 5-8","zones":[5,8]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-yaku-princess","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://www.naturehills.com/products/yaku-princess-rhododendron","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-yaku-princess","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-yaku-princess","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-yaku-princess","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rhododendron-yaku-princess","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://www.naturehills.com/products/yaku-princess-rhododendron","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cold hardy, Evergreen, Compact/Dwarf, Flowering, Container Friendly, Attracts pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rising-sun","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Reaches 8 to 12 ft. tall and 8 ft. wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"2-3 m\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rising-sun","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Reaches 8 to 12 ft. tall and 8 ft. wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"2 m\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rising-sun","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/the-rising-sun-eastern-redbud.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5-9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rising-sun","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.monrovia.com/the-rising-sun-eastern-redbud.html","https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Cercis-canadensis-The-Rising-Sun"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/the-rising-sun-eastern-redbud.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Cercis-canadensis-The-Rising-Sun","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":"full-sun"},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rising-sun","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rising-sun","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rising-sun","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/the-rising-sun-eastern-redbud.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Waterwise","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rising-sun","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/the-rising-sun-eastern-redbud.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"roald-dahl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.34],"union":[1,1.5],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/roald-dahl","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/roald-dahl","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4' x 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/roald-dahl-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS (Royal Horticultural Society)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/353931/rosa-roald-dahl-(-ausowlish-pbr)-(s)/details","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"1-1.5 metres (ultimate height, time to ultimate height 2-5 years)","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/roald-dahl","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"3ft (90cm)","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"roald-dahl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.5,1.34],"split":[{"range":[0.5,1],"sources":["RHS (Royal Horticultural Society)"]},{"range":[1.1,1.34],"sources":["David Austin Roses (US)","Heirloom Roses","Menagerie Farm & Flower"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/roald-dahl","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/roald-dahl","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4' x 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/roald-dahl-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS (Royal Horticultural Society)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/353931/rosa-roald-dahl-(-ausowlish-pbr)-(s)/details","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/roald-dahl","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"3 1/2ft (110cm)","metres":1.1,"band":[0.99,1.21],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"roald-dahl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/roald-dahl","https://heirloomroses.com/products/roald-dahl"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/roald-dahl","https://menagerieflower.com/products/roald-dahl-rose-david-austin"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/roald-dahl","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zones 5-11"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/roald-dahl","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 5-11"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/roald-dahl-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable Zones: 5-11"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[5,11]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"roald-dahl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/roald-dahl","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight and Partial Shade (both listed as suitable)"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/roald-dahl","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight and Partial Shade; North, East, South, West Facing"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/roald-dahl","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Partial Shade or Full Sun, needing only 4+ hours of direct sun to thrive"},{"name":"RHS (Royal Horticultural Society)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/353931/rosa-roald-dahl-(-ausowlish-pbr)-(s)/details","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Full sun; South-facing or West-facing or East-facing"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"roald-dahl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/roald-dahl","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Medium,Tea"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/roald-dahl","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Medium, Tea; \"a lovely fruity Tea scent\""},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/roald-dahl","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Moderately Fragrant; \"sweet, fruit-scented\""},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/roald-dahl-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mild - Tea"}],"note":"sources rate it medium/light","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"roald-dahl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/roald-dahl","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Cutting listed among suitable locations"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/roald-dahl","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Cutting listed among suitable locations"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/roald-dahl","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets and floral arrangements"}],"note":"3 sources state it but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"roald-dahl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.thornless","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/roald-dahl","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"few thorns","polarity":"few-thorns"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/roald-dahl","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"few thorns","polarity":"few-thorns"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/roald-dahl","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Nearly Thornless - Minimal thorns or bristles","polarity":"thornless"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/roald-dahl-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"very few thorns","polarity":"few-thorns"},{"name":"RHS (Royal Horticultural Society)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/353931/rosa-roald-dahl-(-ausowlish-pbr)-(s)/details","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"very few thorns","polarity":"few-thorns"}],"note":"5 sources describe reduced thorniness (1 of them call it thornless) but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"rosa-fragrant-cloud","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"botanicalName","current":"Rosa 'Fragrant Cloud'","outcome":"NAME-UNVERIFIED","sources":[],"note":"the botanical name could not be confirmed against a registry, so no trait was checked","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"rosa-ispahan","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[1.1,1.34],"union":[1,1.5],"proposed":1.22,"margin":20,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/95681/rosa-ispahan-d/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/ispahan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4' x 3'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (1 to 1.5 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rosa-ispahan","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.82,1.5],"union":[0.82,1.5],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/95681/rosa-ispahan-d/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/ispahan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4' x 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rosa-ispahan","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/ispahan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 4-10","zones":[4,10]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rosa-ispahan","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/95681/rosa-ispahan-d/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/ispahan","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rosa-ispahan","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/95681/rosa-ispahan-d/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Very fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/ispahan","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Very Fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rosa-ispahan","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rosa-ispahan","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rosa-ispahan","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rosa-ispahan","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"botanicalName","current":"Rosa 'Ispahan'","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/95681/rosa-ispahan-d/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Listed, as Rosa 'Ispahan' (D), the (D) being the RHS horticultural code for a Damask rose"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/ispahan","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Listed and sold as Ispahan, a Damask rose"}],"note":"name resolves as Rosa 'Ispahan' (D)","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rose-of-sharon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[2.75,3.05],"union":[1.83,4.88],"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-syriacus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8 ft. 0 in. - 12 ft. 0 in.","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282593","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8.00 to 12.00 feet","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Hibiscus)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hibiscus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"this native of China and Taiwan is a durable deciduous shrub that grows 8 to 10 feet tall and 6 to 10 feet wide","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Woody Plant Finder (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/woody-info/Hibiscus_syriacus.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8 - 12 feet tall","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/hibiscus-syriacus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Deciduous shrub/tree, 8-12 ft (2.4-4.5 m), upright vase.","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Virginia Tech Dendrology Fact Sheet (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://dendro.cnre.vt.edu/dendrology/syllabus/factsheet.cfm?ID=283","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Form: Small tree or upright shrub up to 10 feet in height, pyramidal crown.","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Rose of Sharon growing guide)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/rose-sharon","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature size can range from 6 to 16 feet tall and 2 to 10 feet wide.","metres":[1.83,4.88],"band":[1.83,4.88],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County fact sheet (Rose-of-Sharon)","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/06/09/fact-sheet-rose-sharon/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Rose-of-Sharon grows 8 to 10 feet tall and spreads 4 to 10 feet.","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rose-of-sharon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.83,3.05],"union":[0.61,3.05],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-syriacus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 6 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282593","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 6.00 to 10.00 feet","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Hibiscus)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hibiscus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"this native of China and Taiwan is a durable deciduous shrub that grows 8 to 10 feet tall and 6 to 10 feet wide","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Woody Plant Finder (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/woody-info/Hibiscus_syriacus.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 6 - 10 feet wide","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Rose of Sharon growing guide)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/rose-sharon","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature size can range from 6 to 16 feet tall and 2 to 10 feet wide.","metres":[0.61,3.05],"band":[0.61,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County fact sheet (Rose-of-Sharon)","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/06/09/fact-sheet-rose-sharon/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Rose-of-Sharon grows 8 to 10 feet tall and spreads 4 to 10 feet.","metres":[1.22,3.05],"band":[1.22,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rose-of-sharon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","5-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-syriacus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282593","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Hibiscus)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hibiscus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is hardy in USDA Zones 5-9.","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Woody Plant Finder (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/woody-info/Hibiscus_syriacus.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: zones 5 - 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Rose of Sharon growing guide)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/rose-sharon","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy in USDA zones 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Rose-of-Sharon)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/rose-of-sharon/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rose-of-sharon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-syriacus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in locations with full sun to partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282593","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Woody Plant Finder (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/woody-info/Hibiscus_syriacus.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: prefers full sun, but will tolerate part shade","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/hibiscus-syriacus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade, grows in most soils, except those extremely wet or dry.","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Rose of Sharon growing guide)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/rose-sharon","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants will bloom best in full sun, but can tolerate some light shade.","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County fact sheet (Rose-of-Sharon)","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/06/09/fact-sheet-rose-sharon/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plant grows in sun or partial shade and in any soil.","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Rose-of-Sharon)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/rose-of-sharon/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers moist, well-drained soils in full sun to part shade.","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rose-of-sharon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rose-of-sharon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rose-of-sharon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282593","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil, Black Walnut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Rose of Sharon growing guide)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/rose-sharon","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Rose of Sharon is drought-tolerant once established","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rose-of-sharon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-syriacus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are an attractant for butterflies, specialized bees, hummingbirds, and pollinators and are a wildlife food source.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282593","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"Texas Tech University Woody Plant Finder (Hibiscus syriacus)","url":"https://www.depts.ttu.edu/plantresources/Pages/directories/landscape-info-sheets/woody-info/Hibiscus_syriacus.php","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife: attracts hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Rose-of-Sharon)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/rose-of-sharon/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies and hummingbirds appear at the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus syriacus"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"rose-of-sharon-blue-chiffon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[2.44,3.05],"union":[1.83,3.66],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer of the Chiffon series)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/hibiscus/blue-chiffon-rose-sharon-hibiscus-syriacus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8' - 12'","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/blue-chiffon-rose-of-sharon/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 8 - 12 Feet","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/rose-of-sharon-blue-chiffon","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 8-12 ft","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"PlantingTree","url":"https://www.plantingtree.com/products/blue-chiffon-rose-of-sharon","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 6-10 Feet","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rose-of-sharon-blue-chiffon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.22,1.83],"union":[1.22,3.05],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer of the Chiffon series)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/hibiscus/blue-chiffon-rose-sharon-hibiscus-syriacus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 6' - 10'","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/blue-chiffon-rose-of-sharon/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 4 - 6 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/rose-of-sharon-blue-chiffon","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 5-6 ft","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"PlantingTree","url":"https://www.plantingtree.com/products/blue-chiffon-rose-of-sharon","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width 4-5 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rose-of-sharon-blue-chiffon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","5-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer of the Chiffon series)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/hibiscus/blue-chiffon-rose-sharon-hibiscus-syriacus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b , 9a , 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/blue-chiffon-rose-of-sharon/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones : 5 - 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/rose-of-sharon-blue-chiffon","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 5a – to 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"PlantingTree","url":"https://www.plantingtree.com/products/blue-chiffon-rose-of-sharon","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones 5-9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282593","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-syriacus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rose-of-sharon-blue-chiffon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/blue-chiffon-rose-of-sharon/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Full Sun (6+ Hours Direct Sunlight)"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/rose-of-sharon-blue-chiffon","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full sun"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282593","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-syriacus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/hibiscus-syriacus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade, grows in most soils, except those extremely wet or dry."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rose-of-sharon-blue-chiffon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rose-of-sharon-blue-chiffon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rose-of-sharon-blue-chiffon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/hibiscus/blue-chiffon-rose-sharon-hibiscus-syriacus","https://plantaddicts.com/blue-chiffon-rose-of-sharon/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/hibiscus/blue-chiffon-rose-sharon-hibiscus-syriacus","https://naturehills.com/products/rose-of-sharon-blue-chiffon"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer of the Chiffon series)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/hibiscus/blue-chiffon-rose-sharon-hibiscus-syriacus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/blue-chiffon-rose-of-sharon/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"loves the heat of summer and is very drought tolerant once established","claim":true},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/rose-of-sharon-blue-chiffon","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Somewhat Drought Tolerant & Salt Tolerant","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rose-of-sharon-blue-chiffon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer of the Chiffon series)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/hibiscus/blue-chiffon-rose-sharon-hibiscus-syriacus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/blue-chiffon-rose-of-sharon/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Many different pollinators and hummingbirds will enjoy the flowers too","claim":true},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/rose-of-sharon-blue-chiffon","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Hummingbirds, Attracts pollinators","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-syriacus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rose-shrub","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.22],"union":[0.2,15.24],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,2.44],"band":[0.3,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Growing Roses)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/growing-roses/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Roses range in size from tiny miniatures of 8 inches tall to tree climbing giants that will reach 50 feet or more.","metres":[0.2,15.24],"band":[0.2,15.24],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden (Rose, Rosa sp.)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/encyclopedia/rose-rosa-sp","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: 2' to 6' tall, depending on variety","metres":[0.61,1.83],"band":[0.61,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden (Rose Types and Cultivars)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/rose-types-and-cultivars","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Plants range in size from 1.5 to 4 feet tall and are great additions to the front of the shrub border or the middle or back of the perennial border.","metres":[0.46,1.22],"band":[0.46,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Illinois Extension (Roses: Rose Types)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/roses/roses-types","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"has been defined in terms such as \"a rose that is typically over 4 feet high and grows in a mounded shrubby shape.\"","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":8,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rose-shrub","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,1.83],"band":[0.3,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":8,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rose-shrub","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","4-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[5,11],"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden (Rose, Rosa sp.)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/encyclopedia/rose-rosa-sp","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness: zones 4 to 7; although many cultivars (particularly hybrid teas, grandifloras and floribundas) are not winter hardy in Iowa","zones":[4,7],"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"genus":8,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rose-shrub","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden (Rose, Rosa sp.)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/encyclopedia/rose-rosa-sp","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in full sun and well-drained, moist soil.","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension G6600 (Roses: Selecting and Planting)","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/publications/g6600","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Roses grow best in full sunlight. If full sun is not possible, locate them where they get a minimum of six hours of bright sunlight each day.","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rosa rugosa)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286364","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"rosa rugosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa setigera)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-setigera/","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"rosa setigera"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa x centifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-x-centifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"rosa centifolia"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rose-shrub","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are often fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Growing Roses)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/growing-roses/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Many are highly valued for their fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden (Rose, Rosa sp.)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/encyclopedia/rose-rosa-sp","country":null,"form":null,"value":"One of the most popular garden plants, roses are both beautiful and fragrant","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension G6600 (Roses: Selecting and Planting)","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/publications/g6600","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Their ephemeral beauty and delicate fragrance have universal appeal.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rosa rugosa)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286364","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rosa rugosa"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions (Roses)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/roses/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Roses are longtime landscape favorites because of their rich fragrance and beautiful color.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"RHS (Roses growing guide)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/roses/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Some roses have a fruity fragrance while others have a musk or tea scent","claim":true,"level":"genus"},{"name":"Illinois Extension (Roses: Rose Types)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/roses/roses-types","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Shrub roses are also very free-flowering, producing a good supply of fragrant flowers all summer.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa setigera)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-setigera/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rosa setigera"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa x centifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-x-centifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are large, globular and very fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rosa centifolia"}],"note":"10 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rose-shrub","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Growing Roses)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/growing-roses/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Roses are grown for their beautiful blooms, either as landscape color or for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension G6600 (Roses: Selecting and Planting)","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/publications/g6600","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are useful as landscape plants and prized as cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions (Roses)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/roses/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gardeners love roses in part because they can be brought inside and enjoyed as beautiful cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["rosa setigera"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (rosa setigera), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (rosa setigera) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"rose-shrub","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["rosa setigera"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (rosa setigera), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (rosa setigera) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"rose-shrub","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife is attracted to the edible hips. Single-flowered species and cultivars are attractive to bees. Dead stems are used by stem-nesting bees.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Rosa rugosa)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286364","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rosa rugosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Rosa setigera)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-setigera/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fruits attract small mammals and birds as a food source. Honeybees and bumblebees collect and enjoy the pollen from the flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"rosa setigera"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"rosemary","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.22,1.52],"union":[0.61,2.01],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=444418","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.61,1.83],"band":[0.61,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-rosmarinus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/rosmarinus-officinalis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Herbaceous evergreen shrublet, 2-6 ft (0.6-1.8 m), irregular shape.","metres":[0.61,1.83],"band":[0.61,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/rosemary-rosemarinus-officinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In its native habitat, rosemary grows to a tall shrub 4 to 6 feet high.","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/edibles/vegetables/rosemary/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It can reach up to 6 feet tall and 4 to 5 feet wide when planted in the ground but will remain smaller if pruned or planted in containers.","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rosemary","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.61,1.52],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=444418","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-rosmarinus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/edibles/vegetables/rosemary/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It can reach up to 6 feet tall and 4 to 5 feet wide when planted in the ground but will remain smaller if pruned or planted in containers.","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rosemary","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[8,10],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=444418","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 8 to 10","zones":[8,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-rosmarinus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[8,10]}],"note":"every source states 8-10; catalog states 7-10","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rosemary","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=444418","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-rosmarinus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/rosemary-rosemarinus-officinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants grow best in full sun in well-drained soil"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rosemary","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=444418","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The intensely fragrant foliage of this shrub is commonly harvested for a variety of purposes including culinary flavorings, toiletries and sachets.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-rosmarinus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The intensely fragrant foliage of this shrub is commonly harvested for a variety of purposes including cooking and potpourri.","claim":true},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/edibles/vegetables/rosemary/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Rosemary is a fragrant herb that can enhance both your cooking and your landscape.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rosemary","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-rosmarinus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Edible Fragrant Good Cut Good Dried","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rosemary","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=444418","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Established plants have good drought tolerance.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-rosmarinus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Highly salt and drought tolerant; resistant to damage by deer.","claim":true},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/rosmarinus-officinalis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sun. Easily grown, withstand drought and salt","claim":true},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/edibles/vegetables/rosemary/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Rosemary is also an attractive, drought-tolerant plant that works well in containers and landscape beds.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rosemary","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=444418","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to butterflies, bees, and other insect pollinators.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-rosmarinus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract butterflies and bees. American goldfinches eat the seeds.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"royal-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.61,2.5],"split":[{"range":[0.61,0.91],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder"]},{"range":[1.37,2.5],"sources":["Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","Royal Horticultural Society","NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285736","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/osmunda-regalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.52,1.83],"band":[1.52,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/osmunda-regalis-royal-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Royal fern produces dense clumps of bright green fronds, some as tall as 5 feet.","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=osre","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size Notes: Fronds up to about 6 feet long.","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/12001/osmunda-regalis/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 1.5-2.5 metres","metres":[1.5,2.5],"band":[1.5,2.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"royal-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.5,1],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285736","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/osmunda-regalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/12001/osmunda-regalis/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"royal-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","3-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285736","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/osmunda-regalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[3,10]},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/osmunda-regalis-royal-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3 - 9","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"royal-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285736","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/osmunda-regalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/osmunda-regalis-royal-fern","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Partial Shade Full Shade"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=osre","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Shade , Shade"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/12001/osmunda-regalis/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full shade, Full sun, Partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"royal-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"royal-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"royal-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285736","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Best grown in medium to wet soils in part shade.","claim":false},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/osmunda-regalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In climates with cool summers, it can tolerate close to full sun as long as it is given consistent moisture.","claim":false},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=osre","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water Use: High","claim":false}],"note":"3 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"royal-fern","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"royal-jubilee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.37,1.5],"union":[1,1.67],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - the breeder","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/royal-jubilee","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 5ft","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/royal-jubilee","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 5' x 3'","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rosenhof Odendahl","url":"https://www.rosenhof-odendahl.de/erzeugnis/royal-jubilee/","country":"DE","form":"shrub","value":"Höhe ca. 140 cm","metres":1.4,"band":[1.26,1.54],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Belle Epoque Rozen","url":"https://belle-epoque.nl/products/royal-jubilee","country":"NL","form":"shrub","value":"Hoogte 100-150 cm","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - the breeder","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/royal-jubilee","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4 1/2ft (140cm)","metres":1.4,"band":[1.26,1.54],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"royal-jubilee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.82,1.54],"split":[{"range":[0.82,1],"sources":["Heirloom Roses"]},{"range":[1.1,1.54],"sources":["David Austin Roses (US) - the breeder","Rosenhof Odendahl"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - the breeder","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/royal-jubilee","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/royal-jubilee","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 5' x 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rosenhof Odendahl","url":"https://www.rosenhof-odendahl.de/erzeugnis/royal-jubilee/","country":"DE","form":"shrub","value":"Breite ca. 140 cm","metres":1.4,"band":[1.26,1.54],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - the breeder","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/royal-jubilee","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 4 1/2ft (140cm)","metres":1.4,"band":[1.26,1.54],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"royal-jubilee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - the breeder","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/royal-jubilee","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/royal-jubilee","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"royal-jubilee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/royal-jubilee","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/royal-jubilee"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - the breeder","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/royal-jubilee","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - the breeder","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/royal-jubilee","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"royal-jubilee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["medium","medium"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/royal-jubilee","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/royal-jubilee"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/royal-jubilee","https://heirloomroses.com/products/royal-jubilee"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/royal-jubilee","https://www.rosenhof-odendahl.de/erzeugnis/royal-jubilee/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/royal-jubilee","https://belle-epoque.nl/products/royal-jubilee"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - the breeder","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/royal-jubilee","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There is a lovely fruity fragrance with a hint of blackcurrants.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - the breeder","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/royal-jubilee","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There is a lovely fruity fragrance with a hint of blackcurrants.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/royal-jubilee","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Exceptionally Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rosenhof Odendahl","url":"https://www.rosenhof-odendahl.de/erzeugnis/royal-jubilee/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Duftintensität ***","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Belle Epoque Rozen","url":"https://belle-epoque.nl/products/royal-jubilee","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Geur Sterk klassiek rozengeur","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"royal-jubilee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"royal-jubilee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"royal-jubilee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"rugosa-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.22,1.83],"union":[1.22,1.83],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-rugosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286364","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rugosa-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.22,1.83],"union":[1.22,1.83],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-rugosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 4 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286364","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rugosa-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[2,7],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-rugosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[2,7]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286364","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 7","zones":[2,7]}],"note":"every source states 2-7; catalog states 3-9","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rugosa-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-rugosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286364","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rugosa-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-rugosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are fragrant and appear in clusters or singly in shades of rose pink or white blooms.","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286364","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rugosa-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rugosa-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-rugosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is also drought and salt-tolerant.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"rugosa-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-rugosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The plant attracts pollinating insects and butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286364","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sage","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.3,0.46],"union":[0.3,0.76],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281464","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-officinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/edibles/vegetables/sage/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"As your sage grows, it will mature into a semi-woody perennial that reaches 12 to 18 inches tall.","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sage","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"edge","consensus":[0.61,0.76],"union":[0.61,0.91],"edge":[0.59,0.94],"edgeMargin":1.6,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281464","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-officinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"withdrawnFromV2":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.69},"note":"the catalog value sits 1.6% outside the sources' union (0.61 to 0.91 m) and inside the 3% margin v3 allows at a stated range edge (0.59 to 0.94 m), so v2's proposal of 0.69 m is withdrawn rather than applied; 2 of these 2 scored sources publish a range, and a range edge is a figure converted and rounded from another unit rather than a measurement to the centimetre","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sage","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281464","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-officinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sage","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281464","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-officinalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sage","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281464","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-officinalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaves measure 4 inches long and are very fragrant.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sage","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sage","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281464","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-officinalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It will tolerate drought and poor soils.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sage","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281464","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A mint family member that is attractive to bees and butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-officinalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract butterflies and bees.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sally-holmes","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1,3.66],"split":[{"range":[1,1.5],"sources":["RHS"]},{"range":[1.83,3.66],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/119748/rosa-sally-holmes-(s)/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-sally-holmes/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6 ft. 0 in. - 12 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sally-holmes","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1],"union":[0.5,1.52],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/119748/rosa-sally-holmes-(s)/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-sally-holmes/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sally-holmes","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-sally-holmes/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sally-holmes","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/119748/rosa-sally-holmes-(s)/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-sally-holmes/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sally-holmes","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","strengths":["medium"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-sally-holmes/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"White blend flowers with moderate fragrance and 5-8 petals are 3.5 inches across.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sally-holmes","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/119748/rosa-sally-holmes-(s)/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-sally-holmes/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sally-holmes","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sally-holmes","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-sally-holmes/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sally-holmes","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"botanicalName","current":"Rosa 'Sally Holmes'","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"RHS","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/119748/rosa-sally-holmes-(s)/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Listed, classified as a shrub rose (S), holds an Award of Garden Merit"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-sally-holmes/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Listed under the same name, described as a hybrid musk rose"}],"note":"name resolves as Rosa 'Sally Holmes' (S)","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"salvia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.46,1],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 6 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.46,0.91],"band":[0.46,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423&isprofile=0&basic=Salvia+nemorosa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.91],"band":[0.46,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"RHS Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa, Balkan clary)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/60176/salvia-nemorosa/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Perennial Salvia, Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=745&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 2-3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Illinois Extension Flowers (Perennial Salvia, Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/perennial-salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 2 to 3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":1,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"salvia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.5],"union":[0.1,0.61],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.15,0.61],"band":[0.15,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423&isprofile=0&basic=Salvia+nemorosa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"RHS Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa, Balkan clary)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/60176/salvia-nemorosa/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":1,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"salvia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423&isprofile=0&basic=Salvia+nemorosa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Perennial Salvia, Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=745&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 3 - 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Illinois Extension Flowers (Perennial Salvia, Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/perennial-salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":1,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"salvia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This is an easy plant to grow in full sun to partial shade in average, moist, well-drained soil.","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423&isprofile=0&basic=Salvia+nemorosa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"RHS Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa, Balkan clary)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/60176/salvia-nemorosa/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Perennial Salvia, Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=745&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Illinois Extension Flowers (Perennial Salvia, Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/perennial-salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1170, Salvia (Woodland Sage section)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/salvia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most salvias prefer full sun and well-drained soils, but some will bloom well in part shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"salvia"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Salvia nemorosa 'May Night')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALMN","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries (Salvia nemorosa 'Caradonna')","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Salvia-nemorosa-Caradonna","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers average, clay or sandy, well-drained soils in full sun.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"salvia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423&isprofile=0&basic=Salvia+nemorosa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"medium green to gray-green leaves (to 4\" long) are aromatic when bruised.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Perennial Salvia, Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=745&PlantTypeID=2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Reported to be deer and rabbit resistant. Fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Illinois Extension Flowers (Perennial Salvia, Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/perennial-salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Reported to be deer and rabbit resistant. Fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1170, Salvia (Woodland Sage section)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/salvia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Salvias have brilliantly colored flowers, square stems, and attractive, often scented foliage.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"salvia"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["salvia nemorosa"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (salvia nemorosa), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (salvia nemorosa) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"salvia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1170, Salvia (Woodland Sage section)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/salvia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"salvias can be used for mass plantings, borders, containers, accents, and cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"salvia"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["salvia nemorosa"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (salvia nemorosa), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (salvia nemorosa) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"salvia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought-tolerant and is seldom damaged by deer or rabbit browsing.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423&isprofile=0&basic=Salvia+nemorosa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"RHS Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa, Balkan clary)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/60176/salvia-nemorosa/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Perennial Salvia, Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=745&PlantTypeID=2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Illinois Extension Flowers (Perennial Salvia, Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/perennial-salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1170, Salvia (Woodland Sage section)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/salvia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, most salvia species are quite drought-tolerant and require little care.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"salvia"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["salvia nemorosa"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (salvia nemorosa), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (salvia nemorosa) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"salvia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to hummingbirds, bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423&isprofile=0&basic=Salvia+nemorosa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1170, Salvia (Woodland Sage section)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/salvia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"One benefit of growing salvias is their appeal to hummingbirds, butterflies, and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"salvia"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["salvia nemorosa"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (salvia nemorosa), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (salvia nemorosa) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"salvia-april-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.3,0.36],"union":[0.3,0.36],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/salvia-nemerosa-april-night-meadow-sage-1g.html","https://www.gurneys.com/products/april-night-salvia"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/salvia-nemerosa-april-night-meadow-sage-1g.html","https://www.rdwholesalenursery.com/Plant-Name/Salvia-April-Night-April-Night-Salvia"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/salvia-nemerosa-april-night-meadow-sage-1g.html","https://www.northcoastperennials.com/product/salvia-nemorosa-sallyrosa-april-night-ppaf/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/salvia-nemerosa-april-night-meadow-sage-1g.html","https://costafarms.com/blogs/plant-varieties/salvia-perennial-sallyrosa-april-night"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/salvia-nemerosa-april-night-meadow-sage-1g.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height at Maturity: 12-14\"","metres":[0.3,0.36],"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed and Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/april-night-salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 12 - 14 inches","metres":[0.3,0.36],"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"R&D Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.rdwholesalenursery.com/Plant-Name/Salvia-April-Night-April-Night-Salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12-14 in","metres":[0.3,0.36],"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"North Coast Perennials (wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.northcoastperennials.com/product/salvia-nemorosa-sallyrosa-april-night-ppaf/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"height: 12-14″","metres":[0.3,0.36],"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Costa Farms","url":"https://costafarms.com/blogs/plant-varieties/salvia-perennial-sallyrosa-april-night","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It has a nice upright growth habit and grows 12 to 14 inches tall.","metres":[0.3,0.36],"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":3,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.33},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"salvia-april-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.3,0.36],"union":[0.3,0.36],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/salvia-nemerosa-april-night-meadow-sage-1g.html","https://www.gurneys.com/products/april-night-salvia"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/salvia-nemerosa-april-night-meadow-sage-1g.html","https://www.rdwholesalenursery.com/Plant-Name/Salvia-April-Night-April-Night-Salvia"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/salvia-nemerosa-april-night-meadow-sage-1g.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width at Maturity: 12-14\"","metres":[0.3,0.36],"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed and Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/april-night-salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 12 - 14 inches","metres":[0.3,0.36],"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"R&D Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.rdwholesalenursery.com/Plant-Name/Salvia-April-Night-April-Night-Salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12-14 in","metres":[0.3,0.36],"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":3,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.33},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"salvia-april-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","4-10","4-8","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/salvia-nemerosa-april-night-meadow-sage-1g.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Cold Hardiness Zones: 4a-9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed and Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/april-night-salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 4-10","zones":[4,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"R&D Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.rdwholesalenursery.com/Plant-Name/Salvia-April-Night-April-Night-Salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4-8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Costa Farms","url":"https://costafarms.com/blogs/plant-varieties/salvia-perennial-sallyrosa-april-night","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows 12 to 14 inches tall. Zones 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":3,"cultivar":6},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"salvia-april-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia x sylvestris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed and Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/april-night-salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Best in full sun.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"R&D Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.rdwholesalenursery.com/Plant-Name/Salvia-April-Night-April-Night-Salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"salvia-april-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia x sylvestris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/salvia-nemerosa-april-night-meadow-sage-1g.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers: No","claim":false,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"salvia-april-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia x sylvestris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/salvia-nemerosa-april-night-meadow-sage-1g.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Also excellent for cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"salvia-april-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought-tolerant and is seldom damaged by deer or rabbit browsing.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia x sylvestris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is tolerant of gravely or sandy soils and drought once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/salvia-nemerosa-april-night-meadow-sage-1g.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Established plants are tolerant of dry periods when growing in the ground however will appreciate an occasional deep soaking when temperatures are high and weather is dry.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"R&D Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.rdwholesalenursery.com/Plant-Name/Salvia-April-Night-April-Night-Salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"North Coast Perennials (wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.northcoastperennials.com/product/salvia-nemorosa-sallyrosa-april-night-ppaf/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent tolerance to drought and mildew.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"salvia-april-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Flowers attract bees, butterflies, hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia x sylvestris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Flowers attract bees, hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/salvia-nemerosa-april-night-meadow-sage-1g.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies, Hummingbirds, Beneficial Pollinators, Visual Attention","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Gurney's Seed and Nursery","url":"https://www.gurneys.com/products/april-night-salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"R&D Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://www.rdwholesalenursery.com/Plant-Name/Salvia-April-Night-April-Night-Salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"North Coast Perennials (wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.northcoastperennials.com/product/salvia-nemorosa-sallyrosa-april-night-ppaf/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It attracts bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds, and is rabbit and deer resistant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"salvia-blue-marvel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/salvia-nemorosa-blue-marvel.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"10-12 inches","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"salvia-blue-marvel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/salvia-nemorosa-blue-marvel.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"10-12 inches","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"salvia-blue-marvel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/salvia-nemorosa-blue-marvel.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"salvia-blue-marvel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/salvia-nemorosa-blue-marvel.html","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"salvia-blue-marvel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"salvia-blue-marvel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/salvia-nemorosa-blue-marvel.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cutting.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"salvia-blue-marvel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/salvia-nemorosa-blue-marvel.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants are reasonably drought tolerant, once established.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"salvia-blue-marvel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Heritage Perennials (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/salvia-nemorosa-blue-marvel.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to both butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"salvia-caradonna","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.67],"union":[0.3,0.76],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa 'Caradonna')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=258897&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (wholesale propagator)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALCA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24.0-30.0 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries (wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Caradonna","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18-30 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.76],"band":[0.46,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-salvia-sylvestris-caradonna","country":"US","form":null,"value":"24\" tall x 18\" wide","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-salvia-caradonna","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 24-30\" tall","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"salvia-caradonna","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.42],"union":[0.3,0.61],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa 'Caradonna')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=258897&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (wholesale propagator)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALCA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 15.0 Inches","metres":0.38,"band":[0.34,0.42],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries (wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Caradonna","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12-18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-salvia-sylvestris-caradonna","country":"US","form":null,"value":"24\" tall x 18\" wide","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-salvia-caradonna","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 12-24\" wide","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"salvia-caradonna","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","3-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa 'Caradonna')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=258897&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (wholesale propagator)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALCA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries (wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Caradonna","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-salvia-sylvestris-caradonna","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ZONES 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-salvia-caradonna","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones Zone 4 Zone 5 Zone 6 Zone 7 Zone 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"species":3},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"salvia-caradonna","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa 'Caradonna')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=258897&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia x sylvestris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (wholesale propagator)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALCA","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries (wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Caradonna","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-salvia-sylvestris-caradonna","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in full sun.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-salvia-caradonna","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"salvia-caradonna","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa 'Caradonna')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=258897&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia x sylvestris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (wholesale propagator)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALCA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Border Plant Container Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Easy To Grow Edging Fragrant Flowers Fragrant Foliage Mass Planting Salt Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries (wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Caradonna","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The leaves are aromatic when crushed.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-salvia-caradonna","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers Dried Flowers Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"salvia-caradonna","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia x sylvestris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (wholesale propagator)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALCA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Border Plant Container Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Easy To Grow Edging Fragrant Flowers Fragrant Foliage Mass Planting Salt Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries (wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Caradonna","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-salvia-caradonna","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers Dried Flowers Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"salvia-caradonna","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa 'Caradonna')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=258897&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought-tolerant and is seldom damaged by deer or rabbit browsing.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia x sylvestris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is tolerant of gravely or sandy soils and drought once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (wholesale propagator)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALCA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Though it is drought tolerant, it will bloom better with regular watering.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries (wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Caradonna","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought, heat and humidity tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-salvia-caradonna","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates Dry Sites","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"salvia-caradonna","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa 'Caradonna')","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=258897&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Flowers attract bees, butterflies, hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Salvia x sylvestris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Flowers attract bees, hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (wholesale propagator)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALCA","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries (wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Caradonna","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator-friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-salvia-sylvestris-caradonna","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vertical spikes of richly colored blooms last for weeks providing a superb nectar source for honeybees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-salvia-caradonna","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bee Friendly Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds Attracts Birds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"salvia-may-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.5,0.51],"union":[0.41,1],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250510&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer / wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALMN","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18.0 Inches","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/116997/salvia-x-sylvestris-mainacht/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Salvia-nemorosa-May-Night","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18-24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/salvia-may-night","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 2 ft","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Kiefer Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/salvia-x-sylvestris-mainacht-may-night/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 18\"","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":4,"genus":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-may-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.1,0.67],"split":[{"range":[0.1,0.5],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","North Creek Nurseries","Kiefer Nursery","Walters Gardens (introducer / wholesale grower)"]},{"range":[0.55,0.67],"sources":["Nature Hills Nursery"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250510&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer / wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALMN","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 15.0-18.0 Inches","metres":[0.38,0.46],"band":[0.38,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/116997/salvia-x-sylvestris-mainacht/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Salvia-nemorosa-May-Night","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12-18 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/salvia-may-night","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 2 ft","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Kiefer Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/salvia-x-sylvestris-mainacht-may-night/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 12-18\"","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":4,"genus":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-may-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","3-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250510&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer / wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALMN","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Salvia-nemorosa-May-Night","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/salvia-may-night","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy throughout USDA planting zones 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Kiefer Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/salvia-x-sylvestris-mainacht-may-night/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"cultivar":6,"species":4,"genus":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-may-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250510&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Salvia x sylvestris","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Salvia nemorosa","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This is an easy plant to grow in full sun to partial shade in average, moist, well-drained soil.","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer / wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALMN","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/116997/salvia-x-sylvestris-mainacht/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Best in full sun but can tolerate light partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers - Perennial Salvia","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/PlantDetail.cfm?PlantID=745&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Illinois Extension Flowers - Perennial Salvia","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/perennial-salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/salvia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most salvias prefer full sun and well-drained soils, but some will bloom well in part shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"salvia"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Salvia-nemorosa-May-Night","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers average, clay or sandy, well-drained soils in full sun.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/salvia-may-night","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach - Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/easy-grow-perennials","country":"US","form":null,"value":"prefer full sun, well-drained soil, and moderate moisture, with good air circulation","level":"genus","taxon":"salvia"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-may-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250510&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaves of this mint family member are aromatic, wrinkled and soft-hairy beneath with entire or serrate margins.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Salvia x sylvestris","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Ovate to lanceolate, serrate to entire margins, medium green, fragrant leaves.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Salvia nemorosa","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#fragrant leaves","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer / wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALMN","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This is a clump forming plant with oblong leaves which are aromatic when crushed.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/116997/salvia-x-sylvestris-mainacht/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Illinois Extension Flowers - Perennial Salvia","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/perennial-salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Reported to be deer and rabbit resistant. Fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Salvia-nemorosa-May-Night","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The leaves are aromatic when crushed.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/salvia-may-night","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Simply brushing against the textured foliage releases an herbal fragrance that lingers in the air.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Kiefer Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/salvia-x-sylvestris-mainacht-may-night/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance No","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"salvia-may-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250510&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Salvia x sylvestris","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers last a long time.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer / wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALMN","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Border Plant Container Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Easy To Grow Edging Fragrant Flowers Fragrant Foliage Mass Planting Salt Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/salvia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"As some of the best summer-blooming annuals and perennials, salvias can be used for mass plantings, borders, containers, accents, and cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"salvia"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Salvia-nemorosa-May-Night","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Makes an excellent cut flower, fresh or dried, and its leaves are freshly aromatic.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/salvia-may-night","country":null,"form":null,"value":"May Night Salvia blooms are excellent tall and slender cut flower accents!","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"salvia-may-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250510&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Salvia x sylvestris","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is tolerant of gravely or sandy soils and drought once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Salvia nemorosa","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought-tolerant and is seldom damaged by deer or rabbit browsing.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer / wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALMN","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Though it is drought tolerant, it will bloom better with regular watering.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Illinois Extension Flowers - Perennial Salvia","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/perennial-salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/salvia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, most salvia species are quite drought-tolerant and require little care.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"salvia"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Salvia-nemorosa-May-Night","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought, heat and humidity tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/salvia-may-night","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, May Night is quite drought-tolerant, but occasional deep watering during hot, dry spells will keep the foliage lush and support a strong rebloom.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach - Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/easy-grow-perennials","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator-friendly and drought-tolerant once established, species such as Salvia nemorosa ('May Night,' 'Caradonna') perform especially well in the Midwest.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"salvia"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-may-night","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250510&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Salvia x sylvestris","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract bees, hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox - Salvia nemorosa","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to hummingbirds, bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer / wholesale grower)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALMN","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/salvia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"One benefit of growing salvias is their appeal to hummingbirds, butterflies, and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"salvia"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Salvia-nemorosa-May-Night","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts birds, butterflies and bees.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/salvia-may-night","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This is one of the most popular flowers for butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach - Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/easy-grow-perennials","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator-friendly and drought-tolerant once established, species such as Salvia nemorosa ('May Night,' 'Caradonna') perform especially well in the Midwest.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"salvia"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-pink-profusion","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.36,0.41],"union":[0.36,0.41],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","https://romencegardens.com/products/salvia-nermosa-pink-profusion"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","https://www.usperennials.com/salvia-nemorosa-pink-profusion-perennial-salvia-pink-profusion/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","https://www.newblooms.com/products/salvia-pink-profusion-profusion-series"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","https://provenwinnersdirect.com/products/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","https://windingcreek-nursery.com/Plant-Name/Salvia-nemorosa-Pink-Profusion-Perennial-Salvia"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","https://www.newgardenplants.com/salvia-nemorosa-pink-profusion"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Pink-Profusion"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 14.0-16.0 Inches","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Garden Height: 14 - 16 Inches","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Romence Gardens & Greenhouses","url":"https://romencegardens.com/products/salvia-nermosa-pink-profusion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Garden Height: 14-16 Inches","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/salvia-nemorosa-pink-profusion-perennial-salvia-pink-profusion/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size : 14-16\" tall x 16-20\" wide","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"New Blooms Nursery","url":"https://www.newblooms.com/products/salvia-pink-profusion-profusion-series","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 14 to 16 inches","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Proven Winners Direct","url":"https://provenwinnersdirect.com/products/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"14-16 inches tall and 16-20 inches wide at maturity","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Average Landscape Size: Grows to a height of 14-16 inches (36cm-41cm) and spreads 16-20 inches (41cm-51cm), forming a dense, rounded habit.","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Winding Creek Nursery","url":"https://windingcreek-nursery.com/Plant-Name/Salvia-nemorosa-Pink-Profusion-Perennial-Salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 14 - 16 in","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"New Garden Plants","url":"https://www.newgardenplants.com/salvia-nemorosa-pink-profusion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 14-16 inches","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Pink-Profusion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 14-16 in","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.39},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 10 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 10; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-pink-profusion","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.3,0.51],"split":[{"range":[0.3,0.36],"sources":["Hoffie Nursery"]},{"range":[0.41,0.51],"sources":["Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","Proven Winners","Romence Gardens & Greenhouses","US Perennials","New Blooms Nursery","Proven Winners Direct","Arbor Valley Nursery","Winding Creek Nursery","New Garden Plants"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 16.0-20.0 Inches","metres":[0.41,0.51],"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 16 - 20 Inches","metres":[0.41,0.51],"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Romence Gardens & Greenhouses","url":"https://romencegardens.com/products/salvia-nermosa-pink-profusion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Garden Spread: 16-20 Inches","metres":[0.41,0.51],"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/salvia-nemorosa-pink-profusion-perennial-salvia-pink-profusion/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size : 14-16\" tall x 16-20\" wide","metres":[0.41,0.51],"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"New Blooms Nursery","url":"https://www.newblooms.com/products/salvia-pink-profusion-profusion-series","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 16 to 20 inches","metres":[0.41,0.51],"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Proven Winners Direct","url":"https://provenwinnersdirect.com/products/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"14-16 inches tall and 16-20 inches wide at maturity","metres":[0.41,0.51],"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Average Landscape Size: Grows to a height of 14-16 inches (36cm-41cm) and spreads 16-20 inches (41cm-51cm), forming a dense, rounded habit.","metres":[0.41,0.51],"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Winding Creek Nursery","url":"https://windingcreek-nursery.com/Plant-Name/Salvia-nemorosa-Pink-Profusion-Perennial-Salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 16 - 20 in","metres":[0.41,0.51],"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"New Garden Plants","url":"https://www.newgardenplants.com/salvia-nemorosa-pink-profusion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 16-20 inches","metres":[0.41,0.51],"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Pink-Profusion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12-14 in","metres":[0.3,0.36],"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-pink-profusion","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","https://romencegardens.com/products/salvia-nermosa-pink-profusion"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","https://www.usperennials.com/salvia-nemorosa-pink-profusion-perennial-salvia-pink-profusion/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","https://www.newblooms.com/products/salvia-pink-profusion-profusion-series"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","https://provenwinnersdirect.com/products/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","https://windingcreek-nursery.com/Plant-Name/Salvia-nemorosa-Pink-Profusion-Perennial-Salvia"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","https://www.newgardenplants.com/salvia-nemorosa-pink-profusion"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Pink-Profusion"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3a , 3b , 4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Romence Gardens & Greenhouses","url":"https://romencegardens.com/products/salvia-nermosa-pink-profusion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/salvia-nemorosa-pink-profusion-perennial-salvia-pink-profusion/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones : 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"New Blooms Nursery","url":"https://www.newblooms.com/products/salvia-pink-profusion-profusion-series","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Proven Winners Direct","url":"https://provenwinnersdirect.com/products/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy in zones 3-8, be sure to check your USDA zone to ensure success","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Thriving in hardiness zones 3 through 8, the 'Pink Profusion' Perennial Salvia is well-suited to a wide range of climates","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Winding Creek Nursery","url":"https://windingcreek-nursery.com/Plant-Name/Salvia-nemorosa-Pink-Profusion-Perennial-Salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"New Garden Plants","url":"https://www.newgardenplants.com/salvia-nemorosa-pink-profusion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zone 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Pink-Profusion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[3,8]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 10 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 10; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-pink-profusion","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":10,"distinctPublishers":10,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Romence Gardens & Greenhouses","url":"https://romencegardens.com/products/salvia-nermosa-pink-profusion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/salvia-nemorosa-pink-profusion-perennial-salvia-pink-profusion/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun to half shade, dappled sun (ideal is 6+ hours of direct sun or more)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"New Blooms Nursery","url":"https://www.newblooms.com/products/salvia-pink-profusion-profusion-series","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Proven Winners Direct","url":"https://provenwinnersdirect.com/products/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant in full sun (6+ hours daily)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Location: Choose a site that receives full sun, as this plant thrives with at least 6 hours of direct sunlight daily.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Winding Creek Nursery","url":"https://windingcreek-nursery.com/Plant-Name/Salvia-nemorosa-Pink-Profusion-Perennial-Salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"New Garden Plants","url":"https://www.newgardenplants.com/salvia-nemorosa-pink-profusion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun-Shade Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Pink-Profusion","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-pink-profusion","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Dried Flower Easy To Grow Fragrant Flowers Fragrant Foliage Mass Planting Salt Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flower Fragrant Foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Romence Gardens & Greenhouses","url":"https://romencegardens.com/products/salvia-nermosa-pink-profusion","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Notable Features: Cut Flower, Fragrant, Salt Tolerant, Drought Tolerant, Long-Blooming","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/salvia-nemorosa-pink-profusion-perennial-salvia-pink-profusion/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer/Rabbit Resistant : the whole plant is aromatic = yes / yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"New Blooms Nursery","url":"https://www.newblooms.com/products/salvia-pink-profusion-profusion-series","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer Resistant Dry Conditions Feeds Pollinators Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Proven Winners Direct","url":"https://provenwinnersdirect.com/products/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Both the foliage and flowers are wonderfully fragrant, adding a delightful scent to your garden.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Features: Attracts bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds. Resistant to deer and rabbits. Award winner with fragrant flowers and foliage.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"New Garden Plants","url":"https://www.newgardenplants.com/salvia-nemorosa-pink-profusion","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"10 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"salvia-pink-profusion","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Dried Flower Easy To Grow Fragrant Flowers Fragrant Foliage Mass Planting Salt Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Romence Gardens & Greenhouses","url":"https://romencegardens.com/products/salvia-nermosa-pink-profusion","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Notable Features: Cut Flower, Fragrant, Salt Tolerant, Drought Tolerant, Long-Blooming","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Proven Winners Direct","url":"https://provenwinnersdirect.com/products/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great for borders, containers, cut flower, dried flower, landscapes, mass planting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower Gardens: The striking dark pink flowers make excellent cut flowers, adding a pop of color to bouquets and indoor arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Winding Creek Nursery","url":"https://windingcreek-nursery.com/Plant-Name/Salvia-nemorosa-Pink-Profusion-Perennial-Salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"New Garden Plants","url":"https://www.newgardenplants.com/salvia-nemorosa-pink-profusion","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Pink-Profusion","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"salvia-pink-profusion","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Though it is drought tolerant, it will bloom better with regular watering.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant but blooms better with average moisture.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought-tolerant and is seldom damaged by deer or rabbit browsing.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Romence Gardens & Greenhouses","url":"https://romencegardens.com/products/salvia-nermosa-pink-profusion","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established, though blooms best with regular watering.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/salvia-nemorosa-pink-profusion-perennial-salvia-pink-profusion/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"established plants tolerate droughts and drier conditions","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"New Blooms Nursery","url":"https://www.newblooms.com/products/salvia-pink-profusion-profusion-series","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Soil Type: Prefers soil with good drainage, drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Proven Winners Direct","url":"https://provenwinnersdirect.com/products/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought and salt tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerance: Once established, 'Pink Profusion' Salvia is quite tolerant of drought, making it a good choice for water-wise gardens.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Winding Creek Nursery","url":"https://windingcreek-nursery.com/Plant-Name/Salvia-nemorosa-Pink-Profusion-Perennial-Salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"10 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-pink-profusion","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALPF","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees, Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to hummingbirds, bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Romence Gardens & Greenhouses","url":"https://romencegardens.com/products/salvia-nermosa-pink-profusion","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nature Attraction: Butterflies, Hummingbirds, Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/salvia-nemorosa-pink-profusion-perennial-salvia-pink-profusion/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Hummingbirds : yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"New Blooms Nursery","url":"https://www.newblooms.com/products/salvia-pink-profusion-profusion-series","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer Resistant Dry Conditions Feeds Pollinators Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Proven Winners Direct","url":"https://provenwinnersdirect.com/products/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees, butterflies and hummingbirds while resisting deer, rabbits","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Arbor Valley Nursery","url":"https://www.arborvalleynursery.com/plants/pink-profusion-perennial-salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracting Wildlife: Its flowers are not only beautiful but also attract pollinators such as bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds, adding vibrancy and life to your garden.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Winding Creek Nursery","url":"https://windingcreek-nursery.com/Plant-Name/Salvia-nemorosa-Pink-Profusion-Perennial-Salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"New Garden Plants","url":"https://www.newgardenplants.com/salvia-nemorosa-pink-profusion","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Hoffie Nursery","url":"https://www.hoffienursery.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Pink-Profusion","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"12 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-rose-marvel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.25,0.3],"union":[0.23,0.47],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=458495","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"University of Arkansas System Division of Agriculture Cooperative Extension Service, Plant of the Week","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/Salvia%20-nemorosa-Rose-Marvel-Sage-05-11-2018%20.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Rose Marvel is about 14 inches tall and wide.","metres":0.36,"band":[0.32,0.4],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Penn State Trial Gardens (2018 sun ground trial)","url":"https://agsci.psu.edu/flower-trials/Plant-Name/Salvianemorosa-Rose-Marvel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 17 inches","metres":0.43,"band":[0.39,0.47],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP30118 P2, Salvia plant named 'Rose Marvel' (Google Patents full text)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP30118P2/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height from soil level to top of plant plane: Approximately 40.0 cm.","metres":0.4,"band":[0.36,0.44],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Darwin Perennials (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=055000982036998","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 14 - 16\" (36 - 41cm)","metres":[0.36,0.41],"band":[0.36,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/salvia-nemorosa-rose-marvel.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 25-30 cm 10-12 inches","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-salvia-rose-marvel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 10-12\" tall","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-salvia-rose-marvel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 10-12\" tall","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Rose-Marvel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10-12 Inches","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Gertens (plants.gertens.com plant database)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/24039/Rose_Marvel_Salvia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Rose Marvel Salvia will grow to be about 10 inches tall at maturity extending to 14 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 12 inches.","metres":[0.25,0.36],"band":[0.25,0.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-rose-marvel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.23,0.53],"split":[{"range":[0.23,0.4],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Walters Gardens Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","High Country Gardens","American Meadows","North Creek Nurseries","Gertens (plants.gertens.com plant database)","US Plant Patent PP30118 P2, Salvia plant named 'Rose Marvel' (Google Patents full text)","Darwin Perennials (breeder / introducer)","University of Arkansas System Division of Agriculture Cooperative Extension Service, Plant of the Week"]},{"range":[0.43,0.53],"sources":["Penn State Trial Gardens (2018 sun ground trial)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=458495","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"University of Arkansas System Division of Agriculture Cooperative Extension Service, Plant of the Week","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/Salvia%20-nemorosa-Rose-Marvel-Sage-05-11-2018%20.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Rose Marvel is about 14 inches tall and wide.","metres":0.36,"band":[0.32,0.4],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Penn State Trial Gardens (2018 sun ground trial)","url":"https://agsci.psu.edu/flower-trials/Plant-Name/Salvianemorosa-Rose-Marvel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 19 inches","metres":0.48,"band":[0.43,0.53],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP30118 P2, Salvia plant named 'Rose Marvel' (Google Patents full text)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP30118P2/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: Approximately 33.0 cm.","metres":0.33,"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Darwin Perennials (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=055000982036998","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 12 - 14\" (30 - 36cm)","metres":[0.3,0.36],"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/salvia-nemorosa-rose-marvel.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread 25-30 cm 10-12 inches","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-salvia-rose-marvel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 10-12\" wide","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-salvia-rose-marvel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 10-12\" wide","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Rose-Marvel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 10-12 Inches","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Gertens (plants.gertens.com plant database)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/24039/Rose_Marvel_Salvia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Rose Marvel Salvia will grow to be about 10 inches tall at maturity extending to 14 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 12 inches.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-rose-marvel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[4,9],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=458495","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"University of Arkansas System Division of Agriculture Cooperative Extension Service, Plant of the Week","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/Salvia%20-nemorosa-Rose-Marvel-Sage-05-11-2018%20.aspx","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants are winter hardy from zones 4-9.","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP30118 P2, Salvia plant named 'Rose Marvel' (Google Patents full text)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP30118P2/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA zones 4a to 9b.","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Darwin Perennials (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=055000982036998","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4a - 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/salvia-nemorosa-rose-marvel.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-salvia-rose-marvel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy in zones 4-9, it can be grown as an annual in colder areas.","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Rose-Marvel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":10,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source states 4-9; catalog states 4-8; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-rose-marvel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=458495","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/salvia-nemorosa-rose-marvel.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-salvia-rose-marvel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"thrives in a full sun location (will tolerate partial light shade)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Rose-Marvel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers average, clay or sandy, well-drained soils in full sun.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Gertens (plants.gertens.com plant database)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/24039/Rose_Marvel_Salvia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-rose-marvel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"strengths":["strong"],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=458495","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#fragrant leaves","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"University of Arkansas System Division of Agriculture Cooperative Extension Service, Plant of the Week","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/Salvia%20-nemorosa-Rose-Marvel-Sage-05-11-2018%20.aspx","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The opposite, aromatic leaves are 2-3 inches long, bright green","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP30118 P2, Salvia plant named 'Rose Marvel' (Google Patents full text)","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP30118P2/en","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong, sage-like.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-salvia-rose-marvel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The lovely herbaceous-scented foliage is deer and rabbit resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-salvia-rose-marvel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"while fragrant green foliage resists deer and rabbits","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Rose-Marvel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The leaves are aromatic when crushed.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Gertens (plants.gertens.com plant database)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/24039/Rose_Marvel_Salvia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its fragrant narrow leaves remain grayish green in color throughout the season.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"salvia-rose-marvel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=458495","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/salvia-nemorosa-rose-marvel.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-salvia-rose-marvel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nice cut flowers too!","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-salvia-rose-marvel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"are excellent for cut flower arrangements","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Rose-Marvel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Gertens (plants.gertens.com plant database)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/24039/Rose_Marvel_Salvia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"salvia-rose-marvel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=458495","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought-tolerant and is seldom damaged by deer or rabbit browsing.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"University of Arkansas System Division of Agriculture Cooperative Extension Service, Plant of the Week","url":"https://www.uaex.uada.edu/yard-garden/resource-library/plant-week/Salvia%20-nemorosa-Rose-Marvel-Sage-05-11-2018%20.aspx","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established they have good drought tolerance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/salvia-nemorosa-rose-marvel.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants are reasonably drought tolerant, once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-salvia-rose-marvel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water regularly until established, thereafter it is drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-salvia-rose-marvel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hardy and drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Rose-Marvel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought, heat and humidity tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-rose-marvel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=458495","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract bees, butterflies, hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Darwin Perennials (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=055000982036998","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Characteristics: Deer Resistant, Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens Perennial Resource (perennials.com)","url":"https://www.perennials.com/plants/salvia-nemorosa-rose-marvel.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to both butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-salvia-rose-marvel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attracting bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-salvia-rose-marvel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Columns of magenta flowers on burgundy stems will entice hummingbirds and butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Rose-Marvel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"is a favorite among pollinators, drawing bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Gertens (plants.gertens.com plant database)","url":"https://plants.gertens.com/12070009/Plant/24039/Rose_Marvel_Salvia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies and hummingbirds to your yard","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-sensation-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.35,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.23,1],"split":[{"range":[0.23,0.33],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","US Plant Patent PP18,230 (Rijnbeek en Zoon BV), via Google Patents","NVK Nurseries","De Vroomen Garden Products US","Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","Plant Delights Nursery","Bloomin Designs Nursery","Rum River Tree Farm","Valley View Farms plant library","Morningsun Herb Farm"]},{"range":[0.5,1],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257425&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=SALSR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12.0 Inches","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/238882/salvia-nemorosa-sensation-rose-sensation-series/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Salvia-nemorosa-Sensation-Rose","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"HEIGHT: 25-30 cm","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP18,230 (Rijnbeek en Zoon BV), via Google Patents","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP18230P2/en","country":"NL","form":null,"value":"Plant height.- About 27 cm.","metres":0.27,"band":[0.24,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/salvia-sylvestris-sensation-rose-pp-18230","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12\" tall","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"De Vroomen Garden Products US","url":"https://www.devroomen.com/product/salvia-sensation-rose-25-pcs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Compact size (10-12\" tall, 12-16\" spread) makes it ideal for mass plantings and smaller spaces","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Bloomin Designs Nursery","url":"https://www.bloomindesigns.com/salvia-nemorosa-sensation-rose-pp18230/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature size: Dwarf, compact habit up to 12 inches height; spreads 12 inches.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Rum River Tree Farm","url":"https://www.rumrivertreefarm.com/nursery/sensation-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12″","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Valley View Farms plant library","url":"https://plants.valleyviewfarms.com/12170010/Plant/5570/Sensation_Rose_Sage/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"will grow to be about 12 inches tall at maturity extending to 18 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 12 inches","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Morningsun Herb Farm","url":"https://morningsunherbfarm.com/products/salvia-nemorosa-sensation-rose-sensation-rose-meadow-sage","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing to only 12 inches tall, with spikes of hot pink flowers free blooming from May to August.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":12,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-sensation-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.23,1],"split":[{"range":[0.23,0.46],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","Rum River Tree Farm","Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","Plant Delights Nursery","Bloomin Designs Nursery","Valley View Farms plant library","NVK Nurseries","De Vroomen Garden Products US","US Plant Patent PP18,230 (Rijnbeek en Zoon BV), via Google Patents"]},{"range":[0.5,1],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257425&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.75 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.23,0.46],"band":[0.23,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=SALSR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12.0 Inches","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/238882/salvia-nemorosa-sensation-rose-sensation-series/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Salvia-nemorosa-Sensation-Rose","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"SPREAD: 30-40 cm","metres":[0.3,0.4],"band":[0.3,0.4],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP18,230 (Rijnbeek en Zoon BV), via Google Patents","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP18230P2/en","country":"NL","form":null,"value":"Plant width.- About 34.5 cm.","metres":0.35,"band":[0.32,0.39],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/salvia-sylvestris-sensation-rose-pp-18230","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Each 1' wide clump","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"De Vroomen Garden Products US","url":"https://www.devroomen.com/product/salvia-sensation-rose-25-pcs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Compact size (10-12\" tall, 12-16\" spread) makes it ideal for mass plantings and smaller spaces","metres":[0.3,0.41],"band":[0.3,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Bloomin Designs Nursery","url":"https://www.bloomindesigns.com/salvia-nemorosa-sensation-rose-pp18230/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature size: Dwarf, compact habit up to 12 inches height; spreads 12 inches.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Rum River Tree Farm","url":"https://www.rumrivertreefarm.com/nursery/sensation-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 10-15″","metres":[0.25,0.38],"band":[0.25,0.38],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Valley View Farms plant library","url":"https://plants.valleyviewfarms.com/12170010/Plant/5570/Sensation_Rose_Sage/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"will grow to be about 12 inches tall at maturity extending to 18 inches tall with the flowers, with a spread of 12 inches","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":12,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-sensation-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","3-8","3-7","3-9","5-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257425&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=SALSR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/salvia-sylvestris-sensation-rose-pp-18230","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3a to 7b","zones":[3,7],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"De Vroomen Garden Products US","url":"https://www.devroomen.com/product/salvia-sensation-rose-25-pcs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This hardy perennial performs beautifully in USDA zones 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Bloomin Designs Nursery","url":"https://www.bloomindesigns.com/salvia-nemorosa-sensation-rose-pp18230/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8.","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Rum River Tree Farm","url":"https://www.rumrivertreefarm.com/nursery/sensation-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5-7","zones":[5,7],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":12,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-sensation-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257425&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=SALSR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/238882/salvia-nemorosa-sensation-rose-sensation-series/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Salvia-nemorosa-Sensation-Rose","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Best grown in a moist or dry, well-drained soil, in full sun.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"De Vroomen Garden Products US","url":"https://www.devroomen.com/product/salvia-sensation-rose-25-pcs","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Sensation Rose Sage in spring in well-drained soil in full sun positions.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Bloomin Designs Nursery","url":"https://www.bloomindesigns.com/salvia-nemorosa-sensation-rose-pp18230/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to partial shade.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Rum River Tree Farm","url":"https://www.rumrivertreefarm.com/nursery/sensation-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Valley View Farms plant library","url":"https://plants.valleyviewfarms.com/12170010/Plant/5570/Sensation_Rose_Sage/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Campbell's Nursery","url":"https://www.campbellsnursery.com/product/landscape-plants/perennials/flowering-perennials/salvia-sensation-rose/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-sensation-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257425&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#fragrant leaves","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=SALSR","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Easy To Grow Edging Fragrant Flowers Fragrant Foliage Mass Planting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Salvia-nemorosa-Sensation-Rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Oblong green leaves emit fragrance when crushed","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"US Plant Patent PP18,230 (Rijnbeek en Zoon BV), via Google Patents","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP18230P2/en","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance.- None detected.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Valley View Farms plant library","url":"https://plants.valleyviewfarms.com/12170010/Plant/5570/Sensation_Rose_Sage/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its fragrant narrow leaves remain grayish green in color throughout the season.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"salvia-sensation-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=SALSR","https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Salvia-nemorosa-Sensation-Rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=SALSR","https://www.devroomen.com/product/salvia-sensation-rose-25-pcs"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=SALSR","https://plants.valleyviewfarms.com/12170010/Plant/5570/Sensation_Rose_Sage/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=SALSR","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Container Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Easy To Grow Edging Fragrant Flowers Fragrant Foliage Mass Planting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Salvia-nemorosa-Sensation-Rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cut flower, fresh or dried","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"De Vroomen Garden Products US","url":"https://www.devroomen.com/product/salvia-sensation-rose-25-pcs","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses Cut Flower Deer Resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Valley View Farms plant library","url":"https://plants.valleyviewfarms.com/12170010/Plant/5570/Sensation_Rose_Sage/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-sensation-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257425&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought-tolerant and is seldom damaged by deer or rabbit browsing.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=SALSR","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Though it is drought tolerant, it will bloom better with regular watering.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Salvia-nemorosa-Sensation-Rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"De Vroomen Garden Products US","url":"https://www.devroomen.com/product/salvia-sensation-rose-25-pcs","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Exceptional drought tolerance once established","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Rum River Tree Farm","url":"https://www.rumrivertreefarm.com/nursery/sensation-rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, it requires only minimal water.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-sensation-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257425&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Flowers attract bees, butterflies, hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://www.perennialresource.com/variety.php?ID=SALSR","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Salvia-nemorosa-Sensation-Rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"De Vroomen Garden Products US","url":"https://www.devroomen.com/product/salvia-sensation-rose-25-pcs","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Powerful pollinator attractor, bringing butterflies and hummingbirds to the landscape","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Valley View Farms plant library","url":"https://plants.valleyviewfarms.com/12170010/Plant/5570/Sensation_Rose_Sage/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting butterflies and hummingbirds to your yard","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Morningsun Herb Farm","url":"https://morningsunherbfarm.com/products/salvia-nemorosa-sensation-rose-sensation-rose-meadow-sage","country":null,"form":null,"value":"'Sensation Rose' is a great butterfly plant, or for hot sunny borders or mixed containers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Campbell's Nursery","url":"https://www.campbellsnursery.com/product/landscape-plants/perennials/flowering-perennials/salvia-sensation-rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Supports Pollinators Yes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-snow-hill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.45,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.23,0.67],"split":[{"range":[0.23,0.28],"sources":["Plant Delights Nursery"]},{"range":[0.3,0.36],"sources":["Darwin Perennials (Ball Horticultural)"]},{"range":[0.37,0.67],"sources":["Pleasant Run Nursery","North Creek Nurseries","Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","DeGroot, Inc.","Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250255","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/salvia-x-sylvestris-schneehugel-snow-hill-wood-sage","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows to about two feet tall and about eighteen inches wide","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALSH","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 20.0 Inches","metres":0.51,"band":[0.46,0.56],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/salvia-sylvestris-schneehugel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10\" tall","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Snow-Hill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18 Inches","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Darwin Perennials (Ball Horticultural)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=055000982005151","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12 - 14\" (30 - 36cm)","metres":[0.3,0.36],"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"DeGroot, Inc.","url":"https://degroot-inc.com/product/salvia-meadow-sage-sylvestris-snow-hill/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 18-24\"","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Snow-Hill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 16 Inches","metres":0.41,"band":[0.37,0.45],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"cultivar":9,"species":2,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 3 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-snow-hill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.41,0.45],"union":[0.3,0.51],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250255","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/salvia-x-sylvestris-schneehugel-snow-hill-wood-sage","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows to about two feet tall and about eighteen inches wide","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALSH","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 15.0-18.0 Inches","metres":[0.38,0.46],"band":[0.38,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/salvia-sylvestris-schneehugel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"makes a tight, 18\" wide mound of fuzzy, light green, disease-resistant foliage","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Snow-Hill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12-15 Inches","metres":[0.3,0.38],"band":[0.3,0.38],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Darwin Perennials (Ball Horticultural)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=055000982005151","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 12 - 18\" (30 - 46cm)","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Snow-Hill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 16 Inches","metres":0.41,"band":[0.37,0.45],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":9,"species":2,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-snow-hill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-7","3-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250255","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/salvia-x-sylvestris-schneehugel-snow-hill-wood-sage","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4 - 7","zones":[4,7],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALSH","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/salvia-sylvestris-schneehugel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 4a to 8a","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Snow-Hill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Darwin Perennials (Ball Horticultural)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=055000982005151","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4a - 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"DeGroot, Inc.","url":"https://degroot-inc.com/product/salvia-meadow-sage-sylvestris-snow-hill/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 4-8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Perennial Farm Marketplace","url":"https://www.perennialfarmmarketplace.com/products/salvia-nemorosa-snow-hill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 4-9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":9,"species":2,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-snow-hill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250255","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/salvia-x-sylvestris-schneehugel-snow-hill-wood-sage","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/salvia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most salvias prefer full sun and well-drained soils, but some will bloom well in part shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"salvia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/perennial-salvia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALSH","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Snow-Hill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers average, clay or sandy, well-drained soils in full sun.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"DeGroot, Inc.","url":"https://degroot-inc.com/product/salvia-meadow-sage-sylvestris-snow-hill/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Perennial Farm Marketplace","url":"https://www.perennialfarmmarketplace.com/products/salvia-nemorosa-snow-hill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Requirements: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-snow-hill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250255","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Ovate to lanceolate, serrate to entire margins, medium green, fragrant leaves.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/salvia-x-sylvestris-schneehugel-snow-hill-wood-sage","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fragrant blossoms are attractive to butterflies and other pollinators but not to deer.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/perennial-salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Reported to be deer and rabbit resistant. Fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALSH","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its foliage is aromatic when crushed.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Snow-Hill","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The leaves are aromatic when crushed.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Darwin Perennials (Ball Horticultural)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=055000982005151","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Scented Foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Snow-Hill","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant - Foliage","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"salvia-snow-hill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250255","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers last a long time.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/salvia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"salvias can be used for mass plantings, borders, containers, accents, and cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"salvia"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALSH","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Snow-Hill","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its blooms also make long-lasting additions to floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Snow-Hill","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"salvia-snow-hill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250255","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates drought.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is tolerant of gravely or sandy soils and drought once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/salvia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, most salvia species are quite drought-tolerant and require little care.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"salvia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/perennial-salvia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALSH","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Though it is drought tolerant, it will bloom better with regular watering.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Snow-Hill","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought, heat and humidity tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Darwin Perennials (Ball Horticultural)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=055000982005151","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"DeGroot, Inc.","url":"https://degroot-inc.com/product/salvia-meadow-sage-sylvestris-snow-hill/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a very hardy, drought tolerant plant that fills with white flower spikes and lasts most of the season.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-snow-hill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250255","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-x-sylvestris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract bees, hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/salvia-x-sylvestris-schneehugel-snow-hill-wood-sage","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/salvia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"One benefit of growing salvias is their appeal to hummingbirds, butterflies, and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"salvia"},{"name":"Walters Gardens / Perennial Resource","url":"http://pw.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALSH","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Snow-Hill","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator-friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"},{"name":"Darwin Perennials (Ball Horticultural)","url":"https://www.darwinperennials.com/Products/Details/?phid=055000982005151","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees, Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"DeGroot, Inc.","url":"https://degroot-inc.com/product/salvia-meadow-sage-sylvestris-snow-hill/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia sylvestris"},{"name":"Pleasant Run Nursery","url":"https://www.pleasantrunnursery.com/plant-name/Salvia-nemorosa-Snow-Hill","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"salvia nemorosa"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"salvia-violet-riot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.55,0.62],"union":[0.5,0.67],"proposed":0.59,"margin":20,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALVR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 22.0 Inches","metres":0.56,"band":[0.5,0.62],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/color-spires-violet-riot-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 22\"","metres":0.56,"band":[0.5,0.62],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/salvia-sylvestris-violet-riot-pp-26273","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24\" tall","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.5 to 0.67 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"salvia-violet-riot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.51,0.61],"union":[0.51,0.61],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALVR","https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/color-spires-violet-riot-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALVR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 20.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/color-spires-violet-riot-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 20\" - 2'","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.56},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"salvia-violet-riot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","3-8","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/salvia-nemorosa-violet-riot-violet-riot-sage","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4 - 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALVR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/color-spires-violet-riot-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3a , 3b , 4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/salvia-sylvestris-violet-riot-pp-26273","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 4a to 8a","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page, Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"salvia-violet-riot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/salvia-nemorosa-violet-riot-violet-riot-sage","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALVR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/salvia-sylvestris-violet-riot-pp-26273","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Sun to Part Sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page, Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"salvia-violet-riot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALVR","https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/color-spires-violet-riot-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALVR","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers Fragrant Foliage","claim":true},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/color-spires-violet-riot-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flower Fragrant Foliage","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"salvia-violet-riot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALVR","https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/color-spires-violet-riot-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALVR","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower","claim":true},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/color-spires-violet-riot-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: Cut Flower","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"salvia-violet-riot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALVR","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Though it is drought tolerant, it will bloom better with regular watering.","claim":true},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/color-spires-violet-riot-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant but blooms better with average moisture.","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page, Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"salvia-violet-riot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/salvia-nemorosa-violet-riot-violet-riot-sage","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Walters Gardens (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SALVR","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds Bee Friendly","claim":true},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/salvia/color-spires-violet-riot-perennial-salvia-salvia-nemorosa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees, Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/salvia-nemorosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract bees, butterflies, hummingbirds.","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page, Salvia nemorosa)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281423","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"saucer-magnolia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8,"cultivar":2},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":8,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 15 ft. 0 in. - 33 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 20.00 to 25.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature height 20-30 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"These small- to medium-sized trees can grow up to 30 feet tall and 25 feet across, so they can be an appropriate choice for many of today's smaller yards.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature Height: 20-30 Feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Small tree growing 20-30' tall and wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Tree Height: 20' - 30' (spread 20' - 30')\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"is a slow growing, low-branched, deciduous tree capable of reaching 25 feet in height and width.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"saucer-magnolia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8,"cultivar":2},"reasons":[]},"horizon":{"years":12,"sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 15 ft. 0 in. - 25 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Spread: 20.00 to 25.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Mature width 20-30 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"These small- to medium-sized trees can grow up to 30 feet tall and 25 feet across, so they can be an appropriate choice for many of today's smaller yards.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Small tree growing 20-30' tall and wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Tree Height: 20' - 30' (spread 20' - 30')\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"is a slow growing, low-branched, deciduous tree capable of reaching 25 feet in height and width.\", and this row's size is its size at 12 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 12 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"saucer-magnolia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","5-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Magnolia x soulangeana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/magnolia-x-soulangeana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"species","taxon":"magnolia soulangeana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Magnolia x soulangeana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261557","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"species","taxon":"magnolia soulangeana"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Saucer magnolia)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/saucer-magnolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8, Zone 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"species","taxon":"magnolia soulangeana"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions (Saucer Magnolia)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/trees-and-shrubs/trees/saucer-magnolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Saucer magnolia is hardy in USDA zones 4-9a and can be successfully planted in North and North Central Florida.","zones":[4,9],"level":"species","taxon":"magnolia soulangiana"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Trees for Your Home (Saucer Magnolia)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/treeselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=228","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5 - 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"magnolia soulangiana"},{"name":"UMass Extension Landscape, Nursery and Urban Forestry (Saucer Magnolia)","url":"https://www.umass.edu/agriculture-food-environment/landscape/publications-resources/plant-identification/saucer-magnolia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy zones 4-9, but should be protected in zone 4 to avoid bud or bloom damage.","zones":[4,9],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8,"cultivar":2},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"saucer-magnolia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Magnolia x soulangeana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/magnolia-x-soulangeana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"magnolia soulangeana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Magnolia x soulangeana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261557","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"magnolia soulangeana"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Saucer magnolia)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/saucer-magnolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"magnolia soulangeana"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions (Saucer Magnolia)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/trees-and-shrubs/trees/saucer-magnolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Your saucer magnolia should be planted in fertile, well-drained soil, either in full sun or partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"magnolia soulangiana"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Trees for Your Home (Saucer Magnolia)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/treeselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=228","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to partial shade; moist, well drained soils; slightly acid soil.","level":"species","taxon":"magnolia soulangiana"},{"name":"UMass Extension Landscape, Nursery and Urban Forestry (Saucer Magnolia)","url":"https://www.umass.edu/agriculture-food-environment/landscape/publications-resources/plant-identification/saucer-magnolia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Best grown in an acidic, fertile, moist but well-drained soil in full sun or part shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"Cornell University Woody Plants Database (Magnolia x soulangiana)","url":"https://woodyplants.cals.cornell.edu/plant/149","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"magnolia soulangiana"},{"name":"UF/IFAS EDIS ST388, Magnolia x soulangeana 'Burgundy'","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/ST388","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: full sun, partial sun, or partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"magnolia soulangeana"},{"name":"UF/IFAS EDIS ST389, Magnolia x soulangeana 'Lilliputian'","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/ST389","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: full sun, partial sun, or partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"magnolia soulangeana"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"saucer-magnolia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Magnolia x soulangeana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/magnolia-x-soulangeana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"magnolia soulangeana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Magnolia x soulangeana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=261557","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"magnolia soulangeana"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Saucer magnolia)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/saucer-magnolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower color and fragrance Fragrant, Pink, Purple, White","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"magnolia soulangeana"},{"name":"UMass Extension Landscape, Nursery and Urban Forestry (Saucer Magnolia)","url":"https://www.umass.edu/agriculture-food-environment/landscape/publications-resources/plant-identification/saucer-magnolia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Large cup-like flowers up to 8\" across. Sometime fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"Cornell University Woody Plants Database (Magnolia x soulangiana)","url":"https://woodyplants.cals.cornell.edu/plant/149","country":null,"form":null,"value":"fragrant f pink ish -white flowers bloom in mid-late spring","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"magnolia soulangiana"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"saucer-magnolia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"saucer-magnolia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"taxon-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Saucer magnolia)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/saucer-magnolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance Moderately sensitive","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"magnolia soulangeana"},{"name":"UMass Extension Landscape, Nursery and Urban Forestry (Saucer Magnolia)","url":"https://www.umass.edu/agriculture-food-environment/landscape/publications-resources/plant-identification/saucer-magnolia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Not tolerant of wet or dry soils.","claim":false,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["magnolia soulangeana"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (magnolia soulangeana), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"this came out more confident than v6 only once the distinct-taxa rule removed the claim(s) that disagreed, so it is a disagreement about which taxa were speaking rather than a finding; v6 recorded INSUFFICIENT; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (magnolia soulangeana) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"saucer-magnolia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Magnolia x soulangeana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/magnolia-x-soulangeana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Is the larval food source for saddleback caterpillars. Magnolia soft scale produces honeydew that bees love.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"magnolia soulangeana"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"savannah-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.34],"union":[0.82,1.4],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses (own-root grower and retailer)","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/sunbelt-savannah","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 3' x 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Greenheart Farms (licensed Sunbelt propagator)","url":"https://www.greenheartfarms.com/catalog/sunbelt/savannah","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 ft.","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Bloomables (Star Roses and Plants consumer brand, the US introducer's own copy)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/sunbelt-savannah/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size/Habit Compact, 4' h x 3' w","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.71680.1&tab=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 35\" to 4'7\" (90 to 140cm). Width: 3' to 4' (90 to 120cm).","metres":[0.9,1.4],"band":[0.9,1.4],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Regan Nursery (US retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-Kordes-Sunbelt-Collection-Savannah-New-2018","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4- Feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Northland Rosarium (US retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.northlandrosarium.com/products/savannah-korvioros","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 X 3 Feet High and Wide","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"savannah-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.95,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.9,1],"union":[0.82,1.2],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses (own-root grower and retailer)","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/sunbelt-savannah","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 3' x 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Greenheart Farms (licensed Sunbelt propagator)","url":"https://www.greenheartfarms.com/catalog/sunbelt/savannah","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3 ft.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Bloomables (Star Roses and Plants consumer brand, the US introducer's own copy)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/sunbelt-savannah/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size/Habit Compact, 4' h x 3' w","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.71680.1&tab=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 35\" to 4'7\" (90 to 140cm). Width: 3' to 4' (90 to 120cm).","metres":[0.9,1.2],"band":[0.9,1.2],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Regan Nursery (US retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-Kordes-Sunbelt-Collection-Savannah-New-2018","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3- Feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Northland Rosarium (US retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.northlandrosarium.com/products/savannah-korvioros","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 X 3 Feet High and Wide","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"savannah-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["6-9","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses (own-root grower and retailer)","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/sunbelt-savannah","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 6-9","zones":[6,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Greenheart Farms (licensed Sunbelt propagator)","url":"https://www.greenheartfarms.com/catalog/sunbelt/savannah","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones: 5 - 10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Bloomables (Star Roses and Plants consumer brand, the US introducer's own copy)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/sunbelt-savannah/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 5-10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Regan Nursery (US retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-Kordes-Sunbelt-Collection-Savannah-New-2018","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"savannah-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses (own-root grower and retailer)","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/sunbelt-savannah","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun Requires 6+ hours of direct sunlight to thrive.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Bloomables (Star Roses and Plants consumer brand, the US introducer's own copy)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/sunbelt-savannah/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Full Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"savannah-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["strong","strong","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/sunbelt-savannah","https://www.greenheartfarms.com/catalog/sunbelt/savannah"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/sunbelt-savannah","https://www.bloomables.com/plants/sunbelt-savannah/"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/sunbelt-savannah","https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.71680.1&tab=1"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/sunbelt-savannah","https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-Kordes-Sunbelt-Collection-Savannah-New-2018"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/sunbelt-savannah","https://www.northlandrosarium.com/products/savannah-korvioros"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses (own-root grower and retailer)","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/sunbelt-savannah","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Very Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Greenheart Farms (licensed Sunbelt propagator)","url":"https://www.greenheartfarms.com/catalog/sunbelt/savannah","country":null,"form":null,"value":"pink hybrid tea rose with an extraordinary fragrance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Bloomables (Star Roses and Plants consumer brand, the US introducer's own copy)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/sunbelt-savannah/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deeply fragrant, large pink blooms","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.71680.1&tab=1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Salmon-pink. Strong fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Regan Nursery (US retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-Kordes-Sunbelt-Collection-Savannah-New-2018","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Strong citrus scent","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Northland Rosarium (US retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.northlandrosarium.com/products/savannah-korvioros","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Very strong fragrance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 6 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 6","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"savannah-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/sunbelt-savannah","https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-Kordes-Sunbelt-Collection-Savannah-New-2018"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses (own-root grower and retailer)","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/sunbelt-savannah","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets and floral arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Regan Nursery (US retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-Kordes-Sunbelt-Collection-Savannah-New-2018","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut Rose","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"savannah-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Regan Nursery (US retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-Hybrid-Tea-Kordes-Sunbelt-Collection-Savannah-New-2018","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hot & Dry Climates","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"savannah-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"scaevola","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":6,"cultivar":2,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 9 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.75 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Depending on the cultivar, scaevola can range from 8 to 12 inches in height and two or more feet long.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Ascending to decumbent perennial herb to 50 cm high, with coarse yellowish hairs on stems.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"in cultivation, it is typically a sub-shrub to about 150mm high by a width of half a metre\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"With each plant growing about two-feet feet wide and around one foot in height\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"scaevola","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":6,"cultivar":2,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Depending on the cultivar, scaevola can range from 8 to 12 inches in height and two or more feet long.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"in cultivation, it is typically a sub-shrub to about 150mm high by a width of half a metre\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"With each plant growing about two-feet feet wide and around one foot in height\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"scaevola","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Scaevola aemula)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scaevola-aemula/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is hardy in a narrow range of USDA zones (zones 10 and 11) where it thrives in hot and dry summer climates, but it can be grown as an annual in North Carolina.","zones":[10,11],"level":"species","taxon":"scaevola aemula"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Scaevola aemula)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=291574&isprofile=0&basic=Scaevola+aemula","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11],"level":"species","taxon":"scaevola aemula"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":6,"cultivar":2,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"scaevola","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Scaevola aemula)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scaevola-aemula/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"scaevola aemula"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Scaevola aemula)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=291574&isprofile=0&basic=Scaevola+aemula","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"scaevola aemula"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Scaevola aemula 'Blue Wonder')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253132&isprofile=0&basic=Scaevola+aemula","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"scaevola aemula"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (HGIC 1197, Scaevola or Fan Flower)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/scaevola-or-fan-flower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Scaevola is best grown in full sun to part shade and does well in hot, dry summers.","level":"species","taxon":"scaevola aemula"},{"name":"Australian Native Plants Society (Australia), Plant Profile: Scaevola aemula","url":"https://anpsa.org.au/plant_profiles/scaevola-aemula/","country":"AU","form":null,"value":"A position in full sun or light shade is usually suitable and the species makes an excellent subject for a hanging basket.","level":"species","taxon":"scaevola aemula"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension Service, Southern Gardening (Scaevola works as border, groundcover or in container)","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/news/southern-gardening/2024/scaevola-works-border-groundcover-or-container","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It prefers full sun but can also grow in partial shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"scaevola"},{"name":"RHS (Scaevola aemula 'Blue Wonder')","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/69612/scaevola-aemula-blue-wonder/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"scaevola aemula"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"scaevola","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Scaevola aemula)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scaevola-aemula/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"scaevola aemula"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"scaevola","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Scaevola aemula)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scaevola-aemula/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Landscape Theme: Cutting Garden","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"scaevola aemula"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"scaevola","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Scaevola aemula)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scaevola-aemula/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is heat and drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"scaevola aemula"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (HGIC 1197, Scaevola or Fan Flower)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/scaevola-or-fan-flower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"scaevola cultivars have become popular in the United States due to their heat and drought tolerance and pest resistance.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"scaevola aemula"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension Service, Southern Gardening (Scaevola works as border, groundcover or in container)","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/news/southern-gardening/2024/scaevola-works-border-groundcover-or-container","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought-tolerant once established, regular watering during dry spells supports continuous flowering.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"scaevola"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Charlotte County (Become a fan of the fan flower)","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/charlotteco/2025/01/17/become-a-fan-of-the-fan-flower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"fan flowers are able to tolerate some drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"scaevola aemula"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"scaevola","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (HGIC 1197, Scaevola or Fan Flower)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/scaevola-or-fan-flower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract butterflies, bees, and other pollinating insects.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"scaevola aemula"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Charlotte County (Become a fan of the fan flower)","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/charlotteco/2025/01/17/become-a-fan-of-the-fan-flower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fan flowers are very attractive to bees, butterflies, and other pollinators, so expect these floral assets to your landscape.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"scaevola aemula"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"scaevola-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0 ft. 9 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.75 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"scaevola-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"scaevola-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scaevola-aemula/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone 10a to 11b","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=291574&isprofile=0&basic=Scaevola","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"scaevola-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scaevola-aemula/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=291574&isprofile=0&basic=Scaevola","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"scaevola-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"scaevola-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"scaevola-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scaevola-aemula/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is heat and drought tolerant.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"scaevola-pink","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"scilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.15,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.08,0.22],"split":[{"range":[0.08,0.15],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Scilla siberica)","Netherland Bulb Company (Scilla siberica 'Siberian Squill')"]},{"range":[0.18,0.22],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society (Scilla siberica)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Scilla siberica)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281913","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.25 to 0.50 feet","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"scilla siberica"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Scilla siberica)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/16868/scilla-siberica/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"A bulbous perennial to 20cm in height","metres":0.2,"band":[0.18,0.22],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"scilla siberica"},{"name":"Netherland Bulb Company (Scilla siberica 'Siberian Squill')","url":"https://www.netherlandbulb.com/wplant/Scilla-siberica-Siberian-Squill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 4-6 In","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"scilla siberica"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":5,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"scilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.08,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.08,0.1],"union":[0,0.15],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Scilla siberica)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281913","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.25 to 0.50 feet","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"scilla siberica"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Scilla siberica)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/16868/scilla-siberica/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0-0.1 metre","metres":[0,0.1],"band":[0,0.1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"scilla siberica"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":5,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"scilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-8","2-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Scilla siberica)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281913","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 8","zones":[2,8],"level":"species","taxon":"scilla siberica"},{"name":"Netherland Bulb Company (Scilla siberica 'Siberian Squill')","url":"https://www.netherlandbulb.com/wplant/Scilla-siberica-Siberian-Squill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 2-10","zones":[2,10],"level":"species","taxon":"scilla siberica"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":5,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"scilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Scilla siberica)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281913","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"scilla siberica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Scilla siberica 'Spring Beauty')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253163","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"scilla siberica"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Scilla siberica)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scilla-siberica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"scilla siberica"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Scilla siberica)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/16868/scilla-siberica/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"scilla siberica"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden (Siberian Squill)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/siberian-squill-blue-harbingers-spring","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It can be grown in full sun to partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"scilla siberica"},{"name":"Netherland Bulb Company (Scilla siberica 'Siberian Squill')","url":"https://www.netherlandbulb.com/wplant/Scilla-siberica-Siberian-Squill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun,Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"scilla siberica"},{"name":"Van Engelen Wholesale Flower Bulbs (Scilla siberica alba)","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/flower-bulbs-index/scilla/scilla-siberica-alba.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full to partial sunlight.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"scilla siberica"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs (Scilla siberica Spring Beauty)","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/scilla-siberica-spring-beauty.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full to partial sunlight.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"scilla siberica"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"scilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden (Siberian Squill)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/siberian-squill-blue-harbingers-spring","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers have a pleasant flagrance and are attractive to various types of bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"scilla siberica"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"scilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Scilla siberica)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281913","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"scilla siberica"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["scilla siberica"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (scilla siberica), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (scilla siberica) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"scilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"scilla","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden (Siberian Squill)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/siberian-squill-blue-harbingers-spring","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers have a pleasant flagrance and are attractive to various types of bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"scilla siberica"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"scilla-mischtschenkoana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.14,0.15],"union":[0.08,0.17],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281806","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.25 to 0.50 feet","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/25956/scilla-mischtschenkoana/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"A bulbous perennial to 15cm tall, with strap-like leaves and short racemes of starry, pale blue flowers opening with the leaves in late winter and early spring","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/scilla-mischtschenkoana.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5\".","metres":0.13,"band":[0.12,0.14],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/mischtschenkoana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3″-4″","metres":[0.08,0.1],"band":[0.08,0.1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/scilla-tubergeniana","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Flowering Height 6 inches","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"scilla tubergeniana"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":8,"cultivar":2,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"scilla-mischtschenkoana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.08,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.08,0.1],"union":[0,0.15],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281806","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.25 to 0.50 feet","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/25956/scilla-mischtschenkoana/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0-0.1 metre","metres":[0,0.1],"band":[0,0.1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8,"cultivar":2,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"scilla-mischtschenkoana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-7","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281806","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scilla-mischtschenkoana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/scilla-mischtschenkoana-milk-squill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4 - 7","zones":[4,7],"level":"species","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/scilla-mischtschenkoana.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 4-8.","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/mischtschenkoana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/scilla-tubergeniana","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"scilla tubergeniana"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":8,"cultivar":2,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"scilla-mischtschenkoana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281806","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scilla-mischtschenkoana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/25956/scilla-mischtschenkoana/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/scilla-mischtschenkoana-milk-squill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade Full Shade","level":"species","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder ('Tubergeniana' entry)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/scilla-mischtschenkoana-tubergeniana-tubergen-milk-squill","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/scilla-mischtschenkoana.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full to partial sunlight.","level":"species","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/mischtschenkoana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun, Part Shade, Shade","level":"species","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/fall-squill-flower-bulbs-white","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Provide a site with full to partial sun during bloom time and a well-draining soil.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/scilla-tubergeniana","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full Sun/Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"scilla tubergeniana"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens, All About Scilla","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/blogs/all-about-fall-planted-bulbs/all-about-scilla","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun or Shade : Scilla should be grown in full sun or partial shade. They will not flower in deep shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"scilla"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"scilla-mischtschenkoana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/scilla-tubergeniana","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"scilla tubergeniana"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"scilla-mischtschenkoana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"scilla-mischtschenkoana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"scilla-mischtschenkoana","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/scilla-mischtschenkoana-milk-squill","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Interest: Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"scilla mischtschenkoana"},{"name":"DutchGrown","url":"https://www.dutchgrown.com/products/scilla-tubergeniana","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Loved by pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"scilla tubergeniana"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["scilla mischtschenkoana"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (scilla mischtschenkoana), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (scilla mischtschenkoana) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"scilla-spring-beauty","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.18,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253163","country":"US","form":null,"value":"0.25 to 0.50 feet","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"scilla-spring-beauty","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.08,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253163","country":"US","form":null,"value":"0.25 to 0.50 feet","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"scilla-spring-beauty","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253163","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2 to 8","zones":[2,8]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"scilla-spring-beauty","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253163","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/scilla-siberica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"scilla-spring-beauty","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"scilla-spring-beauty","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253163","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy, Good Cut","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"scilla-spring-beauty","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"scilla-spring-beauty","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sea-holly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":16,"levels":{"species":14,"cultivar":3,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 16 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"sea-holly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":13,"levels":{"species":14,"cultivar":3,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 13 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"sea-holly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":14,"levels":{"species":14,"cultivar":3,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 14 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"sea-holly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eryngium-planum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"eryngium planum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eryngium-yuccifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"eryngium yuccifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275988&isprofile=0&basic=eryngium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"eryngium planum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276023&isprofile=0&basic=eryngium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"eryngium yuccifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276046&isprofile=0&basic=eryngium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"eryngium bourgatii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256059&isprofile=0&basic=eryngium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"eryngium giganteum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276062&isprofile=0&basic=eryngium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"eryngium alpinum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256603&isprofile=0&basic=eryngium","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"eryngium variifolium"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/rattlesnake-master-eryngium-yuccifolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Rattlesnake master is easily grown in full sun in most garden soils","level":"species","taxon":"eryngium yuccifolium"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/eryngium-x-zabelii-big-blue-big-blue-sea-holly","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"eryngium zabelii"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/1998/6-12-1998/perenflowr.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sea holly prefers full sun and sandy, dry areas.","level":"species","taxon":"eryngium amethystinum"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/24972/eryngium-planum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Grow in dry, well-drained poor to moderately fertile soil in full sun, with protection from winter wet","level":"species","taxon":"eryngium planum"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-eryngium-sea-holly-blue-glitter","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"eryngium planum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"sea-holly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["eryngium planum","eryngium yuccifolium"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (eryngium yuccifolium), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus","this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (eryngium planum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover 2 taxa and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"sea-holly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eryngium-planum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Steel blue flowers with a ring of spiky ornamental bracts are useful for cutting or drying.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium planum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eryngium-yuccifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Good Dried Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium yuccifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275988&isprofile=0&basic=eryngium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cut or dried flower arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium planum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276046&isprofile=0&basic=eryngium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent long-lasting cut flower that also dries well.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium bourgatii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276062&isprofile=0&basic=eryngium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent long-lasting cut flower that also dries well.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium alpinum"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/rattlesnake-master-eryngium-yuccifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The inflorescences can be used as an unusual cut or dried flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium yuccifolium"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/eryngium-x-zabelii-big-blue-big-blue-sea-holly","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers of this genus have long been treasured by dry flower arrangers.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"eryngium zabelii"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/1998/6-12-1998/perenflowr.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sea holly can also be used as a dried flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium amethystinum"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/24972/eryngium-planum/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"ideal for flower arranging - cut the stems before the flowers are fully open","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium planum"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, Sea holly genus guide","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/sea-holly","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are long-lasting and can be cut and dried for use in winter arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"eryngium"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-eryngium-sea-holly-blue-glitter","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A European bred plant for the cut flower trade (fresh and dried), it is a profuse bloomer that is invaluable for attracting bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"eryngium planum"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/eryngium/blue-glitter-sea-holly-eryngium-planum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great for use in flower arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"eryngium planum"}],"note":"12 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"sea-holly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","nearMiss":["drought"],"derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eryngium-planum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sea holly is tolerant of poor or dry soils, and its spiny leaves are resistant to browsing by rabbits and deer.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium planum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275988&isprofile=0&basic=eryngium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium planum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276023&isprofile=0&basic=eryngium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium yuccifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276046&isprofile=0&basic=eryngium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates light shade, poor soils, drought and saline conditions.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium bourgatii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256059&isprofile=0&basic=eryngium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium giganteum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276062&isprofile=0&basic=eryngium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates light shade, poor soils, drought and saline conditions.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium alpinum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=256603&isprofile=0&basic=eryngium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium variifolium"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/rattlesnake-master-eryngium-yuccifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant, doing best in dry, lean soils.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium yuccifolium"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/1998/6-12-1998/perenflowr.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This perennial is tolerant of dry, sunny conditions and infertile soils.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium amethystinum"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/24972/eryngium-planum/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium planum"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, Sea holly genus guide","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/sea-holly","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Most like very free-draining soil, some even thriving in poor, dry soil, in sun.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"eryngium"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-eryngium-sea-holly-blue-glitter","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought resistant/drought tolerant plant (xeric).","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"eryngium planum"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/eryngium/blue-glitter-sea-holly-eryngium-planum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"eryngium planum"}],"note":"13 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the row carries [\"drought\"], which nothing in the product reads: hasTag is an equality test against \"drought tolerant\"; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"sea-holly","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eryngium-planum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract butterflies and bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium planum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/eryngium-yuccifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts pollinator insects including wasps, flies, bees, and butterflies like monarchs and skippers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium yuccifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276023&isprofile=0&basic=eryngium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium yuccifolium"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/rattlesnake-master-eryngium-yuccifolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are faintly fragrant, with a honey-like scent and attract a variety of pollinators including bees, wasps, flies, and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium yuccifolium"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ERYU","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Value to Native Bees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium yuccifolium"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/eryngium-x-zabelii-big-blue-big-blue-sea-holly","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a butterfly attractant, and its seeds are a favorite of songbirds, but deer avoid it, as they do not like the prickly spines on the leaves.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"eryngium zabelii"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/eryngium-yuccifolium-rattlesnake-master","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Although not a butterfly or bumblebee magnet, small native bees, moths and flies will nectar on Rattlesnake Master.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"eryngium yuccifolium"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-eryngium-sea-holly-blue-glitter","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A European bred plant for the cut flower trade (fresh and dried), it is a profuse bloomer that is invaluable for attracting bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"eryngium planum"},{"name":"Proven Winners","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/eryngium/blue-glitter-sea-holly-eryngium-planum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"eryngium planum"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"sedum-autumn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.55,0.61],"union":[0.46,0.76],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hylotelephium-spectabile-autumn-joy/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249042","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/sedum-autumn-joy","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 24-30 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-sedum-autumn-joy","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 20-24\" tall","metres":[0.51,0.61],"band":[0.51,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/sedum-x-autumn-joy-sed860","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18–24\"","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/autumn-joy-sedum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height/Habit 24 inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sedum-autumn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.61],"union":[0.46,0.61],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hylotelephium-spectabile-autumn-joy/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249042","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/sedum-autumn-joy","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 18-24 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-sedum-autumn-joy","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 18-24\" wide","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sedum-autumn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-10","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hylotelephium-spectabile-autumn-joy/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[3,10]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249042","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/sedum-autumn-joy","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 3-9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-sedum-autumn-joy","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ZONES 3-9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/sedum-x-autumn-joy-sed860","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3–9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/autumn-joy-sedum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3-9","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sedum-autumn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hylotelephium-spectabile-autumn-joy/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249042","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/sedum-autumn-joy","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers Full Sun in Northern States"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-sedum-autumn-joy","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun"},{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/sedum-x-autumn-joy-sed860","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun"},{"name":"Breck's","url":"https://www.brecks.com/products/autumn-joy-sedum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sedum-autumn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sedum-autumn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-sedum-autumn-joy","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sedum-autumn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hylotelephium-spectabile-autumn-joy/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant is drought and salt-tolerant, resistant to rabbit browsing, and requires little attention.","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249042","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant.","claim":true},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/sedum-autumn-joy","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sedum-autumn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hylotelephium-spectabile-autumn-joy/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to butterflies and bees and provide a fall nectar source.","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249042","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to butterflies throughout the growing season.","claim":true},{"name":"Sooner Plant Farm","url":"https://www.soonerplantfarm.com/plant/sedum-autumn-joy","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-sedum-autumn-joy","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/sedum-x-autumn-joy-sed860","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the blooms attract butterflies and other pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sedum-autumn-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.67],"union":[0.3,0.91],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260506&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hylotelephium spectabile"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SEDAF","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 24.0-30.0 Inches","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-sedum-autumn-fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 24\" tall","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum telephium"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/autumn-fire-sedum-spectabile","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 18-24 inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum spectabile"},{"name":"The Growing Place","url":"https://plants.thegrowingplace.com/12120014/Plant/4050/Autumn_Fire_Stonecrop/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Autumn Fire Stonecrop will grow to be about 24 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 24 inches.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum spectabile"},{"name":"Nebraska Extension in Lancaster County","url":"https://lancaster.unl.edu/tall-sedum-beats-heat-and-still-looks-great/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"'Autumn Fire'- Extended blooming from pale pink rose, to bright red, to bronze-red. Medium green foliage. Height 2-3', width 18-24\".","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/sedum-telephium-autumn-fire-hylotelephium-tall-stonecrop-autumn-fire/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"24-30\" tall x 18-24\" wide clumps of grayish leaves 1.5' tall x 1' wide, densely tight look, flowers from mid summer to mid fall.","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum telephium"},{"name":"Gilbert H. Wild and Son","url":"https://gilberthwild.com/products/autumn-fire-sedum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"SEDUM 'Autumn Fire'. 24-30\" tall, 18-24\" spread, full sun, late summer-mid fall bloom.","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Kiefer Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/sedum-x-autumn-fire/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 2'","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hylotelephium spectabile"},{"name":"ServeScape","url":"https://servescape.com/products/sedum-x-autumn-fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1' - 1.5'","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":11,"species":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"sedum-autumn-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.55,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.67],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260506&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hylotelephium spectabile"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SEDAF","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18.0-24.0 Inches","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-sedum-autumn-fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 15-18\" wide","metres":[0.38,0.46],"band":[0.38,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum telephium"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/autumn-fire-sedum-spectabile","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 24 inches","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum spectabile"},{"name":"The Growing Place","url":"https://plants.thegrowingplace.com/12120014/Plant/4050/Autumn_Fire_Stonecrop/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Autumn Fire Stonecrop will grow to be about 24 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 24 inches.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum spectabile"},{"name":"Nebraska Extension in Lancaster County","url":"https://lancaster.unl.edu/tall-sedum-beats-heat-and-still-looks-great/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"'Autumn Fire'- Extended blooming from pale pink rose, to bright red, to bronze-red. Medium green foliage. Height 2-3', width 18-24\".","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/sedum-telephium-autumn-fire-hylotelephium-tall-stonecrop-autumn-fire/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"24-30\" tall x 18-24\" wide clumps of grayish leaves 1.5' tall x 1' wide, densely tight look, flowers from mid summer to mid fall.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum telephium"},{"name":"Gilbert H. Wild and Son","url":"https://gilberthwild.com/products/autumn-fire-sedum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"SEDUM 'Autumn Fire'. 24-30\" tall, 18-24\" spread, full sun, late summer-mid fall bloom.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Kiefer Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/sedum-x-autumn-fire/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 18\"","metres":0.46,"band":[0.41,0.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hylotelephium spectabile"},{"name":"ServeScape","url":"https://servescape.com/products/sedum-x-autumn-fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1' - 2'","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":11,"species":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"sedum-autumn-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","3-10","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260506&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hylotelephium spectabile"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SEDAF","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3,4,5,6,7,8,9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-sedum-autumn-fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones Zone 3 Zone 4 Zone 5 Zone 6 Zone 7 Zone 8 Zone 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum telephium"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/sedum-telephium-autumn-fire-hylotelephium-tall-stonecrop-autumn-fire/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy in zones 3 to 9.","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum telephium"},{"name":"Gilbert H. Wild and Son","url":"https://gilberthwild.com/products/autumn-fire-sedum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 3-9.","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mountain Crest Gardens","url":"https://mountaincrestgardens.com/sedum-autumn-fire/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"THIS PLANT IS HARDY IN ZONES 3 - 10","zones":[3,10],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hylotelephium spectabile"},{"name":"Kiefer Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/sedum-x-autumn-fire/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hylotelephium spectabile"},{"name":"ServeScape","url":"https://servescape.com/products/sedum-x-autumn-fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 4 - 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":11,"species":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"sedum-autumn-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":11,"distinctPublishers":11,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260506&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hylotelephium spectabile"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hylotelephium-spectabile/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"hylotelephium spectabile"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SEDAF","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-sedum-autumn-fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum telephium"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/autumn-fire-sedum-spectabile","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum spectabile"},{"name":"The Growing Place","url":"https://plants.thegrowingplace.com/12120014/Plant/4050/Autumn_Fire_Stonecrop/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in full sun to partial shade.","level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum spectabile"},{"name":"Nebraska Extension in Lancaster County","url":"https://lancaster.unl.edu/tall-sedum-beats-heat-and-still-looks-great/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"it grows well in hot, dry locations with full sun, where other perennials would turn up their toes and die","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/news/sedum-pollinators-love-this-easy-peasy-purple-and-pink-plant","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sedums grow easily in full-sun settings with average, dry to medium, well-drained soils.","level":"genus","taxon":"sedum"},{"name":"Gilbert H. Wild and Son","url":"https://gilberthwild.com/products/autumn-fire-sedum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun, late summer-mid fall bloom","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mountain Crest Gardens","url":"https://mountaincrestgardens.com/sedum-autumn-fire/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Recommended Light Conditions Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hylotelephium spectabile"},{"name":"Kiefer Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/sedum-x-autumn-fire/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Part-sun, Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hylotelephium spectabile"},{"name":"ServeScape","url":"https://servescape.com/products/sedum-x-autumn-fire","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Full Sun , Part Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"sedum-autumn-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"sedum-autumn-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SEDAF","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Border Plant Container Cut Flower Cut Foliage Dried Flower Drought Tolerant Easy To Grow Mass Planting Salt Tolerant Fire Resistant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Nebraska Extension in Lancaster County","url":"https://lancaster.unl.edu/tall-sedum-beats-heat-and-still-looks-great/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers make good cut flowers and can also be dried.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Kiefer Nursery","url":"https://kiefernursery.com/product/sedum-x-autumn-fire/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh or dried for arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hylotelephium spectabile"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"sedum-autumn-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260506&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hylotelephium spectabile"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hylotelephium-spectabile/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought- and salt-tolerant, resistant to browsing by rabbits (but not by deer), and requires little attention.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hylotelephium spectabile"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SEDAF","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Because of its thick, succulent leaves which can store water, sedum is drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/autumn-fire-sedum-spectabile","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance and minimal care are appealing to many, which is why Autumn Fire Sedum is perfect for those landscapes","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum spectabile"},{"name":"The Growing Place","url":"https://plants.thegrowingplace.com/12120014/Plant/4050/Autumn_Fire_Stonecrop/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is considered to be drought-tolerant, and thus makes an ideal choice for a low-water garden or xeriscape application.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum spectabile"},{"name":"Nebraska Extension in Lancaster County","url":"https://lancaster.unl.edu/tall-sedum-beats-heat-and-still-looks-great/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"As a succulent plant, sedum tolerates drought well and MUST have well drained soil.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/news/sedum-pollinators-love-this-easy-peasy-purple-and-pink-plant","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They withstand extreme heat and drought, yet some are winter-hardy as far north as USDA hardiness zone 3.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"sedum"},{"name":"Mountain Crest Gardens","url":"https://mountaincrestgardens.com/sedum-autumn-fire/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"mature Sedum can tolerate several months of drought","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hylotelephium spectabile"},{"name":"ServeScape","url":"https://servescape.com/products/sedum-x-autumn-fire","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought and heat tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-08-01"}, {"slug":"sedum-autumn-fire","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260506&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hylotelephium spectabile"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hylotelephium-spectabile/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Attracts butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hylotelephium spectabile"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (introducer)","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=SEDAF","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-sedum-autumn-fire","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Advantages Bee Friendly Attracts Butterflies Attracts Birds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum telephium"},{"name":"Johnson's Nursery Knowledgebase","url":"https://kb.jniplants.com/autumn-fire-sedum-spectabile","country":null,"form":null,"value":"When in bloom, Autumn Fire Sedum becomes a beacon for pollinators seeking nectar and pollen.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum spectabile"},{"name":"The Growing Place","url":"https://plants.thegrowingplace.com/12120014/Plant/4050/Autumn_Fire_Stonecrop/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a good choice for attracting bees and butterflies to your yard","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum spectabile"},{"name":"University of Missouri Extension","url":"https://extension.missouri.edu/news/sedum-pollinators-love-this-easy-peasy-purple-and-pink-plant","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Their nectar-rich blooms, opening in late summer and continuing into fall, attract a wide range of pollinators, including bees, butterflies and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"sedum"},{"name":"US Perennials","url":"https://www.usperennials.com/sedum-telephium-autumn-fire-hylotelephium-tall-stonecrop-autumn-fire/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies, honey bees and some native bees.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"sedum telephium"},{"name":"Gilbert H. Wild and Son","url":"https://gilberthwild.com/products/autumn-fire-sedum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies & is bee friendly.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Mountain Crest Gardens","url":"https://mountaincrestgardens.com/sedum-autumn-fire/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"it is an important long season bloomer for pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"hylotelephium spectabile"}],"note":"10 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-01","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"serviceberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 15 ft. 0 in. - 25 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 4 to 25 feet.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Height: 15-25'\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"serviceberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 15 ft. 0 in. - 25 ft. 0 in.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Width: 4 to 15 feet.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"serviceberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","2-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Amelanchier)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amelanchier/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"amelanchier"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Serviceberry)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/trees-and-shrubs/serviceberry","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zone: 2 to 8, cultivar dependent.","zones":[2,8],"level":"genus","taxon":"amelanchier"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"serviceberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Amelanchier)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amelanchier/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most species require full sun or partial shade, and they are adaptable to a wide range of soil and pH conditions.","level":"genus","taxon":"amelanchier"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Serviceberry)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/trees-and-shrubs/serviceberry","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to full shade; cultivars grown for fruit will produce best in full sun.","level":"genus","taxon":"amelanchier"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension (Serviceberry: An Early-Flowering Maryland Native Tree)","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/serviceberry-early-flowering-maryland-native-tree","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: full sun to partial shade","level":"genus","taxon":"amelanchier"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, Division of Extension (Serviceberry, Amelanchier spp.)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/serviceberry-amelanchier-spp/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Amelanchier are mainly woodland plants that prefer full sun to partial shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"amelanchier"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1026 (Serviceberry)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/serviceberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Serviceberry requires full sun to partial shade, with flower and fruit production improving with increased sunlight exposure.","level":"species","taxon":"amelanchier arborea"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Downy serviceberry)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/downy-serviceberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"amelanchier arborea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Amelanchier arborea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=h290","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"amelanchier arborea"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Amelanchier arborea)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=amar3","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade , Shade","level":"species","taxon":"amelanchier arborea"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension ST073 (Amelanchier arborea, Downy Serviceberry)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/ST073","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: partial sun or partial shade, full sun","level":"species","taxon":"amelanchier arborea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Amelanchier laevis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/plantfinder/plantfinderdetails.aspx?kempercode=b250","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"amelanchier laevis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Amelanchier canadensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j290","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"amelanchier canadensis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"serviceberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Amelanchier)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amelanchier/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Short-lived (10 days) lightly fragrant white, drooping racemes","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"amelanchier"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Amelanchier arborea)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=h290","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amelanchier arborea"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Amelanchier arborea)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=amar3","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers: yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amelanchier arborea"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Amelanchier laevis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/plantfinder/plantfinderdetails.aspx?kempercode=b250","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amelanchier laevis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Amelanchier canadensis)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=j290","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features showy, 5-petaled, slightly fragrant, white flowers in drooping clusters which appear before the leaves emerge in early spring.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"amelanchier canadensis"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"serviceberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"serviceberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Amelanchier)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amelanchier/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Include it in edible, native, pollinator, or drought-tolerant gardens as an accent plant, shade tree, or screening hedge.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"amelanchier"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["amelanchier arborea"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (amelanchier arborea), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (amelanchier arborea) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"serviceberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Amelanchier)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/amelanchier/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts native bees.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"amelanchier"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Serviceberry)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/trees-and-shrubs/serviceberry","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are excellent wildlife plants that attract pollinators, birds and other animals.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"amelanchier"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension (Serviceberry: An Early-Flowering Maryland Native Tree)","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/serviceberry-early-flowering-maryland-native-tree","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The early flowers provide pollen and nectar to a variety of native bees and other beneficial insects such as syrphid flies and tachinid flies (which are good predators of pests).","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"amelanchier"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["amelanchier arborea"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (amelanchier arborea), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (amelanchier arborea) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"shasta-daisy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"species":6,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"shasta-daisy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"species":6,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"shasta-daisy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"species":6,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"shasta-daisy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Leucanthemum x superbum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/leucanthemum-x-superbum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"leucanthemum superbum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Leucanthemum vulgare)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/leucanthemum-vulgare/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"leucanthemum vulgare"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Leucanthemum x superbum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244689&isprofile=0&basic=Leucanthemum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"leucanthemum superbum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Leucanthemum maximum 'Leumayel' BROADWAY LIGHTS)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=265466&isprofile=0&basic=Leucanthemum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"leucanthemum maximum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Leucanthemum vulgare 'Maikonigin' MAY QUEEN)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250182&isprofile=0&basic=Leucanthemum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"leucanthemum vulgare"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Shasta Daisy (Leucanthemum x superbum)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/shasta-daisy","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun, Partial Sun/Shade","level":"species","taxon":"leucanthemum superbum"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension HortAnswers, Shasta Daisy (Leucanthemum x superbum)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=733&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Full Sun Partial Sun/Shade","level":"species","taxon":"leucanthemum superbum"},{"name":"RHS (Leucanthemum x superbum)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/98781/leucanthemum-superbum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"leucanthemum superbum"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Leucanthemum superbum 'Becky')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=LEUBE","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun (> 6 hrs. Direct Sun)","level":"cultivar","taxon":"leucanthemum superbum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"shasta-daisy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"shasta-daisy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Leucanthemum x superbum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/leucanthemum-x-superbum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"leucanthemum superbum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Leucanthemum vulgare)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/leucanthemum-vulgare/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"leucanthemum vulgare"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Leucanthemum x superbum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244689&isprofile=0&basic=Leucanthemum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"leucanthemum superbum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Leucanthemum maximum 'Leumayel' BROADWAY LIGHTS)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=265466&isprofile=0&basic=Leucanthemum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"leucanthemum maximum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Leucanthemum vulgare 'Maikonigin' MAY QUEEN)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250182&isprofile=0&basic=Leucanthemum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent and long-lasting fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"leucanthemum vulgare"},{"name":"RHS (Leucanthemum x superbum)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/98781/leucanthemum-superbum/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Suggested planting locations and garden types Cottage and informal garden Wildflower meadow Wildlife gardens Gravel garden Cut flowers Flower borders and beds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"leucanthemum superbum"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Leucanthemum superbum 'Becky')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=LEUBE","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other Features: Border Plant Cut Flower Easy To Grow Mass Planting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"leucanthemum superbum"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"shasta-daisy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Leucanthemum x superbum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/leucanthemum-x-superbum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"leucanthemum superbum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Leucanthemum vulgare)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/leucanthemum-vulgare/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#showy flowers #drought tolerant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"leucanthemum vulgare"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Leucanthemum x superbum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244689&isprofile=0&basic=Leucanthemum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"leucanthemum superbum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Leucanthemum maximum 'Leumayel' BROADWAY LIGHTS)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=265466&isprofile=0&basic=Leucanthemum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"leucanthemum maximum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Leucanthemum vulgare 'Maikonigin' MAY QUEEN)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250182&isprofile=0&basic=Leucanthemum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Deer, Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"leucanthemum vulgare"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"shasta-daisy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Leucanthemum x superbum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/leucanthemum-x-superbum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The plant attracts butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"leucanthemum superbum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Leucanthemum vulgare)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/leucanthemum-vulgare/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"leucanthemum vulgare"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Leucanthemum x superbum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244689&isprofile=0&basic=Leucanthemum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"leucanthemum superbum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Leucanthemum maximum 'Leumayel' BROADWAY LIGHTS)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=265466&isprofile=0&basic=Leucanthemum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"leucanthemum maximum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Leucanthemum vulgare 'Maikonigin' MAY QUEEN)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=250182&isprofile=0&basic=Leucanthemum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"leucanthemum vulgare"},{"name":"Walters Gardens (Leucanthemum superbum 'Becky')","url":"https://www.waltersgardens.com/variety.php?ID=LEUBE","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Wings: Attracts Butterflies Bee Friendly","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"leucanthemum superbum"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"smokebush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"edge","consensus":[3.05,4.57],"union":[3.05,4.57],"edge":[2.96,4.71],"edgeMargin":1.6,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275949","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10.00 to 15.00 feet","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cotinus-coggygria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 10 ft. 0 in. - 15 ft. 0 in.","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/cotinus-coggygria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Deciduous shrub/tree, 10-15 ft (3-4.5 m), spreading, loose, wide as high.","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"}],"withdrawnFromV2":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":3.81},"note":"the catalog value sits 1.6% outside the sources' union (3.05 to 4.57 m) and inside the 3% margin v3 allows at a stated range edge (2.96 to 4.71 m), so v2's proposal of 3.81 m is withdrawn rather than applied; 3 of these 3 scored sources publish a range, and a range edge is a figure converted and rounded from another unit rather than a measurement to the centimetre","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"smokebush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"edge","consensus":[3.05,4.57],"union":[3.05,4.57],"edge":[2.96,4.71],"edgeMargin":1.6,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275949","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 10.00 to 15.00 feet","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cotinus-coggygria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 10 ft. 0 in. - 15 ft. 0 in.","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/cotinus-coggygria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Deciduous shrub/tree, 10-15 ft (3-4.5 m), spreading, loose, wide as high.","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"}],"withdrawnFromV2":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":3.81},"note":"the catalog value sits 1.6% outside the sources' union (3.05 to 4.57 m) and inside the 3% margin v3 allows at a stated range edge (2.96 to 4.71 m), so v2's proposal of 3.81 m is withdrawn rather than applied; 3 of these 3 scored sources publish a range, and a range edge is a figure converted and rounded from another unit rather than a measurement to the centimetre","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"smokebush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275949","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cotinus-coggygria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"smokebush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275949","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cotinus-coggygria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"smokebush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"smokebush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cotinus-coggygria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Garden","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"smokebush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275949","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cotinus-coggygria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant has a fibrous root system which is easy to transplant, and once established, is drought tolerant.","claim":true},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/cotinus-coggygria","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sun; tough, adaptable to widely divergent soils and pH ranges, drought resistant.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"smokebush","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cotinus-coggygria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator Garden","claim":true},{"name":"Trees and Shrubs Online (International Dendrology Society)","url":"https://www.treesandshrubsonline.org/articles/cotinus/cotinus-coggygria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cotinus are insect-pollinated and this plant is highly attractive for bees.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"smooth-hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.37,1.52],"union":[0.91,1.83],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-arborescens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=HYAR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"usually 3-6 ft. tall","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hydrangea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This 5-foot-tall deciduous shrub","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"smooth-hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-arborescens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"smooth-hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-arborescens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone 3a to 9b","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"smooth-hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"SPLIT","split":["full-sun","part-shade"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-arborescens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=HYAR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value is outside every source's stated range, but the value the rule would propose (\"full-sun\") is stated by only 1 source, so the sources disagree with each other rather than with the catalog; nothing is proposed","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"smooth-hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"smooth-hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"smooth-hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"smooth-hydrangea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hydrangea-arborescens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It attracts butterflies, moths, pollinators and songbirds","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snapdragon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"species":6,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snapdragon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":6,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snapdragon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":6,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snapdragon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Antirrhinum majus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/antirrhinum-majus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"antirrhinum majus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Antirrhinum majus)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287001","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"antirrhinum majus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Antirrhinum 'Dulcinea's Heart')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=266520","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Antirrhinum majus SNAPTASTIC ORANGE FLAME)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=439229","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"antirrhinum majus"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension EDIS FPS-44 (Antirrhinum majus Snapdragon)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp044","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in full sun; plant grows in partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"antirrhinum majus"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (Snapdragon, Antirrhinum majus)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/snapdragon.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"antirrhinum majus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snapdragon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds (Snapdragon Seeds)","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/snapdragon/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Did you know? Snapdragon blossoms are both fragrant and edible.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["antirrhinum majus"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (antirrhinum majus), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (antirrhinum majus) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snapdragon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Antirrhinum 'Dulcinea's Heart')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=266520","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tall plants are best for borders and cutting gardens.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds (Snapdragon Seeds)","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/snapdragon/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Johnny's varieties are selected for their strong cut-flower performance in the field and greenhouse.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":6,"covered":["antirrhinum majus"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (antirrhinum majus), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; 6 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (antirrhinum majus) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snapdragon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["antirrhinum majus"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (antirrhinum majus), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (antirrhinum majus) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snapdragon","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":4,"covered":["antirrhinum majus"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (antirrhinum majus), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 4 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (antirrhinum majus) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snapdragon-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snapdragon-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snapdragon-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"CONVENTION","wouldPropose":[7,10],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287001","country":"US","form":null,"value":"7 to 10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/antirrhinum-majus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone 7a to 10b","zones":[7,10]}],"note":"every source states 7-10 and this row deliberately stores no zones, which is the library's way of saying \"grown everywhere\" (docs/CATALOG-AUDIT.md records the two zone conventions for annuals as expected). Nothing is proposed: writing a zone range onto a zone-less row would remove it from every zone filter outside that range, and this is one library-wide decision rather than a per-plant error","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snapdragon-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287001","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/antirrhinum-majus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snapdragon-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snapdragon-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/antirrhinum-majus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Makes a good container plant and cut flower.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snapdragon-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/antirrhinum-majus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Low drought tolerance, languishes in the summer heat.","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snapdragon-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287001","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snapdragon-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: .5 to 3 feet; dependent upon cultivar selection\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Snapdragons range in size from six inches to three feet tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Many varieties and colors are available ranging in height from 6 to 36 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snapdragon-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.50 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 0 ft. 10 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: .5 to 3 feet; dependent upon cultivar selection\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snapdragon-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-10","7-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287001","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 7 to 10","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/antirrhinum-majus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FP044)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp044","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant may be a short-lived perennial in USDA zones 7-11.","zones":[7,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snapdragon-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287001","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/antirrhinum-majus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FP044)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp044","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in full sun; plant grows in partial shade"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/snapdragon/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They do best in soil amended with organic matter and prefer full sun."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snapdragon-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snapdragon-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287001","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tall plants are best for borders and cutting gardens.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/antirrhinum-majus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Makes a good container plant and cut flower.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FP044)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp044","country":null,"form":null,"value":"may be utilized as edging in the garden, are well-suited for container planting, and may be used as cut flowers in arrangements","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/snapdragon/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are a long-lasting cut flower, and can even thrive in containers.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension (Bulletin B954)","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/B954/flowering-annuals-for-georgia-gardens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The taller varieties require staking and are grown principally as cut flowers.","claim":true}],"note":"5 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snapdragon-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/antirrhinum-majus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Low drought tolerance, languishes in the summer heat.","claim":false},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Extension (EDIS FP044)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/fp044","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These plants exhibit low drought tolerance and may require additional irrigation during dry conditions.","claim":false}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snapdragon-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287001","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/antirrhinum-majus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snow-in-summer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.15,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.15,0.3],"union":[0.15,0.3],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279079","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.50 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cerastium-tomentosum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snow-in-summer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.23,0.3],"union":[0.23,0.46],"proposed":0.27,"margin":8.7,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279079","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cerastium-tomentosum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 9 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.23,0.46],"band":[0.23,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.23 to 0.46 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snow-in-summer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279079","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 7","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cerastium-tomentosum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[3,7]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snow-in-summer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279079","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cerastium-tomentosum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snow-in-summer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snow-in-summer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snow-in-summer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279079","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cerastium-tomentosum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#dry soils tolerant #groundcover #drought tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snow-in-summer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cerastium-tomentosum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees are attracted to the flowers.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snowdrop","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.12,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"species":8,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snowdrop","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.08,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"species":8,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snowdrop","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,7],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"species":8,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snowdrop","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Galanthus nivalis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/galanthus-nivalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Snowdrop grows best in full sun to part shade in clay or loam soil with high organic matter.","level":"species","taxon":"galanthus nivalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Galanthus elwesii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/galanthus-elwesii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows easily in moist, well-drained, hummus-rich soils in full sun to partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"galanthus elwesii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Galanthus nivalis)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275672","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"galanthus nivalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Galanthus elwesii)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275671","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"galanthus elwesii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Galanthus ikariae)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275869","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"galanthus ikariae"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Galanthus alpinus)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275842","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"galanthus alpinus"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, UW-Madison Division of Extension (Snowdrops, Galanthus spp.)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/snowdrops-galanthus-spp/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow snowdrops in a location that has full sun during the spring when the foliage is present.","level":"genus","taxon":"galanthus"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide (Galanthus nivalis)","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/common-snowdrop-galanthus-nivalis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Provide full sun to partial shade and moist, well-drained soil in USDA Hardiness Zones 3 to 8.","level":"species","taxon":"galanthus nivalis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snowdrop","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["galanthus nivalis"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (galanthus nivalis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (galanthus nivalis) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snowdrop","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snowdrop","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snowdrop","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Galanthus nivalis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/galanthus-nivalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Polinated by bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"galanthus nivalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Galanthus elwesii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/galanthus-elwesii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use it also in cottage, pollinator and winter gardens.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"galanthus elwesii"},{"name":"Plants For A Future (Galanthus nivalis)","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Galanthus+nivalis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A good bee plant, providing an early source of pollen and nectar","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"galanthus nivalis"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"snowdrop-elwesii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.09,0.3],"split":[{"range":[0.09,0.11],"sources":["Fine Gardening plant guide"]},{"range":[0.13,0.3],"sources":["Van Engelen","Missouri Botanical Garden","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275671","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.50 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/galanthus-elwesii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/giant-snowdrop-galanthus-elwesii","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows to the same 4 inches tall and wide","metres":0.1,"band":[0.09,0.11],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/galanthus-elwesii.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 3-8. Height: 5\" to 8\".","metres":[0.13,0.2],"band":[0.13,0.2],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snowdrop-elwesii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.09,0.11],"union":[0.08,0.15],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275671","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.25 to 0.50 feet","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/galanthus-elwesii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 3 in. - 0 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/giant-snowdrop-galanthus-elwesii","country":"US","form":null,"value":"grows to the same 4 inches tall and wide","metres":0.1,"band":[0.09,0.11],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snowdrop-elwesii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-7","3-9","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275671","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 7","zones":[4,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/galanthus-elwesii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b","zones":[4,7]},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/giant-snowdrop-galanthus-elwesii","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Provide full sun to partial shade and moist, well-drained soil in USDA Hardiness Zones 3 to 9.","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/galanthus-elwesii.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 3-8. Height: 5\" to 8\".","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snowdrop-elwesii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275671","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/giant-snowdrop-galanthus-elwesii","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Provide full sun to partial shade and moist, well-drained soil in USDA Hardiness Zones 3 to 9."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snowdrop-elwesii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snowdrop-elwesii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snowdrop-elwesii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snowdrop-elwesii","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/galanthus-elwesii/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use it also in cottage, pollinator and winter gardens.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"snowflake","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":10,"levels":{"species":8,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snowflake","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"species":8,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snowflake","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"species":8,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snowflake","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Leucojum aestivum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/leucojum-aestivum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in organic, well drained, damp soil in full or partial sun.","level":"species","taxon":"leucojum aestivum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Leucojum vernum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/leucojum-vernum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant bulbs in full sun to partial shade 3 to 4 inches deep in fall.","level":"species","taxon":"leucojum vernum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Leucojum aestivum 'Gravetye Giant')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244703","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"leucojum aestivum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Leucojum aestivum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=275800","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"leucojum aestivum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Snowflakes, Leucojum)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/snowflakes-leucojum-growing-and-caring-for-the-star-of-your-early-spring-garden/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They are hardy in USDA planting zones 4 to 8, and these beautiful bulbs will grow in full sun to part shade in well-drained, organically rich soils.","level":"species","taxon":"leucojum aestivum"},{"name":"A.D.R. Bulbs (Leucojum 'Aestivum')","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Leucojum-Aestivum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This species thrives in full sun to part shade and prefers moist, well-drained soil.","level":"species","taxon":"leucojum aestivum"},{"name":"RHS (Leucojum aestivum)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/10003/leucojum-aestivum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"leucojum aestivum"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms (Gravetye Giant Leucojum Snowflakes)","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/fall-planting-bulbs/specialty/gravetye-giant-leucojum-summer-snowflake","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snowflake","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Leucojum aestivum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/leucojum-aestivum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are faintly scented.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"leucojum aestivum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Leucojum vernum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/leucojum-vernum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"leucojum vernum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Leucojum aestivum 'Gravetye Giant')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244703","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"leucojum aestivum"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms (Gravetye Giant Leucojum Snowflakes)","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/fall-planting-bulbs/specialty/gravetye-giant-leucojum-summer-snowflake","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These snow drop shaped blooms, are fragrant and showy!","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"snowflake","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["leucojum aestivum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (leucojum aestivum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (leucojum aestivum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snowflake","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["leucojum aestivum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (leucojum aestivum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (leucojum aestivum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"snowflake","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["leucojum aestivum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (leucojum aestivum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (leucojum aestivum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"spirea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,2.44],"union":[0.46,3.05],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Spiraea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/spiraea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spireas can grow from 2 to 10 feet tall, depending on the species.","metres":[0.61,3.05],"band":[0.61,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"spiraea"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Spirea)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/spirea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant sizes vary by species and cultivar, and they range from 1½ to 8 feet tall.","metres":[0.46,2.44],"band":[0.46,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"spiraea"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Spirea - The Ultimate Growing Guide)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/spirea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature size ranges from 2-10 feet tall and wide.","metres":[0.61,3.05],"band":[0.61,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"spiraea"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"spirea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (Spirea - The Ultimate Growing Guide)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/spirea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature size ranges from 2-10 feet tall and wide.","metres":[0.61,3.05],"band":[0.61,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"spiraea"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"spirea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Spiraea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/spiraea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"spiraea"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Spirea - The Ultimate Growing Guide)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/spirea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It's hardy in USDA zones 4-8, with many selections expanding that to 3-9.","zones":[4,8],"level":"genus","taxon":"spiraea"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"genus":4,"species":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"spirea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Spiraea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/spiraea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"spiraea"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Spirea)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/spirea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These attractive shrubs are fast growing and should be grown in full sun for best flowering. They can, however, tolerate partial shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"spiraea"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Spirea - The Ultimate Growing Guide)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/spirea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spirea performs best in full sun, producing more blooms, vibrant color and brighter fall foliage when given proper spirea plant care. Plants can take light shade, with spring bloomers more shade tolerant than summer bloomers.","level":"genus","taxon":"spiraea"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Spirea, Spiraea media)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/spirea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"spiraea media"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Spiraea japonica)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286473","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"spiraea japonica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Spiraea x vanhouttei)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253831","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"spiraea vanhouttei"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Spiraea prunifolia)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=262114","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"spiraea prunifolia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Spiraea betulifolia)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286471","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"spiraea betulifolia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Vanhoutte Spirea, Spiraea x vanhouttei)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=447&PlantTypeID=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"spiraea vanhouttei"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Japanese Spirea, Spiraea japonica)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=443&PlantTypeID=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure/Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"spiraea japonica"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"spirea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["spiraea betulifolia"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (spiraea betulifolia), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (spiraea betulifolia) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"spirea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"spirea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (Spirea - The Ultimate Growing Guide)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/spirea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Spirea is drought-tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"spiraea"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Spirea, Spiraea media)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/spirea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other tolerances Occasional drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"spiraea media"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Spiraea x vanhouttei)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253831","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates light shade, a wide range of soils and some drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"spiraea vanhouttei"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Spiraea prunifolia)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=262114","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates light shade, a wide range of soils and some drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"spiraea prunifolia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Vanhoutte Spirea, Spiraea x vanhouttei)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=447&PlantTypeID=8","country":null,"form":null,"value":"moist, well-drained soils are best, but tolerates dry sites","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"spiraea vanhouttei"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Japanese Spirea, Spiraea japonica)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=443&PlantTypeID=8","country":null,"form":null,"value":"moist, well drained soils are best, but tolerates dry sites","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"spiraea japonica"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"spirea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Spiraea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/spiraea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"spiraea"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Spirea)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/spirea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Spirea flowers are often visited by butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"spiraea"},{"name":"Proven Winners (Spirea - The Ultimate Growing Guide)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/spirea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Not only is spirea low-maintenance, but the spirea bush also attracts butterflies and other insect pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"spiraea"},{"name":"Penn State Extension (Spirea: The Good and the Bad)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/spirea-the-good-and-the-bad","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its white, pink, and rose-red flowers that may rebloom throughout the season attract pollinators, including bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"spiraea"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Spirea, Spiraea media)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/spirea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds and butterflies are attracted to it.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"spiraea media"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Spiraea japonica)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286473","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"spiraea japonica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Spiraea x vanhouttei)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=253831","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"spiraea vanhouttei"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Spiraea prunifolia)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=262114","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"spiraea prunifolia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Spiraea betulifolia)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286471","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"spiraea betulifolia"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"spirea-double-play-big-bang","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.61,1],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/spiraea/double-play-big-bang-spirea-spiraea-x","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2' - 3'","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/spirea-double-play-big-bang","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 ft Tall","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"spirea-double-play-big-bang","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.61,1.34],"split":[{"range":[0.61,0.91],"sources":["Proven Winners (breeder / introducer)"]},{"range":[1.1,1.34],"sources":["Nature Hills Nursery"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/spiraea/double-play-big-bang-spirea-spiraea-x","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2' - 3'","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/spirea-double-play-big-bang","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 ft Wide","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"spirea-double-play-big-bang","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/spiraea/double-play-big-bang-spirea-spiraea-x","https://naturehills.com/products/spirea-double-play-big-bang"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/spiraea/double-play-big-bang-spirea-spiraea-x","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/spirea-double-play-big-bang","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 3-8","zones":[3,8]}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[3,8]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"spirea-double-play-big-bang","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/spiraea/double-play-big-bang-spirea-spiraea-x","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part Sun to Sun"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/spirea-double-play-big-bang","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"spirea-double-play-big-bang","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"spirea-double-play-big-bang","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"spirea-double-play-big-bang","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/spiraea/double-play-big-bang-spirea-spiraea-x","https://naturehills.com/products/spirea-double-play-big-bang"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/spiraea/double-play-big-bang-spirea-spiraea-x","country":null,"form":null,"value":"drought tolerant flowering shrub","claim":true},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/spirea-double-play-big-bang","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought resistant","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"spirea-double-play-big-bang","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/spiraea/double-play-big-bang-spirea-spiraea-x","https://naturehills.com/products/spirea-double-play-big-bang"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (breeder / introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/spiraea/double-play-big-bang-spirea-spiraea-x","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/spirea-double-play-big-bang","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"spirea-double-play-candy-corn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.61],"union":[0.46,0.61],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=446974","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/spiraea-japonica-double-play-candy-corn-ncsx1/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/spiraea/double-play-candy-corn-spirea-spiraea-japonica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18\" - 2'","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (nursery)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/double-play-candy-corn-spirea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 1.5-2 Feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"spirea-double-play-candy-corn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.76],"union":[0.46,0.76],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=446974","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.50 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.46,0.76],"band":[0.46,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/spiraea-japonica-double-play-candy-corn-ncsx1/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/spiraea/double-play-candy-corn-spirea-spiraea-japonica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 18\" - 2'6\"","metres":[0.46,0.76],"band":[0.46,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (nursery)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/double-play-candy-corn-spirea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 1.5-2.5 Feet","metres":[0.46,0.76],"band":[0.46,0.76],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"spirea-double-play-candy-corn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-7","4-9","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=446974","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 7","zones":[4,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/spiraea-japonica-double-play-candy-corn-ncsx1/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/spiraea/double-play-candy-corn-spirea-spiraea-japonica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Plant Addicts (nursery)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/double-play-candy-corn-spirea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones : 4-7","zones":[4,7]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"spirea-double-play-candy-corn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=446974","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/spiraea-japonica-double-play-candy-corn-ncsx1/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/spiraea/double-play-candy-corn-spirea-spiraea-japonica","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Sun to Sun"},{"name":"Plant Addicts (nursery)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/double-play-candy-corn-spirea","country":"US","form":null,"value":"be sure to plant in full to part sun, ensuring it receives 4 to 6 hours of sun per day"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"spirea-double-play-candy-corn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","strengths":["light"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/spiraea-japonica-double-play-candy-corn-ncsx1/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They bloom from late spring to early summer with mild fragrance.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"spirea-double-play-candy-corn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"spirea-double-play-candy-corn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/spiraea-japonica-double-play-candy-corn-ncsx1/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is drought tolerant once established and generally ignored by rabbits and deer.","claim":true},{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/spiraea/double-play-candy-corn-spirea-spiraea-japonica","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Double Play spirea are typically ignored by deer and even rabbits, and are quite drought tolerant after a year or two in the ground.","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Addicts (nursery)","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/double-play-candy-corn-spirea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, the Double Play Candy Corn Spirea is drought tolerant.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"spirea-double-play-candy-corn","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=446974","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The terminal flower clusters can reach around 1\" wide and and bloom from late spring into early summer, attracting butterflies and other insect pollinators.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"st-tropez-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.8,1.34],"split":[{"range":[0.8,0.9],"sources":["HelpMeFind Roses"]},{"range":[0.91,1.34],"sources":["Regan Nursery (US retail rose nursery)","Heirloom Roses (own-root grower and retailer)","NetPS Plant Finder database (read at The Flower Bin, Longmont CO)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses (own-root grower and retailer)","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/st-tropez","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 4' x 3' - 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Regan Nursery (US retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-St-Tropez","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.77563.3&tab=1","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 31\" to 35\" (80 to 90cm).","metres":[0.8,0.9],"band":[0.8,0.9],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder database (read at The Flower Bin, Longmont CO)","url":"https://plants.theflowerbin.net/12120039/Plant/32853/St_Tropez_Rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"st-tropez-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.34],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses (own-root grower and retailer)","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/st-tropez","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size 4' x 3' - 4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder database (read at The Flower Bin, Longmont CO)","url":"https://plants.theflowerbin.net/12120039/Plant/32853/St_Tropez_Rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"st-tropez-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/st-tropez","https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-St-Tropez"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses (own-root grower and retailer)","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/st-tropez","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Regan Nursery (US retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-St-Tropez","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":4},"reasons":[]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"st-tropez-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses (own-root grower and retailer)","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/st-tropez","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun Requires 6+ hours of direct sunlight to thrive.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder database (read at The Flower Bin, Longmont CO)","url":"https://plants.theflowerbin.net/12120039/Plant/32853/St_Tropez_Rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub should only be grown in full sunlight.","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"st-tropez-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["strong","strong","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/st-tropez","https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-St-Tropez"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/st-tropez","https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.77563.3&tab=1"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/st-tropez","https://plants.theflowerbin.net/12120039/Plant/32853/St_Tropez_Rose"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses (own-root grower and retailer)","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/st-tropez","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Very Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Regan Nursery (US retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-St-Tropez","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Apricot Orange blooms with the scent of sweet anise.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.77563.3&tab=1","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Apricot-orange. Strong, anise fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder database (read at The Flower Bin, Longmont CO)","url":"https://plants.theflowerbin.net/12120039/Plant/32853/St_Tropez_Rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"with a strong anise fragrance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"st-tropez-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-St-Tropez","https://plants.theflowerbin.net/12120039/Plant/32853/St_Tropez_Rose"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Regan Nursery (US retail rose nursery)","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-St-Tropez","country":null,"form":null,"value":"roses are disease-resistant, with longer vase life than traditional varieties.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NetPS Plant Finder database (read at The Flower Bin, Longmont CO)","url":"https://plants.theflowerbin.net/12120039/Plant/32853/St_Tropez_Rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"st-tropez-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"st-tropez-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ornithogalum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ornithogalum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 10 in. - 1 ft. 4 in.","metres":[0.25,0.41],"band":[0.25,0.41],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"ornithogalum"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":10},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ornithogalum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ornithogalum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 2 in. - 0 ft. 5 in.","metres":[0.05,0.13],"band":[0.05,0.13],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"ornithogalum"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":10},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ornithogalum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ornithogalum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[4,10],"level":"genus","taxon":"ornithogalum"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"genus":1,"species":10},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ornithogalum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ornithogalum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"genus","taxon":"ornithogalum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ornithogalum umbellatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ornithogalum-umbellatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"ornithogalum umbellatum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ornithogalum thyrsoides)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ornithogalum-thyrsoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"ornithogalum thyrsoides"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ornithogalum umbellatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281796","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"ornithogalum umbellatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ornithogalum arabicum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281902","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"ornithogalum arabicum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ornithogalum magnum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282362","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"ornithogalum magnum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ornithogalum candicans)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299122","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"ornithogalum candicans"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ornithogalum regale)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=439097","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"ornithogalum regale"},{"name":"A.D.R. Bulbs (Ornithogalum 'Arabicum')","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Ornithogalum-Arabicum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Location : Full sun to light shade.","level":"species","taxon":"ornithogalum arabicum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ornithogalum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ornithogalum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"White bell-shaped flowers with green center that are long lasting, fragrant, and make good cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"ornithogalum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ornithogalum umbellatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ornithogalum-umbellatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ornithogalum umbellatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ornithogalum arabicum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281902","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ornithogalum arabicum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ornithogalum candicans)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299122","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ornithogalum candicans"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ornithogalum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ornithogalum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are long-lasting and make excellent cut flowers for arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"ornithogalum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ornithogalum umbellatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ornithogalum-umbellatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ornithogalum umbellatum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ornithogalum thyrsoides)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ornithogalum-thyrsoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut Long-lasting","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ornithogalum thyrsoides"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ornithogalum candicans)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299122","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Beds, borders. Good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ornithogalum candicans"},{"name":"A.D.R. Bulbs (Ornithogalum 'Arabicum')","url":"https://www.adrbulbs.com/flowerbulbs/Ornithogalum-Arabicum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Ornithogalum arabicum is deer-resistant and one of the longest-lasting cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ornithogalum arabicum"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ornithogalum umbellatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ornithogalum-umbellatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ornithogalum umbellatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ornithogalum umbellatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281796","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Some tolerance for dry soils once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ornithogalum umbellatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ornithogalum magnum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282362","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Thrives in sandy loams with some tolerance for dry soils once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ornithogalum magnum"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["ornithogalum umbellatum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (ornithogalum umbellatum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (ornithogalum umbellatum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem-chincherinchee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.46,0.5],"union":[0.2,0.66],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/ornithogalum-thyrsoides","country":"ZA","form":null,"value":"Ornithogalum thyrsoides is a bulbous geophyte, 200 to 500 mm tall","metres":[0.2,0.5],"band":[0.2,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/11960/ornithogalum-thyrsoides/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"A bulbous perennial to 60cm tall","metres":0.6,"band":[0.54,0.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Western Australian Herbarium (FloraBase)","url":"https://florabase.dbca.wa.gov.au/browse/profile/1373","country":"AU","form":null,"value":"Bulbaceous, perennial, herb, to 0.3 m high.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Lust","url":"https://plantlust.com/plants/48174/ornithogalum-thyrsoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature size: 8 IN - 12 IN - wide, 12 IN - 24 IN - tall","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"GardenCenterMarketing.com Plant Library","url":"https://www.gardencentermarketing.com/plantname/ornithogalum-thyrsoides","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 18-20 in","metres":[0.46,0.51],"band":[0.46,0.51],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem-chincherinchee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.12,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0,0.3],"split":[{"range":[0,0.1],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society"]},{"range":[0.2,0.3],"sources":["Plant Lust","GardenCenterMarketing.com Plant Library"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/11960/ornithogalum-thyrsoides/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0-0.1 metre","metres":[0,0.1],"band":[0,0.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Lust","url":"https://plantlust.com/plants/48174/ornithogalum-thyrsoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature size: 8 IN - 12 IN - wide, 12 IN - 24 IN - tall","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"GardenCenterMarketing.com Plant Library","url":"https://www.gardencentermarketing.com/plantname/ornithogalum-thyrsoides","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 8-12 in","metres":[0.2,0.3],"band":[0.2,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem-chincherinchee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["7-10","9-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Lust","url":"https://plantlust.com/plants/48174/ornithogalum-thyrsoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones: 7a - 10b","zones":[7,10]},{"name":"GardenCenterMarketing.com Plant Library","url":"https://www.gardencentermarketing.com/plantname/ornithogalum-thyrsoides","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 9-11","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem-chincherinchee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ornithogalum-thyrsoides/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/11960/ornithogalum-thyrsoides/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun, Partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem-chincherinchee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Lust","url":"https://plantlust.com/plants/48174/ornithogalum-thyrsoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Ornithogalum thyrsoides is an ephemeral bulb with spikes of fragrant, outward-facing, star-shaped flowers blooming in late spring.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem-chincherinchee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/ornithogalum-thyrsoides","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy bulbous herb of vast horticultural importance because of its long lasting flowers suitable for use as cut flowers.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ornithogalum-thyrsoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Lust","url":"https://plantlust.com/plants/48174/ornithogalum-thyrsoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The stems are 15-18 inches tall and cut flowers will last 10-14 days.","claim":true},{"name":"GardenCenterMarketing.com Plant Library","url":"https://www.gardencentermarketing.com/plantname/ornithogalum-thyrsoides","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Work well as cut flowers","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem-chincherinchee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ornithogalum-thyrsoides/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Grow in consistently moist, organically rich, well-drained soils in full sun to light shade.","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem-chincherinchee","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/ornithogalum-dubium","country":"ZA","form":null,"value":"This bulbous plant grows 100-500 mm tall.","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[7,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/ornithogalum-dubium","country":"ZA","form":null,"value":"This winter-growing species enjoys full sun."}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/ornithogalum-dubium","country":null,"form":null,"value":"as a cut flower","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"star-of-bethlehem-orange","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"statice","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Sea Lavender species can range from 4 inches to 2 feet in height and spread by means of rhizomes.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 8, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"statice","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"statice","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Limonium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/limonium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"limonium"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":2,"species":7},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"statice","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Limonium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/limonium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"limonium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Limonium sinuatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/limonium-sinuatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"limonium sinuatum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Limonium carolinianum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/limonium-carolinianum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"limonium carolinianum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Limonium sinuatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285148","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"limonium sinuatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Limonium platyphyllum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285158","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"limonium platyphyllum"},{"name":"Calscape, California Native Plant Society (Limonium californicum)","url":"https://calscape.org/plant/2209/Limonium-californicum-(Western-Marsh-Rosemary)","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"limonium californicum"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica (Limonium peregrinum)","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/limonium-peregrinum","country":"ZA","form":null,"value":"This medium-sized shrub will provide summer colour and must be planted in a position with full sun.","level":"species","taxon":"limonium peregrinum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"statice","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/limonium/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/limonium-sinuatum/"]},{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/limonium/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/limonium-carolinianum/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Limonium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/limonium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"limonium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Limonium sinuatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/limonium-sinuatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"limonium sinuatum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Limonium carolinianum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/limonium-carolinianum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"limonium carolinianum"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are ncsu.edu. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"statice","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Limonium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/limonium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut Long-lasting Showy","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"limonium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Limonium sinuatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/limonium-sinuatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut Good Dried Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"limonium sinuatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Limonium sinuatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285148","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"limonium sinuatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Limonium platyphyllum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285158","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"limonium platyphyllum"},{"name":"Farmer Bailey (Limonium Growing Guide)","url":"https://farmerbailey.com/pages/limonium-growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut stems should be immediately plunged into cool water. Use a floral holding solution/preservative to extend vase life.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"limonium"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica (Limonium peregrinum)","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/limonium-peregrinum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Worldwide many species are used as popular hardy fillers in the cut flower trade.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"limonium peregrinum"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"statice","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Limonium sinuatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/limonium-sinuatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought Salt","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"limonium sinuatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Limonium sinuatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285148","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"limonium sinuatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Limonium platyphyllum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285158","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil, Shallow-Rocky Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"limonium platyphyllum"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica (Limonium peregrinum)","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/limonium-peregrinum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sea lavender is very drought-tolerant once established and will need minimal watering.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"limonium peregrinum"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"statice","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Limonium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/limonium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Landscape Theme: Butterfly Garden Cutting Garden Native Garden Rock Garden","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"limonium"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Limonium sinuatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/limonium-sinuatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"limonium sinuatum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Limonium carolinianum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/limonium-carolinianum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"limonium carolinianum"},{"name":"SANBI PlantZAfrica (Limonium peregrinum)","url":"https://pza.sanbi.org/limonium-peregrinum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are pollinated by insects.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"limonium peregrinum"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"stephen-rulo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Tuincentrum Lottum (Dutch rose garden centre)","url":"https://www.rozenlottum.nl/en_GB/a-88958886/all-available-roses/stephen-rulo/","country":"NL","form":null,"value":"Heigth 50-100 cm","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":2},"reasons":[]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"stephen-rulo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.76,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":2},"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"stephen-rulo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[6,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":2},"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"stephen-rulo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"stephen-rulo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["medium"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.46404.0","https://www.rozenlottum.nl/en_GB/a-88958886/all-available-roses/stephen-rulo/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.46404.0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Moderate fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Tuincentrum Lottum (Dutch rose garden centre)","url":"https://www.rozenlottum.nl/en_GB/a-88958886/all-available-roses/stephen-rulo/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"stephen-rulo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.46404.0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Can be used for cut flower, exhibition or garden.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"stephen-rulo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"stephen-rulo","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"stock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"stock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"stock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"stock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Matthiola incana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/matthiola-incana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"matthiola incana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Matthiola incana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278041","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"matthiola incana"},{"name":"Mississippi State University Extension (Stock (Matthiola incana) for the Farmer Florist, P3252)","url":"https://extension.msstate.edu/publications/stock-matthiola-incana-for-the-farmer-florist","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Stock prefers full sun exposure; when springtime temperatures begin to rise, it stops producing marketable flowers.","level":"species","taxon":"matthiola incana"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension EDIS FP402 (Matthiola incana: Stock)","url":"https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP402","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in part shade/part sun","level":"species","taxon":"matthiola incana"},{"name":"Chalet Nursery, Wilmette IL (NetPS Plant Finder: Stock, Matthiola incana)","url":"https://plants.chaletnursery.com/12120004/Plant/13894/Stock","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant does best in full sun to partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"matthiola incana"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (Stock Seeds, Matthiola incana)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/stock.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"matthiola incana"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants (Matthiola incana)","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/matthiolaincana.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"matthiola incana"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"stock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":9,"covered":["matthiola incana"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (matthiola incana), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 9 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (matthiola incana) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"stock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":7,"covered":["matthiola incana"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (matthiola incana), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 7 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (matthiola incana) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"stock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["matthiola incana"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (matthiola incana), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (matthiola incana) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"stock","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":4,"covered":["matthiola incana"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (matthiola incana), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 4 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (matthiola incana) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"stock-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 9 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.75 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.35},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["6-10","7-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/matthiola-incana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[6,10]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278041","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 7 to 10","zones":[7,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/matthiola-incana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278041","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/matthiola-incana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers have a clove-like fragrance so plant in areas where the scent can be enjoyed.","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278041","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is noted for its colorful, clove-scented flowers.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/matthiola-incana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-cream","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/matthiola-incana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts wildlife and pollinators.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0.75 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278041","country":"US","form":null,"value":"7 to 10","zones":[7,10]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278041","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278041","country":null,"form":null,"value":"noted for its colorful, clove-scented flowers","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"1.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0 ft. 9 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0.75 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.35},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["6-10","7-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/matthiola-incana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[6,10]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278041","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 7 to 10","zones":[7,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/matthiola-incana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278041","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","strengths":["strong"],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/matthiola-incana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278041","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Extremely fragrant flowers, both singles and doubles, bloom in dense clusters","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/matthiola-incana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"stock-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/matthiola-incana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bees","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"strawberry-hill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1,3.36],"split":[{"range":[1,1.5],"sources":["Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)"]},{"range":[1.52,3.36],"sources":["Heirloom Roses","Grace Rose Farm","HelpMeFind Roses","David Austin Roses (US)","Menagerie Farm & Flower"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/strawberry-hill","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"10ft","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/strawberry-hill","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"5'-10'","metres":[1.52,3.05],"band":[1.52,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin-strawberry-hill-potted-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"8-10'","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/strawberry-hill-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"10 feet","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.41636","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"8'2\" to 9'10\" (250 to 300cm)","metres":[2.5,3],"band":[2.5,3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/244891/rosa-strawberry-hill-ausrimini-pbr-cl/details","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"1-1.5 metres (ultimate height, 2-5 years)","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/strawberry-hill","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"10ft (3m)","metres":3,"band":[2.7,3.3],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"strawberry-hill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.1,1.22],"union":[0.82,1.5],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/strawberry-hill","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin-strawberry-hill-potted-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/strawberry-hill-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.41636","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"up to 47\" (up to 120cm)","metres":1.2,"band":[1.08,1.32],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/244891/rosa-strawberry-hill-ausrimini-pbr-cl/details","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"1-1.5 metres (ultimate spread)","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"strawberry-hill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-11","6-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/strawberry-hill","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zones 4-11"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/strawberry-hill","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zone 4-11"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin-strawberry-hill-potted-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"USDA 4-11"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/strawberry-hill-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Suitable Zones: 4-11"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.41636","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"6b through 9b"}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"strawberry-hill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/strawberry-hill","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/strawberry-hill","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"East, South, West Facing; Full Sunlight"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/strawberry-hill","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Requires 6+ hours of direct sunlight to thrive; faces east, west, or south for full sunlight"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin-strawberry-hill-potted-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/244891/rosa-strawberry-hill-ausrimini-pbr-cl/details","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Full sun; South-facing or West-facing or East-facing"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"strawberry-hill","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/strawberry-hill","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Strong, Myrrh (also described as 'strong, delicious myrrh and heather honey fragrance')"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/strawberry-hill","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Strong, Myrrh"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/strawberry-hill","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"wonderfully intense myrrh fragrance, is touched with a hint of lemon fragrance; one of David Austin's top recommended roses for fragrance"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin-strawberry-hill-potted-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Strong myrrh & heather honey"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/strawberry-hill-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Strong - Myrrh & Honey"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.41636","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Strong, myrrh fragrance"}],"note":"sources rate it strong","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"strawflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"strawflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":8,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"strawflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[8,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"strawflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Xerochrysum bracteatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/xerochrysum-bracteatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"xerochrysum bracteatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Xerochrysum bracteatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292551","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"xerochrysum bracteatum"},{"name":"RHS (Xerochrysum bracteatum, everlasting flower)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/184125/xerochrysum-bracteatum/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Grow in moderately fertile, moist but well-drained, neutral to alkaline soil in full sun","level":"species","taxon":"xerochrysum bracteatum"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension (Strawflower Cut Flower Production in Utah)","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/productionhort/research/strawflower-cut-flower-production-in-utah","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Optimal conditions include loamy, well-drained soil with full sun.","level":"species","taxon":"xerochrysum bracteatum"},{"name":"University of Nebraska-Lincoln Backyard Farmer (Strawflower, Xerochrysum bracteatum)","url":"https://byf.unl.edu/strawflower-xerochrysum-bracteatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Needs: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"xerochrysum bracteatum"},{"name":"Top Tropicals (Xerochrysum bracteatum, Strawflower)","url":"https://toptropicals.com/catalog/uid/xerochrysum_bracteatum.htm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It can be grown in either full sun or semi-shade and requires regular or moderate watering to ensure optimal growth and flowering.","level":"species","taxon":"xerochrysum bracteatum"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (Strawflower Seeds, Xerochrysum bracteatum)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/strawflower.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun","level":"species","taxon":"xerochrysum bracteatum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"strawflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"strawflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Xerochrysum bracteatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/xerochrysum-bracteatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"xerochrysum bracteatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Xerochrysum bracteatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=292551","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is also a long-lasting fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"xerochrysum bracteatum"},{"name":"RHS (Xerochrysum bracteatum, everlasting flower)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/184125/xerochrysum-bracteatum/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"xerochrysum bracteatum"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension (Strawflower Cut Flower Production in Utah)","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/productionhort/research/strawflower-cut-flower-production-in-utah","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This cut flower is also exceptional for drying, as it is nearly dried in the field when ready for harvest.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"xerochrysum bracteatum"},{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds Grower's Library (Strawflower Key Growing Information)","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/growers-library/flowers/strawflower/strawflower-key-growing-information.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"VASE LIFE: 7-10 days.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"helichrysum bracteatum"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (Strawflower Seeds, Xerochrysum bracteatum)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/strawflower.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Glowing pastel blooms are excellent as cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"xerochrysum bracteatum"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"strawflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["xerochrysum bracteatum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (xerochrysum bracteatum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (xerochrysum bracteatum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"strawflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":4,"covered":["xerochrysum bracteatum"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (xerochrysum bracteatum), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 4 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (xerochrysum bracteatum) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sugar-tyme","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"14.00 to 18.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"18-20 ft.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sugar-tyme","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":10,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"11.00 to 15.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"15-18 ft.\", and this row's size is its size at 10 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 10 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sugar-tyme","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-7"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249556&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Utah State University Extension, Varga Arboretum","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/botanicalcenter/trees-of-varga-arboretum/sugar-tyme-crabapple.php","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4-7","zones":[4,7]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sugar-tyme","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249556&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sugar-tyme","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249556&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Utah State University Extension, Varga Arboretum","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/botanicalcenter/trees-of-varga-arboretum/sugar-tyme-crabapple.php","country":null,"form":null,"value":"fragrant white flowers","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sugar-tyme","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sugar-tyme","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sugar-tyme","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=249556&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Birds, Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"summersweet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.52,2.44],"union":[0.91,3.05],"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clethra-alnifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.52,3.05],"band":[1.52,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279194","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 8.00 feet","metres":[0.91,2.44],"band":[0.91,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Summersweet Clethra)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/summersweet-clethra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Summersweet clethra typically grow from 5 to 8 feet tall and 4 to 6 feet wide.","metres":[1.52,2.44],"band":[1.52,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Summersweet Clethra)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=366&PlantTypeID=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 4-8 Feet","metres":[1.22,2.44],"band":[1.22,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Piedmont Master Gardeners, Virginia Cooperative Extension (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://www.piedmontmastergardeners.org/article/clethra-alnifolia-a-versatile-native-plant-in-the-landscape/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Depending on the cultivar, it typically ranges in size from three-to-eight feet tall.","metres":[0.91,2.44],"band":[0.91,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Summersweet clethra)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/summersweet-clethra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This shrub can grow from 3 to 8 feet with an oval, upright shape.","metres":[0.91,2.44],"band":[0.91,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CLAL3","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size Notes: Normally 3 to 6 feet tall, but can reach 12 feet.","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide (Sweet pepperbush, Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/sweet-pepperbush-clethra-alnifolia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height : 6 to 10 feet","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Wikipedia (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clethra_alnifolia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing to 1.5–3 m (4 ft 11 in – 9 ft 10 in) tall, it is a deciduous shrub.","metres":[1.5,3],"band":[1.5,3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"summersweet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.22,1.83],"union":[1.22,3.05],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clethra-alnifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 4 ft. 0 in. - 6 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279194","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Summersweet Clethra)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/summersweet-clethra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Summersweet clethra typically grow from 5 to 8 feet tall and 4 to 6 feet wide.","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Summersweet Clethra)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=366&PlantTypeID=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width 4-10 Feet","metres":[1.22,3.05],"band":[1.22,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide (Sweet pepperbush, Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/sweet-pepperbush-clethra-alnifolia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Width : 6 to 10 feet","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"summersweet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clethra-alnifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279194","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Summersweet clethra)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/summersweet-clethra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8, Zone 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide (Sweet pepperbush, Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/sweet-pepperbush-clethra-alnifolia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones : 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"summersweet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clethra-alnifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279194","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Summersweet Clethra)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/summersweet-clethra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This native plant will grow in full sun to total shade, but will grow best in light, dappled shade, or with morning sun and afternoon shade.","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Summersweet Clethra)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=366&PlantTypeID=8","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to partial shade; prefers a moist to wet soil; tolerant of salt, compaction and some dryness; prefers slightly acid soil pH.","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Piedmont Master Gardeners, Virginia Cooperative Extension (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://www.piedmontmastergardeners.org/article/clethra-alnifolia-a-versatile-native-plant-in-the-landscape/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"While it prefers full shade, it will tolerate everything from full sun to full shade.","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Summersweet clethra)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/summersweet-clethra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily), Full shade (4 hrs or less of light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CLAL3","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade , Shade","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide (Sweet pepperbush, Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/sweet-pepperbush-clethra-alnifolia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"summersweet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clethra-alnifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Numerous, fragrant, small white flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279194","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Summersweet Clethra)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/summersweet-clethra/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The inflorescence, or flower cluster (botanically called a raceme), is white on the species, varies from 3 to 6 inches long, and is extremely fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Summersweet Clethra)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=366&PlantTypeID=8","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant white flowers in small spikes, July and August; crisp, dark green foliage in summer; autumn color is yellow to a mild orange.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Piedmont Master Gardeners, Virginia Cooperative Extension (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://www.piedmontmastergardeners.org/article/clethra-alnifolia-a-versatile-native-plant-in-the-landscape/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The showy, fragrant flowers bloom on current year's growth and are arranged in bottlebrush-like racemes at the tips of branches.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Summersweet clethra)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/summersweet-clethra/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"it provides exceptional four season interest with its lustrous green leaves in the spring, spiky white or pink fragrant summer flowers, golden yellow autumn leaves, and interesting, delicate dried seed capsules in winter.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CLAL3","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers: yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide (Sweet pepperbush, Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/sweet-pepperbush-clethra-alnifolia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This upright, suckering shrub has fragrant, white or pink terminal flower spikes in late summer.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Wikipedia (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clethra_alnifolia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are white or very pale pink, 5–10 mm in diameter, and have a sweet, somewhat cloying fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"summersweet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"summersweet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clethra-alnifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It tolerates full sun to partial shade, but will not tolerate a hot, dry site.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Summersweet Clethra)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/summersweet-clethra/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, plants will tolerate short periods of drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Summersweet Clethra)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=366&PlantTypeID=8","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Full sun to partial shade; prefers a moist to wet soil; tolerant of salt, compaction and some dryness; prefers slightly acid soil pH.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Piedmont Master Gardeners, Virginia Cooperative Extension (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://www.piedmontmastergardeners.org/article/clethra-alnifolia-a-versatile-native-plant-in-the-landscape/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Despite its preference for moist soils, this versatile plant is fairly drought tolerant once it is established in the landscape.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CLAL3","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerance: Low","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"}],"note":"3 source(s) state this trait and 2 deny it","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"summersweet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clethra-alnifolia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds, butterflies, native bees, and other pollinators are attracted to the nectar blooms.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279194","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are very attractive to butterflies and bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Summersweet Clethra)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/summersweet-clethra/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are attractive to bees and butterflies, and the resulting dark brown seed capsules will attract birds during the autumn.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Piedmont Master Gardeners, Virginia Cooperative Extension (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://www.piedmontmastergardeners.org/article/clethra-alnifolia-a-versatile-native-plant-in-the-landscape/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It provides nectar for hummingbirds, bees and butterflies in the summer and seeds for birds in the winter.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Summersweet clethra)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/summersweet-clethra/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is a nectar source for swallowtail butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CLAL3","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use Wildlife: Bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds use flowers. Many birds and mammals eat the fruit.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide (Sweet pepperbush, Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/sweet-pepperbush-clethra-alnifolia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The blooms look like bottle brushes and attract butterflies and bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"},{"name":"Wikipedia (Clethra alnifolia)","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clethra_alnifolia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers, which are attractive to bumblebees","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"clethra alnifolia"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"summersweet-ruby-spice","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.65,1.83],"union":[1.22,2.01],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260880","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/summersweet-clethra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This cultivar can reach 6 feet in height and width","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/summersweet-clethra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"A 4 to 6 feet high and wide cultivar with an oval to rounded form and rosy pink flowers.","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/ruby-spice-summersweet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 4 - 6 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"summersweet-ruby-spice","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.22,1.52],"union":[0.91,2.01],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260880","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/summersweet-clethra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This cultivar can reach 6 feet in height and width","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/summersweet-clethra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"A 4 to 6 feet high and wide cultivar with an oval to rounded form and rosy pink flowers.","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/ruby-spice-summersweet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 4 - 6 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"summersweet-ruby-spice","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-9","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260880","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/summersweet-clethra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8, Zone 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clethra-alnifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/ruby-spice-summersweet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 4 - 9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"summersweet-ruby-spice","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260880","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/summersweet-clethra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This native plant will grow in full sun to total shade, but will grow best in light, dappled shade, or with morning sun and afternoon shade."},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/summersweet-clethra/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily), Full shade (4 hrs or less of light daily)"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/clethra-alnifolia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/clethra-alnifolia-ruby-spice","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to partial shade."},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/ruby-spice-summersweet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Partial Shade to Full Sun (At Least 3 Hours Of Direct Sunlight)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"summersweet-ruby-spice","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260880","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/clethra-alnifolia-ruby-spice","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Broadleaf deciduous shrub, flowers fragrant, reportedly a rich rose but here a light pink.","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/ruby-spice-summersweet","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fragrant flowers will draw pollinators, like bees and butterflies, to your landscape","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"summersweet-ruby-spice","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"summersweet-ruby-spice","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"summersweet-ruby-spice","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=260880","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/summersweet-clethra/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are attractive to bees and butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/ruby-spice-summersweet","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The fragrant flowers will draw pollinators, like bees and butterflies, to your landscape","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sunflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":10,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 3.00 to 10.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 6 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 2.5-4 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Size Notes: From 1-1/2 to about 10 feet tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height: 18 Inches - 10 Feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Most garden cultivars are 4 to 5 feet tall, though some types can grow to 12 feet tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Be astonished by sunflowers, from the 12-footers down to the smaller 2 to 3-foot tall cultivars that fit nicely into smaller garden spaces.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"typically grow to 36 - 108 inches tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Growth Height: 3 - 7 feet tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant Height Up to 36 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sunflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.50 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 6 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sunflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-11","3-10","4-9","1-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277199","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11]},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/sunflowers/sunflower-wild-flower-seed.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA ZONES 3 - 10","zones":[3,10]},{"name":"Great Basin Seeds","url":"https://greatbasinseeds.com/product/annual-sunflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/wild_sunflower_seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10","zones":[1,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sunflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277199","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helianthus-annuus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/105515/helianthus-annuus/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/gardening-minnesota/sunflowers","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunflowers enjoy full sun."},{"name":"Great Basin Seeds","url":"https://greatbasinseeds.com/product/annual-sunflower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunflowers need full sun."},{"name":"Eden Brothers","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/wild_sunflower_seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sunflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sunflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277199","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sunflowers have become very popular commercial cut flowers throughout the world.","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/lets-grow-sunflowers/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"as cut flowers for arrangements (often pollen-free varieties)","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sunflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277199","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/helianthus-annuus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is tolerant of poor soils and dry soils and is drought-tolerant once established.","claim":true},{"name":"Outsidepride","url":"https://www.outsidepride.com/seed/flower-seed/sunflowers/sunflower-wild-flower-seed.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, the plants are somewhat drought and heat tolerant.","claim":true},{"name":"Great Basin Seeds","url":"https://greatbasinseeds.com/product/annual-sunflower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Annual sunflower is drought tolerant once it is established.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sunflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277199","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/105515/helianthus-annuus/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers attract bees and the seeds that follow provide food for finches","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/lets-grow-sunflowers/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sunflowers provide nectar and pollen resources for beneficial insects, along with an abundance of seed for wildlife.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sunflower-lemon-queen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"60-96\" tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sunflower-lemon-queen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sunflower-lemon-queen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sunflower-lemon-queen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/sunflower-wildflower-seeds-lemon-queen","https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/lemon-queen-sunflower-seeds"]}],"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/sunflower-wildflower-seeds-lemon-queen","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"Botanical Interests","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/lemon-queen-sunflower-seeds","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sunflower-lemon-queen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sunflower-lemon-queen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/sunflower-wildflower-seeds-lemon-queen","https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/lemon-queen-sunflower-seeds"]}],"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/sunflower-wildflower-seeds-lemon-queen","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Botanical Interests","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/lemon-queen-sunflower-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sunflower-lemon-queen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Botanical Interests","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/lemon-queen-sunflower-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sunflower-lemon-queen","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/sunflower-wildflower-seeds-lemon-queen","https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/lemon-queen-sunflower-seeds"]}],"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/sunflower-wildflower-seeds-lemon-queen","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Botanical Interests","url":"https://www.botanicalinterests.com/products/lemon-queen-sunflower-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Pollinators","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"susan-williams-ellis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.23,1.5],"union":[0.91,1.52],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/susan-williams-ellis","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4 1/2ft","metres":1.37,"band":[1.23,1.51],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/susan-williams-ellis-english-shrub-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mature Height 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/302148/rosa-susan-williams-ellis-ausquirk-pbr-s/details","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Max Height 1-1.5 metres","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-susan-williams-ellis%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4′-5′","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rosarium Lottum","url":"https://rosariumlottum.com/en/product/susan-williams-ellis-ausquirk/","country":"NL","form":"shrub","value":"Height 100-150 cm ( Busch Rose )","metres":[1,1.5],"band":[1,1.5],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/susan-williams-ellis","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 3 1/2ft (110cm)","metres":1.07,"band":[0.96,1.18],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"susan-williams-ellis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.96,1],"union":[0.5,1.22],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/susan-williams-ellis","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3 1/2ft","metres":1.07,"band":[0.96,1.18],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/susan-williams-ellis-english-shrub-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mature Spread 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/302148/rosa-susan-williams-ellis-ausquirk-pbr-s/details","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-susan-williams-ellis%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3′-4′","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/susan-williams-ellis","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3ft (90cm)","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"susan-williams-ellis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-11","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/susan-williams-ellis","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 4-11","zones":[4,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/susan-williams-ellis-english-shrub-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"USDA Hardiness Zones 4 to 11","zones":[4,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-susan-williams-ellis%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zones: USDA 5-9","zones":[5,9],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"cultivar":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"susan-williams-ellis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/susan-williams-ellis","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/susan-williams-ellis","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight Partial Shade","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/susan-williams-ellis-english-shrub-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light Exposure Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/302148/rosa-susan-williams-ellis-ausquirk-pbr-s/details","country":"GB","form":"shrub","value":"Position Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-susan-williams-ellis%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light Requirements: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Green Valley Garden Supply","url":"https://greenvalleygardensupply.com/products/rosa-ausquirk-susan-williams-ellis%C2%AE-rose","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Best grown in full sun and rich, moist, slightly acidic well-drained soils.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"susan-williams-ellis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","strengths":["medium","medium","strong","medium"],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, US site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/susan-williams-ellis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The medium-strong fragrance is perfectly Old Rose in character.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (breeder, UK site)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/susan-williams-ellis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The medium-strong fragrance is perfectly Old Rose in character.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/susan-williams-ellis-english-shrub-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/302148/rosa-susan-williams-ellis-ausquirk-pbr-s/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A bushy and robust shrub rose to about 1.2m tall, with twiggy growth, and producing fragrant, white, fully-double rosette flowers in small clusters from early summer to late autumn; a sport of 'The Mayflower', David Austin 2010","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-susan-williams-ellis%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong old rose fragrance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Rosarium Lottum","url":"https://rosariumlottum.com/en/product/susan-williams-ellis-ausquirk/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant delicious fragrance","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Green Valley Garden Supply","url":"https://greenvalleygardensupply.com/products/rosa-ausquirk-susan-williams-ellis%C2%AE-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The old rose scented soft white double flowers bloom in flushes from late spring until frost.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"susan-williams-ellis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/susan-williams-ellis-english-shrub-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cutting Garden","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"rosa"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"susan-williams-ellis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"susan-williams-ellis","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/susan-williams-ellis-english-shrub-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"sweet-alyssum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.12,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":8,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 3 in. - 0 ft. 10 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.25 to 0.75 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Sweet alyssum grows 3-9 inches tall with a wider spread.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"It grows in a mounding form to about 12 inches tall and wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Sweet alyssum grown from seed reaches 3 to 6 inches high and spreads 12 inches or more.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.2 to 1 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Growth Habit: Evergreen, herbaceous annual or short-lived perennial, matting and spreading to 12- to 18-inches wide, 3- to 6-inches tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"is a hardy ground cover annual which grows to about 10 inches tall and spreads about 1 foot wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-alyssum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.50 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"It grows in a mounding form to about 12 inches tall and wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Sweet alyssum grown from seed reaches 3 to 6 inches high and spreads 12 inches or more.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.75 to 1 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Growth Habit: Evergreen, herbaceous annual or short-lived perennial, matting and spreading to 12- to 18-inches wide, 3- to 6-inches tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"is a hardy ground cover annual which grows to about 10 inches tall and spreads about 1 foot wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-alyssum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"CONVENTION","wouldPropose":[5,9],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Lobularia maritima)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lobularia-maritima/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lobularia maritima)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278056&isprofile=0&basic=Lobularia+maritima","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source states 5-9 and this row deliberately stores no zones, which is the library's way of saying \"grown everywhere\" (docs/CATALOG-AUDIT.md records the two zone conventions for annuals as expected). Nothing is proposed: writing a zone range onto a zone-less row would remove it from every zone filter outside that range, and this is one library-wide decision rather than a per-plant error","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-alyssum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Lobularia maritima)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lobularia-maritima/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Alyssum does best in full sun to partial shade in well-drained soils.","level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lobularia maritima)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278056&isprofile=0&basic=Lobularia+maritima","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, UW-Madison Division of Extension (Sweet Alyssum, Lobularia maritima)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/sweet-alyssum-lobularia-maritima/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sweet alyssum grows well in full sun in cool climates but may do better in partial shade in hot climates.","level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions (Sweet Alyssum)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/sweet-alyssum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sweet alyssum performs best when planted in a spot that has well-drained soil and receives full sun, but it can also take some shade.","level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening flower growing guide (Sweet Alyssum)","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scened548.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: full sun part shade","level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"Arizona State University virtual plant library (Lobularia maritima)","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/lobulariamaritima.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County (Q: What can you tell me about Sweet alyssum?)","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/07/09/q-can-tell-sweet-alyssum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sweet alyssum thrives in partial sun to partial shade, in almost any soil however they will produce fewer flowers in full sun and poor soil conditions.","level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (Alyssum Seeds, Lobularia maritima)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/alyssum.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun or part shade. Light shade in hottest climates.","level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-alyssum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Lobularia maritima)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lobularia-maritima/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The mat-forming plant produces spreading mounds of fragrant white flowers from spring to first frost where the summers are cool (blooms will decline in hot summers).","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lobularia maritima)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278056&isprofile=0&basic=Lobularia+maritima","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, UW-Madison Division of Extension (Sweet Alyssum, Lobularia maritima)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/sweet-alyssum-lobularia-maritima/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers have a honey-like fragrance and are very attractive to bees, flower flies, stingless wasps and butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions (Sweet Alyssum)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/sweet-alyssum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies and bees are attracted to the carpet of flowers which, interestingly enough, smell like honey.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Sweet Alyssum)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/sweet-alyssum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plant it where you can enjoy its sweet fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening flower growing guide (Sweet Alyssum)","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scened548.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This fragrant plant is valued for its dainty foliage and tiny white flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-alyssum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-alyssum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Lobularia maritima)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lobularia-maritima/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It will tolerate drought and dry soil and appreciates some afternoon shade.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lobularia maritima)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278056&isprofile=0&basic=Lobularia+maritima","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, UW-Madison Division of Extension (Sweet Alyssum, Lobularia maritima)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/sweet-alyssum-lobularia-maritima/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Although it will tolerate short dry periods, alyssum does best with consistent moisture.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (Alyssum Seeds, Lobularia maritima)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/alyssum.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants tolerate heat and drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-alyssum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Lobularia maritima)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lobularia-maritima/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Beetles, butterflies, and skippers feed off the plant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"Wisconsin Horticulture, UW-Madison Division of Extension (Sweet Alyssum, Lobularia maritima)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/sweet-alyssum-lobularia-maritima/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"very attractive to bees, flower flies, stingless wasps and butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions (Sweet Alyssum)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/sweet-alyssum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies and bees are attracted to the carpet of flowers which, interestingly enough, smell like honey.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Sweet Alyssum)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/sweet-alyssum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sweet alyssum can also be grown in the vegetable garden to attract pollinators like bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening flower growing guide (Sweet Alyssum)","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scened548.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (Alyssum Seeds, Lobularia maritima)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/alyssum.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract butterflies and bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lobularia maritima"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"sweet-alyssum-royal-carpet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"6-8\" x 10-14\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"2-4 inches tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"reaching only three to six inches high\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-alyssum-royal-carpet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"6-8\" x 10-14\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"4-8\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"SPLIT"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-alyssum-royal-carpet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-alyssum-royal-carpet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Pinetree Garden Seeds","url":"https://www.superseeds.com/products/royal-carpet-alyssum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part sun"},{"name":"Applewood Seed Co.","url":"https://www.applewoodseed.com/product/sweet-alyssum-dwarf-royal-carpet/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"Hudson Valley Seed Company","url":"https://hudsonvalleyseed.com/products/royal-carpet-alyssum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun (8+ Hours Sun)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-alyssum-royal-carpet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.applewoodseed.com/product/sweet-alyssum-dwarf-royal-carpet/","https://hudsonvalleyseed.com/products/royal-carpet-alyssum"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Applewood Seed Co.","url":"https://www.applewoodseed.com/product/sweet-alyssum-dwarf-royal-carpet/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Hudson Valley Seed Company","url":"https://hudsonvalleyseed.com/products/royal-carpet-alyssum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"a delightful, honey-like fragrance","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-alyssum-royal-carpet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-alyssum-royal-carpet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-alyssum-royal-carpet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Ohio State University Extension, Knox County Agricultural News (Success with Sweet Peas)","url":"https://u.osu.edu/knoxcountyag/2018/04/05/success-with-sweet-peas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most selections are tall vines that can reach a height of up to 8 feet in a single season.","metres":2.44,"band":[2.2,2.68],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 3.00 to 8.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 1.5-2.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 6 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Sweet pea plants produce vines that can reach 5-7 feet in height\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"They grow rapidly up to 6 feet tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,11],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lathyrus odoratus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lathyrus-odoratus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[2,11],"level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lathyrus odoratus)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280383","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11],"level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":7,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lathyrus odoratus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lathyrus-odoratus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lathyrus odoratus)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280383","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Lathyrus odoratus)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/25520/lathyrus-odoratus/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Full sun, Partial shade","level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"},{"name":"UC Marin Master Gardeners, UC ANR (Sweet peas grown with ease)","url":"https://ucanr.edu/site/uc-marin-master-gardeners/article/sweet-peas-grown-ease","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sweet peas thrive with their roots in cool, moist soil and their vines in full sun","level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"},{"name":"Ohio State University Extension, Knox County Agricultural News (Success with Sweet Peas)","url":"https://u.osu.edu/knoxcountyag/2018/04/05/success-with-sweet-peas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sweet peas grow in full sun to partial shade and require rich, well-drained soil.","level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lathyrus, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lathyrus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"lathyrus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lathyrus odoratus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lathyrus-odoratus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It has very fragrant flowers, dark green leaflet pairs, and winged stems that end in tendrils.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Lathyrus odoratus)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280383","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Lathyrus odoratus)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/25520/lathyrus-odoratus/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers, produced in summer and early autumn, are 3.5cm across, strongly-scented, with wine-red standard petals and purple wings and keels.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"},{"name":"Illinois Extension Flowers (Sweet Pea)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/sweet-pea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"},{"name":"UC Marin Master Gardeners, UC ANR (Sweet peas grown with ease)","url":"https://ucanr.edu/site/uc-marin-master-gardeners/article/sweet-peas-grown-ease","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bearing a heavenly floral scent and coming in every color except yellow","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden (Annual Flowering Vines)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/1997/3-28-1997/vines.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sweet peas ( Lathyrus odoratus ) are grown for their fragrant flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"},{"name":"Ohio State University Extension, Knox County Agricultural News (Success with Sweet Peas)","url":"https://u.osu.edu/knoxcountyag/2018/04/05/success-with-sweet-peas/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The long-stemmed sprays of fluted and ruffled blossoms produce an irresistible medley of fragrances that reminds me of jasmine and orange blossoms.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (Lathyrus odoratus)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/25520/lathyrus-odoratus/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"},{"name":"UC Marin Master Gardeners, UC ANR (Sweet peas grown with ease)","url":"https://ucanr.edu/site/uc-marin-master-gardeners/article/sweet-peas-grown-ease","country":null,"form":null,"value":"they make remarkable cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"},{"name":"Ohio State University Extension, Knox County Agricultural News (Success with Sweet Peas)","url":"https://u.osu.edu/knoxcountyag/2018/04/05/success-with-sweet-peas/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"growing and enjoying sweet peas as cut flowers is a gardening tradition","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"sweet-pea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lathyrus, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lathyrus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"lathyrus"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Lathyrus odoratus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lathyrus-odoratus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"lathyrus odoratus"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"3.00 to 8.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"3 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"2.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.76},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,11],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277790&kempercode=b734","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lathyrus-odoratus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zones 2a to 11b","zones":[2,11]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277790&kempercode=b734","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lathyrus-odoratus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277790&kempercode=b734","country":null,"form":null,"value":"highly fragrant flowers","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"6' h x 8\" w\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"5' vines\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"6' h x 8\" w\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280383","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2 to 11","zones":[2,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280383","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280383","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant keeled flowers bloom in clusters.","claim":true},{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/sweet-pea-cupanis-original-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Especially Fragrant Flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Fedco Seeds","url":"https://fedcoseeds.com/seeds/cupani-sweet-pea-5623","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Grow Cupani for enticing intoxicating aroma","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Select Seeds","url":"https://www.selectseeds.com/products/sweet-pea-cupanis-original-seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great Cut Flower","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-purple","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 3.00 to 8.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 6 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height Vine: 6-10 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant Height Up to 72 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant Height: 72-96\"\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":2,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":0.76},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[2,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-11","1-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280383","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lathyrus-odoratus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[2,11]},{"name":"American Meadows (Royal Family Sweet Pea Seeds Mix)","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/sweet-pea-wildflower-seeds-royal-family-mix","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 1-10","zones":[1,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280383","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lathyrus-odoratus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"American Meadows (Royal Family Sweet Pea Seeds Mix)","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/sweet-pea-wildflower-seeds-royal-family-mix","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280383","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/lathyrus-odoratus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/sweet-pea","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Yes","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows (Royal Family Sweet Pea Seeds Mix)","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/sweet-pea-wildflower-seeds-royal-family-mix","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Bring the fabulous fragrance of Sweet Pea to your garden","claim":true},{"name":"Eden Brothers (Sweet Pea Seeds - Royal Mix)","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/sweet_pea_royal_seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees, Attracts Butterflies, Attracts Pollinators, Easy to Grow & Maintain, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds (Royal Wedding Sweet Pea)","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/sweet-peas/royal-wedding-sweet-pea-seed-3426.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Variety is highly fragrant.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension, Bulletin 954 Flowering Annuals for Georgia Gardens","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/B954/flowering-annuals-for-georgia-gardens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sweetpea is grown primarily for its fragrant, colorful flowers, which make good cut flowers.","claim":true}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"American Meadows (Royal Family Sweet Pea Seeds Mix)","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/sweet-pea-wildflower-seeds-royal-family-mix","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This flower is also frequently planted strictly to cut","claim":true},{"name":"Eden Brothers (Sweet Pea Seeds - Royal Mix)","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/sweet_pea_royal_seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Container Garden, Cut Flower Garden, Soil Improvement","claim":true},{"name":"Johnny's Selected Seeds (Royal Wedding Sweet Pea)","url":"https://www.johnnyseeds.com/flowers/sweet-peas/royal-wedding-sweet-pea-seed-3426.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Variety good for fresh cut-flower displays.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension, Bulletin 954 Flowering Annuals for Georgia Gardens","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/B954/flowering-annuals-for-georgia-gardens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Sweetpea is grown primarily for its fragrant, colorful flowers, which make good cut flowers.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-pea-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Eden Brothers (Sweet Pea Seeds - Royal Mix)","url":"https://www.edenbrothers.com/products/sweet_pea_royal_seeds","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees, Attracts Butterflies, Attracts Pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"sweet-potato-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":10,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 6 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.50 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Height 2.5-4 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"rarely above 1-foot tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature Height 5-10 Feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 6-10 Feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-potato-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":10,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 8 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 8.00 to 10.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Max Spread 0.5-1 metres\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"moderately to rapidly spreading sometimes to 10 to 40 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-potato-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ipomoea batatas)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ipomoea-batatas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[9,11],"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ipomoea batatas)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279305","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 9 to 11","zones":[9,11],"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Landscape Plants for the Arizona Desert (Ipomoea batatas)","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/ipomoeabatatas.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA All zones as annual summer annual, winter hardy in zones 9 (with protection) to 11","zones":[9,11],"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":10,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-potato-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ipomoea batatas)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ipomoea-batatas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ipomoea batatas)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279305","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ipomoea batatas 'NCORNSP-021SHJB' SWEET CAROLINE SWEETHEART JET BLACK)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=438510","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ipomoea batatas SWEET CAROLINE BEWITCHED GREEN WITH ENVY)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=366215","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ipomoea batatas 'Sweet Caroline Sweetheart Lime')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=358341","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society, RHS Plant Profile (Ipomoea batatas)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/9185/ipomoea-batatas/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Landscape Plants for the Arizona Desert (Ipomoea batatas)","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/ipomoeabatatas.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dappled sun to full sun with light shade best.","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Sweet Potato, Ornamental)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=527&PlantTypeID=5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to light shade. Moist, well drained soils are best.","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (How To Grow and Care for Ornamental Sweetpotato Vine)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/how-to-grow-and-care-for-ornamental-sweetpotato-vine-ipomoea-batatas/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions (Ornamental Sweet Potato)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/ornamental-sweet-potato/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It prefers full sun, but will grow in partial shade.","level":"species"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County (Fact Sheet: Sweet Potato Vine)","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/06/11/fact-sheet-sweet-potato-vine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Though it requires full sun, it will grow in partial shade.","level":"species"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-potato-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ipomoea batatas)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ipomoea-batatas/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers (Sweet Potato Vine)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/sweet-potato-vine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-potato-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-potato-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ipomoea batatas)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ipomoea-batatas/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is resistant to drought and dry soil but is frequently damaged by deer.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ipomoea batatas)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279305","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Landscape Plants for the Arizona Desert (Ipomoea batatas)","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/ipomoeabatatas.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Watering: Regular summer water is required.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC (How To Grow and Care for Ornamental Sweetpotato Vine)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/how-to-grow-and-care-for-ornamental-sweetpotato-vine-ipomoea-batatas/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water: moderate water needs, foliage will wilt when too dry","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions (Ornamental Sweet Potato)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/ornamental-sweet-potato/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This hardy, drought-tolerant climber comes in a wide array of attractive foliage colors, from bright chartreuse green to a purple so dark it's almost black.","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Nassau County (Fact Sheet: Sweet Potato Vine)","url":"https://blogs.ifas.ufl.edu/nassauco/2017/06/11/fact-sheet-sweet-potato-vine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The vine is also grown for its decorative foliage, vigorous growth habit and drought tolerance.","claim":true,"level":"species"}],"note":"4 source(s) state this trait and 2 deny it","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"sweet-potato-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ipomoea batatas)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ipomoea-batatas/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is an attractant for bees and pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ipomoea batatas"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"switchgrass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.22,1.4],"union":[0.36,3.36],"voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 7 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,2.13],"band":[0.91,2.13],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285211&isprofile=0&basic=Panicum+virgatum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension Horticulture (Switch Grass, Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/switch-grass-panicum-virgatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This long-lived perennial grass typically grows 2½-5 feet tall, slowly spreading by short rhizomes in all directions.","metres":[0.76,1.52],"band":[0.76,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, University of Texas at Austin (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PAVI2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size Notes: Up to about 10 feet tall, often shorter.","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide (Switchgrass)","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/switchgrass","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: flowering stems usually 14–55 inches.","metres":[0.36,1.4],"band":[0.36,1.4],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"USDA Forest Service, Fire Effects Information System (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://www.fs.usda.gov/database/feis/plants/graminoid/panvir/all.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Foliage height of mature plants is mostly between 3 and 5 feet (0.9-1.5 m),; the inflorescence, a 6- to 18-inch-long (15-46 cm) open panicle, often extends to a height of 5 to 7 feet (1.5-2.1 m)","metres":[0.91,2.13],"band":[0.91,2.13],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery (Switchgrass, Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/switchgrass-panicum-virgatum.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 3' - 6'","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/panicum-virgatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height : 3 - 6 ft","metres":[0.91,1.83],"band":[0.91,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"Go Botany, Native Plant Trust (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://gobotany.nativeplanttrust.org/species/panicum/virgatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant height 40–300 cm","metres":[0.4,3],"band":[0.4,3],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"High Plains Gardening, Texas High Plains Region (Panicum virgatum)","url":"http://www.highplainsgardening.com/plant-profiles/panicum-virgatum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height (ft): 4-6'","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"switchgrass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.61,0.91],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285211&isprofile=0&basic=Panicum+virgatum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"High Plains Gardening, Texas High Plains Region (Panicum virgatum)","url":"http://www.highplainsgardening.com/plant-profiles/panicum-virgatum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 2-3'","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"switchgrass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","3-9","3-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285211&isprofile=0&basic=Panicum+virgatum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension Horticulture (Switch Grass, Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/switch-grass-panicum-virgatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is hardy in zones 3a-9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery (Switchgrass, Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/switchgrass-panicum-virgatum.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10","zones":[3,10],"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/panicum-virgatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":11},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"switchgrass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285211&isprofile=0&basic=Panicum+virgatum","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension Horticulture (Switch Grass, Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/switch-grass-panicum-virgatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Switchgrass grows best in full sun and moist soil but adapts to a wide range of soils and weather conditions.","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, University of Texas at Austin (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PAVI2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"Prairie Nursery (Switchgrass, Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://www.prairienursery.com/switchgrass-panicum-virgatum.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Exposure Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/panicum-virgatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun, Sun/Light Shade","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Ornamental Grasses and Grass-like Plants)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/ornamental-grasses-and-grass-like-plants/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Switchgrass prefers full sun in moist to wet soil, but is highly adaptable.","level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"switchgrass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"switchgrass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285211&isprofile=0&basic=Panicum+virgatum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension Horticulture (Switch Grass, Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/switch-grass-panicum-virgatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flower spikes can be used in fresh or dried arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide (Switchgrass)","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/switchgrass","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flower heads are attractive and can be used in flower arrangements, either cut or dried.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/panicum-virgatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attributes Cut Flower, Dried Flower, Drought Tolerant, Naturalizing","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"switchgrass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This plant is resistant to deer grazing, drought, erosion, and air pollution.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=285211&isprofile=0&basic=Panicum+virgatum","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Clay Soil, Dry Soil, Wet Soil, Black Walnut, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension Horticulture (Switch Grass, Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/switch-grass-panicum-virgatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, it is drought tolerant and grows well in high temperatures.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"Missouri Department of Conservation Field Guide (Switchgrass)","url":"https://mdc.mo.gov/discover-nature/field-guide/switchgrass","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It tolerates drought and a variety of soils.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/panicum-virgatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attributes Cut Flower, Dried Flower, Drought Tolerant, Naturalizing","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"Go Botany, Native Plant Trust (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://gobotany.nativeplanttrust.org/species/panicum/virgatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Switch panicgrass is a North American native perennial drought-tolerant grass that is a palatable forage grass and is planted domestically and worldwide for range and wildlife habitat improvement.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"switchgrass","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This is a larval host plant for various Skipper butterflies and the Common Wood-Nymph (Cercyonis pegala) which have one brood from late May to October.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, University of Texas at Austin (Panicum virgatum)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=PAVI2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds , Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"panicum virgatum"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"switchgrass-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.22,1.52],"union":[1.22,1.52],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum-heavy-metal/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251778&isprofile=0&basic=Heavy%20Metal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.8,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.3,0.61],"union":[0.3,0.61],"proposed":0.45,"margin":31.1,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum-heavy-metal/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251778&isprofile=0&basic=Heavy%20Metal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.3 to 0.61 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum-heavy-metal/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone 4a to 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251778&isprofile=0&basic=Heavy%20Metal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum-heavy-metal/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251778&isprofile=0&basic=Heavy%20Metal","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum-heavy-metal/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=251778&isprofile=0&basic=Heavy%20Metal","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum-heavy-metal/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"drought tolerant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.8,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[1.37,1.52],"union":[1.22,1.52],"proposed":1.45,"margin":18.4,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=z240","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum-northwind/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 ft. 6 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.37,1.52],"band":[1.37,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (1.22 to 1.52 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.61,0.91],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=z240","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum-northwind/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2 ft. 6 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.76,0.91],"band":[0.76,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[5,9],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=z240","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum-northwind/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"every source states 5-9; catalog states 4-9","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=z240","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum-northwind/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=z240","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Dry Soil, Wet Soil, Black Walnut, Urban Conditions","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum-northwind/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts birds and butterflies.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.61,1.22],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254228","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/panicum-virgatum-shenandoah","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 36\" tall","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Panicum-virgatum-Shenandoah","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2-3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/panicum-virgatum-shenandoah/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants are 2-3' tall with 2' spread.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.55,1.22],"split":[{"range":[0.55,0.67],"sources":["North Creek Nurseries","New Moon Nursery"]},{"range":[0.91,1.22],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254228","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Panicum-virgatum-Shenandoah","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2 Feet","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/panicum-virgatum-shenandoah/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants are 2-3' tall with 2' spread.","metres":0.61,"band":[0.55,0.67],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","3-9","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254228","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Plant Delights Nursery","url":"https://www.plantdelights.com/products/panicum-virgatum-shenandoah","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3a to 9b","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Panicum-virgatum-Shenandoah","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4-9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/panicum-virgatum-shenandoah/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Panicum virgataum 'Shenandoah' is hardy from USDA Zones 4-9.","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254228","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/panicum-virgatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Panicum-virgatum-Shenandoah","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Can be grown in a variety of soils, but prefers snady loam soils in full to partial sun."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254228","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Erosion, Dry Soil, Wet Soil, Black Walnut, Urban Conditions","claim":true},{"name":"North Creek Nurseries","url":"https://www.northcreeknurseries.com/plantName/Panicum-virgatum-Shenandoah","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established, yet will tolerate wet, soggy soils for short periods.","claim":true},{"name":"New Moon Nursery","url":"https://newmoonnursery.com/nursery-plants/panicum-virgatum-shenandoah/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants tolerate clay, alkalinity, drought, moderate salinity and seasonal flooding.","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"switchgrass-red","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tamukeyama","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"6.00 to 8.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Slowly reaches 6 to 10 ft. tall, 10 to 12 ft. wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tamukeyama","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":3.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"horizon":{"years":15,"sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["the page states no maturity horizon for \"8.00 to 12.00 feet\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years","the page states no maturity horizon for \"Slowly reaches 6 to 10 ft. tall, 10 to 12 ft. wide.\", and this row's size is its size at 15 years"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row's size is its size at 15 years and they do not say which horizon they describe","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tamukeyama","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c564","country":"US","form":null,"value":"5 to 8","zones":[5,8]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tamukeyama","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=c564","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/tamukeyama-japanese-maple.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Filtered sun, Partial shade, Partial sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tamukeyama","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tamukeyama","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tamukeyama","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tamukeyama","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"teasing-georgia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[3.29,3.66],"union":[1.52,4.03],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/teasing-georgia-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Height: 12ft","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/teasing-georgia","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Size 5' - 12' x 4' - 5'","metres":[1.52,3.66],"band":[1.52,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/teasing-georgia%C2%AE","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Height : 12′","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/teasing-georgia-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Height: 12 feet","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/teasing-georgia-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Height: 12ft (3.75m)","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"regional-note","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"teasing-georgia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.82,1.52],"split":[{"range":[0.82,1],"sources":["Menagerie Farm & Flower"]},{"range":[1.22,1.52],"sources":["Heirloom Roses","Grace Rose Farm"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/teasing-georgia","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Size 5' - 12' x 4' - 5'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/teasing-georgia%C2%AE","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Width : 4-5′","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/teasing-georgia-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Spread: 3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"teasing-georgia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/teasing-georgia-climbing-rose","https://heirloomroses.com/products/teasing-georgia"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/teasing-georgia-climbing-rose","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/teasing-georgia%C2%AE"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/teasing-georgia-climbing-rose","https://menagerieflower.com/products/teasing-georgia-rose-david-austin"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/teasing-georgia-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/teasing-georgia","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zone 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/teasing-georgia%C2%AE","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Hardiness Zones : USDA Zones 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/teasing-georgia-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Suitable Zones: 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[5,11]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"teasing-georgia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/teasing-georgia-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/teasing-georgia-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/teasing-georgia","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Partial Shade or Full Sun Tolerates some shade, needing only 4+ hours of direct sun to thrive.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/teasing-georgia%C2%AE","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Light Requirements : Full Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"teasing-georgia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["medium","medium","strong","medium","strong"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/teasing-georgia-climbing-rose","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/teasing-georgia-climbing-rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/teasing-georgia-climbing-rose","https://heirloomroses.com/products/teasing-georgia"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/teasing-georgia-climbing-rose","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/teasing-georgia%C2%AE"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/teasing-georgia-climbing-rose","https://menagerieflower.com/products/teasing-georgia-rose-david-austin"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/teasing-georgia-climbing-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There is a lovely Tea Rose fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/teasing-georgia-climbing-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There is a lovely strong Tea Rose fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/teasing-georgia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Her cupped, 4-5\" flowers feature 50+ petals and emit a delightful and strong tea rose fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/teasing-georgia%C2%AE","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Each bloom releases a strong, classic tea-rose fragrance that wafts on the breeze.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/teasing-georgia-rose-david-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Strong - Tea","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"teasing-georgia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/teasing-georgia%C2%AE","https://menagerieflower.com/products/teasing-georgia-rose-david-austin"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/teasing-georgia%C2%AE","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vase Life : 3-5 days","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/teasing-georgia-rose-david-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Gorgeous long stems make this a beautiful climber and a wonderful cut flower with nice long stems.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"teasing-georgia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"teasing-georgia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tess-of-the-durbervilles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.3,"outcome":"DUAL-FORM","agreement":null,"forms":{"shrub":null,"climber":[1.22,2.75]},"catalogForm":"shrub","catalogFormAgreement":"unverified","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.18153.0","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"3' to 8' (90 to 245cm)","metres":[0.9,2.45],"band":[0.9,2.45],"role":"unstated-form"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/tess-of-the-d-urbervilles-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Height: 8ft","metres":2.44,"band":[2.2,2.68],"role":"other-form"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/tess-of-the-d-urbervilles-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Height: 8ft (2.5m)","metres":2.5,"band":[2.25,2.75],"role":"other-form"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/tess-of-the-durbervilles","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"4'-8'","metres":[1.22,2.44],"band":[1.22,2.44],"role":"other-form"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tess-of-the-d-ubervilles-%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"4-8'","metres":[1.22,2.44],"band":[1.22,2.44],"role":"other-form"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/tess-of-the-durbervilles-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"4-8 feet","metres":[1.22,2.44],"band":[1.22,2.44],"role":"other-form"}],"note":"no source in this record describes the shrub form the catalog holds; the pilot's verified dual-form register (PILOT-2026-07-28.md section 3) is what says David Austin sells this rose both ways; so the catalogued value is neither confirmed nor contradicted by anything here","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tess-of-the-durbervilles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.2,"outcome":"DUAL-FORM","agreement":null,"forms":{"shrub":null,"climber":[0.91,1.34]},"catalogForm":"shrub","catalogFormAgreement":"unverified","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.18153.0","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"42\" (105cm)","metres":1.05,"band":[0.95,1.16],"role":"unstated-form"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/tess-of-the-durbervilles","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"3'-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"other-form"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tess-of-the-d-ubervilles-%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"other-form"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/tess-of-the-durbervilles-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"other-form"}],"note":"no source in this record describes the shrub form the catalog holds; the pilot's verified dual-form register (PILOT-2026-07-28.md section 3) is what says David Austin sells this rose both ways; so the catalogued value is neither confirmed nor contradicted by anything here","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tess-of-the-durbervilles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-11","6-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/tess-of-the-d-urbervilles-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zones 4-11"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/tess-of-the-durbervilles","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"4-11"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tess-of-the-d-ubervilles-%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"4-11"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.18153.0","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"USDA zone 6b through 9b"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/tess-of-the-durbervilles-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"4-11"}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tess-of-the-durbervilles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/tess-of-the-d-urbervilles-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight; East, South, West Facing"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/tess-of-the-d-urbervilles-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight; East, South, West Facing"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tess-of-the-d-ubervilles-%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tess-of-the-durbervilles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/tess-of-the-d-urbervilles-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Medium, Old Rose"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/tess-of-the-d-urbervilles-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Medium strength, Old Rose type"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/tess-of-the-durbervilles","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Moderately fragrant, with old rose and fruity-myrrh character"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tess-of-the-d-ubervilles-%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Strong, old rose fragrance"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.18153.0","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Strong, old rose fragrance"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/tess-of-the-durbervilles-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Moderate - Old Rose"}],"note":"sources rate it medium/strong","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tess-of-the-durbervilles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/tess-of-the-durbervilles","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Long, sturdy stems suited for bouquets and floral arrangements"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tess-of-the-d-ubervilles-%E2%84%A2-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Vase Life: 4-6 days"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/tess-of-the-durbervilles-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"perfect rose for cutting nice long stems"}],"note":"3 sources state it but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tess-of-the-durbervilles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.thornless","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.18153.0","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Short, armed with thorns / prickles, bushy","polarity":"has-thorns"}],"note":"no source describes reduced thorniness; 1 source(s) mention thorns or prickles as present","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-alnwick-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.34],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/the-alnwick-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4' x 3'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/the-alnwick-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/the-alnwick-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/the-alnwick-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mature Height 3-4 Feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-alnwick-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.9,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.61,1],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/the-alnwick-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Size 4' x 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/the-alnwick-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/the-alnwick-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Spread: 3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/the-alnwick-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mature Spread 2-3 Feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-alnwick-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-11","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/the-alnwick-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 4-11","zones":[4,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/the-alnwick-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Hardiness Zones: 5-10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/the-alnwick-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable Zones: 4-11","zones":[4,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/the-alnwick-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"USDA Hardiness Zones 5 to 10","zones":[5,10],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":5},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-alnwick-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/the-alnwick-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sun Requires 6+ hours of direct sunlight to thrive.","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/the-alnwick-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light Requirements: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/the-alnwick-rose","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light Exposure Full Sun","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-alnwick-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["medium","medium","medium","medium"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/the-alnwick-rose","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/the-alnwick-rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/the-alnwick-rose","https://menagerieflower.com/products/the-alnwick-rose-david-austin"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/the-alnwick-rose","https://plantaddicts.com/the-alnwick-rose"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://heirloomroses.com/products/the-alnwick-rose","https://angelgardens.com/rose/the-alnwick-rose/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/the-alnwick-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"She is moderately fragrant with a blend of old rose fragrance and a hint of summer raspberry.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/the-alnwick-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Medium-strong, Old rose","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/the-alnwick-rose-david-austin","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: Moderate-Strong, Old Rose","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/the-alnwick-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Angel Gardens","url":"https://angelgardens.com/rose/the-alnwick-rose/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Moderate, old rose, opinions vary fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-alnwick-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/the-alnwick-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features Cut Flowers","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-alnwick-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-alnwick-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/the-alnwick-rose","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-generous-gardener","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[4,8],"split":[{"range":[4,8],"sources":["David Austin Roses (US) - English Climbing Rose page","Grace Rose Farm - David Austin The Generous Gardener Potted Climbing Rose","Menagerie Farm & Flower - The Generous Gardener David Austin Potted Climbing Rose","RHS - Rosa The Generous Gardener ('Ausdrawn' PBR) (Cl)"]},{"range":[1.5,4.5],"sources":["HelpMeFind Roses - 'The Generous Gardener' (AUSdrawn)"]}],"splitKind":"form-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Climbing Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-generous-gardener-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Height: 15ft","metres":4.57,"band":[4.11,5.03],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm - David Austin The Generous Gardener Potted Climbing Rose","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-the-generous-gardener%C2%AE-potted-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"15'","metres":4.57,"band":[4.11,5.03],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower - The Generous Gardener David Austin Potted Climbing Rose","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/the-generous-gardener-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"15 feet","metres":4.57,"band":[4.11,5.03],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS - Rosa The Generous Gardener ('Ausdrawn' PBR) (Cl)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/196207/rosa-the-generous-gardener-(-ausdrawn-pbr)-(cl)/details","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Ultimate height 4-8 metres","metres":[4,8],"band":[4,8],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - The Generous Gardener, English Climbing Rose","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/the-generous-gardener-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"15ft (4.5m)","metres":4.5,"band":[4.05,4.95],"role":"regional-note"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses - 'The Generous Gardener' (AUSdrawn)","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.37005.0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4'11\" to 14 3/4' (150 to 450cm)","metres":[1.5,4.5],"band":[1.5,4.5],"role":"other-form"}],"note":"the climber sources put this at 4 to 8 m and the catalogued value sits outside that, but 1 source(s) describing the other trained form do cover it, so the number is not proposed","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-generous-gardener","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.91,4],"split":[{"range":[0.91,1.22],"sources":["Grace Rose Farm - David Austin The Generous Gardener Potted Climbing Rose"]},{"range":[2.5,4],"sources":["RHS - Rosa The Generous Gardener ('Ausdrawn' PBR) (Cl)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Grace Rose Farm - David Austin The Generous Gardener Potted Climbing Rose","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-the-generous-gardener%C2%AE-potted-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"RHS - Rosa The Generous Gardener ('Ausdrawn' PBR) (Cl)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/196207/rosa-the-generous-gardener-(-ausdrawn-pbr)-(cl)/details","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Ultimate spread 2.5-4 metres","metres":[2.5,4],"band":[2.5,4],"role":"scored"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses - 'The Generous Gardener' (AUSdrawn)","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.37005.0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4' (120cm)","metres":1.2,"band":[1.08,1.32],"role":"other-form"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-generous-gardener","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-11","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Climbing Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-generous-gardener-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zones 4-11"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses - 'The Generous Gardener' (AUSdrawn)","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.37005.0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"USDA zone 5b through 9b"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm - David Austin The Generous Gardener Potted Climbing Rose","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-the-generous-gardener%C2%AE-potted-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"4-11"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower - The Generous Gardener David Austin Potted Climbing Rose","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/the-generous-gardener-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Suitable Zones: 4-11"}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-generous-gardener","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Climbing Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-generous-gardener-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight / Partial Shade; North, East, South, West Facing"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - The Generous Gardener, English Climbing Rose","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/the-generous-gardener-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight / Partial Shade; North, East, South, West Facing"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm - David Austin The Generous Gardener Potted Climbing Rose","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-the-generous-gardener%C2%AE-potted-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sun to Partial Sun"},{"name":"RHS - Rosa The Generous Gardener ('Ausdrawn' PBR) (Cl)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/196207/rosa-the-generous-gardener-(-ausdrawn-pbr)-(cl)/details","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Full sun, Partial shade; North-facing or South-facing or West-facing or East-facing"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-generous-gardener","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Climbing Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-generous-gardener-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Strong, Old Rose/musk/myrrh"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - The Generous Gardener, English Climbing Rose","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/the-generous-gardener-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Strong, Old Rose/musk/myrrh"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses - 'The Generous Gardener' (AUSdrawn)","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.37005.0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Strong, musk, myrrh, old rose fragrance"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm - David Austin The Generous Gardener Potted Climbing Rose","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-the-generous-gardener%C2%AE-potted-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Medium to Strong, Myrrh, Musk, Old Rose"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower - The Generous Gardener David Austin Potted Climbing Rose","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/the-generous-gardener-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Strong - Old Rose, Musk & Myrrh"},{"name":"RHS - Rosa The Generous Gardener ('Ausdrawn' PBR) (Cl)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/196207/rosa-the-generous-gardener-(-ausdrawn-pbr)-(cl)/details","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Strongly scented"}],"note":"sources rate it strong","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-generous-gardener","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses - 'The Generous Gardener' (AUSdrawn)","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.37005.0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Can be used for cut flower, garden, landscape or shrub"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm - David Austin The Generous Gardener Potted Climbing Rose","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-the-generous-gardener%C2%AE-potted-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Vase Life: 3-5 days"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower - The Generous Gardener David Austin Potted Climbing Rose","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/the-generous-gardener-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"it's great for cutting and enjoying inside your home"}],"note":"3 sources state it but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-lady-gardener","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.23,1.34],"union":[1.1,1.51],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-lady-gardener","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4 1/2ft","metres":1.37,"band":[1.23,1.51],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-the-lady-gardener-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"~4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/the-lady-gardener-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/the-lady-gardener","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"4ft (125cm)","metres":1.25,"band":[1.13,1.38],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-lady-gardener","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.68,1.34],"split":[{"range":[0.68,1],"sources":["Grace Rose Farm","Menagerie Farm & Flower"]},{"range":[1.1,1.34],"sources":["David Austin Roses (US)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-lady-gardener","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-the-lady-gardener-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"~2.5'","metres":0.76,"band":[0.68,0.84],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/the-lady-gardener-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"3 feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/the-lady-gardener","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"4ft (125cm)","metres":1.25,"band":[1.13,1.38],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-lady-gardener","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-lady-gardener","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zones 5-11"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-the-lady-gardener-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"USDA Zones 5-11"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/the-lady-gardener-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable Zones: 5-10"}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-lady-gardener","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-lady-gardener","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/the-lady-gardener","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"East, South, West Facing; Full Sunlight"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-the-lady-gardener-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full sun to partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-lady-gardener","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-lady-gardener","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Medium, Tea - with hints of cedar wood and vanilla"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/the-lady-gardener","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Medium, Tea - with hints of cedar wood and vanilla"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-the-lady-gardener-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Strong - tea rose with cedar-vanilla undertones"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/the-lady-gardener-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Strong - Tea"}],"note":"sources rate it medium/strong","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-lady-gardener","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-lady-gardener","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Cutting (listed among the page's suitability icons)"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-the-lady-gardener-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Very good - elegant clusters suit cutting gardens"}],"note":"2 sources state it but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-pilgrim","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.3,"outcome":"DUAL-FORM","agreement":null,"forms":{"shrub":[1.1,1.34],"climber":[2.44,4.03]},"catalogForm":"shrub","catalogFormAgreement":"full","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-the-pilgrim-auswalker/common-name/the-pilgrim/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"\"vigorous bushy rose will grow quickly to a 4-foot shrub\"","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-pilgrim","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"12ft","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"other-form"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/the-pilgrim-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"12ft (3.75m)","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"other-form"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/the-pilgrim","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"8' - 12'","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"other-form"}],"note":"sources describe this rose in both trained forms at different sizes and the catalog holds the shrub; 1 shrub source(s) put the catalogued value inside their range, so the finding is the climbing form the schema cannot hold","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-pilgrim","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-the-pilgrim-auswalker/common-name/the-pilgrim/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"1 ft. 0 in. - 5 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,1.52],"band":[0.3,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/the-pilgrim","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"5'","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"other-form"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) describe the shrub form this catalog row holds","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-pilgrim","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-pilgrim","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zones 5-11"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/the-pilgrim","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zone 5-11"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-the-pilgrim-auswalker/common-name/the-pilgrim/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b"}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-pilgrim","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-pilgrim","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"\"Full Sunlight\" and \"Partial Shade\" both listed; \"North, East, South, West Facing\""},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/the-pilgrim-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"\"Full Sunlight\" and \"Partial Shade\"; \"North, East, South, West Facing\""},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/the-pilgrim","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Partial Shade or Full Sun; needs \"only 4+ hours of direct sun to thrive\""},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-the-pilgrim-auswalker/common-name/the-pilgrim/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"\"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)\" or \"Partial Shade\"; \"tolerates shade, but flowers best with full sun\""}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-pilgrim","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-pilgrim","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Medium,Tea/myrrh"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/the-pilgrim-climbing-rose","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Medium,Tea/myrrh"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/the-pilgrim","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Exceptionally Fragrant; scent described as \"tea and myrrh\""}],"note":"sources rate it medium/strong","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-pilgrim","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/the-pilgrim","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"makes an excellent cut flower for arrangements"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-the-pilgrim-auswalker/common-name/the-pilgrim/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"\"Good Cut\" value; blooms \"usually grow in small clusters to use as cut flowers\""}],"note":"2 sources state it but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-pilgrim","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.thornless","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-the-pilgrim-auswalker/common-name/the-pilgrim/","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"stems have \"prickles\"","polarity":"has-thorns"}],"note":"no source describes reduced thorniness; 1 source(s) mention thorns or prickles as present","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-poets-wife","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.91,2.01],"split":[{"range":[0.91,1.34],"sources":["Grace Rose Farm - David Austin The Poet's Wife Potted Tree Rose","David Austin Roses (US) - English Shrub Rose page","Menagerie Farm & Flower - The Poet's Wife David Austin Bare Root Rose","Wildwood Outdoor Living - The Poet's Wife | Shrub | David Austin Rose"]},{"range":[1.65,2.01],"sources":["David Austin Roses (US) - English Standard Tree Rose page"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Shrub Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-poet-s-wife","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Height: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Standard Tree Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-poets-wife","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Height: 6ft","metres":1.83,"band":[1.65,2.01],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower - The Poet's Wife David Austin Bare Root Rose","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/the-poets-wife-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Wildwood Outdoor Living - The Poet's Wife | Shrub | David Austin Rose","url":"https://wildwood.express/products/da-the-poets-wife","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm - David Austin The Poet's Wife Potted Tree Rose","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-the-poets-wife-potted-tree-rose","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"3' - 4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - The Poet's Wife","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/the-poet-s-wife","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"3 1/2ft (110cm)","metres":1.1,"band":[0.99,1.21],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-poets-wife","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.1,1.18],"union":[0.91,1.34],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Shrub Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-poet-s-wife","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Width: 4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower - The Poet's Wife David Austin Bare Root Rose","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/the-poets-wife-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4 feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Wildwood Outdoor Living - The Poet's Wife | Shrub | David Austin Rose","url":"https://wildwood.express/products/da-the-poets-wife","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"3.5ft","metres":1.07,"band":[0.96,1.18],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm - David Austin The Poet's Wife Potted Tree Rose","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-the-poets-wife-potted-tree-rose","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"3' - 4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - The Poet's Wife","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/the-poet-s-wife","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"3 1/2ft (110cm)","metres":1.1,"band":[0.99,1.21],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-poets-wife","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Shrub Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-poet-s-wife","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 5-11"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower - The Poet's Wife David Austin Bare Root Rose","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/the-poets-wife-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable Zones: 5-11"},{"name":"Wildwood Outdoor Living - The Poet's Wife | Shrub | David Austin Rose","url":"https://wildwood.express/products/da-the-poets-wife","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: 5-10"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm - David Austin The Poet's Wife Potted Tree Rose","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-the-poets-wife-potted-tree-rose","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 5 - 11"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Standard Tree Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-poets-wife","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Zones 5-11"}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-poets-wife","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Shrub Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-poet-s-wife","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight / Partial Shade; North, East, South, West Facing"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - The Poet's Wife","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/the-poet-s-wife","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Full sunlight, partial shade; north/east/south/west facing"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm - David Austin The Poet's Wife Potted Tree Rose","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/david-austin%C2%AE-the-poets-wife-potted-tree-rose","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Standard Tree Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-poets-wife","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Full sunlight and partial shade; north, east, south and west facing"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-poets-wife","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Shrub Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-poet-s-wife","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Strength: Strong; Type: Fruity - 'a strong, wonderfully rich fragrance with a hint of lemon'"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - The Poet's Wife","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/the-poet-s-wife","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Strong, Fruity - 'a strong, wonderfully rich fragrance with a hint of lemon'"},{"name":"Menagerie Farm & Flower - The Poet's Wife David Austin Bare Root Rose","url":"https://menagerieflower.com/products/the-poets-wife-bare-root-rose-david-austin","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Strong - Fruit; 'hints of lemon that intensify as the rose matures'"},{"name":"Wildwood Outdoor Living - The Poet's Wife | Shrub | David Austin Rose","url":"https://wildwood.express/products/da-the-poets-wife","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Very Strong Fragrance; 'rich fragrance with strong lemon tints at first, becoming sweeter and stronger with age'"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Standard Tree Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-poets-wife","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Strong, Fruity, with a hint of lemon"}],"note":"sources rate it strong","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"the-poets-wife","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":2,"why":"both publish as david-austin-roses","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-poet-s-wife","https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/the-poet-s-wife"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Shrub Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/the-poet-s-wife","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Listed under location uses as 'Cutting'"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK) - The Poet's Wife","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/the-poet-s-wife","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Listed under 'Cutting' in location recommendations"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as david-austin-roses. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"thyme","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.15,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.27,0.3],"union":[0.15,0.33],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281450","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.50 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thymus-vulgaris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Penn State Extension (Herb Garden Plants: Thyme, Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/herb-garden-plants-thyme","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height and Width: Height 12 inches; width 10 to 12 inches.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Herb Gardening: Thyme, Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/herbs/thyme","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Thyme is a low growing (6-12 inches tall) to almost prostrate, wiry stemmed perennial.","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Thyme, Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/thyme","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Thyme is a low-growing, wiry-stemmed perennial that reaches about 6-10” in height.","metres":[0.15,0.25],"band":[0.15,0.25],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (thyme growing guide)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/herbs/thyme/grow-your-own","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Some form small mounded shrubs up to 30cm (1ft) tall","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"thyme","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.25,0.3],"union":[0.15,0.41],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281450","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.50 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thymus-vulgaris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 4 in.","metres":[0.15,0.41],"band":[0.15,0.41],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Penn State Extension (Herb Garden Plants: Thyme, Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/herb-garden-plants-thyme","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height and Width: Height 12 inches; width 10 to 12 inches.","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"thyme","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","4-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281450","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thymus-vulgaris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Thymus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thymus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Penn State Extension (Herb Garden Plants: Thyme, Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/herb-garden-plants-thyme","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Type and Hardiness: Perennial; USDA Plant Hardiness Zones 5 to 9.","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Thymus serpyllum, creeping thyme)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281448","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thymus serpyllum, creeping thyme)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thymus-serpyllum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"thyme","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281450","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thymus-vulgaris/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Thymus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thymus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Penn State Extension (Herb Garden Plants: Thyme, Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/herb-garden-plants-thyme","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light and Soil: Full sun to partial shade; light, dry, well-drained soil with a pH of 6.3."},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Herb Gardening: Thyme, Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/herbs/thyme","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Thyme prefers a full sun location in soil that is well amended with organic matter and well drained."},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (thyme growing guide)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/herbs/thyme/grow-your-own","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Thyme thrives in full sun and free-draining conditions, in the ground or in containers."},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Herbs, Thymus species)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/herbs/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant thyme in full sun in very well drained soil that stays dry."},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Thymus serpyllum, creeping thyme)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281448","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thymus serpyllum, creeping thyme)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thymus-serpyllum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"thyme","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281450","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaves are highly aromatic (reaching their peak just before plants flower)","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thymus-vulgaris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Edible Fragrant Good Cut Good Dried","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Thymus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thymus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The leaves are tiny, fragrant, and their colors vary from green to silver, depending on the species.","claim":true},{"name":"Penn State Extension (Herb Garden Plants: Thyme, Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/herb-garden-plants-thyme","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The dried flowers and leaves scent potpourris and sachets.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension (Herb Gardening: Thyme, Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/herbs/thyme","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Thyme is highly aromatic with a hint of clove and mint fragrance.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension Home and Garden Information Center (Thyme, Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/thyme","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The lilac flowers are borne in small clusters and leaves are very aromatic.","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (thyme growing guide)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/herbs/thyme/grow-your-own","country":null,"form":null,"value":"the aromatic leaves can be harvested all year round","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Thymus serpyllum, creeping thyme)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281448","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thymus serpyllum, creeping thyme)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thymus-serpyllum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"thyme","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thymus-vulgaris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Edible Fragrant Good Cut Good Dried","claim":true},{"name":"Penn State Extension (Herb Garden Plants: Thyme, Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/herb-garden-plants-thyme","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is used in wreaths and floral arrangements.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"thyme","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281450","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant. Dislikes wet soils where it tends to rot.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thymus-vulgaris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Thymus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thymus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Dry Soil","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (thyme growing guide)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/herbs/thyme/grow-your-own","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Thyme is drought tolerant and rarely needs watering, except when newly planted or when growing in containers in hot, dry weather.","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Thymus serpyllum, creeping thyme)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281448","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates drought.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thymus serpyllum, creeping thyme)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thymus-serpyllum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Dry Soil Poor Soil Rabbits","claim":true}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"thyme","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281450","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to bees.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thymus-vulgaris/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Nectar from the flowers attracts bees and butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Thymus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thymus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The nectar of the flowers attracts bees and butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"Penn State Extension (Herb Garden Plants: Thyme, Thymus vulgaris)","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/herb-garden-plants-thyme","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Left to flower, thyme will produce an abundance of small flowers and attract numerous small pollinators, including many species of native bees and parasitoid wasps.","claim":true},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (thyme growing guide)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/herbs/thyme/grow-your-own","country":null,"form":null,"value":"providing a feast for bees and other pollinating insects","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Thymus serpyllum, creeping thyme)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281448","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to bees.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Thymus serpyllum, creeping thyme)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/thymus-serpyllum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"7 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tiamo-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.6,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.43,1.85],"split":[{"range":[0.43,0.53],"sources":["FreePatentsOnline, US Plant Patent PP30,142"]},{"range":[1.08,1.32],"sources":["W. Kordes' Soehne (rosen.de, the breeder's German page)","W. Kordes' Soehne (rosen.de, the same page in English)"]},{"range":[1.37,1.85],"sources":["Grace Rose Farm","Witherspoon Rose Culture","Star Roses and Plants / Bloomables (the US introducer)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"W. Kordes' Soehne (rosen.de, the breeder's German page)","url":"https://www.rosen.de/gartenrosen/rosentypen/edelrosen/tiamo","country":"DE","form":null,"value":"Wuchshöhe: 120 cm","metres":1.2,"band":[1.08,1.32],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"W. Kordes' Soehne (rosen.de, the same page in English)","url":"https://www.rosen.de/en/garden-roses/delivery-type/plant-o-fix/tiamo","country":"DE","form":null,"value":"natural height: 120 cm","metres":1.2,"band":[1.08,1.32],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Star Roses and Plants / Bloomables (the US introducer)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/tiamo/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size/Habit Upright, Bushy, 5–5½' h x 2–3' w","metres":[1.52,1.68],"band":[1.52,1.68],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tiamo-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: ~5 ft (150 cm)","metres":1.52,"band":[1.37,1.67],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Witherspoon Rose Culture","url":"https://witherspoonrose.com/products/tiamo","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5½' h x 2–3' w","metres":1.68,"band":[1.51,1.85],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"FreePatentsOnline, US Plant Patent PP30,142","url":"https://www.freepatentsonline.com/PP30142.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height .-Commonly near 48.0 cm, measured from the top of the soil plane.","metres":0.48,"band":[0.43,0.53],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 3 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tiamo-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.76,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.43,0.91],"split":[{"range":[0.43,0.55],"sources":["FreePatentsOnline, US Plant Patent PP30,142","W. Kordes' Soehne (rosen.de, the breeder's German page)","W. Kordes' Soehne (rosen.de, the same page in English)"]},{"range":[0.61,0.91],"sources":["Star Roses and Plants / Bloomables (the US introducer)","Grace Rose Farm","Witherspoon Rose Culture"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"W. Kordes' Soehne (rosen.de, the breeder's German page)","url":"https://www.rosen.de/gartenrosen/rosentypen/edelrosen/tiamo","country":"DE","form":null,"value":"Wuchsbreite: 50 cm","metres":0.5,"band":[0.45,0.55],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"W. Kordes' Soehne (rosen.de, the same page in English)","url":"https://www.rosen.de/en/garden-roses/delivery-type/plant-o-fix/tiamo","country":"DE","form":null,"value":"natural width: 50 cm","metres":0.5,"band":[0.45,0.55],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Star Roses and Plants / Bloomables (the US introducer)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/tiamo/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size/Habit Upright, Bushy, 5–5½' h x 2–3' w","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tiamo-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: ~2–3 ft (60–90 cm)","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Witherspoon Rose Culture","url":"https://witherspoonrose.com/products/tiamo","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 5½' h x 2–3' w","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"FreePatentsOnline, US Plant Patent PP30,142","url":"https://www.freepatentsonline.com/PP30142.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width .-Commonly near 48.0 cm.","metres":0.48,"band":[0.43,0.53],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tiamo-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.bloomables.com/plants/tiamo/","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tiamo-potted-rose-bush"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.bloomables.com/plants/tiamo/","https://witherspoonrose.com/products/tiamo"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Star Roses and Plants / Bloomables (the US introducer)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/tiamo/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 5–11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tiamo-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: USDA Zones 5–11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Witherspoon Rose Culture","url":"https://witherspoonrose.com/products/tiamo","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy to Zone: 5-11","zones":[5,11],"level":"cultivar"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"cultivar":6},"reasons":[]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tiamo-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Star Roses and Plants / Bloomables (the US introducer)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/tiamo/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Full Sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tiamo-potted-rose-bush","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Witherspoon Rose Culture","url":"https://witherspoonrose.com/products/tiamo","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Requirements: Full Sun 6+ Hours","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tiamo-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"strengths":["light","light","light"],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.bloomables.com/plants/tiamo/","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tiamo-potted-rose-bush"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.bloomables.com/plants/tiamo/","https://www.freepatentsonline.com/PP30142.html"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Star Roses and Plants / Bloomables (the US introducer)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/tiamo/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It has high disease resistance, wonderful repeat blooming, and a lovely mild fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tiamo-potted-rose-bush","country":null,"form":null,"value":"with a mild fragrance that sweetens the air","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"FreePatentsOnline, US Plant Patent PP30,142","url":"https://www.freepatentsonline.com/PP30142.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrance: very light sweet fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tiamo-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are rosen.de","urls":["https://www.rosen.de/gartenrosen/rosentypen/edelrosen/tiamo","https://www.rosen.de/en/garden-roses/delivery-type/plant-o-fix/tiamo"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.rosen.de/gartenrosen/rosentypen/edelrosen/tiamo","https://www.bloomables.com/plants/tiamo/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"W. Kordes' Soehne (rosen.de, the breeder's German page)","url":"https://www.rosen.de/gartenrosen/rosentypen/edelrosen/tiamo","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Für Vasenschnitt geeignet , Hitzefest","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"W. Kordes' Soehne (rosen.de, the same page in English)","url":"https://www.rosen.de/en/garden-roses/delivery-type/plant-o-fix/tiamo","country":null,"form":null,"value":"heat resistant , well for cutting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"Star Roses and Plants / Bloomables (the US introducer)","url":"https://www.bloomables.com/plants/tiamo/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Use For Cutting & Bringing Inside","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are rosen.de; two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tiamo-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tiamo-rose","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"torenia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.25,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":9,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.50 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant Height : 6 to 12 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The second type of wishbone flower ( Torenia fournieri ) is a compact plant with a very different habit. These grow to 6 to 8 inches tall and 8 inches wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"It reaches a height of 18 inches.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"It is a compact plant 6 to 12 in. high, and its flower color ranges from white to blue.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plants are 6 to 12 inches tall with bright green leaves.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height/spread: 8 to 16 inches tall and 8 to 10 inches wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height 1-3 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"torenia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":9,"genus":1},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 0 ft. 8 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.50 to 0.75 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Plant Width : 6 to 12 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"These grow to 6 to 8 inches tall and 8 inches wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"8 to 16 inches tall and 8 to 10 inches wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread Under 1 foot\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"torenia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["2-11","10-11","9-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Torenia fournieri)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287006&isprofile=0&basic=Torenia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11],"level":"species","taxon":"torenia fournieri"},{"name":"Garden Design, How to Grow & Care for Wishbone Flower (Torenia)","url":"https://www.gardendesign.com/annuals/torenia.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: Usually grown as an annual, may overwinter in Zones 10-11","zones":[10,11],"level":"species","taxon":"torenia fournieri"},{"name":"The Old Farmer's Almanac, How to Grow Wishbone Flowers","url":"https://www.almanac.com/plant/wishbone-flowers","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 9a 9b 10a 10b","zones":[9,10],"level":"species","taxon":"torenia fournieri"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":9,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"torenia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Torenia fournieri)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/torenia-fournieri/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"torenia fournieri"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Torenia fournieri)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287006&isprofile=0&basic=Torenia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"torenia fournieri"},{"name":"Fine Gardening Plant Guide (Torenia fournieri, wishbone flower)","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/wishbone-flower-torenia-fournieri","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"torenia fournieri"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Wishbone Flower)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/wishbone-flower/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"In mid to late April, after the last frost, plant them outdoors in part to full shade.","level":"species","taxon":"torenia fournieri"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions (Torenia)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/torenia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They will perform best when planted in partial shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"torenia"},{"name":"Garden Design, How to Grow & Care for Wishbone Flower (Torenia)","url":"https://www.gardendesign.com/annuals/torenia.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Partial shade to full shade","level":"species","taxon":"torenia fournieri"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"torenia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"torenia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Garden Design, How to Grow & Care for Wishbone Flower (Torenia)","url":"https://www.gardendesign.com/annuals/torenia.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good for cut flower arrangements","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"torenia fournieri"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"torenia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"torenia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Wishbone Flower)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/wishbone-flower/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Small carpenter bees can fit inside a wishbone flower","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"torenia fournieri"},{"name":"Garden Design, How to Grow & Care for Wishbone Flower (Torenia)","url":"https://www.gardendesign.com/annuals/torenia.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"torenia fournieri"},{"name":"The Old Farmer's Almanac, How to Grow Wishbone Flowers","url":"https://www.almanac.com/plant/wishbone-flowers","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds Attracts Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"torenia fournieri"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"torenia-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.25,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"8\" (20cm)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"will grow to be about 8 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 10 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"torenia-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":10,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"8\" (20cm)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"will grow to be about 8 inches tall at maturity, with a spread of 10 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 10, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"torenia-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[10,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"torenia-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"PanAmerican Seed (breeder)","url":"https://www.panamseed.com/plant_info.aspx?phid=062106294004669","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Shade, Partial Sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"torenia-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"torenia-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"torenia-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"torenia-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tranquillity","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[1.22,1.32],"union":[1.08,1.52],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/tranquillity","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tranquility","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4-5'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.67031.0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"up to 47\" (up to 120cm)","metres":1.2,"band":[1.08,1.32],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/tranquillity","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"4ft (125cm)","metres":1.25,"band":[1.13,1.38],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tranquillity","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.81,1.52],"split":[{"range":[0.81,0.99],"sources":["HelpMeFind Roses"]},{"range":[1.1,1.52],"sources":["David Austin Roses (US)","Grace Rose Farm"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/tranquillity","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tranquility","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4-5'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.67031.0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"up to 35\" (up to 90cm)","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/tranquillity","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"4ft (125cm)","metres":1.25,"band":[1.13,1.38],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tranquillity","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/tranquillity","https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tranquility"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/tranquillity","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zones 5-11"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tranquility","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"5-11"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[5,11]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tranquillity","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/tranquillity","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight; East, South, West Facing"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/tranquillity","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight; East, South, West Facing"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tranquility","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sun to Partial Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tranquillity","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/tranquillity","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light, Fruity"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/tranquillity","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Light, Fruity"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tranquility","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Light apple/apple-blossom fragrance"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.67031.0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Mild, apple fragrance"}],"note":"sources rate it light","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tranquillity","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/tranquillity","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Listed under Location as suitable for \"Cutting\""},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/tranquillity","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Listed under Location as suitable for \"Cutting\""},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tranquility","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Vase Life: 4-6 days"}],"note":"3 sources state it but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tranquillity","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.thornless","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/tranquility","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Nearly thornless","polarity":"thornless"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.67031.0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"few or no prickles/thorns","polarity":"thornless"}],"note":"2 sources describe reduced thorniness (2 of them call it thornless) but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":5,"cultivar":2,"genus":2},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 4 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 4.00 to 10.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"is usually 5- to 10-feet tall in Phoenix\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Shrub that grows from six to fifteen feet tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":5,"cultivar":2,"genus":2},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 5 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 5.00 to 8.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hibiscus rosa-sinensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-rosa-sinensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[9,11],"level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus rosa-sinensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hibiscus rosa-sinensis)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282563&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 9 to 11","zones":[9,11],"level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus rosa-sinensis"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Chris Martin plant library (Hibiscus rosa-sinensis)","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/hibiscusrosasinensis.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA 9 (with occasional winter protection), 10-11","zones":[9,11],"level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus rosa-sinensis"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":5,"cultivar":2,"genus":2},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hibiscus rosa-sinensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-rosa-sinensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus rosa-sinensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hibiscus rosa-sinensis)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282563&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus rosa-sinensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hibiscus rosa-sinensis 'Persimmon')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263257&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"hibiscus rosa-sinensis"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Chris Martin plant library (Hibiscus rosa-sinensis)","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/hibiscusrosasinensis.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun in cooler climates, partial sun in Phoenix with limited to no western exposure.","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus rosa-sinensis"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Hibiscus)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hibiscus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They prefer rich, well-drained soil with plenty of organic matter and full sun or light afternoon shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"hibiscus"},{"name":"University of North Florida Botanical Garden (Hibiscus rosa-sinensis)","url":"https://www.unf.edu/botanical-garden/plants/hibiscus-rosa-sinensis.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: full sun to part sun","level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus rosa-sinensis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"University of North Florida Botanical Garden (Hibiscus rosa-sinensis)","url":"https://www.unf.edu/botanical-garden/plants/hibiscus-rosa-sinensis.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water: average moisture, somewhat drought tolerant once established","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus rosa-sinensis"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hibiscus rosa-sinensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-rosa-sinensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus rosa-sinensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hibiscus rosa-sinensis)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282563&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hibiscus rosa-sinensis"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Hibiscus)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/hibiscus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are also highly attractive to butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hibiscus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions (Hibiscus)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/hibiscus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Hummingbirds are attracted by hibiscus; many types of butterflies are as well, including cloudless sulfurs, blues and Gulf fritillaries.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hibiscus"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["hibiscus rosa-sinensis"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (hibiscus rosa-sinensis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (hibiscus rosa-sinensis) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-fiesta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"6 to 8 ft. tall\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"7-8 ft.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-fiesta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"6 ft. wide\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"6 ft.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-fiesta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/fiesta-hibiscus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"9-11 outdoors","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-fiesta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.monrovia.com/fiesta-hibiscus.html","https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/fiesta-hibiscus"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/fiesta-hibiscus.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/fiesta-hibiscus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-fiesta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-fiesta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-fiesta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-fiesta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-hula-girl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"reaches 6 to 8 ft. tall, 3 to 4 ft. wide\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"6 - 8 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-hula-girl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"reaches 6 to 8 ft. tall, 3 to 4 ft. wide\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"3 - 4 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-hula-girl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-11","9-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/hula-girl-hibiscus.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10-11","zones":[10,11]},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/hibiscus-rosa-sinensis-hula-girl/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 9 - 11","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-hula-girl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.monrovia.com/hula-girl-hibiscus.html","https://devilmountainnursery.com/hibiscus-rosa-sinensis-hula-girl/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/hula-girl-hibiscus.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Devil Mountain Wholesale Nursery","url":"https://devilmountainnursery.com/hibiscus-rosa-sinensis-hula-girl/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-hula-girl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-hula-girl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/hula-girl-hibiscus.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers for Cutting","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-hula-girl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-hula-girl","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/hula-girl-hibiscus.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 4 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"4.00 to 10.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 5 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"5.00 to 8.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282563&isprofile=0&basic=Hibiscus%20rosa-sinensis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"9 to 11","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-rosa-sinensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282563&isprofile=0&basic=Hibiscus%20rosa-sinensis","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-rosa-sinensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282563&isprofile=0&basic=Hibiscus%20rosa-sinensis","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-peach","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"4.00 to 10.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"4 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-peach","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"5.00 to 8.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"5 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-peach","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b557","country":"US","form":null,"value":"9 to 11","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-rosa-sinensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-peach","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b557","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-rosa-sinensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-peach","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-peach","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-peach","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-peach","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b557","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-president","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"5 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-president","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"4 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-president","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282563","country":"US","form":null,"value":"9 to 11","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-president","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282563","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-president","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-president","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-president","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-president","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 4.00 to 10.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 4 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Hibiscus rosa-sinensis is an evergreen Shrub growing to 2.5 m (8ft) by 2.5 m (8ft) at a fast rate.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Shrub","sourcesDropped":3,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 5.00 to 8.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 5 ft. 0 in. - 8 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Hibiscus rosa-sinensis is an evergreen Shrub growing to 2.5 m (8ft) by 2.5 m (8ft) at a fast rate.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282563","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 9 to 11","zones":[9,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-rosa-sinensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282563","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-rosa-sinensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tropical-hibiscus-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282563","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hibiscus-rosa-sinensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its large funnel-shaped flowers bloom in summer and are an attractant for specialized bees and pollinators.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":8,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[7.62,18.29],"split":[{"range":[7.62,13.2],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Campsis radicans)","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Campsis radicans)","Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Campsis radicans)","Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Campsis radicans)","University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Trumpet Creeper)","Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Campsis radicans)","Plants For A Future (Campsis radicans)"]},{"range":[15.24,18.29],"sources":["Florida Native Plant Society (Campsis radicans)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/campsis-radicans/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 30 ft. 0 in. - 40 ft. 0 in.","metres":[9.14,12.19],"band":[9.14,12.19],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b840","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 25.00 to 40.00 feet","metres":[7.62,12.19],"band":[7.62,12.19],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Trumpet Creeper)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=507&PlantTypeID=5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 35 Feet","metres":10.67,"band":[9.6,11.74],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21175/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Height: 30-40 feet","metres":[9.14,12.19],"band":[9.14,12.19],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CARA2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"A high-climbing, aggressively colonizing woody vine to 35 ft.","metres":10.67,"band":[9.6,11.74],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/campsis-radicans","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Deciduous vine, 30-40 ft (9-12 m), rampant vigor.","metres":[9.14,12.19],"band":[9.14,12.19],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Plants For A Future (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Campsis+radicans","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Campsis radicans is a deciduous Climber growing to 12 m (39ft 4in) at a fast rate.","metres":12,"band":[10.8,13.2],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Florida Native Plant Society (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://www.fnps.org/plant/campsis-radicans","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size: Climbing-50-60 ft.","metres":[15.24,18.29],"band":[15.24,18.29],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1.22,13.41],"split":[{"range":[1.22,3.05],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Campsis radicans)","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Campsis radicans)"]},{"range":[10.97,13.41],"sources":["Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Campsis radicans)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/campsis-radicans/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 4 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,3.05],"band":[1.22,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b840","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 5.00 to 10.00 feet","metres":[1.52,3.05],"band":[1.52,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21175/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Spread: 40+ feet","metres":12.19,"band":[10.97,13.41],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-10","4-9","5-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/campsis-radicans/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[4,10],"level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b840","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Trumpet Creeper)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=507&PlantTypeID=5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 5 - 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/campsis-radicans/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b840","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Trumpet Creeper)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=507&PlantTypeID=5","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun; grows in almost any soil; heat and drought tolerant.","level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21175/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Florida Native Plant Society (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://www.fnps.org/plant/campsis-radicans","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full Sun, Part Sun","level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/campsis-radicans/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Moderately resistant to deer, drought, heat, and compaction","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b840","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Trumpet Creeper)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=507&PlantTypeID=5","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Full sun; grows in almost any soil; heat and drought tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CARA2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerance: High","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/campsis-radicans","country":null,"form":null,"value":"An adaptable plant, it is even recommended for xeriscape gardens in the US Southwest.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/campsis-radicans/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are attractive to hummingbirds which are the principal pollinator of this plant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=b840","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/21175/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollen and/or Nectar Producer","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CARA2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Plants For A Future (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Campsis+radicans","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"},{"name":"Florida Native Plant Society (Campsis radicans)","url":"https://www.fnps.org/plant/campsis-radicans","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Very attractive to hummingbirds which are its primary pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"campsis radicans"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[4.57,7.62],"union":[4.57,9.14],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244592","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 15.00 to 25.00 feet","metres":[4.57,7.62],"band":[4.57,7.62],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/madame-galen-trumpet-vine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 15 - 30 Feet","metres":[4.57,9.14],"band":[4.57,9.14],"role":"scored"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/madame-galen-trumpet-vine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 15-30 ft","metres":[4.57,9.14],"band":[4.57,9.14],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.83,3.66],"union":[1.83,3.66],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244592","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 6.00 to 12.00 feet","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/madame-galen-trumpet-vine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 6 - 12 Feet","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/madame-galen-trumpet-vine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 6-12 ft","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","6-9","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244592","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Campsis x tagliabueana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/campsis-x-tagliabueana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[6,9]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Campsis x tagliabuana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277920","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/madame-galen-trumpet-vine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 5 - 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/madame-galen-trumpet-vine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 5-9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244592","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Campsis x tagliabueana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/campsis-x-tagliabueana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Campsis x tagliabuana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277920","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/madame-galen-trumpet-vine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Full Sun (At Least 6 Hours Of Direct Sunlight)"},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/madame-galen-trumpet-vine/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun Needs : Full Sun, Partial Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244592","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil","claim":true},{"name":"The Tree Center","url":"https://www.thetreecenter.com/madame-galen-trumpet-vine/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"once established it is drought resistant and thrives with little attention","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine-apricot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=244592","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are very attractive to hummingbirds.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Campsis x tagliabueana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/campsis-x-tagliabueana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This hybrid is suitable for pollinator gardens and butterfly gardens.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[8,12],"union":[7.62,12.19],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293845","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 25.00 to 40.00 feet","metres":[7.62,12.19],"band":[7.62,12.19],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Garden Plants Online","url":"https://www.gardenplantsonline.co.uk/product/campsis-radicans-yellow-trumpet-flava-trumpet-vine-climbing/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Final Height: 8 m - 12 m (13.12 ft - 39 ft)","metres":[8,12],"band":[8,12],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[2.5,3.05],"union":[1.52,4],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293845","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 5.00 to 10.00 feet","metres":[1.52,3.05],"band":[1.52,3.05],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Garden Plants Online","url":"https://www.gardenplantsonline.co.uk/product/campsis-radicans-yellow-trumpet-flava-trumpet-vine-climbing/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Final Sideways Spread: 2.5 m - 4 m (8.2 ft - 13.12 ft)","metres":[2.5,4],"band":[2.5,4],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-9","4-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293845","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 9","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/campsis-radicans/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[4,10]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293845","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Garden Plants Online","url":"https://www.gardenplantsonline.co.uk/product/campsis-radicans-yellow-trumpet-flava-trumpet-vine-climbing/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Suggested Exposure to Sunlight: Full Sunlight"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/campsis-radicans/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293845","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought, Clay Soil","claim":true},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CARA2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerance: High","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"trumpet-vine-yellow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=293845","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are very attractive to hummingbirds.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/campsis-radicans/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#hummingbird friendly #NC native #native vine #food source nectar #food source pollen","claim":true},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CARA2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tuberous-begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":3,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tuberous-begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":3,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tuberous-begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Begonia - Tuberous Types)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia-tuberous-types/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This plant is hardy in USDA zones 9 to 11.","zones":[9,11],"level":"species"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Begonia (Tuberosa Group))","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263000","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 9 to 11","zones":[9,11],"level":"species"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":5,"genus":3,"cultivar":3},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tuberous-begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Begonia - Tuberous Types)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia-tuberous-types/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Begonias of this type prefer partial shade to dappled shade and organically rich, moist, well-drained soil.","level":"species"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Begonia (Tuberosa Group))","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263000","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade","level":"species"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Begonia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most commonly cultivated begonias prefer partial shade and a humid environment.","level":"genus","taxon":"begonia"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Begonia)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/begonia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Tuberous begonias grow best in partial shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"begonia"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden (Planting and Caring for Tender Perennials)","url":"https://hortnews.extension.iastate.edu/2004/2-27-2004/begonias.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Tuberous begonias perform best in moist, well-drained soils in partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"begonia tuberhybrida"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden (Growing Begonias in Iowa)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/growing-begonias-iowa","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Those types grown outdoors during the growing season do best in part shade with limited afternoon sun.","level":"genus","taxon":"begonia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Begonia x tuberhybrida 'Jurassic Pink Splash')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=443033","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"begonia tuberhybrida"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Begonia x tuberhybrida 'Jurassic Silver Swirl')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=371051","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade to full shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"begonia tuberhybrida"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Begonia tuberosa 'Fortune Peach Shades')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=266620","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"begonia tuberosa"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tuberous-begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tuberous-begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tuberous-begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Begonia - Tuberous Types)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/begonia-tuberous-types/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are not drought tolerant.","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Begonia (Tuberosa Group))","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263000","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Dry Soil, Black Walnut","claim":true,"level":"species"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Extension (Tuberous begonias)","url":"https://extension.umn.edu/flowers/tuberous-begonias","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Although tuberous begonias must be grown in well-drained soil, they are not drought tolerant, so it's important to water them when it hasn't rained.","claim":false,"level":"species"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden (Planting and Caring for Tender Perennials)","url":"https://hortnews.extension.iastate.edu/2004/2-27-2004/begonias.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Most are not drought tolerant so consistent watering, especially those growing in containers (and more prone to drying out), is essential.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"begonia tuberhybrida"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension Yard and Garden (Growing Begonias in Iowa)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/growing-begonias-iowa","country":null,"form":null,"value":"While most begonias are not noted for their drought tolerance, wax begonias can be, once established.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"begonia"}],"note":"4 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tuberous-begonia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tuberous-begonia-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tuberous-begonia-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tuberous-begonia-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a437","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 9 to 11","zones":[9,11]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tuberous-begonia-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-shade","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a437","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Part shade"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home and Garden Information Center","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/begonia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Tuberous begonias grow best in partial shade."}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tuberous-begonia-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tuberous-begonia-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tuberous-begonia-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tuberous-begonia-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.23,0.61],"union":[0.08,0.76],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tulipa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tulipa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 4 in. - 2 ft. 4 in.","metres":[0.1,0.71],"band":[0.1,0.71],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tulipa (group))","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264613","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.75 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.61],"band":[0.23,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden (All About Tulips)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-tulips","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plants can be as short as 4 to 6 inches and as tall as 30 inches when in bloom.","metres":[0.1,0.76],"band":[0.1,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension Bulletin B918 (Flowering Bulbs for Georgia Gardens)","url":"https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=B918","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Tulipa species & hybrids Tulip H F 4-6″ 4-6″ early-late* 3-30″","metres":[0.08,0.76],"band":[0.08,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":7,"species":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tulip","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.15,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.15,0.23],"union":[0.15,0.23],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tulipa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tulipa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 6 in. - 0 ft. 9 in.","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tulipa (group))","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264613","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.50 to 0.75 feet","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":7,"species":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tulip","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tulipa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tulipa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tulipa (group))","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264613","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":4,"levels":{"genus":7,"species":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tulip","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tulipa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tulipa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tulipa (group))","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264613","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden (All About Tulips)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-tulips","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Tulips should be planted in a full-sun location, but they can tolerate part-sun locations well.","level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"},{"name":"RHS tulip growing guide","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/tulip/growing-guide","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Grow in full sun, although some tolerate light-shade","level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Profile (Tulips, Tulipa)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plantinfo/tulips","country":"US","form":null,"value":"All tulips prefer full sun and exceptionally well-drained soil.","level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tulipa clusiana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tulipa-clusiana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"tulipa clusiana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tulipa clusiana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281818","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"tulipa clusiana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tulipa tarda)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281837","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"tulipa tarda"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tulipa saxatilis)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254106","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"tulipa saxatilis"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tulip","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Profile (Tulips, Tulipa)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plantinfo/tulips","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Some are fragrant and starlike, while others are shaped in the classic bowl form.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["tulipa saxatilis"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (tulipa saxatilis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (tulipa saxatilis) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tulip","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tulipa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tulipa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Edible Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tulipa (group))","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264613","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long-stemmed varieties are particularly well-suited to use in fresh cut arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden (All About Tulips)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-tulips","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tulips can make excellent cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension Bulletin B918 (Flowering Bulbs for Georgia Gardens)","url":"https://extension.uga.edu/publications/detail.html?number=B918","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Most tulips also make excellent cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"},{"name":"RHS tulip growing guide","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/tulip/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Border tulips make great cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension (Production of Tulips as Cut Flowers)","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/production-tulips-cut-flowers","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Customers’ desire for color at the end of winter creates a profitable crop for cut flower growers using minimally heated greenhouses and high tunnels.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tulipa clusiana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tulipa-clusiana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"tulipa clusiana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tulipa clusiana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281818","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"tulipa clusiana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tulipa saxatilis)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=254106","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"tulipa saxatilis"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tulip","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["tulipa clusiana"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (tulipa clusiana), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (tulipa clusiana) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tulip","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tulipa)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tulipa/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Landscape Theme: Children's Garden Cottage Garden Cutting Garden English Garden Pollinator Garden","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"tulipa"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"tulip-couleur-cardinal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.35,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.32,0.33],"union":[0.1,0.8],"voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Old House Gardens","url":"https://oldhousegardens.com/store/bulb-info/TU06/Couleur-Cardinal-Tulip","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Triumph, 12\", zones 3a-7b(8bWC), from Holland.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/tulip-couleur-cardinal-bulbs-uk","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Established height 30-50cm","metres":[0.3,0.5],"band":[0.3,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sarah Raven","url":"https://www.sarahraven.com/products/tulip-couleur-cardinal","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height 30cm (12in)","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Blom's Bulbs","url":"https://blomsbulbs.com/catalogue/couleur-cardinal","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height: 35cm","metres":0.35,"band":[0.32,0.39],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Rose Cottage Plants","url":"https://www.rosecottageplants.co.uk/tulipa-couleur-cardinal/p534","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Flowering in April - May at 14\" (36cm)","metres":0.36,"band":[0.32,0.4],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/58109/tulipa-couleur-cardinal-3/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"J Parker's Dutch Bulbs","url":"https://www.jparkers.co.uk/tulip-couleur-cardinal-1018900c","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 35 cm","metres":0.35,"band":[0.32,0.39],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Lincs Plants","url":"https://www.lincsplants.com/products/tulipa-couleur-cardinal-bulb-preorder","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 40 - 80cm","metres":[0.4,0.8],"band":[0.4,0.8],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Monticello Shop (Thomas Jefferson Foundation)","url":"https://monticelloshop.org/products/couleur-cardinal-tulip-tulipa-gesneriana-cv","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Habit 12 - 14\" H","metres":[0.3,0.36],"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Van Noort Bulb Co.","url":"https://www.vannoortbulb.com/products/couleur-cardinal","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Established Height: 35 cm (14\")","metres":0.35,"band":[0.32,0.39],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Jacques Amand International","url":"https://jacquesamandintl.com/products/couleur-cardinal","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height 13\" (33cm).","metres":0.33,"band":[0.3,0.36],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-couleur-cardinal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.15,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.09,0.11],"union":[0,0.2],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/tulip-couleur-cardinal-bulbs-uk","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Established spread 10-20cm","metres":[0.1,0.2],"band":[0.1,0.2],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/58109/tulipa-couleur-cardinal-3/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0-0.1 metre","metres":[0,0.1],"band":[0,0.1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"J Parker's Dutch Bulbs","url":"https://www.jparkers.co.uk/tulip-couleur-cardinal-1018900c","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 10 cm","metres":0.1,"band":[0.09,0.11],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Lincs Plants","url":"https://www.lincsplants.com/products/tulipa-couleur-cardinal-bulb-preorder","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 0 - 20cm","metres":[0,0.2],"band":[0,0.2],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-couleur-cardinal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-7","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Old House Gardens","url":"https://oldhousegardens.com/store/bulb-info/TU06/Couleur-Cardinal-Tulip","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Triumph, 12\", zones 3a-7b(8bWC), from Holland.","zones":[3,7]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tulipa, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tulipa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tulipa group page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264613","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Monticello Shop (Thomas Jefferson Foundation)","url":"https://monticelloshop.org/products/couleur-cardinal-tulip-tulipa-gesneriana-cv","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 3 - 8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-couleur-cardinal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/tulip-couleur-cardinal-bulbs-uk","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full sun Partial shade"},{"name":"Sarah Raven","url":"https://www.sarahraven.com/products/tulip-couleur-cardinal","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Aspect Full Sun"},{"name":"Blom's Bulbs","url":"https://blomsbulbs.com/catalogue/couleur-cardinal","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Partial Shade Sunny Position"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Tulipa, genus page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/tulipa/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Tulipa group page)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=264613","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/58109/tulipa-couleur-cardinal-3/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"Monticello Shop (Thomas Jefferson Foundation)","url":"https://monticelloshop.org/products/couleur-cardinal-tulip-tulipa-gesneriana-cv","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure Full Sun"},{"name":"Van Noort Bulb Co.","url":"https://www.vannoortbulb.com/products/couleur-cardinal","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full Sun Partial Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-couleur-cardinal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/tulip-couleur-cardinal-bulbs-uk","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Scented No","claim":false},{"name":"Monticello Shop (Thomas Jefferson Foundation)","url":"https://monticelloshop.org/products/couleur-cardinal-tulip-tulipa-gesneriana-cv","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This single-flowered, fragrant tulip dates to 1845 and is still widely grown.","claim":true},{"name":"Van Noort Bulb Co.","url":"https://www.vannoortbulb.com/products/couleur-cardinal","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These fragrant blooms are perfect for cut flowers.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-couleur-cardinal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/tulip-couleur-cardinal-bulbs-uk","https://www.sarahraven.com/products/tulip-couleur-cardinal"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/tulip-couleur-cardinal-bulbs-uk","https://www.vannoortbulb.com/products/couleur-cardinal"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/tulip-couleur-cardinal-bulbs-uk","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good for cutting","claim":true},{"name":"Sarah Raven","url":"https://www.sarahraven.com/products/tulip-couleur-cardinal","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good for Cutting","claim":true},{"name":"Van Noort Bulb Co.","url":"https://www.vannoortbulb.com/products/couleur-cardinal","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These fragrant blooms are perfect for cut flowers.","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-couleur-cardinal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-couleur-cardinal","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Farmer Gracy","url":"https://www.farmergracy.co.uk/products/tulip-couleur-cardinal-bulbs-uk","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator-friendly No","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-flaming-parrot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.55,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/tulip-flaming-parrot.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"22\"","metres":0.56,"band":[0.5,0.62],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-flaming-parrot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-flaming-parrot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/tulip-flaming-parrot.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4-7","zones":[4,7]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-flaming-parrot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-flaming-parrot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-flaming-parrot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/tulip-flaming-parrot.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is said to be the most widely used Tulip for cut-flower arrangements.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-flaming-parrot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-flaming-parrot","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-spring-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/spring-green/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"16″-18″","metres":[0.41,0.46],"band":[0.41,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-spring-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-spring-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/spring-green/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-spring-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/spring-green/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-spring-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-spring-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-spring-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"tulip-spring-green","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"vanessa-bell","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.1,1.32],"union":[1.08,1.34],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/vanessa-bell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4ft","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/vanessa-bell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4'","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Regan Nursery","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-English-rose-Vanessa-Bell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4- Feet","metres":1.22,"band":[1.1,1.34],"role":"scored"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.78356.0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"4' (120cm)","metres":1.2,"band":[1.08,1.32],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/vanessa-bell","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"3 1/2ft (110cm)","metres":1.1,"band":[0.99,1.21],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"vanessa-bell","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.99],"union":[0.81,1],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/vanessa-bell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"3ft","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/vanessa-bell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"3'","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Regan Nursery","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-English-rose-Vanessa-Bell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"3- Feet","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.78356.0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"3' (90cm)","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/vanessa-bell","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"3ft (90cm)","metres":0.9,"band":[0.81,0.99],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"vanessa-bell","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/vanessa-bell","https://heirloomroses.com/products/vanessa-bell"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/vanessa-bell","https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-English-rose-Vanessa-Bell"]}],"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/vanessa-bell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Suitable for zones: Zones 5-11"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/vanessa-bell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Zone 5-11"},{"name":"Regan Nursery","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-English-rose-Vanessa-Bell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"5-11"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[5,11]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"vanessa-bell","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/vanessa-bell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight and Partial Shade; North, East, South, West Facing"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/vanessa-bell","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Full Sunlight; Partial Shade; North, East, South, West Facing"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/vanessa-bell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Partial Shade or Full Sun; can handle some partial shade if needed"},{"name":"Regan Nursery","url":"https://www.regannursery.com/rose/Rosa-English-rose-Vanessa-Bell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Listed as suitable for \"Shady areas\"; no full-sun hour requirement stated"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"vanessa-bell","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/vanessa-bell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Medium-strong, Tea - green tea with aspects of lemon and honey"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK)","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/vanessa-bell","country":"UK","form":"shrub","value":"Medium-strong, Tea, with aspects of lemon and honey"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/vanessa-bell","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Moderately Fragrant - smells like a cup of green tea with honey and lemon"},{"name":"HelpMeFind Roses","url":"https://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=2.78356.0","country":"US","form":"shrub","value":"Moderate, honey, lemon fragrance"}],"note":"sources rate it medium","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.25,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":10,"levels":{"species":9,"genus":2,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Verbenas vary considerably in size. The ground skimming moss verbena and trailing verbena reach 1 foot or less in height and spread from 2 to 5 feet wide. Verbena rigida usually grows 1 to 1½ feet tall, while purpletop vervain and the native blue verbena can reach 4 to 5 feet tall, but only a foot or two in width.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"They tend to be compact, at about 30cm (1ft) tall, and there are also trailing types for hanging baskets and for cascading over the sides of tall patio pots and windowboxes.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 10 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"species":9,"genus":2,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Verbenas vary considerably in size. The ground skimming moss verbena and trailing verbena reach 1 foot or less in height and spread from 2 to 5 feet wide. Verbena rigida usually grows 1 to 1½ feet tall, while purpletop vervain and the native blue verbena can reach 4 to 5 feet tall, but only a foot or two in width.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":7,"levels":{"species":9,"genus":2,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Verbena x hybrida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/verbena-x-hybrida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"verbena hybrida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Verbena bonariensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/verbena-bonariensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"verbena bonariensis"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Verbena, HGIC 1175)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/verbena/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Verbenas require a location that receives full sun throughout the day.","level":"genus","taxon":"verbena"},{"name":"RHS Growing Guide (Verbena)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/verbena/growing-guide","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"They thrive in full sun, in well-drained soil that doesn’t stay soggy.","level":"genus","taxon":"verbena"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Verbena x hybrida)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263340&isprofile=0&basic=Verbena","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"verbena hybrida"},{"name":"Proven Winners, Growing Verbena","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/verbena","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Choose a site with good air circulation that receives at least 6-8 hours of full sun a day","level":"species","taxon":"verbena hybrida"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Verbena bonariensis)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/verbena-bonariensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant V. bonariensis in full sun and well-drained soil.","level":"species","taxon":"verbena bonariensis"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers: Garden Verbena (Verbena x hybrida)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/garden-verbena","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"verbena hybrida"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Verbena bonariensis)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287454&isprofile=0&basic=Verbena","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"verbena bonariensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Verbena 'Imagination')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263338&isprofile=0&basic=Verbena","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Verbena rigida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/verbena-rigida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"verbena rigida"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["verbena hybrida"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (verbena hybrida), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (verbena hybrida) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["verbena bonariensis"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (verbena bonariensis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"no source spoke to this trait; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (verbena bonariensis) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Verbena x hybrida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/verbena-x-hybrida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are fairly drought-tolerant once established.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"verbena hybrida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Verbena bonariensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/verbena-bonariensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Dry Soil Poor Soil Rabbits","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"verbena bonariensis"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Verbena, HGIC 1175)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/verbena/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"While established verbenas are drought tolerant, performance, bloom, and growth rate will be reduced if they are too dry for a long period.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"verbena"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Verbena x hybrida)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263340&isprofile=0&basic=Verbena","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"verbena hybrida"},{"name":"Proven Winners, Growing Verbena","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/verbena","country":null,"form":null,"value":"this durable plant is tolerant of different soils, heat and drought, making it one of the best drought tolerant annual flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"verbena hybrida"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Verbena bonariensis)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/verbena-bonariensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is fairly drought tolerant and doesn’t require watering once established (except in periods of drought).","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"verbena bonariensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Verbena 'Imagination')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263338&isprofile=0&basic=Verbena","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Verbena rigida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/verbena-rigida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought Heat","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"verbena rigida"}],"note":"8 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Verbena x hybrida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/verbena-x-hybrida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"verbena hybrida"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Verbena bonariensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/verbena-bonariensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Hummingbirds Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"verbena bonariensis"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Verbena, HGIC 1175)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/verbena/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"All verbena will attract numerous butterfly species, bumblebees, and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"verbena"},{"name":"RHS Growing Guide (Verbena)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/verbena/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Popular with bees and butterflies","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"verbena"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Verbena x hybrida)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263340&isprofile=0&basic=Verbena","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"verbena hybrida"},{"name":"Proven Winners, Growing Verbena","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/learn/how-plant/verbena","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Highly attractive to butterflies and other insect pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"verbena hybrida"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Verbena bonariensis)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/verbena-bonariensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are highly attractive to butterflies, hummingbirds, and other pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"verbena bonariensis"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers: Garden Verbena (Verbena x hybrida)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/garden-verbena","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"verbena hybrida"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Verbena bonariensis)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287454&isprofile=0&basic=Verbena","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"verbena bonariensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Verbena 'Imagination')","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=263338&isprofile=0&basic=Verbena","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are grown for their showy flowers that are attractive to hummingbirds, butterflies, and other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Verbena rigida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/verbena-rigida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Songbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"verbena rigida"}],"note":"11 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"verbena-annual-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.25,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Garden Height: 6 - 12 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"A well-branched growth habit reaches 8 to 12 inches tall and 12 to 24 inches wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Mature height 10 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 6-12 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height 6 - 12 in\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":5,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 18 - 24 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"A well-branched growth habit reaches 8 to 12 inches tall and 12 to 24 inches wide.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread 24 inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 18-24 Inches\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread 18 - 24 in\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/verbena/superbena-royale-plum-wine-verbena","https://plantaddicts.com/superbena-royale-plum-wine-verbena"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/verbena/superbena-royale-plum-wine-verbena","https://www.milmont.com/Plant-Name/Verbena-Superbena-Royale-Plum-Wine"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (breeder/introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/verbena/superbena-royale-plum-wine-verbena","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 8a , 8b , 9a , 9b , 10a , 10b , 11a , 11b","zones":[8,11]},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/superbena-royale-plum-wine-verbena","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 8-11","zones":[8,11]},{"name":"Milmont Greenhouses (Waynesboro, VA)","url":"https://www.milmont.com/Plant-Name/Verbena-Superbena-Royale-Plum-Wine","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone 8-11","zones":[8,11]}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[8,11]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (breeder/introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/verbena/superbena-royale-plum-wine-verbena","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Part Sun to Sun"},{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants (Houston, TX)","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/superbena-royale-plum-wine-verbena/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirements full sun"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/superbena-royale-plum-wine-verbena","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Partial Sun to Full Sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Verbena x hybrida, species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/verbena-x-hybrida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Buchanan's Native Plants (Houston, TX)","url":"https://buchanansplants.com/plant-library/perennials/superbena-royale-plum-wine-verbena/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are excellent for cutting.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Greenleaf Nursery Company","url":"https://www.greenleafnursery.com/plant/SUPERBENAR-ROYALE-PLUM-WINE-VERB-PPAF","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Heat and drought tolerant.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual-burgundy","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/verbena/superbena-royale-plum-wine-verbena","https://plantaddicts.com/superbena-royale-plum-wine-verbena"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/verbena/superbena-royale-plum-wine-verbena","https://www.milmont.com/Plant-Name/Verbena-Superbena-Royale-Plum-Wine"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (breeder/introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/verbena/superbena-royale-plum-wine-verbena","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/superbena-royale-plum-wine-verbena","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The cascade of flowers attracts butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Milmont Greenhouses (Waynesboro, VA)","url":"https://www.milmont.com/Plant-Name/Verbena-Superbena-Royale-Plum-Wine","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.25,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":9,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":1,"reasons":["this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"0 ft. 6 in. - 2 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is hardy only to zone 9, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[9,11],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/verbena-x-hybrida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/verbena-x-hybrida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are fairly drought-tolerant once established.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"verbena-annual-coral","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.76],"union":[0.1,1],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica-spicata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299638","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata subsp. incana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287131","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"RHS (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/100995/veronica-spicata/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.5-1 metres","metres":[0.5,1],"band":[0.5,1],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"RHS (Veronica spicata subsp. spicata)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/18867/veronica-spicata-subsp-spicata/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=750&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 1-3 Feet","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers (Speedwell, Veronica spicata)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/speedwell","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 1 to 3 Feet","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"veronica","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.1,0.76],"split":[{"range":[0.1,0.5],"sources":["RHS (Veronica spicata)","RHS (Veronica spicata subsp. spicata)"]},{"range":[0.61,0.76],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Veronica spicata)","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata)","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata subsp. incana)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica-spicata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 2 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299638","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata subsp. incana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287131","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 2.50 feet","metres":[0.61,0.76],"band":[0.61,0.76],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"RHS (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/100995/veronica-spicata/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"RHS (Veronica spicata subsp. spicata)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/18867/veronica-spicata-subsp-spicata/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"veronica","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica-spicata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299638","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension Hort Answers (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/hortanswers/plantdetail.cfm?PlantID=750&PlantTypeID=2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone 3 - 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers (Speedwell, Veronica spicata)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/speedwell","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 3 - 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata subsp. incana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287131","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"species":7,"cultivar":1,"genus":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"veronica","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica-spicata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299638","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"RHS (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/100995/veronica-spicata/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Illinois Extension, Flowers (Speedwell, Veronica spicata)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/speedwell","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata 'Spike')","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-finder/veronica-spicata-spike-spike-speedwell","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun Partial Shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Veronica, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"veronica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata subsp. incana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287131","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"RHS (Veronica spicata subsp. spicata)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/18867/veronica-spicata-subsp-spicata/details","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"veronica","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"veronica","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica-spicata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299638","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata subsp. incana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287131","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"veronica","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299638","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants have shallow roots and are generally intolerant of dry soil conditions.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"RHS (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/100995/veronica-spicata/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata subsp. incana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287131","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants have shallow roots and are generally intolerant of dry soil conditions.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"RHS (Veronica spicata subsp. spicata)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/18867/veronica-spicata-subsp-spicata/details","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistance Yes","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"}],"note":"2 source(s) state this trait and 2 deny it","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"veronica","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":4,"why":"both carry the same 47 character sentence, so one is reprinting the other","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica-spicata/","https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299638"]},{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica-spicata/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica/"]},{"tier":4,"why":"both carry the same 47 character sentence, so one is reprinting the other","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica-spicata/","https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287131"]}],"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica-spicata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299638","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Veronica, the genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"veronica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata subsp. incana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287131","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["veronica spicata"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (veronica spicata), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 4 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both carry the same 47 character sentence, so one is reprinting the other; both pages are ncsu.edu. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 4; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (veronica spicata) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"veronica-crater-lake-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255666&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica austriaca"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":1,"genus":1,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"veronica-crater-lake-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255666&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica austriaca"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":1,"genus":1,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"veronica-crater-lake-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255666&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica austriaca"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":1,"genus":1,"species":1},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question","this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"SPLIT"},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"veronica-crater-lake-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255666&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica austriaca"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"veronica"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (species page)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=287013&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"veronica austriaca"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"veronica-crater-lake-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"veronica-crater-lake-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Landscape Theme: Cottage Garden Cutting Garden Pollinator Garden Rock Garden","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"veronica"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"veronica-crater-lake-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Diseases Drought Insect Pests","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"veronica"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"veronica-crater-lake-blue","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attract bees and butterflies","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"veronica"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"veronica-first-love","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.25,0.3],"union":[0.23,0.3],"proposed":0.28,"margin":33.3,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273640&isprofile=0&letter=v","country":"US","form":null,"value":"0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/veronica-x-first-love-ver906","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10–12\"","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.23 to 0.3 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-first-love","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273640&isprofile=0&letter=v","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-first-love","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273640&isprofile=0&letter=v","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/veronica-x-first-love-ver906","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 4–9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-first-love","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=273640&isprofile=0&letter=v","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/veronica-x-first-love-ver906","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-first-love","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-first-love","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-first-love","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-first-love","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/veronica-x-first-love-ver906","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollinator-friendly and ideal for borders and containers","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-red-fox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=m710","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-red-fox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=m710","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 1.00 to 1.50 feet","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-red-fox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=m710","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-red-fox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=m710","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-red-fox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-red-fox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-red-fox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-red-fox","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=m710","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to bees and butterflies.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-royal-candles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.23,0.45],"split":[{"range":[0.23,0.38],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata 'Glory' ROYAL CANDLES)","American Meadows","High Country Gardens","Wilson Bros Gardens"]},{"range":[0.4,0.45],"sources":["United States plant patent PP18,932 (Veronica plant named 'Glory'), via Google Patents"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata 'Glory' ROYAL CANDLES)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257299&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"United States plant patent PP18,932 (Veronica plant named 'Glory'), via Google Patents","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP18932P3/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature height: 40-45 cm in height.","metres":[0.4,0.45],"band":[0.4,0.45],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-veronica-royal-candles","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 10-12\" tall","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-veronica-royal-candles","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 10-12\" tall","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/royal-candles-veronica-speedwell--5-pack-of-quart-pots.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height at Maturity: Foliage: 3-4\" | Flowers: 12-15\"","metres":[0.3,0.38],"band":[0.3,0.38],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"veronica-royal-candles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.15,0.46],"split":[{"range":[0.15,0.23],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata 'Glory' ROYAL CANDLES)"]},{"range":[0.27,0.46],"sources":["United States plant patent PP18,932 (Veronica plant named 'Glory'), via Google Patents","High Country Gardens","Wilson Bros Gardens","American Meadows"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata 'Glory' ROYAL CANDLES)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257299&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.50 to 0.75 feet","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"United States plant patent PP18,932 (Veronica plant named 'Glory'), via Google Patents","url":"https://patents.google.com/patent/USPP18932P3/en","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature width: Approximately 30 cm in width.","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-veronica-royal-candles","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 12-18\" wide","metres":[0.3,0.46],"band":[0.3,0.46],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-veronica-royal-candles","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread 12-15\" wide","metres":[0.3,0.38],"band":[0.3,0.38],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/royal-candles-veronica-speedwell--5-pack-of-quart-pots.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width at Maturity: 12-15\"","metres":[0.3,0.38],"band":[0.3,0.38],"role":"scored","level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"veronica-royal-candles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","4-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata 'Glory' ROYAL CANDLES)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257299&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-veronica-royal-candles","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growing Zones Zone 3 Zone 4 Zone 5 Zone 6 Zone 7 Zone 8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-veronica-royal-candles","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ZONES 3-8","zones":[3,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/royal-candles-veronica-speedwell--5-pack-of-quart-pots.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Cold Hardiness Zones: 4a-8b","zones":[4,8],"level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"}],"shape":{"row":"cultivar","sourcesDropped":2,"levels":{"cultivar":5,"species":2},"reasons":["this row names the cultivar and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a cultivar and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"veronica-royal-candles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata 'Glory' ROYAL CANDLES)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257299&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299638&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica-spicata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-veronica-royal-candles","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-veronica-royal-candles","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"veronica-royal-candles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/royal-candles-veronica-speedwell--5-pack-of-quart-pots.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Flowers: No","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"veronica-royal-candles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata 'Glory' ROYAL CANDLES)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257299&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica-spicata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-veronica-royal-candles","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers Container Planting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-veronica-royal-candles","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flowers Container Planting","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/royal-candles-veronica-speedwell--5-pack-of-quart-pots.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Royal Candles Veronica is ideal for use at the front of the border in perennial and cut flower gardens or along paths and walkways.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"veronica-royal-candles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata 'Glory' ROYAL CANDLES)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257299&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants have shallow roots and are generally intolerant of dry soil conditions.","claim":false,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299638&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants have shallow roots and are generally intolerant of dry soil conditions.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-veronica-royal-candles","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Water Tolerance Low-Water","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"}],"note":"2 sources deny this trait and the tag is correctly absent","checked":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"veronica-royal-candles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata 'Glory' ROYAL CANDLES)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=257299&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=299638&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox (Veronica spicata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/veronica-spicata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife Value: Flowers are attractive to bees and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/perennial-veronica-royal-candles","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies Attracts Hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"High Country Gardens","url":"https://www.highcountrygardens.com/products/perennial-veronica-royal-candles","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"},{"name":"Wilson Bros Gardens","url":"https://www.wilsonbrosgardens.com/royal-candles-veronica-speedwell--5-pack-of-quart-pots.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies, Hummingbirds, Beneficial Pollinators, Visual Attention","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"veronica spicata"}],"note":"6 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-08-02","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"veronica-snow-candles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"union":[0.15,0.33],"split":[{"range":[0.15,0.2],"sources":["Fieldstone Gardens","Sandy's Plants"]},{"range":[0.27,0.33],"sources":["NVK Nurseries"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/veronica-spicata-snow-candles","https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles"]},{"tier":3,"why":"both publish as syndicated-plant-database-botanical","urls":["https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles","https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles-Joca128"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/veronica-spicata-snow-candles","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6-8\"","metres":[0.15,0.2],"band":[0.15,0.2],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6-8 in","metres":[0.15,0.2],"band":[0.15,0.2],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles-Joca128","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Flower Height: 30 cm","metres":0.3,"band":[0.27,0.33],"role":"scored"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"SPLIT"},"note":"SPLIT withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first; both publish as syndicated-plant-database-botanical. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-snow-candles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.25,0.3],"union":[0.25,0.4],"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/veronica-spicata-snow-candles","https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles"]},{"tier":3,"why":"both publish as syndicated-plant-database-botanical","urls":["https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles","https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles-Joca128"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/veronica-spicata-snow-candles","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10-12\"","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles","country":"US","form":null,"value":"10-12 in","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles-Joca128","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"30-40 cm","metres":[0.3,0.4],"band":[0.3,0.4],"role":"scored"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first; both publish as syndicated-plant-database-botanical. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-snow-candles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/veronica-spicata-snow-candles","https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/veronica-spicata-snow-candles","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4-8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones 4-8","zones":[4,8]}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":[4,8]},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-snow-candles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/veronica-spicata-snow-candles","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full Sun"},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles-Joca128","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Grows best in an average to moist, well-drained soil, in full sun to partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-snow-candles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-snow-candles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":3,"why":"both publish as syndicated-plant-database-botanical","urls":["https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles","https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles-Joca128"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower","claim":true},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles-Joca128","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut Flower/Foliage","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both publish as syndicated-plant-database-botanical. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-snow-candles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerant once established","claim":true},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles-Joca128","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Not tolerant of drought conditions.","claim":false}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"veronica-snow-candles","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/veronica-spicata-snow-candles","https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/veronica-spicata-snow-candles","https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles-Joca128"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Fieldstone Gardens","url":"https://fieldstonegardens.com/products/veronica-spicata-snow-candles","country":null,"form":null,"value":"a favorite of butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Sandy's Plants","url":"https://www.sandysplants.com/plant-name/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attractive to butterflies and hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"NVK Nurseries","url":"https://www.nvknurseries.com/plant/Veronica-spicata-Snow-Candles-Joca128","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"viburnum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.22,6.1],"union":[0.61,9.14],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Viburnum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/viburnum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4 ft. 0 in. - 20 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.22,6.1],"band":[1.22,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"viburnum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Viburnum)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/viburnum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Viburnums range in height from 2 feet to 30 feet.","metres":[0.61,9.14],"band":[0.61,9.14],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"viburnum"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":8},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"viburnum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Viburnum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/viburnum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 18 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,5.49],"band":[0.61,5.49],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"viburnum"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":8},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"viburnum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Viburnum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/viburnum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b","zones":[4,10],"level":"genus","taxon":"viburnum"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"genus":3,"species":8},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"viburnum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Viburnum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/viburnum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Viburums can grow from 4 to 20 feet tall and generally do best in full sun to partial shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"viburnum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Viburnum)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/viburnum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Many viburnums flower best in full sun, but light preferences vary from full sun to mostly shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"viburnum"},{"name":"Piedmont Master Gardeners, Virginia Cooperative Extension (Viburnum - A Shrub for Many Settings)","url":"https://www.piedmontmastergardeners.org/article/viburnum-a-shrub-for-many-settings/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most prefer sun, but some do well in partial shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"viburnum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viburnum carlesii)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279002","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"viburnum carlesii"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viburnum dentatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278980","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"viburnum dentatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viburnum opulus)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278939","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"viburnum opulus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viburnum prunifolium)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278961","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"viburnum prunifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viburnum plicatum f. tomentosum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255715","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"viburnum plicatum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Viburnum carlesii)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/viburnum-carlesii/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Korean Viburnum prefers sun to partial shade and moist, well-drained soil including clay.","level":"species","taxon":"viburnum carlesii"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Viburnum dentatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/viburnum-dentatum/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"viburnum dentatum"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Nannyberry, Viburnum lentago)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/nannyberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"viburnum lentago"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"viburnum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":false,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viburnum dentatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278980","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Non-fragrant white flowers in flat-topped corymbs","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"viburnum dentatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viburnum prunifolium)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278961","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Non-fragrant white flowers in flat-topped cymes","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"viburnum prunifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viburnum plicatum f. tomentosum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255715","country":null,"form":null,"value":"non-fragrant, showy white flowers along the branches in spring","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"viburnum plicatum"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Nannyberry, Viburnum lentago)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/nannyberry/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They don't have any fragrance.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"viburnum lentago"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":2,"covered":["viburnum carlesii"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this fragrant claim cover only one taxon (viburnum carlesii), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"4 sources deny this trait but the tag is present; 2 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (viburnum carlesii) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"fragrant","from":true,"to":false,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"viburnum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"viburnum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Viburnum)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/viburnum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deep soak even well-established plants during long dry spells.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"viburnum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viburnum dentatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278980","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Established plants have some drought tolerance.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"viburnum dentatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viburnum prunifolium)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278961","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought, Clay Soil, Black Walnut, Urban Conditions","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"viburnum prunifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viburnum plicatum f. tomentosum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255715","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"viburnum plicatum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Viburnum dentatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/viburnum-dentatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistant to fire in the landscape. Heat, drought, and soil compaction tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"viburnum dentatum"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Nannyberry, Viburnum lentago)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/nannyberry/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance Moderately tolerant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"viburnum lentago"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"viburnum","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Viburnum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/viburnum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts pollinators and birds","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"viburnum"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Viburnum)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/viburnum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Viburnum flowers attract many butterflies, and the fruit clusters are popular with birds and other wildlife.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"viburnum"},{"name":"Piedmont Master Gardeners, Virginia Cooperative Extension (Viburnum - A Shrub for Many Settings)","url":"https://www.piedmontmastergardeners.org/article/viburnum-a-shrub-for-many-settings/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Native viburnums are noted as having special value for native bees, and attract many different types of butterflies and moths.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"viburnum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viburnum dentatum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278980","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"viburnum dentatum"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viburnum opulus)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278939","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"viburnum opulus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viburnum prunifolium)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=278961","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"viburnum prunifolium"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Viburnum plicatum f. tomentosum)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255715","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"viburnum plicatum"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Viburnum dentatum)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/viburnum-dentatum/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It provides nectar for pollinators, including native bees, food and shelter for birds, and is a larval host plant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"viburnum dentatum"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Nannyberry, Viburnum lentago)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/nannyberry/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This shrub is a caterpillar and larva host to the spring azure butterfly.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"viburnum lentago"}],"note":"9 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"vinca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants (Catharanthus roseus)","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/catharanthusroseus.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Growth Habit: Evergreen, herbaceous, short-lived perennial usually grown as a warm season annual in Phoenix, habit dependent on varietal series, muchly branched ranging in height from 4- to 24-inches tall.","metres":[0.1,0.61],"band":[0.1,0.61],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":6,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 1 ft. 6 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0.50 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The plants grow 1 or 2 feet high and about the same width.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1 to 2 feet; dependent upon cultivar selection\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The plant can reach around 2 to 5 feet in height.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"vinca 6-18 12 WPL Tender Sun to Semi-shade\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"vinca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":4,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 8 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.50 to 1.50 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"The plants grow 1 or 2 feet high and about the same width.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 1 to 2 feet; dependent upon cultivar selection\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 4 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"vinca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["10-11","9-11"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Catharanthus roseus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/catharanthus-roseus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[10,11],"level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Catharanthus roseus)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276071&isprofile=0&basic=Catharanthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 10 to 11","zones":[10,11],"level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension FPS112 (Catharanthus roseus: Periwinkle, Madagascar Periwinkle, Vinca)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP112","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA hardiness zones: 9B through 11B (Figures 4 and 5); may be planted in all zones as a warm season annual","zones":[9,11],"level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"},{"name":"Top Tropicals (Catharanthus roseus, Madagascar Periwinkle)","url":"https://toptropicals.com/catalog/uid/catharanthus_roseus.htm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It grows in USDA Zones 9-11.","zones":[9,11],"level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"vinca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Catharanthus roseus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/catharanthus-roseus/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Catharanthus roseus)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276071&isprofile=0&basic=Catharanthus","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1158 (Annual Vinca)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/annual-vinca/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It prefers full sun, tolerates heat and drought, and can be relied on to flower in the hottest weather throughout the entire summer.","level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension FPS112 (Catharanthus roseus: Periwinkle, Madagascar Periwinkle, Vinca)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP112","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in partial shade; plant grows in full sun","level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants (Catharanthus roseus)","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/catharanthusroseus.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full to partial sun, limit direct western exposures.","level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"},{"name":"Top Tropicals (Catharanthus roseus, Madagascar Periwinkle)","url":"https://toptropicals.com/catalog/uid/catharanthus_roseus.htm","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It prefers full sun or part shade and regular watering, although it can tolerate considerable drought.","level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (Vinca Seeds, Catharanthus roseus)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/vinca.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"full sun, part shade in hot climates","level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"vinca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"vinca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"vinca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Catharanthus roseus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/catharanthus-roseus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Moderate to high drought tolerance. Seldom damaged by deer. Some cultivars show good resistance to phytophthora.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Catharanthus roseus)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=276071&isprofile=0&basic=Catharanthus","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Rabbit, Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1158 (Annual Vinca)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/annual-vinca/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"With heat, drought, and poor soil tolerance, annual vinca ( Catharanthus roseus ), sometimes called periwinkle, is popular for summer flower beds in South Carolina.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension FPS112 (Catharanthus roseus: Periwinkle, Madagascar Periwinkle, Vinca)","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP112","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance: high","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"},{"name":"Arizona State University, Virtual Library of Phoenix Landscape Plants (Catharanthus roseus)","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/catharanthusroseus.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Watering: Frequent, regular supplemental water is required in desert landscapes during summer for best appearance.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"},{"name":"Top Tropicals (Catharanthus roseus, Madagascar Periwinkle)","url":"https://toptropicals.com/catalog/uid/catharanthus_roseus.htm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It prefers full sun or part shade and regular watering, although it can tolerate considerable drought.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"},{"name":"University of Georgia Extension Bulletin B954 (Flowering Annuals for Georgia Gardens)","url":"https://fieldreport.caes.uga.edu/publications/B954/flowering-annuals-for-georgia-gardens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is heat- and drought-tolerant, and grows well on poor soils.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (Vinca Seeds, Catharanthus roseus)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/vinca.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vinca plants grow best in well-drained soil with average to low fertility, and tolerate drought and high heat.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"}],"note":"7 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"vinca","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Catharanthus roseus)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/catharanthus-roseus/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"},{"name":"Top Tropicals (Catharanthus roseus, Madagascar Periwinkle)","url":"https://toptropicals.com/catalog/uid/catharanthus_roseus.htm","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The periwinkle's cheery blooms will attract butterflies, hummingbirds and bees to your garden.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"},{"name":"Swallowtail Garden Seeds (Vinca Seeds, Catharanthus roseus)","url":"https://www.swallowtailgardenseeds.com/annuals/vinca.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Vinca flowers attract butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"catharanthus roseus"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"weigela","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1.22,3.05],"split":[{"range":[1.22,1.52],"sources":["Cold Stream Farm nursery (Red Weigela, Weigela florida)"]},{"range":[1.83,3.05],"sources":["University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Old Fashioned Weigela)","Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Weigela florida)","Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Weigela florida)","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Weigela florida)","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Weigela florida)","Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Weigela florida)","Virginia Cooperative Extension, Virginia Tech (Old Fashioned Weigela, pub. 2901-1060)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Weigela florida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/weigela-florida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6 ft. 0 in. - 10 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Weigela florida)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279017","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6.00 to 10.00 feet","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Weigela florida)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/weigela-florida","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Deciduous shrub, 6-9 x 9-12 ft (1.9-2.4 x 2.4-3.7 m), dense, arching, eventually to the ground.","metres":[1.83,2.74],"band":[1.83,2.74],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Weigela florida)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/how-to-grow-and-care-for-old-fashioned-weigela-weigela-florida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The species grows large, 8 to 10 feet tall and up to 12 feet wide","metres":[2.44,3.05],"band":[2.44,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Virginia Cooperative Extension, Virginia Tech (Old Fashioned Weigela, pub. 2901-1060)","url":"https://www.pubs.ext.vt.edu/2901/2901-1060/2901-1060.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 9 feet","metres":2.74,"band":[2.47,3.01],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Old Fashioned Weigela)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=469","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 6-8 Feet","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Weigela florida)","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/749/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Height: 6-9 feet","metres":[1.83,2.74],"band":[1.83,2.74],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Cold Stream Farm nursery (Red Weigela, Weigela florida)","url":"https://www.coldstreamfarm.net/product/red-weigela-weigela-florida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height/spread: 4-5′ / 4-5′","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"weigela","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1.22,4.03],"split":[{"range":[1.22,1.52],"sources":["Cold Stream Farm nursery (Red Weigela, Weigela florida)"]},{"range":[1.83,2.44],"sources":["University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Old Fashioned Weigela)"]},{"range":[2.74,4.03],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Weigela florida)","Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Weigela florida)","Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Weigela florida)","Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Weigela florida)","Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Weigela florida)","Virginia Cooperative Extension, Virginia Tech (Old Fashioned Weigela, pub. 2901-1060)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Weigela florida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/weigela-florida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 9 ft. 0 in. - 12 ft. 0 in.","metres":[2.74,3.66],"band":[2.74,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Weigela florida)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279017","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 9.00 to 12.00 feet","metres":[2.74,3.66],"band":[2.74,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Weigela florida)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/weigela-florida","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Deciduous shrub, 6-9 x 9-12 ft (1.9-2.4 x 2.4-3.7 m), dense, arching, eventually to the ground.","metres":[2.74,3.66],"band":[2.74,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Weigela florida)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/how-to-grow-and-care-for-old-fashioned-weigela-weigela-florida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The species grows large, 8 to 10 feet tall and up to 12 feet wide","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Virginia Cooperative Extension, Virginia Tech (Old Fashioned Weigela, pub. 2901-1060)","url":"https://www.pubs.ext.vt.edu/2901/2901-1060/2901-1060.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12 feet","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Old Fashioned Weigela)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=469","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 6-8 Feet","metres":[1.83,2.44],"band":[1.83,2.44],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Weigela florida)","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/749/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Spread: 9-12 feet","metres":[2.74,3.66],"band":[2.74,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Cold Stream Farm nursery (Red Weigela, Weigela florida)","url":"https://www.coldstreamfarm.net/product/red-weigela-weigela-florida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height/spread: 4-5′ / 4-5′","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"the sources fall into 3 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"weigela","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","5-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Weigela florida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/weigela-florida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Weigela florida)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279017","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Weigela florida)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/how-to-grow-and-care-for-old-fashioned-weigela-weigela-florida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Weigela can be planted in USDA planting zones 4 through 8b.","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Virginia Cooperative Extension, Virginia Tech (Old Fashioned Weigela, pub. 2901-1060)","url":"https://www.pubs.ext.vt.edu/2901/2901-1060/2901-1060.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Old Fashioned Weigela)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=469","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5 - 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Cold Stream Farm nursery (Red Weigela, Weigela florida)","url":"https://www.coldstreamfarm.net/product/red-weigela-weigela-florida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 4-8","zones":[4,8],"level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"weigela","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Weigela florida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/weigela-florida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant this shrub in the full sun to light shade or dappled sunlight, though the best flowering and foliage color will occur in full sun.","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Weigela florida)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279017","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Weigela florida)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/weigela-florida","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to part shade, course leafed, tough plant easy to grow, becomes rangy unless pruned, no serious pests or diseases.","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Weigela florida)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/how-to-grow-and-care-for-old-fashioned-weigela-weigela-florida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Weigela can be planted in part to full sun (6 hours or more of direct sun).","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Virginia Cooperative Extension, Virginia Tech (Old Fashioned Weigela, pub. 2901-1060)","url":"https://www.pubs.ext.vt.edu/2901/2901-1060/2901-1060.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Partial shade to full sun","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Old Fashioned Weigela)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=469","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun to partial shade; moist, well-drained soil is best.","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Weigela florida)","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/749/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Cold Stream Farm nursery (Red Weigela, Weigela florida)","url":"https://www.coldstreamfarm.net/product/red-weigela-weigela-florida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefers full sun but can tolerate partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"weigela","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"weigela","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Weigela florida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/weigela-florida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"weigela","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Old Fashioned Weigela)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=469","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerance: Alkaline Soil Dry Sites Salt Soil Compaction","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Weigela florida)","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/749/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Some drought sensitivity.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"weigela","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Weigela florida)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/weigela-florida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts hummingbirds and butterflies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Weigela florida)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=279017","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are attractive to hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Weigela florida)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/how-to-grow-and-care-for-old-fashioned-weigela-weigela-florida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"have tubular flowers that attract hummingbirds","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Weigela florida)","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/749/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"},{"name":"Cold Stream Farm nursery (Red Weigela, Weigela florida)","url":"https://www.coldstreamfarm.net/product/red-weigela-weigela-florida/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wildlife: hummingbirds and butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"weigela florida"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"weigela-minuet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.61,0.9],"union":[0.6,0.91],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255793&isprofile=0&basic=Minuet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/750/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Height: 2-3 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Jeffries Nurseries","url":"https://jeffriesnurseries.com/minuet-weigela/","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Height: 2-3′","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Urban Tree Farm Nursery","url":"https://www.urbantreefarm.com/product/weigela-minuet/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dimensions (HxW): 2-3′ x 3-5′","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Farmyard Nurseries","url":"https://www.farmyardnurseries.co.uk/product/weigela-minuet/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"typically reaches heights of 60-90cm with a similar spread","metres":[0.6,0.9],"band":[0.6,0.9],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"weigela-minuet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.61,1.52],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255793&isprofile=0&basic=Minuet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 3.00 to 4.00 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/750/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ultimate Spread: 3-4 feet","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Jeffries Nurseries","url":"https://jeffriesnurseries.com/minuet-weigela/","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2-3′","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Urban Tree Farm Nursery","url":"https://www.urbantreefarm.com/product/weigela-minuet/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dimensions (HxW): 2-3′ x 3-5′","metres":[0.91,1.52],"band":[0.91,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"weigela-minuet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255793&isprofile=0&basic=Minuet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Weigela florida species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/weigela-florida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"weigela-minuet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255793&isprofile=0&basic=Minuet","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/750/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Weigela florida species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/weigela-florida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Jeffries Nurseries","url":"https://jeffriesnurseries.com/minuet-weigela/","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Light Needs: Full Sun"},{"name":"Urban Tree Farm Nursery","url":"https://www.urbantreefarm.com/product/weigela-minuet/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun/Part Shade"},{"name":"Farmyard Nurseries","url":"https://www.farmyardnurseries.co.uk/product/weigela-minuet/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"thrives in full sun to partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"weigela-minuet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255793&isprofile=0&basic=Minuet","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are slightly fragrant.","claim":true},{"name":"Jeffries Nurseries","url":"https://jeffriesnurseries.com/minuet-weigela/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This dwarf cultivar blooms freely producing slightly fragrant flowers.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"weigela-minuet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"weigela-minuet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/750/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Some drought sensitivity.","claim":false}],"note":"only 0 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"weigela-minuet","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=255793&isprofile=0&basic=Minuet","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/750/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers attract hummingbirds.","claim":true},{"name":"Farmyard Nurseries","url":"https://www.farmyardnurseries.co.uk/product/weigela-minuet/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"attracts bees and butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"weigela-wine-and-roses","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.22,1.52],"union":[1.22,1.52],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241521","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4.00 to 5.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/weigela/wine-roses-weigela-florida","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 4' - 5'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/wine-and-roses-weigela/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height : 4-5 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/wine-and-rose-weigela","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height : 4-5 ft.","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"weigela-wine-and-roses","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.22,1.52],"union":[1.22,1.83],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241521","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4.00 to 6.00 feet","metres":[1.22,1.83],"band":[1.22,1.83],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/weigela/wine-roses-weigela-florida","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 4' - 5'","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/wine-and-roses-weigela/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread : 4-5 Feet","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/wine-and-rose-weigela","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width : 4-5 ft.","metres":[1.22,1.52],"band":[1.22,1.52],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"weigela-wine-and-roses","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241521","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/weigela/wine-roses-weigela-florida","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 4a , 4b , 5a , 5b , 6a , 6b , 7a , 7b , 8a , 8b","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/wine-and-roses-weigela/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones : 4-8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Brighter Blooms","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/wine-and-rose-weigela","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In Zones : 4-9 outdoors","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/weigela-florida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 8a, 8b","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"weigela-wine-and-roses","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241521","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/wine-and-roses-weigela/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure : Full Sun"},{"name":"Brighter Blooms","url":"https://www.brighterblooms.com/products/wine-and-rose-weigela","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight : Full Sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/weigela-florida/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (species page, zones and sun only)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/weigela-florida","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to part shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"weigela-wine-and-roses","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"weigela-wine-and-roses","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/weigela/wine-roses-weigela-florida","https://plantaddicts.com/wine-and-roses-weigela/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/weigela/wine-roses-weigela-florida","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: Cut Flower","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/wine-and-roses-weigela/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: Container, Cut Flower, Landscape","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"weigela-wine-and-roses","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"weigela-wine-and-roses","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":4,"why":"both carry the same 34 character sentence, so one is reprinting the other","urls":["https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/weigela/wine-roses-weigela-florida","https://plantaddicts.com/wine-and-roses-weigela/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Proven Winners (introducer)","url":"https://www.provenwinners.com/plants/weigela/wine-roses-weigela-florida","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/wine-and-roses-weigela/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies, Hummingbirds","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both carry the same 34 character sentence, so one is reprinting the other. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"white-ornamental-onion","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.23,0.28],"union":[0.1,0.5],"voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282304&isprofile=0&basic=Allium+karataviense","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.50 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-karataviense/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"a 10-12 inch tall stem grows from each pair of leaves","metres":[0.25,0.3],"band":[0.25,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/karataviense/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8″-10″","metres":[0.2,0.25],"band":[0.2,0.25],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/allium-karataviense.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8\".","metres":0.2,"band":[0.18,0.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/allium-karataviense","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: Grows 6-8\" tall","metres":[0.15,0.2],"band":[0.15,0.2],"role":"scored"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/fall-allium-flower-bulbs-karataviense","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 6-12\" tall","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS) Plant Profile","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/832/allium-karataviense/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Height 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/allium-karataviense","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 6 - 12 Inches","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ballyrobert Gardens","url":"https://www.ballyrobertgardens.com/products/allium-karataviense","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 5 - 45 cm (0.5 - 1.5 ft)","metres":[0.15,0.45],"band":[0.15,0.45],"role":"scored"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/allium-karataviense/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height: 25cm Spread: 10cm","metres":0.25,"band":[0.23,0.28],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"white-ornamental-onion","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.4,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.15,0.3],"union":[0.09,0.5],"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282304&isprofile=0&basic=Allium+karataviense","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.50 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS) Plant Profile","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/832/allium-karataviense/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Max Spread 0.1-0.5 metres","metres":[0.1,0.5],"band":[0.1,0.5],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/allium-karataviense","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Spread: 6 - 12 Inches","metres":[0.15,0.3],"band":[0.15,0.3],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Ballyrobert Gardens","url":"https://www.ballyrobertgardens.com/products/allium-karataviense","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Spread: 15 - 45 cm (0.5 - 1.5 ft)","metres":[0.15,0.45],"band":[0.15,0.45],"role":"scored"},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/allium-karataviense/","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Height: 25cm Spread: 10cm","metres":0.1,"band":[0.09,0.11],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"white-ornamental-onion","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["4-8","5-9","3-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282304&isprofile=0&basic=Allium+karataviense","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 4 to 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-karataviense/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/karataviense/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 4, 5, 6, 7, 8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/allium-karataviense.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 5-9.","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/allium-karataviense","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones: 3 through 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/fall-allium-flower-bulbs-karataviense","country":"US","form":null,"value":"ZONES 4-8","zones":[4,8]},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/allium-karataviense","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zones: 4 - 8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"white-ornamental-onion","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282304&isprofile=0&basic=Allium+karataviense","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-karataviense/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Brent and Becky's Bulbs","url":"https://brentandbeckysbulbs.com/product/karataviense/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full Sun"},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/fall-allium-flower-bulbs-karataviense","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun"},{"name":"Royal Horticultural Society (RHS) Plant Profile","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/832/allium-karataviense/details","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position Full sun"},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/allium-karataviense","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Exposure: Partial Sun to Full Sun (At Least 5 Hours of Direct Sunlight)"},{"name":"Ballyrobert Gardens","url":"https://www.ballyrobertgardens.com/products/allium-karataviense","country":"GB","form":null,"value":"Position: Full sun, partial shade (prefers full sun)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"white-ornamental-onion","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282304&isprofile=0&basic=Allium+karataviense","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers have a mild fragrance.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-karataviense/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"3-6 inch cluster of mildly fragrant light pink star-shaped flowers","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/fall-allium-flower-bulbs-karataviense","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Easy To Grow Cut Flowers Fragrant Deer Resistant","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"white-ornamental-onion","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/allium-karataviense","https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/fall-allium-flower-bulbs-karataviense"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/allium-karataviense","https://plantaddicts.com/allium-karataviense"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/allium-karataviense","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Great for Cut Flowers, Deer Resistant","claim":true},{"name":"American Meadows","url":"https://www.americanmeadows.com/products/fall-allium-flower-bulbs-karataviense","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent cut flower for fresh and dried bouquets.","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/allium-karataviense","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Features: Attracts Pollinators, Cut Flowers, Low Maintenance, Continuous Blooming or Rebloomer","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 3 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 3","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"white-ornamental-onion","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=282304&isprofile=0&basic=Allium+karataviense","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants perform best with consistent moisture during the growing season, but tolerate drought after flowering ends.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/allium-karataviense/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The plant is drought tolerant after flowering is completed.","claim":true},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/allium-karataviense","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Resistant","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"white-ornamental-onion","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.vanengelen.com/allium-karataviense.html","https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/allium-karataviense"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.vanengelen.com/allium-karataviense.html","https://plantaddicts.com/allium-karataviense"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.vanengelen.com/allium-karataviense.html","https://www.ballyrobertgardens.com/products/allium-karataviense"]},{"tier":5,"why":"two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first","urls":["https://www.vanengelen.com/allium-karataviense.html","https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/allium-karataviense/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/allium-karataviense.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"this low-growing, bee-loved heirloom","claim":true},{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/allium-karataviense","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Bees and Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Plant Addicts","url":"https://plantaddicts.com/allium-karataviense","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Ballyrobert Gardens","url":"https://www.ballyrobertgardens.com/products/allium-karataviense","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Other features: Bees and Butterflies, Suitable for Container","claim":true},{"name":"BBC Gardeners' World Magazine","url":"https://www.gardenersworld.com/plants/allium-karataviense/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"is known for attracting bees, butterflies/moths and other pollinators","claim":true}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true},"note":"CORRECTION withdrawn: the 5 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. two commercial sellers state the same figure and neither is a horticultural authority, so there is no way to tell which of them printed it first. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 5","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"white-ornamental-onion","set":"community","ruleset":"v7","field":"botanicalName","current":"Allium karataviense","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"IPNI (Kew)","url":"https://www.ipni.org/api/1/search?q=Allium+karataviense","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Name found: Allium karataviense Regel, Trudy Imp. S.-Peterburgsk. Bot. Sada iii. II. (1875) 243, id 528236-1, record carries inPowo true"},{"name":"World Flora Online (record derives from WCSP)","url":"https://www.worldfloraonline.org/taxon/wfo-0000756506","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Accepted"}],"note":"name resolves as Allium karataviense Regel","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"windflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.15,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.1,0.13],"union":[0.09,0.23],"voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Anemone blanda)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-blanda/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0 ft. 4 in. - 0 ft. 6 in.","metres":[0.1,0.15],"band":[0.1,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Anemone blanda)","url":"http://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/plantfinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286103","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 0.50 to 0.75 feet","metres":[0.15,0.23],"band":[0.15,0.23],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Van Engelen Wholesale Flower Bulbs (Anemone blanda horticultural tips)","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/hanemoneblanda.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Anemone blanda makes an attractive 4\" to 5\" tall ground cover in border plantings","metres":[0.1,0.13],"band":[0.1,0.13],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs (The Anemone blanda Windflower Mixture)","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/the-anemone-blanda-windflower-mixture.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 5-9. Height: 4\".","metres":0.1,"band":[0.09,0.11],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Van Zyverden Garden Guide (Anemone blanda)","url":"https://www.vanzyverden.com/garden-guides/fall-planting/bulbs/anemone-blanda/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height: 4-8\"","metres":[0.1,0.2],"band":[0.1,0.2],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Eden Brothers Planting Guides (Anemone blanda bulbs)","url":"https://grow.edenbrothers.com/planting-guides/anemone-blanda-bulbs/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"These flowers are particularly suitable for flower beds, borders, wooded gardens, and rock gardens because they do not grow taller than half a foot.","metres":0.15,"band":[0.14,0.17],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Ontario Rock Garden and Hardy Plant Society, Plant of the Month (Anemone blanda)","url":"https://www.onrockgarden.com/index.php/plant-of-the-month?view=article&id=196%3Aanemone-blanda&catid=22","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Height: 12 cm ( 5 in)","metres":0.12,"band":[0.11,0.13],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms (Grecian Windflower, Anemone blanda)","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/specialty-bulbs/grecian-windflower-anemone-blanda","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height 4\" to 8\"","metres":[0.1,0.2],"band":[0.1,0.2],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"windflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.1,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[0.1,0.15],"union":[0.08,0.2],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Anemone blanda)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-blanda/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 0 ft. 4 in. - 0 ft. 8 in.","metres":[0.1,0.2],"band":[0.1,0.2],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Anemone blanda)","url":"http://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/plantfinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286103","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 0.25 to 0.50 feet","metres":[0.08,0.15],"band":[0.08,0.15],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"windflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","5-8","5-10"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Anemone blanda)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-blanda/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Anemone blanda)","url":"http://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/plantfinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286103","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Van Engelen Wholesale Flower Bulbs (Anemone blanda horticultural tips)","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/hanemoneblanda.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Anemone blanda are good for horticultural zones 5 through 9.","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs (The Anemone blanda Windflower Mixture)","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/the-anemone-blanda-windflower-mixture.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 5-9.","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Van Zyverden Garden Guide (Anemone blanda)","url":"https://www.vanzyverden.com/garden-guides/fall-planting/bulbs/anemone-blanda/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow as Perennial in zones 5-9. Grow as Annual elsewhere.","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Eden Brothers Planting Guides (Anemone blanda bulbs)","url":"https://grow.edenbrothers.com/planting-guides/anemone-blanda-bulbs/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Native to the mountains of Europe, Anemone blanda is suitable for zones 5 through 9.","zones":[5,9],"level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Ontario Rock Garden and Hardy Plant Society, Plant of the Month (Anemone blanda)","url":"https://www.onrockgarden.com/index.php/plant-of-the-month?view=article&id=196%3Aanemone-blanda&catid=22","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"USDA Hardiness Zone: 5 - 10","zones":[5,10],"level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms (Grecian Windflower, Anemone blanda)","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/specialty-bulbs/grecian-windflower-anemone-blanda","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zones 5 to 8","zones":[5,8],"level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":8},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"windflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":8,"distinctPublishers":8,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Anemone blanda)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-blanda/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Anemone blanda)","url":"http://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/plantfinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286103","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Van Engelen Wholesale Flower Bulbs (Anemone blanda horticultural tips)","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/hanemoneblanda.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Anemone blanda prefers to be planted in organically rich, well-draining, neutral pH soil in full to partial sunlight.","level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"John Scheepers Beauty from Bulbs (The Anemone blanda Windflower Mixture)","url":"https://www.johnscheepers.com/the-anemone-blanda-windflower-mixture.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full to partial sunlight.","level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Van Zyverden Garden Guide (Anemone blanda)","url":"https://www.vanzyverden.com/garden-guides/fall-planting/bulbs/anemone-blanda/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements: Full Sun to Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Eden Brothers Planting Guides (Anemone blanda bulbs)","url":"https://grow.edenbrothers.com/planting-guides/anemone-blanda-bulbs/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"For this specific flower species to thrive, it requires either full sun or partial shade.","level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Ontario Rock Garden and Hardy Plant Society, Plant of the Month (Anemone blanda)","url":"https://www.onrockgarden.com/index.php/plant-of-the-month?view=article&id=196%3Aanemone-blanda&catid=22","country":"CA","form":null,"value":"Light: sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms (Grecian Windflower, Anemone blanda)","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/specialty-bulbs/grecian-windflower-anemone-blanda","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirements Full Sun, Partial Shade","level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"windflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"windflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Anemone blanda)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-blanda/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#spring flowering bulbs #cutting garden #bedding plants","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Anemone blanda)","url":"http://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/plantfinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=286103","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Van Zyverden Garden Guide (Anemone blanda)","url":"https://www.vanzyverden.com/garden-guides/fall-planting/bulbs/anemone-blanda/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent for cut flowers","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Eden Brothers Planting Guides (Anemone blanda bulbs)","url":"https://grow.edenbrothers.com/planting-guides/anemone-blanda-bulbs/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Like all anemones, they will last a long time after cut, so get those vases ready!","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Holland Bulb Farms (Grecian Windflower, Anemone blanda)","url":"https://www.hollandbulbfarms.com/spring-planting-bulbs/specialty-bulbs/grecian-windflower-anemone-blanda","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer Resistant, Good as Cut Flowers, Good For Indoor Forcing, Grows Well In Containers, Naturalizing, Perennializing","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"windflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Anemone blanda)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-blanda/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Eden Brothers Planting Guides (Anemone blanda bulbs)","url":"https://grow.edenbrothers.com/planting-guides/anemone-blanda-bulbs/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"As they are quite resilient to drought, watering during the summer months is not typically an issue.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"windflower","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Anemone blanda)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/anemone-blanda/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Van Engelen Wholesale Flower Bulbs (Anemone blanda horticultural tips)","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/hanemoneblanda.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are much loved by bees, butterflies and helpful pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"},{"name":"Van Zyverden Garden Guide (Anemone blanda)","url":"https://www.vanzyverden.com/garden-guides/fall-planting/bulbs/anemone-blanda/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Beneficial to pollinators; Attracts butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"anemone blanda"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"windflower-charmer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/anemone-blanda-charmer.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4\"","metres":0.1,"band":[0.09,0.11],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"windflower-charmer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"windflower-charmer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/anemone-blanda-charmer.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"HZ: 5-9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"windflower-charmer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Van Engelen","url":"https://www.vanengelen.com/anemone-blanda-charmer.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full to partial sunlight"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"windflower-charmer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"windflower-charmer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"windflower-charmer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"windflower-charmer","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"windflower-pink-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.15,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/anemone-pink-star","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows 4-8\" tall","metres":[0.1,0.2],"band":[0.1,0.2],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"windflower-pink-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.1,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"windflower-pink-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[4,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/anemone-pink-star","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 through 8","zones":[4,8]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"windflower-pink-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Longfield Gardens","url":"https://www.longfield-gardens.com/products/anemone-pink-star","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to Part Shade"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"windflower-pink-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"windflower-pink-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"windflower-pink-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"windflower-pink-star","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"winterberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.83,2.74],"union":[0.91,5],"voices":11,"distinctPublishers":11,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ilex-verticillata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 3 ft. 0 in. - 15 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,4.57],"band":[0.91,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d440","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6.00 to 12.00 feet","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Rain Garden Plants: Winterberry)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rain-garden-plants-winterberry-ilex-verticillata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height & Width: 3-12' h x 3-12' w","metres":[0.91,3.66],"band":[0.91,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Winterberry)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=405","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 6-9 Feet","metres":[1.83,2.74],"band":[1.83,2.74],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Common winterberry)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/common-winterberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Common winterberry is a 6 to 10 feet high and wide rounded shrub.","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"University of Tennessee Institute of Agriculture, Tennessee Yards (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://tnyards.utk.edu/ilex-verticillata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6-10 feet height by 6-10 feet spread; blooms in June, greenish white flowers; scarlet red berries on female plants in late summer.","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Winterberry Holly)","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/winterberry-holly","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 6-12 feet","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ILVE","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Winterberry is a globular, upright, medium-sized shrub , typically 6-10 ft. tall (to 20 ft. in some circumstances).","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/ilex-verticillata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Deciduous shrub, to 10 ft (3 m), spreading branches, oval to broad-rounded, suckers and forms multistemmed clumps.","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Ilex verticillata, Winterberry Holly)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/ilex-verticillata-winterberry-holly","country":"US","form":null,"value":"It is a medium to large shrub typically reaching 6 to 10 feet tall, occasionally larger.","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Virginia Tech Dendrology Fact Sheet (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://dendro.cnre.vt.edu/dendrology/syllabus/factsheet.cfm?ID=270","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Form: Upright shrub with multiple stems, reaches heights of 10 to 15 feet.","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Wikipedia (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilex_verticillata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Ilex verticillata is a shrub growing to 1-5 m (3-16 ft) tall.","metres":[1,5],"band":[1,5],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"winterberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":2,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[1.83,2.74],"union":[0.91,3.66],"voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ilex-verticillata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 3 ft. 0 in. - 12 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,3.66],"band":[0.91,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d440","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 6.00 to 12.00 feet","metres":[1.83,3.66],"band":[1.83,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Rain Garden Plants: Winterberry)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rain-garden-plants-winterberry-ilex-verticillata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height & Width: 3-12' h x 3-12' w","metres":[0.91,3.66],"band":[0.91,3.66],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Winterberry)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=405","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 6-9 Feet","metres":[1.83,2.74],"band":[1.83,2.74],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Common winterberry)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/common-winterberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Common winterberry is a 6 to 10 feet high and wide rounded shrub.","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"University of Tennessee Institute of Agriculture, Tennessee Yards (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://tnyards.utk.edu/ilex-verticillata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"6-10 feet height by 6-10 feet spread; blooms in June, greenish white flowers; scarlet red berries on female plants in late summer.","metres":[1.83,3.05],"band":[1.83,3.05],"role":"scored","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12},"reasons":[]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"winterberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-9","4-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ilex-verticillata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d440","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Rain Garden Plants: Winterberry)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rain-garden-plants-winterberry-ilex-verticillata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Winterberry)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=405","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 4 - 9","zones":[4,9],"level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Common winterberry)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/common-winterberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness zones Zone 3, Zone 4, Zone 5 (Northern Illinois), Zone 6 (City of Chicago), Zone 7, Zone 8, Zone 9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Prairie Moon Nursery (Ilex verticillata, Winterberry Holly)","url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/ilex-verticillata-winterberry-holly","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Zones 3-9","zones":[3,9],"level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":0,"levels":{"species":12},"reasons":[]},"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"winterberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ilex-verticillata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Deep shade (Less than 2 hours to no direct sunlight) Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d440","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Rain Garden Plants: Winterberry)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rain-garden-plants-winterberry-ilex-verticillata/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Winterberry)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=405","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Culture: Full sun to partial shade; moist, well-drained soil is best, but tolerates wet sites; tolerates alkaline soil.","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"The Morton Arboretum (Common winterberry)","url":"https://mortonarb.org/plant-and-protect/trees-and-plants/common-winterberry/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light exposure Full sun (6 hrs direct light daily), Partial sun / shade (4-6 hrs light daily)","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"University of Tennessee Institute of Agriculture, Tennessee Yards (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://tnyards.utk.edu/ilex-verticillata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full to part sun; wet to medium moisture level; prefers rich organic soils, medium to fine soils (primarily peats or mucks) but tolerates heavy soil; moderately acid pH.","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Winterberry Holly)","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/winterberry-holly","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: full sun to mostly shade","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ILVE","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade , Shade","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/ilex-verticillata","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to partial shade. Adapts to many soil types, best in moist, organic soil.","level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"winterberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"winterberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d440","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Cut branches are suitable for use in winter arrangements.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Rain Garden Plants: Winterberry)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rain-garden-plants-winterberry-ilex-verticillata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In the fall and winter, winterberry stems can be cut and used in floral arrangements or other holiday decorations.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Wikipedia (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilex_verticillata","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The bare branches covered in berries are also popular for cutting and use in floral arrangements","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"winterberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ilex-verticillata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It tolerates heat, drought, and soil compaction.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Selecting Shrubs for Your Home (Winterberry)","url":"https://web.extension.illinois.edu/shrubselector/detail_plant.cfm?PlantID=405","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerance: Alkaline Soil Dry Sites Salt Soil Compaction Wet Sites Wind","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"University of Tennessee Institute of Agriculture, Tennessee Yards (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://tnyards.utk.edu/ilex-verticillata","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A deciduous holly that occurs naturally in swamps, bogs, wet meadows and wet forests but is still fairly adaptable in the garden provided the soil is not droughty.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"winterberry","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/ilex-verticillata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The Winterberry is a host plant for Henry's Elfin butterfly and attracts other pollinators.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=d440","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Relatively inconspicuous greenish-white flowers appear in the leaf axils in late spring and are attractive to small bees and flies.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Rain Garden Plants: Winterberry)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/rain-garden-plants-winterberry-ilex-verticillata/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Winterberry serves as a larval host for Henry's Elfin butterfly (Microtia elva) and also attracts butterflies and bees.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"University of Maryland Extension Home & Garden Information Center (Winterberry Holly)","url":"https://extension.umd.edu/resource/winterberry-holly","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers: small, not showy, white; June-July; bee-pollinated","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center Native Plant Database (Ilex verticillata)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ILVE","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds , Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"ilex verticillata"}],"note":"5 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"wisteria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":8,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[3.05,11],"split":[{"range":[3.05,7.62],"sources":["NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Wisteria)"]},{"range":[9,11],"sources":["RHS (Wisteria)","RHS growing guide (Wisteria)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Wisteria)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Wisteria is a showy, woody vine that blooms in mid-spring and will grow to 10 to 25 feet, depending on the support it is given.","metres":[3.05,7.62],"band":[3.05,7.62],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"wisteria"},{"name":"RHS (Wisteria)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/wisteria","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"A mature wisteria can reach around 10m (33ft) in trees or spread up to 20m (66ft) against a wall.","metres":10,"band":[9,11],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"wisteria"},{"name":"RHS growing guide (Wisteria)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/wisteria/growing-guide","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Wisterias are hardy, vigorous climbers reaching over 10m (33ft) height and width.","metres":10,"band":[9,11],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"wisteria"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":8,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":6,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures; 8 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"wisteria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"union":[9,22],"split":[{"range":[9,11],"sources":["RHS growing guide (Wisteria)"]},{"range":[18,22],"sources":["RHS (Wisteria)"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are rhs.org.uk","urls":["https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/wisteria","https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/wisteria/growing-guide"]}],"sources":[{"name":"RHS (Wisteria)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/wisteria","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"A mature wisteria can reach around 10m (33ft) in trees or spread up to 20m (66ft) against a wall.","metres":20,"band":[18,22],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"wisteria"},{"name":"RHS growing guide (Wisteria)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/wisteria/growing-guide","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Wisterias are hardy, vigorous climbers reaching over 10m (33ft) height and width.","metres":10,"band":[9,11],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"wisteria"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":6,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the genus and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"SPLIT"},"note":"SPLIT withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are rhs.org.uk. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"wisteria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Wisteria)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9],"level":"genus","taxon":"wisteria"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":6,"levels":{"genus":5,"species":6,"cultivar":2},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones; 6 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"wisteria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Wisteria)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"genus","taxon":"wisteria"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Wisteria frutescens)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-frutescens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"wisteria frutescens"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Wisteria sinensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-sinensis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"wisteria sinensis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Wisteria floribunda)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-floribunda/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"wisteria floribunda"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Wisteria floribunda)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=368417","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"wisteria floribunda"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Wisteria sinensis)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280632","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"wisteria sinensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Wisteria frutescens)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280631","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"wisteria frutescens"},{"name":"RHS (Wisteria)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/wisteria","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Wisterias will grow in any well-drained soil, in full sun. They will grow happily in light shade, but will produce fewer flowers.","level":"genus","taxon":"wisteria"},{"name":"RHS growing guide (Wisteria)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/wisteria/growing-guide","country":"UK","form":null,"value":"Wisterias flower best in full sun so choose a south- or west-facing wall or pergola. They will grow in slight shade but flowering will be reduced.","level":"genus","taxon":"wisteria"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension (Wisteria in the Garden)","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/wisteria-in-the-garden","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Prefer full sun. Established vines grow and flower in partial shade. Chinese wisteria is more tolerant of shade.","level":"genus","taxon":"wisteria"},{"name":"University of Minnesota Minnesota Hardy (Summer Cascade wisteria)","url":"https://mnhardy.umn.edu/wisteria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"This beautiful flowering vine thrives in full sun, and can easily cover an arbor or pergola to create a shady retreat.","level":"cultivar"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"wisteria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Wisteria)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wisteria blooms are highly fragrant and come in a variety of colors, ranging from pink to purple to white.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"wisteria"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Wisteria frutescens)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-frutescens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"wisteria frutescens"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Wisteria sinensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-sinensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"6-12 inch racemes of mildly fragrant blue-violet pea-shaped flowers bloom almost simultaneously, producing a very showy display.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"wisteria sinensis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Wisteria floribunda)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-floribunda/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Edible Fragrant Showy","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"wisteria floribunda"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Wisteria floribunda)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=368417","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"wisteria floribunda"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Wisteria sinensis)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280632","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"wisteria sinensis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Wisteria frutescens)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280631","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"wisteria frutescens"},{"name":"RHS (Wisteria)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/wisteria","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Long clusters of fragrant flowers (racemes) hang from the twining branches in late spring with occasional summer flowers.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"wisteria"},{"name":"RHS growing guide (Wisteria)","url":"https://www.rhs.org.uk/plants/wisteria/growing-guide","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This gorgeous climber produces cascades of fragrant mauve or white flowers in late spring.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"wisteria"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension (Wisteria in the Garden)","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/wisteria-in-the-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower clusters range from 6 inches to 1½ feet in length and are fragrant.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"wisteria"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Gardening Solutions (Wisteria)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/care/weeds-and-invasive-plants/wisteria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Wisteria is a perennial vine with wonderfully fragrant flowers, often lavender, that grow in clusters, similar to grapes.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"wisteria"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Wisteria frutescens 'Amethyst Falls')","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/22409/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant, pea-like, lilac-purple flowers appear on drooping, 6”-long racemes.","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"wisteria frutescens"}],"note":"12 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"wisteria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"wisteria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Wisteria frutescens)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-frutescens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Heat, drought, and soil compaction tolerant.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"wisteria frutescens"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Wisteria floribunda)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-floribunda/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Dry Soil Wet Soil","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"wisteria floribunda"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Wisteria sinensis)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=280632","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerate: Deer, Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"wisteria sinensis"},{"name":"Utah State University Extension (Wisteria in the Garden)","url":"https://extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/research/wisteria-in-the-garden","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Moderately drought tolerant, but requires periodic deep watering during the summer and fall months.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"wisteria"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"wisteria","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Wisteria)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Hummingbirds Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"wisteria"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Wisteria frutescens)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-frutescens/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Bees Butterflies Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"wisteria frutescens"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Wisteria sinensis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-sinensis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Butterflies Pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"wisteria sinensis"},{"name":"Purdue Arboretum Explorer (Wisteria frutescens 'Amethyst Falls')","url":"https://www.arboretum.purdue.edu/explorer/plants/22409/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Pollen and/or Nectar Producer","claim":true,"level":"cultivar","taxon":"wisteria frutescens"}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-30","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"pollinator","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-07-30"}}, {"slug":"wisteria-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[3.05,9.14],"union":[2.44,9.14],"voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=370856","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 25.00 to 30.00 feet","metres":[7.62,9.14],"band":[7.62,9.14],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-frutescens-amethyst-falls/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 8 ft. 0 in. - 25 ft. 0 in.","metres":[2.44,7.62],"band":[2.44,7.62],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/amethyst-falls-wisteria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height : 20-30 ft.","metres":[6.1,9.14],"band":[6.1,9.14],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/amethyst-falls-wisteria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Height: 10 to 20 Feet with support","metres":[3.05,6.1],"band":[3.05,6.1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"wisteria-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":3,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[1.52,4.57],"split":[{"range":[1.52,2.44],"sources":["Fast Growing Trees"]},{"range":[3.05,4.57],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden","NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","Garden Goods Direct"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=370856","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 10.00 to 15.00 feet","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-frutescens-amethyst-falls/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 10 ft. 0 in. - 15 ft. 0 in.","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/amethyst-falls-wisteria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width : 5-8 ft.","metres":[1.52,2.44],"band":[1.52,2.44],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/amethyst-falls-wisteria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Mature Width: 10 to 15 Feet with support","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"wisteria-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-9","5-8"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=370856","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-frutescens-amethyst-falls/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Wisteria frutescens species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-frutescens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Wisteria frutescens species page)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=WIFR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Native Distribution: Eastern US as far west as east Texas, Zones 5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/amethyst-falls-wisteria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grows Well In Zones : 5-9 outdoors","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/amethyst-falls-wisteria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardiness Zone: 5-9","zones":[5,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"wisteria-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=370856","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-frutescens-amethyst-falls/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Wisteria frutescens species page)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-frutescens/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center (Wisteria frutescens species page)","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=WIFR","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade , Shade"},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/amethyst-falls-wisteria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight : Full Sun, Partial Shade"},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/amethyst-falls-wisteria","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full sun to partial sun (best flowering in full sun)"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"wisteria-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=370856","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-frutescens-amethyst-falls/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are lightly fragrant, lavender-purple, and borne in cascading 4- to 6-inch racemes in May.","claim":true},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/amethyst-falls-wisteria","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant lavender blooms in late spring","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"wisteria-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"wisteria-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-frutescens-amethyst-falls/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"this wisteria is also both deer resistant and drought tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"Fast Growing Trees","url":"https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/products/amethyst-falls-wisteria","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Tolerates drought once established","claim":true},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/amethyst-falls-wisteria","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Often deer resistant; drought tolerant once established; generally low major pest issues","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"wisteria-lavender","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/wisteria-frutescens-amethyst-falls/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Its ability to attract hummingbirds and butterflies makes it a great addition to a pollinator garden.","claim":true},{"name":"Garden Goods Direct","url":"https://gardengoodsdirect.com/products/amethyst-falls-wisteria","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts bees, butterflies, and hummingbirds","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"wisteria-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"wisteria-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":4,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"wisteria-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=368417","country":"US","form":null,"value":"4 to 9","zones":[4,9]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"wisteria-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=368417","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"wisteria-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"wisteria-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"wisteria-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"wisteria-white","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"witch-hazel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[4.57,6.1],"union":[2.75,6.1],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach Yard and Garden, All About Witch Hazels","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-witch-hazels","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Shrubs are large, often 10+ feet tall and wide and when grown in part-shade will be more open in branching and habit.","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"hamamelis"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden Smart Gardener, Which witch hazel should be in your yard?","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/smart-gardener/which-witch-hazel-should-be-your-yard","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Witch hazels are small trees/shrubs that grow 10 to 20 feet high and, sometimes, nearly as wide.","metres":[3.05,6.1],"band":[3.05,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"hamamelis"},{"name":"Penn State Extension Master Gardeners of Adams County, Witch Hazel - A Bright Spot in the Winter Landscape","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/programs/master-gardener/counties/adams/news/witch-hazel-a-bright-spot-in-the-winter-landscape","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size varies between species, but most grow to about 15 to 20 feet tall.","metres":[4.57,6.1],"band":[4.57,6.1],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"hamamelis"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"species":9,"genus":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"witch-hazel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach Yard and Garden, All About Witch Hazels","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-witch-hazels","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Shrubs are large, often 10+ feet tall and wide and when grown in part-shade will be more open in branching and habit.","metres":3.05,"band":[2.75,3.36],"role":"scored","level":"genus","taxon":"hamamelis"}],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"species":9,"genus":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"witch-hazel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,8],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"bare-genus","sourcesDropped":9,"levels":{"species":9,"genus":4},"reasons":["this row names the genus and the page describes one species inside the genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"only 0 source(s) state USDA zones; 9 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a bare genus and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"witch-hazel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hamamelis virginiana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hamamelis-virginiana/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"hamamelis virginiana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hamamelis vernalis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hamamelis-vernalis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"hamamelis vernalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hamamelis mollis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hamamelis-mollis/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Dappled Sunlight (Shade through upper canopy all day) Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"hamamelis mollis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hamamelis x intermedia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hamamelis-x-intermedia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)","level":"species","taxon":"hamamelis intermedia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hamamelis virginiana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281023","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"hamamelis virginiana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hamamelis vernalis)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281022","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"hamamelis vernalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hamamelis mollis)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281030","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"hamamelis mollis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hamamelis japonica)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281038","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade","level":"species","taxon":"hamamelis japonica"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center, Witch Hazel (HGIC 1091)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/witch-hazel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most prefer light shade to full sun.","level":"genus","taxon":"hamamelis"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach Yard and Garden, All About Witch Hazels","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-witch-hazels","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Grow witch hazels in part-shade to full sun.","level":"genus","taxon":"hamamelis"},{"name":"University of Minnesota UFOR Nursery & Lab, Witch Hazel - Hamamelis virginiana","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/witch-hazel-hamamelis-virginiana","country":"US","form":null,"value":"The plant can grow in full sun and full shade, but flowers best in full sun.","level":"species","taxon":"hamamelis virginiana"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"witch-hazel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hamamelis virginiana)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hamamelis-virginiana/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hamamelis virginiana"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hamamelis vernalis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hamamelis-vernalis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hamamelis vernalis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hamamelis mollis)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hamamelis-mollis/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hamamelis mollis"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Hamamelis x intermedia)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hamamelis-x-intermedia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hamamelis intermedia"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hamamelis virginiana)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281023","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hamamelis virginiana"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hamamelis vernalis)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281022","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hamamelis vernalis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hamamelis mollis)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281030","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This species produces the most fragrant flowers of all the witch hazels.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hamamelis mollis"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Hamamelis japonica)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=281038","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hamamelis japonica"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach Yard and Garden, All About Witch Hazels","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-witch-hazels","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers are long-lasting and often quite fragrant with a clean, earthy, and spicy scent.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hamamelis"},{"name":"Penn State Extension Master Gardeners of Adams County, Witch Hazel - A Bright Spot in the Winter Landscape","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/programs/master-gardener/counties/adams/news/witch-hazel-a-bright-spot-in-the-winter-landscape","country":null,"form":null,"value":"There are native species, introduced Asian species, and cultivars bred to take advantage of its many positive characteristics including long and unusual blooming times, frost-proof fragrant flowers, and lush green foliage that turns gold in autumn.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hamamelis"},{"name":"University of Minnesota UFOR Nursery & Lab, Witch Hazel - Hamamelis virginiana","url":"https://trees.umn.edu/witch-hazel-hamamelis-virginiana","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Small fragrant bright yellow flowers, each with four crinkly, ribbon-shaped petals, appear from October to December.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"hamamelis virginiana"}],"note":"11 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"witch-hazel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach Yard and Garden, All About Witch Hazels","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-witch-hazels","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Branches collected just as the flowers begin to open are great additions to floral arrangements to add structure, color, and fragrance.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hamamelis"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["hamamelis mollis"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (hamamelis mollis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (hamamelis mollis) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"witch-hazel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension Home & Garden Information Center, Witch Hazel (HGIC 1091)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/witch-hazel/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are moderately resistant to drought once established.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hamamelis"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension and Outreach Yard and Garden, All About Witch Hazels","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/how-to/all-about-witch-hazels","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Witch hazels grow best in moist, well-drained soils. Avoid wet, poorly drained sites and dry locations.","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"hamamelis"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":3,"covered":["hamamelis vernalis","hamamelis virginiana"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (hamamelis vernalis), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus","this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this drought claim cover only one taxon (hamamelis virginiana), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 1 deny it; two on one side are required; 3 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover 2 taxa and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"witch-hazel","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Penn State Extension Master Gardeners of Adams County, Witch Hazel - A Bright Spot in the Winter Landscape","url":"https://extension.psu.edu/programs/master-gardener/counties/adams/news/witch-hazel-a-bright-spot-in-the-winter-landscape","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Witch hazel is pollinated by nocturnal moths in the family Noctuidae, also called winter moths because they are active on cold nights.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"hamamelis"}],"taxa":{"row":"bare-genus","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["hamamelis virginiana"],"reasons":["this row names a bare genus and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (hamamelis virginiana), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (hamamelis virginiana) and this row names a bare genus, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"witch-hazel-arnold-promise","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[3.66,4.57],"union":[3.05,4.57],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246177","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 12.00 to 15.00 feet","metres":[3.66,4.57],"band":[3.66,4.57],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/witch-hazel-hamamelis-x-intermedia-arnold-promise","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Height : 10 to 15 feet","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/arnold-promise-witch-hazel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height 12-15 ft","metres":[3.66,4.57],"band":[3.66,4.57],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"witch-hazel-arnold-promise","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":3,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"edge","consensus":[3.66,4.57],"union":[3.05,4.57],"edge":[2.96,4.71],"edgeMargin":1.6,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246177","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 12.00 to 15.00 feet","metres":[3.66,4.57],"band":[3.66,4.57],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/witch-hazel-hamamelis-x-intermedia-arnold-promise","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Plant Width : 10 to 15 feet","metres":[3.05,4.57],"band":[3.05,4.57],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/arnold-promise-witch-hazel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width 12-15 ft","metres":[3.66,4.57],"band":[3.66,4.57],"role":"scored"}],"withdrawnFromV2":{"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":4.12},"note":"the catalog value sits 1.6% outside the sources' union (3.05 to 4.57 m) and inside the 3% margin v3 allows at a stated range edge (2.96 to 4.71 m), so v2's proposal of 4.12 m is withdrawn rather than applied; 3 of these 3 scored sources publish a range, and a range edge is a figure converted and rounded from another unit rather than a measurement to the centimetre","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"witch-hazel-arnold-promise","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,8],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-8","4-9","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246177","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 5 to 8","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hamamelis-x-intermedia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[4,9]},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/witch-hazel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"They are most adaptable in Zones 5 through 8.","zones":[5,8]},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/witch-hazel-hamamelis-x-intermedia-arnold-promise","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zones : 5, 6, 7, 8, 9","zones":[5,9]},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/arnold-promise-witch-hazel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Hardy in zones 5-8","zones":[5,8]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"witch-hazel-arnold-promise","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"part-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":6,"distinctPublishers":6,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246177","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun to part shade"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/hamamelis-x-intermedia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/witch-hazel/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Most prefer light shade to full sun."},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/hamamelis-intermedia-arnold-promise","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun to part shade"},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/witch-hazel-hamamelis-x-intermedia-arnold-promise","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light : Full Sun to Partial Shade"},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/arnold-promise-witch-hazel","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight Full sun, Partial shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"witch-hazel-arnold-promise","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=246177","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower: Showy, Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/witch-hazel/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"it provides good fragrance in the late winter garden","claim":true},{"name":"Oregon State University Landscape Plants","url":"https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/hamamelis-intermedia-arnold-promise","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers in dense clusters, fragrant, deep clear-yellow, reddish-green at base, petals 15 mm long.","claim":true},{"name":"Fine Gardening plant guide","url":"https://www.finegardening.com/plant/witch-hazel-hamamelis-x-intermedia-arnold-promise","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Characteristics : Fragrant Flowers","claim":true},{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/arnold-promise-witch-hazel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Yes","claim":true},{"name":"Broken Arrow Nursery","url":"https://www.brokenarrownursery.com/hamamelis-x-intermedia-arnold-promise-arnold-promise-hybrid-witch-hazel.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A fragrant, clear-yellow flowered form.","claim":true}],"note":"6 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"witch-hazel-arnold-promise","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"witch-hazel-arnold-promise","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/witch-hazel/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are moderately resistant to drought once established.","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"witch-hazel-arnold-promise","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Nature Hills Nursery","url":"https://naturehills.com/products/arnold-promise-witch-hazel","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts pollinators","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"wollerton-old-hall","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":3.5,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"full","consensus":[3.29,3.66],"union":[1.52,4.03],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Climbing Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/wollerton-old-hall-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"12ft","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-wollerton-old-hall-ausblanket/","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"5 ft. 0 in. - 12 ft. 0 in.","metres":[1.52,3.66],"band":[1.52,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/wollerton-old-hall","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"8'-12'","metres":[2.44,3.66],"band":[2.44,3.66],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/wollerton-old-hall%C2%AE","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"12'","metres":3.66,"band":[3.29,4.03],"role":"scored"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (EU) - English Climbing Rose page","url":"https://eu.davidaustinroses.com/products/wollerton-old-hall-climbing-rose","country":"EU","form":"climber","value":"3.75m","metres":3.75,"band":[3.38,4.13],"role":"regional-note"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK, .co.uk) - page served at the SHRUB-style URL","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/wollerton-old-hall","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"12ft (3.75m)","metres":3.75,"band":[3.38,4.13],"role":"regional-note"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits where the most sources agree","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"wollerton-old-hall","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":1.8,"outcome":"CORRECTION","agreement":null,"consensus":[0.91,1.22],"union":[0.91,1.22],"proposed":1.07,"margin":47.5,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-wollerton-old-hall-ausblanket/","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"3 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/wollerton-old-hall","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"3'-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/wollerton-old-hall%C2%AE","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"3-4'","metres":[0.91,1.22],"band":[0.91,1.22],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources agree with each other but the catalog value falls outside everything they cover (0.91 to 1.22 m); proposing the midpoint of the stretch the most sources support","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"wollerton-old-hall","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[5,10],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["5-11","5-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Climbing Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/wollerton-old-hall-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zones 5-11"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-wollerton-old-hall-ausblanket/","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/wollerton-old-hall","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Zone 5-11"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/wollerton-old-hall%C2%AE","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"5-11"}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"wollerton-old-hall","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Climbing Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/wollerton-old-hall-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (EU) - English Climbing Rose page","url":"https://eu.davidaustinroses.com/products/wollerton-old-hall-climbing-rose","country":"EU","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight; East, South, West Facing"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK, .co.uk) - page served at the SHRUB-style URL","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/wollerton-old-hall","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Full Sunlight; East, South, West Facing"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-wollerton-old-hall-ausblanket/","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/wollerton-old-hall%C2%AE","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Full Sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"wollerton-old-hall","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":4,"distinctPublishers":4,"sources":[{"name":"David Austin Roses (US) - English Climbing Rose page","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.com/products/wollerton-old-hall-climbing-rose","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Strong, Myrrh (with intense hints of citrus)"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (EU) - English Climbing Rose page","url":"https://eu.davidaustinroses.com/products/wollerton-old-hall-climbing-rose","country":"EU","form":"climber","value":"Strong, Myrrh (with intense hints of citrus)"},{"name":"David Austin Roses (UK, .co.uk) - page served at the SHRUB-style URL","url":"https://www.davidaustinroses.co.uk/products/wollerton-old-hall","country":"UK","form":"climber","value":"Strong, Myrrh (with intense hints of citrus)"},{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-wollerton-old-hall-ausblanket/","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Very fragrant; 'one of the most fragrant of the English roses'"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/wollerton-old-hall","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Very Fragrant; 'strong, warm, and intensely floral fragrance is in the myrrh family with gentle hints of apricot'"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/wollerton-old-hall%C2%AE","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Strong, Myrrh; 'Intensely perfumed'"}],"note":"sources rate it strong","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"wollerton-old-hall","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-wollerton-old-hall-ausblanket/","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Good Cut"},{"name":"Grace Rose Farm","url":"https://www.gracerosefarm.com/products/wollerton-old-hall%C2%AE","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"Vase life: 3-5 days"}],"note":"2 sources state it but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"wollerton-old-hall","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.thornless","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/rosa-wollerton-old-hall-ausblanket/","country":"US","form":"unstated","value":"Green stems with a few prickles","polarity":"few-thorns"},{"name":"Heirloom Roses","url":"https://heirloomroses.com/products/wollerton-old-hall","country":"US","form":"climber","value":"minimal thorns","polarity":"few-thorns"}],"note":"2 sources describe reduced thorniness (0 of them call it thornless) but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-28","rescored":"2026-08-02"}, {"slug":"yarrow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.7,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.82,0.91],"union":[0.3,1.22],"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277129","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Achillea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/achillea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,1.22],"band":[0.3,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Achillea millefolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/achillea-millefolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Height: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.3,0.91],"band":[0.3,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ACMI2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Size Notes: Up to about 3 feet tall.","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"AGREE","agreement":"partial","consensus":[0.61,0.91],"union":[0.3,1.22],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277129","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Spread: 2.00 to 3.00 feet","metres":[0.61,0.91],"band":[0.61,0.91],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Achillea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/achillea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 2 ft. 0 in. - 4 ft. 0 in.","metres":[0.61,1.22],"band":[0.61,1.22],"role":"scored"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Achillea millefolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/achillea-millefolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Width: 1 ft. 0 in. - 3 ft. 10 in.","metres":[0.3,1.17],"band":[0.3,1.17],"role":"scored"}],"note":"every source overlaps at least one other and the catalog value sits inside their union, backed by at least one source but not by the majority band","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277129","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 3 to 9","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Achillea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/achillea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Achillea millefolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/achillea-millefolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources agree and the catalog sits inside them","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277129","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Achillea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/achillea/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day) Partial Shade (Direct sunlight only part of the day, 2-6 hours)"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Achillea millefolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/achillea-millefolium/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ACMI2","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light Requirement: Sun , Part Shade"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277129","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf: Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Achillea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/achillea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Achillea millefolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/achillea-millefolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Leaf Value To Gardener: Fragrant","claim":true},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ACMI2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant Foliage: yes","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277129","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good fresh cut or dried flower.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Achillea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/achillea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Achillea millefolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/achillea-millefolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They also make good cut and dried flowers and attract many pollinators.","claim":true},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ACMI2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This is a good garden plant, as it can be used in fresh or dried arrangements and has a pleasing fragrance.","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29","appliedSince":{"kind":"tag","tag":"cut flower","from":false,"to":true,"appliedAt":"2026-08-03"}}, {"slug":"yarrow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277129","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Plants also tolerate hot, humid summers and drought.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Achillea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/achillea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are generally drought tolerant and prefer full sun in well-drained soils and tolerate poor soil.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Achillea millefolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/achillea-millefolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"It is poor soils and drought tolerant and moderately salt tolerant.","claim":true},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ACMI2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought Tolerance: High","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277129","country":null,"form":null,"value":"The flowers are attractive to butterflies and other insect pollinators.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (genus Achillea)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/achillea/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"These plants can be used at the front of the border, in a cutting garden, a pollinator garden, as a ground cover and used dried.","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Achillea millefolium)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/achillea-millefolium/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies and bees and other insects.","claim":true},{"name":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=ACMI2","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Special Value to Native Bees","claim":true}],"note":"4 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow-moonshine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241832","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.00 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.3,0.61],"band":[0.3,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow-moonshine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.5,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241832","country":"US","form":null,"value":"0.75 to 1.00 feet","metres":[0.23,0.3],"band":[0.23,0.3],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow-moonshine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241832","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 to 8","zones":[3,8]}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state USDA zones","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow-moonshine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241832","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow-moonshine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241832","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow-moonshine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241832","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow-moonshine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241832","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer, Drought, Dry Soil","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow-moonshine","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow-paprika","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.5,"outcome":"SPLIT","agreement":null,"union":[0.46,1],"split":[{"range":[0.46,0.61],"sources":["Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder"]},{"range":[0.82,1],"sources":["Monrovia"]}],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241837&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/paprika-common-yarrow.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Foliage grows to 2 ft. tall, flowers to 3 ft. tall","metres":0.91,"band":[0.82,1],"role":"scored"}],"note":"the sources fall into 2 groups that do not overlap even with a 10% band on single figures","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow-paprika","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.6,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241837&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"1.50 to 2.00 feet","metres":[0.46,0.61],"band":[0.46,0.61],"role":"scored"}],"note":"only 1 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow-paprika","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":[3,9],"outcome":"SPLIT","split":["3-8","3-9"],"splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241837&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3 to 8","zones":[3,8]},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/paprika-common-yarrow.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"3-9","zones":[3,9]}],"note":"sources publish different zone ranges","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow-paprika","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241837&isprofile=0","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/paprika-common-yarrow.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow-paprika","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241837&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Fragrant","claim":true}],"note":"only 1 source(s) state this trait and 0 deny it; two on one side are required","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow-paprika","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241837&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Showy, Good Cut, Good Dried","claim":true},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/paprika-common-yarrow.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flowers for Cutting","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow-paprika","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","derivedTag":{"tag":"drought tolerant","why":"build() adds it to every row whose water is \"low\"","water":"low"},"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241837&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Deer, Drought, Dry Soil, Urban Conditions","claim":true},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/paprika-common-yarrow.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A proven performer in hot, dry situations with poor soil.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present; the catalog value is the tag the product ships: build() derives \"drought tolerant\" from water \"low\", so the authored tags array does not carry it and reading that array alone reports every such row as untagged","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"yarrow-paprika","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=241837&isprofile=0","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"Monrovia","url":"https://www.monrovia.com/paprika-common-yarrow.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts Butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"zinnia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":5,"levels":{"species":7,"genus":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureHeight figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":7,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 0 ft. 6 in. - 3 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Height: 1.00 to 4.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"They come in a variety of shapes, including singles, semi-doubles, and doubles and range in height from 6 inches to 4 feet tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"the mature height of which depends on cultivated variety ranging from a short, dwarf 12 inches to a tall 4 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"and heights (8 inches to 4 feet tall)\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"There are dwarf forms that grow no taller than six inches that are perfect for window boxes and containers, but there are also tall forms that are perfect at the back of the flower bed, growing up to three feet tall.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"This quintessential zinnia grows from 1 to 4 feet tall and offers large flowers that are single, double, or semi-double, and they make excellent cut flowers.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"withdrawnFromV5":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 5 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 7 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"zinnia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":3,"levels":{"species":7,"genus":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question","this row names the species and the page describes one cultivar inside the genus, so its matureSpread figure answers a different question"]},"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":2,"reasons":["this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Width: 0 ft. 8 in. - 1 ft. 0 in.\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground","this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a cold-winter garden grows it as an annual, and \"Spread: 0.75 to 1.00 feet\" does not say whether it describes that or frost-free growth in the ground"]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field; 3 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level; 2 source figure(s) were set aside because this row is an Annual, which is this catalog saying it is planted out and killed each autumn, so a zone-5 garden grows it as an annual, and they do not say whether they describe that or frost-free growth","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"zinnia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"CONVENTION","wouldPropose":[2,11],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Zinnia elegans)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zinnia-elegans/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"USDA Plant Hardiness Zone: 2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[2,11],"level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Zinnia elegans)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277260","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11],"level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"}],"shape":{"row":"species","sourcesDropped":1,"levels":{"species":7,"genus":4,"cultivar":1},"reasons":["this row names the species and the page describes the whole genus, so its hardinessZones figure answers a different question"]},"note":"every source states 2-11 and this row deliberately stores no zones, which is the library's way of saying \"grown everywhere\" (docs/CATALOG-AUDIT.md records the two zone conventions for annuals as expected). Nothing is proposed: writing a zone range onto a zone-less row would remove it from every zone filter outside that range, and this is one library-wide decision rather than a per-plant error; 1 source figure(s) were set aside because this row names a species and they describe a different taxonomic level","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"zinnia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":9,"distinctPublishers":9,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Zinnia elegans)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zinnia-elegans/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Zinnia elegans)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277260","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Zinnia, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zinnia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)","level":"genus","taxon":"zinnia"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1149 (How to Grow Zinnias)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/how-to-grow-zinnias-the-best-varieties-care-tips/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: Full sun (6+ hours)","level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"},{"name":"Arizona State University plant library, Chris Martin (Zinnia elegans)","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/zinniaelegans.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light: Full sun","level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Zinnias)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/zinnias/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zinnias grow best in full sun in well-drained soil.","level":"genus","taxon":"zinnia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers (Zinnia)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/zinnia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Exposure: Full Sun","level":"genus","taxon":"zinnia"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension, FPS-623 Zinnia spp.","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP623","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Light requirement: plant grows in full sun","level":"genus","taxon":"zinnia"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions (Zinnia)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/zinnia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zinnias need full sun and well-drained soil.","level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"},{"name":"Cornell University Home Gardening, Flower Growing Guide (Zinnia, medium height cultivars)","url":"http://www.gardening.cornell.edu/homegardening/scene7e05.html","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sunlight: full sun","level":"cultivar","taxon":"zinnia elegans"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden, Plant Profiles (Zinnia)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/zinnia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Give zinnias full sun, well-drained soil and some water-soluble fertilizer every week or two","level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"zinnia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":1,"distinctPublishers":1,"voiceMerges":[{"tier":1,"why":"both pages are ncsu.edu","urls":["https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zinnia-elegans/","https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zinnia/"]}],"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Zinnia elegans)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zinnia-elegans/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Zinnia, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zinnia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Stem Is Aromatic: No","claim":false,"level":"genus","taxon":"zinnia"}],"withdrawnFromV3":{"outcome":"AGREE"},"note":"AGREE withdrawn: the 2 source(s) behind it are 1 independent voice(s), not two. both pages are ncsu.edu. v3 counted distinct domains and read this as 2","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"zinnia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":7,"distinctPublishers":7,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Zinnia elegans)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zinnia-elegans/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"In the past zinnias were used primarily as cut flowers, but now they are seen more often in home landscapes in a variety of colors.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Zinnia elegans)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277260","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent fresh cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Zinnia, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zinnia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Flower Value To Gardener: Good Cut","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"zinnia"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1149 (How to Grow Zinnias)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/how-to-grow-zinnias-the-best-varieties-care-tips/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"A zinnia mix is an excellent choice to plant for a cutting garden.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Zinnias)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/zinnias/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Zinnias thrive in hot and dry conditions, are attractive to butterflies, and taller types are excellent cut flower s.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"zinnia"},{"name":"University of Illinois Extension, Flowers (Zinnia)","url":"https://extension.illinois.edu/flowers/zinnia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Good garden annual for beds or pots. Good cut flower.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"zinnia"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension, FPS-623 Zinnia spp.","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP623","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Uses: mass planting; container or above-ground planter; cut flowers; edging","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"zinnia"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions (Zinnia)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/zinnia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They're ideal for a cutting garden; zinnia bouquets can last at least a week.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden, Plant Profiles (Zinnia)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/zinnia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"This quintessential zinnia grows from 1 to 4 feet tall and offers large flowers that are single, double, or semi-double, and they make excellent cut flowers.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["zinnia elegans"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this cutFlower claim cover only one taxon (zinnia elegans), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"9 sources state this trait and the tag is present; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (zinnia elegans) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"zinnia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"source-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Zinnia elegans)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zinnia-elegans/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Deer Drought","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Zinnia, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zinnia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Resistance To Challenges: Black Walnut Deer Dry Soil","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"zinnia"},{"name":"Arizona State University plant library, Chris Martin (Zinnia elegans)","url":"https://www.asu.edu/lib/camartin/plants/Plant%20html%20files/zinniaelegans.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They are not drought tolerant.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"},{"name":"Iowa State University Extension, Yard and Garden (Zinnias)","url":"https://yardandgarden.extension.iastate.edu/article/2002/7-19-2002/zinnias.html","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Z. elegans requires regular deadheading and consistent moisture to keep it blooming all summer.","claim":false,"level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Zinnias)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/zinnias/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Zinnias thrive in hot and dry conditions","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"zinnia"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension, FPS-623 Zinnia spp.","url":"https://ask.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FP623","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Drought tolerance: high","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"zinnia"},{"name":"UF/IFAS Extension Gardening Solutions (Zinnia)","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/zinnia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, they're drought-tolerant, but will thrive with regular watering.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"}],"note":"5 source(s) state this trait and 2 deny it","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"zinnia","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"SPLIT","splitKind":"taxon-disagreement","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Zinnia elegans)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zinnia-elegans/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies, hummingbirds, bees, and pollinators","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"},{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden Plant Finder (Zinnia elegans)","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277260","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox (Zinnia, genus entry)","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zinnia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Floral nectar attracts butterflies and hummingbirds.","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"zinnia"},{"name":"Clemson Cooperative Extension HGIC 1149 (How to Grow Zinnias)","url":"https://hgic.clemson.edu/factsheet/how-to-grow-zinnias-the-best-varieties-care-tips/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Zinnias are also an excellent addition to a pollinator garden. They will attract a wide variety of hummingbirds, butterflies, bees, insects, and other pollinating insects.","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension, Wisconsin Horticulture (Zinnias)","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/zinnias/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"are attractive to butterflies","claim":true,"level":"genus","taxon":"zinnia"},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden, Plant Profiles (Zinnia)","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/zinnia","country":null,"form":null,"value":"they attract bees and butterflies, especially migrating monarchs that come through in August and September","claim":true,"level":"species","taxon":"zinnia elegans"}],"taxa":{"row":"species","min":2,"claimsDropped":1,"covered":["zinnia elegans"],"reasons":["this row names one species and the narrower sources making this pollinator claim cover only one taxon (zinnia elegans), so one plant is speaking for the whole genus"]},"note":"this came out more confident than v6 only once the distinct-taxa rule removed the claim(s) that disagreed, so it is a disagreement about which taxa were speaking rather than a finding; v6 recorded INSUFFICIENT; 1 narrower source claim(s) were set aside because they cover one taxon (zinnia elegans) and this row names one species, so 2 distinct taxa are required","checked":"2026-07-30"}, {"slug":"zinnia-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureHeight","current":0.8,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"zinnia-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"matureSpread","current":0.3,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","agreement":null,"voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"climate":{"zoneMin":null,"cat":"Annual","sourcesDropped":0,"reasons":[]},"note":"only 0 distinct source(s) state this field","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"zinnia-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"hardinessZones","current":null,"outcome":"CONVENTION","wouldPropose":[2,11],"voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277260","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zone: 2 to 11","zones":[2,11]},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zinnia-elegans/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b, 10a, 10b, 11a, 11b","zones":[2,11]}],"note":"every source states 2-11 and this row deliberately stores no zones, which is the library's way of saying \"grown everywhere\" (docs/CATALOG-AUDIT.md records the two zone conventions for annuals as expected). Nothing is proposed: writing a zone range onto a zone-less row would remove it from every zone filter outside that range, and this is one library-wide decision rather than a per-plant error","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"zinnia-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"sun","current":"full-sun","outcome":"AGREE","voices":5,"distinctPublishers":5,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277260","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Sun: Full sun"},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zinnia-elegans/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/zinnia/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zinnias need full sun and well-drained soil."},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/zinnias/","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Zinnias grow best in full sun in well-drained soil."},{"name":"Chicago Botanic Garden","url":"https://www.chicagobotanic.org/plant-information/plant-profiles/zinnia","country":"US","form":null,"value":"Give zinnias full sun, well-drained soil and some water-soluble fertilizer every week or two"}],"note":"the catalog value falls inside a source's stated tolerance","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"zinnia-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.fragrant","current":false,"outcome":"INSUFFICIENT","voices":0,"distinctPublishers":0,"sources":[],"note":"no source spoke to this trait","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"zinnia-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.cutFlower","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":2,"distinctPublishers":2,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277260","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Excellent fresh cut flower.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/zinnia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"They’re ideal for a cutting garden; zinnia bouquets can last at least a week.","claim":true}],"note":"2 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"zinnia-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.drought","current":false,"outcome":"CORRECTION","proposed":true,"voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zinnia-elegans/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"#drought tolerant","claim":true},{"name":"University of Florida IFAS Gardening Solutions","url":"https://gardeningsolutions.ifas.ufl.edu/plants/ornamentals/zinnia/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Once established, they’re drought-tolerant, but will thrive with regular watering.","claim":true},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/zinnias/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Zinnias thrive in hot and dry conditions, are attractive to butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait but the tag is absent","checked":"2026-07-29"}, {"slug":"zinnia-magenta","set":"builtin","ruleset":"v7","field":"tags.pollinator","current":true,"outcome":"AGREE","voices":3,"distinctPublishers":3,"sources":[{"name":"Missouri Botanical Garden","url":"https://plantfinder.mobot.org/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?taxonid=277260","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts: Birds, Hummingbirds, Butterflies","claim":true},{"name":"NC State Extension Plant Toolbox","url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/zinnia-elegans/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Attracts butterflies, hummingbirds, bees, and pollinators","claim":true},{"name":"University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension Horticulture","url":"https://hort.extension.wisc.edu/articles/zinnias/","country":null,"form":null,"value":"Zinnias thrive in hot and dry conditions, are attractive to butterflies","claim":true}],"note":"3 sources state this trait and the tag is present","checked":"2026-07-29"} ] }